Tidal by Fiona Apple

Tidal

Fiona Apple

3.47
Rating
30095
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
33%
4
34%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 10 of 15)

Good sad girl music. To much of it by the end.

There's a couple of good songs here. Any my wife loves this album. But there's too much that's exactly the same for me.

This is really not my type of music, but she does it well enough that I don’t mind. She’s a little bit jazzy and a bit bluesy, but it never seems like an affectation.

Love this album

Right up my street. It’s gone straight into my album saves so I can relisten. I only picked up her music in the last few years with Fetch The Bolt Cutters so really good to go back

loved this album. very vibey and ethereal. a little more lowkey than my usual preference, but there's definitely a place for this in my regular rotation.

This is just magnificent. Her arrangements are unique, and her voice soars to heights equalling the depths of her emotions. Her voice is mature yet playful, exquisitely smooth yet simultaneously haunting when she calls for it. You can feel her pain and exasperation as if the songs are an intimate glimpse into a complex yet relatable soul. Yet, it isn't depressing or demeaning. Give this an honest and attentive listen, and you will be richly rewarded with a uniquely beautiful experience.

Like a sultry Florence and the Machine, but didn’t really hook me. Criminal is the best song.

Increíble de principio a fin, cada canción tiene una emotividad increible de las voces de Apple, Increíble técnica y talento. 100% seguiré sus otros proyectos. 10/10

One of the most impressive things about this album is that Fiona Apple was only 18 when it came out. If she really did write her own lyrics based on personal experiences, then she was pretty mature for her age. What I enjoyed most about the album, though, is the music itself. I love the piano and the drumming on this album. The beats have a strong driving force, but they don’t overshadow the piano, which really drives the album. The combination of the two works very well together, and the production behind it is pretty solid too.

banger after banger

I like her later albums more

Sultry, sullen, and sexy. I couldn't get enough of this album when it was first released in 1996. Never latched onto anything else she ever released, but this album is pretty incredible.

Tidal is a vibe. Man it's a sensual rich tapestry of foreboding, but groovy songs. I found it to be a bit repetitive on a full listen, but it didn't detract from the experience.

Not sure

Fiona Apple must have been an bigger artist in the States as I do not remember her name or music from back in the day. Musically and lyrically soild. I will be checking out her other records. Stand out tracks: - Sleep to dream - Shadowboxer - Criminal - Never is a promise

I listen to these albums the first thing in the morning as I start my work at home day. This was a pleasant enough way to start the day. Don't think it's ever going to be in any regular rotation though ...

Tidal is very strange, a mix of very high highs and mediocre hills. Some songs I absolutely love and some just don't click for me at all. Not a bad album but one that doesn't quite work for me.

Goes without words, 2nd great artistic statement this week.

Despite the nineties influence that previously I did not like, this album has a timeless feeling that made it enjoyable to listen through

Chill and enjoyable, had a pretty relaxed vibe throughout without being boring.

My kids are really into Olivia Rodrigo right now so we have been listening to a lot of her music. I will be honest that I have turned a corner on her and think she’s actually a pretty impressive pop artist. But every time I hear one of these teenage pop artists that sort of crawled out of a production studio laboratory, it always makes me long for artists like Fiona Apple, who I deem to be more authentic, and to be an overall better songwriter. They’re singing about the same things, but FA just did it in a way that rang more true and impressively. Of course I was like 15 when this album came out, so I’m sure I carry some bias. But I have a feeling that 40-year old Olivia Rodrigo will not come close to an album like Fetch the Bolt Cutters.

This seems pretty good but it drags a bit, just for me.

I have always heard Fiona Apple’s albums were worth my time and I’ve been sleeping on her for too long. I only knew Criminal on this album, which was nostalgic to listen to, but was pleasantly surprised by the entire rest of the album, both musically and lyrically. Will be checking out more of her music!

Wasn't real tuned into this one when it came out, and I should have been. It's a great album.

more contemporary spin on singer-songwriter shlock. not bad not for me bored nnn

A bit too humdrum. Nice but boring. Can’t figure out how it deserves to be on this list.

If Joni Mitchell tried to make an Allanis Morisette album

Never got the Fiona hype. Does nothing for me

Fine. Very 90s

Canta demais! Porém é um pouco meloso pro meu gosto...

Decent tunes - got a bit repetitive

did not like, would never waste time listening again

didn’t listen to the full thing, pretty chill though 3/5

Some good songs some filler. Just a'ight.

pretty good album here. the highs were certainly high - i particularly enjoyed 'sleep to dream' and 'criminal.' the production on this one is still pretty sharp. i thought particularly towards the middle of the album it got a little dull. i know that fiona apple's music is widely acclaimed, especially after this one, so i am eager to listen to more of her music because i could definitely see moments of brilliance on this one. it was just a bit uneven at points for my taste.

Decent album, but I expected to like this more than I did.

Never heard this before. I enjoyed this. She's a really strong songwriter. There seemed to be a few (what I think were unintentional) off-key notes in her singing. The songs stay in the same genre but vary enough that the album doesn't get boring. "But as the scenery grows, I see in different lights The shades and shadows undulate in my perception"

Strong three, got a little repetitive by the end

Heard of Fiona Apple but never listened to this album before. I thought the first half was stronger than the second.

Criminal makes this album go from 2 to 3

Not for me

I get all the hype.. Fiona is one of a kind. Wish I had some fine wine to sip on while dancing in my kitchen

The voice, piano, the production and all the balance throughout is so good. The words are full of the blues…

I can see why folks compare her to Alanis but I'd sooner compare this album to Amy Winehouse or even Portishead. The wiki writeup leaves much to be desired in terms of production coverage. I found this elsewhere: [“She didn’t have all the songs written, and for a long time, it was just me trying to find out what kind of sound she liked— Ella Fitzgerald, Billie Holiday, and the hip-hop records. So, we started from there.” Slater said in an interview with Spin.] Super cool! Dig it! 4

Fav: Carrion Least Fav: The First Taste

The start of something special.

One of the best and most innovative artists of our time in my opinion. Even at her first album she was fantastic, and knowing how her work evolved and developed past it is only a testament to how well it holds up.

I really enjoyed this! I've been aware of Fiona Apple for some time, but digging into her biography was an interesting read. She's been going at it for a while with a sparsely populated discography, but every time she does drop something it's apparently to critical acclaim. This being her first release I'm hoping to get another album to see how it varies. Otherwise this might be one of the first artists I just check out other albums on my own!

The songwriting on this album lifts it to 4 stars or B- for me.

Good album, but some songs kind of do blend together with each other. Why didn't I ever listen to this whole thing when it first came out and settled for only knowing Criminal and Never Is a Promise this whole time? Those two are great songs and all, but I just might like Shadowboxer even more.

It’s OK

Not as bad as I thought

Not my jam but inoffensive

Good voice, good songs. Not something I'd really choose to listen to. Criminal a pretty damn good tune though

3rd or 4th best fiona apple album for me and its a pretty big leap to the top 2. Since I'm pretty sure they're not on this list: Idler wheel is a 5 and fetch the boltcutters is a 4

I don't get it.

Never connected with miss Fiona all that much. Sorry !

I liked that this album used a mix of instruments led by piano. It added depth to a lot of the record. The songs were sung great and had lyrics with a ton of substance. There is some Latin influence in this album which also works great. Favorite songs: Sleep To Dream, Criminal, The First Taste

I love this album. Held up beautifully over time.

This slaps so much.

A new one for me and wasn't sure what to expect. The first track had a triphop vibe and I enjoyed the first half of the album. The latter half wasn't as strong but overall a decent listen from someone I wasn't aware of

Another first. Thoroughly enjoyed

Really great album. She has such a range of emotion in her voice that pairs so perfectly with the music and the poetry of her lyrics that is unlike any other artist

Darn good freshman album with a talented singer and musician. Unfortunately, there were too many production elements that resulted in drowning out the delicacy and mastery of Fiona's voice.

Day#1 Boy this is gonna be tough but im hyped less go

The VNFiona Apple flavour of sad-girl indie-pop has inspired hundreds of not thousands a far less talented and far more annoying copycats through the years. For better or worse that warrants a listen. 7/10 There's power in these songs.

I’d forgotten how good this album is. Such a unique voice.

I’ve tried to listen to Fiona Apple before and didn’t love it. Maybe it was my mood or something because this was great. She is such an icon and I feel so cool being like yeah I’m listening to Fiona Apple. She’s the perfect addition to brat summer!

I was surprised I remembered as many tracks from this as I did, until I looked and realized there were six singles. Overall, better than I remembered, but a bit too jazzy for my tastes.

Primeiro álbum que ouvi dela. Braba, feroz, atacante. 10/10.

Very nice album

Great album... likely her best

Same same

90/100 This is the second album I've heard before and again I knew beforehand how truly great it is. Fiona Apple is probably my favourite pop singer of all time. And even with how amazing this album is she can do even better and has done so later in her career

I’m already familiar with Fiona Apple as a singer-songwriter, having heard her album Fetch the Bolt Cutters when it dropped in 2020. I very much enjoyed that album, and that same amount of enjoyment can be applied to her debut album as well. This can be attributed to how Fiona is able to take emotionally complex relationship drama drawn from her fraught adolescence, and make her stories accessible with well-written hooks. Add to that Jon Brion and Patrick Warner’s contributions on various instruments like the marimba and Chamberlin organ, and you got a piano-driven album with variance. Themes explored range from sexuality with “Criminal”, temptation with “Shadowboxer”, fantasizing with “The First Taste”, and even reminiscing about an ex-lover with “Never is a Promise.” There’s also no denying the impact of the wistful closer “Carrion”, where the relationship comes to a point where there is no saving it, as her love for her partner fades amidst the tickling ivories and jaunty guitar soloing. Overall, I enjoyed Tidal very much, as it serves as a good introduction to Fiona if you haven’t checked her out.

Not bad have interesting songs on it, cool piano and violins

a solid melody and piano driven album. it drags in the middle a bit but finishes strong.

Went in knowing Criminal, but Carrion was fun. Overall a low-key album.

Didn’t like

So I get all the South Park Fiona Apple jokes now

I love this record. It’s not quite as musically sophisticated as her later work but is chock full of bangers.

Excellent album with lyrics I want to go back to explore and varcgy songs that don't feel like they've aged a day.

Pidin tästä! Toki aikakautensa kuuloinen, mutta tasapainoinen levy! 3/5

Täs on pari tosi hyvää biisiä ja loput vähän tasapaksumpaa. 3,5/5 jää nyt kolmeen

Oon kuunnellu Applen uudempaa tuotantoa enemmän ja vähemmän tätä vanhaa. Ihan kelpo poppista kyl!

This heavily reminds me of Portishead's "Dummy". The songs are great, not one miss. My favourite song on "Tidal" is "Carrion". The last few minutes are fantastic. It looks like this week will be a wonderful musical experience. I'll give "Tidal" 5 stars.

I loved the depth of the instrumentation on parts of the album, especially the closing track

full is not heavy as empty, not nearly my love. 🦢🌊🕸🐚🌧️ highlights: sleep to dream; slow like honey; the first taste. see also: love deluxe (sade, 1992); heroin chic; gilmore girls; debut (björk, 1993).

my least favorite fiona apple album and still absolutely fantastic

Fantastic album filled with simmering anger. The Standouts are Sleep To Dream, Criminal, The First Taste, and The Child Is Gone.

Lyrics may be one thing but the overall feel is a collection of songs with a somewhat disinterested delivery.

Lyrics were good powerful. Vocals were not bad Interesting for pop but not in different ways. 3.5/5 Feel bad for giving it so low but this is a list of the greatest albums

It's fine. I'd rather go for a Sara Bareilles of Missy Higgins album instead, if I'm in this mood.

I’m a 40 year old white guy from Boston whose favorite bands are Nirvana, Black Sabbath, and Queens of the Stone Age. And I’m not afraid to admit that, not only did I somehow already know about half of the songs on this album, I also really liked the other half that I didn’t know. Not necessarily going to be something I listen to all the time, but I can’t deny it’s a great album.

This was beautiful and amazing.

Beautiful voice- well composed songs. I don’t recall ever listening to this entire album before - But I will again.

one of my favorite singers from middle school/high school. i've seen her twice in concert (once with Nickel Creek). this is her best album by far.

Never listened to much Fiona. Don't judge me. This is a pretty strong album. I guess especially for her first one at a young age.

Absolute force of nature. Imagine writing this at 19??? Just love her voice and talent.

Sultry jams.

It’s been a while, but finally I got another album I’d never heard, that I can imagine playing because I want to listen to it. Some songs are a little boring and drag on too long. The album in itself is also a little too long, but when Fiona showcases such great songwriting as in the first four tracks and Never is a Promise, I’ve got to 4 it

Будь я Шрэком, мне бы зашло

Loved "Fetch the Bolt Cutters" and wasn't familiar with this one outside of "Criminal". Really dig her loungey/smokey vocals and the songwriting that still sounds fresh and unique after almost 30 years. Very cool.

Cpunkojazzowa z jednymi hitem, ogolnie album nie jest zly, jakby lecial w tle w restauracji to bym nie zauwazyl

I was a fan of here from her cover of Across the Universe. This album I thought started out slow and got better through the album. I love her voice and think that I’d like to listen to more of Fiona Apple. She can sing!

It is fine. She can sing, but it is an odd album to listen to if you are not in a morose mood.

OK album. I liked this one just fine, but I didn’t have connect too much overall. ***

It's okay. Maybe it's all the imitaters that make this less impressive

Красивая, пусть не сильно запоминающаяся музыка. Втягивает в свою атмосферу и завораживает, манипулируя твоим настроением. Первый трек и шестой(кажется) хороши.

Pretty good. Would listen to it again.

Interesting, but I can’t describe it. It has a 90s stink on it. It does make me want to give fetch the bolt cutters another go

Love her always. Love this album. Her lyrics, passion, pain, anger, poetry, and deep low register are soothing and rousing and inspirational as usual. 🖤

Don't have it.

Great voice, great lyrics and some cool instrumental endings. Pretty solid album

Something not quite right with the instrumentation and the vocals too wobbly

Tidal wave of shite

Great start but started to drag a bit by the end

Slinky vocals but slightly devoid of personality.

The mid 90s were a good time for female vocal-led singer/songwriters. I've been intrigued by Fiona Apple, but never really listened to much of her music. This album was fine, but quite didn't grab me, I wanted to like it more than I did. Criminal is classy track though.

I love Fiona. I think her later records are a bit better, but this is still great. For a 19 year old it's pretty incredible. Not quite a five for me, because of a slightly laggy middle.

Criminal is so good. Just makes me want to smoke.

It’s alright, her voice is interesting and the songs can be catchy, but it doesn’t feel consistent enough throughout to hold my attention.

criminal is suuuuuch a good song. i mean, does it carry the entire album... definitely. but man, that song is amazing that said, i can firmly say that i find myself to be a Fiona Apple fan. between Tidal and FTBC, i really dig her style. the moodiness, the brashness and honesty of her feelings. its a great piece of music.

Too eclectic, bit bland, single wasn’t the best song on the album.

Incredible debut for one of the best artists and poets of this generation

I'll be damned this album is so lush and tender. Fiona whips out on her debut something most musicians cannot accomplish even after decades of recording, a subtle and sensual semi-pop album yet heartbroken on the downlow and oh so catchy. How even at its most laborious and long-winded it maintains infectious writing is beyond me.

Better than I expected from the Fiona Apple I've listened to in the past, which I've mostly found to be overrated. Criminal is a bop. Overall a pretty strong album, though I'm unlikely to return to it.

Gentle, musing, piano with vocals. Just a touch jazzy?

🎧Good stuff here. I love Shadowboxer and of course Criminal is a classic.

I really enjoyed the production on this album. It drags a little in the middle but some of the songs are really fantastic. Favorites were Criminal and Pale September

Lush instrumentation and great singing. I loved the first four songs, but it was losing me on the rest until the last song.

Washed over me - the opening track was fun, with the various production bits, but this quirkiness seemed to tail off as the album progressed, and it settled more into pop rock ballad territory. Which for me made this much less interesting. The songs didn't really stand out, and Apple has one of those rather generic-sounding voices that is good but not great.

Just not my shit.

Acceptable

Her voice is wonderful.

This exceeded my expectations. I remember when it came out, but it was great to give this another try all these years later. Tidal has excellent piano-led songs that are beautifully produced and Apple's songwriting is great. I think this album has some of the best and timely mellotron I've heard. OK, I just looked it up and there's no mellotron on the album. It's actually a Chamberlin (a precursor to the mellotron...who knew!).

I had heard a few songs from this album before. Overall I thought this album was very good, and I do wish there was more piano and voice driven popular music in general. However, to me, this album got a little too something towards the end.

I dig Fiona Apple. Never really listened to this album that much, but it's totally Fiona. And I actually like every track. I like her voice, the piano, the variety here. I'm gonna go 4.5+ for me personally. I'm a sucker for a pretty voice and a piano... Never Is a Promise has some really sweet vocals... but also the arrangement on The First Taste really sounds great!

enjoyed, glad i got to roll it and looking forward to the other album by her on the list

(Gordon Ramsey voice) finally some good fucking food "Criminal" is the only song to which I have the lyrics memorized. Not through effort, but through the osmosis of how iconic it is.

Innovative, experimental, authentic, and profound. This shit hits hard. In my book, it’s a perfect nine. It lacks a replay value that would give it a perfect score. You can get these songs in your head and memorize them by heart, but not on the first listen. Not on the second and maybe third either. Otherwise, not a damn thing wrong with it. A very strong debut album. 4/5

steady album. one hit. good but a little down

Can't believe I hadn't listened in full before. Songs are long and meandering which I like but can get a bit tiring. The piano sounds really nice and Fiona's voice is so lovely. 4

I really like Apple's more jazz focused work as opposed to her rock efforts. The jazz genre seems perfect fit for her style with lots of creativity on which she can focus. Nothing wrong with staying in a narrower lane. Give her 3/5 overall with 5/5 within the sultry and jazziest melodies.

Väldigt mysigt album!! Criminal och framförallt Carrion var mina favoriter❤️

Väldigt bra album, har inget dåligt att säga, men fastnade bara för typ en eller två låtar. Bästa låt: Carrion

Very missy higgins

Some songs have interesting stuff going on (the vocal style in Sleep to Dream, the groove in The First Taste, the strings and piano in Never is a Promise, the strings in Carrion), but there's also a lot of generic pop with uninspired breakup-themed lyrics that doesn't really speak to me at all. The vocal and style is quite mature, though the lyrics aren't for the most part. It's a bit poppy for my taste, I would like some more experimentation, and the lyrics aren't great, but I like the arrangements, so I think I'll give it a 3 - close to a 4.

very nice 4/5

If I ever made an album, the album cover would be a close-up of my face. Full thousand yard stare. Criminal made me feel like I was walking into a bar owned by the 1920's Italian Mafia.

1996 19-yr-old artist. Good on her. Piano and vocals

What if Elton John was cock 7?

Got her most recent album served up to me a while ago for this, which I didn't like very much, but I think probably that listening order did her dirty. Would have been much better to have heard this first for context on what her deal is

Indie album, was alright but wasn't my style

At first I was a bit skeptical listening to this. Then about halfway through it hit me how beautiful everything about these songs are.

Jessica Rabbit in the streets type beat.

Actually rather brilliant. Like Amy Winehouse meets Sade with a distinctly American twang.

A first step toward later brilliance.

It took me a while to get into Fiona Apple. I guess I considered her super-long album titles to be too pretentious and never took her music seriously. But I listened to Tidal for the first time probably 20 years after its original release, and this debut effort is my favorite of hers other than 2020’s Fetch the Bolt Cutters. Apple’s voice is tremendously powerful, and the fusion of hard rock and blues into what is essentially indie pop makes the whole album a powerhouse to listen to.

Difficult to review. The music reminds me to Brecht/Weil a little bit. I cannot understand, why the artist has been Grammy - awarded as "Rock Performance". From my point of view, rock is somthing different. When I watch the complete publications (5 Albums from 1996 to 2020) I cannot see big changes. All in all definitively not "Easy Listening" and - sorry - not my taste.

### **In-Depth Review of Fiona Apple's "Tidal"** **Overview:** Released on July 23, 1996, "Tidal" is Fiona Apple's debut album, showcasing her unique blend of confessional songwriting, jazz-influenced vocals, and lush production. The album garnered critical acclaim and commercial success, earning Apple a Grammy for Best Female Rock Vocal Performance for the song "Criminal." **Lyrics:** Fiona Apple’s lyrics on "Tidal" are deeply personal, introspective, and often dark, reflecting her struggles and emotional turmoil. Each song is a poetic exploration of themes such as love, betrayal, self-discovery, and existential angst. - **"Criminal"**: Perhaps the most famous track, "Criminal" delves into feelings of guilt and remorse, capturing the complexity of moral conflict with lines like “I’ve been a bad, bad girl.” - **"Shadowboxer"**: This song explores themes of manipulation and emotional resilience, using boxing metaphors to convey the push and pull of a tumultuous relationship. - **"Sullen Girl"**: A poignant reflection on Apple’s own experiences with trauma, this track uses the ocean as a metaphor for emotional depth and isolation. - **"Never Is a Promise"**: A ballad about broken promises and unfulfilled expectations, it highlights Apple’s vulnerability and yearning for understanding. The lyrics are characterized by their raw honesty and vivid imagery, often leaving a lasting impact on the listener. **Music:** Musically, "Tidal" blends elements of jazz, alternative rock, and piano-driven pop, creating a sound that is both sophisticated and accessible. - **Instrumentation**: The album features lush arrangements, with prominent use of piano, strings, and subtle electronic elements. Apple's piano playing is a central element, providing both melody and emotional weight. - **Vocals**: Fiona Apple’s voice is a standout feature, marked by its rich, emotive quality. She skillfully navigates a range of dynamics, from sultry whispers to powerful belts, conveying intense emotion in every line. - **Production**: Produced by Andrew Slater, the production on "Tidal" is polished yet retains an organic feel. The use of reverb and layering enhances the emotional depth of the songs without overshadowing Apple’s voice and piano. **Themes:** "Tidal" delves into a variety of themes, each song offering a different perspective on Apple’s inner world. - **Emotional Turmoil**: Many tracks deal with feelings of anger, sadness, and confusion. Apple’s exploration of these emotions is both cathartic and relatable. - **Identity and Self-Discovery**: Songs like "Shadowboxer" and "Never Is a Promise" touch on the journey of understanding oneself and grappling with personal demons. - **Love and Relationships**: The album frequently addresses the complexities of love, from the passionate and obsessive to the painful and unrequited. Apple’s nuanced take on relationships is a recurring theme. - **Existential Reflection**: Tracks such as "Sullen Girl" and "The First Taste" reflect on deeper existential questions and the search for meaning in a tumultuous world. **Influence:** "Tidal" has had a lasting impact on both critics and fans, influencing a generation of artists with its emotional depth and musical innovation. - **Critical Acclaim**: The album received widespread praise upon release, with critics lauding Apple’s songwriting, vocal performance, and mature approach to difficult subjects. - **Commercial Success**: "Tidal" achieved commercial success, certified triple platinum in the United States, and spawning hits like "Criminal" that remain iconic. - **Legacy**: Fiona Apple’s debut is often cited as a pivotal work in the 90s alternative music scene, influencing artists in genres ranging from indie rock to contemporary pop. **Pros:** - **Emotional Depth**: The album’s raw, unfiltered exploration of complex emotions is both compelling and relatable. - **Vocal Performance**: Fiona Apple’s voice is a powerful instrument, capable of conveying a wide range of emotions with nuance and intensity. - **Lyricism**: Apple’s poetic and introspective lyrics offer a profound look into her psyche, making for an engaging and thought-provoking listen. - **Musicality**: The blend of jazz, rock, and piano-driven pop creates a rich and dynamic soundscape that supports the emotional content of the songs. - **Production Quality**: The production by Andrew Slater is polished yet allows Apple’s voice and piano to shine, enhancing the album’s overall impact. **Cons:** - **Dark Tone**: The album’s heavy and often somber tone may not appeal to all listeners, particularly those looking for lighter or more uplifting music. - **Complex Lyrics**: The intricate and sometimes abstract nature of the lyrics might be challenging for listeners who prefer straightforward storytelling. - **Consistency**: While the album is cohesive, some tracks may feel repetitive in their exploration of similar themes and emotions, potentially leading to a sense of monotony for some listeners. **Conclusion:** "Tidal" remains a powerful and influential debut album, showcasing Fiona Apple’s remarkable talent as a songwriter, vocalist, and musician. Its blend of emotional intensity, sophisticated lyricism, and lush musical arrangements make it a standout work in the 90s alternative scene and a lasting piece of Apple’s discography. Despite its dark tone and complex themes, "Tidal" offers a deeply rewarding experience for those willing to delve into its depths.

Thoughts before listening: Does this have "Criminal" on it? I'm pretty sure it does cause the second album has the crazy long name. "Criminal" is a great song, but I haven't paid much attention to Fiona Apple otherwise, despite massive critical obsession with every album she's put out. I'm glad to have a reason to listen to something that is so widely revered. Review: Man, I had forgotten just how many hits there are on here besides "Criminal". "Sleep to Dream" starts this off and is immediately recognizable as song that had a big impact upon its release. "Shadowboxer" is another song that I had forgotten about but was pleasantly reminded of this morning. In general, this is alt-rock music based around jazzy piano that has memorable songs that interest me much more at 43 than they would have at 15 when this album was released. The album lost steam a bit toward the end, but then finished with a bang with “Carrion”. 4-stars.

It's not my first time listening to Fiona Apple. Tidal is a great debut album, especially the first few tracks (it gets a bit sleepier in the second half, but I don't necessarily mind it). The lyrics are simple yet moving; I feel like she improves massively on her later albums which isn't a surprise considering she was still a teenager when this one came out. My only true complaint is that the instrumentation is a bit one-dimensional—which isn't necessarily a bad thing for this album—but I wish they would have leaned more into the jazzy element. I feel like the back half of the album could benefit greatly from a more varied production.

Love the lyrics. Extremely slay girl boss with some dare I say blues undertones. Really like her sound.

Super talented debut. So lyrically angry but controlled.

Did not really care about it? Criminal is a good song.

4.5 So smooth, so cool, consistently. Loved this one.

I had so much good will for this but it just didn’t do it for me and that is about all I can say

Good. I was aware of her and heard criminal back when it came out, but I was a teenager into louder stuff, and not all that interested. Genuine chamber pop (a term like psychedelic or polyrhythm that gets thrown around a lot here without necessarily applying). Cool variety of dance influenced to acoustic sort of stuff. Pretty mature songwriting and recordings especially given IIRC she wrote a lot of it in her teens. Apparently she just gets better, looking forward to it if any of thats on the list, if not will seek it out. Don't sleep to dream.

Well, the only way I know how to talk about music anymore is by comparing it to other music, so: It reminds me a bit of Weyes Blood if her music was more art-rock and less baroque. There's also some instrumentals in there which remind me of bands like Bark Psychosis? Super ambitious for an album made by an 18-year old. It didn't absolutely blow my mind, but overall it's pretty good.

the first taste is really good carrion is also good sleep to dream is a good opener, reminds me most of what I consider fiona apples “style”

Liked this one, listened on Friday (today is Monday) so I'm forgetting some of the details, but I remember I liked it. Never really got into Fiona Apple before, this is wild for a debut album.

I mostly missed the '90s, so I only knew "Shadowboxer." But the whole album is good, and I will definitely listen again.

Not my type of music, but I can definitely understand why someone would rate this album. Quite intimate music and the vocals neatly complement the instrumentals.

Sleep to Dream Shadowboxer Criminal

I didn't mind it but I found it greatly unremarkable. In fact the album looped once until halfway through and I had no idea until I went to the bathroom

I did enjoy this but each song felt like it was slightly missing something. My favorites were “Sleep To Dream” and “Shadowboxer”

Just ok for me.

Interessant.

5 stars. All Fiona Apple’s album are 5 stars from me, I love her wordplay and snarkiness, and a lot of her songs will somewhere take a turn musically that isn’t expected. 5 stars.

Surprised to find this as my first random choice. A singer like so many who I have 'heard of, but haven't heard anything by' I wasn't expecting the earth to move, but was really pleasantly surprised and will definitely be paying this more attention. I have also taken time to read up on Fiona and her terrible childhood experience, which makes this music all the more moving and powerful. A great start to my listening project and I will be buying a physical copy of this album ... probably before today is through ...

I love her voice and the instrumentals. great vibe overall. she's a girls' girl. she gets it.

Interesting to listen to. A little slow and subdued for my taste.

This was a chill listen, and I was not aware of her age at recording which is impressive. It does have the one big hit, however, I was largely bored with the rest of this. She has the vocals for sure, but this wouldn’t be something I would routinely select.

While it’s a little sleepy on the backend, this album is a very interesting listen and would fill a number of mood moments. The production is progressive enough that this album would fit just fine if launched in today’s musical market. It’s also understandable that Fiona often gets associated with other like-minded and like-sounding female artists such as Tori Amos, but surprisingly I find Fiona’s sound a little more enjoyable. And to think that the shells of these songs were written by her as a teen and the album in full was released when she was only 18. Incredibly impressive.

Have loved this album for a long time, glad I had a good excuse to cruise though it again. This album from Fiona is captivating from start to finish, such a unique talent.

Recognized most of the album so I apparently listened to this quite a bit when it first came out. As a 14 year old boy the music video for Criminal was….eye opening. I love Sleep to Dream as an album opener. And Fiona was doing a lil reggaeton with The First Taste before that became the drum beat of every pop song. Never is a promise is a very nice song. 3.75

This starts out as a clear 5* across the first 4-5 tracks, but loses a bit of steam from there. Still a very solid album that I've revisited several times in recent years. Absolutely insane she was only 18 when she debuted with this album. Her voice is incredible and I still remember the music video that accompanied Criminal. Great stuff. 4/5

Boring. Nothing memorable on the album sadly. Didn't really enjoy it either 2 ⭐️

Rock. Normal. Me aburrió un poco. Canta muy bien.

Very nice sounds.

Not good, not bad

I was wrong to dismiss Fiona Apple in the 90s.

Classic artist and songwriter. Her voice, her lyrics, her harmonies and melodies - all beautiful. The passion and emotion she infuses in her music makes this record timeless and one to always feel empowered by. Grateful to have experienced Fiona during her peak.

This is my least favourite of her albums and it’s still an absolute barnstormer.

This turned out to be much better than I expected and an enjoyable listen for the most part. Definitely deserves 3*

Really liked bits, had a haunting quality. But less keen on other bits.... Just missed the 3 for me.

So solid 5/7

Holds up so impressively well. Fiona manages to create an aurora instantly and holds it across the track list. 5/5

Unexpected awesome R&B / Soul vibes. Timeless and seemingly looked too by modern artists that produced music decades after its release.

maps is such an outlier song on this album

Sorry to say I found it quite boring

Not my style but, not bad

It's fine, good songwriting and arranging but leaves me slightly cold over all.

Gave it a try. Too much durge

Very album. 8/10

Love her voice, love her lyrics, love her emotion. I wasn't into this kind of music when it came out, but I am now, and it's incredible.

This one really takes me back. Looking at it now as a 40-something, it’s pretty amazing that such mature music and lyrics were written while Apple was still in her teens.

It’s been a long time since I listened to this one and so glad I did again! An amazing album with incredible lyrics over a wonderful jazzy sound. If remember buying this CD and loving it upon first listen and I still do.

How an 18 year old wrote "Slow Like Honey" is beyond me. Loved this album from the first notes of "Sleep to Dream" all the way to the end. So much talent. I'm looking forward to seeing what happens when the Swifties get to college and discover Fiona.

Interesting moody pop.

Love the sultry voice, but a little goes a long way and I think that’s why I didn’t pick up Fiona Apple in 1996. I really like the big songs from the album, Sleep to Dream and Criminal. I also really enjoyed Shadowboxer and Slow Like Honey. I’d like to give this a 3.5 but I can’t so 3 it is.

I can recognize the talent Apple has, and I don't think this is a bad album, but it is very much not for me, and I mostly had to just tune out to make it through. However, I applaud the part it played in brining strong female voices to music in the 90's and the part that played in feminism.

I remember when this record came out. My buddy David got a promo from Coconuts Records where he worked and brought it back to the dorms. My opinion now is the same as then. This is very pretty music. The arrangements and singing are soulful and have still held up all these years later. The production is lovely. The mastering and dynamic range feel open and present without being over loud, even though the disc was cut in the heat of the loudness war. But. Apple's lyrics are sometimes awkward, and I can't get over it. Two months younger than I am, she made this record at 19. At the time, everyone was very excited at her precocious musicianship. And the record IS well written for someone that young. And just imagine how we young men felt about her videos! But this is the 1001. Kate Bush, Billie Holiday, and Joni Mitchell are on this list. There are no excuses or asterisks. This record just doesn't live up to that high standard of the legends of her genre. Still, this record is a great start, and I'm now quite excited to listen to her more mature album(s) on this list. Three stars.

New Fiona Apple album, to me anyway! Great!

Laidback 90s haunting vocals. Atmospheric instrumentals. Amazing how someone could make something so beautiful at 18 Favorites: Sullen Girl The First Taste Criminal Pale September 7/10 Slow but when it hits it SMACKS

So up my alley I can’t believe I haven’t heard this before.

Sleep to Dream Shadowboxer The First Taste

Loved her voice. smoky 90s sound. Such a big voice from such a small woman.

This sucks to say but I really wanted to like this one but it just did not hook me. After three or four songs in, I felt like I've heard enough, only to be met with more of the same damn song and dance for the rest. Maybe another day, but that is not today sadly.

The thing that surprised me the most about this album, honestly, is something another review for this album pointed out: if it were released today, or at least a few years ago, no one would bat an eye at it. In a world with Billie Eillish, it (Apple's voice here especially) doesn't sound out of place. And that's crazy, because not only was this album released back in the 90's, but by a 19 year old. How the hell did this woman at that age have such foresight to make this thing? I have to marvel at it. That being said, because it sounds so modern, it's not really for me. Like I said in my MELODRAMA review entry whatever, a lot of current popular just doesn't do it for me. Even Billie Eillish; I listen to new.wav's blink-182-style'd cover of "bad guy" way more than the original. The specific vibes this album gives off just aren't for me, y'know? I'unno. And I'unno how to end this, so I'll just say that when it comes to me and chamber pop, I way prefer LIL' BEETHOVEN and PET SOUNDS to what this is layin' down.

I've heard great things about Fiona, and they are 100% correct. The production is simply sublime, and her voice just radiates this certain warmth to it.

It’s a 4 that I’m gonna bump up to a 5. I’m kinda just stunned, really, and I’m not really sure if I have the proper words to describe my mood right now. This is the first time I’ve properly heard Fiona Apple, ever; her voice is incredibly unique to me, and her slightly deeper tone just clicked super well for me as the primary instrument on this album. The piano, while it did eventually lose its luster near the end of the album, is a really strong choice for her to play off of, as there were times when she was just gliding with the damn thing. For 1996, this feels like it wouldn’t miss a damn beat if it had come out in 2024. I also really liked the lyrics here; just evocative enough for imagery to sort of let the brain drift away and get lost, but not in a way where you lose all focus on the soundscape and her vocals. There were a few tracks where the lyrics sort of lost me, and when they lost me, the instrumental and her vocals couldn’t really pull me back in. However, for the vast majority of this album, something just captivated me, and that’s why even though it’s nearer to a 4 for me, given the runtime, the occasional extended instrumental outros, and the occasional moments of lyrical confusion, I enjoyed this so damn much that I have to bump it up to a 5.

Ik ben zeker een fan van goede pop muziek, maar dit album is vrij sloom, begint slecht, en weet het tij niet echt te keren.

I wish it hadn't taken until Fetch the Bolt Cutters for me to listen to Fiona Apple but now I'm just so glad to be on the inside. I hadn't listened to this one yet but LOVED IT. She's always been this good?? Wild!

Sleep to Dream 3.5 Sullen Girl 3.3 Shadowboxer 3.5 Criminal 3.4 Slow Like Honey 3.1 The First Taste 3 Never is a Promise 3 The Child is Gone 3.1 Pale September 2.8 Carrion 2.7 Score: 3.188888889

A good album to listen to over dinner. Somewhat depressing and reflective in tone

This is one of those, “who the hell is this?” albums when I saw it and then, “oh, I know this!” when listening. Enjoyed. 3.5 stars.

Siendo aún adolescente Fiona Apple debutó con este álbum dando a conocer una voz rica en matices para alguien de su edad, así como un considerable talento al piano, con un estilo sofisticado y jazzístico. Canciones íntimas propias de una cantautora que, sin embargo, adolece en el ámbito compositivo de cierta bisochez. De todas formas, encontramos grandes temas como la inquietante "Shadowboxer" y "Sullen Girl".

Loved the album

A good album, I liked Sleep To Dream and Criminal.

Meh. Too sad 4 me

Songs I hear quite frequently

Phenomenal voice

I love Fiona's voice, the instruments are all really cool sounds. I especially like the piano/guitar on tracks like Criminal and Carrion. It's hard not to compare this album to Bjork's work around this time and while the similarity is there with the arrangements but where they differ is how the vocals is treated. I do like Fiona's more gentle voice on the more subdued tracks on this album versus if the tracks were more aggressive. I think the grooves that are created in tracks like Shadowboxer are really good

I didn’t think I liked Fiona Apple. Turns out I do like dem apples.

Yeah, while this first album isn't as artistic and weird as her later stuff, it's still got some absolutely soul-bearing perfect songs. Give me "Shadowboxer" as her most perfect song. (At least: today.)

Not my thing. A bit bland 2/5

Love Fiona. This was an amazing album when it came out - every song is great but SIX hit singles out of ten tracks? Greatness. And a perfect broody soundtrack for my angsty teen self. Swanky and jazzy at times, ragey and rocking at others, I really enjoyed the range of emotions displayed here.

Give me strength to avoid such nonsense

Not so much my kind of music, but the vocals are mesmerising and the songwriting talent is admirable.

Quite enjoyed. Relaxing, if a little bleak.

Didn't hate it.

Stellar. 5/5

"Sleep to Dream", "Shadow Boxer", "Criminal", and "Never is a promise" are the best singles and best tracks. The rest is very good but less memorable.

Lush genre defying pop with a deep slow groove and insistent rhythm. Draws on jazz and rock and RnB and trip hop to create a sultry lounge cabaret sound that rises and falls like a deep breathing exercise interspersed with sprints. Her low pitched voice delivers the reflective personal lyrics, ranging confidently from a hushed whisper to a charismatic storytelling, to an almost diva-like whirlwind. Way more musically interesting than her 90s folk singer songwriter contemporaries, the arrangements are so rich: piano driven, drum machines, ethereal slide guitar, xylophones, some sort of overdriven sitar thing? I've heard criminal a million times and it still holds up, the rest I've only rarely listened to, but it's very consistent in sound and quality, though the slower stuff drags a bit. Favorites: sullen girl, shadowboxer, criminal, child is gone

Despite having technically "heard" this album before, I never truly listened to it. I can say that for certain because I sort of dismissed it initially. On this re-listen though, I was utterly blown away. Fiona Apple has always been an artist who sort of intimidated me, maybe it's because I started with her contemporary releases that were more puzzling and difficult to digest for me back when I heard them, lyrically and instrumentally."Tidal", to me, is the perfect blend of enjoyability, depth, and personality that I was hoping from an artist like Fiona Apple. I'll start by tackling this album instrumentally. Although a majority of these tracks have strong piano-driven instrumentals, the rest of the sounds that fill the remainder of the sonic space here help diversify this album. I love the strings on the song "Never Is a Promise", adding a baroque twist to this song; it's the most gorgeous track here. The heavy drum and bassy intro to "Criminal" makes it sound almost like a trip-hop track. The album can be divided into two categories, you have the warmer and softer songs and ones that are more crunchy, visceral, and driving. The direction the music takes tends to match the lyrical angle tackled by Fiona in the particular song as well. For example, the tragic, slow, and almost lost depiction of the song "Sullen Girl" nicely matches the very vast, almost larger-than-life, and elegant instrumental direction the song goes in. A lot of the songs on this album are more than easy to enjoy. Fiona draws from the many areas of the vast world of popular music when composing these songs, resulting in something very eclectic. But that's not to say the songs are watered down in any way; there's something wholly unique about the spin Fiona and her producers put on these songs. Fiona's a subtle singer, I think that's obvious, but her range is evident and never overpowers the rest of the music and is never buried in the mix here. I enjoy her voice here. Lyrically speaking, this album tackles many different themes relating to Fiona's personal experiences with intimacy and self-growth. Fiona's wariness when entering a new relationship is tackled in a song like "Shadowboxer" while her desire to grow past a stifling relationship is put on display in a song like "Sleep to Dream". "The Child is Gone" may be the most tragic song here, depicting a loss of innocence which very much parallels Fiona's personal experience. I don't think I've fully digested this album after one listen but everything about it comes off very personally driven and I'd attribute that primarily to Fiona's writing. This album has everything, the more directly enjoyable tracks on the front of the album, and the mellower, gorgeous, and melancholic tracks that slowly send it off. There seems to be a subtle progression with this album's lyrical themes, and by extension, its sonic depiction of those themes. It seems to be one of personal growth and acceptance, relating to herself and her relationships with others. Maybe my interpretation of these themes is shallow upon first listen, but I think that's the general idea here. This is such a well-rounded and meaningful album that I'm super glad I re-visited.

Wasn’t my thing at all but some enjoyable moments

Not what I expected. Pleasant listening.

Enjoyed the album, good songwriting and lyrics

Love this album, though I think when the pawn is more deserving, still 5 stars nonetheless

Good album, i prefer the first part.

I didn't like it. I know she's supposed to be really talented and all this, and I don't doubt it, however... The actual music was boring, it was plinky plonky phone on-hold music for years and then her voice comes in. Ok- maybe she's talented, but she sat there crooning into the mic, harping on about garbled nonsense. One line really stuck out: 'the shades and shadows undulate in my perception'. Wtf- queen. Just a moment. Stop us Ng big words that add absolutely zero to the song- I don't understand what the hell she means and I don't think she does either. It's a stupid line trying to make her seem interesting and insightful when really she sounds stupid. The lyrics don't fit together and she wobbles it out in the most rhythmless way. Honestly, really disliked it, it was boring and something I'd be pissed off to listen to in a waiting room or lift. Also- the hype for criminal??? What is criminal??? It a song with no discernible hook and whenever it feels like it's on the brink of becoming even slightly catchy, she goes back to singing random shit that sounds worse than livewire radio. To conclude, she may be a talented musician, and I can respect her for that, however, I think her music is rubbish and she should just try a different career at this point.

Really talented, but the songs could be better.

thought it was so cool glad i listened to it on a long train journey added to the listening experience

its good but i prefer when the pawn 3.5

Not sure if it’s an amazing coincidence or if this generator’s algorithm does this, but this is my third straight album released in 1996? I think I’ve listened to this one time before when I did a deep dive in Apple’s music when Fetch the Bolt Cutters came out, and I remember liking it. Sleep to Dream is a really strong opener with a unique sound and a beat that reminds me of Rain Dogs era Tom Waits. Shadowboxer is a stunning song. Great lyrics and imagery combined with a really incredible vocal performance. Listening to Tidal a few times on repeat I really gained a deeper appreciation for how powerful a vocalist Fiona is, her singing is really tremendous throughout the album. I always thought of her as an “alternative” artist, but there’s more jazz here than anything I can think of in the alternative space. She sounds way more like Billie Holiday than Liz Phair. Criminal probably has a lot to do with that alternative distinction. It’s the least jazzy track and was a massive hit, for good reason. I like the song way more now than I did as a kid in the 90’s - it’s definitely a song for grown ups. It’s a catchy as Apple has ever been, but it’s far from a “sellout” song. The back half of the album is very good, even if it lacks standout tracks it doesn’t take much away from the album as a whole. 4.5 stars.

Doesn't resonate with me. Seemed like ok 90s pop.

Perfect record.

Really excellent album. Beautiful voice and deep and meaningful lyrics. Some standout songs, especially Criminal. 4.5.

Very fun

To write and release an album this harrowing, this deeply painful, so palpably learned and lived in, drawn from knowledge so obviously acquired from terrifying experience after terrifying experience, all before the age of 20, you have to understand one thing – womanhood is a petrifying risk, and the path to the summit via girlhood is a cliffside walk all the way up. But even the hauntings along the way can be genuinely gorgeous under the right, delicate light. Fiona Apple knows how to cast that light just before the beauty wilts. Every song here, from the sparsest piano ballad to the most orchestrated pop single, blurs the line between sensual and eerie, mixing dark lyrics delivered in a whisper across a variety of old-school pop and jazz aesthetics. It sounds like they were plucked out of the tradition, or like they've always been here. But only Fiona could've made these exact tunes, modern but universal, designed to pull tears to your feet. This is just one excellent example in a discography filled with multiple examples that only overshadow this record because, again, she was a teenager when she wrote these; a part of me doesn't care that I think "The Child Is Gone" and "Pale September" are only good, because I still am in awe of them, along with everything else here. This is music so emotional, words can't describe the tears, so it's better to just listen for yourself and bear witness.

5.5/10 Highlight: Criminal

This album is wayyyy better than “Fetch the Bolt Cutters”. There are actually several good songs on here, Criminal being just one of them, which honestly didn’t stand out to me. Never is a Promise really stuck out to me for some reason. Lots of switches in and out of dissonance, chest voice and falsetto. Really impressive and beautiful. I came into this expecting to give 2 stars maximum, but this is a really high quality album.

If you’re gonna do the whole singer songwriter thing, either be Sara barielles or just get out of the game. This one was actually listenable as opposed the previous FA we got which was borderline unlistenable. But Shania said it best, “that don’t impress me much”.

Much more accessible than bolt cutters. I enjoyed it in the first listen. I still think “I want you to love me” is her best song and I am still listening to it, but Tidal as an album is significantly better. I think she conformed more earlier in her career, which for a first time listener is easier to digest.

I thought the album started off pretty strong and slowly faded into mediocrity. I definitely enjoyed this one more than Fetch the Bolt Cutters and I liked how the same chord progression was built into multiple songs to make the album feel more cohesive. You can definitely hear the 90s alternative influences and that helps it catch my interest, but it’s still not anything incredible. I’d probably give it two and a half stars if I could, but I’ll round up to three willingly because Criminal is an all-timer for me.

This is decent debut album. Song variety and a big radio hit, but why does she insist on trying to sing in her lower vocal range? Especially with the 90's female OOOOOoooooOoOOooooOOOOoOOOo vocals. It's not for me, but I can see why some people would like it. If this was my first time hearing Fiona Apple I would probably rate it higher, but I know that the praise this album received ultimately lead to "Fetch the Bolt Cutters". I don't want to risk that again.

I like it. Too many genres.

This album arrived at the perfect ‘90s moment: young, female singer-songwriters with an edge were all over the airwaves and on tour. It felt the culture was wide open and could embrace them as easily as grunge or Hip-Hop. Fiona Apple’s record landed right in the middle of all that. Well-crafted songs, great production, and a voice far beyond her years helps make these songs jump out. It’s certainly of its time, but “Tidal” could use a re-listen and a modern assessment because there’s nothing quite like it nearly 30 years later.

Another album I’m familiar with. Fiona’s worst by far though. Contains some of her biggest hits but I find the entire album a bit too held back?

What a great debut that set up a path to even more greatness.

Very good. Close to a 5, but it gets better.

She was a great and unique voice that stood out in her era. Still stands out today, but underappreciated.

it was decent some good tracks a little slow at times but overall a 2.9/5

Super smoky voice. She's got some great track but the last half of the album kind of drones on for a bit.

Shades of Cheryl Crow, Carole King. Not my Tasse de The. But quite listenable. Seems to build and get better towards the close

música para desquiciadas

Que locura, tenía 18 años cuando salió!!! Straight classic. Fiona siempre serás la GOAT.