Reviews (page 4 of 8)
I did not like the loud to quiet shifts. None of the songs had any melody. Sounds rough and poorly mixed, unpleasant to listen to
Love the hair
i've never quite gotten the hype with this album and unfortunately still not on this album
Light 4
Was about to write this off as a “meh” representation of female-led punk from the early 90s. But her “Highway 61” cover kicked things up a notch for the second half. Rounding up from 3.5 because of that strong finish.
A few odd decisions keep this one low, in my estimation; otherwise, it’s pretty good punk.
Kind of a weird one. Seems like Iggy Pop's distant cousin, both looks-wise and musically. Some good lyrics and some good music. Don't love her singing, but I could see it growing on me. Might have even been doing so by the end of the album. 3.5*
I like a couple of the early songs in the album
Super raw! I had heard of the Steve Albini legend and the drums on this album definitely make a good case for his style. It sounds live and raw and in your face and just rocking. I had “Let England Shake” by PJ Harvey earlier in my album generator and I can’t believe this is the same artist to be honest. That was a 2/5 snoozefest and this actually rules.
Incredibly raw lyrics and aggression are palpable from this record. A masterclass in authentic songwriting
I really expected a lot of this, but I don't really connect. VERY 90's in production and vibes, so a bit too disjointed for me.
Respect, but not my thing.
3.5 - Good
It’s alright, very early 90s indie rock, with all the associated being a bit over earnest and committed vs melody. The angst and energy of the youthful cause. I can appreciate it like I did back then , but not going to say like it. 3 Star
The random number generator of this project seems kinda fucked. I got PJ Harvey’s Dry the day before today. I notice that it does this kind of a lot. I don’t really mind in this case though. I liked Dry pretty good. And Rid of Me is shaping up to be pretty solid also. Might’ve been nice to spread them out though. Oh well. I think what I like about PJ Harvey—more than the actual songwriting itself, which can be kind of hit and miss for me—is the actual sound she's getting out of her instruments. The studio production for this record is top-notch, sure, but it all sounds great together. It's a little bit weird at times (intentionally so, it seems), but her sound is big and unapologetic. To me, she expresses a ton of confidence, which probably helps when some of the songs aren't as catchy; they're still interesting. I'm not sure which record of hers I like better so far, Dry or Rid of Me. But this one is a bit more..."experimental" is maybe not the right word, but maybe "creatively less restrained"? It's a pretty solid record. 3.8/5 - rounding up
Noise, somewhat out of tune grunge rock. It's fine, but not really notable.
Has its ups and downs but I liked this on the whole.
I think 50ft Queenie is the only PJ Harvey song I knew before, not just from this album but in general. I don't know, I can't get super into PJ. The songs have good energy, and there's some good guitar and drumming going on, but as songs they don't hook me.
Considered giving this a 5, but decided to grade on PJ Harvey curve, and there are definitely some other of her albums that I like more. Still this is like a 4.75 rating. It's probably her most raw sounding album (and Inappreciate that), which may have to do with Albini producing it.
When you’re 21 & reeling from your first break up, this album (plus Sleater Kinney’s Hot Rock) are what help get you through.
I love the raw angry loudness of this album. If I had been an angsty teenager in the 1990s, I would have easily identified with release. Unfortunately, I was not an angsty teenager in the 90s. Instead, I *knew of* PJ Harvey, but knew very little of her music outside of a track on the "Batman Forever" soundtrack. This was enjoyable.
This was ok 90's alt rock. I'm not sure why she's so heavily represented on this list though. One album would have been more than enough.
wasnt keen, the drumming was diabolical it sounded like a kid with knitting needles on the furniture. She tried bless her
I somehow like and dislike it at the same time. It's simultaneously rock and artsy bollocks. Her vocal style is bizarre, but I quite like how it's quiet one second then BANG BANG BANG the next. A bit too 90s maybe, but kind of appealing to my blatant undiagnosed neurodivergence. "Hey, you're starting to drift away from focusing on this, aren't you? HAHA NOW YOU'RE NOT! LISTEN TO MEEEEE! LOOOOUUUUUD!" Is this another where I need to try again on drugs? I say that evey 25 albums or so, but I promise I don't have a habit. I feel like I probably won't listen to it again. I think I'm fine with having experienced it. Confusion. That's what this album is.
Geius
First listen
The British version of Sonic Youth? Eh.
There's something pretty raw about this album. I liked that that "raw-ness" was in both the lyrics and the in the instrumentation. It caught my interest enough that I'd like to really sit down and listen while completely focusing on the album to be able to take it all in.
I’m torn on this one. It sounds like a garage or dive bar band just letting loose. If I heard this live at some small venue, I’d probably be totally into it. But as a sit-down listen, it’s a bit harder to connect with. It's more of a “right vibe, right moment” kind of album for me. Her vocals remind me a bit of Patti Smith. I respect the album a lot for what it is, even if I’m not sure it’s something I’d put on again anytime soon.
I definitely prefer her debut album more than this one. A lot of similar things going from song to song on this album. Baffled why they would have a sextet version of a song and a rock version on the same album. Also, Legs just intentionally having an out of tune guitar hurt my soul. It was raw, experimental, and unapologetic. Ultimately, it wasn't for me.
Such a solid album.
PJ is such an interesting and talented musician. I love that her songs inspire thought and reflection. Really good album. The only thing that might improve it is some more variety in the track listing with style and tempo. 4/5
Good. But kind of crazy that this is my second PJ Harvey rec in the first 10 days of this project.
Not a fan.
This may be ok but I just don't enjoy this music. Would never seek to listen and would likely turn most of these songs off if I heard them again. 2.5 but I can't round up.
Good album.
Saw PJ this year and she's just as good live as she was back then
Lovely stuff
V good album
Excellent (4.5)
Pj Harvey is the queen and I'll forgive her for supporting fox hunting
Fuckin great stuff, made me want to punch the sky
Nope
Interesting one. I can't say I love Harvey's voice, there's a lot of deep talk-singing and jarring falsetto, but it is sort of captivating. I like the transitions between the open, loud, chugging guitar and drums to the quiet palm-muted riffs almost like you're waiting for the songs to pounce on you out from the dark. I also love off-beat instruments and you'll hear things like snare hits and vocals swerve off the main path quite a bit on this album. Shout out to the fuzzy bass. Makes for a cool sound. Some of this actually is reminiscent to me of early Tool. The guitar sounds great on this album. Standouts were "Missed" "Rub 'Till It Bleeds" and "50ft Queenie." The Dylan cover was kinda cool. I hope Harvey sought out therapy after this album. Or perhaps recording this was the therapy? Either way, it's dark and gritty and raw and I kinda love it. It's a strong 4/5 for me, I don't love the vocals all the time but this album has such a cool sound, it's really close to a 5.
Kinda reminds me of Tom Waits. Also pretty grunge-y. Sure sounds like 1993. Doesn't resonate with me -- partly because the lo-fi recording sounds a little raw. Normally that's my jam but this is a but unfinished-feeling. On the other hand, if you were an alt listener in '93 and were sick of the testosterone and mediocrity of the Afghan Whigs, this would be the perfect antidote. This works better for me when it's heavier (usually true of grunge and garage). I don't love the textures they picked but it feels very DIY. 'Rub It 'Til It Bleeds', '50ft Queenie' and 'Me-Jane' all landed for me (plus the loose Dylan cover) and I can hear just what folks like about Harvey. There weren't many prominent women in this genre and her presence is vital and noteworthy (as is her Englishness, in a highly American grunge wave). Well worth anyone's time: this is a pretty singular voice with what seems like a clear vision. It didn't blow my hair back but maybe it'll be your favourite thing! An album like a plate of good olives. Another 4/5 because it's mostly not for me but I'm pretty sure it's for someone out there!
PJ Puf N’ Stuf. Back with the FOURTH PJ Harvey record and jr happens to be some early work. Long before the days of the big city dreamer, we had a rocker on our hands. I have already enjoyed some stuff from this album, so I’m looking forward to it. Out of the city, into the bathtub. Rid of Me - Got a good early 90’s rock song here with the classic insanity vocals. I don’t know if they’re classic, but they are HARROWING. And I don’t mean ploughing a field with a disc harrow. Missed - Hmmm. Yeah this one was a MISS. Everything is getting real boring. Legs - Sing it Kermit style. That riff rumbles pretty good, but yeah those vocals are silly. I like when she gets more unhinged. Fewer kermit affectations, more inconsolable caterwauling. Rub It ‘Til it Bleeds - Gross. Both in the title and the grimy, disgusting track that this turns out to be. Who thought that in 7 years, all this passion would be gone. Hook - The real pop fans rejoice for the hook! Oh, wait no. Avert your ears my fragile music haters! Man-Size Sextet - This one is uhh weird. I remember the first time I went to Scotland and saw “Man-Size” tissues. What the hell is that all about? Much like this song, I am left bewildered and amused and ensnared in the maw of an orchestral cacophony. Well maybe not that last part. Highway ‘61 Revisited - Can somebody do a whole album through a 90’s landline? I’m sure it’s been done. Never mind. 50ft Queenie - HELL yeah. This song rips. Yuri-G - Forgettable tune. Man-Size - Have I been punked by a remastered edition or something again? Whatever. I wrote a big opus about how much I hate changing the track order on subsequent releases of records. It’s like changing the ending to classic literature. Whatever. Decent song, preferred the inclusion of the sextet. Dry - Kermit hath returned. And I was wrong about the song order changing. She’s just quirky. Decent song. I probably need to dive into the lyrics more. Me-Jane - Me side character Big Ape Man. Me like banana. Snake - Man, she fucking gets the fast songs. They get me AMPED. Ecstasy - Nice close. This is so heavy for what it is. Think of the general perception of PJ Harvey and the rest of her output. I knew a few of the tracks going in, but it borders on sludge at points. There are blistering fast passages and just dismal lows that are so filled with hatred that I can’t help but love them. I think if you had to limit this list to one album per artist (I know - how would we survive without 16 Bowie albums?) this has to be the PJ Harvey one. But then, I simply don’t live in a walkable community, so I don’t get the New York one. This is a good record. Challenginng, but worth the obstacles it places in front of the listener. 3.5 HIGHLIGHTS: Legs, Rub It ‘Til it Bleeds, Man-Size Sextet, 50ft Queenie, Snake
Really wasn’t into the first half but the latter was pretty good
Solid. One of the songs had me convinced my headphones were broken
Her second album. Rock / Indie. Raw, emotional and, I think, most important of all l, authentic. The album is produced really well. Rid Of Me is a nice juxtaposition of whispered and in your face vocals. Rub 'Til It Bleeds is a really good track. I also like 50ft Queenie. Yeah, a good album.
I liked this more than dry but that could be because I knew what to expect this time
I have to be in the right mood and then I appreciate her.
Interesting! Not my vibe but interesting
…in which she buries him and spits on his grave
ihres letste womer gha hend hani easy langwilig gfunde. das isch viel früener viel grungiger. viel meh edge. mags sehr. gad legs hani seehr cool gfunde. find wie sie singt (so de kermit mengmol) au streng zum lose. ahaa es isch steve albini. das macht sinn. rub til it bleeds isch immer chli s glich aber s tönt au recht cool. de sextet shit checki sogar dasch no nice für so experimentelle scheiss. uh dylan cover? han glaub s original vlt eimol glost weiss nume dass es album highway 61 revisited heisst. aber cover slappt no. man-size coole titel. aber sie renntmer langsam devo. dry tönt seehr cool. allgemein ischs sehr grunge, rock bluesy mit steve albini-hässig production. finds recht cool. het mi etz au nüt us de socke ghaue aber ich glaub es isch au nöd 1993.
PYJAMA HARLEY ihres album usem 2000 hetmer ja leider nöd vill geh teilwiis het mich ihri stimm gad ah the yeah yeah yeahs erinneret damn vill herter alsi denkt hett rid of me hani jz nöd crazy gfunde aber es het öppis unhingeds wommer na gfalle het hahah missed nimmt denn s tempo wieder usse, es tönt chli leer? legs to! ok weniger, chli meh grunge ohh drums mached sache rub till it bleeds baut uuf und...wett en explosive moment haa aber schaffts zumindest bi mier nöd gross öppis uuszlöse, ah sich na cool aber s hittet nöd so wies glaub sött man-size sextet isch ja uultra unagnehm, aber dur das halt no cool, forderet chli usse me-jane isch GEIL mitem 6/8 oder was es au immer genau isch, s hetmi chli ad arctic monkeys erinneret (eifach sehr vill weniger sheffield) snake au geiil unhinged hahaha hetts gern lieber gha als ichs effektiv han, s het immer wieder recht rohi und au kreativi sache gha aber es het wenig in mier uusglöst, sorry pj, vlt bin ichs problem :( es isch aber definitiv intressanter gsi als s andere album yey!
Raw, angry and full of grunge. This is a noisy, aggressive album that screams at you for 47 minutes. The production is extremely down to earth, and not hugely polished, making it feel like you're listening to a live gig in an indie music venue. All this makes for a strong listen and an accomplished record, albeit one that leaves you emotionally drained by the end. 4 out of 5.
Third PJ Harvey album now. None dud much for me but this was a bit raw-er. Liked it slightly more than I expected to
Not bad for a girl
I really only know PJ Harvey's more recent stuff which I do enjoy. Loved this more raw sound, I should have listened to this far sooner. 4.5/5
7.5/10
The Albini production makes it sound samey to other bands he's produced.
This is the second 1993 Grrrl rock album of the week and i take it back, THIS is the one all the lesbians should have been drooling over
soft/loud, Hole, Albini Rid of me Hook Man size Me Jane
Rock is the right expression for this. I'm not sure I understood who PJ Harvey was, but this is not really what I expected. Pearl Jam, Led Zepellin, quite heavy going in spots. Not in a bad way really just surprising.
Un rollercoster di emozioni e stile. Bello
I’m pretty sick today so I’m Gonna keep it brief. First song okay, missed is 5/5. I like this whole thing really. I get why they and queens were sold as a combo deal so often. A lot of cool time signature stuff. Tops: missed, rub til it bleeds, man sized sextet,
I think this is my 3rd PJ album. Solid album but I'm a bit jet lagged so I'm not in the right frame of mind for a proper listen.
First time listening to this artist. Grunge Did not like, very shit
Good 7.7
Raw, emotion hooks from the beginning. Album feels live. Fizzles in the latter half. Still enough here to warrant coming back. 3/5
An interesting listen - an attribute that seems exceedingly rare on this list. Points for originality. Can't say I enjoyed it, but it didn't bore me, and that's gotta be rewarded.
Heard it before. Oh Polly Jean, how I love you. I adore this album but I've always had one major gripe with it. And it saddens me to say it because I love the guy's music: Steve Albini buried PJ's vocals in the mix so hard that you can barely hear her on some songs 4/5
I like this, I think it would be awesome to see live.
For the amount of albums this person has, I really thought this could be something enjoyable. It was not. None of the songs on this album are in their top songs on Spotify so I check which songs are the best by PJ Harvey and Rid of me was one of the top answers. It was too quiet and then suddenly too loud. Now I generally like a song that does that (I had a feeling that it would) but this was not enjoyable at all. The whole album felt like how people mock the vocals for 90s alt grunge female artists. Maybe this is the inspiration.
Didn't like it.
A raw and ripping emotional workout. Feels like PJs most personal record; incisive, gutsy and cathartic. Love her shredding on the slide.
I liked this better than the other PJ Harvey album, but it's just not my favorite type of music. I could listen to one or two songs and sorta jam to it, but after a bit, the screamy vocals and abrasive guitar just makes me want to turn it off
Tough one to rate. The title track is amazing and absolutely floored me, probably my favorite single song I've heard from her so far. Even more dark and unhinged than her debut and I was ready to like this album even more. The second song is really good with an almost Midwest emo-like guitar pattern to start. However, nothing really super grabbed or stuck out to me in most of the rest of the album, despite liking some of the tone and energy. The drumming is still great, even heavier guitars, more contrast in the quiet/loud sections, production is pretty raw (thanks Steve Albini), but maybe the songwriting just isn't as good (or at least didn't speak to me as much)? Dylan cover is kinda cool, I liked especially the vocals on Me-Jane as well. Overall a step down from Dry for me.
It‘s pj harvey, our queen, but it‘s not one of her masterpieces
Ok fuck no. Nono, not listening to this voluntarily.
I love interesting, confident women. And I love the punk rock approach - strip it down, say it honestly, and play it with passion. To me this album sets PJ in a regal line - Patti Smith, Debbie Harry, Chrissie Hynde, Kim Deal, Karen O, Karla Chubb (apologies to all of the divine misfits I'm momentarily forgetting). And it adds a healthy dose of "I don't give a shit what the suits want this is how I hear it in my head" ala Fiona Apple.
Really cool and unique album. Great song diversity and nice angsty tone
Overall: 8/10 PJ has become one of my favourite artists lately. Her voice is just incredible and I love how she's able to paint a picture of her experiences through her lyrics. I think this album takes a bit of time to get going but the second half is perfect. Fav Song: 50ft Queenie
Good early 90s alternative rock by PJ Harvey, although I preferred Stories from the city....and Let England Shake to this album. 3+ stars.
Jeg vil virkelig like PJ Harvey, altså. Jeg vil det. Men dette var ganske bråkete og skranglete. Kanskje dette er et på-vei-til-jobb album, men et soundtrack for noe annet.
Goat
Raw vocals/guitars/drums, some dissonant strings mixed in
Gostei ao ponto de ser bom mas não extraordinário que despertasse emoções... me lembra a trilha sonora de um filme de ação, um sentimento de algo virgem mas não inocente, algo agradável mas também barulhento. As canções se mostraram muito fluidas, sem cortes ou maquiadas... isso é impactante e muito legal ao meu ver
This was really close to a 5. Loved the noise. I will def be checking more of her stuff out and coming back to this one. 4.5/5
I liked a lot of the elements from this LP. PJ sounds maniacal and unstable which makes the lyrics an interesting listen. To go with that, the raw, thrashy production (most notably the drums) complements this perfectly and makes for a really good album. 8/10
As always, PJ delivers.
Pretty cool somewhat old-school rock album, I liked it.
first listen meh
I do not like this. This just feels like generic garage rock. Top track: “Rid of Me” (I guess)
I've never heard of PJ Harvey, which is clearly on me. It's really interesting! Grungy as fuck, raw as hell, very fun, if aggressive sounding.
--Rid of Me...grungy but a little boring. the very end gets interesting --Missed...a 3 minute song squeezed into 4.5 minutes --Legs...I like the rawness but something's still off. It's maybe too slow? I need more of a kick --Rub 'Till It Bleeds...takes a while to get going but it ultimately rocks. I feel like the drumming on this album could be more assertive or slightly more complicated. She could use a Grohl-type back there --Hook...uh, where are the hooks? --Man-Size Sextet...it's certainly different --Highway '61 Revisited...good cover. feels like a full band effort and it works --50ft Queenie...here we go. more uptempo stuff like this, please --Yuri-G...good groove. the tracks that she keeps under 4 minutes are more focused. interesting how that works --Man-Size...definitely digging the back half over the front --Dry...we bring back the sluggishness of the opening tracks --Me-Jane...chaotic but it works. loud/quiet/loud stuff --Snake...is the snake a penis? --Ecstasy...an overlong closer on an overlong album
Didnt really care for it
Much heavier and darker than the PJ Harvey I'm familiar with in the later 90's and 2000s. Overall a 3 but not something I'll really come back to.
Man-Size Sextet is fantastic, but truth be told I would be more interested in listening to the strings by themselves. There are a few bits and pieces beyond the sexted that I enjoyed, but by and large this wasn't for me. The final three tracks were much more enjoyable than all the rest of the album, save Man-Size Sextet. 3 stars
I tried.. I really tried because everyone thinks this is a masterpiece. It has good elements, but for the most part I was just tired after every song. I just couldn't make it through the whole thing. 2.49 / 5 stars, I couldn't give it 3... it's just too exhausting.
Couldn't completely get into the music. Wasn't bad, just not my usual.
Cool production and some stuff that I like ok in here. Just a little too annoying for my tastes
Composition 5 Sound Design 6 Performance 7 Cohesion / Flow 5 Fun Factor 4 Pretty boring sounding grunge / punk adjacent affair, very Nirvana vibes but without the lyricism that makes Nirvana stand out.
Major grunge girl vibes.
The instrumental structure of the songs had a grit to them that was like sandpaper to my brain (a good thing), but that was all that I liked about it.
PJ Harvey’s songs on Rid of Me are a microcosm of the album itself. Each song tends to build before erupting into a fiery maelstrom, only to return back to its droning build around its acoustic caldera. The album, similarly, takes a turn half way through, only to return to its earlier roots. While I appreciated the Bob Dylan cover, this 90’s album will not be a repeat listen for me, even though it was enjoyable.
Honestly solid album, PJ Harvey is one of the best female rock singers in the 90s.
This was surprising given previous albums of hers I'd listened to. Much more aggressive and raw sounding.
Gear: HEDD Audio HEDDphone Two Artwork: 😏🛁📸 Production: 🔊🔈🫶 Music: 🥩💔✋ Rating: 🦵🦵🦵(🦵)/5
Kinda sounds like when my wife gave birth.
Rating: 6/10 I really respect the experimental nature of this, even though a lot of did not really click for me. Will definitely listen to again though, this intrigues me.
I don't know why, but I've never really listened to PJ Harvey, but I do enjoy this a fair bit. I might listen to this again.
Yay
This one went harder than the other ones. Pretty gud Will I listen to again: 99%
Heard the name not the music but I enjoyed this. Angry early 90s indie
I thoroughly enjoyed this album. PJ Harvey's energy comes through and I particularly liked the first song starting soft and then going hard out of no where. It set the tone for the rest of the album.
She has a voice like Bjork meets Courtney Love. It's punchy and punk but it's also a bit boring too at times. A bit samey and I can't bsee me listening much to this again.
Edgy != good
When this came out, I remember reading in the music press how scary and intense it was. However, as a 15-year-old girl in 1993, I found the unapologetic rawness so exhilarating. Even today, when I got to 50ft Queenie, 47-year-old me was lip syncing along while adopting a power stance in the living room. This was just such a formative album for me and I love it.
3.5
Bedre end Dry, ikke lige så god som Let England Shake. Endnu en banger
En af de bedste grungeplader!
Really nice
Allora prima voce femminile in questa classifica e assolutamente apprezzata. Non conoscevo però alcune canzoni come rid of me sono delle chicche
Strongly influenced by the dynamics of the pixies but not hitting the spot to the same degree. Good but not brilliant.
This is some lesbian rock.
This is an album that needs repeated listens for me because I KNOW for a fact that there's so much to dig out but I can't do it yet. The only reason I'm giving it 3 stars is because I know it's not bad, in fact it's been highly lauded, and I absolutely ADORE Albinos production on this, but it hasn't clicked for me. Maybe one day it will. Mad respect to PJ Harvey tho, ill keep trying I swear
Why is this album so quiet? Ah, there it is. What awful mixing for actual listening. Who uses dynamic range like that? Also the song is awful. How is this the 153rd best album Rolling Stone's heard? That list must be as bad as this one. Maybe they rated this album when they were feeling particularly emo. Have these guys heard of music? Pretty sure it's not whatever this is. This is a 1.
Punk and avant garde. Not something I’d reach to toss on the record player but a good fit for this list. Unique, artistic, and a good one-off listen. The opening track jump-scare got me good. Every piece of this album felt deliberate, even if it was challenging at times.
"woohoo my band and I can make some noise"
Wow, this album was bursting at the seams with angst and rage. Her raw vocals paired with the ear-pleasing guitar and drums made for an energetic listen. The production complemented the raw, grungey nature of the album. would listen again in a heartbeat!
You Crawled Between My Legs 1001 Albums Generator 111 (09/04/2025) This album is so cool. PJ Harvey and her trio of musicians who had released one album together previously came together with producer Steve Albini to make Rid Of Me, an aggressive, feminine take on punk and alt rock. The opening track opens with a really quiet build that explodes into a great chorus. Missed is by far my favorite song, with angular, strange guitar and odd time signatures. I saw this song get compared with Slint and I think it's an apt comparison. While the first half of Rid Of Me largely feels like a pot of anger coming to a boil, 50ft Queenie kicks off the more concentrated anger of the second half, and it is fantastic. Seriously, every song from 50ft to the closing Ecstasy is fucking great. Dry is almost poppy, but still has its grit. I will call out Snake as well as a great distillation of anger into a 1.5 minute piece of punk. This album is seriously alomst perfect, with my only qualms being with a couple songs on the first half that don't stand out to me as much. PJ Harvey should certainly be seen as one of the best women in rock music based on the quality on display here. 4.5/5, rounded down to a 4. Favs: Missed 50ft Queenie Snake Least Fav: Man-Size Sextet
Troisième album proposé après 'Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea' que j'avais plutôt apprécié (noté 3/5) et 'Let England Shake' qui m'avait déçu (2/5). Ce nouvel album présente un son plus agressif que les précédents. L'accompagnement est parfois inattendu ('Man-Size Sextet' et ses cordes), sinon c'est le classique guitare (saturée) / basse / batterie. La structure des morceaux est en plus plutôt originale, pas trop standard. A ré-écouter donc ! =>3/5
Grungey pop punk. It was okay, just a little flat.
Art is subjective, yes, and my subjective experience of this album was one of great discomfort and distaste. The instrumental structure of the songs are fine, maybe even good sometimes, but this is completely overshadowed by the unbearably whiny and simply terrible vocal performance. Most songs lack a melody entirely, and the artist is nearly impossible to understand. I couldn't sit through a single song in its entirety. I have a hard time believing that abstract projects have any real influence on the music industry aside from showing future artists what not to do.
Tried to find the 5 star rating in this but it just seems so unbalanced.
There were parts of this I really liked, but then she would ruin it with her voice.
She does rock quite hard, and seems to have a good time, but the last half is juist not for me at all. Too punk for my tastes
I will never understand why music critics fellate PJ Harvey albums the way they do. If some British dude put this out he would be labeled a wanker. Good thing this list is insisting on shoving PJ Harvey down your ear holes 4 times with 4 albums. YAY!
3.5/5
She can’t sing and the instrumentals are nearly as intricate and complex as an AC/DC album. I can think of any number of teen garage bands that sound better than her.
Albums like this beg for a zero or negative stars rating. I find it inconceivable that anyone has this crap on their playlists.
I thought this was a pretty solid early 90s alternative/punk/grunge album.
Not my genre but it looks like it was very popular somewhere.
Not my cup of tea
Favorites: Rub 'Till It Bleeds, 50ft Queenie, Ecstacy The second PJ Harvey album on this list so far is, in my opinion, better than the first (Stories From the City, Stories From the Sea). I really enjoyed how raw and angsty this album is, makes it feel much more personal to PJ and I felt like I was really engaged with it more. 8.5/10
Конкретно этот альбом мне не супер, по отдельности буквально 1-2 песни зашли, но прикольный тембр и прикольно, что какие-то песни как будто для театра написаны, а какие-то совсем контрастные
I know it’s supposed to be amazing, but I just could not get into it. Not for me.
An amazing album, honestly at first I thought it's pretty close to In Utero, but by the end I guess not. Nevertheless I loved the sound of it. I find albini's production to be a little inconsistent throughout the album, but it still manages to capture the essence of each song. Did not pay that much attention to the lyrics, but what i heard was pretty damn good. So I think this is either a stroooong 4 or a low 5. I think after first listen I'm gonna give it a 4, but I JUST might change it later
Love it - Quiet, Loud, Quiet. Raw
Album 876 of 1089 PJ Harvey - Rid Of Me (1993) I enjoyed this one a lot. She absolutely rocks - the tunes, the raw attitude, the sheer talent all shine through here. What struck me most is how she balances power and vulnerability at the same time. The songs hit hard, but they never feel forced. A big part of that edge comes from Steve Albini’s production, which keeps everything raw, jagged, and in-your-face while still letting PJ’s voice cut through. It feels almost live, like you’re in the room with the band. PJ Harvey is just one of many awesome female rockers I’ve been glad to discover (or rediscover) through this project, and she makes a strong case for being near the top of that list. Albums like this remind me how much presence and personality can carry music. Definitely one I’ll come back to.
Lots of screaming and distortion pedals but I don’t hate it. Add this to the pile of stuff I like because it sounds like everything else I liked from my teenage years.
A crash out play list
Its good some songs are grating but i think thats the point
Love Polly Jean, this was a banger.
Rid of Me – PJ Harvey (1993) | Alternative Rock / Noise Rock | Avg: 5.38 | Favorite Song: “Rub ‘Til It Bleeds”* Rid of Me is a brutal, jagged listen. My personal score reflects just how abrasive and uneven the experience can be. “Rub ‘Til It Bleeds” stands out as the one moment where PJ Harvey’s raw intensity feels locked-in and purposeful, rather than overwhelming. Elsewhere, the album veers between chaotic and disjointed, with several tracks landing in the 4 to 5 range. There’s definitely a daring edge here, but it’s not always the kind that invites repeat listens. That said, the album isn’t without merit. When the production clears enough space for the songwriting to breathe—like in “Man-Size Sextet” or “50ft Queenie”—there are glimpses of something more impactful. But overall, the project often feels like it’s prioritizing shock and rawness over structure or replay value. It’s aggressive, confrontational, and emotionally charged, but not always in a way that rewards you for sticking around. For fans of primal catharsis, it might be gold—for everyone else, it’s a tough ride.
1/5
Incredibly melodramatic and grungey. I’ve never liked PJ Harvey and this album has done nothing to change that. What was it about this thread of 90s rock music that took itself so seriously? Harvey murdered that Dylan cover as well. Drums sound good though.
Always so this and thought I would like and I do. Not sure if my fav of hers but in the debate with songs from the city
Make PJ Angry Again
Similarly to yesterday's Sonic Youth, PJ Harvey is another artist that I've gotten to form my opinion on more and more over the numerous albums she has on the list. She has 4, which is a little high in my opinion. I'd cut it down to like 2 or something. She's good and I think it's important to represent women in regards to the development of 90s indie/alt-rock, but I also feel like 4 albums is a lot for an artist like her. How do I feel about her at large? Well, I've enjoyed everything I've heard of hers, but I can't call any of it a masterpiece. I mean, even Sonic Youth had Daydream Nation. PJ Harvey is just solid and not much more in my eyes. This rings true for my last album of hers, Rid of Me. This is her most acclaimed album in many ways. Really? I don't know, I feel like she's made better. I'm not as big on this one as I thought I'd be. Rid of Me is good, quite good actually. The songwriting is certainly emotive. The instrumentation has some cool moments. There's some good songs. However, I'm not huge on everything here. For one, this album shows off Steve Albini's production at its absolute Albiniest. It's honestly a little hard to listen to at times. Even within his production discography, the production of Rid of Me makes In Utero seem clean by comparison. I can see someone really vibing with the production, but I wouldn't say that that person is me. I said some songs were good, with the title track, "Missed," and "50ft Queenie" being highlights, but others aren't for me. I really didn't care for "Man-Size Sextet." Maybe this was her best album at release. It might be better than Dry, but I haven't heard that album in a while so I can't really confirm. I think she's done better since this though. I definitely preferred Stories From the City, Stories From the Sea and even Let England Shake. Do I just prefer her later work? I don't know. All I know is that I like but don't love PJ Harvey in general. This album's good, but I think it's a little overrated. It's kind of in that Yankee Hotel Foxtrot territory for me where I get the appeal and enjoy the album, but I strongly prefer other albums over it. I think at this point I prefer YHF, but Rid of Me is still a good album. Light 4/5.
Genre: Alternative Rock Heavy, loud, and full of great energy, Rid of Me is not the sort of album I usually gravitate towards, but I did enjoy it. I feel like the mixing is weird, though. I can barely hear PJ on some of the tracks unless she’s really going for it. Probably won’t revisit this, but it didn’t offend me very much at all, either. 50ft Queenie was great! 3/5
I want to like this but I just don't. Minimalist arrangements and an antagonistic style throughout, daring you to admit you aren't enjoying the experience of listening to this. I will.
PJ is very hit and miss with me. She has a few songs I really like. I think I like the attitude and idea of her efforts more than the end product in most cases. 2.5/5
I imagine my younger angst-ridden 90s self would like this more, but I just never quite understood the appeal of PJ. I’ve given her catalog a fair amount of listen and it never hit home for me. This might be her 3rd album received on this exercise and again nothing really stands out. I know this album particularly received a lot of praise and is probably the best representation of music style being portrayed as it should due to the raw edgy production style of Steve Albini. And I can also appreciate the band’s musical abilities mixed with unpredictable time signatures, arrangements, etc. But in the end, it’s not enough for me to revisit.
I’m starting to think this whole exercise can S my D. Our 3rd PJ Harvey album? You’re telling me 0.3% of the albums I should listen to are from this crazy chick? Come on man! Oh shit… is there more coming??? I looked back and I hated London Shakes. Stories I was apparently okay with. I don’t remember either and maybe I’ll need to go back and listen. With that said, I came into this with an open mind. First two songs I thought we might have something here. Sure, a little raw and unique but I liked it. Legs is where it seems PJ forgot people have to listen to this. Something she seems to do quite often. What the eff is Man Size Sextet? But there were moments where the whole band hits a groove that were absolutely great. Gotta give credit. And by “S my D” I meant “Solve my Dislike”
We’re now 75% through the PJ Harvey experience of this 1001 album challenge and I can confidently say… it’s not me, it’s her. Just can’t get into her stuff and think it mostly has to do with her vocals. I know some enjoy the raw sound, but it's not for me. I think her backing band is pretty awesome on this album, though. I’m rounding up for them. 2.5/5
More bland, garage-style UK punk. Awesome... Ok this actually improved as I went on. Still doesn't have quite enough to get to a 3, but the least I can give it is a High 2.
Not sure what I expected, but this is decidedly rougher in tone than what I had in mind. Doesn't help that the album artwork for some reason had me thinking this was going to be some warehouse electronica from the UK... Love the roughness of the cut throughout and found this to be a generally satisfying record to listen to. Lots of deep toned-down bass, sludgy tempo play, and satisfyingly minor guitar. Stuff like this is comfort food to me. Only song that jumps out as notably out of character with the rest of the album is "Man-Size Sextet" with its horror-film evoking strings. Otherwise, I loved the rough edges on Missed and Rub it Til' it Bleeds is great. Add to that, the instrumentals on Dry remind me of a Better than Ezra song I can't place. Overall makes for a solid record to close the week on. High 4 edging on 5.
Sludgy 😩😩😩 music
Sounds like she recorded this playing in the basement of a dive bar. Definitely worked for the grunginess of this album. Song songs were good but for me mostly were hard listening to the style of music. Need to know where I know a cover of Man-Size but I can't find it anywhere. Really low 3 but better than a 2
I really liked the first PJ album we got. Second one was solid enough. Man-Size Sextet is scary! Interesting cover of Highway 61 Revisted. Still prefer the OG but not a bad take. Me-Jane rules. That bassline is sick. This album had it's ups and downs for me. Nothing crazy special but definitely interesting. Still didn't like it as much as Stories and for that it gets a high 3.
I love so much of PJ Harvey but this is an album that sounds better in theory than execution Just a hard to enjoy listen
Literally the blueprint for everything I want to be as an artist, love her and this record so much
Great album slightly let down by the usual Albini production issues.
I very much like the work of the trio on this and I have enjoyed Ms. Harvey as a vocalist on subsequent albums, but on this disc she seems a bit over the edge.
At her grungiest. Raw and unpolished but it all works
2/10… alternative rock / 90‘s indie
Sonido sucio, interesante.
3.5
Ho hum…hum.
Cool, weird, love it
I feel this is the start of grunge.
It has some good tracks and sounds great. Don't think I would need a copy of it.
No thanks
Not quite
Not for me this one
Interesting. Mostly fine with a few duds.
POLLY JEAN 4EVER i love the raw edge on this whole album. it’s urgent and scary and manic but also powerful and deliberate. fav tracks: rub ‘till it bleeds; man-size; rid of me; highway 61 revisited; legs; yuri-g; dry; 50ft queenie
This one has always been a hit or miss for me depending on my mood. Today it was a hit! Although I can't say any of the songs that weren't already my faves stood out to me, because I think the harder sound earlier on just doesn't resonate with me as much as her mid/later stuff that has some really gut-punching melodies balancing out that edge. By nature this style is less melodic, but I think it's in service of the overall emotional tone she's trying to convey here so it definitely works even if it's not my personal preference; it especially works for me on "Rub 'Till It Bleeds" and I imagine that how I feel when listening to that song is how others feel about this whole album. Fav tracks: Rub 'Till It Bleeds, 50ft Queenie, Ecstasy
There's certain sounds that are just unpleasant to listen to. The back half of this indulges in that so much that it makes any of the good parts hard to recommend.
3,25
1993 totally passed me by. In the grip on my own alcoholism.
not her best one, too raw, too furios, I like later works much better.
pj harvey te amo
I liked some of the songs here but less than I had hoped. 3 stars or C-.
Qué gran disco
Didn’t land quite as immediately as the previous PJ Harvey I listened to, but it’s made me want to come back for more
Whoaaaa!!! Amazing songs, grungey vibe, and PERFECT sound. I liked this even more than the debut, which is of course an all-time classic. I now understand why many of my old friends rocked with this girl... the name always sounded like boring 90s indie for me but once again I was wrong. What an idiot!
Brilliant. Brutal. Steve Albini's production is always raw, and PJ absolutely makes the most of it. Several of these tracks are amongst my favourite rock performances ever - Dry, Mansize, 50ft Queenie, Rub till it bleeds. It's not a 'pleasant listen, the quartet piece in the middle is harrowing, but it's engrossing throughout. A must.
Love how heavy this sounds, and how she surprises you with those moments of heaviness. Kind of like how her sound surprises you - you don’t expect that kind of music to come from someone who looks so mild mannered like her (in the best way)
Not sure what to say on this one. I listened to it twice, and it kinda just went in one ear and out the other. It wasn't bad, but it didn't make much of an impression.
Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea is my favourite album of hers, while her earlier albums are a bit of an acquired taste for me. That said, this was quite enjoyable and a welcome change from some of the same-y stuff on this list.
she has grown on me considerably.
Not really a fan
Interesting take on grunge sound. Def pixies and melvins influence. Great Albini production.
Love PJ Harvey - this isn't my favorite album though. Her range and raw sound is so fascinating.
I have never heard of this woman
i dont like it.
Soft-Loud? Make it make sense, please.
Some nice 90s rock segments followed by screeching and illiterate poetry. 3/10
Raw, punky. Pretty darn good. Probably not for everyone.
Cover 7 Rid of Me but not 4-Track Demos (Harvey's reinterpretation without interference from the producer, supposedly)? I'd call this Suicide Punk. There's languid darkness, agony, anger,, angst. I really like this album but sometimes it's too intentionally muddy and dumbed down (the drums are are just bashing) as if mimicking 70s 80s self-recordes underground punk, which were cheaply done with crap equipment and not necessarily a lot of talent (musicianship-wise). i get it. It's an aesthetic, one I like actually but not always and only for so long. .
Visceral
Why are we still doing PJ Harvey? This isn't good. At all.
See my notes for her "Dry" album. My comments to this one are similar, although it is more P J Harvey's screechy voice, rather than screechy violins which turned me off from this, the second of her albums which this project has presented to me. That said, there were some screechy violins on one track, and a couple of other tracks were just awful, in my opinion. So, again, despite some really great hard rock and grunge guitar work, I feel three stars is the best I can do.
Remind me to listen to this when I'm miserable as fuck
Day556 - i had to switch back to my 90’s teen angst mode and then this album clicked
it was a fun listen, glad to get 90s music and a female artist!!! Wouldnt listen again but like the voice and instrumentals 6/10
A good rock album. It had some strong guitar and vocals and never got boring. It’s like British grunge but more feminist and also not quite grunge.
This was the kind of dynamic sound CD's promised but rarely delivered. A super cool album!
Not for me (weirdly), I think it was the drums in the end
I couldn't stand it. There's very few albums I dislike as much as this one.
I wished I loved anything as much as this list loves PJ Harvey. IS THIS HER THIRD ALBUM ON HERE?
Good to hear this again. First 3 songs are amazing, then it loses it's way for me. To Bring Me My Love is much more consistent
Got into it a little bit but found it too abrasive overall. Edges a 3 based on 50ft Queenie which is fastastic. Prefer the musicality of, say, a Fiona Apple overall.
This must’ve been about the fourth time I’ve tried listening to PJ Harvey. Each time I walk away from it thinking I just don’t get the hype . This was a challenging listen for me. She strikes me as the kind of artist I can listen to for one or two songs on a late night, Jules Holland TV show, but an entire album of hers is way beyond my tolerance capacity. The most positive thing I can say about this album is that it sounds unmistakably like PJ Harvey, the worst thing I can say about this album is also that it sounds like PJ Harvey.
Rocks. Uncompromising, gritty, and raw: those kinds of adjectives. Picked up as it went on to the point of steamrolling over me.
First Morrissey now PJ Harvey, is it Get Happy week? 🤦🏻♂️😅 Tortured and painful, no redeeming features.
Inconsistent but some interesting stuff towards the end.
Not for me, verging into *too* grungy and experimental at the expense of an enjoyable listening experience.
Its so raw and hard in a way that music just isn't now? It's really interesting just how music is recorded and how mistakes have emotional intent. I think that is what is missing in music. It's not the guitar and it's not the rock n roll per se, rather it is the human intent and concept that is missing in music. I'm not really into this type of music, but man it hits very different in 2025 than I think it did when I listened to it for the first time in the late 90's. It's like an extinct animal.
It's good, but it feels a bit more unpolished and raw - and not always in a good way. Still, the vocals of PJ Harvey are a delight.
A raw and grungy sound with occasional odd time signatures and rythms. Plenty of emotion in the vocals. Despite that, there is that occasional song where the sound is thinner, taking the momentum out.
Almost gave this a 4. 3.5
3rd or 4th album I've listened to from PJ Harvey and she still sounds like a dying cat too often for my tastes. Started out heavier and ok, but got pretty rough. Was a little better towards the end, but not something really worth returning to. 2/5
Another high quality release from PJ Harvey with her usual vocals of raw emotion, songs full of passion and fury, intense lyrics, blitzkrieg guitars all wrapped up un-neatly in a grunge style Steve Albini production.
Good stuff
Niceness from harveyness
PJ Harvey just gets better and better the more I listen
I really like PJ Harvey, and this album in particular as I think it was the first "proper" gig I went to in the Bristol Anson Rooms. But do we need 4 PJ Harvey Albums in the 1,001 !? I love the raw, dirty dinging and guitar; the sensuality and ferociousness of it.
I'm feeling less annoyed by this album. I guess this is progress in my appreciation towards PJ Harvey.
Loved the dynamics and the tension on here. Very raw, very punky, and it reminded me a bit of the Pixies at times.
After the first two songs I thought I was finally getting a good PJ Harvey album. Unfortunately this got worse as it went on.
Hyvä PJ albumi
...
Strong
Great song to open the album with, and what follows is mostly experimental endeavours by PJ, exploring every possible genre and venue where her mind can take her. It's quite hit or miss, withca heavy leaning towards the latter. I'm still PJ Harvey fan, but maybe her later work is more suited for my taste.
I've never been a fan of PJH, but I recognize that this was some good stuff!
My fourth encounter with PJ on this list. And holy heck, that breakdown in the opening track! PJ Harvey's gonna stop my heart one of these days. There's an intense punkish element to this music, with hints of Patti Smith, Dolores O'Riordan, and (maybe) Björk. But grittier than all three. The melodies are a little wonky throughout the record, but you can tell Harvey's singing with utter determination and passion. There's also a sort of trepidation in her voice, heard in the slightly wavery tone that's become her signature by this point. It's particularly apparent in the songs Legs, Rid Of Me (title track), and Me-Jane. The style is more rock-oriented than her later works, and I think it works pretty well with Harvey's vocal quality. Lots of post-punk elements such as atonality, slightly industrial drumming, and chords that don't match the melody (although we also see this with Dylanesque folk-rock, so it could be a universal thing). Man-Size Sextet is insane. It's uncomfortable, screechy, unnerving, and (tonally) matches its lyrics dead-on. The only track to prominently feature strings, and it does so in a brutal fashion. Another unconventional technique is the ultra-bendy guitar playing in Dry. The solo near the end of the song is wild. But is the music *good*? Well... not exactly. It's engaging, sure - because of how it breaks music conventions rather than how it builds upon them. Every song is likeable enough, so I can't give lower than 3 stars - but the songs just aren't enjoyable (or relatable) enough to warrant any higher than that either. Atonality should be reserved for very exceptional cases, maybe once per album at a stretch, but this record relies entirely on not having a catchy melody. Or indeed any catchy/memorable moments at all - whether they be riffs, hooks, vocal hooks (which happen just a couple of times here), or something else. You can grab someone's attention and also have the musical chops to justify it, but Harvey doesn't quite get all the way there. Still, it sounds pretty badass. 3/5 Key tracks: Rid Of Me, Rub 'Til It Bleeds, Man-Size Sextet
PJ Harvey has managed something on this album I’ve never felt before. I like is all the songs sound, Steve Albini is great as is PJ’s voice. But uh. I don’t remember any of those songs. I don’t actually like any of the songs on this album. None of them have a hook. They just sort of exist in this nice sounding cloud of anger.
Kinda grungy, kinda indie, and some very confusing time signatures. I had fun listening to this record, it felt almost like pre-art-rock in a way. Lots of really fun and bizarre song structures. PJ Harvey’s voice has that essential early 90’s female grunge tone to it, but far more dynamic than a lot of her peers at the time. I found the vocals to be really quite beautiful. Not just the vocals, but the tone of this record is regularly turning on a dime, going from soft gentle ballads to powerful guitar rock and back again, it works really really well. Excellent production value, every instrument sounds really nicely placed and levelled in the mix, and that only adds to the enjoyment of this record. I was entirely uninformed about this particular PJ Harvey release going into this one, and I’m glad I had no judgements previously. I haven’t really found any faults to declare here, as a product of its time I think this record is in pretty elite company. 5*
We’ve had one PJ Harvey album that I thought was pretty good and one that I really kinda hated, so maybe this one will provide a verdict on how I feel about this lady that the author of the 1001 list seems to like very much. My major comment about this album is that the mixing does an extremely annoying thing on almost every song where there are whisper-quiet sections that make you think you need to turn your volume up, but as soon as you do you will be accosted by a jarring throttling up of the volume. It’s super obnoxious and I have to deduct like 1.5 ⭐️ from the maximum possible score for this alone. Also the vocal track is very… muddled? muted? throughout and I have a hard time making out anything she is singing. Also very annoying. The last song doesn’t suffer these mixing maladies and also happens to be my favorite. Otherwise, this album is… fine. Didn’t suck but didn’t knock my socks off. I guess. I feel like I’m not even really sure what I listened to because it was mixed so badly.
I think I mentioned something similar before when we had her “Dry” debut album, but goddamn PJ Harvey has such a strong connection between her heart and her singing voice. She is once again masterfully expressive on this album, it’s so hard to believe this was performed in front of a recording microphone - it feels much more ‘real’ than that! “Man-Size Sextet” is for sure my standout pick for this album. The arrangement is so haunting and on-edge. I felt forced to be just as tense as the song was! “50ft Queenie” was fantastic, much more of a traditional, chaotic, clangy rocker. The many ways she uses her voice in different registers and intensities on this song alone astounds me. Outside of Björk, I’ve never heard anyone do all that in the span of a few minutes and still put it into a song that jams. The end of “Me-Jane” was very catchy with the way she sang “dont LOOOAD it on me”. It’s just crazy to me that this can all exist in a persons head and heart, and even crazier that she vocally can perform it in such an emotive, yet intricate manner. Just an awesome listen, STRONG 4/5, could absolutely be a 5/5 if it’s your jam
I think I got this album before. Still do not like it after a second listen.
It was my first time listening to this record. In contrast to Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea; Rid of Me follows a more visceral style: less sophisticated, more in your face. I liked it a lot, another highlight in PJ's discography.
Vaag en pretentieus
There's a very strong chance every PJ Harvey album in this project gets 5 stars from me, even though I so rarely think to put her on when I'm listening to music at work, around the house, in the car, etc. I have a weird relationship with her music, but it's almost all fantastic.
Halfway through this album, I thought "When will this be over?" That's not a good sign for a 47 minute album. The second half picked up and I kinda liked one track.
I liked a lot of this album, but too much of it came across as just noise for me to want to return to it.
1. Interesting pa intro. 2. Not memorable. 3. Quit whining, woman. My god. 4. No me ta gustando, mano. 5. Noise rock, shitty tho' 6. WTF is this shit. 7. ... 8. God, stop. Ya es un chao para mi que vaya el 8vo maldito tema y siga pareciéndome una mierda. 9. Na, ya lo cerré el youtube music. No me calo más esta mierda. "Utter shit show"
PEEEEJ. She just keeps getting better. I prefer the Parish era but Albini is Albini
War sehr cool, aber der mix hat mir nicht so gefallen, ich hätte es cooler gefunden, wären die krassen vocals mehr rausgekommen
soaring vocals, distorted guitars - chef's kiss!
This is a fantastic record. I feel like more people need to listen to PJ Harvey and I never got why she wasn't more popular. I don't know that this is my favorite record of hers, I'd have to go back and listen to some of the others again, but it's up there for sure. My only real complaint with this album is that the dynamics are a little off for me. I shouldn't have to adjust the volume from song to song or especially not within the same song. That might have been a deliberate choice (like the first song starts playing for a minute and a half or something super quiet so you turn up the volume and then it's like 'joke's on you, now the real music starts!') but it's kind of distracting and irritating. But that's a pretty small complaint and otherwise this is an utterly brilliant album. 5/5
I first heard PJ Harvey in the mid 90s on the Batman Forever soundtrack. I think I should like her music but I don't. I keep trying to listen to it, and it's not happening.
Hate how quiet then loud it gets, was literally a jumpscare. Pls stop making “music”
Maybe this would require a few more listens, but I'm leaning more towards that I respect this rather than loving it. There are definitely good songs here, Dry in particular, so I'm gonna give this a 4.
fierce and aggressive. i would not want to get on her bad side.
When I tried to listen to this on spotify the audio was awful. Then I tied on youtube and it was the same. It just seemed poorly mixed or perhaps badly compressed as a digital file. Did a little research and it seems the only really good way to listen to this album is on vinyl due to the way it was mastered. With that in mind I have to say I did not enjoy my listening experience. Vocals too soft then too loud sometimes in the same song. One of my biggest gripes with music is when vocals are too low in the mix and that has never been more of an issue for me than with this album. I am sure it is some sort of artistic choice but it ruins it for me. Maybe I am just an Audiophilic Philistine.
Loud, at times abrasive, but consistently good (post-)punk with obvious Steve Albini influences.
Great
I really tried to like this but it’s basically just a woman ranting over loud and boring guitars and drums, sometimes discordant as if two radios are being played at the same time. Not for me.
Grunge-inspired, but not so much to date it terribly. Vocals are very powerful and filled with raw emotion, suiting the instruments that are typically more associated with a somber male vocalist. Man-Sized Sextet has an almost horror movie dissonance and buildup.
Diva
PJ Harvey is my absolute favourite artist, and this is in my opinion her best album. 5 stars is not enough!
I don't understand the poor mixing comments. She's certainly mixed low on many of the songs, but I can't see how it isn't intentional. I think the low mixing being intentional comes off clearest on 'Hook'
Boring
Do not love, may never listen to again.
Aggressive, spiky and raw. Produced by Steve Albini, this brilliant album still sounds fresh and urgent today.
Not blown away but every song was good
Total garbage
1/5
Another PJ album?! I think I’ll stick to her later stuff. The first track was downright unpleasant and the rest not much better!
Ok yeah this was excellent and I see why people rate it so highly.
I was informed boys aren't allowed to listen to this but I still liked it a lot
I found this rather grating and annoying.
Original but sadly I am very demanding when women vocals it is about and her voice doesn’t do it for me
Meh
Pretty great alt-rock. One of the best, actually.
Raw, hard hitting, great songwriting that feels very personal. Would share with most
Not horrible, not great
Did not need another PJH within the week… BUT 50ft Queenie and Yuri-G were quite bangers.
I liked this one better than Let England Shake. This one was way more raw and rockin. Still had a few songs that I was dying to skip but overall solid album.
Imagine a maze built tall with dense, lush conifers; exciting surprises tucked artfully behind corners that themselves seem to leap out from nowhere. A maze that teases its enigma proudly; inviting its participants to take an elevated view, to admire its complexity from on high – a maze whose architects are confident that the moment you descend from the vantage of a verdant horizon, you’ll again be scratching around, none the wiser as to how to locate the core. And now imagine that finding the treasure at the guarded centre is the least of your worries – you can’t work out how to actually get in. “Rid of me” represents a sort of musical purgatory. I was listening to this album only recently, the day after Steve Albini died – and while I enjoyed it, bristled to it, let it wash over me … I never felt myself washed away by it. And that’s flustered me; precisely because I can tell there’s so much in there for me to delight at. Whatever it is, though, I can’t grasp at it. For an album that does so much to trace the outline of a thoroughly frustrated mind … maybe that’s about right. It’s a niggle I might never rid myself of. See you next year.
Wanted to like this but struggled. Her vocals were OK but didn't seem to fit with the discordant music. Prefer Dylans version of Highway 61 to hers I'm afraid.
I have never listened to PJ Harvey before, I enjoyed this album
I love PJ Harvey, and I really like this project, but some songs here don't wow me that much. Maybe all thata will change with this listen, we shall see, we shall see! Before I even start the album, one thing I always associate with it (and the artist herself) is vulnerability. The vulnerability to be angry in detail. A lot of times anger is shown in song it is shown in a way that hides the speaker, protects them. PJ Harvey says fuck that and tells it as it is. Let's listen. Rid Of Me is the kind of song that I always love: a slow burner. I love the contrast between the quiet verses and the explosion of the chorus. And the build-up with "Lick my legs, I'm on fire, lick my legs, of desire" (still not sure if she says "legs" or "lips" in the second sentence but oh well) just adds to it. And this is what I mean with vulnerability. At the end of the day, she is singing about unrequieted love, begging this person to stay with her. The anger of the chorus is just an answer to that, to the fact that the person got her to that point. Great stuff. Missed is still a bit of a mistery to me. You could tell me it was about love, about Mary Queen of Scots (as Genius seems to think), or about the Mother of Christ, and I'd believe you. I am more leaning to the last interpretation, but still. An absolute banger. Legs is a wild declaration of love and devotion, the kind that is toxic to both. She kills him, she loves him. The bridge in this is amazing. Love the way she seems to be tauting him, even after, well, cutting his legs off. Love her. A lot of PJ Harvey songs sound like they're about sex. Maybe the lines themselves, or the way she sings (sometimes moans) them. But this one... yeah there's no mistaking it here. But still, even when speaking about sex, that dark, disgusting layer is still present. Damn that album cover is perfect for this. Still, I think there's something to the dynamic of the relationship I may be missing. Why is she calling him weak? A fucked-up power dynamic at play? Could definitely see it. Again, Hook is a bit of a mistery to me. Sure, part of it is clear (a man making promises and taking advantage of a woman). But there seems to be more that I'm not fully getting. Man-Size Sextet, besides sounding very creepy because of the violins (which I love), could be interpreted as Harvey imagining herself as a man? Creating her "man version"? The imagery of a "babe looking good" and the final verse, talking about taking a girl out of her head and setting her on fire, setting her free as well. Yeah I like this version. The Dylan cover is actually... pretty good. Not much to add, she manages to make it very distinct from the original, in a way that it seems like a completely different song. Fifty-foot Queenie is a demonstration of the assertion of power and aggressiveness usually reserved for men but in a woman. Great Sure, a song about being in love with the moon, why not? But also, I like seeing the adoration and submission being used for a female being (is the moon a being? whatever). A different take on a song from the same album. This one is more of a rock version, so I guess it feits more with the album? I so like the change in mood that the other version brings. Hey, I guess it's a good thing we have both. Dry is definitely one of my favourites here. Again, another song that can be seen on a sexual level (the sentence "you leave me dry speaks for itself"), but I think we can go further. "You've come all this way, no hair out of place" shows a "perfect" presentation, and yet... he leaves her dry. Even sucking on the well (desperation, trying to have hope and grab on to the last possible resort) still leaves her dry. It seems that this person, despite possibly being pretty and all that, just does nothing for her. No interest is piqued. She's dry. I also like that this belongs to a very niche list of songs that share a title with an album in an artist's discography despite not being on that album. Don't know, I'm a nerd, I just like those fun facts. I was not expecting to find out this song was about Tarzan?? Why did I not know that before. Sure Polly do what you want, I'll listen. Snake is possibly the most aggressive song on this whole album, and it has no build-up, it just starts with a guitar riff, some loud drums and louder vocals, and it stays that way for most of the track. It reminds me of "Long Snake Moan" from "To Bring You My Love", not jusr because of the title but also because that track is also "all-noise-no-build-up". Like both. The lyrics here though... I love when heavier records use religious imagery, and here we hear what Eve's reaction might have been after eating the forbidden fruit. Yey. Ecstasy is the perfect send-off for this thing. Not the heaviest track, it still has the sound that runs through all the songs in this album. The same kind of guitar riff and percussion. Lyrically, it's pretty simple. She's in ecstasy. The delivery is so fucking good though. Love it. Overall, I'd say that this listening experience actually made me appreciate this album much more! Before, I thought the songs just melted into each other and couldn't really tell them apart. Now I've grown to like them all. I firmly believe this is a no skip-album. However, the idea that I had that the tracks sound similar still stands. While I did enjoy every song here, the instrumentals are very similar thoughout. And some songs are more forgettable than others. Still, this is PJ Harvey at her angriest, and I love it for that. And that album cover is so iconic it needs to add points to the whole thing. I am kind of unsure on how to rate this. Maybe if it was a bit shorter I'd give it 5, but as it is I might settle on 4. But it's a very good 4, I promise. Loved this. Bye.
I should spend more time with this, today was not that day though.
I did enjoy this.