Tidal by Fiona Apple

Tidal

Fiona Apple

3.47
Rating
30095
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
33%
4
34%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 12 of 15)

#40. You know when you listen to an artist who was a one hit wonder and it blows your mind and you think "Oh shit, this is amazing! Why haven't I been listening to this the whole time?" Yeah, this wasn't one of those times. This is just Criminal, and nine other songs you wish were as good as Criminal. Because that song is so good that it is strong enough to singlehandedly drag an otherwise two star album into threedom. 3/5: acceptable Song added to playlist: Criminal I've created a playlist on Spotify that consists of the best and/or my favorite song from each of the albums in this book. This list can be found here if you are interested: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7MAXDGLWlwLkFLb8veGfkA?si=FqkQQPgZTFWG0jAUJXLFZA&utm_source=copy-link

Decent album and good memories. I think I had this in HS and liked it but barely remember. 3.2/5

Not my type of music.

Apple is an amazing artist, but this just isn't to my taste.

boring and a bit too slow for me

A monster hit and a bunch of other good songs. Made me want to listen to more of her albums. Rating 4.

The brilliance of this album is overshadowed by the gigantic hit she had.

Her fans like it.

Interesting album

Den mest spelade låten på Spotify är Criminal från denna skiva. Den låten innehåller textraden "What I need is a good defense, 'Cause I'm feelin' like a criminal”. Detta enda krimiminella I sammanhanget är denna texts uselhet. Musiken är generisk och svår att komma ihåg.

Otroligt menlöst. Shadowboxer "bäst" hittills. På samma sätt som en hård bajskorv är bättre än diarré. (The Child is gone är lite "bättre") Kommer inte ihåg nåt fram till #6. Och då lyssnar jag aktivt. Gör inget annat (åker tunnelbana). Inte ett gott tecken. Händer inget. Shreks "trollfru" också heter Fiona, och jag tänker att hon ser ut som musiken låter/är. Hemskt tråkig.

Plågsamt dålig skiva. Nog den värsta musikaliska upplevelse i mitt liv. Mådde fysiskt illa. Kritikern som ville att detta album skulle inkluderas borde skjutas i huvudet.

Inte riktigt min typ av musik det här. Inget är riktigt dåligt men inget är heller riktigt bra. Man blir inte fångad av någon låt. Känns bitvis Amy Winehouse:igt (dock sämre version) och bitvis lite Norah Jones:igt. Gillar det förra men har svårare för det senare. Svårt att välja ut bästa låten, blir nog Shadowboxer…

Great voice. But only a handful of good songs.

Pop mezclado con soul, jazz... está bien. Un 4.

Vocals and piano where great but overall wasn't a style I enjoy

Okay Roxy you’re right, this shit slaps.

Blah. Some interesting vocals but mostly just blah.

One of my favorites! Not a bad song on this album. Perfection!

This Fiona Apple album has good vibes good vibes and good grooves feels like something my parents would have put on on sunday afternoon at like 5:30 and you listen to it as they cook dinner and the sun goes down

I need to listen to more Fiona

First listen Saved 7/10 Top track: Criminal

Already have it on loop. Definitely drags toward the end and contemplated skipping the last song. More rock than I expected in the best way possible. 4 or 4.25ish

I am familiar with the artist but was not familiar with this album as an album. It's nice. The pianist and violinist are excellent. OK, I cheated, and wanted to know who was playing, so looked it up... and Fiona herself is the pianist on some of the tracks, and she wrote everything. Wow. Impressive. Definitely makes this a solid four star now.

Beautiful poetry set to meh music. Well-crafted, but frankly boring songs. Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, Criminal, and The First Taste standout, but the rest of the record had me listless. That’s a shame, too, because her voice is beautiful and her story is captivating. This album smacks of session musician production. Maybe if she’d had a band who’d suffered for these songs like she did. 3/5

This Apple is far from rotten, first time ever listening to one of her albums and it was a pleasure

Put it off after the first song, her voice is awful. Not a fan of female singers.

Languorously ominously compelling album -a magnificent voice and the arrangements play with dischord/dissonance in places that are unexpected to spin pop music in a different direction. I’ve heard individual Apple songs, but the first time going through the album was an interesting sonic experience!

Started off quite good but then tailed off and made me fall asleep!

Tidal is slow, and I'm glad I gave it the time it needed to stick with me. It's the kind of album you listen to from start to finish. Some really strong tracks stands out, particularly the high point Never Is a Promise. Medium 4

Pretty good. Can’t think of anything to say. Words.

Good album, Criminal is a great single. Personally, I prefer later Fiona's albums, but still a good one.

väldigt tråkig

Fiona Apple's music spell-binds me. I love listening to her dissect each word, stretch each vowel, crunch each consonant. There's an unmatched artistry in her voice. On this album though, the backing plays backing, as opposed to leaving space for her voice to truly shine. The effect leaves Fiona Apple washed out, as on the album cover. But who am I kidding? It's still magic.

Pretty good, I like the vibe. A little bland

I really had no idea who Fiona Apple was before this album. I have heard "Criminal" before, but had no idea who it was. This album was fantastic. Beautiful voice, emotional, and powerful. This is something I never would have listened to before, but am glad I have now.

I didn't know what to expect coming into this album since I haven't ever really given Fiona Apple any attention, but this is a fantastic album. Every song has a unique feel but the whole album is still a cohesive project, which is more than I can say for most albums out there. Fiona's voice is incredible and her slight rasp gives her a really interesting vibe. I couldn't even imagine what genre this album would be but all of it is great and I think I need to start paying a bit more attention to Fiona's other work. Jazzy, beautiful, easy to listen to, 8/10.

I missed out on this album when it first came out and REALLY wish I hadn’t.

This is one of my absolute favorite albums! Not a bad song on it!

Une très belle voix et de la bonne instru, il manque juste une couple de bangers et t'aurait un 5

The album started slow for me, but really picked up with Criminal, which is a 10/10 song. All timer. Slow Like Honey and The First Taste were also incredible. From there, the album stepped down a bit, but was still fantastic. I think what I enjoyed most about this album is how cohesively schizophrenic it seemed. The production is all over the place, but somehow makes a clear picture when viewed together. I really loved it. Looking at Wikipedia, I'm somehow shocked that Van Dyke Parks is responsible for the strings, but it also makes complete sense. A lot to revisit here. Great album.

First track SLAPS. I love her voice, and the instrumental hits hard while also being very attractive - makes me think of some White Stripes tracks.

I liked some songs, very much emotional wine drinking vibes. Probably wouldn't reach for it

Clear Jazz influences. Not something I would listen to, however.

Kinda disappointing compared to her more recent output. Some strong stuff on here but it was slow as honey.

A nice listen, but not particularly my thing today. It all feels a bit dreary and generally drags on too long, so generally it just got complutely tuned out. I think I could appreciate this chamber pop kind of thing when I'm in the right mood for it. I think it's one I'll keep around because I bet it'd soundtrack a self-reflective winter countryside walk nicely. But right now? Meh. Favourite: Sullen Girl

Just overall kind of boring, didn't vibe with it musically and zoned out of the lyrics.

I liked this one overall with a few awesome songs. Carrion, Never is a Promise, Slow Like Honey

Pretty good pretty pretty

I forgot how good Fiona Apple is.

I found this to be better than I expected. 3/5 Might listen again

Good metaphors, good voice, not my favourite style

very good. first song i was like this isn’t my vibe but it got better and better. melancholy but in a great way

After listening to Tidal, I can say its a very solid album. It is really somber throughout the majority of the album but was also groovy and upbeat whenever it needed to be. I also don't think there was a single bad song and the songs all felt distinct enough from each other, It's definitely a pretty great album. Best Song: Criminal Worst Song: Slow Like Honey

I really liked that one, nearly gave it a 5. There's a variety of songs on it that appeal to me in various ways.

Love her vocals. This album feels grand. Nothing really grabbed me, but I want to come back to this..

First time listening to album, and overall I enjoyed a good chunk of the tracks. Some of it was a bit slow for my taste, but there was a lot of soul, emotion, and beautiful writing that absolutely make it worthy of being on this list. It starts and ends on very high points with a bit of a lull in the middle. Overall not my fave but recognize her talent. Album art 2.5 stars.

1. Sleep To Dream - I liked this one, especially the lyrics. The piano at the end was cool. 2. Sullen Girl - I liked the style of this one, especially the outro. Really sad though so need to be in the mood for it. 3. Shadowboxer - I like the prechorus “no reverence to my concern” it flows well. Interesting style a little bluesy 4. Criminal - of course I know criminal, a bop. I really like the outro. 5. Slow Like Honey - I really like the sound of this one, it’s kinda calming but also kinda builds. 6. The First Taste - wow kinda a bop. 7. Never is a Promise - I don’t mind this one, a little slower than some of the others. I like the theme of it though. 8. The Child is Gone - I kinda like the sound of this one, but one of the weaker tracks imo. 9. Pale September - this has a really cool sound. 10. Carrion - I like this one, it’s cool how the music changes throughout and it really goes off at the end. I actually really liked most of the songs on this, I feel like being piano driven really helped the lyrics. It’s insane to me that she wrote all of these alone..so good! I like the kind of bluesy pop sound and actually really liked her vocals too.

Willing to accept I'm probably missing some nuance but it didn't do much for me. Can't win em' all

It's fine

Very raw and emotional lyrics. The jazz influenced instrumentals have an experimental sound that almost mimics Apple’s unwound emotions while creating the album. Enjoyed it immensely.

Great pop album, like seriously.

fina fiona äpple

3,5 beter als verwacht

Pretty darn good

Pretty mediocre, nothing stood out too much. There were songs on the second side that were really unimaginative but in the first side some carried this album. Overall not bad, not great. (62%)

16 year old me loved this album. 40 year old me wishes 16 year old me had listened more closely, and still loves this album. Keep fighting, Fiona!

Super excellent! My work doesn’t need to have a ton of contrast or attempt to be super wide in scope, as long as it knows what it is

Full is not heavy as empty Not nearly I've had three big bites of the Fiona Apple. This was the first and longest chew. I discovered Tidal early on and marveled at the vocals. I love a deep female vocal and oh my days can Fiona run deep. The story about writing Criminal in 30 minutes or whatever it was just to show the record company she was the business is a rockstar gem. I appreciate this fledgling release for what it is. Brilliant. I came back to this fine artist when discovering Extraordinary Machine and fell in love with the tongue flipping lyrics. It is an equally amazing album. Our most recent interlude was for Fetch the Bolt Cutters, which was a ball tearing emotional tirade that gave me armour against the world when I needed it the most. Fiona Apple, I love you for what you've shared with me, for what you've given the world.

Started a bit meh but this soon grew on me, loungey yet dramatic and accusatory. Great voice. Good work Ms Apple.

Only knew Criminal but enjoyed the rest. 4/5

I'd like to cut the album in half and rate it separately. The first part is amazing, but the second is eh. What's the best thing about the album? Those eyes!

I liked it, but ending was pretty boring. Pity that now I don't remember much beside the boring ending, but that says a lot too

I liked it, but it didn't really grab my attention too much. It sounded very samey to me, and didn't really feel like it built any tension or really went anywhere too adventurous. Id rate it a 3/5- good enough to have on in the background, not good enough to appeal to my specific tastes.

Complex folk that doesn't do much for me.

Songs are too long for me haha.

Fiona Apple is ok. This isn't my favorite album of hers though

Probably more like a 3.5

I cannot believe she wrote this at 17-18, absolutely insane. Gripping songs you still see the influence of in so many songwriters and performers today. Shadowboxer, Criminal, Slow Like Honey, The First Time, Carrion, all these songs made my jaw drop

I never really listened to Fiona Apple, but I always heard about her and her music growing up. Now I understand why.

As a big fan of many of her contemporaries and successors, I’ve always wanted to like Fiona Apple but have never really been able to get into her music. Listening to this all in one go I see the appeal and artistry but it still just doesn’t do anything for me, like, on a personal level.

Mächtige Stimme, reife Texte. Klavierbasiert.

18!?!?!?!?!?!? Probably her weakest album (tough competition) but man, what a talent.

Criminal may just be the best song made ever. Beautiful voice on beautiful Melodies. “Child is gone” is powerful yet mellow and beautiful. Can’t believe I haven’t heard this before.

Not for me, but I could see why other people might enjoy it

Very good. It still sounds fresh. It feels like it could be released now. Except the song The First Taste. That song sounds very ‘90s.

Another one where I know I like her other stuff better. This is good but not essential to me. Still can’t deny the power of that voice

I like Fiona Apple. My high school memories of her were how her album titles caused a societal eye roll, but since then I’ve familiarized myself with the actual music and enjoy it quite a bit. All this came to a climax when she released Fetch the Bolt Cutters and it became one of my all-time favorite albums. This one’s good too.

I liked the first few songs. When the next few didn't really change things up in terms of tempo or tone, my interest waned. I'd have rated this much higher if not for being a little bored of it by the end.

Good but unremarkable.

I am a big Fiona Apple fan and this album started her career off strong. This is a great album from start to finish with some of my favorite tracks being "Criminal", "Sleep To Dream", "Carrion", "Shadowboxer" and "Sullen Girl". "Shadowboxer" in specific is one of my favorite songs and is in my constant rotation because I can never get enough of the piano and the crescendo of the song. Personally though if I had to pick a Fiona Apple album to put on the list (besides FTBC cause I know that is on this list too), I would definitely pick "When the Pawn...". I just think WTP is the more consistent album and reaches higher heights. I also think it took the experimentation on Tidal up a notch in a good way. Despite my preference to WTP I still love Tidal and it was my first introduction to Fiona. I personally think that she really made a lane for herself that she has built on time and time again and still continues to make incredible work. My main criticism for this album is that it does have weaker songwriting when compared to her other works but given this was her first album (and she wrote everything at 18 or younger), I don't hold it against her that much. Overall this is an album that I come back to once or twice a year and every time it hits me just how good this album is for a debut and a debut for someone so young as well. 9-9.5/10

Meh, had a few alright moments on it.

cool album v bluesy vocals

Increíble de inicio a fin.

Amazing album. The singles are fantastic and there are some surprises in First Taste and others.

I love fiona apple. 5 easy ,maybe 4 if i don't jive. this has to be a 5 because I just listened to it 2x through.

Kevyttä naissolistin tunnelmointia - viihyttävä, ”klassinen” tyyli. Paljon pianoa. Ehkä kuuntelen vielä joskus uudelleen. Mieleen tulee 500 days of summer elokuva jostain syystä.

Didn't love it

I remember listening to The Idler Wheel when it came out in 2012, but I didn't get the hype and never dug further into Fiona Apple's work. This debut album is definitely very cool and accomplished. Piano-pop sauntering up the indie charts. Her voice is robust and undeniable. The first 5 tracks have a really distinct touch which sets this apart from your run-of-the-mill 1990s songwriter record. But the later 5 tracks slow down into more generic ballad territory. I mean, still high quality, but backing down from the promise of the A-side. Actually, "Never is a Promise" is very memorable and sounds like Regina Spektor at her peak (before Regina Spektor had even released an album). It's not a perfect album, but damn it was worth hearing before I croak. 4*

Not for me. Do not enjoy the singing style. Some songs have a chill vibe. Lyrics are weird.

Most popular - Criminal: has most potential Sleep to dream: forgettable Sullen girl: too slow Shadow boxer: somewhat interesting Slow like honey: kind of smooth and jazzy, is this where the titular phrase comes from? First taste: hmmm…? Never is a promise: not sure Child is gone: ehh Pale September: boring Carrion: zzzzz…

Very cool album. Fiona Apple is at her best with the more bombastic/weird tracks. Album kind of slows down for me on the B Side. Though she's got an incredible voice and has a consistently great grand piano sound throughout. great orchestration. in some of the songs as well. Highlights Include: The First Taste Criminal Carrion

Jolie découverte. Belle variabilité dans les chansons, voix cool, instrumentations réussies.

Je ne connaissais pas celui-ci, mais j'ai écouté d'autres albums plus tardifs de Fiona Apple (et bien aimé). Celui-ci bof bof.

6/10. Just a solid album but didn't move me to anything particular

Pretty good, I enjoyed a few. Chill album, has a familiar sound but in a comforting way.

Rediscovering this album brought a wave of nostalgia and happiness, as memories tied to the tracks resurfaced, making the overall experience truly enjoyable.

Not bad, not really my thing though

Een soort Katie Melua x PJ Harvey hybride. Als je hier echt van houdt ga je waarschijnlijk ook naar de fandagen van Goede Tijden Slechte Tijden. Huisvrouwenmuziek. Dan is het even de vraag hoe erg ik me er precies aan stoor. Een strenge 2 of een milde 3.

I like it but can’t love it. She’s very talented. Not sure what genre this is but the mix of grunge/triphop/blues is very cool. I like her tone. Something just not quite doing it for me to push it to full marks though.

This is a good counterpoint to Patti Smith a few days ago and I wish I had a better vocabulary to explain why. Where Patti is weird, edgy, and bad, Tidal is different, quirky, and very fun to listen to. There’s still a few pop singles and it’s not like Fiona Apple is some underground artist or anything (neither is necessarily a bad thing) but she has a very distinct sound and I enjoyed listening to this.

After listening to “Sleep to Dream,” I had high hopes for the rest of Fiona Apple’s Tidal based on the opening track’s 1965 Dylan-esque lyrics and haunting piano. In a way, the song does set the tone for the rest of the album, but only in that each track sounds more or less like some variation of every other track. I don’t mind her monotone voice, and if anything this can be spun into a positive; the instrumentals just need more variety to make that happen. “Criminal,” apparently one of her biggest hits, does not stand out to me at all. A nice little Easter egg is the tinge of mid-20th century jazz-inspired xylophone in the background. I noticed Apple covered the Beatles’ “Across the Universe” in 1998 and had to give it a listen. While she does a fine job, the song still sounds too similar to most of the songs on Tidal. Her voice is pleasant and her lyrics are well-written, but the monotony just leaves too much to be desired.

I really enjoyed this. Not something I would listen to on a regular basis, but in the moment its really good 4

singer songwritery but with some dope jams

Really pleasant listen even if none of the individual songs really stood out to me. The overall album experience was lovely.

cover is the best part

It’s alright,perfectly fine.She has a nice voice and the piano playing is good but the songs aren’t catchy and the overall feeling of the album is slow and lacking in energy.

Fiona making pianos scream, chapter 1

Fín bara

Chill and good, might listen again?

Enjoyable listen but I probably won't go back to it

Very sad

Solid, wish I was into it when it came out

I've never heard of Fiona Apple before but the album's pretty good. Would I listen to it of my own free will? Doubt it.

Will be adding this to my playlists for sure. Very good.

Not gonna lie, Somehow this was my introduction to Fiona. I missed out. This album has made it to my favorites list.

I don't think it was my cup of tea personally but I understand why people like it

Interesting haunting vocals, probably wouldn’t listen too often tho

Sweet but mostly boring

Criminal

A classic never dies. Loved it then love it now.

Liked some songs but felt like ther was a bit of filler too it.

Pas complètement convaincu, je ne suis certainement pas le public. Je sens bien qu'elle est énervée contre quelque chose mais je ne sais pas trop quoi et cela ne me touche pas trop. "Criminal" est pas mal, "Never is a promise" est très touchante, le reste est un grand flou jazzy qui me passe au dessus.

Competent, if a little busy. There is, however, no real standout among the songs. 3/5

Fint ja. Beste låt: The first taste

A quality soulful, moody album

I been on the tidal shit maan

Fiona Apple’s debut album is a fully formed feminist pop masterpiece. She skillfully took on the entertainment industry at large and had the musics chops to back it up. Here lyrics are resolute, vulnerable, and occasionally heartbreaking. Her background in jazz and classical music gives her the technical proficiency to pull off an emotional tour de force.

This is angry and weird and good!

"shadowboxer" and "the first taste" are excellent, the rest is quite good too. another fiona apple banger. though i guess this is her first album.

приятный сюпрприз от стриминга

sleep to dream and criminal were already favorites

Here’s one I’m familiar enough with to rate, but I’ll listen to it again anyway. Because it’s great. The record’s current is turbulent with vigorous emotions that pull you every which way. There’s a sultry sad rage to it, and it’s a tremendous album from such a young voice. 9/10

I remember this album really annoying me but listening to it now I can tolerate it. Still not crazy about the r&b sound. The house song “The First Taste” is very well executed, however, and my favourite cut on here.

De va bra

Never heard of the artist or the album and, tbh, was expecting pop. Pleasantly surprised, most enjoyable.

Not sure how I missed this first time round. Great album!

Not her best. Missing some of the rawness that was …Bolt Cutters

kinda boring

oh fuck yeah. fav songs: sleep to dream, criminal, slow like honey, the first taste, carrion.

Doing this challenge has introduced me to multiple albums that I feel like I SHOULD like, but I just don’t for whatever reason. Take this album, for example. I didn’t realize how similar Fiona Apple is to Regina Spektor. Even their voices are similar. But I love Regina Spektor and thought this was blah. Not bad, just not for me.

I love her voice so much!!! My favorite song on this album is probably Sleep to Dream. The only thing for me is that the instrumentals are pretty long at the end for some of them.

Sorta Rickie-Lee-ish but a bit less interesting.

Very good, catchy, interesting, unique

I was told that Fiona Apple is like PJ Harvey, just from the other end of the pond. After listening to her album, I can tell that's a big exaggeration. I didnt feel the same emotional package like PJ presents in her songs, instrumental parts are just there, Fiona's voice is soothing and rather...normal? Basically, I wasn't impressed, I didn't have fun, but it's definitely not the end of the world. Just not my thing.

4/5 Classy

Jaa a. Taustalla meni ihan ok.

Nautin tästä.

First time listening to Tidal, and Fiona Appel in general on a full-length scale. In the beginning, I was a bit disinterested, as it didn't catch me properly, which I find to be a common feature for my personal taste of some similar, baroquesque, artsy, indie-rock singer-songwriters. The album became better for me in the second half with some more minor, darkish compositions like the child is gone and Pale September. Overall interesting and I look forward to listen to more of Fiona 2.9/5

Your basic 90’s pop music

Incredible album, with so much heart in it. I've read that some of the songs were written when she was 16 but you'd never be able to guess which ones because the subject matter and writing on every song is from such a mature place. This may have come out in 1996 but it sounds timeless. Apple doesn't have the greatest voice but it's unique and every word sounds like it is dripping in emotion and depth. Favorite Songs: Criminal, Sleep To Dream, Shadowboxer Least Favorite Songs:

some songs are fine, some are not. I don't really have an elaborate opinion on this one.

interesting album. Overall enjoyed, had not heard much from her.

Need more time with this

Very smooth and thick sounding. A new type of music for me

It’s alright, okay? What more do you fucking want from me. Albums like these really remind me of the swirling cascade of humanity that is just slowly spinning down the drain beyond sight. I don’t know who Fiona Apple is, and after I’m done listening this I won’t remember. She’s just another one of those perfectly average artists who will be forgotten alongside the rest of us. I become gripped by a creeping dread while listening to music like this, since it reminds me of the interminable march of history towards an end point of oblivion. But after that deluge of death consciousness, I assuage my panic by forcing my self into the painfully temporal process of listening to this album. It becomes an all encompassing, rapturous moment as I stick myself firmly in the present as past and future wash away, a temporary glimpse of enlightenment and the end of suffering as facilitated by a mediocre soundtrack. This transgressive act of being, of disabling the conscious speculative aspects of your brain, renders you a being wrapped in time rather than hurtling towards it on rails. All that’s left is awareness of the things around you, that becomes your reality. And it’s totally liberating. The air is fresher, the light sweeter, and everything more full. Moments like that make me want to get into Buddhist meditation practice, because they’re just fantastic and I’d like to make them easily replicable. But this album is fucking not great. Don’t listen to it.

Not completely my style but picked a few favorites

This is such a great album, I didn't know this existed and the fact this is a debut album is more impressive. At points it sounds like some really premium lounge music. Other times it's got very cliche but enjoyable lyrics. Highlight for me would be Criminal. Excited to hear more from Fiona.

Better than I expected - completely missed out on her, mainly because her name is so vanilla. Some fun stuff, but also quite sleepy in places

инди тня ну так тихо мне ваще всё равно related bjork ну да конечно

I didn't finish it, it was okay so far

9 i love fiona apple

I like the album.

Not for me

Like Kate Bush if she was less spunky

LOCURA 9/10

Her words still say things I couldn’t say. Amazing.

Jesus it's slow. Not my music, but I understand what people see in it and why she is considered a great artist.

Heard it before?: No Enjoy it?: It’s magnificent, every track just comes together and has its own unique power Favourite song: Track 7 - Never is a Promise

Glad I ended up getting this fiona apple record as I've listened to When the Pawn and Fetch the Bolt Cutters but haven't listened to any others. While I've had roughly the same opinion of Fionas music, it was a slight shock to me to hear how honed in on her own sound she was from a very early age. And how profound her lyricism has been even this long ago. This album doesn't sound confined to any 90isms at all either.

WTF STOP STARING Slow and boring. Started strong, but didn't keep up The cover makes me uncomfortable

also all right for what it is i like the album cover

fiona apple's tidal is her debut album, released when she was just nineteen. my goodness, it's so beautiful! some of this album can be so delicate, but sometimes there's a darker undertone, and it's so delicious. i'd also describe the album as smooth. not smooth as in jazz typically is, but smooth like untouched water. as a singer songwriter, apple crafted music that is definitely emotional and personal. actually, i wonder if tidal is more personal as her debut. "sleep to dream" kicks off the album, and gosh some lyrics are delightfully scathing! musically, the songs are great and i have no complaints, but her lyrics are definitely a highlight.

So, I made the mistake of reading that this was acclaimed to be more "mature" in the vein of Tori Amos. As a Tori Amos fan, I then set some expectations that ended up being a bit unfair. In reality, this album ended up kind of boring me and didn't really have a lot of the bizarre highs and lows that a Tori Amos album has; it just kind of stayed mellow and a bit one-note for me. Ultimately, though, this is another first album from an artist where they knew what they wanted to do and they did it, which is cool. Fiona would go on to take this chamber pop template and become a star in that genre, so props to her!

So 90's, but I definitely have more appreciation for her now than I would've back then. Such a beautiful, natural and simple voice that is still so powerful. Fun listen.

Started great, but it didn't quite maintain that level for me

i don't know...it seemed pretty good but maybe not meant for me...she seems serious and the record sounds good, God bless her, i hope she's okay

She's an icon

Nice and chill after yesterday's

Pretty good got a bit bored though

The prototypical jazz-alt-rock. It certainly brings an artistic touch to that 90s sound which can appear stale at times without injections of originality like this album. Fiona is a natural writer. Her moody and poetic lyrics are accented by piano and string accompaniments that bring wonderful music forward and personally to the listener. The songs don’t necessarily resonate with me to the point where I’d listen to this often, I can see a teenager from any generation after mine benefiting from the angst and frustration, but that sweet zone has passed for me.

Average...

Outstanding, angst mixed with some lovely melodies

I love Fiona's voice.

It started and ended strong but the in-between just was not for me

This was miles better than the 'Fetch the Bolt Cutters' album. I especially enjoyed the 'The First Taste', 'Sullen Girl', and 'Sleep to Dream' which sounds like 'Destiny' from Zero 7, but maybe a bit worse. I didn't feel like it was really my kind of music though, maybe if I had given it more chances it would stick to me. Still going to have to go with a weak 4, recognizing that she is a very good singer and plus points for sounding different.

This felt way more standard than "fetch the bolt cutters" that came up a month or so ago. This was a nice listen with great singing and that typical 90s pop piano. Shadowboxer and Criminal were two songs that stood out to me. Ultimately I think this album is a strong 3, maybe it will grow more during re-listens, I can definitely see myself coming back to this album.

Man, if every song wasn't five minutes long, this would probably be a 4. I wish this album was a bit more concise, because I like what's going on here, but then it goes on way too long. I liked the piano and her voice was alright. My favourite song was The First Taste.

HL: "Carrion", "Shadowboxer", "The First Taste", "Criminal" At least 4 stars, maybe more, gets comparisons to all kinds of artists but it stands apart from most albums I've heard aside from "Fetch the Bolt Cutters". Nice to know that the offbeat, avant-garde sensibilities were there from the beginning (percussion in "Sleep to Dream", the extended instrumental outro in "Criminal") July 11, 2023

A lovely introduction to a wonderful artist. Tidal has songs that tend to blend into one, and end up sounding quite similar at times - but the standout tracks amongst them all are Sleep to Dream, Criminal and Shadowboxer. Having said that, I enjoy all of Fiona Apple’s other albums, so this is an album that I think I will find myself coming back to, and hearing elements that I didn’t hear the first time.

I didn't get it at the time and i still don't.

Where we already hear what she will become.

2/10, 20%

I don't know the story behind Fiona Apple, but I'm definitely disappointed that she didn't make more music. Criminal and Shadowboxer were obviously huge successes, but the rest of the songs on this album are equally impressive. Her voice is iconic (in my opinion), and I dig the whole vibe. It's sexy. Like an old jazz lounge singer, but with all the teen angst of the 90s. Every time I hear her, I'm reminded of the old jazz classic "Fever" - and I think almost everything on this album measures up to that. It's so good.

Good, easy listening album. Great songwriting and production.

Really enjoyed this. Very vibey, evening album, moody loved it.

Complex and deep, effortless cool

not sure why this one is on this list, nothing memoriable about it

Does nothing for me.

Listened Before? No Album opens with a confident Fiona over a simple, but moody drum line. Piano and orchestral flourishes are really nice. Cool song. Sullen Girl sheds all of the confidence of the preceding track for a more somber piano ballad. Beautiful mixing on this. Love how she controls her voice throughout. Shadowboxer and Criminal are both jams in their own right. Pretty impressive that both of these songs (over 5 minutes) received radio airplay in their full forms. Drifted into the background for a while there, but this was a really pretty and seemingly complex album. I would like to dig back in with a bit more focus later. On first impression alone this is an easy 4 / 5 for me. Songs are varied, but flow from one to the next nicely. I enjoy the way she uses her voice. Added to Library? Yes

‘Sullen Girl’ and ‘Criminal’ are two truly excellent songs that I was already familiar with. This was my first time listening to the album in its entirety, there’s not a bad track in there, and it’s unbelievable how young she was when she made this. Best tracks: Sullen Girl, Criminal, The Child Is Gone, Never Is A Promise

I went into this knowing only Criminal and I left it with Criminal being the only song that I really enjoyed, however I wouldn't day that I really disliked the others. This is one of those albums where I like what the artist is going for more than I like the execution. I definitely enjoyed some of the instrumentation on the tracks that I found to be just okay. I do think that I could find more appreciation to some of the others tracks with more plays.

Tidal Songwriting ,singing, arranging and production all are so unique. What an amazing artist and great album

I love her. I love when music can manage to find a balance between being weird and being catchy/listenable and she is a master of that.

She's so cool. I love how she uses her voice. Never is a Promise is my fave.

This album is incredibly sexy and soulful. I remember when it released and I couldn't get enough of Criminal, but being a grunge kid, didn't really want to give any time to the rest of the album. I'm glad I've heard it now. It's so good and her vocals are amazing.

Love this.

Pretty voice

Not bad.

Top 3 Songs: 1 - Criminal (4) 2 - Sleep to Dream (1) 3 - Shadowboxer (3)

slow like honey carrion

A bit soft and girly for my tastes, I see why all the hippy girls were into her in the 90's. Very good musically just not my thing.

Good album. 4* for this one.

Didn't give it a close listen, but some interesting, dark sounds.

The jazz elements/influences and Apple’s vocal delivery really stood out and made this album attention grabbing.

Talented singer-songwriter, Fiona Apple is impressive considering she was only 19 when her debut album was released. A collection of solid songs that were mature beyond her years, as many were written years earlier and it stands as one of her best albums. I didn't listen to Apple during the 90's, so I'm still "new" to her music and though I don't love it, I can see her appeal and talent and for the most part the record is enjoyable. She has one of those voices you either love or hate, but for me her voice suits the style of music and message she's trying to project.

The first 5 songs come out with such fury and power. Unfortunately the rest of the album has none of that same power.

I liked this but didn't love it.

10. It’s a 10.

idk, sooo late 1990s - beginning 00s

Remember the massive hype / love for this album "back in the day". Didn't really understand it back then so was quite excited when this came up in the album feed as it seemed a good change to reassess. But, no, whilst still a perfectly nice album, still don't fully understand the love or inclusion on the 1001 list.

Sounds like she wanted to do torch songs but got talked into doing some radio friendly songs. I liked the radio friendly songs better but the torch songs weren't bad.

Нудная, тянучая музыка… чуть не заснул…

albumi kuin upokkaan valtakunta... ei kaikille tarkoitettu, viileä mutta raivoava... tyrskyjen kuningas ja laineiden mahti... album coverissa nähdään siunattu henkilö, silmät avattu upokkaan armoon, järkyttyneenä mutta vihdoin, ensimmäistä kertaa todellisesti rauhan ympäröimänä... laulut on perustettu syvyyksien mestarille, ei tarvitsisi olla hyvin laulettu mutta siitä huolimatta fiona tuo täyttä laatua levytykselle... criminal

Got into Fiona Apple via the fantastic Idler Wheel... around 2015 (not sure what prompted me) and also deeply enjoyed her last album. Went back to her older stuff upon learning she was something of a phenomenon I was only vaguely aware of. But it was all a bit 90s pop production, whereas the sparseness in her later stuff I think is what drew me in. Which is odd since I was a fan of Tori Amos stuff from a year or two before this came out. It is good though, it's not as dated as all that. And my god, she's 18? Writing and playing this stuff at 18, that's depressingly accomplished. The second half of the album is quite gentle, Never is a Promise one of the stronger of these, but several others aren't very memorable. Carrion picks up at the end but meanders too much beforehand. In short I think she's great, and this is a good album, not one of hers I'm likely to return to however.

Angelic voice.

Not over! Not under! Just middlingly whelmed! Now where’s my 2.5 option?

I came into this one with some concrete ideas — not positive ones. I bought this album when it came out and never really liked it. I have tried, on many occasions, but always felt Apple's songs lacked joy and momentum and it sucks the life out of me in a recurring cycle. Sylvia even came to me a month or two ago suggesting my band do "Criminal," so I spun it afresh and halfway through was feeling the same way. I do like that song, but it seemed to just go on and on... So I was ready to pan this album, but I dutifully queued it up (cued it up?) and I must have been in the right mood (for the first time ever) because I was feeling it. The album is certainly front-loaded, but I was connecting with Apple's angst (or whatever you want to call it) in a way I had never done before. I didn't love "Slow Like Honey," and had to stop listening at that point anyway. So it was with renewed interest that I picked up and spun the second half of the album only to find all those old feelings returned. Just a slow broil of a mood I wasn't interested in. So, a 4 for side one and a 2.5 for side 2. She's a critic's darling, which is usually not a good sign for me, and I can't see what all the fuss is about. She's talented, but the end result is not alluring except on the exceptional tracks — and there are a few on this album. I guess that qualifies as a mixed review?

I dig her swagger, her sound is unique, and her arrangements are on point. On the con side, though, she has zero range, and some of her vocal flourishes are borderline embarrassing. Also, the melodies here are entirely unforgettable. The hook from Criminal is cool, and the first song got better with a second listen, but mostly the album left little impression. I was hoping to like this more. I love her cover of Across the Universe. Maybe her other albums are better.

The singles of this album are remarkable and Apple’s voice is unique and melodic. The bulk of this thin is diminishing returns however, and many tracks feel and sound identical.

not bad, not really my thing but got some enjoyment out of it

Beautiful voice. Didn't care for this when it first came out, however can see why it's on this list. 3/5

nervous but in the good way

This is an absolute staple of the 90s. Awesome album.

I don’t know if I can explain why I like this album so much, but I do. 4.5

Will need to re-listen to this one sometime.

Interesting songs but not really grabbing, it felt like a mix of Bjork and Regina Spektor for parts but with nothing to keep me there.

Love Fiona's voice. And her music is sultry and powerful.

Confident debut, but not as strong as her other releases. Some songs sound a little similar with this brooding vibe. First half stronger than the back half which feels pretty long.

A bit disappointed by this. It’s good, but I think her later efforts are miles better. This gets a lot of hype too so perhaps my expectations were just too high! Much prefer Feth the Bolt Cutters from a few years back - a lot more interesting musically and lyrically. When The Pawn… is better too, but perhaps thats just my taste given how highly rated this is

Enjoyed this more than expected as I thought it would be very tough to get through but it passed by pretty comfortably. That said it was pretty bland and I wouldn't listen again.

Not my cup of tea.

Another artist I had never heard before but I quite enjoyed this album, especially more than Carole King yesterday. Don't think I'd listen to it again but perhaps some of the highlights I would revisit. Highlights: Sleep to Dream Shadowboxer Criminal Carrion

Inoffensive, uninteresting, uninspiring. Yawn Would fit in a reception or a cafe or similar, but certainly not on a list of albums you should hear before you die.

This is a good album, Great singer and the songs aren't repetitive or overly formulaic. No real highs or lows, but consistently good through the album. Love the choice of instruments. Feels like a 3.5 stars kinda album. I liked it a lot, but there were no homerun moments that will push it into the 4 star rating. Sorry Fiona.

Such a good voice and great instrumentals to go along with it

I really like orchestra in these songs. Fiona Apple also has a beautiful angsty voice. Little jazzy on "Slow Like Honey" Really enjoying the change in sound on these songs. Very pleasant listen.

It was aight. 7/10

May 15 2023

I just don't think it's my type of music.

She seems mad, but I enjoyed.

One of my favorites!

This is just a fantastic album. Apple is such an incredible lyricist it's hard to believe this was her debut. "Slow Like Honey" is the only one that didn't do much for me, otherwise every song is incredible.

fav tracks: sullen girl, criminal, carrion least fav: the child is gone

If it wasn't for hearing her cover "I Want You" by Elvis Costello on some VH-1 show, I probably wouldn't care about her much. I was sort of impressed that this was associated with Jon Brion (a true genius). There were brief moments when I heard a great jazz singer in there somewhere and as much as I tried to keep that frame of mind, it kept getting pushed away. I would love to hear her re-do this album someday in more of the style of the jazz standards and jazz singers that Fiona Apple obviously loves, but for now, too much of this left me mostly flat.

Such a talented singer/ songwriter. And only beginning her career with this first album. They say to write about what you know. Could she really know this much disappointment in life so young? That is sad but makes really good music.

Love Fiona

Damn fine album

I always looked forward to the Criminal music video popping up on VH1 back in ‘97.

I remember when this came out in 1996. The first five or six tracks are an A, the rest are B. Great album don’t really listen anymore.

I love Fiona Apple but I’m not convinced this is her best album. Although her voice and lyrics are incredible even on her first album I think the piano arrangements are kind of snoozy, especially on the last few songs. I think the songs on her later albums are much more dynamic and I’d have chosen “when the pawn” or “the idler wheel” for this list over “tidal”.

Solid 4/5 Would listen again. If I remember it's existence.

Bootiful Very relaxing I also loved her voice, and her range was really impressive Fave song would be Never is a Promise, it was just a gorgeous song

This album just did not do it for me. All the songs blended together, and I honestly have no idea why it is an album I should hear before I die.

Didnt get to listen to the whole album but Fiona Apple is always unique and entertaining, if not exactly easy listening, not perfect for any occasion.

Fiona Apple - great name. Also some enjoyable tracks on here.

That is a terrible album cover. The music is a little better, although It’s a little too loungey, if that’s even a word. She does have a good voice, though.

She has an amazing voice. I likes this album.

Fiona Apple is kind of badass, right? Her voice is super smooth. Shadowboxer is a rad song, she's like a lounge singer! Her voice + piano takes center stage in her music. I read her bio and it is sad. Good art rarely comes from a nice place. Impressive for a first album and overall I enjoyed the flow of the music.

Too down tempo and jazzy for my liking. She does have a nice voice however.

She's very talented but didn't really grab me.

I’m more of a Gala apple guy. This album is perfect for driving laps around the Perimeter while question the very existence of your being. You know, normal stuff. This is my first taste of this apple. I apologize, that sounds weird. I dig the layers that most of the songs slowly build throughout them, including my favourite on the record, the opening track Sleep to Dream. There’s a few slow as honey songs that kind of lulled me to sleep. But her vocals take centre stage in every song as she’s got some serious pipes, it’s almost criminal how good they are. I heard some classic 90s female singer intonations, which made me laugh. After her voice, there’s some absolutely beautiful piano work on this album, making my admiration for her talent increase significantly. Earning her an extra star in my mind. Apparently she was 18/19 when she created and released this album, which makes it even more impressive.

I've been heading to the orchard for some years now so I am familiar with Fiona but had not bitten into Tidal before and let me tell ya... this album is crisp. Her voice is amazing and she's a wonderful song writer. Sleep To A Dream is classic Fiona Apple in my mind, the way melody kind of ebbs and flows. Criminal is probably my favourite on the album, no wonder it was a hit. Carrion stands out to me as well, what a beautiful song to close out on. Great album, will keep coming back to this one!

Very solid album. This song has a good variety of songs at a variety of tempos. She has such a great voice and the songwriting is quite interesting. I don't really have any major highlights or lowlights to point out here, it was just a good end to end album. I listened to it over and over all day yesterday.

Fiona is not quite my music; I think if I listened to her 15 years ago, I would have loved her! Especially with my Emotions™ as a teen and stuff, but it is good, just not for me right now. "Shadowboxer" is good, though not quite my style, "Criminal" is familiar and iconic. I really like "The First Taste" actually! "Carrion" is also good, and also would work well as a song to scream-sing.

Love it. So 90s.

Way better than the Bolt Cutters that I got last week. Wish I got this first.

This will always be a 5

Practically have this album memorized. 9 fantastic songs on a 10-track album. The composition, lyrics, diction are all off the charts and she was 18/19 when she recorded it. Blows my mind.

Better than I thought it would be!

Quite good.