Metallica by Metallica

Metallica

Metallica

3.76
Rating
30829
Votes
1
3%
2
9%
3
24%
4
35%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 12 of 16)

5/10 Modem Metallica is meh.

A few great songs...many other middle of the road tunes.

Knew a couple of these songs from back in the day, plenty of new ones too. Great album with lots of big hits.

On ne muutamat hyvät biisit ja sitten on Metallica-biisit, jotka ovat kaikki samanlaisia ja siksi niputettavissa paitsi Sad but true joka on todella hyvä. Mut siis sinänsä pidän siitä kuinka tavallaan tosissaan nämä ovat ja kuinka ovat tällä levyllä mestareita omassa soundissaan.

Ei esteettinen katastrofi, joskaan ei suuri nautinto - vain parin hitin ja keskivertoa kiinnostavamman riffin kantama, filleriä sisältävä LP, niin kuin LP:t nyt tuppaavat olemaan. Miksi ei 3? Koska bändin poporientaatio ei poista musiikin raskautta, eikä ainakaan paranna sanoja (Nothing Else Matters - iik).

There are some bangers on here and there are some average songs. Not as good as master of puppets which is basically perfect.

Metallica at their absolute peak. 2.75 stars

Best Song: Enter Sandman. Maybe the only track on this album that actually rocks. Also I used to say that "Now I lay me down to sleep" prayer when I was a kid, so it's got some nostalgia going for it. Worst Song: Wherever I May Roam. Classic Metallica: Overly long, slow, and meandering. Overall: My metal hot take will always be that Metallica is hugely overrated. So ploddingly slow for a band that was so heavily marketed as "thrash". It feels like music that's best suited for toddler-stomping in a wide circle. Music for people who unironically view throwing up "devil horns" as a form of counterculture.

Oh, no. Please no. More Metallica? At this rate there are going to be 33 Metallica albums on the list, and they all sound the f£%^ing same. One is too many, and the returns are diminishing badly. We're well into the hundreds of albums, and given the tedious length of these, close to 5% of the time has been spent listening to this one terrible band. 0 🌟

ok now they’re just trolling us. this is the 4th metallica album. are 5% of the songs you have to hear before you die from one band?

Not into metal - but found it pretty good.

I hate Metallica. The songs are too long. But I love this album. Fuck.

Wow this album is way better than I thought it would be. Not too big a metal/metallica fan, but these songs are really strong. Enter sandman I have some fond memories of, as they played live on Pinkpop, and it was afterwards one of the first songs I heard on the radio driving back, reliving the experience again. The unforgiven is also really nice.

favourite: enter sandman, the unforgiven + some other ones least favourite: holier than thou it's metallica

This was a great album. I enjoyed almost every single song on this album, plus there were so many iconic songs on this album. I think this is Metallica at their peak. I do admit it is a bit of a front heavy album. Cutting a few songs from the album probably would’ve been beneficial, but it was an amazing album for what it was. 4.5

An iconic album.

A classic Metallica album. Not my favorite, but still really good. 4.5/5

In my opinion this is their best album . Great songs, great production, and just the feeling when I listen to it.

Well. Tight sounds, crunchy guitar, juvenile songs. Sonically it's great, can appreciate the quality, but it just sounds formulaic. Perhaps they invented the formula - I don't know and I don't care, it's just tedious.

Pretty solid throughout. Only throw away track is "Nothing Else Matters". It feels like the boring brother to "One".

Yet another timeless classic

The music is great, but I can’t get into the cheesy angsty lyrics. Some classics on here though and undeniably a classic album in its genre. 3.5/5 goes up to a 4.

In meiner kleinen Sammlung befindet sich auch ein Album von Metallica, Master of Puppets von 1986. Nachdem ich das "Black Album" jetzt gehört habe, muss ich sagen, dass es dagegen abfällt. Ja, jede Menge Smash Hits, einige auch tauglich fürs Formatradio. Aber die maschinenhafte Energie des 86er Albums fehlt mir.

Objectively the intro hard rock and metal album for many individuals. It was mine for a time too. Many of my peers cited this as their foyer in metal. For me my tastes have grown but subjectively this album is a good started for those who crave more than just rock and roll. It is a blended hard rock/metal album though. Its not the heaviest thing, but sonically and track wise its a good start.

Ein Klassiker für mich. Hör ich immer wieder.

Since I got this album’s predecessor “…And Justice For All” a couple of weeks ago, I feel obliged to compare the two. Firstly, and perhaps most obviously, the music itself is a lot less complex and prog-y here than it was on the last album, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing because it made this album a lot easier to digest for me. Secondly, the lyrical content is a lot less political here, with the band instead focusing on more personal matters like childhood fears, religion and death, so, while the lyrics may have less of an impact, its not like the songs don’t have any meaning at all. Overall, this album is a fun time that also tones down a lot of the aggression from the previous album in the hopes of reaching a wider audience. Favourite tracks: Enter Sandman, Sad But True, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam, Through the Never, The God That Failed

Def not for me, but unsure if lacking merit? Fav: nothing else matters

Lo reconozco, es un placer culpable.

Thinking of packing this project in. Life is too short to listen to Metallica

Some great intros and then the same tediously drawn out sound failing to reach a climax

I've always found Metallica a pretentious band. Even their most popular songs, like "Enter Sandman", are boring and substanceless. Watching paint dry would've been a greater pastime than listening to the "Black Album." Both Black Sabbath and Nazareth did it better.

Ahhh, when Metallica stopped making noise and learned they had something to say. This is Metallica at its best, still load, still metal, still deep …..but finally crystal clear.

Soundtrack of my youth. I had the album, posters, and mullet to prove it.

Love this album. Every song is a banger. And I don’t even love Metallica because I feel that the drums could just be so much better, however it was the early 90s and real metal was only just coming into its own so it’s fine. Still a 5/5

i thought metallica was way harder than this aha

The only reason this isn’t a 1 is because of Enter Sandman.

Alright, Sandman and Nothing else matters are easily the best two tracks, the rest sounds like filler

Must have album in any collection… Masterpiece…

Great. Play it loud.

Did not dislike it as much as I expected to, but probably also wouldn't come back to it for a re-listen.

This album goes crazy. Not a single miss.

Probably the album that most people think of when someone says Metallica. Lots of good stuff on here and I did enjoy going back and listening to this one all the way through again. Say what you will about Metallica, musically or otherwise, there are a lot of great songs on this record. I get that thrash metal isn't exactly for everyone, and there's a valid argument that this album isn't exactly thrash metal anyway, but it's undeniably solid. I think where this album is lacking most is in production. It's not bad but I think the balance between the low and high frequencies is off a bit. Maybe it's sort of scooped? I'm not sure. I listened to the original, not a remaster, so maybe that's something they fixed later on. I've never been a huge Metallica fan but I really like this album. I probably wouldn't go out and try to find it at the record store but I would play it again for sure. And maybe pick it up if it happened to be at the record store and I didn't want anything else. 4/5

I've never listened to this album in its entirety before, but it's obvious that this album was very influential in the space. Feels quite ahead of its time, like it wouldn't be out of place if it had been released 10 years ago.

Not my type of music but it's cool anyway

This album is an absolute masterpiece.

þetta er auðvitað bara .... black album

Love every bit of this pretty much other than Enter Sandman just because I can go anywhere and here it. Work like this is how you transcend genres as a band.

Opens pretty strong with Enter Sandman, can’t go wrong there. Doesn’t really let up from there, Sad but True, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam all excellent. The drop in a ballad with Nothing Else Matters and this is a really good album. Yea, there is some cheese for sure but Metallica sticks it with their self-titled. I’d argue the only stinkers on this release are Don’t Tread on Me and The God That Failed. Overall though, no issues. 4 stars

Not so much into heavy/metal. But this one I really like. Guess it’s iconic

I’m biased, grew up with this one, absolute classics in here and imo best Metallica record

Somehow they made heavy metal accessible and mainstream.

4.5/5 Best Track: Nothing Else Matters

Not as good as I remember it.

Metalnumre man kender, god energi hvis det endelig skal være

Fuen fuon... mas gosto de Nothing Else Matters, a famosa.

Proving that I'm no metal-head, my first thought was that Metallica is one of those rare bands that became better when they sold out. The engineering and production on this album are gorgeous. The guitars are as full and rich as anything since Eddie’s Brown Sound and it finally sounds like Lars is playing drums instead of slapping wet cardboard with wooden spoons. By Holier Than Thou I started thinking that, like REM, Metalica’s music is maybe more enjoyable when you can’t understand the lyrics. But that's not entirely correct either. Some of the lyrics are pretty damned good. It’s still a Metalllica album - which means it gets pretty monotonous pretty quickly. But it sounds amazing and the riffs are outta this world. The riff of Enter Sandman is worth 3 stars all on its own.

Man, this brought back memories.

Goes hard

I've never been very deep into metal but Metallica seems to speak to me a lot of the time, as does Iron Maiden. While I think I prefer Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning, this is a great release.

A solid album, I liked Enter Sandman and Wherever I May Roam the most.

1001 Albums 1: This is my first time rating a project on here and it is Metallica's self title. I think this album is pretty good. There are quite a few classic tracks on this album including my personal favourite \"Enter Sandman\". The main downside is that this doesn't stack up to Metallica's releases prior to this in my opinion. It serves as Metallica's last truly good project and as a step into the mainstream and one out of the thrash scene. Rating: 8.5 Fav Tracks: Enter Sandman, Sad But True Least Fav Track: Don't Tread On Me

Same as other heavy metal bands: just not my style. it gives me headaches to listen to several of these songs in a row. Really not enjoyable. Nothing else matters is probably the only exception in this album.

Classique également, mais beaucoup plus inégal que ses prédécesseurs.

Not for me

So many classic songs, with kick ass riffs. Sometimes all you need is a James Hetfield chugging power chord. Lyrics are a bit cringy though. Kirk’s wah drenched solos are a guilty pleasure. Lars’ drumming is plodding but suits the style of the band. I’m also happy that you can hear the bass here unlike … And Justice For All Second half kind of dips in quality. Highlights: Enter Sandman, Sad But True, Wherever I May Roam

I mean, if I have to listen to Metallica...

So many hit songs.

I very rhythmic and influential album. The lyrics sometimes compliment the grittiness of the songs. Some of the songs drag on a little, as if you would be banging your head and knocking into people during the repetition. "Enter Sandman" is such an iconic song, and "Struggle Within" is a great closer. 3.5 stars

Great album, lots of all-timers but its a little too long and gets a bit repetitive

Couple classic songs in Sandman and Nothing Else Matters but the rest is forgettable.

Feels like listening to one long song instead of an album. Only exception is the Song "Nothing Else Matters". In my Opinion it lacks in variation

For some reason the whole album reminds me of that spoken word part in Thriller. Solid album tho

I was debugging code, this gave me the strength to continue. Slightly geared towards pop, not too harsh which is also nice. Strong album with a few hits.

4 stars because they fought Napster

Hey-yeeeeeaaAH. 5 staaaaaarsAH. 4 stars truly listening back, but it's a classic in my personal catalogue.

Ironically dark and slow, Metallica made a big shift in the direction of metal with this one. Some of their most iconic tracks were born from this album and this is what I think of when I talk about their sound. They get so into the new style that it can be a bit dense, but if brooding, angry, and a little bit powerful is what you're feeling this is the album for you.

This album is listenable which is something the prior Metallica album isn't. This isn't the obnoxious yeah metal machine gun drum stuff. It's slower and the songs have a more traditional song structure. At times it's seems less metal and not hard rock. Those are the times I considered actually listening to this again but the end of the album was back to what I don't like about metal.

Not a big fan of Heavymetal, but Metallica and some of the songs are a classic, Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters of course.

A real heart banger

Great album. Peak Metallica.

a classic. it really stands the test of time, a great album!

Famtastic!!!

More like Midtallica.

Quite repetitive and nothing stand out but good voice and music

J'aime mieux la version acoustique de plusieurs chansons, mais c'est parce que c'est avec celle-là que je les ai découvert. Reste que c'est du bon stock.

Enter sandman is such a fantastic song. That with nothing else maters makes this album great. Also I have seen them live and was so blown away.

Not to my taste but I powered through.

Alright, so I went into this expecting to give it an obvious 5/5. It's Metallica's magnum opus and it created a hits machine for the band. I love so many of these songs and was happy to discover some new ones. HOWEVER, as I was jamming out, I realized that every single song takes waaaaaaay too long to get the the lyrics. Every song pretty much has a minute or more lead up. Now a lot of people probably credit that about what makes it so great. The musical talents of the band. But I've always been a lyrics man, which is the only reason I can't give it a perfect score. 4.8/5

Copypasta from Master of Puppets... I was never a "fan" of Metallica due to all the tryhards of the world, but as I grew up I realized that these dudes rock. There are certainly things left to be desired with the band and with this album, but overall it was a fun album. I knew most of the tunes, but never listened to the album in it's entirety.

Pas tant mon genre, un peu lourd

How much more black could this be? the answer is none, none more black. A good album that I enjoyed a lot when I was a teenager. My guitar teacher told me to start on Master of Puppets, Ride the Lightning, and Justice for All over the black album. But this still holds up and definitely made them into the mainstream band they are today.

Enter Sandman is a classic, nothing else on the album stuck out to me

That’s tough, I loved this in 7th grade but was way too cool for it in 12th. I guess I’ll just have to try to give it an honest listen 30 years later. It pretty much holds up! The instrumentation is top notch, but the lyrics are dumb and boring. It would be a five if it were in a language I don’t understand.

It's probably a 4 star album but I just don't love Metallica...

Soundtrack to my Jr high.

its metallica

Just an amazing album, not much to add to an absolute classic

Unreal this was their debut. Can’t imagine listening to this for the first time in the early 90s

Great album tons of fun and great intro Album to Metallica

ah Guitar Hero, I remember ye well

Klassisches Metallalbum, das ein paar Must Hears beinhaltet, jedoch heutzutage nicht mehr hart vom Hocker haut

They're competent musicians, certainly, but I can't remove their public selves from their work. Self-important blowhards who acted like they invented heavy metal, this album was massively overplayed when I was younger, and it's not gotten better with age for me.

Was in high school when this came out and it was on everywhere. I’m more of a Master of Puppets guy but despite the over exposure of this album and it’s loathing by grassroots Metallica fans, it’s not an awful album.

There were a lot of disputes about Metallicas direction when this came out. The songs are shorter and maybe a bit on the commercial side but nonetheless a great album.

Still so good. So fresh.

I get it, but that doesn't mean I have to listen to it.

what a sick album, amazing how so many bangers are on the same thing, and even the lesser known ones are good

Hetfield's voice is interminable and this record offends the senses with non-stop samey droning guitars with none of the same violence and character of their previous thrash work. Dismal listening.

Nothing else matters is my fave track! This album also didn’t do it for me as I am not a metal fan, I can see how it was so integral to the genre though! Definitely worth the listen but also definitely not my cup of tea.

Very hype album. A few mediocre songs in the middle but overall I really enjoyed it. Also Lars you suck and held the band back.

This is a great rock record. It’s sort of the start of a lot of popular “metal” music, but it still feels very rock, nonetheless. It’s a great album to vibe out to with a few real standout tracks, but a few boring songs hold it back from real excellence.

I honestly don't care about all of the critiques about when and if Metallica sold out. This was a profound influence on my musical tastes when I was young, so it gets a bonus start for that!

I went in with an open mind, I'm certainly no metal head. "Enter Sandman" will always make me think of the great Mariano Rivera. I dug the production, one of the best sounding metal records I've heard. Some good head bangers. But at the end of the day, I was not blown away, and did not do much to change my general opinion of Metallica.

Second metallica album in a row, this one I am much more familiar with. I think it says a lot seeing as how so many of the songs on this album ended up become some of Metallica's most famous songs.

Probably very good but I really don’t value it.

I was impressed at the number of songs I actually liked. Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters are classics, but there were some other fun bangers!

Amazing iconic metal album

Epic classic.

Nostalgic but boring.

Love this album since it came out. Probably haven’t played it all the way through for 20 years. Still holds up. Remaster is better in my opinion.

It's tough because overall Metallica sucks but they do have gems. Nothing Else Matters is a good song, Enter Sandman has a killer build and Wherever I May Roam is very tight. This album has some chaff but some very solid songs.

Enter Sand Man I give a 3 out of 5. Nothing Else Matters I like. The rest is kind of corny and a bit 2 dimensional sounding.

It's Metallica!

Album #12 I never understood the draw to Metalica that many of my classmates had back in the day. I still don't but I listened to this album entirely. I was impressed that I could understand the lyrics for the most part and it wasn't just a bunch of screaming men stroking their guitars and drum sets in a violent manner. I often see that the song 'Enter the Sandman" is listed as one of the best songs of all time, I don't see it or hear it. They weren't my cup of tea in the 80's and still aren't. I am glad that someone is drawn to their music, why, I have no clue.

As good as it gets in this genre - excellent guitar work, meaningful songs. Of course it's on this list.

Lars Ulrich LOVES his cymbals, I can say that much. I would say I enjoyed the album overall. Some songs got tedious after a while, but maybe that's because I am not used to metal and have not listened to Metallica before (only some songs, but not on my own volition). I can see why this is one of the best-selling albums ever, very replayable and enjoyable, even for non-metal fans, such as myself.

Ugh, vorige album vond ik helemaal niets. Dit album is in elk geval een stuk melodieuzer dan het vorige album en op het eerste gezicht iets minder scheurende gitaren. Begrijp me niet verkeerd hoor, het is nog steeds scheurende gitaren wat de klok slaat en elk nummer bevat op zeker een gitaar solo, maar het is iets minder pure thrash metal wat ik opzich goed trek. Ok laat maar, na ongeveer de helft van het album is hte toch weer de pure thrash metal van het vorige album, lange gitaarsolo's en ik weet niet. Deze muziek is voor mij zo erg als "IK BEN BOOS OP DE WERELD VROEGER WAS ALLES BETER KINDEREN WETEN HELEMAAL NIEEEEETS" En dat vind ik nogal jammer. Hoeveel metallica albums staan er in deze lijst? FAVO: Ik vind opzich Enter Sandman wel een prima nummer.

not my jam, forgot to rate before but probably downloaded a song or two

An album I'm incredibly familiar with. It's not my favorite Metallica record nor is it their best record, but it's the record that put them (and metal as a genre) on the map. It's one of the most important records ever made and definitely one of the most influential records. I have to imagine a lot of people picked up guitars and drums after listening to the Black Album.

No thank you

I understand the importance of this album but it is definitely not my thing. Enter Sandman is a great song but this just isn't for me.

Enter Sandman.. I never recovered

oh goodness. first song had me excited which quickly faded as i was met with repetitvness for the next hour of listening. it was a struggle to finish the album, i don't recommend it.

a landmark in metal, filled with tracks that have become genre anthems. it's a timeless classic that still resonates powerfully, capturing a sense of familiarity and awe. songs like "enter sandman" and "nothing else matters" are more than just hits; they're the essence of what makes metal so impactful. listening to this album is an exhilarating experience, and this was not the first and certainly not the last time.

It had two of my favorite Metallica songs on it.

I used to have this album. It still rocks, I like it a lot even though I have heard it so many times. Brings me back to when I tried to learn to play guitar.

Top shelf. One of my fav albums.

Big sound like army Marching toward death and darkness Heart beats in time. Rock.

This album blows.

Never really got into Metallica. They have some good stuff but overall they are kind of hit and miss with me. That being said, the black album has many of the ones I was previously familiar with.

kinda long

This was just great. I can't wait to listen to it again.

Some excellent tunes here. So far the best of the metal music.

Really consistent. Metallica lives up to its name, no fluff here. Not my favorite genre, but I respect their commitment to the sound.

Nothing else Matters - just wow, always a pleasure to listen to

Lo mismo que el anterior.

I found myself getting more and more angry through each track - not because I hated the album or anything like that, it was just the style of m,usic is so abrasive and angry it just rubbed off on me. As you can probably tell, not my bag at all, but giving it 2 stars as I made it the whole way through.

Lol, 6 of the first 7 tracks on this album are on my gym playlist. Favorite track: Nothing Else Matters

It's almost as good as St. Anger.

Cmon now, one of their best albums. I can’t NOT hate Enter Sandman shit just gets me hyped. 3.8

Yeah baby, accessible metal. I had this beast when I was at Uni - loved the edge to a couple of the billion stream bangers, but honestly couldnt remember any of the filler tracks. Still - worth a few stars for some epic riffery

This album has a place in every divorced dad collection (and the growing list of albums I heard through the wall of my brothers room) , and for good reason! Cant help but enjoy Enter Sandman, Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters.

Oh fuck yeah bud. Enter Sandman is a beast

The definitive Metallica album. Best sound, Best songs, Best mixing. Another easy 5 stars.

Excellent overall with a couple outstanding tracks.

I know that the hardliners think of this album as the beginning of the end for Metallica (for me it was Load). My brother was a metal head, so I had experience with their early albums before this one was on my radar. But this is what launched them into the mainstream - and if you were 10 or 11 in 1991 like was, mainstream Metallica was still pretty awesome. And Justice for All was probably their last great album. Not a ton of virtuosic solos here or cheesy speed metal. But if this was the first introduction to them, it would still melt your face off.

•Not owned: Streaming •Meticulous production and great use of tempo and riffs. •3.5/5

Look - I didn’t get Metallica when I was a teen and all my friends were obsessed. 25 years on and that hasn’t changed. I didn’t finish it because honestly, what’s the point?

I'm not big fun of hard rock, but this group has really an incredible level and a lot of soft songs that to the aftermath

Not really my cup of tea

Throw back to college. I have seen Metallica 5 times. Songs still hold up. Although not my first choice genre. I have to be in a certain mindset

A tricky one to rate,... I loved the previous three albums, and when this came out it was a complete surprise, and took me a good few listens to get into. I had a chronological playthrough of their albums about 6 months ago and, not having heard it for a few years I appreciated it a lot more. And at least it's not Load...

It's fine, I get why it's a classic because it was different then but now it just sounds pretty generic to me.

Grrrrrr rughhhh.

More of the same old Metallica sound, lifted to the heights of metal greatness by Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters.

One of my favorites of all time

Amazing album

Lots of talent on here, makes even metal listenable. A couple of songs that are part of American culture.

Very melodic, bass heavy album. Felt upbeat and energetic to me. 90s grunge feel. Dig it. Can listen from top to bottom.

Can’t go wrong with Metallica. Listened to this album during a workout and was a great listen!

1. 5/5 Classic song that I'd heard before but never listened to with intention. Great song. 2. 4/5 Good song, bit I couldn't grasp the meaning behind it. 3. 5/5 4. 4/5 5. 5/5 6. 5/5 Great Solo 7. 5/5 My Favorite song thus far 8. 5/5 Another great classic song that I vaguely knew. 9. 5/5 10. 4/5 11. 5/5 12. 4/5

great album

Not my cup of tea, but there's some interesting musical motifs throughout. Weird reference to West Side Story in 'Don't tread on me' that felt both really on the nose and clumsily executed. Most songs are way too long, don't really have much purpose in being as bloated as they are. I still recognize the impact this album has had in music generally and in the metal genre specifically. 2/5

Some memorable tracks from my music listening past. Some 'oh god, its the same noise over and over and over again' with no idea about the lyrics. a bit Meh. Not shocking but meh. 2 stars

First half was sick. Then I got a little fatigued with the constant drone. The singles definitely rip, but I am not a Metallica convert after that album.

A few bangers

Not my vibe, like enter sandman

The Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters ...aún así ...

God I hated this so much. What a bunch of cry babies. That horrible muddy, swampy guitar sound, lyrics that basically come down to how terrible their life is, titles that are straight out of toilet graffiti at an emo school, it's such a cliché it's unbelievable. Just grow up lads. The worst song of all is Nothing Else Matters, because you've spent hours having your ears assaulted, then you finally get to a song with a bit of light and shade, and it turns out the light at the end of the tunnel is an oncoming train of misery and self-pity. Genuinely one of the worst songs committed to record, and their ongoing popularity is a blot on humanity's already quite blotty record.

The Unforgiven // Wherever I May Roam //

hell yeah

Metallica hasn't ever really been my thing, but there are a few songs that I've had from here that I'll continue to keep in rotation

The quintessential Metal album. Metallica is just a classic. The riffs, the drums, the singing, the lyrics - it's all around a certified banger. Not even my favourite Metallica album but I can't find anything bad about it. Favourites: Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters

Very thoughtful lyrics, but generally just loud, roaring unrest and angst against the “they.”

🙏🏼

couldn't listen to it. I hate metal

Fetter Rocksound. Klassiker. Nicht alles mein Stil. Stereogitarren.

"Nottingham else matters" gefällt mir ja sehr gut - aber der Rest ist wirklich nicht mein Geschmack

Parts of the music are interesting, and lyrics are catching, but I find the general tone to be harsh. The hard beats wear on me before too long. No surprise that I like the softer songs better.

This is not my choice of music but I did listen to it. Some of the songs were better than others but I probably will not listen to any of them again.

Surprisingly nice to listen to.

Classic Metallica album from the early 1990s. Plenty of hits on this one. It was a bit of a departure from their previous work and controversial amongst Metallica fans at the time. A good listen, though.

forgot how many metallica hits are from this album.

not my typical genre but was still an enjoyable listen

9/10 first time actually listening to a metallica album in full in one sitting (two sittings tbh) and wow.. AN EXPERIENCE

It was one of the first CDs I bought for my portable player and heart it over and over again. Enter Sandman is one of my favorites of all time! In addition, I have seen them live in the Weserstadion in Bremen together with my best friend Holger. What a concert! During Nothing Else Matters Holger has called Electra to say her that he loves her! Hach! ❤️

Énergie indéniable. Travail sur la progression dramatique et le récit narratif. Plusieurs pièces puissantes et inoubliables

Highlights: Enter Sandman* The Unforgiven Wherever I May Roam Nothing Else Matters Don't Tread on My sampling the music from "America" in the musical West Side Story is great music writing. This album was great at its peak and forgettable for a lot of it. Songs like Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters are metal music at its peak but many of the other tracks were mostly forgettable and slightly repetitive. This seems like a great album to listen to if you want background noise that involves heavy drums and guitars. I will definitely continue to listen to the good songs on the album but I dont plan on re-listening to the whole thing anytime soon.

Not much to say about this one. Main stream metal album that I didn't find to be all that unique. Solid quality but nothing that really sets it apart these days. Fav songs: wherever I may roam, nothing else matters.

The first four songs are straight head bangers, the next few start to feel like the same and I was ready to rate this a 4 and then nothing else matters provides a complete 180 and then back to head bangers.

3rd Metallica album in 2 weeks, and they still kick ass. This one is not quite as good as Master of Puppets, and doesn't have the novelty of the S&M album, so I'm gonna put it at 4 stars.

Waaaay too bloated

Heavy metal has never been my genre. However, it wasn't a bad listening experience. Not sure if I would listen again but I understand it's importance.

Ein gutes Album, definitiv

Volltreffer.

Masterful crossover metal. Tight. A little samey

Not the biggest Metallica fan, but they have a number of songs I enjoy very much and this album contains a good number of those songs. Outside of maybe being overplayed, who doesn't just rock out to Enter Sandman? I think I crank anytime I hear on the radio. My personal favorite from these guys is song #2, Sad But True. The lyrics fit perfectly with his angry sing style. Best song off the album, imo. Several other songs I thought were very good include, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam and Nothing Else Matters. Thought the album went on a little too long and could have cut off a couple songs at the end, but all in all a very good listen. Hard to believe this album is almost 25 years old, but still stands the test of time of some pretty good headbanging tunes. Am I a bigger fan after this album? Probably not, but some times I forget that Metallica can find that sweet spot when you need a banger and may have to compile a Metallica work out setlist. I'm going with a 4. It has 2 of my favorites by these guys. 4

This is probably where my opinions of Metallica become confusing for even me. I know this is one of those game changer albums. The kind of album that makes an industry pivot and creates generations upon generations of musicians. I also don't really care for about half of this album. The songs that are memorable are very much so but everything else is especially forgettable. I don't know what to say about this album that hasn't been said. It's not my favorite Metallicka album but it does have some of my favorite singles. I like that I can hear a creative evolution. I can respect a band doing something different and it's cool when it works out. Anyway, not a bad album. 3.5

3.5 I used to not be able to stand Metallica, but they’re a group I’ve learned to appreciate in the more recent years of my life (see: my review of S&M). They really do have a lot of great songs that I used to write off before, and a lot of them are here on this album - Nothing Else Matters, The Unforgiven, Sad But True, and of course, Enter Sandman. As a less cynical (or maybe more seasoned) music fan now, I really appreciated their inclusion here. As for the rest of the album, there’s nothing unenjoyable, but it’s a lot of the same kind of thing in a less remarkable form, making this whole thing feel kind of one-note, especially for its duration. I found myself really enjoying the album at the gym as it kicked off, but around the time Nothing Else Matters concluded, I was ready for it to start wrapping up - especially being that the four songs that follow it are probably the least remarkable stretch of songs on the album. A handful of great songs here that I’ll be revisiting, but I’m not sure how often I’ll be giving this thing a full listen - really wish this just would have ended with Nothing Else Matters. Still, much higher than I probably would have rated any Metallica album five or so years ago, so for better or for worse, my musical taste is broadening a bit.

Enjoyed that.

Wasn’t a fan. Thought all the songs blended together and lacked variation.

pretty damn good album, rock and shit. Beginning and ending are strong, middle sags a bit. Nice tone on guitars, James does his classic vocals. Significant 27/77 Liked 12/77 Added 3/77 maybe? YYmaybe

One of my top 10 favorite albums ever

It's the black album, come on!

A metal classic

Enjoyed the album with the classic Enter Sandman on it.

Da ist mir zu wenig Musik drin. Eintönig und öde. Kaum ein Riff... Und immer dieser Aggro-Gesang. Nichts für mich!

Though many will accuse them of selling out with this album, I'd argue it was more of a gradual decline, not an overnight drop. Fortunately, on Black Album they were still able to give us a decent few classics. Enjoyable, but hardly essential. Three bells out of five tolling for you 🔔🔔🔔

We know all the hits around here, but it has been a long time since I listened to the whole thing start to finish. It's a good record but it doesn't rank among my favorites for them. It hurts to say it's 3.5 stars rounded down, but I'm having a hard time giving it 4 stars today.

In Holland, I saw an array of bronzed supine beach bodies lift dumbbells in synch to Enter Sandman, the trainer at climax instructing “Enter night… exit light…keep it slow... SUPERSLOWWW” in a Dutch accent as heavy as the riff. Wildest moment of a stag weekend in Amsterdam, so thanks for that, Metallica. Lyrically, James Hetfield minus Noel Gallagher equals Thom Yorke, so to those who deny that Metal is the conduit of the real, living Devil I say: you are fools. I wonder if James Hatfield writes down his lyrics. If he does, does he read them? I’m familiar enough with the Metallica genre to state that this is strong Metallica. The songs are short for Metallica, but long for normal mortals, so: Misery! Took me a weekend to get through this, though I’m sure I thought it was fine back when it and I were shiny. Nowadays, I cannot abide chores. Two.

I hate Metallica. Their earlier albums were irritating, this is just boring one-note ponderous tedium. The singer sucks, the lyrics are amateur schoolboy crap, and the production sounds better with the '80s Phil Collins material it was developed for. Please no more from these shitheads [edit: downgraded further as the whole thing is fucking terrible. Just noticed it has the stupid Karen flag snake on the cover to warn right-thinking people away from this heap of shit]

one of the best album that i ever heard

every song on this record is amazing 10/10

This made the 12 year old in me so happy.

I really love this album by Metallica, there are a lot of great songs on here. One of the best metal bands during the 80's and 90's, I have a lot of fond memories of listening to their songs.

Uhhhhh 100 stars. Hands down. The thrash metal gods!!! I was still living in Montana when I first heard this album. I remember very distinctly being in the back of Justin's suv..I think it was a Blazer?? can't remember but we were going to a party somewhere in the mountains and he had this tape playing the whole way. Such a great album all the way through, every song is incredible! If I have the chance to catch these guys live before they stop performing I would pay stupid money...I think they are actually on tour right now. But the closest they come is Denver? I'll have to look it up. Anyways, like I said 100 stars if I could but 5 will have to do.

Previously on 1001 albums: >Didn't know I liked Metallica this much Turns out I didn't. Don't get me wrong, I still like the music, but it pales in comparison with live versions of these songs. It's especially evident in Sad But True, the performance just sounds lazier

without the symphony orchestra it's pretty meh, I like his voice but not much more than that nothing else matters is really good tho

trash and boring but made a point

If there's any genre that I listen to on my own time more than any other, it's probably metal. And yet, I haven't gotten an outstanding metal album yet for this project. Sure, I started with Van Halen and that was pretty good, but I have yet to get a truly defining metal album for this project. Until now. This is a really good album from one of the greatest metal bands of all time. Say what you will about their later albums or Lars's drumming or whatever. Their first 5 albums are some of the best of the genre, and this was the last of those. This is probably the band's conservative album. Not so much in the political sense (aside from Don't Tread on Me), but rather in the sense that it's not quite as experimental as albums like Master of Puppets or And Justice For All. Despite that, the style is so finely tuned that nothing else matters (see what I did there?). There is some variance in here. Look at this album's two most iconic tracks, Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters. The sounds have similar aspects, but the tone is very different between the two songs. The instrument playing is quite good, as this was near the end of Metallica's peak. I was surprised by the quality of James Hetfield's singing for songs like "The Unforgiven". Metallica's performance when playing live can be hit or miss, but the studio quality for those early albums was top-notch. The writing is solid and gets the points across well. Those points, by the way, remain relevant to this day. Overall, while this album probably isn't Metallica's best, it does remain as their most successful album, and absolutely deserves to be on this list for its excellent quality and cultural significance. Light 5/5.

I know it's a classic but just seems like generic metal nowadays.

Favorite Songs: Enter Sandman Sad But True The Unforgiven

Well a perfect metal pop album if there ever was one - and it’s still hard as nails when it wants to be. I mean yes overplayed to death and yes many a cliche but to put yourself back in 1991 and hearing this for the first time - whoa. Not only that - it’s persistently being present over 30 years on… essentially this is the Beatles of heavy guitars. Not to mentioned well paced and doesn’t over stay its welcome. A classic for sure even if I’m jaded to most of it.

Cat: I don’t know why this album in particular gets me fired up, but it does. Great guitar, drums, vocals, bass, everything. Lyrics are alright haha

I honestly tried to like this album despite my dad’s strong hatred for the band. Started off strong with the first one just because I know of it and its impact on the world (and Riveras song) but honestly his voice is just so painful so try to deal with. I miss rock and this is definitely it so I’ll give it that, but definitely not a great one.

This is music for an army of braindead orcs marching out of Mordor. Jingoistic bullshit - this was probably Henry Kissinger's favourite band. enjoy the maggots, pig. 4 Metallica albums and counting. This band is awful. Oooh another growling in E minor song? ugh. Great guitar player tho. .... ok personal feelings aside this isn't the absolute worst. I still don't like it - will hold my nose a little for Enter Sandman even if it now unfortunately rivals "Crazy Train" as "most played song between periods" at hockey games.... it's catchy. Some melody in a few cuts and yeah Bob Rock gave this the big power pop production but .... no no no the drums sound like ass cannons. no I retract anything positive I really hate this. 3/10 1 star

Powerful songs - albeit, don’t know what any are about. But the music itself is moving.

4 stars but only because it would be rude to the genuine 5 star content

Amazing. I’ve loved this album for a long time, but haven’t listened back to back in a while.

not my thing, songs too long

Metal metal metal! After a while it all sounds the same.

Bit plodding

Ремек дело - 10/10

One of the best metal albums OAT

I can definitely see why a lot of people love this album. Very well crafted with moving lyrics. Just not for me.

1. enter zandman - 4 2. zad but true - 2 3. holier than thou - 1.5 4. the unforgiven - 2 5. i may roam - 1.5 6. dont tread on me - 1 7. through the never - 2 8. nothing elze matterz - 3.5 9. of uuolf and man - 1 10. the god that failed - 1 11. my friend of mizery - 1 12. the ztruggle uuithin - 1

3 out of 5

very funny album. very hard my favorite song was nothing else matters

After listening to this album, I remembered why I don't like metal. Giving a high rating only for Nothing Else Matters

Very nostalgic for me

Metallica will never not be a 5/5 for me. Just seeing this album pop up today put a smile on my face.

Jeg har altid været kontrær overfor den her men altså… der er sgu nogle meget fede numre på. Kan bare ikke så godt lide produktionen og balladerne er lidt corny. Jeg elsker James hetfields stemme så meget

Fed hegn! Klart den værste Metallica plade indtil videre i 1991

Det er fandme sådan men starter en plade! Gider simpelthen ikke til at fluekneppe for at retfærdiggøre at give den 4, så den får en 5'er..

Love it! Def one of the best metallica Albums! 4.5/5 Very good album to hit the gym or serve the military but on any other day i dont relly have the need to hit play on it. Replay Value is missing for me!

Forgot about Sad But True \../ Metal ballads are silly Not my genre, but still good

I listened to this 10,000 times.. good album for someone who hates metallica... Other than that.. Not so good

Radio hits aren't bad, but songs are too long. Huge for the time. 3.6

For the consistency of their sound, a surprisingly diverse range on the album. The final song is a very modern sounding banger

Really enjoyed this. Would be a great road trip album

So well produced, you can hear everything even through all the distortion. This is about as heavy as you can get while still having mainstream appeal. All the songs are almost the same tempo, so they all sorta serve the same purpose. My Friend of Misery has an amazing guitar solo that I never see talked about anywhere, even in guitar circles.

I don't have anything specifically against Metallica, but this album really just plods on compared to their earlier stuff that I'm more familiar with. Spotify also has me listening to a "remastered" version which I suspect is mostly a louder/more compressed edition, so that doesn't make it any easier to listen to.

Respect! Love it. Lyrics - absolutelly masterpiece. Classic. Nihilistic Through the Never, social criticism in Holier Than Thou, understanding for human destiny in Nothing Else Matters, struggle with faith - The God That Failed etc... Yes, Metallica changed the sound a little, but lyrics were questions from eternity. Five star.

I don't own nor have any desire to own an Ibanez guitar.

Rounded up a 4.5. Not my favourite of theirs from the first five but the production brings it up and the remaining four are four of the best metal albums of all time.

First Metallica album I bought, and I remember quickly getting bored of it. Luckily I went back through their catalogue after and fell in love, rather than forward. This album is terribly overrated. So many more misses rather than hits. And Justice... wasn't amazing admittedly, but this album marked a slight but distinctive change from their earlier stuff that was definitely for the worse rather than the better. Probably sneaks a 3* due to a few of the decent tunes on here

How is this over 30 years old! I get why it's on the list, but not really my thing

I like Metallica's music much more than I like Metallica. This album in particular stands out.

Good album, one of the few that i actually enjoyed listening to

9/10 Metallica at their best but it’s not the thrash Metallica that I fell in love with growing up :)

Noteworthy for its slow, deep style of heavy metal. I'm very familiar with all of the singles on this album and liked them alright when I was younger, although I never owned anything by Metallica or listened to a full album. They feel a bit overplayed now but they definitely stood out back in the 90s.

My feelings about this album are complicated. It's maybe the most popular metal album of all time, an accolade that isn't entirely undeserved. However, pretty much every metalhead has listened to this album, hell half of it still gets played on the radio from time to time, and knows how important it is, but has also found something they like better than Metallica.

Damn the guitar is good. Not what I would usually listen to. Solid album. 3.5?

Man this is way better than I thought. I made fun of it a lot but it really solid.

Its by far the most accessible Metallica album. Everything is good, the production is top notch. However, that does lessen a bit of what makes thrash so enjoyable so its not perfect. That feeling metallica wasn't comfortable with the material can be noticed

It was an enjoyable album, but only a few songs really stood out and I can’t say I’m the biggest Enter Sandman fan.

Brilliant! It's such a great album. I can't count the number of times I've jammed to this.

Superb, cohesive and changed metal forever

Wow this album takes me all the way back. Going to show my age but definitely has this on cassette tape. Didn’t have to fast forward through many songs. Lars Ulrich is such a badass on this album. I love him on the drums. NGL it gets me so hype

I've never been a metal fan, but I don't mind listening through this album every few years. Some absolute classics.

I’ve always disliked them but I gave it a fair listen. It’s musically sound but still feels as douchey as ever. Made me drive aggressively.

The older I get the more I like Metallica.

Amazing front to back! Was hoping for a new album that I never listened to but I'm always happy to rock with Metallica.

Ark, j'aime définitivement pas Metallica pis c'est pas cet album là qui me fait aimer ça plus

It's Metallica. Never been a huge fan or anything, but this isn't one of their bad albums at least. Solid 3.5 at least.

Lots of catchy songs, unique sound

I don't normally like this kind of self-aggrandizing American Metal but this the best example of the aforementioned. I respect the band and the trials they have gone though.. I enjoyed this.

Nice one. Not my favourite band, but really nice album.

Iconic metal

This feels like a guilty pleasure. Is it cheesy and low-brow? Yes. Did I enjoy it? Also yes. Gives me a hit of that middle school-era nostalgia - both the good and bad.

Eh. Enter Sandman is a classic but the energy feels a little off for me. A lot of mid tempo/slower jams that don't hit as hard as ride the lightning or master of puppets style songs.

I've never listened to this album from start to finish, but I'm very familiar with all of the singles from it. When it comes to the singles, "The Unforgiven" and "Nothing Else Matters" are tied for my favorites. I love their slower pace, and they both feature some of my favorite guitar playing from Metallica. I really enjoy James Hetfield's growling vocals, and he shines on those songs. "Enter Sandman" would be my next favorite, with its fantastic cymbal crashes and screeching and wailing guitar solo. As for "Sad But True" and "Wherever I May Roam," well, those are unfortunately two of my least favorite Metallica singles. The guitar playing is pretty ho-hum to me, and they don't offer Hetfield anything unique to perform vocally. The other songs on this album are good, but the singles are what stand out. As a whole, the album sounds great and cohesive, with memorable guitar playing, great vocals, and a good mixture of lyrics. I think this album has earned an important place in the history of music and popular culture. For a band like Metallica to create something that stays true to themselves, but that has also been accessible to so many people for the last thirty plus years is absolutely incredible. This album brought metal into the mainstream, and has managed to keep it there. I grew up in a household where metal was definitely not allowed, but Metallica still managed to make into my ears quite a bit throughout my childhood and teenage years. This album firmly earns its place on this list for the impact that it's had.

Enter Sandman - 5/5 Sad but True - 5/5 Holier than Thou - 5/5 The Unforgiven - 5/5 Wherever I May Roam - 5/5 Don't Tread on Me - 4/5 Through the Never - 4/5 Nothing Else Matters - 5/5

Like REM but hard Rock.

Classic album that brought Metal to the Mainstream once again with tight catchy riffs, sleek production, and easily quotable lyrics that are just generic enough that they are relatable to all. The singles on this album are everywhere - I mean Enter Sandman has 1.2 Billion Streams on Spotify alone. That's insane. While this doesn't scratch the same itches that Master of Puppets or Ride the Lightning does, it does usher in a new era of rock music and created an entire industry of Adult Contemporary Rock that still dominates the jock DJs on FM radio. I know that this sounds negative but I really do like this album, its just been played to death. Nothing Else Matters is really just Metallica's - Wish You Were Here moment but it at least it somehow still is an enjoyable listen even though its also been played to death. Best Tracks for me: Where Ever I may roam, The Unforgiven, etc.