Reviews (page 12 of 14)
I loved this! Such a great change of pace! I loved the music, and the live performance where I could hear Keith Jarrett reacting while playing was great! I am very happy this is on the list. Really terrific!
It's nice but doesn't keep my attention.
Quite relaxing
Nice relaxing
Не большой фанат концертных альбомов, но это было прямо хорошо
Cool for what it was
In the right mood and the right setting this is excellent, but it's very specific and I can't say it deserves higher than a 3 because of that.
The story surrounding this album is great, that's why it's on here I guess, but the actual music itself doesn't do much for me. Apparently it's all improvised, which is quite impressive, the way it still flows and channels different moods and paces, but it's still an hour of just the piano, which isn't quite enough for me really. I'll be generous and give it a low 3 becuase of the story behind it and that it's a seriously impressive performance, but I didn't particularly enjoy listening to it. 3/5.
Part I- 1/5 Part II a- 1.2/5 Part II b- 0.9/5 Part II c- 1.3/5 Total- 1.1/5
Nice chilled piano. Nothing extraordinary but relaxing background music. 5/10
Piano on a Monday was a choice lol. Great piano though!
Piano shit, not my thing
Long
The infamous concert. Good. 3.9
Yep that sure was a piano concert with occasional moaning in it for some reason.
I'll start by saying, I'd never heard of Keith Jarrett. I listen to some classical music, some pianist's here and there but not really often.. and this album blew me away. I was absolutely moved, taken away by this album. The places this album took me in my mind.. I loved this album. Keith moves a single, granted 20 minute long, track through sooo many different moods and themes its just.. incredible. he truly is a master musician. Overall: 4.7/5
This is one of those albums that on the surface is incredible but if you look into the story behind the album it becomes legendary. Keith played this amazing two piece performance on a baby grand piano due to a mistake made by the promoter and if you don't know the difference a baby grand piano are literally made for houses and have a much inferior sound to Keith's preferred concert grand piano and is like half the size. That is an astonishing accomplishment but it is dwarfed by the fact that this entire album all 67 minutes was completely improvised while having a completely uncomfortable setup. Baby pianos have a lot weaker sound than concert grand pianos but that is especially the case when it comes to the lower register of the piano and Jarett still manages with techniques like ostinatos to strengthen the sound of the bass notes. In all honesty I cannot do a track by track review like I would usually do because there was no intent behind these songs. This album is more an experience of a musician who is truly a savant and has a complete mastery of his instrument more than just about anyone else. It is like hearing Charlie Parker or Sonny Rollins on sax or listening to Hendrix or Tosin Abasi on guitar. It is truly one of the most astonishing musical performances I have ever heard and is among the 2-3 best live albums I have ever heard. He just whips out these long, improvised motifs that are just as good as you will hear in any of the most well reviewed jazz albums of all time. I would suggest anyone who likes this album just look up any video of him improvising. More than any other musician I have seen the music seems to flow out of him in an absurdly natural way. It is one of the most astonishing things I have seen. One of my favorite aspects of this album is how he made the two songs so contrasting with the first being a long, light piece that makes me imagine it being played in a tour of heaven. It is so beautifully played and has these repeating parts that are really addictive to hear. Whereas the second piece is a much punchier track that is just incredibly movement inducing. I really can't think of a simile for what I could imagine this track being used for and I tried for like 15 minutes. It is a completely unique experience and it is incredibly well done with those large periods of intensity juxtaposed with slowed, more emotional parts. I may like other jazz pianists music more like Herbie Hancock, Thelonious Monk or Bill Evans but when we talk in terms of talent and skill I think that Jarrett is comfortably in the top 2-3 conversation. He plays like it is nothing more than breathing to him and it almost comes of as spiritual in the way he plays. In conclusion, this is easily one of the best jazz albums of all time and is one of the best live albums of all time. It sort of makes sense I like this cause I am a big fan of free jazz but nevertheless listen to this album it is great.
Nichts für mich
Perfect background music i guess lol
I began listening to this on my AirPods, but after a minute or so I knew that the fidelity and emotion of this required my nicer cans. Boy was I glad with that decision- This album was simply a masterpiece of raw emotion channeled into a piano with expertise and passion. I could listen to a man pour his heart out with this type of skill all day. The songs appear to have no real gap between them so the 4 part breakage only appears to be a way for this guy to rest before again blowing everyone away. The songs go from peaceful and melodic to laying down some jazzy funk and everything in between. Truly beautiful.
Not my cup of tea but it was good!
Piano music for the soul that gave off a kind of a lofi vibe. Probably won't recognize a note of it if I ever hear it again, but not because it wasn't good. I just can't pick our instrumentals unless I've heard them a thousand times.
Not bad, but nothing incredible.
An hour-long solo record feels so self-indulgent that it was hard to enjoy. It gets one star for teaching me that the interplay between musicians is something I need in my music. (Headphones users beware, Jarrett's foot stomps add nothing but annoying low frequency thumps when his piano mic picks up the vibrations)
I think it’s incredible the level of talent involved to improvise in this way and in those circumstance and I’m glad for the piece of history I learned. But I don’t think I’ll miss this album either.
Nice but long and not too interesting to listen to, to be honest.
Nice piano tracks for an improv show, the fourth one was very nice, the rest kind of nice background piano eith mildly intresting melodies
If I’m going to listen to a piano album, I’d prefer Yanni over an album like this with 17 minute songs where the pianist is moaning and “woooing” in the background. Didn’t finish after the first song.
Masterpiece
Nice calming classic piano piece
Amazing what he did. Proof that talent wins over technology.
Really enjoying it. Piano solo jazz.
Maybe I just don't have the ear for it, but it seems completely unremarkable. The random moans from listeners on the live recording were also very jarring.
Bleeding me away that this was all improvised.
Just piano so not much to take in other than it is very relaxing in the initial minutes. Essentially an hour long piano piece performed live. The random grunts and other noises are kind of hilarious on such a serious piece. Can't say I know enough about piano to say how impresive or not this is. Probably good to put on for a quiet party or something.
Great performance, but it’s not something I would ever really listen to again. Nice piano skills though.
instrumental piano parte 2a y final de la parte 1 brutales muy bueno
This was a pleasant surprise. This isn't my typical style of music to throw on but I was very interested in what I was hearing throuout the whole album. When listening to this, it reminded me of Adam Holzman. I consider both, him and Keith Jarrett to be piano virtuosos. To which, I am familiar with the former from being the active keyboard/pianist for Steven Wilson. I loved the live aspect of this record. You can hear subtle voices through out and it added a bit of charm, and humanity to what I was could only describe as inhuman talent tickling those ivory keys. This would be perfect to see live as I can't fully comprehend what I am listening to. If I could see what I hear, I would have even a higher appreciation to what I am hearing. Any type of record similar to this, I would day the same. Great listen.
In a nutshell: screw it, I'm just gonna play. If you haven't heard of this album, go to the Wikipedia page first. I can't believe that the promoter and Keith still went ahead with the show. What could go wrong leading up to the gig DID go wrong. Yet Keith pushed through and pulled off a remarkable performance. Pretty impressive on a half sized piano. Overall: 7/10
Undoubtedly talented, and with a very appreciative audience it seems to be a masterclass in improvisation. Several pieces are really good but overall I just don't 'get' jazz improvisation. Maybe I need to listen more
en tiiä miksei herrasta kuullut aikasemmin. pianonkikkailija läpikotaisin. suosituin soolo pianonpäpyttely albumi mitä koskaan tehty... huomaa että täydet poppimessut päällä kun joka saatanan sävelen jälkeen ollaan taputtamassa käsiä yhteen kun oltaisiin vittu päiväkodissa... ja jonkun täytyy huudella siellä taustalla kävellessä luulin että joku top 5 toimintakeskus asukas huutelee takaa... vai huuteleeko virtuoosi itse, en tiedä mutta autismd.com mukaan ei ole mikään telkkari ohjelma house pianisti jakso kyseessä... look it up... part 1
It was fine. I forgot it was playing after a while. No strong feelings.
A pretty solo piano concert. Nice dynamics between soft and quiet vs loud and playful. Was pleasant music to grade papers to.
Improvised solo jazz piano. Lord have patience, I couldn't finish this one.
Faisal probably came while listening to this
Wow! Went in with no expectations, enjoyed every minute of it. Just super chill jazz piano.
Boring, prefer classical piano piece.
Shoutout to the man having audible eargasms in the front row
At first I was really impressed with the melody. Very nice piano background music.
This is not music at all but it was ok in the background
Improv jazz, super impressive but not riveting for me
I'm ready to give up
Simply beautifully amazingly played. What a musical genius! Downloaded the album. 5/5
Mmm...not something I would have chosen to listen to. However, he is clearly an accomplished pianist and I detect an element of progressiveness in his compositions.
piano
5 minutes into Part I and I thought I wasn’t going to finish the album. I did not like it. 12 minutes into Part 1 I was looking up the history and reading all about it. This album was a very pleasant surprise for me. I dig Jazz a little bit straight up piano only Jazz isn’t my favorite. This extended jam has really changed what I thought piano jazz can be. I’m very happy with this one.
Good as background music but kinda boring if you’re listening to it alone.
Very relaxing. Surprise of a listen
Amazing piano performance. The vocalizations remind of GameCube video games and take me out of it. Sorry Jarrett.
2/4 First song was partially incredible, Second song was boring
Fantastic record that I wish I had discovered sooner. Keith Jarrett creates an atmospheric sound with just keys, and adds in little yelps when getting excited about the sounds and the feels. Part II B was my favorite. Found a groove that is unmatched by many pianists out today. Would love to own this on vinyl.
Great piano playing, not quite engaging enough for me
Relaxing. Interesting story on the recording.
Good, if you like free-form jazz? A bit too unstructured for my taste.
Beautiful, sounds incredible for a live performance recording even if it is just instrumental. Thought that was a young Lionel Richie on the album art for a second
Really enjoyed Pt. II C and Pt. I, easy to see why it's a bestseller!
It's scored more about the lore behind the album than the actual album it's self. A series of unfortunate events befell this show and the fact Jarrett was able to perform is a massive miracle. Long solo instrumentals aren't my thing, but you can throw this on as background music and be pleased with yourself
Not for me
I was on a musical journey. Gooood stuff that I didn't know before. Yeah.
my ranking system is very random but I do feel like I lend a lot to my feelings on the impressiveness of a recording. and from all I’ve read & heard of this album, it feels genius. who am i to deny that impulse.
nice background music
This is some nice piano and it help me get a lot of work done
Beautiful jazzy improv, what's not to love?
El álbum "Keith Jarrett: Köln Concert" es un registro notable en el mundo de la música. Grabado en 1975, destaca la destreza del pianista Keith Jarrett en una noche de improvisación en Colonia. Una serie de infortunios marcaron esta grabación aun así la ejecución es prolija. La fusión de elementos de piano clásico y jazz crea una experiencia musical interesante. La ejecución de Jarrett es enérgica y muestra su maestría en el piano. Su técnica es innegable, y su capacidad para crear momentos etéreos marca la dirección del concierto. El álbum se enfoca en escalas mayores que transmiten una sensación de serenidad y emoción. Jarrett juega con la tensión y el alivio de manera hábil a lo largo del concierto, manteniendo al oyente comprometido. Si bien es accesible para la mayoría de los oyentes, es una experiencia que podría no repetirse con frecuencia debido a su singularidad y profundidad. "Köln Concert" es una muestra de la habilidad y creatividad de Jarrett.
Lekkere dagdroom music
A concert recording... from 1975. Hard pass. Pleasantly surprised, it is a dude playing piano pretty well. No obnoxious crowd noise.
Beautiful album - great songs. 4/5
I love this album. There’s so much emotion in it. You can hear him going where the piano leads him. Also, that is an exquisite sounding piano. This album accomplishes everything you’d hope. It, first and foremost, entertains, as it is undoubtedly enjoyable. Secondly, you have the technical stuff, like production, arrangement, instrumentation, and structure, which are all fantastic. Lastly, it makes you think as all good albums should. Makes me wonder if music is any less of an art if it’s created on the spot instead of being composed beforehand. In this case, I don’t know how Keith could have done any better except for maybe having a little more time to create bits that spread the album out a little more so there’s more versatility and range. Otherwise perfect in my book. 4/5
I’ve never been much for jazz piano, and with little background info the first part of this concert felt unremarkable. But upon reading about the significance of this album, the out of tune piano, Jarrett’s late arrival, his few bites of pasta, and his playing changing based upon the condition of the only instrument he was able to rely on- this quickly changed to a remarkable show. Jarrett’s playing, while something that I am admittedly not well versed in, was beautifully improvised and transcends the classical jazz piano that one would expect with a number of grooving “bass lines” coupled with his wandering right hand.
Good album.
Ok piano
Good background music and performance. Not life changing or anything though.
At first I was like "oh great, piano for 68 minutes", but I stuck it on while I got shit done and was like "day-um, this is good stuff".
takie pykanie na pianinku. Ani muzyka klasyczna, ani filmowa - nie wiem co to 3/5 max
Solo jazz piano album? Yes please.
First Keith album. Jazzy piano. Not my thing but gave it a listen
A great listen from end to end, very impressive.
Lovely album.
Beatiful music and a lot of atmosphere. Gets a little boring imo thoughwith only piano over the full album length.
Wow. Learning about the piano conundrum made this all the more enjoyable. I’ve never to listened to anything like this before but I love it.
its spa music. smooth, relaxing, inoffensive.
The making of this album is way more interesting than 60 minutes of “vamping”
Interesting story about this live performance. Performance was an overall enjoyable listen… but I could not get past the person audibly moaning in the recording.
Not my thing
The virtuosity on display is pretty amazing! A strong album that takes you on an instrumental voyage. Liked it a lot!
Jaunty soulful album. Didn't fully resonate with me but I liked it a lot still
Ya like jazz? Ya like classical music? If so, then listen to this.
Really enjoyed this. Will be revisiting it in the future. This is live!? What a show that must have been. Listening to this while working is an absolutely blissful experience.
Interesting but got old since its over an hour. Good to listen to with other things going on. I would listen to more by this artist
Not my style
A beautiful work that falls flat in some places. After looking up the history of this concert though, it makes sense as only the middle keys of the replacement piano worked. A beautiful piece of art.
Not my cup of tea. It was alright, but I’ve heard other piano concertos that I would rather listen to.
Enjoyed this. I'm glad I heard the music before reading about the back story. The imperfections only serve to emphasize the improvisation and I couldn't work out whether the infrequent calls made by the artist during the performance were from euphoria or annoyance. Having read the story about the piano, I'm sure both. I would be happy to add this to my collection and check out his other work.
Was not familiar with Keith Jarrett. Perfect album to have on in the background at home or work.
impressive but not my jam
Really good piano performance. Nice variations in each piece. That said, it's just not my thing. This one is a pass from me.
Listened during a nap, made it pretty wild.
Not into classical music at all and the songs were so incredibly long I kept skipping them halfway through due to boredom. But I could tell it's a masterpiece, just not my thing.
Reading through the background on this makes me really appreciate the talent. That said I don't see myself revisiting this except maybe as background music. Even then the random moans are a little distracting
Great live performance.
Ух, как же он стонет 8/10
Klaviermusik.
Good
Nice relaxing album
Listenable. Nice for background.
I like it, but it fades into the background after awhile 3.5/5
It’s just nice piano for an hour.Complete background music.
mesmerizing
very cool, very diverse for a solo piano album
Awesome album, great story behind it.
Serious piano overload. I would love to listen to this album with a piano player. I feel likes it’s so technically brilliant that it’s a bit lost on me. Can’t help but admire the shear talent and passion. Incredible!
This is beautiful music. I really enjoyed it. I had heard of the artist but for whatever reason thought he was some sort of "soft jazz" type deal, which is of course completely wrong. A nice find in the 1001.
I just couldn't quite connect with this.
It's a lot of piano lol. A little too much for my uncultured brain. I could see getting into it more if I trained my brain to listen to it better.
A fun introduction to Keith Jarrett, nice for on the subway or cooking dinner
Starts slow but ends up taking you on a journey. Apparently best selling solo jazz album of all time!
Rewards a close listen. It can drift into becoming background music, but Jarrett will inevitably play some phrase or melody that will grab your attention and bring you back into the moment.
Goes beyond jazz and classical. This is the sound of pushing through frustration while exploring within limitations.
1. At last I get to listen to the full length Barry Norman theme. 2. This is the music played in Mel Gibson’s retirement home. 3. This album was better when they had Jarrett’s original song titles: “Sharon at the Rodeo”, “Miles Cut Yr Hair”, “Where’s My Currywürst, Vera?”, and “Tony, Get The Wheels!” This is obviously a powerful performance in its idiom, a record beloved by many, and a demonstration of what a virtuoso can do under what were apparently crappy circumstances. This is not something that was my jam today, but ended up being decent company for the hour before we went our separate ways.
Quite a dramatic backstory to this helps the music come alive beyond what you hear initially. I was going to make a crass analogy with my history of Doordash breakfast orders, but Jarrett's performance is too good for that. Embraces the best of both "jazz" and "classical", and makes me imagine catching this live would have been the '70s equivalent of seeing Liszt at his peak, man. Listening to this at a high school football game, where nothing happens repeatedly, may have enhanced my appreciation somewhat; think less, but see it grow. Another one that makes me glad I'm doing this project, good stuff. If you're interested, the burrito I salvaged was pretty great too.
It's pretty impressive how captivating an hour of just solo piano improv can be, music is weird. Enjoyed this a lot though, he manages to put so much emotion into his playing, and knows exactly how to build intensity throughout these long pieces. Again, the fact that this was all improv is incredibly impressive, deserves a high rating just for the technical ability on display.
Dette var ganske kult! Digger at man hører han nynne og lage litt lyder en gang i blant, det styrker på en måte det virtuose - musikken bare strømmer ut liksom
"The Köln Concert" by Keith Jarrett is a testament to his exceptional talent as a pianist. Recorded in 1975, this live performance is a remarkable display of improvisation and musicality. Jarrett's piano work is nothing short of extraordinary, showcasing his technical prowess and creative depth. The album's production captures the intimate ambiance of the concert, allowing the listener to feel as though they are in the room with Jarrett. However, the extended improvisations can occasionally feel meandering, which might not resonate with all listeners. While "The Köln Concert" is undoubtedly a remarkable showcase of Jarrett's skill and creativity, its free-form and lengthy nature may limit its appeal to a specific audience. For those who appreciate virtuosic instrumental piano music, it's a must-listen, but others might find it challenging to engage with over its duration.
Real boring
Calming, nice blend of classical and jazz piano. Must be in mood for lots of piano
Delightful.
Just fine background music.
It started off real nice, then it started to get a bit tedious after a while. I didn't even really like it as background music. 2.5/5 rounded down
Obviously a great talent, but that doesn't make it an interesting album.
Technically superb, listened to it twice to try and take it all in, although unlikely to listen again in future
Didnt finish the first track
Excellent playing. Very chill.
Just really boring and tinny. It doesn't know if it wants to be jazz or classical, but there's not really anything interesting to listen to here. Might be okay at the lowest volume in a coffee shop and by lowest volume, I mean muted.
It's improvised ????! It's soooo fucking cool, smooth yet so upbeat at the end of the first part. What an awesome listening
didn't listen
Epic, absolutely loved it
Beautiful jazz piano, love the vocalizing
4.5
The background story of making this live album is quite fascinating. I'm not really into improvisative piano music (coming from a family full of classical musicians incl. pianists) and while Jarrett's talent is amazing this albums feels a bit incoherent and directionless because of its free style. I enjoyed listening to it but admittedly I'll never be someone who understands and loves jazz music that much.
I had no idea what this wa and liked it a lot
sure i guess
Apparently no one had ever improvised on piano before 1975
i’m not going to lie this is very much not my thing. good music for background listening i think, but i am simply not cultured enough to appreciate this properly and this is a Me problem. it is impressive, and beautiful, but not something i would pick up to listen to again
Just gorgeous, in addition to being just a massively, monolithic and sui generis performance – it's hard to imagine a more impressive achievement. It swings, it rollicks. It ponders, wonders and wanders. One feels quite grateful the show wasn't cancelled, and would be interested in an oral history (including audience impressions) of this grand evening and wholly memorable affair.
69/100
Not my jam
Fascinating back story, left to perform on a rehearsal piano, rather than the grand piano he expected, Jarrett abandoned his planned set and improvised for more than an hour. Interspersed by his on yelps as he surprises even himself. Still, interesting more because of his technical virtuosity and the chaotic circumstances behind its creation.
Brilliant. Was not expecting this to be so captivating.
Cool piano performance. Does get a bit boring though.
Jarrett really jams despite the awful circumstances of this concert. It's pretty impressive. I didn't at all mind the long length of this live album.
Good skills by Keithy-boy here
baita som, clássico e tals, pianao muito bem tocado né tcha
HAIKU REVIEW Drifted away with mesmerizing piano like a waterfall
The ability to improvise something that sounds so carefully crafted, with every chord and melody spending virtually no time between conception and existence and yet still sounding like it's exactly where and when it's supposed to be, is an incredible talent.
приятный альбом в начале был
I couldn't make it past the second song, this has gotta be some sort of torture 😭
Yeah, good piano but just not my vibe, a bit too dramatic and stressful.
The solo piano is nice for about 30 mins, and then I needed a break. DNF
Happy to have read the story behind this concert and recording prior to starting. I would be interesting to be able to hear an identical performance with correct piano. I dug further into the life story of Keith Jarrett and continued to be impressed. The background info, the fact that most of the music is improvised, and bad luck of Jarrett's evening make this album a must listen album. The moaning was weird though.
I don't know what this is. There is something about it that is deeply appealing in the same way that other experimental artists like Battles, Silver Apples, and Can are. But this has soul in a way that those groups do not. The live, acoustic nature of this recording makes it so human.
wow 5*
Very cool!
Definitely not what I was expecting, as I wasn't familiar with Keith Jarrett at all. I also find it misleading to label this as a jazz performance. From my perspective, this clearly seems like a performance of contemporary classical music, with slight jazz influences. The only other jazz aspects here is in Jarrett's past experience and that full improvisation is typically associated with jazz. Be that as it may; Jarrett's playing and compositions are fantastic and recording quality is sublime and in no way behind studio quality. This is a wonderful record and deserves its popularity.
While very impressive, this is not something I’d likely listen to again. It does seem like the kind of thing that would be more interesting live, but I don’t particularly think this live recording gives that feeling as it ends up sounding about how I’d imagine a studio recording would anyway.
Interesting concept and story behind this album/recording. Not something I would normally listen to or really enjoy. Was good to have on in the background and that's all I can really say about this one.
Sublime
Very interesting finding out that this is all improv. Wasn’t really that into listening to just piano for over an hour but also didn’t hate it.
Keeping consistent with my relationship with jazz, this is very nice to listen to, but I am humming none of it.
As a current learner on the piano, I am in awe of Jarrett's touch and feel. This isn't sturm und drang playing for the most part, but a quiet virtuosity, the odd tasty flourish showing through the cracks in the paving. Funny, it's also quite hard to categorise this. The Köln Concert straddles classical, jazz and easy listening in equal measures. Perhaps it's a little too easy on the ear as it can fade into background music at points. Still, a pleasant experience.
Osaahan se soittaa. Minä vaan en ymmärrä arvostaa tällaista.
Vaati kyllä aika paljon kärsivällisyyttä, että jakso kuunnella loppuuna asti. Ei huono, mut liikaa
Already owned this. I really enjoy listening to this album.
This was one of those albums that I had never heard before, but absolutely need in my life. Keith Jarrett's improvised pieces are unclassifiable. They are clearly rooted in classical music, but have an unstructured feel. The use of certain chords and chromatic notes give the music a modal jazz feel while other parts show rock and blues influences. Jarrett's characteristic vocalizations are peppered throughout which only add to the extemporaneous nature of the recording.
I hated this one. The moaning, the extended clapping, the aimless improvisation that felt like it went nowhere for lengthy periods of times. I clearly am not the audience for improvised jazz
Literally impossible to pay attention to
an HOUR????
Good but too long. Alfa backstory to this story.
Good enough to earn its length. I didn't appreciate his moaning or the clapping bt audience. the actual music was fine. The second half was better.
Extremely beautiful but much too long (just like my butt cheeks)
meh
Didn’t listen, was half hour classical music pieces and not the exact vibe for the day
very cool
Förvånandsvärt mös
Haunting, melodic and utterly transcendent. Although, would it be sacrilegious to say it reminds me of build mode in the original Sims game? 8/10
zzzzz
there are some bits where he settles into a melody for 2/3 minutes at a time and it’s some of the best music out there
ok
"The Köln Concert" is a live recording of solo improvisations by American pianist and composer Keith Jarrett. It was recorded at the Opera House in Cologne, Germany by 18-year old Vera Brandes at 11:30PM following an earlier opera performance. Jarrett began his career with jazz drummer Art Blakey and also worked with musicians Charles Lloyd and Miles Davis. Jarrett's requested piano was not secured for the concert and he famously used a smaller baby grand piano which forced him to played differently. The album became the best selling solo album in jazz history and best selling piano album. It also cemented his reputation as the top pianist of his generation. The album has two parts with the second part having three sections. "Part I" starts with a vamp (repeating musical loop) with improvised material layered within. That's pretty much what Jarrett does throughout the performance. He goes to just improvising then back to the vamps and improv. He adds yelling as well. The pace picks up at the end. Lovely. "Part II" is a similar format to "Part I." "Part II a" has more of a rolling vamp and he adds funk. In "Part II b," the improv has a spiraling feel. He closes the album with "Part II c" and a straight six-minute improvisation. This album is quite compelling. Never boring. The variation of the vamps and improvisation for over an hour is impressive. His yelling adds emotion. An album everyone needs to hear if just one of the parts.
Despite enjoying piano, this did absolutely nothing for me. Found it too smooth and dull to be jazz (how on earth is it classed as jazz?) and not structured or atmospheric enough to be neo-classical. Just found it really really dull and disappointing
I'm not one for solo piano music and so apart from isolated sections I didn't find this very engaging. Trying to appreciate it for what it is, I thought it was fairly linear, with few changes in tempo or style. While Keith is clearly a very talented musician I needed more variety to keep my attention for the hour. Wouldn't come back.
Pleasantly enjoyable and never grating. Relaxing. Nearly fell asleep with it. Smooth, melodious. As a wise soothsayer one said, "if could choose any instrument to be a master of, it would be the piano."
It's quite nice and chilled out piano music. It's nice as background but I wouldn't listen to it again.
All very pleasant. I do like piano music, think of I could choose any instrument to be a master of, it would be the piano. The live recording of the concert made me feel like I've had a glimpse into a world which I wouldn't have experienced otherwise. Bravo He looks like Howard Moon on the cover. Probably won't listen again, but glad I did!
hmm, 3
Beautiful piano jazz. It just does not do much for me apart from being good background music. It gets a 3.5/5. Fav ‘track’: Pt. II B
I should say this first: he's a very talented musician and this is very impressive. Okay, now: what are we doing here? Where is the arbitrary line between classical performances (not allowed) and this? If I need to listen to an album of live piano music played on a stage before I die, shouldn't it be Bach? And if there is no Bach, leave this off. Weird rules, weird inclusion. Best track: I'd be lying if I said these didn't all blend together for me
one of the most emotional albums I've ever heard, it has a lot of contrast between moments of delicacy and moments of explosion, great dynamics, a masterpiece!
A 60 minute piano improvisation that never felt forced or incohesive. A very strong change of pace from the typical sort of music I listen to.
3rd July 2023 Listened twice in the day while working from home. Went to see Indiana Jones with Ollie in the evening. Loved this. Jazz piano that doesn’t sound like it, sounds like a Pixar soundtrack.
If there was a visual novel about elevators this would play in the main menu. That being said, I mildly enjoyed it
first half was uninspiring, third song was good and then it fell off again
Veel muziek is associatie: waar ken je het van, waar lijkt het op, welke geschiedenis heb je ermee? Dit album kende ik omdat er een stuk uit het eerste deel in een Italiaanse film zat (Caro diario). Man rijdt op een scooter minuten lang door een desolaat landschap in een zweterige buitenwijk van Rome met kotjes, vuilnis, fabrieken, braakliggend terrein, om uiteindelijk uit te komen bij het vervallen monumentje voor de vermoorde filmmaker Pasolini ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CaZfXfW6qxA ). Pas jaren later kwam ik erachter dat die muziek geen werkstuk was van de filmcomponist, maar dat het van deze plaat kwam. En o ja, verder had mijn Parijse vriendinnetje deze in de kast staan. Over herinneringen gesproken. Als je er geen voorgeschiedenis bij hebt, is dit album misschien enkel een hoop getingel. Maar jemig, wat een virtuoos, alle kanten op vliegend pianospel, kennelijk grotendeels geïmproviseerd. De zaal zit vol, de pianist neemt plaats, en laat het ter plekke op zich af komen wat er eigenlijk uit zijn handen komt. Die avond in Keulen in 1975 was het dit. Een warm bad van muzikale vrijheid. Waarbij de ironie is, dat er later bladmuziek van is gemaakt, zodat het nu ook door anderen uitgevoerd kan worden (Ralph van Raat speelt Keith Jarrett, 15 oktober 2023 live in Paradiso). Voor mij een muzikaal monument, al snap ik dat je hem niet even in de auto afspeelt. Maar voor alle goede muziek is er een juist moment.
Even iets heel anders. Een kale piano. Na een tijdje luister ik niet meer actief en wordt het wat gepingel. Prima op de achtergrond. Maar dit was een concert. Met publiek. Pfff...denk dat ik dan wel even was weggezakt.
Ik start dit op zaterdagochtend, met weinig verwachtingen. Het opent als een poppy track, wat me doet denken aan Jackson Browne of Fleetwood Mac. Al snel begint hij wat te improviseren lijkt het. Ik hou toch meer van een bepaald stramien qua songstructuur, een bepaalde houvast. Maar onmiskenbaar is gelijk de virtuositeit. De man is geen pannenkoek. Bovendien is de stijl best wel rocky en bluesy, absoluut niet klassiek, dat bevalt me wel. Ik krijg er steeds meer een glimlach van op mijn gezicht. Al is het wel aan de lange kant. Maar omdat ik in een goede bui ben, zal ik 4 sterren doneren.
Transcendent.
Outstanding. Extemporised piano for an hour, apparently on a practice baby grand in poor condition because the roadies set up the wrong piano by mistake, not the concert grand he'd asked for. You'd never know. Fabulous stuff.
4.4 - I wouldn't put this guy in the pantheon of GOAT jazz pianists alongside Art Tatum, Erroll Garner, Ahmad Jamal and Thelonius Monk but I do appreciate his crystalline clarity and the constant flutter of colors throughout this performance. Mostly it tracks somewhere between "film score for a 1970's Dustin Hoffman movie" and "Mr. Rogers explains how crayons are manufactured." It's the type of record you'd hear playing at your favorite indie bookstore.
The first song is an epic and made for a great listen. The second two kind of fell into the background for me. And the final was a nice closer. Far from a close listen or analysis on my part, but my general take was this was a very enjoyable piece of piano. Kind of strange to hear him grunting with effort or effect at times, but otherwise high quality stuff that I don't know how to properly review. So on the feels alone this is a soft 4.
I... I wish I was cultured enough to can. But unfortunately, I cannot. I am an uncultured swine who cannot discern anything other than competently played piano. I'm going back to Slayer.
DELICIOSO pra ouvir estudando, impossível fora desse caso
Concierto para piano. Me ha gustado. Un 4.
Precioso, sobre todo la primera canción.
There's only so much you can do with just a piano. But God damn it, if Jarrett doesn't do it all here. Great improvisations that go from eclectic jazz to sweeping balladry to rocking blues. The story behind the titular concert is quite interesting too. But as I said earlier, there's only so much you can do with just a piano. As fantastic as he is at his craft, I started to get a little bored as I neared the hour mark, missing the interplay of other instruments. An extended improvised solo can be impressive, but it can also grow wearisome. After hearing this album, I now rank Keith Jarrett amongst the best pianists of his time. But I don't necessarily feel compelled to listen to this recording again.
Interesting album but after a while it feels like noodling
Nice background music for a 4am morning in the cold on a full moon night
I'm impressed... but an hour of piano music isn't something I'd ever choose to listen to.
Klimper. Gut und hörenswert, aber nicht das Über-Album, zu dem es gerne hochstilisiert wird. Jarrets eigene Einschätzung, das Album sei zum Soundtrack verkommen, trifft es ganz gut.
Werkelijk prachtig! Alleen is twee uur aan enkel piano iets te veel voor mij
Classic
Du bon piano, mais une heure juste de ça ça fait un peu lassant, ça devient un peu comme un bruit de fond. Je m'attendais à de quoi d'un peu plus jazzy aussi (dans le sens plus de syncopes). 6/10
impressive piano, but not interesting me
I don't think I'd ever choose to listen to this but it is pretty good.
The first 20 minutes of this and the last 15 or so are really good! The middle I could take or leave, but I still really liked the album. The story makes it something else, and it's always great to get introduced to new instrumental music.
Very good, but kind of boring overall.
So chill, he's a brilliant player and honestly love this album.
Nothing like listening to a man tickle the ivories for an hour. Good stuff.
I wish I knew more about piano to give this a more credible review. But this was by far the best solo piano album I have ever heard. It even tops Peter Griffin's performance in Family guy when Lois would force him to get absolutely buckled because it was the only way that he knew how to play piano.
This was extremely enjoyable to have on in the background whilst working. Once I'm all caught up on these albums I'm gonna listen to some of his live stuff with Miles Davis.
I’m sure this is great I just don’t really know why. Maybe it’s a if you get it you get it? I can’t do what he does and I liked all of it, but I just didn’t get why it’s special
I’d never heard of this but it’s incredible. It’s not just jazzy noodling, but he develops themes and pays them off beautifully.
Technically very impressive but just not my cup of tea
boring
Fenomenal concert recording. I am pretty much speechless, whatever happened to Keith Jarrett on that faithful day in Cologne was amazing. Looks like from now on I will be on a hunt for a vinyl version of this concert.
I liked this for about 10 or 15 minutes. After that it was just sort of banging on the piano for another 50 minutes. It's not bad. But a little monotonous.
While it is overlong, this album simply demonstrates a great musician with his back to the wall, who comes out fighting. The record works beautifully as a late-night relaxation, or first thing in the morning. Brilliant, timeless playing.
Listenable.
Wow! Improvised genius. What a gorgeous piece of music. Obviously not something I'd have listened to at all without this list, but this entranced me all day and I managed four listens. I'm not sure how frequently I'll listen to it again, but I will. Usually that would mean 4 stars, but for being different and for the obvious brilliance of the musician and recording it's an obvious 5.
pop melodies in jazz setting works for me
Not my bag really. Can appreciate the technical accomplishment for sure, but didn't really connect.
I do like some Keith Jarrett, but not my fav
Another new artist for me here. Only 4 tracks. I'm thinking jazz? Maybe just a pianist. Wow, I guess he played with Miles Davis for a time. Damn he's good! That was nice. It was relaxing.
Now I need to listing to more Keith Jarrett solo stuff. I love the piano sound, and reading the story of how this concert came together made it sound even better.
Heard it before?: No Enjoy it?: Yeah, it’s perfect background music, that’s how I feel is best to listen to classical as a genre
The story behind this album is insane and this dude is a god tier musician. At the start I wasn't exactly sure what to think. I was laughing a bit cause it sounded like some dude was cumming in the audience but it turns out it was the guy cranking the piano. By the end of of it I was really enjoying it. Not my go-to music by any means but Keith's craft is worth admiration. If you're a piano player you're probably losing your mind over this. Score: 90 - Bonus points for insane artsmanship Art: 60
It's 1 hour of pleasant piano music. Very talented musician, this reminds me of building houses in the Sims 1.
I wasn’t expecting this. So much passion and excitement from a piano
I happened to listen to a podcast all about the making of this album, which was fascinating. The album itself, a little less than fascinating in and of itself. But then again, jazz is not my bag. Still glad I’ve listened to it. (The podcast was Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford, episode called “Bowie, Jazz and the Unplayable Piano” if anyone is interested.)
Perfect on its own way especially considering the backstory of circumstances leading up to the concert. Couldn't listen to this every day but when I do listen - wow!
Truly a magical hour of music. There are certain musicians who cannot make a mistake while improvising. The connection between their feelings and the music they play is direct. Jacob Collier and Herbie Hancock immediately come to mind as other examples. Jarrett obviously also possesses this skill. Listening to music like that will always be a treat. There’s a reason why this became the best selling solo piano album to date.
i cannot believe this performance is entirely improvisations. it’s hugely impressive technically, and just good to listen to. really great
I really enjoyed this. Nice change of pace.
I hadn’t really listened to an album like this before—and the fact that something like this can exist, with genuinely ear worm Melodies and brilliant variations on themes, while being IMPROVISED, is just mind blowing. The first part especially, just due to the novelty and the scope of what I was hearing floored me. However, the charm did begin to wear thin by the latter second part, where I just ended up more impressed than musically satisfied. Still a triumph, and an essential listen.
Highlights: "IIB" I try to avoid any argument for an album from backstory, but the main justification for me would be that someone can claim it's *what* you're hearing. In this case, you're hearing a master performer adapt to create something for a specific difficult object. That's more of what John Cage had in mind than whatever industry gossip tells you about an artist's mental state or personal life during an album's production, or even its political climate and public reaction. I don't have the musical knowledge to nail down specific revelations this album could give us. Maybe we could say a characteristic of Davis alumni was searching for continuity without decisive key centers, and this is one more adventure of that kind. I wonder how Jarrett feels about the success of this album. A lot of its success is a conversation starter from its backstory about constraints and suffering in artistic process, and my main takeaway is question as well: if an artist sees fit to take up improvisation, do they accept that one day their greatest work will just move through them athwart all their intentional career?
Emotional. Sprawling. Epic. An improvisational feat!
I don't know what I was expecting, but it wasn't this. It's all a bit flowery and very busy at the moment, a few minutes into the first track. This last track sounds like Elton John should start singing soon (I like Elton John). This is not the Jazz I like, but it's alright. 3 / 5 stars.
Beautiful
Background music I guess. Had to break it up though. No one's got time for pianisting for an hour sorry old fella.
Yeah look someone with as little musical knowledge as me ain't qualified to write about this. Multiple times throughout this id forgotten it's just a dude on a piano. I was left in awe every time I was brought back to that reality. To think that people can create hours of music like this, of what I presume is unwritten? Is just so wild. I listened to this whilst grinding out Orthos in the lab and it still took me to places. Fav Track: that bit where he was stupendously rapid on them keys
Sometimes a piano instrumental record hits just right for me, and sitting in the soul-sucking office today it was what I needed to get me through. Really enjoying the flowing and flourishing passages that recalled for me the environmental narratives of Lubomyr Melnyk. Even heard a bit of Joe Hisashi in there - Jarrett's influence seems wide-ranging. Hard to intellectualise something like this without any music background to speak of but I can grade it in how it created narratives for me, recalled sensory experience and developed emotions, and I think this did all of the above pretty well. Fave track: Pt. I
Happy to come across some more records I hadn't really had a deep dive into before - had this on my radar before but never found an opportunity to sit with it and give it a proper listen. Such precision playing and creativity beyond comprehension to construct an hour long improvisation like this. It's easy to get a bit lost in the sound and have it become background noise, and there are those moments of laughter or cheering or groaning that snaps you back into reality and makes you remember this guy is playing live and everything is right off the dome. Overall, I'm not sure it blows me away in the same way some of the other jazz entries have, but still a great listen. Three and a half. Fave track: Part II
i like piano but this was just ok I wasn’t wowed or anything
Extraordinary improvised piano music. The album is like watching an extraordinary creative intellect just ticking over. It feels like having a great idea every few minutes. Extremely rewarding, beautiful stuff.
Extremely well done, talented, I’m sure really inspirational for people but I’m not going to listen to it again
Moans and groans throughout made me laugh. After enough time solo piano music becomes just background music no matter how talented the pianist is. Enjoyable background music though
Not much to add, one of the most perfect pieces of music ever created. Extra-ordinary to think it was all improvised. On tracks one and two you can hear someone composing in real time.
The amount of talent on display here is jaw-dropping. To be able to improvise a full hour concert that holds the attention throughout is nearly unbelievable. Another I might want to by on vinyl. 4/5
I hadn’t heard of this album or this artist before, but I enjoyed it more than I expected I would.
a pleasant, “time pass me by” piano album. not my thing, but well done and executed live. smooth and clean. not too tacky, over done in its light jazz format. it is fine.
Jag önskar att jag också kunde spela piano så!!! De va nice att ha i bakgrunden när man läste.
I owned this album 30 years ago in the form of a pirate cassette tape from Bali - which demonstrates a certain status. I guess it is jazz in the miscellaneous sense. Anyway, I was happy to hear it here.
After about 20 minutes, I considered skipping the rest of the album simply because I had gotten the feel of the album and because such lengthy improvisation isn't my thing. But I not only wound up listening to the whole thing, I went back and played it again! Wow.
Wow...very nice piano.
Calming I guess
Refreshing. Not the type of genre I would ever listen to but after the dross of the last 10 days if was nice to hear something talented. First track was the best, but the other were pretty good. 3.5*
I really enjoyed this. If you haven’t read the Wikipedia article for this album, do yourself a favour and read it. Probably more of a 4.5.
largo
I try not to let meta biographical considerations influence my judgment of music, but every time I hear this, I just shake my head in awe: the dude was hungry, sleep-deprived, and playing on a out-of-tune practice piano with badly-working pedals. And it was almost midnight when the concert got started. The way Jarrett is able to take all that and just go with it and manipulate the piano in the middle register is just amazing. And those little moans and wails throughout, adding just the right touch of soul to it all. It all melts away into such a sublime beauty that could be the soundtrack to monarch butterflies migrating. Look up! Look around you!
Très partagé sur ce disque. Mais au final cette improvisation de plus d'une heure reste impressionnante et parfois très belle. Je pense que plusieurs écoutes m'aideront, mais au bout de deux, je suis déjà plutôt emballé
Amazing album. Incredible that it is live and improvised. The artist can be heard reacting to his own playing (humming, singing, shouting). Perfect album to work to or to relax.
Good album. Loved hearing Keith Jarrett sing along at points.
I mean it’s good I guess?
A pretty mind-blowing piano jazz album. The fact that he is improvising every track while playing on an old, barely in tune piano makes it even more so. You can hear Jarrett himself singing along with his improvisations and it just adds more to this live concert. Beautiful music really. Best Tracks: Pt. 1; Part 2 A
While impressive as an improvisational piece, this is at the end of the day simply an hour of piano playing. Inspired as it may be, this LP opens a whole can of worms about list inclusion when it comes to more classically-oriented pieces – if improvisational piano is worthy of 1001, aren't at least 100 other classical pieces with inspired performances or innovative designs?
This is miles outside my wheelhouse and realistically I'm unlikely to come back to it, except possibly as background music. BUT I thought it was good. Aside from the obvious musical ability required not only to play this stuff, but to improvise it in front of a live audience, I was impressed by the way he seemed to switch between several different styles - only a couple of which sounded like 'jazz' as I know it. I find solo piano can be quite meditative when it's slow and sparse, but the rhythmic, repetitive nature of some of the other sections was equally hypnotic in its way. Also, bits of it reminded me of the Breath of the Wild soundtrack. So that's good.
The moaning 🤣
belos pianos e muito bem improvisados, mas uma hora é foda
Very zen, good to put on in the background for chill work or to zone out to. Would listen again
Cool music to do my performance review to. Will keep this one in the back pocket for doing mentally taxing tasks and self reflection.
Nooo
Great, and the story behind the concert is very interesting