Reviews (page 2 of 15)
Beste rap album dat ik ken. Ik ken er eigenlijk maar 1 🤭 wel veel goede liedjes
An absolute classic...that I've never actually listen all the way through! Glad I had the chance to today because what an album!!! Of course, I knew a lot of these already, but it was great to hear the album in its entirety. So many clever lyrics/rhymes that are synonyms with Eminem at this point!
Good
It’s a classic. I remember being appalled at the lyrics until I got used to Eminem
Beats are good, flow is fire, but Eminem’s entire roleplaying trauma-dumping schtick is so cringe, especially on tracks like “Kim”.
Альбом прям написал Слим Шейди. Мат, насилие, гомофобия, сексизм - все в этом альбоме
eminem is sharp on this album. points off for weak features and length. 3.5
I listened to this for the second time again to see why everyone loves this album and it's so unhinged and anti anything that's been made at this time. So it's getting a 5
Slim Shady in the house. The Goat. Strong album from Eminem, from legendary early classics to some more lyrically dense songs. This album has a ton. I enjoy the little lyrical touches he always seems to sneak in-between his lines. There are a few low songs on this album. Like the song where he murders Kim, it feels like just raw rage that anything else. But I still keep the album in high regard. Keep it up white boy
Theres like 3 or 4 really good songs on this album, 10 or so that are just good but not great. The remaining are kinda fucked up but that's what you expect from old school em. I don't think this album is as good as everyone says it is, but it's still definitely worth a listen, even for non rap fans. Controversial perhaps but I like Slim Shady LP better. It's a bit more unhinged. Might as well go all the way fucked up.
I don't think I can say anything positive about this crap
This doesnt sound half as good when youre above the age of 13
This would be a 4, but this album is so long. Still "Stan" is on this album so it can't be less than a 3 3.5
Drug Ballad still holds up
Slaps you in the face. It’s so damn catchy. Tongue in cheek lyrics, that are sometimes disturbing, but I think that’s the point in many cases. His persona is original. You just have to crank it up and let go! F’n love this! Just a guilty pleasure I suppose. I hadn’t listened to it in so long.
Cringey edgelord lyrics. Some tracks had a decent beat
yeah
Coming back to hate on this
This is so dog
Have I listened to this album before No How familiar am I with this album Unfamiliar How do I feel about this artist? Neutral Pre-Listen Thoughts: I don't really know hip-hop/rap. very well, but I know people like Eminem. Favorite track(s): Stan Post-Listen Thoughts: This started out as a four, but then gradually worked its way down to a three. I think it could’ve been a little bit shorter. For an album to be this long I expected it to have more substance.
För mig är detta en nostalgisk resa tillbaka till när jag var en wigga, bra beats, ganska cringe texter men ändå många bra klassiker som Stan, Who knew, the real slim shady och många fler.
Not saying a couple of these beats don’t get me singing at a party like a frat boy but I just can’t take this guy seriously 😂 the dick slurping noises really ruined my morning
I'm gonna have to come back to this when I have energy to spare to listen to eminem's kermit ass voice for 40 straight minutes
more of a 2,5 past the age of 14 i never really had a eminem moment, some of the beats go pretty hard but this must be the most on the nose ass album ever made. i fucking HATE diegetic ass story sound effects in music (like the pen scribbling in stan) and this album seems to distrust the listener enough that it needs to be in every other song
Although Eminem will always be nostalgic and has some bangers, this hasn’t aged well. Can’t stop thinking the crowd for this was mostly white American Pie dudes, hard listen
a painful listen (derogatory) bet i wouldve loved this if i was 12 years old one and done for me, had some good beats tho
I've loved Eminem since I heard My Name Is when I was 10. He's my favorite rapper. I really liked this album. It has one of my favorite Eminem songs on it, Stan. That song introduced me to Dido, and I loved the video because Devon Sawa was in it (childhood crush). I also own and love the songs The Real Slim Shady, Marshall Mathers, and The Way I Am.
I really love reading the reviews on this. I think there are a lot of nostalgic songs here but... it is pretty dorky and represents some of the worse parts of the early 2000s
3 stars Listening to this album is like watching a 2000s Judd Apatow movie. If you were there at the time, you get it. A lot of things don’t age well, but there is also a lot to appreciate. There is clear skill and craft put into this. But it’s a little over long and over the top. “Kim” in particular is just unnecessary in its entire existence. Just shocking for the point of being shocking. Not a masterpiece, but significant enough to have earned a position here.
no thakn you
white boy tries to be edgy
Pretty uncomfortable listen for me. Am I a pearl clutcher now?
long but good
I'm way too old for this edgy shit.
This is my first Eminem project and I enjoyed it wayyy more than I thought. The beats are so fun and his storytelling is insane. The constant fucking in the ass stuff brings the rating down
Stunning. Not a massive rap fan in general but this is stunning! Dark lyrics on top of beautifully crafted backing tracks creates something dark and armospheric. Stan is a great highlight as is Marshall Mathers. Kim is one if the most unsettling listens i can ever remember. Grear stuff.
juvenile but talented
Started on 10/1, Finished on 10/13 I want to like this album. I really like the first half of the album but the second half gets so grotesque and aggressive that I struggled to finish it. I liked a lot of songs from the album, but overall rate it at a 3/5. Listened to the whole album but skipped the Ken Kaniff Skit Favorites: Kill You, Stan, Who Knew, The Way I Am, The Real Slim Shady, Bitch Please, Under the Influence
Damn. DAMN What a good album
1.5
One of my least favourite artists. He can Rap, but I do not like his lyrics or style. “Stan”is the only good song on this album and there’s a couple that have decent beats chore to listen to 1.5/5
Been a classic, knew every song. Embarrassing to listen to in 2026 tho
Lyrically great
Šlykštus agresyvus vaikas, žinau kad jei nebūtų tapęs populiarus, gal mano šeima nebūtų tokia išsiskyrusi.
This album makes how people (boys, teens) interacted with the world in the 2000s make a lot more sense to me; there's a lot of evocative imagery here Eminem is trying to tell a deeper narrative with, that can easily be and was taken on as a shallow, aggressive identity; similar to south park, gta. If we ignore how this was (mis?)interpreted (a little generous to eminem) this is a 4/5, memorable, enjoyable, and resonant, but its hard to distance it from how its vile language was taken literally.
s falloff isch genuinely crazy
Linguistic genius. Doesn’t quite hit like it did as a 16 year old boy.
Eminem is undeniably talented, and that shows through here, but even at the time I just couldn't with the sophomoric shit lyrics. He does definitely have a way with words, and if you can just go with it it's tolerable, and even great.
The real slim shady at his finest
not the type of music I like, still a couple of good songs here but overall nothing that I would listen to again. A 2 star because of the 2 songs I liked
I liked it until I saw someone acknowledge that it's just an album where the artist complains about haters and asks people to suck his dick. Also the homophobia
eminem might just have changed my view on rap
i cant believe gen z is trying to cancel eminem
This was definitely an interesting album. Very difficult to rate. I find some things are great, while others are...not that good. Starting with the good: Eminem's ability to write rhymes is spectacular. I also really like his phrasing. Also on the positive side, some of the "political" songs: "Who Knew" or "The Way I Am". I also like the humor he uses in some of the songs. The lyrics of "Stan" (probably my favourite track) are also great. Apart from this, I also enjoyed some other tracks like "Kill You", "The Real Slim Shady", "Criminal", or "Marshal Mathers". On the negative side, I'm not a big fan of the musical choices. And, to be honest, I find some of the allegedly transgressive stuff (especially when related to sex) pretty childish, or even ridiculous. The transgressive themes work better when related to violence ("Kim") or substance abuse ("Drug Ballad" is ok). That being said, I'm already in my fifties (and I was not into hip-hop back in the nineties). I guess I would've enjoyed this much more if I had listened to this when I was in my twenties. In any case, I think this is clearly in the 4 star range. Probably not if based exclusively on my personal taste or preferences, but this is objectively interesting and original.
Yes
I love this and hate it at the same time. I'm coming to Kim as I'm writing and I've listened to it a time separate from this so I know how terrible it is. Cannot get past how offensive these lyrics are. They are offensive, inappropriate, homophobic, and misogynist. I am not fond of how he talks about killing and beating his wife. He even talks about rape a few times. I tried so hard not to like the album but I cannot help but tap my foot to it, which obviously means that this is a great album. I think that he gets how sad he was at the time because when I listen to ts, I feel deep in depression. no highlights because I can't bear to. 7/10 cuz I can't bear to give a rating any higher. P.S. Eminem is still a bully white boy who can't get get bullied for race or gender very easily.
Album #209: Eminem – The Marshall Mathers LP ⭐⭐⭐⭐ I absolutely hate people telling me that I should be offended by something. Signposting it. I find it to be the most hacky thing. And this album has aged very strangely in my opinion, because back then there wasn’t really a cancel culture like there supposedly is now. I personally don’t believe in cancel culture, because a lot of these guys are out there with these huge platforms trying to get cancelled, saying whatever they want while also saying you can’t say the things that they’re saying. Ricky Gervais for example! And nothing ever happens to them. And they know nothing is ever going to happen to them! It’s so hacky, so boring, and so unbelievably unfunny and unentertaining to me. So when you’ve got Eminem here talking about how much I should be offended by all the stuff that he’s saying and all the outrageousness, it just rubs me wrong. Not in an offensive way, in a boring, eye-rolling kind of way. But I suppose it’s not really his fault because this was a different time. He did get in trouble for some of the stuff he said. He nearly got banned from going to Canada. He had the government kind of speak out against him. But at the end of the day, he was still able to make this music. He wasn’t cancelled, and it just goes to show you can say whatever the fuck you want, especially when you’ve got enough talent and charisma about you. He’s just an amazing rapper. He’s an incredible wordsmith, very witty, quite funny and very creative. I probably like this less than The Slim Shady LP, which I’ve reviewed already, because I feel like he’s trying to one-up himself with how disgusting and crazy it all is. It’s slightly try-hardy. The juxtaposition between that and how he doesn’t want to be bothered by fans, while also seemingly not giving a fuck, just kind of confuses me. It’s a bit jarring. Similar to The Slim Shady LP, he’s actually not my favourite thing about it. He’s got a very musical way of rapping, which I really love, but the music itself is the best part. The production is top-notch. It’s a fantastic-sounding album, and the choice of beats suits his tone and his music so well. It’s goofy. It’s not overly serious. The little asides and samples here and there are really funny throughout. Great beats. After this album I lost interest in his music. I think he got too serious and too self-referential. He was already getting that way here. This whole album is about himself for the most part, about all the work that he’s done before and how offended we should all be. He lost track somewhere after this album, in my opinion. But he is capable of amazing songs. Stan has gone into the dictionary now, but when songs get that well-known that they enter the zeitgeist, you almost forget what got them there in the first place. Listening to it today, it is an amazing piece of work. It’s a big outlier on the album as this serious song, and it’s a little jarring in context. But as a standalone piece, it’s phenomenal. So yeah, great album. Really enjoyed it. It’s very entertaining. It’s impossible to be offended by because it’s so ridiculous, in my opinion. And that should have been known when everyone else was getting upset about it back then. How could you take something like this seriously? It’s impossible.
Iconic album with a couple of mega-hits. Stan is so iconic that it created a new term in the English language. The Real Slim Shady is probably the biggest rap hit of that decade. I think it really set the trajectory for being a rap GOAT.
Итс э риал слим шейки, плз стенд ар плз стенд ар Но я прихуел с 72 минут белого репа
291.
Probably a 4 in reality but I'll top it up with nostalgia.
FUCK slim shady im so fucking scared how many of the things he raps about did he actually do like is he a serial rapist or just pretending nevertheless eminems early stuff is so catchy icl and i used to be a big fan at like 13
Bien.
So much anger, violence, and misogyny. I'm not into it. But it's clearly a very influential and culturally important album. That (and the fact that some of the music is pretty catchy) are what elevates it from a 1 to a 2 for me (although I'd do 1.5 if that was an option).
Sacando Stan que es un tema que está bueno, no pincha ni corta. Una vergonha!
This album does remind me of the kind of people I hated in middle school but you can't deny it sounds good
Enimem is so incredibly talented and one of the best artists out there, in my opinion. I remember when this album came out and how high my expectations were based on his previous work. While this record can be really hard to listen to at times, especially as a female, Eminem is playing a character much like an actor plays a part. The character is certainly drawing on his own life experiences though and this makes the album really painful and makes me empathetic to all the pressure and criticism Eminem was trying to navigate. His lyrics show a real vulnerability and anger that is covering significant pain, but he channels these into profound beats and words combined with his amazing voice and rap ability. This record will always be legendary to all, but to me personally as well.
7.8/10. Em's second album, it was fueled by hitting it big, being discovered by Dr. Dre, and going more into drug problems and relationship issues with Kim, particularly surrounding their daughter, Hailie. There is an obvious influence of anger, sadness, drug use, and newfound success, all shown heavily, but the album gets particularly dark for the tail end. I enjoyed it, I haven't listened to much of his other albums, only the hits, but this one still had the rawness that some of hit later albums lack (especially when he got clean), as the anger at the world was still with him.
Gave up half way through track 3 - there’s only so many rape references that I am willing to put up with. And that would be none.
Trying to shock or just fucked up? Not sure. Elements of humour in most of the songs.
Just not my music
This was an interesting one. I am usually quite lyrics-deaf: I guess that's an advantage in this case. However genuinely awful or provocative (is there such a big difference between being a violent misogynistic homophobic incel or pretending to be one?) the stuff Eminem was rapping here, I could enjoy the music, rhythm and flow (not Kim: that's too hard to stomach even for a lyrics-deaf person). Then I went back and try to listen to what he was actually saying and found most of it stupidly funny. While the Slim Shady LP was repetitive and boring to my ears, I found this one way catchier and more enjoyable. (And I usually hate hip-hop, probably because of the lyrics-deaf thing...)
It's actually insane how many Hip Hop albums can be a 5/5. I think this says a lot about the genre of Hip Hop as a whole, especially most recently from the 90s and onwards. I mean compare it to other genres that have been spitting 10/10 classics since the 60s and even before then. That being said. I think that this album has to be rated at a 5/5 for it's influence and it's staying power from the 2000s onwards. It's tough to think of ONE of Eminem's albums not being listed as a 5/5 (but honestly, it's closer to 4.5/5 and higher) THE POINT IS TO MAKE YOU UNCOMFORTABLE. THE POINT IS TO MAKE YOU MAKE A SCRUNCHED FACE AND BE DISGUSTED WITH HIM. THE POINT IS TO MAKE YOU FEEL LIKE THIS IS DATED, BECAUSE IT FUCKING IS DATED. IT'S A TESTAMENT TO HOW DIFFERENT THE CULTURE WAS MOVING IN 2000. IT'S A HISTORICAL MOMENT WHERE HIP HOP TRANSCENDED FROM THE EAST COAST V WEST COAST, BLACK COMMUNITY, AND GANGSTA RAP ERA OF THE 90S. A WHITE DUDE HAD TO RAP HIS ASS OFF AND SAY SOME OF THE MOST UNHINGED SHIT IN ORDER TO GET PEOPLE TO PAY ATTENTION TO HIM. LOL. YOU'RE MISSING THE FUCKING POINT IF YOU RATE THIS A 1/5. ALIENS HAVE TO HEAR THIS SHIT. (at least one of the 2 between MMLP and SSLP by Eminem, tbh I'll list the other one as a 4). BUT DUDE YOU'RE MISSING THE POINT, THIS ALBUM IS WHACKED OUT AND IT HAS TO BE ON THIS LIST. The production knocks because Dr. Dre was experienced and a FORCE at what he was doing. Eminem was going stupid on the bars on this one, and spit his way to creating 2 iconic songs in Stan and The Real Slim Shady. The former is literally the reason why it's a word that's used as slang today to refer to crazy people who love a pop culture figure. I don't know man. Kim is one of the most "free speech premium" moments of all time. An unhinged dramatic recreation of domestic abuse on fucking wax that is soooo off putting that I doubted leaving 5 stars on this thing, but THAT'S THE FUCKING POINT. It's closer to a 4.75/5 but I gotta round up. It's gotta be on this list. Even if you've watched FD's video on white rappers and realize that yeah man...this dude definitely benefitted from being a white rapper who rapped his ass off. Whatever man. Politics aside, it's a stupid moment in history that has to be accounted for. He was a cult figure. If we cut this album list down to 100, he would have one album on it. It's that serious. Fucking kids in (insert 3rd world nation here) give a fuck about this record still. It's fucking crazy. You don't gotta love it, I get it.
For all the positives on this album - Stan is a great song, and Who Knew is a pretty solid social critique explaining that societies problems go way beyond one man with a microphone - there are just too many things that make this an uncomfortable listen. Kim is an horrific listen, far more so than Kill You, and although some of the observations about other singers can start out with some amusement, for instance Christina Aguilera and J-Lo, they get carried on to a nasty level that's no longer entertaining. It's misogynistic and homophonic and too aggressive for me, and while I agree with the comments on parenting, and I appreciate that a lot of this may have been quite therapeutic for Eminem, it's not nice. Eminem may not have been the cause of the problems, but this is not a solution. 1 star.
great but tweak
je pensais vraiment détester donc c'est une agréable surprise si on enlève le ken kaniff skit qui me DEGOUTE
It would be difficult to write a more immature album.
Other than interesting rhythms and instrumentations, a total lack of any redeeming social value
3.5
I just don't like Eminem...
Incredible stuff, and still fresh after all these years
4/5
🫡
Great delivery. The beats and the storytelling really pull this together. Very intense but great album.
fuck sitä ja fuck tätä. Fuck Marshall Mathers, en mä tätä jaksa kuunnella. Hittisinkkubiisit on hyviä ja meneviä mutta ei tätä toista tuntia jaksa kuunnella.
4/5
The song “Kim” could have been a therapy session.
Great album, great story telling and lots of hits
Quite violent and of its time. So homophobic it becomes gaym
This is very conflicting. It's absolutely terrible and we've had to skip songs for the first time in over 400 albums. But then again, Stan is incredible! If you did a greatest hits of this album and got rid of the blatant homophobia (not just language, but sentiments as well), it would be great. Who cares that you don't care what we think Marshall? It's horrible.
Strong start, middling middle, forgettable end. Why were rap albums during the c.d. period so long....
MMLP is a technical phenomenon undercut by content that is impossible for me to defend. Stan is a masterpiece. It's storytelling and the escalating weight of the story are magnificent, right through to the tragic end. Elsewhere though, Kim and Kill You aren't edgy. They're rehearsed violence against women played dead straight. The "Slim Shady is Satire" defence is weak. Satire only truly works if the audience gets the distance, and plenty have failed to understand the nuance in the character. True satire doesn't punch down against the already oppressed. It punches up against power regardless of consequences. It gets 3*, because musically this is a landmark record in Hip-Hop that most records will fail to surpass. Ethically, it's not something I can give the absolute seal of approval to.
3 - decent
Stan was decent but outside of that everything else was awful edgy trash.
I was in high school when Eminem first blew up, but I could not stand him at the time. Now, a quarter century later, I have developed a lot of respect for the man as an artist. There's a reason why this album was so overplayed back in the early 2000s. Em's lyrical cleverness is at times jaw dropping. And his delivery/performance of said lyrics is at times playful and energetic, and other times harsh and venomous. Brilliant record if you can put aside your feelings about what he's actually rapping about. Highlights: "Stan", "The Way I Am", and "Kill You".
Many tracks are bangers - but the misogyny knocks off at least 1 star. Regardless, I do like MM, though I'm embarrassed to admit it
Broidi osaa tehä musiikkia mutta sanotukset ei oo mun mieleen. Siis musiikillisesti hieno teos, ja valtava osa popkulttuuria. Mutta en aio kuunnella uudestaan. Sanotukset on todella täynnä vihaa.
what a misogynistic and homophobic album
At what point does extreme depictions of violence, homophobia, and misogyny stop being defensible under the lens of satire? I imagine around the time you name the album after your real name instead of your alter-ego character. Did this list really need more than one Eminem album? I got the idea after listening to Slim Shady. Why does this list need two albums with the same basic content?
Favorite Track: The Real Slim Shady
This proves conclusively that a white guy is fully capable of making gangsta rap every bit as crass as his black brethren. While the rapping and beats/tunes are fine in and of themselves, the content fails to rise above the usual fare (tons of misogyny and homophobia, and apparently his favorite catchphrase is “Suck my dick”, which he repeats like he gets a royalty every time he says it). And his contempt for the listener fairly jumps out of the speakers. We are told that we are suckers if we buy his album, and are invited to just shut the fuck up and listen. Thanks, but I think I will have to decline both offers. Glad I heard this, but don’t need to ever hear it again. What unmitigated shit this is.
classic
Stan and Real Slim Shady are very good and really important. Like Stan has been introduced into the lexicon. The ultimate fan culture critique. But, Jesus, these other songs feel less like satire and more just gross and mean spirited.
There is no doubt the music is racist, sexist, misogynistic, and homophobic. Eminem's actions raised questions about how homophobic or racist he really was - less so about how misogynistic and sexist. Do I like this because I'm separating the artist from the art? No. I guess I'm just genuinely aware of how many of these "isms" occur in our entire culture, frequently, but then cease to matter when it's someone we want to defend (I am looking at you supporters of Johnny Depp who failed to see they both sounded toxic as fuck). All the same, I WAS an angry white kid with a shitty environment, living in homes and dealing with "the system." So I am half gay, liberal, and feminist and also hypocritical, because this album is special to me. It was my transition from Prozzak to rage. So join me, Saturday People, in admitting you kind of like it too.* * The writer of this review would like you to know that they do not condone, endorse, support, or take responsibility for any of the words contained in this album.
1001 albums to hear before Marshall matters 185# I can't hear the gimmicky shouty angry rapping of Eminem and be OH YEAHH THIS SOUNDS GOOD. nop, he never was an artist i admired and it continues that way. I kinda have a weird small pleasure seeing him nowadays putting out albums unequivocally bad like Revival, it's my moment of 'i knew it' Well, i don't despise all his tracks. Stan is really good, but it almost owes all it's credit to Dido's sample. His pen work is really good. I can't say the contrary, but the performance... is really not for me. I liked the 9 mile movie though, it's pretty good.
Was ready to give this a 5 but the relisten was hard. What was fresh, incendiary and subversive in the 90s reads try-hard edgelord today. And I listened to it today :(
Story telling is unmatched, some bits have not aged graciously, but im sure he does not give a shit. Dre's production from the good ol days. I'm bias because this was my childhood
This is very intense.
Behind the edgy lyrics are some bangers and funny/sarcastic lines. Some songs are rather forgettable though 7/10
Very weird to revisit 25 years later! The thing about Eminem on this album is how much he’d like to remind you how edgy and dangerous he is at all times, that kinda blunts the effect. Then he writes a banger like Stan and it turns out it’s not him but his rabid fans who are also in love with him. Speaking of which he has all these homophobic lyrics then says on his biggest hit that it’s fine for gays to marry which was an opinion very ahead of its time in 2000. It’s nice that Eminem has gotten his act together and also has standard normie lib politics now, glad he didn’t go the Kid Rock route.
Ma Eminem legenda. Vrh album i brutalni hitovi. Čika čika Slim Shady
Some classics on here but a good 40-50% of this album has aged terribly. Kim alone knocked off a star for me. So tired of hip hop skits having sex skits. Good beats and samples
I enjoyed the first half at least. The second half wore me down and I wanted it to be over quicker.
After the first song I wanted to give him a wedgie and shove him in a locker. By the end I wanted to hit him with my car. The beats are good and the lyrics are… I don’t wanna say “clever” but like… the rhymes and wordplay and all are really good but the subject matter is atrocious. Like, the Drug Ballad had some decent commentary and stuff… so he can write meaningful songs but instead he chooses to posture and preen and act like a shithead 8th grader.
An exceptionally good album that manages to be challenging, entertaining and provocative all at the same time. And I don’t have a nostalgic attachment- I was aware of it and knew the popular songs, but this was my first time listening to the whole thing.
Loved it. Loved the shock value and music is genuinely interesting
2 out of 5. A better effort than his debut but this is still a hard listen.
music is love
Fuck that Kim song thats some fucked up shit
Really struggled with this one. Like most people who grew up in the 00s I have a certain amount of nostalgic affection for the radio singles, but much of the rest of the album is a brutal slog of misogyny and violence and even knowing that those elements are part of the performance doesn't make them any easier to listen to.
Lyrically puerile, but technically awesome.
Okay, this is a tough one. On the one hand, Eminem is clearly at the top of his game on this record - he's a genuine wordsmith at several points, who absolutely deserves the accolades he's been given both inside the rap community and out. Loads of these songs are not first time listens for me, as growing up in the 2000s they were basically everywhere, despite the claims of "too hot for radio" throughout. And hell, 'Stan' has changed the vocabulary of a generation with its realistic depiction of an obsessed fan. So how can i not give it high marks? However, it is EASILY one of the most misogynistic, homophobic, crass, ableist, and omni-misanthropic records i have ever heard, and despite MM's attempts to have his cake and eat it ('oh, I'm not actually condoning this, it's all an act and a story, and you're dumb of you believe it'), it probably contributed much more heavily to the overall cultural negative opinion of minorities and sexualities than any fan would claim. I know that songs like these kept me firmly in the closet as a teenager, so how the hell can i give this any points? So yeah, awesome, awful, brilliant, terrible, three stars I guess.
I couldn't do it. Couldn't drop back into this album again -- I just didn't have it in me. It's brilliant for what it is, but Marshall Mathers' world just wasn't a place I wasn't to visit right now. I've heard it so many times.
yeah alright it was pretty good! nice album bub. This man is a menace! I want pictures of Eminem!
If literature and cinema can have their boogeymen, why can’t music? Eminem is a troll who mastered the art of rhyming. You’re repulsed by what he says but are amazed by how he says it. Hannibal Lecter and Patrick Bateman on wax. 4.5 star album but bumping it up for the pearl clutchers.
Two songs, in, so far pretty funny. After listening, there's about 2 good songs, and I don't really like rap.
Marshall Mathers is one of the best lyricists to put pen to paper. Not many albums can make you laugh, cringe, cheer, cry and think while also being enjoyable to listen to. A true unicorn album that deserves all the praise and controversy it seeks. Top tracks: Stan, The Way I Am, I'm Back, Under the Influence
No me gusta
Alternatively brilliant and purile, but what are you gonna do?
Okay
Ι λοβ ιτ, η αρχη ειναι φουλ τελεια και εχει και φουλ δυνατά κομματια και προφανώς καποια σεξιστικα
you know the genres feature on this site is a neat idea, it'd be cool to look at how you like a bunch of music and how you rate that music reflects your preference in different styles and movements. it could be a better metric than listening time, like the streaming services use, since that's just an engagement measurement and doesn't reflect appreciation or enjoyment. but then the problem of sampling method arises. you may be measuring based on a list written by some british guy who decided eminem and kanye west should represent hip hop.
Kannte von ihm bisher vor allem die Hits und finde alles darüber hinaus auch relativ unspektakulär. Kein schlechtes Album, aber auch nicht herausragend für mich.
Derbe, schlecht gealterte Sprache, einige grandiose Songs.
Jamais écouté avant. Je ne sais pas trop quoi penser de cet album. D'un côté, je dois bien admettre l'efficacité cathartique de ce déferlement de violence, parfois à la limite de l'insoutenable (Kim, au hasard). Que ce soit les textes, à la fois radicalement excessifs et parfaitement ciselés, le flow rageur d'Eminem qui semble cracher sa haine ou ses moqueries au visage de l'Amérique et de son hypocrisie puritaine, que les prods tout en noirceur qui l'accompagnent, tout concourt à un album réellement marquant. Sans parler, bien sûr, des incontestables tubes qu'il contient. De l'autre, balancer les pires horreurs possibles, les saloperies les plus violemment misogynes et homophobes, même "pour de faux", n'est-ce pas une forme de provocation très adolescente, très compatible, au dévut des années 2000 en particulier, avec des ambitions commerciales ? Beaucoup moins subversive, en somme, qu'elle prétend l'être ? D'ailleurs, l'album s'est vendu à des dizaines de millions d'exemplaires et est aujourd'hui considéré comme un classique, preuve qu'il n'est pas si dérangeant qu'il veut bien s'en donner l'air... Trois étoiles donc, pour l'incertitude. Top : Stan Flop : Amityville
Listened to this one a lot with my friends when we were young. We had no business at all listening to these lyrics at that age, but hey, it's Marshall Matters!
Almost gave this 3 stars cause I have some nostalgia for Stan and The Real Slim Shady, but then Kim happened and I was like nah 2 stars. The music itself is decent, but God are these lyrics outdated. Hell some of them were probably outdated when it released. Eminem is a talented musician, but his lyrics are plagued with misogyny and homophobia. ⭐️⭐️
I would say the shock factor of MMLP hits even harder today than it did back in 2000. Homophobia, mysogony, and the many vulgar words Eminem throws around are way less acceptable now. If the shock value is all Eminem brought to the table I think it would be easy to dismiss his work as something crass that has aged poorly and move on. But here's the thing, Eminem shines in spite of the crassness, not because of it. His groundbreaking wordplay, delivery, and manipulation of his lyrics allowed him to break through an enormous racial barrier in hip hop. Many regard him as the greatest rapper of all times and I think giving his debut album anything less that a 5/5 would be a disgrace.
For the first couple of tracks it can definitely feel like “haha screw the man I can say what I want and there’s more important things to focus on than the slurs and violence I rap about” and you can definitely see where the appeal is at least. Near the end of the record, I got real tired of all of the general bigotry and hatred. Slim really wants a reaction out of you, and even though there’s clearly more to the record, it is not easy to stomach everything that’s being said. There’s no denying Eminem’s intelligence and self-awareness in his rapping, and I can clearly see both sides of opinions on art like this, but you have to use your position of power as a successful artist and musician for something better than this.
Inte min musik, låter väldigt likadan hela skivan. Upprepande beats och loopar. Ordbajsande. Kill You och Stan bäst.
Stan was extraordinary at the time. A white rapper telling a story and splicing in a pop song as the chorus. He brought different cadences to rap, and a knack for quirky rhymes. I was struck by how basic some of the arrangements were, deliberately, to keep the attention on the vocals. There's lots of F yous, but little in the way of glorifying guns or mysogyny.
Nope
It’s too funny and clever. Tongue and cheek offensiveness
fun album if you don't take it too seriously
Actual cringefest millennials undefeated
Idk why so many of the songs needed to be about killing women
Would be pretty decent if I didn't speak English, produced very well but lyrics are really bad which unfortunately is a big deal for a rap album
Such a great album with a few of some of his most well known songs. Not my favorite album of his, but still an amazing album. Really was different then a lot of other albums around that time.
Sublime
Hit after hit!
Not a fan of this genre but Eminem is a better rapper than the mumble stuff that passes for hip hop these days.
This is really good. Slim shadt and Stan are iconic. Bit longer than I was expecting, but a really good album.
I really like Eminem’s voice and storytelling. I feel a bit mixed on this as an album. The Slim Shady personna is interesting as an artistic choice but has diminishing returns for me, and there are tracks like Kim that I respect artistically while never wanting to listen to again. Standout Tracks: Stan, The Real Slimy Shady Rating: 3
Would not buy
Lyrics please
the beats are good. the rhymes are clever and juvenile. the lyrical content is rough. welcome to 2000. mtv is playing britney spears, n*sync, eminem, "the thong song", "back that azz up", p.o.d., limp bizkit, papa roach and blink 182. america is truly a melting pot. luckily 9/11 would happen soon enough and sort it all out and we would all be better off in our relatively fast ascension into the christo-fascist, techno-surveillance pearl clutching landscape we've been in ever since (less an eight year reprieve, give or take) where country songs about jesus ruling america and our hearts play as the background to the doings of white losers that internalized the surface level message of these songs as whole their personality. as fortune would have it, we've elected them all. frosted tips and puka shells have been covered by ubiquitous red caps and replaced by a crucifix. was this the last time music was dangerous? certainly this pervasively and explicitly in the cultural zeitgeist.
Introspective lyricism, violent misogynistic Real slim shady Marshall mathers
Outstanding from top to bottom. This is where he really finds the sound that I identify with eminem. He voice has this hoarseness that loses the higher pitch from the slim shady lp. Its such a leap that brings a sense of maturity while being almost as immature as the last album. Hes having fun on this album, but he is angry. Hes angry at everyone and has reasons. Its just great. Whats really interesting is to listen to the lyrics and figure out what he is joking about and what he was actually dealing with at the time, which we get to learn looking back. The eminem show is my favorite of his albums, but this one sets up everything after it.
Classic.
It’s senselessly immature. Like, it’s not good. It’s not clever or smart; it wasn’t a product of talent, just novelty. The violence is whatever but the misogyny really bothers me. I would hate it if I hadn’t been 16 when it came out and also senselessly immature. That being said, I like it more than it deserves.
There are hints of something good here, but the content of the music is unbearably awful. Kim is a truly awful song, the lyrics are misogynistic and homophobic. He really had a grip on so many kids around Michigan and tries his hardest to pass the buck in this album Favorite Songs: Stan, The Real Slim Shady
Had to tap out of this one, to be honest. I gave his last album on the list a full chance but I just couldn’t be bothered this time. I hate Eminem. Well maybe hate is too strong a word but at best he does absolutely nothing for me and at worst actively irritates me.
18-year-old me would have rated this a 5. I don’t have this angst any more
Nope.
Great, but I don't love hip-hop. Some songs are classics, some are funny, some are just disturbing (WTF is Kim?), but all are entertaining. The album as a piece of art is cohesive and very high quality. The songs themselves are catchy, with a decent variety across the album. Eminem talks a lot about 'not caring if people like his shit', like throughout the album, over and over... I like it Eminem, don't worry, since it concerns you so much. Unfortunately, for me, hip-hop just automatically gets rated lower, because I don't enjoy it as a genre as much as others. At least for now.
2000’s provocative shock slop. Seriously. To imagine a world where I was once a little kid bumping nothing but Eminem makes me cringe so hard. What was I cooking? What was I relating to? This just aged so poorly. Lyrics aside, (it’s proactive and stupid, that’s the point) it just really has no place in my mental as a fully grown adult. Even the rage songs are just so dumb I can’t even enjoy them for that purpose. At least in Eminem Show there’s some actual human substance behind it, these early records are just so foul and out there it’s really not enjoyable to listen to. Also when did they start partially censoring even the explicit versions of these songs? What happened to preserving art? Favs: Drug Ballad Criminal
Wow this is so so outdated. Eminem is a weird guy leaning too far into the character and not truly being sincere enough. It’s really edgy and silly but it’s so so vapid it’s like a bad comedian. That being said what else was he supposed to do to get noticed. He opened up a genre to so many and did it by getting noticed. The iconography and legacy of this record it’s and stays with us. Songs like kill you are some of the worst things to ever hit the airwaves. A diss track about your ex wife yikes just a weird guy. All art is shrouded in truth and so in order to get over his own fears he wrote and performed that. The skits are actually outdated nobody knows shaggy and his Eminem beef anymore and making it a whole timepiece. I understand this album changed the landscape of hip hop but without that aspect and where hip hop has gone now I feel as if it just sits on my CD shelf as a memory of a time of lyrical freedom and nostalgia. May I never actively search out Eminem as I have moved past this. I think some of the beats are nuts though and Eminem has never faltered on that front.
Has his best stuff on, but only enough to make a short EP. Sadly there’s another hour to get through after that, and two stars might be generous.
I spent a lot of time debating my review for this, but I ultimately fell on the side of "10-20 years ago, I would've given this a three; today, I just do not have the patience for this kind of rhetoric." 'Kim' was so uncomfortable to listen to, a full hour plus of screaming about how much you don't give a fuck really does not convince me that you actually don't give a fuck, I truly do not understand the appeal of a full album of this. 'Stan' does still hit and some of the beats/production almost gave this 2 stars, but I'm gonna say no.
Wildest lyrics on the block, but captivating
There are some decent beats and melodies. The big hits are genuinely good. Stan is excellent storytelling. The Real Slim Shady is a great hit. Other than that it didn't resonate. The shock value and the provocation has a specific age of peak appeal; I'm no longer in that demographic
Eminem's return is still pretty raunchy like most late 90's and early 2000's media was, but it feels like this project is more self aware of it's shock value and uses it in a smart and calculated way to elevate the songs. There is still a fair amount of homophobic lyrics sprinkled throughout this project that surely look shameful in the current year. This album feels like watching Eminem progress through a day and it's interesting seeing just how good all the skits tie in for the most part. I think this album improves on the beats/production which was a small but delightful thing to hear. I think one of the big problems with this album is the pacing, it's not the best and I think this project drags a good bit, which isn't good to hear since almost every single one of his projects are over 1hr long. The second half of this project just turns into molasses and it makes it really hard for me to keep up the same energy and excitement I had for this project before. I don't get why people are so crazy for this still unless they have strong nostalgia with this album, aged like milk yet people still praise it?
I have a lot of struggles with Eminem. Obviously there's terribly misogynistic and homophobic lyrics all over the place and the disjointedness here is jarring, one song is violent, then fun, then Stan, then I hate my fans. It's so chaotic and not my style. I am glad he seemed to get his life back together though.
Look, I get it. I get that he ~dOEsn't really MEAN~ any of it (raping his mother, killing his ex girlfriend, the absolute MOUNTAIN of homophobia, school-shooter apologia, et cetera et cetera et cetera). I get that he's looking for a reaction. I get that this is ragebait. I get that I ~shouldn't take it so SERIOUSLY~. So I don't, obviously, not really. But the volume and the monotony of the cruelty on display here is just—honestly, it's difficult to get through, at first, and then somewhere along the runtime it just becomes almost laughable. Oh wow, you're so edgy and cool, you're going to complain for an hour about gay people? About women? You want to ~pretend~ (he doesn't mean it, guys, really! all of these words are in no way at all indicative of ANY actual underlying prejudice! he has gay friends, even!) to play along with the played-out age-old myth that they're the source of your white man problems, somehow? You're punching down. You're punching down at a target that's already been beaten to death for thousands of years. It's not new or insightful or interesting. It's just ugly, and boring.
NO PONGO 4 POR LOS HITS.!!!!!!!,,,, el álbum me gustó demasiado, muchísimo más de lo que esperaba y ps ns, estoy encontrando un gusto oculto por el hip hop o ns q género sea JAJAJA
Great album, love Eminem. One of my faves growing up
This takes me back. I was 16 when this came out and super into hip hop. I wonder how I feel about this now. This aged like milk. Super immature. Still catchy but dated.
I am actually kind of appalled at the language in this album. I'm not woke in anyway shape or form lets be real, and yet the obtuse use of the f slur in this album is disgusting?? Like I get it's his whole schtick but it's actually just cheap songwriting, just use normal swear words if you want to be provocative, like I don't get why Eminem feels the need to be so OVERTLY HOMOPHOBIC?? Don't get me wrong 'Stan', 'Under the Influence', 'Slim Shady' are all songs that I've listened to before and will listen to again probably, but when an album has me coming away from it feeling gross?????????? Nah man not for me.
I appreciate it but not my kind of music. It was listenable
It’s intense. Not sure about this one
Will the real Slim Shady please stand up
I actually enjoyed most of this. I say that 'cause this album got plaaaayed out when it came out. Everyone and their mom was bumping this nonstop (for real, my best friend's mom loved this album and played it all the time, plus she did meth, so it was played legit 24/7). Probably won't return to it ever again, but I like it more than I used to. Feel like it's actually a pretty good time capsule for the era.
Быстро устал от речитатива, как и всегда.
I like it. it's so overly abrasive that it makes you think okay what is he actually trying to express, although maybe a little too much at times.
it’s a little cringe in 2026 but i have to hand it to him, it really was a complete left turn entry into this genre when it came out and it was so successful
Eminem is a talented musician but he takes his talent to degrading and profane extremes here and it's concerning how Eminem normalized the level of explicitness now rampant in modern popular music. I'd prefer songs by him like Lose Yourself and Mockingbird compared to reading what's on this album and I'm skipping it.
очень неплохо, просто не мой вкус. мне кажетса что если бы я любила рэп это было бы 5 звезд
에미넴 내스타일 아니다.
It’s a product of its time but still a good album.
Not for me x2 Favorite song: drug ballad
I just feel like the exaggerated violence stuff is a bit played out and I get he was the first guy taking the gangster rap violence to this level but that doesn't mean it's *good*. The whole album reeks of sensationalising, trying to be so shockingly violent that people buy the record to see what the fuss is. Stan is so melodramatic it's comical. Do you reckon Slim still sent the last letter, even though he wrote "come to think of it, it was you". 'I'm Back' is probably the best combination of beats and raps, because most of the other tracks just have these phenomenal beats and really unenjoyable verses. 'Marshall Mathers' really cringes me out. The echo voice is so so lame. Christ imagine him doing the different voices in 'Kim.' He really is the rap equivalent of a TikTok sketch content maker
CLASSIC!
why is it - on this site, in general - that when you're Black and rap about violence, homophobia, misogyny, you're a monster, but when you're white, you're interesting and complicated? is this record really either of those things? i'm unconvinced. the success of this chilly, abrasive, ugly music - ok, fine, perhaps that's interesting. the fact that, despite his shocking, sophomoric lyrics, Eminem has thoughts and feelings, that his provocations come from a place of real desire or pain? eh. less so. isn't that kind of the case with everyone? maybe everyone who likes edgy jokes but has an inner life with a full spectrum of emotions should get to make bloated, nasty art about how tormented and complex they are and no one should ever be able to get mad at them because of it, but i certainly don't want any part of it. ugly (sonically, not morally, it really does just sound bad), completely unappealing stuff that is only interesting if you are for some reason only able to afford internal complexity to one white rapper and are then using that perceived complexity to pretend it's discerning and cool to be into crap you liked as a greasy teenager
I’d forgotten how lyrically clever Eminem is. The album as a whole works really well together however the genre isn’t quite where I’m at. For occasional listening however, when I’m in the mood? Perfect.
Ha! Well controversy… does Eminem have merit? Probably not. Entertainment value? Absolutely. 4 Boolean: True
Mucho “suck my dick” monótono y ni por qué está Dr Dre le ayuda.
So uninteresting to me
Some genuinely excellent songs that push hip hop, but much of it seems like just shock-jock lyrics years later
The thoughts I have about this are not original, which I suppose is unsurprising given the amount of ink that has been spilled about this album over the years. So I'll get right to the point: as a pure technical rapper, Eminem is incredible - as Chuck Klosterman put it, he is literally good at talking, which he does incessantly. His music creates genuine catharsis - it did for me on this most recent listen, when I was having a terrible day in general and just wanted to listen to the most fuck-the-world shit I could find. He is obviously intelligent and self-aware. He knows exactly what he's doing here, which both enhances this project and makes it utterly inexcusable. On the better tracks Eminem shows signs of self-reflection; "Drug Ballad" is a seemingly genuine portrait of a man losing control of himself at the critical point when he's now able to fully fund his addictions (one of the most dangerous times for any addict). "The Way I Am" is even better, acknowledging that the music industry is enabling his worst tendencies and intends to chew him up and spit him out. And of course "The Real Slim Shady" works as both a poisonous pop confection and a deconstruction of everything Em says on "The Way I Am," an admission that, yeah, actually it's a good thing the label demanded another "My Name Is" or else this impish masterpiece would've never been written. And therein lies the rub, because "The Real Slim Shady," along with numerous other tracks here, traffics in the central meme of this album, which is that nothing Eminem says or does is ever his fault - it's *your* fault for reacting to it, and the fact that you react to it gives him power over you. And it should be lost on nobody that this exact pattern is the playbook run by a million edgelord scumbags, up to and including the Slim Shady-in-Chief currently tearing down the country in a fit of addled rage. I respect Em and I am so incredibly tired of living in the world he helped create. I'm sure he would say that's my problem and not his.
Funny, I actually laughed surprisingly.
low 4.0. É um bom álbum que acaba sendo um pouco longo demais, com algumas músicas fillers. Eminem consegue contar uma história interessante e sua performance é sublime, com paródias bem feitas.
I really loved this album when it came out. It's very of its time and doesn't really work in today's world. Still it has some of Eminems best tracks and the highlights are brilliant
This is fucking hilarious and I love it
To spawn a word that’s still in the zeitgeist 26 years later, makes this album influential. I Stan it.
well ok Eminem calm down with the homophobia and misogyny it doesn't make u cool
Some songs I liked more than I expected, but I don't like his whole deal. The voice and the flow and the edgy lyrics. Not for me
I can't get past songs like Kim to make this a classic. As I've aged, this has not unfortunately. Some of it is downright embarrassing. 2/5
This is the album with Kim on it. Insane, emotional
Bangers all around
He is very talented. I enjoyed it more when I was in my late teens/early 20s but I still respect it.
Back when this released, I wasn't "into" rap. I was more on that nu metal scene with some industrial mixed in. This is a really good record, Stan is a great bit of introspection and is contrasted by The Way I Am, which might be my favorite Eminem track. Real Slim Shady might be the most biting critique of the industry in decades as well. Some of the bars absolutely did not age well, and I can see how people think they were juvenile. Which is fair, but this is also a really start look into how the late 90s were. People just talked like that. I am glad we all grew up, including Mr Mathers.
Really complicated thoughts on this album. its obviously super influential and musically/technically great but equally the meaning behind a lot of the songs really grates on me
#110 I have a lot of complex feelings about this album. On one hand, it feels edgy for the sake of being edgy. On the other, the rhythm / pacing / flow is absolutely incredible and the choice of sampling is genius. You can't separate the endless misogyny that is so deeply ingrained into the foundations of this album and yet the artistry behind some of the musical choices is hard to deny. With all that being said, I think Eminem fans are idiots most of the time. Not because of their love for the music but because of the incessant need to defend him. It can be true that he is pro-choice and that his music helped to make overt rape culture and misogyny OK. He tries to dissuade this notion in "Who Knew" and, yes, he's right that these issues were there before. What isn't true is the idea that much of this album, his attitude, and choice of lyrics didn't fuel the homophobic, misogynistic hate trains of the 2000s. It's a hard album to rate. My biggest struggle is with "Kim". It's visceral and haunting, which could have been incredible if not for the fact he quite literally name drops his actual partner and made her a hate figure for years. I don't care if they were as bad as each other, and I don't particularly care to find out more about their history. What I do think, is that when you have a platform like he did then you have a responsibility. This was misused so outrageously. Anyways, there isn't really a conclusion to my thoughts here. Just a rant about the complexities of taste and that it isn't really possible to separate art from the artist or vice versa. I think it's important it's on the list as it was an era defining album, and influenced a huge amount of (racist, homophobic, misogynistic) culture. Positive or negative, it's an album that I think is important to listen to and explore. Final thought: the album has a lot of small dick energy. You're mad because Christina Aguilera doesn't want to date you? Grow up!!! ꩜ average track rating: 2.9/5 ꩜ favourite track(s): stan, the real slim shady, bitch please II ꩜ least favourite track(s): kim, drug ballad ꩜ album rating: ★★⯪☆☆ ꩜ number of albums left to review: 979 ꩜ number of albums from the list that i agree with being on the list: 52 (+1 Marshall Mathers LP) ꩜ albums from the list that I would consider on my list: 23 (+1 Marshall Mathers LP) ꩜ albums from the list I won't include on my list: 87
Símbolo de uma era. Ou se odeia pq é politicamente incorreto ou se ama por causa disso. E a música, pouco importa. De minha parte, acho quase tudo muito imaturo, com alguns bons momentos e sacadas, como a "conversa" com a música da Dido.
I wore out this cd when I was a young fella. It's a tough hang at times. Parts of it haven't aged well. But I'll be damned if some other parts aren't a ton of fun. That said, I it's a bit bloated. A few of these tracks didn't need to be on here. So I'm gonna be probably the only person who gives this a plain old, middle of the road 3.
ez
Wigger
Good one to listen to in the background because it forces you to pay attention to it. It was interesting enough that I'm glad I listened to it, but now that I've heard it I can't see myself being motivated to return to it. A few songs are pretty crazy. 6/10.
i like when they have a little intro track ken kaniff what am i listening to this feels wrong steve something there’s a lot of talking in this album was expecting more rap feels like snippets of some tv show kill you ok this is more vibe basic but satisfying instrumental parts i like i like the chainsaw noise lol the real slim shady i should probably listen to the lyrics more carefully but this is vibes who is slim shady i like the descending “eeeeee-eeeeee-eeee-eee” etc in the background towards the end who knew you make hype music do you bro this guy swears a lot like idm swearing particularly but it feels dominating/unnecessary? idk i sound like my mum. she has a point sometimes tho. bro why u trying to sneak a plastic gun through customs is it real or is this like joel and the watergun oo we’re beating our wife not sure i’m a fan of this guy even if it’s a joke idk the vibes of these songs are fine but i’m not sure i’m very much of a fan of some of his lyrics. someone tell me if this is meant to be clever/ironic or smth. but seems unpleasant in places. ty spotify ads for alerting me of the existence of silva bumpa, what would i do without you. drug ballad “you have the right to remain violent” i like this as like a vaguely clever line amityfair similar to others he wants to kill someone’s family this guy seems to be quite angry/upset :(
idk if I can contribute to the discussion that's already been had about this album. all I can say is that, despite the frankly abhorrent bars, these are some bars
Oh boy this'll be interesting. 72 straight minutes whatever the fuck it is goes on in Eminem's brain. I would also like to add that I accidentally put last album's review in the middle of the listening notes. Whoops Listening notes: Wow eminem's been doing this "cancel me I dare you" bs for a long time Jesus fucking christ straight in with the horrorcore Norman bates reference is mildly funny The whiplash from "shady will fucking kill you" to the genuine masterpiece that is Stan is so strong. Maybe Eminem is the first person in history to *not* write better when on psychedelics It's actually fucking crazy I get chills in the third verse of Stan and then right after it we get "fuck shit ass bitch cunt shoobity doo-wop" His first word was in third grade?? Bozo This song makes me feel like cruising around the 313 in my fred flintstone car drinking miluakee's best (please god tell me someone gets this reference) Interesting to see the continuation of the 'bum on your lips' motif we find across eminem's discography. It's so satisfying when he crosses the bar line Fucking hell Columbine reference Lots of homophobia in this one Wow a whole minute long skit where he gets his cock sucked I think he might be from amityville Xzibit has some fucking hard lines how come I haven't heard of him Oop here it is eminem's 6 minute long fantasy about killing his wife. It's genuinely an interesting piece though. More subtle than it sounds I guess And here we go right from that into "I was high when I wrote this" More homophobia in this one This is probably the hardest time I'm going to have rating one of these albums. Not because of the quality of the musicianship - eminem's rhyming and dre's production remain top tier throughout - but because of the actual lyrical content. Some of what he says is genuinely repulsive, and I'm aware this is very much the idea but it gets to a point where you think "what am I condoning by listening to this?" You can do horrorcore without all this relentless misogyny and homophobia, and by god is there a lot of it. It also makes you wonder what the point of it really is, what is he proving by being this provocative? That he can say what he wants? You can surely do that with only *one* joke about raping your own mother, so why are there more? All this aside (and it's a lot to put aside mind you) it's clear that when he puts down the vicodin and takes his right hand from under the table eminem can be a masterful lyricist. This is most clear on 'Stan' and 'Kim', the latter being a harrowing track not just because of its violence but also how vividly he portrays the fractured mental state of the character he's playing. All in all, the album is incredibly well-made and well-rapped, but with the lyrics frequently jerking you out of it with whatever atrocity was lurking in shady's mind when he wrote the track. I find myself able to deal with this in most but certainly not all cases, which knocks down this album that could otherwise be a solid 5 to a 4
Kill You Stan The Way I Am The Real Slim Shady Kim
hip hop not my taste sorry
Ебунячая легенда
m&m
Of its time, interesting to listen but a bit too much of the same.
how did i listen to this at 12....
I avoided this when it was new. It wasn’t a genre I enjoyed, and young me didn’t get along with the people I knew who listened to it. But I gave it an honest chance for this project. There is definitely some creativity here that is worth praising. But it was hard to listen to. I get that it is intentionally offensive — he seems to be making a point with that. But sometimes it like he leans into that just so he can say hateful and gross things. Maybe I’m wrong and there’s more to it than that, but at the end of the day I just didn’t like listening to it.
Not only did this album invent the word “stan”, but it also made people misspell Christopher Reeves’ name. To showcase the absurdness of this album, here are different lines from just one song, “I’m Back” “I don't give a f*ck if this chick was my own mother, I'd still f*ck her with no rubber and c*m inside her and have a son and a new brother at the same time and just say that it ain't mine” “I take seven {kids} from {Columbine}, stand 'em all in line. Add an AK-47, a revolver, a .9, a MAC-11 and it oughta solve the problem of mine, and that's a whole school of bullies sh*t up all at one time” “I used to be my mommy's little angel at twelve. Thirteen, I was puttin' shells in a gauge on a shelf. I used to get punked and bullied on my block 'til I c*t a kitten's head off and stuck it in this kid's mailbox” Man this album is a parade of horribles put together into a surprisingly great piece of music.
6 / 10
So many bangers but my god this shit is vulgar and dark
Bien.
Like your experience of listening to Doggystyle last week, I was embarrassed to have The Marshall Mathers LP on when Aislinn walked into the room. The ubiquity of its singles in 2000 should have dulled that embarrassment. It's not as though she hasn't heard these words before. I'd only known the censored radio edits as a teenager, but the missing blanks never concealed much; the internal rhymes usually made the omitted slurs obvious enough. She also knows about this project, so if she catches me listening to something objectionable she'll ask whether it's our album of the day. There is, in other words, an acceptable reason to find me deluged by a torrent of "sluts" and "faggots". Even so, I wanted the headphones back on. Like pornography, certain forms of art change when another person enters the room. The embarrassment is no longer private. The problem is that, unlike pornography, there was no escaping Eminem in 2000. His work was everywhere: buses, shopping centres, bedrooms, MTV. That ubiquity raises a question that has never really gone away. Challenging art often depends upon context. A line such as "You cheap, lousy faggot" in Fairytale of New York has an artistic function inside the song that disappears once it becomes something drunken strangers bellow every December. The song really is more of the order of a Eugene O'Neill play than a pop hit - the industry forces a category error. Elvis Costello recognised a similar problem with Oliver's Army, suggesting radio stations simply stop playing it rather than rewrite a lyric whose meaning depended on dramatic and historic context. Interestingly, the source of the problem is the appearance of the one offensive word that Eminem studiously avoids using. Art earns a certain licence because it asks us to enter a protected imaginative space. Pop music, however, is designed to escape that space. It leaks into supermarkets, taxis and children's bedrooms whether we invite it or not. The question, then, is whether The Marshall Mathers LP deserves that artistic licence. Its defenders generally argue two things. First, that the album is a satirical defence of free speech, saying outrageous things precisely to test tue boundaries and expose society's hypocrisies. Second, that the record stages a dialogue between Marshall Mathers, Eminem and Slim Shady, in the wake of his initial success, allowing one persona to critique another. If either argument holds, then the ugliness of the language becomes part of a larger artistic design rather than an end in itself. Neither argument holds. Genuinely transgressive artists usually risk something. Momus, for instance, was sued over songs by Wendy Carlos and the Michelin corporation. The physical albums containing the songs were destroyed and he lost substantial sums in the process. His targets were specific, identifiable and powerful enough to answer back. Eminem's provocations rarely work like that. The album attacks journalists, celebrities and campaigners often enough, but its deepest reserves of venom are directed towards women and gay men: groups broad enough to symbolise anything he wishes and too diffuse to answer collectively. If satire punches anywhere, it usually punches down. Chris Morris understood this better. His parody of Eminem, JLB8, is funnier than anything on The Marshall Mathers LP precisely because the self-appointed provocateur had himself become a worthy target. Satire gains force when directed at power, hypocrisy or certainty. It loses force when outrage becomes the point. The only person to sue Eminem was his own mother, a reminder that the work is soap opera rather than critique. The album's central contradiction arrives with Stan. It remains its masterpiece because it imagines, however briefly, the consequences of treating violent fantasy as emotional truth. Eminem responds to an obsessive fan not with mockery but with patience, urging him to seek help, cherish his pregnant girlfriend and recognise the difference between entertainment and life. His reply arrives too late. Stan has already driven off the bridge. If the whole record possessed the moral seriousness of that final verse, The Marshall Mathers LP might be a far richer work. Instead, the following song immediately retreats into incredulity. Who Knew acts as though the very suggestion that songs might influence people were absurd. No reasonable listener believes artists are directly responsible for crimes committed by their fans. That isn't the issue. The issue is that Stan itself demonstrates Eminem understands communication carries consequences. He writes an entire song about precisely that. Having recognised the problem, he immediately pretends not to. No serious person could write the concluding verse of Stan sincerely and then release the album as it is. That pattern runs throughout the record. Whenever responsibility approaches, somebody else is blamed. The record company wants him to be outrageous. Hip hop, his chosen genre, rewards violence. His childhood damaged him. Slim Shady said it. Eminem said it. Marshall Mathers merely watched. The album's defining characteristic isn't rage but evasion. It continually insists that nothing is really under its author's control. Sartre called this bad faith: the comforting fiction that we are merely the products of circumstance rather than agents capable of choosing differently. The Marshall Mathers LP is saturated with it. Eminem presents himself as both the most powerful voice in popular music and the least responsible person in the room. But he had a choice. That's what ultimately distinguishes him from performers like Jerry Sadowitz. Sadowitz understand that transgression works because it is contained. Audiences knowingly entered a room where normal rules are suspended before returning to ordinary life. Eminem wanted no such containment. His record company wanted these songs on heavy rotation. He wanted them there too. The point wasn't simply to offend but to offend millions and profit from the offense. It was not enough that he denied his own capacity to choose, he denied the public choice as well. No one could avoid his vomit and vitriol. We were all subject to the desires of a juvenile demographic and the companies that would exploit their worst impulses. That commercial ambition is crucial because the album repeatedly mistakes mass exposure for artistic courage. There is nothing inherently brave about saying offensive things when every mechanism of popular culture is amplifying them. He attacks journalists and celebrities and other rappers, never anyone with the power to shut him down, never anyone who is actually affected by his bile. Indeed, the existence of both explicit and clean editions demonstrates how comfortably outrage could coexist with market expansion. Where Momus had records destroyed, Eminem diversifies his portfolio - a version with inexorable Kim and one without. Where Momus loses out, Eminem and his company maximise profits. None of this would matter so much if the music justified it. Dr. Dre's production is fine, giving Eminem ample room for to display his technical ability. His internal rhymes still tumble over themselves with a certain precision, and his command of rhythm is impressive. Yet technical brilliance continually serves dramatically thin material. The album mistakes escalation for development. Louder, nastier and more offensive becomes a substitute for saying anything new. Even Stan, for all its power, reveals Eminem's limitations as a dramatist. He awkwardly overexplains, drawing attention to the contrivance of the dramatic device when Stan questions how he will send the tape to Slim. Eminem's final sign-off, recognising that "it was... it was... you," is pure melodrama, reminding us again that the whole Eminem performance is soap opera. The worst offence, however, is in the strawman of Stan himself, at every opportunity, Eminem paints his number one fan as a fucking idiot - no idea how he'll send a tape from a submerged car; carefully printing the address in block capitals because writing by hand is hard. The barely contained contempt for his audience makes a mockery of the whole enterprise. Actually, no, the greatest offence of Stan is the utter dreariness. One might try to pin this on Dido, whose Thank You provides the musical basis of the track, but her song has an actual chorus, there is harmonic movement and uplift, it goes somewhere. Stan is all mire with no release. By the end of the record, what lingers isn't outrage but exhaustion. Every attack is somebody else's fault. Every excess belongs to another persona. Every criticism proves his enemies don't understand satire. Everybody else is shit. The album demands complete artistic freedom while declining the corresponding burden of artistic responsibility. The Marshall Mathers LP is not a great work of transgressive art. It is a piece of commercial entertainment that appropriates the language of transgression while remaining remarkably safe within the structures that profit from it. Momus lost records. Costello withdrew his from radio. Genuine loss and genuine agency. Eminem sold millions of copies in two editions and became the biggest star on the planet. The album's legacy isn't simply that it made offensive language mainstream. It helped normalise the idea that outrage is, in itself, a form of courage, and that refusing responsibility is a defence of free speech. Twenty-five years later, that seems far more significant than any individual slur and the impact is felt. The worst people online are called Stans and the right to be offensive is everywhere online and elsewhere. The cock-headed belief that lashing out is a defense of 'free speech' is the norm. I wouldn't say that this was Eminem's fault - he'd have a tantrum if I did - but he and his fellow angry boys contaminated the discourse for shits and giggles - and money, lots of money. They polluted the air and the media with self-indulgent shit-taking and now everything is clogged up with shit. "I never knew... I never knew..." he yaps. Well, now you know. NB: I was walking the dog last night and there was a bunch of teens on the promenade, hurling stones, harassing old people, just destroying everything around them. One of them was wearing a Slim Shady t-shirt. So I'm knocking off another half star. -0.5 This album qualified as a cultural event no doubt - I remember the buzz about it among many of our peers in school. I expect there were young men who listened to almost nothing else that year. If that’s a sad thought it’s also perfectly understandable - here’s an album not only remote from the burden of substantive musical material (as most rap albums are) but which is also remote from the lyrical world of gangster rap. Eminem is excluded from offering any spin on the story of the black experience in America or the gang experience so all that’s left to him is the nihilism, the vulgarity and the self-aggrandisement. The Marshall Mathers LP proved ideal for young men with no real interest in music (two bars, round and round and round) and equally with no real interest in rap. Eminem’s facility for cartoonish provocation was gold in an era in which South Park was the coolest show on TV. South Park was very funny - exactly because it understood where public discourse (and popular art) had drawn the lines and when to cross them. Eminem had no such awareness, no such wit - just a limitless energy for the proliferation of images with which he could degrade himself and his audience. It was hard for young men to tell the difference in 2000, it is frightening to contemplate their struggle in 2026. That Will Smith line is funny though. 0.5/5
outside his hits, all sounds the same
The Marshall Mathers LP is proof that even iconic albums can age like milk.
Overall Rating - 2.03/5 (4.07/10). Where it wasn't deliberately meant to shock, it wasn't bad. Marshall is skilled, but most of this album seemed like an excuse to swear and use every foul and disgusting slur in the book and get paid for it.
I don't understand how this album made it onto the 1001 list.
I find the shtick difficult, but I suppose that's part of the point. The skits I could completely live without. But he is absolutely as good as there has ever been, and the production keeps up.
I can enjoy Eminem in small doses, but 72 minutes is a full-blown overdose. The best thing I can say about this album is that it contains fewer racial slurs than most rap records.
An album made by a white dude who appears to hate everything and everyone. His hate really comes through like a steam train. However amongst all the anger and homophobia there is without doubt a talented man. He makes every featured artist sound shit and stands out above the crowd. ‘Stan’ is without doubt an absolute genius track. ‘The kids’, ‘criminal’ , ‘the way I am’ ‘drug ballad’ and ‘Marshall Mather’s’ all sound great too. However this childish angry man keeps rearing its head amongst the great tracks which is a massive shame. Undoubtedly talented and for an album that isn’t my usual liking and something I actively avoided as a teenager I actually enjoyed on the whole. Best track- ‘Stan’ which in itself is a 10/10. Worst track- ‘ fuck you’ Childish, immature and unnecessary. 7/10
Eminem - Marshall Mathers It was ok. I don't know if it's all tongue in cheek or ironic or parody or whatever. I'm not clever enough to work any of that shit out. Too obvious to say best track was Stan so I'll say I enjoyed Drug Ballad as well. Worst track - Kim was hard to listen to. Maybe it was also the best track 🤷 But I'd never want to hear it again. 5/10
There's a decent review in here that breaks down the likely intent of juxtaposing empathetic songs like Stan and crude shit like Marshall Mathers or Kim but I'll be honest, in the moment listening to this I felt half embarrassed people would hear it, and the homophobia and misogyny is pretty repulsive. That said, the songs are good, Stan and Slim Shady are of course great. Can't deny it's a good album.
This could be a 2 or a 4 for me. It’s gross. It’s shocking. It’s spiteful, violent, self indulgent, sexist, brutal, and raunchy. It’s horrifying, but it’s exactly what he set out to create. He set the standard for this style of Hip-Hop and showed off his incredible talent. His rapping and flow are on full display. His ability to elongate and shorten syllables, to stretch and emphasize sounds, and to paint a picture (no matter how grizzly) are truly one of a kind. It’s not something I would fill my mind with often, but I think in terms of picking a target and nailing it, he did it.
I know that this is supposed to be shocking and he doesn't (I'm hoping) feel this way about women, gay people, and Christopher Reeves. That being said, it still is hard to listen to many of these songs. His flow is creative, his wordplay is unmatched, but I would never come back to 80% of these songs. The beats are fine, but could be more interesting in my opinion. 5/10
Stan is a classic, such a good song, sheesh. Also, this being from the 2000s, this was during a time when people were extremely conservative and didn't want to have their children listening to "trash or obscenities," but the world is full of it; no matter what you do to protect your children, they will be exposed to it. The more things change, the more they stay the same, 26 years later. He's angry that they blame everything and everyone except for the parents themselves. Parents can't always protect their children from everything, but they want to blame the people who don't fit the mold. He is angry that people both love and hate him, and that he can't just be himself without judgment. This is actually a very cool album that displays both the power he possesses and the ridicule that comes with it. I think this is a timeless album and reminds me why Eminem's legacy is so powerful. But mannnnnn this is definitely a very offensive album lmfaooo I don't love how offensive/violent it is, but also, that's the point of the album. This is supposed to be an album that is pure rage coming straight from him without it being catered to anyone but himself.
lowkey did not listen will get back to this
Rap with humour
Always felt the same about Eminem. It's his voice and delivery I don't like. Apart from that, there is some great stuff here. So I'm caught in the middle. 2,5 upto 3.
Eminem geht eig immer, nicht das beste Album
Nicht meine Musik aber der Song kim war cool
Find ich ganz gut. Wollte eigentlich 5 Sterne geben, aber mir persönlich war es teilweise zu viel. Z.B rappt Eminem, wäre er kein Rapper geworden, wäre er Rapist geworden. Find ich nicht toll. Sowas kommt halt öfter vor, auch das er seine eigenen Fans "Retards" nennt muss nicht sein. Keine Ahnung vielleicht bin ich auch empfindlich oder checke es nicht. Aber jetzt kann ich höchstens 4, für wie gut das Album sonst ist geben, oder sogar nur 3, teilweise besonders in der Mitte des Albums war es teilweise recht langweilig.
A definitive 2000's turn-of-the-century MUST LISTEN record. Even if you are not a fan of rap music this will definitely make you think. Eminem was a larger-than-life artist that was not afraid to dive into his hardships and commiserate with them through vulgarities and expletive expressions. He had a knack for creating catchy songs out of rapid-fire internal rhyme schemes that you would find in a rap nerd's almanac. He packaged the classic hip-hop essence for a middle White America audience and ushered in the breaking of the class barrier that existed within rap music of the era. Nothing more to say than WHAT A RECORD. I had not heard this in its entirety but jeez what a banger. 10/10!
Boy, this goes on for a long time, and I'm not really much of a rap fan, but the man can certainly be funny.
Kill you was really not good. Not really enjoying this album. I think its a 1 star album for me. Its 1 star for me.
Throughout my listening to this album, I listened to my coworker talk about a young girl in her family dealing with a toxic mutually self-harming relationship, then we discussed the political state of the country. So, I always knew the violent lyricism was gonna be one of the biggest hurdles with Eminem, but I thought I knew the extent of what violence entailed. I thought I had listened to the Marshall Mathers LP before back when I was a more active Eminem fan. Turns out, I had not heard this album before, and just one song in, this album was already way more explicitly malicious and violent than I had previously heard from Eminem. Obviously, the lyrical content here sees Eminem deliberately trying to lean into shocking, problematic lyricism as a game of chicken with mainstream attention, seeing just how much vulgarity they'll let him get away with. He also makes many good points about the general hypocrisy of the country, focusing on Eminem's music as a uniquely violent influence amidst countless other pieces of violent imagery in the media. However, that solid point does not absolve Eminem of the responsiblity for how much his music might influence listeners. This is a dynamic he's clearly aware of, as he refers to it countless times throughout this album, especially on Stan. Most of the songs are musically good, as he has an incredible knack for intricate flow and witty storytelling, playing hand-in-hand with minimally simple production full of enough little tricks to keep the beats interesting (such as the slowly building storm in Stan). And Eminem is obviously a far more self-aware artist than many of his biggest detractors give him credit for, as he constantly interrogates his own relationship with society. However, that self-awareness can be its own damnation, as continuing to write lyrics as problematic as his often are while clearly understanding what those words can do, is irresponsible. And honestly, my problem isn't even with the explicit over-the-top violence, so much as it is the casual and pervasive attitude of misogyny of homophobia. These threads aren't solely expressed in obviously provocative moments, they seep into even the genuine and honest moments, which is where they become a problem. Even calling this album the Marshall Mathers LP implies a level of emotional honesty which makes the casually hateful lyrics less satirical. The lyrics aren't bad because I think Eminem is gonna kill someone, or because a kid will be corrupted by his excessive cartoonish violence; they're bad because they casually reinforce and provide justifications for hate crimes and domestic violence to people who are already in that pipeline. And sure, that very argument means that Eminem's music probably won't be the final straw for most people who act in violent ways, but why would you even get that close to making something which could inspire violence? There is a general lack of balance between "don't take this seriously" lyricism and emotional honesty about his life and upbringing. For example, the song Kim is an ugly fucking song, but I think there could be an album which makes an artistic statement that earns a song as intense as Kim, where the discomfort and horror is deliberate and done in service of something grander. But the Marshall Mathers LP is not that album, as it waffles back and forth between those two tones in a way that undermines each approach. There are still plenty of hits here, because he's Eminem, but as a whole package, this is a difficult listen, especially if you're someone who believes in the power of language and that words have power even if you don't intend them to. Highlights: Kill You, Stan, Paul (Skit), Who Knew, Steve Berman, The Real Slim Shady, Drug Ballad
I have to have a certain level of respect for this but holy fucking trash
This is new to me, i only know eminem for two songs and honestly it's kinda not my type of genre BUT, i like how it sounds. Let's see what happens. ok i didn't like it
None of the criticisms about the lyrics or how it’s aged are particularly out of order, but it’s just so easy to forget how good Eminem was good at rapping. He’s been working for over 30 years and has 3 good albums to show for it but goddamn he was so good for those 3 albums.
Day926 - i love the real slim shady the rest doesn’t do much for me. the skits in hip hop albums were a terrible idea and ruin what could be great albums
Quite a conflicting listen, which is probably exactly what Em wants. So much brilliant and provocative lyrics, delivered incredibly. But, the beats are pretty varied in quality and it's not always clear the line between button pushing and basic unpleasantness.
Classic init
It is a bit to much "talkning" (rap talking ig) for my taste. I can like it sometimes but it depends on how it sounds. The Way I am sounds a bit more my taste compared to the first 3 full songs. A bit to little happening in that song though. Marshall Matters best so far, not playlist worthy though for me. Beats and instrumental are good, but his rapping in this album is just not for me. So sadly 1 star since I wouldnt come back and listen to it. Hiphop can be so much better.
Such a strong album by him. I really appreciate his technical ability. However, the subject matter at times was a little too much.
Absolute classic. If it does shock or offend you, well, it should. That was the point - to insult the listener while madly rapping great verses with such mad passion, that you are just left sitting in awe. Amazing album.
Album 258. The Marshall Mathers LP (https://open.spotify.com/album/5xifZlByZcZecgkP7sYSoW?si=vAeJqVyTRl-TwPCkqugkjA) — Eminem (2000) This album is definitely a monumental Eminem work. It's badass from the start to the end. His white rap is so bright that niggas lose their vision and begin to think he is black. GOATed artist. There are so many bangers, so much greatness 5/5 Liked: — Kill You — Stan — The Way I Am — The Real Slim Shady — I'm Back — Drug Ballad — Amityville — Bitch Please II — Under The Influence — Criminal — The Kids
not a bad album, just over played. Not something I would listen to at work.
For the previous eminem album I wrote: "That was enough Eminem for a while." That was album 1396 days ago, but the "for a while" wasn't long enough. This is just a hiphop shitshow.
I'm not the biggest rap fan at the best of times. So white guy rap was never going to be my thing
Stan The Real Slim Shad Both those tracks stand up. Three dimensions and feel like a real deconstruction of self and fame. The remainder has some shock factor and horror elements that I think have aged terribly and also seem a bit one note after a while. You can’t deny Eminem’s talent with rhymes and his flow but this has aged terribly in terms of content.
Grew up hearing all his biggest hits everywhere but this is my first time listening to a full album. I knew it's gonna be a tough listen after the first song, horrendous lyrics. I tried to zone out and not pay attention to the lyrics on other songs but then he used the f slur in a different song 6 whole times. I'm sorry but I refuse to believe this guy genuinely read the dictionary to expand his vocab as people say, his lyrics are shit. And I'm not buying the whole "Slim Shady is his alter ego" thing. If I were a musician I simply wouldn't make an alter ego for myself that is violent and phobic in various ways. At the end of the day it's you who has to get on stage and sing it to people. Be creative and become and evil alien gyno like that other guy on the 1001 list 1/5
meh
Eminem is effective at what he does, which usually involves shocking the listener with horror stories and plumbing the depths of repressed fears and desires. There are the album tracks, which are designed for maximum impact and generate a lot of buzz around the record, and then there are the hits which are carefully constructed so that they’re very offensive but softened enough to air on broadcast television. It’s a powerful marketing tactic, but what is to be found for listeners like myself, who are not interested in the gratuitous angst and looking for something beyond it? Some clever wordplay and a solid collection of beats. And, mercifully, a little Snoop Dogg.
Fuck fuck fuck
Full of bangers
I've already heard the mainstream songs on here, and they are the best songs ("Stan", "The Real Slim Shady"). Yes, the lyrics are violent and offensive, but I expected that. The beats, for the most part, are addictively catchy and Eminem's rapping was so real and honest. As I've said before, it's not my preferred genre, but I liked this more than I thought I would.
eminem is frustrating. he's insanely talented, buty the violent nihilism and misogyny of this album is just hard to stomach. had i been 16 when this came out, maybe i'd have a different relationship to this album (duh, of course i would). that said, "stan" is a stone-cold classic of amazing writing, imagery, mood, and delivery.
A visceral, violent bit of rap. Lovely stuff.
9,5/10.
Even een dienstmededeling. Het zal me aan m'n reet roesten dat het Slim Shady aan zijn reet zal roesten. Ik heb er niet voor gekozen deze ellende aan te horen, ik drink de gifbeker leeg omdat het moet van het boek. Geinig, het nummer Stan staat erop. Maar helaas, want na de eerste 25 seconden van dit album stond al vast dat ik het een dikke moddervette 1 ging geven (de derde al van vandaag), en daar hou ik het bij. Kom op zeg, ik laat me aan het begin van de plaat tot het bot beledigen en vervolgens ben ik zo achterlijk (of zo lief) om toch de volle 72 minuten aan te horen. Dan ben ik toch wel iets meer respect waard, dacht ik zo. Hoe dan ook, je moet toch potdomme geestesziek zijn om zulke 'muziek' te maken, en geestesziek om het (uit vrije wil) te luisteren. Ik begrijp het gewoon niet. Ik begrijp het echt niet.
Ik schreef eerder dat we Eminem kunnen zien als een zwarte strip, waar de negatieve kant van de samenleving wordt uitvergroot, maar wel een strip die met de flows, de muziek en de samples in suikerzoet roze getekend is. Eminem zelf ziet de referentie ook, en wijst mij op het gebrek in de analyse. Hij noemt naast de aangehaalde elementen zijn humor als kenmerkend. Althans, hij noemt zichzelf in Marshall Mathers een 26 jarige iele Cartman. Ik geef het toe. Die referentie is goed. Eminem is het muzikale equivalent van South Park. Daarmee moet ik maar net als bij South Park in die tijd door de minder smakelijke elementen heen kijken. En de waardering voor de suikerzoete creativiteit laten spreken.
Ik moet bij Stan de hele tijd denken aan het nummer van Arjan Lubach, wat natuurlijk een hilarische cover is. Dat moet Eminem toch hebben kunnen waarderen lijkt me. Qua waardering van mijn kant: ik had totaal geen zin in hiphop vandaag en al helemaal niet 70+ minuten schijtlollige hiphop met de nodige onnodige krachttermen. Zo'n nummer als Stan is dan een fijn intermezzo, alleen jammer dat dat al na 5 minuten komt. Wat minder fijne intermezzos, zijn de overbodige skits. Ik snap het nut niet zo goed van dit soort stukjes op een album. Mocht ik de neiging hebben om mezelf er door van kant te maken, dan zal dat niet gaan, want het nummer dat daar over gaat, mag ik niet afspelen van Joetjoep. Maar goed, zoals ik bij het andere album al zei, de beatjes en de baslijntjes zijn dan wel weer tiptop in orde. En dat maakt het op zich best ok om te luisteren. Het is wat aan de lange tijd, maar ik kom er toch met enig gemak doorheen. Niet meer dan een vergeetbare 3, dat niet natuurlijk.
this was terrifying and disturbing
Haven’t heard this since it came out, so after 20 odd years later it sounds completely different to me. It’s a bit cringy in parts and close to the bone. Did it in two halves cos it goes on a bit.
I’ve heard high school boys swear less. Painful and childish.
A few really great songs, but all those skits, what are you? A comedian?
Within the first 3 minutes I get "how about you suck his fucking cock" and "slut, you think I won't choke no whore til the vocal chords don't work in her throat no more". Yes yes I get that Eminem's schtick is his persona that doesn't represent his actual views but jesus christ go to fucking therapy. I had some hope at points because he has so much emotion and anger and it could've been channelled into making something powerful but any possibility of that is thrown away behind "BITCH FUCK YOU EAT SHIT AND DIE BITCH" for a solid hour. Also the actual beats? rhythm? songs? are choppy as hell and abrasive and generally awful to listen to. How the hell did this guy become one of the greatest rappers of all time?
Точный и выверенный алгоритм. Очевидная и понятная легендарность. Каждый трек выверен и отточен до предела. Сам подход к написанию треков полностью и всеобъемлюще ощущается при прослушивании. Вся читка безусловно хороша и поражает слух, минималистичные биты, идеально сочетаются с манерой исполнителя. Вот что можно сказать прослушав 2 песни из 19. Далее минималистичность битов превращается в скучность и однообразность, читка и флоу - аналогично и также чудовищно перегружено. Целиком альбом слушать было в тягость. Конечно отдельные легендарные треки приятно разбавляли рабочую атмосферу, но получить удовольствие и отдохнуть сильно не получилось. Мне очень не понравился альбом, так долго я альбом давно не ощущал, несмотря на видимый и очевидный профессионализм и качество - это максимально грустно и скучно. Моя оценка альбому 3/10
Pretty good album, this was better than I was expecting. I never really listened to any of Eminem albums before, just songs here and there. This one has that early sound - of course - of just most filthy lyrics up until that point in time in music. He does all the don't's and zero of the do's. It's borderline hilarious after a certain point with all the horrendous stuff, you start seeing more humour in it than bigotry, for me I reached this point when "Marshall Mathers" came on. I like - not alone obviously - "Stan" for it's introspectiveness, sounds so down-to-earth, the topic of course, not what is actually done. I think this is a good album, especially once the shocking lyrics wear off, it started to have a real charm to it. I would have this album as a must-hear album on a list if I ever created one. I wonder if I liked this one that The Slim Shady LP would be good, better or worse. Hmmmm. Highlight Song/s: "Stan", "Who Knew", "Marshall Mathers" and "Bitch Please II"
oh yes. i’m sorry to say that i have basic respect towards eminem so please don’t kill me. and also, one of my favourite genre is music that makes other people feel offensive. the more offensive the better cause i dont give a fuck about everybody cause im a really bored teenager so the concept of pissing people off is one of the best thing ever. and actually this is a banger and everybody who dont agree are fucking suckers with the woke mind virus that digged so deep into their mind that they think about nothing but feminism all the time and they should kill themself. 4/5 p.s. i think i shouldnt continue to call myself a "stan" of my favourite celebrities. ill call myself a fanboy/fangirl instead.
An improvement on Eminem's formula in almost every way. Where The Slim Shady LP was filled with juvenile shock humor and excessive violence to the point of becoming cartoony. The Marshall Mathers LP is Eminem's response to sudden fame and critics. Em is clearly effected by the attention he's getting, positive and negative, and he addresses this dichotomy several times over the course of the record. The writing has greatly improved, as have the production and samples. Some of Eminem's biggest songs are on this album: "Kill You", "Stan", "The Way I Am". Unfortunately, Eminem doubles down on being crass, vulgar, and generally offensive, but this time it's more weaponized with purpose against "Stans", critics, haters (including ICP), and his ex-wife ("Kim" is fucking intense) rather than solely attempting to shock or press buttons.
Meilenstein, größtenteils super witzig, teilweise aber auch ganz schön bedrückend
One of the most interesting listenings so far, I was alive and well aware of this at the time. What a truly intoxicating blend of self, time, experience, culture, history. Just damn. This album was and will never be "for me". It's for him and everyone without this voice or anywhere to place this anger. Honestly so interesting to hear it now. I wonder so many things. There is so much anger and sadness in the world still naturally, but how is expressed now? I don't know, alone on the Internet, screaming in the void? Such like a bursting bubble of emotions and culture like and so singular as well. He's so alone in this, reaching out for almost anything, including so much more pain.
About an hour too long. Curious how the best Eminem songs does not contain any references to fellatio.
its well written ill say that
ngl i was not looking forward to this album, 72 minutes is a big ask from a guy who i already doubted had even made that much audio worth listening to across his entire music career. still, i went in hoping to be proven wrong, but..... nahhhh. this just absolutely fucking sucked to listen to. ill get this out the way up front, yeah he's got good flow and wordplay, and yeah the dr dre beats are solid, obviously. but the themes and actual lyrical content just fucking suuuuck. its not that im offended by it, like lets be real, its 2026 and world leaders are saying worse shit than this out in public on the regular. i'm more just like, weary i guess? there wasn't any new ground to be covered by saying heinously bigoted shit, it's just edginess for the sake of being edgy, presumably with the goal of scaring the conservative americans of the day. but women and minorities are the ones being thrown under the bus for it, and throwing himself under there with us doesn't make it any better, yknow? this "oh, im not a misogynist/homophobe/etc, i hate everyone equally including myself" schtick was everywhere back then and all thru the 00s and 10s. its south park shit. it's postal 2 shit. it's early 4chan shit. and its so, so fucking lame. its a shame he committed so hard to it cos like, the exactly one track where he doesn't do this, "stan", is actually pretty good! it's also the only time it seems like he has anything interesting to say, with the topic of parasocial relationships being probably even more relevant now than it was back then. but in the context of this album, sandwiched between tracks about killing women as it is, it feels a little hollow maybe? and don't even get me started on the icp diss track immediately followed by audio of him roleplaying violent j and shaggy 2 dope sucking each other off. that shit is just straight up embarrassing, dude. damn. this might be the worst album we've had yet. i feel like hearing it lowered my opinions of everyone involved in its production. u really don't gotta listen to this before u die: if anything, doing so will actively make ur life worse.
que atrevido eminem
Its alright. Really just dont really like Eminems music
Absolutely love Eminem! There are many reasons why I like his music. This is not my favorite album at all. His lyrics are raw and what I love most about him. The way I am will always be my favorite on this album.
Absolute classic
holy peak. lyrical genius