Reviews (page 4 of 16)
I loved this album when it came out. I bought it and listened to it endlessly. I get separating the art from the artist in some cases. Art like this is usually a blend of many people working together, one of them being terrible doesn’t necessarily kill the whole thing. And I can recognize the historical merit of this album, and if you’ve never listened to it I think you probably should, just for the context. But I can’t listen to it anymore.
Bosh as, all round good. fair few favourites
yes i know it's rather ironic that i'm giving this a 4 because i hate kanye as a person, but it's just so good
Honestly kind of a slow burn for me. I came to Kanye after My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. But The college dropout is just so much more classic. I feel like MBDTF is still great but sounds like some sort of pinnacle of Bling Era Rap and very much of its time and has aged a little mildly. My favorite Kanye is still TLOP just because his full on insanity is so important for his legacy and that moment and release and album are so ridiculous while also being some of the last truly great music Kanye made. but I think college dropout might be what I go back and listen to most. Needles to say this is a 5 star. Kanye is the definition of an auteur and I think this is one of the top 10 most fully formed and brilliantly executed debut albums in history. It's so consistent, the theme is so good and original, it was simultaneously incredibly progressive and instantly classic, Kanye was on an all time greatest rap producer in history run right at this moment and this is just the perfect showcase of his talents and vision. My how the mighty have fallen. I miss the Old Kanye.
The College Dropout is an attempted concept album that mistakes repetition for cohesion. The college theme is beaten to death through endless skits, while the actual songs rarely build toward anything meaningful. Instead of feeling like a carefully structured statement, it feels bloated, unfocused and desperately in need of an editor. The production is the biggest problem for me. That constant chipmunk-soul style is unbelievably grating: pitched-up vocal samples, crowded arrangements and harsh mastering pile on top of each other until the album becomes physically tiring to listen to. After about thirty minutes, it stops being “soulful” and starts sounding like Alvin and the Chipmunks discovered a sampler and refused to turn it off. And the songs themselves simply aren’t strong enough to justify the runtime. Too many tracks drag, hooks repeat endlessly, the rapping is technically limited, and the humour ranges from mildly amusing to painfully dated. Even the supposedly emotional moments often feel buried underneath production that is constantly screaming for attention. There may be an interesting album somewhere inside The College Dropout, but this version is overlong, badly paced, poorly mastered and genuinely headache-inducing. If dropping out of college was the concept, apparently dropping out of mixing school was part of it too. 5/10
I kind of ignored this at the time because he seemed like a bit of a dick - and it seems like I was on the right side of history on that one. However, despite all the principled 'I will never listen to him...' stances on here, I thought I'd give it a spin - and you know what? It's actually really good. He's still a dick, though...
Listened previously. Expectations: High - Verdict: Very Good - People criticise Kanye's rapping but I really don't mind. Of course the production is the real highlight though. There are absolute bangers here. I think the second half loses a little steam but still an incredible album.
Kanye really hates school!
No puedo separar el arte del artista porque lo que hacemos es un reflejo de lo que somos
Don't listen to nazis
Nothing bad in this album
GOAT
Kanye tiene canciones buenas, pero este CD parece una versión Temu de Common.
I had never listened to a Kanye West album before. I really only knew him as the buffoon who married a Kardashian. This album is good. I am not a rap fan, so downgraded to 4.
This *was an incredible album but I'm not going to play it. I don't listen to people actively preaching hate. Kanye needs medication.
I own a physical copy of this one. Is Kanye nowadays a crazy ass cunt fuckwad? Yes. Is this album still dope as fuck? Also, yes. 5⭐️ album 🗑️human
Man, this was a breath of fresh air back in 2004.....amazing production, lyricism, features, everything.......EVEN the skits aren't bad. Still holds up 20+ years later (judge the art not the artist!)
digno, me gusto. aprobado. la verdad muy cambiante, no lo termine todavia, pero essta muy bueno la verdad
Used to love this record. But Kanye is a piece of shit, so fuck giving him any extra streaming royalties.
me senti um pouco afetado por escutar esse álbum enquanto ia pra faculdade
Iconic. Some great tracks, that had a huge cultural impact. However the seeds of the mans downfall are lain across the whole album. Anti science shit leaking through the tracks... I think education is important.
People has always told me that the only saving grace of Kanye is that he at least wrote The College Dropout before he went off the rails. I cannot fathom at all what the fuck they are talking about, this is so mid.
The New Workout Plan is getting added to my playlist. Loved the variety on this one, even within songs.
The beats are cool but there’s something about this dude that just doesn’t vibe with me and I don’t think it’s just because of his public persona. There’s just a cold, crassness to him that I think would feel sociopathic even if I didn’t know he was actually that. His sexual lyrics especially lend credence to that for me. Most rappers are misogynistic but there’s something particularly cringey about Kanye’s brand of it. Perhaps if he cared more about his college classes and less about partying and getting lad he’d know it wasn’t 300 Romans, but rather Spartans who fought the Persians. (Not that he doesn’t have a point about the College grift).
This was a lot more fun than I expected.
Capitalism imposes on us a system wherein, in a manner of speaking, we "vote with our dollars". Intentionally selecting this album on a platform and listening to it (directing my attention to it) is an endorsement of it *and* supports the artist. Kayne (or whatever the fuck he calls himself now) is a vile & tragic human being. Are my two-tenths of a cent of streaming revenue going to make-or-break this man? No, but morally I can't and won't justify it. I cannot separate the artist from the art in this case. (1/5) I recall liking some of the hits on its release, but I never got into the album. I freely admit it could be musically good, but I won't give it any of my attention. I used to love Louis C.K. and Bill Cosby as comedians. Once I found out what monsters they were, I quit watching/listening to their work. I've certainly never purchased or watched (not that it's easy to find their stuff any longer...) anything by them since. I noticed another reviewer select an album from a band that *wasn't* on the list. I've called this phenomenon out a few times and found out from someone in my group that the Doobie Brothers were shunned from the list. Today, I'll continue this exercise by listening to a classic Doobie Brothers album -- "The Captain and Me" -- and leave a thought here. A high (3/5) from me for "Captain.." with two big hits on it, "Long Train.." and "China Grove". "Dark Eyed.." was a solid track too. "Evil Woman" was a big miss. A good example of a mid-70s country-folky rock band with some decent production. Recommended for a backyard BBQ mix.
Nope. Fuck this dude. Didn't understand the hype then, and not about to give him a penny of streaming revenue to find out if I missed anything.
Variety: 2 Adequacy: 5 Listenability: 5 Uniqueness: 2 Emotionality: 2 = 3.2 rounded down to 3 "The sheriff and his buddies with their samurai swords/ You can even hear the music at night" The Doobie Brothers have always been around for me. Forever a staple of the classic rock stations I grew up listening to, with tracks on the soundtracks of dozens of popular movies, they were pretty unavoidable. Their brand of laid back, smooth rock was easy on the ears and the hits, at least, were all pretty damn catchy, even if I had no idea what they were singing about. I never listened to any of their albums all the way through until after I fell in love with the Yacht Rock web series, and did a deep dive. I found a lot to like, and I think I also found a way out of the hole I had dug myself into where I had become dismissive of so called "lame" or uncool bands. Deep down, the Doobies, Hall and Oates, and Christopher Cross were baked into my musical tastes from an early age. I just had to accept it, and not worry about what was cool or not. Besides, a LOT of those 90s bands that were the epotome of cool do not hold up so well now. The Doobies, at least their best stuff, does. There's no Michael McDonald on this one though, so they are starting off with a handicap... THE TRACKS Side one "Natural Thing" - Fine stuff. I especially appreciate the effect of the strummed guitar played through some sort of cheap sounding amp. That ultra slick early 70s studio production is on full display here, but it's still got life in it. "Long Train Runnin'" - Growing up I heard this SO much and yet NEVER knew the name of this one. I still would never remember it except now I get that info on a little screen when it comes up in the Classic Ricks satellite radio station. An all-time classic. The percussion. The lead vocals. The backing vocals. And that guitar line. Every part of this is solid gold, baby. "China Grove" - Another big radio hit, this one has much more of a party vibe to it. I don't think I ever paid attention to anything but the chorus as a kid. The guitar riff, and the keyboard on this are also killer. Nothing deep going on here, and I'm ok with that. "Dark-Eyed Cajun Woman" - Meh. Creepy lyrics aside, it's ok musically but nothing special/ The strings are an interesting touch, but the electric piano is the draw. "Clear as the Driven Snow" - Strong Crosby Stills and Nash vibes here, with maybe a little John Denver thrown in. I think it's almost always more interesting to read any song from the 70s or 80s with "snow" in the title as either a paen to or a warning against cocaine. As innocent as this one might be, it's much more fun to imagine this as the internal dialogue of a guy who's trying to kick the devil's dandruff, and maybe having doubts. Musically a lot going on here, and we get a not quote epic multi-movement thing. Steers clear of being anything close to progressive though I think. Side two "Without You" - A nice bit of southern fried boogie. Foghat must have been taking notes. Some guitar hero gymnastics, but nothing too complicated. Good stuff. "South City Midnight Lady" - We get our thoughtful acoustic love song. Aside from the great playing ( are these guys capable of dropping a wrong note?) this is mostly dreadful "you light up my life" dreck. Leave this garbage to Seals and Croft. "Evil Woman" - As interesting as the chorus is, I can't help but feel like this song is some sort of parody of hard rock/ metal sounds that were coalescing around then. The Doobies throw a bit of southern rock stank onto it, but it is s sound that ill suits them. The same material maybe sped up ad played with sincerity by a Deep Purple or a Uriah Heep maybe? Instead this reminds me more of Spinal Tap. "Busted Down Around O'Connelly Corners" - A pretty little interlude of a song. Reminiscent of stuff Lindsey Buckingham would be doing just a few years later. "Ukiah" - Another solid umber. Not an all time classic but among the best of the album. The urgency in the lead vocals and the guitar solo, contrasted with the slow down/ start back up in the chorus make for some of the best dynamics on the whole thing. "The Captain and Me" - A more than solid closer. This one moves through all the modes ( limited as they were) that the Doobies excel at. Especially love the banjo on this. Groovy rhythms abound, and we get an awesome sprint towards the finish line from about 3:30 on that brings back elements of "Long Train Runnin'" to nicely tie things up with a bow. HIGHLIGHTS - "Long Train Runnin'" - "China Grove" - "Without You" - "Ukiah" - "The Captain and Me" - MIDLIGHTS - "Natural Thing" - "Dark-Eyed Cajun Woman" - "Clear as the Driven Snow" - "Busted Down Around O'Connelly Corners" LOWLIGHTS - "South City Midnight Lady" - "Evil Woman" FINAL THOUGHTS The Doobies, as ingrained as some of their songs are in my mind, will always be a greatest hits band for me. There are just too many awesome songs spread among too many albums and, without revisiting each of them, I don't think I'd ever rate a single release higher than a 3. But not any lower either. There's a level of professionalism here ( I think a lot of these guys would go on to be much sought after session guys and producers) that is at the tippy top of the era, and their ear for melodies is something to be admired. I just don't think they have much that endears them to me personally. Maybe it's a nostalgia thing, and if you were at the right age when these came out they would feel much more essential. But I can't imagine anyone's mind being blown by this stuff. Not even the biggest Doobie fan on earth. The Doobies are just alright with me. The Doobies are just alright, oh yeah. PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - The highlights as usual FURTHER LISTENING - Can't Buy a Thrill by Steely Dan - Silk Degrees by Bozz Skaggs - Dixie Chicken by Little Feat
Here in 2026, the first thing I'm going to say is that it is hard to reckon the appreciation I had for this and the next two Kanye West albums at the time with his increasingly erratic and disturbing behavior over the years. I'm only going to discuss the album itself. A close friend had this album and we listened to it A LOT in 2004. Those first three Kanye albums were really good, my preference being for Late Registration, which is the only one I bought. In retrospect though I think this one may be the better album. Honestly though, I stopped listening to him after Graduation. There are moments of pure brilliance on The College Dropout. When the sound production, beats, and the vocals merge into a shining sound. For me it is the tracks, "All Falls Down", "Jesus Walks", "Never Let Me Down", , and "Two Words". "Through the Wire"is a talent showcase novelty. On these tracks the album rides high. However, while a talented musician, West is also quite a flawed one too. He indulges in far too many bad and provocative skits. A few of the tracks are reaches too. Overall the album could've been trimmed by about 20 minutes. The New Workout Plan is atrocious. So is School Spirit. Slow Jamz misses the mark as well. And as for "Last Call" I originally heard it as a chest banging defiant outro story of perseverance and now I just hear it as a whiny and petty airing of all grievances. Its a sad turn. He was never a "genius" just very musically gifted and his debut album is the very definition of a 3.
It's not the best Kanye album imo, but definitely the most charming. Between the school concept, the sense of humour, the positive message it's just a very likeable album. The production is so soulful, vintage Kanye with amazing soul samples. The sounds are lively and epic, it fits his maximalistic vision but it's not obnoxious as on some of his later albums (I'm looking at you MBDTF). All Falls Down, Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down, Two Words, Through The Wire are among the best 2000s rap songs. What makes this special as well as this is pretty much Kanye's best rapping performance. Pretty much, because he did get even better on Late Registration a year later, but the passion he shows here is incredible and insanely contagious. The way he raps, you just feel every word he says even if he is not the most flashy technical rapper. It makes the songs super engaging and replayable. The more melodic songs like Spaceship or Slow Jamz also work despite having a bit of a different vibe. The whole album is very cohesive, the songs are bangers while the skits bring personality and are funny. It's amazingly produced too. Unfortunately there are some songs that have aged poorly. Get Em High, The New Workout Plan and Breathe In Breathe Out are a bit too obnoxious and the humour on those songs doesn't land that well. The rest of the album is really great which puts it easily among his best albums.
Aside from the fact that rap and hip hop simply aren't my kind of music, Kanye West is finished. His statements have disqualified him. A Hitler lover! Doesn't he know how Hitler and all of today's fascists and racists think about "Black" and non-white, non-Aryan people? Zero points, you know, one point.
My grad school roommate in Philly introduced me to this album. It was definitely an experience, but (like most people, I presume) I have mixed feelings about Ye… he’s a talent for sure, but “complicated” is an understatement.
The album is a reminder why Kanye was popular. The album has a sense of humor. The talking between songs messed up the flow for me. I did like the “I’ll Fly Away” interlude. “Jesus Walks” is my favorite on the album. I also enjoy “the New Workout Plan” and “School Spirit.” “Last Call” is far too long for me.
Highlights: We Don't Care, Graduation Day, All Falls Down, Spaceship, Jesus Walks, Get Em High, The New Workout Plan, Slow Jamz, Breathe In Breathe Out, School Spirit, Two Words, Through The Wire, Last Call Absolutely iconic. I love the chipmunk soul style - the sampling is just brilliant.
I have a really specific memory of a girl giving me this CD to listen to in first year maths because we were both 13 and having a friendly argument about how our respective favourite music (me: punk rock; her: hip hop) were the true genre to give voice to social commentary. It didn’t win me over then and it doesn’t now but my opinions on hip hop have obviously soften, as I’m sure have hers on punk rock. Anyway I was pretty sure she liked girls so I asked her if she wanted to go to the movies with me and she said “I’m not a fucking dyke”. I didn’t even have a crush on her, I just wanted to talk to other queer girls. Turns out she is fully a lesbian and now I’m married to a man. Life’s strange journey, eh? I’m not rating this because listening to Kanye during this period of his life is a huge buzzkill.
Nah
Puhelaulu ei vieläkään ole mun musaa. Tää sisälsi liikaa ”gangsta” hommelia ja N-sanaa. Rytmit ihan ok, mutta laulu liian löysää.
great album, what a shift to what he is now
No thank you!
El mejor album de kanye y de los mejores de la musica en general
Kanye never disapoiment
Muy buen álbum, me gustó
The worst part of this was definitely the skits, New Workout Plan, and Get ‘Em High. Some of the production is impressive. The only song I kinda liked was Never Let Me Down. A couple others were listenable. I suppose the final “story” track is interesting once but I can’t see why you’d ever want to play it a second time. I really don’t like the baby/chipmunk pitched up voice that features throughout the record. The length was just unnecessary to me too. Lots of ideas could have been dropped to make this a tighter story and strengthen the concept. Torn between a strong 1 and a light 2, but it’s so much better than the previous hip-hop albums I gave a 1 to. Not particularly looking forward to more Kanye, though I know it’s coming.
god
Not every song on here is a masterpiece but this is an absolutely game-changing debut. Making a hit with your mouth sewn shut is frankly insane
unfortunately this is really quite good
If Kanye had died in 2011, he would be considered one of the greatest artists who ever lived. It's truly incredible how somebody this introspective has become what he has. In hindsight, though, there were some clues there.
Not many words for it. A classic for a reason.
Review Kanye West. ‘We don’t care’ track to sum up my feelings of this album before starting it however I found myself bouncing along to this track. ‘Graduation’ started with a what the fuck was that Kanye comment, my thoughts entirely 😳 ‘All falls down’ features a nice female vocal. ‘Jesus walks’ a track I remember from the mid 00s and it’s not got any better listening to it 20 years later. ‘Workout plan’ I’m not entirely sure what’s going on by this stage of the album, women thanking Kanye for a workout plan that’s made them the envy of their friends, rapping about Michael Jackson two songs in a row and Halle Berry getting shoehorned in too. Then as the tracks go on I hear rapping about a nap sack sprayer, lots of talk of degrees and not working and a lot of rapping about niggers, women and college. The rest of the album just seemed to mould into one constant noise and by the time the album had finished I was relieved. Not my cup of tea but I can appreciate the production of the album was on point and at times it was easy listening. The best track been ‘we don’t care’ Hopefully tomorrow’s offering will be more up my street. Best track - we don’t care. Worst track- lil Jimmy skit. 1.5/10
Kanye - A lesson in how to make 20 minutes of music stretch to 4 times that length with pointless dicking around nonsense. Occasionally I would find something I liked but then I would remember what a horrible example of a human being he is.
Not sure who this is aimed at. Definitely not me.
Claramente no es un mal disco pero no se si es porque personalmente detesto a Kanye pero no veo la genialidad de la que todo el mundo habla y de paso lo aburrida que me sentí a veces por la excesiva repetición de ciertas canciones. Rescaté par de canciones no mucho más. Pero no está mal
I love his music, but he has better albums
Heard this before
I dropped out early on this one...
I miss the old kanye
Geras, bet aš jo nemegstu lol
Graduation and MBDTF better but still goated
Zit gewoon zo goed in elkaar.
Kanye West may be the most overrated figure in music. He is neither a genius nor a visionary. His production is often clunky and cheesy. The record is alright, but that's about it.
nazi scum
Kanye West is a bigot and an asshole. Was he always like this? I don't know. What I can tell you is that I bought The College Dropout in one of its first weeks way back in 2004 and, listening to it today, it is still every bit as wonderful as it was then. Innovative-yet-warm-and-inviting beats, lyrics that are simultaneously thought-provoking AND laugh-out-loud hilarious, created by a man full of swagger but at this point still possessed the ability to be humble. I put this on expecting the 73-minute track time to wear on me as the album went on, but no, this is a perfect listen from start to finish. I miss this Kanye.
I loved it. Kanye managed to make this album so easy to listen to.
Really like this - I can hear what’s leading to later Kanye. The second half of the album seems to drop off but 'Last Call' is a great ending to the album.
man I hate Kanye but damn his music is good
Very good
Hip-Hop não é minha praia, mas achei criativo e divertido. Quatro estrelas por achar muito bom, mas ainda assim não sentir conexão. Músicas favoritas: - We Don't Care - All Falls Down - Jesus Walks - Slow Jamz (melhor do álbum)
Por gusto personal 2,5 estrellas. Entendiendo su importancia y su influencia, 3,5 estrellas
if only it wasn’t made by a literal nazi 😔
каньэ каньэ не ожидала я от тебя такого сока
Nice hooks, and nicely produced album with lot's of featuring artists. Because I'm not familiar with the genre and artists sometimes it was hard to keep track of this.
WOW. Absolute banger. Soooooo creative and I didnt get bored once. Kanye was THE best in his day. Makes me extremely sad about his descent into overt antisemitic ranting, cos he was a true talent
Nope. Not listening Hard pass. No streaming revenue for bigots.
CDO is easily one of his best projects I’m not arguing.
It's nice to go back and listen to a really good early Kanye album from before he started having...issues.
It was a better album than I was willing to give credit for based on Kanye as a person
Une de mes albums préférés. Les skits sont drôles ou beaux parfois les deux. Que des classiques (all falls down, Jesus walks) et si on en sort je dirais Spaceship. Les tops lines chantés de Kanye sont toujours belles et pleines d’émotions ou de sincérité. On retrouve quelque chose dont Tyler, The Creator à hérité. Et du rap clean touchant et précis. De belles invitations aussi.
Obviously opinions of this album have been colored by the artist's actions. Separating art from artist this album is good. It far surpasses the other rap albums that I've listened to on this list thus far Dre, Snoop Dogg, Notorious BIG. It is interesting, and entertaining, and each track feels distinct.
Before Kanye became (or at least went public as) an anti-Semitic right-wing nutjob, he was a pretty good rapper. Not something I'd really seek out to listen to, but I don't mind it. "Spaceship" and "Slow Jamz" were the highlights for me.
The best of the Kanye albums on this list and the only one I could really see myself returning to. Crazy that a late 20s Kanye is less of a megalomaniac than Kanye in his 40s.
Brilliant production and great lyricism work on almost all songs the messages hit deep. I truly miss the old kanye
Meh
Previously listened to this plenty of times before. An album of my childhood. When Kanye had more of a fun/relaxed vibe to him. Kanye is definitely enjoying himself more during this era. Nothing but fun music, and a twist of comedy too with the skits which are famous for this reason. Very enjoyable album as per. Never gets old and timeless. 8/10
Kanye obviously not a nice person but there’s some great tunes on here
I so, so desperately wish this dude wasn't such a damn freak. I get the hype man, I really do. What a debut. He has basically perfectly captures the zeitgeist of the millennial without being pretentious or annoying. In fact, he's very cool about it. Not to mention, the music hits and his flow is outstanding. But now he's a nazi. What the actual fuck? I'm still rating this album as I would regardless, but it's a shame I can never call myself a Kanye fan.
I don't think I can review this in good conscience, at least not without the knowledge of what Kanye West has become hanging over the proceedings. it would bias my judgement. voting a 3 here, but if I could give no score I would.
Nope. All Kanye West goes in the garbage now.
Fuck Kanye
no. for obvious reasons I am absolutely not listening this album
VERY GOD, the best album from Kanye by far
I had never listened to Kanye in my life. I started the album ready to give it a 1/5, but what a surprise from this asshole
2.5
это надо объяснять? поставил бы 0
He did some fine work here. Nice blend of lyrics, beat and harmonies. I was pleasantly surprised
Good album. Can hear his message in the lyrics. Great production. Clearly talented, but also clear he suffers from mental illness today.
это странный реп и пение мимо нот… люди любят продакшн ай гес
I will give him a star for being a great album. Hard to support him but also most famous people are fucked up.
På Yeezus fanns ändå nånting i den nedstrippade vågade produktionen. Här finns absolut ingenting. Det har inte ens kvalitet som listpop i dom mest hjärndöda sell-out alstren. Jag vill inte ens kalla det här för hiphop. Jag var inne på det i Frank Ocean kritiken, hur neo-soul och hiphop flyter ihop till nån urvattnad sörja, mycket av detta har vi att skylla Kanye för, kanske börjar det här. Det tog i stort sett död på den ganska spännande neo-soulen som fanns runt den här tiden och en stor del av den i alla fall kommersiella hiphopen gick helt vilse i den där sörjan. Vi måste också återigen betona vilken usel MC mr. West är, det märks om inte annat tydligt när Talib kommer in och gästar. Jag vet nog faktiskt ingen som är sämre än Kanye på rak arm. Jättelångt är det också till på köpet. Jättedåligt
Mycket själ och hjärta i den här skivan. Gillar hur den knyter an till soul, gospel och r’n’b. Liten dipp i mitten av skivan. Men det vägs upp av stark inledning och stark avslutning. Bästa spår: Jesus walks, Never let me down, Spaceship, School spirit, Two worlds, Family business,
Kanye visste utan tvekan hur man samplar soul för att få till ett snyggt sound. Det märks inte minst på denna debut som soloartist. Jesus walks, slow jamz och inte minst School spirit är riktigt bra. Dessutom många gästande artister som i stort sett genomgående bidrar positivt. Samtidigt lider han av hip hopens bristande omdöme. Bara för att det ryms 70 - 80 minuter på en CD måste inte dessa till varje pris fyllas. Allra minst usla små sketcher (eller för den delen work out-tips). Komiker är ytterligare en bana som Kanye inte ska slå sig in på. Han måste väl ha fyllt sitt mått av felval i livet med råge redan. Nedskakat hade det kunnat bli en 4a.
The College Dropout har inte åldrats söärskilt väl Det är inte alls så bra som jag tyckte det var när det kom. Jag har främst tre invändningar mot The College Dropout. Skitsnacksspåren mellan låtarna är riktigt jobbiga och gör skivan onödigt lång. Kanye borde låta bli att sjunga. Allt för ofta låter det som Black Eyed Peas (inte minst i The new workoutplan). Det här drar ner betyget ordentligt. Spaceship är riktigt bra, i afrofuturistisk tradition om rymden som frigörelsemetafor. Men bäst blir det när Common och Talib Kwali eller Ludacris tar över micken. Här är beatsen också tyngre och skitigare. Överlag är det gästerna som gör skivan lyssningsbar. Att ägna en hel skiva åt utbildningsförakt får mest Kanye att låter som en bortskämd snorunge som tycker det är orättvist att inte hela världen dyrkar honom som det stora geniet. Svag trea.
Follow your leader
LIKEIT
Nothing he does or says will ever diminish this album's greatness in my eyes. His best work. 10/10
Musically great but …..
I'm not sure if it was because I was aware that it was a nazi album playing at me that made me not enjoy this, but I was surprised that I didn't enjoy this as much as I didn't.
I don't agree with Kayne but this album was quite good and I see why it was popular.
Sailed the seas to listen to this without supporting Kanye or tainting my algorithm. I understand the hype now, still not for me but I get it.
Pretty good. Family business is my favorite. Never listened to Kanye before and i’m fairly impressed. When the artist puts so much of themself into their art you really can’t separate it from the artist nor should you. It’s sad how he ended up. It tints all of his work knowing that the success he raps about will sour and he’d become a real life villain. Dude has serious fucking problems but I can’t deny he was talented.
As pretty much every other reviewer pointed out, Kanye West is an awful person. However, I'm determined to listen to every album on this list and rate without bias. To be transparent, he did not receive any streaming revenue from my listen because I use new pipe to listen to all of my music (I hate ads just like everyone else). And honestly, I'm sure he's not the only artist on this list who is controversial or hated. My first exposure to rap/hip hop on this list was OutKast, and I liked the musical diversity and uniqueness in that music. This album also has some good and unique instrumentation and beats/sounds (there's violins) and the rapping is not about the typical subjects, but serious issues that aren't cookie cutter. The guest appearances shine, especially the female vocalists ("All Falls Down" as one) and the use of harmonies. I'm not into the skits that seem to be common in these types of albums. Speaking musically, I thought it was good, definitely for a debut album. Mental illness is unfortunate and always seems to take down creative individuals.
First hip hop album we’ve had in a while that isn’t exhaustingly repetitive. There is some really good stuff in here. This Mr. West has a bright future!
What a debut album. Wonder where he ended up later
It's too bad he's such a crazy asshole, because Kanye could create excellent music (although his free-styling is dogshit, see Breathe In, Breathe Out). The backing tracks are incredible, and his lyrics are accessible to a wide audience. You can draw a straight line from this debut to Kid Cudi, Kendrick Lamar, Chance the Rapper, Childish Gambino, Tyler the Creator, etc. But then he lost his got damn mind, so minus 1 star
3.9/5 great debut not his best
Peak
finna dropout
A challenge to get through. As I was settling into a song, I'd get taken right out with the most ignorant of lyrics. There's clearly some creativity here, but this didn't live up to the hype for me.
Kanye West is a reprehensible individual. Not my type of music either.
First Listen: Dec 04 2021 i miss the old kanye. insane debut album, so so so good, crazy how this is like weaker album for him cuz this would any other artist best. if anyone gets on my dick about giving stream money to nazi dw i got ts on vinyl pre nazi arc so im chilling.
First time I actually get this record and really good. Fuck Kanye anyway.
Surprisingly enjoyed, tried to listen to him before but this is top stuff. Not my favourite genre but clearly great
No. On principle.
Being a middle aged white guy, I don't listen to rap anymore. If I do, it's what I listened to in high school. This came out when rap was phasing out of my life. I never bought it, but Jesus Walks was a banger...still is. And while I liked listening to this, it's got two things that I grew to hate about rap music: 1. Skits 2. Features Maybe a skit here or there is funny but...ugh, just play the songs. And as far as the features go, I didn't play this to hear... J. Ivy? He was terrible. GLC and Consequence? Jay-Z was fine but the rest of the features on here were just mediocre. And I get it, that's what rap is these days and has been for a long, long time....part of the time it doesn't even seem like it's about the artistry and what a rapper has to say but instead it's about how many features they can cram onto an album. I want to hear a Kanye song to hear Kanye's voice and his lyrics, not anyone else. So those two things and it's too long. Can definitely trim some songs off this thing and make it tighter. Giving it a 3 cause I enjoyed a lot of it but I know I won't ever play it again.
still an absolute masterpiece, it's precise, serious, funny and was the breath of fresh air hip-hop needed in the 2000's
All time classic.
no voy a escuchar a esta sw, aunque su musica sea buena, no me interesa.
To be this genre, it isn't bad. But it's not my genre.
No
Thought this would be a tough 75mins to get through but was half decent
As far as rap albums go it doesn't get more influential than this. It's not my favorite Kanye album but it changed the game. Putting Ye's production skills on full display, coupled with his ability to assemble artists around one vision and showcase his own pen catapulted Kanye from super producer to global phenomenon. The all star cast of Jay Z, Twista, Talib Kweli, Common, Mos Def and more came to table to be apart of something special. Along with his polo shirts and backpack wearing style he ushered in a new style of hip hop marrying (semi) conscious rap with soul beats. And while I could do without some of the skits the bulk of the songs are undeniable Kanye classics. All Falls Down, Spaceship, Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down, Get Em' High, School Spirit, Through The Wire and (probably me favorite) Two Words all bangers and make this album a must listen. Even if you hate Kanye it's hard to deny the genius here.
Masterpiece
This was the first time that I listened to a Kanye West song. He has a great talent for rhyming, but I really can not understand the choice of themes and content for his songs. Ugly cover, stupid intro and humour. 1. 25 / 5
Realmente son 4,5 estrellas pero ya que. Pedazo de álbum debut del Kanye, revolucionó todo un género. Más allá de lo que representa Kanye hoy en día, no hay que negar que una vez fue amado por muchos.
Undoubtable an iconic and essential album with some of the best tracks and flow of any hip hop. HOWEVER, I’m pretty surprised by how put off I am this time around by the degree of Kanye commentary
I did not listen to this waste of space
I love Jesus Walks, but Kanye doesn't get any money from me. Won't even give this a listen
- i'm going to try really hard to give it a fair shot. but jfc this guy - favorites: spaceship, jesus walks - rating: 2.5/5
finally an album i know. this is still his best album. he is incapable of releasing a better album. this album is so unapologetically black, with references to black faith and black pop culture in general. the narration is hilarious and feels like your own uncle in a sense i miss the old kanye notable: all falls down, slow jamz, the new workout plan 5/5
one of the greatest hip-hop debuts of all time and his best album there i said it yeah i miss the old kanye sometimes the album might feel slightly corny (new workout plan) but the music never loses its personality or impactful commentary highlights: we don't care, all falls down, i'll fly away, spaceship, jesus walks, never let me down, through the wire 4.5/5
interestingly powerful
Se me hizo raro los interludios y despues las canciones tan largas. All Fall Downs sigue siendo el mejor tema que tiene, lo escuche anoche jugando y ahora estudiando y no siento que otro tema destaque. eso si Last Call es plenamente aura como cuenta la historia.
Pass
Rap. Fattar inte storheten. Gäsp. Etta
5 / 5
Don't like rap and although he is a very a talented musician and wordsmith he has some serious flaws as a human being. I tried to listen to entire album but 2 1/2 songs in was the limit.
Classic Kanye album. Only reason it’s not a 5 is because of Graduation’s and MBDTF’s existence.
muss ich nicht unterstützen
5/5
A classic album that I grew up listening to. I miss the old Kanye. 5/5
Je ne souhaite pas l'écouter 😒
Paeans to the chip on his shoulder. Disappointingly compelling at points 3.4
meh. no está mal, pero no hay ningún tema q me haya volado la cabeza. No me gustó, ni me disgustó, tampoco lo volvería a escuchar. le pondría un 5/10 pero no puedo
Agonizingly wonderful
Too bad he's insane.
Good. Certainly one of the better rap albums I’ve heard on the list. Worth a second listen.
Kanye’s on my block list. Fuck Nazis
First off, let's talk about the album and separate the art from the artist. Because... hoo boy, Kanye is a trainwreck to end all trainwrecks. This is, honestly, a really good album. The beats are tight, the rhymes are inventive, the skits are funny. I wish he hadn't tried to separate the skits from the songs, because it really inflates the track count when an intro skit shouldn't really be separated from the music it's supposed to introduce. The skits don't completely stand alone on their own, they need the song to support the scaffolding. And then, we get to "Last Call". Why? WHY? WHYYYYYY? It's too long, it's self-aggrandizing, it makes no sense, nobody cares, Kanye. We didn't need this track AT ALL. My Rating: 4/5. Let's be honest, we all liked this music BEFORE Kanye lost his mind.
Number: 82 Date: 03/25/2026 Artist: Kanye West Album: The College Dropout Year: 2005 Genre: Conscious Pop Rap Rating: 3 Notes: Before: ======= OK, I've already had one Kanye album which is plenty. Per policy: "“An artist shall be represented on The List by no more than one album, except where multiple albums by that artist demonstrate materially distinct artistic character and historical significance. Where two or more albums by the same artist are determined to be substantially similar in style, scope, or cultural function, only one such album may be included, with preference given to the earliest released work.” During: ======= 3 Intro 4 We Don't Care 2 Graduation Day 2 All Falls Down 3 I'll Fly Away 3 Spaceship 3 Jesus Walks 2 Never Let Me Down 1 Get Em High 3 Workout Plan 2 The New Workout Plan 3 Slow Jamz 3 Breathe In Breathe Out 3 School Spirit Skit 1 4 School Spirit 3 School Spirit Skit 2 3 Lil Jimmy Skit 3 Two Words 3 Through The Wire 3 Family Business 1 Last Call ----------------------------------------------------- 2.4 WEIGHTED AVERAGE After : ======= 2 my personal rating 3 suitability for this list 4 impact ----------------------------------------------- 3 composite rating
It's such a relief to listen to this for the first time and realise he's a mediocre rapper
love
Better than I thought it would he but still fuck Kanye
Great hip hop album that starts very strong and lags with skits towards the end (and a really long coda track). If this were trimmed a bit, it would be a five. Also Kayne is a bad person and fuck Trump. Still good music. Top tracks: "We Don't Care," "All Falls Down," "Jesus Walks," "Get Em High," "Spaceship"
an incredible debut, and a fantastic case study in "love the art, hate the artist". But this was all before he went off his Zoloft and turned into a Nazi so it's ok. Jesus Walks rips, the skits are funny, the guest bars are tight, and the writing is unimpeachable. Getting a 4 because I know what's coming up next from him (complementary and derogatory).
—We Don’t Care…great beat —Graduation Day…is that JB Smoove? Hot damn I hate auto tune but he makes it great —All Falls Down…Syleena Johnson hook is great —I’ll Fly Away…an interesting diversion. Decent not great harmonies, maybe intentional —Spaceship…great production but not much to it. Scratching that, it’s growing on me. Kanye is probably the weakest link in this —Jesus Walks…oh, is racism a problem, Ye? kindly fuck yourself. This shit slaps tho —Never Let Me Down…entertaining but a little generic —Get Em High…love that sample. Love Talib Kweli. Nice, fat low end —Workout Plan…skit —The New Workout Plan…solid but not special. The last two minutes is better —Slow Jamz…Twista spitting hot fire. Entire song is fire —Breathe in Breathe Out…meh —School Spirit…skit 1 is too real. Song is good but too repetitive. Something tells me Ye hates the American higher education system —Two Words…great build into an epic —Through the Wire…fun —Family Business…nice piano. nice but no banger —Last Call…12 minutes long? This better be good. First four are good. Second 4 is the same, time to wrap it up. Yeah, delete the last 8 minutes of this track. Also, the last 12 years of your career, Ye. That would be great
Not my style. Still an alright album if you think he wasn’t a nazi back when he made it but will be steering clear of it going forward.
im not interested in listening to Ye now for obvious reasons
Listened to the first song and it was actually painful
Classic hop hop album. I don't like Kanye as a person and I haven't listened to his stuff in a while but the while ago I did listen to this album it's not as good as people say it is, Late Registration, Graduation, Yeezus are just much more interesting though this album has countless bangers. Y'all gotta stop rating albums you didn't listen to lol
Interesting to hear this up against the greatest of the greatest and not only holding its own but swinging heavy. Fuck his nazi beliefs, hope he heals some day.
The fact that I began listening to this album, albeit as part of my Kanye re-listen before BULLY comes out, the *day* it's chosen, AND I have no clue it was going to be chosen, is kind of crazy. Anyway, thought I might as well put it down here. This album is phenomenal, and that's not even counting the fact this is his debut album. The most clean and vibrant instrumentals backing up every single song, the melodic and captivating singing from Kanye and the people he had sing as well, the iconic usage of chipmunk soul (dumb name I'm sorry even if it's accurately named) which provides a central hook to keep each song feeling unique and memorable...this album has it all. While I haven't listened to the work Kanye was involved with before his debut, yes not even Blueprint, you can feel the passion and effort that had been building up and waiting to burst out straight from the first song. The skits I personally find entertaining and funny, and the extended reading by Kanye on Last Call doesn't feel out of place; the album is dealing with topics that Kanye has felt weren't properly represented in that era of rap music, and the artistic statement made by simply *having* a song that is 75% a script reading is astounding. Love this album to bits since I first heard it, and this re-listen has only made me love it more. Favorite Songs: Jesus Walks (10/10) / Two Words (10/10) Least Favorite Song: The New Workout Plan (7.5/10) Overall Album Rating: 9.5/10
Too poppy and too long. Even aside from who Kanye is this album did not hit me as hard as I was expecting and I don't really want to hear it again.
No.
Some good bopping tracks on this, which makes it quite fun but the braggadocio gets a bit lame after a while. Fun in places though.
I miss the old Kanye.
the first of Kanye's many 5s
I get it, but this album is undeniably good.
Ah, yes, before Kanye lost his mind... there's no denying how talented this guy is, though.
One of my favorite Kanye albums. It's just so much fun. 4.25/5.
this had absolutely no business being this long…….. this was just so bad
No.
Goeie hiphop van de jonge Kanye, I dig!
Ik had veel bias op voorhand want Kanye is een nazi en rap is ni bien ma wow dit album is echt zo fire. Af en toe een nummertje da mij minder zegt ma het totale plaatje is MI BOMBOOO
Classic Kanye. He used to make such bright music. Soulful yet fun. It feels dated but in a good way.
Before Kanye lost his marbles, or at least let everyone know that be lost his marbles
fav songs: we don't care i'll fly away jesus walks family business soulful, quirky, polished 70/100
Okay, hip hop isn’t really my thing but i could listen to some of these from time to time. Fav might be “Two words”
Listening to this is making me realize how much I've been sleeping on Kanye. Chose to avoid him out of spite for him (and his fans) but I'm regretting it now. This album is such a banger even though it's not the usual type of music I listen to. The way he raps is just so satisfying to the ear.
This is the first time I’ve intentionally listened to Kanye. And yep not my thing. Sounds like any other main stream rap album except nothing really grabbed me.
The College Dropout is clearly a high-quality and influential album, and I even recognized “All Falls Down”. Still, hip-hop doesn’t really connect with me, and I tend to let the slower, groove-based tracks pass in the background.
very competent i'm just tired of Kanye
I don’t care for Kanye at all, but this was pretty great, I can’t even lie.
Love it. Peak Kanye.
An enjoyable listen that drags on the final track with Kanye telling a story over the beat on the end track. The skits are funny, but would be irritating on repeat listening.
God such a good album, too bad about kanye
This is my second Kanye West album. As usual, Kanye West is a very controversial figure. This album isn't as good as the previous one I got, My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. This was an okay album to listen to, but nothing amazing.
Questionable man solid album
album #10 incredibly produced! some real bangers on here. i had never listened to this album before, and i can understand why it was on the list. it's a real shame that he made an album with some real lyrical gems only to turn around and become a nazi. boo you! favourite track(s): the new workout plan, family business least favourite track(s): two words number of albums left to review: 1,079 number of albums from the list that i agree with being on the list: 4 albums from the list that I would consider on my list: 1 albums from the list I won't include on my list: 9
From the time before he became a nazi A third of the album is odd short spoken word segments I do like Jesus Walks, but the rest is not really my thing Maybe 'cause I ain't no nigga dawg
Two words is standout and something I wouldn’t have heard if not for this list
Classic. If only he hadn’t gone insane.
There was far more on here that I recognised than I expected, and musically at least, there’s a lot to like. But he’s still a self-aggrandising cockwomble who vastly overestimates his own brilliance.
This gets 1 star because Kanye West is fucking insane. But like, damn, this album is still amazing and would get 5 if Kanye wasn't Kanye. Jesus Walks is an all timer, We Don't Care and School Spirit are great, and Last Call just being a 12 minute interview over a beat is a really fun thing to listen to. Don't be a weirdo nazi shithead tho.
Love this. A great album
God, I wanted to hate this. *must...separate...art...from...Nazi...* Fuck you, Ye. Fuck you especially for making me like this album.
How on earth to rate this? Groundbreaking. Catchy. Interesting. Deep. Jesus Walks is a peal for help and an expression of faith. Then, um, listen, he really went off the rails, he should take his drugs, no shame in prescriptions here. Album remains solid though. It would be a 3 but it loses a star for it's dislike of women.
A more sane and composed Kanye, however I much prefer his more creative projects (Yeezus, etc.). Still tracks like “Through the Wire” and “Family Business” are still in rotation heavy.
Pre-crazy Kanye slaps
Terrible human, pretty good music.
I'm so used to all the Kanye-isms and overly jerk-off-y decisions that come with the average Kanye album that all of that being gone surprised me more than how damn good this album is. There's still the occasional "why would you say that bar," but it's still surprising how few and far between they are. It's like everything good about Late Registration and Graduation but with this undeniable hunger to it, like he's throwing his entire weight into this album to make sure something sticks. Good news for him, everything in this album sticks like it did in 2004.
This is the best hip-hop can really get without dipping its toes in other genres. Kanye was too powerful and you know who had to take him down.
Huge shame how utterly vile Kanye has become, but it’s a good album. Way too damn long though.
Kanye West.. Amazin'. Anyway, without thinking about the person. I don't like this style of music. I just don't understand it. However there was some better bits where I was actually kinda enjoying the music so I can't just dump this into the 1* tier. So 2 it shall be.
Kanye is a dick, but I'm trying to listen to this album putting that aside. I'm not a hip-hop fan, but this album is refreshing in that it's not gangsta rap, and it's pretty tuneful as a whole, in that sense it's fairly listenable. Possibly a bit boring. Lyrically/thematically, a lot of it (unsurprisingly) is about college/education, and Kanye's apparent bitterness about people who decide to actually get an education. I don't really know how I felt about the album as a whole, a lot of it was perfectly listenable, but then there's tracks like "Last Call" which is just an irritating monologue. The "Workout Plan" skit was dire and unlistenable. I think it's probably a 2.
I do try and separate art from artist so I begrudgingly put this on with the compromise I'll only listen to half. I can understand why people like this. It's repetitive but it's sometimes got enough variation that it's hard to notice. The lyricism has the issues I generally have with rap where the flow gets ruined by them suddenly speeding up to squeeze multiple syllables into one beat. I appreciate there's some talent in this but it takes me out the music so much. People were generally saying that the lyrics were unusual for rap and to some extent I agree but I've heard albums on this list from before this album talking about similar issues. Sure it wasn't rap but idk why that matters. I doubt this album massively improves in the 2nd half and I didn't feel any desire to keep listening so you get a 2
woke
++*: The New Workout Plan, School Spirit, Family Business ++: We Don't Care, Graduation Day, All Falls Down, I'll Fly Away, Spaceship, Get Em High, Workout Plan (Skit), Slow Jamz, Breathe In Breathe Out, School Spirit (Skit 1), Lil Jimmy (Skit), Two Words, Through the Wire +: Intro (Skit), Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down, School Spirit (Skit 2), Last Call 9,5/10
Kanye sucks as a human being but this is still good hip hop album
If I get another Kanye West album during this year I just might actually kill myself. At least this album was a lot better lyrically and less misogynistic than My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy was. The bar is in hell.
Not many artists came out swinging on a debut album quite like Kanye did. It’s almost like he didn’t expect to get another chance.
When Kanye was at this early stage in his career, when he was the underdog with a lot to prove, he could do great things. This album and my beautiful dark twisted fantasy (2010) are probably his best; in the case of the ladder, after losing dignity in the public eye, he exiled himself to somewhere in Hawaii to only record for a focused stretch of time. During the record recording of this album, he got into a life-threatening car accident and had to surgically wire his jaw shut, so you can imagine he had a big chip on his shoulder. It's a tale old as time: the once underdog and spearhead of the counter culture becomes the one thing he sought to destroy. It reminds me of the Simpsons, a show that started edgy and is now mainstream and watered down. Anyway, this album is still phenomenal. In many ways, Kanye was a pioneer for combining hip-hop and gospel in a way that no one else had. And this album has a lot to say: about religion, materialism, education, the black experience, etc. His words about higher education resonate with a generation that was failed by the system; many people spend a fortune on their education only to end up in a menial entry position job where their superiors are only where they are because of family or connections. A generation whose hard work is not rewarded in the same way of generations prior. He does not mince words, a trait that has gotten him in trouble, and makes some bars fall flat, but is generally a strength and what gives his music so much character. The skits are hilarious. If it weren't for a few few weaker tracks ("Get Em High," for example) I'd give it a 5 without hesitation, and I still think this deserves an eight or nine out of 10 for being the revolutionary and timeless album that it is.
"Jesus Walks" is pretty cool, but, for me, there's a pretty steep drop-off, after that. I guess the words are kind of interesting as poetry/theater/story-telling, but musically a close call between 2 and 3 stars. But I'll raise it to 3 overall for "Jesus Walks" plus the words (and a few Chi-town shout-outs don't hurt, either, lol). The "Spirit" songs, btw build off a great (duh) Aretha Franklin song, "Spirit in the Dark" (which I'd rather listen to than anything on this album).
What in the fuck was that, Kanye? I told you to do some shit for the kids... Similarly to Innervisions, this album feels like a musical/story and at the same time has nary a bad track. There are very few albums which achieve both. I don't feel like I need to say much, because many people agree it's one of the greatest albums of all time, but ... what an amazing debut record. I kinda feel like I grew up with it because it's one of the CDs I remember having from the first. And it sounds even better to me now. There are fantastic performances (notably from J. Ivy on "Never Let Me Down"), super-fresh production, and tons of fun wordplay. Was Kanye the greatest musician of the 2000s?
I’m sure I judged this album based on how I’ve seen Kanye act since 2004 so this may or may not be a legit review but this just sounds like a rich frat boy trying to be cool and hard, without any real street cred. Overrated as an artist and public figure, as I see it.
Next
Nope. F*** Kanye
Not the most popular view but this is Kanye west best collection of songs. All laced with fun and great production. Witty lyrics delivered loosely. All falls down, spaceship, slow jamz are songs that were only bettered sporadically. The skits take this away from being 5 stars.
He's so damned weird! But he does have creativity...I hate scoring this.
i mean this is like one of my top ten albums of all time so
Relisten Despite the insane nazi shit that he fell into in recent years, his older discography is, for better and worse, very far removed from the person he is today. Haven't listened to this album since I was still in college so hearing it now made it hit a lot harder, the whole thing feels like an anthem for twenty somethings who don't know what to do with their lives. I like almost every song on this record and it's as crisply produced as it was 20+ years ago (except that Jay-z sounds like he did his feature in a phone booth on Never Let Me Down). Re-listening to it definitely gave me a newfound appreciation for it, it's a hell of a first album. It also just makes me sad knowing all the insane shit that would happen afterwards. Hope he gets the help he needs, but this version of Kanye feels like a distant memory. Favorite Tracks: We Don't Care, Spaceship, Never Let Me Down, Family Business Least fav: Get Em High 5/5
Elite. Amazing Friday album
Not my genre
Never really listened to Kanye much and don’t really plan to now bearing in mind his general attitude and maybe mental health state. However this album shows that at one point he was a real talent before it all got to him. He was sadly one of the worst Glastonbury headliners that I can remember (whereas Kendrick Lamar was one of the best)
i really gotta actively listen when i get a hip hop album bc it’s way more enjoyable when i can actually understand the lyrics
A damn shame. I give it about ten years before I'm ready to give this the true consideration it probably deserves. But what an incredibly fun, interesting time.
It’s disappointing Ye has so many mental issues because I reached Jon Hamm flow state while listening to this. Like why must he be so unhinged. Jesus Walks, School Spirit, Two Words
Ugh. I don't particularly want to listen to the world's most arrogant self declared nazi, but okay. It sounds like every other rap song. I guess it's like how Seinfeld isn't groundbreaking in hindsight because so many other shows copied it. This album is FINE. Maybe if I was listening in 2004 I'd have been blown away but this is very pedestrian, very samey. Good production, good writing and performance. I just feel nothing. I don't get the hype around him, but I don't have to, since he believes his own hype way too much. Also oh my god why is it so long, it has no need to be this long, it's all the same. I get he's doing the whole "what if I mixed hip hop with soul music and gospel" thing but I just don't believe him, it seems like he's trying too hard to force something and it comes off as inauthentic. I feel nothing from this album.
If you separate the art from the artist, this is an amazing hip-hop album, and it isn't even his best work. The problem is that Ye's antics over the past 15 years hang over his actual art.
Musically not that interesting - not something I would put on regularly. There is an endearing element to the lyrics in spots. Props for being a debut album but my interest ends there. 3/5
Classic album with bangers, actually never listened to to whole album until now. It's been maddening to see how low Kanye has fallen.
Music was ok, but he’s a shitbag
Separating art from artist here, this is a fantastic album, I really like the way the skits break up the album. My stand out songs were Spaceship and Jesus Walks
Kanye West is an awful person, this album isn't much better
Not in my edition of the book! 2004. 3 stars. As a musical experience, there is a lot to like here, despite it being a rap album - he moves effortlessly from style to style, has sharp lyrics and production, and a sense of humour. Set against it are excessive length and filler. You can see why he got the kudos at the time. As rating for West as a person: 0 stars. No time for Nazis.
Kanye has always had a great sound, definitely one of if not my favorite rapper. This album specifically makes me think especially being in college because he offers a pretty harsh critique of the system. Definitely a fun listen
Separate art from artist and this album is great.
A debate for the modern age: can you separate the art from the artist? To argue for "yes," art is its own independent thing. It has a life of its own, outside of the individuals or team that created it. It represents history. It represents those who love the art and hate the art. Its story is completely independent of its artist, yet the artist is quintessential to its story. Art can be defined by its technical skill. A painting is realistic. A musical is performed well. Art can be defined by its impact to culture. To argue for "no," we live in a digital age. By listening to this album on Spotify Premium, I am giving tiny amounts of money to the artist. The artist can then use the money to continue to live their lives as they choose, without my consent or contribution. By listening to this album willingly, you could argue that I support Kanye West. That I can be associated with him, as one of his "listeners." That title comes with baggage, because Kanye is not a good person, and it is important to me that I am one. I don't know what the right answer is. It's a good album. Maybe even a great album. But to boil down its nuisances into a 1-5 star rating is impossible.
B+ We Don't Care 3 Graduation Day 4 All Falls Down 3 Spaceship 3 Jesus Walks 5 Never Let Me Down 3 Get Em High 3 The New Workout Plan 4 Slow Jamz 4 Breathe In Breathe Out 3 School Spirit 4 Two Words 5 Through The Wire 4 Family Business 3 Last Call 4 I used to love this album, but knowing how antisemitic Kanye is, it just sounds so much flatter and repetitive. It’s a good album, but it ain’t allat.
This is one of the few hip hop albums I ever owned on CD, and while I liked it I certainly don't remember getting through all 20+ tracks. Lot of filler and the last 12 minute track was unnecessary, but overall pretty great. I didn't really follow Kanye after late registration so this is what I think of when I think of Kanye. Among less positive things.
95
Wow
Classic- reminds me of high school. Not my favorite in the trilogy but an amazing debut and a great intro to an era-defining producer. So sad that his legacy is forever tarnished and I have to feel bad abt streaming this album and giving KW my $.03!
Even if you´re not a fan of Kanye or hip-hop in general, this is one of these albums that are so great that you can be indifferent to it
Not really listened to Kanye West before. In recent years, his behaviour and statements have made him problematic so I thought the ship had sailed for me. I listened to Graduation on the recommendation of a friend a couple of weeks ago and enjoyed it, so wasn't disappointed when this came up. I'm not the biggest rap fan, but there are some artists and tracks I like. I'm willing to be open minded though. I've pretty much enjoyed what I've listened to by Kanye so far, I appreciated the influence of Lauren Hill who is up there for me as one of the best. Feel that this album just goes on a bit long though, so it's 4 stars for me.
Gran disco! Me encanta, lo disfruto bastante de inicio a fin. Para mi el mejor de West y de los mejores del género un rap muy genuino y podría decir con ideas del hiphop clásico. Buen disco
La producción y algunos de los mejores performances de Kanye (siendo que no es taaaan buen rapero). Merece volverse a oír
Didn't listen and never will.
You really can’t go wrong with old Kanye. Hate the man but he did make some good music in the past. Definitely prefer some songs over others but wouldn’t say any are “bad” necessarily. I think the last half of the album is stronger and more my taste. 7/10 for the art but -10000/10 for the artist.
I think he’s ok now?
They want some Marvin gayeeeeee
Everybody want to know what I’d do if I didn’t win…. I guess we’ll never know
He’s a genius.
Hard to separate the art from teh artist sometimes. but man this is a masterpiece
Good in the gym.
Lots of bangers on this
No querría ponerle esa puntuacion porque es una persona muy problematica pero kanye es un artistazo y el album me ha parecido buenismo
I would give all five. But its a goddamn Kanye west, so four
It would be weird to think about Kanye becoming a neo-Nazi antisemite with a lot of personal issues, drug addiction, porn addiction and all the controversies that he acquired through the years, at the moment this album came out. But if you really listened to the things he has said through the years, even in this album you can see that Kanye's career came to be thanks to his personality, his pigheadedness that made him work even in some dire situations (Through the Wire). And this characteristic, that made him so well estimated as a hard-working artist with no compromises in his work, became a show of arrogance and dubious working ethics. But more than that, we can see how here, he already exposed some of the thinking and way of seeing the world that influenced his work and decisions in the years to come: His disdain (somewhat justified) of the academic system, dropping from college and how he feels it's not only something people fear due to it being the standard route of life, but that school indoctrinates people in a studying wheel without experiencing or doing real things. And how this became an anti-academic nightmare, believing conspiracies and harmful ideologies. His strong believing and faith, represented through the famous "Jesus Walks", and how he feels this strong assessment of "people can't sing of Jesus in the radio" that nowadays feels like typical crying from Christian nationalists, but then could be felt as a differential factor compared to other artists. And how it became nothing more than soil for his, and other people, weird nationalist Christo-fascist beliefs, that even when he tried to distance from them, a lot of people still have and celebrate, thanks to him bringing to the mainstream. His general contempt and opinions that more than the typical bravado and presumption a rapper must have, today is more known as the real personality and thinking of Kanye. What I think these things reveal, is that the life of Kanye has been the result if all of these characteristics took the worst outcome possible. We could talk about at which point it went like this, or what could've been done to prevent it, but at the end of the day, the way Kanye West is today, should not be strange considering this: that he was the same from the beginning, and despite his music changing in technical and artistic aspects, the content and message was at his core, the same. All the good and bad, and dirty aspects of his work are here in some or other way. In that sense, I feel this album it's quite good, albeit a bit weird to listen nowadays with all the recent events. As a debut album, it's impressive. In musical and technical aspects, I prefer more recent works. I don't love it, but it's quite sad that it's so well regarded, more than anything, due to how an asshole and an egomaniacal drugged, washed-out artist he has become.
i don't really know what's going on here, to be perfectly honest. the beats are consistently pretty good, vocals and production are mostly good, and best as i can tell the lyrics are absolutely all over the place. it careens from political commentary to regulation issue misogyny to daily life to out-of-pocket ableism to weird religious screeds? completely unpredictable.
*Such a good hip hop album unfortunately from a brainwashed maniac
This was my first ever time listening to Kanye West and I was astonished by how good it was. There's musical complexity here I really hadn't expected from a rap artist. Great production sound, actual tunes (although some probably sampled from elsewhere) and lyrics that were sometimes thoughtful. One or two tracks were less good but overall I have to say this was really impressive.
I’ve never really connected with Kanye. I’ve listened to several of his albums, including this one, and while I can’t deny he’s an immensely talented and influential songwriter, rapper, and producer, his music doesn’t resonate with me much. That said, there are still several great songs on this album
"You were the Chosen One! It was said that you would destroy the Sith, not join them! Bring balance to the Force, not leave it in darkness!"
Do younger generations look at old Kanye records the way I look at Elvis?
estilo musical que nao me agrada
Yeah, a common refrain throughout my reviews is ideological agreement != enjoyment, the corollary does not hold, I cannot give West any credit for writing good music. Is he the only monster on this list, no, call it recency bias but I won't positively review a Kanye West album, regardless of how good it is. 1/5
Kanye's debut album has a nice backstory, such as Kanye slowly climbing up the music industry ladder, the non-gangsta rap approach to hip-hop which the suits are not and the fateful near-fatal car crash he was involved in two years prior to release, whi h both he understandly references a lot. The album contains a lot of pop-styled hooks (examples: "We Don't Care", "Spaceship", "Through the Wire.") Usually the hook is done by yearning, pitched-up, soulful vocals referred to as chipmunk soul. The album's first 4 proper tracks (non-skits) kick the album off with a strong start, lots of good hooks, such as "We Don't Care", "Spaceship" and "All Falls Down". The second part (tracks: 8-11) of the proper tracks do dip a bit in quality, mainly Jay-Z's part on "Never Let Me Down" and the worst track on the album "The New Workout Plan", only track that I just flat out do not like, everything about it. Though I do quite like "Get Em High" the verse by Talib is excellent! The third part (tracks: 12-17) is a good section of the album that has songs that are probably the epitome of chipmunk soul, whilst its also quite fatigued by the worst obnoxious skits on the album, "School Spirit" being the highlight of the section. The final section (tracks: 18-21) is pretty good, it has the classic "Through the Wire" and the finale "Last Call" is for sure a bit daunting, but Kanye's in-depth story makes it go by fast if it manages to entrances you. Now a section just dedicated to Jay Z: Hats off to Jay-Z always managing to ruin an otherwise good song (Never Let Me Down) He always has to reference the same 10 nicknames that he HIMSELF started, just a huge bloody eye-roll. It's so bad and predictable it makes it so good (in a funny way.) This is my second time listening through this album, if this was my first time listen this would've been a solid 4, but some songs hitted harder on the second listen so I feel this has to be a 5 at minimum. It's production and thought it was given is done very well. Highlight Song/s: "We Don't Care", "All Falls Down", "Spaceship", "School Spirit" and "Through the Wire"
got a pass from a jewish person to enjoy this
Lowkey I thought the skits were too much… but not too much to make this less than a 5
I miss this guy
“We at war with terrorism, racism, but most of all we are at war with ourselves.” Kanye needs to get back on his meds and listen to this album.
3.5
It’s a great album, didn’t love the skits in between songs. In light of recent Kanye events I think a 3 is warranted
Fav part were the interludes (I don’t know if that’s what they’re technically called) and Get Em High
Oh he think he funny huh 4.5 but rounding up
Used to be a big Kanye fan in high school but I can't support him anymore
Not my bag
Fantastic debut. Let's hope this guy doesn't do anything weird.
9/10
Overall Rating - 2.65/5 (5.31/10). Not a fan of the style, but I have to admit that, before he went completely insane, he was pretty good at this.
Virkelig godt i sin genre. Meget catchy melodier. Men man kan jo ikke blive Kanye-fan nu ...
Haven't listened to Kanye in a while. This honestly just reminds me why he 𝘸𝘢𝘴 so popular. There's no one who quite compares to his style of music. You really do see his immense lyrical genius in the song "Slow Jamz" lyrics: "She got a light-skinned friend look like Michael Jackson" "She got a dark-skinned friend look like Michael Jackson"
Miss the old Kanye. Pretty legendary debut album. Only have a surface level knowledge of Kanye but the lyricism here is some of his best imo. Beats are inventive and well-engineered. That said, nothing had me hitting the download button, but really good album. Will probably give it another listen soon
Back when Kanye made sense. Also didn’t realize how many samples of this album were used in other songs, ie workout plan for one of J Cole’s songs. The skits were also hilarious, get your degree!
Amazing album
Fantastic album which makes it even more of a shame he lost his mind
Of course he has turned into an abhorrent individual who suffer severe mental illness. Taking the pure artistic nature of the album, this is fantastic.
I enjoyed the first half more than the second - overall a decent debut, if this young man can work on his stamina then I have a feeling things are looking up.
Groove, hard lines, an impressive debut album
ew
To say this album was a large part of my life is a hilariously reductive understatement. This was the soundtrack to a huge portion of my early twenties. I have an unsurprisingly more complex relationship with Kayne now, but this will never stop having mattered to me.