Reviews (page 11 of 15)
Part #625 of “I don’t like this as much as I’m supposed to.” But I do like it. And I LOVE “Cherub Rock”. Just not an all-time favorite. 3.5/5
I've already heard melon collie and I've passed through one or two songs here but this project overall is amazing, near perfect, and remarkably produced. How it didn't make it's way into the Apple music top 100 is beyond me.. Every track brings it's own significance that makes each one special to me. I can't think of a bad song on this record realistically! Cherub Rock and Disarm are just two examples of perfect tracks. The electric guitar distortions makes this entire thing feel destructive and powerful. The band even feels a bit ahead of their competitors on this LP for the time it released.
Really cool grunge rock album.
5/5
Bands on the cusp of a breakthrough are at their most interesting and their most unpredictable. Before the Pumpkins became the Led Zeppelin of Alternative Rock, before Billy Corgan became the bald, monk of underground rage, before they released their hit-making magnum opus, there was the dense, fuzz guitar anthem “Cherub Rock” and its haunting acoustic cousin “Disarm,” which arguably goes harder than any of the blistering guitar assaults the band ever produced. “Today” is a spiritual companion to “Smells Like Teen Spirit,” and it might be the only successful single in Rock history to simultaneously warn against suicide while celebrating a release from this veil of tears. For fans of guitar-based Rock, the Pumpkins offer layer after layer, with Corgan and James Iha making the case for the best, most effective guitar partnership of the last 30 years. Their debut was an exciting promissory note for ‘90s Rock. “Siamese Dream” delivered on that promise, paying that investment back, and then some.
I've never known an album start so well for the first five tracks and then get a little worse each time until the end. The high energy at the start just drifts into slow meandering walllowy music, which I find boring. There's one exception around track 9/10, which is actually a decent song, but then it drags out a completely unnecessary middle section and kills the song. This and Mellon collie show that the pumpkins were a band who needed someone to tell them no sometimes
Except for maybe Abbey Road, I doubt that I have listened to any album on this list more than Siamese Dream by The Smashing Pumpkins. This was one of my stone cold favorites in college. I knew some of the songs, especially "Today" and "Disarm," but I really got into the Pumpkins and this album when Mellon Collie came out. I saw them twice on that tour, late '96 and early '97. There were a few amazing singles off of this record, but many of the tracks aren't just songs. They are spacey, anthemic, prog-rock compositions produced from the context of a 90s alternative ethos. So much of my music taste was introduced to me by this band and this album. Creativity must have been just pouring from Billy Corgan during this period. Every song ebs, flows, changes, spaces out, and dive bombs back in. I love this record. I have always loved this record. I will always love this record. Five stars.
I do like it a lot, but it's one of those albums that I can't seem to fall in love completely with
I didn’t remember the pumpkins rocking this hard
Amazing top to bottom. Rocket is my new favorite song.
Enjoyed album. Sweet sweet was very good
i like this a lot actually 4/5 tho bc the songs are all long as fuck
Smashing Pumpkins – “Siamese Dream” So I normally don’t do this, but we sorta had an “Album Club” a few years back with some friends of mine, and “Siamese Dream” was one of the albums that we reviewed – so here is what I wrote up back then… I have always enjoyed the Smashing Pumpkins – though you could probably say that appreciation has been “from more of a distance”. They came along in the midst of my working a full-time position at the hospital, while going to graduate school, all while raising 3 kids (i.e. my youngest was born in 1989). I have referred to this period as sort of my “blind spot” when it comes to music. It’s not that I wasn’t familiar with the bands of the era or their music, it’s just that I was not able to devote the kind of attention to those albums, the way I was when I was young… So I had this album in the collection, and was extremely familiar with each of the songs that found their way into heavy rotation in my area (i.e. “Cherub Rock”, “Today”, “Disarm”, and “Rocket”…). What I found interesting with this exercise, is that I can’t remember a single time when I ever really listened to this album from start-to-finish. Not sure why, but I think I thought of it more as a collection of songs, as opposed to a true album. So this little journey has been good for me in that respect… What has always attracted me to the band, has been the incredible uniqueness of their sound – as in they really don’t sound like anyone else – which always scores high marks with me. And while I can’t qualify it, they have always sorta had a “progressive” feel to them, which also serves them well in my book. However, I have found that the not-quite-as-popular songs of the Pumpkins (i.e. the ones that I think are well done…) really do tend to age well in my eyes… Not sure why, but this is a clear trend for me with this band – and there is one song off of this album that fits that bill exactly – for example sorta like “Rhinoceros” was for me off of their first album. I am also happy to report that after this little exercise, I have added a couple of more of those “not-quite-as-popular-but-they-really-seem-to-work-for-me” tunes to the collection from this album… Also have to add that while I generally prefer live offerings to the studio, that is NOT the case with this album. It’s not that they are poor live renditions or anything like that, but they really captured a unique sound on this album, and I really think there was just no way to recreate all of the nuances in the live setting. As for my track-by-track thoughts, here we go, and I paid no special attention to lyrics, just what seemed to stand out as I moved through the album, so most songs are taken as a whole… 1. “Cherub Rock” – 5-stars out of 7… This my friends, is THE perfect way to introduce the listener to THIS album! It clearly announces the arrival of the sound, tempo, and style right from the starting gate. There is not another song on the album that could have filled that lead-off spot, which created the perfect mood for what is about to follow… 2. “Quiet” – 3-stars out of 7… Someone once said that all of our Presidents can’t be Jefferson’s and Lincoln’s, and the same holds true for Smashing Pumpkins songs on this album. Not that this is a bad song – because it is NOT, but by comparison, it is one of the weakest on the album. And even after repeated listens (i.e. and I probably listened to the whole thing all the way through 5 or 6 times – in addition to extra listens for particular tracks…) it never gained any traction with me… 3. “Today” – 6-stars out of 7… So if this were the first time that I had ever heard this album, we’d have that great start, but then we’d have that backslide with “Quiet”, and then my mind would start to wonder… But then just when I was about to really question things, “Today” comes on – and then all is right with the world! Incredibly original, and I really enjoyed the softer parts in contrast to the bombastic sections. This is a spectacular song all the way around… 4. “Hummer” – 7-stars out of 7… So for me, this was the eye-opener of the album. I don’t ever remember hearing this one back in the day. I’m sure I did, but my attention span must not have been there at all as I have no recollection. The more I listened to this one, the more I absolutely fell in love with it… Just feels like a truly complete song in every way, and is about as perfect as it gets… Don’t think I’ve ever experienced as much of a disconnect between listens to a single song ever, which is in part what is really striking for me. In my opinion, one of the best songs on the album, and I wish it were 12-minutes long… 5. “Rocket” – 5-stars out of 7… Another one of the big four that I was quite familiar with – and probably the weakest of the 4 “hits”… Still good to listen to, and no real complaints here – just found some of the other options far more deep and compelling… 6. “Disarm” – 6-stars out of 7… The last of The Big 4 – and also an incredibly original track. The diversity between those four popular songs, is probably one of the greatest strengths of the album, and probably something that helped contribute to its success in attracting listeners from different musical persuasions to this creative and well-constructed album… 7. “Soma” – 4-stars out of 7… Here is the next of the not-quite-as-popular tracks that has really grown on me – though I do remember this one from my initial listening’s. Doesn’t quite have the grab of “Hummer”, but I enjoyed the relaxed pace, and it is perfectly slotted in the album’s running order between “Disarm” and “Geek USA”. Also really enjoy the piano sections on this one… 8. “Geek U.S.A.” – 5-stars out of 7… This is one of the two really loud, fast, and rambling efforts on this album (the other being “Silverfuck”) and of the two – THIS is the one that I prefer by far! A bit of an unbridled feel to it – which is always appealing, and the music has just a hint of Soundgarden to it which doesn’t hurt either. Also has sort of that musical theme component (i.e. a repeat of a musical section from a previous segment of the album) that runs through the slower mid-section (i.e. the part right after Billy sings the “Siamese Twins” line…). Just another really complete effort, featuring an awesome display of musicianship! 9. “Mayonaise” – 7-stars out of 7… So when I mentioned earlier that “other” song of the “not-quite-as-popular” ilk that I had been hooked on early in my original listening’s of this album – well this is the song that I was referring to. When we were at the beach, if someone held a gun to my head and said, what is the best song on the album – I would have said “Mayonaise”, and it wouldn’t have been close! Now that says a lot because of just how good it think the more popular songs are, but for me – this is it, and it will always be my favorite – as well as the defining song of the album for me! The fact that it was able to work its way onto my musical psyche despite work, grad school, and 3 young children says an awful lot… Pure perfection as far as I am concerned… 10. “Spaceboy” – 4-stars out of 7… No real strong feelings here either way, as it is not bad – but it just doesn’t really measure up to the run of songs that leads up to it – but how could it… That string had to end at some point… 11. “Silverfuck” – 3-stars out of 7… Okay – this is probably where I may differ from several of you, but I really don’t like this one… Sure there are snippets here and there that I’m okay with, but as a whole, it just comes across as bloated, excessive, NOT all-that-original, and fairly simplistic as compared to the rest of the album. The energy is fine, and the musicianship is always top notch, but even after repeated listening’s, I found myself actually saying “…Dear God – this is almost 9 minutes of my life that I’m not going to get back…”. This is the song that I’m really looking for answers to – so if anyone can help me understand what I am missing here, please share… 12. “Sweet Sweet” Nice acoustical bridge that re-calibrates the listener, and sets up the closing song of the disc. Nothing exceptional, but does lead quite well into the “Luna”… 13. “Luna” – 4-stars out of 7… Not sure why, but every time that I listen to this one, it feels like I have completed the journey, and it feels like I have returned to the other side of the starting point if that makes any sense. The perfect song to close out the album… Was a bit worried when I started this exercise because I began it during the week that I got the flu – and there are just some types of music that are not meant to be listened to while congested, nauseated, and headache infested… I listened to segments (4 songs at a time) during that sickly early part of my endeavor, but after I got well, I was back on track. As for final thoughts, I don’t think that I have listened thoroughly enough to all of the other Smashing Pumpkins albums to really be able to speak to whether this is their best effort or not. I will say however, that this one sets a standard (especially as just their 2nd album) that would be hard for ANY of the post “Siamese Dream” efforts to live up to. It is an incredible album, and everyone needs to have this in their collection, and enjoy as a whole – as this is one of those albums that is greater than the individual sum of its parts, and is an absolute masterpiece…
why tf is it so long holy shit
Want to hear another example of the power that Butch Vig has in music? Never knew he co-produced this album with Billy until today. But suddenly it all makes sense now. The Smashing Pumpkins are a band that unfortunately feel like they used up every interesting idea they had in the first 8 years of their 30+ year long career. Of course they couldn’t have known how far they would get, but in hindsight it’s clear they haven’t been running on the same fuel they had in the 90s for a long time. And I’ll get the chance to talk about the real cause of that eventually, hopefully sooner than later. Although, I also wasn’t aware of how much of that fuel for this album in particular was not good. It’s unfortunate how riddled this album’s creation was with personal and artistic roadblocks. From a work schedule that pushed Billy, Butch, and the rest of the band to their limits and even caused Billy to have a nervous breakdown, to Billy’s excessive control over every aspect of the recording process. In which he would undo much of the work that his fellow guitarists were creating and just simply do it himself. He forced Chamberlin to play Cherub Rock until his hands bled once. And all of this was so that they could get as perfect and close to the sound they wanted for the record. And what you hear now is that. A labor of intensive work and love that resulted in one of the best produced and written alternative albums of the 90s. Say what you will about Corgan and his voice or personality, but they struck gold with this record. On many songs, such as Today and Mayonaise, there is brief respite before these thundering riffs of shoegaze-esque guitar comes in, completely fuzzed to shit. I don’t know how they managed to find a balance between intensity and warmth so perfectly, but it paid off. Speaking of Mayonaise, I’ve always loved the way pure distortion peaks through the main riff in short bursts on the chorus. What you hear on this is also some of the finest drumming of any 90s band. Jimmy really is underrated as hell, and the way he writes such unique and iconic drum parts is amazing. If you don’t believe this album’s sound was brought about in some way by the rising popularity of shoegaze at the time, especially with the release of Loveless not even two years prior, this was mixed by Alan Moulder, the same man who mixed that previously mentioned album. I’m still not sure whether I like this, or their following record more, but I do know that this one is an incredibly solid piece of work. Rating: 8/10
Such a nice album, always a great listen.
Great classic alternative album
A brilliant grunge album, well produced and delivered.
I'm neither a teen or angsty, so it doesn't appeal to me that much but I see why people enjoy it. 3*
Throwback to my youth. I had forgotten how much I love this album.
Another one that bounced off me at the time, probably due to silly band name syndrome (I was reading Smashing in the UK sense of the word). I was expecting a scrappy grunge album but actually got a well produced post rock thing instead, even featuring (gasp!) string arrangements on some tracks. I mostly enjoyed it, but I think I probably would have loved it if it was shorter and scrappier.
Pretty good album, perhaps their better, the music is strong, but I still don't know if I like or despite Corgan's voice.
Favourite tracks: cherub rock; quiet; today; hummer; rocket; soma; geek USA; mayonnaise; Luna; disarm
I wish I liked this. Musically it's great but not a fan of Billy Corgans voice. Can absolutely see why people like them and I can hear other artists have been influenced since this album but I think I missed the boat with the pumpkins. 2/5
Very good 👍 feels like an album that will get better with more listens.
Meh. I don’t understand what the big deal is about the Smashing Pumpkins. They’re not bad, I just don’t know why the big hub-bub.
One of best albums of the '90s, nay of all time.
Cherub Rock Today Hummer Disarm Soma Geek U.S.A. Soaceboy Silverfuck Boy does this put me in a great mood. I loved this album through and through. The sound produced by this band is killer. Justin and enjoyable album to chill or work to.
great
tomorrow's much too long...
Parempi kun muistin! Hyvää ysärii! 4/5
Tää oli teinimpänä tosi siisti, mutta vähän käy raskaaksi ja paikoin siirappiseksi nykyään. On tossa silti vielä ihan toimivia biisejä. 3/5
Eäh eipä vieläkään kovin paljon kiinnosta tämä bändi. liian poppista. 2/5
very coherent album, to the point of being a little same-y. they get some cool sounds, particularly that panicked guitar tone. it's really in my style but I end up wishing it had a little more bite. I like a lot of the writing too but its ultimately a little hard to stay invested throughout the album. its like 2.5 straight-down-the-middle star
OK, not one of my favorite bands. A couple of good songs.
I already knew a few songs from this album. It's a pretty good listen. I enjoyed it, even the songs I didn't already know. I want to go back and give it another listen.
Un disco excelente, el mejor de uno de los grupos fundamentales de los 90. Mezcla psicodelia, rock, pop, heavy, shoegaze, progresivo, cuerdas que embellecen composiciones deprimentes... todo encaja y suena de maravilla. Los años no le han hecho mella. 1993 fue el año de otros discos, pero este fue de los mejores y más exitosos: debuts de PJ Harvey, Bjork, Suede y Radiohead, el último gran disco de U2, discos muy buenos de Nirvana, Pearl Jam, New Order, Aerosmith, The Breeders, The Afghan Whigs, Morphine, Liz Phair, Cypress Hill, The Posies, Teenage Fanclub, The Waterboys, Yo la Tengo, Mazzy Star, The Boo Radleys, Mercury Rev, The Auteurs o DM3. Disarm, Tonight, Rocket, Hummer, Soma, Luna, Mayonaise... siguen sonando tan grandiosas como entonces. Es un paso de gigante desde su debut, pocos meses antes que Nevermind, y un par de años antes que su continuación con el ambicioso y excelso Mellon Collie... aunque también un tanto excesivo si lo comparamos con Siamese dream. Aquí apuntaban muy alto y la línea era claramente ascendente. Con Mellon Collie se agotaba la virtud de hacer discos geniales y con Adore el talento se secó salvo en fugaces pasajes de su ristra de megalomanas publicaciones
Helaas -1 ster voor de stem
Listening to this album made me remember why I disliked The Smashing Pumpkins back in the day. The devil's in the details, like how some tracks drag on to the point where they get repetitive, or how the vocalist's voice sometime isn't mixed well and is too quiet compared to the instrumentation. Some of the slower tracks have the potential to be epic, but are dragged down by the vocalist who's got an unpleasant, 'whiny' quality to his voice. I will say though that a couple of songs like Mayonnaise, Soma, Cherub Rock, Disarm and Hummer are worth a re-listen, even if I really dislike the vocals on this album.
After hearing so many bad attempts at rock, this felt like a breath of fresh air
Smiling politely, enjoying this album
The opening riff from Cherub Rock- chefs kiss
Dull
good
Just a great album and one that holds up really well 30 years later.
cherub rock mega wall of soind und no geil findi. quiet het e rieeeese solo hobbla, cool. today macht de relativ ruhige gsang mit hässiger gitarre move, cool. de fuzz bass isch super. und d strophe sind super cute. hummer sehr cooli chords mega tension. disarm isch sehr whiny gsi aber no guet als ballade. oke soma isch glaub die richtig ballade. sehr melancholisch ihm isch all by himself. aber s funktioniert findi. mayonnaise isch huuere schön im intro, mit de hert gitarre immerno cool. spaceboy isch au huere schön, wenn au nüt ultra soeziells oder so.
nimmtmi sehr wunder, han nonie öppis vo ihne würkli glost cherub rock mega ami iwie hahahah d snare isch ultraaa crisp today mega grunge I BI SOO MÜED disarm no cute I guess oke nei hans eig würkli na gern somaa bangeeer, weird und trz catchy MAYONNAISE MIT SENF cools intro aber s riff findi denn echli lacking hey ich glaub er liebt die person, binmer aber nöd sicher ja eig fun album aber au für mich nüt megamegaa spannends
I never listened to much Smashing Pumpkins, other than what was on the radio. That said, most of these songs are recognizable. Enjoyable sound. Heavy guitars, but not pounding in your ears. Definitely a niche band though. Low 4
An old favourite - absolutely loved this as a younger man. Still holds up, but I can see how it might be a bit repetitive
Like this!
Not sure what to say about this except that it’s amazing. Was a gift from my then gf now wife to me for my 23rd birthday back then so brings back a lot of great memories.. but that not why it’s amazing. SP album's after this can’t compare, this was their peak imo
One of my favorites from the 90s
Cherub Rock, Today, Soma
Just a bit dull, innit. Favourite track: Soma.
One of my all time favourites!!!
A banda tem um estilo muito característico que talvez não agrade todo mundo e talvez nem eu gostaria se conhecesse eles agora. Mas esse álbum é muito nostálgico pra mim. Acho muito gostoso de se ouvir. Fave: disarm
Like it. Brings back memories of junior high.
Very cool. So good. Five stars.
Great album!
Funny how I don't love Billy Corgan's voice yet still find this to be both one of the best bands ever, and this album just great. It could have to do with how I like "whole" bands, and not just individual singers first. Not that I don't love singer/ songwriters and all that, but I appreciate that the background musicians have a name, and in the Pumpkin's case, they matter by contribution and are part of a whole that is wonderful.
Today is the greatest day I’ve ever known. I loved this album actually. Great moody vibes. While Cortana vocals seem to be a point of contention between reviewers, I find them to add to the overall vibe and draw you into each song. So I like this album. Today is my standout.
Cleanly produced, lots of highlights with a couple songs that feel a bit like filler. Solid album
The Smashing Pumpkins reminded me this week that no matter how old I am, 90s alternative will always be my favourite. I didn’t give this band the attention they deserved in the moment. For the me guitar stands out. At times very shoegazy which is want held me back for years, but when Billy cracks up the tone, I love it. Cherub Rock needs more of that. Also sneaky good at the softer songs, Disarm has always and will always be one of my favourites of all time. 8.5/10
This is miles better than Nevermind, but nobody tell Billy Corgan because we need his angst for sustenance.
Not my type of music bu i see the apeal
The songs were great but they were a little bit the same
A couple of all time classics on this one. A great album that I haven't had the chance to listen to in full.
Wasn’t into it when it dropped, but now I see the appeal
E-Gitarren Klassiker
Another album that’s better than its mediocre hits! At its best it’s grooving and beautiful — at its worst it’s Billy Corgan complaining on top of guitar noise.
Thoughts before listening: Well this is one of my favorite albums of all time. This came out when I was 12 and just getting into music. It blew my mind then and continues to blow my mind when I listen now. It’s such a big rock sound for an alt rock band whose peers mostly leaned heavily on the punk rock aesthetics of angst over technique. Really helped them to stand out from the pack, and the songs from Siamese Dream remain absolute top of the heap of 90s alt rock. Review: This album still just sounds so modern and vital. Many of the Smashing Pumpkins' contemporaries are starting to sound dated 3 decades past their primes, but Siamese Dream could be released today. Its a timeless record that has been an absolute joy to revisit after a few years without listening. Many of these songs will get added to the playlist, but I especially like "Cherub Rock", "Today", "Hummer", "Disarm", and "Mayonaise". This is a 5-star album.
Excellent.
Always thought I disliked The Smashing Pumpkins. Turns out I was very wrong. Absolutely loved this album.
The smashing pumpkins might not be for everyone, but my gosh are they for me
Fool enough to almost be it Cool enough to not quite see it Doomed Pick your pocket, full of sorrow And run away with me tomorrow June We'll try and ease the pain But somehow, we'll feel the same Well, no one knows Where our secrets go I send a heart to all my dearies When your life is so, so dreary Dream I'm rumored to the straight and narrow While the harlots of my perils Scream Mother, weep the years I'm missing All our time can't be given Back Shut my mouth and strike the demons That cursed you and your reasons Out of hand and out of season Out of love and out of feeling Fool enough to almost be it And cool enough to not quite see it And old enough to always feel this Always old, I'll always feel this No more promise, no more sorrow No longer will I follow Can anybody hear me? I just want to be me And when I can, I will Try to understand That when I can, I will This is just straight up an amazing album. 5/5
Sonido y voz vibrantes y hermosos
Amazing album! Listen to it twice in a row. So many great songs and powerful yet tender melodies, with an melancholic sound and thoughtful lyrics.
Love it! Love it! Love it!
Really good album, with a couple heavy hitters
A distant cousin to Nirvana with plenty of grunge, angst, and sound. Never quite soaring into melodies or singable lyrics/hooks, Corgan does have musical moments. The bells on “Disarm”,
It's not a bad album by any means, it just didn't hook me. I wouldn't feel the need to skip past any of the songs but I also wouldn't pick one of them to play on purpose. I personally found the quiet moments stronger, the end of Hummer stands out, and overall that's probably my favorite song from the album. I do agree with some of the other reviews that said they found the guitar to be strong and the vocals kind of held it back, I definitely appreciated the melodies more than any of the singing.
Absolute masterpiece, IMO their best album
songs were good but I can't stand the vocalists voice
I love it, the soundtrack to my teen years
Fantastic
Verrassend muzikaal, en ik waardeer de "artistry". Wanneer de gitaarmuziek niet te hard is, is dit echt goed. Voor de muzikaliteit en het gebruik van toffe klassieke instrumenten in o.a. Disarm net 4 sterren.
I like it but without à big enthusiam
Some classics on this album, didn't think I liked them but their stuff was pretty interesting
So many notable singles on this list, but I don't really love them like I used too. I do still like Disarm a lot and it's probavly my favorite on the album. I also liked Soma into Geek U.S.A. The rest of the album, however, was pretty bland to me. And while Crogan's voice is certainly unique, I dont know if I really wanted an hour of it.
2nd Smashing Pumpkins since I started this gig. Song structure and guitar sound is good although the leads are weak and sloppy for the most part , the drummer is excellent. This would be a lot better if the singer didn’t blow.
4/5. A very expressive and loud album. Simple instrumentation and mostly simple lyrics as well, it's somehow easy listening despite the wall of sound of every song. It has a buzzing and shoegaze feel yet the production is really good that it takes away the annoyingness of what shoegaze usually feels like. It's not a perfect album but I did not enjoy more songs than I was expecting and appreciate the unique sound. Best songs: Disarm, Mayonnaise, and Silverf***.
Ok but pretty average stuff ngl
I just can't enjoy the monotonous sludge of distorted guitars and Corgan's petulant whine.
Heavy metal with different moods
Okay
Alternativ rock, 90’er, grunge
Instantly recognizable as a band. They found their space in the scene and I understand their popularity. The songwriting is alright, and the band also sounds tight. But I just can't tune into their music, stylistically the production sounds too crisp. Corrigan's voice is grating and the songs don't stick with me. I appreciate the fact that the lyrical themes are dark, in a way that seems genuine. But it's easier to relate to that if you dig the music (which I experience when I listen to Alice in Chains)
A couple months ago I decided that this is probably my favorite album. Whenever one song comes on shuffle I almost always listen to the entire thing. I listened to this a couple of hours ago and I am typing on my phone so I am just going to list a bunch of things I love off the top of my head. 1. This album probably has my favorite production and mixing of all time 2. That layered big muff guitar tone is my favorite guitar tone, especially on mayonnaise 3. All the drum parts are killer and all the fills have so much energy and weight to them 4. The bridge in geek USA maybe the greatest minute of music ever recorded and it gives me chills every time. 5. Geek usa is probably one of my top 10 all time favorite songs. I love how it mixes all the different parts together. 6. This album has great lyrics vocal hooks/melodies and Billy's singing has so much emotion behind it 7. Cherub rock is such a good song and is so much fun to play on guitar 8. Soma is such a great song. It may be my favorite solo of all time, there is so much emotion and power behind it 9. Idk what that string synth sound thing is on space boy but it reminds me of a melatron and I love it 10. I love all the mini solos Billy and James throw in between the vocal parts Ok I think 10 is enough but I could keep going 10/5
Too much screaming and minor chords
I'm not really a smashing pumpkins fan but this is probably my favourite album of theirs, for what it's worth.
A good album for sure, a great album? Not for me. It was acceptable and nothing more than that.
i liked the band, nostalgia helps them gain 3 points, 2 under normal conditions...
Great alt rock / grunge album. It's a lot more polished than the other albums of the time. Had a great balance of sounds and styles. Good listen that didn't get boring
I was pleasantly surprised by this album. In general, "grunge" isn't a genre I gravitate towards, but this album was cohesive, moving, and fun. I also enjoyed the lead singer's vocals a lot in the context of the songs and the album.
A reminder of my teenage years, great album. 7/10
There are few more distinctive voices than Billy Corgan's and this album is a belter.
Good Pumpkins
if only the Pumpkins just kept doing this, instead of seeing the success of "Disarm" and deciding to make a bloated double album.
Pretty good grungy stuff ye
Absolutely amazing mid 9 alt rock masterpiece
...und wieder sehr lauter Gitarrenrock, eher langweilige Wiederholungen ohne Erkennungswert. Es ist nicht erstaunlich, dass die Klicks im zweistelligen Millionen Millionenbereich eher die ruhigeren balladenartigen Songs betreffen. Zu den 100 Alben gehört dieses für mich nicht.
Wow. I was just listening to this tonight thinking I can’t wait until it comes up on my list. It's a top 5 album for me. Not a song I don't love, and as a whole the production is as close to perfect as you can get with this type of music. They're absolutely on their game, and the combination of influences from My Bloody Valentine, to Black Sabbath, to The Cure, to Rush, all shine... and packaged up so well. The guitar tone, the solos, the drumming, the vocals (yes I dig Corgan's vocals). Great mix of quiet and loud, the dynamics are absolutely dialed in! Love it! 5/5
This is a great album, truly representative of the 90s alternative rock. It feels sad but energetic, raw and angsty but still fun. The guitars are a blast.
Slow rock, easy to listen to, a couple of popular songs on it
Better than I expected it to be. Some great guitar tones. But the whole thing is just too long and too dense for what it offers.
wonderful album, something special in the early 90s while being in the grunge vein but somehow still outside it
Smashing.
very solid record
This album is peak 90s alternative, it really exemplifies the Era. Songs like Today, Disarm, and Mayonnaise off this album are basically a prototype for other bands of the time. Heavy distortion, quiet lyrics that suddenly get loud to punctuate. Great album
i hated this i hate the nineties goodbye
I hate being a contrarian, I really do, but the general confusion to the Smashing Pumpkins' success and popularity has always been nagging at me. Their unnecessarily long, bland alt-rock that was so terminally 90s seemed more a contemporaneous fluke rather than a testament to some musical prowess. Listening to 'Siamese Dream' and comparing that to any of the much maligned recent releases, it does feel like the band has not changed at all, but the sudden clearer production shows that their music has never been good to begin with. Basically, I am not eloquent enough to properly describe my dislike of the band and the album, but it does feel like I am not getting "it" for the same reason I could give a shit about Tagamotchis. I am not a 90s baby, nor do I hold some nostalgic hard-on for 90s stylings. For that, the album sounds to me utterly lacklustre, bearing all its emotional weight in its lyrics (those too can be quite dumb, though), rolling on with some exceptionally weak writing, practically non-existent hooks, godawful unfitting vocals, trite production that makes each song like a bleached monotone mess, and unjustified runtime. And I feel bad for feeling this way, because it seems like I am missing out on some amazing masterpiece everyone else figured out and I am just some Debbie Downer scratching his head.
Sonido rocanrolero indi. Canciones cañeras y otras más suaves. Me gusta.
Bit of a strange case in the sense that while I enjoyed this overall, I don't think I like their songwriting. Not for a whole album at least. It just gets too samey yknow. 3 and a quarter stars.
Wouldn't revisit this for sure. It was a bit too long for that, and not really diverse. Wouldn't say I disliked it either, but it's just meh. Middle of the pack album, which is not bad, but I'm not here for these meh experiences.
I quite liked the shoutyness, but wasn't really taken by any of the songs, and on Friday I wasn't in that much of a shouty mood anyway. I think this wouldve got a higher rating if it was a different day
Mayonnaise is one of my favourite songs of all time. But some songs are not very memorable - 4.5 rounded up.
👍 👍 👍 👍 👍
It was better then I thought but the are still not my favourite band.
In truth I was never a fan of Smashing Lumpkins, however, this album has all the ‘90s rock edge and not the alt-emo-nasal-whine of their later work. Key tracks for me are Hummer (which my copy has a skip in due to a scratch on the CD and it sounds weird not hearing it on Spotify), and a Cherub Rock, a song that was inescapable in the ‘90s. This is overall a great flashback album even for the non-radio hits you may not have heard.
I like this album even better than I did in the 90s. I wasn't much of a Smashing Pumkins guy tbh. I was ride or die for Stone Temple Pilots. (I guess I needed a little more hair metal and glam in my grunge.). Anyway, this is an awesome grunge record. Disarm is so good. Also, I heard on a podcast recently that Courtney Love wrote in a letter to Billy Corgan the words: "the killer in me is the killer in you." Mind blown. Cherub Rock is also one of the better rockers from the 90s.
Surprised by how much I liked it.
Not a fan of rock or it's alternatives.Too noisy for my liking. Like a few. The least noisy ones. Ones that seem like they were recorded simply to balance out their noisiest bangers, almost as an afterthought.
Nada mal, crecí oyendo sobre el grupo pero nunca lo había escuchado. Tengo una sensación mezclada de las canciones. Hay algunas que me gustan, otras que no y otras que me gustan a partes. Aún así el disco es ligero y se disfruta.
Good variety of styles. Some cool riffs. I always found Billy Corgan's vocal style kind of interesting especially when he goes from strained (if that's the right word) to a soft voice. It kinda tugs at the heartstrings
Nope.
Ja, dit is gewoon een rock album. Niet te verwarren met een ruk album. Ik vind er niet heel veel aan, vind de rustigere nummers wat mooier dan de schreeuwende gitaren nummers. Maar altogether vind ik dit niet een heel erg bijzonder album. Het voelt voor mij echt als een 13 in een dozijn rockalbum. Ik vind zijn stem ook niet zo prettig, das beetje jammer want ik denkd at als dit je ding is dat het een sterk album is. FAVO: Disarm, Soma, Spaceboy
liked
I'm still fresh from not really liking another Smashing Pumpkins album just three or four days ago so hopefully after two I'm done with them. I still don't like the singer's voice and I'm just not a grunge fan.
I like it Will I listen to again: 80%
Tremendous!!!!
it was fine
Great!
really dig the first half...
Smash this record
Pure nostalgia
I’ve listen to this before….. loveeee
3.7
Ok.
Perfect example of 90’s alternative rock
Some good songs but didn't really enjoy the album as a whole
I love this album still listen to the damn thing! Reminds me of high school. Gen-xers unite!
Sorry, Smashing Pumpkins is not for me. This one is better than Mellon Collie, but only just.
Another great one. Never gets old.
Disarm alone is a 5.
i never gaved to much of a chance for Smashing Pumpkins when i heard the first album but they showed to had their unical sound, One of the most influentials introducers of Shoegaze-ish, and also one of the most memorable Grunge bands, this album is so noisy, ethereal, so sweet, 1990's music as it core and unical. 8.5/10
I got through 2 songs, they kinda overplayed and whiny… if I want that vibe I’ll listen to the deftones as they make me head bang 🤘🏼 more … pumpkins are just melancholy without the metal
Good, but somewhat whiney 90’s rock. Yeah, that’s all I feel like saying about it.
4/5 ⭐️ Best song: Luna Worst song: Silverfuck Comments: Loved this album and its grungy, whimsical energy. Reminds me of my best friend from school who used to listen to Mayonnaise all the time. Also very jealous of my girlfriend who is seeing them later this year
Meh
46/1001 🌕🌕🌕🌕🌑
This was great. Some songs are too long, and as a whole sometimes songs sound sort of similar. But the highs on this album are incredibly high and the lows aren't very low. Came very close to 5 stars for me, but didn't get all the way there.
Monster production, grungy riffs and layers and layers of overdubbed angst. “Today” and “Disarm” two particular standouts.
Favs: disarm, soma, spaceboy
One of my all time faves.
amazing album
Probably the better album from the Pumpkins... but I still think they're very overrated, despite the rave reviews others seem to wax lyrical about them.
Dislike: Meh: Quiet Sweet sweet Like: Cherub rock Today Hummer Rocket Disarm Soma Geek usa Spaceboy Silverfuck Luna Added to playlist: Mayonaise
Well, I wondered when Smashing Pumpkins would appear, although it's a bit disappointing to get them right after another 1990s phenom (Offspring), as they share some of the same general wall-of-sound 90s thing. (To be fair to Offspring, though, their lyrics are *much* easier to distinguish than Smashing Pumpkins. And to be fair to Smashing Pumpkins, they're so much less annoying/offensive than Offspring.) I own this album (apparently one of 6 million others), and at one point enjoyed listening to them more than I do now. Listening to this album again makes me think more of a time and place (1990s, DC) than it does of whether this is a "greatest" album or not. And I think even when I bought the CD I felt like they kind of had one song in them that they found several variations of to put together a full-length album. (I suspect if I ever took the time to decipher the lyrics, or ever watch their videos, I might be slightly disabused of this monochromatic image. And hits "Cherub Rock" and "Today" *are* somewhat different, I'll admit. "Rocket" not so much, and "Disarm" maybe the most distinctive, but I never really liked that hit.) Fine, but nothing special (despite the Wikipedia entry describing the album as "widely regarded as one of the greatest albums of the 1990s and of all time"), and a nice blast from the past. That said, I wish I knew then about what went into making this album (thanks, Wikipedia people), as it would have made the context of the album a lot more interesting. Talk about stressful and harrowing! And shades of the film "Whiplash" with the suicidal lead singer making the junkie drummer perform "Cherub Rock" until his hands bled....
Nice recording with good musicians but I just never got that into it
Riffs changing from rock to heavy metal to gothic to psychedelic. Provoking lyrics carried with the range of vocals. Will be a new band to commit to now.
Cannot argue with this album. Many people like Mellon Collie... more, but I never really connected with that in the way I did this when it came out. It is absolutely of an era, but is standing the test of time very well. I sound old to say: they don't make 'em like this anymore.
The only thing more amazing than Billy Corgan playing all the instruments on this album is that he slept with Jessica Simpson … and dumped her.
I like them a lot somehow
In a nutshell: sweet dreams are made of this. So close to perfect. I can only nitpick. The outro to Hummer was too long. Sweet Sweet is nice but only a filler track. I would have placed Luna elsewhere on the album and ended the album with Silverfuck. This was a first time listen for me, and it was a joy. Overall: 9/10
Been years since I listened to this & I had forgotten how strong the song writing is on this. Disarm is emo perfection.
Alternative classic takes me back to my teenage years.
Quintessential rock album of the 90s.
Iconic. 4 stars because their 5 start album was their next effort.
I keep trying to listen to The Smashing Pumpkins but fine I get a headache. I think it's his voice. 1 star
The smashing pumpkins help create the sound of the 90s. From disarm to cherub rock, to today these dreamy, crunchy, and raw songs helped the mainstream move past the overproduced pop music of the 80s.
Not much of a Pumpkins fan but there are some decent songs on here.
I'm a '90s kid - I never owned a Smashing Pumpkins cd or listened to one of their albums straight through but I know most of these songs from alternative radio/my brothers' cd collections. Cherub Rock, Today, Rocket, Disarm, and Mayonaise were the singles. Disarm especially stands out as the song with the church bells and string arrangement- very grand! This is a consistent set of 90s alt rock jams
Billy's voice is very distinctive. I've had a hit/miss history with the band but I like the orchestral slant here. Quite extravagent in places and quite thrashy in others places which demonstrates variation. Still on the fence though.
Good head nodding rock
Great 90’s rock
I have heard this band a bunch obviously, but have never listened to them outside of the stuff playing in the world, radio hits and what have you. They are certainly a very easy band to goof on which I enjoy doing. This was about what I was expecting, a bit dramatic, but cool guitar tones, and the songs are catchy for sure. Decent album.
I don’t know why I’ve slept on Smashing Pumpkins for so long, they’re right up my alley. This is gorgeous.
Great reintroduction to an album I never fully absorbed. Guitar play, lyrics, tone, all there.
Un lindo disco, pero demasiado largo para mi gusto. Se nota las influencias de otras bandas, pero también como crearon un estilo y una estética propia más allá de eso.
I knew the hits, the album is pretty heavy and it sounded great on the buds. My first time listening through. I thought it was great, if I was a teen in the 90's this would have been on heavy rotation. The girl on the right looks like my buddy Bledsoe.
It's fine, like a couple songs and have heard most of them but never in one go. Worked well with my run.
TSP’s sound is what I mostly associate with 90s rock/alternative genre. This is probably from the ridiculous amount of 90s movies using “Today” on their soundtracks. The whole album gives me that “after high school 90s cd that you’d play in your parent’s basement at full volume” vibe. The lyrics are angsty, angry and depressing. I thoroughly enjoyed listening it even though I’m not in my parent’s basement anymore.
Didn’t know so many of their singles were on this album. Greatness all around
One of the greatest albums that ever has or will ever be. Sonically daring, Corgan tortured himself (and his bandmates) to achieve this and we get to reap the reward forever. This is one of those albums I would call important, because to me, it changed the game.
I didn't realize that I knew more than one song on this album. I like Cherub Rock, Today, and Disarm but never got into the band enough to buy or download a full album. I also don't know that I ever knew the names of these songs :) The album makes me feel nostalgic for a time in the '90s when I was too young to really know what kind of music I actually liked. I remember friends who were into rock liking them but I don't think I fully appreciated what they had to offer.
"Cherub Rock" and "Today" are awesome songs. The rest are definitely grungey, angsty time capsules of the 90s. The Smashing Pumpkins mix emotion and rock really well. Great album.
Honestly, boring.
Hadn't listened to this in ages. They were always adjacent to the grunge scene, and they were on the Singles soundtrack -- so I knew them from there. Then came "Mellon Collie" and I wrote them off. Revisiting was...much as I remember. Several bangers (Cherub Rock, Disarm, Rocket, Mayonaise), but then a whole lot of fuzz. I mean, no one needs 8 1/2 minutes of "Silverfuck" unless you're feeling nostalgic for Metal Machine Music or something. Anyway, some good, some bad.
It is an amazing album, really loved all of the songs, specially Luna, it was super fun.
8/10 I prefer Mellon Collie, but this is still a really great album
2nd best album of the pseudo-shoegaze strain of music (albums like you'd prefer an astronaut - HUM, fantastic planet - failure) mayonaise, silverfuck and Luna are the standouts here. seeing sp live in june so this album has been in heavy rotation for me in recent months. 9.4/10
This is one of my favorite albums! I listened to it for the first time last year and fell for it instantly. Those iconic guitar textures are on another level and the general vibe of the entire album just rocks! A must listen for alternative rock fans. “Mayonaise, “Geek USA,” and “Silverfuck,” are favorites.
Great 90's rock.
Deep, layered
Really, really good album. I'm biased because this was around during my late teens / early twenties but I never listened to the band at that time, and as such I don't really have any Rose tinted view of it - it's just a superb album. Also, I don't get people hating on Billy Corgan's voice when there are plenty of other things to dislike about him
Pretty good
A classic of my youth. Holds up so well to this day.
I hadn't expected to enjoy this as much as I did. Spaceboy really spoke to me. An all around good listen. Would revisit again.
Incredible album, with many beautiful songs and also many angrier songs. Absolutely zero skips here which is impressive for an hour long album, there's no way The Smashing Pumpkins can top that, right?
I went to a Smashing Pumpkins concert once. They had an energy that got you hyped. "Today" is probably my favorite song of theirs. I've never really been crazy about Billy Corgan's whisper-shout singing style, but it does have a charm and it's growing on me. I am really liking the guitar sound in this album.
Das Album hab ich schon früher gemocht
Banger
I loved this album as a teenager, and many of the songs still hold up, but there is also a good deal of filler on this. Not as cohesive of any album as I remember.
Cherub rock is such a great opener. Highlights: cherub rock, today, disarm, silverfuck (love some good drum drives)
Great album one of my favs
One of my favorite records from that time period.
De que me suena a mí esto??
Un clásico
Fucking amazing album; one that grew on me a lot over the years, as I didn't like most of it when I first listened back in high school or something. In fact, it's still growing on me to this day, as I only saved Spaceboy and Luna after this listening session (I only have Quiet left). Billy Corgan is honestly an underrated guitarist and he rips on a ton of these songs, a handful of which I consider perfect (a large handful tbh). Not a bad song on this thing though. The drumming is also insane. Deservedly ranked among the best albums of the 90s, as it truly captures the "sad happy music" sound that makes so many of the best albums of that decade so great. If you like this album, you must watch the acoustic album release show they did, especially the Cherub Rock performance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzwOwzGtiZw
Can’t 5 star this album fast enough. Once I hear that opening drum roll of Cherub Rock, the emotions of the album come rushing back and I get excited for the next hour of listening. Aside from all of the amazing sounds and creative guitar work, I love how personal to Billy Corgan it is. As much as Billy Corgan is an egomaniac, control freak, and unpleasant pontificator, you can’t help but to feel bad for him as you start to understand that there is a deep insecurity rooted within him. This album feels like it’s Billy’s way of showing that insecurity to the world; of psychoanalyzing himself for all to hear. The record starts with and has some of its strongest moments in the grand, arrogant, powerful chords that capture Billy’s harsh side; the lust for greatness and belief in supremacy over all of the other poser musicians in the world (including those within his own band). While it progresses, it starts to see-saw between the grandiose and a milder, sweeter, sadder sound. As the Pumpkins guide us into these more melancholic moments, it begins to feel like you’re hearing the truth of how Billy feels inside. That he would gladly return all of the stardom and fame and acclaim for the chance to go back in time to those days of his childhood when he was the most disconsolate and make them just a little bit better. That every extra bit of fame makes him feel even worse for carrying around all the pain and makes him want to withdrawal from the world to spend his days in bed alone. The album is magnificent, anxious, dejecting, angry, calm, and, most of all, beautiful. 10/10 — best non-singles: Hummer & Silverf***
Definitely some absolute bangers on this album. The last two songs on the album are pretty weak to me that give it a 4. First four songs come out absolutely ripping
I remember Cherub Rock from Guitar Hero. At the time, it was one of my least played tracks on the game but it’s definitely grown on me a lot over time. I hadn’t really paid much attention to Smashing Pumpkins in general until a few years ago. Let’s listen! Songs I already knew: Cherub Rock, Today Favourites: Today, Mayonaise I’ve said it many times before, but I love the unnecessary level of distortion found in a lot of 90s alt rock, and Siamese Dream is absolutely no exception. Each song would sound perfectly fine as an acoustic song, but that ridiculously heavy guitar tone adds so much punch. For a long time, I’ve been unsure of if I like Billy Corgan’s voice, but it suits every track here perfectly. There are no bad tracks here, and I found myself loving everything I heard.
Sometimes, an album is ruined not by poor craftsmanship, but just the sheer overwhelming presence of ego. This is one of those albums. It's got some great songs, but they're completely overshadowed by Corrigan's ego and conceit.
I certainly know OF the Smashing Pumpkins, though I couldn't name any songs off the top of my head. Digging into this, the sound is certainly familiar, and I'm pretty sure I've heard a few of these songs. But after an hour, it starts to blur together. Yeah it's grunge, and you can certainly hear similarities to Nirvana. It OK, and has a few points that are higher than the rest. but nothing that hangs with me 30 years down the line. Solid 3, but nowhere near making 4. 3/5
8/10 Highlights: Disarm Cherub Rock Soma Today Silverfuck
Manchmal verleiht man ein Album oder ein Buch und sieht es nie wieder. Das ist mir mit diesem Album passiert. Jetzt habe ich also Gelegenheit gehabt, es nochmal zu hören. Ungefähr 25 Jahre später. Einige Songs gefallen mir immer noch. Für mich der Auftakt zum noch abwechslungsreicheren Mellon Collie Album. Das habe ich nicht verliehen.
Easiest 5 star I've given. Every song is an absolute banger. And, kills just as much now as it did 30 years ago.
So my first two days using this app I got two Smashing Pumpkins albums. I really regret not being more scathing in my review of Mellon Collie cause after having to sit through another Smashing Pumpkins album in a consecutive day, I can honestly say that I hate them. Billy Corgan has a huge ego and no talent, he uses random lines of teenage poetry and slaps them together without any actual meaning or substance, and his voice drives me up a wall. The only way in which Siamese Dream is better than Mellon Collie is that it is shorter.
Que tostón, tío. Suenan a lo mismo que weezer, pero con un rollo de adolescente castigadito insufrible. No es mal disco. Pero tío, que castigo.
90’s music- all the same and all awful. I couldn’t make it through.
Awesome album
Absolutely incredible, mayonnaise is a masterpiece, Luna and sweet sweet too
Hat für mich keinen krassen Wiedererkennungswert. Songs 1-5 klingen finde ich sehr gleich. 2,5/5
Ich habe zu diesem Zeitpunkt noch nichts gehört, muss vorweg sagen, dass deren Live-Auftritt beim Hurricane 2013 mit das unerträglichste an Live-Performance war, was ich bisher erlebt habe (bitte stimme mir zu, Moritz). Das soll ich ja nicht beurteilen, ich gehe aber seitdem sehr vorsichtig mit der Band um. Oft hilft es, mit wenig Erwartungen an etwas ranzugehen. Den Intro-Song fand ich schonmal ganz cool. Die weiteren Songs auch. Habe dann aber vergessen es bis zum Ende aufmerksam weiterzuhören. Der Sound hat mir aber insgesamt gut gefallen.
- Der gelungene Abschluss einer wunderbaren Woche bei diesem schönen Game - Fuck ich liebe die Smashing Pumpkins. Und wie fett ist dieses Album?! - Dieser untenrum so wahnsinnig gut ausproduzierte Bass, wunderbar eingebettet Billy Corgans einmalige Stimme, die sich irgendwo zwischen Engel und Dämon hin und herbewegt, und dann natürlich diese dicken Fuzz-Gitarren, die in meinen Augen bei keiner Band so gut klingen wie bei den Pumpkins. - Erst letzten Sommer habe ich in Spanien am Strand wieder viel Smashing Pumpkins gehört. - Ich habe zugegebermaßen einen starken persönlichen Draht zu dieser Band. Wir hatten zuhause zwei Alben von den Jungs und Mädels auf CD, die ich irgendwann gekapert und in meine eigene Sammlung habe einfließen lassen: Siamese Dreams und Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. Die Alben haben mir in irgendeiner Phase mal sehr aus der Seele gesprochen. Auch wenn ich damals nicht geahnt hab, wie düster manche Texte doch sind. - In dem vermeintlich melancholisch/schönen "Today" geht es um den Suizid, vor dem Billy Corgan kurzzeitig stand. Trotz der inhaltlichen Schwere ist der Song einer meiner Lieblingssongs aus der Ära 90's Grunge/Alt-Rock (und die Konkurrenz ist groß). - A pros pros Konkurrenz. Billy Corgan hat sich zu der Zeit stark mit dem ebenfalls schwer depressiven Kurt Cobain verglichen. Er war quasi besessen und von Ehrgeiz zerfressen auch den großen Durchbruch zu schaffen, wie Nirvana mit Nevermind. Es muss sehr schwer gewesen sein, zu dieser Zeit und in den Folgejahren mit Billy Corgan zusammenzuarbeiten. Das Album ist unter viel Streit und fast Auflösung der Band entstanden. Später zerbrach die Band daran. Bis Corgan sich Hilfe holte, die Band etwas umformiert wurde und schließlich ihre Reunion feierte. Inzwischen ist Corgan mir sogar echt sympathisch geworden. - Doch bevor ich hier ins Plaudern abdrifte: An Nevermind sind die Smashing Pumpkins natürlich nicht ansatzweise mit dem Album herangekommen, dennoch haben sie den weltweiten Durchbruch geschafft und sich zu einer Genregröße etabliert. Gleichermaßen gefeiert von Fans und Kritikern. - Das Album, sowie der Sound der gesamten Band sind absolut einzigartig. - Und bevor der Kommentar von Lassi kommt: Die waren nicht kacke live, der Mischer hat die Gitarren leider einfach ohrenbetäubend schmerzhaft eingestellt!! Rating: 4,25/5
- Habe mich nie näher mit den Smashing Pumpkins befasst. Kannte nur ein paar Songs und fand die "ganz gut". - Dieser Eindruck hat sich nach dem Hören wirklich gar nicht verändert. Gut, dynamisch, aber berührt mich nicht. Ansonsten ist mein Kopf dazu irgendwie leer, sry. 3/5
Ganz solides Album, das ich mir bestimmt mal wieder reinziehen werde. So richtig hängen geblieben ist bis auf "Disarm" allerdings kein Song, was den Wiedererkennungswert für mich etwas schmälert.
MY YOUTH.
Very Varying
Feels like high school
Didn’t like this album. I give it 1 star.
His voice grates on my ears after awhile. Appreciate the history and what it did at the time, but damn its like a railroad spike on a chalkboard
One of the better alt rock albums from the 90s
"Today" and "Disarm" are the obvious standouts, but this is solid all around.
This was one of Gen X's defining albums. Perfect 90s rock.
Lots of memories come along with this one.
Ganz ok
I liked Rocket, but I found the album kind of boring. I have never been a huge fan of Billy Corgan’s voice outside of select tracks, so I won’t hold it against them. I liked the use of strings and varied percussive elements, I just wanted something with more hook, admittedly more like Bullet With Butterfly Wings.
The album I would to choose to send into outer space.
I hate Billy Corgan so much. I hate him. And I hate how good this album is. It is so good. From such a douche. Hate that I have to give it a 4. it's so good though.
Bill Pumpkins has his head so far up his own ass that he's a brilliant songwriter.
Standout: Mayonnaise
Heavy
90's alternative rock at its best. Billy Corgan captures the sentiment of the era with his heavily distorted guitars that also sound like what somebody from the 90's thought the future might sound like. Siamese Dream doesn't growl so much as it snarls. It's got attitude, but the attitude of an art school loner rather than a tattered-jean-jacket-wearing rocker.
For strong of a full album listening music fan that I am I'm really surprised that I've never listened to this album in it's completion before because this was really popular when I was a returning student at UCSC and there must have been somebody I knew that had a copy of it but I never made an effort to listen to it. I have mixed feelings about this album, so far it's kind of been a little disappointing because it just sounds like a swamp of like sounding songs but then KILLER IN ME KILLER IN YOU comes on and I have memories of thinking oh this must be a really good band but yeah, after listening to the other songs on the album it's just they're just kind of okay. the lead singers voice wears on me after awhile.
I went to Secondary School in a different town to where I lived. My hometown had a School, but I so hated the town, and the fuckers that I’d previously been at school with that I wanted out. A few years later, when I was in Uni, I went back to the town on the same train that I must’ve caught a thousand times before. As it started to pull up to the station, my phone started to play Mayonnaise, and as I walked up the slope and saw the town centre for the first time in years, the heavy riff started, and for a moment I was transported into the start of my very own Teenage Romantic Drama, the protagonist coming home for the holidays, going to a party, seeing everyone from school, and how they’ve changed, inevitably falling in love with his former best friend. It was a perfect moment, one of only two I’ve had regarding music. The other involved Road To Nowhere by Talking Heads and another train, thinking about it. Huh, weird. Maybe it’s because Alt Rock in the 90’s has always been so intrinsically linked to adolescence and so revisiting is invariably going to feel nostalgic, but Smashing Pumpkins always felt particularly nostalgia fuelled to me. I was never even the biggest fan of them. They were a bit too Proggy, too much guitar noodlery, not enough Punk. But relistening at a time when I have less teenage angst and more genuine Existential despair, I better understand it. The problems of your 20’s are similar to those of your adolescence, but if anything as a teen I felt more hope. There was possibility, there was a chance of getting out, of opportunity on the horizon, even if the present was less than shining. Nowadays, ‘I’m not living, I’m just killing time.’ But at least the music is beautiful. Bleak and despairing, but Beautiful
February 5, 2024 HL: "Disarm", "Cherub Rock", "Today", "Hummer", "Soma" When I implied earlier that "Blitzkrieg Bop" was the greatest opening song, I forgot about "Cherub Rock" :/ Now, I gave Mellon Collie a 5er back in '22, but part of me feels that was temporary insanity, considering I revisit several of the other artists generated around that week (FKA Twigs, Spiritualized, MBV) a lot more. However, today is a reminder that I continue liking the Smashing Pumpkins' music, even if Corgan's angsty lyrics don't always hit the spot.
It is iconic 90's alt rock with the depth of Corgan's lyrics and skill at guitar shining at their brightest. The signature sound doesn't vary much and the tracks do begin to run together. Good emo vibe for an extended pity-party.
An amazing classic alternative album. A favorite.
Disarm and Today are good. As I’m not into grungy and grungy riff rock the rest of the tracks are not so good 2.6
4.1/5 Best Track: Disarm
It's a cool album, but as with so many albums that are considered "normal rock" I miss something. I could also not stand that singer of the length of an album.
Much better than I remembered/expected. I was never a fan of Pumpkins but I really liked this album. Age changes taste. Pretty cool demos, etc. at the end.
Nice. Love cherub rock!
This was good. High 3*
Just sneaks in at a 4. It was a 3 for most of the day.
not as Whininy ans nasal as I remember it. but it is still very whiny and very nasal. i am not at all a fan. but people around me are. and I have never understood why I really tried. I went in trying to fight my bias and be objective. but I failed. I just dont like his voice. but many others do. and that is fine. Personally if I never need to hear Billy Corgon again i will be very happy. the music was great but
Good can be a bit repetitive but overall good
Very nostalgic of that nineties emo, angsty teenage vibes. But not for me. But not bad!!
My girlfriend likes to call this the Hard Rock Cafe band/album, and I say it fits. Love this album.
As much as I'm trying to, I'm having a tough time distinguishing the tracks from one another. Would probably have to listen a bunch more to do that. But I like the vibe of the music in general, definitely smashed some pumpkins. There's a lot of electric guitar... sludge? And it makes me feel like a tragically misunderstood 2000's teenager dissociating in their room and playing this cd on repeat, simultaneously driving their parents insane. And I'm into that sorta vibe. Very cool and recognizable album cover. Wonder whats the story behind it and the two girls.
Alternative music staple
Luka is wrong about the Smashing Pumkins, they're great
Enjoyed!
This album was the soundtrack to my first broken heart. This tells more about my age, than the quality of the record. But I like it. Couldn’t listen to it a while, but I’m enjoying it right know. It’s a kind of angry and depressed Black Sabath sound. I prefer the Pumpkins.
Now this is a really good album, with some excellent songs on it! Knocked it down a star, as there are a couple songs that aren't as good. Overall love it though!
I think usually people consider Melancholy the SP magnum opus, but this album is absolutely fantastic. Everything I like about Melancholy I like about this album as well. Top shelf. 4.3.
Großartig. Die unterschiedlichen Stile, die Mischung. Ich lieb‘s.
I'm disappointed to say this, thinking I was a fan of the Smashing Pumpkins after Mellon Collie, but I found this to just be alright. There isn't as much variety in this album, and it leads to a lot of songs that feel like the stereotypical image of "alternative rock" were it to be formed as one, singular album. There are great things here, stuff I already know, such as the hits which are stellar, but I felt much of the rest of the album often had a decent hook, but felt aimless by the end, or just feels like a lesser take on one of the singles from the album, and it makes it so I can't help but feel this project is bloated. On the bright side, again, those hits are fantastic, and the instrumentation is great, it just feels like its missing something that made Mellon Collie special. Perhaps I shouldn't be comparing them, but its hard not to, because this pales in comparison.
Bonafide classic, probably in my top 25 albums of all time. The guitar tone is just incredible
Solid album. Forgot (never knew) just how hard Smashing Pumpkins is. Couple forgettable tracks, but this album hits you immediately with the riff on Cherub Rock. Hummer and Disarm stand out as well. I didn't care for Soma or Quiet. 4 stars.
Cherub Rock - 7.5/10 Quiet - 8/10 Today - 9/10 Hummer - 8/10 Rocket - 7.5/10 Disarm - 9/10 Soma - 9/10 Geek U.S.A - 7.5/10 Mayonnaise - 10/10 Spaceboy - 7.5/10 Silverfuck - 7.5/10 Sweet Sweet- 7.5/10 Luna - 9/10 TOTAL - 87/140
worse than i expected but still has some bangers
Enjoyed it more then I expected. Way more recognizable songs then expected. Not my favorite singer, but still way better then the pearl jam guy.
I love Siamese Dream. Great album, with a lot of fun memories associated with it.
Noisy, disruptive.
I liked it! Need more listens to solidify my opinion and find favorite songs.
Great Album
Fantastic album! I knew a lot of the songs already, but the whole thing really works! I Know Billy Corgan is an asshole who actively has made the sport of pro wrestling worse, but he’s got a cool rock voice.
Not as good as I remember, love the fuzz guitar. Today, Soma and Disarm are standout tracks for me.
Love it. Today and Disarm are the two most well known tracks and are probably the standouts.
Man, I know I'm conditioned due to what was popular when I was growing up, but boy do I love this sound.
Classic alternative rock / grunge album, very emo vibes. As opposed to Radiohead, this was a good album in a genre I like. Kinda similar to Nirvana, slightly less depressing, slightly more to the point. Apparently a band that inspired Fall out boy, MCR and Silversun Pickups.
Didn’t hate but didn’t love. It was alright but not my type of genre
Love me some pumpkins. 5/5
I like Smashing Pumpkins, but for me, there's something lacking.
Not as good as Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness, but still good. Rocket and the song before Rocket where very good.
I always get the Smashing Pumpkins and Scouting for Girls mixed up even though they sound nothing alike. After listening to this album, it’s no longer a mystery; they’re utterly forgettable!
Have listened to a bit of the Smashing Pumpkins in the past and liked what I heard, never listened to a full album before though. So I’ll check out some more
Another great album. 2 days in a row we've had some classic Guitar Hero tunes, so much nostalgia. What a tune Today is.