Reviews (page 9 of 15)
This is a cool freakin album. I didn't always pick up on the lyrical themes but I definitely noticed it at different points in the album. What I did pick up on was the sweeping, full sound from start to finish. It wasn't always the same sound but there was a constant medley of instruments, from the classical and/or orchestral stylings of Suite II and III Overtures and Say You'll Go to the soulful and jazzy stylings of Neon Valley Street and BabopbyeYa to the funky big band stylings of Dance or Die, Locked Inside, Cold War, and Tightrope. She kept changing moods and tempos without sounding out of step. She can both rap and sing...well. I was really impressed. And then there was Come Alive - what a banger. Not the first time on the album she had killer guitar licks or bass lines but it's oh so glorious. I couldn't get enough of it. One knock is the finishing - there are some abrupt switches from song to song even when the sound of one leads into the next. Still, this album was like Michael Jackson meets David Bowie with its high energy and varied styles embedded into a science fiction fantasy. Even a bit of Prince with her different vocal deliveries (for example, Faster vs. Mushrooms and Roses vs. Wondaland vs. BabopbyeYa). I didn't realize artists were still this ambitious and creative.
Interesting album - it's progressive R&B! I'm not a big R&B fan, but I can appreciate the creativity on this album. Plus, there are a lot of tracks with just the kind of weirdness I like (e.g., Make the Bus, Wondaland, Mushrooms & Roses). Really liked Come Alive (especially the crazed singing towards the end). Some nice guitar solos on the album also (e.g., Neon Valley Street). BabopbyeYa provides a dramatic over the top ending. I enjoyed the album more and more each time I listened, which is always a good sign. I'll give it a 4 and would definitely revisit.
actually the first album i'd listen to again and with songs i've saved separately! really liked it for the most part
Couple of good songs, but really just fell flat for me.
Not my thing but I can appreciate the technical goodness about it. Really smooth vocals, catchy enough beats. somewhat the same but I can't say it's anything special.
Crazy diverse album. When I first listened to it I had never heard a Janelle Monáe song before, and I became an instant fan after this. So fucking catchy all over the place while still leaving some quite cool experimentation
I do sometimes miss when Janelle Monae was making these insanely intricate, operatic albums - some of the compositions are so lush and gorgeous it stops you in your tracks - but these structures were also clearly kind of a gilded cage of Monae's own design, and that feels really evident in the back half of The ArchAndroid.
I am a huge Janelle Monáe stan. I would love to give this album a 5 for that reason alone. However, as a huge Janelle Monáe stan, I have listened to their other albums, and I know two things: 1) as far as robot-themed epics of love and race and revolution go, The Electric Lady is superior and 2) as far as groovy-ass R&B albums that touch on as wide of a thematic and sonic ground go, Dirty Computer remains the best* (*read: my favorite) album of the 2010s. That being said, this album remains ambitious in scope, silly at times in execution (on purpose), and with some all time bangers left over - if you've never gotten chills from watching the "Cold War" music video, well, I'm assuming you've never logged on to YouTube before. This laid the groundwork for Monáe's best work, but wow, what a foundation.
Det är något med det här som är väldigt tilltagande. Gillar att det är sån skillnad på låtarna och brett spektra på genrer. Det är väl långt men på något sätt så håller det. Väldigt coolt album
Unique and enjoyable. I have come to appreciate albums like this. They take one out of their comfort zone and show you something different. After listening you are forever changed for the better. Gaining a broader and deeper meaning of what music really is.
A sci-fi concept album focusing on civil rights and discrimination through many genres while referencing things like Blade Runner, Terminator and especially Metropolis. It's geeky but also very heartfelt and fun, with a lot of passion put into the album. Previously I have listened to their album The Electric Lady and was happy to listen to another album of theirs!!
I couldn't really get into this too far removed from what I like and too eclectic to get settled
Love these concept albums. Pretty awesome melding of different genres and styles, there's ups and downs, and it's all a little psychedelic which I like.
Starts off decent but it’s just too long. I assume the concept is great but didn’t hold me and the singles I was very indifferent too. The songs I liked I did enjoy though 3/5 could of been so much better
This isn't my style of music, but I didn't hate it.
This was worth a listen. For an early career album this is excellent. Nice range of styles.
I wasn’t expecting to like this and I loved it… except for the few weird bits
Wow, I really loved this album. Definitely one of the best albums that's been new to me. I especially loved Faster.
This is a nearly perfect album shimmering with genre bending energy and so much soul. There's talent all over here and amazingly focused collaborators with the sole exception of "Of Montreal" who rarely lands for me. I'm going to give it 5/5 though as even that can't knock the momentum loose on this album. If Monae were to pitch the idea for this album to a room of industry insiders, who would say this is a good idea? This is a contemporary pop album that is a mishmash of throwback psychedelic soul featuring a woman who is styled after even further back throwback styles such as Metropolis-esque 1920's deco. It's clear that nobody really knew how to "sell" this album but fortunately Monae is a powerhouse in her own right while inspiring the belief in some other powerful friends. Good times.
Very different and interesting! I feel like of the albums I've listened to so far, this is probably the most technically beautiful album I've heard.
Really fun, boundary-pushing pop music highlighted by Janelle's vocals and excellent composition. I think some fat could definitely be trimmed, (especially the track with Of Montreal), but the highlights really stand out for me. 8/10
Truly on another level, one of the strongest albums ever! I've heard this a million times and it still sounds amazing, in the production, her vocals, and the sheer variety of genres explored. I love this album, one of the best to ever do it!! 5
I hadn't heard any of it before. Some good songs in there
не очень понимаю, как это тут оказалось, просто не самая лучшая попса
It has a wide range and i really enjoyed it a lot! Songs went smooth and I enjoyed the first listen a lot! (3.5/5.0)
This is not my genre of music but I can really appreciate the breadth in what Janelle has done an amazing job at creating many unique and distinct sounding songs in this album. Do I like the songs? Eh, not so much, but I do appreciate them. I did like Come Alive (War of the Roses) a decent amount. 3/5 stars.
Really good ... There are some very good, deep songs on here, tons of great beats, and a couple that were a little too pop for me.
This is really irritating
Excelent album, I love Tightrope
Never heard of her before, but rather enjoyed the album.
Loved this, she’s just amazing.
Mediocre, middle-of-the-road dance- and R&B-flavored pop, with boring, nonsensical lyrics. I have no general problem with nonsensical lyrics, mind you, but I have a problem with someone pretending to be all deep and futuristic for the sake of marketing, but ultimately saying nothing.
Sounds like Disney channel music
Listened to about 4 songs. Pretty good.
So much diversity on this album that it’s hard to find a throughline. It opens with a great rap piece (Dance or Die) and migrates through some really smart R&B (Locked Inside), though it’s hidden under a too standard pop melody and production. Then we’re on to what might be a Bond theme (Sir Greendown) + some very proper-sounding British torch songs (Oh, maker). Symphonic pieces are mixed in with tunes that give Pharrel (Tightrope) & Outkast a run for the money. Definitely hear some of Bowie’s influence, which is well applied. It’s a lot. But, Monáe is so talented, her delivery is so energetic, and the production is generally so interesting, that it makes me want to stick with it and understand what she’s up to. It’s a high 3, verging on a 4 — but I might come back to this and raise the score.
Great Production and Concept
Very interesting concept. Wasn’t expecting the intro to lead into such an energetic trip. Enjoyed it. Didn’t resonate with it as well as some people appear to have, I guess it’s slightly out of my usual style. It’s fun to spot all the different and eclectic styles/genres throughout. Make The Bus was like an R&B, psychedelic Bowie track. I liked Neon Valley Street. Can’t imagine listening to it by choice, but if it was on I could listen happily.
It was extremely pleasant, I loved the production on it but there isn’t a moment that I can point to where I said that it really enjoying this. Overall, I would say that this album is a tad unfocused and didn’t really major in anything.
Catchy, groovy tunes, gives me modern Michael Jackson vibes - Voice and instrumentals are diverse and standouts, they are clean yet have the old-school R&B feel - Not much to complain about, but did not blow me away
This was fresh and quite unique sounding to me. She seemed to incorporate several different genres/sounds but kept it all quite cohesive which made for a pleasant listening experience. 3.5 stars but I'm feeling generous so rounding up. Blend.
Thoroughly enjoyed this! I haven’t listened to much Janelle Monáe previously but not sure why - will be adding to my playlists
Fun album, started stronger then fizzled
Year 12 drama production ah music - would give points for effort but feel like I've heard this kind of music done much better
Couple interesting ones but a lot of missed opportunities. Feel like cold war was so close to being a great song
Big fan of this album! From start to finish - cool sounding songs, great vocals. Overall, great album, that I will 100% listen to again.
Pretty dang cool and I didn’t know it existed.
She's really good - the album conceptually is interesting and I appreciate the variety of styles here. And an Of Montreal feature! Cool
This was pretty cool, lots of different interesting music. Listens almost like a musical soundtrack
Damn, what an excellent package this album is! Making your debut studio album a concept album feels like a risky move, but Janelle and company pulled it off rather flawlessly. There are so many different genres across this thing which helps keep things feeling fresh, and the instrumentation is crisp and tight - and Janelle herself brings her A game on vocals. The collabs with Big Boi and of Montreal also deserve a shoutout; both very nice additions.
Pop, dance, 2010 -> 2-3
The ArchAndroid is a case of good ideas with mixed execution. There was mostly the idea of combining a couple of music genres with a pop touch like R&B, Opera, and even somewhat of a metal influence in Come Alive. Most of the time, these ideas worked pretty well with the songs being catchy and Monae generally having a similar energy to a lot of the R&B artists from the 60s and 70s. But other times, the songs could either be boring, annoying or (in a rare case) both. I guess this is somewhat expected of an album that is over an hour long but it still remains an issue for me. All in all, The thing i can say about this album is that there is good and there is bad. Best Song: Tightrope Worst Song: Mushrooms & Roses
amazing album, tons of variety and great musicians. The vocals are awesome and the vision is intriguing.
Sick almost did a double
Album is interested in sound, and songs are thought out in relation to each other. I love the classical influences. Sometimes has a musical theatre feel. However, I think its core, most common soundscape is one that doesn't resonate with me. I don't know how to define it, I think there's a reference I'm missing. There are so many amazing sound moments though. They just don't often build to be consistently amazing songs. Best tunes: the overtures, sir greendown, tightrope, neon gumbo, mushrooms & roses, wondaland
Odd and a hard listen. "Dance Or Die" and "Wondaland" were likeable. I was looking for the Metropolis and futuristic buzz...sort of there. This effort could have benefited from editing. A sauna with gummies listen? Snuff out!
Random mix of genres and random features but quite unique and flows well in some parts, others not as much but overall was a solid 6/10
luv u Janelle Monáe art deco cyborg pop album
Never heard of it before today but I did enjoy it.
9/10 banger
I've listened to enough Afro/Soul-Funk to know that I can only really enjoy about 25 minutes of it. But I can see both the inspiration and the novelty of this album. But Suite II Overture was my favorite part and it was obviously the only non-pop-funk song on the album lol
Bra album, kräver vidare lyssning men många bra låtar
Really enjoyed Dirty Computer (Make Me Feel is one of the best songs Prince never wrote), remember seeing this record in the end of year lists years earlier and being intrigued by the Fritz Lang aping cover. Didn't get around to it though. I know enough to know she is an extremely interesting artist. So here we go. Oh man, I love how this never lets up. No break between songs. Going to take time to digest however. Pop can pop and be accessible while staying interesting. Plenty weirdness here however although curiously most songs aren't standing out to me despite all being different. The Of Montreal song sounds like all Of Montreal songs, ie, mental, catchy, but never sticking to the same melodic rhythm for more than about 15 seconds. Which is distinctive, to say nothing else. This record is for sure a little too long. Dirty Computer is most definitely more accessible than this. Gonna rate it highly though.
Great album with loads of different styles and genres. It's pretty epic in length and scope but I didn't get bored during it as it's always bringing something new in from song to song. She is cool AF too which helps.
Not for me
Satte 4 först. Insåg efter några dagar att de mina två första album (Monaé och Vaughan) var solklara 5:or i jämförelse m övriga album.
Interesting concept for an album. I got tired of her voice after a while, though. Still, it was a cool experience but, I don’t think I’ll be listening to this again.
there is, Pawsibly, a slight wonkiness to the cluster of breathlessly propulsive tracks near the front and slower more soaky tracks near the back, but thats something to see if its smoothed out on future listens i think. otherwise, maybe literally perfect HFJFSHJFS its a crime its been so long since i listened to this...perfectly produced, perfectly performed, feels enduringly like one of the biggest records ever made yet remains entirely distinguishable and cohesive, finds its stunning afrofuturist class warfare aesthetic thruline between the base elements of all the different styles in the pot here and builds some of the craziest shit ive ever heard on that baseline. i never heard their other (increasingly divisive) records but i think i trust the vision here more than i trust the taste of music nerds. amazing, placetaking, placemaking, placeremaking music
This was not some Beyoncé sound a like crap album. Janelle is a really talented singer. The music has some cool jazz / R&B elements to it. Thought I would hate it. It wasn’t bad at all 1001 album worthy: Yes - 29/49
A fun and refreshing album that’s on this list. I really really like this and enjoyed it!
I remember there being a lot of critical discourse in the late 2010s that genre was dead. The existence of this album proves that such discourse was at least several years too late.
Andi from Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery?? I’ve never heard of this album but what a strong start to this project. Psychedelic space funk. Also, I totally forgot about Of Montreal, what a throwback.
Claire de Lune inverted the way it was was an absolutely brilliant choice
Ehh
What an album. I had a grand time listening to it a few times. 57821 and Cold War were some of my favorites.
Many genres at once
pop perfection! i can’t believe there’s an of montreal feature on this thing.
Любимая исполнительница. Хотелось бы, чтобы она выпускала больше музыки, но то, что имеется - очень хорошо. Лучшая песня - Cold War.
A fresh take on RnB. I like she is trying new things, even if it doesen't always quite work.
I love when the days album is by an artist I have never heard of so I have no idea what to expect when I start listening. After the first song I went about making breakfast with the album playing in me headphones and suddenly 7 songs had passed and I was really enjoying the music. While its not a style I often listen to myself songs from this album will have their place in several playlists so I can groove along when they come up.
R&B is one of my least favorite genres so I’m not listening to this.
I've always kinda liked Janelle Monae, I've never listened to this album though, pretty excited to check it out. This is pretty cool, reminds me of Lauryn Hall quite a bit. There haven't been a ton of tracks that have stood out in a big way to me, but overall it's been pretty good. I'm pretty impressed with how varied the songs are, quite a few different vibes going on.
Creative style and weave. Mellow enough but this didn’t really knock my socks off…
It’s really hard to cross pollinate genres without sounding forced. And to do it across a single album is even more difficult. That is the biggest strength here. Janelle does a great job interweaving genres that most likely don’t belong together by injecting some modern production and themes as connecting tie-ins throughout. The Fritz Lang Metropolis nod is cool, but outside of a few really good songs, this one is overall just too long and did not rise to the level I expected. Still, very impressive for someone in their mid 20s.
I know of Janelle but honestly didn’t know what to expect here. Admittedly I probably expected something much poppier, for no good reason. I thoroughly enjoyed this, just a really fun album. The wide pool of influences used here is about as varied as Janelle’s talents, just really impressed.
Nice vocals. Interesting variety of songs and styles. I appreciated the guitar solos. Come alive was prob most memorable for me. Make the bus was annoying. A couple songs brought that bass and I liked that. Where the fuck did 57821 come from? Felt so random. That’s a review…BaBopByeYa.
I’m a fan of Janelle Monáe and expected to like this more than I did. Some solid tracks and cool mixing of genre but ultimately didn’t make it to great status IMO. I suspect we may see more from her on this assuming Dirty Computers shows up. Also shout out to what has to be the best artist page on Apple Music. If you know you know… 3.5/5
Interesting and varied music, even though the lyrics aren't really my thing.
The new age synth electro genre is not my thing. It’s not terrible I’m just not into it.
Few catchy remarks but probably needs to be heard a few times to get into the swing of it.
She's a massive talent, incredible voice and vocal range and a great songwriter..The production is just a bit too slick for me. Not my cup of tea.
This is not my cup of tea. I can't imagine I would ever listen to this.
Wonderfully eclectic
This was a fantastic surprise. I'm starting to think I just like R&B a lot. this is such a black girl confidence bop!
Catchy Sound, interesting mix of genres
Wow, that was an actually great album! For some reason I expected a classic, modern rap album, which I'm not so fond of, but instead I listened to a really catchy, Childish Gambino-like r'n'b record. I actually never even knew that Janelle Monae was a singer before she started her acting career, so this album was full of surprises. I basically liked the whole side A of the record, which happens only with great releases. Great style, very enjoyable singing/rapping by Janelle, honestly great music. Something more modern to have in my vinyl collection.
An interesting album with so many influences. A couple of standout tracks but the majority of tracks couldn't stick in my memory.
Impressive and varied debut album. Ends up a bit of a mixed bag but still a nice listen
dead
I like the beginning of the album more than the end of it
Overall: 8/10 I really appreciate the genre-blending Monae does on this album. It's still a pop album at the end of the day but she experiments with making danceable bops and beautiful ballads, all with a futuristic angle. Tightrope is also may be the most fun song I've heard while going through this list, I adore it. I could see this getting a perfect rating from me after a few more listens. Fav Song: Tightrope Least Fav Song: Say You'll Go
Uno de los mejores trabajos de R&B contemporáneo. Janelle Monáe nos lleva a través de un recorrido sonoro hipnotizante, mostrando todas sus capacidades creativas con pistas de diferentes tintes, un poco Rock n' Roll, un poco electrónica y un poco de ambos. Recomendado, pero no sé si imprescindible.
Interesting ! Idk what to think… I can’t see the Metrópolis influence. But i really liked the third part more than the other two. 3 stars for me, good album, not essential
Dirty computer is her best album.
This one has some high highs. It felt like a Prince album in the way it seamlessly flowed through and flirted with different genres. It would’ve been so much better if the record had been trimmed down. Definitely saving a lot of the songs.
Wow. This is quite good. The first few songs are actually amazing. The vibe changes in the back half , a little more laid back for my liking but still good. This was a nice surprise as I did not know what to expect.
Very varied. Not all of it good.
A real mixed bag for me. Some absolute bops and then some songs that just... I guess that just aren't for me? Wouldn't listen to the whole thing again.
Fuck yeah. I slowly discovered over the last decade. I heard Tightrope and Dance or Die and loved those tracks. Eventually I listened all the way through and was shocked by the variety of styles here and Monae’s commitment to each. Add the overall concept of the album, and it’s really a cool piece of work!
Film music-ish. Very nice
“Refreshing” not a cookie cutter album, but infuses sounds to make something new.
I don't really know what to make of this but I think I liked it?
Some good tracks on this, but a long album
i am pleasantly surprised by this album! it definitely helped to listen to it knowing it was a concept album and had a movie/story to it. janelle’s voice is absolutely incredible! “come alive (war of roses)” is def an example of that. great song. 3.8/5
Enjoyable album, but not particularly remarkable IMO.
A true magical banger that set up Janelle as a superstar.
She's writing modern pop music that's on such a higher level than the pop music that gets played on the radio. A radio edit of "Tightrope" should have been a big hit, regardless. I'd never heard this album before. Such a wealth of ideas. Sometimes too many elements are packed into a single song that it's overwhelming. From a purely sonic/visceral standpoint this album is sung, played, recorded and produced beautifully and goes all over the map stylistically. There's another layer, lyrically, that relates to a time-travel narrative... it's a complex work of dystopian sci-fi told in lyrics. Not something anyone can digest in one listening, but holy cow! ...a little like walking in on friend's "hobby" where they had told you they "like trains", but their entire garage is transformed into a miniature city and countryside with a working network of trains/tracks, miniature homes and buildings with lights inside, farm animals... details everywhere that you can't take in on one visit and you're amazed but worry a little about your friend's sanity. If anyone actually reads this before listening to this album, check this out: "The ArchAndroid is a concept album that continues the story conceived in her debut EP. Partially based off of Fritz Lang’s 1927 magnum opus film Metropolis, it loosely tells the tale of an android named Cindi Mayweather as she struggles with both her role as a messianic figure to free other androids, and with her forbidden romance with human Anthony Greendown. Watching Metropolis or fully studying the narrative will only strengthen your listening experience, though it isn’t necessary." [Medium]
3.5
yasss
I didn't know she was a musician but this album is as good as Glass Onion (the movie).
Probably not a bad album if you like the style. However, it is not for me personally. Can't say I would recommend it to a friend.
Great
Sci Fi RnB? Had no idea what I was missing.
A bit hectic and overproduced for my taste but has very good tracks. Cold War is incredible, for example.
I dont like pop of mostly any kind. Good voice sounded better than usual pop crap but still not to my liking
Not my thing, but major props for having a unique vision and trying something different. Too long by half.
Great flow from Suite II Overture to Locked Inside. This album has a lot of great songs, but some songs are a bit weird. The weirdest one was Neon Gumbo, but at least that one is short. There's 7 stand-out songs. Hard to pick a favourite.
Definitely not for me. I just don’t get it.
I had high hopes for this one but it was just ok? No stand out tracks that I would revisit and I’m not sure I would want to listen to this in its entirety again. Very talented though and I do like how ambitious of a debut album this is. It just isn’t for me.
This album art was super familiar for me but I can't remember when/why I listened to this before. This is some really great soul/R&B/pop music. It's unique and layered and so much better than any straight pop album these days.
Es ist ein Album, das zweifellos viele beeindruckende Momente bietet mit einer Mischung aus verschiedenen Genres und Stilen ist, die manchmal überwältigend sein kann. Die Highlights des Albums sind sicherlich die kraftvollen Tracks wie “Tightrope” und “Cold War”, die Monáe’s außergewöhnliches Talent und ihre kreative Vision zeigen. Diese Songs sind energiegeladen und fesselnd, und sie heben sich deutlich hervor. Jedoch gibt es auch Schwächen. Die Vielfalt der Stile und die komplexe Struktur des Albums können dazu führen, dass es sich manchmal chaotisch und überladen anfühlt. Die Übergänge zwischen den Songs sind nicht immer nahtlos, was den Hörfluss stört.
eh ok
First five star review I've given to an album I didn't previously know/own. Unique, varied and accessible. Definite listen again. (Three times already).
Fantastic. Simply amazing.
I came to Janelle Monáe late but I really love her last two albums. Very pleased this thing got me to finally go back and listen to her first. I don't think it is quite as good as the ones I know but that could just be that it's hard to take in a 70+ minute concept album in one day.
Not a fan. Was too poppy and bright for me.
Great variety, from R&B feels to pop-rock-esque
It was great just not my kind of music
Cold war och Tightrope är bra men övriga albumet känns inte lika bra som annat jag har hört av henne.
really consistent. so full of character and life. take away Make the Bus and its pretty much perfect
it all sounds pretty derivative to me - trying on a Prince costume, a Stevie Wonder costume ... it lacks a unifying feel.
Such a lot of difference, yet so little of it is good. Are the ableist lyrics really necessary?
First time listen. Big production, quite high concept. Bit better than expected. Faint praise.
There are moments on this album that I enjoy, but I felt like it was too chaotic
absolute MONSTER of an album. she pulls you in with the first half being a stellar pop/funk/electronic/disco album. then slowly we get deeper and deeper musically and stylistically until we reach the final 8 minute orchestral track to bring everything to a climactic end. simply brilliant
Maso
Gewoon goed album maar wel groot contrast tussen eerste 6 a 7 nummers en de rest van het album. Het album begint heel sterk maar verliest gaandeweg steeds meer zijn charme tbh. Niks ten nadele van de artiest verder, misschien ligt het gewoon niet in mijn straatje. Of net niet in de juiste mood om ernaar te luisteren. Een lage ***1/2 afgerond naar beneden.
Superambitieus als debuut en tegelijk zo goed uitgewerkt, heb eigenlijk niet veel klachten erover dus dit is meer een 4.5 omlaag afgerond. Misschien kon het ietsje getrimd worden qua aantal nummers, maar moet het nog een paar keer luisteren om daar beter over te oordelen en dat is het enige nitpicky dat ik kan bedenken, iig.
Top album, did not expect. Ik zie mezelf dit oprecht nog een keer luisteren. Wel op niche momenten, maar still. Good stuff. Favo tracks: Cold war, come alive, wondaland
A lot of this was pretty good, a pretty interesting take on pop music. Janelle Monae felt like the sort of artist you get on Jools Holland a lot, somebody doing a quirky take on a well established genre, and the sort of thing I like well enough at the time but would never seek out. The album was bloated full of nonsense, could have been about half the run time. The shorter, snappier songs were the better ones in general. Not too sure how I feel about it, I think it might warrant another listen as long as I skip the dull bits. Probably a 3.5., closer to a 3 at the moment.
Parts of this were very good and avante garde - very much an 'artist', and other parts were rather tame (Say You'll Go is as bland an R&B-based love song as you can get). Cold War was great, and I knew Tightrope from various adverts. Really clear voice. Production not over-done. Feels like a really strong 3, let down by the inclusion of a few too many boring songs.
Never heard of Janelle before. It was fine as far as pop records go, sounded very well produced. Just not really my thing. Nothing particularly stood out. 2
I recently had the privilege of watching Fritz Lang's Metropolis accompanied by a theater organ performance of the original score, and I can feel a lot of the DNA from both the film and its soundtrack in this album. There's a massive stylistic variety on this album, and it stands utterly unique from most of the music of today. There is a lot about this album that I love- but unfortunately I can't bring myself to love the album itself. The thing that frustrates me is that I cannot pinpoint *why* I feel somewhat apathetic to this album, despite liking so much about it. There are a few tracks I do love, especially "Wondaland" and "BaBopByeYa," but the whole package just doesn't land for me. That said, I am still a fan and hope that I can grow to appreciate Monáe's work more.
I loved some of the bops on the album. Overall, I didn't know she had so many instrumental songs.
I am so impressed by this, what a find. The ambition of it, the breadth of skill and the variety. I love the commitment to such a cool concept. The musicality and production across the whole thing is superb. It's really upbeat for the majority of the album, but there's so many little hidden moments and gems sprinkled throughout, with lots of different moods and themes. I love the variety of instruments, with the cool guitars, the brass, bells, the cinematic sweeps.. I haven't even properly dug into the lyrics yet, but the snippets I've looked at are really interesting. This definitely isn't in my usual wheelhouse, but I'm honestly so impressed by this. She's seriously talented, and I love the huge ambition and skill on display here. That's why I'm going big. What an eye-opener.
Never have I ever listened to Janelle Monae before and I’m glad I finally did! Super weird album, but I’m giving extra credit and rounding up for what felt like a smooth, groovy ride anyway.
Ehh I have it a try not for me I enjoyed 1 catchy song
I had heard Tightrope on the radio or whatever. Quite pop-ish to me but there was some good moments in the album.
really inventive, groovy and quirky . 5
Really fun variety
Die erste Hälfte ist ein Fünfsternealbum
Really fun album. I first heard the song Tightrope on a K-Mart commercial which lead me to finding out who Janelle Monae was.
A striking album that I've been listening to since it came out in 2010. I still return to this record given its eminently listenable with fantastic hooks and themes. It's fatal flaw from being the fullest of my five stars is that the interludes, tempo and vibe shifts means that this record is neither completely a hype/dance record nor is it totally a chill/relax record either. That said I'm certain its in-betweenness is an important part of what makes it continually rewarding and interesting. And yet, without a single mood or vibe to map it onto it can sometimes lose out to more straightforward albums with their one-dimensional tone.
好新的专辑
nicht so meins
Hat mir leider gar nicht zugesagt. Ne tolle Künstlerin und interessantes Wiki, aber die Musik hat mich gestresst und wenig unterhalten. Songs der Playlist hinzugefügt: Keine
This one was a surprise. I'd never heard of it before, but the creativity involved got my interest right from the start.
DNF - what in gods name was this
Sweeping, epic, a stunning achievement. Really incredible
I have a lot of time for Janelle. She has the voice and look to be very straightforward pop superstar. And she sort of is ... but in her own very Janelle Monae way. I've always like ArchAndroid, but not as much as her first foray into the concept. It covers a lot of ground, and it feels a bit too ambitious. But it's it's always interesting and unique.
I love how this album has so much variety and so many interesting sounds. The run of psych songs later in the album was soo good. She is an impressive vocalist and she seems a bit weird which is a big turn on for me. What gives her the right to be gorgeous, talented, and also interesting?
Really fun record! Janelle Monae is really interesting to me, I had heard about this but never commited. It's really cool and varied. She plays with a lot of cool elements of pop, psych, jazz, funk and prog. I love the storytelling and how this album flows from one song to the next telling a story. Its a really fun take on pop music and really pushes the boundaries of what the genre can do.
this MIGHT be a perfect album
Pre-listening thoughts: we’ve been getting a lot of 2010s albums lately and I need that to slow down cause we’ve still got like 980 to go 😭 I can’t burn through all the recent ones right now and just be left with 50s jazz which we’ve gotten almost none of. But anyways love Janelle Monáe but I’ve only ever fully listened to Dirty Computer by her so excited for this! Post/during listening thoughts: I remember playing Tightrope on Just Dance and then later in life being shocked to find out that was Janelle Monáe and that she sings bc I knew her as an actress first. But hello???? This is her debut album?! This is INSANE. Overture already had me gagged. But this is something still so fresh even though it’s from almost 15 years ago. It’s genre bending, and hooks you at every turn with its smooth transitions that somehow manage to twist every uniquely crafted song into each other. Not to mention Janelle’s vocals which have such power but also flit and float effortlessly. The instrumentation is so full and funky and experimental with massive success rates. God I love this. 10/10 DID I NEED TO HEAR THIS BEFORE I DIE: you know what yes Fav tracks: this is a no skip album Least fav tracks:
It was ok.
It didn’t really resonate with me, but it’s definitely a quality album. It has a lot to offer and every track sounds unique and different.
I went into this album completely cold and was delightfully surprised. It's eclectic, weird and expansive, but still very musical and enjoyable (despite mostly falling into genres I don't listen to much). Songs that I'm sure I'd never heard before felt quite familiar, which was bizarre but wonderful. I think I'll re-listen to this a lot.
I wasn’t expecting today’s selection to be an Afrofuturist concept album inspired by Fritz Lang’s Metropolis, but it turns out that it was exactly what I needed this morning. It’s gloriously textured and complex and I’m already listening for the second time. I’m also a sucker for any album that has an orchestral overture! My highlight is the psychedelic Mushrooms & Roses which explores the unexpected subject of robot sex. Droidtastic!
When I saw the cover my first thought was "ugh, an R&B album" (not exactly my favourite genre). I launched the album nonetheless. I rapidely understood my mistake. Comes Cold War, and I'm totally won over. Comes Come Alive, and I know I'll relisten to this. It's very diverse (too diverse?) but it's full of (good) ideas, she's clearly not afraid of exploring uncharted territories and of unholly alliance between genres.
Wacky album cover Stranger profile picture too I had a bunch of notes written but they didn't save :) A really strange blend of styles in one album, very different. I listened to it all once through in the background but had other noises going on. I relistened to it on shuffle and was consistently surprised by the difference between songs. Actually some very funky tracks, I got into a few of them Interesting having the "Suites" II and III combined into a "mega album". Does make it feel longer but its a solid heap of tracks. The inclusion of overtures leading into each suite was interesting as well. Overall I was surprised by my enjoyment of this, I wasn't expecting much to be completely honest. Come Alive (War of the Roses) was very reminicient of Diablo Swing Orchestra (probably because the entire song is swung) I swear I've heard Locked Inside's chorus somewhere else, I just don't know where. Has to be in an edit or reel or something. Same with Faster, no idea. Cold War was a vibe, 16ths on the hats, very groovy. Lots of bell and ride during the choruses, very fun "Oh Maker"'s 1 and 3 drum+bass pattern reminded me a lot of Christmas songs for whatever reason (During the higher section at 2:00 especially), but also of electro swing tracks like Proleter's April Showers Plenty of the songs had interesting, very artsy, motifs and decisions that don't feel very mainstream (Which I'm all for, when its not the entire track). The change of genres throughout the album often caught me offguard Not a great album, but plenty of great songs
Very differant, was hit or miss and felt very disconnected, but the originality and unique songs made some of them a banger. Overall I think its strengths in the songs outweighs the negatives, and I adore some of the songs, low 7 high 6,
Way too damn long and gets progressively worse, but still pretty fun on the whole
Quite an eclectic, soulful and unique record. Oh, Maker and Come Alive were my favourites.
Sounds a lot like ambient store music, or restaurant music, or music that would go in a big box office movie that I don’t want to see. Vocals are beautiful, tonally, some fun guitar riffs in the background but I have no idea of the structure of any of these songs are and I find that I just want to skip to the next song/turn it off. There are a lot of different styles blended in and I think that to me, is very overwhelming.
What a storyteller. *Favorite tracks: Dance or Die Cold War Tightrope Come Alive Neon Valley Street BaBopByeYa
way better than i would have expected
I expected to really dislike this album, but I didn't. However, the best and worst thing I can say is that it just sounds like a lost Outkast album that Monae found and recorded her own way... but I don't think it is as good as "The Love Below," and I'd rather listen to that every time. I might give this a 3.5 stars, because she is trying for something, but it just doesn't hit enough for me or impress me enough to really say I'd add this to my library or listen to again.
This was intriguingly good. I'd never heard of the singer before but the album opening was brilliant. Didn't maintain those heights but overall very enjoyable and something I'll come back to
This is great. So many influences I can hear, from Lauryn Hill to Bowie to Ella Fitzgerald to more modern indie rock. Janelle's amazing voice is the constant. Really enjoyed this one.
This girl has a voice! Fantastic instrumentation. Very inventive production. Fun ride start to finish. Fav Track: Locked Inside
Janelle Monáe has an incredible voice and can switch styles so easily—it’s impressive. You can hear hints of Rihanna, Beyoncé, and Lauryn Hill in her sound, and there’s a lot of R&B influence. But honestly, the style changes felt forced to me. The songs are well-made, but I just didn’t connect with any of them. I appreciate her talent and the effort to do something different, but it just wasn’t for me. 2 out of 5.
She is one of the best singers and the writing is great. This album is actually better than I remember, but it's a lot all the time. This feels like it could easily be 3 albums and not how it's placed on the album. Then the songs themselves are just... To much? Trying a bit too hard? I don't know. The whole album seems busy and it starts to distract from the star, Janelle herself. That being said I remember it being a lot worse when I heard it when it first came out so maybe in 20 years it will sound perfect?
Meh. Not for me.
Too all over the place for me. Previous album was better
This just didn't do it for me.
This was an impressive listen, a mish-mash of different genres and influences from all over the place, but it all somehow comes together and just works.
Unexpected, interesting.
pre: I really like Janelle Monáe but I mostly know her from songs here and there (I have listened to Come Alive approx 1 million times). I like the theatricality of her performance. Looking forward to seeing if a straight-through listen holds up. Not my normal listening but I really enjoyed this, I will listen again
Totally new artist for me so I had no expectations going in. It is certainly not my usual style, but it’s not bad, I really liked Dance or Die & Tightrope. I’m not going to run out and buy the album but I could see those songs ending up on a playlist or something like that.
Nothing here grabbed my attention - I’ll pass
Before listening: I have definitely heard some Janelle Monae but don't really have an opinion beyond that I vaguely optimistic abut the listen. Four songs in: I liked the classical intro and the idea behind the album, the music is sometimes just vaguely poppy soul but with more interesting lyrics. Nine songs in: Yeah still feel pretty good about the album as a whole but really haven't heard a song yet that I think really stands out
Favorite tracks: Locked Inside, Thugga Massina, Mushrooms and Roses. Surprising amount of variety across this record.
It's decent. I'm not mad at this. I can see the influence it has on music I listen to.
Really good. Great vocals and some really fun production choices at times
I really enjoyed this album. Janelle's voice is gorgeous. She has a cool vibe as well. There were 3 songs I could have done without. That's the reason for the 4 stars.
I really don't like this much. It's too strange and not in a good way There was nothing I liked about this album at all, except her voice which is very nice.
A fun and varied album. It’s no Death in Vegas but has some of that feel.
Phineas and Ferb music if they had the budget of seven trillion golden doubloons. Holy shit. I've known of this album's existence for less than 24 hours and I can safely say that this is my favorite R&B album of all time. I didn't even know the girl from Glass Onion was a singer. Uhh five outta five!
Yes. This is a cracker. Full of memorable songs that will get you up and dancing, or nodding in a reflective mood, as the mood befits. She's not a bad actress either you know...
I’m not sure how I feel about this, but I do know that I am tired of popular music, especially hip hop and other stuff along those lines, starting an album with something orchestral or such. Like they’re trying to portray a certain cultured-ness. And then popping them back in later. All while littering the rest of the album with profanity and ugliness. It was interesting once or twice, but I’ve now come across it far too many times for it to be original. Granted, the rest of this album stays away from the gutter, but the played out trope is there. As for the rest of the album, she obviously has a good voice, especially on the songs that didn’t over-auto-tune her, whether intentionally or otherwise. But a lot of it I just got tired of halfway through. I wouldn’t intentionally listen to this again, but might not rush to shut it off either. Still, I feel the only reason it’s on this list of essential listens is to sprinkle something more contemporary, regardless of deserving a spot, because it doesn’t.
This album had me constantly asking what it was. It’s a chameleon with so many different colors. R&B, stadium rock, electronic, pop, etc. Janelle Monae has a great voice. I loved how in the first half of the album, sets of three songs would transition directly into each other. That said, I fell off in the second half of the album because it was on the longer side and had lost its luster. I also don’t think these songs work as singles. That’s not a bad thing, just that it works better as an album. Standouts: Dance or Die, Faster, Locked Inside, Tightrope, Oh, Maker, and 57821.
Klassikko, jolla kovia kappaleita, mutta myös liian taiteellista tavaraa.
Prob one of the strongest 4 stars ive given. I loved it but didnt think it was as good as my other 5s. Maybe itll grow on me some more and then ill prob put it even higher.
Super cool, music great one spng different from the other, high end production. Some songs are really bangers. The last one is my favourite
great songs <3
A bit like yesterday, this probably should be a 3.5. Have seen her a few times and she’s been incredible to watch, but I rarely choose to listen to the records, as good as this one undoubtedly is. Best track - Tightrope
I can't believe how different each track is on this album! It's a fantastic sound, with catchy songs and a consistent musical theme. It's a very eclectic group of songs, spanning so many different genres and transitioning between them so effortlessly. 'Locked Inside' is a funky sounding track. 'Sir Greendown' is more relaxed and psychedelic whereas 'Cold War' starts off and you're wondering where it's going to go, and it ends up being a dance track. 'Tightrope' goes back to funky. These four songs all come in succession! 'Come Alive' is my favourite here. I can only describe it as a kind of rock and roll burlesque sound which really shows off vocal Janelle's vocals. She hits and holds a high note at the end of this track for a good twenty seconds before ending it with a great rock sounding "Ow!" 'Wondaland' is a sweet and sparkly pop song with a catchy chorus and the final one 'BaBopByeYa' sounds almost like a modern James Bond track. This album keeps you guessing what's coming next with everything sounding so different genre wise, yet sounding so similar and fitting together so well.
ty janelle monáe for envisioning and creating beautiful new sonic worlds 🙏
I thought the album flowed really well together. As someone that doesn't pay a ton of attention to which song I'm on in the album, the songs flowed so well that I couldn't really tell when one song ended and another began. Songs were pretty unique and different than what I'm used to, would listen to some more.
Interesting album, definitely unique. None or the songs in particular really stood out to me, but if I could retroactively lower my rankings to put this one above the other ones we've listened to so far, I would.
Loved it. This would be a five except for there was one bit of TERRIBLE rapping that was just obliged back then, and some of the songs were kind of forgettable.
Ok
This was a great listen. Experimental at times, some great pop, some classic influences. Really everything I could ask for in an album, let alone a debut album.
Songs: Cold War
We love a concept album with a cohesive sound and cool vibes. This is the first full Janelle Monáe album I've listened to, but whenever I hear songs by them, even out of context, I'm always pleasantly surprised somehow. So I think I need to just lean into it and admit I'm a fan.
'The ArchAndroid' feels not like a single artist's debut, but a culmination of various collectives' collaborations deep into their careers. Janelle Monae proves her ability to transcend simple genre or style, it just blasts into every direction and succeeds beyond expectations.
I had never heard of Janelle Monáe. Maybe she isn't so big in the UK? I don't know. But this album is brilliant. Yes it drags a little towards the end. But this is a fantastic sound, with catchy songs and a consistent musical theme binding together the multiple genres. I loved it and will be putting this on rotation.
I'm shook by this album, I am kicking myself for never listening to it despite enjoying her singles. This blew me away and I will absolutely listen again. Perfect balance of concept album, upbeat bops, retro gems. I favorited 3 tracks on this album in YTM while listening, which says a LOT. I'm a little torn on this rating, like can I really give this a 5 compared to the Beatles or something?? But damn, I'm going to. 4.7/5 Listening notes: Bold move starting this album out with silence then a classical instrumental suite! Then sliding into a Saul Williams feature! Dance or Die - hell yeah moved seamlessly into Faster, which also rocks keeps the energy moving into Locked Inside Sir Greendown slowing into a beachy 60s vibe Cold War - I guess this was a single but I don't recognize it. Definitely feel the Big Boi influence on this track I am blown away by this album so far! Tightrope - goddamn. I know this was big but honestly I can't believe it didn't reach the status of Bruno Mars etc. This should be played at every wedding reception instead of Uptown Funk. I should be sick of this song. Second half of the album becoming more eclectic. moody Neon Gumbo into a folksy pop Oh, Maker. Come Alive - first track I don't love. It's a little cheesy, retro rock Mushrooms & Roses - Ok now some heavily distorted psych rock... yes. Not an Of Montreal collab in here! perfect. Wondaland kinda silly robot track that still slaps. 57821 some ethereal retro folk Say You'll Go - pretty ballad with a little Claire de Lune outro
Pretty chill and catchy tunes, pleasant listen.
This was good, and so varied in style and sound. I just didn't know what to expect next and I loved it. Is there anything Janelle Monae _can't_ do? Five stars.
Enjoyable if unremarkable. No big swings and misses, which I feared. But no real hits, although "Cold War" gets close.
Pretty indifferent. If I heard this album again, I probably wouldn’t recognize any songs.
Cool and different.
Amazing debut!
First listen. Pretty good. Pleasantly surprised.
3.5☆/5 10.11.2024
Not entirely unpleasant, but not of interest to me. Lush sound at times.
Ok
Pas possible
как обычно не большой фанат рнб и сложновато когда начинают кричать, но в целом (наверно потому что разнообразно) не так скучно
Holy schneikeys, I had no idea I was going to love this record.
She has such a great feel for rhythm and the Of Montreal collab almost puts this at 5. It's a 4.5, but going to 4 for a bit of same-ness.
A truly great album! Some individually bops of songs, but also a throughline that makes it cohesive and even greater than the sum of its parts. Inventive, but easy to listen to.
I feel like labeling this as R&B/Soul is a bit misleading. A lot of it just sounds like pop. I found a good bit of it to be obnoxious. I enjoyed sir greenwood but that’s it.
Very good, just not sure I’ll go back and listen to it again.
Epic and ambitious. Multi Genre dabbling pays off with an eclectic and exciting sound.
KCK represent! Fortunately, this also just kicks ass on its own. I’m glad I got this on a Friday, because I was able to use the rest of the weekend to listen to the rest of her discography. I don’t know if anything else quite matches this, her debut album, but them’s the brakes sometimes.
frisch und lebendig, cooler mix von stilelementen mit groovigen songs. auch nach mehrmaligem hören ein tolles album, welches nicht langweilig wird!
Schlimm. Wäre ich nicht im Auto gefahren hätte ich schon lange aufgehört und abgeschaltet.
This album is enjoyably eclectic. The range and diversity in sound within its own genre is astounding. A breath of fresh air.
Surprisingly good album. Eclectic and ever changing genres and they were all handled very well
Great album. I am mostly struck by how far reaching across genres it is. Opening with classical overture, then moving to 80s and 90s pop and rap, and Sir Greendown is a 1950s enchanting soft hula sound, club sounds for Cold War, the almost cartoon sound of Oh Maker. 57821 is 1960s soft gentle psych pop. The whole thing is extremely ambitious and expansive, and importantly succeeds. For sure this album deserves its place on the list; it's not like anything else I've heard. And there's so much to hear, not just in terms of the length. And although it's very long, crucially it's interesting enough that I was never ever bored.
Hit and miss. Some bangers, some weirdos.
Not for me personally but like the transition between songs
Good just not me
Surprisingly good album.
I shit you not, before this album, I only knew Janelle Monáe from her bit part in We Are Young by Fun. All 10 seconds of her before Nate Ruess banishes her to the background. Then here comes this album, my first from the 2010’s. How have I gone so long without hearing anything about this? It’s a masterful blend of genres that Janelle transitions through each and every one of them smoothly. The suite suite was mostly very good, even if I felt it was a few tracks two many. The third suite, however, is a five star effort in itself. It really leans into its futuristic, psychedelic themes with the likes of Wondaland and Make the Bus. It’s also a wonderful r&b album, with the fantastically moving Say You’ll Go. In parts presenting an epic dystopian future and in parts keeping the pop vibe that was present in the 2010’s, this album is making kick myself for deeming Janelle Monáe as the Na Na girl for that one Fun song. Favorite track: Say You’ll Go Other hits: Cold War, Tightrope, Make the Bus, Wondaland, Neon Valley Street, Come Alive (War of the Roses), Oh,Maker
so so very bland
Ko da sam pustio otvoreni radio. Nista spektakularno loše a ni spektakularno dobro. Tu i tamo nesto zanimljivo iskoci. Produkcija, naravno, bolesna. Nemam kaj tu za reci, pop ko pop tog razdoblja. Nikad cuo niti jednu srvar. 3/10
Na trenutke zanimljivo na početku, ali onda ode u neku komercijalu stalno. Locked inside mi ima dobar gruv, ali s njenim glasom mi opet to zvuči komercijalno i neposebno. Ima kul glas doduše, samo mi u ovom aranžmanu zvuči jako neoriginalno. Usto, imam osjećaj da se cijelo vrijeme događa previše i izgubim se svako malo u tome svemu. Skužila sam da ljudi hvale Cold war i rekoh ajde u svakom slučaju ću bar do tu poslušati i krene i dođe mi muka. A mislim, i zamišljala sam da takvu publiku privlači i da su pjesme više na tu stranu. Postaje sve gore što album ide dalje. Od negdje trećine albuma nadalje zvuči ko da slušam radio u trgovini i ne uživam nimalo. Na trenutke čujem Loreen, Beyonce, onu Doja Cat i slične koje ne mogu čuti, ali kao da mi se gubi u nečem neodređenom, kao da nema svoj djir, nezz. Mushroom and Roses mi polu zvuči dobro, što je fani coincidence. 😂 Nakon prvih pet pjesama sam htjela dati 2 (3/10), ali nastavak albuma me pomaknuo na 1 ili 2/10. Odustala sam od zadnje 4 pjesme, nemrem. Nekako sam naivno očekivala da neće biti toliko novijih albuma 🥴 ajmo se vratiti malo!
2.5/10 Ma gle, kužim da je ovo kao dobro, ali ja jednostavno nemam kapaciteta za ovo. Poslušao sam pola albuma i dat ću trojku jer kao nije loše, ali opet, nije mi toliko dobro da bi poslušao cijeli album Baš se patim, isto kao i prošli album Ima elementa ovdje svega i svačega, ali baš me neće. I evo dok sam ovo tipkao i napreskokce slušao album, odem guglati, baš da vidim i da probam nešto otkriti. Pa kaže da je ovo zapravo konceptualni album. Snimljen kao soundtrack za drugi i treći akt Metropolis filma. Što me dovelo do toga da shvatim da ja baš i ne volim konceptualne albume Yup, prošao kroz top 50 listu najboljih konceptualnih albuma prema Rolling Stone magazinu i slobodno mogu reći jebes takve albume. S tim na umu, spušta se ocjena, jer sad uz to što mi je loša glazba mi je i ideja albuma pretenciozna Hvala gospođo Džanela, idemo dalje.
4.5/10 Ocekivao sam da ce mi biti zlo do kraja albuma ali bila je ustvari podnosljiva pozadniska glazba. Ono sto mi je ok su neki funky dijelovi, trubice, malo world musica u nenametljivoj dozi i pokoja zanimljiva gitara u pjesmama. A i zenska zna pjevati. Ali ovo mi vec skoro spada u "gledam ovo svaki dan na MTV-u" kategoriju, barem dok je bilo muzike tamo umjesto realitya i dok im je pisalo music television na dnu logotipa. To je manje bitno jer da moram bas birati izmedju ovog i Beyonce koja se stalno vrtila, mislim da bi ovo ipak izabrao. A i ova Janelle bi bila danas vjerojatno poznatija da se skroz prilagodila dobitnoj pop formuli tog vremena. Na kraju dana, nemam se s cim poistovjetiti na ovom albumu niti vidim situaciju gdje bi ovo pustio, ali zbog ocekivanja da ce mi album biti skroz shitty i par, sitnih iznenadjenja koje krije cu mu malo povisiti ocjenu.
Unbelievable!
Qobuz 44/16. Really good recording, electro funk not my thing but enjoyed this.
i was absolutely BLOWN AWAY by this album. it brought elements of funk, pop, experimental, and soul to create an incredible album.
Inventive and kind of cool. "Tightrope" was the only one I'd heard before, and it's fun. Would listen again!
She has a beautiful voice and super deep, symbolic beautiful lyrics. It was super unique and different. The scifi feelings imparted on classical, hip hop, R&B and afrocentric sounds was really interesting. The only criticism is there might have been a little too much on the album and it didn't all seem to flow all the time. But it really did feel like it could be the soundtrack to a scifi musical about a droid looking for love.
This is a pretty cool & creative fusion of different music styles. I'm not usually into symphonic music but it's woven into the music in a cool way that makes me feel like a really awesome movie is about to start. Sexy, romantic, and groov'n.
Wow. The sounds in this are so rich it almost feels decadent. It’s creative and sexy and just super freaking cool. Love love love.
Good album.
It was ok. I liked some of what I listened to but I don’t think I’d buy it.
sounded like andy grammer and an edgy disney soundtrack had a baby.. bad, and nowhere near worth listening to before i die
Made my eardrums happy
Her voice is great and fits the varied song styles. Production was great. I just don’t feel the need to listen again.
This really was an unexpected and fantastic album! I have a hard time categorizing it, but I enjoyed it thoroughly and it will be going into the rotation and I will listen to her other albums.
Liked her in glass onion, not so much in this album
Shit slapped so hard
This was different and fun. Would revisit
It is funny to me that I don’t really think that I’ve ever listened to that much Janelle Monae music. I associate her so much more with acting so music from her has been a blind spot. However, after listening, I don’t think that my thoughts behind that weren’t true. This album had some fun spots but otherwise was an uneventful listen
Never heard of this but given its critical reviews and genre description I was hoping to be pleasantly surprised. I can't say I enjoyed it; I found it boring. 70 minutes and none of the songs caught my ear. To me, Janelle Monae's cultural recognition far outweighs her mainstream output, as evidenced by my not recognizing or vibing with any of the songs. One explanation would be an "alternative R&B" blind spot to experimental, non-mainstream acts such as this. Another interpretation would be that I gravitate toward catchier songs vs artsier songs, and she is firmly in the latter group. She takes herself very seriously: like Prince but with less of a talent for producing earworms.
I absolutely love this album! Listened to the deluxe version, twice. It’s not at all what I’m into but there’s real artistry in her work. I have heard, on good authority, that she is quite the live performer. Impressive album.
Interesting but not for me
There was some songs I could really jam to and was very excited where the album was heading. Then, I thought the album was over and Spotify changed albums, yet to my surprise, it was the same.
Suite II is sooooo good. This is hell of a debut album Favorites: "Dance or Die", "Locked Inside", "Cold War", "Tightrope", "Oh, Maker", "Come Alive (War of the Roses)", "Mushrooms & Roses"
I liked that. No time for a review
The song Tightrope is very good, the rest is just kind of mid and something I wouldn't purposely listen to again
A fantastically creative album from one of the best talents around
Surprisingly decent. Never ever listened to her stuff. Kind of gave me a lady gaga vibe
Strange album. Appreciate the effort, but it try’s to do too much and mostly results in a muddled mess. 2.5/5 Probably won’t listen again
It was a fun discovery
Wow. Now this is a concept album in the best way. I love the range and the bold way she goes after different sounds. So many different approaches yet so much Janelle Monáe in each approach! This needs more than one listen for sure.
An all to rare occasion where the list has delivered a new artist I hadn't heard of that I'll be checking out more. I admired the commitment to the concept of this album and it was clearly executed but it was a lot to take in on the first listen, I could have happily cut a track or two , hence the four instead of five.
Fantastic album, beautifully arranged with huge musical variation and wonderful songs.
Pretty good. Nice.
not horrible, but i think she’sa better composer than singer.
***a wide variety of sounds and songs, some pleasant, some not. An ok album
Eh
Janellelle on annettu liikaa minuutteja levylle, tuolla b-puolella tapahtuu kaikkea kummallista. Pidin alun vahvasta popista enemmän kuin lopun genrekokeiluista. Tosin Janellella on upea ääni. Eikä biisit huonoja ole, ihan hyviä, eivät vain kovin mieleenpainuvia enkä ymmärrä tätä albumikokonaisuutta - kuin monipuolisuus olisi hyve itsessään.
A-puoli alkaa raidalla nimeltään "Suite II Overture", mikä saa pelkäämään pahinta. Tästä huolimatta levyn ensimmäinen puolisko on kaiken kaikkiaan hyvää musiikkia: se ei ehkä sisällä varmaa hittiä, mutta toimii rytmisesti ja tuotannollisesti vetävänä poppina. Ikävä kyllä B-puoli on juuri sitä, mitä sen avaustittelin (Suite III Overture) perusteella voisi olettaa. Sekavaa, kummallista: musiikkia, jonka tavoitteena on saada kuulijat yliarvostamaan tekijäänsä. Listan poikkeuksellisin pettymys. 2+
Just no. Talentless, overproduced crap
I'm not sure what to make of this. It's at times both familiar and completely alien. Musically it's refreshing to hear someone taking much bigger swings that your average pop/R&B artist would and I certainly appreciate that. I listened to the whole thing, no skips. It's eclectic and ambitious but ultimately not much really grabbed my ear. I guess it's just not really my thing.