Reviews (page 3 of 16)
not terrible
nazis don’t get streaming credits. did not listen.
His antisemitic ramblings overshadow my ability to listen to his music, skipped
Will not listen.
4.5 /5 damn why was i even avoiding this piece 😭 this is firee 🔥 no this album is more like drinking fresh spring water in the morning. if that even makes sense.
10/10 miss this Kanye BAD
There's some great variation here in the beats, rapping was decent, and lyricism was good. I actually laughed out loud a few times, namely with the School Spirit skits and the MJ bar on Slow Jamz. Last Call was a bit annoying since it's just 10 minutes of him talking about his record deal complications, but the saxophone and the whole beat in the background made it not entirely tedious to listen to. Favorite Track: The New Workout Plan - This is a great song that quite effectively criticizes the way that many men only value women for their bodies, but in a comedic and upbeat tone. Genuinely funny song.
i don't look at hitler's art and I don't listen to this nazi's music
Uhh, nahh, no thank you. Some catchiness here and there, but all overshadowed by negative perception of the person.
Not bad, but also Kanye.
I’m really torn by this n on its own, it’s a 4 or maybe a 5. I legit think Kanye is/was a creative genius. But also just an awful, awful person. It’s a shame he couldn’t be neutral to good, so I could enjoy his music without guilt. Anyway, I’ll give it a 3.
i loved this album - came out when i was squarely in college. melodic, fun, clever. very of its time with the skits
I didn't think this was that interesting and I like a lot of rap. I just felt like the lyrics weren't that intriguing and while his style is good, the beats were not great. There just wasn't much for me to latch onto here. That said, listening to this gave me a new perspective on how much growth Kanye had as an artist. I had My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy earlier in this countdown and it was amazing. Great to see how far he came from this album, which is inferior to MBDTF. Still, not awful. 3 stars
despite being my least favourite of the college trilogy, it's STILL a classic.
Super production, with the bass standing right out - some great verses, some less great rhymes
No. I hate this record!
irrespective of my opinions on kanye as a person, this album was actually better than i thought
yeah, no. not a chance
First time listening to Kanye's music intentionally, this album passed me by when it came out. As a hip hop/ r&b album it's great, lots of easy beats with the chipmunk soul to add a lightness to the feel. The vocals also flow very well and aren't all about how hard or rich he is which is refreshing. A good amount of variety in styles including the skits/ interludes which break up the flow a bit but are fine as a style, the Last Call monologue while interesting for backstory is not something I would go back to regularly. Well produced and enjoyable to listen to so I'll rate it that way. Don't need to mention the man himself as plenty of other reviews have that covered.
Rather enjoyed this.
No song better defines the appeal of Kanye West than Through the Wire, written and recorded in 2002 with his jaw wired shut after a car accident. He’s a force of will — rejected by the establishment and his peers, but fighting through until he was the rap star he envisioned himself to be. And while he may not have the poetic prowess of his forebears, his plain delivery and honest, messy lyricism have the rare effect of exposing a man’s heart and soul. His layered and intricate production here changed hip-hop at the time, but it was the intimacy he offered that changed it more in the long-term — and the naked humanity he offers is why, even as his worst impulses have taken him places impossible to defend, I still can’t quit him.
Incredibly important album in the history of hip hop and popular music in general, bursting with originality and great ideas. Fantastic from the start up until track 8. However, I can do without much of the rest of the album, including the 12-minute-plus final track. Part of his charm is that maximalism and excess, but to me, it gets kind of irritating after 30-40 mins.
I can dissociate man and artist, but this is just boring music.
Gotta separate artist from the work. This album is cohesive and well put together, and an absolute blast to listen to!
Better than expected.
Not my thing
Unclear if it could have been a 5 if not for the Kanye West of it all
I wandered around the mall to this album, passing time as stores were opening up, so I could buy Seth a pair of shoes for his birthday. For the second time in this project, I have come across an album I am already intimately familiar with; however, where Frank Ocean's Channel Orange was a great album I liked from a well-respected artist, The College Dropout is one of the foundational albums of my childhood, from a deeply problematic and troubled artist. I knew Kanye West would be on this list, and I had to prepare myself for how to go about his work. Growing up, before Kanye's turn towards hateful rhetoric and public unraveling, he was one of my favorite artists. Countless albums of his defined my childhood and my music taste, and coming to grips with his promotion of hate was the first time in my life I truly had to grapple with the ethics of listening to music which resonates with you from an artist who is doing active harm. As a result, It has been years since I've listened to a Kanye West album, as I could not personally navigate my own level of comfortability. But as Kanye's behavior has calmed down, and he has issued an apology (though if his past is anything to go by, this is likely to be invalidated at some point soon), I personally felt ready to relisten to this album. Through all my personal turmoil over this album, I was ultimately not surprised to find that upon relistening to it now, it still hits me just as it always as. I still hear the old Kanye when I listen to this album, the artist who reshaped public conceptions of hip-hop and persevered in the scene through persistence and hard work. Kanye's production style, with chopped up soul samples pitched up to chipmunk levels, was revolutionary for the time, permeating the scene and influencing it for years to come. Kanye's skills as a rapper and lyricist have often been maligned as his weakest point musically, but maybe as a result of finding him so young, I have always enjoyed Kanye's somewhat corny, overly sincere lyricism. While a little ham-fisted, there is something honest in how bluntly he speaks on societal issues and causes this early in his career while still finding some levity. Especially on The College Dropout, he still has a self-aware sense of humor which gives the entire album a sense of identity, and his personal story of grinding day in and day out to work for this moment is easy to buy into. This sense of humor is also prevalent in the album's many skits, a common trend in hip-hop albums which I find incredibly entertaining here despite typically being a weak point for other artists. This is also an early showcase of Kanye's knack for bringing countless artists together on his albums, and while that trend starts here mostly as a buffer to give some market viability to an unproven new artist, Kanye would go on to hone this skill into one of the biggest tools in his repertoire. Honestly, there was only ever so much fault I was going to be able to find with this album; I spent over a decade cultivating a deep love for this entire album, and a few years of distance did very little to dull that connection. Even a long, winding, 13-minute self-indulgent victory lap like Last Call keeps me captivated for its entire runtime. I have heard it said before that we can be victims of fandom; as in, we often have little control over what artistic works resonate with us, especially when we have so much time to ingrain them into our very being before having reason to discount them. I remain skeptical of Kanye as a person, so long as he refuses proper help and demonstrates no true level of healing or thorough remorse, but it would be dishonest to pretend that I don't still love The College Dropout. Highlights: We Don't Care, Graduation Day, All Falls Down, I'll Fly Away, Spaceship. Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down, Get Em High, The New Workout Plan, Slow Jamz, Breathe In Breathe Out, School Spirit Skit 1, School Spirit, School Spirit Skit 2, Lil Jimmy Skit, Two Words, Through The Wire, Family Business, Last Call
Cannot STAND Kanye West.
kann ja sein, dass die musik ganz ok ist. aber keiner wird mich dazu bringen die musik von diesem nz anzuhören
Pretty nice, beats are pretty basic though.
Kanye’s debut album. This is my least favorite of the three albums he has on the list and its still a 10/10 for me, which really shows how great Kanye is AS A MUSICIAN, and maybe someday he will be as great of a person. Two Words and Family Business are two very beautiful songs and The New Workout Plan may be one of the most fun-to-listen songs of all time.
not listening on principle sorry. already listened to one kanye album for this project.
I'm still coming to terms with the fact that I really, really like Kanye's music. After MBDTF, this is basically a confirmation. I slightly prefer the former, though. Favourite track: Jesus Walks
PHD: pretty huge dih
I like Kanye he’s cool
deep sigh what an album, still good how did he go from there to now 💥spaceship 💥jesus walks 💥never let me down 💥get em high 💥two words
Just not a fan of Kanye’s style of music. Like I know Jesus Walks is supposed to be a banger but I just couldn’t get in the groove.
All falls down, slow jamz, never let me down all good, everything else is still pretty good
Nah
Right from the get go, this album had me hooked. The different collaborations, beats, and lyrics worked to tell an incredible story of success through adversity. The messaging was largely any how you can be successful without a degree, and that a degree isn’t gonna garner what you think it will. I get why Kanye thought of himself as a musical genius. This album exemplifies his talent, rhyme schemes, story telling, and beat master. Despite its length, it doesn’t feel like a chore to get through and each song flows into the next seamlessly. It’s absolutely worth the time.
He’s got a bit of a messiah complex and gone a bit rogue. Likes the N word , a lot. Ok in places
Probably should have stayed at college and learnt something!
If ever there was an artist where I really want to hate the music too, this is that twat! Annoyingly this is kinda good, with a really cool vibe and flow only really ruined by his vocal ramblings. There is no indication in this well constructed album of the idiot he would become. Standard score reduction for being a Nazi.
Nazi twat
Great album, not my favorite of his.
Kanye on his way up to his peak, is better than his way down from it
Pish
I see it´s a tremendously played record but it just didn't cut it for me. Guess I´m not young enough.
i'm not qualified to comment as I don't follow Kanye much but this was an outstanding listen and is justified to be on this list.
I can see why people think Kenye is a genius but I can see why he's off putting. This is a debut & "most humble." He gets props from me because he's from Chicago. This is a very long album. I want those 12 minutes back from having to listen to Last Call. I don't care. I don't care about their fancy pants shoes or hats. Shut up! Don't care. 3
Several really good songs, and some clever wordplay. Super inconsistent, however.
The Gay Fish™️ truly is one of the greatest rappers of his generation. This is an awesome debut from someone who very much believes in himself, to keep it kind. His ear for sampling is superb and the beats are absolutely fantastic. To be clear, Kanye’s behavior of the last several years has been reprehensible, but it’s a bit disappointing to see the virtue signaling one star reviews that refuse to listen to the album because Kanye is a POS. Most of the major artists on this list are problematic in some way and if I skipped them all on moralistic grounds, I probably wouldn’t do this project.
will not listen.
Unfortunately there is not a zero rating, otherwise I would rate this album, and any by Kanye West, as a zero. I will not listen to anything by Kanye West, on principle.
heard it before what a beautiful record love the soulfulness of the samples and relatability of kanyes lyrics
Not 100% my cup of tea but jesus walks is great
Funny skits, great production, and an awesome era for Kanye. Great album. Rating: 7.5/10 Favorite Song: Spaceship
Bicho queimadão, vários reviews jogando a nota lá em baixo. Foda, o artista cagar com carreira, ainda mais ele com um negócio tão absurdo que não dá pra acreditar. Tentando separar a arte do artista, parece que ele tem um talento foda. Pelo que vi é o primeiro álbum dele, ele era produtor, tipo o Raul. Tentou fazer a própria arte, e parecia manjar o que o mercado curtia. Não é meu estilo de música, não ouvirei de novo, mas vou dar 2* pela qualidade.
Ya lo había escuchado previamente, a pesar de que tengo preferencia por otros álbumes de Ye, este lo empezó todo, no tengo tantos sentimientos o pensamientos sobre este disco.
4 stars for Sid. Actually very good even though he's a fascist nutter.
Has as many incredible songs as I remember, but a few more skips too
peak
I'm not the biggest fan of either the genre or the artist, I had to listen to the album twice to start enjoying it. Definitely deserves its spot on the list, that's for sure. But still, it didn't make me see the magic others see in Kanye.
Polubiłam ale nie potrafię docenić tak jak inni
If half stars were a thing on here it would be 4.5 stars. Putting two skits back to back is diabolical sequencing.
I really tried to look past the human being that created this album and expected it to be a pretty good listen. But it was very disappointing. Apart from a little while in the middle of the album the whole thing felt pretty disjointed. I could not really get into this album throughout. 2/5
If you’re apt to set expectations for an album based on the aggregate score, you cannot do that here. Look at the reviews and you’ll see very few low star reviews are for the album or the music. It’s just that they don’t like the man. Fair enough I guess. Your lowly review on this site is making a big difference but it’s probably better to just rate music and stop skewing results based on other criteria. This is one of the greatest rap albums of all time. The man himself doesn’t change that.
Whatever man. Fuck this guy to the degree that i was really bummed getting this record generated for me and i don’t wanna do it. I dunno, it’s probably really good. God man, gimme a break from all these dumb motherfuckers.
God, the skits are so annoying. The music’s good though
I went into today’s listen knowing this album and placing as my favorite Kanye album still holds this spot as of this listen great album! Best song has to be Family Business
It’s a bit embarrassing that more than 20 years after this was released, this is my first time hearing this album. Growing up there were a lot of people around me who said that rap isn’t real music… and for a long time I bought into that idea. I had the realization years ago that people in previous generations said the same thing about black music in their time whether it was jazz, early rock, r&b, etc. That realization and learning more about the culture that produced hip hop really changed my view. However Kanye's personal shortcomings kept me from giving him a chance. Upon listening to this album, it is clear to me that it is a masterpiece. There are so many incredibly strong songs, it’s especially impressive for a debut. Family Business, We Don't Care, Never LetMe Down… the list goes on. I'll definitely continue listening to this album moving forward.
Kanye is not the first, and won’t be the last, highly questionable character on this list and that’s probably a gross understatement. I’d completely understand anyone who wanted to skip this one entirely, I myself don’t really listen to his music anymore but if this is going to give me the chance to I’ll certainly take it. Thankfully this is pretty straightforward, just reviewing the album itself. In my view, this is one of the greatest hip-hop debuts, if not debut albums full-stop. I don’t have anything but praise for this project. Kanye was in and around hip-hop and other genres, primarily working on production and making a name for himself in the years before he dropped this, most notably work on Jay-Z’s classic The Blueprint. He references this and talks about his journey up until this point on Last Call. This allows Kanye to enter his debut as an outstanding producer and already on the path to one of the greatest samplers ever with his chipmunk soul sound, sampling classic R&B and Soul tracks into magnificent hip-hop beats. These samples even complement the lyrical themes he’s going for on these tracks. There are so many excellent examples here but Spaceship’s sample of Distant Lover by Marvin Gaye might be my favorite. On top of these beats, Kanye displays entertaining, clever, and funny lyricism throughout. His flow and the way he enunciates his words gives him a certain grip over the listener’s ear that’s hard to describe. He sounds genuine and self-aware here, making it clear why he and this record were such a cultural phenomenon and he became so loved by so many. I can’t imagine what it was like when this revolutionary project dropped, offering something so different to what most hip-hop releases sounded like at the time. Even the skits and interlude moments here I found highly enjoyable as they build upon the album’s dedicated themes. The whole thing is littered with classic tracks and memorable moments. If I had been exposed to Kanye sooner, I could have seen this becoming my favorite album of all-time. In a way, I’m pretty relieved that didn’t happen. 1 re-listen Favorite Tracks: All Falls Down, Through The Wire, Jesus Walks, Slow Jamz, Family Business, Two Words, Spaceship
Expectation: -> This should be 2-4 range, most likely a 4. 1h 16-min could make this a challenging review. Not a Kanye fan. Never previously sought a Kanye album. But I'm a fan of most popular hip-hop and rap plus I've liked three Kanye songs on Spotify prior to today. After listening: -> Not sure if this album is prime Kanye but it surrre sounds like it. Impressive skill, creativity, lyricism, variety. Excellent collaborations. I have not looked, but I'm guessing that this album received accolades back in the day. Track ranking: (not including Intro, skits, etc.) Never Slow We Spaceship Falls Breathe Wire Family Two New Workout Jesus High Spirit Call Graduation Fly
fuck this guy. But his music is surprisingly good, not my normal genre but I really enjoyed it.
While he has become a complete shit show, in my opinion he made one great album. This is it. His rhymes are on point here and there are no signs of the bizarre, unintelligible rants to come.
Kanye's fifth best album. Still a classic.
Jesus Walks Never Let me Down Slow Jamz
All Falls Down Spaceship Breathe In Breathe Out Two Words
I never heard anything by Kanye that I liked, but enough friends thought he was a genius that i figured "Maybe it's just me, maybe i'll hear something one day that makes me understand". It happened with other artists, could happen here. Well, this is the firat Kanye LP i've listened to in full and...no, I can stick with my first opinion. Production is ok, but really doesn't blow my mind. I guess Jesus Walks is interesting enough? His rapping is passable, but doesn't really blow my mind. None of the lines stand out as amazing. What really sums it up though is the vibe. I'm used to hearing rap of people boasting about their cars and money and women - fine, it's boring, but whatever. This is different. This feels more like the whining of a kid that got bullied, talking about how now he's famous he's going to bully everyone else. The whole 3 track skit mocking higher education...I guess it's meant to show how brave Kanye was, but it just sounds like the most whiny 'chip on my shoulder' bullshit. It's said that when you're used to privilege, equality feels like oppression. This whole album felt like that - the guy who usually has no struggles, talking incessantly about the one time he was treated like less than a god, and how one day he'll show everyone. Ugh. 2, because itsnlt even offensive enough to be a 1.
Music is good; but not a rap fan
No nazi trash
hmmm...okay okay it's good. i like (most of) the skits and songs. they're relatable & innovative. artist/ art separation, idk.
very good, even not being my style of music, i really enjoy it
Early Kanye ist einfach geil. Manchmal sexistisch tho
People have hyped up this album for so long but I'm kinda underwhelmed. Really could't decide between a 3 or a 4 but I had to stop listening halfway through that last rambling song. So many of these tracks overstay their welcome.
I'm still not terribly familiar with Kanye's catalog but I was impressed by the previous Kanye album in this project (My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy) and I know I've heard "Jesus Walks" before. Like that other album, this one has a very impressive guest list. And just like with the other one, listening to this, I get it now. I see why everyone was blown away by him at the time.
Cut the rap and talking and you've got a good album! Most of the instrumentation, samples and singing is good
why did i not listen earlier the production on this is incredible
So far, only "All Falls Down" and "Spaceship" have really stood out to me. I'm not enjoying the album that much overall, and I think part of it is Kanye's vocal style—it just doesn't click with me. The melodies and featured artists are generally good, and the lyrics are decent, but nothing has grabbed me enough to want to revisit the entire album. I could see it working as background music, but I don't think I'd listen to the full album again.
10/10 perfect Kanye's debut album
more like 3.5 actually. I like Kanye.
Just like kid rock Will not be giving kanye any streaming time. Fuck this guy
Same old rinse and repeat hip hop genre nonsense with better production chops.
кани прайм
There are two undeniable here. 1. This is a great album. 2. The artist is a complete narcissistic piece of shit and a trash human.
I remember loving this album when it came out. Kanye was a breath of fresh air then. Through the Wire was a great intro for me, and then bangers like Jesus Walks, and Slow Jamz followed. It was quite a time to be alive. A lot of those songs have held up, if you can separate the art from the artist. Biggest Hit - Jesus Walks Biggest Miss (if I had to choose ) - Family Business Not So Hidden Gem - Through The Wire
642/1001 2026.06.23 🌑🌑🌑🌑🌑 No soporto este estilo, y no tolero a nazis. No voy a gastar ni 5 segundos es escuchar a este mierda.
i don usually listen to kanye but omg this album is definitely a must listen!!
3.88
Best Track - "All Falls Down"
I wanted very much to not like this. However, I must admit, it’s a pretty good listen. I wanted very much to dock this based on the despicable human being that Kanye has shown himself to be, and yet, at the time this was released, Kanye had yet to fully reveal his true inner assholeishness, so I decided that I can feel comfortable just judging this on its musical merits. Lastly, I wanted to bang on this when I saw it checked in at 76 minutes. But really, until the last half of the last track, this moves along very briskly and pleasantly, such that you have no concept that it is actually as long as it really is. Four stars for me.
Musically 4 star, lyrically 2 star, so gets a 3.
I don’t think this is Kanye’s best album, but it did lay the foundations to what he becomes, and it’s a very good listen, although it’s one of those with only a few repeatable tracks, and more of a story line through it. Have to give it a 5
Nostalgia is a big factor in this rating but it really is a great album even if Kanye can be hard to get behind these days.
Probably the best Kanye album
A troubled genius. I don’t have any issue separating the art from the artist…not sure what that says about me, but this gets 5 stars from me all day long.
Very good album, every song and skit is a 10/10
Had to fish out my old bootleg CD I burned back in 2007 so I wouldn't give streaming revenue. College Dropout-era Kanye would've written a whole diss album about Ye for how much of a cringey bigoted sellout he became. Would've been 5 stars from me if you asked 5-6 years ago. It's unfortunate to see such pure talent put into this art comes from the "Scoop-diddy-poop" guy in the black Klansman robes. One star for being a MAGA shithead. No idea how someone who wrote The College Dropout and Graduation can be the one cranking out garbage and ranting about Jews on Twitter. He can try to hide behind his bipolar disorder now because he lost so much revenue, but I don't buy that. Your mental health is NOT your fault, but it IS your responsibility.
Stay in school.
Maybe that teacher he was talking about had the right idea all along….
Fasciste.
Déjà au secondaire, quand Kanye était all the rage, le cover m'intriguait. Je n'étais pas un grand fan de rap, mais je trouvais que ça sortair des codes traditionnels. J'aime beaucoup le flow de Kanye, je trouve qu'il est smooth et qu'il drag. J'ai aussi l'impression qu'on a affaire ici à un album concept qui traite de scolarité et de performance, ce qui n'est pas si usuel comme thèmes dans le rap. Je trace la ligne entre la politique et la musique et je dois rendre à Ye ce qui est à Ye, c'est un excellent album. D'ailleurs son personnage politique très coloré est d'après moi une grosse façade boufonne.
Kanye avant qu'il devienne coucou et antisémite. C'est plate à dire mais cet album est assez grandiose et mets en lumière ses talents de rappeur mais surtout de producteur (quoiqu'il avait déjà fait ses armes un peu avec Jay-z précédemment). All falls down gros classique
nie noj ulubiony cos tam git cos tam nie
“When Kanye was actually good.” Banging album.
Kieltämättä hyvää räppiä.
Kanye is obviously an arsehole, so I streamed a rip of this on YouTube to not give him any money. I never understood the tortured genius impression people have - this music is not particularly interesting apart from a few cool samples he picked and is often downright ugly sounding. The skits just suck. Admittedly I’m not big into this kind of music but acts like Kendrick or RTJ sound infinitely more interesting to me. It’s not a one star but it’s not far off.
I can respect the man’s craft and there’s some good stuff on here, but it’s very convoluted. The ego has always been his biggest enemy.
Say what you will,but ye drops heat
aldrig gillat varken hans stil eller hans sjukt repetitiva samplade beats, sen är han nazist också så det hjälper ju inte
Yeezus! Interesting, hadn't heard this album before it's enjoyable and unique enough though I don't love Kanye music 3/5 + (why no Jew talk?)
- Umm, it’s good, that’s for sure. Not my thing though
Bad.
I LOVE this album.
gran álbum
THE GOAT! I listened to this on repeat back in college and right after.
I was surprised. This wasn’t too bad. Kanye sounds coherent in this album. Too bad his mother died suddenly. I think she was the person that was making sure that Kanye stayed grounded in reality. Of course, having an overlooked Traumatic Brain Injury did not help either.
Separating art from the artist here... I don't really listen to or like rap/hip hop. However I can appreciate that this is very good. He is a good rapper. Each song is unique but still flows well together and the writing and rapping is also great (i think.. im not exactly an authority) i stopped paying as much attention in the latter half... 12 minute long final song is diabolical. however it was (unfortunately) objectively good. just not my style i would never listen again even if it was by someone unproblematic
Torn here as this is my first Kanye album on this list. This is a classic album but it’s extremely difficult to separate the art from the artist here. Gonna call it a 2 star and move on
I wasn't in the mood to waste my time on this... sorry, but no, sorry! I'm sick of getting dragged into controversies! Kanye was never my type, especially now that he's shown himself to be the stupid jerk he is! I’d give it a zero if I could! In fact, I’m starting to get tired of all this Anglo-Saxon stuff: I’m sure there’s much more interesting music in the world than what’s on this list—or is the idea to always stay inside the same bubble?
Bagus tapi bukan buatku
damn, 2004 kanye was a different dude, huh. self-introspection and political consciousness! wild. anyway pretty strong album, didn't transcend me but definitely good stuff.
the best hip hop album of all time
Rappers and intro sketches go together like peanut butter and terrible sketches. This is a long album, a bold choice for a debut album. I am not loving Kanye's or the children's singing on We Don't Care. All Falls Down is a great song, one of my favorite hip hop songs of all time. We should have seen him eventually losing it. Jesus Walks is another good one. He's undoubtedly talented. I like Jay-Z, but I like Kanye's verse on Never Let Me Down better. Get Em High is a jam. Kanye, Talib Kweli and Common is a crazy group of MCs on one track. It would have been cool if the three of them had done an album collaboration like Talib did with Mos Def. SKETHCHES!!!!! Why?!? A lot of featured MCs...I don't think they were calling them collabs yet when this came out. Apparently he's not a fan of college. Mos Def too...he has Blackstar on different tracks. Through The Wire is a cool concept and it's crazy that we was able to rap that well while his jaw was wired shut, the Chipmunk singing through the track is annoying as hell though. A 12:40 "song" to end the album? The internet existed when he did this...nobody needs a 12 minute interview over music to end an album. This album just lost a star...this is so stupid.
Я вдруг понял что совсем забыл оценить College Dropout поскольку разбирать такие альбомы ОЧЕНЬ СЛОЖНО. Я не скажу что он мне понравился, ровно как и не скажу обратного. Спасибо Мистер Кайне, что создали великолепный жанр "Душа Бурундука" конечно, но, как мне кажется, какой нибудь My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy или Yeezus будет изучать интереснее. Для фанатов же, наверняка пластинка крайне интересная, ведь это не только (очевидно) качественный релиз со своими хорошими моментами, но и, так сказать, "стартовая точка" для Кайне как для фигуры-кумира за которой следят миллионы, со всеми своими противоречиями, спорными моментами, со всеми этими изобретательными семплами, темами с Богом которые прослеживаются уже здесь и прочими, прочими приколами. И тут как бы, наступает момент шо ты думаешь "ну не буду же я как дэбил писать очередной отзыв в стиле: ыы ну чота вроди прикольна" НО В ТО ЖЕ ВРЕМЯ, мне-ж натурально надо месяцы потратить на изучение его дискографии и в частности порядочно так времени на изучение этого альбома, шоб составить более менее комплексный и интересный обзор. А оно мне надо? Оно мне не надо))00)0) Так что, чё сказать? Альбом нормик, со своими хайлайтами, монструозно большой, но как мне кажется, у Кайне есть релизы намного интереснее. Переслушивать не буду. не моё.
Solid storytelling but mediocre sound
I don't need to engage with Kanye, thank you. I'm sure his music is good and a thing of its time. Instead of listening to this, I listened to For You by Tatsuro Yamashita since City Pop is probably not on the list. Good stuff, very entertaining!
Nazis get 1.
goat
People tend to miss the old Kanye, but in my view the oldest Kanye music is a bit dated and lacks some crunch. Maybe he went off the rails with the crunch, but you need some crunch ya know. This album in the first few tracks reminds me a lot of Miseducation of Lauryn Hill. The same school theme, and the instrumentation, piano-led like in I'll Fly Away feels very of that ilk. Its all quite nice but very safe until Jesus Walks, what a song, what a great beat. There's a too many stupid skits and filler if you ask me. There's also 4 or 5 of Kanye's absolute best tracks, so its a bit of a tough call. Kinda depends what you value in an album, quality or quantity. Intro - 0/5 We Don't Care - 4.5/5 Graduation Day - 1.5/5 All Falls Down - 5/5 I'll Fly Away - 3/5 Spaceship - 3/5 Jesus Walks - 5/5 Never Let Me Down - 3.5/5 Get Em High - 2.5/5 Workout Plan - 1/5 The New Workout Plan - 2/5 Slow Jamz - 5/5 Breathe In Breathe Out - 2.5/5 School Spirit Skit 1 - 2/5 School Spirit - 3/5 School Spirit Skit 2 - 2/5 Lil Jimmy Skit - 2/5 Two Words - 3.5/5 Through the Wire - 5/5 Family Business - 4/5 Last Call - 4/5 3.6/5
Terrible. Horrid. Untalented
intro– he sounds like goofy we dont care– how many times can one man say 'man'??? how can a profesh singer be so pitchy?!?! graduation day– girl i js gwaduwado. pure background music. PURE lift music all falls down– dont pmo whys it actually alright 🤬 ?!?! nvm theres a woman in it thats why 🥳 ill fly away– no idea spaceship– lowk bangin 😓 what is that beat i HEARRR jesus walks– lowk bangin too damn. its the beat again i swear its not kanye
This is one of those albums you have to separate the art from the artist. Kanye's debut album and he comes out on fire, creative raps and great takes on social themes of the black community. He is a good producer and made some cool beats. It's a nice change from the popular gangster rap of that era. Way too long! JFC an hour and 16 minutes, I hate the fucking skits. It is a good hip hop album and brought conscious rap back to the forefront but it is too damn long, cut the skits axe a couple songs with all these guest artist and this would have got a higher rating.
Not my favorite style of music, and the guys obviously has mental health issues and screwed up politics, but this is coherent and groundbreaking album
Ik weiger sorry
Ja nee not doing that
Ik wil niet eens GECATCHED worden dat ik hiernaar luister op airbuds of spotify vrienden
Masterpiece - Ye's first solo studio project, this album revolutionized the hip hop sound scape from the early 2000s onward. Taking an unorthodox approach to rap, Ye managed to mashup gritty hip hop drums with accoupling chops of soul music which results in a unique and must listen to for all hip hop/music enjoyers. Definitely one of the most influential albums of the 21st century Best song - Slow Jamz
Ok, no está mal. pero tuve problemas al inicio ya que detesto a Kanye. Este y Graduation son muy buenos.
Um clássico de um artista que não gosto tanto. Legalzinho, mas nenhum supera Graduation.
I liked it. Kayne's still not super-confident in finding the kind of refined, Kanye's-special-sauce sound that he would uncover later in his career but it has legs. The College Dropout, while being great in its own right and an excellent stepping stone towards true music greatness, fails to reach the kind of wild highs we would arrive at in, say, MBDTF. Part of it is definitely that he's leaning a lot harder into his own traditional rapping ability here, which has always been good but has never quite matched the heavenly level of his ear for clever production. Also the skits kinda suck. Fav tracks: We Don't Care, Spaceship, School Spirit
I was just listening to this yesterday instant five star, I don't even need to think about it. I love kanye, i love kanye
Guess I need to stand with the hard pass people!
Booooo
Can't get into this one.
Peak period KW.
Not the worst rap album. Thats the highest praise I can think of.
2026.06.09
At the end of the day, he's just a gay fish who used to be married to a hobbit and didn't take his meds while hanging out with MAGA Nazis... go swim little guy! This was the only album by him I actually listened to (thanks to Limewire) and he was pretty revolutionary before he lost his marbles.
One of the best debut album of all time.
He is nuts. But man this is a bad ass album. I had a lot of fun listening to this. 8/10 just because of past transgressions. Top song We don't care
I recognize that the production and the song-craft is good. There are reasons why Kanye is so critically acclaimed and has sold a lot of records. He does a good job of blurring the line between underground gangsta rap and commercial radio-friendly pop rap. Much of this record just doesn't interest me, particularly the "skits" and the last song that just drones on and on and on and on and on (I think it's still going, honestly...) and the more poppy mixes. It's an ok record that I'll likely never listen to again.
It’s alright but he’s a nazi soo
Theres a reason Kanye is one of the most acclaimed artists of the 2000s. Still don't like skits but they worked in on this very well.
Still so good. Urgent and fresh, even all these years later. Kanye’s debut is one for the ages. The skits kill some momentum, but that really is just a sign of the times. Listening to “good Kanye” bums me out knowing how everything worked out, but it’s always nice to be reminded of the artist he was.
Another Kanye album I really wanted to dislike. But sadly I quite enjoyed it. Not as much as the other one I reviewed for this but pretty listenable with some great samples made into catchy songs.
Im a fan of Kanye’s music, and he’s a musical genius. This album has never really done it for me though
Good stuff. Dude was a genius.
Grew up on this one so tough to separate that from the nostalgia but Kanye was special before he lost his mind. Still think Jesus Walks is his best song
A personal favourite, regardless of the artist himself. Honestly, an album that I really feel listeners need to separate the art from the artist. This is a hip-hop gem, with funny lines/skits, solid production, and a voice for the everyday person.
Not my fave Kanye but still stellar
Classic.
Primero salió michael rancio, con sus controversias, y ahora me salio kanye occidente, con sus otras controversias. Musicalmente no conozco mucho de rap, pero me gusta a nivel producción y los géneros en los que se mueve. Es divertido el muchacho y los skits le dan el toque. 7/10 porque no puedo separar lo desagradable que es el hombre.
Pretty epic and enjoyable
Good album
It’s beast mode………
yeah so... basically the best and most formative music ever for me... soooooooo ..........
послушал несколько раз за выходные. Как по мне, относительно средний альбом. Хотя, как я узнал из описания, один из 3лючевых рэп-альбомов. Возможно потому что тут по минимуму гангстеров, наркотиков и прочей тематики, свойственной рэпа.
great
Through the wire
Fuck man, why did you have to be insane...
nicht so gut wie das andere, mehr classic rap und halt kanye west...
The skits are super annoying, but the music is great. 4.0/5.0: Great
lot of really great songs on this but man theres a lot that shouldve been cut as well
it’s a very nice album and i would rate it higher if i didn’t despise kanye as a person
Real example of separating the art from the artist. This was a total banger of a debut album. Introspective, it reintroduced conscience hip-hop after a run of boasting about product placement. Talked about materialism, religion, race, and higher education. And it's funny. Of course, the giant elephant in the room is how you feel about Kanye, especially in 2026. I feel like I should take a strike down because he's been absolutely repugnant these last few years.
8/10
FFS Kanye, you should have kept your jaw wired shut.
Stupid
Look, this album was really good.
good flow, real themes. great variety and creativity. emotion. people have opinions, but there's no getting around it- this dude is talented. literally such a banger of an album, but you have to listen to the whole thing. so real.
I’ve already given this man steaming income off one album for this project. I will not give another. A pity-he’s got some talent, but I couldn’t even. I got ice cream instead. The ice cream was 5/5: earl grey with shortbread crumbles and raspberry jam, inspired by the jammy dodger cookie.
un artista que te enamora a primera escucha su gran versatilidad, una lástima sus polémicas.
And here, in fact, is the album that first made gangsta rap wither! Got it back to back with Get Rich Or Die Tryin'. It was Kanye West who pushed stories about the plight of black villains out of fashion, giving way to calm and even instructive stories about family, religion, choosing one's path, and conscious consumption. This was superimposed on sped-up samples of old soul. The problem is that the album is overloaded with fillers. Instead of three skits mocking achiever syndrome, they could have used just one. The last song is a twelve-minute mash-up of the artist's career history and thank-you notes to friends; it feels like a cartoon added onto the rest of a VHS tape. Yes, the dude has been going downhill lately, but that's no reason to dismiss his older works. We're not — pun intended — westoids, are we? "- Kanye West?! You're my hero! - Do you like my music? - You're a musician?.."
As awful as Kanye is now, I can't bring myself to rate this album low. It's an incredibly tight, funny, and interesting album with plenty of great tracks on it. I won't put it at a 5, but it does crack 4 stars for me.
What a great album. Have to take a point away because of current day Kanye though
Easy listen - not Kanye’s best
My first real listen enjoyed most of the album…have to try more
I had quite literally never listened to Kanye West until this album, and I was actually really surprised with how much enjoyment I got from it. Is it my preferred style of music? No... but I enjoyed branching out and listening to something different. In a way, it kind of reminded me of 'The Who Sell Out' in the way that some of the album is set out, for example, the track 'Intro' and 'School Spirit Skit'. I enjoy that kind of creativity with an album, especially one of this length, as it keeps things fresh and stops you getting bored so easily. Due to the number of songs, it is hard to remember how each one was after the first listen, but there were some stand-out tracks that definitely made a mark on the first listen. Favourite lyric: 'They say, "Oh, you graduated?" No, I decided I was finished.' ('School Spirit'). Favourite Tracks (there are more than usual due to the album being so long): We Don't Care The New Workout Plan All Falls Down Never Let Me Down Get Em High Last Call
I don't listen to Kanye west
He's great here. Makes me sorry for what he becomes. Separate art from artist, I guess...
8/10 As with many artists, particularly when looking retrospectively at their work, it's important to separate the art from the artist, unless their worst side is specifically present within the art. Yes, Kanye is an immensely troubled and problematic man, but looking at this album on its own merits, it's an excellent and innovative piece of work. Where hip-hop often falls down for me is on the repetitive nature of the beats and musical content. Some rappers also fall into the trap of having very straight rhythmical flow to their delivery, so I can find some of those elements detrimental to my enjoyment of the music. Fortunately, Kanye rarely falls into that trap, with the majority of tracks offering good range, longer from chord structures and motifs, and plenty of rhythmical and tonal variety. The amount of harmonic complexity and tonal layering also elevates this record, with enough depth to the compositions to reward deep and repeated listening. Kanye's also on pretty great lyrical form, flipping smoothly between comedic, sentimental and introspective in various measures. He does touch on moments of stereotypical rap subject matter, but it's largely done with a knowing wink, rather than a more direct approach. There are some moments of supreme quality scattered across this record. So much of them, in fact, that there's a 10/10 record hiding in here; We Don't Care, All Falls Down, Spaceship and more are truly excellent pieces, but there are moments when things slip.back into the more straight, repetitive brand of hip-hop that feels more derivative and less invigorating, such as Get Em High. The skits are also pretty awful and feel out of step with the quality of the rest of the record, as does the overly long, self-indulgent and portentous closer; Last Call. Apparently, the LP of this album doesn't contain the skits, which would probably be enough to elevate this to a 9/10 for me, but with those included, it feels overly long, a tiny bit patchy and just a step away from that 5 star ranking. But it's still bloody great. Intro - This is incredibly irritating and not as funny as Kanye thinks it is. Thankfully it's just an intro. We Don't Care - The choice of samples and general flow of this is great. It has a soulful side while maintaining a bit of hip-hop grit. Most importantly, there's a strong melodic and harmonic focus to the track, including from Kanye's vocals, both sung and rapped, which is where I often fall down with rap music. There's also plenty of range and variety in there, as well as some great hooks. An excellent opener. Graduation Day - Sadly, we get an actual track with skit dropped over it. The music here is decent enough, but the over autotuned vocals are a detriment to the track. But this is hardly much of a track anyway. All Falls Down - And now we're back onto the good stuff. Again, musically, this is really rich and it reminds me of Lauryn Hill. Turns out the vocal is lifted and reperformed from a Lauryn Hill track, so that makes sense. Plenty of rhythmic range within the rapping too and there's still a lot going on across the layers of instrumentation. The bass is great, in particular, but everything weaves together beautifully. I'll Fly Away - A musical interstitial now. It's pretty, jazzy and soulful. This is the kind of thing I can get behind. Very nice. Spaceship - This is another great one. Nice use of the Marvin Gaye sample, but it's developed into a completely different vibe with the layering of everything else and the chorus is excellent. Apparently Kanye sings the lead on the chorus, and he does a great job. His vocal reminds me so much of someone else though, but I can't put my finger on who. This is a solid blend of soul and hip-hop, but with a funky psychedelic twist. Love it. Jesus Walks - A nice change of pace now. There's a good bit of drive and aggression to this. It's dark, funny and the vibe is so strong and consistent. The rhythms are excellent and well layered. It's not got the harmonic richness of other tracks, but positioned on the record like it is, that doesn't matter a jot. The insistence and intensity are the all important parts here and it's executed brilliantly. Never Let Me Down - Hook city again, but we still get a bit of darkness hanging over from the last track, which is excellent song sequencing. The depth and vibe to this is excellent and the variety of rapping styles between Kanye, Jay-Z and J. ivy adds extra flavour and style to the mix. The transition out into the more subtle piano focused section at the end is gorgeous. Get Em High - Back to something with a bit less range, but it's more rap focused and again, the song sequencing helps stuff like this to work as part of the album structure. It's probably the weakest track up to this point because it's too repetitive and long, but the rapping is still solid. Workout Plan - Again, this is a bit annoying. Less annoying than the college guy at the beginning though. The New Workout Plan - The mix of rhythmic layers is great again here and he mixes up the delivery of his vocal to pull it around nicely. It's not quite got the harmonic depth of the best tracks, and it calls back to a more traditional hip-hop sound, but there's still plenty going on. There's also a cool change up of style late on too and I'm a sucker for a tall box. Fun. Slow Jamz - Another nice change in pace now. Yes, it's a slow jam, but it's also pretty funny. There's some great range in rapping pace and style here, but it's all backed superbly by the underlying slow groove. The chorus has great hooks too and the overall vibe is quality. Nice. Breathe In Breathe Out - The lilt to the groove is great. It's another with less depth and range, but with the album sequencing, doesn't drag things too much. The rhythmic flow is solid and it's hard not to bob to the beat. Not my favourite, but still pretty good. School Spirit Skit 1 - This is a bit funnier than the earlier skits, but still not great. I feel like these are the moments that age this record the most and let it down. School Spirit - This is a touch repetitive, but the vibe is still great. The melodic inflection to his rapping adds a lot of depth that enhances the track in a way that a straighter delivery would never have managed. While it does drag a little towards the end, it's still pretty good. School Spirit Skit 2 - Meh. Lil Jimmy Skit - More Meh. Two Words - We're back to something with way more depth and range. The beat is tasty, and there's enough development to make it interesting and varied throughout. It's layered beautifully, and every touch enhances the groove and vibe. Each listen exposes another little touch of quality. Through The Wire - Another soulful groove and we get more of Kanye's rapping range despite delivering it with a wired jaw. There's some lovely bass and guitar stuff in here and it's another with impressive harmonic depth and feel for a genre that can sometimes skimp on those elements. The beats are also layered really well to add depth and nuance. Family Business - This is a really sweet and pretty track. The simplicity of the gorgeous piano and bass arrangement is lovely. The use of choral work adds a good harmonic depth as the song progresses and Kanye's slightly melodic and rhythmically varied rap delivery works superbly. Excellent. Last Call - The core of this is great, but good lord is it self indulgent and over long. To be fair, he does throw in a decent bit of musical range and variety across the track, but it's also quite a rambling and unfocused narrative in which Kanye tells us how he got signed and gives a bit of side-eye to people who couldn't see his genius. In hindsight, one would suggest that this track is kind of an indicator self-important and fame hungry personality that would derail him over the next couple of decades, but it's in stark contrast to the introspection and conscience of the rest of the record.
for some reason physically repulsive to me.
Great highlights like Thought the wire, all falls down, we don't care and slow jams. But too much filler and too many annoying skits about degrees. Could have been a 4 or 5 just by cutting the run time in half
Okay, interpersonal issues aside, there's no other option but 5 here. A breakout album with this wide reaching vision, each song being unique, funny skits, it all comes together perfectly.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ Kanye är verkligen upp och ner för mig. Detta är ett bra album. Inte lika bra som My beutifull dark twisted fantasy. Gillar att det är mycket sammarbeten, det gör albumet varierat. Jag gillar inte allt men helheten är ändå en 4a. Bäst är we don't care, All falls down, Jesus walks, Never let me down, Slow jamz, Through the wire
How do you separate the art from the artist? Shame he went so badly down the rabbit hole. Perhaps be was always like that. Opinions are irrelevant, it's getting a 1 even if the actual art is better.
I have no idea how to rate this. Almost skipped the album, he's that repulsive. It's an entertaining listen, and a glimpse into the artist before he fully went off the deep end. That's why it gets the 2 star instead of the 1.
Meer fan van het latere werk van Kanye, maar het valt niet te ontkennen dat dit een erg sterk album is. Net geen afgeronde 4 sterren.
Kanye is uiteraard een groot trendsetter geweest voor hiphop en pop in de zeroes. Dat maakt dat ik ook enigzins verbaasd ben hoe slecht grote delen van deze plaat agen. De context van Kanye zal er ook wel mee te maken hebben, maar los daarvan zijn veel van de beats en flows op deze plaat zo duidelijk 20+ jaar oud. Highlight van de eerste Kanye platen, inclusief deze, is wat mij betreft hoe hij de featured artiesten verwerkt in de nummers. Dit zal uiteindelijk natuurlijk culmineren in de briljante platen met Jay-Z en Cudi, maar die kwamen niet uit de lucht vallen als je deze samenwerkingen hoort. Om mee af te sluiten: Fuck Kanye. Sla je lokale nazi.
I think it’s clear that Kanye is a pretty fucked up dude. Narcissist with money and a microphone. Sucks for the world. Fortunately, I don’t give him two shits of my time. Not a big social media guy. He only enters my orbit on this platform. The music is decent, the rap is about average. Nothing special here, and not my thang.
Greatest album of the 21th century
Absolutely great hip hop album. Couple songs never cared for, but the album is a classic.
It sucks that Kanye West is the person he is now because right here is an extremely talented young rapper in the making. The beats are excellent, the production are excellent and some of Kanye's lines are funny as heck. 4/5
Top 2 Kanye album and it ain’t #2
the more melodic/layered tracks, some of which are definitely highlights, work better than the more traditional hip-hop ones, probably because neither kanye’s lyrics nor his flow are particularly interesting. it’s a bit too long and uneven for its own good, but I do get what the fuss is about.
Even though Kanye went crazy and fell off, this album is a straight classic. We wasn’t supposed to make it past 25, jokes on you we still alive!
i will stress: i do not like or care for kanye west as a person. but i can separate art from artist, to a degree. i found this one to be perfectly fine, though its length really threw me off. by the mid point toward the end, i just got really tired of the song length. i'd say all the really good ones are on the front half of the album, and then unfortunately the middle chunk of the album didn't capture as much of my attention. the skits i found just okay, if a little grating since they were all back to back. i'd prefer if they were spread out over the album. basically i didn't start paying attention again until we got to through the wire. however, for a debut, it's definitely a stellar start-- kanye's lyrics have always been highly praised by critics, and he really flexes that prowess. they're dense with great flow, and the wordplay / rhyming scheme in some verses is pretty fascinating i probably would have liked this way more if it weren't for the length, which is largely inflated by the very last song on the record (a whopping 12:41 runtime....). highlights: all falls down, jesus walks, through the wire, family business.
as much as we've come to loathe the man, the album is still fantastic
4.5/5
~ INCOMPLETE ~ not streaming atm. will circle back
Not for me
Back in the beginning, before he was nuts, he dropped a banger of an album.
Kanye is a deplorable person but a few of his records before he went off the deep end are essential to understanding the evolution of rap and are admittedly pretty damn fun. This era of Kanye is him at his most sane and his funniest, and this album in particular is one of the most consistent, stylistically interesting rap albums of the 2000s. Gorgeous, colorful soul samples everywhere. Skits that are actually pretty funny. Not a single bad song! Impossible for me to hate on this; if anything, it makes me a lot sadder about how he’d end up. Probably easier for me to like since I started listening to Kanye before his heel turn into bigotry - I get it if you have to skip this one.
This is great, though not quite up there with My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy for me. Just a bit too long and the skits are irritating for the most part. Can totally see how he got inspiration from Lauryn Hill which is never a bad thing. This is my kind of rap so fair play to him for moving away from all the gangster nonsense And yes I am separating the art from the artist otherwise why bother as half the artists on here would be binned off
I got this back to back with My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. Naturally, I broke them up by working through the rest of my backlog, first (saving Sepultura for a palate-cleanser). An hour and fifteen, Yeezy? That's a daring debut. Man, the anger was there from the beginning. As usual, I am annoyed at how good this is. At the same time, it's in line with the quality of the greats that he calls out (A Tribe Called Quest, for example). That's high praise -- those are genre-defining artists. Kanye is more of what I imagine to be a torch bearer. He's carrying on the quality from a previous generation and let me tell you: this is leaps and bounds better than Drake or all that Soundcloud/benzo rap bullshit. At the same time, Kanye is just a tall man standing on the shoulders of giants. Maybe I'd call him a genius if he weren't so busy doing that himself (and other, much worse things) but I won't. He's great. But not *the* great. 4/5
spoczko, typowy rap ale tez nie tak ze juz to slyszalam , moze dlatego ze z lat 2000 (bardzo to slychac) kilka piosenek mi sie spodobalo reszta w miarę okej ale to juz raczej dla osob ktore słuchają takiego rapu I PREFER KANYE
not a fan
Just not my style of music.
“Separate the art from the artist” is doing some really heavy lifting here but his talent during this era is undeniable.
made sure to listen in a way that wouldn’t give him any money because kanye is an evil evil man… but dang he made some GREAT music
I can see why he got big, but I've never cared for or about Kanye outside of a song or two maybe.
more than an hour is too much for Kanye... and his shameful history doesn't make it easy to give it a honest review... But besides that, he never was a genuis. Using samples over and over....... not as genius as composing yourself
great album! I saw this tour in college
i'd love to veto this one but i already knew it and loved it before he came out as a literal goosestepping nazi. the music is phenomenal, but in the face of the shit he's said and done it does not matter. his downfall is the kind of thing that keeps me up at night. fuck Kanye and fuck you for making me think about him. if you've never heard this one before, skip it and spare yourself the cognitive dissonance. or just pirate it so he doesn't get paid off of your streams.
Everything about this is on point, beats, lyrics, production and features
Hip Hop, 60 eme album =>1/5
I can listen to this on repeat forever
I don’t like him, I rarely enjoy rap and there’s too much justification provided for the parental advisory sticker. That said, there is something to this music that has pushed and reshaped the genre. For that there should be some acknowledgement despite West being a terrible human being.
I dont like kanye west as a person but i believe that you can take the art from the artist. The collage dropout is a fantastic debut album and one of my fav kanye west album ever it is 5/5 for me one of my favrapalbums
Uncomfortable listening. Iconic sound (at least for the first half of the album and the last few songs), but I don't think this man should have a public platform anymore (at least until he can get his mental health, his hate, and his ego in check)
eu odeio tudo o que esse mano representa, e me afetou o suficiente pra eu odiar a arte dele, principalmente pq essa bosta que ele representa ele enfiou na arte tbm já tinha ouvido esse álbum em 2022 ou 2023, antes da merda bater no ventilador em níveis maiores (ou antes de eu saber das polêmicas dele) é bem produzido obviamente, ele tbm influenciou todos que vieram depois - mas isso é óbvio e ele não merece vanglória nenhuma a essa altura não muda nada na minha vida e não mudou nada quando eu ouvi, só pensei que era legal 3.5/5 / 7/10 arredondo para 6 pela bosta que ele é
It’s kind of wild to revisit this, everything about Kanye is already kind of there, we just didn’t notice it. Terrible misogynistic rhymes and homophobic jokes and lame sex puns, a refusal to take responsibility, etc. but mostly it’s realllllly HS. The music is insanely good though, but the lyrics aren’t and it goes on forever.
The College Dropout is an amazing record. Kanye was the first to really take an old song, speed up the sample, and put that weird, high-pitched vocal underneath the rapping. It was jaw-dropping because nobody had heard anything quite like it before. Soon enough, everyone was trying to imitate it, but you have to give Kanye credit for doing it first. The guest rappers on here are all phenomenal, especially Jay-Z. On 'Never Let Me Down,' he drops that perfect line: 'Hov's a living legend and I'll tell you why / Everybody wanna be Hov and Hov's still alive.' The album captured hip-hop rubbing up against pop and somehow still working without destroying the core hip-hop element. This was the point where hip-hop was setting the trends, rather than just trying to follow them. Then you have 'Jesus Walks,' which is such a subversive song. While other rappers tried to be subversive by talking about drugs, guns, and violence, Kanye comes in and raps about Jesus. As he points out right in the track: 'They say you can rap about anything except for Jesus / That means guns, sex, lies, videotape / But if I talk about God my record won't get played, huh?' Of course, it ended up becoming a massive hit anyway. The only reason I can't give this a full five stars is because, well, Kanye went a little bit crazy later on, and that has to count for something.
What an album. Such a shame the master behind an absolute banger has become the person he is today. For the purposes of this, without a doubt a 5/5.
What a debut. I’ve been into this album pretty much since it came out so I’ll never argue with another listen. This is GOAT for me. The social commentary is so eye opening. Not that it told me anything I didn’t know, but to hear it put the way it is, and in the conceptual format it is, really changing how I understood some of those social concepts. It’s very real and raw, but also sarcastic and funny at times. And all that isn’t even mentioning the beats, the flows, the guest features… it’s all just so good.
Yes it’s very good, but I no longer have any desire to revisit any of his albums
I saw him in 2001 opening for U2 with just a boombox and a microphone. He never got any better in my book. I just don't understand the fascination or the declaration that he's a genius. He can write clever stuff but it's just not catchy, my kids are brainwashed and I hate that. Minus points for the silly and unnecessary skits & abusing the N word. From my perspective, outside of "We Don't Care" and "All Falls Down" "Spaceship" & "The New Workout Plan" were gibberish. "Jesus Walks" & "Never Let Me Down" were average. The rest were super average and overly wordy with messy beats. A ton of filler, not much killer. Impressive listener counts, that's a fact, no song with fewer than 46M listens. 2 stars, it's not as cool as people want you to believe. No one will listen to this shit in 20 years.
Admittedly, I don’t really listen to Kanye and I’m more familiar with the Graduation Album. This was a bit of a disappointment as it tends to have so much hype.
00’s Hip Hop ⭐️Slow Jamz
what I'm gaining from this, is that he's probably referring to his life as a teenager with this entire album. oh and his early adult years?
I mean, its Kanye. Quite simply the most impactful artist in the 2000's/2010's, and his debut with "College Dropout" was the start of a self-propelled cultural shift. His producing, in combination with absolutely insane features flow flawlessly from track to track, holding your attention the whole time. Is he rapping about the abject failure of the higher education system, churning out people with degrees but no skills, and how it has failed black culture? Just rapping about "fuck school"? Or was he trying to just rap about what he knew and push his confidence in the scene to a new level? What is indisputable is his insane name recognition and top hits coming out of this record, and its insanely unfortunate that he took the path he did. 4/5 stars.
Good one. Through the Wire is my favourite. The album is a bit silly and over-the top in portraying a caricature of a people with a degree but I feel like that's the point. Good beats and I like Kanye before he went completely bonkers.
Beginning was really good, but then the album proceed to become kinda meehhh, 3.5+
My new favorite rap album!
He is a very talented rapper and producer and that is demonstrated on this album, where his ego doesn't lord it as much as some of his others. Just not my thing.
Kanye fan yes, Ye fan no obviously. The last 2 minutes of The New Workout Plan has been my ear worm on repeat this listen, has the strong beat and auto tune good stuff that’s makes 808s and Heartbreak my favourite album of his that won’t get a feature on this list.
Unfortunately, he really is great at his craft.
I entered this a cynic but it did really win me over. As a fan primarily of 808s & Heartbreaks through to (mostly) The Life of Pablo, I came into this knowing only a few songs (none of which were really my favourites) and also thinking that stylistically this would be a long way from the pop maximalism I love from MBDTF. I also haven’t intentionally listened to any Kanye in quite a while (although obviously still exposed to it everywhere) and so was actually very pleasantly surprised by a lot of what I heard. The curation skills were in full effect and there wasn’t a lot that I would describe as obnoxious. School Spirit and Never Let Me Down were the big standouts to me, and I got so excited when those first moments of Autotune flickered in towards the end of The New Workout Plan (I think it was that song?). Quite a few songs that I didn’t enjoy much at the start also won me over by the end, and surprisingly I wasn’t turned off by all the skits (even 2 in a row!) or the 12 minute closing song, although the whole thing was too long. Anyway I really don’t need or want more Kanye West entering ny collection in 2026 but here we are
i don't know how to talk intelligently about music, i love this so much - probably my favourite kanye album as a whole piece, even though the liked songs ratio is lower than others. he was so HUNGRY and CONFIDENT - it's INTOXICATING to listen to more skits in albums!
He was really good once. Shame.
I miss old Kanye!!
Not for me.
2000's rap, making me think abt high school musical. Chill. Will probably not listen to the whole album in one shot again, but some songs are cool
It's good I fear. It's good like Sandman, and Father Ted, and Rosemary's Baby, and all those other pieces of influencial art that suddenly leave a bad taste in your mouth because of who made it. Oh well. Atleast you can say that this was the peak.
Ridiculous that this is a debut album, it's so, so good. My introduction to Kanye was Late Registration and I've somehow never listened to this until now. The production, lyrics and flow of the album are so impressive, the skits are funny and there's a perfect balance of serious and not-so-serious songs. There's no song I didn't enjoy but my standouts are All Falls Down, Spaceship, Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down, The New Workout Plan and School Spirit. An incredible debut album from an incredibly flawed genius.
Another music icon I know nothing about. I let the music do the talking and find there’s not much here for me. As usual the rap albums made in this era mixes in some R&B which should make the backing tracks more interesting but always end up sounding so boring. Also the usual bragging and “n” words just sours the whole vibe. No wonder youth culture is so fucked up these days if this garbage is what they’re putting on a pedestal. I really hope the other albums get better because listening to this was a really lame experience.
This is not bad at all, but I still don't get all the hype with Kanye. He's a good rapper (his old stuff ofc, before he got crazy) but it's nothing that groundbreaking.
Already listened
I did as much as I could (it's a long album). There are some good moments but it's just not my cup of tea.
If this was by any other artist it'd likely be a strong three-star album. But Jesus, if any artist was worthy of a zero-star rating, it'd be Kanye.
The hardest part of this was listening to each track for less than 30 seconds so that the douchebag wouldn’t get paid. Can’t separate the art from the artist which is a shame because it’s good music and the collabs are fire.
Everything on this album is great except that last song. It is also a testament who how far that Kanye has fallen. I guess that is what happens when you fly to high you will be burned.
I have him blocked, which is a shame bc I used to really enjoy his music before all that stuff. Why can't I give 0 stars?
Could be worse, but it's not worth listening to again.
I was very reluctant to give Kanye any time or streams but for completion's sake I did it. It was long. A few 2000s classics at the start but mainly just him coming across as already not a very nice guy tbh. Not great rap because it's so full of other random stuff.
Impossible for me to rate this one objectively because it was such a massively defining part of my adolescence. It's very difficult to listen to now that Kanye has become what he has become, but I love it dearly.
Not a Kanye fan
Nope
I miss the old Kanye
listened before already and have loved, like absolute classic. if you are having a good day either put this on or if you wake up one morning and feel it being a good day, put it on
Surprise like from me. Never listened to Kanye, but I will go back to this one from time to time.
I can appreciate the musicality but not really my preferred genre of hip hop. Listened to about half of it. Lyrically there was a lot of Black consciousness and religiosity to start. I am generally good with the first and less enamored of the second. In this case, the combination along with the Kanye centered Kanyeness of it felt like a precursor to the dark web of conspiracy theories and antisemitism that he later descended into. Somewhere around The New Workout Plan it takes a hard turn toward body shaming and misogyny dressed up as self aggrandizing sexuality. Hard pass. So this gets a nah from me.
The production is modestly interesting, but the vocals are pedestrian. A good example at times of how an overreliance on rhyme can mask (to some extent) a real failure to write lyrically. There are lines that just sound like some dipshit talking, but -- it has rhymes! So, that makes it lyrics! It's notable that the energy level rises so noticeably on Get Em High, highlighting how ordinary the preceding material is. A lot of swearing and being crass ... if you can't match that stuff with inescapably compelling drive, beats, deftly deployed samples, etc. -- then you just sound like a juvenile asshole. And trivial. Overall, a very elaborate exercise in pointless nihilism. The skits, as they accumulate, become a tedious abomination. Last Call is a fascinating, sprawling account of how a hugely talented, ambitious narcissist navigates a strange, uncertain industry, working deliberately and diligently to realize his dreams of becoming a fabulously wealthy, immensely popular artist and monstrous human being.
In 2004, I was separated from my first wife. I was teaching yoga full-time, and taking care of my son half the week. I was pretty much alone in Albuquerque; I knew folks from yoga, but felt like I needed to keep my yoga life separated from my social life. I'm forever grateful for Kristine M, my elder by a decade but a fellow movement person with whom I shared a lot of creative touchpoints back on the east coast. I was listening to the Black Keys, delta blues, Wu Tang Clan,my lifetime hits, etc etc... but not Kanye. I learned about him much, much later, when he was making Yeezy's famous, and before he was cancelled etc. This does have some agile wordplay, some challenges to the boundaries of hiphop at the time, and some good grooves. Relative to Wu Tang, Kanye is an also-ran.
No option for zero stars
A lot of hate for this album in my group. I'm a bit delayed in my rating of it. Are most of the songs on here sexist, misogynist, childish, silly? Sure. Is Kanye's production/flow everyone's favorite? No. Did I skip many songs on here? Yup. Am I writing everything as a question bc I'm too tired/lazy to write out all my feelings about Kanye? Absolutely. Some songs on here are bops, it's impossible to ignore. And this production style is one I like. Unfortunately it's really hard separating this artist from his "art."
[Seemingly obligatory reference to the fact he’s not a good person] What can I say? It’s truly astonishing this was his debut. So fully realized, so-well written and produced. Can’t help but love this album.
Fantastic for a freshman effort, but short of a perfect score in the context of this list. Slow jamz, through the wire, the new workout plan are all hits, but some of the misses (Jesus walks, all falls down) make this album a bit too bloated
I'm not a fan of Kanye West, but I'd consider a few of the singles from this album to be guilty pleasures. I've never listened to this album start-to-finish, so we'll see how this goes. Yeah, definitely file this under "guilty pleasures." I'm hoping that whatever the fractions of a cent will be paid to Kanye as a result of my streams will be put to use getting Kanye some help with his mental health.
Love the album 4/5. Hate the guy
Högt och lågt på denna
Några låtar står ut, men senare album nådde helt klart andra höjder.
Några grymma låtar men resten fångar mig inte tyvärr.
Han har talang ändå.
Not worth comparing. I was generous to one album, this person doesn't deserve the attention
Kanye really was a master when it came to beats and production. Really clean on both fronts on College Dropout, mix in some really clever songwriting and some well placed features and we have ourselves a pretty great hip hop record. Jesus Walks opens with one of his greatest lines in , “We at war with terrorism, racism, but most of all we at war with ourselves” some of the preachy lines that follow got my rolling my eyes pretty heavy but the beat is so good that I can’t help but bounce to it regardless. It really does speak volumes to how talented Kanye was. Even the comedic track, Workout Plan is actually pretty great, humour tracks are tough to pull off well but I think Lanye nailed it. Best feature track probably goes to Syleena for All Falls Down but I did also really enjoy Mos Def towards the end on Two Worlds. I’ve said it many times, skits can wear on me and that did hold true with College Dropout. I get that they help tell the story a bit but I still don’t care for them. Still a very good album, 4 stars
When one of the worst dudes in music ends up making great music. Tragic.
One of those whose art is hard to separate from his behavior over the last decade or whatever, but man this album is full of astute observations, sick rhymes, earworm beats, deft hooks. And he would keep this going for a number of albums. It’s not my five but it’s more than a four. Would expect he will show up at least a few more times here.