Reviews (page 3 of 8)
Rv
Raw and loud grunge rock. PJ Harvey’s band is killer on this album. They mix in some hard country rock later on the album, and dip into punk territory too. It’s a lean, mean sound. 3.5
I typically like most 90's rock bands. It's probably my favorite time period for the genre and more often than not when I think of my favorite rock songs most of them tend to come from this era. PJ Harvey has always been on my periphery but not really an artist that I listened to much and going through this album I can kind of feel why. There are a lot of cool ideas here; the guitars move between a post-rock malaise and a more distorted crunchy downpicked sludge, and it's awesome. The drums are raw and heavy and have that huge Steve Albini / Butch Vig sound, and the compositions are well crafted too. For my tastes though, her voice just kind of hangs around the instruments and doesn't often make the tracks go to the next level. Sometimes it comes close- like "Man Sized Sextet". It's bleak and heavy and her sung-through-her-teeth vocals on top of screeching forte strings is a very daring and attractive sound for me. This version is great.. but I don't like that they include a more "regular" version of the song, with full rock band treatment. It feels less daring and less committal in a way? Worst of all I know exactly how they feel here too, like there's times where I'll record a song and put a crazy reverb or a distortion on the main vocal and I'll really like the way it sounds but then I'll think "wait what if this is a really good song and it doesn't need this weird choice? If I released this song would releasing two versions solve that problem?". With it being such a saturated period of time of amazing bands (Nirvana, STP, Soundgarden, Alice in Chains, Bush, Pearl Jam, Radiohead, Green Day, Smashing Pumpkins, Nine Inch Nails, Weezer.. the list goes on and on), I think that the bar of quality is really high. I also personally listened to a lot more of the radio rock bands because I was a child in the early 90's and most of the music I listened to was in the car so whatever was on the radio is what we were listening to. This means that there's a lot of acts that were pretty popular but didn't have the airtime that Nirvana had and ultimately I didn't hear much of them until later in life, like The Pixies, Pavement, Sonic Youth. And I think PJ Harvey is in this group. Alas, I will do my due diligence and listen more because I think I would like this band if I gave the tunes some repeat listens. Great album cover. I always say that I love "motion" in still photography / album covers and this one is awesome.
Brought down quite heavily by the awful mixing, what tone-deaf bastard did this? It's not bad at all, but that listening experience is dampened - that, and it feels a little quantity over quality when it comes to the songs.
PJ Harvey is another one of those artists that seems to only be discussed among critics and other people who are really into music. I don’t think I ever heard anything by her before the late 00’s. Seems like she was too big for the indie circuit, but not quite mainstream enough to crack the charts in the US. Similar story to a lot of musicians on this list. Anyway, I’ve been in the mood for 90’s “alternative rock” the last few days, especially new-to-me tracks, so this was good timing.
++: Rid of Me, Legs, Rub 'til It Bleeds, Hook, Man-Size Sextet, 50ft Queenie, Yuri-G, Me-Jane, Ecstasy +: Missed, Highway 61 Revisited, Man-Size, Dry, Snake 9,1/10
Songs are either kinda shit or all the same. Really grating but I guess I respect her talent
Meni jedan od najdražih albuma ikad
Interesting 90s album that I liked, but didn't love. She's a good lyricist with an interesting point of view.
fuck this album.
2/5 Nicht so meins.
3.5
That was better than I expected - almost a 4
I didn't want to like this, but did.
Steve Albini has produced some of my favorite albums, and his touch made those albums better. I cannot say the same thing about this one. This is a ferocious album, with fierce vocals and gnarly riffs; the guitar on the second track almost sounds like Slint. I wish I could hear all of it better. The hollow drum sound on this is great, but the guitars almost sound muffled. The opening track should have these big explosive climaxes, but the quietness robs them of their power. While crisper production would help, the songwriting is also a bit thin as well, with too many songs that go on for too long without enough happening. Lyrically this rivals Exile in Guyville in the depths of feminism it explores, but the music doesn't quite match its anger.
Alt-rock. Har ikke hørt noe særlig på PJ Harvey før. Hardere enn jeg hadde sett for meg, men ikke helt min stil. Top 3: Rid Of Me, 50ft Queenie, Dry
intruiging dark lyrics and punchy sound, worth revisiting
Each PJ Harvey album I encounter feels very different from the ones I've heard before, but they're always good. Highlight here: "Rid of Me," which starts off restrained until it suddenly crashes in with full intensity.
I am blind to whatever reason this is on this list. At best it's probably just divisive. I'll admit PJ Harvey is doing something different here, I just wish it was something I could get behind. Uncomfortable mixing, vocals that are full of emotion yet somehow don't move me at all, and stylistic choices that have me scratching my head. My best guess is that this is music for people who are growing tired of standard music, so if that's where you're at I suppose I could mention this album. Otherwise, I think PJ Harvey is a whiff for me. Lowlight: Man-Size Sextet
not for me
Brutal!!
Abrasive and without reward. Includes one of the worst Bob Dylan covers ever recorded (Highway 61 Revisited) which is more forced and sillier than William Shatner doing Mr. Tambourine Man. Try as I might, I can't think of anything positive to say about Rid of Me. A bad experience all around- not wasting any more time on this one.
I like the first half: the tonal shifts, volume shifts, dissonance, the voice. I found the second half to be less uniformly coherent with each song or maybe it just got too much for me.
Don’t have any particular feelings either for or against this.
Yep 👍
Sounded pretty good but not something I’d be racing to listen to again
I did not hate it, and enjoyed the whole In Utero of it all. But some of the wailing got on my nerves. I know, I know ... the raw emotion is the point. But I can't help it, it frickin' annoys me.
Emotional and a little aggressive…but I don’t hate it! Likes: Rid of Me; Rub Til it Bleeds; Highway 61 Revisited; 50ft Queenie
It’s just not enjoyable to listen to. The vocals are off key and not in time with the music. The music would be fine, but it doesn’t jive well with the vocals. It gives off an extremely sheltered suburban goth kid that’s trying to be edgy, but just doesn’t get it. Like toothless punk, which maybe is the progenitor of the alternative music movement.
Weird AF
Yah I’m not afraid to admit I was horribly disappointed with this album. I didn’t hate it or dislike it. The problem is that the first album of PJ’s that I had ever heard was like just a few months ago when this list gave me “Stories from the city, stories from the sea” which is an all time great album. I’m pretty sure I have it a 4 or 5 I loved it that much. In fact it’s one of the go to examples I use when people ask me what major acts have I discovered and fallen in love with since starting this list. But sadly this album is just NOT that album. Again this album wasn’t bad or boring. It just wasn’t anywhere near as good as the last album. But again it has its moments, like for example I can appreciate that this album is much more raw and immature compared to “SFTCSFTS” and it almost feels more like a grunge album. And the highlights for me were songs like “legs” and “rid of me”. But as a whole I was kinda left wanting more.
średnie 2
weird and wondrous, couragious and raw. listening to this, i felt always on the edge, being pushed around. and this without being too aggressive or negative.
i liked it okay
I love pj Harvey
Stand-out tracks: Rid Of Me, Missed, Yuri-G, Dry, Me-Jane Very edgy. I prefer her more down to earth stuff like on her other album. This was just a bit too much for my liking.
Highlights: Rid of Me, Legs, Yuri-G, Man-Size, Snake I mean it's all right... But nothing to write home about. Through the years I got the impression that she's a darling of the critics so I expected a bit more. I'm not saying it's bad but it didn't click with me. I do see why the critics would praise her doe. The style is in tune with the rest of 90s alternative rock, but paired with wacky lyrics. And by wacky I mean Diddy yandere freak wacky, but they are also pretty clever. There's a lot of talk about gender dynamics and shit like that so I think that's what got the critics on board. Cool I guess, but the package ain't no earworm. It aims for the "artsy expression" label. Sometimes the template changed - for instance Man-Size Sextet was an interesting change of tune. Won't be revisiting the record itself and this might also apply to the highlights except maybe for some "funny" or clever ones like Legs or Man-Size.
My second PJ Harvey album. Enjoyed this one about the same- thrir sound is an intersection of punk and alternative, and I like the singers voice. Overall- good album
I certainly appreciate that PJ Harvey is considered formative, but I felt somewhat bludgeoned by this album and am surprised it primarily was a trio.
How many Polly Jean albums are on this list? This felt disjointed and off kilter.
P J Harvey had passed me by. No idea why. Loved her voice, loved the drums.
Rid of Me has always been one of my favorites. I’m really drawn to its dark overall sound and the rough, distorted guitars, and I genuinely love every track. Although it shares some similarities with Nirvana, it feels more controlled and deliberate, with a unique sense of tension and aggression. There’s something raw yet precise about it that keeps me coming back.
I enjoyed this but don’t know that it ever fully got me, something about the varying volumes kept just making me think my headphones were broken which is not really the fault of the album but oh well. Keen to listen again though i think.
Sorry PJ, this just wasn’t for me.
I love Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea and I did know that this was going to be a very different sort of album so I was bracing myself for that. I think this had some great moments and I really liked the first few songs and the overall ferocity but it maybe became a bit too much for me. Was going for a 3 but then remembered some of the other things I’ve a given a 3 to and had to bump it up
I love PJ Harvey and she has a great ability to reinvent her sound but for mine this gritty, grungy sound is her best. Steve Albini produces the three piece band perfectly, emphasising their simplicity. Harvey is lyrically in great form and I almost constantly have the double chorus of Rid of Me running through my head. 4.5
We need more girl grunge.
I think I had the exact same response to this album as the last PJ Harvey. Though, maybe this one felt more cohesive as an album.
I don’t have much to say about the album in general, it was fine. I just can’t believe that there are two more from this artist on the list.
What is this voice that she is doing cuz it's kinda throwing me off
i had never listened to something like this before, interesting but maybe in a so not good way ahaha. creative tho :)
nice enough
Amazing album that really captures an angst and aggressive tone with some dynamics that her peers at the time didn’t really do in recordings.
Enjoyed on the relisten, not unlike pixies at times
I feel like this could grow on me but at the same time there is not a lot drawing me back to listen again? It is quite samey all the way through Maybe I need to give it a proper relisten and actually give it my full attention rather than listening whilst working 3
Definitely back on track for me with this album! Alt rock is one of my favorite genres of music and PJ Harvey and this particular album are one of the groundbreakers in alternative music. Harvey really didn't break out into the mainstream until a couple of years later when "Down By the Water" was on the radio and MTV non-stop, but I actually prefer this earlier album to that. It's much more raw and I think it shows off Harvey's voice more. I've listened to this album before, but it's been awhile. It was nice to revisit it and I added some of the songs to my regular playlist so I can hear them more often.
Mein Gott, wie turnt mich dieses Gejammere und furchtbare Gekreische ab!
5: I will happily play this album anytime 4: I may occasionally play this album of my own free will 3: I will happily listen to this if someone plays it in the background 2: I will tolerate this if it is playing in the background 1: I will leave the room if someone plays this in the background Hovering between a 3 and a 4. I'm confident I'd grow to like this album with repeated listens. It's a bit much to come to grips worth on a first listen.
It was okay, I guess Stand-outs - Rid Of Me - Yuri-G
Was surprised how much I enjoyed this, considering I didn't like her other album on this list. Appreciated that her raw sound and emotional vocals really created a whole listening environment, 3.5/5
all you need to make an all-timer rock album is: to know how good power chords sound with a few open strings, to have a supernatural instinct for dynamics, to be able to sing like a wild creature, and to be exactly this cool. easy right
Rocks. A true wildman of a singer. That’s what I like to hear.
this is kinda nice i like it
Feel like it's wasted potential. A fantastic recording sound and very cool vibe let down by a monotonous first half.
missed this album when it first came out. I have had this blind spot for female artists most of my life which I am trying to remedy now, this album is helping with that. This album slaps. Ok.... Album is a high 4 but DEMANDS an immediate re-listen... Let's see how this goes. It goes well.
Really improves when you listen in higher quality than the pirated mp3s I listened to on my classic iPod in 2011. The production shines here though I don’t really feel carried along by the music itself. Could improve with more listens.
Honestly didn’t listen to the whole thing today, but will soon. I haven’t listened to it’s entirety since like 2010, but a solid classic
It almost seems like you must have a terrible voice to make this list
Very talented
At the beginning, everything was fine but... then it went to being so horrible, and, again, to something nice, and then... Well, I guess you get the idea. I understand the point of this record, but that "artsy" album is as good as bad. Or even worse than better. It sometimes goes hard (even if there's a very grunge sound I don't end up liking), and there are some nice ideas and pretty cool songs, but there are others that seem to be there just because they sound strange... however, some feel so out of place and others are just so uninteresting and bland that I just don't know what's the actual point of this album... Well, at least there are some pretty nice moments too. Not all is so bad. But some songs could have been made by Yoko Ono and many people would throw trash at her just for being Ono. However, some songs on this album are not much better or different. And I can't find anything interesting on it, honestly.
My rating 3.2
Love rock music with a female vocalist. Very dirty distortion, grungy.
Kinda good icl I’m surprised even. I liked ‘Missed” and only a couple of the tracks were pure screaming
What a debut it is! It still sounds so angry and wild after over 30 years.
This is my third, and I believe last, PJ Harvey album on this list. I liked "Stories by the Sea..." a bit more than her debut and second album. I think this is a good example of where the music is just not for me. I did not the songs to be compelling and multiple listens did not correct this for me. I recognize the influence and how much people enjoy this one. I can't rate it lower because of that. I didn't like the production on here. Maybe others like it and kudos to them if they, but for me it sounded too raw and too messy with me struggling (absent a few songs) to really note where the production improved the music. A low score for enjoyment and a high score for how influential this album was.
Rid of me har aldrig varit speciellt lättsmält, det är riktigt stark tobak. Så jag har aldrig riktigt gett den en chans förrän nu. Positiv överraskning då det fångar tidsandan under tidigt 90-tal, men det är lite mer och intensivare än det mesta annat under det tidigare 90-talet.
A energia da PJ sempre chamou minha atenção e esse álbum encapsula isso, punk para caramba fechando 14 faixas em menos de 50 minutos. "Legs" e "Me-Jane" foram excelente descobertas nessa ouvida, com certeza ele entrou nas minhas apreciações recorrentes
Album 72 Top 3 favorites off the album: Highway '61 Revisited, Legs, Man-Size Sextet More PJ Harvey! Good for me! The grittiness of this one is different from the album I listened to earlier. I found myself adjusting the volume regularly on my earbuds because it's quiet, then really loud, then really quiet, and back and forth. Anyway, grittiness: similar weight, but done... cleaner. That doesn't clarify anything. There's less distortion going on instrumentally, but the vocals have become even more raw. Lyrically more physical (Rub It 'Til It Bleeds... ouch). It's gritty in its own way. Man-Size Sextet was a listening experience. There's some Shostakovich out there that it's in the same vein with, his string quartets especially. A good listen for sure.
Другий альбом Харві в списку. Цей подобаєтсья більше. Альбіні дав свого звуку, все стало гучшніше та шумніше Пару пісень мені прям не сподобались. Тому думаю 4 буде справедливою оцінкою
Якийсь такий альбом, що мені нема що сказати. Просто ок.
ok...
dont like it
Not for me, but feels like an album that came out nearly a decade earlier than when this style became popular.
Maso
no me gusto
LOVE the disturbing strings and overall madness of Man-Size Sextet. 50ft Queenie and Yuri-G are also great. The whole album should be something I hate, style-wise, (similar to X-Ray Spex) but for some reason she gets away with it and I like it.
I love PJ Harvey and I like this album as a whole and I adore some of its parts (the title song is phenomenal! I love Dry!), and it's a great listen, but it's not my favourite PJ's album in her discography. (My favourites are To bring you my love, Uh huh her and Stories...) I'll give it a very strong four! It's a good one.
Rid Of Me? Not For Me. I didn’t mind a couple of songs (namely 50ft Queenie, Dry and Snake) but honestly most of it really rubbed me the wrong way and I ultimately had to skip through quite a few parts (honestly found the wailing in Legs so insufferable I couldn’t stand it). I feel kind of bad about not really liking PJ Harvey because I know how influential she is but I just can’t get around the sound. To be honest I find I like very little at all from the 90s in general though. (1.5 stars)
Good stuff. Not for me, but hell yeah. 3.8.
Left me a little dry tbh
pretty fun! kinda getting into PJ Harvey
Somebody get the drummer some more sticks, because he's slamming on that drum. It sounds like everyone was just straight up abusing their instruments (in a good way). Even the singer is rough on her voice. Definitely enjoyable, although the singer was a bit tough to understand at times.
Harvey really leaned into grunge styles here, which is cool. Heavy, and fun to listen to, although I feel its missing something instrumentally. I liked this, but its hard for me to give it more than a 3.
Meh
The grungy, raw sound works really well here. There's also a wider volume range than most music has, which makes this album more unique for better and for worse. I enjoy the vocal performance a lot, and it's a very interesting album. I can see a future where I might rate this higher. Favorite track(s): "Legs"
I can understand why it’s interesting, unfortunately that didn’t cause me to enjoy it
I liked part of the songs, but when it gets too noisy I disliked it.
Not my cup of coffee
Don't know quite what to make of this. Weirdly quiet all the way through but some decent listening
I really actually liked this. Never listened to PJ Harvey before and I know she has always been critically lauded. Guess there is a reason for that.
This was a grower for me, but ended up really enjoying it
With grunge and alternative rock being all the rage by 1993, a relatively new artist from Dorset, England by the name of Polly Jean Harvey decided to put her own staple on the genre, which turned out to be a masterstroke as 'Rid of Me' is certainly one of the most fascinating albums to emerge from the early 90s. Produced by the unconventional Steve Albini (Pixies, The Breeders, Nirvana, The Jesus Lizard), 'Rid of Me' possesses that raw, guttural and aggressive sound that's commonplace with Albini-produced records, but is driven by Harvey's similarly unconventional vocals cutting through the mix like a ball of energy bursting at the seams. With songs like 'Man-Size', 'Hook', '50ft Queenie' and the title track, PJ Harvey storms through the record with her infectious presence and unpredictable tonal shifts that never fail to keep you on your toes, and she's ably supported by Steve Vaughan on bass and Rob Ellis on drums. What truly is impressive about Harvey's vocals on this record is she can turn on a dime from sweet and souful to chaotic and intimidating, sometimes at multiple points in the song. The sheer fearlessness of her vocals and incredible range prove her status as one of the 90s most fascinating musicians, and the fact she'd go from this to 'Stories From the City, Stories From the Sea' in just 7 years only highlights how unique and varied her discography is. I found PJ Harvey's music later than I'd care to admit (Nick Cave's 'Henry Lee' was the first time I'd heard of her) but I'm glad I did, because her fearlessness and desire to push the envelope resonates with me greatly. 'Rid of Me' is certainly one of the more 'off-the-wall' grunge/alternative records, but that's the genius of PJ Harvey for you: bliss in chaos. Best songs: Rid of Me, Rub 'Til it Bleeds, Hook, 50ft Queenie, Man-Size, Dry, Ecstasy
i would’ve enjoyed this album more if it wasn’t masted so badly on streaming + a lot of the songs sounded the same
Didn't get it. Very 90s grungy sounding - which is to say, more noise than music. Lyrically incompatible. I think the front half might have been better than the back half, but it pretty much sucked too much to give it a second pass to confirm. Contemporary comparison: I gave all of Nirvana's albums 2s, and this was worse than that.
This was ok. It was a little too moody for my liking. This could be higher if I was in the right mind set. Not much higher.
This was an ok album, didn't blow me away but not the worst I've heard!
Euurgh, j’ai VRAIMENT pas vibé là-dessus, ce genre de «lamentation rock» à la Björk ou Radiohead me fatigue énormément, et l’instru est tellement raw que je pourrais attraper la salmonelle. Non merci
Punky, Energetic, wail-y, alright but I wouldn’t listen again 3
Raw, sexual, unapologetic. This record certainly does not pull any punches. I loved how I could not predict the direction the album would go in. The musicianship as a whole is excellent, and the song structures were pretty interesting with lots of complicated time signatures that worked well. I do have complaints: the recording quality is not brilliant, and whoever mixed it needs to be fired - this really hampered my enjoyment of the album as a whole. 6/10
8/10
Scho okay
geht mir zu oft in die grungige richtung...
The mixing is kinda bad, and the first part of this album is better than the latter half, but I still enjoyed it. Would revisit.
Love the drums. Albini crushed it as usual. Never been a big fans of PJ Harvey, though. Shrug?
Did not like it on the first listen. Its pretty annoying and empty to me. Could get to the end of the second listen 1.5
Starts and ends with really strong tracks. Some interesting moments throughout that might raise it up to a 4 in time. 3.5
like a 3.5 for me i thought i would like it a little more than i did, maybe just not my cup o' tea!
maybe a little harsh... probably a lot closer to a 3... i liked the album at parts and really wanted to like it as a whole but idk it did nothing for me!!!
I've never been truly sure about the production of this album. Yes, I know it's Albini, but ... Not her best, but still warrants a decent rating. Anyway, it's on my shelves. Heard before ✅️ Listened this time ✅️ Revisit ✅️ Disappointing ★★★☆☆ (6/10) Total reviewed : 230 Already owned : 53 Purchased : 12 To buy list : 2 Nope : 163
meh...
Va duuuuro. Muy buen disco. Nunca le había dado. God bless her. Y god bless a Steve Albini man, sobre todo por esas baterías que suenan a ruido de obras, suenan increíbles. Man-size sextet colándose por el medio fue una grata sorpresa. Suena increíble. Stank faces durante todo el disco. Good shit.
A national treasure. Amongst strong competition, this might be my favourite of her albums
Love this…Tom.
Some powerful stuff here. Emotion really comes through. Nicely done
I love this album, especially the sound of it. I love sparse arrangements and harsh sounds and dynamics.
Indie rock with some grunge in the instrumentals. I didn't really hear the punk which I consider a positive. Unfortunately it's still the next worst thing, indie. The vocals are quiet and weak. The instrumentals sound discordant and empty. Also I find the album cover unsettling.
I love everything about PJ Harvey except for the music. I really wish that I liked her, but she probably only has one or two good songs an album.
It was fine. If a friend made me listen to this I would say I liked it
I've only heard one other album from PJ Harvey (Dry), and I remember liking it more than this one. The biggest fault of this album is that it's very one note. Every song is doing the same thing, and it can get old. I also don't like that there are two versions of the same song on a standard edition album. I think I would/will listen to a song or two off of this album again, but I don't see myself playing the entire thing anytime soon. Three stars. (Favorite track: Rid of Me.)
Good. ★★★★
My favorite PJ Harvey album so far!
This is... Hmm. I don't dislike it. It's got some cool musical ideas, but I dunno. Something about it doesn't click with me. Maybe it's less melodic than what I'm used to. Maybe I should give it another chance. But for now it's not bad, not great.
Did nothing for me. Couldn't connect at all. Can understand it being something special to someone, but I found it dull and noisy with no meaning
eh
This is, for me, one of the best ever lo fi records. Steve Albini produced (same year he did In Utero) and did an incredible job of seemingly staying out of the way and just capturing Polly Jean and her band at their rawest and best. Not my favorite PJ record, but probably #2
Wild behavior to this on here
Loved the first half
Zou het niet wegdraaien als het op de radio was (alsof ik ooit radio luister ??? hoor mij), maar ook niet crazy bijzonder Yuri-G is een fucking hilarische titel voor een doomed yuri over zangeres en de maan. Tevens de grootste banger van de plaat wel
niet de vibe voor gisteren. Beetje boos en meh.
I really liked this album! The production is intense and rough, which I think pairs very well with the overall themes of the album. Femininity is not just sunshine and rainbows, it is a lot of suffering at the hands of the world and the men that inhabit it.
jaa hartstikke lekker schoonmaakalbum. lekker boos, lekker interessante muziek
7.5/10
This was a solid album! I listened to only one other PJ Harvey album ( that was on this list) and this one was much better and more cohesive. The album experiments a lot, but with the production it somehow contains all the sounds. Biggest Hit - Rid Of Me Biggest Miss (if I had to choose) - man size sextet Underrated Gem - Missed
Lame. Noisy. Repetitive.
Although I find the raw grungy sound to be most predominant here, the album still sounds quite unique stylistically. There's nothing particularly great and nothing I truly like, but overall it's fine.
Interesting and seems before it’s time. It just wasn’t something I’ll listen to again.
Can someone please fire the sound editor? Almost every song is so quiet I have to turn the volume way up, excepte for like THREE PARTS OF THE SONG THAT ARE BLOW YOUR EARS OFF LOUD. I really don't get PJ Harvey. Hard to pick a best song because they all suck. Best song: Me-Jane
This album sounds like someone heard a grunge track a long time ago down a long hallway and wanted to recreate it. It's sparse and understated. I just don't get PJ Harvey
This was great, like a mash of alternative rock with grunge all recorded really basically. A garage band dream, if you will. I really liked the more aggressive and complicated tracks in the beginning, though it did trail off by the end. The Albini effect is high in this, making them sound like they’re not using any effects at all but not like it was recorded in a tin can like so many other attempts at “tool-less” production. The drums in particular are stellar, and I especially like it in songs like “Legs” where the cymbals aren’t individually mic’d up so you get this great sound like you’re in the same room as the band. The songs starting at “man size” started to lose me but I really liked the previous stuff. Overall I enjoyed this; the kind of stuff I missed when I was younger for whatever reason but would’ve liked then as well.
I quite like the lady version of Bukowski. She's tough but fair and we need more like her.
this is the second album by both PJ Harvey and her band PJ Harvey (with bassist Stephen Vaughan and drummer/backing vocalist Rob Ellis). while it was the last album by the band, it would prove to be a breakout success for the woman the band was named for! with 12 original songs (one of which—"Man-Size"—appears in two wildly contrasting versions) and a Bob Dylan cover, Harvey and her trio deliver a set of passionate performances, balancing the raw, dark, often sexual energy of her lyricism with a keen sense of structure and dynamics. the title track, for instance, obviously draws you in with that incredibly quiet introduction; you're left waiting for the moment where things are going to explode, as they so often do with rock records, and when Harvey and co. finally pop off, the results are beyond gratifying. this is also one of the best Steve Albini engineering jobs I've heard so far; he really manages to capture the feeling of what it's like to be in a room listening to a band just *play*. light 9/10.
4/5 https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/pj-harvey/rid-of-me/ More familiar with and fan of PJ’s more recent sound (Let England Shake). This slaps too, but having never really listened to it much before, it’s quite a lot. Some absolute bangers tho, so will add it to the rotation.
Went in with high expectations, but ended up having to force myself through the album.
I like some songs by PJ Harvey, so I had high expectations for this one, but it's a big NO from me. 2.5⭐
Man, I’ve slept on PJ Harvey. Both albums I’ve gotten so far have been instant favorites.
Not a bad alternative album, but, I didn't enjoy it as much as some of her other albums. Highlights: "Missed"
Couldn’t get through it.
Raw talent.
I didn't get to listen to the whole album, but the majority that I did listen to was AWESOME. I reeeeally dig her sound. The rawness, the power, the grit, was very enticing. Definitely drives me to listen to her more. I will absolutely go back to this album.
Starting off the album with Rid of me, I like the rhythmic guitar! This girl also has a really cool voice. I’m definitely vibing with this. It’s also nice to have some female representation on this list! It’s been quite male centred so far. The chorus is so bombastic! That was really unexpected but so so welcome. Missed is also a very cool track. Almost reminds me of if Evanescence and Florence and the Machine had a baby. Legs is good, but I feel it’s very similar to the previous tracks. Rub till it bleeds and hook were fine! I can’t decide if I like Man Size Sextet or not. The music is good, but the cacophony is not really for me. I very much enjoyed Highway 61. From here, I thought the album was quite good, but nothing really stood out to me. The closer, ecstasy, was good and wrapped the album nicely. A bit of a shorter review, it was good, and I just wish it had more ideas in it. Every song sounded very similar. 6/10 or 3/5 ⭐️ 24/1089
Seriously good album
Not a fan
If only the title of this album - Rid of Me - could be taken on board by the algorithm that has given us three PJ Harvey albums in a week. As is the case with these reviews and ratings, I'm trying to avoid being too influenced by the running order of the albums but I could hardly bear to listen to this artist. PJ Harvey on Saturday and PJ Harvey on Sunday made for a pretty depressing prospect . However, this offering is much better. I suppose there are many artists whose albums 15+ years on from the first are not so good. This is an early PJ Harvey and had a strength and conviction lacking in the later albums.
This is my second PJ Harvey album in a row, and my third overall. I thought yesterday’s Let England Shake was absolutely dreadful, but I went into this one with an open mind. This is undoubtedly the best so far, and I now appreciate that being versatile and reinventing your sound with each album is bound to bring some misses. This, however, is a definite hit, with some great tracks, a strong vocal performance, and Steve Albini’s production is always a treat to hear.
This shit sucked
It’s a vocally impressive loud-quiet-loud record, with some underrated weirdness (Dylan cover, Man Size 2x). All said, it’s got hooks, but it’s never felt like the classic it’s touted to be when compared to her debut.
I love Pj but this album never really worked for me as well. It's got some good songs but seems like a very different artist to a lot of the later stuff
Enjoyed it. Probably a 3.5-4/5, will need to give it another thorough listen to decide for sure.
Hell yea
Pffffff - this isn’t bad, but it’s not very interesting. I’ve had a couple of other PJ Harvey albums on the list, and this is better than those in some ways and worse in others. The grungy elements are ok, but it’s generally quite dull, so it’s sitting at a low 3.
Brutal listen.
Giving house, giving it girll. Not really my taste
Would give 3.5 if possible
Too noisy for me
Enjoyable but would need more listens.
Not my kind of music, but some interesting lyrics
Awful
Great album. Aggressive and a little sultry, PJ Harvey sounds pointed and raw. Steve Albini did a phenomenal job producing this album and sounds quite a bit like In Utero.
Just not for me, I didn't really connect with it at all.
This sounds very current with the time it was released. I hear the influence of Nirvana, Sonic Youth and others. Harvey's scream/yell/sing thing fits well with this record.
She reminds me of a 90s Janis Joplin. Good music, but some of the songs sound the same.
Crunchy and noisy. Very much enjoyed this, but not quite enough for five stars. Four it is.
Steve Albini was a mad genius
Pretty good. Some of it was weird but mostly good.
7/10
Raw like the meat at the deli...which has also expired. 2/5
I couldn't get myself to enjoy this, no matter how much I tried. There is much better PJ Harvey music out there.
Dry. That's the word that best describes PJ Harvey's music. Her Feminist message is important, and fully supported from me; I just wish it was better peoduced. Favorite Track: "50ft Queenie".
Favorite Track: Rub Til It Bleeds
There were a few good moments, but the screaming and wailing got to me after a bit. Very different than the only other song I know by her.
Not bad
Badass angsty edgy 90s girl rock. I really hated the first PJ Harvey album I heard (the one from 2000) but this is a completely different side.
This album rocks. It's badass front to back. Real good shit.
Good - a bit sparse and punky to be a five, but solid. Better than Yes.
I would have been so into this in the 90’s, had I known it existed. Weighty and unpolished, just how I like it. The weirdness really hits when she goes for it. Probably as close as an album could get to 5 stars for me before it gets the honor.
What a force! Powerful passionate and a little angry. Some serious catharsis going on here.
Ferocious, stripped-back arrangements built from slashing guitars, sudden silences, pounding drums, and vocals that swing from whispered menace to explosive screams move this alternative rock album like standing in a locked room with someone slowly losing control—intimate, confrontational, unsettling in its raw emotional volatility and you have the Impulse to back out.
A complete waste of time!!
Fuck this album goes hard. So raw and so so so damn good. 10/10 Favorite tracks- “Rid of Me” “Dry” “Ecstasy”
It's OK rock music.
This was lacking a bit of the edge that is typically Harvey. Not a totally bad thing, just not what I expected.
No Notes… perfect!!!!
We support women in rock even if we never actually listen to rock!!!
Highlights: Me-Jane, Rid of Me, 50ft Queenie. In a nutshell: woman size. Ms Polly Jean Harvey didn’t think she would record a second album, let alone a first, but she did. The main difference between her debut Dry and this album is a different producer (Steve Albini) and the lofi sound quality is gone. More blues punk and grunge. In a man-sized world, PJ joined the growing number of women making noise in the 90’s. Kathleen, PJ, Liz, Shirley, Tori, Courtney and more- they were exactly what the music world needed. Overall: 5/10
I loved this. Raw, loud and packing a real punch. Reminded me a bit of Hole but also later songwriters such as Courtney Barnett, so I get why this is considered a landmark album in alternative rock. This one will stick with me
Polly Jean Harvey telling us how it is.
Loud. Kind of messy, but there were some good songs on here. I’ll have to revisit to see which ones I liked the most but I was satisfied.
Nah. Sounds like tortured animals.
Unredeemable noise
Turgid shit. Patti Smith wannabe.
Had a few PJ Harvey albums here so far, enjoy a female vocalist especially over gritty rock.
Better than Coldplay
I dont really dig her but saw her live and she was an amazing performer with great vocal range. Thougjt she sucked but after that I can listen to any of her albums and like em. Just dont love em
This is the last PJ Harvey album my group is getting, and I guess it decided to save the best for last. I can definitely hear a blues influence in her sound on this album, and that really goes with my sensibilities. 4.5 bumped up to 5.
I think I’m at a 5. A slightly muddled & hard to explain 5, but I’ll try to get there. Everyone has those occasional thoughts that pop into the head for just one moment; some deeper part of the psyche that buries itself 99% of the time, and yet that 1% creeps through to suggest something that feels unlike yourself. This album, to me, is what happens when the 1% tries to influence you more & more; it’s what happens when one's deepest anxieties & unspoken thoughts try to coexist with a carnal feeling of innate desire. PJ Harvey wrote this album after suffering a nervous breakdown, going through a breakup, gaining an eating disorder, and getting effectively kicked out of college. It is a perfect cocktail for those thoughts to creep in, and instead of letting them "win", I think she managed to distill their essence into this album. These are all written from a feminine perspective; not an explicitly feminist one, but a lot of those themes go hand-in-hand on this album, with those deeper thoughts probably acting as a subliminal hatred of patriarchy & male expectation. Granted, sometimes it’s pretty blatant, given that “Legs” is about her murdering a boyfriend by fully cutting off his legs, but I digress. A lot of the album is rooted in a conflicting desire for both love & revenge, probably inspired by her own relationships of the era. It’s kind of bipolar, in a very understandable way. For as much as she takes pleasure in seeing this pain inflicted to other people, she also seems to reach out and beg for forgiveness. It is hard to reconcile with the idea that one’s attempt at healing might just involve pulling other people down, but it’s captured perfectly here, with those snapshots of regret coming through just as quickly. I can’t say I’ve heard that cocktail of emotions captured so potently in audio form. The other aspect of desire is explored in other ways than just love; “Missed” is directly about missing out on the fruits that other people find in religion, wondering how a God so big can be so hidden to her eyes. Even the cover of “Highway 61 Revisited”, for as strange as it may seem, has a place here; it’s a track that’s all about seeking approval, whether it’s Abraham seeking it from God, Mack seeking approval to place all his scattered bullshit on the highway, or the family members seeking approval from their parents. Didn’t think I’d get a Bob Dylan song through PJ Harvey’s interpretation, but here we are. I want to really specifically point at “Man-Size Sextet” & “Man-Size”, which may end up getting away with being the only example of a remix on the main tracklist actually working to the benefit of an album. The “sextet” version has more instrumentation, with an eerier tone to it, as the strings piercing the soundscape bring to mind the shower scene in Psycho. I see it as a representation of multiple voices in the head, blurring the expectations of the night to come in a negative way. The other version forgoes the full sextet to just let one person try to pull off the whole song. There’s an emptiness to it, and one that comes across as more clear, but more desperate, since a single person can’t carry a melody by themselves. The emptiness is really potent, and it shifts the entire mood of the track. It somehow works, and it didn’t leave me mad. All of the intent aside… how does it sound? You can have a great concept for an album, but if you don’t execute it with the respect it deserves, you end up with something like “Antichrist Superstar”. Thankfully, this album’s high concept doesn’t need intense ambition behind it, or at the very least, PJ Harvey makes it feel effortlessly executed. Her compositions / structures here give a lot of space for her vocal power to breathe, along with giving each instrument a sense of intrusion that makes each track pop that much more. Steve Albini’s production work here is as good as I had hoped it would be; he uses a sense of space & volume for each track that fully grabs the ears every time. Whenever a major drop happens, or a silence washes over, it adds a living atmosphere to each track. In a way, I’m reminded of “The Downward Spiral”, but through the lens of rock bottom angst instead of pure rock bottom depression. All of my yapping aside, I think it’s an album where you have to hear it & buy into it to grasp what it’s going for. I don’t think it’s one where everyone will grasp that, or feel it in the same way that I did here. I admire the hell out of it though, and I think it deserves all the critical acclaim it gets. There are spots where the execution feels a little anti-album; a few longer outros & intros and some repetitive moments, but for the most part, it’s a 48-minute snapshot of emotions of all kinds captured in a way that I’ve never really heard before. It kept me really captivated, even if it took a bit to get there. I think it’s a 5, and for the last PJ Harvey album we’ll get on the list, I think this is one hell of a way to get rid of her. Overall, then, for someone who I’d never heard of going into this whole 1001 albums thing, it’s a hell of an impact. I really need to relisten to “Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea”, which I gave a 3.5 bumped down to a 3, but everything else was a 5 or higher. That’s a 4.625+ average, and that speaks to her versatility. I think she’s a damn fine artist, and I certainly need to seek out more of her stuff. Good job, PJ.
# Album Name: Rid of me # Artist: PJ Harvey # Rating: 4/5 # Comments: Cracking PJ Harvey album. Very emotional, lots of rock with a tinge of grunge. Take a dip in the middle which knocked it down from a 5 # Top Tunes: rid of me / missed / rub / queenie / me jane / ecstacy # Would I listen to it again? yes
Pairing loosely grunge-tinged sounds with lyrics that border on gibberish yields exactly this kind of mess. I listened intently, desperately hunting for one song worth praising, but came up empty. Were this blaring in a pub, I’d make an immediate exit.
3.2
Fun.
Wow! I wasnt that familiar with this record and I’m annoyed I didn’t py it more attention sooner. A different side to PJH that I wasn’t as familiar with. It sounds like what I think a lot of 90s rock bands wish they’d sounded like: raw, clever, considered. I know the production divided opinion, but I’m definitely in the ‘Albini aced it’ camp. Tres good, will be a repeat listener
Much preferred this to the previous PJ Harvey album, songs sound much fuller and heavier, lots more going on. Started slowly but got much better as it went on. 50ft Queenie had a big riff and there were a few other standouts, will need another listen.
I don't know why I avoid PJ Harvey. This was another strong effort; aggressive rhythms and lyrics, and great fun to listen to (listened twice). Standouts were Rid of Me, Legs, and Yuri-G, but I strongly enjoyed the whole album. More entertaining than Dry. I didn't dislike anything on the album, it thundered along.
More PJ Harvey! Think I enjoyed this more than the last one, but not as much as Dry either. Bit heavier with more attitude. 3.5 again. Not sure I'll be rushing back
First listen, honestly I am not entirely sure I get it, but I can totally see it grow on me. Sometimes it just sounds like she's making cool sounding noises (that is meant as a compliment). I suspect she may have been influenced by Patti Smith in her vocal delivery.
Great
Good Oll’ Rock, I like! 4 Bäretätzli
Jä nä-ä Holt mich nöd ab. Zu rockig, zwneig punky defür
I can’t describe how incredibly good it felt to listen to this record for the first, second, third and fourth time yesterday - imagine being brought close to multiple orgasms by a record: that was basically my experience with this masterpiece perfected by Steve Albini‘s production.
Of all the PJ Harvey albums the generator had thrown at me this is pretty easily my favorite. The first half is good, but the second half just turns it up to another level that just has this really manic and raw energy. Any album that features a Highway 61 Revisited cover is also appreciated. Favorite songs were Rid Of Me, Rub Til It Bleeds, Highway 61 Revisited, 50ft Queenie, and Me-Jane.
Awesome guitar throughout but personally struggled a lot with the singing, some aspects were good and others felt very chalk-on-a-blackboard scratchy.
Steve Albini's engineering contributes to this wonderful sound.
The production means that many of the songs don't have the same edge to them as they would have done. But at the same time, I really liked 50ft Queenie and Yuri-G and I don't think the production of those two songs were different from the rest. So I don't really know anymore. I prefer the punky riot grrrl stuff here. I wish I liked this more, this is something I should enjoy really.
personal favorite PJ harvey album, easy
Very gritty - really enjoyed the second half of the album in particular
Very raw and emotional.
PJ Harvey 3 of 4. Still don't get the high praise. It has its moments, but most of it is just meh.
abrasive
Wow love this. She's probably one of the best band leaders ever, just so much varied talent and charisma. I think the production (Steve Albini) totally suits her songwriting and aesthetic at the time, as the grimy, guitar heavy style is just amazing. The guitar tone on here is of the best ever probably. I think Steve Albini's ethos at the time (and in general I guess) was to make it sound like a live performance, which this album nails totally, and to be honest I think that's all you really need, production wise. The guitar parts are incredible, very punky, and of that loud-quiet Pixies era of technique. I love the duo of the man-size song, one with squeaky strings and stuff, and one with guitars. I feel like there's some Bleach Nirvana influence in some of the guitar riffs, or maybe that's just because of the production style. Singing and lyrics are brilliant, she has a few different styles, all of which work brilliantly over the backings. Lyrical themes are probably one of the most influential parts of her 'legacy' as I don't think many were so honest/straightforward and brutal. Favourite songs: all pretty much. Overall around 9/10
This started playing again after my first run through and I let it run. Such a varied and raw album but what an impression. A future 5 with more listens. Me-Jane the initial highlight.
more rocky again, love!
I enjoyed a lot of this. I think it's one I'd like to come back to. It feels like something that'll grow on me with a bit of time. There were some really cool bits that I don't think I gave enough attention to.
Bruh come one now
Why the hell have I slept on this for 30 years?! This album is outstanding. it really is like nothing else. This is the second PJ Harvey album I got and honestly, the first one was pretty much what I thought a PJ Harvey album would sound like, albeit with a couple surprisingly good songs. THIS one, however, is a goddamned juggernaut from start to finish. Is it a 5 star album? Probably not, it's a 4.5 in a world that's just, and fair. But it's an absolute rocking good time, and I would absolutely listen to it again for fun. Like Skunk Anansie, I think this gets an extra half star for the surprise factor - and the fact that there really isn't a weak song on the album.
This slaps. Really solid music.
The middle of the great PJ Harvey trilogy of albums!
I get it. It's very rough around the edges and sludgy intentionally. That's kind of cool. Although I do wish I could hear the songs a bit more clearer. Either way, very good album by an artist I'm usually not as in love with as a lot of people seem to be. Key tracks: Rid of Me
People slagging the production on this one really dont understand the concept of rock. Steve Albini manages to make it sound raw and live, and at the same time detailed and focused. Great songs, great performance, excellent production. This one goes on my to buy list.
Pretty noisy and many lyrics are repetitive.
This is an interesting album. I've listened to it maybe five or six times in my life, and every time, I quite enjoy the experience while listening ( I love the way it sounds), but it never sticks with me. I'm left with no desire to return to it, and when I do, years later, it feels like I've never heard it before. I think this one sits between 3 and 4 more so than any album yet. I bad about giving it a 3, because it's better all the threes I've given out, yet it doesn't really deserve a 4 either. In the end, I'll round up for the concept of PJ Harvey.
I hate that you can't save reviews when rating, just in case you get interrupted and have to step away. Goddamit. Oh well, skipping the review. This is fucking great and gets a 5. I'd give it more if I could.
I’ve been revisiting this album every five or ten years since it came out, wondering what is wrong with me since I can’t really get into it. I like the guitar tone, the uncomfortable sex/violence/gender subject matter, the live sounding production (mostly), and I like her voice. After listening again, I think I just don’t get enough hooks, either guitar or vocal melody. It makes it so I enjoy the experience of the album but I couldn’t sing a single line back to you. I have two smaller gripes. First, is that I think this bassist sucks. For the most part he just plays the guitar line and rarely engages with the drummer, leaving him on an island and burying the bass in the mix under the guitar. Second, the mix sounds very live, and I like it generally, but I don’t think you can hear the kick drum and the compression/mastering is bananas especially on the first track. It’s probably intentional to get you to turn it up and split ears, but it’s crazy low. Favorite is 50ft Queenie and least favorite is Rub ‘Til It Bleeds for all the reasons I listed
Kinda like the Bjork situation: I think PJ Harvey is deeply cool, but I don't like her songs so much. They're okay, and all have interesting parts. But this album is mostly too dissonant, and the songs too loosely structured, for my taste.
3/5 - If someone does a remix of this that isn't intentionally annoying, I'd probably give it a 4. As it is, it's a pain in the ass to listen to and keep adjusting the volume to actually hear the tracks. I like the noise and attitude here a lot.
Before the world had “Jagged Little Pill” the cool people had “Rid of Me”
I tried. Put it on and it somehow just faded to the background as if I wasn't listening to anything at all.
Shoutout to women and weed
polly jean my beloved…
Raw, which is a good thing, but also a little too basic.
A Woman Under The Verge of a Nervous Breakdown.
Raw and powerful sound
Too slow and grating
Liked some songs. Found that I could not really get into it.
This one not so much
The third PJ Harvey album that this list has given me, and it's as bad as the others. I really hate this style of singing with the screamy constipated sound
i thought i'd really enjoy this album...but i did not. female alt singer-songwriter is my jam, but this is just so...droning, same-y, needlessly loud, cacophonous. man-sized sextet - i did very much enjoy this one and found it very interesting me-jane is another stand-out, snake as well
Not her best album as IMHO 'To Bring you my Love' was when she hit the mark. No stand out tracks and it's a bit heavy on the percussion, which is annoying with her voice grating at times. No stand out tracks, just a bit jarring and not in a good way.
Much more creative than a lot of the grunge/alt rock of the time.
Way better than I was expecting, I love the raw energy of this album and PJ Harvey’s voice is soooo good. Definitely recommend this one. Standout Songs: Missed Legs Rub 'Til It Bleeds Man-Size Sextet 50ft Queenie Man-Size Dry Me-Jane
I got 2 PJ harvey albums in a row. Listening to 2 tracks off the first album, that was enough to give both these albums a 1. So so boring.
Now this is the palette cleanser I needed after that fucking dross that was Adele. THIS is actual talent. Polly Jean shrieks and wails and growls and sings about a range of emotions. In a just world, this would be a multi-million selling album. Fuck. I'm still ranting about Adele's shit. Sorry Peej. Best Tracks: Rub It Till It Bleeds; 50ft Queenie; Man-Size
Very interesting sounds there PJ
In the end really good album. Like I don’t really remember the exact moments when I was like wow but I definitely had those moments where I extra ordinarily enjoyed some tracks while some are just there. First track definitely got me Solid 6.5/10 might even increase on next re listen
THIS album doesn't make any sense. it fast, it is slow, its chaotic
oseudo gronge? Bof
Hun er go'. Men har fortjent flere gennemlytninger. Det blev lidt hakket i stykker over flere afteners madlaving.
Didn’t land for me personally but I can appreciate the rawness in her performance
Raw and energetic, much better than I remember. Patti Smith on steroids
PJ Harvey's early albums are just great stuff.
Strange album. Not really my cup of tea.
I really want to like the music of PJ Harvey ... but, alas, it's just too much caterwauling for me.
Incredible, full of energy. Some of the songs would not work individually but as part of the album, they are all enjoyable.
I truly hope that there are more albums by PJ Harvey on this list, because I definitely do not regard this as her best. As an artist, she grew over the years and maybe also outgrew the experimental indie-noise of this album. I was never a fan of Steve Albini's "sound" either, so that doesn't help. It's not bad, but it just doesn't resonate with me as her later albums would. 3/5
I think this album was fine. There were some good tracks but there were others that really dragged this album more than it should. I would have given this a 4 if they would have trimmed down the album. PJ Harvey's music is enjoyable as I did review a previous album made by her but this one did feel repetitive.
Woof. Too much like the first album that came up here, and not enough like the second. Not really for me.
Not bad. The mix is weird but also sounds like grungey indy music from the 90s. This is also the fourth album by PJ on this list so far??
She's quite good!
boring
It's not bad, I just don't enjoy PJ Harvey
it good but stories gooder
I enjoyed this album more as it played, not sure if it was because the later songs were better or I was just acclimating. I would have liked it more if it was either - a little more slick and poppy, or heavier - instead it sits in this middle ground of being raw and angry but not really catchy enough for pop or heavy enough for hard rock. I’m sure this was probably intentional, but for me, moving further in one of those directions would have been something I would listen to more than once.
Songs were good until the chorus then they got too heavy for too long.
Great raw sound and lots of angst.
I'm a bigger fan of her solo stuff. But really liked 50ftQueenie off of this album.
The snare drum on this album sounds exactly like In Utero, I suppose makes sense with Steve Albini and all, and I thought that was cool. But that's about all I thought was cool about this. It's that lethal mix on the linear scale of boring and annoying. I want to like PJ Harvey for the vibe, but everything about this album was simply awful
wish i could be this cool, angry feminist and pretend to like this album but omg it’s awful. I’ve seen her live 2,5 times now and this is not the PJ I’ve experienced
Not in the mood
DON’T YOU WISH YOU NEVER, NEVER MET HER?
So energetic! Her best album
1.me - 1 2. mizzed - 1 3. legz - 1 4. Rub -1 5. Hook - 1 6. Man - 0 7. Highway - 1 8. Queenie - 0 9. Yuri - 0 10. Size - 0 11. Dry - 1 12. Jane - 1 13. Snake - 1 14. Ecstacy - 1
I've started getting some insight to hopefully rate semi-objectively, this was OK for me - not my favourite of PJ's work. 🔥 1. Raw, Uncompromising Sound Produced by Steve Albini, the album is a masterclass in abrasive minimalism. The recording captures the live, unfiltered power of the PJ Harvey trio — no polish, no overdubs, just sharp dynamics that swing from whisper-quiet tension to violent distortion. Songs like “50ft Queenie” and “Man-Size” are practically feral in their intensity. 💔 2. Feminist Ferocity and Subversion Harvey flips the male gaze on its head. Her lyrics dissect sexuality, obsession, and power dynamics with visceral honesty and menace, often adopting roles of both predator and victim. The title track, for instance, is both erotic and vengeful — a performance of female rage that was groundbreaking in the early ’90s alt-rock landscape. 🎤 3. Defining Artistic Identity This album cemented PJ Harvey’s reputation as a bold, uncompromising artist. Compared to her debut (Dry), Rid of Me is darker, stranger, and more confrontational — establishing her as someone who would constantly reinvent herself rather than settle into one sound. 🌍 4. Influence and Legacy It influenced countless artists across genres — from Fiona Apple to St. Vincent — by proving that female singer-songwriters could be dangerous, experimental, and unapologetically loud. It also helped shape the sonic identity of the ’90s underground scene, bridging the gap between punk’s rawness and indie’s introspection. 🎧 5. Critical and Cultural Impact Upon release, it divided listeners — some called it “unlistenable,” others hailed it as genius — but time has confirmed it as a bold artistic statement that expanded what rock could express. It’s an album that still feels confrontational, intimate, and alive.