Reviews (page 4 of 15)
Okay
I like this album.
While I generally can’t stand the “stomp clap” genre of music I have to give Arcade Fire credit for maybe doing it best. They may have given rise to bands like Mumford or the lumineers, but at least they did it with some originality.
Arcade Fire is some solid indie rock, I'm never disappointed when it comes on, but I never find myself really loving it either, pretty middle of the road
Really engaging effort…leveled up my expectations
It was fine, inoffensive, and very much an album of 2004.
Already listen to it, but not really my type of genre
I don’t allow myself to listen to the music i used to love by men that were later discovered to be abusers but man i used to love this band
very pretty album, definitely really emotive but didn't keep me the most engaged or interested
This album is one of the few I would listen to on repeat. I’ll never forget my sister introducing me to the album through “Crown of Love” while driving down a Florida highway on the way to the beach and breaking into a disco dance when the drumbeat hit. This is the most gorgeous and hopeful doomsday metaphor that I’ve certainly ever heard.
I definitely preferred this one to "Neon Bible" even though it was a long time ago, I remember not liking it at all, this however wasn't too bad. It's nicely-done densely layered indie rock. The vibes on the first track are amazing, so magical. The violins do a good job of giving drama that some of the songs require. Not too bad of an album. Highlight Song/s: "Neighborhood #1" and "Haiti"
I don’t like arcade fire
too boring too indie i like goth music
War gar nicht so schlecht, aber auch nicht so gut.
Super Album, super Band. Tunnels sehr schön, eines meiner Lieblingslieder. Crown of love und Rebellion auch top top top. Rest ist auch gut. Fand The Suburbs etwas besser war, geb aber trotzdem eine 5.
I'm happy that Arcade Fire found a better sound on their future albums, because their debut did not connect with me at all. Boring and derivative, and sounds like it was produced in a 2x2 tube room. Just an uninteresting mush of sounds that never go anywhere or say anything
We all like this one.
One of the best indie albums, every song has something special about it
Alright sound, couple of good tracks with nice texture, overall ok. Pixies plus melatonin and violin.
Love Arcade Fire despite the win butler induced eye rolls
On paper, not my jam but this is such a great distillation of mid-aughts indie
First time hearing. Thought it had a "jolly" sound that I enjoyed. The second half of the album is soo much better than the first half though - so a bit unbalanced in quality for me.
Nice in between alt rock with some good tunes and an original feel. I don't know that I would seek them out or build a play list around them, but listenable.
Fun, epic, driving through a tunnel, sun, indie, nostalgic, alive
Hyper vivant, melancholie, contrasté (triste et joie), intense
favorite track: neighborhood #2 laika very cool indie rock feeling
Sounds like every other hipster indie band from the early 2000s - fuzzy and sweet, slightly whiny and mostly inoffensive. The only noticeable twist is the strong Talking Heads influence ; but Talking Heads did it better in the first place, so why bother ? I didn't hate it, but I also didn't connect with it on any level, and it did become a bit annoying towards the end. Kind of a pointless addition to the list in my opinion, there's no way this band deserves three albums... 3/10
Bought on release, pulled in by the hype. Musically it feels like a messy Têtes Raides style sprawl with violins, just way more dramatic. It constantly flirts with falling apart, a kind of organized chaos. Coming back to it now, I get the appeal, especially in the early 2000s when rock was fading into something blurry and lifeless. This sounded alive. Still, just like in 2004, I can’t fully get on board. The voices and that overload of sounds wear me out. I could come back to it though, because I feel that it was and still is special and might give it another try… in a decade.
Not my type
I’ve heard this before. I haven’t heard it in a long time but I’ve heard their stuff from the past decade that wasn’t very good, so it’s a good time for a revisit. This is a very mid-00s indie rock album. I’m recognizing a lot of these songs from last time I heard this or being played at parties, and the rest are sounding a lot like devotchka or Sufjan Stevens or other orchestral acts from the time. And this is a good thing, I liked those acts at the time and still listen to them regularly. This is feeling extremely nostalgic for me even though I don’t really know these songs. All in all a well organized album with some pretty great songs. Il have to revisit more of their stuff.
I thought I might like this, but I didn’t…..
Not as bad as a funeral but not as fun as a wedding
Album de gran calidad. Consigue que el oyente fluya con este rock/pop de los 2000. La calidad del sonido y de las armonías es espectacular, se nota que hay gente con talento detrás. El hilo musical de las letras le da un toque especial y mas cercano. Mi fav sin duda es “Crown of love”. Mención honorable a “In the backseat” y “Power out”
One of the ones I’m very familiar with. They were such a great band, a shame they sort of teetered off. Went from releasing great records to releasing very average records with some great songs. Looking at you Reflektor. I’d happily argue that Suburbs is their best, but this is pretty close! 4.5
Arcade fire must be the band I like the most that I've made the least effort to listen to. I remember listening to power out on MTV2, really liking it and not bothering to seek out the album. And now here we are! And the album is great too, theres a lot going on that takes it above most the indie of the time it was usually lumped in with. Think I prefer suburbs but it's a close run thing.
Probably my favourite of the Arcade Fires so far. I would argue there might be a bit too much of them on the list. Crown of Love, and Neighborhood 1 (Tunnels) were my favourite tracks. Dreamy, sincere indie rock. Not nearly as deep as it pretends to be. 3.5.
Got a very distinctive sound haven't they. It's good, exactly what I expect from them. Suburbs is still the best one we've had, but this was very good too. No real complaints 4
sensible hymns with a soft touch and a hint of goofyness
I get that Arcade Fire and this album specifically was insanely influential, but I can't not hear it's influence in the some really bad music of the 2000s and 2010s. It sometimes just sounds like Imagine Dragons or Twenty One Pilots to me. I like the rest of the album much better than Neighborhood 1-4, and I like when the female vocalist sings, she has a really unique voice. Maybe more time needs to pass before I can listen to this baroque rock stuff and not cringe, idk.
Oh my god. I played this so much when it came out, and I can't believe I'd almost forgotten it existed. This album is so powerful, so raw, and always has me in tears.
Pregnant with the “shout stomp” folk movement
“Now that I’m older my heart’s grown colder.” This is the first album I looked forward to being released. The Arcade Fire EP hit me like a revelation and when Funeral came out I became a confirmed indie rock kid. What a perfect soundtrack for turning 18. The world seemed so big and full of possibilities. And even though it’s a lot more twee than most stuff I listen to these days it still holds up.
White generic slop, boring
Thought it was fine. Has a melody that I like, but can't make out any words. Seems like decent music to put on in the background.
It's good. I think it's genre defining of a genre I don't really like all that much. Certainly is good though
Funeral is a masterpiece. I don't love every track individually, but as a unit it is great.
Washed over me a bit, Arcade fire have got some great tracks though...
I am very familiar with this one. When I first heard it I wasn't convinced, but over the years it has grown on me. I revisit it occasionally and it's aging well.
good album good vibes
Tip debut
Not my style, but good to expand outside my comfort zone a bit.
Let me start by saying that Régine Chassagne has the voice of an angel, and is a top 3 voice crush for me. She’s woefully under-utilized in Arcade Fire albums, but that’s just my opinion. Her backup vocals in “Crown of Love” are devastatingly beautiful. As an album, this was one I knew would be an instant 5/5. The number of hits is basically the entire track list, and there’s a frenetic energy to the whole thing that captivates the heart and soul. Jumps up into my top 5 to date.
Maybe I've been exposed to too much Arcade Fire. Maybe I just wasn't in headspace to appreciate them. Regardless, my impression of this album was that it was fine. It's clearly musically adept, and some of the songs were enjoyable, but it didn't bowl me over by any means.
Love the vibes, instrumentation is very fun and very them.
Super
Eh, some tracks i really liked, others I really didn't
I know this album well from a different era in my past and it brings back memories of a strange time. It’s such an emotionally wrought album in itself. It’s not the sort of thing I listen to now. And I never listened to any other Arcade Fire album after this. Really, I should give it a five because it’s so consistently itself …if that makes sense. But it feels somehow alien to me. I think a 4 is how I feel about it.
Not my cup of tea. V unrelaxing
Litt som MGMT, så er det mye nostalgi tilknyttet dette. Hyggelig gjenhør, men Arcade Fire er mye hit and miss for min del.
For en debut! Var spesiell når det kommer ut og er en plate jeg fortsatt kan både danse til og bli rørt av. Min mest klinke femmer til nå.
Grei indie, det her. Blir litt glutenfritt til tider. Sterk treer.
Stort sett kjedelig og intetsigende, til tross for det litt sirkusaktige uttrykket. Rebellion (Lies) kommer inn som et seint høydepunkt.
The finest of noughties indie rock. Played this to death back in the day
I listened to this album a lot back in the day and it is solid throughout.
Another AF album I slept on
Probably their best album. There are a couple of good songs, but overall I can’t quite understand the appeal.
One of the best albums I've heard
This is a nice sounding album. It definitely has that indie sound to it, which a lot of people will like. I'm not too convinced by this album, I don't dislike it. But I think it lacks variation, for my taste at least. This is definitely right up some people's alley, and I will say there are good highlights on the album. But this kind of indie rock isn't really what I'd find myself listening to more often. I like the instrumentation for the most part, I think it can occasionally feel a bit empty at points but the bass and guitar are generally speaking quite good. I definitely have people in my life who would love this, just isn't really my thing tbh. Fav track: Wake Up
Was hoping with such a lively band name for something more exciting! Didnt like the voice and the tracks had a similar sound ….so got bored. But not too awful!
Fav-crown of love
⭐⭐⭐⭐ Nästan som en definition av indie-rock. Homogent album med bra produktion, intressant instrumentering, hur spår byggs upp i crescendon och ändrar riktning samt tonartsskiftningar. Ibland låter produktionen hemmagjord som att den är inspelad i ett vardagsrum, men förmodligen medvetet och bidrar snarare till en genuin känsla. Jag gillar Win Butlers röst och inlevelse och Régine Chassagne bidrar med variation och nästan en lyxig känsla speciellt med det franska inslagen. Albumet är väldigt jämnt, inget spår jag tycker illa om mer än att det är mindre intressant. Kanske lite få riktiga höjdarspår (förrutoma Wake up och Rebellion) får därför en 4a. Bäst är Neighborhood#1 och #2, Crown of love, Wake up och Rebellion.
This album is better than I remember.
Tremendous
Idk bro this sounds kinda dated in a fleet foxes sort of way. Important, but it might be washed.
I disagree with the other bulk of reviews it seems. This is some solid indie rock. Sure, everyone copied them, but sometimes the wheel is pretty solid.
arcade fire sucks
:/
Loved it! Enjoyable album!
i like this
Disregarding the mess that 2025 Arcade Fire have become, this is a phenomenal debut.
dentro de este genero que no me gusta porque se me hace muy empalagoso, este album fue lo mejor que salio 7/10
I knew the name more than I thought i knew their genre evidentally. Good music, easy to think over for background music. 4
Muy indie para mi
I will not listen to an album where I have to struggle to hear the singer. I have no idea why bands/artist do this. It is not sultry, it is not mysterious, it is simply disrespect for your listeners.
perfectly nice album, just less my thing (very millennial hopecore)
I love this album. It was such a big deal when it came out.
Olipa erinomainen albumi. Poikkeukselliset instrumentit ovat ehkä tämän bändin ja albumin juttu. Toki on hyviä biisejäkin. Mielenkiintoinen, pitää otteessaan vaikka onkin rauhallinen meno. Positiivinen yllätys. 4/5
Loved this album a lot especially the nbhd #2(laika) I wasn’t expecting it to be like this but I liked it nonetheless
Pues sí me gusta pero muy meh. Ni se que más opinar. Muy genérico todo
Estuvo entretenida no me disgustó, lo volvería a escuchar,
Música de publicidad de cámara de fotos. No me disgusta, tampoco me enloquece. Meh. No queda guardado.
Utterly forgettable.
I remember how good this was when it came out. But I also remember we are supposed to be not down with Arcade Fire
wake up???? woooooooo rebellion???? double woooooo
not ky cibe
8/10 Best songs: Neighborhood #2 (Laika), Neighborhood #3 (Power Out), Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies) My first album in this project was Arcade Fire, and now, over 120 albums later, I'm getting another one of their albums. I find this rather interesting. Anyways, I have been listening to various songs by Arcade Fire for decades now. When they're good, they're very, very good; but sometimes the songs just fall into a mire of pretention and dull repetition, and that gets old fast. This album is much the same - some absolute bops (there's a reason Wake Up has been on my playlists for over 20 years now), some incredibly average songs. Overall quite good though.
Banger
A let down
Ugh
1. I thought it was gonna be heavier. I really like the vocalist straight off the bat. Reminds me of millennial hopecore but in a good way 2. i dont like the production in this one. 3. They are blending together. However, it's reminding me of big thief.
9/10 classic
I can't deal with another album of banal. Lasted 1 min of the first song and oh my goodness I mean it's almost a talent in itself to be that GLARINGLY mediocre.
mmm not my style
Wasn't surprised to find out that the band was Canadian after listening to this album
mid
Thursday 16 April 2026 Pretty good and I liked, don’t know how often I’d listen though I’m yearning
3.5 haven't been the biggest fan of indie pop and rock since I was like 13 but I like a few songs on this album so I'll be generous and give it a 4. No songs particularly stuck out to me though. Issue with a lot of indie music is that it all sorta sounds the same. Best songs were probably Rebellion and Laika.
Я уже не знаю что придумывать чтобы как то описать релизы девятой сотни
I like how some songs were soothing, and others were more high energy. My favorite track I think was neighborhood #3, but I enjoyed them all, and I would probably need to listen to them a lot more to be certain. I’m not very good at reviews or critiquing music but I hope to get better as I rate more albums.
Gen X got grunge but we got this. This album's influence on the decade following was huge. Just like grunge, the scene got flooded with swathes of corporate plants trying to cash in on the genre hype. I'm in my 30s. I was listening to this album a lot in high school. I was one of the few people I knew of at my tiny, rural high school that listened to anything other than Toby Keith or Eminem. Back then, this album sounded fresh, almost magical. Today, it feels like a bunch of ideas done better by bands that influenced and were influenced by it. The 2000s were an awkward stepping stone in a lot of art mediums, I think I'm just not a big fan of a lot of bush era popular art. That said, it does deserve to be talked about, but I don't know how often I'll return to this album.
This album felt more like storytelling through songs than a traditional album. It wasn't what I was expecting (I was expecting Radio Single Arcade Fire), but I thought it was pretty good. Only giving 3 stars because I probably won't listen again, not because it's anything against the album.
The earnestness is both annoying and exhilarating. What else could it be than "Canadian indie rock"? But it makes me feel young again.
Um lindo funeral.
Not as good as when I first listened to it when I was 14, but what is?
Cute
Un gran álbum indie, Funeral de Arcade Fire Me dio paz escucharlo. Si lo escuchás entendiendo la historia , podes disfrutarlo mas: empieza con la pérdida de los adultos y quedan los niños tratando de entender qué hacer con eso, y así llega el momento de crecer. “ My parents forgot what they were doing“ - Me hace acordar a mi amiga Lu
very cool love the vibes
consistent... not my thing tbh
I remember liking this more when it came out.
Nothing really stood out
Such a good album! Amazing from start to finish.
I really like it.
All-timer album right here. Fantastic album front to back. Probably the best Arcade FIre but the Suburbs could give it a run for it's money.
classic album
Besserer Rock.
Nice listen, but nothing that stood out to get it any higher
Loved it! Easy listening, great vocal, great sound.
Tunnels Crown of love
This is a very good album and I really enjoyed it especially the mixing of indie with lush orchestration and was a treat to listen to. It was very close to getting top marks but there are 2 songs on it that are not as good as the rest of the album and as such did affect my enjoyment as a whole.
2000s sound. As I listened I kept thinking they sound like other bands like MGMT, Fleet Foxes and Modest Mouse with the whiney kiddie voice and group singing. I did like the classical instruments though.
Eipä jäänyt tästä mitään mieleen. Aika tasapaksua huttua...
Kan kuuloinen vokalisti. Menevää meininkiä
Pre listening: The first album generator gives me that I don't only know well but also own physical copy of. But do I love it, I don't know. Unlike many reviewers here I didn't grow up with it. Back in 2004 I was listening to punk and following years were years of nu-metal. I got familiar with their music some 10 years later and my first album was Reflector. But I appreciate Funeral for what it is. Plus I have stupid connection with the second track as am Alexander, older brother and come from the same place as original Laika.
Arcade Fire is another one of those bands that people whose tastes normally align with mine went NUTS over and I just didn't get it. Like most of those bands, I didn't hate or even dislike it, but it just didn't do anything for me. And my Arcade Fire-loving friends just could not believe that I didn't love this band the way they did. Oh well... This is the one Arcade Fire I own and after several listens I liked it OK but then put it down and basically didn't touch it again. The opening track DID grow on me and I would say that I really like that one. But the rest? Eh. Maybe I just need to see them live...
A few good/great songs on here for sure, but I got a bit bored in parts. V atmospheric tho
Great album 4.2
not really my cup of tea
8/10 really good nice to think too
Desconocía el artista no me agrado mucho las canciones, tal vez no es mi tipo de música o solo se siente vacío sin sentimientos
I thought this was a really nice album even tho I found it as white noice and often get distracted by what I was doing at that moment, my favorite was crown of love
Un disco muy bueno por ser el primero de la banda 8.50/10
A really good album some really good songs, songs that I would listen to again just not enough bangers to get 5 stars
4/5
Eu entendo o porquê do backlash que esse álbum tem recebido em tempos recentes. O win butler é um jegue, os últimos lançamentos da banda foram terríveis e em geral há um cansaço em relação a música indie dos anos 2000. Mas! Funeral é um clássico por boas razões. Se há um cansaço a culpa é menos do Arcade Fire e mais de seus copycats que vieram depois. A produção não é boa em termos técnicos, mas ela acaba criando uma atmosfera muito peculiar: meio-nostalgica, meio-moderna, marcando a dobradiça que é a experiencia do fim da juventude.
Indie rock, chamber pop, art rock, baroque pop, symphonic rock.
8 / 10
схоже на зе драмс
Meh
Le doy un 9/10 a Funeral. Me pareció un álbum muy interesante, con un concepto muy bien construido. Siento que habla mucho sobre crecer, aceptar cambios y despedir etapas de tu vida. Es de esos discos que te hacen reflexionar sobre el futuro, incluso con cierto miedo, pero al mismo tiempo te obligan a sentirlo todo. Es perfecto para escuchar en una noche donde estás sobrepensando, o incluso llorando en el carro. Tiene una carga emocional muy fuerte, pero nunca se siente exagerada, es más como un abrazo al corazón para saber que todo estará bien. Las canciones que más me gustaron fueron: - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) - Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) - Haiti - Wake Up - Rebellion (Lies) - Crown of Love - In the Backseat - 7 Kettles
bien menos laa canciones que eran neighborhood
I'm just not a big fan of Win Butler's voice. Lots of good songwriting and old-timey sounds on the record, but can't get past his voice.
Dreamy vibes, chill. Lo veo como soundtrack de alguna película romcom o algo así al momento de la revelación final. Medio aburrido igual
Used to be a favourite, but it just doesn’t grip me in the same way anymore. A handful of excellent songs but gets a bit samey in-between.
Another album that really defines and brings me back to a specific era. In the early 2000s, this album was huge. The Arcade Fire were indie darlings of the time. This debut is both larger than life and intimiate. By centering the album on a story of a neighborhood blackout in winter, they managed to take a relatively mundane subject (for rock n roll standards) and elevate it into a story of people helping one another and kids finding refuge with peers among the isolating suburban world of adults. It's simple, beautiful and human. There's a brief moment for me when I'm tempted to switch to other music, but I'm always drawn back in by the opening notes of "Rebellion (Lies)", one of their best songs. Win Butler would go on become a symbol of progressive, squeaky clean, but cool musician, in contrast to the entitled, toxic rock star imagine that would have been idolized in previous decades. Given that, it's a shame that Win Butler himself turned out to be a creep. But you can still feel the innocence and wonder that was present in this beautiful debut. It's still one of the best of that decade.
throwback!
Besides the lyrics, is it just me or the albums lil bit kinda like hopecore or smth? The one which play on the end of survival story
Some haunting and atmospheric works on here. But I don't think this is the best Arcade Fire album and it's hella whiny. I left an Arcade Fire show early because I came for the opener and people around me seemed more into it than I could be.
no good music comes out of canada
Don't know what the fuss is about
Generational Anthem level. Still love yelling along with it
Listened in the car and on a walk and countless times over the past 22 years. This is the album the defined my personality in high school. Even despite their lackluster later discography and Win's recent controversies this album remains a monolith from my formative years. One of the best albums of its decade and I adore it. 6 stars if I could.
I grew up and not really into it anymore lol
total ass tbh.
Eh, not for me but not awful. I liked Haiti okay enough and Neighborhood 2 wasn't awful but it's just overall didn't do much for me. I probably would've liked it more with a different vocalist. 3, but closer to 2.5
Nah not for me. Wake up is maybe the only song I like here. Arcade Fire’s “The Suburbs” album is the first instance I can think of where I brainwashed myself to like an aesthetic because it was someone I respected’s favorite thing. Female vocalist is really low in the mix when she’s on, and those are the parts of this album I enjoyed the most— so I’m not feeling great about this one :\
kinda boring? this era of indie rock was so obsessed with being “important” and “bombastic” and it might have felt that way at the time compared to their more sleazy counterparts but it sort of rings hollow now. at least, the earnestness they present on this record doesn’t resonate with my own earnestness, then or now.
Did not expect anything from this, never heard of it. Instantly had to listen to it three times to make up for that
I knew that this band existed but I only listened to their music because of this project. And I really like what they are doing!
Interesting for sure. I didn't hate it : )
This is more of a conflict than expected. Its great, but it's it great great? Listening to this objectively, it's as good an indie pop album as when it came out. It's lofty and ambitious, but also pointed and bleak. I really really like it as an album, yet oddly am loath to give it a 5. Strange, why is that? Spoiler it'll get a 5. It really is some beautifully crafted pop music.
No thanks
didnt listen
I liked this one of course. My expectations were incredibly high, and sadly i was not blown away, but it is as good as their other entries in the book. Not a fan of the mix, but learning how it was recorded, I can see why it sounds like this. Love it's influence, and i had lots of fun with it. Might have to pick it up on vinyl later. Solid 4
Wake up is clearly the standout but everything else is fine. Not my favorite album of the year winner
It's not my genere but I find it very emotional and rich of colors.
Emotional and Nostalgic. Beautiful and Overcast. Energetic and Somber. 8:42pm 3/29/2026 XM
Unfortunately, didn't resonate complety with this album however, saved a song so that i can give it a second chance someday :) Maybe, who knows, I'll find someone who can change my mind about this album.
It’s got the song!!!!!! What else is abouts this?
Three albums on this list is a bit excessive for this band. This is the second one by this band I’ve heard so far from this list and it’s not doing much like the other one I listened to. I don’t really understand why they’re so popular although they do have a fairly inoffensive sound so that’s probably how they found appeal. These songs just sound so second rate. Whatever style they’re going for is done pretty lightly. In a way it does seem kind of classically Canadian to take indie rock and make it sound so bland. I’m Canadian so this band is kind of embarrasing to me, ugh. Although there are apparently many people in the world who like this but I suppose that’s not surprising because most people in the world are very conservative. I’ve been trying to keep my comments as kind as possible but I’ve been getting a run of sub-par albums lately so I’m losing my patience with the amount of crap on this list…
I love this record with all of my heart, but it's unfortunately the ship that launched a thousand trilby donning millennial whoop indie pop bands in early 2010s
Better than expected.
4.3
Solid...3 stars
Not my cup of tea
lots of nostalgia associated with this album, great opening terrific finish. compared to all of my favourite albums probably gets a 3.7 out of 5
muy chulas algunas canciones pero vaya, no es genial del todo
Wake up Rebellion (lies) Neighborhood #3 (power out) Neighborhood #1 (tunnels) Haiti Neighborhood #2 (laika)
Just a beautiful record. Wake Up is worth 5* alone.
TS ASS. ok its alr
Lo escuché mientras lavaba el auto👍🏽
"I want to listen to neutral milk hotel" "we have neutral milk hotel at home" albums that make you listen to in the aeroplane over the sea again. Itwas good! I liked the Neighborhood series and Haiti.
Refreshingly different to other 2000s bands here 4*
Like Neon Bible The whole thing feels overwrought But sincere, at least
Fond memories of walking around listening to this album around the time of my uni final exams (in 2022, sorry olds).
There are a few great songs on here during the second half, but the first side does pretty much nothing for me and I can’t shake the feeling of this whole thing just being a bit pretentious. I’ve given this thing multiple tries over the years and it’s either just not for me or overrated.
Boring. I don't get this kind of music. There are so many skilled musicians and songwriters out there, why would you listen to this boredom in layers?
big wet fart sound
“They say a watched pot won't ever boil Well I closed my eyes and nothin' changed Just some water getting hotter in the flames” A lyricist he is not, but Rapist…. Yep Music is lovely still, each songs flows into the next and it’s whimsical. Im still a sucker for this album. I wish the band would carry on with out their lead, Win Butler. Rot in hell Win.
big hearted anthemic earnestness. its saccharine for me, but im not so young any more. and despite being a millenial, this album never meant much to me. and despite FUNERAL being cloying and a bit precious for this 40 year old, its important to remind myself that this band is a band that created a new sound at the right timing... arcade fire was highly influential. they are the indie version of what pearl jam was to grunge - everyone imitated and pummelled their sonic approach into the ground to the point where its so so grating to listen to. it can hard to remember how it was once original. the difference is - pearl jam is still awesome, and I think this is just fine. low 3
like average
Listened to this and totally forgot it was on our list. Fantastic album that put arcade fire on the map. I don’t think it’s as tuneful as almost anything else they do but the vibe is great.
Not bad. I've never really got Arcade Fire but I don't hate them
geen fan van Arcade Fire, maar dit viel redelijk mee... is het een album dat je moet gehoord hebben? Nee... Is het een slecht album? Nee... Is het een goed album? Bwaah...
This is such a great record. Deducting a point because Win Butler is a chump.
Very, very good album.
NGL this was kinda buns. Not even good at all cheks. Why did this get recommended to me, they can't sing or write a hook. Utterbly uninspired and bland album.
lagu emosional, vokal nya oke dan juga opening nya boleh juga.permainan melodi nya juga mellow. Permainan instrumen nya sangat mendalami. Cocok buat yang suka alternative rock
First 5 star - what a great album .
I bloody love this album. Always have and probably always will.
Это самый интересный альбом из тех, которые я слушал за последнее время. Каждая песня содержит в себе историю, и некоторые из них трогают до глубины души. Тут всё ещё невероятно сложный слоган для меня, да и музыкально не всё меня цепляло, но этот альбом я хочу запомнить и ещё не раз к нему вернуться. Такая же крепкая 4, которую я когда-то поставил до сих пор лучшему из предложенных альбому-American Idiot
I don’t know, it’s creative and has nice instrumentals and production quality but the whiny vocals are so off putting
One of my favorite bands
Bringing back early 2000s vibe. Hard to believe this album is over 20 years old! There are some great songs on this one. 7.75/10 Top song Rebillion
What a album. A wall of sound. A fantastic debut. Awesome live band too. Sadly diminishing returns of late and Win being a sleaze bag have ruined a once great band.
fajne
Why was Coldplay more popular than them?? This rips
Very unique art pop rock great sound even though i am not crazy bout prog , however it is recommended
Really establishes a vibe. Sounds like a slice out of time.
48 minutes of perfectly mid music. extremely inoffensive. i've probably heard this playing in the background at stores before but it just washes thru and leaves no trace in my memory. i guess i like the vocal style and vocal processing but again, other artists did it the same on much more interesting tracks. rebellion comes closest to standing out but... not really. mostly this album just makes me wish i was listening to the killers instead.
While it's not one of the really formative albums from my youth, the earlier sound of Arcade Fire really gets to me. I'll take the AF Liker stigmata in this friend group with no resistance. I have listened to it a couple times through on roadtrips, but it's been years since I've done it in full. An ex-relative of mine once said this album was the best liveshow he'd ever been to and I believe him in spite of rumors of them pulling some stinker shows in semi-recent. Forgive me for this 5/5
sounds like U2 fucked modest mouse
ME pasó lo mismo que con The Suburbs. Rock lavado con poco punch. Es como Imagine Dragons, no es para mi.
I wish I could give a 2.5 star rating, it's just ok, little overrated to my ear but there is flashes of brilliance
Banger
Dont know how to discribe it. But great music. Nothing to complain about. I think its an album that requires more listens
This sounds derivative and not very interesting. Not plain bad, just boring
Feels quite dated, may have been refreshing and new in the 00s but feels old and stale now.
3.5
Bon album mais pas marquant personnellement quelques chansons qui mon fait penser a mon ex
2nd Arcade Fire album to come up through this journey already... they are talented
God lyd! Litt vanskelig å få grepet om det.
More like 4.5
Wake Up is the definition of a millennial optimism song
not that interesting to me
A little odd. Not my flavor.
oh my god
i was hyped to listen to this cause ive heard great things about arcade fire but honestly. did not live up to it. maybe ill try listening again but it just sounded like background music - easily ignored.
Interesting indie album, very melodic, but the voice and melodies don't always hit for me. Some great songs and great concept behind the album. 1. Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) 2. Rebellion (Lies) 3. Neighborhoood #2 (Laika)
5/10, it was okay and fit the vibe of the day, but I didn't find the singer to be especially talented. I can definitely hear the influence this album had on alt-rock and surfer rock from the late 2010s, early 2020s, which I thought was quite cool, but I would not seek out this album to listen to by choice.
Bland
my day of reckoning. this was not the first album i called my favorite album ever, but it was the first album that i Expected to be my favorite album Forever. my biggest worry was that i would not be able to form a new relationship to it underneath all my layers of baggage, brain fuzz, and memories of a person that i No Longer Am. i was sort of right...i know every bit of this record like the back of my hand, so im not pulling any kind of Raw Experience out of it anytime soon. but it was comforting to be able to more fully understand Why it was so important to me...my love of it predated my self-conscious project to thaw my thoroughly frozen heart, but it definitely was one of the forerunners to that life shift. the A side brings together a v vivid and consistent picture of a child pov processing Big Feelings through lightly fantastical images...these days i mostly see what all the songs are metaphorically pointing to, but i think part of my attachment to this record was latching onto the actual narrative/sensory pictures painted on tunnels, power out et al. i think it does speak to a lot of my Future taste in art, on both levels. i think the B side is a clear step down, or at least is essentially extraneous to what i get out of the record these days...4 kettles completes a thought that im not sure is meaningfully expanded by the proto-suburbs Broad Vagueness of the big ennui anthems. still i essentially enjoy the music, and i think the two tracks sung by regine are welcome exceptions to all this...haiti productively breaks the focus on imperial north amercian imagery, and in the backseat ties up both halves of the album in a very beautiful way that still pricks my heart more vividly than maybe anything else on here. this will never be as important to me as it once was, but its possible nothing will ever be As important to me ever again as this once was. for better and for worse...i may crave similarly powerful experiences to no avail, but i also now live a broad enough life that One Piece Of Art doesnt have to serve as a liferaft all on its own. its better for me that i dont need records to save my life. but i cant erase the ones that did.
?? vergessen
Really wanted to give a 3.5 but since that’s not possible, it gets a 4 based on the strength of the last 3 songs on the album (In the Backseat is hauntingly beautiful)
Gosh Arcade Fire you do it for me, holy. Suburbs is a 7 so this kinda has to be a 5.
The production is awesome on this album. Very wide range of sounds and instruments. Songwriting is also fantastic.
A core pillar of millennial optimism that will always make me emotional. Co-opted by commercials and trailers and other marketing nonsense, but damn. We were once young and thought maybe we could pull this mess all together. Maybe we still can.
some stupid self-indulgent lyrics in here sub-par musics and musings, amusings it goes to places I wouldn't go with my huge hunting dog aka Rebellion, but then it moves toward In the Backseat which is lovely, but if I didn't go, how can I come?
Remarkable first album and easy to listen to. Songs are cool and it's never boring. From beginning to end it's an enjoyable listen.
Has some great hits on it. Lovely record. If it were a double record with neon bible it’d be a 5. Standalone 3/4
Different for sure. Calm and cool, but not really my thing.
It's fine but reminds me too much of the pretentious people that would enjoy it.
This is Arcade Fire in their prime, with a very characteristic sound and iconic songs. That being said, not really my cup of tea, although I vibe with some of the songs (e.g. Rebellion (lies) and the classic Wake Up), while recognizing their artistry.
I really liked this album. I missed it when it first came out. I'm glad that it crossed my path, it was my first listen but it won't be my last
This is likely more nostalgic than good, but damn does it slap. I hate that they started the "bring all your friends into the recording booth".
Music is quite good, well.organised, singing is definitely not for me
I like Wake Up, but the rest of the album fell a bit flat for me. Shouty and loud, but not in the way I tend to enjoy.
Didn't like it at all. Nearly puked at the Crown of Love - I guess this is how it sounds when someone's getting a shovel up their ass. There's a shitload of much better indie bands out there if someone's fancy.
The best thing about this album is that it proves you don't have to be amazing musicians to make incredible music! Nothing is technically advanced or difficult to play, but it all just works. Music of the people and songs that sound great on your 1st listen or 100th. This sounds like it was released this year and it's 20+ years old. Generational talent & bangers. Amazing debut album and set the table for an awesome follow up.
Meh
Songs for advertisers to sell cars to
ok
Couple of hits but not my taste.
One of my favourite albums. Such atmosphere. One of the best indie rock albums in the 2000s
Pretty confused on the hype for this one. Best album of the 2000s? Come on, it's good but come on.
Second half of this album is better than the first. Enjoy the "Wake up" song from the Tommy Lee Royce nice gay play, and the final song from the blizzard first half. Can't always tell what he's saying and it's not the music I love, but good array of instruments and styles to keep me engaged.
Really enjoyed this one, could become one of my favourites
I’ve seen this live!
Sorry sure it’s maybe dad alt, dad indie at this point. But the first song is so gooood, the kind of song that makes you think about all of life all at the same time and your family and neighbors and community and love. The multi instrumentalism of it all makes the songs so full of depth musically. Fond of the drumming and fond of the many voices.
"Вот и все! Неплохая получилась история: интересная, весёлая, порой немного грустная, а главное поучительная". любимые треки: • neighborhood #1 • neighborhood #3 альбом подойдёт тем, у кого острое желание почувствовать себя главным персонажем любовного фильма, либо его синеволосой пикси девочкой.
Very queen inspired. A little boring. Good nap music.
Holy mid
Really good album!
I really liked it overall, especially crown of love, but I feel like it's one of those albums where you listen to it the second or third time and it clicks then🤔
Вдохновляющий и мелодичный инди-рок из 2000-ных.Интро сразу мысленно перенесло меня в то время. Отдельно отмечу 5 и 10 треки, как наиболее понравившиеся.
I listened to this album once before for some reason, I’m not listening to it again.
91/100.
Took me a few songs to get into, but settled very happily into the vibe in time.
Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) - 3/5 Neighborhood #2 (Laika) - 4/5 Une Annee Sans Lumiere - 3.5/5 Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) - 3/5 Neighborhood #4 (Kettles) - 4/5 Crown of Love - 4.5/5 Wake Up - 4/5 Haiti - 4/5 Rebellion (Lies) - 3.5/5 In The Backseat - 3.5/5
Inascoltabile e noioso. Non l'ho nemmeno finito
I just don't get it! I see a lot of people 5-starring and I cannot for the life of me understand why. I've heard this name a lot and saw them in a couple of videos, including SNL, but most everyone sounds bad there. But these folks seem to sound bad everywhere. They're average musicians at best and their singer(s) are Quite Bad. Maybe the lyrics are deep, but none jumped out at me in a few listens. Sort of average views on mundane things. Usually I can say something is not for me, but I can understand why someone would like it. But here, this is just bland every-band sort of MOR crap. Sorry if you love them and are offended. I'm sure you're a fine person. AND I'm happy you're on this list trying to widen your horizons and improve your musical tastes. This is a 2 album at best. Because I could see them with a different singer making some decent music... maybe.
i just don't like arcade fire
Man, I listened the hell out of this thing back in the day. For some reason it didn't land as hard this time. And the recent Neon Bible hot harder than ever. Still good though.
overall i found the combination of song length and slowness of the tracks to not be my cup of tea but there was still several songs i enjoyed. would make for good background vibes. •standouts: une année sans lumiere, neighborhood #4 (kettles), crown of love, wake up •favorite: crown of love
Already listened to dat shit too also pretty fire
1: Wake Up 2: Neighborhood #3 3: Crown of Love
Yeah, yeah, I know Win’s a creep. But this is a remarkable achievement. I was 20 when this came out and it hit the indie world like an atom bomb. One of the best rock debuts; determined by them immediately having a fully developed sound. Track one, album one, and it was apparent it could be no one else. Fresh, exciting, layered, beautiful - Funeral is THE indie rock album of the 00s.
I was already a big fan of this album before this. Such great sounds. My favs are Tunnels, Power Out, Wake Up (Check out the live version with Bowie, great performance), Rebellion.
I wasn't sure about this going in. Arcade Fire were a big deal when I was younger, but I never bothered investigating them. I think the album definitely gets better as it goes along, as the intensity builds, but therein lies the problem. The best songs are all at the far end. Haiti, Rebellion, and In The Backseat are all excellent, I just found it a bit of an uphill slog to get to them. The view from the top can be worth a trek sometimes. 3.5 rounded up
pretty good!!!!!!!
A great album, but prefer the Suburbs
Is it just me, or could this stand to be remastered? I thought it would be an easy 5, but it just sounded… not as good as I remember, apparently.
Don't care for the vocals, instrumental is alright. Lackluster
Dejligt. Har aldrig dyrket dem, men kan virkelig godt lide lyden.
what i’ve been searching for.
Diferente a lo que he escuchado antes pero similar a otras bandas, sonido unico que recomiendo tener en sus playlist
Overrated
“Neighborhood #3” stood out and I enjoyed it, but the album as a whole feels somewhat uneven. “Wake Up” in particular was everywhere at the time, which makes it feel especially familiar. Each track has its own character, and there isn’t a single sound that immediately defines Arcade Fire. It feels like a classic example of early-2000s alt-rock: memorable moments, but hard to pin down as a cohesive identity.
Evocative of the late 00s and early 10s. The production still holds up. I think I overplayed this album but still enjoy it occasionally.
I got a fevah and the only curah is more millennial whoop!!!