Reviews (page 13 of 16)
Foundational album in my life
Really tough rating for me. This album was a gateway into metal for me, but I also think I've heard so many better albums since that introduction. Don't get me wrong, so many bangers on this. But listening to it again it feels like it's too long. Lop off a couple songs and this would be a "no skips" album.
Classic. Especially the Unforgiven is 100
Not a fan of heavy metal but I did like Enter Sandman, Unforgiven, and Nothing Else Matters
Forgot just how many good songs were on this album.
Was ok
As a hard rock album, it's fine. More hard rock bands in the '90s could have used Kirk Hammett. But knowing what they'd done and where they were going, hard not to resent almost everything about this album.
Of their core albums before they helped numetal gain a strong hold, this is their weakest. It is also the most popular. It certainly catches a couple of zeitgeist type topics and has become anthemic for various reasons.
The beginning of the end? Decent hard rock album, it's nice they slowed things down so Lars could keep up. It's all very pedestrian though, isn't it? Oh, I don't know! It's not terrible, a bit too long and bands evolve etc. 2.5 / 5 stars.
There are two albums in the discography of Metallica which will always get a lot of flak: This one here, also known as The Black Album, and the later released 'St. Anger'. Both albums are pretty good in their own right though. This one here gets flak because people who have usually no clue of metal or even hard rock know some of Metallica's singles and think they are cool enough. It's the surface of an iceberg. But that can still be magnificent enough, can't it? 'Enter Sandman', 'Don't Tread on Me' or, yes, even 'Nothing Else Matters' are all great songs. It's certainly a worthwhile album to get more into this band.
Not much to say here. Admittedly, I grew up on this record and it was this band that got me into drumming. But there's not a duff track on this masterpiece. Favourite tracks: yes.
leider einfach richtig geil
Perhaps if I had been 16 when this album came out, I would’ve liked it. Not sure it would’ve been a favorite even then. However, I was 31 when this came out. I had a wife, 2 kids, a solid start on a career. I just didn’t have the testosterone driven anger at the world, that this seems to call upon. And I’m good with that. I’ll go 2/5, just for “Enter Sandman” is a very good song, I do own that one. But don’t listen to it very often. 2/5
Some I hadn't heard in a while. Enter the Sandman a classic.
Repetitive and formulaic, but I think their hits are enjoyable enough.
Certified classic.
Fuck yeah! Metallica’s most awesome album! Not a bad track in there (actually there 5 tracks I never listen to, but the other tracks more than make up for them!) Just revisiting this one - knocked it down a star, seemed appropriate considering some of the awesome albums I have given 4 stars to!
I love Metallica - I was so excited to listen through this album and I thought this would be my first 5 star rating. It has some absolute bangers, but the full listen through wasn't quite as good as I expected and there are a few songs I'm just not that into. Still a solid 4 for me :) All time face Metallica track: Unforgiven EDIT: I saw Metallica live for their M72 tour and had to come back and fix this rating, this album has so much good stuff on it! Plus since rating this there are other albums I've rated 5 for just loving one song, so I felt like this was an INJUSTICE for all!!!
Favorite tracks: Enter Sandman, Sad But True, Holier Than Thou, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam, Through The Never, Nothing Else Matters Least favorite track: Don't Tread On Me
Много пафоса, видимо я говнарь. В принципе норм, можно привыкнуть, с каждым прослушиванием по ощущениям лучше.
It was good but isn’t smth that i would listen everyday
Man, listening to this album brought up a LOT of memories. Not all of them good. It's a really powerful metal album, one of Metallica's last good albums. But lyrically there's quite a bit here that feeds a bit of an incel mentality, and I can really only see that with some serious hindsight and separation from the material. There is a 'victim of society' mentality present here that I think can really burrow in to someone's mind, and I wonder what impact this may have had beyond the album. Whether it's giving a false sense of injustice, a need to prove oneself (in some ways as better than), or facing rejection with anger - there's a lot on display here that just isn't healthy. But musically holy shit. What a great album full of incredible tracks. Mark's absolute cruising here with insane solos and this becomes less thrash and more power metal, but you can also hear Metallica's sound evolving from here.
I know that a lot of people bash this album for being too "commercial", but I liked it. I have a lot of really good memories associated with this album. Do with that what you will.
This album rocks
Вновь Металлика. Самый известный (мне) альбом. Сами песни, сведение, музыка и, главное, ностальгия ) вспоминаю Алису из лагеря и анфоргивен, а потом и Никиту со всем этим альбомом.
Familiar with the album. Not all the tracks are great but overall it's a monumental album. Love how the black cover is done unironically due to Spinal Tap spoofing it.
Staple in the hard rock genera
i know the album very well, listened to it when i was younger
Really impressed! The opening and the first half of the album are just perfect. "My friend of misery" seemed to work for this moment quite well. Maybe the most impressed I've been with an album so far on this list (only 10 or so)
As an above average Metallica fan, nothing like some of my friends (I'm talking about you), I find this album a good remembrance to what they once were, a hard hitting, down to earth band, without many innovations and unnecessary elements in their songs. Enter sandman I can't stand to hear it anymore, but it is one of, if not the most well known song that Metallica has, very catchy tunes and lyrics Sad but true very hard song, hits you in the face and you're happy about it Holier then thou took longer than I liked to actually begin giving you something but nonetheless good song Wherever I may roam, very good feeling intro solos, the instruments alone are very relaxing and start preparing you for what's to come Don't tread on me, not my style, can't tell you why actually Same for trough the never, maybe these songs are a little repetitive for my taste The others songs I hadn't heard in a long time, was good to reminisce and the nostalgia was good, but unfortunately time didn't do well for these songs If I was comparing Metallica albums it would be a 4, not my favorite, but in the bigger context it's a 5 when compared to the whole scope of music.
2 primeiras já dá feels da banda hauahahaha. Interessante quando tu sabe tocar a música e agora analisa de uma forma crítica. Fico pensando como era na época, ouvir pela primeira vez uma música que seria uma clássica foda. Tipo a gente ouvindo o álbum do blink agora, tem música foda, mas a gente nunca acha que vai chegar nos pés das antigas. Mas as antigas um dia já foram novas também. Profundo. Unforgiven eu não conhecia, por mais que seja uma das mais famosas. Talvez já tenha ouvido, mas esqueci 100%. Gostei da vibe. Clássico de música de banda metaleira, que as "calminhas" são boas. Mas 6 minutos, irmão... Do nada uma música de deserto. Foda que depois as músicas pra mim parecem muito parecidas, acho que quem deve ser mais viciado deve curtir huahuauha. Veio Nothing Else Matters, essa é fudida, vibe massa. Ainda no esquema de banda de metal serem os responsáveis por fazer as melhores músicas mais calminhas huehuehue. É também a clássica música de adolescente que tá aprendendo a tocar violão/guitarra, pegar essa música pra se pagar pros parceiros. Depois de Nothing Else Matters fiquei um pouco de saco cheio, nada me impressionava tanto. Album fudido, deve ter sido um dos melhores do Metallica por ter 3~4 músicas muito clássicas. Esses albums "Self-Title" costumam ser fodas mesmo, né? huahuhuaah Só não dou 5 estrelas por que to indo pra um lado mais pessoal nos rankings, um 5 estrelas seria um beatles, the who ou tenacious d pra mim heuhehuehu, albums que posso ouvir 50.000 vezes sem enjoar e arrepiar. Mas aqui iria um 4,5 bem de boa.
UUHUHUHUHUHUHUHU (Quem não der 5 estrelas pra esse álbum vai apanhar. Eu sei que tu não vai dar Well, seu safado, eu vou me vingar quando vir The Who hein) Um crássico aonde eu estou obviamente completamente enviesado, mas fazer o quê, são fatos kkkkk 1. Enter Sandman: Mais um hino de quem tem carteirinha do rock e é do rock. Apesar de inegavelmente já estar "cansada" de tanto tocar em tudo quanto é lugar e muita gente não aguentar mais ouvir ela, isso tudo se deve justamente ao quão bom ela é pra ter sido tocada incessantemente tantas vezes assim. Riff épico, eternizado, solo clássico, energia daóra. Música lendária. 2. Sad But True: Música delicinha, com uma vibe bem pesada. A afinação 1 tom inteiro abaixo que a gente odiava fazer na banda, querendo ou não, traz um peso diferenciado pros riffs e é essencial. As paradas e entradas junto com a bateria são muito foda e não tem como batucar junto na mesa tentando acertar sincronizado. 3. Holier Than You: Ao contrário das duas primeiras, essa não faz parte das clássicas que todo mundo conhece. Mas deveria porque porra, olha esse riff animal que entra quando acaba a intro. Música animada, gostosa, pra CIMA. 4. The Unforgiven: Essa arrepia foda. Uma das músicas mais bonitas deles, com um dedilhado clássico no início. A entrada do vocal muito foda. Refrão calminho e gostosinho que tem que cantar junto. A entrada do solo muito foda também, saindo do silêncio, criando um pouco de tensão e explodindo no início do solo. Que obra de arte. Faz jus ao nome. 5. Wherever I May Roam tem esse início diferenciado feito com uma citara elétrica que ficou fueda. As guitarras entrando depois fazendo o mesmo riff, só que versão pesadona. Brinca bastante com mudança constante de cadência, fica bem devagar, depois acelera de volta, depois volta a ficar devagar e por aí vai. 6. Don't Tread On Me já é uma das um pouco mais underground, mas eu adoro o refrão dela. Como o vocal e a guitarra vão se complementando. 7. Through The Never já começa frenética, tem mais daquelas paradas repentinas que o Metallica faz muito, e depois volta certinho no tempo, curto isso. Também curto muito o vocal e o riff se complementando nos versos. 8. Nothing Else Matters: Aí chegamos na lendária né. A que todo mundo com um violão na mão numa rodinha de amigos é obrigado a eventualmente tocar o início. Dedilhado fudido de lindo, tanto o da intro, quanto os dos versos. Nas partes mais quietas, tem uns instrumentos orquestrais no fundo, uns sintetizadores/órgãos/algo do tipo, que dão um brilho extra foda pra essas partes. A entrada do solo é uma das melhorinhas também, solo entra com uma nota cravada rasgada dando uma voadora na boca. Coisa linda. 9. Of Wolf And Man: FAZ O LOBINHUUUUUUUU AÚÚÚÚÚUUUU. Essa aqui é outra que é um pouquinho mais underground, mas eu adoro e é uma das minhas favoritas. Esse início é foda demais. Bateria entrando na porrada, guitarra vindo no contratempo, aí abrindo no riff lindoso. Ela é rasgada, bruta. O refrão dela vai crescendo. 10. The God That Failed tem uma história interessante. A mãe do James era bem religiosa, aí eventualmente ela ficou bem doente, teve câncer e precisava de tratamento médico. Mas ela recusou qualquer tipo de tratamento e confiou full que deus iria curar ela. Aí ela obviamente morreu e daí veio That God That Failed. 11. My Friend Of Misery: Destaque pra melodia foda de baixo na intro que volta ao longo da música algumas vezes. 12. Eu gosto dessa música até porque eu não consigo não gostar de uma música do Metallica. Gosto do refrão dela, e dos riffs. Mas com certeza ela é a menos boa do álbum sim. É a que menos tem características marcantes. Ainda mais num álbum desse calibre aqui, que a barra tá lá no teto. Mas ainda fecha legal esse álbum magnífico. Esse álbum é uma sacanagem. Não sei como ele soa pra alguém que não conhece talvez metade das músicas, como imagino que seja o caso de alguns aqui. Mas pra quem é bitch do Metallica, esse álbum é 10/10 easy. Riffs fodas, com timbres pesados, rasgados. James é uma máquina de riff épico. Cheio de músicas clássicas que já ouvimos 478 vezes.
I dug this album and concert!
One of Metallica's best albums, some essential tracks here. 4/5
In the end, just decent
Traaaaaaaash
Wow, I had no idea this came directly after ...And Justice For All. It's so drastically different from the thrash metal of their previous albums, so I always figured there was more of a transition period into the sound of The Black Album. I don't know if I'll rank this one above the previous album, since I'm a sucker for thrash, but either way, this is a good album! It certainly feels like a more radio-friendly rock sound, and as a result, it's not as heavy and it certainly feels a bit cheesier than their previous works, but I don't mind that at all. It still rocks either way, and its popularity and acclaim makes it one of the most important albums in heavy metal. Favourite: Enter Sandman
Enter Sandman is a brilliant album opener. I was starting to get a bit worn out by Holier Than Thou. The Unforgiven drew me back in. The rest of the album was good. Not much to say about it.
Very large difference between songs, with a good balance across ( having some breathing songs in between)
Not their best album, arguably the start of the downfall of their music, but it is not bad
Extreme adaptability for metal band
10/24/23 2:30 S Tier————————— Enter Sandman Nothing Else Matters A Tier————————— Through The Never Holier Than Thou My Friend of Misery B Tier————————— The Struggle Within Sad But True The Unforgiven Wherever I may roam Don't tread on me The god that failed me
Tuesday 10/24/23, 2:30, Office S————————— Sad But True Wherever I May Roam Enter Sandman Through the Never A————————— Nothing Else Matters The Unforgiven My Friend of Misery B————————— Holier Than Thou Of Wolf and Man Don’t Tread on Me C————————— The Struggle Within The God That Failed
Man komme ikkje utenom
Heilt greit. Et par sterke riff
Do old head Metallica fans still hate this or are they over that?
Classic from my ten age years. First half of the album is brilliant, fades in the second half a bit.
Great Album
Although fans of their earlier thrash work continue to call it a sellout, Metallica's "black album" was, and continues to be, their best work. It's the album that moved them out of the realm of the isolated long-hairs and launched them into being, for a time, the biggest band in the world. And the reality is - the album is that good. Not a weak song on the album, they all hold up over the decades that have passed. A masterpiece that deserves 5 star plaudits.
Pretty good, but I got sick of it fast.
En ekte Classic. Uansett hvor mye dritt jeg gir Metallica kan jeg ikke late som om dette IKKE er et godt album. Legit. Sånn alle låtene folk kan av metallica er på dette albumet. Nothing Else matters, sad but true, senter Sandman, The unforgiven osv osv. Eneste låta jeg ikke liker her er kanskje «Don’t tread on me» som er litt for viking-Metal for meg
Liker, men syntes instrumentalen er på et helt annet nivå enn vokalen, som trekker det helhetlige inntrykket ned. Favorittsang: Wherever I May Roam
Just doesn’t do it for me today.
Classic Metallica
The original metal album and certainly the one you would give to a new listener to genre.
Enter Sandman is bekend en wel grappig maar als ik heel eerlijk mag zijn ook niet zo geweldig. Sad But True en Holier Than Thou verdwijnen een beetje in een generic Metallica soep. The Unforgiven was anders maar ook niet fantastisch. Nog meer Metallica soep NOTHING ELSE MATTERS. Deze vind ik leuk. 10/10 Soep Ik vind eigenlijk alleen Nothing Else Matters leuk, 1,5/5
Enter Sandman - Ik denk net een beetje te metallic achtig voor mij. Maar op zich wel goed nummer. Sad Bit True - Geen slecht nummer denk ik, maar niet voor mij. Holier Than Thou - Beetje te heftig The Unforgiven - Minder heftig, beter dan vorige nummers Wherever I May Roam - Weer beetje hetzelfde, iets te heftig. Ik zou hier niet perse voor mijn plezier naar luisteren Don’t Tread On Me - Nog heftiger XD Trough the Never - De zang is meer losse woorden uitschreeuwen Nothing Else Matters - Dit is het eerste nummer dat ik denk ik daadwerkelijk voor mijn plezier zou luisteren, iets rustiger dan de andere en minder geschreeuw Of Wolf and Man - Dum dum tu dum The God That Failed - Wederom iets te heftig My Friend of Misery - Eigenlijk hetzelfde The Struggle Within - Gelukkig het is voorbij (Zo erg was het niet hoor, maar niet helemaal mijn muziek) Metallica is niet echt iets voor mij. Eigenlijk het enige leuke nummer is Nothing Else Matters, en misschien Enter Sandman. Voor de rest is het iets te veel metal, niet helemaal mijn genre. 1.8/5
Metallica
Came out the year I left the Army. Lived in the California Apartments in Colorado Springs, CO. Roommate was John, a childhood friend of 3rd cousin Devin. Ashley moved from Montana and we shared an 1 room spot and had a demon kitten. About the time I got into White Zombie. Enjoyed riding my Yamaha Verago 750 up past Monument to solo fish, hike and camp off the South Platt in the Rocky Mountains. Mild child days, no worries, no fucks.
75% forgettable 25% first ballot hall of fame probably a 4 star
Metal becoming pop is always seen as a tragedy, and maybe it is. Although we can't deny how it skyrocketed Metallica's fame, as well as the popularity of metal itself. The overplayed classics in this album are among the songs that got me into metal. But of course, it is a tragedy because of how bland it can sound. It's unlike hair metal, which covered the genre in so much synth and sparkles that its nauseating. Metallica's approach here was to take their masculine riffs and angsty lyrics and execute them in a basic, predictable way. It worked. It didn't work. Depends on who you ask.
I don't want to LISTEN TO THIS ANYMOaoRE-a-uh! thruggadugchugdugdug thuggadugchug its place in historeeeea-uh is unmisTAKEable YEAH but I don't want to HEAR IT A-UH-GAIIIINNNNN! YEAH! meedley meawuuuuh bree a wreauh mreeeeuuwwww thruggaduggachuggachugchgchgchg music: hated. (⌐■_■)
It rocks. It’s not their best, Cliff Burton isn’t on it. But it’s good and it rocks.
The album that made Metallica a mainstream band. Solid easy listening metal start to finish.
Not really my bag. There are some great songs on hear, but most of these songs felt twice as long as they should be
YEAHHHHH!!!! METALLICA!!!! *Enter Sandman : 10/10 *Sad But True : 8/10 *Holier Than Thou : 7/10 *The Unforgiven : 8/10 *Wherever I May Roam : 8/10 *Don't Tread On me : 7/10 *Through The Never : 7/10 *Nothing Else Matters : *Of Wolf And Man : *The God That Failed : *My Friend Of Misery : *The Struggle Within : An hour album, a bit long for me, Didn't like it as much as I thought I would be but still a very good album, Not liking the vocal that much DECENT 7
Good
Epic
The first Metallica album I didn't hate, but apart from the hits it is just too much of the same.
Probably my favorite Metallica album
This album has most of the songs by Metallica that I like, it is just 20 minutes too long
Has some absolute classics. Has some absolute shit.
The vocals are to choppy to be perfect, but close
Beginning of the end of the Metallica that I love but this album is still a banger.
THE gateway metal album
Metallica have grown on me a bit, this does have some great tracks on it. It trails off a little towards the end, and I do prefer the live album.
Good rock album. One of my go tos for working out in he gym
Het lijkt wel een best of, tenminste ik hoor toch een aantal bekende klassieke nummers. Het genre is niet helemaal mijn smaak, maar op het terrein van Zware Metalen weten deze heren van wanten.
Typisch jaren '90 zou je zeggen. Maar het opent met Enter Sandman. Met o.a. het gebed komt dat aardig richting een modernere opzet van bijvoorbeeld een Rammstein. Terwijl de gitaarsolo weer dichtbij de gitaargoden van een paar decennia eerder komt. Het is tekenend voor het album; een plaat van alle tijden. Ook de andere hits knallen er natuurlijk uit. De grommende stem is troef bij Metallica. Een heel album is misschien wat veel daarvan. Zelf bij een wat rustiger nummer als The Unforgiven kunnen ze de rauwe inval niet laten. Dit is dan ook het enige commentaar dat ik kan bedenken. Het blijft een vijf-sterren plaat.
Eindelijk weer zware metalen. Een van de bekendste albums van de grote 4 thrashmetalbands, the black album, samen met Master of Puppets misschien. Hier ook een aantal dikke hits, met enter sandman en nothing else matters, al is die laatste bijna een outlier in het geheel. Verder is het namelijk gewoon fijn in het gehoor liggende thrashmetal, al gaat het wel wat trager dan veel van de genregenoten. Toch zijn de drums ouderwets rauw, de gitaarsolo's gelikt en onder de laag dikke gitaren zitten ook nog eens hele goede liedjes. Een album waarop eigenlijk alle nummers goed zijn, iets dat echt een uitzondering is. Daarom een hele makkelijke 5 sterren.
Rock metal
Niet mijn stijl, ondanks bekende hits als enter sandman en nothing else matters.
I learned all the songs on guitar for this album!
Now that I have 30 years of perspective, I can see why the hardcore fans said they sold out with this album. Also, you can clearly see the beginnings of James Hetfield, world’s hardest lounge singer.
This definitely takes me back to high school!
4 Metallica LPs on 1001!
Yes this is regarded as an iconic metal album but apart from Enter sandman it sounds very cliched to me. I’ll round up to a 3 because I’m feeling strangely generous today
A front end banger, classic metal songs and a few slower ones just as classic, great fucking tunes.
I mean it's Metallica, that notwithstanding I'd never actually listened to their "band named album" before. Thoughts while listening: It's a good listen so far, however, their prolific tracks in Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters seem to be the only standouts so far. Closing thoughts: My Friend of Misery and The Struggle Within were pretty strong closers, especially the instrumentals. Overall, a solid listen.
This album was like pulling teeth for me... I did not care for the vocals or the lyrics ("I hunt therefore I am" ok dude). The songs felt very repetitive and full of machismo. I suppose heavy metal just isn't my genre. Songs that I didn't hit skip on: 5 - Wherever I May Roam; 8 - Nothing Else Matters Would I revisit this album: No. lol.
Muziek voor gymrats
Un disco formativo
I have had an aversion to Metallica since Napster. First album I listened to entirely. It isn't bad, of course, but it isn't for me.
A solid entry with some real classic thrash riffs, although I hadn't realized Don't Tread On Me was so starkly anti-soviet. Guess the band's fans make more sense now.
A bit biased with my mood but so many hits. The Unforgiven is a huge nostalgia hit for me. Nice to listen to a few songs I'm less familiar with. 🤟🔥 5/5
It’s 2005 I just learn how to jerk off and this was when this band made music of kids like me think this was hardcore shit, now it make me feel like an old man and this is now just grilling out door with the boyz kind of music as when complain about micro-injuries just by sneezing. Decent Gateway metal album, (3.5/5)
Bro this was a blast to the past i listened to this album in middle school on repeat. To the point i hated Metallica for a while. After a long hiatus it was so fun to listen to again. The album definitely holds up. I still won’t listen to Metallica frequently but still a great band
Initial thoughts: Wow, what a throwback. I will confess I've never listened to the album front to back though, excited for this one. Final thoughts: They say that structure of metal is similar to classical music. Listening to this album, I found it fascinating to how true that saying was. However, this album took that saying way too literally. More than half of the album had the same basic structure. So much so, that I even found myself wanting to skip songs because it really felt like I already heard it. Now, the iconic songs truly cannot be beat. Throw in some nostalgia glasses of me and Zack playing guitar hero until 1am while trying not to wake his parents, and these songs really are so good. Enter Sandman, Sad But True, Nothing Else Matters, these are songs that even people who don't listen to this genre will recognize, and for good reason too, they are fantastic pieces of music. Sadly can't say the same for the rest of the album. Some songs were just so... boring...? On my second listen I listened through my hi-fi set up and the mastering was excellent, so I guess they got that going for them. But still so... weak...? Does this album deserve 2? No. Does this album reach a 3? Barely. I would probably rate it 2.8, so rounded up we have:
Holy shit this album is boring. High school loser party album.
Only 2 good songs.
Some good old classic with energy and lots of feeling
7.5.. classic songs mixed with mediocrity.
The unforgiven is a great tune on this, I really appreciate the coherence of sound
Not a fan of metal. With the exception of the first track which is classic and catchy, I was not into the rest.
2/5
Classic.
This was one of my first cds I got as a kid. It still holds up but I do think some of their older work is better
like memes aside they did a solid job on this album
Heavy metal like PoP Warrior Within, very good album
One of my favorite albums of all time!
10/5/23: start of the journey. I have listened to this album before; for someone who isn’t a big metalhead this is a very solid album. A lot of memorable songs and heavy riffs and would keep in the collection.
Amazing album!
Obviously a milestone album for them. The lyrics are consistently impressive. Many songs are classics, some are strong and passionate, about a third are unmemorable.
I didn't really need to listen to this one. I've heard it a bunch. It's a classic metal album, but not among my favorites from Metallica. They're a band who informed and influenced my early appreciation for metal, but a band that I moved past pretty quickly. This was a turning point in their career and sound. A few too many ballads and downtempo songs for me. Not a lot on this album that I feel really holds up or has the staying power to make it worth revisiting in 2023. Of Wolf And Man, for as corny as the lyrics are, is probably the only song that I think has anything to say today. Musically, it has some complexity and some interesting turns. The rest of the album is a bit too safe, especially the few hits/singles. At this point, Metallica were clearly aiming for rock radio. You can hear the watering down of any of the elements that made them different in the albums before this one.
Landmark LP that launched the band into the highest echelons of rock superstardom. This is definitely the crossover from heavy metal to hard rock that frustrated fans, who considered themselves die-hard, but opened the band to an audience much wider and deeper than ever. This album includes multiple signature songs that may be the only Metallica tunes many people have ever heard, but they have heard them. Adding to the album itself, the documentary that accompanied its making makes this an all-time lock for five stars.
Solid album. Less thrashy and more refined/polished. Really starts to crossover into rock more so than metal. For better of for worse. Standouts are "Enter Sandman" and "Nothing Else Matters".
Not super excited to get started with this one. I guess it works for background music if you’re getting drunk on someone’s back porch. Nothing really stands out here musically besides kirk’s got a few really cool riffs. James’ lyrics are terrible. Drums are boring af. Didn’t really notice bass besides the opening to (I think) misery my friend which is a bass riff written by a middle schooler. A few cool songs I guess, none are coming with me. Lady Luck, please send me an album I give a f about!
The album starts with good energy, but quickly loses steam. It gets dull pretty fast, and by the end it feels like it's the same drum line on repeat with generic guitar riffs.
Listening to the singles on this album brought back vivid memories of the videos, and sitting around all day in summer with friends watching MTV. What a time. 3.5 stars bumped to a 4 because of the memories.
I remember ripping the packaging off this cassette in summer of 1991 driving home, and reveling in the perfection. Enter Sandman had already played on MTV but it was the first time I heard Sad But True and all the other tracks. Still my favorite band. Metallica - the best of all time.
Love, Love, Love it.
You can never really go wrong with a Metallica album (almost anyway). I don't listen to them regularly, mostly at the gym but they are still good. I like alot of songs on this one
Enter Sandman might be one of the best album openings ever but apart from that - and maybe Unforgiven - this album is not very exciting.
It's been a long time since last good metal album. There are one of the best (if not the best) Metallica songs. I totally get why some people say that this the best album of this band. I'm not big fun of Metallica but this is still good metal album and it fits on this list.
The Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters ...aún así ...
4th or 5th best metallica album
Top album from the goat metal band
Enter Sandman is an all-timer, and The Unforgiven is pretty good. The rest is kind of boring.
Most incredible album
Not for me, although 'Sad But True' & ' Holier Than Thou' sound okay and have nice lyrics
Au début j’étais impressionnée que ça aille aussi hard, pis rendu à la moitié je me suis fait chier fake j’ai écouté Rage Against the Machine à la place
Apparently you need to give a child a new food stuff between 12 and 30 times for them to accept it. I don’t know how many times I’ve listened to Metallica but I still can’t accept it. I’ll tell you when I get to 31 because obviously then I’m gonna love them. Just not now.
This is the one album that both my wife and I turn up the volume. It very commercial, but well produced. This is one album that I can still listen to over and over. I just connect.
It’s long. The songs are similar. Sometimes there’s a bit too much guitar noodling. That being said, I think it’s great. Metallica’s sound is unmistakable.
There's a reason why the top two streamed Metallica tracks on Spotify are from this album. This is where the thrash and muscle from their first five albums get slightly refined and sweetened and on the strongest material, it's excellent. Not every second of the album is a winner, "Holier Than Thou" struck me as particularly ponderous, but on the whole, this is solid heavy rock from one of the most popular bands ever. I might sound like a fan, truth is, I don't own a single Metallica album (who knows where my cassette versions of Master Of Puppets and And Justice For All have gotten to). I've always admired how they were able to get ever more popular without alienating their early fans — not an easy feat, but a testament to the fact that these guys delivered the goods, and I appreciate them maybe more than I love the music. But this might be their best album. I guess I need to listen to all the others to make that determination. Not making any promises...
1 hour and 5 minutes is, by any measure, an unhealthy amount of James Hetfield. Don't get me wrong, I'm not a hater. He's an astounding rhythm guitarist. And his delivery of the line, "Hush little baby, don't say a word," is comedy gold. I'm just trying to urge moderation. So kids: If you want to listen to this album, do so in three-song increments. In between doses, take a half-hour break. Go for a walk. Listen to Taylor Swift or The Beatles. Remind yourself that joy exists. Following this advice will make your listening experience much more powerful... and no one will get hurt in the process.
I appreciate Stranger Things use of Enter Sandman even more now that I made it halfway through this album. Maybe there is real musicianship in this band but I won't ever truly know b/c I hit play and start thinking about Beavis & Butthead and how much adolescent boys stink and I don't understand any lyrics and the din just makes me f'in crazy.
Love this album, music of my childhood
Metallica's first big letdown, and their last album that can be considered good. I liked this album a quite a bit for around a year when I was a dumb kid, but even then I was disappointed that it was more hard rock than the thrash they perfected on their first 4 albums. Nevertheless, production is great and this is a highly-accessible classic hard rock album.
Can see why this is one of the top albums of all time. Classic Metallica. Some all time bangers on here. This album still gets a lot of play.
Decent album with the obvious standout tracks. Enjoyed them at the time, but not the full album.
goated album nuff said
Even though a consider myself "a bit" of a metal head I was never very big on Metallica. They have a handful of songs I've enjoyed over the years but for the most part they rely on that Thrash metal sound too much which has always kind of bored me. The Black Album is different though. They have a ton of bangers on here that still hold up even today.
Reminds me of my favorite roomie who had one CD... this one. I've still heard it enough.
Haven’t listened to a lot of Metallica, but this was pretty good. I might have to listen to even more Metallica
Great
Nostalgia kicks in hard with Metallica so I can not do anything else but give this a 5 star rating
лайк, лайк, лайк
Спасибо что без оркестра. Уже +1. Но я так и не научился кончать от тяжелой музыки и металла. Не, ну звучит очень круто. Очень плотные рифаки, композиции прям как симфонии, только под тяжёлые гитары. Металично, короче.
They're last great album, as long as you can get past Lars' neanderthal drumming (c'mon, Lars, just a little nuisance nuance or subtlety in your playing, maybe? Guess not. But that's okay, you do you.) Compared to previous albums, not all of the songs are as distinct among the tracks they're sharing vinyl with. Nevertheless, still a strong set.
Fuck yeah. This album fucking rips. Not perfect songwriting from end to end, but instruments and vocals are perfect in every case. Definitely some new ones in here, good album listen.
Neutral, closer to a 3 than a 2 though. I’m positive I had a favourite song from the album but I didn’t write it down and now I can’t figure out which it was… Overall I prefer the first half of the album though. Already knew Enter Sandman.
Torn. Two amazing songs that I love, but I don't like the genre so much so would never choose to listen to the rest.
I liked this way more than I was expecting. Some really solid songs and nowhere near as annoying as I thought it was going to be. 3.5 stars
It's not very typical of this book to select a band's sleekest / most commercially successful albums, but they did in this case. This is metal at its commercial peak, and one my teenager self's favorites. Listening to it now, some tracks are a bit cheesy, but... five stars will do.
Þetta er djöfulsins partý. Rosa nostalgía. Fíla þetta.
Sooo good
Metallica used to be pretty sweet, but it's tough to take them all that seriously now because they are so ridiculous. This album is a bit hit or miss from me, but ultimately it's pretty good, I definitely prefer the earlier stuff from them.
Classic!
A straight shot of adrenalin. This isn’t my style of music, and yet I was surprised how many of these songs were in my consciousness! Well crafted music by thoroughgoing musicians.
All the songs I know and love one one album
2.5 I just don’t like Metallica
Je connais toutes les chansons, alors je suis un peu biasié. Le fait que j'ai écouté l'album des dizaines de fois, cependant, pas souvent de A à Z comme cela impacte un peu la note. Il y a deux metalica, peut-etre 3 maintenant, et cet album est clairement l'apogée de ce qu'est la deuxième vie de Metalica et pour cela, on ne compare pas avant les albums avant, mais après. Dans ce cas, 4.85 car la 1ere vie est pour vrai supérieure.
My first ever album recommendation from this website was AC/DC’s “black album”, which I found to be a very ear-piercing and gut wrenching experience! Fortunately, my second album recommendation was a far superior “black album” in Metallica’s self titled. I listened to this album for the first time a few months ago while on a walk, and I found it to be respectable but not mind blowing. When I listened to this album this time, however, a few tracks that did not stick with me the first time around clicked better in this listen! While I still prefer their more trash-centered works such as KTA and MOP, this album is absolutely no slouch by any means, and I can see why it is arguably their most popular release to date. I would give this about a 7/10, which translates to a 3.5/5 on my rating scale.
No bad songs but some are forgettable Favorites: Wherever I May Roam, The Unforgiven 1, Nothing Else Matters, Of Wolf And Man Least liked: The Struggle Within, Don't Tread On Me
My least favorite Metallica album
Even though its not thrash metal its still a 5 out 5 for me.
14 year old James would have loved this album. 33 year old James... meh. The last half was pretty bad.
It's so good.
Excellent album - bringing in Bob Rock took them to the big leagues, even if I prefer their thrashier sound more.
Close to 5, but a couple songs bring down an otherwise exceptional album. Those songs: Nothing Else Matters and Sad But True. Come at me
Great album
Kultaista tykitystä, sitä Metallicaa parhaimmillaan. Levy täynnä klassikoita ja nekin kappaleet mitä ei oo aikasemmin tullut niin paljon kuunneltua ei kylmäksi jätä. Kyllä tämä ihan 5 tähteä ansaitsee
I've got nothing bad to say about this album. I don't really begrudge the fact that they transitioned out of Thrash Metal and made more standard heavy metal. It should also be mentioned that this is an excellently produced and mixed album. Over 30 years since it was released and you can single this out as an example of a great sounding album.
Echti Legände. Härt. Weiss echt ninig eb 4 oder 5 Sterne. Isch nöd würklich min Sound. Aber scho s'paar Goldschätz drunder. Halt ebe doch nur 4 Stern. 5 wäreds wänns mini Musig wär.
Polished to a chrome.
I don't know if I liked Enter Sandman and Nothing else Matters because I already know them, or if they are really the two standout songs from the album. It was a nice enough album, but did not make me a Metallica fan.
Everyone figured the death of original bassist Cliff Burton would hit Metallica hard, but no one could've guessed that they would pivot away from thrash metal to make simple heavy metal and, dare I say, bland hard rock. Sick riffs were traded in for grooves and even ballads. While Master of Puppets was their landmark album, this self-titled album (sometimes called the black album) is certainly their most commercial album. This sold over 17 million units and none of their albums have come close since. Everyone knows Enter Sandman, Sad but True, the Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters. It's the only Metallica that your classic rock radio station will play, because their other stuff is either too heavy or too sucky. For all the good that this album was, it was also the album where Metallica distinctly sold their soul. Now you can play these songs on Guitar Hero Metallica.
I wish I was pirating this album out of spite. They're an ok band but man if they aren't annoying with who can and can't play their music. This album enters with enter sandman which is a great song, but I remember my shitty high school football team coming out to this song thinking they were hot shit only to lose every game but like 2 or 3 during my entire time there
Lyrics have never been Metallica’s strong suit, but the the instrumentals here are powerful and bombastic. A landmark of early 90s metal.
Black album is legendary
60% elemental and classic and 40% questionable in a Spinal Tap sense. Overall I enjoyed it
This site knew Friday is deadlift day, and Metallica did not disappoint. Even the slower songs have so much energy I felt like I could (and probably should) run through a wall.
From Nirvana to Pearl Jam to the Red Hot Chili Peppers, a number of late 20th century rock bands hit their strides in 1991, but perhaps no band hit their stride more gracefully than Metallica did. After the successful trio of Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets, and Justice between 1984 and 1988, the band blew expectations out of the water with this tour de force to open the nineties. Take the album’s opening track and you’d be forgiven for thinking it’s the band’s Mona Lisa, with a hummable chorus and a mysterious hue. But dig deeper and you start to see that it’s actually their Sistine Chapel. Aside from the obvious religious theme, the electric opening and structural diversity puts “Enter Sandman” at the top of its genre. If only I could’ve seen Mariano Rivera ascend the mound at Yankee Stadium to this masterpiece. From the schizophrenic “Sad But True” to the patriotic “Don’t Tread on Me” to the intergalactic “Through the Never,” the band continues to communicate a wide range of emotions and themes throughout the record. It’s funny how we associate music with memories or places without even meaning to. I had never actually heard “Wherever I May Roam” until it popped up on my shuffle the other day at EoS, but I wouldn’t be surprised if I forever associate the song with lat pull-downs. If that keeps my rotator cuffs intact, I’ll take it. With “The Unforgiven” the band proves they can play at a slower pace than their usual gasoline-drinking style, further revealing the intensity of the other tracks. “Nothing Else Matters” continues this trend, and through lyrics like “I’ve never opened myself up this way,” they recognize they’d broken into a plane of existence metal had never seen before. Or, to put it in their words, the Earth had become their throne.
I'd give it a 5 but the second half of the album felt like already tread ground for the most part.
Wish I could give a 9 here, fantastic album
all very similar
Classic Metallica. I actually like this slower Metallica better than the earlier fast thrash-metal Metallica. Enter Sandman obvious standout but all are good. Great guitar and bass sound on this. Drums sound great too. 4.5 Stars
If all metal were to be like this, call me a metalhead. I have to shout out the album cover is a very cheeky wink to White Light/White Heat…
Really enjoy most of these well known songs, but as an album they start to blend together (maybe that's intentional?) My mind wandered off in the back half as it tends to.
this is obviously a landmark album but just doesn't speak to me
I was familiar with most of the songs on this album. The problem with it and it is a problem with most Metallica songs is that they are all too long. The album is over an hour long. Each song, even the good ones, could be cut by a minute at least. Tighten the songs up and it is a better album.
Long, drawn out, repetitive, and angsty. The same guitar tone, same gruff vocals, the same up-down stroke riffs in the same minor keys. Really not sure what's going on here that others hear. Other then having "Metal" in the name, what's cool about this?
5 stars for Nothing Else Matters on its own.
I pretty much grew up with this album, as familiar as my own skin. Love it more with every listen. Nothing Else Matters is a perfect rock ballad. Just a perfect LP.
to everyone hating on this album…. calm the fuck down and grow up. yes, it’s metal for dummies. there’s no denying that. it’s perfectly palatable for the lowest common denominators of our society who think they’re hard. but come on, it’s still good? the song are catchy, production is slick with epic heavy riffage all throughout. it’s radio metal so ya it’s not overly clever,,,,….. but it’s fine for what it is. it’s listenable. a lot of lyrics are honestly kinda boring. and obviously it’s way too long. it definitely should’ve ended at Nothing Else Matters; the four after that were completely unnecessary.
El disco es buenísimo. Tiene tremenda calidad, pero esa voz satánica nunca va a ser lo mío.
I kind of feel like this is basically a Motley Crue record, just heavier, more beefed up and sans eye shadow.
"Never opened myself this way. Life is ours, we live it our way. All these words I don't just say. And nothing else matters." --- Favourite Tracks: Enter Sandman Summary: I tried to keep an open mind with this as it's definitely not to my usual tastes, I knew of Enter Sandman going in which I didn't mind, but from there it all felt very repetitive and one note. I'm sure it was very influential and clearly has a massive fan base, but it's just not for me - the highlight was when my headphones interrupted the album to tell me the battery was low.
Released just weeks before Ten and Nevermind, Metallica’s self-titled could be seen as the final gasp of the 80’s. Thrash metal at its most radio friendly, and yet it never feels like a sell out move. If the awful 80’s mainstream rock movement was needed to build up to this album, then it was all worth it.
Never listened to this directly, but am varying degrees of familiar with the hits. There's something truly epic about a slow metal banger, which I'm hearing on The Unforgiven. Only a few songs in, but so far enjoying it more than I expected to. The first half was good, the last half got boring. I'll give it a 4/5 for rocking, but yeah definitely found it to be top-heavy.
The "Black Album". Good metal, but Master of Puppets is better. This was the age where James Hedfield adds a "yugh!" to the end of the last word at every sentence.
From thrash metal to trash metal, am I right? Call them sellouts if you want but it's undeniable that this cemented Metallica as bona fide rock stars with catchy singles fit for radio play. Shoutout to Biffy Clyro for having the best cover (Holier than Thou) on the tribute album.
I'm not a Metallica fan so my opinion is moot in these matters, but this isn't a classic for me the way it is for so many others. It's clear that this is their effort to hit the mainstream; and it worked! Good on them, but I almost cringe at the sound of James' aggressive vocals over some of the softest music I've ever heard. That said, the songwriting is solid on a lot of these songs -- not many metal albums have as high a hit ratio as this tracklist does -- and the production from Canadian legend Bob Rock sounds pretty good for the most part. The string sections on certain songs really add to their instrumentation too. But the whole affair goes on a little long for my tastes. This is probably a 3.5 for me, but in the absence of half stars, I'm going to lower it to a 3, because Metallica are sorta uncool sellouts.
4.5 Almost perfect. The last few songs are kind of lackluster in comparison to the rest.
It’s just such a redneck/all American music is extremely boring in its pretentious shallowness. It portrays the classic American feel of power which the rest of the world found irritating once, and laughable now. Music for Bible Belt angry teenagers with zero culture
Alles aan dit album is een 5/5 ook de start van het unforgiven drieluik, prachtig. Ze brengen metal naar de gewone luisteraar
Ja hallloooow beste self titled album? ik denk van wel. de bangers zijn ook wel de banger der bangers op aarde. Nothing else matters wow dat is toch soms met traantjes hoor. All time classic bruur wat een stem.
Bwah
p676. 1991. 1.5 stars. Lumpy, plodding Spinal Tap for the 90s, but with an irony bypass. Definitive proof that one classic song does not make an essential album. Bonus point for Enter Sandman.
I was born a year AFTER this came out and I'm probably the furthest thing you can get from a metalhead or aficionado but there's no getting around the fact that Metallica's eponymous effort absolutely fucks. I had only ever heard Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters off this record before and was pleasantly surprised by how not-bored I was by the rest of the tracks. I think what impresses me about Metallica is that they aren't so far down the thrash rabbit hole that they haven't lost sight of the importance of dynamics - some later groups just sound like a wall of noise to me. Here though the gentler moments (like in Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters) make the harder moments stand out even more clearly. Thought it was really interesting that Metallica's current top three listener cities are all in Central and South America! Through the Never was a cool track.
As a yankee fan I will always have fond memories of Mariano Rivera walking to the mound with Enter Sandman playing. Plus it’s a great song. The rest of this album, especially the second half, does not live up to it. So many of the songs sounded identical and the lyrics were trying too hard imo. Not much interest in hearing this again front to back.
Whether or not we call this heavy metal, thrash metal or just heavy music, this changed the landscape when it was released in 1991 (and I am not just referring to Mariano Rivera). The releases up to that point was a not mere metal - there were hints of punk, hard rock, prog, blues and classical. This was, however, their attempt at mainstream success abd ob that level it was wildly successful. If I was to choose one Metallica release, it would be ...And Justice For All. There are parts of Metallica that are uneven, but there is no denying the power.
Dark and dense. The drums and guitars are excellent but like most metal the lyrics aren’t as good. I like this but listening straight through made me want it to be shorter.
This was well done by just not my personal preference. It certainly deserves a place on the list. Kirk hammet is a beast.
Classic. 5/5
Metalheading with classics
I have just listened to Wet Leg and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs. Metallica they are not. Contrary to what that sentence might imply, I mean that as a compliment to the two former bands. This is the exact opposite of the Beatles' 'White Album': Metallica's 'Black Album' is the opposite colour, and is also the opposite of excellent. My father loves Metallica. I hated the band with a (very childish, I might add) burning passion in my childhood and I have very little interest in wasting sixty-two(!) minutes that I shall never get back. 'Enter Sandman' is one of the worst songs I have ever heard. Heavy metal, to be frank, is not a great genre: I struggle to comprehend how there seem to be so many metal albums on this list (a lot of which have received critical acclaim, to be fair) yet only one metal album has ever been nominated for the Mercury Prize in its thirty-year history. Why does it have to be turned up ever so loud -- is it to disguise the fairly mediocre instrument playing and average vocals? I'll gladly take classical music over this any day, given that it is played with... well, class. Who on Earth decided that Metallica get four albums on this list when neither Louis Armstrong or Édith Piaf have a single one? Eric Clapton and Radiohead (Radiohead!) also have four. Metallica are not on par with these greats. At least remove some of their albums and make way for something much better, like '13' by Blur or Rina Sawayama's début. That said, this album appears to have had a wide influence, which is a criterion important as to whether it should be in the top 1001 most important albums. 'Most important' is definitely different to 'best'. I do have friends who are big fans of Metallica and metal in general. 'Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness' is an amazing album (yet, I mostly listen to the art rock pieces on it). If metal is what you like, then listen to it, enjoy it and don't let me, a random Internet album-listener, spoil your fun! While it is personally not to my taste, I can appreciate that there have to be some positives. And, out of respect to my father, I may give this a 2. Or not (to be honest, I did not give it a listen). Maybe another day. I have the whole summer to waste those aforementioned sixty-two minutes.
50% of this album is phenomenal, shame the quality dips down for the rest. 3.5 stars.
5* for production & mix
A classic
First listen. I prefer thrash Metallica to this. Beyond bored with the five singles I've heard ad nauseum the past 30 years. Still, I can't deny this is a good album. "Through the Never" was great - I'll be adding it to a playlist for sure.
A classic really.
Very good. Rating: 4.0
a huevo! Amo!
Well I have my own reasons for disliking the band, it's hard to deny that this album very much shaped the way that metal would be created in the early 2000s. This is especially true when you look at bands like Avenged Sevenfold
too metal for my taste
Not a big metalhead, but greatly enjoyed this album.
I can't seem to appreciate heavy metal music.
Love the band. Love the album. Lars sucks.
One of those albums that it feels like 1 long song and I don't know how I feel about that
Enter Sandman is one of those songs you don't seek out but can't help but bop along to. Nothing Else Matters is a total slog for. And the rest? I guess Nothing Else Matters. Sounds good for 91
Three big radio hits: Enter Sandman and The Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters.
Not a regular listen for me. But, still a very strong album.
No thoughts
Gatekeeping metal is a virtue as old as time, and discussions of Metallica selling out already began with 'Fade To Black' from Ride the Lightning. In any case, Metallica definitely did not sell out with The Black Album. Instead they smashed through all fictional doors in the music industry, and every single metal act in the last 30 years owe them for this achievement. And yes, perhaps we could agree to a 10 year break on playing 'Enter Sandman' and 'Nothing Else Matters' - who knows, perhaps even they can become listenable again at some point?
Metallica might just be the quintessential “12-years-old-and-discovering-metal”-album. It’s been a while since I heard it. It’s still heavy, it’s dense, it’s filled to the brim with classics. It’s Metallica quitting their faster, thrashier and more complex sides in order to finally emerge as the biggest metal band ever. And overplayed, as some songs on this album are, this is a landmark album.
For my taste, I just can't get into how angry this album gets although I am a fan of the slower songs. Standouts include Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven, and Nothing Else Matters.
Actual MASSIVE album from a band that played a MASSIVE part in my childhood. lets get it. ..SAD BUT TRUUUAAAHH the melody in ''unforgiven'' sounds like 311 if you really concentrate. (listen #3) im finding myself like waiting for it to be over, i did not expect this reaction. "follow the god that failed" is so edgy like boy im really bout to get you lol this album was sadly disappointing
Metallica
Pretty good metal on offer here.
YES. This album gets me so pumped!! I didn’t even realize how many bangers were on this album!! Listen again: yes Purchase for my collection: for sure Favourite Song: Wherever I May Roam
Has moments of life, but overall drags
Dynamically snore inducing. But the riffs are often great, and it's delivered with conviction
An hour and two minutes of perfection.
Band of my youth, I've been to quite a few concert of Metallica in my life, awesome experience. I'm not a fan anymore, but I still appreciate some of the older albums, like Ride The Lightning, or ...And Justice For All. It's a bit more complicated story with Black Album though. As a young metalhead I was full of clichés, so automatically I assumed Black Album was the worst record by Metallica up to date. It was more in soft metal genre then their usual thrash, and suddenly they became more popular, which is unacceptable for a fake metal purist. This approach changed with time - I still don't think of it as the greatest album, but I almost equally like every song on it. Only exception would be Enter Sandman, because I find the main riff very frustrating for some reason. Nevertheless, very good album, which opened the metal genre to the wider audience.
Ah memories
My first time playing through a Metallica album. Man this album goes hard. Felt so raw grungy and powerful. Love the use of eastern spounds, and even some cowboy sounding sounds on some tracks. I'm a fan now.
I wanted to dive into this album, but 3 tracks in, all I was able to get out of it was, "yup, that's metallica". I think I don't have the background in metal to appreciate the nuance here, or maybe it's just a vibe-based album that doesn't click with me.
Far from their great records in the 80s, bloated and uninspired songwriting and compositions.
I love this album so much.It’s so good.The front end is so stacked.Enter Sandman.Sad but true.The unforgiven.Holier than thou.Wherever I may roam.Nothing else matters.All some of the greatest metal songs ever written in my opinion.Sure the Album Starts to slow down at the end After of Wolf and man but it’s still better than almost 99% of albums.No wonder it sold so well.Kirk Hammet’s Solos are Great the Riffs are great Lars’ drumming is tight it’s all so cohesive.
Haven't listened to this for years and I was expecting to be all snooty that it's their sellout album etc etc but this just slams.
It was an amazing experience it was very amazing. I was amazed at how it sounded and was very intricate.
Near fantastic album, however when I first listened around a month ago I thought it was just average, so I’d need to qualify it by giving it a 4. Really more like a 3.75 tho.
It’s a classic for a reason! Though I did find it a bit repetitive sonically.
Brutal guitar riffs and big booming vocals. Just an absolute fucking genre definer.
The most boring metal in the world. Nothing Else Matters and Enter Sandman are undeniable classics. The rest, not so much. And I just can't stand picturing the people listening to this, and REALLY liking it. I don't exactly know why, but listening to this album feels like carrying a skateboard by the trucks. You think you're cool, but everyone with the same interest looks at you with disgust. 3 Metallica might be the most overrated band of all time. Master of Puppets is good though. 2
My brother had shit taste in music most of the time. But he owned this cassette and played it a lot in his Jeep. Which was super cool. And while it's not my favorite metal album, it was one of my first. And the riffs are still have melting.
7/10
Truly a masterpiece!
Not sure if this is really metal since Metallica had evolved so much by this point. But it’s heavy and melodic and I have time for it when it comes up in my suggestions.
Rating: 8/10 Best songs: Enter sadman, Sad but true, The unforgiven, Nothing else matters, The god that failed
According to my records, it's 13 years since I last listened to this all the way through. Let's go! #32 all time artist listens
Like listening to a pubescent boy trying to fuck a brown crayon.
Last good album
Herrje. Bis auf die offensichtlichen Knüller gar nicht mal so gut gealtert. Gerade so drei Sterne, aber wirklich gerade so.
I like Enter Sandman. Listening to the album through though, it all starts to sound a bit samey to me.
This was Metallica’s “comeback” album. They traded in their thrash style for a more slower, heavier style. It was no coincidence that they had to stay relevant with the grunge movement that was exploding at the time. This was probably their last good album.
Les libertariens on souffle
j'ai écouté de loin
A masterpiece. Probably their best album (although my brother in law disagrees) and definitely their most successful. Pretty much every track is a classic, but even the lesser heard songs kick ass.
Дико захейтили альбик...ну кнч не сравнится с тремя первыми, да че мелочиться...со всей дискографией группы (даже гараж инк с каверами лучше сука). Каждый хоть раз играл хоть одну песню отсуда на батиной гитаре. 7/10 продались чуток...
26/04/23. Suena bien, pero me aburrió un poco
yeah good
goofy. a light 3 stars
I didn't hate this as much as I thought I would. In fact I some of the songs are kind of catchy. What I don't like is that it's like chugging a can of testosterone, the vocals, the guitars, the drums, everything is just so aggressive. I first heard this, probably when I was 12, and I didn't like it, I thought it was frightening. I am no longer scared by it, and I like it slightly more than I did back then, but I will not be putting this on voluntarily.
Peak Metallica.
"The Black Album" is pretty widely loved by fans as well as influential on many heavy metal bands. In terms of music... it's alright. It's a bit straight forward and and kind of too clean for my tastes, but none of it is "bad". It's kind of like a persons best intro to metal, and they can get into this... then move on to other stuff. I guess Metallica never quite gelled with me a ton except in middle school.
This was actually really decent, some absolute bangers!
BL: I listened to Metallica a little bit whilst I was in my metal head phase when I was 13-15, however I quickly used them as a stepping stone into deeper cuts and more hardcore things which i thought were cooler. Aware of maybe 2/3rds of the tracks on this album. Will be interested to see what I find it like now I don’t listen to too much metal. AL: I enjoyed it a lot. “Enter Sandman” is overrated but “nothing else matters” is still a gem to this day. A lot of cool stuff and a thoroughly enjoyed listen through. FT: “The Unforgiven”, “Nothing Else Matters”, “The God That Failed” 4/5
it was fine. Can definitely see why people love them, but was the first album we established a #dnf tag
Faktisk gode greier
Wow
Anybody who has listened to the radio in the past 30 years has heard a majority of these songs already. I don't dislike Metallica at all, however I don't really consider myself a fan either. Despite their legendary status, that still doesn't sway my opinion of their music. I've enjoyed these songs throughout the years, but due to hearing them so much, I just don't care to hear them anymore.
It has great sound and some huge bangers, but it’s overstated by about half an hour. Was gonna give it four stars but fuck those “don’t tread on me” assholes
5/5 I didn't expect to *LOVE* this album. Of course, I had heard the hits and loved them. I had never sat down and listened to the whole things front to back. It has levels, moods, and it's a vibe. The melodies are actually really beautiful and I don't think they cursed a single time (in this album) but yet they are badass and hard. James Hetfield voice goes from nice to gritty and screamy showing range and, (or Kirk Hammett) and Jason Newsted shred in a way that isn't too widely and self absorbed. Was surprised to find out that it was from 1991. For some reason, I thought it was much older and withstood the test of time. I think it has so far and will.
This isn't a short album but it never seemed to drag on to a point it annoyed me. The peak for me is unfortunately the opening track and so it all went downhill from there but it never lost it's power and momentum which was nice. I'll possibly revisit this one if I need something to chug along to.
What a great song to start an album with. I never really listened to a Metallica album before, but I'm glad I did.
hearing it immediately after Back in Black by ACDC, it is unfair to compare - the drumming and seething power is different here... angrier and more snarl (which make the AC DC boys seem sinpler, happy and loud). not that darkness is needed in rock - its raw power it taps into. but here there is also a somehow subtler finesse that is more easily heard - details that endure scrutiny. Shit guys, I need to say its Ornate, and what they are doing is "on show". a performance of power, almost POSING, no illusion of spontaneous animal rock here. ?. maybe that is part of the magic of AC DC, it works and you don't question why. (whereas if we call this virtuoso stuff more "American" - well it is from the first track, it's telling you why it's special - the slapping/tapping timbre and thunder drums is really attention grabbing... then the restraint and musical "The Unforgiven" shows their control in a way that juts spoves their skill but also everything I just said (even if the cutover form intro int hat song is harsh IMO). I Like it, I admire it, but I find myself feeling it's much more "commercial" and pristine as heavy rock goes. The skill and talent of the musician's is beyond question. showpiece stuff. But what is missing? relatability? is all this showing off putting distance between artist and audience?. and yes, too much twiddling on the guitar at times, and what that up-tick and "ah" at the end of words. over-laboured? yes to me it is Ornate heavy rock, at times it even operatic "wherever I may roam" was tiresome for me. I guess this is what 1001 albums and thinking about music does - I sound like a record shop tosser now. who cares. no one is ready, ha! Nonetheless the first song from the album is all class. 4.5 stars... marked down because it's a bit much, despite great musicianship.
I struggle with the seriousness and portentousness of this type of pop music. The most cringeworthy element is when they do a "ballad" like The Unforgiven. It's all so "heavy", so serious in its intent as to be laughable. So when they er er er the guitars at least you get that this "metal" music has a kind of purpose which is to be loud and aggressive, and that's it. But here's the thing, it's completely one dimensional, there is no variation on the theme other than the portentous slow ones. Ok, so having said that Sandman is the apotheosis of this type of pop music, all the elements that have some appeal come together and it works. I remember at one point Channel 9 used it as the theme for State of Origin, it was perfect. My other point goes to the rhythm sections of this type of pop music. With the roots of rock and roll being black music, a good rocking band needs a great rhythm section, it's what moves us emotionally and makes the connection to the feel of the thing, in any of the genres. Take AC/DC, Phil Rudd swings and both the Mark bass players hold down those 16th notes in lock step with Phil, it's what makes the groove over which Angus and Malcolm do their thing. With Metallica there is no bass player period and Lars is an awful awful drummer, I have no sense of what it is he thinks he is doing, it is completely fucked and makes for an especially jarring listening experience. This process is really challenging, having to listen to so much awful music, interspersed with the occasional great record.
I was one of those “Black Album converts”, and to this day this album remains for me a benchmark for heavy metal. Such a huge sound, so many awesome riffs, actual melodies with intelligible (and mostly tolerable) lyrics, and most importantly for this genre - makes me move! There are a couple of tracks that I sometimes skip over if I’m not in the mood, so 4.5 stars, but this time I’m rounding up.
I loved Enter Sandman. Do not know the rest of this album & what with Easter & all, & having once watched that doco where this lot took themselves so seriously it made me double-upwith laughter, I have no time or desire to listen to it now. Two stars.
Metallica's Black Album is metal for people who don't really like metal. It' loud, sure, with big catchy riffs and lots of angry yelling, but I find it hard to really ascertain what I think about it. Bob Rock (still unforgiven by many old school Metallica fans) helped the band slow down, simplify, increase the melodic content , turn up the bass and embiggen the sound to polish a commercial monster that sold a bajillion copies and turned Metallica into one of the biggest bands in the world. What I still don't understand is where the band (and record label) got the idea that a thrash band could become a blockbuster mainstream success. And yet they did, invested a year and million dollars in this perfectly honed unit-shifter., And shift units it did! In some ways, this fits into the same cultural space as AC/DCs Back in Black; it's a highly polished hard rock album from veteran road warriors, that sells to the point of ubiquity. But it lacks the humour and cheeky charm, and most of all, the swing of AC/DC. Paying out on Lars Ulrich is a cliché these days, but I swear I can hear him counting the beat while he plays. The slower, simpler beats highlight his limitations (no swing), and this is rare example of a hugely successful band that doesn't have a great drummer. There's nothing wrong with having a drummer with limitations (see Mo Tucker or Meg White) if it adds to the musicality of the band. You have to wonder what how much better this record could sound like with a great drummer. AC/DC are a good comparison, as they are also working in the simple, hard rock genre, but they play with swing. The songs are catchy (especially the singles), though I find the length exhausting. I own a copy of this album, but honestly never play it. It's an important album, as probably the biggest unapologetically and unambiguously metal album to sell this many copies. But it is overplayed and over-polished for me to the point where I am a little sick of it, although I can admire the achievement,. I begrudgingly give three stars for having the ambition to turn metal into a mainstream genre, and actually achieving it.. But that means it really is just (louder) pop music. If I want to listen to metal (which I sometimes do), this is not the album I would choose to play.
I didn’t think I liked metal but this was pretty great!
3/5. A solid metal album but a little too long with not much variety throughout. I’d pick about 5 I’d listen to often and the rest not necessary.
Had this when it came out. It's a decent pop-metal album. Mostly amused remembering that a high school friend misheard 'Sad But True' as "Sex Patrol". More likely to listen to Master of Puppets if I'm in a 'Tallica mood tbh.
Outstanding album, start to finish. Love Metallica
The last good album from metal grandmasters has the most radio-friendly songs.
Memorable riffs and some genuine classic rock songs (all five excellent singles) - all well played and bellowed (I like Hetfield’s range). More accessible than earlier Metallica, but still a bit too thrashy overall for my taste across the entire album. A four because the singles are excellent.
Too discordant for me