Reviews (page 2 of 14)
Really amazing album - certainly of a type but strong songwriting
un embole
Essential. Amazing
I wish my commute had been by horseback rather than train. Quality singing and songmanship.
With a few chords and storytelling to match the great writers Marty Robbins helped define American country music.
I was surprised by this one. I will be honest I don’t really like Country music. But this album had a very different sound from more conventional Country. I liked the sort of Folk art feel of some of the songs and there was also a kind of Buddy Holly and Elvis Presley vibe to some of the music.
The all time classic. Thank you Fallout! 7
Another one where there's nothing inherently wrong with the music or style but when you listen to a whole album of it in one go it's just a bit much. Western-inspired music is mostly about shooting people, getting shot, getting hanged, riding horses or women, and unsurprisingly this album is mostly about those things. Still an interesting alternative to something more modern.
First listen. How many times does the narrator die? This dude has been shot and killed (or hanged) in almost every song. Like bro, give it up.
This album is better than you might think it would be going in. Yes, the songs all sound similar, but Marty Robbins has a great voice and these are fun "tales of the trail" folk songs. It's not some perfect album because it does get a bit repetitive, but I enjoyed listening to it.
Bangin
"Baladas de pistoleiros e canções de trilha". O título define muito bem o conteúdo do disco que é praticamente uma coletânea de canções country, sem muito a acrescentar.
Good cowboy songs - 3/5
This was really fun. It's exactly what you would expect and album from the 50's with this title to, and I'm so glad I listened.
Man in sound better thanI expected to, still not my kind of music
Super not in the mood for this. Still ok. Was happy when it was done. El Paso was the best
I know albums are supposed to be cohesive but this just felt like the same exact song over and over again. And I know I’ve liked stuff like this before but mary poppins just couldn’t do anything for me
Giving this a 5 felt wrong… but just know the thought was there
Yo this cover is absolutely insane what am I looking at, is he a wax figure???
Tråkigt og spesielt. Nærmeste en ener hittil, men det blir nok 2 av 5 her.
MOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOLTO SITUAZIONALE: LO ASCOLTEREI SOLO SE FOSSI A CAVALLO NEL MEZZO DEL NEBRASKA. 2/5
Prety bad album cover. "Big Iron" was a good song and I liked the storytelling on some songs. Also his voice sounds really good. However it sounds dated, its repetitive as hell and overall, rather boring. As far as 50's cowboy country music, this is probably a masterpiece, but I dont think its makes it deserving of a spot on this book. 2.5/5
Cowboy music :)
I guess this was the equivalent of gangster rap in the fifties. I like the old records on this list. Anything pre-1963 ish is a blind spot for me.
Classic country music
Decent, maybe the weaker of the 3 star country albums I've heard (or maybe I need to bump some of those other ratings up)
A two
Kinda fun but not really my thing.
Story songs set to both kinds of music: country and western. Outlaw songs that are decidedly not Outlaw Country. Wears a bit by the end.
i think this might be my favorite Country album that i've gotten so far. this guy has a really nice voice and it was pretty relaxing, even though the subject matter is anything but. it's not anything too crazy, but for it is, it's good :)
Listening session: october 9th, while taking the train back home Listened to before: no Thoughts: I’m not a country fan, but this was okay, just a bit too long for my liking Favourite tracks: Big Iron & The Master’s Call
I enjoyed this a lot more than I thought I would.
Yeee haaaa
The songs pretty much all sound the same, but they are FANTASTIC! I love these old western stories. Every song is a full fledged tale and they had me absolutely gripped. Really enjoyed this listen.
Marty Robbins has a fantastic voice, and Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs immediately pulled me in with its storytelling. “Big Iron” was a great opener, with Robbins essentially telling a complete Western story through song. “A Hundred and Sixty Acres” had an almost Irish folk-ballad quality to it, while the dark “They’re Hanging Me Tonight” reminded me musically of an Elvis ballad. I also enjoyed “Cool Water” and the continued storytelling of “Billy the Kid.” The stories change from song to song, and the melodies aren't exactly the same, but eventually the album started to feel very much the same. Robbins' smooth country crooning and the Western arrangements create such a consistent atmosphere that, by the end, the individual songs began blending together for me. I actually think I would enjoy these songs more if I heard them individually, mixed in with other artists. As an entire album, though, there wasn't enough variety to keep me fully engaged. Still, this was a really good album. Robbins is an excellent storyteller with a great voice, and I can absolutely understand the appeal. I enjoyed my time with it, but there wasn't anything here that I expect will stick with me long after the album ends.
Something different
Real cowboy hours. I'd watch these stories as a series of vignettes.
Big iron, 3.6
One of the greatest albums in country music. The storytelling is as good as it gets. Marty sings these old west tales with a perfect voice, clear and steady, and he makes every character and every dusty road feel real. Songs like Big Iron, El Paso and Billy the Kid stay with you for a lifetime. There is a calm authority in the way he delivers the stories. Nothing is rushed and nothing is overplayed. The band stays tight and supportive, giving the songs a clean, cinematic feel without ever getting in the way of the narrative. You can almost see the landscapes and the gunfights while the record plays. The production is simple and effective. Everything sits in the right place, the voice stays out front, and the sound has a warm, classic presence that still holds up. Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs is a landmark. Timeless storytelling, perfect singing, and songs that refuse to leave you.
A lot more sad and emotional than I was expecting. Certainly the right vibe for waking up at 3am for the third day in a row to go to a fucking grocery store. Songs were quick and packed with story. Great album
Really great Western storytelling. A lot of bangers on here tbh. I can’t believe how well this has lasted through so much time.
I do enjoy a storytelling album and songs and this was definitely that. Not one I would likely return too, but it was fun
Not something I’m going to listen to on the regular but it’s fun for what it is!
Olha, desde o inicio dessa serie esse foi o Album que eu mais me identifiquei, achei muito bom principalmente as letras. coutry raiz, letras de duelos, tragedias, historias de e amor e amizade... Violões maravilhosos e divisões de vozes impecáveis
Music has thankfully changed for the better. Top track: "El Paso"
I'm sure this is important and it's a fun listen. Still just a 3 for me, idk.
--Big Iron...Fallout: New Vegas. if you know you know --Cool Water...very nice harmonies. track feels as cool as the title --Billy the Kid...traditional Americana with some Mariachi thrown in. the minor key adds a sinister flavor --A Hundred and Sixty Acres...fun, carefree cowboy tune --They're Hanging Me Tonight...sounds like an Elvis ballad (laudatory) --The Strawberry Roan...pleasant but basic. plodding --El Paso...the white-cowboy-falls-for-Mexican-girl song. I'm being glib; it's good --In the Valley...another one that sounds like it was written for Elvis. did Elvis ever cover this guy? (later edit: he did) --The Master's Call...this is basically "Big Iron". that's okay because "Big Iron" is great --Running Gun...another fun ditty but I’m starting to get the point --The Little Green Valley...more pleasantness --Utah Carol...and we close with even more pleasantness. this LP has a beautiful vibe that it sticks to like grim death. I wish there were at least one track that flipped the formula a bit. a good listen nonetheless
what taylor swift sounds like to men
Franky Lane gör det så mycket bättre. En tvåa
OH MY GOD, IT HAS THE SONG FROM FALLOUT!!!
Fun old fashioned western music, while campy and of an older time, this one has an undeniable charm to it. The story telling in these relatively simple songs make for a fun listen, where it's enjoyable to follow the stories of outlaws and rangers in a traditional western style.
I've listened to this album many times and am already a huge fan, and was delighted to see it drawn from the list for the day's listen. I enjoyed it, perhaps more than any of my prior listens, as I cruised the gorgeous countryside of the Methow Valley on a sunny afternoon in early October. The golden aspen trees that lined the ranches, orchards, and coulees of this beautiful part of Washington State was the perfect setting to enjoy the dulcet sounds of Robbins vocals, and helped me find an appreciation for simpler times in a more rural land, where someone's demise could be easily predicted by the relative size of their gun.
Solid country album. Not usually my style but this was well done. Big iron is a goated song
4 - Old Timey western songs. Odd how upbeat and genteel the music is with the gritty subject material
My grandfather absolutely loved this kind of music, and I had never really listened to this kind of music much. Today made me think of him a lot while I listed to Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs. This is an album full of old timey western movies. Good guys fighting the bad guys, lovely maidens in trouble, and black hats and white hats. There was some really good songs in this collection, and the nostalgia of listening to this stuff in my pap's truck as a kid with him, man, it struck a chord I wasn't expecting.
Pari hyvää biisiä ei yksinkertaisesti riitä
Solid throwback. Some great songs but also some weaker moments and it tends to feel repetitive at times
I suppose it's culturally significant as the Library of Congress thinks, but in terms of its placement on this list I think it can be removed. I don't see it having meaningful influence on current or future generations.
I don’t love a whole album of stories as songs. I prefer a song to have bridges and choruses generally. Not as bad as I expected but not a fan
Much prefer old Western music as compared to American Country (at least Nashville version of Country).
Big iron on his hiiiiiip
I'm not sure how many Gunfighter Ballads one needs in their life, but I've had enough.
Nice voice and pleasant harmonies, though musically repetitive. I would think the album's intent at the time was lighthearted entertainment. Yet, I find it hard to rate this 1950s country western album with my 2026 perspective and its emotional weathering over the years of guns and misogyny.
Is it just this album cover or did Marty Robbins always look like Nick Cage? I'm surprised at all the five star reviews of this album. I mean it's fine and certainly better than the pop country garbage that comes out now but it's still just like campfire sing-a-longs for an hour. Fun fact - one of the first songs I learned to play on guitar was El Paso. So there's that. If someone was browsing though my record collection and found this I wouldn't be embarrassed, but if someone walked in the front door and this was playing I'd have to do some explaining. But I can't imagine a time when I would play this even if I did have it in the collection. At least it's tolerable and good for one listen. 2.5/5
Old school country I think grows on me the more I listen to it. Solid album, thought it gets repetitive if anything. Big Iron slaps.
Silky smooth vocals and fun lyrics. This genre hasn't exactly aged well with the topic of the songs and such, but its still a good listen. Big Iron has stood the test of time.
This is it. This is the best country western album ever written. No one else needs to make another one. We hit our peak 59' and no one else has surpassed it.
5.5/10
I did not expect to enjoy this. But here we are. I've always enjoyed "cowboy/gunslinger songs", and this is where they came from. I can imagine Volbeat taking huge influence from Marty. Good stuff.
This is a great album that I first heard about from an 8th grader I was teaching in 2022. The kids are alright. 😁 There are a number of albums on this list that I criticize because they don't hold up 20, 40, or 60 years later. This album is different. No matter how quaint or old-fashioned the music might be, it's still quality guitar playing and the stories absolutely hold up. This album is a testament to country western's longevity. If only more country singers told stories this good.
Very classic western sound. I knew a few songs actually
This is quite a songwriting tradition in itself
Schöne Stimme
makes me feel like a cowboy
Gunfighter Ballads... new lows FFS
god i don't think i'll get any country albums here i don't like will i
Ah this guy! I've heard this before. It's quite endearing. Not really my first choice. But fine to listen once over.
Classic, still holds up nearly 70 years later. Bonus points for Marty looking like a PS1 character model on the cover. Rating: 9/10
So far pretty good, cool water
Fun times, gun times. I'm going to throw this a bone because it's really well sung, well recorded, and the kind of wonderful music it's a joy to come across.
Yeeehaw ! Fine but not my thing. A few of the tracks are repeats too, which I find a bit annoying. Big Iron was cool though. 2.5/3 That cover art doe...
Not usually my kind of music but I enjoyed nonetheless. Big Iron was my favourite song
Even though I am not a country music fan, this album is charming and enjoyable. There are a few known songs on here and none of the songs are bad. Pitchfork: n/a Rolling Stone: n/a Best Songs Big Iron El Paso
I didn’t think I would like it and it’s definitely samey but it has some good stuff!
HEEEEY I KNOW THIS ONE AHAHAHAAA big iirrooon
Não conhecia, excelente
Some of the most beautiful cowboy songs ever sung. Legend.
Good music can transport you to a different time, I felt like a late 1800s Cowboy who lived off the land while listening to these little ditties, is this an album that pushed music forward? Not enough to warrant a 5 star rating in my eyes, but this was fun beyond "Big Iron" which I've heard countless times already
YEAH
não é meu tipo
This was surprisingly quite enjoyable! I might go download Red Dead Redemption now
I don't need to listen to this one to rate it (catchup time baybeee). Yeah, I really love this album. I think 99% of western movies kinda blow but man, western folk and ballad is so good. I could see how the multi-part harmony would sound repetitive to some but I'm all for it. I think I know all the words to this album by now. I've discovered better western folk albums but this one is the only one on this list. Favorite(s): Cool Water A Hundred and Sixty Acres Least: Billy the Kid 5/5
Fav: The Hanging Tree, El Paso L: The Valley songs 3.5 Why is El Paso on there twice? The music world could use more ballads. Dated in a good way. Cover: 2.5 Kind of a cool pose Name: 2.5 Descriptive but not super accurate Minecraft Parody: They’re Griefing Me Tonight or Flint and Steel (Big Iron)
there's no doubt that marty robbins is talented, but these songs, these are a major contributor to the bullshit, highly romanticized view of the ultra-mythical old west. these are just laughably bad songs. that said, "utah carol" is also a legit banger
Not sure what I expected with a title like this but... this was not for me. Yeehaw.
Marty had a great voice. Lot of outlaws, bad decisions, and dying on this album, but it is called “Gunfighter Ballads.” “A Hundred and Sixty Acres” is a cheerful outlier. Mini western stories. There is no getting around singing along to “El Paso” and “Cool Water.”
Good storytelling. Quite a specific country sound but nice guitar playing.
Marty Robbins has a unique ability to make a sad or tragic story sound so cheerful... but without losing that sense of melancholy. This is an amazing record.
There's more murder in this album than NWA - Straight Outta Compton. This album is proper country, great stories that aren't just country buzz word bs. Definitely one of my top five country records. This album influenced a lot, you can hear where Elvis got his sound from. Willie Nelson's Red Headed Stranger takes the gunfighter ballad motif & runs with it. When you look into his life you'll know Robbins really was a true OG, homie even raced NASCAR for fun.
If you’re in a cowboy mood, this is the album
What a lad!
Simple, effective songs Really liked it. Big Iron and El Paso probs my faves.
Just for fallout alone
MARTY "FUCKING" ROBBINS!! Now this is an outlier from the typical album on here. If there's one critique I have of this whole 1001 thing is the lack of diversity in music genres. I'm glad they included this one. Big Iron, and El Paso are classics.
Good stuff.
I can see there being an audience for this, but it damn sholl ain’t me
Easy listen, some interesting songs. Standout songs: Big Iron El Paso
Oli ihan letkeää kuunneltavaa. Tykkäsin levyn soundimaailmasta (akustisia soittimia), mutta levyhän on tehty vuonna 1959.
Un embole, album muy viejo, no me gusta el genero
Remains a classic for its consistency in rhyme schemes, tales, and guitar licks.
I’ve heard the Grateful Dead play El Paso on about sixty different recordings and I knew Big Iron, but every other song here was new to me. Just a delightful set of western songs about cowboys. He paints a great picture for all these stories. One of the best country albums I have ever listened to.
Very odd. How many times does he sing about 20ish notches on a gun? It’s got that folk sound mangled by over production. Even with the folk sound though the lyrics are pretty out there.
🤠
nice
Nice country cowboy music
It sounds like it would fit right in in a Fallout game.
Wow I love cowboy tunes. I really enjoyed my time with this album. It made me reminisce of the time in my life when I was obsessed with the Django Unchained soundtrack (it was one of the very first albums I ever saved on Spotify and let me tell you, it did NUMBERS in my house and also on the commute from Wollongong to USyd and back). I think I’m just so enamoured with the storytelling that makes up outlaw country. It’s unsurprising when you consider alongside the fact I’ve been a longtime Johnny Cash fan but alas! El Paso was my fave and I was so glad it’s on the album twice. Also fun fact from my Wikipedia search, Marty Robbins born in Glendale, Arizona married a woman named Marizona. MARIZONA. I’m obsessed.
Some charm to this but not really my thing. The Master's Call won me over the most
Hell yeah Marty Robbins fuckin rocks shame he was a dick in real life
Listened to this before on an aborted run through this list... Not for me - so won't be listening again...
"I wanted to be a COWBOY, baby!" Fav Tracks: "They're Hanging Me Tonight", "Cool Water" and "The Master's Call".
It's nice music, but almost all the songs sound the same to me. Also whining about women in almost every song annoying, but I think that's a problem with country music in general.
Nice, contains the classic "El Paso" (I dunno where I heard it but sounds awfully familiar). Very harmonious and unique.
Hard to rate an album like this today. Sounds like a million parodies or movie songs about itself
Solid.
Interesting how older country/western and hiphop/rap is more appealing to me than newer stuff in the genres. This one might be a four based on a couple of songs, but not quite feeling it today
Pretty fun western music, couple of tracks I really liked. But it's a bit too old-timey, I guess?
Beautiful Classic Country
This was an amazing album. His voice is so smooth. The storytelling is stellar: sometimes funny, dark, always heartfelt. Classic Western is more entertaining than it gets credit for.
Not terrible but not something I’d ever seek out on my own.
Well I thoroughly enjoyed that. Having grown up with the sounds of Willie Nelson, et al in the background, I've long had a soft spot for a bit of 'outlaw' country. While this record isn't quite that - it doesn't have that rougher edge to it - it was clearly a huge influence on Nelson, Cash, and co. Great storytelling, and a wonderful voice. I now want to take the afternoon off and watch westerns. Also, it was fun to hear Cool Water - Walls and Bridges is probably my favourite John Lennon album, and he clearly lifted from this track for his song, Old Dirt Road.
I suppose there is some historical importance for this whether it is to do with country and western, the development of ballads in pop or somesuch? Well I am a fan of of westerns of all eras so I am going to give this some leeway, and it does hold some interest as the narratives go but I am not convinced they bear repeated listening.
One of my all time favorites. Incredible story telling and a wonderful voice.
Ye haw. Enjoyed this more than I thought I would
Some tunes ok. Production sounds a bit dated
Actually a bit catching. 6/10
Meh
Big IRONNNNN BIG IRROONNNNN
Perfectly fine western novelty songs, and 'El Paso' is a classic, but I have never understood the devotional enthusiasm this record inspires. The vinyl folks hunt for it like crazy.
Classic and cohesive, to a fault! Objectively, his voice is a bit of an odd fit with the songs’ themes, but somehow it still works.
There’s really good stuff in here, definitely Red Dead Redemption listening party type of music. Some of the lyrics are dated but what do you expect when it’s from the 1950’s
Marty's voice is so pleasant. Enjoyed this. 3.5/5
Guns n tears
This was a nice, pleasant listen. Marty has a pretty voice. I'd put it on again on a Sunday afternoon, but I don't have much to say about it.
This was actually way more fun than I was expecting
People used to love western shit huh
Overall good songs for the era just not quite my thing most times
Okay, I swear I’m not gonna rate every one of these 5/5, but come on.
I listen to this all the time as is, so even before starting I know it’s gonna be bops top to bottom
I am not really a country music fan but I enjoyed listening to most of these classic old tunes / cowboy stories
I really enjoy this album. My dad listens to it often so I have fond memories of it. I love my a good singing cowboy. Listened to it 3 times. 8.5/10
I loved this way more than I thought I would. I haven't heard 'El Paso' in so many years.
It’s a nice listen, with some fun stories of the wild west, but man all these songs sound the same
Im a sucker for storytelling songs. And each one can be connected to another. Truly embodies the wild west attitude back then, for better or for worse. Truly a way for people to cosplay an old fashioned cowboy. Good example of storytelling music, may be good for my fist episode of let me tell you a story. I dont know much about Marty Robbins and honeslty im a little scared to look him up lmao.
War never changes
Absolutely a classic record. Not enough stars for this one. 1000000/5
No way.
Notable Textzeile: I'm as sad as the willow That weeps in the valley Since you've gone Since you've gone from my arms Ich finde das sogar recht abwechslungsreich dafür, dass es auf keinen Fall Country als Musikstil verlassen darf. Auch das Storytelling und die Stimme sind gefällig, schön, angenehm. Ist das gefährlich, aufregend oder innovativ? Nö. Gefällt mir trotzdem durchaus und hat meine Laune gehoben. Dafür eine solide 3.
Title describes the album accurately. Hier wird jedes Western Cliché bedient, wobei ich die Lyrics und das Storytelling ziemlich clever finde. Marty Robbins hat auch genau die Stimme für diese Songs. Leider ist Instrumentierung und Arrangement unglaublich soft und nimmt den Songs jede Wirkung. Keine Sorge, er ist nicht wirklich lonesome oder kurz vorm gehängt werden, hier ist immer noch ein liebliches Gitarrenpicking um den Vorabendplausch nicht zu irritieren. Western Pop für die Vorstadt, für die little Boxes und das schicke neue Radio im Wohnzimmer. 1950s safety blanket.
Ich mag sehr wie beschwingte Melodien sehr düstere und blutige Texte transportieren. Außerdem ist Breaking Bad undenkbar ohne "El Paso". Mir gefällt sehr viel daran. Auch wie wenig ernst sich das ganze selbst nimmt.
I could see riding a horse and shooting some bandits to this.
honestly, slaps. this dudes voice is off the chain.
Fantastic.
It is old...gives you western movie vibes, kind of nice but nothing you would listen too all day...
3,5 stars
With his silky smooth voice and shiny black boots, Marty Robbin’s takes on a journey through the old west with top-notch storytelling and classic country instrumentation. A surprisingly pretty record, it kinda lacks a little bit of grit, but the songs are great. This goes to prove that the white middleclass obsession with crime and outlaws started waaay before rap music. I could go on about this, but I choose to just state that it’s fun. 7/10
A good album, but probably won’t be coming back to it much. Loved Big Iron and Masters call. Always been a fan of El Paso.
Ja gut, das erstbeste Lied kenne ich von ihm. Die andere Lieder sagen mir irgendwie nichts und holen mich leider auch nicht ab. Es gibt eine Respekt 2
May be my first full listen through of this. I typically use this as an album to sleep to. I love everything about it. Great story songs. Classic country sound.
Fun to have something totally outside of my norm. This record is great and I will definitely listen to this again.
Hmmm 50’s country. Early country, twang, slight hula sounds too? Lame lyrics. No thanks.
dachte das wird eine katastrophe aber hat echt bock gemacht!
THIS THE ALBUM WITH THAT SONG BIG IRON I LOVE. So many fun TikTok vids to this song that I’ve seen were so silly and fun. Like think he ACTALLY had a big a clothing iron on his hip.
great voice and captivating atmosphere. can only think of New Vegas when i hear “Big Iron”
Liked the album, it reminds me somehow of Tyrolen music and sometimes Johnny Cash. ★★★½
Quaint and mostly about the lyrics than the music. Not really interesting as a dedicated listen start to finish, but each song in isolation could work in the right context. For the songs in isolation this could be a three star. But I'm rating the album experience.
had mostly heard the singles. Was a little confused by extended El Paso. excellent
TL;DR: Cowboy cosplay which flucutates from sublime to tiresome. BEFORE: I've heard of the guy. That's about it. AFTER: Marty Robbins' rose-tinted cowboy songs are beautifully played and sung, but there are a few dull tracks here. There is also a lot of misplaced mythology around the Wild West™ that this music perpetuates while ignoring the uglier side of colonisation. That being said, some of these tracks are fantastic despite their origin. HIGHLIGHTS: El Paso is a superior country ballad. Big Iron kicks things off well with an upbeat rhythm, infectious melodies, close harmony vocals and fantastic lead guitar. The Master's Call and The Hanging Tree are similarly strong, dramatic compositions. Billy the Kid, Utah Carol, Running Gun and Saddle Tramp are also very good narrative songs. LOWLIGHTS: The slower songs are all very similar, which can be tedious - Cool Water, In The Valley, The Little Green Valley etc. Robbins also seems to have an unhealthy obsession with Mexican women for a staunch conservative. VERDICT: It's a strong 3. I'm not a country guy and some of this was not quite as engaging, but overall it was pretty good.
This was very fun and enjoyable. Will I ever listen to it again? Doubtful.
Coked out Cowboy tunes
I liked it more than I thought I would. It was like a spaghetti western but in music.
Pretty fun album. You still hear these in movie a TV soundtracks.
Everything you need to know is in the album title, and it sure delivers. Classic Western tales, lots of gunslinging, death, hangings, wrangling horses, and imagery evoking the old west landscapes. Was a fun listen, definitely a time capsule of music that we likely won't ever see again.
Gangsta rap for your great-granddad. I'm sure if I was born during the Great Depression, I would find this awesome... but it's really hard to appreciate today. There's a couple of really good songs ("Big Iron" is a banger and should certainly be on a movie soundtrack somewhere), but the remainder of the album is just very dated, and is rooted in a mythology and a musical culture I can't really relate to, no matter how hard I try. I didn't hate it though - this kind of old school country is much more palatable to me than the modern stuff, and the "dark lyrics on a jaunty tune" gimmick is definitely interesting. I won't listen again, but it was all right as a one-time experience. 4/10
Beautiful voice, sometimes reminiscent of the King on a few ballads. But cowboy stories and old-school country have too much Cohen brothers’ filling in this :) Nice as evening background music.
What I have to say about this is that I definitely would not have listened to this but for doing this list. Actually recognized El Paso. That’s a famous one. Who knew? At first I thought this was a joke. But as I listened, I found myself entertained. It’s a little like a country western version of Elvis but actually much better. I’ll put this in the “not exactly great, but fun anyway” category.
Seriously? How can this be included? Really dated and just not worth it.
I might of enjoyed this when I was a kid, when I used to like watching the old american cowboy films, nowadays it was a hard listen.
I feel dusty AF! great old-timey western songs really transports you to the trail days. Crazy he recorded this in one 8 hour session! Glad this was included will be looking for a vinyl copy for my collection.
Big Iron isn't even the best song on Gun Fighter Ballads and Trail Songs.
I can't give this album an honest listen. I got so burned out on hearing Big Iron when Fallout New Vegas came out. It's just so dated. And I'm not a fan of the old westerns from those days. They're too rose gold painted and this music just makes me think of that. No thanks, I'll pass.
Well, this is a pretty old country album. Certainly, it's older than any country album I've had on this list. It's probably the best produced of any 50s album I've had on the list, so it gets points for that. It doesn't necessarily confirm to what the modern listener thinks of as country, instead being a kind of folky, Western-themed crooner pop. Robbins has an excellent voice, and the album's sonic backgrounds are excellently produced, but it doesn't really inspire as much feeling as the likes of Johnny Cash. Still, it's an objectively good album with strong storytelling lyrics and excellent production, and it definitely should be on this list(well, for an American, it should be). This album is the lowest ranked of 5 1959 albums globally. Other 1959 albums rated by me: Kind of Blue(1/5)-5 Time Out(2/5)-3 The Genius of Ray Charles(3/5)-3
🔥🔥🔥
Very western story telling. Kachow
El Paso is a banger
Album #252 Marty Robbins: Gunfighter Ballads And Trail Songs Outside of jazz and Buddy Holly, I really haven’t found any albums from the 50s that had aged well enough for me to be interested in, and outside of Johnny Cash and Townes Van Zandt, I’ve never been particularly infatuated with a country artist; well, on both of those accounts Marty Robbins has just proven me ignorant. Some of the finest songwriting that I’ve ever heard; you would think that an album in which most songs are about the tragic deaths of outlaws, the material would start to get dry real quick; but Robbins somehow manages for each song to remain captivating and cinematic, while also having its own unique identity. The instrumental is minimal yet feels enormous, and Robbins' voice is the perfect sombre narrator to each of these stories. The crown jewel of the album in my opinion is ‘The Master’s Call’, an epic tale about young man who turned bad, only to be redeemed by a close encounter with god and death; this is one of the most impressive songs that I’ve ever heard, the way that Robbins is able to paint a picture and express emotion is something that I’ve found in few other artists, and it came out in 1959. When it comes to albums that have impressed me the most on this list, barring the ones that I’d already heard, they tend to come from genres that I don’t listen to much: The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady showed me that jazz can be just as engaging as other forms of music, Ágætis byrjun showed me that there is more to post-rock outside of Talk Talk, and now Marty Robbins has redeemed my faith in country more, now that I now there are more than two excellent artists in the genre. This album is the definition of timeless; I’m confident that in hundreds of years people will still be able to put this on and feel every word that Robbins sings. Best Songs: The Master’s Call, They’re Hanging Me Tonight, Big Iron Worst Songs: None Score out of 10: 10
Prekvapivé pre mňa. Mojej mladšej dcére aj vnučke sa to hneď zapáčilo. Tým, že mi pripomína Johnnyho Casha, je to z toho lepšieho typu country.
p44. 1958. 3 stars. Single paced late 1950s C&W. Points deducted for filler and sentimentality, but the highlights are still fabulous :)
I liked it. Reminds of old bars in my home city and in my grandparents farm community. Reminds of my dad playing old songs in his guitar. It's very lyrics heavy and has a interesting guitar. It can be repetitive, especially if you don't pay attention to the songs and find the nuances. It's not an album I would listen to all the time, but I like it.
Just sounded like big iron on repeat for 45 minutes. Not a bad song, but the album doesn’t hold up and gets repetitive
Elvis imitator inging cowboy hymns?
Cowboy music
Nostalgic and smooth as velvet, Marty Robbins' album romanticizes the cowboy culture of the old west. He sings tales of heroes and villains, love and loss, as only an old cowboy can. An excellent use of guitar and vinyl.
Big iron and a rare 5 star with only one liked song since it’s such a vibe but not a regular type of album
This really blew me away. I put it off for a while but the sound quality was excellent the songs were really pleasant. My gripe is that it's repetitive, but still a really solid, quant album.
Big Iron 3.2 Cool Water 3 Billy the Kid 3.3 A Hundred and Sixty Acres 3.2 Ythey're Hanging Me Tonight 3.2 The Strawberry Roan 3.2 El Paso 3 In the Valley 3 The Master's Call 3.3 Runnin Gun 3 The Little Green Valley 3.1 Utah Carol 3.2 Score: 3.141666667
This album was a surprising amount of fun. Big Iron is probably the highlight, but it's very old school country singing about outlaws and cowboys. What country should be really. It was a fun album and I enjoyed my time with it.
Gunfighter Ballads And Trail Songs isn't the worst country album I've ever heard. Despite this, I still didn't enjoy it.
Big Iron on his hip
Hi, I'm Woody! Howdy howdy howdy!! His voice is just lovely, but can't foresee myself sticking this on again too often. Apart from Big Iron, obviously. I must say that I just find fascinating the whimsical 1950s desire to create media relating to the life and times of cowboys. I can't imagine any modern day artist randomly releasing a 15 song album detailing a fictional account of idk... a munitions worker or something?? Maybe more artists of today SHOULD do that? I rather like the storytelling style!
When I saw this was another country album I groaned to myself before hitting play. Song One came on and I realized I know this from Fallout and then I proceeded to actually appreciate how good the music is on this Western record.
So I randomly learned of this record about a month ago because a guy from Converge talked about it on Amoeba What's In My Bag. I think I mentioned this in a previous review, but (with some exceptions) narrative/storytelling songs are not my favorite thing. Westerns and the outlaw aesthetic have also never appealed to me. But this is a top notch representation of this genre.
Am I a country convert? Great story telling. The guitar carries you along.
I love this albums inclusion because it’s so uncool. Finally, some sort of representation for the music that normies were listening to. Pretty sure my parents didn’t know who Coltrane was, but they probably heard the hits from this record. It’s easy to look down your nose at this impossibly-square crooner cosplaying as a gun-toting outlaw, but there’s a real outline here to the American imagination that, real or not, found a way to express itself as brave frontier badasses, even when the 50’s rendered that persona completely inert. Myth-making at its most commercial and comical.
I don't know how to describe this album other than immersive - the auditory equivalent of a John Ford film. Lovely voice and great storytelling, but I did get bored by halfway through.
I’m sure it’s not a lot of peoples’ cup of tea, but I thought these were quaint. Definitely a lot of nostalgia in hearing Marty’s rich voice and imagining the “romance” of the west, where the bad guy gets shot and the good guy saves the girl. It’s all a little samey, though, which is maybe to be expected.
Not an artist or album (or indeed style of music) that I know well, so was interesting to discover it here. I enjoyed the story-telling and the overall production, particularly the clarity of the guitar-picking and some of the harmonies, which are really well sung. The guy has a great voice, tonally, and I like the understated style, especially when overlaid with the harmonies. It's the less ballad-like numbers which resonate more with me; I enjoyed The Masters Call, Running Gun, The Hanging Tree and Saddle Tramp. 160 Acres and Big Iron are probably the two songs which stand out for me. Others feel less memorable and, when groupes together suffer from a lack of dynamism / variety for me, personally. As an album, this is (as described) a collection of similar themed tunes, in a style that I like but don't necessarily love, and so I'd be more inclined to dip in and out of it than listen as a whole; for me I'd prefer 10-11 songs, vs the 15 on here. Lastly, I can't get my head around this having been first released in 1959 - 67 years ago.
Ended up enjoying it more than I thought I would. Nice to have some musical variety as well.
ouin... ça pis Willie Nelson, c'est pas mon buzz...
Wow vraiment aimé! Je me sentais comme un « lonesome cowboy » perdu dans le wild west.
My hopes weren't high when I saw the cover and after listening they didn't get up. Country music is just not for me. I can't relate with american culture. In addition to that, the album was just repetitive. And when I say repetitive it's the rhythm, the lyrics and the vocals. To conclude, it's a very boring album.
Heavily carried by big iron
Ooooohhhh what a delight!!! So weird and niche and sometimes racist but overall amazing. Can anything be racist but otherwise amazing? I'll ponder that, but in the meantime, I'll be singing about the notches in my pistol and the gal whose heart is wasted on a cowboy like me.
I was really surprised when I got this album since it’s totally far away from what I usually listen to but that’s the beauty of this, to give new songs a try. I can’t hide I went into it scared because I don’t like country music, however I was pleasantly surprised that it was more diverse than I expected. The songs sound repetitive though. I can’t bring myself to delete it from my saved albums because I want to give it a try again. I feel like it’s a grower.
Lots of fun! I enjoy this every time I hear it, but I would never claim it to be one of my favorites. Big Iron slaps!
I absolutely adore this album! It has this amazing ability to transport you back in time to the days of cowboys and the old west from the moment you press play. At 15 tracks and just under 45 minutes it doesn't over stay its welcome. Phenomenal from front to back, an album I listen to at least once a year and one of my favorite country albums and probably one of my all time favorite albums. 5/5
I'm not a country person, but this was much better than I expected.
7/10
Well, it got so that every piss-ant prairie punk who thought he could shoot a gun would ride into town to try out the Waco Kid. I must have killed more men than Cecil B. DeMille. It got pretty gritty. I started to hear the word "draw" in my sleep. Then one day, I was just walking down the street when I heard a voice behind me say, "Reach for it, mister!" I spun around... and there I was, face to face with a six-year old kid. Well, I just threw my guns down and walked away. Little bastard shot me in the ass. So I limped to the nearest saloon, crawled inside a whiskey bottle... and I've been there ever since.
Boring and very repetitive.
Pretty samey although there was something about El Paso I kinda liked.
I mean.... it's basically Western gangsta rap. Shoot guys, riding Ho-rses.
Initially I loved this but my stamina for cowboy ballards waned quickly.
I would listen to El Paso or Big Iron as a novelty one-off, anything more is too much
There was some overlap between this album and my Gunfighters Top Trumps I had as a kid, which earned this an extra star.
Of it’s time I’m sure, but in 2026 Britain I have no shared identity with murderous Texan gunslingers. Nice voice. Very tedious album.
Some fun songs for sure. I likely wouldn't relisten but if I ever have a day with cowboy vibes.. I know what to play
One of my favourites, this.
Goated. Not much else to say.
Felt like I was in the old west
i was really excited to see this album on the list - some of these songs i genuinely really love (like i love a good western vibe). however as a full-album experience i felt like it dragged a little at points...all the songs are pretty similar (hence the title).
Generally not into country, but there’s something so pleasing about a perfect artifact like this. It evokes the Western obsession of the 1950’s, the (yes, problematic) misty-eyed romance of the frontier and Old Mexico. This was the era of my mom’s childhood, and some of it still had tendrils into my girlhood in the 1970s. It’s nostalgia I can appreciate on a historical, cultural level. Marty Robbins has a smooth voice as well, well-suited to these simple tales and guitar strums.
Bom demais. Sou fã de filmes westerns, e me trouxe uma sensação onde eu estivesse assistindo aos clássicos de John Ford, Howard Hawks e etc, nos momentos específicos onde se reúnem e cantam músicas, tomando seus copos de argila cheio de whiskey ou cerveja. Baita trilha de filmes, faltou só alguma do Enio Morricone da trilogia dos dólares, de resto, excelente.
Fallout 3 New Vegas OST!
This is a low 4
그냥그럼
also big fun
Anyone who doesn’t like this album is officially an opp
Dad had this album and I used to listen to it when he was at work. Excellent voice, storytelling and atmosphere. A big 5 iron on my hip.
I wasn’t my cup of tea but I honestly loved ot
While not my taste for the most part, I did enjoy that every song in this album actually told a story that was fun to follow. I've always enjoyed Sea Shanties for a similar reason. Many of the songs in here reminded me of the early Tremors movies, and of course Westerns in general. Enjoyable even though I probably won't be coming back.
Essential? Maybe not. Enjoyable? Definitely. I added “Big Iron” to my playlist.
What a fun album! From a musical perspective, this isn't brilliant, typical Western guitar and some basic bass. However, the songwriting is fantastic, I mentioned this last time, but it's necessary, it's an album all about Cowboy storytelling. The highlight of the album for me was 'Big Iron', but 'El Paso' was a close second! Lots of people struggle to enjoy this album because of its 'Cowboy' style and can't look past some of the dated factors, but I think it's necessary to take into account the culture of when the album was released to get a proper understanding of the album's meaning!
wild west nostalgia and gunfights, not for me
I'd give this album a 6/5 if I could. It's one of the best "country" albums every recorded. The stories told personalize figures from the wild west better than any John Wayne movie or Louis Lamour novel ever could. Robbins' voice is as smooth as butter and in my humble opinion he is one of the most underrated artists of the era. I celebrate Robbins' entire, very lengthy, catalog so I may bit a bit biased.
I can’t not think of Tim Robinson’s “The Night the Skeletons Came to Life” sketch from I Think You Should Leave while listening to this.
My dad used to listen to this and similar artist when I was a kid and I actively hated it. I was very surprised how much I enjoyed this. I guess I kind of like this kind of music now?
1.5 - I don't like this, but there are far worse country albums that could come up on the list.
A collection of romance for and about an American history that never quite was. Decent crooner, lousy material.
Heroes and villains, this album doesn’t choose a side for its perspectives, but it does tell compelling stories of the West.
i get it, its folky southern ballads about daring honorable western men
1. "Big Iron" 2. "Billy the Kid" 3. "The Master's Call"
cowboy music :D i've always wanted to be a cowboy.. big iron best song 🙂↕️
1) A Hundred And Sixty Acres 2) Little Green Valley 3) El Paso Least Favourite: Strawberry Roan
Pretty unmoved by this collection of tunes. Mythologising of the Wild West is generally a bit uninteresting, but maybe it's different if you're American.
Early outlaw country, with great storytelling and beautiful singing.
What a lovely album. Beautiful vocals and BGVs. Interesting orchestration. Great and fun stories and lyrics. Just a fun and delightful album.
Lowkey campfirey.
4.3. Really enjoyed great songwriting and story telling. Dead head here and love when they do the country ballads.
Not quite Elvis….but maybe where he got ideas.
I love this album, full of great strumming guitar, Marty Robbins' fantastic voice delivering infectious vocal melodies and great, evocative lyrics. Each song is like a mini western film, relaying tales of cowboys or the hard life on the trail. I hadn't listened to some of my 5's in years but I come back to this one regularly (in fact it's my 16th most listened to album ever, according to Last.fm) Highlights: Cool Water, Big Iron, Running Gun, El Paso
컨트리 안사요
4/5
Unique, poetic, lovely voice
Basically an audiobook, which I thouroughly enjoyed. For the people who played Fallout: New Vegas 3.6/5.0
good songs i like it
As an album experience I find this a little lacking because the songs fall into like one of four archetypes but the good stuff is good.
beautiful voice but this is a book for the ears
4/5
Low-key un vibe haha
Marty Robbins, what a legend. Simply one of the greatest singers to ever come out of a popular music in America (maybe the world). Beyond El Paso, Robbins had a diverse and wonderful career starting in blues and rockabilly before becoming one of the premium outlaw/cowboy country/pop singers. It's wild just how smooth and powerful his voice is - other than natural talent, I believe Robbins background really led him to become someone that understood and felt for the characters in story: ordinary American people. He was in the navy, but also worked as an amateur boxer, in addition to odd jobs such as digging ditches, driving trucks, and being a mechanic's helper. These songs feature, among others, outlaws, vagabonds, bandits, troublemakers, and murder balladeers. This music is literature. Gets 5 stars only because it's the only Robbins album on the list. I recommend "The Best of" anthology for those looking to learn more. When I worked for college radio, his music changed my view on the country for good and opened me up to a world of music I had never heard before.
solid 4.0.
Very fun - reminded me a lot of Glenn (??) Campbell
Good album.
You know when an album on this starts and you just know you'll like it? This was one of them, despite being classic country. Because it's proper cowboy/I suppose literally outlaw country, but early. It does drop off a bit after the first track into more basic country where Big Iron is proper cowboy balladry. El Paso and The Master's Call other highlights. But lyrically the storytelling was great too. And it was also often funny - They're Hanging Me Tonight, for example, even if not intentional.
i wanted to give this everything from a 2 to a 4, so i’m going to settle on a confused 3.
I thought this was gonna be abysmal, but then I realised it was all stories in song form about, well mostly being lonely, miserable and people getting shot. So then I decided I was judging it hastily and I should give it a go... But then I heard it. It's all that bopping baseline nonsense in every song. I don't see how you think you can portray death and heartache if the guy next to you is going "bom bom, bum bum, bum bum be bum bum bum. It's too jolly, even when the chords are minor. The stories were ok. Often predictable, his voice is alright, every so often you felt he meant it. I feel like I want to hear these ballads in a more stark environment. A single guitar and a withered voice. Maybe add some backing vocals for effect at the right moments. I feel I might be describing those later Johnny cash albums that I reviewed as not that great in a previous review here. Ah well. I didn't hate it. I won't look it up again, but it didn't ruin my day.
Loved this! Really fun
You put Grady Martin on lead guitar and you can’t go wrong. However the songs on this are so great. One of the first real country albums in a sense. And Marty sings them great. And that’s a cool cover isn’t it. Cool water is the standout track of an album full of standouts.
Music Trail songs you say....? Quirky and fun in a campy sing-along campfire style Entertaining warm ballads. A surprising delight and strangely irresistible.
It put the western into country and western. All the tunes here are fantastic, it's great sound. Gets the Tex Mex flavour in there too which would have been quite a thing at the time. Love this record.
I've been watching old John Wayne movies recently. They're corny and a bit politically suspect, but pretty entertaining. This is the album equivalent of 'The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance'-- there's cowboys and senoritas and murder and revenge and justice and shoot-outs. The story telling is top notch and the tunes are great. Lots of fun, hard to criticize. My son Alfie wandered into my office while I was playing this. "Oh yeah," he said "Big Iron! That's a great song!" He knows it from playing Fall Out. It is a source of constant surprise to me the variety of sources that young people use to learn about these days -- video games, music placement in TV and movies, tictoc videos, ads -- but, as a result, I think young people have much broader tastes these days and are familiar with music from a variety of eras and genres. And he's right, that is a great song.
Turns out I don’t hate all country music
I really like the first song (big iron) but the rest is not really the music I listen to too much so I found it a bit hard to finish the album
What all music should aspire to
A perfect album of storytelling, with unbeatable atmosphere and songwriting without flaw. I love me some Nick Cave (to name a comparable storyteller / songwriter) as much as anybody, but he dreams of attempting to write songs as pure, unaffected and elemental as these. These songs sound like they've been around a hundred years. Best track: "Big Iron"
Marty Robbins recorded the entire album in a single eight hour session on April 7th 1959. One day. Thirty five minutes of cowboy mythology, gunfighters, doomed love affairs, and trail songs that sound like the American West smells. Columbia Records producer Don Law had no idea there would be a market for it. The album peaked at number six on the pop charts and went Platinum. Don Law was wrong about a lot of things that day. Robbins got the idea for El Paso in 1955 while driving his family home to Phoenix for Christmas. He saw the city limits sign, thought it sounded romantic, and wanted to write a song about it. By the time he reached the other side of the city he had forgotten the idea completely. Four years later it became the first song to win a Grammy for Best Country and Western Performance and sat at number one on both the country and pop charts simultaneously on Christmas Day 1959. Some ideas are worth forgetting and then remembering. Big Iron and El Paso are genuinely great story songs. The same quality that makes Johnny Cash a 4 in my collection lives here too. A great narrative does the work that a drum kit does elsewhere. It builds tension, moves you forward, and pays off. Robbins understood this instinctively in a way that most songwriters spend entire careers chasing. The rest of the album is pleasant, competent, and exactly what it promises, which is cowboy music performed by a man who grew up in the Arizona desert and clearly meant every word of it. 3 out of 5. One star for El Paso, written on a Christmas drive and forgotten before he crossed the city limits. One for Big Iron, which is a perfect song by any measure. One for recording a Platinum album in a single afternoon, which is either genius or a very efficient use of a Tuesday.
A phenomenal album with amazing harmonies. El Paso is incel music though
I used to think it would be cool out on the vast planes as a cowboy....but not if they are playing this!
1959. I was 5. I remember my parents had Roy Rogers/Dale Evans records that we would play. Don't remember really caring much for the music but it was something to listen to. We also had Peter and the Wolf, a symphony for children, written by Russian composer Prokofiev, liked it more than this album.