Tidal by Fiona Apple

Tidal

Fiona Apple

3.47
Rating
30095
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
33%
4
34%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 11 of 15)

I couldn't really get into Fiona Apple. It certainly rates high from a musicality perspective, which is where my 3rd star comes from, but it didn't strike me with any particular feels.

Forced myself to listen to the full album for the sake of wanting to do it for all 1001 of them. It was a miserable experience. No way anyone is listening to this today without being forced too. This must be on the top of circulation for black ops torturing.

Very few artists are in a genre all their own, where almost literally no one else sounds like them, and their own sound is incredibly mutable but instantly recognizable. Fiona Apple is one. I had never given this album a thorough listen before, even after Fetch the Boxcutters came out and reminded me to go back through her catalog as she's this absolute force to be reckoned with whenever she decides to surface. What a debut!! Everything else that came out around here really just feels like imitators now. Generally more accessible than her later records (though I hesitate so claim she is still finding her voice - she already knows her sound - it would simply continue evolving as she did). She's kind of like if Bjork made sense. Wish I had had more time to listen to this without doing anything else. Will need to revisit.

Ah Fiona. This is much more conventional than her later stuff but still has that out there vibe. By the second half I kind of forgot I was listening to music. Shadowboxing is good. The whole thing is good but it definitely takes its time in a way I don’t completely appreciate. Very high 3.

Nice soft music but nothing special for me

Wow, a really strong album all the way through. Was only familiar with the hits Shadowboxer and Criminal but I was surprised at how good the entire record was. Even more impressed that she was only 18 when she made it.

I did not expect to give this a 5, but wow. Maybe it's my own ignorance, but this album is like nothing I've ever heard before. Some tracks sound baroque and some sound like Sade. I was hugely impressed with the song "The First Taste, and was floored by lyrics like "Never is a promise and you can't afford to lie" (on "Never in a Promise") that said so much so simply. I also can't believe this is a debut album. Well done.

Reminds me of Joni’s Mitchell, not a terrible album, although I don’t think I’d listen again

I almost like Shadowboxer and Criminal

Frowny. 3

Early works providing foundation for career

I'm not sure what I just listened to, but I thought it was excellent. Love to have that much variety in an album.

Pretty voice

I'm having a bit of a bad run of albums for me. Seems fine, just doesn't resonate. Will I listen to again: 0%.

Shadowboxer // Carrion

Very nice

Fantastic album!

I somehow never got into Fiona even though she should've been right up my alley. This was a really good album, especially when you realize that it was released when she was only 19. There's a maturity and polish to it that seems crazy when you compare it to the kind of stuff other artists put out at that age—unfortunately, a lot of that probably has to do with growing up too fast due to trauma. The songs are all piano based and the lyrics are confessional and personal. There isn't much variation from the slow ballad. Criminal is probably the "rockiest" song on the album, and The First Taste is the most playful track. She has great voice control and sounds more mature than her years. Highlights: Criminal, Slow Like Honey, The First Taste, Pale September

soft, young but husky voice, really pleasant album to listen to front to back. thing is that i felt it almost too long

generally not a fan of pop and she got a very generic voice and she does not hit those notes... Redeeming thing is that some brief jazzy parts are alright, but the rest is bland.

It's alright, I'd give it a 3.5 if I could.

Debating between a 4 or 5. I’m leaning 4 knowing that Fiona Apple has some 5’s down the road.

Good first half. Dragged a bit in the second half. Standout songs: Sullen Girl Shadowboxer Criminal

all the songs sound the exact same her voice annoys me

Meh: Slow like honey Pale September Like: Sleep to dream Shadowboxer The first taste The child is gone Carrion Dislike: Added to a playlist: Sullen girl Criminal Never is a promise

Nooit van gehoord :') niet mijn smaak

Wealthy white girl in her 20s living in california in 1999 music. Overrated wank and of its time. Rip off of "is this Indian musak" on one track. Did fiona ever find herself, eyeroll

One of my favorite albums!!

Classic art pop album. Not her best work(that goes to her sophomore) but well-worth a listen.

Classic! One of the few albums I can say had an impact on me growing up. An emotional record that isn't too depressing and has a good mix of powerful tunes like Shadowboxer but also calm songs like Pale September. The only song I usually skip is First Taste.

Capitalizing on the other soft but well-written solo female singers of the 90's, Fiona Apple gained (Tidal) waves of support early in her career. She creates very vivid emotions in her music to inspire feeling in the listener, and this much more harmonic approach fit my style a lot more

Was good. Not really the normal sort of thing I like but I'd listen again!

Omg her voice is beautiful

Respect that she wrote all of the songs and released this when she was still a teenager. This isn't something that I would seek out but I like her voice and get how this would appeal to others.

Very nice listen

Hell yes. Jazz diction but her musical choices span such a wide path. Hard to believe she was so young when she made this album.

Loved it

Im a legit fighting to put this on a 5 star, but this is such a beautiful album with amazing production. Nothing more to say, solo le falta un UMPH.

Fiona Apple you have so much power with your voice. 9/10. This the type of music I really really enjoy.

There's nothing here that's particularly good. Sometimes her voice sounds really nice, but on the whole it's forgettable. Definitely not a bad album though. Just not special.

4/5! Songwriting is great. Feels like Carole King meets Patti Smith meets the 90s. In the vein of powerful female singers of the late 60s - early 70s.

This is one of my favorite albums of all time. Her anger, her longing for thins to be better, OH I LOVE it.

Didn't realize I knew "Sleep to Dream" until it came on; guess it just got overshadowed by "Criminal" in the intervening years. The rest was OK, although left me underwhelmed compared to her later more interpretive work (Cy Coleman covers and Watkins Family Hour collabs and the like)

Very talented. Wasn't the right album to listen to while cooking dinner. Piano-heavy. Was having a hard time connecting with the lyrics - only made it 5 songs. Will return later

I had never heard about Fiona Apple before this album came up here. I had not heard any of the songs on the album before. Therefore a big surprise: I really like it. Will definitely be listening to her again!

Album # 33 Very bluesy, reminded me of K D lang but not my cup of tea

Not a fan of the album

I owned this, buying it when it came out. I had always listened to the songs that were the singles, but I never really listened to the whole album. Listening to it again today, I appreciate it a lot more than I did back then. But, to my credit, I was a teenage boy and this album was not for me. Not that it is for me now, as a middle-aged man. But I definitely very much liked it. Great to revisit and excited to listen to it more.

It was nice, not much to say about it. Middle-of-the-road.

Not doing it for me.

Through this site I find I'm enjoying experiencing how different people's reactions can be to the same music. A lot of people seem to love this and that's cool and you certainly don't need my blessing to enjoy it. I on the other hand wanted to shove pencils in my ears by about half way through.

Beautiful, haunting and smooth all mixed together. Several radio hits, but some of the other tracks are absolute jewels. Puts me into a melancholy mood, but supports me through it.

This is not for me. Some of the piano pieces are nice. But overall way too slow, and sad, and not my thing.

This album was just so boring and felt like it never ended. All songs was just a background sound that was just dull.

This is a good one.

She has a very nice voice but there was something about it that I didn’t like. The songs were to long which mane the album to long.

Masterpiece

Fiona Apples værste album EASY og det er stadig ret godt

Fuldstændig vanvittigt at hun skrev og indspillede den her plade da hun var 18 år gammel. Lyder pissegodt men pladen er lidt frontloaded og bliver lidt ensformig, imo klart den mindst interessante Fiona Apple plade.

There's nothing wrong with it but just doesn't do anything for me. I'm not a fan of over emotional 90s singing and this feels a bit teenage for my tastes.

Pretty forgettable

Special Styles

I enjoyed this mire than I thought I would. I liked it way back when it came out but more so today. Older and wiser? Fiona’s timeless music or my life?

Sorry didn't get it.

One of my favorite albums ever. Fiona Apple always delivers.

Un excelente álbum de música alternativa de los 90's, el cual a pesar de ser un LP debut, logra establecer una identidad sonora sumamente fuerte de una de las compositoras más destacadas de Estados Unidos. Un fuertísimo inicio de carrera para Fiona Apple, quien hasta el día de hoy se mantiene como una influyente figura del indie femenino.

An odd artist who didn't really fit her time, is she alternative rock, is she jazz, is she experimental? All of the above most likely. A crazy good debut, incredible at 19(!?). Several tracks were consistently played on the radio and never cloying or overplayed (to my dated memory). There are some lulls on the album, keeping it from a coveted 5 spot but truthfully just barely. A very good and nearly timeless listen.

Best Song: The First Taste. Even though I loved the slower, more understated tracks, something just hit when that jungle beat came in on this one. Worst Song: Carrion. Felt too disjointed, like it was really two or three songs that mashed together. Not the strongest close to the album. Overall: Beautifully flowing tracks, with relaxed but insightful lyrics. The vocals are the star but the instrumentals really augment as well. Definitely one I'll be coming back to.

IT'S A GOOD ONE. Now this one didn't get quite as deep in the feels as the Joni Mitchell did, which I got before this, BUT it is a very heartfelt and simply *smooooth* album. There's so much blues and jazz influence on this piano-led laying-out of emotions. I love it. But even though it's emotional the whole thing just reads as *cool*. She's telling you how she feels, but she's also telling you she's over it and too detached to care at this point.

Always heard of her in 90s but didn’t know any of her songs. Enjoyable album. Nothing overly memorable but a lot of respect for her talent and songwriting abilities. Kind of album I’d listen to on an airplane. I enjoyed this one.

Nice instruments good chording, but too melancholy for daily listening. It was alright

Oh this is OK isn’t it? Nice enough. Falls a bit too easily into background music. I like her deep velvety expressive voice, the arrangements are quite atmospheric and sweeping but never too dramatic. The same descending progression seems to appear a few times. Not setting the world on fire for me but a pleasant and thoughtful trip through some not too tempestuous seas.

Fiona Apple is good enough to make me like this genre of music. Always a good listen

More dull moments than strong moments, but the strong moments are especially strong.

Cute. Sara barellis vibes. A touch or adele. Peaceful voice

Not a fan, sorry! Never heard anything more than the singles in here before today. About halfway through the album she sings in a higher register and I received it like sweet relief from her normal singing voice, which to me sounds flat, both in terms of tone and intonation. She also sings with a "tough guy" attitude on some songs that feels unnatural to me. I like all the vibes and marimbas throughout the record. The music is otherwise not all that interesting to me and some of her lyrics sound awkward. I guess you can tell I never understood her appeal.

Listening to this album makes me think of when I was interning with the Minnesota Historical Society (probably summer 1999?) while the exhibits team was developing an exhibit "Sounds Good to Me: Music in Minnesota", and while Fiona Apple has nothing to do with Minnesota (as far as I know), one of my projects was to create a sort of mix tape that would play constantly in a high school-style locker with headphones for visitors to listen in on. I'm nearly certain that one of the songs was "Criminal", and I enjoyed hearing it as I worked on the tape (which was DAT, naturally), which also had songs by other Lillith Fair luminaries, plus I'm sure some other equally forgettable pop/alt music. That said, I enjoyed listening to this album, and I'd probably listen to another Fiona Apple album some day (the current favs seem to be "Fetch the Bolt Cutters" (2020) or "When the Pawn..." (1999)). Once again, though, since none of the fans out there consider this her best album, I wonder why this project seems to favor debut albums so much? (But maybe I should stop wondering this and just accept it...)

I hadn't heard this before but did recognize a few songs. She's a great songwriter, and the music was tight. What kept tripping me up was her voice--she sounded like she was straining a lot to stay within her range and this ended up limiting the songs and the music. Maybe she needs a vocal coach or maybe she's like Dylan in that some of her songs would be best performed by someone who has a better range.

It’s safe to say Apple doesn’t miss. With only five albums across her whole career, I guess they all better be good. Anyway, this debut rules. Maybe the most underrated of her’s. I think some tracks flirt with a more typical 90s production aesthetic, but aside from that, no notes. Pop this on with a good pair of headphones and take a moody walk through your neighborhood.

Bad, bad girl; good, good debut.

cool ans new

Allright, she can sing, very traditional arrangement and instrumetelisation.

She is a good singer, but not a great one. And for the type of music she makes, you need to be a great singer. Ends up sounding a bit worse than if it would have been slightly simpler to better match her singing capabilities

Powerful voice. Surprisingly well recorded and mixed. I'm floored how much I enjoyed this, actually incredible.

Fiona Apple is, without a doubt, an outstanding creative force. I only recently discovered her with Fetch The Bolt Cutters, but am pleased to hear that her earlier output is no less captivating. Favourite tracks: Sleep to Dream, Sullen Girl, Criminal, Slow Like Honey, Pale September.

A veces las canciones eran un poco raras. Aún así me han gustado.

I’d heard Criminal before, in one of those collection CDs, I honestly can’t remember the name of it. I enjoyed it, but it didn’t resonate with me at the time, and I didn’t spend any more time listening to Fiona Apple. Fast forward to today, and I see what a fool I was, because this stuff is great. The middle of the album kind of sucks, but I found restarting on the last few tracks revived my interest. The first few songs are bangers.

Its broody and angsty, the brand of it is clear. I like the silky tones, it gives it a jazz/lounge singer sound.

I like Fiona.

Kat Stratford type beat <3

Solid album with great piano, vocals, and instrumentation.

Slow for sure but some of these are very solid and it's clear she's talented. Criminal is a banger.

Simply beautiful. Where has this and her other albums been my whole life? I never realized how much Fiona Apple influenced some of my favourite artists. Excellent listen and absolutely why doing the 1001 Albums Challenge was a good idea.

Trent Reznor vibes on the vocals Overall portishead vives

Well made 90s art pop, uses a lot of elements from old school chamber jazz music in order to differentiate itself. B

Fiona Apple halt - what's not to like?

This album is great. It had a consistent vibe throughout but every song sounded unique. I really enjoyed the voice of the singer and I will definitely listen again

Never heard this but a decent listen.

Strong vocals, powerful lyrics, great album.

Sleep to Dream: 4/5 Sullen Girl: 5/5 Shadowboxer: 4/5 Crimina: 4/5 Slow Like Honey: 4/5 The First Taste: 5/5 Never Is A Promise: 4/5 The Child Is Gone: 4/5 Pale September: 4/5 Carrion: 5/5 Avr.: 4.3

I tried, I really did, but just cannot enjoy her.

Not so much my thing. I wanted to like it. A track or 2 hooked.

My mom would like this album. Same song with different lyrics. Sounds like the end of a sad toy story moment. Couple of good songs in there though.

Very enjoyable, but slow music. Would listen to when I’m feeling depressed most likely.

Criminal by far the best song. Instrumental were pretty solid. Overall too slow for my liking/not my taste in music.

I quite enjoyed this album. It felt very 90s and I enjoyed that because I don’t tend to listen to this type of 90s music. I liked shadowboxer. 7/10

Cool vibe. Raw

Out of that amazing wave of 90s female artists - Tori, PJ, Björk etc - Apple is the one I just didn't really get.

Assured, majestic and heartbreaking

Shitty backing music made so some girl can hear herself sing

TIDAL is good chamber pop for anyone, worthy of Ella Fitzgerald or Billie Holiday, Apple's heroines, and great chamber pop when considering that these tracks were written over a period when Apple was 14 to 18 years old. Poignant lyricism is matched by competent piano composition. Apple has said over the years that she did not want to record everyone one of the songs with piano, and that piano was merely her compositional tool, but Slater insisted on it appearing on each track. I personally think Apple had it right, that some of the songs might have benefited from song arrangements that leaned away from piano and incorporated the other instrumental and genre vibes more. For example "Never is a Promise" could have benefitted from a James Bond ballad song arrangement treatment, and "The Child is Gone" could have benefited from some brass. Of the singles, I think the eclectic Bossa Nova vibe of "The First Taste" is criminally underrated, even if it is clearly inspired by the vibe of Sade. The hits are worthy of the plays. "Sleep to Dream" and "Criminal" haven't lost their potency. I dig the outro of "Carrion", a pleasant way to end an album of teenage darkness. The well known songs lyrics are written well, but it can become easy to tire of the juxtaposition and contrast technique that Apple uses extensively as she exhibits the tidal on TIDAL. As an aside, Jon Brion's fantastic performance on marimba, tack piano, dulcitone, and chamberlain are evocative shades of darkness that really help the songs fill out. Not sure this album belongs on the 1001. A Tori Amos album and a Sade album more than cover the lyrical, musical, and 90s decade better.

Nothing special.

Super mellow and lovely. I haven't really listened to much Fiona Apple besides the hit singles; I might have to fix that.

I've not listened to a full Fiona Apple album before. There are four or five good songs on this one, some of which are 90s classics. She deserves to be on this list.

Basic enough songs with not much listening value. Not enjoyable to the ear and offers nothing of substance. "Never is a Promise" is the only slightly redeemable song. 2 stars.

Maybe I don't get it, but it's just very middle-of-the-road to me. On top of which, several of the songs on this album are discordant in a way that puts my teeth on edge. I couldn't even make it to the end of Shadowboxer. Sorry.

Fiona absolutely deserves to be on this list. IMO, her best album is the follow-up to Tidal, "When the Pawn..." which I'd give 5 stars. Notwithstanding, this is a solid production with her trademark soulfull voice, acerbic wit and frenetic delivery. Still can't believe she was only 19 when this came out.

Float-y kinda music. Not really for me.

dark angry and fun

Nice, but not really that interesting to me. I can see teens and 20 something girls loving it back in the day. Lots of minor chords and nice vocals, good melodies, reverby atmospheric background. I hear Pink Floyd, Joni, and other influences. It would have been a nice counterpoint to the Whitneys and Mariahs popular at that time. The mix is nice with the voice nicely out front, didn't pay much attention to the lyrics, which is probably the major point. However, by the end I was feeling annoyed and ready for it to be over. Go figure.

Whilst I had heard of Fiona Apple (great name!) I had never intentionally listened to her music before. If I was to guess I would have said she might have been a teenage pop artist or a rapper but I didn’t know really what to expect. Whilst she was neither of those things she neither tickled my interest to an extent that I would listen to her again or seek out her music. Quite an unforgettable album.

Eh whatever.

Masterpiece

So awesome. Probably on the best of 90s album list.

True 5 star album

Excesiva pero muy interesante.

This was way better than I remember it from the 90s. Nice to revisit.

2 out of 5.

I wanted to give it a 4. Criminal is so good. But I just couldn't get into it that much outside of that song. But it's good.

I think I listened to this album on my own already but excited to delve in more! The first taste is still one of my favorites from this album

Criminal is worth the price of admission on this one alone! Pretty great all around album

I love this album. Criminal is a stone cold classic

Nice discovery, It was an enjoyable listen

Better than expected. Nice experience

This was hands down over of my favorite albums as a 90's teen! Haven't listened to it in at least 20 years but still knew all the words. Album still holds up for the most part, it's amazing to consider how young she was!

Sultry, droning, good background music

One of the best albums ever made.

Kind of chill, kind of jazzy, kind of out there and “alternative” as well. Favorite song was probably the first one- “Sleep to Dream.” I liked the sound and enjoyed this album, didn’t knock my socks off though. Three stars for this album.

I was really enjoying the album for the first half but as I got further in I will admit I was getting a but bored. So im mixed, at first I was pretty sure it would be a 4 star album but I lost interest so that definitely brings it down. I enjoy the instrumentals and thought that they put in that little extra effort that lends more depth to the album. The singer definitely holds her own in terms of vocal quality. Im going for 3 stars.

I didn’t have time to listen to it so I will be giving it a 3/5 just to be safe,

Lots of meh. Nothing that speaks to me or even make me move.

Stimmungsvoll

Some okay songs, but not my vide.

First song was an absolute banger. Criminal was good. The rest was what I expected, not really up my alley

I like this better than I did in the day, but it falls off after “Criminal”.

Totally forgot how great this album is

THIS album is so great! A classic.

Pretty good album. Reminded me of Portishead. Had that dark alternative thing going on.

Starts out quite haunting with Sleep to Dream. Haven't listened before...good to have some nice piano backing...By the third song I was a little impacted by the repetition sounds. The whole of the album gets to be a little droll towards the end. I guess it is good for background or sleep.

First time I've heard more than just the big singles and apparently I hadn't heard all of those (Shadowboxer is great). Great album, excellent voice.

Long time favorite of mine. 4.5 stars. Fiona is a favorite artist as well.

6/10 POP noventero

Incredibly artistic and complex piece of music. Very emotional. Not a single bad song here. Not even an average song here, everything is top notch.

I bought this album when it first was released and listened to it non stop for awhile. It’s really good. She has a tremendous, unique voice. Not to mention excellent songwriting and piano skills.

Some great songs here but Apple had not found her groove yet

Not my style. Music was too sad.

I had this CD when it came out (I had nearly all the CDs that came out in this era), but nothing had stuck with me other than Shadowboxer and Criminal. This was likely an album that I put on as background music, I don't remember the back half of this album at all. I had mixed feelings about this one - the singles were great (and I really liked Carrion this time around), it's got a moody late-night vibe to it. But her albums have never quite clicked with me (which is a me problem). I'm glad I listened to it, but it's probably not something I'll throw on on purpose again.

Fiona is queen.

Great debut album, except it drags a bit at the end. Vital talent though!

Her voice leaves a lot to desire.

Jazzy, groovy and absolutely cool. Probably my favorite album so far in this 1001 albums. Reminds me of early Björk and I absolutely love Björk.

Some amazing songs but too many slow songs weigh this down for me. I’d give Fetch The Bolt Cutters five stars, though.

Meh, not my thing

Favorite Tracks: Sleep to Dream Criminal Slow Like Honey

This is my first exposure to Fiona Apple, believe it or not. I really enjoyed it. She gave me reminders of Amy Winehouse, Sara McLaughlin, and Nora Jones, all of whom I enjoy. I will listen to more of her work.

Fiona Apple's voice has so much character in it, and I do like piano-based soft rock. I really like the little chamber pop flavor as well. "Criminal" was not one of the strongest songs on the record, but I'm still glad I got to hear it with context.

Its aight.

Such a bad ass goddess

Wow. What a voice. I really enjoyed listening to this album.

Les gens chelous de mon bahut idolatraient cet album. Je comprends pourquoi maintenant c'est pas mal du tout. Je sais pas pourquoi je croyais que c'etait un truc de dépressif suicidaire.

Best song - Criminal

Interesting album. Very mellow, but good modern listening.

Sultry voice with excellent range. Musical composition is complex but catchy, with a range of instruments all perfect for the songs' moods. Fantastic album.

Was pretty decent. This rating would vary based on the mood I was in.

99% of my Fiona listening has been to 'The Idler Wheel..." which is a masterpiece, think i've heard this once before though. 'Criminal' is obviously a banger, and the rest is actually very memorable for being mostly piano ballads. She had some serious songwriting chops even at such a young age, super impressive.

I'd heard the name before but hadn't heard the music. After three low quality albums in three days, I was wary of another mystery artist. But I found it to be very easy to listen to and enjoy. Scale: 5 - My absolute favorites. 4 - Albums I like. 3 - It was ok to listen to but I wouldn't seek it out. 2 - Didn't like. 1 - Absolute shit.

Very nice. Great rainy day album.

Love it! Fiona's awesome and this is an amazing debut album, especially given her age at the time.

I've been a fan of this album since it came out. Still like it.

Een van de singersongwritermevrouwen uit de jaren negentig, blijkbaar. Het zusje van Sheryl Crow en van Aimée Mann die laatst langskwam. Wel aardig hoor, maar Fiona is niet de beste van het stel.

Dit album een paar dagen teruggeluisterd en het kost mij moeite om het terug te halen. Geen goed teken. Het is een standaard '90s zangeres. Niets mis mee. Maar ook niet interessant. Ze heeft af en toe een uitschieter nodig. En die uitschieters, die zijn er nou net niet.

Fiona Apple valt volgens mij in de categorie waar we vorige week ook al Aimee Mann uit hadden. Al staat er op wiki hier als categorie: chamber pop. Voor elke artiest is er een apart hokje blijkbaar. Het doet mij gelijk al heel artsy fartsy aan, een vrouwelijke Rufus Wainwright. De alternatieve instrumenten en geluiden halen het weg bij de gewoonlijke gitaar of piano singer-songwriter muziek en geven het wel een karakteristiek geluid, dat moet gezegd worden. "Criminal" is een prima nummer, waar tenminste een beetje tempo in zit. Verder is het kabbelende kamerpop, maar in het Chinese restaurant zetten ze dit liever niet op, want het klinkt niet bijzonder opgewekt. De nummers duren ook te lang, waardoor het moeilijk is om je aandacht erbij te houden. Ik krijg te vaak de neiging om de boel uit te zetten.

Powerful debut album, raw and pure.

This is good. Again, another album that I don't think I would choose to listen to, but it was thoroughly enjoyable. Fiona has a great voice - throaty and bluesy, and while the production was not my favorite (very appropriate for the time it was released), the songs are strong and catchy.

Really like it.

The template for angsty young woman rock, at least for me

Not for me

Really powerful, soulful album. Amazing introductory album from Fiona Apple. Makes such a strong first impression.

It was ok!

I still know this album by heart!

How are you going to have two Fiona Apple albums on this list and neither of them are "When The Pawn...". This is pretty good. Probably the worst full album of her that I've heard though, as it was pretty repetitive at times. She wrote this at 18 though, god damn.

Love this album

Fiona Apple - Tidal - Did not like “Sleep to Dream” at all! “Slow Like Honey” was moderately enjoyable to me.

Very good singer / songwriter album of the 90s era

Not much to say about this one. Not good, not bad

It's a nice sound and it's good songwriting but it doesn't quite connect with me for some reason.

10/10 goes from strength to strength

This was nice

It's interesting listening to this album for the first time now almost 30 years after it came out. It was impossible not to know about Fiona Apple in 1996 with the album and the Criminal music video being ubiquitous in all music media. Years later it's a wonder how good this album was and still is and how immensely talented Apple was already at the age of 19, especially in light of how great the rest of her output has been. Really excellent listen.

This album finished better than it started - maybe it grew on me. I like the slower stuff more, honestly, which is a surprise for me. The piano and low, sullen sound was more appealing and worked better. Not amazing, but not bad. Fav tracks: Slow Like Honey, The First Taste

Solid, a couple playlisters and a couple skips. Overall an enjoyable listen even if it’s not my most preferred genre.

Funny how knowing only one song by an artist gives an impression of what all their songs are, but then actually listening to the whole album creates a different impression entirely. I guess that's why we're doing this 1001 times, eh?

My first time listening to Fiona Apple, and it was great. Ten stellar tracks, each with their own unique instrumental feel and brilliant, non-overblown piano part. The mixing is done well, allowing Fiona's beautiful and emotional vocal to shine. Fiona also incorporates a hard-to-describe theatrical element to her performance that adds drama and variation to each of the songs. The songwriting style is unadventurous but honed to near perfection. Sleep To Dream, Sullen Girl, Criminal, and Carrion are highlights. The album cover is the only obvious thing bringing this album down (a blurry brightness filter on a poorly cropped selfie isn't ideal).

Certified bangers

Peaceful Fiona Apple for a Thursday morning

It's wild to me that basically every Fiona Apple album is on this list EXCEPT the one that I think is unequivocally her best (Extraordinary Machine). But I still love my gal and I'll give her 4 stars. Back half of this is better than the first half.

Lyrical genius. It’s feminism, anger, self-radicalization.

I liked sleep to dream the most

Langsam, melancholische Melodien. Schöne Stimme

When your eyes gaze upon the piercing light blue, somewhat turquoise eyes of Fiona Apple's, it feels as though you've been sucked down a vortex. For her debut album Tidal is a steamroll avalanche of rage, contemplation, aimlessness and introspection. This is the kind of album that you must listen to all the way; if one dares to skip a track, it is tantamount to breaching a sacred code. Coming across the remainder of Fiona's discography, it becomes apparent that not only does she take her time with her craft but she enforces that her efforts have meaning; a bridge to cross in the path of discovery. Tidal was the first step taken in that beguiling, often rewarding path.

Enjoyable album 8/10

left a lot to be desired. I don’t consider it a classic album at all. If we are rating it in among the best albums ever I rate it harshly. But among average albums, it stands out as something special.

Glad to return to this one. Maybe not as out there as her other stuff but she has a great voice both literally and as a writer. How can you describe Never is a Promise as anything but beautiful?

So very, very boring

I've checked out a few of Fiona's albums before and never been much moved, but this was fantastic right off the bat. Much more punchy than her other stuff. A very impressive debut. Favorite tracks: Sleep to Dream / Pale September

Loved it! Beautiful album. Apple croons like a lounge singer. She has a beautiful haunting voice and her songs are just beautiful. Theee if these (Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer and Criminal) were favorites from my college days. I enjoyed all but one song on the rest of the album. Apple fell off my radar after this album, and happy to see she kept making albums and even won more Grammys. I will be checking out her other work.

I was not really a fan

Good start. Got a bit samey. Nice though. 3.0

A mixed bag. One of those artists I like but want to love, but can’t make that jump. Fetch the bolt cutters is the best of her work I’ve heard. This is quite diluted compared to that, which is understandable as it’s her debut and shows that she’s really grown as an artist. Starts strong and gradually declines in terms of quality for me. First four tracks are great, then I drifted out. Stuck in a hard place where I know I need more time and listens to really get everything out of an album, but don’t have said time and want to listen to more music, I also am trying to not force myself to like stuff and to let things go and move on hoping something clicks. This didn’t click but I can see its quality.

How the hell do you write something like this at 18?

Honestly this album is pretty great! The first track is overrated dogwater, but the rest of the songs really pack a powerful pop punch and with great arrangements paired with a very beautiful voice, you get one phenomenal pop album. Would definitely recommend, and I'd say it is a 4.5/5

Nicht schlecht, aber nicht ganz meins vermutlich.

Fiona Apple is my favorite American singer-songwriter. I met her with the theme from the TV series The Affair. The rhythm of her arrangements, the intimate lyrics sung by his warm yet powerful and sensual voice made me immediately fell in love with her.

Not the best Fiona album, but they're all good. 5/5

Susan Vega like. Easy to listen to but mostly uninteresting.

So prior to hearing this album, I thought Fiona Apple was an actress from the 90s. Apparently I was wrong. The album was solid but didn’t blow me away to the point that I’m not convinced Fiona Apple wasn’t also a middle tier actress.

Nicht mein Geschmack.

A slay and a serve. Indescribable voice and lyricism. Truly one of the greats.

So much better than I’d expected. I can see why she’s so loved. Love the classical influence

Surprisingly good listening. I was expecting more experimental stuff, but instead a very solid collection of tracks

Great album; very soulful and emotional, with catchy instrumentation and Fiona’s sultry voice as the cherry on top.

I have a short list of singer/songwriters I adore. Sadly Fiona Apple isn't one of them.

This was a heat. Honestly only thing I knew about Fiona apple is she dated pt Anderson and has a funny story about being stuck in a room with a coked out pt and Quentin Tarantino while the nerd out about movies which sounds like absolute hell. Yeah but I loved this the album felt like it was breathing very atmospheric she has a lovely voice and even prettier eyes. Strong 4.8 soft 5 -B

Meh it’s just not really my thing. The album looped and I didn’t realize. I guess it’s pleasant to have on I understand liking it

Rating: 8.5/10 Great album, a lot of fantastic songs on here. Sounds very mature for a debut album, Fiona Apple's vocals and lyrics really shine here as well as the instrumentation. The production and the wide range of instruments used is impressive on this album. I think the album slowed down for me right after the midway point but even the worst songs on here are still very good. Favorite songs: Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, Criminal, Slow Like Honey, The First Taste, Pale September, Carrion. Least favorite songs: Never Is a Promise, The Child Is Gone.

The highly anticipated Fiona Apple. Bout time I get around to this album. I was not let down, but with the high expectations, id say they were met. Not exceeded. But it was a good listen! Regret not trying this sooner.

Beautifully produced, breathy vocals, jazz-leaning chamber pop. God this was boring! The songs all seem to be about the same thing, something about relationships, lots of angst, very dull indeed. Not even interesting enough for 1 star, so I'm giving it 2.

didn 't like this one.

Clearly iconic. Every track will live rent free in your brain for eternity.

I never understood what was so great about Fiona Apple. Her growling vocals just sounded off. Personally, I thought much of her output was just dullness masquerading as artfulness. This album in particular was hailed as a great music from a new artist, but I never understood why.

really cool drums and stuff idk if it’s just the mood I’m in but it didn’t really hit that hard for me

I think she has better albums than this.

Pretty good.. she’s obviously VERY talented

Fiona Apple has a beautiful voice but it’s almost too smooth, too good. It creates a dad rock/jazz feel to it which I truly hate. Yet somehow I loved Tidal, there is some unnamable quantity to it. It’s sad and soulful. I absolutely love Sullen Girl. I’m positive this will be my highest rated album of this genre 8.1/10

Each song was emotional and unique.

Nice voice. Good album overall.

Always enjoy Fiona Apple. Would listen again.

Quite a mature sound for a young Fiona Apple, with many of the tracks being easy listening to the ears.... but that's as far as it goes for me... easy to listen too, nothing memorable, instantly forgettable, it wouldn't be something I'd choose to listen too, but more akin to something playing in an elevator, or shopping mall.

Inga större fel men det ju så tråkigt.

Criminal. The end

I didn't give her a thought back when this came out. Then Extraordinary Machine came out and I loved it. I have since listened to Tidal over the years and I'm a fan. More appreciated for when she canceled a tour to be with her ailing, aging, dying dog. I dig this record.

i skipped this when it came out because, indie rock snob, but i got into her by the next one and it was good to sit down and re-listen to this with focus. Solid debut!

I could listen to Fiona Apple any day, you don't need to tell me to do it. Hard to believe she's less than a year older than me, in 1996 I was still young & dumb yet she sounds wiser beyond the ages we are now some 27 years later.

Liked it a lot. I'd only heard Criminal, which I still think is the best track, but a lot of them were great.

Throwback to my angsty teenage years

Fiona's voice is great and the songs are good, but there is not enough here to make me want to listen to this record again.

Nice and sad

Sohva, sunnuntai, kuppi kuumaa teetä tai kaakaota. Hyvää chillausmusiikkia. Lenkillä liian hidastempoista, mutta tykkäsin silti.

This was good, nothing jumped out at me.

'Tidal' is like a musical tidal wave – it swept me off my feet, left me drenched in its brilliance, and now I can't decide if I need a life jacket or just want to ride the waves again.

Meh, not bad music doesn’t appeal to me though.

Such a nice voice

Seeing those eyes after rating another mediocre album filled me with an adrenaline shot of joy. Teenage me grabbed her second (and better but not on this list) album, then devoured this one too. One of the few albums I can say I was too young to fully appreciate. Only one track is anything less than perfect: The First Taste (and that's because it fell into some weird 90s R&B hole). Not ashamed to say I screamed along to Shadowboxer and Criminal in my car. And that closer - Carrion. MY FEEL FOR YOU BOY. So much soul in that delivery. This album shaped me and my taste in music. Easiest 5 I've handed out so far.

I'd never heard of Fiona Apple before today, nor was a single song on this album familiar to me. Carrion and Criminal were quite nice, and while I didn't have a bad time listening to the rest of album, I found it to be forgettable. I wonder why it made the list.

Nice surprise.

borderline girl

# 118 : well I struggled to listen to it, and I found it drawn out, tedious and boring. It’s the kind of music they play in shopping centre toilets to stop people from loitering. Nothing really grabbed me - not even the so called hits.

She's really matured as an artist since releasing this. It's still very good, but her later work is better.

This album was pretty good. Fiona Apple has surprising range. 4/5.

Bedre enn frykta, men fortsatt ingen fulltreffer

Reminds me of Sara Barielles and a little Brandi Carlile. 4 out of 5… it’s definitely my vibe.

Never listened to Fiona Apple before this. I had a great time. Jazzy, moody and just impressive song writing and vocals. Favorite tracks: Shadowboxer, Criminal

Þessi er eins og síðasta plata sem ég hlustaði á með henni, vinnur verulega á strax við aðra hlustun. Þetta er töff hljóðheimur og flutningur, ekki endilega brjálæðislega catchy en ljómandi gott fyrir því.

Perfection

I don’t think I’ll ever be objective about her music. I felt the songs best when I felt isolated and moody, but I don’t want to put them into a china cabinet and only bring them out for those special occasions. The songs make me reflective, not necessarily in a melancholic way. It made me want to push everyone away but also hold them closer.

I didn't know what to expect. It's good. Smooth but not too smooth. Good songs, good lyrics. Favorite song: the first taste

Great record should not have dismissed it during my music snob period in college

Prima rustige muziek voor op de achtergrond, niks specifiek speciaals

Relaxed singer-songwriter vibe

7/10 Angsty Sheryl Crow. Enjoyed it a surprising amount. The production is rich and full. My favorite songs were the first 5 on the album, though. Did not get better as it went along.

I thought I knew this album, but I only knew the singles.

Lovely, it kept distracting me from what I was doing.

Sexy and a little psycho

Who can forget that video! The album builds and builds with each song. 'Shadowboxer' and 'Never is a Promise' big highlights. She's awesome - incredible voice, creative as hell, and her later albums are even better.

Jazzy, bluesy, pop, emo…I mean she was 18, it’s impressive. Billie Eilish should thank her.