Reviews (page 5 of 15)
I liked this one much better than The Suburbs.
An important debut for David Bowie's favourite band in the 2000s. Some useful pounding anthems in the alternative rock mould like 'Wake up'. Also nice to have a track with four parts in an album so early in a career - quite risky some would say. Their appearance at Fashion rocks with their legendary admirer was career defining for them at the time. This album gets better and some better work was to come from this Canadian bunch.
Meh
Their debut and probably their best - at least my favorite from them. So much better than their next one (that was on the list earlier).
I've liked this album more each time I've listened to it. It's now reached its fully-formed 5-star status.
i came across Azure fire randomly one day about Three years ago, while i was Exploring YouTube for new music. wake up was the song i stumbled on and liked it, but I didn't go deeper into their discography. yesterday when the album was recommended, i knew immediately that i was gonna love it and i did.
Incredibly raw and emotional coming of age! Wow didn't expect to get emotional at 3 am lol
Didn‘t connect with this one much. interesting to hear however, how their sound developped.
Wonderfully composed, with evocative lyrics and breathy vocals. I think the Suburbs still holds my favourite spot for the best Arcade Fire album, but this was good too.
That's all the arcade fire on the list done. In reverse order no less. A consistent high as on this album are the instrumentals and arrangements. This type of indie is at its best when attempting to pull on your heartstrings, ebbing and flowing within a single song. The big movements of the album get lost. My rating is not as high as it could be due to a thing that improved as the band matured: the vocals. On this album they almost sound yelled, causing the tone to drift uncannily off key. On some songs it even sounds like he's standing in the back of the room and that doesn't help. The radio hits from this band notably have the least of those issues.
music is love
Rhythmic, grandiose and atmospheric. The album starts and carries you to the end on a wave of sound and has aged very well
only regretting not having listened to it earlier
Pretty, but not my style. More like soundtrack music than an album I’d choose to listen to.
Royo rock independiente de los 2000 tiene un pase para sentirse en un videoclip
I kinda liked it, very indy sound
Solid 4.0. Creative, influences like Talking Heads, Kate Bush, pre cursor to MGMT
This is what I think is a textbook definition of indie rock. It is very cohesive album, especially that one song that transitioned into the other one sooooo beautifully. The songs in the beginning of the album sounded quite similar to one another, but once we got past the songs that are titled "Neighborhoods", the songs were more unique and interesting to listen to. However, I would not say that this album is boring. The dynamic instruments kept this album lively. I enjoyed listening to this album and I think I will listen to this again. My favorite song off the album is Wake Up, which tracks since it is one of the most popular songs of this album.
Reminds me of Ants From Up There (this must be an early inspiration). Vocalist always sounds like they're on the verge of a mental collapse- half-wailing? Reminds me of Isaac Wood (a lot). Good composition throughout the whole album- very orchestral. Interesting, provoking lyrics! I like the one review that called it the whitest album they ever heard. Songs do blur together, though, and I can't differentiate between them all that well. Great cover art though.
COME ON ALEX YOU CAN DO IT COME ON ALEX THERES NOTHING TO IT This is an easy 5, it was the soundtrack to my life at 15, I literally don’t know what to say about it, I just love it so much.
I read a lot of Douglas Coupland in the 90s and the Arcade Fire is the the best analog I can think of for the mood of Coupland's writing. Firmly Gen X. This is thoughtful and fascinating indie rock, paving the way for a new generation of bands exploring wider use of instrumentation and complex song structures ( and a bit too much stomp clap Hey!). Lots of great singalong songs too, and lots of songs that build from a quiet start into a thundering finish - Rebellion (Lies) a great example.
So they made shitty music from the start and didn't improve even an inch? Incredible. This is just a mish-mash of songs that don't go well together, the melodies are boring, and even if there is a more interesting riff or something, it just disappears, never to be heard from again. The singer just can't sing, and his voice is so grating too, and the backing vocals aren't better either. Had a dogshit of a time listening to this.
It's really apparent when listening to this album, especially when keeping in mind the 2004 release date, how influential it was on the indie scene. This is a sound that would go on to be imitated with greatly varying degrees of success for years, even up until today with bands like Black Country New Road, a band I love, taking very clear cues from this release. If that's the sort of music you're into, there's a lot to enjoy on this record, some really lovely instrumentation and arrangement, and great conceptual elements of grief and loss of innocence explored. I do think however the songwriting isn't always fantastic, there can be a lot of samey moments, and if you weren't sold on this whole sound, this record is definitely not going to be the one to sell you on it. I did, however, enjoy my time with this overall and really appreciate the influential aspects of the album, I really do feel it earns its spot on the list Fav Track: 7 - Wake Up Best Three Track Run: 7, 8, 9
7/10
This record was on repeat for me for about a month at least in 2004. I loved it so much then. It still holds up. 9/10
Still as fresh as when it came out.
The music that we are constantly playing says nothing to me and my life. pretentious!
Vocals are more annoying than anything else. Very gospely. Production is good
Not bad but just not my preferred genre.
Here, Arcade Fire goes headlong into its “Teens Against the Adults Featuring Children’s Choir” energy (a sound pioneered by Floyd’s The Wall). Several very good songs here, but few hooks to keep the listener coming back. A high 3, low 4. A 4.
I just wish I could like it 100%, but it felt too millennial. Mainly the “yeah!” Some good parts for sure
And here we get to a classic example of an album I already know intimately getting generated for me on the 1001 albums generator. I love this album dearly already, to the point in which I own it on CD and have listened to it many times both on CD and on Spotify. All this to say, it is an incredible album. From the opener all the way to the closer, this album is a beautiful, masterful suburban art piece of longing, love, loneliness, and growing up. Not a bad song on here, and not even a single song that isn’t incredible. The opening 5 songs are the perfect introduction to the album, going through flavors of art rock, PPR, and indie pop all while maintaining the indie rock center, anchored by Win Butler’s incredible, emotional lead vocals (fuck that guy but he’s a great frontman). After that is an assortment of different songs, each nothing short of breathtaking, ending on one of the most beautiful and emotional songs of the 00s, that being “In The Backseat.” This album is spectacular in every single aspect. 10/10
An all time favorite
This one is enjoyable as background music but nothing pulled me in further.
Actually I LOVED it.
quite lovely
Great listen. It was good to re listen to this album but didn’t hook me.
much better than the last arcade fire album
Visite au cimetière de la Chartreuse, y'a pas de hasard !
I liked it. Strings at the end of the album were awesome. 2010 indie vibes. Wasn't my thing at the time so was glad to come back to this one.
Transition from Haiti into Rebellion (Lies) is one of the best album transitions ever.
Brilliant record from start to finish, I absolutely love it - Arcade Fire are one of the best alternative indie artists out there, and this is one of their best efforts. Neighborhood #1 sets the tone so well and the rest of the album has no skips. An absolute classic of the indie game.
Kind of meh
A lot of layers in this music. Takes a couple listens to unlock some of those layers. The compositions are beautiful. The performances leave something to be desired in my opinion, overall a good first outing for this group.
Not for me.
Ei kolahda. Tasapaksua. Laulaminen osittain rääkymistä ja musiikilliset koukut puuttuu. Viimenen kappale pelasti vähän, oli sellainen jonka voisi lisätä jollekkin soittolistoista
Oikein menevää indierockia, mitälie. Bändi mistä kuullu enemmän ku mitä kuunnellut, varmaan hittibiisin sieltä täältä.
Got this in fairly quick succession after Neon Bible and felt this was just as good, if not better. Really enjoyed them both and actually I probably did Neon Bible a disservice with my scoring so I'll mark this one up to make up for it.
Damn another one of these? There are good moments here but it doesn’t live up to the other two on the list. Just a lot of yea they’re a good band but eh.
This is different (especially for 2004) and I'm glad the list put this in front of me. Otherwise, I probably never would have heard it because I thought this was one of those middle-emo bands like The Ataris or Newfound Glory. Not that I have an issue with that music; I just never seek it out. I'm not necessarily sold that this is a five star album, but I do think I'll give it the opportunity to grow on me some 3.75
It was alright not a big fan of the genre.
In the years since, I find this to be pretty diminished (even though I was only passingly familiar with it at the time). Stomp Clap Hey for the art crowd, skewed by sex allegations, and general monotony of the songs here. There are still a couple that make the grade.
I didn’t expect this to tickle my fancy in the way it did
Is it still my favourite album? I'm not so sure anymore.
What did I know about this album/artist before I listened? Okay, I know that they are an indie rock band, maybe from Canada? I’ve heard exactly one song from - “Keep The Car Running” - which I don’t believe is on this album (*checks* it is not). They won Album Of The Year at the Grammys in the early 2010s for the album The Suburbs. I bought cheap tickets to see them at some point in the last ten years that I ended up selling to Timmy (the guy who recommended this album!). Like, I know who they are and some of their significance, but I have not knowingly heard anything from this album. What are my first impressions? First song was okay. I like the music and the way that the sonic elements were being introduced bit by bit. It all built to a satisfying climax and an extended outro, which when done right, I am a sucker for that kind of thing. I liked the lyrics enough, I imagine this is going to be an album full of aching and loss based on the tone that has been set (the thing IS called Funeral, after all). I didn’t mind Win Butler’s vocals, but I’m interested to see if I get tired of him by the end of this album. He has a warbling, wandering quality to his voice that isn’t awful, but I don’t know that I’m going to be into it after 50 minutes. What genre(s) come to mind as I listen? Are there any specific artists that are evoked? "Une année sans lumière" had a little bit of 90s Springsteen popping in (appropriate, given I know he was a stated influence among bands like this and the Killers as the 2000s went on), and I heard a little Jimmy Eat World on this and “Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)”. Is the production appropriate for the sound/era? I mean… I don’t know that you could get more early 2000s indie here if you tried. I guess I knew that this was a larger-sized rock band and had at least one multi-instrumentalist playing some non-standard rock instruments, but it was still a surprise to hear the accordion and the strings when they came up. Listening to this helps contextualize a lot of the bands I was seeing/playing with in the mid-2000s Kalamazoo DIY scene, where this was really rampant (and perhaps even more experimental/indie?) and the vibe felt really pompous/highfalutin’. What did the lyrics evoke? What did the singer sound like? Were the lyrics more simple or clever, direct or vague? The lyrics are my favorite part of the record. The first half of the album tells a story of a town hit with a power outage in the middle of winter, and I can see where my first impression came through here. Definitely more of a set of lyrics devoted to aching than loss, necessarily. The second half of the record is just… other songs, which is fine (I don’t necessarily think a conceptual suite of songs has to encompass the entire album), but it hits different after the telling of a saga of songs. I was concerned about what to expect vocally as the album went on, but I’m finding myself warming to Butler’s voice. It’s also nice that he’s not the only vocalist here, as Régine Chassagne has a lovely voice and I wish she’d take lead on more songs. What is your favorite track/why? “Neighborhood #2 (Laika)” - The verse sounds like an indie-rock version of a punk rock call-and-response-type song, and it segues nicely into a chorus with a different vocal feel. The two seem like they should clash, but they work really well. Least favorite/why? “Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles)” - I liked the lyrics to this, but it with most of these songs pushing five minutes, this one felt too long and too drab. Not enough variety in the music and not enough momentum to really warrant the length. “Crown of Love” - Look, I’m just gonna say it, 6/8 is not my favorite time signature, so if you’re gonna write a song with that signature, it’s gotta HIT. This was a boring, meandering dirge, and the abrupt switch into an upbeat 4/4 for the last minute felt more jarring than a heightening of emotion. What sort of situation/vibe would you find yourself playing this album in? Playability factor? I suppose I could see myself putting this on if I was in an introspective mood in the middle of the night. (maybe I’d be lucky enough to fall asleep if it was late enough) Final summary? I was really interested to listen to this, and as it turns out, I had heard a few of these songs already. (I swear, I always assumed “Wake Up” was a Polyphonic Spree song!) As the album went on, though, my mind was wandering and I was less engrossed in this listen. The first half was neat in concept, if not execution, and I was hoping for a satisfying build as the album continued into the second half, but it seemed like it lost steam after that. Interestingly, that’s how I felt about a lot of these songs as a whole: these tunes kept seemingly building to something, but then couldn’t deliver in the end (most of these songs were too long anyway). I wonder if the album had been sequenced differently, if that would have made a different. Switch side A to side B, and vice versa, and maybe reorder the non-suite tracks, and then at least it would have felt like there was a cool thematic climax at the end of the record. I dunno, I’m probably not gonna seek this one out for a second listen, but I’d politely ignore it if someone else played it.
This album was okay. To me it sounded a bit too average and plain. But there were some great songs with good hooks ore riffs. This would be a great album to listen to in the background of a non-intensive activity.
First listen to this a while ago, I actually gave this a 3. Since then I have listened to this again many times and I can definitely say my opinion has changed. Really good, really cool and very enjoyable. Good to listen to when cycling home at night, really sets a vibe. I can't say it is a masterpiece by any means, I just really like it.
Going into this I thought I’d only heard a select few, but as I listened I realized all of these songs lived deep in my subconscious somewhere. Arcade Fire’s a band I’ve always explored in bits and pieces, so it was a good experience listening to all these songs in context. You can’t deny that it takes you somewhere…well, at least I can’t deny it took me somewhere. Yes, somewhere very millennial twee whimsy, BUT, more importantly, to the fictional neighborhoods of the world they created here—swirly, mauve, harrowing, and full of people trying their damnedest to save each other. That said, certain parts of this don’t hit like they should. I gotta respect it, but I doubt I’ll return to it any more often than I have before. This one will stay in my subconscious…til next time.
Pretty standard fare for its era. Finished listening moments ago and cannot recall one melody or lyric. Also didn't ever want to skip it so there is that. Perfect mediocrity. Its... beige. Really unsure how it is on this list.
This one on paper should have been a banger for me. An alternative indie album? Perfect. But it was just okay. I did like the strings in many of the songs, that is always fun to listen to. My favorite song on the album was Crown of Love but it's probably not something I'm going to add to any playlists anytime soon. 3/5.
These guys certainly go to a lot of neighborhoods. Would have hoped one of them they visited might have made them sound better. I do appreciate their uniqueness. They certainly tried something different. And I'm sure it has an audience for others. Just not me. "Rebellion" and "N2 - Laika" were fairly good.
Boring. Forgettable.
"Somethin' filled up my heart with nothing"—that's exactly how I feel after listening to "Arcaden Fire," and I'm not supposed to cry and scream about it. Another one of those totally overhyped bands and albums that really get on my nerves. I thought, "Give it a listen, I can clean at the same time." But of course, that was a stupid idea. The music, especially the singer's voice and the violin, was simply unbearable. ... After Radiohead's "Kid," this album wasn't on any of my lists. Boring and annoying at the same time, and I know none of the songs will leave a lasting impression on me. That's a shame, of course, but for that to happen, I'd have to want to listen to the stuff, and I don't. So I'd rather continue my contemplative wiping and hum to myself. Of course, nothing from "Arcaden Fire."
Instrumentals were good but I just did not dig the vocals
now, this certainly did influence a lot of the mediocre indie rock of its time, and the follow ups aren't really good, and Win Butler has allegations, but this is also way better than i remember it being to me 7 years ago in high school. i guess hearing the dull shit that followed primed me to appreciate the intricacies and emotional pull of these songs. there's something really special about the lyrics in Tunnels. music that defined millennials, for better and for worse. deserves to be one of the 1001? even if i hated it, it certainly does
Eh, it was fine but not really for me. The songs blended into one another. Wake Up and Rebellion were my faves among them.
I loved this album … wish we had half stars and would go 4.5
2/13/26 - Listened during work. I have heard this album a few times before and never really understood the hype. I may have liked it more today than previous listened but I still can't give it more than a 3. I just find some of it annoying, and I used to really like this kind of music. Oh well. Top song - Wide Awake (I do love this song)
I had already outgrown Arcade Fire a bit before the allegations came out, and now it is hard to listen to them. I also think that The Suburbs is better.
I'm a Canadian born in the 90s, of COURSE I love Funeral by Arcade Fire
Meh
Auch ein tolles Album. Werde jetzt nochmal den direkten Vergleich mit "Neon Bible" ziehen, um zu entscheiden, welches der Alben mein Favorit ist.
Nice and relaxing but i wasn't in the mood for that today
Other than the one song everyone recognizes, the rest was forgettable.
idk it kinda moved me
would listen to this for a gurl
I think I finally hear what my mom heard when I listened to indie (3.7 but rounded down)
Easy driving listening that gets more interesting toward the end of the album. Alt rock and orchestral at times
Sounds like what u listen to when ur having a identity crisis
Uplifting soulful and joyful
⭐️⭐️⭐️ Cet album me fait penser à l’ambiance de Life Is Strange, certaines musiques sont très sympa. J’aime l’atmosphère.
Borderline perfect. Shame about him, eh?
I liiiike but I do not looove
This was a life-changing album for me. I listened to it blindly, the week it came out, at a local store that let you hear new CDs before purchasing. It's hard, now, to reflect back on how revolutionary this sound was at the time. I remember being blown away and buying it that same day, then racing home to listen to it in full. It not only changed the way I approached listening to music, but the way I made music. Unfortunately, it now sounds a bit dated, and they found a way to improve on their own sound, especially on The Suburbs and Reflektor. So, while I fully expected to give this a 5, after re-listening to it in its entirety for the first time in years, I'll stick with a 4. Huge album for me, though.
One of my favourite albums since I was about 15 yo, and imo one of the strongest debut albums anyone has ever released. Perhaps I'd not feel as strongly if I heard it today for the first time, and maybe I'd think it's all a bit millennial cringe (like yesterday's), but then I'd be a different person with different taste. An absolute landmark of indie, even if Win Butler is trying everything in his power to diminish it I feel like nearly every song has the band pouring nearly everything they've got into it, with so much energy and catharsis throughout. I'd never really heard anything like "Wake Up" before, and it was probably the major catalyst that sent me down the indie rabbithole that I'll never get out of (along with In The Aeroplane), but needless to say I love most of the others. Kettles is eh, but it works as part of a transition between the high energy of "Power Out" and "Wake Up"
really good, prefer this to neon bible from the first listen. i feel like im not normally one to notice when the "mixing is off" but i think the mixing on this isnt great? the vocals feel way to quiet on some songs? Probably not going to happen due to the controversies around the band but a remaster of this would be pretty epic Enjoyed how this flows as an album as well, it wasn’t every track but the transitions between a lot of tracks worked very well 4
3.6 2x i like it
This is at least the 10th mid-aughts indie/alt rock album I've listened to on this list. I find most of it dreadfully boring. Meh
Sleeping is giving in
FAMOUS LOOKING ALBUM COVER!! POTENTIAL WHTE BOI CLASSIC™. You there sir step right up, you bet your sweet bippy that this thing has everything the the unmelanated melancholic could desire. It really is our time to shine. Our time in the sun. Although if you get me slathered in sunscreen under the tyranny of a summer's day with a UV index north of 5, I'll be shining alright, and about three minutes away from a nasty rash and bout of heat stroke. Thousands of years of heritage from the north of Scotland to produce a guy who says mean and often unfunny things about music on the internet. Battling the English and breathing your last on the bloodstained hills of your homeland, knowing one day that your progeny will be a chubby asthmatic chortling to himself making snide remarks about art, had to make that death sting a little worse. I am deeply sorry that I am both using the English language to make this apology, AND such a disappointment. Speaking of disappointment! Too much stomping, too much clapping. We had moments here, but too much happiness overall. Sorry everybody. Maybe this is for a different brand of white bread. I am the discount Old Mill variety. I have the nutritional value of a pinecone and I am NOT for sale. 2.5 HIGHLIGHTS: Allegations incoming
Power Out and Wake Up are some of the best song in a live setting I've ever heard. I mean, seriously: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6nze9-4ywpk Argument could be made there's enough filler that it should be four stars, but the high points are so high it's gotta be a 5.
4 out of 5. Crown of Love is a beautiful song.
It’s OK
Good indie album. Wake Up makes me think of Secret Life of Walter Mitty. Great scene.
not bad. my first real jump into the indie rock area. 6/10
a bit too whiny for me personally. The last one I enjoyed though!
Prachtig uniek album
I really liked the story telling of this album
You aren’t true indy snob if you don’t insist this is Arcade fires best album. Bonus points if you claim it’s their only good one. I don’t subscribe to either but it’s still a 5.
This was amazing. First time I listened and I’m glad I did.
Quite a fun relisten. Not a great deal to say but it's a very solid album.
good 4 stars for me
Nope
Music of this era can be so indistinctive. Just sounds like so many other bands. I don't like the strained voice vocals but otherwise having it on in the background was inoffensive enough
Arcade Fire is one of those bands that’s been recommended to me endlessly, and for whatever reason, I’d never really given them a proper shot. I can see why people would assume I'd like this, but honestly, it didn’t do much for me. I didn’t dislike it by any means, and there’s nothing here I can really fault: solid songwriting, strong vocals, and genuinely interesting lyrics. It just screams early-2000s indie pop-rock, though, with some tracks feeling like a softer, more melodic progression of Pixies, adding things like strings and brass. Overall, it's a sound I see the appeal of, but one I simply don’t care for all that much.
My first and second times listening to this album were entirely different experiences. On my second listen, I enjoyed and appreciated this album WAY more than the first time. I will likely keep this album in rotation.
nostalgic being 4 years old
This album was ok, I could listen and enjoy if it were playing but I don’t think I would choose to listen to it
8/10 Favourite: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) Least Favourite: Une année sans lumière
Good album not too long.
94/100
Los Arcade Fire son el grupo de su generación. La escena de canadá tuvo a principios de siglo una fuerza imparable con The New Pornographers, Broken Social Scene o Godspeedyou Black Emperor! Pero sin duda, por influencia, carrera y éxito son Arcade Fire el mascarón de proa. Su trilogía desde Funeral a The Suburbs es sencillamente inigualable. Luego Reflektor tuvo su brillo, pero perdieron el paso. Win Butler y Régine Chassagne están soberbios, como también Owen Pallett. ¿Mis favoritas? Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels), Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles), In the Backseat, Wake Up, y obviamente Rebellion (Lies).
Альбом открывает песня с нарастающей мотивом, что, как по мне, является идеальным началом для альбома. На фоне инструментала вокал кажется небрежным и грязным, что так же играет в лучшую сторону для альбома. Вцелом создаётся атмосфера, что данную музыку играют "одарённые бездари", так как вся грязь играет только в лучшую сторону альбома. Такие песни как wake up звучат, как гимн альбома.
Meh. Arcade Fire isn't my thing, I guess.
I remember my friends loving this album and playing the hell out of it, but this just whooshed way over my head even back then. Indie rock is such a mixed bag, you get a couple iconic singles but a ton of warbly ghostly sounding funeral music from a mid 2000's indie film.
I dunno man. This one had the singles I knew but I just don’t think I’m a fan of Arcade Fires brand of indie music
this was a great album i love listening to music from early 2000's and having a different listen of music from recent times. Its great 8/10
First one I've done on this. Good album Pretty cool with some interesting new stuff Didn't take in much of the lyrics Would listen again
A little bit underwhelmed by this one. It's a solid enough record with some interesting, almost classical influences, but it sure isn't one of the all time great indie rock records I was promised
Definitely an album I never would've seeked out but I might have to look into more Arcade Fire, I SO enjoyed this!! Made me feel very nostalgic for some reason? I would say it was a solid no skip album, I enjoyed all of the songs
2/2/26. It's hard for me to be objective about this album because it's an old favorite, and definitely informed my music taste early on. Love the instrumentation, storytelling, and how the entire album feels like a movie. Always nice when I get to replay it.
4.5/5. Great vocal performances and incredible atmosphere. Very shocking album.
pretty cohesive album! it evokes a certain emotion i'm not sure what to call. i wish i could appreciate it more but i cannot get over the voice. don't know what it is. it had some good songs but none made a huge impression on me, i think. a lot of songs were kind of repetitive. i think it was lacking that sort of punch that i like in my music. nothing wrong with that! i just think it would be better appreciated in the ears of another listener.
not for me
It reminds me of Franz Ferdinand, what isn`t a good thing, because i dont like it. It sound emotionless and boring.
id give it 3 stars not very good as miles davis and beatles best albums its a bit overated the end song is fantastic idk bro it sounds like fantanobait were he would give a "ten on this record"
Pouquíssimas bandas conseguem alavancar todo o Zeitgeist de um subgênero em sua estréia. Arcade Fire é uma delas. Esse álbum exuda Indie Rock da década de 2000. É a síntese perfeita desse momento no tempo e no mundo, físico e emocional. Pessoas mais céticas verão isso e simplesmente irão descartar este álbum por considerá-lo clichê ou genérico, mas o impacto deste disco em mim é profundo e real. Essas faixas me emocionam e me trazem de volta a momentos que minha memória já havia apagado. A formatação do disco é brilhante. A suíte “Neighborhood” em sua primeira metade é encapsulante e aconchegante. Uma temática agridoce e emotiva, com uma sonoridade melodramática e fantasiosa. Novamente, pessoas mais céticas ouvirão este som e só imaginarão um hipster barbudo tomando uma IPA gelada e falando sobre boletos, mas há em minha perspectiva algo mais atemporal nessas canções. Uma espécie de saudade de um lugar que nunca existiu. Um vão de memória e espírito jamais preenchível. Igual a namorada ideal que você nunca conheceu e nunca conhecerá. Igual aquele amor adolescente que nunca funcionou e nunca funcionaria. Igual aquela casa daquela avó naquele Julho de férias escolares. Igual aquele sonho que ainda existe e que te perturba tanto quanto te encanta. Me agrada tremendamente o estilo de produção do álbum. Produção analógica que complementa muito bem as ordenações mais melosas das canções. Um grande deleite ouvir este álbum e as canções derretendo umas nas outras, o álbum inteiro é um grande e contínuo Highlight, mas menção honrosa a In The Backseat, possivelmente um dos melhores closers de qualquer álbum já gravado. É de tirar o fôlego. Ouça esse álbum e depois o ouça novamente logo em seguida, nem que você tenha que o ouvir escondido, como uma forma de prazer secreto, temendo ser taxado como fanboy ávido da Pitchfork, ou alguma espécie de weeaboo fissurado na cultura franco-canadense, esquisito seria. Indie Rock é um gênero difícil de catalogar exatamente, e suas raízes são extensas e entrelaçadas, derivando de incontáveis lugares e grupos diferentes. É algo que parece servir perfeitamente na palheta de quem possui gostos mais ecléticos. Baladas-Power-Punk-Medievais. Isso não existe e essas palavras não encaixam juntas, mas foram a síntese que meu cérebro manifestou ouvindo o disco. Então que seja. Ritmos pulsantes, dancem Iggy Pops. New Order lançou seu primeiro disco em 1769 e ele se chama Funeral. Pode ser? Nostalgia futurista e etc. Tudo muito doce. Eu amo esse disco. 5/5
How can you not love a classic
Couldn't even remember what this sounded like by the end of the day.
Best driving album ever?
already heard this several times, love the first few albums from this group a lot Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) - 5/5 Neighborhood #2 (Laïka) - 5/5 Une année sans lumière - 4/5 Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) - 5/5 Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles) - 4/5 Crown of Love - 5/5 Wake Up - 5/5 Haïti - 4/5 Rebellion (Lies) - 5/5 In the Backseat - 5/5 Average score: 4.7/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Pitchfork is basically dead, and the sheen on this once-great band has been dulled by poor taste and bad behavior. Funeral is like a glowing ember, reminding us what started it all: a magnificent rock record. Not a perfect one. There’s some easy sloganeering and one or two skips. But way better than it had any right to be—a small tribe of earnest young hipsters recording blog rock’s “Teen Spirit” in a loft somewhere for pennies. “Rebellion” and “In the Backseat” are also stunning; AF made great music after this, but nothing they did beats those tracks for me.
No skips every song is perfect
I’ll get crucified for this, but Arcade Fire just isn’t for me. I’ve listened to this album multiple times over the past decade plus, and it’s never really emotionally clicked. I appreciate the arrangements and songwriting and thematic elements, but vibe-wise… it’s weird that I can’t put into good words how not into this I am. I won’t give up on it, and maybe someday it will hit. But not today.
1, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10
woah that was actually incredible
I don't know if the album was named Funeral in an attempt at irony or in ignorance, but this is the funeral soundtrack to "indie rock." These bands outsmarted themselves into irrelevance. And for the love of all that is good an holy - enough with the 2* albums!
Arcade Fire has released albums which I consider to be close to on par with Funeral, but in a way, it seems like they are always working to top Funeral. Sometimes it works (The Suburbs) and sometimes it does not (their newest album, which is not good). Arcade Fire's attitude is "Shoot for the stars, even if you fail, then you will crash back down to Earth and be accused of sexual misconduct." Sometimes you eat the operatic chamber pop and sometimes the operatic chamber pop eats you. I think I prefer Neon Bible slightly more than Funeral, but a lot of that opinion depends on the day you ask me as well. I think Neon Bible has better individual songs but perhaps Funeral is the better album. This is a great debut and I think it's well worth a listen. It is a concept album of sorts but fortunately they do not go full "Tommy" and insist on the concept overwhelming the songs at times. My favorite songs are: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) Neighborhood #2 (Laika) Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) Crown of Love Wake Up Rebellion (Lies)
есть общая предвзятость против них, то ли из-за одинаковости, то ли из-за намеренной небрежности, но в целом они интересные, удивлена что песня которую лучше всего знаю оказывается с первого альбома
The early 2000s. A little more my speed, but not a mind scrambler. Good tunes including the “hit” Rebellion (Lies). I’d listen again
I have listened to a bit of Arcade Fire in the past, but never this album. Man, was I missing out! It’s the first time in a long while I’ve liked EVERY song on an album. Legit listened to this three times today, it is so so so good.
Like Neon Bible, there are high highs, but I don't think it’s the masterpiece some make it out to be. That would be The Suburbs.
Fun album. A lot of it a really liked, the rest of it I merely liked.
I understand why this album is on this list. I was not excited to listen to it, but couldn’t turn it off. I was, however, happy when it was over. I kept trying to find a phrase to describe it besides “unnecessarily dramatic”, but that just stuck in my head.
1/27 Meh
I know it's a well-respected and highly influential album in terms of its themes and overall production... but it's not really my cup of tea. Faves: Crowd of Love, Wake Up
I have listened to this many times over the years but right now I can't separate art from artist.
fajne intro i nutka wake up, troche taki radiohead, tylko troche szybszy. Generalnie calkiem w porzadku intro bdb!
eh not really my thing…the instrumental was cool at times though
Best Track - "Rebellion (Lies)"
The string instrumentals were beautiful and felt quite theatrical at times. I feel like its consistently building up to something, however it never ends up as powerful as you feel like its going to get. i loved the singers voice and thought it blended so well with the guitar. His voice has a very raw and intimate sound to it. The songs arent very aggressive but they get you going. Fav song was rebellion (lies)!! Perfect length for an album. 7/10
Almost a four star for the moment we were in listening to the album - it just fit so well. Not quite though. A little slow to be going on the regular rotation. I did enjoy it though and will be exploring more of Arcade Fire’s music.
p902. 2004. 2 stars. Distinctly average Stateside indie rock from the critic darlings, with no redeeming features.
I have never understood the hype behind Arcade Fire, but to be fair, never took a deep dive either. Maybe I'll be pleasantly surprised. T1- I could listen to this. T2- This makes perfect sense for 2004. Maybe I only heard them once they blew up in the early 2010s. T3- I really enjoy this song. Sonic shift from the first two tracks. So far this album feels like a mix of Flaming Lips & Modest Mouse/Cold War Kids. I've lost track of individual songs at this point. T7- Oh, this is the record with "Wake Up" on it. I think I like this song a lot. News to me. I expected to hate this album and was pleasantly surprised.
its like fine slightly above average Id say but not like amazing but it did grow on me the second listen through solid 7/10
I really like this album. It's a shame the lead singer sucks so much.
Transcendent, magical blending of voices and instruments and noises and melodies and feeling. Well done!
Lived up to all the hype when it was released. Excellent.
In spite of everything, I still like this. I like the twists and turns the music takes, especially in tracks like Rebellion (Lies), Crown of Love and Wake Up - the latter being my favourite thing by them by some distance. The album has a big sound, the strings giving them an almost theatrical feel at times. This is the only record by them I’m really familiar with - it really embodies that early ’00’s American-Canadian indie sound when films like Garden State, and bands like The Shins and Broken Social Scene seemed to represent a new, fresh alternative. Life was especially enjoyable for me around that time and records like this were the soundtrack - listening now reminds me of many good times that even sex pest allegations can’t shake. (Win Butler’s, not mine…)
A good indie album. With it's own distinct feel and sound. I enjoyed it when it was released and enjoyed listening again now, though I haven't listened to it a lot in between. Several times when listening this time around it brought to mind David Byrne, which certainly isn't a bad thing, not sure why but there we go... It's another one which I can't quite see why it is on this list. Decent enough but not amazing.
a fun indie album type vibe; 7/10
10/10 – Masterpiece
Liked it, but it was very much background music. Didn't make us feel anything. Kind of like Black Country New Road but a bit worse.
Amazing. So lucky to see them tour this and the great albums that followed.
Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels): 6/10 Neighborhood #2 (Laika): 7/10 MBPW Une Annee Sans Lumiere: 5.7/10 Neighborhood #3 (Power Out): 5.6/10 MBPW Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles): 5.2/10 Crown Of Love: 5.1/10 Wake Up: 5/10 (2min left is peak) Haiti: 4.8/10 Rebellion (Lies): 4/10 In the Backseat: 4/10
I forgot about the album as soon as the first song started.
4.4
Enjoyed but not as mind blowing as the press wants you to think. I enjoy The Suburbs album.
already know this album but i haven't listened to the whole thing. got that early 2000s sound and style (duh). perfect for my radio-friendly indie playlist lol. i love arcade fire but i think i prefer their latter albums (they were more experimental). only 2-3 tracks stood out to me in funeral. maybe i just got tired of this specific indie rock sound... i blame the millennials. BUT it made me feel nostalgic.
Should certainly be on here. I certainly briefly loved it. However, I haven't been able to stand this band for years. Shit people to boot.
❤️
Dank
I thought it was just ok. It is decent music, the kind of music that is the soundtrack to an average rom com movie.
ne spomnim se kera ampak ena pesem vmes mi je zeloooo vsec. mislm da crown of love, supr je pa cel album tud
Gostei não. Não faz meu estilo
5 stars This band has become somewhat of a stand in for 2000s hipster cringe, so when I find myself giving it 5 stars there’s a hesitancy I experience. But when I listen, I’m transported to a time 20+ years ago when Arcade Fire weren’t a known band by the masses (pre Who the Hell are the Suburbs?). I remember seeing AF perform “Laika” on Conan the winter of 2005. I was a freshman in high school and I was enraptured. Wild pack of weirdos wearing football helmets that they banged on, wailing like it was the most important song on earth, with an accordion!? It was amazing. The sweet ending of Regine singing “the police disco lights” capped it off. I needed to know this band. I immediately illegally downloaded the album (the only way I consumed music at the time) and burned a CD with the name of the band and album title scribbled on. It became a staple of my CD wallet is carry around and listen to on my discman. The album is consistent. They are singing like it’s the most important album ever, and they were a scrappy bunch of weirdos who had no reason to think they were important other than their passion for what they were doing. The emotion works. Banger after banger. Every song hits. The one thing is knock it is something I remember writing in my epinions.com review of it at the time (which was probably titled something like “A Funeral Worth Attending”): many of the songs end with a shift into dancey (Tunnels, Crown of Love, Wake Up) that I’ve grown to love but also maybe is a bit predictable? I don’t know. My bias is 100% a factor in how I view this album, but I can’t experience it as anything but a 5/5.
It was awful, boring, and so mediocre that I simply couldn't understand what this album was doing on this list.
I like the energy on this album. Really gets you pumped at times. Favorite track: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)
Immature
Beautiful sounds that kept me interested from beginning to end. Fun fact: Rebellion is the opening theme of the popular Italian political talk show “Otto e mezzo.”
Somewhere between nostalgic slideshow and early FIFA soundtrack... okay
The first time i listened to this it was a slog to get through to be honest, however this time it did hit differently. I owe this to me being in a very different mindset then i was in when i first listened, it spoke to me a bit more, even got me a little emotional. I don’t thin this is one i’ll revisit in it’s entirety again but theres definitely one or two songs that did something for me.
Melachonic, easy listen, variated Great production
Didn’t know this album, but will repeat listen.
скучно, но приятно уху
I enjoyed a few songs
Always a fun listen.
Artsy
Good, but seems less magical each year 3.5
Really good indie rock. Has aged well. Not boring. Great soundscapes.
Almost makes me forgive the lead singer for being a creep
Nästan bättre än jag minns!
Seemingly a caricature of indie pop
Ok
Fraudulent
Early 20s flashbacks. Love this album but back then it was overplayed…. It brought back good memories
Iconic. Recognised more than I expected. Needs a second listen. First one of these, definitely need to listen closer from now on
Entertaining, but some songs were a little bit redundant in the album, but maybe i have this idea because i was reading while listening the album, it may be an attention issue
Not a big fan of Funeral. The first track was amazing and was really looking forward to listening to the rest of the album. However, after that the quality started dipping. For some reason just didn't really connect with any other tracks and was happy when I finished listening.
honestly, i liked it a lot. had a great time, now exploring their other albums, also really good.
pretty cool
Favorite song off the album: Man on the moon Number of songs I liked/added to a playlist: 4 Not one I’m likely to repeat but generally pleasing, it was pretty good and not quite but almost rock.
I don't love or hate this album, It has some good songs in it and the style is fine. However I don't like the vocals and the lyrics. This really reminds me of those cringe millenial music, because that is exactly what this is. This isn't that bad for there are way worse albums, but this album is not good either.
Previously added to favourite songs: Tunnels, Power Out, Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies). Didn't feel the need to add any others, but still really like everything else. An album that feels intimate and epic at the same time. Probably a 9/10, but I will round up.
I was 15 when this came out so this became a foundational text for me. I probably like it a little less today but when Tunnels starts up I can’t help getting the feels.
Yes
bellissimo album, veramente alcuni pezzi spettacolari. tra le preferite: crown of love, wake up e in the backseat. io dopo ho ascoltato anche l’altro album the suburbs: bello!! sentitelo se potessi forse metterei 4,5 non proprio 5 ma comunque stiamo là
Ho sempre pensato fosse un band leggermente meno mainstream da nominare solo per fare gli alternativi e invece è proprio un bell’album. Pezzi preferiti Wake Up e in the backseat. Menzione speciale per neighborhood 3. Darei 4,5 ma non si può
6* Niet helemaal mijn ding, vond het niet bijzonder.
Absolute banger of an album
Funeral do quê? As duas primeiras músicas revelam a dimensão da grandiosidade do álbum. Há uma sensação de sufocamento e opressão, mas, ao mesmo tempo, é necessário estar munido de sensibilidade para adentrar a atmosfera da obra. Crown of Love consegue estabelecer, com precisão, uma ponte de sentimentos por meio do contrastre melódico: ao mesmo tempo que relata situações de pessr, suas melodias épicas provocam tensão em quem ouve. Com isso, torna-se a minha faixa favorita do álbum. Há uma opinião que me interessou: o álbum expressa uma espécie de “catarse” ao transpor o desabafo da dor como uma forma de superá-la. Em resumo: é coisa de outro mundo.
Com 14 anos eu sentia por esse álbum o mesmo que eu sinto hoje, agora com o dobro da idade Com “Funeral”, Arcade Fire faz uma cerimônia em homenagem a quem fomos antes de morrer com as dores do amadurecimento e celebra a vida que ainda merece ser vivida, mesmo que continuemos a morrer repetidamente na vida adulta Faixas favoritas: Neighborhood #2 (Laika), Neighborhood #3 (Power Out), Crown of Love, Wake Up, In the Backseat Menos favoritas: Haiti
It didn't click for me and came across as dull, probably need a few more listens
Never heard this record but I understand why it was an essential hipster album for so long, feels super expressive and like the band is following instincts to make a better record. It is unfortunately kinda a poor man's Broken Social Scene tho
3/10
It's just OK, don't believe the hype
Not my favourite arcade fire, much prefer the suburbs
felt like game ost, nice
An album that had a huge impact at the time. Not really for me as I found it somewhat overblown, overbearing and sloganeering.
This is very Canadian. I don't know how to explain it but it's just very Canada in its vibes and sound and content. Of course there's a franglish song. It's interesting I like it but it's also just meh. I'm only halfway through however. Yeah I like it but it's kinda unremarkable. Also they're using American spelling which is crazy. Favourite: Haiti Least favourite: Neighborhood #4
I recognize it's great, I'm not a fan nonetheless
4/7
3,5/5
I really like this. It so nearly scrapes a 5 but something holds me back. Reflektor should totally be on this list, so underrated. 4.5
I personally didn’t like the sound of the album the first song on the album was my favoritebut I will check out the artist again
4.5 first listen was a transcendental experience. Will definitely be putting on more Arcade Fire. Fav songs: Neighborhood #1, Neighborhood #4, Wake Up
Never listened to Arcade Fire before and this album was a huge surprise. Wonderful and will most likely buy a copy on vinyl.
I'm not a big fan of theirs but i do like this record.
You know, there's some good songs in there. But that's it
This one was weird and didn't like any of the songs.
This debut is when AF first caught my attention. It's still their best.
Great album, top to bottom.
I liked this. Used to listen to them all the time, but they kinda faded away, don't know what they have been doing. I see they have more albums than when I listened ... I may have to check 'em out. Come on marketing people .... market!
Fave track: crown of love Least favorite track: uhh… neighborhood #3 I guess? All the Neighborhood songs are great. #2 with those strings are you kidding meeee. Neighborhood #4 is beautiful I LOVE FINGERPICKING!!!! The speed up at the end of Une année sans lumière is perfect. Crown of Love ARE YOU KIDDING ME this shit is beautiful. AND THE SWITCHUP AT THE END. im obsessed. wake up is a banger. Levitating while listening to In the Backseat - specifically love the subtle bass drum. OK Arcade Fire i didn't know you balled like that (jk i did hear through the grapevine that you balled like that i just never took it upon myself to truly listen to u but im glad i am now). This album is so unique and beautiful, i didn't expect to like it as much as i did.
I enjoyed this. Very 2000's indie vibes, like Mumford and Sons. Another album that grew on me as I listened.
Loved
Buen album.
Great album that I have heard many times. I really like the easy vibe it has, not too aggressive but still gets you going. The vocals have a nice variety and the music too. This type of album is right up my alley and I'm sure I will continue to listen to this many more times.
Production is absolutely beautiful and is what caught my ear the most. Lyrics are very poetic and make me think a lot of what they could mean, which was a bit difficult to catch. Vocals have that indie sound that not a lot of people like or think it is the best but I did not think they were the main focus of the songs. My favorite song was Crown of Love, honorable mention is Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles).
Pretty good album for background, listened to it three times. No song fully caught my attention but good vibes. Indie ish?
The 2nd half of this album sums up the Oughts hipster moment more than maybe anything else. Give me Wake Up and Lies anyday with some skinny jeans, a PBR and a mustache. The album as a whole is a bit weaker than i remember.
Standouts Wake Up
this is the beginning for this band. feels energetic amd immediate, was a trendsetter release. it has aged well, even if win butler has not. good album.
A very nostalgic album for me. I first listened to it in 2014. I was surprised to realize that it’s been two decades since it came out. You can really hear the indie blueprint in it; I ended up adding 7 out of the 10 tracks to my liked songs.
I loved this - right up my alley. Overall Rating: 8.7/10
It's...fine, I guess? Nice production, good arrangements, solid performances, but it all kinda sounds the same to me, and doesn't particularly grab me. Favorite track: "Rebellion (Lies)"
Ok well, its a good album. Listened to it many times. I prefer neon bible or whatever it was after this but rebellion and wake up still go extra hard. We can forget about their more recent stuff since butler turned out to be... himself
Not a fan of this. This is a 2 star for me. It's too... I do not know. Not for me.
Woah I loved it my fave were In the backseat Neighbourhood #2 The guitar and the instrumentals were amazing, I love the singer's voice even though I don't know much about them, I'll definitely listen to more Arcade fire
Indie de verdade. Achei no som um pouco de interferência dos graves em cima dos médios, mas pode ser problema dos meus fones.
This is much more in line with what I typically listen to, but I haven’t gotten to this album yet so I’m thriller to be listening
It was okay, nothing crazy. I like their other albums better, but this was their beginnings so I can appreciate it.
Great lyrics, great emotion, great sound. Nuff said
Coming of age riding away from new experiences
bop
It was different I knew 1 song
Great album, loved the strings and the swelling, dramatic crescendos. Crown of Love and Wake Up are the highlights for me. I listen to Wake Up during takeoff of every flight I take. (Thanks Walter Mitty)
i think i went into this wanting to give it a 5 as i know im supposed to grant god like status to Funeral by Arcade Fire buuuut i’ve always been a The Suburbs girlie and a lot of this album fades into the background for me. with the exception of course of Wake Up, which is one of the best songs ever made
I’ve always loved this album. It makes me feel extremely nostalgic. AF knows how to transport you with their instrumentation
Stunning album. Haven’t listened in a while - and it was even better going back in again. Every song outstanding.
nice album. a bit of a change for them
It sounded like an early 2000s album, and it sounded like it would be in a movie soundtrack. Couldn't hear what they were saying and the song names were pretentious.
didn’t think id like it but currently listening to “in the backseat” and the girl’s voice surprised me!
This was nothing. It could have been any other indie alt band from the early 2000s till about 2015. I could name off 10 bands and they all sound like this. Group love, alt j, Mumford and sons, the lumineers, ect ect ect. And I like some of that stuff but its not new or unique. And what do I get out of liking the correct band that sounds like every other band? Validation on the shitty internet? When an album plays on streaming it just plays the next song like the final track. I thought it ended twice and then when it did I couldnt even tell cause the new band it threw at me for engagement sounded exactly the same. Man im raging hard on this one but I really feel this way. Its so samey and mostly bad to be honest. At best its fine. Id never put this type of crap on willingly. But if I hear that holes in my sweater song in target I bob my head a bit. The only track I knew was wake up and ive always hated that song. Ok so to preface ive never seen this movie but it sounds like a montage in nick and Noras infinite Playlist where they get back together after a fight or something. Its so sacchrin and gross. Screw this album and all it is. It sucks so bad. I was gonna give it a 2 but writing all this riled my up and you get a shithole 1 you bitch
En bauta innen indie rock. Dette må være tidenes vinteralbum. Alle sangene utstråler en episk og atmosfærisk kvalitet. Tunnels maler eksempelvis helt tydelige bilder av tett snøvær på en vinterkveld. Noen mindre interessante spor er det (f.eks. Neighborhood #4 (Kettles) og Une Annee Sans Lumiere), men alt i alt er dette et fantastisk prosjekt. Top 3: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels), Neighborhood #2 (Laika), Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)
I liked this album. Sound was good, songs were varied and interesting. If there was a fault for me it was wins voice. Just feels like a stronger voice would level it up.
not really my thing
For Claudia 🫡
A classic emo grunge rock album. Personally, not a fan of the vocals, they tend to rely heavily on whining and screaming. There was some interesting instrumentation.
I just began listening to this and I like it already
2.5 no meu coração
Crown of love é bastante corny. Não achei ruim mas não me pegou também. Wake up é melhor, mas nada demais imo. Acho que o que me incomoda são os "backing vocals". O álbum é agradável de ouvir, só que não me tocou mais que isso. É meu primeiro contato com a banda, nunca tinha escutado nada deles. Não particularmente me suscitou curiosidade pra ouvir o resto, mas não desgostei de ter ouvido também. Pra um debut, é maneiro. it's fine. Duvido que vá escutar de novo.
This was a very lovely and relaxing listen. Wouldnt mind hearing again!
Can recognize that this is well-written and well-produced, just simply not my cup of tea :/ wish I liked it more!
Fokking geggjað
This album already sounds like the music I currently love. I can definitely see myself turning on this album when studying, going on a walk, or on a long car ride. I’m stuck between a 4 and a 5 because while the album is not absolute perfection, I love the vibe it gives off. I definitely need to listen to this album again to truly appreciate the songs on it.
a middle school classic
I love arcade fire especially since they wrote the soundtrack for the movie Her (2013)
I have never really liked the Arcade Fire sound and "approach" to music, and I don't understand why they got as big as they did, though I think a lot of it has to do with the same reasons I find them usually bland, where other people hear a consistent sound that seems to have resonated with a generation after me. In any case, this album is closer to other indie rock from the time, as this was their first album, and they were still forming what they wanted to become. I just personally think they ended up expanding on the parts of this album I don't care as much for, in the later albums. I don't really ever revisit it, but I do find value in it, and I have some sentimental value attributed to it from my past life. In the end, I think they did introduce something new to the modern music scene. I just wish, after this album, they would have done more than just create the same blanket of sound that doesn't click with me.
Kinda mid for the hype it got.
Great album
Quite a pleasant listening experience
Too much noise, too little order. Maybe I’ve already passed the time of listening to this kind of sound, or maybe I haven’t reached it yet to truly understand it. At least it didn’t work for me.
Solid album with good mix of pop rock
Favorite Songs - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels), Une Annee Sans Lumiere, Crown Of Love, Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies), In The Backseat
Some cool music and some which to me feels kind of meh. This is my third Arcade Fire album, and I'm not certain that they all warrant a spot on this list.
I've already reviewed Neon Bible (3 stars) and The Suburbs (4 stars), and I have 7 of the 10 tracks from Funeral already on an existing playlist or two or three... haven't I paid my 2000s indie-pop dues yet? This review should be about an experience we all might have one day: exhaustion with a sound that once wore the crown. When I saw who I'd be reviewing today, I sighed — and it wasn't out of relief, and it wasn't out of joy. I was deflated and let down by Funeral showing up today. Mind you, it's not because this album is bad at all. While I don't think it's the perfect Arcade Fire record or the ultimate expression of what the band has to offer, it is a solid debut and sounded pretty good in 2004, even if I only heard bits and pieces back then. Maybe this should be part of the review, too: at the time, I was into the harder stuff, so I didn't form a bond with this record when it arrived. Just a weak attachment later in life after coming around to The Suburbs. So here we are with Funeral over 20 years later. It's fine but outside of Rebellion (Lies), it's ultimately kind of lifeless now.
Tracks have similar tempo and vibe. Stand outs were Wake Up and Tunnels. Overall, I liked it, but I'm not sure how much I would listen to it.
Didn't like much
Verging too much into stomp clap for me to get past
Crown of Love and then Wake Up, wow. Shame the singer’s a perv.
universally recognised as perfect: #7 #9 favourites: #1 #4 meh: #3 unsure: #6 the transition from haiti into rebellion is lovely would def be classified as stomp clap music now but the album is so instrumentally layered and complex(?), it would be crazy to do so
It’s been some years since I listened to this whole album. Forgot how good it is. Solid 4.0
There’s several studies about how nostalgia is what you watched/listened to/read in your most formative years and how those are always comforting (I guess as long as your formative years are comforting). Anyway this came out when I was a senior in high school.
Hørt i stua hos mamma 2. juledag
'Then we tried to name our babies / But we forget all the names that / The names we used to know.' Miraculously, and this is the band's saving grace, Arcade Fire isn't soft. In fact, they're hard, but not b/c they have a generic relationship to grunge or metal: they're indie-folk, or whatever, thru & thru. They're hard b/c they're loud and have soul - even at lower volumes, these tracks have a fighting spirit, punching their way for a place in the cosmos. Win Butler not only sings as if he's got something to say, but as if these are the last moments of his life to cry his heart(s) out. 'W/ my lightning bolts a glowing / I can see where I am going.' This is wake-up music - not a slap in the face or a warning sign, but an ecstatic, realistic parade of funereal fire.
Solid album.
This is an album I probably would've not listened to, at least at this time of my life, if it wasn't given to me. Its a good, non-offensive album, nothing to write home about but still a good listen and creates a nice atmosphere. I really like the album cover and I think it does a good job of conveying the sound of the album. Overall I did enjoy this album and I will definitely revisit the songs.
Absolute masterpiece, this album had great instrumentals with using guitar, piano, violins, and yes… kettle pots. This album discovers fears and anxieties of loss, through everything. This album resonates deep within me emotionally and confounds me in a way I’ve never felt before.
Wonderful debut. Ten fantastic songs.