The Marshall Mathers LP by Eminem

The Marshall Mathers LP

Eminem

3.45
Rating
30005
Votes
1
8%
2
14%
3
25%
4
32%
5
21%
Distribution

Reviews (page 3 of 15)

What sounded edgy and metal at the time plays pretty trite now. The cultural references are pretty embarrasing. Regardless, Slim can rap is face off, so there's that.

Never understood the love for this album. Just Slim trying being an edgelord with very little actual meaning. It might actually hit if I found him at all threatening, but I just don't.

Tengo muchas opiniones sobre Eminem en general. Siempre le tuve un poco de bronca porque mucha gente dice que es un rap “accesible” tipo flaco por qué el escuchar a una persona negra no te parece accesible qué tipo de racistada es esa, además de que como persona no me gusta y sus lyrics dejan mucho que desear (suelen ser muy de ego, sexo y drogas, lo cual me hace perderle el respeto al rapero q solo habla de eso). Dicho esto, el flow que tiene eminem es brutal e innegable y hay canciones que están en el Walk of Fame del rap en general, entre ellas mis dos favoritas de este album: The Way I Am y The Real Slim Shady. La segunda mitad del album está flojisima y DR DRE NO ESTÁ LOCKED EN TU BASEMENT, VOS SALISTE DE EL DE ÉL 7,5/10

First impression: The silliest intro ever. Really enjoyed the album all throughout. Beats were bussin, bars were slappin, what else could you possibly ask for? Favourite track: Stan (grew up with it) One sentence: A satirical album made to underscore the industry's largest hypocrisies, enveloped in personal struggle, emotion, and violent imagery that is borderline concerning yet reeaaally catchy. Will I revisit? Hell ya

Eminem has lost a LOT of credibility over years of less than perfect releases, but the Marshall Mathers LP holds together as a masterpiece still today. Many of Em’s best songs are here; Stan is iconic, The Real Slim Shady is hilarious, and Kim is a violent terrifying experience, but certainly memorable. Is it a toxic masculine desert disc, probably, but does that make it inherently bad,I don’t think so. Much like Fight Club for cinema, I think both have taken hold of a certain kind of guy and become a sort of free speech armor for the reprehensible. Not for the faint of heart, and I can see why our government was so upset, but artists should always have the freedom to tell their story, even if it speaks to the darkest side of masculinity, or at least as it existed at that time. It’s an essential document in hip hop, at the least, and should be heard at least once.

The only real Shady

Not a word of his lyrics has aged well at all, but the flow's great. The whole piece struggles to provide a coherent message beyond shock value. I think he really had a hard time squaring the edginess and outsider stance that was an asset on the first album with his newfound fame.

Första gången jag lyssnar på hela det här albumet, hört många låtar innan. Riktigt bra!

God, bring back skits on records. I was just listening to Stankonia by Outkast (which actually only came out 5 months after this record) and had the same thought. I feel like that's one thing that has largely been lost to streaming, because everything is about individual songs and streams not many artists worry about album construction, which obviously makes things like interludes/skits irrelevant. Anyways, I grew up just outside of Detroit, went to college in Detroit, and have lived in Detroit since. That's to say, I have heard SO MUCH Eminem. He is basically the city's mascot. I've known every word to The Real Slim Shady since I was in the fifth grade, when my mom didn't realize that when she put this album on her iPod it (to her absolute horror) went onto mine too. I love this album, it is probably my favorite of his, and I do think it is very funny that to this day, every single white guy who grew up in the same area as me will list this as one of the most important albums of their adolescence. Though having been around those boys in my childhood I can confidently say this is not a record for boys to hear before they can understand that Slim Shady is a character. I knew a lot of parents who let their kids listen to Eminem because he was "local" and didn't really listen first, which resulted in a lot of elementary school boys having language about sexual violence that they didn't understand, but understood enough to know it was what you said to girls to make them uncomfortable. Some favorite tracks: Bitch Please II, Under the Influence

My opinion of Eminem is constantly at odds between his brilliant technical skills as a rapper and his need to be the biggest edgelord imaginable. Thankfully, The Marshall Mathers LP is much more representative of the former. Even the edgier songs are edgy with some purpose here (well, a couple of them, at least, let's just ignore the existence of songs such as Kim). However, in my opinion, the album really drops in quality in its second half (with a couple of exceptions). Also, while the skits are scarce and short, most of them are straight up unbearable, Ken Kaniff in particular. Overall, probably the best Eminem album, but I'm not the biggest fan of his even when he's in top form, so that piece of praise is relatively faint. Favourite track: Stan

Angry af - lot of bangers

Eminem is another in a long line of pop star assholes who think he invented being an asshole. The misogyny and homophobia is so over the top and moronic as opposed to edgy but the dope is talented and knows how to put rhymes together with enough hooks to make some of the album listenable. But some of this shit is just unlistenable ("Remember Me?", "Amityville"). And enough has been written about "Kim' and whether is legitimate art/performance, etc, etc. but it's just a really bad fucking song.

Like the other Eminem album, there’s definitely talent out into this thing. It’s just that the lyrics and message of it all is so vile in such a juvenile way that it ruins it completely

It’s telling that this album appealed to a younger self. But as an adult, the "edgelord" posturing is hard to look past and made this a real struggle. The album leans heavily into an "only joking (or am I?!)" defence to mask its more offensive instincts, obviously exaggerated for shock value. But this isn't the problem - it's the emotional void. The record constantly pivots between a whining, "poor me" narrative about a difficult childhood and the pressures of fame, while simultaneously offering zero empathy to anyone else. It's the emotional depth of an angsty teenager acting out. In hindsight, he seems to lack any self-awareness when he complains about parents worrying he’s a bad influence. Does he ever stop to ask why his material appeals so heavily to children in the first place? (Note: On a relisten, he does actually state that it's for middle schoolers multiple times. But whether he's joking or serious, it's still true.) It feels too "try-hard" and self-absorbed, and it honestly left me with second-hand embarrassment. I'm sure at the time it was outrageous and fun, but by today's standards, it sounds like stuff an incel would say for attention. It's all just too juvenile. The track "Stan" deserves a call-out for its innovative concept and exploration of parasocial relationships, but the nuance and insight there seem almost accidental compared to the rest of the record. That is the real shame. I think there are interesting ideas that could have been explored well if there were less cringey acting out and a bit more maturity. "Stan" proves he is capable of more, which makes the rest of the album feel even more disappointing and performative. Beyond that, while the production is solid and he possesses a distinct style which he's perfected, it’s telling that the standout track was one he wasn't really on. A lot of the featured artists offered a well needed break. In the end I'd rather just listen to Del Tha Funkee Homosapien and enjoy life. 2/5

Music for boys about insulting, assaulting or killing women and gay people. As we are reminded consistently it's all just a big joke (or we should suck Eminem's dick). Andrew Tate was 13 when this album came out.

I remember being at school when this came out. I wasn't a fan of Eminem at the time, but then I only ever heard snippets of his work so I didn't have a fair assessment. Listening to the whole album, I thought it was very good, on the whole. Some of the themes are not very pleasant and parts are just puerile and seem to appeal to teenagers (hence he was popular when I was in school). It's hard to fault the craft and skill with which he does it all though.

I told my dad how much I hated this album and he said “just imagine living through it when it came out”

Like listening to a mental breakdown. Incredibly effective and deeply uncomfortable. It’s unfortunate Em has become the lots of complicated words guy cause when he just cuts right to it he nails it.

This is a really tough one to rate. I was not ready for the emotional rollercoaster this record with throw at me. I get that a lot of what he was rapping about was some pretty raw emotion, but most of it was typical gangsta rap nonsense - grabbing his nuts, how he was going to kill people, he is the best, don't mess with him, blah blah blah. I like other albums of his more, and I want to rate this higher, but I just can't.

It’s ok but it’s absolutely wild that Eminem didn’t get put on some kind of watch list with these albums man

Pre: Now here is one from my early teens. I haven't picked this up since 03 or so. I used to listen to it on my portable cd player, doing that funny walk so the disk doesn't skip. Post: Eminem is an absolute master on the mic. His flow is undeniable. He has a wide variety in delivery that invokes strong emotions and his lyrics are little sound bites that I still repeat 26 years later. (And this album has resurrected some that were hiding in my subconscious- uh oh). I can see that the tone/theming is there to shock, provoke and question. For each piece of excellent (and still relevant) social commentary there's equal amounts of homophobia and misogyny that now I'm an adult is embarrassing. As a parent if my kids were listening to this I'd almost certainly throw it in the sea. Guess my parents were right. [Amityville] is the least popular song, but I prefer it over the bulk of the record. The radio classics continue to be earworms with [Stan] being the standout. The fact the title is now part of the general vocabulary and in the Oxford English Dictionary is testament to the strength of the story told here. Not sure I'll ever pick this up as an album again. It's the worst of 00s culture and I want to leave it back there. I'm rating this here and now a conflicted 2.5. **

An album/“artist” I completely wrote off when I was younger I was totally open to coming in and finding out I was wrong. This album sucks. He’s such a weird dork. If it’s meant to be a parody it’s a bad one. Feels like the birth of incel culture. Probably the worst album I’ve listened to on this list so far. Don’t disagree with it being on the list, because I think it’s good to know how crap it is.

First time listening to an Eminem album in full because I hate the guy. This hasn’t done much to change my mind.

Increíble, se me hizo muy innovador para mi cerebro, creo que simplemente te fuerza a marcar el bit con la cabeza

Catchy songs that seemed to have gained popularity from the shock factor and the crude humor of the time. He points out society being hypocritical but still uses backhanded arguments. Dr. Dre definitely captured a sound that embodied him and it was well done, but I'm glad Eminem has matured from this, not saying his music has gotten better, but we should all move on.

Arguably the sound of my teenage years as these hit from 16-19 years old for me. I never owned this or any Eminem album but didn't need to as you heard them all the time. I didn't expect this many bangers. The first half was loaded and the second half ended up being arguably better. One of the best hip-hop albums imo and part of an amazing 3 album run.

This album is elite idgaf what anybody else says

Maybe its the Detroit in me but this album is still amazing. The Way I Am is his best song and its been heavily in my rotation the last 2 years. I cannot believe people do not see how satirical he is with a lot of his edgier content. Its horror rap teetering on what was socially acceptable in the 2000s. Its very of its era but for every derogative comment outwards theres 3 at himself. The only song I don't like here is Amityville. Never been for me. Favorite Songs: The Way I Am, Stan There is also a very good video on Eminem and how White America in the 2020s is missing a role model that points a finger back and says "ok yeah but food stamps and heathcare suck for us to..." youtube.com/watch?v=AKevy6Bzkng&vl=en

Between "Stan", "Who Knew" and most notably "The Way I Am", I though thus was going to be a be a more introspective album than the previous... But from "The Real Slim Shady" through the rest of the album through the rest, it's the same shit just on steroids again (like "Bonnie & Clyde '97" before) the worst part being his spousal murder fantasy, and again bringing his child into the narrative. This is not what I enjoy about music at all... Fuck this guy! (3.7) ★½

The lyrics are bad, but the rapping and production sounds really cool. 3.5 stars

In terms of lyrical content, this is a pretty easy 0. Still, there's a few decent tunes here. "The Real Slim Shady" probably the best thing here, but my god is there a sea of crap to wade through. 2 stars.

Blockbuster stuff. Eminem truly at the top of his game here. Along with the monster heavy pop crossover high art hits Stan, The Way I Am and The Real Slim Shady you also have Drug Ballad which is pretty cool because it sounds like it’s got Goron groans from Ocarina Of Time on loop and Gwen Stefani as backing singer. From front to back there is lots of preposterous controversy - Kim and Dr Dre killings are obviously ironic. 4 chainsaws out of 5.

I think the song Stan is still so relevant to fandom culture and parasocial relationships nowadays, also I love Dido's "Thank You" which is sampled throughout, it's a great contrast to what's happening with the lyrics Growing up in the 00s/10s I feel like it was mandatory to know The Real Slim Shady by heart, like a lot of rap songs from this era you're never quite sure why you know it but you just do The rest of the album is very mid, I think you need to have consumed it at a very specific point in time to be into it, listening to it in 2026 is eye opening in a lot of ways

Not for me at all. A wash of insipid loops and clumsy rhymes. Stan is interesting, at least, and The Real Slim Shady is okay, but after that the rest of the -unusually long - album felt like a chore.

This was a good listen. I always forget how dark Eminem's work can be until I hear it again. Not going to be something I pick up listening to often.

I knew Stan and The Real Slim Shady, but the rest of these tracks are just Eminem talking about himself in a less interesting way, with plenty of I'm-not-being-serious-so-it's-OK misogyny in there. I was expecting more.

Not a bad listen, if you like being shouted at by a very angry person. Some good grooves.

Hasn't aged well. I prefer him when he's funny instead of just pure rage.

I’ve listened to plenty of Eminem’s music through the years and this album was an enjoyable journey today. Stan & Criminal were stand outs for me. Happy listening all

Terrible

Eminem is just undeniably a great rapper, if his whole violence/misogyny shtick didn't come off as forced and corny to me I'd probably regard this album very highly

Not my cup of tea but obviously good at what he does

Vulgar, but iconic

I don’t listen to him often but when I do I enjoy it. He is a story teller with his music.

mkaaaay I don't think I have ever listened to an Eminem album in its entirety so let's see!! Update: I kinda liked Stan (w Dido) just bc of the chorus.... I think I'd heard it before Slim Shady was okay I'm back was okay too wtf with Ken Kaniff Kim kinda scared me... Okay.... I wouldn't listen to it again lmao 😭😭😭

*Stan is fantastic but a lot of this became dated quickly and sounds like it exists for shock value only. *Also a victim of 90s/2000s CD overload with too long a running time

An album that creates contrasting feelings for me. I enjoyed the overall sound of the album, with a consistent pace and force to it that meant it was a compelling listen (although I was losing interest by the end of this 70 minute marathon). Stan is perhaps the best track for holding your attention (it’s the origin of the term for an overzealous fan, don’t you know). However, even by the standards of rap in this period the misogyny and homophobia is off the scale, and really dampened my enjoyment. I know that Eminem was a prime target for the puritanical right including Lynne Cheney, so maybe there was an element of playing up to the hype. Even so, it holds back my enjoyment of an album with some strong aspects.

I’m rather torn on this album. Sonically it was really strong, with great beats, really excellent rapping, and powerful storytelling on many tracks (e.g. ‘Stan’ and ‘Kim’). However, while I realise that the extreme violence, misogyny, homophobia, etc. are deliberately played for over-the-top shock value and ‘humour’, I just don’t enjoy listening to it. Also, the amount of self-referential tracks where Eminem complains about this, that and the other also got a bit tiresome by the end of this rather long album. Still enough quality (and certified bangers) for 3 stars overall, despite my strong reservations about the lyrics.

its good, just violent

Listened to this on repeat as a teenager.

Too much screaming. Em have some chill

not super into rap, but this album is iconic. enjoyed quite a few of the songs.

One of the most important pivitol rap albums ever. Eminem confirms he's here to stay and catapults into icon status. Incredible skill not only in lyrics but delivery and flow as well. He tells a great story and sells it too. "Kim" is genuinely horrifying to listen to. A lot of his best songs are on here, and on my 3rd listen the deep cuts have come around on me and I love them. Well except the "Amityville" chorus which is annoying. And my god that ICP diss skit is disgusting. But at the end of the day it's an easy 5

So I mean it’s intentionally shocking, misogynistic and juvenile. I don’t have an issue with profanity but by golly he was really working to put that to the test. He’s undeniably talented and his rhyme schemes are very good, incorporating entire lines rather than just the end of a phrase. He’s smooth. That being said I didn’t enjoy any part of this. While his lyricism and wordplay are good I don’t find his beats engaging so I wasn’t super interested sonically. I’m not the biggest hip hop fan in general but even then this doesn’t rank anywhere on my list of enjoyments. That convinced with the massive length of the thing I was just overall fatigued most of the time listening to it. I feel conflicted on a score because there is legitimate great talent but overall I am sticking with purely my enjoyment of it.

A deeply personal rap album and it's all bangers???

god. damn. legendary. album.

Overall: 3.09 (rounded to 3) Consistency: 2.36 Originality: 4 Enjoyment: 2 Virtuosity: 4 1. Public Service Announcement 2000 - NA 2. Kill You - 2 3. Stan - 3 4. Paul (Skit) - NA 5. Who Knew - 3 6. Steve Berman - NA 7. The Way I Am - 3 8. The Real Slim Shady - 3 9. Remember Me? - 3 10. I'm Back - 3 11. Marshall Mathers - 1 12. Ken Kaniff (Skit) - NA 13. Drug Ballad - 3 14. Amityville - 1 15. Bitch Please II - 3 16. Kim - 1 17. Under the Influence - 3 18. Criminal - 1

This is the first time I've listened to this full record, not because I didn't know about it, but because the people that I knew liked it in when I was younger were angry people who were cruel to me. I have obviously interacted with conversations online about it and I understand now that the anger, vitriol, and vulgarity expressed in the record is not a sincere statement of belief or intention. In other contexts, I even enjoy such transgressive elements. Maybe its just been too long or maybe I can never truly understand this record from outside myself, but I still can't get past the lyrics. Despite its intense and impressive introspection and musicality, this album will probably just never hit me right. I know he aims to provoke, and it I guess it landed. I feel like I "get it" now more than ever, and I still don't enjoy listening to it. If I do have a more serious critique to level beyond how it makes me feel, its that while the album is intentionally revolting, in both senses of the word, against popular culture, it misfires in many cases by expressing what were, or are, simply majority opinions in coarse language. While calling someone the f slur was gauche in polite society, a majority of Americans in 2000 thought that being gay was immoral. Eminem's misogyny on the record is uncomfortably violent for most, but it doesn't mean the sentiments behind it weren't broadly approved of. Too often on this record he sloppily picks easy targets, despite proving that he is capable of more on other tracks. Whether or not he meant what he said, the violent, bigoted, and hateful language present was extremely popular, and not just among people who understood that it was intentionally provocative.

Enjoyed it up to a point, then the shock value wore off and I was just left with someone being offensive for the sake of it. Nice to hear some of the songs from my past again though

un poco fuerte de escuchar, si. Pero tmb tiene temones

Yeah sure

Rap is not my kind of music, but this was interesting. A lot of different moods in the songs, I liked it better than most Rap albums I got so far.

not bad not really my vibe got some bangers tho

It wasn't my sort of music but it very successfully made me angry

There are some classic songs on here, but there is enough other stuff that I would never choose to put this on.

This is the first album I couldn't get through - I think MM is a good maybe even great MC but just not for me - his range is so narrow and I'm not in it.

Terrible lyrics at times, amazing flow at times.

This is a massive nostalgia hit for me. This album is a 5, not because the songs are perfect, but because culturally, it was so massive. It's hard to argue against that. Overall, this was such fun to relisten to, and enjoy again. Classic, stupid, angry Eminem. Can't go wrong.

It really does feel to me like half this album is the best rap the genre has to offer of its time, and shit that feels like Slim was contractually obligated to make.

I mean, it's not my vibe, but! The concept, the vibes, the music and the lyrics are a solid 4. for you, Mr.SlimShady.

There is a whole star for nostalgia - this is just awful to put yourself through

I've never been a big Em fan but also recognize that he has a lot of talent and can be a very compelling performer. But the lyrics. Yeah, most of these are hard to get through. But there are some incredible tracks too. Stan and The Real Slim Shady are classic tracks. Bitch Please lends some nice west coast flavor. But there's also Kim, FFS. Overall, it's a slog and I really don't ever need to hear it again

06/11 Never was a fan of Eminem but I admit there are some interesting moments in this album

Eminem is the Don Rickles of hip hop.

Too ass long

I enjoy the beats, don't like the misogyny and homophobia. I think I'll stick to listening to Eminem's greatest hits every once in a while.

Cancel culture would have a field day if this was released in the last decade

A little crude, but so many sick beats/bars.

Not for me

Tough album to review. I have immense respect for Eminem, but I feel like the more childish aspects of these songs really detract from the stronger songs. I think he's unbelievably talented, and the production on this album is off the charts. The overuse of certain terms just grated on me, and detracted from the experience. Then there was "Kim". Yikes. I love some things, and never want to hear other parts of it again. 3* because even the songs I hated the lyrics to were kinda bops.

i hate that there are remnants in here that make me go "i get it". i get why people liked it and felt seen by it, especially in 2000. there are parts of it, like the discussion of fan culture and the media reaction to him, that are interesting. not to mention the production and music quality have gone up significantly compared to the debut. but those are not really enough to make this listenable as an album in 2026.

First time listening. I see why people like it.

(Pasted from my other group. ) Listened to this in isolation a long run. It was, a lot. Eminem is amazing but I felt the sicko skits in this one were kinda overdone. I found myself craving -- I think -- some of his later stuff that has deeper themes.

i respect eminem as an artist and all but man some of these tracks were vulgar and not necessary for my ears

Wasn't expecting to see this album but it's also not surprising as it was a part of American culture growing up as a kid in the late 90's with friends trying to understand their frustrations with life, authority and romance. I think his writing is pretty impressive from a technical perspective, the way words are put together and then looped in a seamless way is pretty good. Most of it is excessively self performative or posturing which muddies the songs where he gets more introspective on the challenges of rapid fame and para social obsessed fans. I think he wanted to tell people to get fucked, prove his "cred" to the industry and show that he was a complex individual, and in that regard I think the album is a success. It's just not always pleasant to listen to between the heavy sample/ sound effects and shock value lyrics.

Feminist women love Eminem but some of this shit was really hard to stomach (and I get it!! That’s the point!! But I’m still not sure that it makes okay or worth my time). The thing with Eminem is that he really just is that good at what he does. The highs are really high (to the point where I stopped halfway through this album to go and listen to Curtain Call). One of the things I love most about Eminem is the way he seamlessly integrates pop culture into his music and I deeply enjoyed all the many references throughout. I think this album is best when Eminem is reckoning with the perceptions and ideas of who he is (Who Knew, Stan, The Way I Am). I want to give this a 3 but Stan and The Real Slim Shady deserve more than that

I hope isra is participating because I know she loves eminem. I was reading about how Lynne Cheney gave a speech to congress about eminem and his inappropriate lyrics… makes me think about the moral panics!! anyway there are some genuinely shocking lines in here but also some real emotional gravitas. the last verse in stan still kinda moves me every time I hear it? it’s like a scene in a horror movie where you know the devastating information just before the characters do. Also, the janky real slim shady is fun but I feel like he perfected that particular type of eminem song on without me. On the whole it was actually more violent than I expected and kim was a very unpleasant song to listen to. ken kaniff was also pretty bad. the whole thing did keep me engaged and have some good beats. Also just to end « they’re my motherfucking balls you better let go of them they belong in my scrotum you’ll never get a hold of them » what a line

I can’t deny the talent and skill of this album. I also remember exactly when it came out. I remember the controversy around it and at the time I defended the backlash to it. These 25 years later, the composition of the album, the way he’s able to build versus on top of everything and to show a side of himself as an artist, while showcasing a commentary on society at the end of the millennium, is incredible. However, I now found myself just skipping through the songs that now have been overplayed or meme’d out of existence. So much I feel that the legacy of this album has been co-opted by a group of folks the album at the time didn’t intend to speak to. Late stage millennials and Gen X nostalgia drip has perverted this album. The rage I think someone might have felt during this time, that this album spoke to is now no longer the source and its kidnapping today and has left a blemish on its longevity. I am rating the album highly because it is something he admits he’s been ‘chasing’ since its release, but context now is a must in order to enjoy it.

hes faking

Beats were kind of cool. I'm not a fan of his voice or the aggression in the music.

It was good. My favorites were Stan, What I Am, Drug Ballad, and Criminal. Overall, I would give it a 3.8/5!

It was embarrassing then, it's somehow even more embarrassing now. Exhaustingly edgy, like the inane ramblings of the worst child that you hope no child you care about goes anywhere near. The most charitable reading is that it's all a 'joke', but even then, it isn't funny, at all. Obviously this is absolute trash, and proof if proof be need be that popular ≠ good. So, let's consider skits instead - is there ANY good skit, even on a less repugnant record than this? I really don't think there is, and hopefully during this trip into the mainstream I will eventually find a skit where I think 'Oh, I definitely would listen to this more than once.' But somehow I doubt it. uhhh I just heard Kim - wtf

Räpi rütmi ja musikaalse osa poolest on tegu väga soliidse albumiga. Mulle meeldib kuidas eminemi hääles on seda pinget ja emotsiooni, mida mõminaräpist ei leia. Siiski tekitab minus konfliktseid tundeid lüürika. Laul "Kim" eriti, oli tõesti raskesti kuulatav, sest eminem räpib naise tapmisest selle pärast, et ta ei meeldi talle tagasi. Viimases laulus "Criminal" räägib ta aga sellest, kuidas ta loomulikut ei tee asju, millest ta laulab, vaid tegu on ainult ta mõtetega. Siin võibki vaidlema jääda nagu alati, et kas mõte on piisav süüks. Räppmuusika on juba definitsioonilt tihti graafilise ja rämeda lüürikaga (mis see sõna oligi, kirjandusžanr), aga siiski sellise teksti paiskamine kultuuriruumi ja ka kiitmine näitab väga hästi meie ühiskonna kohta kuidas naiste ja vähemuste vastane vihakõne on ignoreetitav ja normaliseeritud. Ma jään siiski inimesena alati lõpuks positsioonile, et sõnad pole lihtsalt sõnad. Huvitav kuidas me oleme siia jõudnud. Kui kuulata arhailisi laule, siis need ei ole mina kesksed ja tugeva sõnastusega. See on teema, mida saaks arutada kaua ja pikalt. Igatahes, "he's a ten, but he fantasizes of femicide". Muusika eest 4/5, aga kogupildina 1/5.

Listening to this album, I was reminded of those talented authors that use the foundation of a greek tragedy to justify whatever power fantasies they wish to indulge in with a veneer of prestige. This comparison is a poor one, as fascinatingly, Eminem is completely aware of this persona being largely a juvenile power fantasy. It'd be more accurate to say that in this comparison, Eminem's fickle intelligence is that power fantasy, and this indulgent and grotesque caricature of a juvenile power fantasy is that veneer. It's disappointing really, as these flashes of brilliance clearly aren't just flashes, but rather the foundation of his art, which remains obscured by blood, semen, and shit. I hear a person curbed by their nature, fame, community, beginnings, and that which runs through all of these things, their masculinity, or that which makes them slightly more than just a person. I hear the twin, nigh- inseparable fantasies of a man and a boy, and seldom, they seperate, and I hear an artist.

This one is hard to rate. You have the obvious classic hits that are great, but you also have the songs where Eminem uses his alter ego Slim Shady to talk very vividly about violence, killing and very negatively about gay people. I am compromising with saying it’s a little bit of both. It could have been great, but the latter part ruins the album experience for me. Favourites: Stan, The Real Slim Shady, The Way I Am

I mean, other than the rampant misogyny, excessive depictions of violence, pervasive homophobia, its trivialisation of real world tragedies, dated pop-culture bashing, jarring use of skits, inconsistent quality of guest features, repetitive lyrical musings, its hypocritical "satire" defence of the lyrics supposedly being written by a cartoon character despite the album bearing his own moniker, its shirking of any accountability, sonically repetitive production, glorification of heavy drug use, depictions of incest and causing outrage for outrage's sake, this was a fantastic listen!

Overall pretty solid album. I like the dark production and think Eminem has a great flow. That said, I do think it overstays its welcome, and some of the songs begin to sound very samey by the end. Also, some of the lyrics definintely aged HORRIBLY (some were pretty awful at the time really), but that has already been discussed to death.

What a classic. Eminem’s verses are so dense and clever. Dr. Dre’s productions is crisp and fun. I’m not going to pretend I wasn’t a edgy boy when I was a kid in 2000’s, but the homophobia is a really tough pill for me to swallow here.

I appreciate the uniqueness of his style, but I just don’t connect with this kind of rap

Profane, but very vivid lyricist

“how many records are you expecting to sell when your second record sends you directly to jail” made me laugh hahahhaa at times this was a truly tough listen, at times this was really cool - I can’t give it more than a two stars for the rampant homophobia and misogyny xoxo

Classic Oldschool Eminem Rap. Some amazing songs on here, some skits do get annoying, and some of the "graphical" violence put me off. 1. Stan 2. The Real Slim Shady 3. Kill You

Phenomenal artist. Unique. Filthy. Misogynistic. Satirical. Unapologetic. Funny.

It shouldn't be a hot take, but Eminem is only famous because white men wanted something violent and misogynistic and childishly angry after the grunge and post grunge era, which was, by rock and roll standards, pretty feminist and thoughtful. And while Em is certainly a more mellowed dude and has better politics than you'd expect (I suppose getting money sometimes helps you grow the fuck up), the majority of his fans revere him as a great white savior. At this point, having already made his mark on shitty white men, you start getting the tightrope. You have the absolute homicidal glee of Kill You and then the 180 of Counselor Marshall being the voice of reason in Stan, and then gets back into the ultraviolet in Who Knew, while starting to take it meta, arguing with the critics. It's funny how the free speech absolutists always end up being really really focused on insisting that they did nothing wrong. And sure, I get the need to have an outlet. That's a part of lots of music (gangsta rap long got this same reputation just for talking about surviving in ghettos and gang life, but for some reason, can't put my finger on it, Em hasn't had it stick). I get the idea of creating a world and a persona that isn't you. But it's weird to have created a persona for yourself who is such a piece of shit, and then spend so much of this album oscillating between doubling down and going full on victim. “Radio won't even play my jam,” he unironically growls on a radio hit. But that's not really all. Because again, if Eminem wasn't ironically part of the blueprint for the white grievance that gave us the trash politics of the last 15 years that he is probably not aware of his part in, it wouldn’t be the only album like this out there. But without that? Em's flow tends to be about reference, about name dropping, about mining culture and being snarky about it. It makes The Real Slim Shady incredibly dated. Imagine not knowing Eminem, and hearing him in 2026 rapping about Britney Spears. Imagine hearing him then rap another song (two tracks later on the album) that also whines about Nsync and Christina Aguilera (and then a third time on the next track). It's either lazy or obsessive (sort of like his homophobia. Or his mommy issues. Or or or) One thing he -is- good at, though, besides playing the victim, is picking music to steal to rap over. I am sure I'll have to hear his first album too, so we'll get there. Dido's “thank you” doesnt really make a lot of sense on Stan, but she got big retroactively off it. And yet, the best thing on the album is Bitch Please II, which basically rides off of Dre, Snoop, and the laurels of a track that was better. Anyway, this is childish pap. Some dude in your high school class heard Kim and felt some real feels about it and definitely made it his personality. Some dude in your class who will say terrible things about black folks thinks this is the greatest album of all time. That's probably true even if you were in high school in the 70s. This is music for broken shitty white men of all generations, regardless of what the artist wants to pretend. And honestly, after over an hour of this bullshit, and expecting i'd at least be able to praise the dude's flow? Nah. That's not even interesting, and even less so after 18 tracks of cringe rhymes and cringier skits and cringiest “oh poor me, i am not being serious, the real oppression is happening to me” bet-hedging. 1* and to paraphrase ol’ Three Personas, one can suck my dick if one doesnt like that shit.

An old favorite. i actually like his other one better though

I'm not a hip-hop guy, and know very little about it, but I know what I like, and this album has so many amazing tracks. The flow of his rhymes just land perfectly. And the choruses are catchy as hell. Only knock on this album is the skit tracks and one or two other filler tracks.

Eminem's entry in the "I just got famous" album canon. I really like his flow but like I said about Slim Shady, you can only make so many anal sex jokes IN ONE SONG before it feels recycled. That aside, this was an evil-fun, super campy hip hop record. Chappell Roan should take notes for her inevitable upcoming take on the post-big-break album.

Un poco ruidoso para trabajar jajajaj pero Eminem es top

Controversy bordering on being cringe, featuring some really unwanted stuff. But it has Stan and the real slim shady on it, and honestly despite its flaws I’ll probably listen to it again.

I have a lot of reactions to this, and I can't synthesize it into something coherent after one listen. I'll share the dominant two. 1) What does someone's background have to be to enjoy this or relate to the feeling of being so oppressed economically and culturally that they want to hear about Eminem's mother being strangled and raped because it's freeing to be able to say it and not care about the backlash? That's a scary and sad thought. 2) I can only imagine the backlash Eminem received after his first album, and this album was released only one year later which means the backlash must have been immediate, and Eminem must've written this incredibly fast. In response, he writes one of the most self-reflective albums I've ever heard. I don't really agree with or understand most of his perspectives, but I give him credit being transparent and reflective with his response while keeping a good flow.

Getting this on the first day of Pride month is one of those things that feels like a homophobic assault - mostly because this thing is an assault that is occasionally homophobic. I made it four minutes into this 72-minute album before the first use of the f-slur, which is a record for this list.

This is a great, great album. He's got a wacky voice and some amazing wordplay and I'm giving it a 5.

So much talent and production in service of too many bad things to say. Not every song or skit has the most objectionable content, but between the really offensive ones, there's a lot of paranoia and feeling sorry for himself. He makes Kanye seem reasonable sometimes. It's a shame. He's so good.

2/5 - Wow, is this hard to rate. On the one hand, Eminem's talent and flow are probably the best I've ever heard, but his misogyny and homophobia are total shit. I listened to this a bunch when it came out, and It's an album I think you need to hear, but I really have no more stomach for the crap he has to say, no matter how good he is at saying at. I would given this a 4 or 5 at a different time.

OK in small doses

What a great album. Although it has the sexist touches, kind of twisted so fine for me...apart from that great beats, great lyrics, nice overall...

A borderline perfect album. yes it's vulgar and disgusting and homophobic in places (he's since become best friends with Elton John and regrets his statements) but the quality of the song writing and just how different it was made it such an incredible piece of work. There's a reason nobody messes with slim.

Technically very impressive. Eminem is at his best when joking around or skewering hypocrisy. The darker stuff loses its shock value quickly and isn’t all that good.

Odio el rap, pero esto es una obra de arte. Con razón tanta gente lo sigue.

This album was huge in late 90s and this guy was everywhere. The hits were hooky and popular and he seemed an alternative with clout in a heavily weighted genre. But none of it has aged well. He no doubt is clever and has a gift for phrasing but too many of the songs are violent, misogynistic, and offensive some 25 years later and this ends up feeling more like a blemish or stain than a beauty mark. I’ll give him points for talent but don’t really care to ever hear this again. 2/5

This was good. Never taken in a whole Eminem album at once before. Obviously, he’s fantastic and despite the album being a little patchy this was enjoyable.

Dette blir den snilleste 3'ern jeg har gitt til nå. Noen morsomme og lekne låter, men jeg har lite til overs for låtene der Eminem skal tøffe seg (som er alt for mange).

Fyren er jo både flink og morsom. Det er jo kanskje ingen nyhet, men var uansett et gøy gjenhør. Koste meg gjennom mesteparten av albumet.

Det her va favorittalbumet mitt som barn. Måtte alltid skippe Kim, da det faktisk ble for voldsomt. Men ja, det e jo bra når han e morsom. De fleste sanga e over fem minutt, og det blir kjedelig da det instrumentale e stort sett helt likt gjennom hele låten. Kunne kanskje kutta noen spor.

Kjedelige beats (med noen få unntak), pubertale tekster med sinnslidelser som krydder, irriterende stemme. Et sykdomstegn for samfunnet at dette ble så populært som det ble. Svak toer.

Slim shady is a jam, the rest of the album is filled with bigotry, homofobia and sexism, which I guess was the point.

Back in the day when Eminem was fun and listenable. Have a lot of great laughs during the album

No I love him

If I was ten years younger, this would been s great albun

I’m not a math genius or anything but I thought this was excellent as long as I kind of filtered out the lyrics. I saved “The Real Slim Shady” to my playlist.

I'm not much into Rap, but I kind of like Eminem. His rhymes and his flow are unique, and he worked with some of the best in the business. It shows. Production is on point, music and beats are also. The lyrics are up for discussion, but bear in mind that Marshal Mathers and Slim Shady are alter egos, so their respective mindsets are exaggerated, and so are their lyrics.

yea well it’s eminem

Just really juvenile stuff here. Possibly entertaining if you are a 15 year old egdelord in 2001.

I liked this way more than I thought I would. Listened to it three times. The way he constructs rhymes sounds very unique to me. The subjects are a little cringe but really fun to listen to. I guess I'm 14.

Eminem has a reputation for some of the most technically skilled rap of all time. He also has a reputation for some of the most vulgar lyrics of all time. Technically, this lives up to Eminem's reputation as a rapper with a unique gift for flows. The hooks and beats are all strong. However, the lyrics are pretty much exactly what you'd think based on the reviews hear. There is some social and political commentary here, but there's also a lot of unnecessary vulgarity. The lyrics to songs like "Kill You" are an attempt to be as offensive as possible that just ends up sounding tedious. This music is very much from a particular point in time where the processed anger of gangster rap and nu-metal ruled the charts. It didn't really age well beyond that time period, despite a solid technical foundation. If he was more willing to write more relatable songs and less violent fantasies, this would be an all-timer. As is, I just can't do these lyrics(especially "Kim").

He’s genius level-talented on the mic but uses it to...do some tired edge lord shit with more corny-ass melodies and beats.

Very good album, some absolute classics. One of his best (his best?)

have you ever heard of a cartoon called the nutshack fave track: the real slim shady

has Eminem just always sucked? has he always just acted like a middle schooler while being a grown ass adult with a job and a tax income? has his music always just been for 15 year old gym bros who unironically use terms like "femoid" or "mogging?" cause it sure seems like it. 1/10 FAVOURITE SONGS: STAN, BITCH PLEASE II LEAST FAVOURITE SONGS: LITERALLY EVERYTHING ELSE

I'm definitely a little personally biased towards this album... when I was quite young, I believe the first musical artist I became truly invested in was either Eminem or Linkin Park. Both were around the same time Either way, a lot of the songs on this album were the first Eminem songs that I ever heard, so they have a special place in my heart. I wasn't an album listener at the time, though, so there is a lot of new material here. And I can't pretend I don't have a soft spot for this man, despite all the objectively awful stuff he says. Perhaps it was him who instilled a sort of contrarianism in my young self, which now makes it hard to not enjoy his provocative tendencies. The Slim Shady LP is definitely better, though, isn't it...? Favorite tracks: Kill You, The Real Slim Shady, Amityville, Criminal

Kill You directly into Stan made me laugh, and at the same time it felt like a pretty effective direct statement of intent for the record, right. It's brute force but it does work. But I think I basically imagined it, with how the rest of the album is. Can't pretend to not already know many of these songs, of course. As an album I think it belabours the same points too much, given the length of it and the number of tracks. It's retreading a lot of its own ground. And despite that perceived 'statement of intent' from the way the album opens and the way it's titled, it's so self-indulgent through most of this, like he's not exactly shy about firehosing his shock value material out as the bulk of the record again. It's still a fairly breezy listen in the moment despite everything (at least when it's not graphically depicting DV). The beats are obviously stellar, the production is carrying pretty hard. Could've cut like 4 or 5 tracks for length though. When it's retreading its own lyrical material so much it really starts to drag.

Love Eminem. He's right there with DMX for my favorite rapper of all time. His lyrics, beats, flow, lyrical speed and clarity, and catchiness of the songs are all on top notch. That said, it loses a bit for the over the top violence in spots, but that just makes it not my favorite Eminem album; it doesn't make it bad. Part of what makes music special is to feel like you're hearing something real, that speaks to you. And the ultra violent lyrics, even if they're facetious and not intended to be serious, don't accomplish that

I write and rewrite this review so I guess I'm at a loss for words. Am I glad I heard this - yes. Was it way too much for me - yes. Will I listen to Eminem again? Only if it's on this list. SUM(1 - 5)/5 =

Listened to this in isolation a long run. It was, a lot. Eminem is amazing but I felt the sicko skits in this one were kinda overdone. I found myself craving -- I think -- some of his later stuff that has deeper themes.

Still incredible after 26 years. He sounds every bit as fresh as when the album was released. And his talent is still incredible. But. The subject matter was bad in 2000 and has not gotten less objectionable over time. The album is also a little long.

Did not finish the album. While I can understand this was from a different time and rap is another form of poetry, it was hard to sit through line after line about self-harm and domestic violence and hear slurs used towards those he doesn’t agree with that are regularly targeted at the disabled community. Not for me.

This is one of the most seminal albums of all time. It was a virtuosic performance of gutty music. Not only is the word-defining song Stan on this album, it's just so lyrical and real. We all loved it.

#365/1001. Somehow this quote snippet from Wikipedia sums up Eminem: "Originally intending to write a love song for (his wife) while using ecstasy, the rapper hoped to avoid overt sentimentality and thus began writing a song of hate." I guess he just pretends to be mad about everything and hate everyone, and beneath the surface loves everyone unconditionally.

The lyrics are really dark but give a thoughtful story, at least some of them. Not something I would pick and listen to but all in all the album was an ok experience.

Eminem’s best work, first album where nostalgia takes over, loved it then, love it now

So much homophobia.

Props to putting what I’m sure is one of many Eminem albums on this list. Undoubtedly Eminem is a legend in his own right, blending funny witty violent lyrics with great samples (Dido’s Thank You being the obvious example). This album has some classic songs that have stood the test of time, Stan, The Real Slim Shady) and other songs that haunted me at the ripe old age of 12 when I was a devout Eminem fan from its detailed accounts of anger and violence (Kim, which I can’t stomach to listen anymore but appreciate what he was trying to do). It’s not my favourite album, but like any classic Eminem work it has me singing along to the lyrics many many years later.

Eminem’s best work in my opinion, and one that suffers only a bit from skits that weren’t great then, and definitely did not age well 20+ years later. Yet the songs are so good, it’s easy to skip and overlook the skits.

Misogyny and homophobia are a bit of a turn off for me dawg. Pass.

Markoolio fast med ett par bra spår. Pajas

Eminem var ju riktigt tufft när man var liten! Fint med nostalgi och Stan är ju en banger än idag. Med det sagt så finns det så mycket skräp på denna alldeles för långa platta. Jäklar vad misogynt och homofobiskt det var! Varannan låt handlar om att slå sin fru, och det framställs som nåt coolt. Kim var ju bara hemsk att lyssna på, både pga text och förfärligt dålig musik. Jag stör mig på alla plojiga ljudeffekter som de lagt in också. Stan räddar upp plattan till en tvåa, men utan den hade jag satt ett. Ibland blir man förvånad av vad barn lyssnar på för musik ”nu för tiden”, men efter att ha hört detta inser man att det knappast var bättre när vi var små.

Topphits och kan uppskatta konceptualiteten men blir lite väl långt och enspårigt (spåret: suck my dick) för att det ska hålla hela vägen. Mycket svårt att betygsätta men landar nog trots allt i en svag trea.

Lika delar roligt som direkt obehagligt. Så jävla uttrycksfullt, teatralt och berättelsedrivet att man aldrig blir less trots att skivan är lång. Såklart stark nostalgifaktor på hitsen också. Väldigt nära en 5a.

Började riktigt, riktigt skoj. "Oj vad snabbt han pratar", tänkte jag. Och vilka lustiga texter! Efter typ 3 låtar börjar dock rösten i mitt huvud viska "bjäääääring". Efter 8 låtar vill jag att skivan ska vara över.

Vilken ordsmed! Finns ju inte en rad med dåligt flow, nästan varje rim dras två, tre, fyra, fem varv längre än man förväntar sig och fan vad roligt det är. Och grovt. Och mörkt. Och vad är sant och vad är ploj? Det är det som gör det så fett va. Skrattade åt detta i Kill You: "Know why I say these things? 'Cause ladies' screams keep creepin' in Shady's dreams And the way things seem, I shouldn't have to pay these shrinks These eighty Gs a week to say the same things tweece Twice, whatever, I hate these things" Duckade bokstavligen en kula en fredagseftermiddag vårterminen 2000. Hela skolan var samlad för nån sorts öppen scen i gympasalen. Jag, en åttaårig bonnpojk i stora svarta kläder skulle mima hela The Real Slim Shady. Cringe. Som tur är pallade inte mina klena nerver trycket. Jag bangade och fick tröstas av några äldre flickor. Lite pinigt det med men jag slapp att i skam blåsa skallen av mig med grannens älgstudsare. Släktens ära osv. Säger som kungen säger till Mozart i Amadeus " It's quality work. There are simply too many notes, that's all. Just cut a few and it will be perfect.".

too much swearing and bad lyrics

Yeah, nah. He’s talented and there is some really nice production, but this is music for suburban kids that want to seem scary. And why the fuck is this so long?

I recognize the impact of Stan, but I wouldn't find myself casually listening to this album so I can't give it more than a 3/5

Damn. I knew Eminem was an edgelord, but I guess I memory-holed just how violent and misogynistic this album is. Mixed bag. There are some great bars, and a few tracks really land. Where I struggle is that the Slim Shady persona looks suspiciously like the person he was at the time. Transgressive art has to walk a tightrope, and a lot depends on the distance between the artist and the transgression. I kept thinking about American Psycho, which works for me because the gap between Bret Easton Ellis and Patrick Bateman is easier to trust. Ellis hasn’t given us much reason to doubt that distance. And even then, plenty of people still miss the satire and take Bateman at face value. That gap is much harder to trust on this album, especially when you’re hearing a murder fantasy about his then-wife during a period when his real life made the violence feel less theoretical. “Stan” still works for me because it feels like a story with a point of view. “Kim” collapses that distance. It feels less like performance and more like a pressure valve for real rage. The rage is being performed by the guy who actually had it, aimed at the person he actually had it toward. Even in my most charitable interpretation, I’m not sure what point it’s trying to make other than catharsis. Which is pretty fucked. I’ll admit that my own proximity to domestic violence is shaping how I’m experiencing this album revisit. He got clean, became a dedicated father, and by all accounts grew past this version of himself. But knowing what was happening around this album changes how I hear it, and I can’t really unhear it. I can admire the songcraft, but “it’s just a character” doesn’t fully survive contact with the context. And outside of my incessant moralizing, large parts of it dragged for me. The skits wore thin fast. But it made me think. 2/5.

So angry I'm still getting content warnings on the songs, the voice of a generation of kids with bad bleach dye jobs

I was excited for this record because I knew "Stan," and thought that it was a beautiful and sad song -- ahead of its time -- about parasocial relationships. So, I wondered what else would be on this record, and how Eminem would depict other parts of his changing circumstances. I was not impressed. The violent misogyny is disgusting. It doesn't escape my notice that the "Stan" is the only moment of real empathy on this record, and it's reserved for a man. But "Stan" shows us that Eminem *is* capable of emotionally textured writing; he can go into this gear when he wants to. He just doesn't want to. Other reviewers have made comments such as "Even though it's an offensive album, you can't deny its mastery." Actually, you can. Being an artist is not just about technical expertise. (I’d even argue that technical mastery is lacking here; if “suck my dick” is your best retort on multiple occasions, you’ve got some work to do.) Artistry is about saying something that other people need to hear, that they do not have a way to put into words themselves. Eminem knew that his work was inflammatory, that it would make the world a crueler place, that it would give young men a vocabulary and a license to embrace their worst impulses, and he did it anyway. His intention was to shock people, and part of being a good artist is to *check your intentions* and realize when they are wrong. On the Wikipedia page, it's noted that Johnny Cash defended the record, saying that "Folsom Prison Blues," "Jesse James" and a host of other songs are also violent. (I myself appreciate "Down By The River" and Nick Cave's Murder Ballads record.) Due respect, but the difference between these songs and The Marshall Mathers LP is the sense of morality. In "FSB," the man in prison admits that he did something wrong. "Jesse James" is a Robin Hood story, a legend. The Marshall Mathers LP is simply cruel. It was important to listen to this record as part of this tour of music history, but it is a despicable work.

Man can he rap, just not sure how much is parody in some cases.

Lyrically this is a bit intense for me as an adult but there are some absolute classics on here.

a couple of alright songs, but not really my cup of tea.

I don't have much to say about the album. It's fine. The Real Slim Shady is great as always. I'm sure the songs have strange lyrics but I wasn't listening to the words much. What interests me is Eminem. I was a huge fan when I was twelve. I listened to "The Eminem Show" nigh daily, but completely stopped my listening when I matriculated in high school. I now volunteer as a music teacher, and half of the 12 year old boys are Eminem fans. What is it about Eminem that excites male tweens so much that loses its sheen in grade 9??

it’s really not that great. he’s pretty corny and that edgelord shit gets old real quick. the beats aren’t anything to write home about either. stan is probably the only good song on here lol the rest is either terrible or okay at best. “oh man why do people think i’m a homophobic, misogynistic, violent person???? it’s just a joke they don’t know me!!!” *next song* “i’m a homophobic, misogynistic, violent person! i mean everything i say!”

Rap's generally not my thing, but this does have some absolute classics (Stan particularly).

I mean teenage/ high school staple. When this came out I was going through a real rap stage and honestly I found him so influential. I get it, along of songs are about this that and the other and as I’ve got older they don’t mean much to me but at the time, you just think all that’s cool as fuck. Fair play for this been in the mix. Can’t actually name a bad song on here really.

Gotta give this a 4 locsd it when it came out still stands up today and loved it for shock value when it came out sneaking it behind your parents back

While I do enjoy most of his radio songs, Eminem is just not for me. The misogyny, homophobia, and violence are just super off-putting. It's really part of the reason I was pushed away from hip-hop in the 90s (continuing into the early 2000s).

Sigh. What are we even doing here? It's like the rantings of a crazy person set to a drum machine and samples of a shitty ringtone on repeat. This guy needed therapy way worse than he needed a record deal. But he’s rich and I’m not, so I guess I’m the idiot here.

5.5 / 10

This album was huge when I was a tween. I just can't get into it. I'm not a big rap fan but this just feels like something a 13 year old boy would create. It feels like its claiming to be edgy and funny while spouting incredibly mysoginistic and homophobic phrases. I think this album can exist and people can be offended by it but I just didn't get any enjoyment out of it. It's over the top but it pushes the edge a bit too much. I understand its meant to be voice of a lower class or the street but maybe I'm just too old to enjoy this.

Slim shadyyyyy

God this aged so quickly. Feels like a time capsule, very jarring to listen to now.

Utter rubbish. 72 minutes of misogyny, homophobia, violence. It's rap music for 13 year olds that find these things edgy and cool. To anybody with a developed frontal lobe it's just offensive for the sake of being offensive. First 1 I've given and I didn't even think twice. To give it its dues, Stan is the only bearable song with great sampling from Dido and a relatively interesting story.

That was fun

Bom, mas muito misógino. "Kill you" é péssima. Stan é fantástica. Vários versos homofóbicos e generally violentos. Porém, it does hit.

4/5 Generational rhymes and storytelling, but I’m happy that the dude nowadays is sober and corny instead of on drugs and horny.

Outrageously sexiest, misogynistic, homophobic lyrics but so much so that it's very hard to take it all too seriously. 'Stan' has stood the test of time and overall this was a very fun, listenable album. If we're discounting music based on questionable lyrical content then that's rap and hip-hop out, as well quite a bit of the rest of it

Incredible follow up to slim shady lp, this album is a perfect 10 out of 10 as long as you skip Kim

what the hell what the hell what the hell what the hell what the hell what the hell what the hell

Rating: 3/5 Favorite(s): Stan/Drug Ballad Least favorite: Amityville

Rating: 4/5 Favorite Song: Criminal Least Favorite Song: Remember Me?

This ia probably the best from this era of Eminem and it features the highs where his controversal style works (Stan, The Way I Am) and where it just comes off as edgy (Kim, Amityville). At least this had some good songs compared to Slim Shady LP, though the lyrics is arguably worse, especially in the second half.

DNF I understand it’s iconic but…

There are some great songs on here but this didn't age well overall. The misogyny etc is exhausting.

Biased because this was a huge part of my childhood but it’s iconic 2000s rap and helped define what the genre evolved into

It's an amazing album! It's very over the top and uses a ton of profanity, which adds a certain uniqueness to it. It's got very catchy tunes and melodies, and it's definitely one of his greatest works. Eminem is truly a genius when it came to connecting his albums. This is supposed to be like a sequel to the Slim Shady LP and the way he connects them is genius. Listening to those two albums (I felt I had to listen to the Slim Shady LP before this one) has made me appreciate Eminem a whole lot more. Insanely good!

Well… this is one of those albums I feel like I have to apologize for rating well. Undeniably disturbing. Kim is a case in point. That’s more than a simple skit. More than homophobic and misogynistic, it’s gleefully unapologetic about its provocative nature. But man it has me laughing out loud at every turn. It’s well done. A horror fest of male fantasy not unlike American Psycho in its own way. After writing American Psycho, Bret Easton Ellis came out. I am not the only person to see his struggles with his own sexuality in the novel. It does make one wonder about Mr. Mathers, no? Boolean rating: yes, glad I actually listened to this album. But it would be better at UNDER an hour not almost 15 minutes OVER

Green River - Good Commotion - Decent Tombstone Shadow - Decent Wrote a Song For Everyone - Decent Bad Moon Rising - Good Lodi - Decent Cross-Tie Walker - Good Sinister Purpose - Stylish The Night Time is The Right Time - Decent Broken Spoke Shuffle - Decent Glory Be - Decent

Wigga rap lol

This is classic Eminem. Accept no substitutes.

< the Beatles As someone who was the right age for Eminem when he released these albums, I have just never understood the appeal. Some of his more goofy shit is entertaining but holy shit this album takes itself too damn serious. No thank you

Definitely not

...but if you can get past the misogyny, homophobia, and graphic violence...

genuine drivel besides stan. some of the worst written lyrics ever to be penned. i'm not a puritan or anything who hates taboo subjects in music but there's only so many times i can listen to eminem rap about fucking women and ripping apart the gay and mentally disabled. just gets boring.

This is difficult because I find Eminem so off-putting and a lot of his shock value stuff is just tiring but then sometimes there is a song like 'Kim' that is so reprehensible and insane and yet this guy was like one of the biggest artists in the world for a minute. It's just very fascinating to me. He certainly has skill and the production is OK sometimes. And his vision of the world is so depressing. I have no idea how to square all this with a number rating.

Altså... Det er jo flere ikoniske låter her. Men mye dritt også. "Kim" er for drøy.

No me gustó. Me gusta el rap pero no este tipo, no es mí estilo, me pareció violento de más. Es un álbum para angry wannabe black white boys qué se creen que por ser agresivos son más machos. Rescato una o dos canciones nomás.

Didn't realise how much of a nutjob psyop eminem is but the music is great

The first Parental Guidance album I owned (bought in Oban), and I was curious to go back to it. It was terrible! A deeply unpleasant listen. Favourite track: N/A

I think the best songs on the album are Stan and The Real Slim Shady. The rest of the album was fine but I think those were the only real standouts for me

yikes, but also

JOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOJ kao što sam već napisao u osvrtu na album dr. drea (»the chronic«, inače žešće smeće), žao mi je što sam prvom eminemovom albumu koji sam preslušao u sklopu ove stranice dao kečinu, i to prvu. neki kasniji albumi, bilo rep bilo rok bilo šta god, pokazali su mi da postoji mnogo, mnogo lošija glazba. ispravimo zapravo nepravdu s evo drugim njegovim albumom koji preslušavam. je li dobar? nije. usudim se ipak reći da je trunku bolji od slim shady LP-ja, prije svega zbog stvari »stan«, koja je fakat okej, s dobrim refrenom. ostatak je eh, ali eminemu se ne može zamjeriti manjak reperske vještine, čisto formalno, jako je, jako dobar. sadržaj je takav kakav jest, meni glup, ali sam shvatio da mi je ipak bolji od tipičnog "jo jo niga, pul da čriga", barem eminem ima neku osobnost za razliku od takvih repniških dozlaboga ofucanih opetovanja. sve u svemu bezvezan i predug album, ali nije dno dna

There is an incredible level of skill, and talent on display here. Even as a “non-rap” person, I can pick up that Eminem is in a rare tier as a performer, and this album probably hits pretty close to his prime. That said, it kinda sucks that so much of that talent is in service of a particular kind of early 2000s edginess/shock value that I just find to be kinda gross. I know that the performing-to-shock has its place/validity, but this went a bit beyond “wow, what challenging themes to confront.”

Is it too much to ask for one rap album that doesn't feature bars about beating, raping, and/or murdering women? It's not a joke, it's not social commentary, and it's not good rap. DNF this 2000s edgelord trash.

I remember sneaking listens to this album as well as the Eminem Show when I was a kid. I've been a fan forever, and this album is dope. I feel like the Slim Shady persona was for sure an artifact of the times, and I'd argue it was a necessary one. Every kid in school knew this LP, and every parent was, predictably, against it. Eminem plays up the age old argument that art causes violence by hamming it up to the extreme and calling out the hypocrisy of, well, everything. People claim the lyrics are horrible and violent and childish, and sure, they are, but look at most every other rap album (and a lottttt of rock albums) in existance; there's really very little difference. Musically though the beats are heavy and Eminem's rhymes and flows are freaking pristine. It's just a cool album, playing up a "horror" aspect of music which is not widely explored territory in the industry. Standout tracks are "Kill You" "Stan" "The Real Slim Shady" and "Amityville" I dislike the skits and I assume they are as bad as they are because he's making fun of skits that appear on most rap albums. Either way they bring the album down like they always do. The album's also too long. Overall I can put aside my nitpicks as there are a lot of bangers on the album and it's a major hit of nostalgia. It's a 4.5 for me, almost perfect but there are a few songs that need to be chopped and in spite of what it is some of it is pretty cringe-worthy today.

Abrasive. Not interested

This one was hard to rate for me. First, I thought I was going to give it a three or a four but I had all weekend to think on it. I decided to rate it much lower. At first wall I was listening, I was struck by the message that people need to take responsibility for themselves and not blame the ills of society on musicians. While that might be the case in part, I also feel the majority of this album is shock for the sake of shock. I do realize that this is probably the point in driving home his message, but it was a bit much. There are some absolute classic songs on this album though. Definitely the hardest review that I've had so far.

Had some classics. He also talked about he would fuck his mom as a roast. He just kind of weird but overall good.

really hasn't aged well

Great album - scored 4 as it got a bit samey re bitches and killing

slim shady… skits engraçados e samples bons

un clasico al nivel de scary movie y jackass, edgy como solo eminem puede el album se alarga mucho y por muchos momentos se siente mas como ser controversial solo por ser controversial yo a los 12 años - 5 estrellas yo ahorita -3 estrellas

Buen disco y gran concepto. Lo disfrute bastante. Esa dualidad de alter egos es muy divertida. Gran musicalidad y buena producción. Recomendable, te guste o no el género.

Memorable songs, it isn’t bad if you ignore all the lyrics. I do like Stan though

Better than Coldplay

I can see why it is on the list. Without giving it more of a listen and understanding what it is about more fully I am not sure how to score it as it is either horrific , offensive, rape filled , misogyny or it is a satire on rap and focuses on men's mental health issues....

Der US-amerikanische Rapper Eminem legte mit diesem dritten Soloalbum ein Werk vor, das den Hardcore Hip-Hop und Horrorcore des Jahres 2000 auf eine neue Stufe hob. Aufgenommen in mehreren Studios rund um Detroit – darunter The Mix Room, Encore Studios, Larrabee Sound Studios, Chung King, The Record Plant und 54 Sound – entstand die Platte in einem kreativen Intensivmarathon von kaum zwei Monaten, überwiegend produziert von Dr. Dre und Eminem selbst sowie den Bass Brothers, The 45 King und Mel-Man. Aftermath Entertainment, Interscope Records und Eminems eigenes Shady Records verantworteten den Vertrieb. Inhaltlich ist das Album eine Abrechnung mit dem eigenen Ruhm, mit Kritikern, mit der Boulevardpresse und mit persönlichen Dämonen zugleich. „Stan" – mit Dido als Stimme der Vernunft – seziert die pathologische Seite des Fanseins mit einer Präzision, die kaum ein anderer Track der Rap-Geschichte erreicht. Daneben tobt sich Eminem auf „Kim" und „Kill You" in fiktiven Gewaltfantasien aus, während „The Real Slim Shady" und „The Way I Am" die Absurdität des Popbetriebs karikieren. Der Kontrast zwischen diesen Polen macht die LP so schwer einordenbar – und so fesselnd. Kommerziell brach das Album sämtliche Rekorde: 1,76 Millionen verkaufte Exemplare in der ersten Woche allein in den USA, Grammy für das beste Rap-Album 2001, Platin-Regen auf mehreren Kontinenten. Die Provokation war dabei kein Selbstzweck, sondern Mittel zur Verdichtung – wer genau hinhört, findet unter dem Lärm ein Album voller innerer Logik, schwarzen Humors und überraschend verletzlicher Momente. The Marshall Mathers LP ist kein angenehmes Album – aber es ist ein notwendiges: ein Dokument einer Figur, die das Widersprüchlichste verlangte und genau das lieferte.

6/10 (changed to 3 from 2)

An all time classic, even if some of the shock elements feel a bit dated.

Emm, IT S EMINEM, okey, so obviously it s a high grade, maybe not 5 but 4 for sure. I would give 4.5 but i cant😭. So yeah, it s nice and there are a few popular songs.

😅🤢 I like some of his work but.....not much. He's a provocateur and I don't wanna feed the troll.

eh, stan saves it

It’s not for me but I respect it

This is the first rap album that I feel I've truly understood. I think part of the reason I enjoy Eminem more than others is because his music is more relatable than other rap artists. I'm not one to use drugs, drive fancy cars, enjoy the night life of the city, or get on fights. I do, however, understand strained relationships, being misunderstood, and many of the other topics from this album.

So um. That happened. Not what I personally would write music about, but it works. Honestly, it's a really good album and I enjoyed it. Very harsh and scary, but it can be fun. Very interesting to say the least.

Álbum bem consistente do Eminem. Divertido e raivoso. CVJ Vivian.

Yes! Good!!@

Al principio lo venía disfrutando, pero despues como que entendí porque lo idolatran niños de 12 años

Really good actually. I think that I've avoided a lot of Eminem albums because his later output doesn't interest me. But his first three are pretty good

Don't make me go through an album by Eminem ever again.

Classic - tonally dark record.

Eminem, quel rappeur!! Les albums de rap toujours trop long à mon goût, tu coupes 15-20 min à l’album et ça n’enlève rien à la qualité. Kim, Stan, Kill You.. bcp de bon morceau, et du moins bien comme le refrain de Under influence qui fait edgy ado. 4-/5

Too much homophobia

a masterpiece 🖕

I have mixed feelings about this album. I’ll start with what I liked. I thought the actual rapping was really good. There’s something about Eminem’s flow that tickles my brain in just the right way. I think Stan is a masterpiece of a song. The storytelling was so captivating, that I stopped what I was doing to listen to it with my full attention. That is where my notable praises end. A big aspect of this album that I didn’t particularly like was the lyrics. The over the top lyrics felt like a gimmick, and I got tired of it by the end of the album. I’m not the biggest fan of his style of saying anything for shock value, and to make people mad. There may be some artistic merit to it that I’m not seeing, but it comes off as immature to me. Shock value can only get you so far. I didn’t necessarily hate this album, but I don’t see myself ever listening to it again.

This is a hard one. I understand what hes going for, but its a bit too mutch. The character wise bit kinda is drowned by the sheer amount of nastyness without a clear nudge to the fact it should be character based. Rapping techique wise its great, cant say the music isnt wel produced. But would never put it up myself. A very influencial album without a doubt but man this will age worse and worse i think. Reflection material

An angry whiteboy raps about being mad and disliking being famous for more than an hour straight. It's an interesting timecapsule and a classic, but I would not call it "good". It's bad, raunchy and that's exactly the point. It's made by a rotten guy, made for a rotten audience in a rotten system. In that way it has some interesting things to say as a culture study. However the copious amount of homophobia en misogyny (even for its time) makes it a hard listen and hard to defend. The runtime doesn't help as this record can't seem to decide whether it wants to be gangster rap, horrorcore or some kind of satire. Some tracks (such as Remember me and Amityville) could easily be cut as I don't see what they bring to the record. In general when people express Eminem is their favourite rapper I see it as a major red flag. Either they don't know enough about rap to have a favourite rapper (which is fine) or they are racist. Because Eminem doesn't have the best beats, the best flow or the best bars. But he is angry and white. If you identify with this music, I have bad news for you. All that being said, Eminem has some bars, good flow and brings a very infectious manic energy to this record. This energy can be too much such as in "Kim" which sounds like a horror movie made into a song, but that's a matter of taste I guess. There is a reason from among all the white boys trying to stake their claim in the rap game, only Eminem made it big. If the record was a little shorter, more self-concious or more overtly critical of the systems that created Slim this record could easily be a 9/10, but it just isn't. 7/10

The homophobic and misogynistic elements can be hard to swallow, even when you view this as a product of the time. Some of the lines he drops here would rightfully get him clowned on if released today. The line about being 'heterophobic' is particularly embarrassing and its a shame it happens at the end of the record to ensure it leaves a bad taste on the listener as the album concludes. When the album isn't being bigoted, the rhymes are quite funny and witty. Eminem has a great flow and delivers his rhymes with a shed load of intensity. He can get dark and is not afraid to rap about some ugly stuff, even when some of it may just be shocking for shock value's sake. The aggression he brings on 'Kim' is actually rather frightening and he shows his talent for storytelling on the mega-hit 'Stan'. The album might be a bit bloated for me to return to in full anytime soon, but there is enough strong tracks on here like 'The Way I Am', 'The Real Slim Shady' and 'Marshall Mathers' here to say that I enjoyed my time with this overall.

More important than good. Eminem is a good rapper but his lyrics are often juvenile

6.5/10 I understand why it was significant

A defiant classic in rap music.

Mietteet ennen kuuntelua: Kun tämä tuli aikoinaan, tätä tuli kuunneltua aikas paljonkin. Mitenhän nyt, viimekerrasta on paljon aikaa. Kuuntelun jälkeen: Ihan hyvää kamaa se on. Hittibiisit on hittimäisiä vieläkin. Emminemmi kuulostaa parhaalta ku se on vihanen.

Klassikko tämäkin, ihan hyvää kiukkusta räppiä, paikoitellen vähän raskasta ja cringeä, mutta niin kai se ideakin on olla jotenkin tunteita herättävää. Kuunteli ihan mielellään kyllä alusta loppuun.

This was an iconic album for me in college and thought that it was the best rap album of all time before I started really listening to hip hop

Sekavan vuosituhannen taitteen ajan soundtrackia. Angstinen nuoren miehen soundtrack. Ajalta, kun matkustettiin paljon junalla ja julkisilla walkmanit korvilla. Eli kyllä,, tätä levyä tuli kuunneltua paljon. Tällä pystyi ruokkimaan orastavaa vihaa kaikkea ja kaikkia kohtaan. Ja vaikka itse olin bändijätkä niin Eminem oli ja on rapun punkkia ja heavy metallia. Eminemin Flow oli jotain ihan uutta. Älyttömän kovaa tavaraa. Paljon muistoja ja toki myös sekoilua. Rohkea, mullistava levy. 4/5

Kann verstehen, warum es gut ist, aber ich mag die Stimmung nicht

Hard hittin’!

This is more a calculated marketing piece than actual art. By very deliberate intent, it's provocative and polarizing. I would describe the experience akin to taking a nice, hot, soothing shower with toxic sewage water. The rundown: (-) Shock value for the sake of shock value. Lame. (+) Transparent self-awareness about using said tactic. Respectable. (+) Beats and flow are tight and make you want to listen again. (-) Lyrics are trite and make you want to never listen again. (+) Overall production. (-) Skits. (+) Tapping into and exposing some very real, very ugly human nature and hypocrisy. (-) Ultimately being just another artifact in that pile of ugliness and hypocrisy. Even though it deserves it (practically begs for it), I'm actually not going to fail this since it DID achieve what it set out to do: prove that people are easily triggered and manipulated. Any points for aesthetics? Nah.

There is a notable amount of nostalgia to this album. So there is that. I wouldn’t consider this Eminem’s best work. This also leaned into more shock value than intrigue.

It was ok.

Mostly unbearable. Dido is the only redeeming thing on this album for me.

This sophomore album from Eminem has high peaks and some low points too, as if often the case for Em. However it unarguably cemented his place in the hip hop mainstream and influenced generations of rappers to come. This is actually an album my mum had on CD when I was growing up so I'm very familiar. Personally the Eminem show is a more cohesive and iconic hip hop album but the importance of this project can't be denied.

Sounds like a petulant angry kid…mad about the world…self absorbed. It would have appealed to young kids especially those experiencing abuse and bullying. So there is a place for very personal unpleasant experiences to be shared. For me it’s a masterpiece of horror with homophobic, misogynistic infantile wordplay…a litany of abusive words. Ugly.

This is undeniably a very influential album. I think Eminem definitely has a skill for rhyming, and there is something infectious and cathartic about the personality of his music. The song "Stan" is so infamous that people use the word Stan to refer to someone who is a fan of someone or something to the extent of losing all reason. A few of these songs definitely could've been left out, but the better ones definitely have an impact. There's definitely a quality of marketing sensationalism that we have found on other rap albums, but I also think there's some extent of genuine, creative expression. I can imagine he was a comforting outlet for people that grew up with similar struggles. I think arguments could be made whether such an outlet is a net positive or a negative. I mostly tend to agree with the opinion that words are just words, and I appreciate when people and artists aren't afraid to be real, but again, in some moments, it just feels like needless sensationalism to rake in a profit

Ummm, . . . no. I'm tempted to say this isn't so much music as . . . confession? Or public therapy? He's sort of bleeding negative emotions, which isn't very interesting (interesting only in the way that a car wreck is interesting), and feels selfish and needy. I mean, a few bits are kind of clever, but, to get to them, you have to wade through mountains of sludge; it's SO not worth it. I just would never choose to listen to this; life is too short, and there's too much good music out there. 1 star. Catchy groove on 'Real Slim Shady.' But then it just keeps repeating, and gets old fast. Like the whole album. Had to force myself to listen to the whole thing.

I don't really like it, but I have to give credit for it's cultural staying power. It's ironic that Eminem is so aware on this album of his influence on his fanbase, and yet the worst thing about him is his influence. It's unfortunate that he inspired a generation of white rappers. It's unfortunate that his whole shtick is being a bad person. He's a very talented lyricist, vocalist, and there are a lot of well-produced songs here that people still love more than twenty years later. Not for me though

It took me 4 times to finish this album and then I paused my project for 3 weeks.

An album I would replace this one with: A Tribe Called Quest - Midnight Marauders (1993) 5/5

I’d forgotten how much i enjoy this album. It did get me thinking though, how much great art is borne of fragile male ego - imagine what you could create if you weren’t entitled little Fuckboys!! Crazy. Anyway, I’ve decided I’ll be knocking off a full star for inexcusable slurs so this is stuck at 4 for me.

5 for nostalgia, 1 because this really didn't age well

오 .. 힙합

will never listen

Absolute nostalgic banger

Good but HARD listen. 3.5/5

Rating: 7/10 Review: Torn on this one. Eminem is an excellent rapper. The production on this album is equally amazing. I like how most of it sounds. I just can’t get past some of the content. Listen again?: Maybe, probably just individual songs over the whole album

Holy I didn't realize how big this album is... Stan is a great song and always felt like it came from later in his career than this album.

A perfect summary of the American zeitgeist in the year 2000. This album dropped the summer before I started middle school in middle America, it was everywhere and a real curiosity for a pre-adolescent. I haven't listened to Eminem in 20+ years, but it was interesting to revisit since this was such a cultural touch-stone as I was growing up. The lyrical content that caused so much controversy upon release is suprisingly insightful as a critique of the culture that was outraged by it, yet didn't have the self-reflection to look inward at the moral rot that would hollow out the American dream over the next two decades. It's hard not to think about how much we've lost as a country over the last 26 years since this album was released, and how at our core as a country, we are all worse, more sick and depraved, than Eminem ever was.

Qué locura que 26 años después siga siendo tan impactante. La narrativa y los sonidos ambientales son de otro nivel. Igual la crudeza de las letras me sigue pegando igual o más fuerte. Brillante pero bien dificil de digerir

Es un buen disco, me gustaría poder entender la letras, el bajo lo es todo.

Es un gran álbum pero me cuesta escucharlo. En cierto sentido es un logro generar tanta incomodidad. La verdad es de los pocos que escucho canciones sueltas porque hay algunas que prefiero esquivarlas (kim) No queda guardado.

more expletives than a touretts conversation overall not a bad cd

The zeitgeist of 90s Optimism didn't just die suddenly with four aircraft in September of 2001. It was already wounded badly by the pickaxes of Woodstock 99, Columbine, and this album. First time at Fight Club? You have to fight.

“These people think it’s a crime to tell them what’s on my mind”. Well bud. Everything on your mind is a crime.