Reviews (page 6 of 15)
Listened to it before. It's comforting, cozy and feels very nostalgic to me. Like a warm summer evening, a cigarette, rusty guitar strings and running in flowery fields.
One of the early-aughts bands I wrote off at the time because they weren’t punk. Though I am actively trying to expand my horizons, I feel mildly justified in my initial prognosis. I’m certain I’ve heard some songs by them before, but I wouldn’t have been able to tell you if it was Arcade Fire or The Arctic Monkeys, or Kings of Leon or any other number of bands I conflated in my own head. I don’t even know if any of those bands sound like the others. All that said, there were some moments in this album I truly enjoyed. The last minute of Crown of Love. Then”oh THAT song, moment I recognized Wake Up from some dusty corner memory of who knows when. I still wouldn’t say this is my type of music, but Arcade Fire left the door of possibility open.
można dać 6 gwiazdek, idealnie dopasowane do dziisiejssego humoru i sytuację
Incredible, 2000s indie at its absolute best. Very nostalgic but not in a way that feels dated at all. This holds up incredibly well. Beautiful album.
I have not been complimentary of Arcade Fire in the past. I thought The Suburbs was bland, boring and a bit crap, and was very disappointed in Neon Bible when it came out and haven’t listened since. I was very pleasantly surprised by this, then, when it turned out to be perfectly good early 21st century indie rock. Not massive stand-out, but I enjoyed my time with it.
I have already listened to this record and it’s god awful I hate arcade fire
Sounds like the soundtrack of a night filled with cheap whiskey and cigarettes spent trying to hold pseudo-intellectual conversation but you’re just talking over each other and when it’s all said and done nothing has changed but you remember nodding your head a lot and it was kind of a good time but now you have a headache and you shaved your beard into a mustache… and there’s a dick on the side of your face.
"I prefer Pink Elephant" - Literally nobody
Fun listen with smooth moments, nothing ground-breaking musically or lyrically
I knew of Arcade Fire simply because they're from my hometown. However the album didn't leave a strong impression on me. It's very typical mid-2000s indie.
It’s just not my thing. Don’t take it the wrong way.
Crown of love Neighborhood 1 Rebellion
I liked some songs. Will definitely add them to my playlist.
Listening to this album brought me back to high school, sitting on my bedroom floor doing homework & scrolling through tumblr. Very nostalgic & comforting. Plus it’s just a beautiful album.
12/20/25 I was vibing! 7/10
Favorite track(s): Neighborhood #2 (Laika), Neighborhood #3 (Power Out), Wake Up Heard before Previous rating: 7/10
This is second Arcade Fire album I’m being dealt here. Last time I gave them 1/5 - it was unbearable! This one is much better - I’d say it’s twice as good!
Neighborhood.
I like these guys
I find this type of sound very boring.
18th album with group. Yesterday I was looking at a bunch of lists of the top albums of the 21st century, and for some reason I kept on seeing Funeral so I have high expectations. This does not disappoint though. It is much better than The Suburbs. Nice mellow indie rock, Good Songs - Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels), Neighborhood #2 (Laika), Une Annee Sans Lumiere, Neighborhood #3 (Power Out), Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles), Crown of Love, Wake Up, Haiti, Rebellion (Lies), and In the Backseat. Bad Songs -
I liked it!
JACIE GACIE nie spodziewałem sie prawie popłakać na samym początku, ogl mega album, jedynie w środkowej części mógł się wydawać lekko monotonny ale w ogóle mi to nie przeszkadzało bo podczas słuchania byłem na spacerze w słonecznej pogodzie wiec idealnie. 5/5
Did not finish all the way through. I will finish listening to it, as I was pleasantly surprised!
Yes! I saw them on this album tour!!
deus abençoe o indie do início dos anos 2000 puta merda
de fato, indiezinho do início do séc xxi eh bacana demais. millennials acertavam às vezes, parabéns pra eles. gostosim de ouvir e tem umas pedrada, hein
Twee Talking heads. Twee but not in the way GIRLS the TV show is, but I know each of those girls would be listening to this. I don’t think I’d listen again but I can understand why people do like this sound. It’s of a time of American apparel and instagram filtered topshop changing room selfies.
I think this has aged quite poorly compared to other records in this era and in this orbit. It's quite melodramatic and overblown in parts, but still has parts that are interesting and straightforwardly entertaining pop songs. It uses its maximalist ideas just to deliver straightforward musical tropes rather than do anything particularly interesting
No annoying which was a positive surprise.
Revolutionary post war and FUCKINNN LOVE IT
very solid record, but not amazing
some good songs but your average 2010s indie/folk record
I found some of the more energetic tracks entertaining, especially when they built up a head of steam, but I can't get behind the vocals, which are fairly indistinct and sound like they were recorded using a mic in the next room. Once of those groups that only really gel if you found them at that special time in your life when every artist was the best ever.
Decent
Didn't particularly capture my attention.e
As a whole, this album is good. Arcade Fire has a very distinctive sound that they carry throughout the album. Wake Up deserves to be turned up and holds a special place in this album. It immediately reminds me of Where the Wild Things Are but it also just elicits this feeling of wonder that is so nostalgically beautiful. After finishing the album, I'd say it is a 7/10. Not many songs stood out to me other than Wake Up, but overall, it has a nice sound.
yeah this is a pretty perfect album. not quite the suburbs for ME but one of the best debuts ever. neighborhood #3 is still my favorite
I liked this album! Especially the last song In the Backseat, the vocals were raw and the tone was different than the rest of the album. Probably not something I would listen to again, but worth at least one listen through!
Whilst I have listened to Neon Bible and The Suburbs a lot I do not think I ever went back to listen to the Funeral so hearing most of this album fresh. Without the familiarity or prior listening the album feels a little one dimensional and dour. Fortunately I do like the dimension they are in so I did enjoy it.
Funeral After enjoying Neon Bible I was looking forward to this, but I didn’t really get on board with it, it felt a lot like the same song over and over, and the same song going on and on. And coming after the enjoyable eclecticism of SFA, the slightly po-faced seriousness of this doesn’t land that well, falling into that morass of late 00s US indie rock that I struggle with, the similar tempos and drum patterns, the similar melodies and the similar sense of self importance. I’ll definitely listen to Neon Bible again, but I don’t think I’ll come back to this, so it's a stingy 2 for me. ⛪⛪ Playlist submission: Neighbourhood #3 (Power Out)
Central to this album is the Neighborhood suite, focused around a town where the kids seemingly want to get away from their dysfunctional parents. 'Neighborhood #1' starts with atmospheric pace and builds to a riot of sound. For an opening song on a debut album it's highly sophisticated. The more I listen to Arcade Fire the more it makes sense to tie them into a lineage of the dark post-punkers (Joy Division, Cure) married to the expanse of Springsteen's heartland rock. In amongst these epics you have the ability to weave an affecting melody is up there with the best. The album feels a more personal/nostalgic take, compared to the cynicism of Neon Bible. The latter is so well conceived though, that is my preference. But this is of course excellent.
A lot of these albums are by artists that I have never listened to so it is interesting because I usually don't know what to expect. This album was different but it was good and some of the songs were almost ethereal.
Prva polovina je najiritantniji zamislivi indie, srećom kasnije se dosta popravi utisak. Ni blizu Suburbsa i tako njihovih kasnijih stvari, ali ispao je ok album.
I love this album, it is absolutely brilliant. I remember flicking through the music channels late one night and landing on MTV2 just as Rebellion was starting. I was blown away, literally the next day I went to buy it and it’s been a favourite ever since. As a three album run I will put this, Neon Bible and The Suburbs up with the very best. Their last few albums have been quite mediocre however. Hopefully some day they can return to this kind of form. Top Track - Neighbourhood #3 (Power Out). Outstanding song, definitely in my all time top 5-10
Pretty good! Haven’t listened to ‘Wake Up’ in years and was surprised that I was kind of over it by the end considering how much I loved it back in the day. Love a full orchestra/band, band.
I had never listened to Arcade Fire before. They were hyped up pretty big at the Grammy's and it made me less interested. So, I was quite hopeful listening to this album that I would be blown away and regret having not listened to them for all of these years. The first song was pretty good. I was intrigued. Unfortunately, the rest of the album meandered. I was not blown away and I had no interest in having a 2nd listen. Nothing really stood out after the first song. Is their best album or just one of their albums that I should listen to out of 1001 other suggestions? I'm beginning to question this 1001 list.
This album came out during the years when I wasn't buying albums--and I kinda regret maybe never listening to this all the way through (honestly can't recall). It's an album that makes me wish I had a record player and that I could put this on and listen with that visceral connection that I picked this album to play and now I'm going to listen to this. In other words, it's fantastic album. This is the kind of music I love: grounded in real human suffering, which is to say in true feeling, yet also expressive of the optimism and even joy that can come out of engaging, directly, in that suffering. Let us weep and let us smile because in true sadness there is also joy. There's a lot of music I listened to in the years around when this came out that I've totally forgotten. I had forgotten this too, in that it's been too long since I've listened to it, but coming back was such a delight.
A good artist/art differentiator. Turns out Will Butler was a bit of a cock. I think it was Hearing Things — a Pitchfork offshoot — that I noticed was started the wave of rethinking Arcade Fire in lieu of Will's behaviour, basically hedging with "idk, I was young; I liked it" I was and I did, but I think I still do. In 2005/6, it took me a while to get over his voice: a thin warble; the whole thing feeling tentative and unsure compared to the music I grew up with. But gosh, it doesn't feel unconfident now. Tunnels feels like church bells; a call to prayer. Power Out a tight-jean freakout — a shivering monster. 7 Kettles, sitting shiva. Wake Up, a wall of woh-ohs that would spawn twenty years of soundalikes. Rebellion, a cocksure chorus I tried in total vain to capture playing with a friend. And I think that's really it: so much music sounded like Funeral afterward. But not before.
Same review for the previous Arcade Fire album applies here. Initially didn't like Arcade Fire other than Wake Up. Had multiple mates that are huge fans and I've tried and tried and repeatedly listened but I just don't hear what they hear. It's good. It's not amazing. That could also just be based on forced familiarity. 3.5/5. Raising to 4.
I've loved this album since its release. Serendipitously, I found out on the day that I was assigned this album that a very good friend of mine died unexpectedly. So I got drunk on an airplane and listened and it helped me cry. No way I can be objective.
Heard of band but not sure I know any music. Cool start on neighborhood #1. Really good production for the most part, wish the vocal were a little louder. Love the piano. Fun song. #2 is a fun/well produced song as well, is there a connection to number 1? Unclear. Less of a fan of une année. Good guitar, don’t like the drums. Feel choppy. Just a little too slow overall. That’s until the last 45 seconds. Great solo. This is what I wanted tempo wise. Xylophone is uneccasary on #3, but rest of it I like. I also love the cohesion of the album so far with the different neighborhoods. #3 is so good, keeps getting better as it goes. Love the guitar. Great songwriting. #4 is pretty good not the best or worst. Good songwriting, music is kind of simple compared to the rest of the album. Crown of love is fine. Good songwriting but just doesn’t hit me. Really cool last 55 seconds. I’ve definitely heard wake up before, sounds like a radio song. Guitar is awesome. This song is so good. Haiti is fine, saved by the transition into rebellion. Rebellion is awesome. One of the best on the album. In the backseat is a great ender, captures the theme of the whole album. Constantly build up. Really fun album. Would listen again. 3.4 stars
This is the whitest shit I have ever heard.
Very nostalgic, I love it so much
enjoyed that. indie rock in the background, but whole album good in total
Thanks, but I'll pass. 2
OK. The songs all do the most obvious thing and the vocals are pretty weak.
Makes me feel warm in the winter, somehow very familiar. FOUR!
Overall it’s pretty good but i feel weird enjoying it after the allegations.
1.7/5 I didn't really know what to expect since I've only ever read the group's name somewhere, but never intentionally listened to their music. Now that I have, I can say that I didn't miss out on anything. At least on this album, Arcade Fire sounds if you gave MGMT or Empire Of The Sun a violin, put some more effect pedals on the mic's line-out and moved them to Canada. In other words, it's really boring Indie / Hipster music. I've ranted about this whole genre before so I won't do it again, what I have to say though is that this album definitely doesn't belong on this list (but what does at this point?). The album always sounds like this "You grow up and break free"-theme that never hooked me to begin with, it sounds watered down and very inoffensive. Probably perfect for secretaries and people who don't know what life is about (but not when they're 18, but 35+). So 35-18 = 17, put in a dot for good measure and you'll arrive at my rating: 1.7/5
Love the string intruments
I must have been the last person sleeping on Arcade Fire, because as a first run this one is incredible. I usually try and give each album on the list a couple listens to get a better feel for it ('try' being the imperative word there, time-willing) but this was a zero hesitation replay. I usually find that the folksy twee style of indie rock in that 2000s era to be a little dorky, but it works perfectly here. fav tracks: Neighborhood #2 (Laika), Crown Of Love, Rebellion (Lies)
Wake Up is still pretty good. The rest of it didn’t click for me.
some bangers but overall some of the tonal elements of songs were disruptive to my listening experience.
top 5 album of all time for me. all hits, no skips. remember seeing them live in like 2005 on some talk show, performing neighborhood #2 (Laika) and just being blown away by that performance. been a fan since then but i hate that win butler being a sexual predator, since that took some of the joy out of the music for me. yeah thats horrible, bit this fucking album man. strap me to a rocket and send me of to the russian taiga blasting this one on, as we in sweden call it, full patte.
This was cool! The perfect cross between high energy and tragic. It’s also really fun to listen to on a plane. The songs blend together but it still sounds good so I don’t mind that much. 7 kettles sounds sm like a Wilco song I wonder if there’s any influence there. Fav songs: neighborhood #1 (tunnels), crown of love
Shame about Win Butler
It was good to get another opportunity to listen to this record. I don't know exactly why I've been unable to connect with it in the past. The music is solidly arranged indie rock, and it was recorded well, though I did find myself wishing for more depth. I listened several times and found Funeral to be a decent background record. I listened very closely one time and realized that this music deserves more attention than what I was giving it. A close listen revealed more layers than I had initially anticipated, and I appreciated that. In fact, I'd now say that Arcade Fire's Funeral is kind of a bridge between other, more noise-oriented and droning Montreal bands like Thee Silver Mt. Zion Memorial Orchestra. That was a cool surprise. But that same close listen brought up another glaring issue. I can't understand most of what the lead vocalist (Win Butler?) is singing, and when I can, I'm not impressed by the writing. And it's weird, too. I actually find that the singing and the phrasing lend appropriate texture to the music. But it's straining to try to understand the lyrics, and I'm frustrated most of the time. I'll be excited to listen to any future Arcade Fire offerings on the 1089, but this one isn't going on my go-to list any time soon. Three stars.
Sigh. First The National, now this. I mean, it's ok but I could do with less whiny indie.
Day 1000 and a complete masterpiece! One of the best debuts of the aughts.
Second Arcade Fire Album provided fromt he list. The more I hear the music the more I like the band. Uplifting music and interesting lyrics.
Ahhhh Funeral. It’s been a long time. Having been quite the hipster in 2004, I of course am no stranger to Arcade Fire. This thing to the world by storm 20-ish years ago. It’s always been an odd one to me. I absolutely love some of these songs, particularly “Tunnels” and “Wake Up.” But the others don’t hold up to repeated listens. Overall this is a generous FOUR STARS
Good
Incredible indie rock album. Hard hitting themes with strong lyrics and brilliant instrumental sounds Wake up and crown of love personal favourites from the album
good vibe but not my pick of choice
It’s hipster bullshit but it’s still good.
Pretty good 7.5/10 very vibey with horn and string instruments 👌
Rentoo taustamusaa
Solid album with one absolute banger.
Hmmm I think I do like this more than The Suburbs on account of length, but it's still just kinda ok!
As an album I appreciated this more than The Suburbs, which we got not too long ago in this challenge - the instrumentation was rich and varied and the songs kept me engaged throughout. However, as far as truly getting into Arcade Fire goes, I think I missed the last train.
If Win Butler didn’t have such a whiny voice for half the album then this would probably be better. Alas.
Gahh why must Arcade Fire make me turn against Montreal for a second time!! There are morsels of good ideas here, mostly in the instrumentation, but their entire sound is built upon angsty melodrama that I do not find at all relatable or enjoyable.
I like this album a lot, which makes me hate The Suburbs even more. It was the first LP I ever purchased. I feel like they really make the most of the number of people they have in the group here, keeping the instrumentation interesting. The desperation on some of these tracks is palpable.
Not for me
Good but boring. Enjoyable as background music. 5/10
Just ok
It's not bad, and there are some good songs, but overall it fell flat for me. Especially the first half. "Wake Up" is really good. I remember hearing about this band in the mid-2000s era, but never got into them. Listening back to this, I can see why - pretty uninspiring overall. But they are at least capable of something special. 2/5.
La grande période d'innocence d'Arcade Fire... Estifi que c'était bon d'aller les voir en show dans ce temps-là.
Nostalgie quand tu nous tiens. Un album que j'ai beaucoup écouté au secondaire. Je diraisnque toutes les tounes sont pas mal des hits. J'ai pas réussi à aimer autant Arcade Fire après même si j'ai essayé avec Neon Bible et Suburbs (et plus récemment avec WE).
Classique indie et le début de la « scène montréalaise ». Bien que ce n’est pas l’album d’eux que je connais le mieux (ce serait The Suburbs), je réalise quand même que je reconnais chaque chanson presque instantanément. Y’a du bon tube et du bon ver d’oreille là dedans!
Nooo not more Arcade fire, no need for more than one of their albums on this list, snoozefest
I bobbed my head to this off and on while writing this morning and it was fine. Can't say it grabbed me but was enjoyrable.
Reminds me of Vivaldi: perfectly pleasant background music
idk, man, it's * less interesting than the emo stuff that came before and clearly inspired it * less interesting than the rock that was happening at the same time as it * less interesting than all the indie pop rock stuff that was popular afterwards
I really tried to like this! It has so many influences that I do like and I know a lot of people love Arcade Fire, but I couldn't get into it. This is the epitome of soundtrack music, consistent, droning, not too interesting to pull attention away from the visuals. There is some nice piano and violins but they're hard to appreciate because everything is mixed at exactly the same level creating a flat, monotonous drone. It's a mix of styles I like but they've all been mixed into a grey goo. Disappointing. The cover is really nice though! The composition is interesting and pleasant, it gets a 4/5.
Still as gorgeous as it ever was, tainted only by the circumstances of its lead singer. But make no mistake, of all the indie bands to circle around the mid-2000’s this was the one that stuck, and for good reason. It’s hard to give it a perfect score both because of its flaws and what we know now, but it’s still a gorgeous stunning album.
I used to think this was one of the best albums of all time, now I don’t really care to listen to it any more. Tried selling my record from 2008 or so but the dude wouldn’t take it from me. Naive melody: the album. Is that Owen Pallette on violin? Cuz he’s the only instrument doing anything but too much at the same time.
Torn between a 3 and 4, not my favorite arcade fire record but very cohesive, high 3 low 4 I think
One of the most formative albums in my development as a listener of music. It felt revolutionary when I first heard it, and it still holds up. One of my all-time favorites.
Masterpiece
When the weekly music papers died around the turn of the century, we turned to Pitchfork for our opinions on the day's music scene. They were often far up themselves with misguided promotion of new-prog nonsense like Animal Collective, but they got it right with Arcade Fire. This album is just beautiful. There are great tunes to leaven some of the Pitchfork-friendly pretentiousness, which sets them far apart from most of their contemporaries. A stunning debut album which they will never better because it's impossible to do so.
There are some beautiful and orchestral songs on here, but I find it extremely annoying when there's one instrument really high in the mix keeping time by playing the same chord continuously for the entire song. And unfortunately that's almost every song on this album.
Still good.
My kinda vibe enjoyable listen
Although much of the album revolves around themes of death and mortality, make no mistake - this album is largely upbeat and energetic. Bold and experimental, the album has an indie-rock vibe, featuring choral vocals and lively guitar riffs, but also the strings, horns and xylophones of Baroque-pop. Such a mix of instruments results in a continuous sound - there is a lot going on, all the time. Yet, while loud, it still manages to be reflective. It has been said that the band experienced much personal loss during the making of the track. But rare among rock records, particularly during the garage rock era of the early 2000s, the album subtly captures the band's more melancholic emotions.
Man, this is some hipster bullshit. Also, I'll say Win Butler can suck my dick, since giving consent ruins it for him.
Derivative
I really love this album. The "shuffle" kind of style they had on this album is tremendous.
Nostalgi
This is a beautiful album. I assume this completes my trilogy of arcade fire albums and that they do only have three on the list. 4 and 5 for those. This was always my favourite and was a 5 before I enjoyed having an extra listen today.
I know this record very well, and it is one I go back to. Absolutely perfect in my eyes, S-tier all the way.
Pretty boring, not my thing. Couple decent moments but they’re lost within the rest of the album which is nothing special
Can't really be objective on this. All I hear is magic.
Well this is more highly rated on here that I expected. I accept that I just don’t get much of the critical acclaim rock music from the period very much, have little infinity towards it, a disconnect with what was perceived as the cutting edge of rock at the time hearing a dull bland drone. Old man shouting at sky time ( insert Grampa Simpson meme). I didn't find this bad per say, but struggled to touch what makes it relevant? Sees like It was on, but it didn't seem to do anything in particular, go anywhere. I just don’t hear a masterpiece that others are describing or anything close, just a fairly bland conglomerate of a series of rock tropes since the 70s, under that sheen of 21 century production. If this is someone's greatest album ever good for them, as it likely has meaning and context in time for you, personally I had little interest found it dull, 2nd listen didn't get any better, that dull guitar sound and wall of rhythm that is so prevalent in Millennial rock, whinny vocals again a stable. Not for me 2 Stars And as side note last artist I had on here all the top reviews were all linked bar none to allegations of misconduct, pillarising the artist, though not substantiated in that case but everyone had issue myself included - art vs artist, etc etc though similar situation here it seems when googled - but not much mentioned?? Be it unsubstantiated it is an issue/or isn't, but people seem to pick and choose their moral stand ( if they like the artist/ he isn't such a prick?).
Excellent
Add it to the list of fine records that now come with some troublesome baggage but damn if it isn’t still a fine listen. Tune after tune delivered with a distinctive, rich signature sound, it still sounds fresh 20 years on.
It’s good and well-made and complex and all that, but not really my thing. I did like the random French though. Benefit of Montreal bands.
It was fine
Actually up there as one of my favorite albums. A classic from a band that makes classics. Too bad Win is an a-hole.
Older I get the more this album grows on me. Some songs I really like other songs I slog through. Net net, a banger. I also have some treasured memories being in a live room belting out “Wake Up” that are eternal.
This was a solid 2 until I hit Wake Up, then I thought "well this would be a 2 but this song elevates it to a 3." Then I heard the last few tracks, which I never did before and it's a solid 3. A lot of skips and a lot of it is too artsy fartsy for my taste. But Wake Up is a banger and there's a couple others I'd revisit.
Grittypretty growlin' howlin' Arcade Fire have mastered the _drop_ ✅✅✅ Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels) ✅✅✅ Neighborhood #3 (Power Out) ✅✅✅✅ Rebellion (Lies)
So good I had to listen it to it over and over. Takes me back to a time and place - yet still feels like it could come out today and be a banger of an album.
I was subjected to this album a lot in 2005. My reaction again is annoyance.
🥁🪇🥁🥁🪇 WOAHHH OHHHH WOAHHH OHHHH WOAHHH OHHHH WOAHHH OHHHH 🥴 😭 😫 🥁🥁 WOAHHH OHHHH WOAHHH OHHHH WOAHHH OHHHH WOAHHH OHHHH
later
According to 1001 albums you should listen to, this album single handedly showed up emo music for the “emotionally illiterate, self indulgent, angst ridden garbage” it is. Strong words about an entire genre of music. The blurb also mentions that Arcade Fire dabbled in Krautrock before landing on indie rock and boy am I glad they didn’t stick with their original plan.
A weak 4 out 5 fire...Too much unnecessery fillings.
Some good tracks, but never quite matched the hype.
Mulle lihtsalt tundub see album kohutavalt igav. Võibolla kui ma kuulaksin seda plaati mitu korda läbi, siis jääks midagi meelde, aga esmasel kuulamisel on tõesti raske ühtegi lugu siit meenutada. Ei aita ka fakt, et mulle see vokaal ei sümpatiseeri üldse. Võibolla mulle lihtsalt ei meeldi indie rock või see vaib.
Transcendental. A religious experience for millennials (that's me). Contender for most tears shed on an album. Win Butler you will pay for your crimes.
I already knew how I would review this album before re-listening (spoiler: 4.5). Upon reading the reviews, it feels like listeners fall into one of three camps: 1) those who weren't exposed to the indie rock zeitgeist of the 2000s 2) those who were 3) those who were and hated it This album is so deeply ingrained in that indie rock fervor of the aughts. And, in a way, it helped kick start the movement. At least in the sense of transitioning truly indie music into the mainstream. Listening to Funeral restrospectively, it's hard to believe it wasn't released on a major label. Yes, it's the very definition of indie rock from that era, but so much of what happened after bands like Arcade Fire blew up was that indie rock became more associated with a distinct sound than with the record labels releasing the music. Hell, I remember Arcade Fire playing at some awards show (Grammy's maybe?) with David f'ing Bowie. Anyway all this to say, Funeral is definitely getting points in my book for being culturally and historically relevant, like it or not. But, is it a good album? Truth be told, it's not a perfect album by my definition but it's damn close. And the three songs that don't exactly do it for me are probably someone else's favorite. Each track is a work of art: the lyrics, the composition, the way they tie thematically into the album's overall concept. Arcade Fire won't blow you away with their instrumentals, but neither did Bowie. It is more how those instrumentals are arranged to create a portrait of something greater than itself; a prominent showpiece on the mural of 21st century music if you will. And in some ways that's a good metaphor for Arcade Fire themselves. They kind of became the poster child for indie rock, something far bigger than this album or even any of theirs, could claim. Funeral, upon reflection, is a masterpiece...a personal 4.5 star rating easily becomes a 5 when I account for all this album represents. And sorry to the haters but you don't have to like the music to recognize its brilliance and ultimate worthiness for being on this list.
Enjoyed it! Not much else to say
Þetta er sko alveg tónlist sem ég fíla og Arcade Fire kunna að semja slíka tónlist. Fagmannlega gert án þess að ná einhverjum ofurhæðum en bara virkilega gott stöff
This is one of my favorite albums. A lot of nostalgia for this one. 5 stars.
Good album, especially for a debut. Not as polished as some of their other work, but I guess that’s to be expected. Definitely worth another listen.
I have heard of this band plenty, but never listened to them before, pretty sure of that. I'm halfway through now, and it's not that bad, but it's kind of boring to me as well, can't see this going for more than 3 stars, maybe less, will see after I finish listening to this fully.
How do I rate this? On the one hand, this is a fantastic album - deeply nostalgic, great songwriting, and truly one of the standouts of the indie music I grew up with. On the other hand, the allegations against Win Butler have soured my previous love for Arcade Fire. On the music alone, in a vacuum, it’s an easy five for me but I can’t unlink the nuance around Arcade Fire and the legacy of the band now from the work.
I like Arcade Fire but have never loved them This is the closest I’ve come Wake up is an all timer
I love this album. Before Butler became a terd.
Good but not particularly memorable
6/10… chamber pop / indie rock / *2004
Kut muziek
This is my fave album and I wish I had more stars! Fire Joe Morgan/Newman track by track review 1. "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)" - Fantastic start, the driving notes set the tone of the album. And like a lot of these songs, has a great time change towards the end. 2. "Neighborhood #2 (Laïka)" - Ah, this album is going to have songs that connect to each other. This rousing chant song elevates the energy. 3. "Une année sans lumière" - Now time for a slower number with my second fave track on the album. This somber, haunting Régine tune has a great refrain. 4. "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)" - This was the song CD101 played the most from the album and it might be my least favorite on the album (which is to point out how amazeballs this album is, because this song still slaps). This hard rocker though lacks the nuance of other tracks ... 5. "Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles)" - ... Like this one, another soft ballad. When I first got this album--bootlegged, btw--this track cut off. This is a simple nice palate cleanser. 6. "Crown of Love" - My fave song on the record. This song builds to an incredible crescendo and really shows off the symphonic beauty of the band, especially the strings. 7. "Wake Up" - The huge single from the album that got overplayed. It is fun to sing along. 8. "Haiti" - This slow song has really grown on me. It sounds like a beach and is a great bridge to ... 9. "Rebellion (Lies)" - The most raucous song on the record and my bronze medal winner. I jump up and down to this song a lot. 10. "In the Backseat" - What starts as a very slow coda grows into defiance later. Huh, I'm realizing that this album does a great job of rise and fall throughout (and the slow songs generally have a fast and furious end). Although this album is ostensibly about death, I find it more their operatic album. 'Neon Bible' is their dark album, 'Suburbs' melancholy, 'Reflektor' dance party, 'Everything Now' the anti-corporate U2 'Pop' album, 'WE' the paranoid one, 'Pink Elephant' brooding. But 'Funeral' remains their first and their best.
this is good and stuff. hipster as fuck to be honest. Wake Up is a fucking BANGER. Win Butler is a dork and a sex pest, but so are a ton of folks on this list. This is not a justification. Rebellion Lies is also good. Whatever, it's a 2.
Wack.
It was ok, would listen to Arcade Fire again, given the right mood.
8.5/10
One of my favourite albums. Full sound with excellent composition.
it's alright. it didn't feel very compelling or interesting, so i'm not sure what the hype is about from reading other reviews. this reminds me of something that would be playing in a spot that sells $25 burgers and has a logo of a silhouetted man with a handlebar mustache. standout track: neighborhood #3
A classic album full of top quality songs.
Nice discovery! So creative!
A lot of different styles/ instruments. Very pleasing for the ear!
Really suprised by this album! I really liked it!
The proto indie rock album that influenced how indie rock would sound from 2007 and onward.
Kevät
Interesting. A lot going on. Would need another 2-3 listens to start unpacking it. And I’m pretty sure I’m willing to do that (once I get through the current backlog).
Meh.
Worthy
Caps the best week we've had. What a run. Strong memories of being in Fopp in Edinburgh and listening to this on the instore headphones after it received a glowing review on Teletext. What a time.
Pretty good album. First album of what now has become a slightly annoying stadium rock band
This is the first time I have listened to an entire Arcade Fire album at one sitting, and I can say I enjoyed every track. For not really knowing them, this was an eye-opener. Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles) very haunting piece but my fav. Putting this one on my add to vinyl collection list.
An exciting interesting album without any particular standout songs/singles. An example of being interesting but accessible
Decent not really my jam though
Great first album If David Bowie and Talking Heads gave birth to a band
Did this come out as an answer to the horrible emo scene that was dominating the suburbs at the time? Possibly. It felt like a direct message to me, even if the whole is greater than the sum of the parts. It was an easy answer to, "Oh if you don't like My Chemical Romance then what do you like?" Though Sufjan was and always will be better.
great music, horrible vocals
This wanted to be great but did nothing expansiveness enough to truly achieve that.
SO SO GOOD! Reminds me a bit of the Beatles, in terms of voice and experimentation.
I've never actually listened to Arcade Fire until today, but I have three quick stories that should help illustrate what my impression of them was before going into Funeral. 1. My first serious girlfriend (who I had a pretty traumatic breakup with) was one of those annoying "hipster" girls who was really into amateur photography and indie rock. Arcade Fire was one of her favorite bands. 2. I once saw a new Arcade Fire CD (can't recall which one – probably The Suburbs or Reflektor based on the timing) on sale for like $1.50 at a Brookstone in Maine and considered grabbing it, but ultimately decided against it – I just had a gut feeling it wasn't going to be my thing. 3. That whole "Paft Dunk" stunt at Coachella back in 2014 (along with Win Bulter dedicating a song to "all the bands at this festival playing real instruments") left a bad taste in my mouth for a long time. I'm sure it was in good fun, but anyone clowning on the kings of French touch presumably weren't putting out music I was going to enjoy. With all that out of the way... I tried to go into Funeral with an open mind, but it was hard not to hear the album as a bunch of pretentious indie rock. The vocals were so unintelligible that I had no idea what I was even hearing half the time. I can't say I genuinely hated it the whole way through, but there also wasn't much I really enjoyed. This is one I'd be okay not coming back to – hopefully one of Arcade Fire's other Book Albums will do more for me. Highlights: Crown of Love, Rebellion (Lies), In the Backseat
Canadians this whiny must be Toronto Maple Leafs fans. Didn’t like Arcade Fire as a kid (the radio played them constantly for CanCon), still don’t like them. The album concept and structure is interesting though.
I don't feel as connected to the 2000s indie rock bands
Behold, an Arcade Fire album I didn't just hate.
RIP
It's chill, I like it.
OK..
This sounds so timeless
Beautiful as hell with a stellar final 3 song leg
Truly the 500th best album out of Rolling Stone's 500 Best Albums of All Time.
Love my alternative whites
beautiful wonderful free
Yeah it's ok
LET’S GOOOOOO I actually used to not like this album and tell people. I cringe about that sometimes. It’s perfect. (Win Butler is still a creep tho).
I enjoyed some of the songs but mostly wasn’t for me
Immediately and unintentionally swam deep into the ol’ nostalgia well starting at Tunnels and it carried through all the way to the end. I struggled if I should even rate this one if I was so compromised. OTOH why else does anyone engage with art in the first place? This album is strong enough lyrically and to grab someone in 2025, or at least that’s how I can explain being bowled over emotionally. It does lack some depth and isn’t as expansive musically as their later material. That being said, no real skippers IMO. Set the standard for a lot of indie music that followed.
A classic. Reminds me of freshman year of college. Kind of forgot about a couple of the songs but it’s got some bangers. I think Suburbs is probably a more cohesive album lyrically? ‘Neighborhood #2’ always kinda makes me laugh for some reason, like who the hell is Alexander.
This is a solid album throughout, but man, "Rebellion (Lies)" DOES SOMETHING TO ME. Indie fugue state. Millennial madness. Every time I hear it, I'm like, "Is this my favorite song of all time???" I'm thumping and hooting and hollering. EVERY TIME YOU CLOSE YOUR EYEEEEEES!
I went back and gave this one a new listen earlier this year or maybe last year, there's good stuff on it and it was definitely influencial for better or for worse. I think they're a slightly overated band, even tho I love some of their songs, this is probably a 3 1/2 for me if I had to give it a rating, which I do. I'll round it up to a 3 star because I'm a bitch Best tracks: Neighborhood #1 & 3, Wake Up I'll try not to use "overated" for the next ones haha
288/1089 - Boring, too long and bad voices. Only thing it has going for it is instrument competency.
There is pretty stuff here and it has some great use of instruments that are not traditional to the alt-rock genre. But I just don't know...I don't dislike them, they just aren't this end all be all of rock bands that everyone makes them out to be. There is little here that seems THAT unique or THAT different. Its emo alt-rock.
I like Arcade Fire. They have a really good creative energy. Sometimes kind of messy and chaotic but in a good way with interesting instrumentation. They rock out some pretty powerful jams with a unique sound. They are a band I can listen to over and over and discover new things in their songs.
Funeral is a good album but it never really spoke too deeply to me. This was exciting for 2004, but now it sounds earnest and overwrought. 3.5 stars.
Today I learned the first half of this album was based around a terrible ice storm in 1998 in Canada. That makes the album even more interesting. And the fact a lot of them had recently lost family members was another layer I wasn’t aware of. I listened a few times today, and this got better each time I listened. They cultivated a really unique early aughts indie sound. It’s emotional and rockin’ and the songwriting is quite beautiful. Awesome debut for them!
Liked this better than I thought I would. Couple repeat tunes: Crown of Love & Wake Up. Sounds even better with my newly acquired headphonezZzZzzz
Beetje dramatisch
Funeral — дебютный студийный альбом канадской инди-рок-группы Arcade Fire, выпущенный 14 сентября 2004 года на лейбле Merge Records. Предварительные записи для Funeral были сделаны в течение недели в августе 2003 года в Hotel2Tango в Монреале, Квебек, а сама запись была завершена в том же году в аналоговом формате. Тексты песен альбома основаны на темах смерти, перемен и потери детской невинности, навеянных недавней кончиной членов семей нескольких участников группы во время его создания. Первая половина альбома, получившая название the 'Neighborhood' suite, повествует о городе, борющемся с отключением электроэнергии посреди зимы, и основана на личном опыте во время ледяного шторма в Северной Америке 1998 года. С альбома было выпущено пять синглов, самым успешным из которых стала песня "Rebellion (Lies)", занявшая 19-е место в британском чарте синглов. Альбом был номинирован на премию «Грэмми» в 2005 году в категории «Лучший альтернативный музыкальный альбом». Он получил широкое признание критиков и возглавил многие списки лучших альбомов года и десятилетия. Сейчас его часто называют одним из величайших альбомов всех времен. Как сообщается на сайте сайте Metacritic, альбом был вторым самым выступлений на конец десятилетия ТОП-10 списков, только за Radiohead Это определённо не ужасный альбом, он есть и имеет право на существование. Интересно послушать, местами хорош. Но и такая высокая оценка критиков мне не очень понятна. Веет от этого альбома какой-то претенциозностью, что ли. А может все жанры с приставкой "барокко" имеют такое настроение, не знаю. Экспериментальщиной и резкой сменой инструментала в треке уже никого не удивишь, но может в 2005 это было ещё в новинку. Ну и я люблю, когда в альбоме есть общая тема или в ней рассказывается история, это интересно как произведение искусства само по себе. Говорю этому альбому "окей".
Normal, hi ha cançons originals.
Reminds me of high school. Less moody than I remember.
One of my all time favorites! Incredible album from start to finish. This was my introduction to Arcade Fire, and I still remember the first time I heard it. Such an original, full sound, really love this album. Highlights: "Wake Up" and "Rebellion", but the whole album is great.
It still hits but not like it did when I was in my early 20s. But isnt that in line with the theme of the album? Still fantastic and I can listen to it multiple times in a row.
never asked
Crown of love and Wake up are great songs. Another band let down by annoying af vocals
I remember this from when I was a teen. Perhaps overplayed, but love Wake Up for instance.
Arcade fire beschde
No thanks
У Фаєрів видатний був стрік з перших чотирьох альбомів. Хоч навколо цього є загальний консенсус, що він кращий, мені він подобається найменше з чотирьох. Але це безаперечно дуже сильний дебют і важливий альбом для нульових
Шикарний альбом, який гарно постарішав. Suburbs люблю більше, але тут впевнені 4 зірочки від мене.
За кілька місяців одне від одного, у подружжя музикантів Regine Chassagne та Win Butler померли бабуся та дідусь. Вони спільно проживали це відчуття особистого горя, яке зрештою й стало фундаментом, на якому виріс дебютний альбом їх гурту Arcade Fire, з красномовною назвою Funeral. Замість того аби йти звичним шляхом, Arcade Fire перетворили особисту трагедію на майже казкову історію про молодих людей, що намагаються вирватися з полону сімейних спогадів, страхів та втрат. У відкриваючій пісні Tunnels, вони розповідають про закоханих, що прокопують тунелі зі своїх будинків, аби зустрітися одне з одним та втекти від скорботи, яка зависла над їхніми родинами, аби помріяти про доросле майбутнє. Так, це трохи наївно, але саме ця непідробна наївність й робить альбом таким «особливо-живим». Навколо цієї історії втрати та любові, гурт вибудовує унікальний музичний світ де залитий струнними, еклектичний звуковий ландшафт прикрашають емоційні, величні немов хорові приспіви. Кожна пісня тут побудована наче скульптура з прискіпливою увагу до деталей, де звичний інді-рок з брудною гітарою набуває масштабів симфонічної сюїти. Усе працює на створення атмосфери великої пригоди справжнього життя, де сум та надія постійно йдуть поруч. І тому Funeral досі звучить настільки особливо, бо насправді це альбом не про смерть - він про те, як жити далі після неї. Неймовірно щирий та натуральний шедевр, що яскраво вирізняється серед купи вимушених альбомів, які намагаються продати нам награний сум.
I didn’t mind it, but I don’t quite get the hype or why this is considered such a groundbreaking album. I guess you just had to be there.
A cynical person's idea of sincerity. I don't buy it.
Up until Wake Up I was unimpressed. Not exactly bored, nor was anything particularly bad, but there was little about this album that grabbed my attention. However, Wake Up was fantastic. It was larger than the entirety of the rest of the album together. The word that popped into my head for it was anthemic, with that uncomplicated but driving riff and the background chorus. Then the orchestration came in. Just a great song. It made me think I needed to start the album over since I had to have missed something. Them the rest of the album made me realize that no, it was one really, really good song in the middle of a mediocre album.
mid
This was heading for a 2 at the start of the album but once you get into it gets better. Some good tunes and I like the orchestral vibe of a lot of it. Might get higher with further listens but I've over 600 albums left to listen to so I can't
It's fine, I can see why people like it.
I’ll take another godawful Neil Young album after this
I KNOW this band is terrible as people (specifically Win and a little weirdly Regine). But I'm too nostalgic for how great this album was for it's time. How epic every concert was with this band that I saw (minus the end towards the allegations coming out). It really is the orchestral, semi-twee/goth indie rock epic.
This is pretty good. It drags a bit, but the instrumentation is good.
perto dos outros dois esse foi bem fraco
Gear: ZiiGaat x Hangout.Audio: Odyssey 2 Artwork: ✒️🪶🍂 Production: 😱🔪👂 Music: 👀❓🤷 Rating: ✒️✒️/5
Splendid
Loved it
Crazy good debut with poetic lyrics and a wall of sound that just sounds gorgeously epic. Wake Me and Rebellious are all time greats.
This is a debut album from one of the few post-2000 era groups I’ve heard of (because they have been on SNL a few times). The album started unremarkable but gained steam as it progressed. It is good for a debut effort but not quite to the four-star level.
A second Arcade Fire album, eh? I "have" this album digitally, but I never bought it because it didn't live up to the single that interested me - 'Rebellion (Lies)'. Still pleasant indie stuff, nice instrumentation (dare I say, orchestration), but the vocals are too muddly. And there are better songs about Laika, like Ireland's 2025 Eurovision entry! Highlight: 'Rebellion (Lies)'
I put this on my ear phones while I did my morning workout and was Hal way through before I even noticed it was playing! The whole album just washed over me without leaving a single sonic imprint.
All Time Classic. Iconic 00s Rock-Hymns and the sweet smell of youth.
Fantastic album, even after all these years. Such a great introduction to Arcade Fire
Vibes: 3/5 Instruments: 2/5 Production: 4/5 Emotional Value: 4/5 Storytelling/Lyrics: 4/5 Stand Outs: Neighborhood #3, Rebellion (lies) Overall Rating: 3.8
Not their best but still a good listen
Love it!
Simply great.. the emotions it evokes. Would love to see this album performed live by them. Wake up was a standout upon this listen
Great album & songs More like a 3.7
Generally solid throughout.
The one star is for Wake Up. The rest was white noise to me.
Won’t pretend it doesn’t get a nostalgia boost, but it’s better than the other album we listened to.
Probably a 2.5. Much better than the last Arcade Fire album.
Okej men inte mer
It's ok, not really my thing.
Oh shell yeah! :) This is one of the albums that I love, lots of good. I'm clearly tired writing this and need to finish my coffee.
Noisy and demanding. The art value is low while begging for relevancy is high.
Theatrical, bombastic, but astonishingly cohesive and accomplished for a debit.
5/1001 Some interesting sounds and creative oddball stuff on here. I can see how some would not like this. For me, this is one of the good ones.
I can’t get into this band, my mind and my body are indifferent.
This is the only Arcade Fire album I have in my collection
Not for me. 1/5
I'm not really a big indie rock type. But this wasn't bad. It was a good listen through and through, good vibes and enticing.
Much more my alternative style. This is fun, but not a jam. Crown of Love has a good jam at the end of it.
Arcade Fire have a big sound and big emotions! The melodies soar on this album! The arrangements are beautifully orchestrated, but it still feels like a rock record. There’s a touch of Springsteen in the mix here. There are so many great songs on this album that feel like anthems. Really powerful, beautiful music that holds a special place in my heart.
Even though I'm a huge indie rock fan, I was really late to Arcade Fire and didn't start listening to them until my mid to late 20's.. not entirely sure when but definitely after college years when my friends were spinning their records daily. It's kind of a double edged sword because I would have loved to have these tunes pushing me along those confusing times, but also I feel blessed to get to listen to the band and it's still really fresh for me. This is maybe my favorite album of theirs. Its size is filed under "Bruce Springsteen", it's quirk and uniqueness is listed as "Neutral Milk Hotel", and it's instrumentation is analogous to "Sufjan Stevens". All huge complements. "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)" is fantastic. I love this epic opener and it's set a perfect tone for the rest of the album. "Wake Up" is tough yet tender and is packed full of emotion. When the backing singers sing, you can tell they feel every single note. "Rebellion (Lies)" is the first Arcade Fire song I ever heard and while it wasn't love at first listen, it's really come around on me. It's got that Springsteen charm but colored in this funkier indie rock set of crayolas, where there's burnt sienna's instead of oranges, and blood ruby's instead of reds. I don't know if that makes sense but it does to me. I'm giving this a 5, and I think it's my favorite Arcade Fire album. My favorite song of theirs isn't on it, "The Suburbs", and if it was it would be one of my favorite records, but that's OK that it's not. There's so much good stuff here.
I’m biased towards this as I’ve heard it so many times and love it, but it still slaps
Rating: 9/10 Amazing indie rock album with plenty of catchy riffs, melodies, and choruses.
Este disco estaba en todos los blogs de aquellos años. Siempre lo consideré sobrevalorado y mi opinión no ha cambiado desde aquellos años. Malo no es, en todo caso, pero no llega a esas 5 estrellas que veo tan fácilmente entregadas en los comentarios.
Had some highlight songs but a lot of it sounded the same.
Ganske bra.
A pure shimmering turd of a record
verrassend. best leuk
Amazing album about death and growing up. So much feeling here and ridiculous highs like wake up. Very high 4, just has always had a couple of skips for me.
Where the wild beasts are
Pleasant and empty
I think it was pretty cool uhhhh........ I don't really have anything to say so uh... Yeah.
Oh, Canada. I often find mid-aughts records don’t age that well. This one stills feels very good. The music on this album fills a room in a way that is cozy and epic at the same time.
Thrashed this when it came out. Holds up well listening again over 20 years later
Skip
Still sounds great! Lots of nostalgia here. Easy 4
Well, this takes me back to my first marriage. This album got overplayed when we began dating. It wasn't what I was into, but I endured because she liked it. Eventually, it grew on me. Didn't think I would listen to this again. There's something different about this band. They aren't like a corporate cutout, but they aren't super "indie" either. Just good ole mature music for adults who don't like to blow their ears out ti heavy music. Kind of folky, but not folk music. Neighborhood 3 and Wake Up were always favorites. This album is a good 4 for me.
This stuff just doesn't really grab me.
Just can't get into it
Qué disco tan increíble. Casi lo amo al 100%, pero curiosamente la única canción que no me encantó es la más famosa, Wake up. Me dio un tanto de hueva. Pero el resto del álbum me pareció espectacular, lo disfruté mucho y me dejó muchas ganas de volverlo a escuchar. De hecho creo que es el que más me gusta de Arcade Fire, así que tenga sus 5 estrellas.
Listened to this already! I'll give it a second listen. Decent, fun, everything sounded good if a little poppy. Enjoyed the album, solid 3 - 3.2, had a fun time listening to it. The vocals were very very solid.
Arcade Fire has always fallen flat for me and I'm not sure why. Their songs, while energetic, never feel exciting. This may be a testament to how influential they are, but almost every song sounds like it could easily be in the background of a commercial for Home Depot or some fabric softener. There were a couple of cool moments.
Perfectly pleasant listen but it really just needed a little more energy and power as many of the songs have a languid, almost flat tempo to them. I have to assume that this was the artists intention for it to be dreamy but in this case it's a little bit uninteresting. Top Tracks = Wake Up & In the Backseat
Another turd where my favorite song was the final track because the assault on my ears would soon be over. The strange noise coming from my refrigerator is equally as pleasurable to listen to
Mid
Sympatoche
Trop bien aussi
Immaculate album. Perfect from front to back.
Listened to this a lot as a teen, Haiti was on several mixes. Some dated sound choices, but the anthems are undeniable.
DIOS SANTO. NO PUEDES SIMPLEMENTE EMPEZAR TU DISCOGRAFÍA ASÍ ¡NO PUEDES!
I like this album, but I'll admit that to me it feels more "important" than enjoyable. There is a lot going on that I don't have the musical chops to be able to describe. Interesting instrumentation, rhythms and melodies. But I don't find myself wanting to listen over and over
I'll admit some bias here but this was a "love at first listen" album for me in college, and I hadn't revisited it in totality in a while. I think it's an almost perfect indie rock album that is bombastic and over the top in all the right ways, both vocally and instrumentally, but also gives you a break at the right times. Putting the monumental anthems of Wake Up and Rebellion (Lies) back to back would have been almost too much, so Haiti is in between as a bit of a break before diving right back in. I love the counterpoint of Win and Regine's vocals, I love the ornateness of the arrangements, the mid-song changes in direction, how it all flows, everything. I still think this is their best album of a pretty great opening three-album run (yes Suburbs is great too) and to have this be a debut is just stunning.
At their best with heavy hitters with the right amount of unexpected indie elements (power out, wake up). At their worst with whiny ballads that seem like playing indie band BINGO. they’re only missing a whiny pathetic trumpet player. Crown of Love is embarrassingly bad especially when it leads to a song as monumental as wake up. Still it’s arcade fire. When I think arena indie rock they are THE band.
I’ve always liked Funeral by Arcade Fire, but I’ve never been fully convinced it’s as groundbreaking or important as many make it out to be. So, I decided to give it another listen today to see if my view has changed. After today’s listen, I’d say Funeral is a good indie album with some excellent moments, though it’s not quite the masterpiece it’s often described as. Tracks like “Crown of Love,” “Wake Up,” and “Rebellion (Lies)” really stand out — Rebellion in particular has been a favourite of mine for years. However, the songs surrounding them feel fairly standard, even a little basic by comparison. Overall, it’s a solid album but not a game-changer — a steady 3/5 for me. Favourite track: “Rebellion (Lies)” – a fantastic song. Least favourite track: “In the Backseat” – not terrible, but the album ends with a bit of a whimper. Album artwork: A cool, distinctive cover that fits the tone of the record.
Kinda surprised how much it still hit. This is an institution of time and place for me and maybe that’s why I don’t find the dance rock as cheesy as I might otherwise.
This is the second Arcade Fire album that I've encountered so far on this list. I truly hated Neon Bible. I don't know why but even the artwork on this irritates me. It's less bad than Neon Bible but will never come back to this. It's of a time and I'll be leaving it there.
Mixed thoughts on Funeral.. I like about half of it, and it was a breath of fresh air at the time. I was prepared to go lower given the tone is a bit cringe but tunes like LIES are still huge.
Very good. No notes.
okay
Quality Canadian indie.
Some of the best indie rock songs of the early 2000's with a couple of songs I'm not crazy about. 8/10
I wish Win Butler wasn’t a creep.
So this is what Canadian rock music sounds like... I like it.
Loved it
This is such a fantastic album, not one skip track. I hadn't listened to it in a few years but loved every moment. It was on heavy rotation for me for several years.
Great Album
The textures and genre blending on this album are so refreshing and still sounds great 20 years later Rebellion (Lies) is incredible as a piece of song writing
*2004. Debut *Neighborhoods, Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies) *Great debut album. RATING - 8/10
Some nice stuff here but ultimately not very memorable.
Cool, chilled beautiful.
Perhaps through my ignorance I have not listened to Arcade Fire before. Listened to it twice and the second time it certainly started to grow on me. Interesting reading their wiki page. Colourful story. Noting David Bowie’s obvious liking of them it makes me think that perhaps their influence can be heard in his last album “Blackstar” which I thought was different from any Bowie album before.