Reviews (page 2 of 8)
Don’t get me fuckin’ started. It’s a 7/5. An all timer. A friend for life. It makes you want to go back and retrospectively lower the scores of all the other albums. I like it.
Didn't particularly enjoy this one, too grungy for my liking and quite dull. Cool looking album cover though.
The vocals and honestly everything else too just don't do it for me. 1/5
When this album, there were aspects of this band/album that I liked and aspects that I didn't. I still listened a lot, without loving the album. I feel the same now - it's nice to hear now as nostalgia, but I still don't love it. If I could, I would give it 3.5
On her second album, PJ Harvey once again blew me away. The immediacy of this album, the intimacy and the (in the most positive way) dirt of the album are incredible. It lives in a grim and menacing world that constantly fluctuates between paralyzing quietness and overwhelming noise, accompanied by a voice that demands your attention and guides you to the light - or maybe to disaster. An impeccably produced album that showcases the force that Harvey’s voice can create without being overwhelming. There is no artifice on here, there is only PJ Harvey’s soul projected onto us.
I much preferred this album to the previous P J Harvey album that came up in this list (whatever that was?). Stripped back alternative rock album, I can hear echoes of Siouxsie Sioux and Patti Smith here.
While the raw and gritty Steve Albini production is great, this record would not work as well as it does without the charisma of one PJ Harvey. She is so effortlessly cool on here and her primal screams make for a compelling listen. The slow-burn opener builds up anticipation before exploding into a chorus of noise. This record could be described as grunge-adjacent that gets weirder as the record progresses. I throughly enjoyed every track on here.
Really liked this. Sounds familiar but not heard anything like it ironically.
I liked the rage
I like PJ Harvey, usually, but there's something just off about this album that rattles my nerves a bit. Maybe it's the weird mix. It's either too quiet or too loud. Some bits I love, some bits make me recoil. Maybe that's the point. I prefer other Harvey albums, this all seems so undecided and confusing.
2.6/5
I really like her. This is the third of her albums this site has sent me. I really liked 2011's Let England Shake. 2000's Stories from the Sea... didn't compare favorably but was still decent. This is her second album, from 1993, and is wonderfully raw. Great stuff. Not as "listenable" as Let England Shake, but has an original core energy that must have carried her through 3+ decades of work.
solid
The quiet parts were a little too quiet at times. Then when I turned up my speakers, thinking something was wrong, I got blasted out of the room. I was never big into PJ Harvey, but I do respect her. There were moments I really loved, and some stuff that just didn't hit.
Raro, ya se veía que tenía potencial y bastante fuerza
I know that Rid of Me was critically acclaimed, and for cause: it’s raw, grungy, aggressive, left-field and doesn’t follow guidelines, which usually, critics loved. But for me? It wasn’t. Besides the grungy part, which I loved, all the rest was tough. I thought it was noisy, deconstructed and everything was scattered in every direction. 2/5. Rough listen for me. I understand what the album is, but definitely not for me. Won’t listen again. Rid of Me : 2 Missed : 2 Legs : 2 Rub 'til It Bleeds : 3 Hook : 2 Man-Size Sextet : 1 Highway '61 Revisited : 2 50ft Queenie : 1 Yuri-G : 2 Man-Size : 2 Dry : 2 Me-Jane : 2 Snake : 1 Ecstasy : 2
She rocks
Canções carregadas de eletricidade contagiante e vocais viscerais com marca pessoal e cativantes. Ótimo disco.
I like some of her other albums, but this album does nothing for me. Odd.
1. "50ft Queenie" 2. "Missed" 3. "Rid of Me"
I wonder if everyone would agree that if there could only be one album per artist that this would be hers. Not knocking the others, though I didn’t love Dry, but this is just clearly her best, right?
Braucht man nicht.
I wanted to like this more than I did, so I may need to revisit. The lyrics were captivating and the music fit them well. 3.4/5.
Miss consistent. Never a bad album, always interesting and unique.
Me re gustó, pero me agarró en un momento en donde necesitaba algo menos sufriente u oscuro. Sólo por eso le bajo un punto, porque quizás otro disco me guste más, pero la verdad impresionante. Musicalmente genial, las baterías me gustaron mucho. Me encantaría escucharlo nuevamente prestando mayor atención a las letras. Me gustan los juegos que hace con su voz, muy a lo Sinnead o Dolores O'Riordan.
Sehr Cool!
Love how the title track is just one riff for like five minutes—she pulls it off too. Such a classic
Really boring
I like the other one better, but this one's a banger.
Pretty good but probably not something I'll seek out. I think maybe the production/sonics of the LD don't fully do the tracks justice. I like the last track 'Ecstasy' best, the guitar's bad ass, but I wish they turned the bass line up.
Bon, je vais la faire simple mais un disque qui commence par un ordre chuchoté puis qui fini par nous sauter à la gorge comme un pitbull affamé mérite qu'on s'y attarde quelques minutes. En 1992, le monde découvrait une tornade nommée Polly Jean Harvey avec Dry. C’était aride, abrasif, tranchant, foutrement prometteur mais putain qu'est ce que c'était bon. Puis pour son deuxième album, la fille du Dorset qui ne voulait pas juste confirmer l’essai dans son coin de campagne anglaise, a pris un vol pour Chicago afin de s’enfermer avec l'ingénieur du son le plus intransigeant et puriste de la scène indépendante américaine : Steve Albini. Le résultat ? Rid Of Me. Quarante-huit minutes d'une violence psychologique, charnelle et sonore inouïe. Autant le dire sans détour, je lui colle un gros 4 sur 5. Car c'est un disque immense, une baffe monumentale et même si sa radicalité brute et sans concession peut en effrayer plus d'un. Pour bien piger le truc, il faut tout d'abord retourner en 1993. Le rock alternatif commence à puer le fric et la récupération des majors, le grunge devient un produit de supermarché et les chemises de bûcheron s'achètent en prêt-à-porter de luxe. Débarque alors cette Anglaise décharnée qui, sur une pochette en noir et blanc signée Maria Mochnacz, balance sa tignasse trempée dans un mouvement quasi animal, le regard noir, prête à t'égorger. Pas de maquillage baveux façon MTV, pas de pose calibrée, juste une femme, son corps, et une tension électrique prête à déborder. Ce qu'on remarque dès la première seconde, c'est cette alchimie dévastatrice entre Polly Jean et la patte Albini. Le producteur de Shellac et des Pixies ne « produit » pas au sens où les maisons de disques l'entendent ; il documente une agression sonore. Les amplis crachent, la basse grogne et la batterie sonne comme si Robert Ellis cognait directement sur votre cage thoracique au milieu d'une pièce vide. Albini applique ici à la perfection sa marque de fabrique : des dynamiques poussées dans leurs derniers retranchements. On passe d’un murmure étouffé, presque inaudible, où Polly Jean rampe sous tes draps, à une déflagration sonore qui t'explose les tympans sans crier gare. Sur le fond, Rid Of Me est une autopsie sauvage des rapports de force, de la domination masculine, de la luxure et de la vengeance où Polly Jean ne joue pas les victimes larmoyantes. Elle incarne des monstres, des furies, des obsessions toxiques. Le morceau-titre qui ouvre les hostilités donne le ton : ça démarre dans une intimité toxique et malsaine pour finir en un hurlement terrifiant où elle réclame qu'on lui lèche les jambes en feu. Sur « 50ft Queenie », elle se transforme en géante vengeresse, beuglant qu'elle fait dix mètres de haut avec une rage jubilatoire et totalement démente. Tout l'album est traversé par ces éclairs carnassiers, à l'image de « Man-Size » qui taille en pièces la prétention virile avec un sarcasme mordant. Même sa relecture du « Highway 61 Revisited » de Bob Dylan est un coup de génie pervers : elle dépouille le classique folk-rock de son flegme d'origine pour en faire une cavalcade furieuse, hystérique et complètement possédée. Alors, pourquoi ce n'est pas un 5 sur 5 absolu, me demanderez-vous ? Parce que Rid Of Me est un bloc de granit tellement abrupt et suffocant qu'il peut parfois être difficile à écouter d'une traite. L'austérité voulue par Albini, ce son presque trop sec et anti-commercial, frôle par instants l'exercice de style masochiste. C’est précisément cette intransigeance qui fait sa grandeur, mais c'est aussi ce qui le rend moins universel ou envoûtant que son successeur To Bring You My Love, où elle apprendra à marier cette fureur primitive avec une dramaturgie plus ample et théâtrale. Il n'empêche que Rid Of Me est un album majeure dans le rock des années 90. Un manifeste viscéral où PJ Harvey a démontré qu'une femme avec une guitare électrique pouvait être dix fois plus menaçante, imprévisible et viscérale que n'importe quelle bande de gars à cheveux gras. Une œuvre brute de décoffrage, éprouvante mais indispensable.
Rid of Me offers a different perspective on youthful angsty; instead of insecurity and bashfulness, it’s explosive and almost manic. “Man-Size Sextet” was the climax of this for me; it was so full of derangement and unsettling production. PJ Harvey also offers an uncomfortable dissection of sexuality. It’s not sexy, but rather it’s a means of controlling power, an outlet of obsession, and self-immolation. Two tracks that really demonstrate this are the track “Rid Of Me,” which is purely about sexual domination and humiliation, as well as “Rub It Till Bleeds”. PJ Harvey’s Rid Of Me offers one of the most energetic but messy depictions of femininity and youth. There’s a rawness on this album that’s maybe unmatched in all of music.
Day 389 Don’t know if I’m just in a good mood at the moment or what but this is the 3rd 5/5 album I’ve had in a row. This was amazing. Highlights Legs Rub til it bleeds Dry
Shocked this is my first listen. Female vocals on some heavy grunge? Sign me up. 4/5.
Raw, emotive, feminist post-punk. This is PJ Harvey unleashed by Albini's production, and the result is perhaps her strongest album. One of the great female fronted rock albums of all time, and the early introduction to one of the most interesting pop artists of the last 20 years.
Bit of a change of tone. Maybe 3.5
It's got good guitar sounds and her voice sounds pretty good too, but the style of music is too grunge for me, didn't really like any songs
I didn't like it at the time and haven't changed my opinion.
It's an emotion. Hate and vengeance flag this album
Not necessarily an easy listen: the songs are angular & challenging, but while most rock tends toward raw intensity, the cold energy of the production & Harvey's voice works for me.
I always forget how good she is. Surprised to bring you my love isn't on this list
Generally enjoyed this! "Rub 'Til It Bleeds" "50ft Queenie" "Yuri-G" and "Man-Size" were the standouts for me.
wanted to like this more than I was able to. cool vibe but honestly a bit of a slog.
Meh
Wierd one. Some of the songs were great and some were... well different. Did like the overall sound of the album buuuut this is still 2,5/5 at best. The more "heavier" songs were to my liking.
Way heavier than I was expecting. I kinda like some parts of this. 2.75
I think I would like this more on a second listen. It was interesting but none of the songs really grabbed me. It sounds pretty modern today so I bet it sounded wild in 1993.
1.75 - A few good songs. Several I hated. I expected to like this more.
Raw, somewhat atonal, noisy, but in a good way
Tough
Molto meglio di LET ENGLAND SHAKE.
Aggressively feminist and amazing for it. 50 ft Queenie indeed.
Do I like PJ Harvey because she sounds like a Gen X Patti Smith? Strong possibility!
better than I expected. certainly and obviously influential on a great many artists who would follow. very consistent but in that way also kind of boring.
not my thing awy
Very solid experimental alt rock album. Didn't 100% work for me in every song, but there are some definite standouts that made the album very enjoyable. No bad songs, but it would be better if the album was shorter. Top tracks: Missed, Rubber 'Til It Bleeds, Man-Size
I came across PJ Harvey at some point in the automatically generated stream from my music streaming service. I thought the songs of hers I heard there were great. Her voice is powerful, and the music is remarkable. This is now her second album in this project. I found parts of it pretty exhausting. I’ll definitely keep listening to PJ Harvey, but I don’t think I’ll go out of my way to listen to this album again. 3/5
Another ok album, I feel this should be my thing but I just can’t get into her stuff
Both too soft and too rock at the same time.
P J Harvey is clearly an artist whose work needs to be recognized in the list of 1001 albums I must hear before I die, but FOUR of those works? On a list that includes ZERO works by Warren Zevon?! It's not a Morrissey level of grotesque over-representation, but it's creeping that way. With that out of my system, I'll try to give this particular album the props it deserves. Its grunge-influenced rawness can still be off-putting, but that seems to be the point here. The topics Harvey is focusing on (mostly sex, love, and the casual entitlement of men) are things that often present themselves in our lives as raw and off-putting, so the writing and production seem to be right on target. But for someone like me (who may have come to it too late in life) it's the off-putting that lingers. Maybe "Man-Sized" and "50-Foot Queenie" manage to push through what can feel like a deliberate mess just for mess's sake into true emotion or insight. I really want the inspired choice to cover Dylan's "Highway 61 Revisited" to work for me, but it never quite does.
Tuff
Prob her coolest record, with the songs being held underwater and then letting them gasp for breath, focusing on the sounds of guitar pickups instead of riffs. It's not the one I reach for, but its a good one.
For reasons I don't understand, I had never listened to this album — and holy fuck, it’s fierce. PJ Harvey sounds like an absolute battle axe, self-determined and eager to punch holes in the patriarchy with lines like “I’m calling you weak,” the gender and power ambiguity of “50 Foot Queenie” and the whole “lick my legs” refrain, which flips the script on conventional sexual dynamics. Steve Albini’s production boils everything down to bone and gristle, leaving the listener feeling abraded sonically and conceptually. Fans of latter-day Harvey might be surprised to hear her sound this raw and pissed off.
This, not Tori, is what I want in a singer who is sometimes furious and sometimes alluring. Guitar will always outrank piano as an instrument of power and rage.
Enjoyment: 4/10 Replayability: 2/10 Cohesion: 5/10 Flow/Pacing: 3/10 Artistic Merit: 6/10 Weighted Average: 3.85/10 Review: This albums has a pungent raw/grungy energy that I just don't jive with. There's good tracks sprinkled throughout, but I wouldn't want to listen to the whole album again. Liked Song(s): Rub 'Til It Bleeds, 50ft Queenie, Yuri-G Disliked Song(s): Rid Of Me, Legs, Man-Size Sextet Recommend? No Heard Before? No
This went in more punk directions than I was anticipating and not mad about it.
Gladly
I was a little surprised by this one. It's much darker and grittier than I expected from PJ Harvey, and I really enjoyed most of the first half. It reminded me a lot of some of the post-rock albums that came later in the decade. The second half gets more experimental, but it still fits with the overall sound of the album rather than feeling completely out of place. Overall, this was a pleasant surprise. It took me somewhere different than I expected, and I enjoyed it more than I thought I would.
I still prefer her debut album 'Dry', but this is an incredible display of the Harvey/Ellis/Vaughan trio firing on all cylinders. A masterful display of pure, raw emotion that goes from quiet to explosive in the blink of an eye.
Ok, inte min smak. 6/10
Like it 3/5
Harvey e Albini são uma condição tão boa quanto queijo e goiabada. A fórmula é simples, mas a execução é incrível, ideal. Um álbum dinâmico, que trabalha muito bem a amplitude do volume e a intensidade vocal de PJ. Seus dotes composicionais ainda não haviam sido totalmente refinados, mas pouco importa quando você tem uma artista tão autêntica e com tanta energia vital. E é nisso que o disco te conquista. Som pesado e frenético. Faz o tempo passar rápido e é viciante de certo modo. Clássico. 4/5
close to being something i could really enjoy but idk what’s missing, maybe it’s a little diversity in instrumentation? there are some good moments though
Another PJ Harvey album?? This one was just ok for me, very 90’s but well mixed to get the soft loud soft vibe (thanks Steve Albini). No real standout hits I’d go back to.
Raw, sounds like it was recorded in the manager’s office of a 7-11
Absolutely fine and not my thing are compatible verdicts and this record earns both simultaneously. Polly Jean Harvey and Steve Albini make a predictable combination in the best sense — raw, close-miked, no reverb, no sheen, just presence and intensity in a room together. The blues foundation underneath the noise is genuine, the emotional world is real, and Harvey's voice doing things from near-whisper to full-throated howl within the same song is an instrument operating at a level the surrounding rawness doesn't always deserve. The title track makes the strongest case — quiet menace building to complete abandon over a bass line that sounds like it was recorded in a cave, one of the great opening statements of its era. Everything it promises the record delivers consistently, which is the mark of an artist who knows exactly what she's doing. Knowing exactly what you're doing and making something that generates no pull toward return visits are not mutually exclusive outcomes. A respectful three, honestly delivered — well done, not sought out, filed accurately.
RID OF ME is one of the those bare bones prototypical tedious sounding Steve Albini produced albums that just oozes 90s tropes. What works for NEVERMIND, doesn't really impress me with Polly Jean's compositions. Far too skeletal, like demos that weren't even fleshed out. While I enjoy dynamics in music the mixing of the quiets and the louds are so far apart that it makes it quite difficult to pay close attention to the album without constant fiddling with EQs and volume. Seems not so much raw, as just sloppy, in typical Steve Albini method. I much prefer PJ Harvey's later work, post Nick Cave, when she started incorporating more lush and full production ideas and really begins to actually sing and shape the expression of her vocals rather than the melodramatic howling we get one this one. Flood's production styles really are better suited to her work.
Not really my jam. Way too cacophonous
After many listens, I dont think this is very good
It feels so much like this should be something for me - it’s noisy abrasive alternative rock from the early 90s, produced by Steve Albini and held as a cousin of riot grrl work - but I don’t know, it just doesn’t click with me. There’s moments where I’m leaning forward in the metaphorical seat, but a lot of it simply isn’t jiving with me. I think part of it is Harvey’s voice and how it’s mixed, and part of it is the particulars of songwriting and music arranging and all that, but it all just feels like a question I can’t answer. We’ll see how the other PJ Harvey albums land down the line I guess.
Very cool and slick. A lot of the songs sound similar, but great album.
As if more evidence was needed that PJ Harvey is one of the best women in rock music history. The rawness and the emotion here are both amazing, taking her sound in a very different and much harsher direction compared to her already fantastic debut. It's rare for artists to actually get more aggressive as they go, but I'm so glad that she did that with this album as it gives even more depth to who she is and how that's reflected in the music she makes.
Vokal enkelhet möter punken med en krasch! Men ingen trafikolycka. Det gifter sig. Kompetent band och mästerligt låtskrivande. För mig saknas det något, svårt att säga vad ... Därför blir det bara en fyra.
I remember listening to one other album from her on this list. The one coming after this. Apparently I also listened to the first one already which didn't leave an impression. This one I didn't like however, the early 90s influences are there in full effect. Weird sounding, quiet loud quiet. Nothing I really like. The connecting factor in all the albums from this period I didn't like it's the producer, Steve Albini. I think I just don't like his production style
PJ Harvey continues to be a bit too heavy for me.
Holy hell fuck yes. This album holds a special place in my heart. Raw. Blast at full volume and get messy. 5/5
I would rather listen to you scrape your fingernails across a chalkboard.
I think this will be a 5 in the future for me. Huge riffs, huge drums, huge vocals, such raw attitude. Shoutout Steve Albini for this and in utero in the same year.
Borderline female Herm Yarl.
Good album. I don’t go back to it often tho.
Really enjoyed this album and I know I need to listen to it more often. Great music and Steve Albini recording it too? What a great sounding record.
Muy buen disco, gran voz de la Harvey y melodías poderosas llenas de coraje y rudeza. Buen disco, buenas influencias soul, en general muy sólido.
Incredible that I only find out about PJ Harvey and this album just now. I don't usually listen to albums from this list twice, let alone spend the rest of the day catching up with the rest of the artists' discography.
Meh. Not great
Favorite Track: 50ft Queenie
Might be a little bit contextual but wasn't really into this today. 4 albums of hers in the list might be a little bit too much for me but then Neil Young has apparently seven. The more I listened the less I liked it.
I’ve got give this one another listen. Definitely intriguing and drew me in on first listen. But I was more so enamored with the production more than the music. But I’m sure that was just me
This isn't the first time I've heard a PJ Harvey album through this site. But unlike the last time, this album sounds more raw and visceral, with a heavier sound. The problem here is that some tracks shouldn't be even half as long. Four-minute songs that shouldn't even be two minutes long are filled with a lot of nothing. This ruins the album experience by half. 2 stars.
1/5
Thursday, 30 July, 2026 Solid album. Nothing stood out much, but very enjoyable listen.
Weird listen while running through the KC hood
Angst-y indie rock with a sexual equality viewpoint. PJ Harvey is a master of crafting musical worlds that have an uneasy and challenging feel. The first third of the album feels very much like a break up album. With PJ Harvey expertly conveying the darker emotions of being rejected and unwanted. It is in your face and has some angry growl-y guitars. By the time we get to "Man-Size Sextet" the addition of the strings puts a crazed rage into the mix. This feels like pure rage at the inequality between men and women when relationships end. And a desire for PJ Harvey to be on the other side of this divide. On the other side of the "Man-Size Sextet" we have the manic rebound of "50ft Queenie". Which feels like manic rebuilding of a life independent of anyone. The reflection of "Man-Sized" without the strings feels like a reconsideration of the crazed thought earlier. Realising that they were right and then figuring out how to put that into everyday life. The last quarter of the album sounds like a declaration that PJ Harvey wont be treated the same way again. I think that this is probably the best musical representation of the emotional turmoil faced by women at the end of a long term relationship. I say this as a man, so I could be totally wrong. If I am, I am sorry for the misinterpretation. (4.125)
I really liked the shouty bits.
I felt there must be a very specific frame of mind that you need to be in to enjoy this. But couldn’t work out what frame of mind that is - borderline psychotic? Stoned? Being neither, I merely endured most of this. And having not found anything approaching even 3 stars by half way, I gave up.
Don't know why I never got into PJ Harvey, shoulda been a no-brainer really. Don't love everything on here but I think I'll like it more with repeat listens so four stars.
My 2nd PJH album, it’s intense! I’ll likely call it her grunge album. There are some good reviews here already, I won’t try to summarise what’s good about the album, will take me some time to process it. (Should I pause the generator and just listen to this and other PJH albums?) It will take me extra long to process Man-Size Sextet - I’m excited by its inclusion - reminds me of the version of Hyperballad that Björk did with some famous string quartet - I liked that one for its austerity, which also made it readily intelligible. Anyway, for now I’ll say this is Pretty Wonderful, 9/10 - I may give it a higher rating when I get to know as individuals the songs that I don’t yet get, which would probably get me over the feeling that “it’s a bit same-y”.
Das ist also grunge? Ist eigentlich ganz nett, weiß noch nicht ob ich alles verstehe aber klingt ganz nice
Rocking stuff. Loads of energy. Steve Albini's production is perfect for these songs. Raw and direct.
I don’t know, am I biased against these types of artists that I just don’t relate to? I guess so but that means this album is a bore to me, some of the guitar parts are interesting but I just don’t think the vocalist adds anything
Tried to listen but did not enjoy at all
was prepared to love this but it mostly just stressed me out
I can’t pretend to be cool enough for this kind of music, but this takes some dark and intriguing turns.
Quiet Loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud quiet loud
Some cool guitar and I like the rage in her voice.
This album is both good and not at the same time. Sometimes I feel like she tries a little bit too much. But also there is some quality in it. I think Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea is a much better album.
I wanted to like it much more than I actually did. Musically here and then some nice, raw tunes, but I'm not into the vocals.
Raw, aggressive, alt-rock/punk blues. There's rage and tension with haunting vocals and sublime guitar work with emotional depth. Very good album full of energy and attitude. One of her best.
I didn't listen too closely, but I think if I listened to it more I would really like it. I liked the instrumentation, the arrangements, and the rawness. Might have to come back to this one.
Really good production but I don't think the songs themselves are composed particularly memorably. Keeping things within the same key and style (loud soft interplay) often yields a bland sameness that is unfortunately the case here.
*a lot of screaming
Teški užas. Ne znam tko može ovo slušati. 1/5, 1/10
Very good discovery from this list. Loved this album a lot and I look forward to listening to the rest of her work
I like her voice. The whole album is sonically quite dark. Something I would have liked more when I was younger I think
PJ at her most Patti.
1st listen: Replace Steve Albini by Butch Vig and it would be a much more approachable and enjoyable album 2nd listen: Ah no, the recording is perfect as it is. But some of the songs are still "hard to get" 3rd listen: Yes, the beginning and end are superb, the middle part I don't get even at the 3rd listen. If the album would be: Rid of me ("don't you with you, never met her" is peak!) Missed (interesting timing, and the guitars!) Legs (especially the drums, a bit too much whining for my taste) Rub Til It Bleeds (probably just the picture of it :) 50ft Queenie (great energy) Me-Jane (again super interesting timing) Snake (not sure what she sings about, but that's what I call commitment) Ecstasy (great guitars) Then it would be 5 stars.
Not for me
Too discordant.
Qobuz selects a review for many albums and foregrounds that review on the album’s page. The review for this album made it sound like Steve Albini’s production was borderline unlistenable and an endurance test for listeners. Then I clicked play and it’s just a regular ol’ Albini album. Sounds like In Utero. Perfect.
Mauvais de chez mauvais.
C’est vraiment mieux que let England shake mais c’est pas non plus crazy
this is pj harvey's second album after her debut, dry (which i listened to in 2024). compared to that album, this album is a lot crazier. it's louder, it's more aggressive, and... well, noisy. noise rock this time around. the album was written in a mildly surreal manner, and while the lyrics can have feminist themes, harvey insists that she doesn't focus on her gender as much when she writes lyrics. is it noise rock, or is it just noisy alternative rock? i can't give you an answer. what i can say is that rid of me gets intense. the music almost boils through your headphones. it's not as accessible as a lot of other albums in the original 1001 album list, and some listeners might give this one a 3. i'm giving it a 4 because this will be the third album i've heard from her? i think? and honestly i think this style of music really works well for her. i feel her exhilarating energy with most every track. the songs were generally enjoyable to me so i can't be that nasty to it, you know?
Maybe this album would be good with someone else mixing it. Unless it's meant to be a showcase for a crunchy guitar with a neighbour woman complaining about the noise next apartment over.
I got this back to back with Iggy & The Stooges' Raw Power. I wish they'd been able to collaborate. Queen Polly Jean throws down here. Just an ocean of angst, sex, more sex, and crunchy riffs. Wonderful
I might be too square for the first half of this album. I think the second half really picked it up for me, especially the singles.
I’ve never been entirely convinced by descriptions of Rid of Me as simply “abrasive” or “confrontational”. They’re true, but they only describe the surface. Underneath all the noise is something much older. This is a blues record. Not in the sense of twelve bars or familiar licks, but in its grammar. Polly Harvey takes the language of the blues, desire, boasting, religion, sex, betrayal, bodily experience, and sets it loose in a thoroughly modern emotional landscape. It’s the language of the blues applied to love gone odd. Or perhaps better still: curdled love. Every song explores another mutation. Love becomes possession in “Rid of Me”. It becomes spiritual yearning in “Missed”. Manipulation in “Rub ‘Til It Bleeds”. Swagger in “50ft Queenie”. Obsession in “Yuri-G”. Physical domination in “Me-Jane”. By the time “Snake” arrives, desire itself has become body horror. Harvey isn’t writing about relationships ending. She’s writing about what happens when love spoils but refuses to die. Steve Albini’s recording is a huge part of why it works. The trio sounds astonishingly alive. Every sound feels deliberate yet completely in the moment. Harvey’s voice frequently disappears into the ensemble, clipped, distorted and half-buried, because it isn’t always functioning as a narrator. Sometimes it’s simply another instrument. Nobody asks what Eric Clapton is “saying” during a solo. Harvey often treats the voice in exactly the same way. The album constantly surprised me. “Missed” slips into an elegant 11/4 that never once feels mathematical. “Man-Size Sextet” suddenly abandons the band altogether for a voice and string sextet, somewhere between Bartók and Bernard Herrmann. Harvey’s reconstruction of “Highway 61 Revisited” strips away Dylan’s grin and exposes the song’s biblical grotesquery underneath. Then “Dry”, after forty minutes of deconstruction, almost sounds mainstream. I genuinely caught myself thinking, “Good Lord, she could enter Eurovision with this.” That’s less a comment on the song than on how completely the album recalibrates your ears. One phrase kept returning while I listened. Harvey’s world is full of corporeal feedback and resonances. Everything eventually becomes physical. Bodies, instruments and emotions continually set one another vibrating. Even “Ecstasy” ends up there. That huge ringing opening chord followed by the most insolent slide guitar imaginable, and suddenly “I’m in E” seems to mean ecstasy, the key of E, and being inside the guitar itself all at once. What impressed me most was how little of this feels self-conscious. The odd metres, the chamber strings, the buried vocals, the Dylan cover, none of it exists to show how clever Harvey is. Every decision serves the emotional world she’s built. By the end, I wasn’t hearing an alternative rock classic. I was hearing a feral modern blues record. Harvey takes the blues, to half-quote the album, sets it alight and sets it free.
HeadBanger.
Guess I'm not a PJ Harvey person after hearing 2 albums (but saw I gave the 2000 record a 3, odd)
"Rid Of Me" is abrasive, uncompromising, raw, and visceral in terms of both the material and the recording choices. The album strips away any semblance of commercial polish. Steve Albini’s signature recording approach captures the band in a way that feels immediate, highlighting an excellent use of dynamics both musically and vocally. A prime example of this approach is the cover of 'Highway 61 Revisited'. Harvey completely dismantles the track, leaving it almost unrecognisable compared to the Dylan original, trading its rolling blues-rock swing for a frantic, screeching energy. For whatever reason, I no longer find this album easy to listen to. When I bought it originally, upon release, I loved this album - it was firmly in 5-star territory. However, as the years have passed, my enjoyment of the record has come to depend very much on my mood. At times, I cannot play more than two or three tracks before I can't listen anymore. At other times, I listen and enjoy it, but certainly not to the extent I used to upon its original release. Its relentless, bruising nature makes it a difficult companion over the long term. Four stars. Side one 1. "Rid of Me" (5/5) 2. "Missed" (3/5) 3. "Legs" (4/5) 4. "Rub 'til It Bleeds" (4/5) 5. "Hook" (3/5) 6. "Man-Size Sextet" (3/5) Side two 7. "Highway 61 Revisited" (4/5) 8. "50ft Queenie" (5/5) 9. "Yuri-G" (4/5) 10. "Man-Size" (4/5) 11. "Dry" (5/5) 12. "Me-Jane" (4/5) 13. "Snake" (4/5) 14. "Ecstasy" (4/5) Total - 56 /70 Average - 4.0 370/1001 196/370 albums reviewed were new to me.
I should like it, but I don't.
I still feel it's not really for me, but as this is my third PJ Harvey album I feel like it's starting to grow on me. I liked the raw energy, but it still felt controlled, not transcending.
I was optimistic about this - never listened to one of her albums. I found it really rough. ok 2.5
Didn’t love it
Was a good album. Hadn’t heard PJ Harvey before, but I enjoyed it. Worth listening to.
an ALBUM
I found this album a little too raw for me today, might have been the mood i was in but I thought I LOVE it. Strong 3 from me today.
4 albums from PJ Harvey - really? That being said, I did sort of enjoy this album - I think I'm just PJ'd out! Lots of respect for her music, but I find it hard to get into (and I don't really know why, there's lots of background noise today at the studio, maybe it’s just too much!).
A name I have heard before, but no idea how it sounded. A Steve Albini production, which is a pro, and a Bob Dylan cover as a bonus. Positively surprised.
Listening to this yesterday with my daughter, couldn’t get the volume right, then the 1st track blasted out after a quiet start, she said “ what the hell are you listening to”😂 Not my favourite PJH album, but a decent listen
Not for me
I want to talk to whoever produced and mixed this album.
chaotic, unpleasant
Legs is good. Grungy, dirty guitars, nice relentless slow beat. The vocalist is quite raw. Rub 'Til it bleeds same deal. Methodical grunge. Vocals not bound by most conventions. So far, a few songs I enjoyed. Overall, it's a 3 from me dawg. Making a voice sound like scratching electric guitar strings. I'd give this singer a 5, the album as a whole concept suited to an indy demolition theatre performance a 5 for a night, as a musical album going up to 3.5 and maybe 4 with Ecstasy. She's making the human voice do incredible things. Yup, Ecstasy has that greasy dug in feeling which works wonders in 3/4 time. I have no idea ranging from 3 to 5 on this one. Gonna sit on it for a spell.
i wish i could PJ, I wish I could
Sexy fucking rock. Punk DNA of Patti Smith. Rid of Me, obviously excellent, but also Man Size and Dry standouts. Went and listened to some Nina Hagen after this one
Polly er frábær listamaður. Góður lagasmiður og þessi hráa orka er geggjuð. Albini líka alltaf góður.
This is pretty damn good. Not listened to PJ Harvey before, but really dug the tone and vibe. Really strong ending to the album, too - Snake very punchy and short, Ecstasy a climactic finish. Only criticism is there could have been a bit more variation in tone, but it's a picky one. Will definitely listen to some of these again.
It satisfied a 90s grunge itch, for sure. Not in my top 100 though.
I can see why this is a top album. Very good collection of songs. Words I’d use to describe this would be powerful, raw, and for whatever reason the word exclusive comes to mind. But in the sense that this sound is exclusively theirs. Kinda sounds like doom metal, with some blues and like midwestern emo. Great album.
Another PJ Harvey album... "yay". Looks to be our 4th on this album, and with that said I think she'll officially have the join Morrissey and Elvis Costello as the most occurring artists on this list which deserve MAX one entry. Still not understanding the deal with this lady after listening to this album. 14 songs is also way too many in my opinion to get an overview of what the album is. Especially when everything sounds sort of the same. I guess technically this could deserve some sort of 2, but going to give it a 1 out of spite.
Always when we get a PJ Harvey album (which is unreasonably often) I groan a little. It’s just music that feels too pretentious to me. However, looking back at my reviews I’ve given her a 4 and a 5 (insane right?). So maybe I will like this. I did not enjoy this. It’s not bad but it’s too grungy for me, the 90s again come and make rock music bad. The guitar tone is good and the vocals work most often, but there is just something missing. “Rid of Me” is by far the best track. I wonder if the bridge of “Maneater” with Nelly Fortado with the line “Whish you never met her at all” is a callback to nearly the same line in “Rid of me”. 2 stars.
Блюз-панк, гранж, немного "авангардов".
An amazing voice but music that I don't really enjoy unfortunately. Its to slow and kind of whiney in a lot of places for me to enjoy almost any of the songs even with the amazing voice cant comes through at a lot of places. I can definitely see what a lot of people would enjoy this but its just not for me.
nice songs sound album
Heavier and weirder than I was expecting. I enjoyed it. 3.5 rounded up
Excellent riot grrl entry from the early 90s. PJ Harvey is a total badass and this album rules.
Was only ok for me, would I listen again? Probably not
Listens: 3 Standout Tracks: Rid of Me, Rub 'Til It Bleeds, Ecstasy Truth be told, while skipping though this album to figure out which tracks were my stand out tracks, I remarked, out loud, how much all of these tracks sound the same instrumentally. There's not a ton of variety going on here. It's not bad music, but its a tad repetitive. It's sort of 48 minutes of maybe two or three different variations of the same music. It's solidly grunge music. It's okay, middle of the road grunge music.
Very raw. She has a lot of talent however the songs are a bit weak. 3 stars only.
This is by far my favorite thing PJ Harvey has done. I love how raw and uncompromised the album sounds. The guitars and drums sound so thunderous and alive. There were a couple of songs, I wasn't crazy about, but it is still all around a great album! Low 5!
Goes hard as hell. RIP Mr. Albini. Little fish or whatever still her best, I've heard, but this is what all the other "riot grrls" liz phairs etc should have been striving for though they never had a chance. No one does.
- A bit on the grungier side for my taste, but pretty good, low 3.
What is the point of this? It's an awful lot of not great noise.
I like the idea of the album with it's LoFi-elements and sparse instrumentation, but I have to listen to it more times before I give a more true rating. Also this is more of an evening album than a morning album (I always listen to my daily album in the morning, half asleep...)
Dogshit. Amateuristisch
very beautiful and raw
I am slightly familiar with PJ Harvey, having liked five of her songs on Spotify so far. Only one song is on this album, It's the one called "Rid of Me" (the title track). In addition, I also like that song she does with Nick Cave called "Henry Lee". So I'm very curious to learn more about her songs and hopefully pick up a few good nuggets. Thoughts after listening three times... I was digging the first 4 songs "Rid of Me", "Missed", "Legs", and "Rub 'Til It Bleeds" - but kinda started zoning out on most of the rest of the songs. I also liked "Dry". That's cool - I now have 4 more PJ Harvey songs in my library! Liked songs on Spotify: 5/14 Rating: 2/5
I don't need this, never missed it. Ignore. 2,7
tipično pidžejharvinski. ne mogu reći da je loše jer nipošto nije, ali nekako mi je isuviše generično i distorzijski stopljeno te zacijelo slabije od dva njezina albuma koja sam prije ovoga slušao. zbog toga albumu ne gine solidna trojka
weird art
This was perfectly serviceable. Nothing standout and nothing amazingly bad.
Polly at her angry best
Я так конкретно и не могу понять что именно мне не нравится больше всего. То ли этот надрывный вокал PJ Harvey, где песни либо нашёптываются, либо происходят вот эти распевы и постепенное повышение тона голоса. Эти завывания кажутся излишне театральными и фальшивыми и скорее раздражают. Либо аранжировки: Ощущение, что очень много полагается на монотонный бой и вот эту вот "басовость" с гулом и зацикленным ритмом. Для меня слишком уж непритязательно и скучновато. Скажете: ну прост тебе не нравится жоский женский вокал с такими же жоскими аранжировками. И будете не правы: Я очень люблю иконический вокал Ким Гордон в сочетании с таким же панково-нойзово-гранжевым звуком. Или же Juliana Hatfield на Only Everything где аранжировки тяжелы но интересны, а миленький тон голоса с ним контрастирует. В итоге, пока ты доберешься до первой действительно интересной композиции - Man-size sextet, тебя уже задолбает как это всё в целом звучит. Наиболее примечательная: Man-size sextet Оценка: мэх.. 3/5.
PJs debut Dry may have been an intense listen but at least it had some warm tones. Rid of me basically removed all the enjoyment and we are left with the musical equivalent of nails down a blackboard. The production is good, the songs are not
Great album and the real intro of PJ Harvey to the world.
This album’s so gritty I thought I was eating sand. I’ve slammed other albums on this list for lacking soul, authenticity. This album is all soul though, so much emotion in this I found it impossible not to appreciate
My third album in a third distinct decade from PJ Harvey and I can confidently say I have inadvertently witnessed the complete decline of the band in reverse. This album is energetic, grungy, heavy and varied. It's fun, dude. It's far from perfect (Man Size Sextet can fuck all the way off) but it's solid. And it's the first time I felt the band actually belonged on this list. What the hell happened Peej? Did you grow up? Did something happen between then and now? I may never know, and quite frankly, nor do I care. In the title track she belts out a repetitive mantra; "don't you don't you wish you never never met her". I know now who she was singing about. She's singing about her future self.
I wanted to like this album which had a few things going for it, but overall it just didn't work for me.
Good, but not great. Not the best by PJ.
Cool record. Unique sound, really weird in spots, some hot grooves at times. Not really my thing but I appreciate the oddness.
This is a 4.5 - the exact amount of feminine rage I needed to bring to this Monday morning.
I love her voice. This album has great vibes.
Cool.
I didn’t particularly love this, but the opening track has stayed with me for a while. I think I have heard this albums influence on a lot of other albums, so I’m thankful it’s a thing but I’m not sure how fast I’d rush back to it.
This is my 3rd PJ Harvey album in as many months, and I understand there are 4? No matter how good, I don't think any artist should get more than two (in very rare cases, at that). That said, I liked one of the former, and was pretty aggressively meh about the other. This one, I quite like. 8 appreciate the dynamics, and since that's something nobody does anymore, I was thinking there was something wrong with my headphones. No, it's just the way music is supposed to be recorded. I can't exactly pinpoint why I like this, really. It's got a very "recorded in a garage by a garage band" feel to it, which I normally don't like. Actually, there is a lot about this I wouldn't like in another album, but it works for me here. Me-Jane is probably the highlight of the album for me. Adding this to my personal collection ⭐⭐⭐.75
Oooooooh PJ Harvey!! I will always remember how big of an impact Down by the Water made on me when I first heard it. It has such a sinister sound to it. I've never heard this album before. But so far I'm liking it. I like the slow trancelike intro to the first track. I'll make you lick my injuries. Love that line. 1993 I was 14 when this album came out. This was a time in my life, when so much media was censored from me. So theres no way I would have even gotten my hands on this. The album does not sound polished. It sounds like the band is in the room with you, possibly too close, possibly holding a broken bottle. That dynamic is the point. The quiet parts are really quiet, and then the loud parts come in like violence. It’s not mixed to be comfortable; it’s mixed to make you lean in and then get punched. The whole album is full of sexual tension, anger, humiliation, control, and revenge — but it never feels like a tidy confession. It feels more like performance art dragged through blues-punk mud. Yeah this album was so dope!
Grew on me while listening. Definitely takes a bit to get on its wavelength. Grungy, heavy. Some instrumentals reminded me of Soundgarden. Uncomfortably visceral lyrics. Gross stuff, smushed in your face.
PJH is like the punk Joni Mitchell. I get their importance but it isn’t for me. Throw in a chorus every once in a while. Certainly doesn’t need 3-4 albums on this list.
4/5
PJ is feeling so many things and we are lucky that she shares those raw emotions with us in this impressive way.
Highlights: Missed 2.4
Seems fine. I didn’t really get the hype. Some solid horror esque music but Harvey’s voice gets absolutely buried in the production
music is love
Another artist I know I should carve time out to listen to but at least I’m able to address that in part through this challenge. Very much enjoyed this album.
This was my entry to Harvey's catalog when I bought the CD of this on initial release. Although I think there are other albums of hers I like more, this is still powerful stuff. The cover of Highway 61 is brilliant. 50ft Queenie is another standout.
Feels like a demo that's missing some instruments.
Rock on!
Not bad but needs a few more listens to really get it. 3/5
look at my girl she is a wow
Never been part of the hype. It’s pretty good for what it tries to achieve but unfortunately it is not my vibe.
Quite unexpected by "Man-Size Sextet".
This is brilliant. I love the give no fucks attitude.
One of those artists that people pretend to like to sound cool and hip
Je sais pas
Tough listen in parts, not too sure some of the songs were songs or just thrown on for a laugh.
DJ шляпа
By the 4th song, I was in a bad mood. This album is more suited for angry teenage girls.
Angry girl music. Not for me
Oh I really like her recent stuff from the show Bad Sisters (also great show). Grungy, raw, and it works. I dig it.
Pretty good. Sounds like 1993.
This was alright. I think I appreciated the artistry more than actually loved the music
I like the energy on this but ultimately for me it was just an album that I probably will never come back to again but no reason that I can point to
some notable highlights, but overall a forgettable and relatively harmless grunge album. 5.5/10 FAVOURITE SONGS: MISSED, HOOK, MAN-SIZE LEAST FAVOURITE SONGS: MAN-SIZE SEXTET
Finally I understand why people big PJH up! This is cool, edgy, out-there rock
Never quite got over the hump for me
Review - not a terrible album but I should really just listen to Let England Shake more Score - 5/10 Need to listen? YES
I did not expect the Hole album from yesterday to be better than PJ Harvey, but here we are. PJ Harvey has better music, this album ain't it.
Good album. Guitars and vocals are great. Definitely feel that 90s angst in the music and lyrics.
An okay album, I liked Rid Of Me and Rub Til It Bleeds the most.
definitivamente um dos álbuns já feitos no mundo... não é muito o eu estilo mas foi interessante de ouvir
Unreal Rip albini :(
Fine.
The raw energy and cynicism of Gen Xers in their youth, distilled into album form.
Didn't really stand out
Heartfelt and interesting, raw.
Raw, passionate, longing, self-hyping, grim and even dirty, this was a (somewhat psychotic) blast. Been putting PJ’s music off for ages, but i knew i’d like it, because she comes from the era (90’s) and subgroup (Jeff Buckley, Fiona Apple, Radiohead etc) that i like a ton, and i see why she’s compared to them. Can’t wait to listen to her other stuff. Standouts are rid of me, missed, highway ‘61 revisited, man-size and me-jane.
I didn't have enough time today to be critical. I don't think I hated it but wouldn't really say I loved it.
Definitely preferable to the other two records of hers that I've heard from the generator. The production is better and songcraft is better on this one. Like a hand and glove.
Not really my thing
I hadn't listened to this in maybe 15 years. I now believe my life would've been infinitely better had I kept listening to PJ Harvey.
Uwielbiam gniewne damskie brzmienie. PJ Harvey to moja nonkormistyczna idolka. Płyta jest odważna, emocjonalna, osobista i po prostu mocna. Można tego nie lubić ale trudno tego nie szanować 8/10.
Hell yeah
This album is an angry beast.
This one's real interesting! It's definitely not something I'll be hearing very frequently, but I appreciate the record as a piece of art. A lot, like, I'd be absolutely smitten to have this in my collection. I think the type of rock it aims for isn't my typical sound, because it's not frequently executed so well. I appreciate how I can feel emotion on her voice, I really appreciate how the production makes her voice mesh with the overall sound, sometimes sacrificing traditional mixing expectations. I loved hearing Dylan in the middle and having it fit perfectly with the concept. I can appreciate she doesn't see herself as a feminist, because this is just raw expression, she's just making a coherent sound that people can resonate with. And yes, maybe if you have feminist views it can be easier to appreciate some of the lyrics themselves. Honestly, I really like how when I'm not completely paying attention to the lyrics, which tends to be my default for a very generic overall listen, the music still sounds like the message. This is one of the few times I can honestly say that I'm glad I heard this before I died. 4.2/5
This website is obsessed with PJ Harvey and it makes no sense cause she’s so dreary.
2.6
She can rock
Favorite track(s): Missed, Legs, Rub 'Til It Bleeds, Hook, 50ft Queenie
First time sitting down and listening to PJ Harvey and have to say I was impressed! Sounded like Patti Smith & the Banshees even though she still had Siouxsie vibes. Super creative album and can see a lot of influence coming from this in '92. The "Highway 61 Revisited" cover was super cool & liked "Rid of Me" and "Yuri-G" the most for songs.
3 out of 5. Really middle of the road here, not bad but nothing grabbed me either. I did like how hard it went.
Some songs were good, some were quite strange.
RAW
meh
= the Beatles
Sounded very experimental. I wasn't a fan, but I'm sure it sounds great to others.
It was better than I thought and still managed to be three-chords worth of monotony. There's no way that this album is that same one as all the 4-5 star reviews.
"Dry" hit me right between the eyes- raw, aggressive, angry, tender, and above all musical. "Rid Of Me" picks that torch right up and tosses some gasoline on it.
Bad grunge
A nice variety of sounds, ranging from bluesy Southern rock, high-energy punk, and some more classic “alternative” sounds. Her voice even shifts to fit the style of each track.
Damn, this was a surprise. Hard edged and energetic and...emotionally raw? It's all working together. Some great guitar work, and the moment I felt it was getting a little same-y it switched up on me. It's one to come back to, works as an album or most any song as a one-off. Tried to get into her later stuff and it bounced off, so I never gave her a shot and it turns out I was wrong.
I can't connect with anything on this album
I’d heard the name PJ Harvey before, but to be honest I didn’t know whether it was a man or a woman :-/ Now I know, but I don’t really like the music. It’s not terrible, so I’ll give it 2 stars anyway...
29/04/2026 This is on the higher end of 3 stars. I have never heard of her and wouldn't go to her again.... but it was alright. Spotify listeners: 1.5 million
Not my thing at all. I still haven't heard a PJ Harvey song that I think is good! 1.5
Kismet - I met a woman at the gym today who had this album cover tattooed on her. It's an all timer and my favourite of PJ's albums. Pure Polly Jean-ius.
Great album and PJ Harvey was really something to listen to and see around this time. Has stood the test of time
Best Track - "Rid Of Me"
I like this iteration of PJ Harvey the best. 'Rid Of Me' is raw, abrasive, confrontational and deliberately uncomfortable, charged with sexual tension while exploring the darker side of desire, obsession and intimacy. It’s a genuinely intense listen with some great songwriting, and Steve Albini’s production takes the record to another level, really wringing out the emotion from the material.
I can appreciate PJ Harvey, and I can hear the influence she had on artists I like, but this just isn’t for me. The production and mixing also left quite a bit to be desired at times. I liked her Dylan cover, and some of the other songs were alright, but I got pretty bored near the end of it. I appreciate her talent and influence, but I didn’t vibe with this.
Brilliant, she can’t put a foot wrong.
Steve Albini rules.
It's 3.5
Not a fan
PJ Harvey has better albums
Another totally kickass cover, and with apologies for the objectification of a very cool, talented, and beautiful woman, but AWOOOGA. Anyway, it was far, far too late in life when I started really listening to PJ Harvey. I knew "Down By the Water," which I enjoyed for its immense creepiness, but hadn't done any deep dives until a few years ago. To state the obvious: she's amazing, and her catalog contains multitudes. "Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea" is probably considered her opus, and rightly so, but this one is my personal favorite. This woman can really fuckin' rock, and when she decides to just let it rip it's really incredible. The odder tracks ("Man-Size Sextet" "Snake") don't quite work as well for me as the (somewhat) straightforward punk-ish songs, but they're not bad. Also the odd, long stretches of quiet ("Ride of Me" "Snake," again) are a choice that I don't quite understand. These are pretty minor complaints are far as these things go. Best tracks: "Rid of Me" "50ft Queenie" "Yuri-G" "Dry" Weakest tracks (but still ok): "Man-Size Sextet" "Snake" "Ecstasy"
Espectacular disco, pura energia
I preferred this to the first PJ Harvey album I got. The grungy alty vibe of the album really suits her voice. The songs were pretty good and although I preferred the original the cover of highway 61 was really cool. I think I’ll come back to this album in time as I do find the length hurt it a bit as it did feel a lot longer then it was but overall a pretty good album
I did not have strong feeling for this album in either direction.
Lowkey visceral.
I wish PJ Harvey made more albums like this one. I really like the heavy, almost Grunge like sound going on here. I think it fits her well and makes for a good sounding album. The entire loud / soft dynamic that was popular is on here as well, after the first songs build up it just barrels ahead.
Not perfect, but so close. Love her voice and the raw emotion.
4/20/26. Really enjoy PJ's work. Cool to hear more of her earlier music to see how she's grown as an artist over the years, but I do prefer her later stuff. Still some gems on this one.
One of the most violent and intense albums I've ever heard. It's unlikely you'll give this one a 5 after your first listen, if you rate it that high at all. But as hard as it is to digest it, once you do, you'll be going back for more. The title-track nears an industrial sound, and 'Snake' is as disturbing as punk can be. Can't get enough of PJ Harvey's discography.
Lovely
Not bad.
She continues to be not good
no me va muy rock heavy 1/5
3.5/5
Я хочу знать, кто разозлил эту женщину. Тяжёлый, злой, сильный альбом. Но, если честно, мне совсем не понравилось. Надо послушать другие работы, в радио следом включился трек в более мелодичное исполнении из позднего альбома, вот это мне по душе.
I loved this album already. Such raw emotion and rocking sound.
Du rock qui se prend un peu au sérieux j'ai trouvé, un peu toujours pareil, j'ai préféré son autre album qui était moins rock
Pas ma came
Je suis pas dans une bonne série pcq pas fan non plus
I guess I’m a PJ Harvey fan now. 5/5
just when i needed some female rage, this masterpiece came around. thank you generator
sometimes it really does feel like this
3 stars
I have never really gotten into PJ Harvey, so I'm glad to have the opportunity to listen to this. I had Stories from the City... on CD or my iPod years ago and remember enjoying some of it but never really going beyond that. I definitely appreciate the 90s grunge/pink style on this and her whole vibe, but I don't see myself revisiting this very often. It's interesting because I really enjoy Hole and Bikini Kill and other musicians that are of somewhat of the same ilk, but something doesn't totally click with PJ Harvey for me. The cover of Highway 61 Revisited is very cool! 2.5
⭐⭐⭐⭐- Alternativ rock med punkig attityd, har ett visst grungesound. Rak mixning och produktion, rösten möjligtvis lite låg i mixningen. Tycker man lyckats få produktionen ganska tidlös, jag tänker iallafall inte på att albumet är gjort 1993. Detta var min första kontakt med PJ Harvey och det var en positiv överraskning och det kan bli intressant att lyssna på mer av hennes diskografi. Albumet är rått både textmässigt och i produktion. Jag gillar albumet i stort men det har några mellanspår (framförallt Hook) och är baktungt därför får det en svag 4a. Bäst är Man-Size sextet, Highway '61 revisited, 50ft queenie, Man-Size, Dry, Me-Jane.
Back in the CD era (and I suppose in the vinyl era too) you might end up with one album by an artist and never come across another. That happened to me with PJ Harvey and Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea. I don’t think I was aware that she was part of the alternative scene, I just thought of her as a cool songwriter that was also friends with Thom Yorke. Between those days and listening to this album now, I learned a bit more, and I had heard a number of the tracks here. And my experience was sort of the opposite of Stories, because my attention was drawn to Steve Albini’s production and the sound over the songwriting. This really is how I want “alternative” to sound, sludgy and live, and the sound almost made it a 5 for me. In the end though I think I missed some of that clarity of focus that is there with Stories… like why a cover of Highway 61? I liked both versions of “Man-Sized” but found the repetition distracting. And there were a few other moments that made me think “What is going on here?” Perhaps if I had picked up Rid of Me instead of Stores in the 90s this would be a five for me now, but I think I’ll save it for my old friend.
Strong album. Excellent guitar sound.