Ellington at Newport by Duke Ellington

Ellington at Newport

Duke Ellington

3.42
Rating
27847
Votes
1
5%
2
13%
3
34%
4
31%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 3 of 12)

First listen

Not normally my kind of thing but this was great.

In the end it's still jazz that ends up as background nusic

I enjoyed this much more than I expected. Normally jazz isn't my thing and normally live albums bother me, but i thought this worked really well. Of course the sound recording wasn't as good as a studio, and you could hear the crowd, but all those imperfections added together to make this more than the sum of its parts. As I listened I could almost picture this entire scene, an outdoor New England park, emcee giving interesting (in my opinion) context to all of this, and the crowd getting very into the entire thing. The album was too long, but thats because they included the live versions and studio versions of most of the same songs.

An interesting listen for sure, especially all the very dated commentary. Performances sure were different in the 1950s. Ellington is obviously an exceptional musician and his band is also top notch. I just know so little about this kind of jazz. It doesn’t speak to me personally, but it’s objectively good…. Or maybe even great. I’m just not qualified to say much about it. Apologies, but because of my own ignorance and the music isn’t my taste, I have to give it a 3.

Don't listen to the album linked in this website, that is a remastered extended edition which is over 2h long. The original was only 43 mins long. Search for the original and you won't be disappointed, great stuff and without all the filler and introductions that are in the extended version. Someone has made a Spotify playlist with only the tracks from the original, listen to that one. Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue is a fantastic album closer.

Jazzy! Almost crashed my car.

I don’t know how to rate jazz. I am sure this was great

silky smooth jazz with a lot of pathos and patina. it's a lot to just browse through and enjoy. occasionaly this might be enjoable but certainly not an everyday listen.

horny and danceable but otherwise not my thing

I listened to the 1 hour 6 minute long version labeled as the original. While this still seems a bit longer than the original I think it’s a lot closer to the version meant to be listened to. It’s a dynamic fun album that seems to do a fantastic job at capturing the energy of a live show (its actual liveness is debated)

I imagine this slaps for people who like jazz, but I am not one of those people. 2.5

I haven't listened to the 2 hours-long live album of this one. Instead, I went for the 1 hours-long original album, which was really nice to listen to. I am starting to like Jazz!

There are few styles of music that translate in a live album. Even fewer better than Jazz, and Duke remains a king.

Good, but could do without the occasional obnoxious trumpet and the crowd noise that gets more prominent later in

The duke

Good jazz

Just not me. Sure he’s a nice fella but an awful entertainer.

Not my usual genre but I really enjoyed this album. Ellington's jazz orchestra is a nice mix of big band and smaller jazz groups. Accessible (i.e. not too complex) jazz by good musicians in a live atmosphere worked for me. The really high pitched trumpet at the end of a couple songs was actually painful though.

Conceding of course that this 'Live' performance was juiced up with studio overdubs, it is still a highly enjoyable listen and a testament to the big band era. Out of fashion at the time of this recording, this was a statement by Duke and the boys that their time was not over. They hit a variety of moods here, my favorite maybe the sultry Jeep's Blues but all offering something special. The crowd at points sounds like Bernie Mac at Def Comedy Jam or something, absolutely going apeshit!

Don’t like jazz

Solid Jazz listen.

This album almost certainly didn't work for me because it was two jazz albums in a row, which is more than I listen to in an average year. I also personally cannot handle squeaky wind instruments.

The set list of this dual-disc album is quite unique... Though it is not the best live jazz album I've listened to, it's a good one.

Not my taste … respect for the artist , a legendary musician! Also I’m not fond of live recordings ..

I mean it was ok not rlly my type of listen

What do you think of Dook Smellington as on online name?

Lengthy album but a great vibe for this morning. Think I'll put on my jazzy blues playlist for the rest of the day.

Not really my thing but it was very good. Admittedly I had to start skipping the introduction tracks.

This one really takes me back…wait. This album is 70 years old! This was a party back then. Tame by today’s standards.

Everything here is great - fun and technically brilliant - but the only absolutely essential thing is Paul Gonsalves' extended solo on "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue." And it is absolutely essential, to the point Gonsalves literally collapsed from exhaustion after playing it. A great starting point for big band or jazz in general.

I hear the hype for the Duke. Makes me want a martini and cigar and just sit back and listen to the magic.

very good vibe, lots of talking though

I like a whole lot of this. Occasionally gets a little too frantic, but overall, pretty incredible.

jazz is gr8, im js rly not in the mood rn.

Very good, but it drags a bit too much for me. 3

This album had the fascinating quality for me of deflecting my sustained attention — I kept getting lost in thought. It certainly captures the sound of this era of big band in perfect clarity, and I can’t imagine many people could complain about hearing it given that it is just so straight down the middle. Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue in itself took this to a 4 for me, that shit was insane. And then I thought the slower songs near the end of the set were really beautiful with complex chords composed of all the different instruments. The drum solo on Skin Deep is a reminder of how deeply connected jazz and 80s/90s hip hop DJs are.

3 de 5 Uno de los en vivo más legendarios de la historia del jazz, es mundialmente reconocido por el electrizante solo de 27 coros del saxofonista Paul Gonsalves en "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue", que llevó al público a un explosivo frenesí sin control. El lanzamiento de este trabajo consagró el resurgimiento de la carrera de Ellington. A destacar: Track 2 - Festival Junction Track 4 - Newport Up Track 6 - Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue Track 7 - Take the "A" Train Track 10 - Skin Deep

Loved this! I need to listen to more jazz

Maybe live jazz is where it’s at for me, because this record is a lot more exciting than a lot of the studio-bound jazz of the period seems to be. The band seems to feed off the audience, and the crowd noise adds to the excitement. This is never going to be my favorite type of music (it seems just so abstract to me) but on this one, I can just barely spy why people loved it. Best track: “Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue”

An incredible classic jazz album. The live complements add so much and it was incredible to hear the Duke like this. The full band sound is just so vital and fun, moving from person to person as the solos and focus moves. It ends on such a high note, and keeps momentum moving quickly. Just don’t listen to the version with interruptions between every god damn song.

6/10 - jazz is always welcome but there are better jazz albums out there

A lot of talking and the horns are a little too high pitched

Jazz is not really my genre, yet somehow it is my second-highest ranking so far. Go figure. It’s hard not to give this five stars for the incredible musicianship.

Pretty chill jazz, good background music.

Ton of wasted time with them talking and introducing the people playing the instruments. This is one of those things I think it was probably better to experience live in a music hall with a bar or whatever around a bunch of tables in 1956, not as a live album in 2026. The music is still pretty good though.

I like it a lot. I wish he sang too

An excellent live concert. You can feel the energy of the crowd in the record.

No denying this gentleman is a phenomenal pianist and composer. Sadly, when there are no lyrics, I feel the tracks pass over me, pleasantly of course, but just over me without reaching me. I don’t have a Jazz gene to do this album a creditable review.

I wasn’t expecting to like this, but it was a bit of a revelation. Excellent all the way through with the highlights being Diminuendo and Crescendo in blue 4 stars.

É um jazz bem puro, o trompete da banda é insano mas no geral n curti tanto

And this is the kind of jazz I don’t like.

Wow this isn’t really my usual kind of jazz at all but it was a lot of fun and caught me in just the right mood to enjoy it

This is definitely the way more accessible type of jazz. I'm much more into the big band stuff, and for the most part this is a thoroughly nice listen. I like the really, really strange sound they get out of the trumpet at times. Like the musician is being strangled, hah. 3.5 rounded up.

MY GOD IM SIPPING SUNSHINE OUT A WINE GLASS absolutely electrifying and bombastic chune here. im not too deep in classic jazz, but i cant decide between this or bitches brew as my all time favorite. one can only properly experience this album as a soundtrack to their metropolitan transit journey. as a true city slicker, this album hits harder any fall onto concrete. 5/5

High quality music, just not my cup of tea.

I start reading reviews and Wikipedia, this is weird before I even listen to a note. I'm wondering was it the 1956 album that scored the entry into OG 1001, perhaps in conjunction with the hype about the gig, or maybe the exhaustive/exhausting 1999 album? Wikipedia page includes a narrrative of the original concert - says the 1956 album was only 40% live - says of the 1999 double CD that "the Voice of America live recording and live Columbia tapes were painstakingly pieced together using digital technology to create a stereophonic recording of the best-known Ellington performance of the past 50 years" - then gives a track listing for the 'complete' CD that doesn't match the concert sequence as narrated up the page? So I'm not sure if I 'have to' listen to the whole 2 hours. From reading reviews here, it seems many people think they should listen to all 2 hours, but quite a few people don't complete that .... I decide to listen to everything on the 1956 LP (the available artifact for most of the period when Ellington's career was boosted), and I'll start with the CD version of at least Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue. Re the big band feel generally: I was pleased that Diminuendo in particular is a LOT jazzier than the big band style I was expecting. Re the big saxaphone solo: I don't find it as exciting as I was expecting from the write-ups. The big drum solo: I was not a fan. The festival showpiece (parts 1-3, studio version): listening to part 1 felt like a chore, old-fashioned and formulaic ("big band" that says little and goes nowhere); part 2 was a bit more interesting (but I couldn't pick a relation to part 1); part 3 was more with-it (I like an uptune and some crunchy horn chords). Jeep's Blues (studio version): this was my favourite track - smooth, but also enough flair in soloes and other band interplay to hold my interest :-) Overall, for me it's Okay, 6/10.

Based on the original recording not the “complete” version . “culturally, historically, and aesthetically significant”

While I respect its place in history, and there's no denying Duke Ellington's superb talent in bridging big band and jazz, this is awfully long. Did I feel that I had been transported to a different world years before my birth? Absolutely, but all the spoken filler between tunes was a bit much. Also, the prolonged screams from the muffled trumpet were not my favorite.

One of my first jazz records. It’s Jo Jones in the wings you hear urging the band on in Diminuendo. 1. Newport Up 2. Jeep's Blues 3. Diminuendo And Crescendo In Blue

This is a great album! These guys are beyond talented and I really enjoyed this one. 9/10 Top song Diminuendo and crescendo in blue

Onhan tuo alansa legenda, ja ihan kovaakin kuultavaa. Mutta alkaa kyllä äkkiä toistaa itseään.

Kyllä tätä kelpaa kuunnella 👌🏼

Uff. Un fenómeno. La rompe toda. No se puede dejar de escuchar a un tipo con un talento así. Y encima album en vivo. 8/10

Some good trumpeting. Decent Big Band.

This might be cheating, but I listened to the 60th anniversary addition of this album instead, which cut about an hour off the runtime thank the lord. Boiling it down to just the music best showcasing the Duke himself. Duke Ellington was my introduction to jazz, and is still my favourite artist in the genre. The chugging blues scale holding down the base makes his music feel alive, and more approachable. Gets the toes a tappin.

Good jazz and swing but no singalong ability

Quintessential jazz, what's not to like?

Fav song: Jeep’s Blues (track 5) I don’t normally like jazz but this was actually pretty good

I couldn't finish it, I haaate trumpets

Review - two Newport live recordings in a row, bizarre. Never really listened to Duke Ellington but this was good. Hard to find the original 45 minutes track listing rather than the 1999 extended edition that's like 2.5hrs long but worth it - original was good. Score - 7.5/10 Need to listen? YES

not as good as Joni Mitchell’s Blue

Ellington. Newport. 'Nuff said. Five stars.

This is a weird choice for the only Duke Ellington to appear on the list. How many Beta Band records show up? Also, the list album is Ellington at Newport, and the linked album and art are from the complete version. Everyone complaining about the length is listening to the wrong album. Duke's signature work is from an era before the concept of albums, and his most exciting, innovative work came after this album. Weird choice.

I really wanted to like this, but I didn't. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ most Revisit ❌️ ★★☆☆☆ (4/10) Total reviewed : 333 Already owned : 76 Purchased : 16 To buy : 3 Nope : 238

Looked night and day for the shorter version. Unfortunately stuck with the one that lasts forever. This is never ever gonna be something j enjoy. It has none of the things I like about music. Performed well, skillful etc. But to my brain, and my less educated pallete, its uninteresting TWO HOURS AND SEVEN MINUTES

“Jazz is like life. It goes on for longer than you think, and then as soon as you’re like ‘oh, I get it’, it ends! 🎶And the next thing you know, you’re a ghost in a backpack🎶” - The Ghost of Duke Ellington

Absolut!

a ver, muy lindo de escuchar, pero son 2 horas de disco!!!!!!!! me muero del aburrimiento solo prestandole atencion a esto. es muy buena musica, mas de fondo. pero el disco en si como album nose me cansa. aunque se nota una charla en la musica, ademas de las presentaciones no ?

I have to be really honest — Being a live album is what kills it for me. Half the album is people talking, the instruments don't sound that great because it's a live album, and it feels kind of a shame. As for the music, I enjoyed it quite a bit, but the sound quality takes away points from it for me. Also TOO DAMN LONG.

Listening session: may 25th, while eating breakfast and getting ready in the morning Listened to before: no Thoughts: this must be some really good jazz (like the drum solo in Skin Deep), and I liked some parts, but 2 hours was too long for me to enjoy Favourite tracks: Pt. I-Festival Junction, Pt. II-Blues to Be There & Skin Deep

Fantastic. Surprisingly upbeat, I expected (like?) more melancholy from this kind of jazz. I wonder if the complete album is the one meant to be here or the original.

Que grande duke. Buen disco de jazz

Crowd went fucking mad for it didn’t they

Pretty wild to discover that duke Ellington is in fact not just a horrible caricature from that awful Big Mouth show But at the end of the day this is still jazz, and I’m still not loving it 2

Pretty long to listen at..

I do like jazz and do recognize Duke Ellington's talent but this was a LOT of jazz to sit through. Grew a bit tired of it by the end...

I hate rating this one so low.... but the whole point of me going through this list is to see what I like. I do not like this. Couldn't get past the first song. Maybe it's the best album in the history of jazz, but it's lost on me.

Amazing live performance

Music to my ears

Duke Ellington is one of America's greatest composers, this is one of his group's greatest recorded concerts, and the 1999 complete restored version is one of the most welcome musical resurrections of all time. This is as good as it gets.

Virtuosic but too trad for this dad

Cómo toca esta gente es impresionante. Nota: 3.4

Not my favorite genre. Very talented performers, though. 2.5/5.

Big Band not exactly my thing, but a rowdy and wonky 50s live recording IS exactly my thing. Extra star for all the times a horn was too loud for the mics and it sounded all fucked up

A very well-liked Jazz icon that I, ashamedly, know very little about. So I was quite eager to dive into this live record. Really made my workday that much more tolerable as I threw it on and immersed myself in its peaks and valleys for nearly 2 hours. It's a very easily digestible and light swing album; it has that fluttery feel that a lot of jazz albums of its time do. Say, for maybe the opener 'Black and Tan Fantasy', which feels more bitter than anything else here, with these odd, twisted solos. There's a lot of tension building on this track before you get that euphoric, explosive finish. It's a strange opener, but I dug it because right after that, you get 'Tea For Two,' which is the polar opposite side of the spectrum, an incredibly infectious and melodic track. There's a generally very dexterous feeling to the "Big Band" performances here - they're not super clunky or heavy, but agile, light as a feather, and very slick, elevated by the many spot-lit solos that almost lead the backing band, as opposed to the other way around; noticed this on "Take the 'A' Train" especially with that killer trumpet solo. But the band does ultimately remain feeling "Big", nothing about that's changed, you'll get these huge drowning horn jabs all over this thing that just scream "'50's swing". Some other highlights are 'Sophisticated Lady', which is this slow, brooding track over this much less outspoken, atmospheric backing piece. A mellowing change in pace. 'Dimineundeo in Blue' brings back that squawking sax over what is maybe the lightest playing in the concert yet, with Duke's piano remaining a highlight. I love the way it cools the atmosphere almost instantaneously, like closing the shutters of a once bright room, setting the tone for the solo to come. And apparently, this was the song that kicked off the riot captured in this performance; you can really hear the crowd growing restless as that monstrous tenor solo just keeps going for a good chunk of the song. I get it, it's a damn great solo. The vocal moments on this album were pretty good too, adding some variety, which there is already plenty of (in terms of players) - my favorite was the song 'Tulip Turnip.' Pretty good live record that manages to keep things fresh for its longer duration. I'm pretty sure I listened to the "Complete" version, which isn't what was originally intended, but the monolithic nature of this version, with the constant switching of soloists and players, made the whole thing feel very alive and dynamic. Great record.

Gets dinged a star for all the talking, though mercifully that's all isolated to its own tracks so you can easily skip it. Otherwise, perfect.

Nope. Not for me.

Primer musiquita en franchute

got bored

Det må erkendes at de er dygtige til deres instrumenter - og tror da også at det er en rimelig fed oplevelse live. Med det sagt er det næppe noget, som jeg kunne finde på at sætte på hjemme i stuen.

*74 Formel: + Skud ud til Clark Terry på trompeten + holy shit der er stemning på crowd + de spiller ualmindeligt tight - anders må få ret i at det er lidt noget tissemands-jazz = det er nok nært best in class - men det er ikke rigtig min favorit class.

Tungt og ikke mig

Tissemandsjazz Tænker, at der er en grund til, at jazz er blevet spillet på barer, hvor der også er blevet serveret champagne i spandevis og så mange baner, som din næsevæg kan klare. Det føles prætentiøst og noget, der kræver, at du er bedøvet for at kunne holde det ud eller i hvert fald at nyde det. 1.8

Dårligt mixet live-optagelser gør simpelthen ikke noget godt for mig. Når man så smider en stressinducerende trompet oveni, så er den altså svært at komme igennem.

Ved ikke hvad tissemandsjazz er, men jeg synes det her er helt okay. Big band jazz er ikke min favorit jazz genre, men det er svært at komme uden om hvor dygtig the Duke var og synes både det svinger og er lækkert. Er også godt med på hvor vigtig koncerten var, men synes ikke jeg får specielt meget ud af denne live optagelse i den sammenhæng.

Great easy listening for a jazz album. I thought it was exciting at times and sad in others. It’s crazy how expressive jazz can be. I really feel like during this experience, especially listening to this album I have started to get it.

I first tried listening to this on a train where I felt profoundly travel sick, so that wasn't the best start. I can't really get into the big bombastic tunes here but the slower, quieter ones are definitely interesting. 2.5, wouldn't listen again

Exhilarating stuff. It’s usually disheartening to see I’ve been served a live album up from the list, but occasionally they do deliver and those that do deliver are nearly always the jazz albums. This record is a living breathing document of Ellington’s Newport jazz festival set, and the crowd noise and compere butting into the songs makes you feel in the thick of it. Sound production is top notch too, they’ve done a really good job of giving these instruments the room they need to soar.

Heard of duke Ellington but never this album. 2 jazz albums in a row is interesting. Going to be hard to live up to miles Davis. Festival junction is a banger. Way more going on with this song than any of the miles Davis songs I just heard. Really cool horns obviously. Less piano with this one. Blues to be there is more similar to a miles Davis song. Less put together, very horn heavy. Still pretty good. Really really cool sounds on Newport up. Incredible horns. Doesn’t even need anything else. These songs feel a lot more orchestrated compared to miles Davis. I like that better, but I bet jazz purists don’t. Jeeps blues is very audibly pleasing. Definitely the best one so far. Awesome horns on diminuendo. They feel almost triumphant. Just a positive/fun song. With that being said it didn’t need to be 15 mins long. Great piano on a train. Supplemented by an awesome trumpet that comes in around the 2 mins mark. Sophistacted lady is just ok. Not too impressed with the rendition. Some cool sounds for sure just doesn’t grab me. Drums are crazy on skin deep. This has to be one of the first drum solos. I really like the live element as well. This is a really cool album. Not as polished as some of the jazz albums I’ve heard so far but just really fun. So many good elements. 3.4/5 stars.

Once again I'm wrestling with whether live albums should count... although I must admit that for jazz (a hugely improvisational genre) there's more merit to it than for most genres. Duke and his band play exceptionally well, and it's a great recording. The crowd going absolutely bananas and aggressively demanding more music feels more like it belongs at a metal gig than a jazz gig - but then again, metal fans would never be so impolite and disrespectful.

going way back to the 1950s for a legendary live jazz performance by sir duke ellington and his crew. it's said to be one of the most important jazz recordings in history, both by music critics/historians and by the library of congress. ellington's charisma and his efforts got him a nice record deal after the record released. despite what it may sound like, only a decent portion of the album is actually live. it's very elegant and wonderfully vintage jazz stylings, but the only thing that prevents me from rating it higher is the really crunchy mastering on most releases of the record. makes the horns and winds sound like nails on a chalkboard. i just loooathe any jazz album that insists on squealing at the highest pitch imaginable.

I've never really found the genre to be captivating, but this was a nice easy listening experience.

Live jazz album. Did they have to include the intros of all the musicians?? Sorry this is bog-standard jazz (by today's standards) with way too much speaking included. I'm sure it's historical, but it's not very fun to listen to. Diminuendo In Blue is a nice track, but far too long. Crowd love it, it's positively a riot for the 50s Ooh Skin Deep goes hard with the drums Best track - Black and Tan Fantasy, Tulip or Turnip, Skin Deep 3 stars - spoken sections are annoying but get less and less throughout and the musical skill and crowd enjoyment also grows

2/5 more jazz just not vibe im looking for

Great jazz.

Nice jazz, amazing trumpet skills, but not something I would want listen to generally speaking

El jazz no es lo mío

2/10- Mike and Josie Duke didn’t understand the assignment

A great album I love jazz so much

It’s jazz

Solid live jazz album Standout song: Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue

Not my kind of music

no me gusto, muy de estados unidos

Jazz is not really my thing

C'est choubidou

C'était pas mal plus l'fun que d'écouter Deep Purple au Japon la veille.

Not for me.

i fucking love jazz. what an amazing album

Bara fínasti jazz (ef maður hlustar á upprunalegu plötuna). Ekkert of kreisí, og nokkrir góðir hook-ar.

One of the greatest jazz composers

Pt.1 - Festival Junction - 4/5 Pt. 2 - Blues to Be There - 4/5 Pt. 3 - Newport Up - 4/5 Jeep's Blues - 4/5 Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue - 5/5 Half of this is a studio album masquerading as a live album because Ellington was a perfectionist and didn't like how the first suite sounded live and wanted another go at it, adding in canned applause and other sounds to make it sound live. That part doesn't detract from the part that lifts it up, the nearly 7 minute sax solo on Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue. That alone is worth 5 stars, but I'll have to take a star off for faking the live recording. Overall: 4/5 Favorites: Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue

Almost perfect, just a little too "big bandy" for me.

The year is 1956, and everyone is breathing jazz. This album feels less like a standalone record and more like a time capsule from another era. For about an hour, you get to experience a small piece of history. The band is excellent, and the music flows effortlessly. That being said, while I admire the craftsmanship, I couldn’t truly connect with it emotionally. I found myself more fascinated by the era surrounding the album than by the album itself. "Blues to Be There" is my top pick.

This was really hard to rate. At first, a few songs in, I would have said this is live jazz at it's worst. The mix isn't great, the constant breaks in music to announce the next song is annoying, and the energy seems off. All that being said, as it goes on the energy shifts, and everything starts building and building to that Paul Gonsalves solo in "Dimuendo In Blue" and goddamn if you aren't ready to riot along with the festival attendees by the time you're 3/4 of the way through that solo. As a cohesive album? Ehh I dunno. As a showcase of live jazz when everything clicks and comes together right at the end? Perfect

good enough jazz

MUY largo. Demasiado, pero tiene muy buenos temas. Lástima que no escuché todos.

jazz no ta bueno 2/5

The Spotify version is over 2 hours long...Yeah, not doing that!! Found a condensed version on YouTube, which was okay (for jazz!). At least there was some melody and everyone seemed to be playing the same tune!! Historically, a big deal, occasionally engaging, frequently a bit… much.

A bit long hey yho

This was objectively excellent.

-este album se siente a esos videos en tiktok que parecen pinturas de acuarela pero como que se empiezan a mover -vibes de Soul la peli -el jazz esta underrated -hubo un momento en que si se sintio medio larguito, pero chance es porque no escucho jazz muy seguido -vibes de que los Aristogatos tocan esto lol

Big band sound's not my cup of tea, and this Complete version is a little too complete, but there are some tracks I love (Diminuendo in Blue)! Great recording, sound quality is tops.

Malisimo se la pasa hablando el negro este me canso si no estuviese hablando la mitad del disco le daba mas estrellas pero me agarro en un dia sin paciencia es un 1

Man, some really good grooves on this one. Also, was unaware that a trumpet could produce notes so high... damn. Minus one star 'cause it's live and we all know how I feel about that.

Old head jazz is always gonna be boring but I didn’t hate this enough to give it 1 star

I like jazz

I knew because I got a 5 star album yesterday, I would get something I hated today. I was right!! I got my “favorite” genre of music - JAZZ! I didn’t like this, but it was better than some of the previous jazz albums I’ve had to listen to because it was more big band than straight jazz.

Duke Ellington really understands how to manage the ebb and flow of a tune. Each rendition on this record is absolutely breathtaking. The band is completely in sync as they follow the pull of the music, managing complex dynamics and outstanding solos with grace.

i love the energy and i wish i could have been there

Trop bien !

I don’t think I’ll ever be able to get into big band jazz. I can recognise the excellence on show here. I can tell there is a story going on with the recording too. Ellington is obviously an absolute master of the game. It’s just that, even as someone who can safely now call themselves a jazz fan, the particular aesthetic presented is not one that resonates with me. I find it hard to put a score on something that is obviously top class but doesn’t work for me. I want to rate things on my own feelings though, and the piece of art as I experience it, so while I’m likely to skew my taste average for jazz in general, I’m going to have to be harsh here.

What a dreamy listen, loved this silkie smooth stuff

While jazz isn’t really my thing I can appreciate the musicianship demonstrated on this record. It’s flawless and hard to believe it’s live. Unfortunately I find jazz to be a bit long winded and dare I say boring! Sorry! But this gets an extra star from me because of the playing.

Not a huge jazz fan, but I’m sure this was a classic in its day

Big band jazz isn’t my thing, and I suspect I’m not going to come across a recording that is going to change my mind, but I didn’t mind this. I’m of two minds about the live format: I didn’t care for the announcer or the crowd noise; that said, the band has an energy on record here that might have been difficult to reproduce in the studio. The issue for me, and this is all a matter of taste, is that I just don’t care that much for this as an active listen. I prefer this on in the background rather than something I’m paying close attention to.

Them white people was going UP for Duke at this concert goddamn. So much control Highlights: Blues To Be There, Take The A Train

I went back and forth a bit on the sound, both the occasionally intrusive crowd noise and some tracks where the orchestra felt muted, but the performances are really a lot of fun. Big band orchestras are not really my thing, but I loved it especially when the clarinet was featured. Like I said, I went back and forth between wishing this was performed in the studio and recognizing that the live performance was truly electric, but I wouldn't dispute including this on a list of must-listen jazz albums. 4/5

Going from Duke Ellington to Snoop Dogg was quite the change and what a difference 40 years makes! Interesting to hear the most popular style of music before Elvis/Chuck Berry/Beatles. Sped up jazz with big beats and fun solos. Not my favorite music but interesting to hear this slice of Americana. Set the tone for a generation that 'if you become a great musician, you'll be successful & famous.'

I suppose it was kind of interesting hearing the big band jazz compared to the other more improvised, strung out 'cooler' type. I feel this had a bit more going for it, for someone completed disinterested in jazz that is

Jazz nice. Or not. By far not the worse jazz album iv generated. Some of these songs were enjoyable and had a tune. However one of the tracks sounded like a bee trapped in a bottle. Not for me but tolerable.

I still don't like Jazz, but this is a very cool time capsule of a major musical moment that is essential. I will also never listen to goddamn two hours of jazz in a row again.

This was very easy to listen to

I imagine this would have been even better had it been recorded at a studio, but it's still great.

I'm like 50% sure I already listened to this album. Not really, but how many mid-centrury live jazz albums are on here? I accidentally had the album set to shuffle, so maybe I didn't get the entire experience, but I don't need to listen to it again to get the full picture. it's jazz. there are long-ass drum solos. The audience is really into it though, which definitely enhances the experience.

the music was fine but why do i have to listen to an album where every second song is him talking. i’m over live albums

2/10 Not a jazz guy, sorry :(

A classic

A vibrant and demanding presence on this live jazz record. Crowd participation and announcement interludes contribute to the experience. Particularly admired the unconventional works of the trumpeter on Festival Junction. Throughout this record we won’t just witness the riff of spontaneity of the live jazz experience, but also time travel to the slight spice that the 50’s carried. I’ve been to Ronnie Scott’s in ‘26 yet something still feels difference here. The rowdiness in crowd prevention is incredible and the way it recharges itself and merges into Skin Deep is awesome.

Duke Ellington's performance on July 8th, 1956 in Newport, Rhode Island.

Interesting. Not my cup of tea but good piano vibe

Great live album demonstrating straight recording without overdubs and post manipulation

I am evidently in the minority in that I really like a live album. Usually (The Who's Live at Leeds isn't great; I'm sure there are others). Nothing like getting that feel for an artist.

Highlights: Festival Junction Just for notice, I only listened to the tracks from the original pressing (the link takes you to some complete edition). I don't feel like giving away two hours of my time for this type of instrumental jazz. I do like a big band record from time to time, but this just wasn't the one. It was just ok, but my barbaric uncultured ahh just doesn't see what's so special about this live recording... Not the first, not the last.

It was long, it was live, and half the "tracks" were just introductions, but its Duke Ellington, and jazz kinda gets a pass for the live music thing. Beautiful music.

Gorgeous. At one point while listening, I felt like I was inside a noir movie. A master no wonder they called him "Duke."

I’m sure it was an amazing night and the music is great, but listening to a live recording is like drinking lukewarm tea. It fails to capture the physical vibe, yet it's cluttered enough to obscure the intricacies

Banger after banger.

First jazz album for me, pleasant. Didn’t feel too detached for me given the year of release.

fletcher flashbacks

Pretty smooth jazz performance. The guy on the trump had rent due I guess because he kinda went in.

A bit before my time but overall good. Wish it had been remastered so the sound quality was better.

Pretty damn great!

Great Songs: Pt. 1-Festival Junction, Sophisticated Lady, Day In, Day Out Good Songs: Black and Tan Fantasy, Tea for Two, Take the "a" Train, Pt. II- Blues to Be There, Pt. III-Newport Up, Diminuendo in Blue, Jeep's Blues, Tulip or Turnip, Skin Deep Mid Songs: The Star Spangled Banner, Duke Introduces Cook & Tune, Duke Announces Strayhorn's a Train & Nance Duke Introduces Festival Suite, Pt. I, Duke Announces Soloists / Introduces Pt. II, Duke Announces Hamilton, Gonsalves, & Terry / Duke Introduces Carney & Tune, Duke Announces Grissom & Tune, Duke Introduce Tune(s) and Paul Gonsalves Interludes, Duke Introduces Johnny Hodges, I Got It Bad (And That Ain't Good), Duke Calms Crowd, Introduces Nance & Tune, Riot Prevention, Mood Indigo, Studio Concert Bad Songs: Father Norman O'Connor Introduces Duke & the Orchestra, Duke & Band Leave Stage, Duke Announces Nance & Procope / Introduces Pt. III, Announcements, Pandemonium

Nice old style jazz.

ohh me encanta este género de música

LONG asf. all i could hear was speaking and 🎺

Amazing stuff. The recording was great too. It felt like I was there on the front row.

Funny to get this album directly after the Who's Live at Leeds. It leads to comparison. While I usually like this album, I certainly enjoyed listening to it again. The Live at Leeds blows it away with both its fidelity and skill. Duke is not Townsend, of course, and he was going for something different: a greater soundscape and certainly more lyrical moments. Those don't have as well, or as desirable as, the Who's raw talent. In other words, I would take Ellington in the studio and the Who live any day.

very easy to listen to. i don't sit thru a lot of full jaz albums.

I genuinely loved this. Easy to listen to

Man I really can't stand jazz or live albums like 90% of the time. Thank god they sound competent.

Funky jazz

This album slapped way harder than it had any right to. Really funky tracks with some absolutely insane musical talent on display. I did only listen to the 5 tracks from the original LP, which I think probably saved this album from some harsher criticism, particularly since I really dislike Live albums. As a brass player myself, I am in awe of the trumpet playing here, it's nuts. This album isn't something I'm going to listen to again, but I can't rate it lower than a 4 out of sheer respect for the insane talent on display. Great playing, enjoyable music, very good album.

The first song blew me away. Full of texture, raw and interesting was over before I knew it and I was looking forward to more. 5/5 2nd song was a bit too slow for my liking but not bad. 2/5 3rd song kinda just had me stressed the whole time... 2/5 4th song we're back to the slow stuff the 1st song was so good come on... I'll admit that this one is more interesting than the 2nd song 3/5 5th song... 15 minutes... the bar is high the crowd slowly getting louder during the solo is so crazy to me... I hate solos and this one has been going on for so long.... is it ever going to end... I kinda can't believe this crowd sound is real, at concerts I've been at their will be the occasional holler during a solo or something, this is constant. okay the solo is finally over. This ending is genuinely amazing why did they spend so long on a dull solo????? 2/5 -> 4/5 wtf do I rate this begrudging 3 carried by the 1st song and the last 2 minutes of the last song

This is some of the better jazz I've listened to. I still can't get on with it but it's better than some of the more the pretentious smug stuff. And it's fairly short (I didn't listen to the double disc extended edition, over 2 hours!). Ok, which is a complement from me when it comes to jazz.

I'm giving this points for the obviously great musicianship alone and influence he has had on the genre and music as a whole, but this older/more traditional jazz is just something that I don't find myself personally resonating with all that much, plus the fact that this is a live recording isn't ideal either as it doesn't sound too clear. 3/5

A pretty lively big band set--but not nearly as great as Duke's earlier eras--except for the famous solo in 'Diminuendo/Crescendo' which gets everyone hopping. That's a blast.

Loose and swingy; virtuosic. I listened to this one on background, I admit.

Sure. Fine. My general reaction to every jazz record I've had on this list. Perfectly pleasant to listen to...nothing that gets me excited or that I’ll likely listen to again.

Big band jazz era end, Great sunday morning Dimineuendo and crescendo in blue

Too long, too much announcing, and trumpet too loud. Otherwise enjoyed this album. Rating: 5/10 Favorite Song: Tea for Two

largo como puteada de tartamudo pero i like jazzzzz

Buenas cosas, pero larguísimo. Me gustó igual

Netto gutes Album, Brutto viel Schrott und sinnlose Saalaufnahmen dabei

Jeder gerade Song ist überraschend gut. Jeder Ungerade ist langweiliges Gerede darüber wie gut die geraden Songs sind...

Great live recording.

Oof, that was long, and a live album, which I personally don't like. The album is kinda ok, but the recording is not great and there are introductions as well. I can kinda see why it is on the list butvit was hard to enjoy with the poor recording in an outsoors event. Not my favourite jazz album from this list. 3/5

I think I like trios, quartets better. This was also amazing. The energy must’ve been crazy live. Lower 4

The talent throughout this album is through the roof. That part is irrefutable. On this note, I enjoy the genre, and I'm taking into consideration this has to be one of the oldest albums in this generator. With that out of the way, it's literally difficult to hear the music, especially with the talking, and audience. There are great live albums, but this one is almost too overbearing. Favorite Track: "Festival Junction".

Nice jazz

enjoyed it, but i also intentionally listened to only the songs that were on the original album :)

a 2+ hour live album (compilation?) that keeps in all the annoying parts of listening to live music. awesome. that said, it's duke ellington so credit where credit's due. probably not coming back to this when the studio takes are much more listenable though. tulip or turnip is a gardening banger though favorites: the star spangled banner (lol), black and tan fantasy, take the 'a' train, tulip or turnip

Enjoyable. ★★★

This has felt a little more lackluster(?) than other Jazz albums I've heard on this journey, but it hasn't been without it's charms. I was surprised how much air was utilised in "Blues To Be There"; there were times I had to check that the track was still playing. Listening to a recording of something like this live, and from so long ago, I can't help but feel that something is missing that was there for the audience when it was recorded in '56. "Diminuendo And Crescendo In Blue" started well enough, but the longer it goes on, the easier it is to lose focus, especially as the audience noises do more to interrupt than enhance the atmosphere. Overall, this another one of those albums that was simply "nice enough".

Don't like it

I can't tell one jazz from another. Probably obvious if you read my notes for other albums. This seemed like a decent enough jazz to me though.

Really enjoyed this as another turn of pace from the general rock that's been given so far (on album 26). The quality was great, as if it's being played by a jazz band today, and I quite liked the introductions between the songs of each artist. Sort of felt like you were sat with a martini watching it yourself.

I’m sure it’s great, stellar outfit but I just can’t get into jazz

There is a lot of Jazz in this list. I don't mind it, and enjoy it, but it is not a genre I listen to purposefully or collect. It was a good listen. I would listen to it again, but not necessarily by choice. 3 stars

"Ellington at Newport" is a live jazz album by American jazz pianist, composer and orchestra leader Duke Ellington and his band of his concert at the 1956 Newport Jazz Festival. Jazz and big band are the Wiki-listed genres. Some critics have called it the greatest performance of his career and stood for everything jazz had been and could be. Ellington was the band leader and played piano. His band included on trumpet (Cat Anderson, Willie Cook, Ray Nance, Clark Terry, Herbie Jones), on Trombone (Quentin Jackson, John Sanders, Brittany Woodman), Johnny Hodges (alto sax), Russell Procope ( alto sax, clarinet), Paul Gonsalves (tenor sax), Harry Carey(baritone sax), Jimmy Hamilton (clarinet), Jimmy Woode (double bass), Al Lucas (bass), Jimmy Grisdom (vocals) and Sam Woodyard (drums). In 2022, the album was entered into the US National Recording Registry by the Library of Congress for its artistic significance. A baritone sax solo by Harry Carey opens "Festival Junction." Ellington's piano and the band kicks in. The alto sax continues the lead supplemented by other horns. The layering of horns begins and there's that big band sound. A quick tempo more in the bepop jazz area. "Blues to Be There" slows things down. Piano and sultry horns. Stark. The trumpet is in the lead. The song goes big band at the end. The standout track on the album is "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue." Snappy jazzy drum tick and a piano. Horns blast and glorious horn layering. Handclaps start, the pace picks up and Paul Gonsalves comes in with a tenor sax. Gonsalves continues to solo for eight minutes and the crowd erupts. The song ends with an explosion of horns. The songs are split between a couple of bluesy songs with the remainder a big band sound with horn solos and layering of horns. And the layering of horns is the best I've heard. The beat changes between and sometimes within songs going from a quicker bebop tempo to slow and bluesy. The drums and piano tend to control the pace with the horns following. It's unclear (from what I've read) if the audience noise was overdubbed in or not but, regardless, they are very enthusiastic. This was a joy to listen to and, if you are any bit of a jazz or big band fan, this is a must listen.

I really liked the jazz of Ellington of the 50s. Im actually a jazz lover, Ive heard before to Ellington, however I didnt listen this album before. I just have one note about something in particular of this album and is the high pitched trumpet that I didnt LOVE but recognise as a new musical sound.

I can see this being a pinnacle of the genre, but I'm just not that big of a fan of the genre to begin with.

Ellington at Newport captures exhilarating performances, masterful improvisation, and infectious audience energy, transforming live jazz into something vibrant, historic, and endlessly replayable, proving why this concert remains one of the genre’s defining recordings decades after its original release for listeners.

Finally managed to listen to this - I enjoyed the big band jazz and appreciated the musicianship all round. You could tell there were technical problems with the recording, and the chap who talks in between stuff got way too much time on this record, but all in all quite enjoyable. Made a nice change.

Jazz 🫰

Less yakking more music

I'm not a musician. At most, I'm an amateur music historian. Listening to this gave me a small window into what Newport in the 1950s could have been like. It's interesting to imagine what the music, race, and cultural exchanges between Duke Ellington's audience and the Newport crowd could have been like. Listen to the crowd getting upset when Father O'Connor suggests the band might be done. The crowd wants more. I think the 1950s were more complicated than people expect.

It’s technically very good, but just feels a bit trad jazz and straight laced to be exciting. The live recording was annoying andI just found it a bit dull

This is the first jazz album on the list that made me somewhat understand what people see in it as a genre. For a brief moment. I found myself actively listening around halfway through “Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue” - not unlike the audience, I became engrossed in the (genuinely incredible) saxophone. But then the ending sounded like a dog’s toy - and I quickly caught myself, remembering that me and jazz are not friends.

I do not care it has been raining for the last two days in Newport in July 1956, Father Norman O'Connor! At the point the introduction to this album felt like it would continue for eternity, I bailed on the "Complete" version and jumped to the "Original" version, because I was going to throw something if I had to listen to 2 hours 7 minutes of this. 1 hour 6 minutes (which Amazon claims in the original, despite Wikipedia telling me it was originally 43 minutes) felt more doable. And presumably cut out some of the priest ramblings. I don't like jazz. I do generally like big band/swing, so this at least gave it a chance. I might have said this before, but I think I could possibly see me liking this sort of thing if I was sat in a club having a drink, watching the world go by. I don't like it when I'm doing the washing up. Jazz feels like music for a specific place to me. This was just about ok. Clearly very talented musicians who play off each other very well, but it's just not something I want to listen to. And I'm saying that after listening to the short version! 2/5

this isn’t really my kind of music however I really like that sense of nostalgia this gives me and I just created a nostalgia playlist haha what a coincidence but anyway the sax playing is phenomenal. as someone who isn’t the hugest fan of jazz but can appreciate good music, I think this album shows a high degree of quality playing aswell as amazing vocals!!

The last half of show fucks.

Do ya like jazz?

Sorry, Duke, but I just don't like jazz. Sounded like the crowd was having a great time, which was nice.

Larguísimo. Me duermo en vivo.

Que excelente experiencia, siempre ha gustado el Jazz, lo más gracioso es que conocí a Duke por la serie de Netflix big mouth primero jajajaaj, su álbum no me defraudo. Me encanto.

Clearly great but I’m not really into big band jazz—feels too old timey for me.

I like all Jazz

(Accidentally?) listened to the two hour version of this live performance. 0 regrets. I understand now and have infinite fomo of not being in the rowdy ass crowd from this show. "Duke calms the crowd down" come tf on

Love that I got this album just as I was watching Carol. Never listened to jazz before that much, so it's nice that my first proper listen to an album was one by Duke Ellington, who's apparently a legend within the genre.

Classic Duke Ellington

Me gusto la primera(la conocia) y la ultima del album

Diminuendo and crescendo was a joyful 15 minutes was so fun, skin deep drum solo ripped. Took until the fourth piece to really get going, did not love festival Junction.

Ik vind big bands altijd leuk om te kijken op youtube. Ook duke ellington heb ik op youtube gezien en heel leuk. Ik vind het wel minder leuk om dit als album voor mijzelf te luisteren. Het is wel heel goed, maar ik mis toch de experience van de show

Big band Jazz is meestal niet mijn favoriete jazz. Duke Ellington staat ook niet bij mijn favoriete jazz muziekanten. Het is een smaak ding, van mij hoeft de dansbare swing ook niet. Op dit twee uur durende album zitten zeker goede momenten, maar als geheel is het niet interessant genoeg voor mij. Het live gevoel voegt zeker iets toe, maar de opname is niet optimaal, je krijgt meer de sfeer mee, niet zozeer de individuele muzikanten. De composities zijn goed en de arrangementen voor de band zijn leuk, maar daardoor gaat ook een groot deel van het improvisatorisch wat je meer in bebop etc tegen komt, iets wat ik zelf leuker vind. Ik zal de technische capaciteit van Duke Ellington zeker niet ter discussie stellen. Zijn album met Coltrane vind ik bijvoorbeeld vele malen sterker, juist omdat daar het improvisatorische en de interactie veel meer tot zijn recht komt.

In het nummer festival junction vind ik t vet hoe die trompet haast “hui- hui” zegt. Het publiek speelt ook een erg belangrijke rol op dit album, het is vet om te horen dat ze af en toe helemaal leip worden op bepaalde momenten. Als je luistert naar t publiek weet je wanneer je moet opletten. Verder is de dynamiek erg tof. Ik had er wel bij willen zijn in 1956.

I can hear and respect the talent on wild display. I can understand and even appreciate why so many love jazz like they do, but frankly I just don’t particularly enjoy it. This is no exception. Stay tuned.

Incredible jazz, even my four year old could tell

It's good but some of the sharp horn bleating is off-putting for me

Pretty cool album. I can dig it daddy-o. Some truly amazing moments in here. The 2 hour runtime can be a bit off-putting, but a clever digital listener might be able to reduce that by selectively hiding some of the banter tracks, though that might arguably take away some of the charm of this one.

Loved it!

Love the Duke

I've got a soft-spot for big band jazz. It's weird because I rarely ever choose to put it on, but I almost always enjoy listening to it. There's some really interesting history about the recording of this album and the re-release for CD in 1999, so I ended up listening to this twice so that I could try and hear the differences between what was recreated for the original LP versus what was remixed and remastered from the performance for the re-release. Maybe not one I'll come back to often, but gotta give it credit for multiple listens in one sitting. 3.25/5

Good jazz. Jazz isn't always my thing but this one is good. 3.5/5

There are trumpet sounds I wouldn't think possible. I just wish it wasn't a live album. It drags it down a decent amount unfortunately.

This is a very good live jazz album. The short spoken interludes from Duke Ellington and the audience's cheers definitely add a thrill to the music, and the drum solos on the last track ("Skin Deep") are excellent.

Jazz isn’t my fave but overall it was fun and interesting. Prefer the more lively, but could all be background music for a classy glass of wine on the deck. crescendo in blue a fave.

What jazz is!

Transported to a jazz bar

I’m blown away by the energy from this live show from before I was born. This rivals kind of blue

Some really really good solos

Very impressive for a live performance and how long it went. Overall good but not my thing

What masters! A bit overindulgent with the trumpet sometimes though.

im dead im listening to the star spangled banner at 8:30am my besties are from newport this is cute they both would have the same reaction to the star spangled banner at 8:30am now it's a podcast okayyy duke ahead of his time tbh the only time i heard duke ellington was in big mouth so sorry 38 SONGS?? girl 2 hours of club penguin pizzeria music favorite song: idk i gave up

Technically wonderful but it's not my style. I'm not a fan of the high-pitched trumpet. 3/5

I’ve heard this before, but it’s been almost 30 years. My college roommate had this one and I’m guessing every other pre 1970 jazz record on this list will have been in his collection. There’s too many versions of this album and I clicked on the 2 hour double disk one. Listened all the way through that and then found the original 40 minute version. I’m not a big fan of big band jazz but Duke Ellington is a head above the rest. Also they seem to have added some of the bebop style here instead of stagnating I dig it and I’m gonna listen to every version of this again.

Very nice

*I prefer quartet/quintet style jazz of eras a little later than this, but this live performance is about as good as big band can get.

I like his jazz better than others but I’m still not an overall fan of jazz.

objectively good music and good musicians but oh my this was a looong listen for someone who's only sorta into jazz

I looked up if I wasn’t listening to the jungle book soundtrack, but turns out that’s even something different

- kyl hyvä kunnon jatsi toimittelee ja toimitteli taas

Sounds pretty good! I’m not a big enough jazz fan to understand all the nuances of the music, though.

Jazzy but too many talking (no music) tracks.

Litt mye snakking for min del.

A vivid and exciting document: at times tasteful and restrained and at others giving way to ecstatic indulgence (if Wikipedia is to be believed, the live recording was blended with studio overdubs thanks to a little sleight of hand, but it doesn’t detract from the experience). I listened to the original LP track listing but I’m pleased to see that there’s much more material to indulge in.

The energy is palatable here. Jazz is an emotion, a state of being....and Ellington really transcends that here. All these years later a modern day listener is still enamored by the fantastic playing of all of these artists, especially on "Diminuendo and Crescendo in Blue" a song older than most human beings on this earth are today. Crazy to think that.

Bueno para poner de fondo 8 am

Jazz clasico, como si estuvieras en un bar por los años 50

Pretty easy 5 stars here

Big band jazz at its best. 5 stars.

Dammit! Duke is amazing, and his playing on this reflects that talent and wonderful sound... Only to be ruined by talking and the audience (the clapping was a big let down). Rarely does a live album do anything right.

Jazz works better live

i'm not a big fan of jazz, i don't really listen to it, so this album to me sounds like any other jazz performance. i can't really tell what makes jazz good (or bad), unless i hear something new or innovative in the songs that works really well with the already established sounds of the genre. but this record just sounds like the most stereotypical jazz album to me. this album is what you think of when someone says the word 'jazz'. and maybe that's a good thing, i guess it shows that you're really good at the genre that you are performing. anyways, 1/5 because i felt like i was actively suffering and felt no enjoyment while listening to this.

Duke has always been my favorite big-band leader and composer. It strikes the right balance: fun without being sweet, intellectual without being overly cerebral. He really is a towering figure of American art. And there are some jaw-dropping instrumental performances here.

I've enjoyed that but it hasn't made me want to listen to it again. There's nothing wrong but maybe there's nothing catchy about it.

Maybe I'm simple minded, this kind of jazz shares with some classical music a kind of lack of discernible pattern of cycle that i don't really like. Talented musicians for sure though.