The Marshall Mathers LP by Eminem

The Marshall Mathers LP

Eminem

3.45
Rating
30005
Votes
1
8%
2
14%
3
25%
4
32%
5
21%
Distribution

Reviews (page 5 of 15)

I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve heard this album. It seeped into my life early, either blaring from my older brother’s bedroom, echoing through high school speakers as lunch period wound down. What continues to surprise me, even now, is how playful the record feels despite the ferocity of Eminem’s delivery. The aggression is real, but it’s laced with mischief. The beats are inventive, the skits grotesque and confrontational, and Slim Shady delights in provocation, taking aim at anyone and everyone without discrimination. The guest list is familiar and expected (Dr. Dre, Snoop Dogg, D12) figures who anchor Eminem within his established orbit. Yet The Marshall Mathers LP is not merely an exercise in shock or bravado. Running beneath the album’s outrageous humor is a persistent gravity. Eminem writes through the lens of childhood neglect, poverty, fractured faith, and the suffocating consequences of fame. These themes are the emotional engine of the record, giving weight to even its most cartoonish moments. What ultimately emerges is a deeply tragic album masquerading as spectacle. The violence, satire, and outrage function less as ends in themselves than as coping mechanisms, ways of processing trauma in public, often at the listener’s expense. That tension between playfulness and pain is what gives the album its staying power. Decades later, it hasn’t dulled or calcified.

Luigi’s Mansion sounding ass album

PSA 2000 - stupid, childish Kill You - stupid, wildly misogynist even by Eminem standards, might appeal more to a particularly shitty 13 year old kid Stan - probably the most interesting thing Eminem has ever put out. I like it but I don't know if it'll be enough to redeem the rest of the album. Paul - why bother including this? Who Knew - more edgy bullshit, more stupid hooks Steve Berman - bad acting, stupid script The Way I Am - at least this one has a good hook. The version of Eminem that's at war with mainstream media is a lot more interesting than the obnoxious Slim Shady bullshit where he just shouts the most offensive thing he can think of to get attention. The Real Slim Shady - the overplayed anthem of the worst people I knew in middle school. I almost like it now that I've got a little more distance from it. Remember Me? - mid gangsta rap I'm Back - forgettable. It's been like 2 tracks since you said something weird about your mom, better fix that. Marshall Mathers - oh no it's so hard being famous. Time to shout slurs and talk about your mom again. Cool bass line, bad singing, stupid lyrics. Ken Kaniff - The only thing more embarrassing than beefing with ICP is that the most creative thing he can come up with is calling them gay. Drug Ballad - forgettable Amityville - more of the same schtick. Bad hook. Bitch Please II - it's a pretty decent Snoop song until Eminem shows up Kim - man fuck off Under the Influence - the worst hook yet Criminal - okay

Portrait of an angry young man devoid of depth and interiority his flow is so good, the beats are great, and there is no substance. absolute waste of talent. there's a reason this album was an immediate red flag back when it came out. the only kind of person who could see themselves in this were either just as vacuous or genuinely found the violence and bigotry aspirational. either way you didn't want to be around them. the casual, extreme misogyny and homophobia might give you the mistaken impression there's some kind of transgression here, something interesting even if it's vile, but no actually. other artists have explored that ugliness in interesting ways or with a critical eye but you aren't getting that here. I don't just hate this, I think it's an active waste of time and talent. Fuck me I'd rather be listening to my bottom ten all in a row than spend another second with this.

The Real Slim Shady

As one part of British rap icons Houmous & Chutney I can really understand the struggles Eminem has faced to be taken seriously in this industry. 3.9 3/18 Stan

I love The Real Slim Shady. I think it's a genuinely great song, despite some objectionable lyrics. Otherwise, Eminem just kind of disappoints me. Great music, great delivery...but just so many lyrics that are just stupid, or downright misogynist. He may be great but I'm over it. 3

found myself laughing at some of the simplicity/absurdity of some of the lyrics. "kim" is crazy thou

It's the first time I listened to this album cover to cover. Almost all songs are about how influential he is, how talented he is, how he didn't want the fame but it found him etc. It has a couple of classics though

NIet het hele album vindt ik genieten maar grotendeels wel bangers.

almost heard all The skits are funny I think the first songs are better but the last ones are more interesting/meaningful

A few good songs here. Classics even. But the rest? Sophomoric but I don't think my 14 y/o self would even like this.

Like a lot of hip hop albums of the era, too long and full of skits and filler and a lot of the shock stuff is much harder to be entertained by now. Conservatives hated this at the time, liberals would hate it if it came out now! But there's no denying the skill, the innovation, the impact. The classic high points still slap. "Stan" hasn't lost an ounce of its power. As the deep cuts go, I really like "Drug Ballad."

Courtney: an old favorite of mine. Didn’t age that well but still nostalgic for me Craig: Didn’t like it as much as I thought I would

This is incredible story telling

For sure unapologetically homophobic and hadn't aged well but does have some tunes that I thought were very cool when I was a teenager

Oof. Despite being much more sonically polished, this aged even worse than the slim shady LP. Too many winces and cringes and foreshadowing of the even worse version of Em. His discography may be the most poorly aged in the rap canon.

Kai tää oli aikoinaan kova jollekk7n

Vähän räpistä ymmärrän mutta tämä kaveri on kova ⭐️⭐️⭐️

Eminemin riimit on kyllä parasta kekseliäisyyttä mitä räpmusiikki on kokenut. Silti tällä levyllä ne on puettu vähän liian väkivaltaiseen muottiin jotta meikäläinen saisi siitä täyttä nautintoa irti. ⭐⭐⭐

[Verse 1] I don't do Black music, I don't do white music (Nope) I make fight music for high school kids Muy real, son canciones tristes para un highschooler depresivo o un niño que se siente tuff. Bro, tu opp es la hora de dormir y tu mayor preocupación es hacer la tarea. El álbum no esta mal pero entiendo que puede ser más profundo para personas mayores. Para alguien como yo que aun no nacía, simplemente no lo es. Solo es el personaje de slim shady siendo edgy.

Too much of it has aged badly to go 5, but the best stuff here is some of the best music ever created.

God, this is difficult. As a pre teen, I was solely devoted to 90s alternative rock and had sworn off hip hop. This album was amongst 3 that opened my eyes to how good hip hop could be. Since then, I haven’t revisited the record much. I suppose it’s the severe downfall Eminem had in the late 2010s. It’s a slightly dated album, but it has its merit. It’s stacked with classic hip hop songs, but Eminem’s delivery is off putting most of the time. Regardless, it’s not something I will listen to with full enjoyment.

I’m pretty sure I owned this at the time, it might have impressed a teenage me but it’s just a bit cringeworthy in places, I know a lot is in character, but it wouldn’t really wash today. It’s overlong, with the usual skits and to be honest, too much filler. It has some good tracks on it, I’ve always felt Stan was well written but on the whole, he just doesn’t interest me these days.

There is 1 genuinely great song "the real slim shady". The rest is cartoonish and not that funny when compared to redman or wu tang clan of the time. It veers from mock threatening to silly and there isn't much nuance. Always thought that Eminems greatest hits album would be excellent as his choice of singles are but this album is a bit of a chore.

This record was quite long in the sense that the track list was expansive, but that isn't a bad thing. I enjoyed this instrumentation and lyrics. Favourite Track(s): #1 Hot Song, Two Beads at the End, Maybe Partying Will Help Least Favourite Track(s): Take 5, D, The World According to Nouns

Some great songs followed by some songs I felt less strongly about.

The Real Slim Shady is a classic and Stan to a lesser extent, but like The Slim Shady LP, this one just seemed to disappoint. I get that his first two LPs propelled him into pop culture stardom. But, in my opinion, The Eminem Show is his best album and it's surprising that it isn't on this list.

What an album. I can't claim to like his depictions of horror and violence, but you can't escape that's it's just brilliant. The guy is a force of nature.

2000s hip hop. Horror core, hardcore hip hop, theatrical and whacky. Regarded his best album. Stan is a great song. Fun album.

Absolutely not. Fuck that.

Classics. Not going to listen to this on my own again. 4/5

Although there are some "classics" on here (Stan has always been wildly overrated to me), this is mostly just edgy lyrics for the sake of being edgy over some lackluster Dr. Dre beats.

already listened

Not for me, don't really care about it. Tom Green mentioned. 8 Mile was a film.

Altså er jo sykt bra, men et helt album med eminem ble for mye for meg

Marshall Mathers LP was a great album, I remember listening to it with my brother when I was a kid. Some of it didn’t age well at all but overall it has some of Eminem’s biggest hits. Eminem has a very unique style of rap and the album is very much a sign of the times but it was a nice listen.

Where do I even begin. I had to private my listening status on both Spotify and Airbuds to listen to this. From the start, the first 25 seconds you could tell this was about to be a loooooong album. I say that a lot but this one really outworks the rest. He "raps" like he's a 7th grader who just learned how to cuss. This is more like trashy slam poetry than music. The songs were absolutely terrible. The only reason why some songs got some points was because there was someone else singing. I can't tell you enough how much of a relief it was to hear anyone else speak. He says "if you don't like my music suck my dick" in TWO of the songs and in an interlude literally gets his dick sucked, probably because he knows his music is trash. In another song he talks about how he wouldn't mind having sex with his mom? Seriously dude, there is a fine line between rap and blabbering. Not to mention, how the absolute worst of the worst in this album is a staggering 6 minutes long. If you decide to make a song that long in that generation you better hope at least one of the lyrics are listenable, maybe even a head nod. NO absolutely unbearable trash. I hope rappers look at this album and say "I want to be nothing like that guy". Is this why this album is part of 1001 albums? To show how NOT to make music. A good year was subtracted from my lifespan listening to this crap. If anyone catches me listening to this again shoot me in the head and fuck me in the bullet hole.

2.1/5 I had a mate who used to listen to Eminem all the time so Ive heard alot of these songs many times. A few good songs but so many skits that unfortunately bring this down because I have to skip them. Also the team ups with like D12 etc bored me.

The only Eminem album to iwn

I feel very white giving this a 4 but it's just good

I hadn’t listened to this in years. I wasn’t sure how it would have dated. The answer is mixed. There’s plenty of content that I find uncomfortable listening, but to be fair I always found it problematic, I guess I was just more willing to overlook it when I was younger. I am able also to separate art from reality but certain elements of material here are needlessly unpleasant. With that said, to my ears, the beats and flow have not diminished over time. Eminem is undoubtedly a talented wordsmith and while I might prefer Dre to be in charge of production duties more widely across the album, musically the album stands strong a quarter of a century on. Strangely I’m not too bothered by the skits, but the album is still too long. This used to be an 8/10 for me, and it’s probably 7 now, but with a full star only system, I’m not gonna knock it down to 3.

Not a fan … or a Stan … but liked it more than I thought I would.

The highs (slim shady and Stan especially) are classics and they’re wonderful. The rest is fine. Goes on a bit long and is a little too angry. Impregnating your mother to have a father and a brother should not be accepted, even if she does look like JLo

I'm contractually obligated to like this album as a resident of Southeast Michigan

This man is angry. He's a talented lyricist, and I like the inclusion of sound effects. But it's a little abrasive, which is I guess is the point, and one note for me. I also believed Stan was real for a hot minute when I was a teenager, thanks Mike. Also, way more homophobia than I remember

Stan is great but the rest is just a load of homophobic wank

Album que je ne connaissais pas. Un joli flow. Une belle découverte car je ne connaissais pas vraiment Eminem

Like a deranged journey through the inferno of his mind. At times the personal and the political blend. Absolutely fantastic stuff.

Yeah, he’s good and all but the “I’m just playing” doesn’t really excuse some of the lyrics. He sounds kinda incel.

A lyrically incredible record from start to finish. Having grown up listening to Eminem and specifically Curtain Call on repeat, but having never listened to this album, I absolutely loved it. It includes some of his hits such as Stan, The Way I Am and The Real Slim Shady but I was equally as impressed with the lesser known tracks, especially Kill You. The lyrics are 'offensive', hilarious and extremely hard hitting, especially Kim, which was quite the uncomfortable 6 minute listen. This is an artist at the absolute peak of his powers, with a truly brilliant array of songs.

Я поважаю Емінема за його вклад в музику, але крім пари пісень не моду нічого слухати. Тексти занадто агресивні. Я не люблю реп і цей альбом не змінив думку

I love only BP part 2 I guess that one song is good enough for a 3?

Listened to on the flight from Graz and on Frankfurt at 6am 😴 Favourite song: Marshall Mathers

Listened doing the washing up and walking to work. Heard before, brother got it for Christmas from our auntie when he was 11/12

Harsh, funny, horror-inducing, light-hearted. This packs no less of a punch in 2026 and it’s a clever album. Just when you think it’s getting too dark or too silly, it yanks you the other way. I’ll be honest enough to say I was pretty late to this album, I probably started listening to Eminem mid to late 2000s as a teen with his later work that probably lost the plot a bit. But it has a really strong running order with some commercial hits (Stan, The Way I Am, Slim Shady), plenty of darker cuts and whimsy. It’s crass and shocking but that’s sort of the point, a definite moment in time and a great rap album.

This is an exceptional album in many ways in that it's off the charts a truth in a way.  It's all the dark and human elements spewed into an album.  Disgust of his record label, his broken relationships and ultimately him as a person as he came to be, including the deeply flawed self.  I find it amusing in a way in that it can be a truth that would probably not be "allowed" today and ironically a kind of perspective on the industry of celebrity that rings true today. I don't care about the negative themes on this album or the politics of the subjects etc as that's not the point you don't have to love it.  You just get to enjoy his expression, warts and all.  This is where Eminem excels as it's not like he is lacking complexity or skill as a rapper, but he makes it easy to absorb.  He can be dark and twisted, lunatic or angry; it doesn't matter.  He brings the rage and just nails the delivery in a way that embeds you to the story.  My problem with many rappers is the lack of use of melody or getting a musical flow.  If you fail to do that enough, it stops becoming music and it's an art in its own right in a vacuum.  I am naturally void of the ability to "see" the story in music especially if lyrics build that element.  With Eminem that evaporates, and I feel like I can see it.  Its unique and deep. OK, not everyone likes the vision of Marshall but it's gritty, funny, and classic.  

When you are eleven years old in the early noughties listening to music on the school bus through a shared pair of headphones on a Sony Walkman (CD player), this album is absolute gold. This is probably Eminem's best album. Offensive, dark, silly. Its filled with bangers infused with Eminem's unique and unrivalled rapping style. The first half of this album has me bopping along with a huge smile on my face. Beyond the great beats and the punk attitude, its the sense of humour running through the music that keeps me coming back to Eminem. I will say on a full relisten that the album is 20mins too long and could probably have been distilled by culling some of the tracks in the second half. That said, the extremely dark songs, e.g. 'Kim', showcase the emergence of a style of horror-rap that is culturally significant. This is a cultural commentary on an unsavoury side to America that rings true to many. If you don't get it, consider why people enjoy horror movies, not all art is supposed to make you feel good. Finally, for those who are easily offended, you know that's the point, right? Just be aware that when you are grasping your pearls, you are exactly the person that this music is supposed to offend and your reaction continues to be a key element driving Eminem's enduring popularity.

The Way I Am is probably my favourite Eminem song. Every song on this album is a banger.

This is a very conflicting album to review. I don’t normally do this, but I decided to read some of the other reviews before forming mine, and this is a great point raised by someone else. “while I realise all the bigotry and homophobia is part of the act, it is hard to digest at points, Kim being the biggest challenge.” It’s important to note that Slim Shady and Eminem are two different personas, but it’s easy to forget and also easy to just lane it as an excuse to say some pretty crazy things. There is a theme that whenever I listen to an Eminem album, there are parts that are so good. Like one of the best things I’ve ever heard. And then there are parts that are just can be both absurd and other parts that are just straight up terrible. Overall, I did enjoy the album. Maybe more than I’d be willing to admit, but there are definitely songs I’d skip.

So overly aggressive, a few standouts and a few new songs to me.

Groundbreaking...? Maybe. I'm not a big fan of rap music per se but there are some really good moments on this LP.

Look he's clearly a talented rapper and can write hits, and there's some brilliance on display here. But the whole being shitty to shock people schtick comes off as contrived and sure doesn't do it for me.

- bizarro - letras insanas - kim uma das músicas mais perturbadoras já feitas - álbum FODA

I very much dislike the misogynistic lyrics, but I can’t deny that the beats are very good.

It's got the Slim Shady song, but that's about all that's kinda good.

Eminem’s opus and a huge cultural juggernaut at the time. It’s also part of the reason why some of the songs here are not as enduring as other artists from the era. The pop culture references are too often cemented in its time and other aspects have aged poorly (but still better that the Shady LP). But there are songs here that are just as strong as ever. Stan and The Way I Am, for example, remain some of his best singles. While albums cuts like Criminal and Who Knew are standout album tracks. As always with rap albums from this time, the skits have little replay value. But the impact and quality of a lot of what’s here can’t be denied.

A disturbing peek into the troubled mind of a rap icon.

Hip-hop doesn't become music even when white criminals make it. I'll save myself the trouble of even listening to it. 1/5

1/5 Not for me. Kim is one of the craziest songs i’ve ever heard though

One the best rap albums ever. Launched him into top-level fame.

Undeniably talented. Truly one of the best. When this came out I was in Middle School and loved it, but then again, it has the humor of a middle school child. Doesn't quite hit the same on adult ears.

Some very good songs, but some very, very weak songs, making this album overall not enjoyable.

some good beats but overall YIKES

I imagine I'm probably not the only one who has mixed feelings about this album. On one hand, nostalgic slim shady classics like 'Stan' and 'The Real Slim Shady' are always fun. I enjoy, and regularly listen to hip hop, rap, and pop from the early 2000s, so the genre is my style. However, listening to this album all the way through was...tough. All of the lyrical misogyny (especially doing the song Kim...yikes) was hard to swallow. Idk if it was meant to be received as tongue-in-cheek or somehow subversive, but it just read as Good-Ole-Classic-Angry-White-Guy misogyny to me. And don't get me started on the anti-queer lyricism in 'Criminal'..! Lowkey, I feel like this is the album that Red Pill guys and incels listened to growing up lol. That said, ALL of the beats on this album are fire. 2/5.

βαρέθηκα λίγο

el disco de stan y the real slim shady, algunas mejores, otras peores, buen disco en general

Did not fuck with it very much.

Not bad. You can see why it’s popular. I don’t mind some hip hop but it’s too brash and annoying for me.

One all time great slim track and one sad Stan. The rest ranges from good to borderline.

7. It's Eminem. Kinda weird the choice of what's next from song to song i. e. the intro, then Stan, then a high energy song after then a more personal one after. Made it feel like a bunch of tracks not a typical album. Themes good reminded me why people like him. Too shouth for me

3/5 God I fucking love m&m's

Favorite track(s): Stan, The Way I Am, The Real Slim Shady

This was so cartoonishly violent wtf, why do you hate women. Still giving it two stars bc of Stan + Slim Shady though.

I try not to apply a 2025 lens when listening to an album, but man, that was hard to listen to at times.

Great album, eminem's skill is undeniable but the lyrics are just a bit too cringe. He really leaned into the offsensive for the sake of being offensive and it takes the shine off what's otherwise a 5/5 album.

I remember getting this as a teenager and my parents absolutely hated it, for good reason. I do cringe a bit at some of the bars and aspects haven’t aged well, but it’s undeniably a classic, sophisticated, has genuine depth and complexity to it… in addition to a cartman impression.

I don’t know if it’s nostalgia listening to this growing up because I don’t think I’d like it now but I liked listening to this.

nicht ganz gehört, aber eminem cool

MY FAVEEEEE

Strong 2/3. Though I really can't get on board with the constant use of violent misogyny, homophobia, and unhinged violence references, I cannot deny the sheer skill that Eminem has as a rapper. Furthermore, the production on this album is incredible; creepy, fun, hard, atmospheric, etc. etc. This really feels like an album that's meant to be listened to start to finish, and though a track like Kim makes me viscerally uncomfortable to listen to, that might just be the point.

Liked it more now than I did at the time, the lens of nostalgia helps and now I appreciate the production value and lyrical phrasing. Like many rap albums it has too many tracks and not a fan of skits but overall can see what its a classic for a generation of hip hop fans. 3.4

It's undeniably a work of art as music, but damn are some of these songs hard to listen to. Not just because of the upfront homophobia and misogeny and whatever other heinous shit he says, but some of these songs just so amateurish. The highlights of this album are amazing however. Stan is incredibly heartbreaking, and eases you into the rest of the album, and Slim shady is hilarious and catchy as hell. Favorite song: Stan.

Enjoyed it

Dated a little but still a watershed album.

I liked this much more than I thought I would. I didn't take to Eminem back when this came out as too many neds were into it. It's a genuinely exciting and engrossing album. Lyrically sharp, well produced with a lot of variety with unexpected twists and turns, and some great hooks. Intentionally shocking and clearly designed to court controversy, it does at times become puerile. There are some songs which are genuinely uncomfortable listens too, which is obviously the intention. Still, holds a special place as I saw him live not long after this was released and to this day it's the only time I have seen the biggest music star in the world live.

A formative listen for the younger David Macnamara, and I reckon it'll also be one for my 10-year-old son too, which is somewhat troubling.

Yeeeeesh this is nostalgia voting

I grew up in a white mostly lower middle class area and this record was owned by every angsty kid. 20 plus years later it feels kinda try hard.

Enjoyed the singles but a lot now feels dated and very 'ooh look how shocking I am"

i can understand why only a couple songs went mainstream.

I'm back was best een banger. 3 sterren

Reaudição

Eminem is entry level hiphop, the rapper you first get into as an early teen before you discover there are so much better hiphop out there. Sure he's a great rapper, but the music? As of 2026, he's got more shit than good albums. Some good songs here, Stan obviously, The Real Slim Shady, Bitch Please II but overall it's a bit mid despite good production. Kill You and Kim for example are absolute shit songs.

Stars off for the rape

I mean the nostalgia is real but with a relisten it’s still a phenom

This stuff is really strong - the fluid way he raps is pretty amazing. I definitely can see why it's such a well-regarded album. Would I ever go back and listen to it again, though? No, I really struggled to continue with it - a lot of the lyrics were a bit much for me. I'd probably give it a 4 if I didn't speak English. 3/5

Yeah so this is several minutes too long and the shock value content gets tiresome, but goddamn if it isn't catchy at times too. The Real Slim Shady and Stan are all-timers.

Classic Eminem. It really don't get any better than this from Slim Shady.

un poco bastante disgusting im back nice

Wow - this was really good!! First time ever hearing Stan.

pretty good tad bit explicit for my liking but otherwise pretty good

This album is where Eminem hit his peak, everything coming together just perfectly. Some of the lyrical content hasn't aged too well, but I'm definitely not going to mark it down because of that. There's a diverse range from humour to horror, all beautifully delivered. It's one of those rare albums where there's not a single dud track. I listened to this loads when it first came out, and relistening now reminded me just how good the production, beats, and delivery are. Easy five star album.

Okay, yeah...it's good. I can't fault it for quality. Very creative rapping, classic hiphop production. But...damn it's a difficult listen for me at this stage in my life. There's so much negative, angry energy. Good record.

I’m so sorry I hated this.

This guy has issues.

Får litt minuspoeng for de nasty skitsa som ikke var så ålreit å høre på mens jeg jobba. Og kunne sikkert kutta halvparten av låtene da albumet er ganske langt. Da hadde han kanskje hatt noe bedre materiale han kunne gikk ut i disse dager og. Men runder opp siden dette er utrolig bra på sitt beste - Stan, The Real Slim Shady osvosv spilles og snakkes om i dag og av en grunn.

Her var det mye greier, sliter litt med å plassere ratingen. Noen bangers, men kunne definitivt kuttet en god del her, litt vel langt for min del. Legger det på en 3/5

Nokre som får meg tilbake til barneskulen, nokre nye bra for min del men òg ein del som eg tykte lite om. Høyrer nok Ikkje gjennom HEILE albumet igjen.

2026.01.09.

Stupid childhood reason why I tend not to gravitate towards rap. Picture it! Vague early 90s there was a comerical for Kool-Aid with the Kool-Aid Man (Oh Yeah!) dressed in an open Hawaiian shirt complete with bling rapping his little Kool-Aid rap. My weird little brain thought that was the stupidest thing ever & I was turned off by rap ever since. UNTIL this man came along & showed me that rap can be more than just Money, Drugs, Ass, N-bombs & over-inflated egos. He showed me rap can be dark, hysterical & satirical. This is a dude who says you can rhyme orange by how you say the word similar to orange. Not nearly as good as Slim Shady LP but still on the level. Em touches on such topics as: censorship, parental responsibility/accountability, the wear & tear of fame, insane fans & his hatred towards POP music such as Britney, Nsync etc. I had to skip Kim, I've heard it before & don't need to hear his angry fantasty about killing his wife again. I get that his music is his therapy but my God. He did it better with '97 Bonnie n Clyde anyway. 4

78/100. The Marshall Mathers LP by Eminem is a good rap record with a mix of different elements, from childish humor to violent horrorcore themes. The album flows well, and Eminem’s sharp lyricism is on full display. However, the interludes absolutely tank the rating for me, they're god-awful and disrupt the listening experience. Without them, this could have been even stronger.

Listened on the drive to and from work. Certainly not a record for anyone with a weak stomach. But if you can get past the misogynistic and homophobic character acting the messages of celebrity worship, media hypocrisy, and male loneliness are as relevant today as they were in 2001.

looove eminem

An angry album featuring unwell people was not to my taste

Influential, but badly aged. I lived through my eminem face and grew stronger from it. Kim is still one of the worst tracks I have ever heard

I liked the song about writing a letter and then the slim shady song lol

Exactly 497 albums ago, that is, a year and a half, and nearly half of this list ago, I aspired to become more culturally attuned and educated on the finer points of music. ‘What expansive worlds would these 1001 albums hold?’ I wondered. Today, the generator gave me fucking Eminem. Yesterday, I had the Red Hot Chili Peppers. Before that, Slipknot. Half way through this list, and I’ve discovered a few good albums, yes. For the most part though, I’ve been sifting through vapid inanity, hoping to find a gram of gold. I’m definitely not becoming more culturally attuned. In fact, I’m beginning to consider if I even like music or culture in the first place. I mean, Mathers actually made this album on purpose, and it was celebrated. What the fuck, world? Generator, if you give me another god damned Eminem album, I’m going to pull a Stan.

Stan is great and I like The Real Slim Shady well enough, but the rest is… just not good.

I think I understand now why, for much of my younger life, I did not like rap. In my predominantly white, small, rural hometown, rap was synonymous with Eminem. And I do not like Eminem. Now, I do not dislike Eminem because I am offended or pearl clutching or anything like that. I am fully aware that the shock value is all a bit. He literally says so in Stan - which is a great song by the way. Maybe one of the most prescient songs of the 21st century. He then repeats this in the last track on the album. No, my issue with the shock value Eminem is going for is how trivial and childish and boring it is. It is equivalent to the torture porn horror films of the era. Trying to be shocking for the sake of it. Not much to say. Empty gesturing. Once you get over the initial shock of what you are hearing (if it even perturbs you in the first place) it becomes so mundane and uninteresting. I think the album does work though as an interesting time capsule of the late 90s early 2000s when politicians spent a decent chunk of time having congressional hearings about the dangers of Grand Theft Auto games, Eminem, and South Park. And I will hand it to the album for calling that out.

Fav song-Stan

Stan’s a good song. I think he’s doing too much with the rape and murder stuff though. I can appreciate what it’s done for hip hop.

Skemmtileg! Mikill húmor og grípandi lög

Klassi. Ansi agressíf, sem er gaman í þessu tilviki. Nýtur líka góðs af nostalgíunni.

HhohoHIPHOP für weisse TrailkerParkTrashKidies GOAT! und natürlich Dr. Dre. c

Bom álbum, com ícones e fillers

Bom mas seilá

This aged like milk. The lyrics are cringe and the beats are repetitive and uninspired. No wonder his lyrics had to be shocking—without them, this is boring.

Great album.

Buen álbum. El rapero de mi generación y nunca había escuchado un album suyo completo. 8/10

Nobody tryna cancel u brochado💔 Stan 10/10 incredible The blowjob was unnecessary Catchy beats, sometimes corny lyrics Half the shit bro be saying is just "they hate me cause I'm white/grab my crotch too much/say I wanna rape women/say I wanna shoot people/say slurs Amiryville 1:20 ts was not needed🙏

Feels very childish, in subject matter and when Eminem sings hooks. Though horrorcore in general is definitely not for me. Stan and Eminem's sometimes-used rap skill pull it up a bit.

No thanks M&M

Nostalgia album but I think it still holds up.

Where I thought the Slim Shady LP was a great balance of funny and edgy, the Marshall Mathers LP is more like funny and whiny. I still like it, but it’s hard to listen to a decamillionaire complain about how hard fame and fortune are

Coulda been a 4 but then went way overboard with homophobic edge lording at the end

Göttliches Album, das sind 5 Sterne und das Ende der Diskussion. Nur wacke Pussies geben weniger

Voller Nostalgieflash, hab ich als Jugendlicher auf und abgehört - gut, dass ich die Hälfte nicht verstanden habe, teilweise sehr grenzwertig. Hat sich dennoch sehr gut gehalten. Bin zwischen 4 und 5 geschwankt, aber die erste Hälfte + Bitch Please II sind es 5 wert.

Einige Songs machen das Album 5 Sterne würdig. Stan ist ein zeitloser Banger. Leider sind die Skits und die Texte über Rape usw. nicht so nice. Daher nur 4 Sterne von einem Eminem Fan

There’s violently misogynistic and homophobic lyrics, there’s some tracks I didn’t care for all, and then there’s Stan, one of the best tracks in Hip Hop history.

He’s an angry Elf!

Disturbing for the most part but some nostalgic bangers like bitch please 2

I just dont like rap. I can appreciate the message behind some of the lyrics but this was not the vibe for me today.

Awww... poor little pasty white boy. Go get some therapy for your hate.

All he raps about is violence. He’s like a Disney adult finding out they can swear. He sucks

I am a fan of album's that flow seamlessly and I feel like the insert of skits really adds an extra layer to the project to make it feel more visual. overall, pretty vibey and melodic. i think the beats are smooth and flow really well from one song to the next. eminem's lyricism is also so strong and clever.

can be argued sonically, but lyrically… no

No. 65 The beats are fantastic independent of the lyrics. His flow and rhymes are incredible.

a classic in my home lol. my mom has always said that marshall mathers was her first husband

????????

The features on the album were so good Fav songs: Asshole, The Monster, So Much Better

A master class in rapping, rhyming and cinematic storytelling, aided and abetted by a stellar production. Eminem further cements his position as one of the best MCs of his generation with an incredible flow, a unique mix of white trash, horror core and hardcore rap, and a level of irony and burlesque rarely seen before in hip-hop (except maybe with Kool Keith). Juggling between multiple fictive personas, he creates a vivid and theatrical gallery of monsters that only serves to mirror the society that produced them. The level of pearl-clutching this album seems to cause is absolutely hilarious, and only proves that it's still relevant today. People whining about the slurs and the violence clearly don’t understand the difference between an author, a narrator and a character. Do they also think Borat is a real documentary about a real Kazakh man ? Anyone who listens to Stan or Kim and doesn’t understand that the whole album is satire / social commentary just deserves to be laughed out of the room. Yes, it’s crass, juvenile, provocative. It’s the hip-hop equivalent of shock-rock, it’s meant to be over-the-top. And this record completely hits the mark in that regard, reaching ridiculous levels of trashy dark humour that haven't really been matched since (or maybe by R.A. the Rugged Man and J-Zone). It’s absolutely no coincidence that the last track is a South Park tribute ; they all come from the same place of anger at the world and its insanity. 9/10

“Steve Berman” says it all. With this record, this young white kid flips and makes fun of everything, with a great flow and a rare mix of emotions, from cynicism to melancholy or rage. It’s very funny, offbeat, openly provocative but it is still over the top rap. A real bomb, consistent from start to finish, and one Eminem will struggle to match again. Loved and still love it.

Omg just that

I’ve listened to this album many times since it was released. Strangely, it gets more shocking the older I get. Maybe it’s the slowly changing social environment. Despite that, Eminem is in peak form on this album. 3.6/5.0

I’m surprised at how little I liked this album. I heard Eminem was considered great and this was almost a trash album. 1st half much better than the second

Creative lyrical Stan is a shocker The Real Slim Shady is iconic Eminem

I’ve listened to Eminem, I like Eminem, but have I listened all the way through? No. His lyrics are just so good, still relevant to today. Wanna talk about reading somebody honey he wrote the book!

Unlike the Fatboy Slim album this was interesting and engaging even if it isn’t normally a genre I listen to.

Dated beats, homophobic and misogynistic lyrics, bigotry - it's all present on this album. And although the same can be said about N.W.A's "Straight Outta Compton", at least that was an authentic expression of lived experience. That can't be said about this album by a white boy called Eminem, even though he tried to present these trash opinions as his alter ego "Slim Shady". Whether it was meant to be satire or a provocation, I don't buy it. It's a sophomoric album for sophomoric listeners. Not me. 1/5

Rap is definitely not my genre. But there’s no denying how talented Eminem is. Hated Kim, Hated Kill You. Loved Stan

Some of the skits are just awful and there is alot of homophobia and misogyny in this album which is a real turn of. But if you ignore the 14 years old boy humour on this album (which is pretty hard) the album is great, really catchy and even tho some people might struggle with the violence im here for it. Kim is too much tho.

Kill you-4.5/10 Stan-5/10 Who knew-4/10 The way I am-4/10 The real slim shady-8/10 generational Remember me-3,5/10 I’m back-6.5/10 Marshal Mather’s-4.5/10 Drug ballad-4.5/10 Amityville-2/10 Bitch please 2-5.5/10 Kim-3/10 Under the influence-5.5/10 Criminal-4.5/10

There were some examples of really cool lyricism and one or two songs that weren’t bad, but the amount of discussion of the rape and murder of women was hard to listen to. I actually skipped through the ends of several songs where it was just uncomfortable, including especially the song titled Kim. I used to listen to Eminem when I was a kid and didn’t really understand some of the hate he received, but as a 28 yo woman listening to his music made my stomach churn.

Yes, there are parts of this album that are very hard to listen to, but it shouldn't simply be dismissed as hateful and/or juvenile. It's a very candid and raw snapshot of Eminem as he struggles to process his abrupt ascent to ultra-fame and all that came with it. From overzealous fans, to industry haters, to reactionary media blaming musicians like him for all of the ills in American society. In response to the latter, he has dialed up the edgelord content to 11 throughout. Much of it is tongue in cheek. The trouble is that it's not always obvious and the literal interpretation of some of these lyrics is, frankly, irredeemable. Eminem earned his reputation as one of the most talented lyricists in rap with this album. The rhyme schemes are dense and his delivery is adept. The singles are all obvious highlights. Unfortunately, this being an album from the early 00s, it was required by law to have terrible skits throughout. The latter half also is noticeably less strong than the former. Light 4.

At least Stan was good, but still awful

Like Tropic Thunder, it's a classic, but you couldn't get away with this shit today.

I wanna say this is overrated. That could just be bc it was so insanely huge & played a zillion times tho. There’s no denying the popularity, significance, or impact in its time. Listening now brings a similar sense of mild cringing embarrassment as thinking about my own early adulthood. And I don’t think that’s *only* bc they overlap. It was cool AF at the time, but now probably best left to memories—be they fond or cringe. I cannot stress enough just how 5stars this album was in the early aughts. In damn-near-2026 I’mma dial that back to about 3. Plus a 1/2 star bc 3 seems low for an album of such significance. But then we’re gonna round back down bc I think I may prefer the SSLP

kinda depressing but honestly good

Like the last Eminem album I had parts of this were really rough. There are some pretty solid songs on here (Stan, Who Knew, The Real Slim Shady), but there are also plenty of songs that are almost painful to listen to. Despite that, Eminem is somehow always a better rapper and lyricist than I expect him to be. I've yet to hear a rap album where I consistently enjoy the sketch tracks, and this was no exception. Suffering through Ken Kaniff did prompt me to look up the history of sketch tracks in rap and hip hop albums though, so that was fun. 2.5, rounding up.

Eminem's greatest work, all on one album. From "Stan" to "The Real Slim Shady" to "The Way I Am" to "Kim," Eminem changed people's perspective on the rap format by deciding to write songs about more vulnerable aspects about his life. Effortlessly witty and vulgar, Eminem created what many people consider one of the greatest hip-hop albums of the 2000s.

Huge influence on me as a teen. The flow and beats are unmatched. Opened up my eyes to a lot

Listening to this album makes me feel bad for Eminem (or at least the Eminem of 2000). This is music written by an troubled guy. It's also really hard to listen to because of how edgy and heavy it is. The constant f-slurs don't help either. I had to take a few breaks while listening. Eminem is a technically gifted rapper and Dre's production is clean, but I won't be returning to it anytime soon.

A classic

I’ve never been able to get onboard with Eminem. He is undeniably talented, but he applies his talents in a direction that makes it difficult/impossible to enjoy his work.

Incredible, but I always found it slightly over the top

Clever lyrics, didn’t love the beats, some repetitive themes about struggling with fame, wildly homophobic

You really just need like two songs

Great production, skilled lyricist, but none of the writing aged well. This was some 13-year old fantasy stuff, and it was a really tough listen. I don’t think I’ve ever heard a more consistently homophobic or misogynistic album.

Two great songs

Not my favourite

nem ouvi

1: 7/10 funny | kill you 2. 2/10 just don’t like it странный звук маркера постоянно сзади , не нрав когда вумен поет ну и он тоже не оч |stan 3. Ну рэп 6/10 не слушала бы все равно | who knew 4. прикольно начала, get the fuck out of my office 9/10 потому что не песня 5. вначале будто про дрэйка тихо говорит, не нрав мне 2/10 |the way i am 6. Ну 100 раз слышала, core memory с типом с колледжа под это, ну 8/10 Но я бы тоже не слушала, уже хочу чтобы этот альбом закончился …. 7. Вот этот ор в конце вообще ужас, 3/10 | REMEMBER ME 8. Они будто +- все одинаковые, будто одна песня 4/10 9. какая-то спокойная песня но снова оч похожа, там какой-то будто второй чел еще есть хотя я его не вижу в фите, чуть будто отличается от остальных, but still 4/10 | marshall mathers 10. ЧТО ЭТО ЗА НАЧАЛО ТФ sounds disgusting why am i listening to cock sucking tf 0/10 | Ken kannif 11. Да снова не нравится мне просто уже и женский голос добавился | Drug Ballad 5.5/10 12. Одно и тоже amytville | 4/10 13. Эта получше уже кстати А потому что это фит с огромным количеством людей я пон ну 6/10 | Bitch Please II 14. меня пугает эта песня первая минута будто перед убийством и каждый раз когда он разговаривает я пролистала половину меня оч она пугает 2/10, 7/10 за идею | Kim 15. So you can suh my dihh if u don’t like my shit ну с этим я согласна Ну а так 8/10 повеселее Лослушивать не прям хочу прикольно что фит с кем-то, у него песни получше когда это фиты | under the influence 16. Предпоследняя песня фух, 5/10 Дефолт 17. ну 5/10 спокойнее песня, в конце последние 5 сек прикольный звук Album review: 3/10. Just not for me. Not saying song are bad but i don’t like this type of songs. Mostly felt like the same song all over just w diff lyrics. When he do feat w someone sound much better but still not my thing. The sucking dick in Ken Kaniff was weird asf even tho it’s funny but sounds rlly bad lmao, and song Kim is scary asf. In overall wouldn’t listen to it. A heard a few good songs, but this album didn’t make me feel like Wow his songs are so good. No offense. 23.12.25

Sociopathic yet compelling

Very nostalgic feels like high school - the horror rap elements are simply not for me nor the deeply dated worldviews but there are hits

I originally listened to this when it came out. Enjoyed the same tracks now as I did then and was happy to have the chance to re-listen to this. Had forgotten just how much there was to Eminem’s lyrics.

Ok this has some very challenging (to say the least) lyrical content and the skits are generally needless but this remains a great album. The production is on point and this represents Eminem at his best, before his focus became faster and faster delivery I know Eminem brings a lot of baggage but there is no denying the impact of songs like The way I am and The real slim shady. Album tracks like Kill you and who knew could easily have been singles with the only mis step being remember me, but that may be due to a lack of Eminem. Stan obviously sits on a different level and demonstrates the impact of story telling through rap to wonderful effect. Overall i think i’ve move down from a 5/5 to more 4.5/5 as my ability to look past some (a lot) of the lyrical content has changed with age and at times it feels like it could’ve been tighter (lose the skits and a couple of tracks)

This album has not aged well - the skits are juvenile at best, and offensive. Some tracks are actually quite hard to listen to (“Kim”). If you put all that aside, the meat of this is an example of the second album being so much better than the debut. Tracks like “The Way I Am” and “The Real Slim Shady” are classics, and typical of Eminem’s output at that time - but it’s “Stan” that, still, makes you stop and seriously listen. You would see less gimmicky tracks in work after this album’s release, but it’s this album which gives you a sense that there was more to Marshall Mathers than just shock lyrics. If I had a 3.5* option, I’d give it - but actually, all criticism aside, it’s better than that.

The Generator linked to the clean version on Amazon Music by default, which was very confusing given that it dealt with the opening Public Service Announcement by just completely skipping it. I nearly carried on playing the clean version out of pure curiosity - I assume it's 75% silence - but searched and found the original instead. I loved this record when it was released. I still see why I would have done to be honest. Songs like Kill You and I'm Back are catchy as hell. But when the Generator gave me the Slim Shady LP, I mentioned that I felt very differently about that as a middle aged woman than I did in my late teens/early 20s. I wasn't sure if the same would be true for this record. It's probably not the popular opinion, but for all their shock value, I think Eminem has always thought carefully about his lyrics. However the subject matter in this album is where he started a bit more self reflection, in places at least. The writing is far better for it, despite often being as hate filled as on previous releases. Stan is a really powerful song and I entirely understand why it was such a massive hit. It changed the world's vocabulary. I genuinely find it fascinating there are people who use "stan" in context and have no idea where it came from. The Real Slim Shady basically defined an era. I can entirely play the MTV VMAs 2000 performance of this song in my brain while listening. It's still great. To me, this is a much better album than The Slim Shady LP. I still enjoy this (with reservations) while my memories of that album were so much better than the reality of listening to it in 2025. There is still an absolute ton of misogyny, homophobia and violence on this album, but there feels like (a little) more commentary on where that came from and (a little) more thought about the impacts. Though, you know, he still wrote tracks like Kim, which urgh. I hate skits and I had completely forgotten this album has the Ken Kaniff skit on it, which is probably the worse skit in the history of skits (bet that didn't make the clean version of the album). This was probably a 3.5 for me, but I can't justify a 4. 3/5 [After listening to the record, I read the Wiki entry. I particularly enjoyed: "In his book Edited Clean Version: Technology and the Culture of Control, author Raiford Guins writes that the clean version of The Marshall Mathers LP "resembles a cross between a cell phone chat with terrible reception...and a noted hip-hop lyricist suffering from an incurable case of hiccups".]

you listen to this and wonder whether all those old people were right about his music

took me back to being 12 and playing hypixel

Even I, the least hood-person in the least hood-country during a sheltered childhood, was affected by this album in 7th class. It took us all with it, from catchy (Slim shady, The Way I am) to beautiful melodies (Stan) to being outright shocked (Kill you, Kim, ...). Lyrics don't hold up perfectly, but from pure nostalgia, the 5* are warranted. For a non hip hop person the most important hip-hop album.

Genre changing Album that had an effect on millions of people. I’m a Stan!

Top tier

What a talent, he can literally make anything rhyme with "suck my c*ck", as he demonstrates quite often! I didn't feel this one had aged so well though or maybe it's me that hasn't aha

fine. most songs were good but a few i really didnt like

good but not my speed for the entirety of an album

There are like two good songs on this album. The rest is bad. Some of them are downright annoying. I thought I would like this album considering I've been getting into Hip Hop and I knew I kinda liked some of his songs. But this is just not good.

If there’s one good thing I can say, Eminem really knows how to put on a show. This guy just complains and whines all over this album. A lot of artists do this, but at least they put the effort in to make it sound good. This was just a miserable listening experience overall. Ken Kaniff was absolute rock bottom of getting through this noise. Won’t be listening to this again.

Another solid Eminem album, nearly as good as his first major studio album, the Slim Shady LP. Beats are solid, Eminem is still rapping hungry. There are probably a couple more skippable or just average tracks here, but nothing that is bad. This and Slim Shady LP are his only two truly great albums. The third one, after this, is decent, and then it starts to go downhill. Some of these tracks transcend hits, like Stan, the Real Slim Shady and Drug Ballad. 5/5

Hay algún disco de rap/hip-hop que no se pase de los 40/50 minutos? es que aún no encuentro un disco en esta lista que no exagere con los minutos dedicados. Eminem dedica 72 minutos a sus problemas con el resto del mundo, pero agota.

Yes, Stan is a provocative song but the anger of this album as is the case with all Eminem albums turns me off,

The legacy of this album is complicated. It can easily be interpreted as violently misogynistic and homophobic, but I think the gratuitousness of both is intentionally satirical and pushes the boundaries as art should. But it is definitely tough to listen to at times.

I thought I was going to not enjoy this as much as I did. I listened to it quite a bit back in the day and thought that I might find it a bit too crude and offensive 25 years on - but no, it’s a classic. Beyond one or two filler tracks, everything else is high calibre - dark, disturbed but highly self aware. Kim is still pretty harrowing though and I won’t be playing it around the kids any time soon.

Conflicted on this one. Has some brilliant moments but also some stuff that maybe hasn't aged so well. No doubt it's an important and influential album for it's time.

I remember this being quite controversial on its release. I quite enjoyed the music but not so much the message which I found hard to relate to. 8 Mile provided more context on Eminem’s background and upbringing. Listening to it now I can appreciate the album in its historical context and feel less shocked by the misogyny and homophobia. It is the sound of an angry man saying fuck you to anyone and anything in his way. I do hope he has found peace as he got older. Solid 4.

It's offensive undoubtedly, where's the line between edgy & downright antisocial? Elton John's story about why Eminem isn't homophobic convinces me that this is firmly tounge in cheek, it's a shock jock approach to selling records and as a commercial success it certainly hit the mark. The final track,The Kids, which is samples South Park is another bit of supporting evidnce that this album isn't to be taken seriously. I'm also conflicted on rating an album with 'skit' tracks that mean you want to keep a finger close to the skip track button. The genius of the rhythm & rhyme comes through strongly but ultimately it's probably only 6 or 7 tracks within a bloated 77 minutes. Despite all these contradictions i think it's great

Let down by a very mediocre second half.

The 2nd half drops off a bit, but still holds up.

Definitely mixed, few known iconic songs. Couple definitely not his greatest work that’s for sure

An unreal wide sunny

Great album, horrible lyrics

3.5 - Not quite a 4, just because of how graphic some of the lyrcis are. Hasn't aged too well.

Storming. Absolutely brilliant. One of the best rap albums of all time. Enjoy!

I've never seriously listened to Eminem before this and expected to hate it but I'm honestly impressed. The ridiculousness of a lot of the lyrics is annoying but hilarious. I honestly don't know how seriously I should take this and that makes it even more entertaining. Would give it above a 3 if it didn't start to wear on me by the last quarter.

Needs more then 5 stars to rate this album.

klasyczek

Legend. Might wanna change the diddy references lol. Glad I listened to this one, it was a first for me. Will definitely be coming back to it

This album is banger after banger. The one stars just do not get Eminem. The absurdity is the point.

I’m half half

It's fine. I still like some songs on it, but it has aged poorly.

I see why my mom didn’t let me listen to Eminem when I was younger. I love how bold and not politically correct he and this album is. He was definitely ahead of the times. Bars after bars

No lo terminé. No me gustó ni poquito.

Struggled with this. I believe that Eminem has talent as a wrapper and is clever. This album goes too far into being offensive and shocking people for me to enjoy.

Just too much

Two things can be possible at once. The Marshall Mathers LP is an artistic breakthrough AND inexcusably misogynistic, homophobic, and sophomoric. Twenty-five years later, this sounds like edgelord rap, basically a 4chan full-length. Eminem can talk about Slim Shady being a character and how the Marshall Mathers LP reflected his real experiences and mindset at the time. Fine. But none of this shit is OK, and I can't get beyond its more noxious moments ("Kill You," "Who Knew," "The Way I Am," "Under the Influence," etc.) Dre's production is great, Eminem is undeniably talented, and the Marshall Mathers LP sold 25 million copies, so its legacy is set. Counterpoint: Fuck this album. Rounding up to two stars because of "Stan," which owes as much to Dido as it does Em's lyrics.

When I worked in a record store in 1999-2000, we sold so many damn copies of this and I was amazed at how people of all races loved Eminem. I was really turned off back then by the misogyny and homophobia and just generally did not listen to this kind of thing. Still am turned off by it, but I (rightly or wrongly) don't necessarily feel as offended by it now - life has gone on and turns out there are things much worse than edgy lyrics. Never listened to this before, will likely never listen to it again, but it was an extremely compelling listen and I give it credit for that.

Modern day story teller

I had a huge Eminem phase from 13 to 14. And this was the first revisit I did since then. It holds up however some tracks suck. Also some questionable edgy for the sake of being edgy bars.

My feelings about Eminem and his lyrics are too complicated for this review

Confronting lyrics and themes. Dark comedic twists. Brilliant!

Will the real slim shady please stand up

Most interesting when he's considering the parasocial-ness and institutional hypocrisy surrounding him, uninteresting when he's relentlessly misogynistic and gross just for the sake of it

Always been a bit 50/50 on Eminem. I think one hand what he did for hip hop in terms of other opening it to a more widespread (white) audience has never been done before. But I feel like something about the theming of the song has aged terribly. I know a lot is purposely edgy but I can’t get past some of the songs, like the first one. He’s an amazing rapper, and there are some really good and funny bars on here. The production and beats are also great, pretty sure it’s Dr.Dre and him who did it, and always love the little verses which Dre does whenever someone mentions him. The features are good, I really love the Snoop Dogg one. Probably is too long, but doesn’t feel as offensively long as some rap albums of this era. Favourite songs: Stan, who knew, the way I am, the real Slim Shady, remember me, I’m back, Amityville, bitch please II, under influence Overall around 7/10 (only just)

I don't like every song, but this has been one of my favorite albums for a long time. Great work of art.

This album told a great story. I've never heard anything so fun and tell such a detailed story (or multiple stories at that). Overall an amazing album.

Great, but bloated album. Lose 4-5 tracks and this would be one of the greatest rap albums of all time. Ending this album with "Kim" would have been chilling. Baffling decision to include those last few filler tracks.

There was no need for me to hear this before my death.

This album had such a big impact on me as a kid I think I gotta give it a 3

Love the emotion and silliness

Great album for the most part. Was pretty grossed out by the dick sucking skit (those sounds 🤮).

I enjoyed listening to this. Holds up.

Med numre som The Real Slim Shady og Stan havde jeg forventet mere. Der er 18 numre, fraregnet de tre instrumental-versioner og de to skits. Og det er ikke rigtigt fedt. For rap er det klart bedre end noget af det andet, jeg har været igennem her, men jeg havde troet, han havde flere fede sange.

I understand that Mathers is a rap god, but I just cant divorce the bangers in this album from the absolutely disgusting and disturbing content interwoven in all the other lyrics. Genuinely some of the most vile and sophomoric stuff I’ve ever heard.

Banger som faen, Eminem har talens gave og føkker med no hevy beats

Has there ever been someone as talented as Eminem who was as weighed down by his own hang-ups? I've never been mad enough or misogynist enough to relate to his music, even though his flow is extraordinary and the beats are fantastic. I know there's all sorts of arms-length commentary about and ironic distance from the violence, but it doesn't come across as particularly meaningful or clever. Too much of his persona is defensive, navel-gazing and self-aggrandizing for me to be very interested.

Controversial nowadays yes, but it was also meant as a satirical album. Eminem is probably one of the best lyricists / rappers/ poets of the modern era. Amazing beats through the entire album thanks to Dre. Regardless of whether people like Eminem or not his talent and skill and intricacies are undeniable.

I forgot how violent and offensive this album is. Maybe I'm getting old but a lot of these songs didn't sit well with me. Still need to give this a 4 because there are some amazing songs on this record.

Amazing album. Not something I throw on a lot anymore but when it came out, this was insane. Very different than anything else at that time.

I like this album a lot but it is hard to listen to all the homophobia and Kim is brutal. That said, I have so much nostalgia on this one I have to go with a 4. Stan is still one of my favourites.

Had some great songs, but not an album I feel very comfortable listening to

This is supposed to be Eminem's magnum opus, but I think 'The Slim Shady LP' is better. The main difference between this project and the previous one is Eminem focusing way more in the shock value. In this album his sounds way more aggressive and the lyrics are more menacing and vulgar, but I think a lot of the bizarre scenes portrayed through his lyrics are not as appealing or interesting as in his prior record; and I'm talking in general. Obviously 'Stan' and 'Kim' construct some really interesting narratives. 'Stan' narrates the history of an obsessive fan that ends up killing himself and his girlfriend over him not getting a response for the artist. It also works very well as a critic against obsessive fans, even to this day. 'Kim' is another great example and a genuinely disturbing song about a very heated fight between Eminem and his ex-wife Kim that concludes in him murdering her. What 'The Slim Shady LP' and 'The Marshal Mathers LP' have in common are two things: weak choruses and weak beats. Apart from 'Stan', 'The Way I am' and 'The Real Slim Shady', Eminem still doesn't know how to write a memorable or decent chorus. For a rap album it shouldn't matter, but the fact that every song has one chorus, it is impossible to ignore them. Maybe in this project he improved a little bit, but is not that noticeable. When it comes to the beats, I think in the most part they only work as a companion for Eminem's great flows and deliveries without adding much more. Some exceptions would be 'Stan' in which the beats create a very moody atmosphere; 'Marshall Mathers' with the exact same reasons as the previous one; 'The Way I am' has a very dark piano and bells; 'The Real Slim Shady' and 'Kim' because the very distorted beat adds a lot to the unsettling theme. In addition, I think at this point I can firmly say that I'm not a fan of the West Hip-Hop sound. I do still like it, but I do prefer a lot more what they were doing in the East. There are also some aspects about this record I want to mention like the fact that its is one hour and twelve minutes with very forgettable songs, the terrible feature of Bizarre in the song 'Amityville', the super unnecessary skits and the overall homophobia in this record. I'm aware that the latter is meant to add to the 'shock value', but I honestly think it should, at least, be toned way down and I would prefer if there wasn't any. In the end, quite a disappointing album when taking account the status of this album.

So catchy but so full of hate and sadness. If I think the artist (or th artist persona) hates me, I just am not going to score it high.

4.5/5 the fact that people are still pissed and giving this album 1/5 due to the lyrics makes it deserving of an additional 0.5 points.

He just says every thing he can think of that would make someone go "oh my god! did he just say that?" Stan is a good song until i remember the only reason it's good is the sample </3 idk i obviously wasn't there for this album like you edgelords were... in fact, i wouldn't be born for another four years. it's just not for me, and i know that... i am aware of that fact... and i am sorry. i'm sure some of these songs could be really good if i listened without any clouded judgement, but my judgement of Eminem is swathed with smog

I feel like I may have summoned this album by listening to Tyler, the Creator's Goblin this weekend. Same edge, and even the same fondness for cartoons (Eminem: South Park, Tyler: Adventure Time). Review: Basically what Brandon said. The highs are highs (Stan, Real Slim Shady, Criminal) but the album is way too long. I never knew Em has beef with ICP, and now I had to listen to a Juggajob skit with allusions to NWA's "Just Don't Bite It."

I love the energy and lyrics behind everything here. “Kim” felt a bit long for my taste but I think it was just meant to be challenging. “Criminal” is such an awesome end to the album. 4/5 only because I know (vaguely) that Eminem grows and changes a lot as an artist after this.

certified hood classic but the f slurs and r slurs have aged like milk. still, worth listening to if for no other reason than to better understand eminem's impact. it's a good album

It's so wild listening to Eminem after not listening to Eminem for an extended period of time. In the back of my head I know he got a LOT of flack for the kinda stuff he says in his music, but some of the shit he says on here is actually diabolical. His rhyme schemes are crazy though. Bro has a lot of talent for sure. Conceptually, I like this album. In practice, this one is kinda tough to listen to. Am I going to tell you Kim is a bad song? No. I am going to tell you that I am never going to throw on Kim. There are the obvious bangers on here: The Way I Am, Stan, The Real Slim Shady, etc. but I would go so far as to say my favorite Eminem songs aren't even on here. It was cool to hear D12 on here though. RIP Proof

In all honesty, I have never been the biggest fan of Eminem. My opinion suffered via the simple fact that, as a young lad, the most annoying people I had ever met up until that point were massive Eminem fans. They listened to his music and had that same kind of crude sense of humor, but never really said it was a joke or dropped the persona. Naturally, I did not want to be around these individuals or share any of their interests, so I wrote Eminem’s music off (excluding his huge hits and singles ofc). With that bias in mind, I did enjoy parts of this album, but the PTSD flashbacks from those mouth-breathers were definitely unpleasant. My first thought was that it just hasn’t aged well, but I’m not sure that I’ve ever been edgy enough for this kind of thing to be that appealing.

I started listening to Eminem when I was 21 or so (I distinctly remember being infatuated with his BET cypher from 2016), which may explain why I really struggle to enjoy his music. I think ‘Revival’ came out that following year or the next and it was enough to convince me Eminem was not worth my time. ‘Kamikaze’ was fun to listen to the first couple times. Anyway, I certainly don’t have the associated nostalgia that others do. Edgy humor just doesn’t make me feel good and I don’t think his content aged well at all. That being said, his talent as an emcee is undeniable. Certainly in the top ten of all time. “Stan” is a classic for a reason.

I expected to give this a higher score actually. I have this CD somewhere. I’m not an Eminem hater, which I expect several in our listening group are, but my fandom is mostly in the past tense. I think he’s quite talented in spite of his more obnoxious qualities, and honestly I project that onto his fanbase more than him. I think you can listen to pre-2009 Eminem without reaching for the Mountain Dew and Xbox controllers, but that’s just me. He goes through these phases of going in and out of style. He’s like the McRib of music. I’d say I’ve outgrown the horrorcore elements but I also don’t find them particularly offensive or whatever. Just kinda try-hardish. Like, overall, as a person, it seems like he’s only ever really hurt himself; I’d rather him say fucked up shit than do fucked up shit. Maybe a hot take but I can pretty much find a 1:1 comparison in a B.I.G. song for every “shocking” moment here other than the celebrity name drops so I don’t quite know why Eminem is held up as being uniquely offensive. “Kim” is a bit much but it’s supposed to be. I don’t think even at the time he was treating it as anything other than some primal scream therapy. I don’t like it but it accomplishes what it is supposed to accomplish and if you listen to it in the context of being a prequel to 97 Bonnie & Clyde (as intended), it’s an interesting juxtaposition and actually pretty effective. On the censored version that my brother bought from Walmart back in 2001 or whatever, they replaced it with a South Park themed song about drugs that’s pretty fun. Anyway, the good stuff here is very good but like probably north of half of this album sucks. I will say without qualification there’s some excellent songs on this album (the singles, Bitch Please II), and there’s some other pretty good stuff (Kill You, Criminal), but we’ve also got the aforementioned Kim, three stupid edgelord skits, two songs with D12 members who are not especially good at this, and some other very forgettable stuff. And the album is like 75 minutes long and I’ve made my stance on that very clear.

Can't say this didn't age well, it was real edgy then and now. I mean, it's infamous. It 100% should be on this list. It's a solid rap album. It also feels like crinkling styrofoam in many parts. I wonder how the trajectory of my life would have changed if the Scott County public library would have actually let me check this CD out when I was in 5th grade. Sadly, the world missed out on getting E-Mudreezy: Kentucky's best rapper.

Killer. Doesn't age well for 2025 sensibilities but I like it.

Eminem fully falls off after those first three solo albums and the 8 Mile soundtrack but this remains his opus.

Klare 5 Sterne. Wie absurd ist es eigentlich aus heutiger Sicht ein Album mit einem Skit anzufangen, dann mit „Kill You“ einen prolligen Disstrack zu bringen, um beim dritten Song mit Stan dann den wahrscheinlich besten Storytelling-Raptrack überhaupt abzuliefern? Sehr wilde Mischung.

Da sind schon top Songs dabei, auf Album-Länge aber auch teilweise Filler. Und es fällt auf, dass das Album nicht nur bzgl. Lyrics, aber auch stilistisch nicht so super gealtert ist. Reicht daher nicht mehr für 4 Sterne.

Nicht das Meisterwerk, zu dem es immer stilisiert wird. Die Beats sind teilweise sehr schlecht gealtert, die Texte zum Teil natürlich auch und bei knapp 75 Minuten Laufzeit ist etwas Ausschussware dabei. Abgesehen davon aber dennoch beeindruckende Rap-Skills und ungewohnte Tiefe.

Gefällt mir als Album glaube ich eigentlich ganz gut ohne das weiter spezifizieren zu können. Wirkt wie eine gute Erzählung.

Keine Diskusion.

Mir ein bisschen zu lang geraten, deshalb nur 4,5 von 5, aufgerundet dann aber 5. Ich mein was will man hier gegen sagen?

First time I have listened to a full Eminem album. It is a great Album and the songs i hadn't heard grew on me the more i listened

a classic

Alors comme ça, on écrit une chanson qui parle de tuer sa femme ? Mauvaise stratégie, ça fait plus edgy qu’autre chose. Si on omet ça, c’est dans l’ensemble un album plutôt cool et la chanson Stan est très bien écrite. Pas un album sur lequel je reviendrais, mais si on omet Kim (grosse omission, je sais), c’est vraiment pas mal et y’a beaucoup de moments mémorables.

An album that is brilliant, but I can barely stomach listening to. I wouldn't dare say Eminem can't rap about murdering women and use homophobic slurs (among other topics). And the album was hailed by critics, and he got lots of defense from other artist. The guy really spoke to many young men. But it's not for me. At least nine of the songs have some reference to violence against women in some way. Is it great art? Most definitely. Is it distasteful? To me, yes.

Thoughts before listening: I used to own this CD, and this album came out during my college years. It's good and I'm going to enjoy listening to it, but man Eminem's lyrics are hard to stomach now as a mid-40s guy. Review: This is causing major flashbacks for me. Eminem is definitely good. Its hard to argue that he isn't one of the most innovative and interesting rappers of all time. Great beats and potentially the most recognizable delivery of any rapper ever. Nobody else sounds like Eminem. That being said, my original assessment that I can't take these lyrics still remains. I'll give this 3-stars.

Really hard to overlook the extremely crass and unsettling lyrics...yet I'm doing it

Very intentionally Eminem's most provocative album. In this he struggles with his newfound status as a superstar. In particular, he questions the public discourse that accused his music of creating violent shooters on schools. Ultimately however, he points toward the media landscape as the primary culprit, saying their obsession with the hypermasculine homophobic caricature of slim shady, rather than the real artist, is to blame. He then proves his own point by turning that caricature up to 11 fir the whole album, and still having it go platinum. Favorite track is Stan

This might be the ultimate guilty pleasure album and maybe my favorite rap album. Stan is up there for favorite hip hop song as well. All the songs execute their concept well and not too many skits. Each song is unique enough that I remember them easily by the title. One or two of the features on the back half are weaker and the BJ skit was tough but besides that I love it. Eminem at his best, for whatever reason I find the narratives he paints much easier to follow than other rappers. Rating: 4.9

I really not into 2000's rap, but I'm convinced that Eminem is the best that camed out at the time. His raspy voice adds so much to the songs, it gives a constant sensation of hearing someone really angry. I like it.

There are some tracks that I like, but overall its quite uneven and goes on a bit too long.