Reviews (page 13 of 16)
Standout tracks: We Don’t Care, Spaceship
It's Kanye, so you know what you're getting. Great production and sampling. Lame lyrics. Ugly ego. This album evokes memories of a time when Kanye was almost endearing, as opposed to the insufferable turd he is now. Some good tunes here, even if some are beginning to show signs of age. An impressive debut album that is unfortunately tied to a narcissistic personality.
Quite enjoyed it even though its not my preferred genre
Blue Scholars vibes, especially the opening track and some flow hallway through the album. Gives similar upbeat 2000s summer feel, but is nowhere near the lyrical content of Blue Scholars. Decent album, a couple of bangers, don't care for skits. It is Kanye though, you can definitely hear the ego throughout, but significantly more humble than 2023 Kanye.
Before he spent a decade taking the rap game back to school a few times, Kanye was humble—or at least still able to pretend. Unlike his future works, much of The College Dropout's content is genuinely grounded and relatable; even the title and cover art of his debut evoke a self-effacing sense of dejection. But as a no-name producer for bigger names, Ye was the only one in the room who knew what his future held and he clearly felt pressure to prove it on his debut. While his later output—especially his rapping—would become raw and uncut, the bars here are remarkably tight. No head-shakers about bleached assholes here. While his wit and flow are uncharacteristically slick on The College Dropout, his production skills remain the undisputed star of the show and the source of his influence on the shape of hip hop to come. His signature chipmunk soul sound was fully formed right out the gate, inspiring many other artists to jam sped-up soul samples into their beats in Kanye's wake. Later West staples like orchestral strings, techno synths, and overdriven autotune pop up here and there as prototypes foreshadowing the rise of hip hop's future architect. All of it coalesces into a varied but cohesive podium from which Kanye introduces himself to a pop culture that would consume him as he consumed it. Standouts: It's been a while since I heard this, so I was taken aback by how just how many great songs are here. There's a lot of filler tracks on this album, but none of them are actual songs. "Through The Wire," "Slow Jamz," "All Falls Down" and "Jesus Walks" would all be unmatched peaks of any other career. Sleepers: "Breathe In, Breathe Out" goes hard while still matching the tone of the rest of the record. It's hard to call it underrated, but "Spaceship" deserves more credit as a rare example of a very smooth hip hop waltz. Stinkers: The last 8 minutes of "Last Call" is an interesting story to hear once, but adds unnecessary bloat to an already long runtime. The same can be said of the multiple skits, though the School Spirit skits have a legitimately funny payoff. four out of four degrees: associate's, bachelor's, master's and doctorate
Not me
I'm trying to ignore how much i dislike him as a human (BTW, mental health is a very serious problem and should not be ignored) but it's just music I cant connect with. I just didn't like it.
Kanye is sketch AF but the album is good.
Fantastic
One of Kanye’s finest albums. Great listen.
Classic album, great intro, the skits between songs takes away a bit
Fun as hell
Dumb music for dumb people.
Can’t stand Kanye and that Yeezys record was not good. This album has some likable tracks though. It’s hard to deny he has a talent for what he does.
I must have listened to this when it came out because i knew a lot of the songs. It's interesting to hear what he sounded like before becoming a walking trash bag.
Kanye is a terrible human being and I wish he wasn't talented so I wouldn't have to hear about him. But he is, and it's evident on this album. By far my favorite of the Kanye we listened to. That's not to say I enjoyed it, I didn't really. But I can see how much talent is here. Give me this 100 times over that terrible Yeezus album
Great album, bad dude
Couple of good tracks, otherwise kind of a slog.
блин, так приятно начать слушать вдумчиво канье с такого расслабона (особенно понимая как поедет он дальше кукухой)
Ахуеть, репчик про школу, серьёзно? Нет, можно было конечно по названию предположить, что так и будет, но даже все возможные ожидания это переплюнуло. С творчеством Канье у меня знакомство очень поверхностное; я слушал Donda, потому что мы обсуждали всякие разные концептуальные альбомы с Артемием Соловьёвым. И тогда на меня это произвело впечатление, потому что там были местами супер-минималистичные биты, хоралы, он был прям весь нагружен... Здесь же скорее вайбы Бисти Бойз: репчик про школу, про большой член, про диплом. Блин я так ору с этих панчей про "что ты оставишь после себя? Диплом", это мега хорошо. Да и вообще он сделан ещё так, будто из прошлой эпохи. Вот этот вот запитченый женский вокал... не эксперт, когда это появилось, но сейчас это звучит уже очень старомодно. Эх, был бы ты Канье человеком нормальным...
Great Album, they do not make them like this anymore
It’s still very hard to listen to Kanye. His antisemitism ruined this so much. Why has everyone forgiven him? Fuck him. Having said, had he not become that, this would probably be 5… I’ll give it a 4.
Great album, nice throwback to the proper Kanye music. Good to chill to.
Not that interested. More like anecdotes of an angry man set to music. Not worth the reputation.
No me apetece nada. Ninguna de estas canciones está entre las 10 más oídas en Spotify. Vamos a pasar una horita con esto. Coritos de niños y rap. Y veo influencias de Lauryn Hill que me parecen bien. Me guardo "All falls down" y "Jesus Walks" pero tengo que darle otro repaso, creo que también a su disco con más hits, "Graduation".
Man fuck Kanye as a person, but this album is so fucking good. I got this in my rotation heavy already. It really is baffling that the guy who made this album and said "George Bush doesn't care about black people" ended up a fucking republican and worse, a Nazi. I'm not gonna gush too much about it, but this was so extremely influential in hip-hop that he basically shaped the next 15 years of hip-hop after this album after. From the production to the flows to the personal content of the album this was such a home run. Hate the man, but love the album this is a light to decent 5 out of 5 no doubt.
You know it's really a shame that guy went and became a Nazi.
1. Family Business 2. Never let me down 3. All falls down
Easily one of the best albums top to bottom, the flow is tremendous, absolutely insane use of the human voice
My favorite album of all time PERIOD. I wasn't really expecting there to be any Kanye on here so I was very pleasantly surprised. Everything about this album is just incredible from Kanye's early soul sample production to the incredible cast of mid 2000s rap legends on here, not to dismiss Kanye's rapping and singing on this album at all because that's also amazing. The skits are some of the only skits on any album that I actually find funny and well done, Late Registration's are also great though. All around incredible album and incredible listening experience could not recommend more. All Falls Down is also my favorite song of all time. Favorite Tracks: We Don't Care, Graduation Day, All Falls Down, Spaceship, Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down, The New Workout Plan, Slow Jamz, Breathe In Breathe Out, School Spirit, Lil Jimmy Skit, Two Words, Through The Wire, Family Business, Last Call
Pros: Admittedly I have never listened to a Kanye album before now. I like the sound, it’s fun to listen to, better than I anticipated. Cons: I can’t really relate to most of the things he raps about, and I have a difficult time getting past Kanye being Kanye… I wish entertainers would just stick to what they’re good at.
I'll be honest, there's rarely a week that goes by that I don't jam at least one track from Dropout. I think West's strength has always been in production, and it shows on his debut. Check out that big, high stepping beat with those keyed up soul samples on School Spirit for a prime example of the sound he established on this record. The impact of that vibe is still reverberating in hip hop almost 20 years later. it's kind of bittersweet listening to this album in the time where kanye has lost his damn mind, but the dude had some great verses on this album. I'll put All Falls Down up against any 'conscious rap' tune. It seems kind of ironic listening to kanye criticizing materialism, but I respect that he has always been willing to voice his own struggles with faith, insecurity, wealth and fame. 1 star deduction for song to skit ratio being 1:5
I have never understood the appeal of Kanye. This is odd, but also doesn't seem that technically impressive. Maybe I'll read the other reviews and discover what I'm missing. But this album didn't change much for me.
I want to start off by saying Kanye West is one of my least favorite people on the planet, and I hope he gets the help he needs because it’s warranted. That being said, I want to rate this album as a true album separate from the artist’s antics, and it’s great. I bought this on CD on a whim at a truck stop between Texas and Pennsylvania as a teenager. I think I had heard one or two songs on the radio and thought I’d give this CD a chance. It was perfect for that long car ride up and back, and the album was on repeat. “All Falls Down”, “Jesus Walks”, and “We Don’t Care” were on repeat. It might be nostalgia talking a little bit, and I was exposed to this well before Kanye went crazy, but I still look on this album fondly and find myself listening to a song or two from it periodically. 5/5 but I’m slightly ashamed to be doing so.
59/100
I don't know much about hip-hop but from the records that were on my list from this genre, it was one of the most enjoyable ones so far. Musically there are some quite good songs here. What I dislike about the album the most is the length - with so much lyrics it is really overwhelming to listen to it in one sitting for someone like me who is a non native speaker.
He's a really bad person and I hate him for that, but I cannot deny he has made some of the best hiphop music ever.
Highly grudging - as much as i don’t like Kanye I did enjoy some of this album and especially the flow over the whole thing, and the more soul influences. I think it’s probably good for a rap / hh album that’s just not what I really enjoy listening to. I enjoyed the themes of the songwriting - education, money, power.
It's old kanye, so it's automatically better kanye.
This album was not made for me. I didn't connect to it's religious motifs or personally relate to its description of black Americans culture, struggles, oppression. Absolutely not holding that against it, I didn't really care for his tone (it felt monotone and staccato in a bad way frequently) & the album was SO long. I don't want to rate the first non-rock album I finally get low but I just don't fuck with Kanyes less like "pop hits single on the radio" stuff (maybe with repeated listens but idk)
Ah what an absolute corker. Shame he's an absolute bell-end and beyond that publicly anti-semitic amongst other less-than-shining attributes. The recent events make reviewing his older work very complicated and confusing. But I've always loved this album a lot it's one of my favourites and hugely nostalgic of a teenage era of life, the skits take me to another time and place in my head. The rhymes, lines, and riffs are absolute pure genius. So so clever and an insight into a very different mind, very big shame he has now ruined it all. I'm rating 5 as an appreciation of this old work but begrudgingly because I'm very pissed at this man.
Well I know this is regarded as one of the best KW albums and I have to say I agree. It was tight and funny and far less self involved and weird as his latter work. Obviously hard to feel that supportive of him given his recent antisemitism and general idiocy... But listening to this separately from those thoughts it was good wasn't it
Probably my favourite Kanye album, absolutely brilliant. Good mix of fun, serious, happy, sad, just hits the right notes. Shame he's a twat but it's a right banger.
I’ve been in the dark about a lot of Kanye’s music. Man this album is really well produced, I’ve ’known’ about it, but never listened. Good character and great beats.
Music's good. Unfortunately it's Kanye.
I was expecting to hate it but i didn't. Enjoyed the rhythms some of the lyrics washed over me which was probably a good thing. Couple of songs seemed a bit egotistical. If I'd concentrated on lyrics I might have scored lower
Why did you have to blow it kanye?
This album was pretty cool. Too bad Kanye is a skinhead facist. That was saved by the fat kid in super bad
not listening
One of the most impressive debut albums in hip hop.
Surprisingly good--but too many skits.
Some good points from the collab artists but I don't like Kanye either in his music or his off putting personality so there is zero chance I'll come back to this, I have more fulfilling things to do such as get a root canal.
Amazing album. Strange that he is aligned with christo-fascists these days
Ignoring recent event. Not really my taste in music, so I went in with some trepidation. However, I was mostly quite surprised. There were some deeper lyrics and obvious passion to the album. Would I listen again? Probably not, but if something like this came on again, I may not instantly pass it by. Beats we're good for running to - nicely timed and album builds though the songs well. Running rating: 6/10
I've never listened to a Kanye album before, the only song I recognized was "through the wire" it was ok as an album overall. Beats were good rapping was decent, all the guest appearances were better than anything Kanye rapped. So overall meh, not going to give another listen
Fuck Kanye.
Mitä räppiin tulee niin mä en oo kaikkein perehtynein, mutta mielestäni varsin kelpo levy. Ymmärrän miksi tää oli iso juttu. 3/5
Joku sanoittikin tuolla jo sanasta sanaan ajatukseni: "At the time of The College Dropout's release, every pop rap record consisted of bad gangsters rapping about the difficulties of growing up in Detroit, robbing stores and spraying your rivals with a glock. Kanye changed this with humorous, touching lyrics, extremely rhythmic optimism, fire beats, and a touching and honest view of his own faith and failures. He inspired a generation of rappers to express themselves more genuinely and explore more alternative forms of hiphop, and it's something I still greatly admire him for. An easy 5/5." Mielestäni kaikkien aikojen paras rap-levy ja ehkä myös paras pop-levy.
Jos turhat skitit ja muu läski leikattais pois, olis helppo 5/5. Valitettavasti ilman tiivistämistä jää neloseen, vaikka osa Kanyen parhaista biiseistä onkin täällä.
Its a classic. despite his controversies i still enjoy this album a lot.
Its production is much more interesting and unique than most rap albums on here, but it’s still not for me.
BEST SONGS: -All Falls Down -Get Em High
2/5. I’m not a big rap guy and definitely was not a fan of West’s Anti-Education rhetoric. My favorite song ended up being the “Last Call” song. A 12 minute spoken word story about Kanye’s upbringing and his first record deal.
When Kanye is good, he’s amazing. I wish it were a greater percentage of his stuff.
Decent album, not my typical genre. Good for background listening. The longer I listen to it, the more I like it though!
Ik probeerde hier met redelijk open mind in te gaan. Het begon best prima opzich, al excelleerde het nergens. En toen kwam er een tirade over diploma's en wat niet, toen was ik er wel klaar mee. Ja we snappen het Kanye, jij bent vast veel slimmer dan iedereen en hebt college niet afgemaakt, maar kom op, je hoeft je niet zoveel beter dan iedereen te voelen. Stomme gay fish. 2 sterren.
4.5
I've never given Kanye much of a shot in the past, and unfortunately it's harder than ever too now. That said, this is a damn good album. 3.5/5
Don't like this man or his music. Narcissist!!!
Some cliche and self-absorbed lyrics but original style and a great break from gansta. All Falls Down is great.
This was rap, rap sucks.
This was rough. Basically Kanye babbling about with some beat tracks playing in the background for over an hour. Pretty stupid. 1/5
My second Kanye album, and I'm rating it the same as the first. Seems like the guy has always been a dumbass, just a musically talented dumbass. Lyrics are just embarrassing. "The drug game bulimic, it's hard to get weight So nigga's money is homo, it's hard to get straight" "Ooh girl your breath is harsh! Cover your mouth up like you got SARS" Glorifying drug dealing, discouraging kids from going to college, and many, many other things I just can't relate to in this. The album closes with a super long story about how he got a record contract with a beat underneath. I'm sure this won't be the last Kanye West album I'll be forced to endure, unfortunately.
Surprisingly relevant, especially in this day and age when Uni is expected of you.
still great, Kanye things just kind of aged funny for me
Wow so fun!
Oh Kanye. This album, like so many more of his, is a masterpiece. I was grooving to this, cranking it on my way into work only to remind myself that he's a Nazi and to turn it down at red lights, lest people think the wrong things about me. Ugh. I want him to get the help he so clearly needs, but mental health can't always be used as an excuse... I mean, he was always kinda an asshole... I'm meandering, but Kanye was my first true foray into Hip Hop as a whole; he hit when I was in high school and was a total breath of fresh air in comparison to the stuff that was coming out. I loved his music, he was smooth, confident, funny and had great production. It's a bummer he went the way he did
Literal self-identified Nazi. There is no amount of good this album could be that would convince me to listen to it.
I no no
oh been waiting for this one. 5
There's probably not an artist anywhere who does a) generally good work and b) makes me feel exhausted upon immediately reading their name. I listened to this album a lot when it first came out. There's a lot of really good work on this. But I haven't listened to it in years, mainly because I don't want to think about Kanye. But here we go. I mean, this is good. There's really nothing here that loses me. And I kind of like out anti-college it is. It's pretty obsessed with college being a waste of time which seems petty but it's beaten into the ground so hard that it becomes funny. This is good. I wish Kanye was a likable guy.
Kanye is an unlikeable mess when he's outside of a studio, and sometimes within one too. But this? It's pretty great, highly entertaining and made me laugh more than once. Can't deny talent, even if the person who wields it is deeply unpleasant.
Legendary
Enjoyed more than i thought i would but a little too much swearing for me!!!
Not really my style, but not terrible. All the interludes were mostly awkward feeling and not funny.
R&B Rap ja pop tyylinen sampläys.. Hyvä albumi nautinnollinen
Not my cup of tea.
damn bitch what happened
This a real good album. Alot of fun, so many top quality bars throughout, full of cheek and wit. Fav track: Two words 4/5
The irony of these (great) bars stings. Jaunty, fun, intelligent and incredibly accessible. The style wears a little thing for me over the inflated runtime. Fave track: Jesus Walks
Clear mixed feelings here - but I also doubt anyone is really ever going to read this. So yeah, Kanye has damaged his legacy a fair amount by his own doing. He can get fucked. If he dropped a new album tomorrow, I'm not sure I'd listen. This album is also very very good. It is very very good. I listened to this a lot in high school, and I liked it a lot then. And this listen was also really good. So I don't know. I'll give this rating today based on just how I'm feeling about the spin I gave over the weekend, and maybe I'll change my mind later and go back and change it. Let's move on to the next one. Fave track: Through The Wire
Bijzonder goed debut album. Met dit album heeft hij laten zien dat hij niet alleen goed kan producen maar ook kan rappen. 'Through the Wire' blijft mijn favo hitje van dit album. Funfact: Mevrouw Chaka Khan was helemaal geen fan van hoe Kanye haar nummer had gesampled tot dat het een hit werd. Jammer dat Kanye zo'n bipolaire gek is.
Through the wire is echt een van mijn allllllerlievelingsnummers dus was zo blij dat jur op vakantie zei dat we deze moesten luisteren!!!! Niet m’n favorietste album van Kanye maar als nog dikke 4 sterren voor toch wel een absurd invloedrijk en vet album
Onwijs sterk debuutalbum, hits die vandaag de dag nog steeds worden gedraaid. Kanye als producer vind ik misschien wel een van de beste, hij kan samples gebruiken als geen ander. Maar rappen kan die ook. Humor, zelfreflectie en ironie komen genoeg voor op het album, waar ik samen met de skits wel van hou bij hiphop. Het behoort helaas niet tot m'n favoriete Kanye album, met een lengte van ruim een uur staat er te veel filler op. Ander puntje wat me hier opvalt is de hypocrisie die ik in de andere reviews lees. Het maakt mij niks uit wat je van alle artiesten hier vindt, maar ze zijn er als de kippen bij om Kanye van alles te beschuldigen en af te doen, terwijl ze wel gewoon 5'jes aan MJ, the Smiths en alle andere freaks uitdelen. De 1001 lijst zit vol met weirdo's, pedo's en andere psychopaten. Als je die eruit haalt blijft er weinig meer over. Luister gewoon de muziek, een statement maken in je sullige review boeit niemand wat (net als wat ik nu doe).
This is actually better than his later works. The songs are more fleshed out and there's more energy in this compared to his rapping on the later albums which is almost lazy and the songs feel somewhat incomplete. I still don't like Kanye as I think there's better rappers out there and the fact that he's a crazy racist.
top 5 hiphop
Going to speak to the historical context of this album and give credit for the novelty and creativity. But the more that comes out about this artist the less I can support him. He's an ignorant and potentially mentally ill racist.
Good
Fuck Kanye. But GDI his early stuff is just so good. Have to separate the artist from the art sometimes I guess...
I was surprised by how much I enjoyed this album. I can see why it was so culturally important when it came out. Every song still feels fresh and it's an album I could see myself listening to frequently. It makes me kinda sad to think how talented Kanye was compared to who he is now.
I don't listen to Kanye any more at all these days, and it's certainly been a while since I've listened to this, and man is this a great record. Still sounds as fresh as it did nearly 20 (!!!) years ago when it came out. Great record.
He's unfortunately a genius. Still opting for 4 stars here since I think this one is weaker than some of his others (like MBDTF and Graduation.) Also, he can handle getting a hit to his ego.
It's personally difficult to fully grasp how pivotal this album is for Kanye and hip-hop in general. I tried to be egregiously critical (or nitpicky, I guess is the better term) of this album as it is not my favorite Kanye album. I actively tried to not give this a 5 but I definitely forgot how consistently good the album is. I _think_ my one gripe besides a song or two is that Kanye went really skit heavy towards the back end of the album. I guess it makes sense given that Kanye really likes skits/outtakes when he listens to music so this album, in a way, is a reflection of that. Also, I think the mixing/mastering is interesting. It feels its age, definitely. It sounds boxy. It was like the first thing I noticed when We Don't Care started playing. I think this is excusable as it only got better with future releases. Will we ever get an explanation on why Kanye said on Two Words, "So I live by two words: Fuck you; pay me."? That's four words. One thing this album does better than other Kanye albums is that his humor really shines through this album. Sure, there are corny, funny one-liners in songs in other albums but there are whole bits that aren't meant to be taken seriously here. Examples of this would be The New Workout Plan, all the skits belittling the value of college degrees, and the build up to Twista's verse in Slow Jamz just to name a few. Feeling a light 5 on this one. If this whole 1001 album experience was a tier-list ranking, TCD would be in S-tier but probably at the far-right of it just like where Kanye is at now politically.
Same as I said on the other Kanye album... Many of the more tolerable moments involved guest vocalists.
No thanks
I like that old Kanye
If someone tells me they’re a nazi I believe ‘em
Listen, it's a fine album and if I were rating this 10 or so years ago, I would've given it three, maybe four stars. But hindsight's a bitch and his recent antics and rhetoric and faux-gospel antics make listening to his weak linguistics (but jammi' beats) akin to someone directly vomiting in my ear. He's a dick (and a tiny one at that).
In 2023, Kanye West is a maniac. He is an attention whore with a bizarre clothing line, a MAGA weirdo and a stain on culture and society who is surrounded by Yes Men. But in 2004 when he came out with The College Dropout, then Late Registration and finally Graduation? The absolute KING of rap for a few seasons. It was a pleasure to re-listen to The College Dropout. Amazing album! Great skits and bouncy, lighthearted and beautiful rapping and rhyming. All Falls Down was the first KW song I heard, and it’s still excellent almost 17 after I first listened to it. Other hits include Jesus Walks, Slow Jamz (fast rappin from Twista!), Never Let Me Down, Through the Wire and smooth, light and family-focused track Family Business. One you can nod your head to. What ever happened to this likable version of Kanye?!
Passable, if I ignore the talking sections. 2.5*
Not as good as the twisted fantasy one. That one had a vibe, this one seems a bit more rambling…
Not too bad, not at all my kind of music. I found it easy to listen to but not special
This feels a LITTLE bit like being "yeah but have you seen Hitler's paintings they're pretty good" / separating the art from the artist but I simply can't go lower than a 5. It's such a shame, I think he really does need help for a couple different disorders and is also a deranged ultra rich guy. Nice to travel back to when his feet were still on the ground.
Listening to this, you can’t help but sigh and wonder where it all went wrong. This is a fantastic album and it’s not even his best work. The sampling is out of this world, the rapping is clean, smart, and funny. Jesus Walks is a classic, but imo it does kind of foreshadow his later Christianity overload. Still, a triumph.
I expected more of a rap album and was surprised that this had a lot more R&B feel. Liked it more than I thought I would. Too bad he lost his mind.
I have not listened to Kanye since he became a nazi but man this was great to hear. What an excellent album musically. “We Don’t Care” is a powerful mission statement and has to be one of the best track 1s on a debut album ever. The skits I would be happy to never hear again (especially the one making fun of people who get degrees) but the songs were all on point. Phenomenal production, biting commentary on race and lots of humor throughout. There is a of course a strain of intellectualism here which makes his support for trump less surprising in retrospect. I MISS THE OLD KANYE.
He's a better producer than lyricist. Feel like I'm talking about a different guy to current Kanye
Stronger was probably the best track on this album which worked well around the Draft Punk (?) sample. I'm uncomfortable with a lot of the lyrics on the album, I appreciate it's nearly 20 years ago, but they still don't sit well with me . The beats were okay.... probably would have enjoyed the album better without the lyrics. This is not a genre of music I'm a stranger too. I've struggled to identify what about the album gets it on this list. I was glad when it finished.
I wanted to hate this...but it was actually quite good and I can see why it is on the list. Kanye came across as an amusing guy and the tunes were interesting but there is the artist vs art argument agian which is tricky ( my very next album was MJ's Thriller so some interesting morale quandaries this week ...
Solid set. Only one clunker in the list - stupid Workout song. Otherwise pretty good stuff. I am obviously not a hip-hop guy, but this is really good for an album without real guitar and drums.
A great start to a strong musical career. Creative, leans heavily on a good sense of R&B which not enough hip hop or rap does today. Found myself singing along which is rare for a rap record. Runs a little long, no rap album needs to be an hour.
A hip hop masterclass from a world class asshole
I hadn't listened to this before, but I see the appeal. That said, Kanye is a bigot. Kanye's use of some outdated terms that are pretty offensive these days. We don't listen to Kanye in this household.
When Kanye wasn't a dick
Where did it all go wrong Mr West
I hate Kanye and this album isn’t that good either
It's inventive, knows what it's grounded in really well, the features are all brilliantly selected, the samples are all used effectively, the tunes are banging, the rapping is great and the lyrics are not only refreshing but also genuinely funny and memorable a lot of the time. 5
This was pretty fun but I think I liked some others of his better.
4.0
Before Trump. Before the conspiracy theories. Before the antisemitism. It's easy to forget amongst all of his various controversies, that Kanye West was (is?) a rapper, and a good one too. He showed his promise on this debut album, with a charming, easy-going vocal style. There's some occasional wonky production, including on the hit single, but overall, an auspicious first effort.
It’s a 3-4
Always a great producer. He's also a dickhead. Debut album is full of decent tunes even if not a favourite genre of mine. I will always hate skits. Its. It's too long too.
I wanted to not like this because Kanye is... yeah. But, damn it was really great (could do without the skits though)
dnl
3.5 stars. Very impressive debut album. Lyrics tend away from "gangster" feel and are more introspective. The sped up beats/production as well as the guest artists are the strong points of this album. Although there are plenty of hits, personal favorite is "Spaceship."
Grounded Kanye was a thing of beauty. This album was the culmination of at least 6 years of work as a producer and it shows. Every track is inspired and unique, well written, clever, and produced to perfection. Kanye's like seemed to take a dark turn somewhere between Graduation and 808s, it's sad really. I truly do miss the old Kanye.
Hip-hop fusión. Está bien. Un 4.
Family Business escuchable. Me ha parecido un rollo. Igual si tradujera las letras ....
peak audio
Ele sabe que é o maior
Better than expected
Can ye be bothered - no!!!
kanye... nope
This is quite the dilemma, it feels a bit like the medical research done by Nazis in WW2, should we use it to save lives, knowing it was based on unethical experiments? Although Kanye West is a terrible person, this is a very good album. It's also a breath of fresh air compared to the generic gangster rap garbage that was doing the rounds at the time. If it was anyone else it would be a 5 star album, but because I know it's a bigot that produced this, I'm reducing it to 4 stars.
I did not want to like this, because of what Kanye has become. But man, he really had some talent. This was great.
Not a fan of this music.
Amazing, but Kanye :(
Didn't listen because Kanye is nuts
You know where I stand.
Classic... Way better Rap Opera than the streets album. Oh how far we've fallen from grace, hearing Kanye through gritted teeth is inspiring, hearing Kanye act like a crazy fool, annoying. The art is still good though, 3 stars for chipmunk rap.
This album resonates with me.... And I have good memories of it. Its sillly and creative and hits hard and has variety. It doesn't feel like the hip hop that I dislike. It has a story and a message.
Always Heard How Kanye West was a amazing rap artist and probably the best artist of the 2000's, I have never heard really any of his albums but have liked a few of his songs. So was quite excited to give this a listen! After Listening to this you can tell alot of modern artists used Kayne's West's style nowadays. he pioneered a generator. aside from the skits and school spirit this is a amazing album
Je trouve Kanye West imbuvable, mais dans ce premier album il a une conscience sociale et de bons textes. J'aime mon hip-hop plus «dansant», mais c'était satisfaisant
Feels like high school
Not interested
Classic early 00's hip-hop. Without the sketches would be perfect. Still can't rate it lower than 5 because it's better than a 4 for sure.
We Don’t Care- Catchy and poignant 👍 All Falls Down- Another catchy hook, with lyrics about consumerism 👍 I’ll Fly Away- pretty rendition of a hymn leading into next track Spaceship- I really like the chorus, GLCs verse lacks for me a bit 👍 Jesus Walks- This is a powerful track, if feeling a bit put on at times Never Let Me Down- Kanyes verse is amazing, Jay Z flexing as usual 👍 Get Em’ High- meh The New Workout Plan- This is good, but not something I would want to listen to a lot, and its defo v dated Slow Jamz- a nice slower track, with some v accomplished rapping 👍 Breathe In, Breathe Out- this is fine, nothing special School Spirit- Another catchy track, also the censoring is pretty funny 👍 Two Words- Again accomplished but feels a bit dated Through the wire- v interesting story I didn’t know about 👍 Family Business- Cool sampling, evocative stories but also annoying children voices lol Last Call- Pretty self indulgent but interesting Ambitious and accomplished album, 5/5
My first Kanye album and all I can really say is that it was okay. It's crazy to think that 20 years ago Kanye was a real human being with actual coherent thoughts. The lyrics are good and the concept is good. It feels genuine. I feel like the album drops off after the halfway point. The last song especially didn't really do anything for me in it's 13 minutes. Also didn't care for the skits, I never do. They do add to the entire album as an experience but I wouldn't listen to them again. All in all I thought it was alright. Maybe the next one will be better. Score: 60 Art: 60
It's a good debut. I miss the "George Bush doesn't care about black people" Kanye.
Even though I know he is a very well-known public figure and there seems to be no shortage of commentary on him, I must admit I know almost nothing about his music or his life. It's not some statement on my part; just sort of fell into place that way and I have not yet felt compelled to learn more. For whatever that might mean, this is my first listen (at least that I'm aware of) to any of his music. There seem to be some parts that make this at least in part a comedy album, but when it's on the music side of things, there are some really nice tracks in there. It's a bit more groovy and soul-like -- even some gospel and gospel-influence blues, too -- than most of the rap I've heard, and from what the Wikipedia article tells me there are quite a few contributing artists on this album. I don't know enough about him to be able to tell if the religious themes are part of the comedy or if he is (or at least at the time of this album, was) really religious. I don't listen to any religious music, so it's not my area of expertise. Overall, a little frenetic at times and, frankly, the comedy bits are a little boring to me, as are some of the songs, but it's somewhat entertaining.
Almost a 5, but no truly great song on the album.
I really wish Kanye wasn't so controversial. He does have talent
good album but hard to digest as the artist has gone off the rails.
Listened to this before and it feels really long for some reason. Jokes on you, I made it past 25 by now. Quite a journey. Like the intermissions. Interesting concept album. + All Falls Down + Two Words
Shows a very distinct pivot in the more mainstream rap and brings forward another album that does a great job describing the experiences of people who could not really benefit from the things that others could by no fault if their own
Ja varför inte. Förstår varför folk tycker om ye för hans musik, men har som person är ju lite kontroversiell.
Jag tänkte ge den en fyra men fan ta honom.
Kanye's best album.
Not Kanye again please
4.5
All of Kanye’s music should be removed due to Nazi affiliations and tendencies
Good fun!
I seriously dislike Kayne the persona but damn this is a great album. Clever, funny, introspective, real, and superb production. Credit where it's due ....
I couldn’t listen to it bc Kanye is a little off the rails but it’s such a good album…
gg
This is terrible.
Jackson Pollock: Well I know it well, and its a 5. Fav tracks: Jesus Walks Two Words Family Business Last Call Through the Wire Never Let Me Down All falls down Least Favs: The New Workout Plan Skits Overall: While not my personal Kanye favourite album. Its an amazing debut with a lot of songs I love. The skits are not too punishing. It is a tiny bit bloated, but not many wasted tracks to be fair. Its probably slightly on the low side of a 5. Like a 9.2.
It made me so sad to listen to this and know how Kanye turned out. This album rules.
It's remarkable how lucid and uplifting this album is. I would not have thought that Kanye was capable of making music like this given his current state.
Superb debut. While it could be tighter, Kanye immediately cements himself as a killer producer, great songwriter and a serviceable MC. The guests are amazing and the singles are classics, certainly among the greatest rap debuts or even best debuts overall. A great record.
It's some early Kanye. He writes some good instrumentals but its hard to separate that from his cringey lyrics and personal life
Not listening to any of this cunts records.
Terrific beats and strong samples make for a rich, layered and highly tuneful sounds. The soul and gospel effects are particularly welcome and balance out the excessive length and endless braggadocio. Opener is great, maybe the best cut, “Slow Jamz” is outstanding (lines like “I’m gonna play this Vandross/You gonna take your pants off" are the sorts for which we listen to hip-hop”) “Through the Wire” is great too. This is a concept album that doesn't need the concept. The jokes about degrees are more silly than not and there are far too many of them. Still, pretty great.
Kanye se fait ici voler la vedette par son narrateur, inspirant et expirant les h comme personne.
Kanye rejoint Michael Jackson dans le top 2 des artistes du générateur, il tente même de lui infliger un superbe jab du gauche, mais Michael parvient à l'éviter et à contrer d'un supperbe uppercut. S'en suivra une phase de ground and pound qui verra Michael s'imposer par soumission grâce à un superbe étranglement, mais Kayne aura définitivement fait douter notre champion des 1001.
I'm really not into hip hop. And I can't say I'm in love with this album. But as much as I want to rate this 0 stars for Kanye being a complete ass-clown, I really don't hate it either.
4.5/5. Everybody not wanting to cancel Kanye because he made Graduation but if there was an album that saves him, it’s this one. A strong debut that puts Kanye’s groundbreaking production and samples on full display. It singlehanded elevated the relevance of alternative hip hop and marked the shift of mainstream hip hop from shitty pseudo gangsta rap towards emotional and socially conscious lyrics.
This will be the second Kanye album I've ever listened to, the first one being given to me by the generator some time ago. Unfortunately his stock has plunged since then, and he was already at what I had assumed was rock bottom. Making it hard to be objective but I'll give it a go. It isn't starting out strong. Yeah I'm not giving this another hour. I've made it nearly halfway through this project without bailing on an album but today is the day. It might be great but it is also really irritating and I can't.
No, it's okay guys, he watched 21 Jump Street. Actually, I'm shocked, but I quite liked this. What happened between this and Yeezus that went from something so good to something so... Yeezus. Any way, this was pretty great, nothing amazing, but satisfying flow and great beats. Only some songs where my dislike for Kanye started to shine through, but that ego definitely wasn't fully developed yet.
Ignoring certain words spoken by Mr west (thank God for Jonah Hill) pretty good album
4th April 2023 Listened during the day while working from home. Kitchen cabinets and range dropped off, chatted to Douggie and watched Chelsea Liverpool in the evening. Having seen Jeen-Yus I appreciate this already great album more. Ye does have some chips on his shoulder! It’s not 5 despite having some all time classics on it because I think it’s overlong. 4.5 if I could.
Gave up halfway through. The only decent stuff is where a sample of another song was used. Naff.
Kanye's music might be good, but he's a bad role model and worse person. He's lost touch with the time and effort and message delivered in this album. I cannot support his over inflated ego through streaming revenue.
I will not listen to this ignorant bigot.
Best Song: All Falls Down. Easily the most iconic samples on the album, and Kanye is restrained enough to not bungle it with too ridiculous bars. Worst Song: Get Em High. This would be a great Snoop song, but it's a pretty weak Kanye song. Both features are just okay too. Overall: A big album full of huge hits, but given its runtime it inevitably has a few duds. None of the features are that interesting (Jamie Foxx notwithstanding), and some of the tracks linger too long on beats that aren't worth that much time. Feels like a mid-2000s time capsule.
Great, much better than I thought it was gonna be.
Catchy I suppose.
Overall I agree that this is an important cultural album, it launched Kanye into stardom and redefined hip-hop at the time of its release. Looking back, it has its faults: the album is overlong and includes annoying skits that balloon the run time. Absolute classic tracks though, and definitely deserves to be included on this list. It's hard to not let current news impact your listening to an album, Kanye's recent Nazi shit is unforgivable. But I still try to separate the art from the artist, and keep the time frame in mind when listening to these albums.
fuck ye
No.
One of my favorite albums. Bummer Ye has gone off the deep end and now I have mixes feelings about it.
Somewhat ironically as I had Taylor Swift yesterday, today was interrupted by Mr Kayne West with Collage Drop out. He's a knob, but I just cannot deny the talent, its such a good album and slow jamz is a masterpiece. Loses a star because he is such a knob so it's 4
Har jo hørt den før, men stadig rigtig god. Lille, søde Ye. Der er lidt fedt der kunne skæres fra, men man kan ikke lade være med at smile over den barnlige spænding og energi.
Not even going to bother listening to this. Very few albums with the explicit content warning have been listenable to so I won't waste any more of my time on them
So many similarities between the debuts of Kanye and Eminem - both angry with “things to prove” and machine gun sprays of words. The chipmunk soul of Kanye makes this album inimitable (well, at least until it was imitated to death in the late 2000s), but it’s damned weird to see the sociopolitical trajectories of them both two decades later.
Awful man. Amazing album.
Fuck this guy.
oh thank fuck I'd already heard this so I don't have to listen to it now for this dumb challenge
This will always be seen as a classic no matter how crazy Kanye becomes. Gotta give it up for a rapper that uses a Happy Gilmore joke in his raps. Never been a fan of skits just keep the jams rolling.
this album makes me want to go back to school just to drop out (fav tracks: all falls down, spaceship, jesus walks, slow jams, through the wire)
Fuck this piece of shit and fuck him too!
I miss the old kanye
I miss the old Kanye, straight from the 'Go Kanye Chop up the soul Kanye, set on his goals Kanye
A couple bright spots, but you definitely expect more from a self-proclaimed “genius”. Also, if you look at the album credits, apparently it takes 95 people to make an album.
If we had been doing this between 2005-2010, definitely would have gotten 5 stars. Still a classic album that brings back good memories.
I enjoy some hip hop every now and again but how on earth is this album on the 1001 list? Almost every song on this album sounds like it was written produced and performed by and for children. Extremely basic, repetitive rhythms and a whiny voice don't make for very good music. I was halfway through my second listen before I realized that I'd heard the songs once before.
What kind of trash is this? So long and so bad. Can I get my time back?
Pretty cheesy album. Beats were the best part. I’m sure this was revolutionary for middle and high school kids in 2004, but doesn’t really age well in my opinion.
Not all bangers. Comparing this to other rap records at the time was night and day. Kanye makes a point of steering away from the thug shit with a bit more vibrancy. The secret is that he hacks up old songs and pitch shifts the vocals!! Kanye also has an eye/ear for what is cool at the time and capitalizes on it. I would argue that most of his success has rode on the backs of his features, licensing, and ripping off other artists. I did listen to this album a lot in my formative years though!!
Interesting
This is a really good album that is brought down by some crappy skits and a stupid Kenny Powers-esque autobiography at the end. It's fairly simple production but also catchy and does a great job of getting that foot tappin. Lyrics are decent but Kayne was never a poet. Highlights include Jesus Walks, Never Let Me Down, All Falls Down, and Workout Plan.
Alright people, breath in, breath out - let’s leave Kanye’s persona at the door, and please know that We Don’t Care what your preconceived notion of rap music is. That’s my intro. This is album is perfect when you are stuck doing a mundane task you don’t want to do, like data entry. Because it’ll fire you up so much that you’ll throw that laptop right at your bosses face, as your career all falls down. First and foremost, it’s a masterclass in production. I haven’t heard a hip hop album with the variety and ingenuity of these beats. Kanye’s roots as a beat maker is on full display here as every song feels completely different from the others. Guy has enough background singers to make even Pete Davidson jealous. Kanye may be an ego maniac, but his music has always been about taking risks and pushing creativity. Which includes incredible features. Kanye’s songs are never afraid to put other people in the spotlight, and in that sense you might say he’s…selfless? …nah. I find the songs so good that I actually don’t really want to hear the skits, even if they are slightly entertaining. Especially, since I’m being reminded of the fact that my BComm isn’t worth the paper it’s printed on. Something that my student debt reminds me of everyday. They never let me down. When looking for the best track on the album, I just have two words: Jesus Walks. I’m no “god-bro”, but the song makes me want to run through the wire of a chain link fence. Overall, the songs on this record are incredible, even if Kanye is not an incredible person. But the best part: I got a free workout plan in the form of a downloadable PDF after I signed up at kanyewest.com , which inadvertently put me on several government watchlists.
Positives: I really like most of the actual songs on the album. Through the Wire grew on me a ton and on my last listen was probably my favourite. I like the gospel choir he uses occasionally. Negatives: Fuck Kanye. The skits are just awful, ruins the flow of the album. Last Call... I have no words. The concept is stupid. Fuck Kanye. I feel like Slow Jamz isn't too far off from being a Flight of the Conchords song. Hearing Ludacris transported me back to high school. Would give this a higher rating if it wasn't for all the 'extra-curriculars'.
I don't think you're likely to hear Jesus Walks from your local church choir. Fuck Kanye West as a person but he can make music. This is nowhere near my style and I won't be revisiting this one in the future, but there's plenty to enjoy in here for a listen or two. I'm not really a lyrics guy so my problem with a number of these tracks is that the music is extremely repetitive within one song. Just the nature of the genre I suppose. I will say that Kanye's beats are at least pretty good on a number of the tracks, and there are definitely some tracks that mix up the sound more than just changing who is rapping. There's a lot of filler tracks in here that probably make more sense if you're paying attention to the lyrics, but really just serve as a distraction for me. I think my favourite is Never Let Me Down, and the lowlight is certainly Last Call which is a garbage self-aggrandizing jerk off that lasts for seemingly 3 or 4 hours. Boy does Kanye seem to have contempt for higher education. As an alternate universe Patrick Roy might say "I can't really hear what Kanye says because I got my two degrees plugging my ears."
One or two songs were ok.
Varje låt låter likadant.
crap
Word persoonlijk niet gelukkig van de artiest. Ik luister eigenlijk nooit naar hem en dat is na het luisteren van dit album ook niet veranderd.
Really good album, had heard most songs before, but listening to them again was even better. Production and lyrics on point as usual from Kanye, I just hoped the features were a little bit better for me, but overall a good project.
Habe ehrlich gesagt noch weniger erwartet. Gab sogar ein zwei Lieder die ich ein bisschen gefühlt habe. Aber will diesen Menschen eigentlich echt nicht unterstützen. Das fällt mir auch nicht besonders schwer, das Album hatte genug schlechte Songs auch.
The voice who talks to Kanye is hella funny and it’s really interesting how it’s a whole story in one album and all the songs fit in there. I’m not a big fan of this speaking rap thing but I like the beat/melody of the songs. In a lot of rap songs it’s always the same beat and rhythm and here it’s a bit more interesting. This is really well produced. Best songs: Jesus Walks (I really like the back vocals and the melody as a whole, there are always new elements which keep it really interesting), Never let me go (This shit fire), the new Workout plan (especially the second part), two worlds (this is such a vibe)
Great album
HL: "Two Words", "Jesus Walks", "Through the Wire", "Never Let Me Down", "Slow Jamz" 3.5 Pretty strong debut despite the filler, lyrics weren't as obnoxious as I feared from other Kanye releases, and the big features (Jay-Z, Ludacris, Mos Def) don't overshadow his own contributions. May I also say that, uh, fuck this guy & what he's become March 6, 2023 Note to self: revisit Enter the Wu-Tang & Illmatic, two past 3-stars I might rank more highly now.
Great album that manages to carry its vibe to the very end. Kanye achieved his goal and history was made. Hard to imagine hip hop culture without this album.
Crappy person, solid album. Don’t love all the skits, but didn’t take away from it too much.
This is Kanye's first album and I still think it's the best showcase for his rapping. He went on to make even better overall albums and albums I enjoy even more but he clearly had something to prove on this one and it features some of his best lyrics. His vocal performances are also brimming with charisma and energy. I love how he doesn't just rap -- every verse is a full performance, emphasizing the emotions, underlining the jokes and finding fun games to play within the rhymes. He has a big, over-the-top style. There's no mistaking him on a song. And of course you could listen to this and just enjoy his production work. Man, I still can't believe how good "Jesus Walks" is. It's so layered. There are so many classic tracks on here ("All Falls Down," "Jesus Walks," "Get Em High," "Breath In Breathe Out," and "School Spirit" are my favorites) that I can easily forgive the supremely stupid (but also pretty funny) "Workout Plan," the self-indulgent closer "Last Call," and the dumb skits about the guy with all his degrees. ---- I've written on here already about how I felt conflicted approaching the music of one of my all-time favorites after, you know, he declared his love for Nazis. 🙄 I hope he gets help. I hope he makes music again. But either way, I've decided that I have too many good memories listening to his music that I won't let anyone take that away from me. Not even the guy that made it. 🤷🏻♂️
I'm going to wait until Steve posts his review and I'll just echo that. This is of course a 5/5. Something that I found interesting was how Kanye started to steer the direction of rap away from gangsta rap, although some of that genre's lyrical subject matter also exists here on this album, like drug dealing/addiction, poverty/struggle. This might not have been THE album to do it on it's own, but it definitely was a part of the conversation. "All Falls Down" "Jesus Walks" "Through The Wire" are 3 truly amazing rap songs and easily some of the best to come out of the genre.
- all falls down
Reviewing this is so complicated. This album changed rap when it needed to be changed. The music is phenomenal and a lot of the rapping is really, truly amazing. But a lot of the content has aged very poorly with a lot of sexism throughout. Reviewing this record in a vacuum is really difficult as Kanye has now allowed his mental illness to ruin his career. This was an achievement in the genre. And it's been sullied. One other thing to note. The final track on the album, "Last Call" is a complete waste of time and there is no excuse for it to be almost 13 minutes long.
What can I say about an album clearly not meant for me? I just can't get past the content, and knowing more about Kanye lately leaves even less room to attempt to enjoy what he's offering. Can I even compliment his creative use of the Hampster Dance Choir on several tracks? Nope.
Wow. He was a genius.
My first time listening to Kanye. Was shocked at how many songs were unique and different. Enjoyed this more than expected.
De pop-invloeden in nummers zoals 'Never Let Me Down' het fijner om naar te luisteren dan andere Hiphop albums. Dat is namelijk niet mijn favoriete genre. Wel vind ik dat muziek niet compleet los kan worden bekeken van de artiest, zeker niet als veel nummers gebaseerd zijn op persoonlijke politieke/religieuze geloven. En door Kanye West zijn recentere uitspraken heeft dat toch een flinke negatieve invloed op mijn beoordeling.
Debuutalbum Kanye West, autobiografisch met verwijzingen naar social issues. Opgevuld met skits, alles rond het thema van college. Muzikaal goed maar naar mijn smaak te cynisch over hoger onderwijs. - leukste nummer: All Falls Down Opvallend genoeg met bijdrage van Israëlische artiest Miri Ben-Ari
So I think this was the first album I ever knew every song to and listened to consistently. Growing up the songs on this thing were everywhere for me so the nostalgia is just unbearable. I love every single bit of it - the beats, the features, and Kanye’s absolutely hilarious and creative writing. This will forever be one of my favorite records. 10/10
Ok 3/5
This album is funnier and more ecclectic than I'd remembered. Great production as you'd expect. Jesus Walks is still an absolute number. You can see the makings of the man we now know here. Despite that and a few unnecessary tracks / underwhelming feats it deserves a solid rating.
Most people prefer this era of Kanye, as it’s much more uplifting and soulful, both in terms of lyrics and production. After his mum died his music got a lot more experimental, noisy and generally unhinged… which I actually prefer. His debut album, however, is an exception for me. So many bangers on here, but I have to mention The New Workout Plan. It has those disjointed strings playing throughout, and a beat switch near the end accompanied with talk-box vocals. Overlaying this are genuinely funny lyrics, which brings the whole thing together and makes it one of my favourite Kanye songs. Shit SLAPS. The story behind Through the Wire is very unique and is technically great as well. Jesus Walks may have converted me to Christianity. The skits are actually funny and don’t get boring on repeat listens. Even the Last Call, which is mostly him talking over a beat, is enjoyable. All in all, I prefer TLOP, but this is still God-tier and deserves a 5.
Sample legend. Think higher of the album after watching Yeezus. His nuts mentality been around since the beginning. Sot All Falls Down Jesus Walks Through The Wire 3.5/5
Oh ya
went into this with an open mind but, Christ, this is terrible. bland smug irritating juvenalia. I guess this confirms my prejudice about post-2000 pop music, hip hop in particular. consumerist trash composed by a tedious dickhead, the aural equivalent of his ex-wife
nope!!!!!!!! i refuse!!!!!!! i did NOT use to love kanye and his work so DO NOT ASK!!!!!!!!!!! it pains me to see someone so influential harbor such an objectively horrible and harmful worldview
Clearly a huge record and tremendous breakout for a hugely important artist... in a genre I really don't understand well haha Kanye is obviously one of the elite hip-hop producers/writers ever. He's also someone who has, in the intervening time since this record was released, developed some serious mental health issues that make it hard for some to consume/understand his music now. All Falls Down continues to resonate despite the passage of time and oddities of the author.
I dig this album. Wish I could let the kids have a listen.
I don't really know why people like Kanye. Jesus Walks slaps but the other songs feel just okay, I didn't mind them playing. But he's a nazi so he gets a 5
always heard this album was a classic but it was kinda meh, his other stuff is way better School Spirit was sick and I've always liked Last Call
Man... This album was golden. There's a lot of great songs and each one is different from the last. It has some beautiful vocals supporting a lot of the tracks and some great humor spread throughout. Usually I get a bit fatigued listening to entire albums after about 30 minutes, but I was able to listen through this whole album no problem. Great great great stuff.
Not a Kanye fan
Anti-Semite should be zero
It’s a shame Alvin, Simon, and Theodore did not get any credits on this album. -2 stars.
Highlights: "Through the Wire," "All Falls Down," "Slow Jamz," "Family Business," "Jesus Walks" Enough has been said about this too recently, and most of it's accurate. Here's more anyway. Kanye is our John Lennon, in a bad way. I get that murder rap was out of control and he was right to look for something affirmative, but it only kind of excuses the way he talks out both sides of his mouth about materialism as his alternative expression of masculinity, which he makes more palatable by balancing against racial commentary. It feels like Kanye understood that Jay-Z had a lean-out neo-conservative neo-respectability politics he agreed with, but it had become too dry, too much straight-laced inventorying of assets, and it just needed a raving lunatic like him to evangelize. A weird thing about Kanye's lyrics here is that he's somehow his most sympathetic and insightful when he is angriest. The way he draws lines in the sand and shuts others down can be very cutting. I don't want to do scrying about how we might have read his MAGA meltdown into this stage of his career, but his vision of the world's ugliness at least is much more coherent than his solutions. It's the music that puts him in history. His corrective to hip-hop was rehashing the kind of things people like Fugees, Mos Def, and Kweli were already popularizing. It's the music that gives it weight. The gift to us is his perennially counterintuitive use of distortion on aux percussion and the lean into the incongruity while chopping samples, turning that into a source of impact. And at 80 minutes, there are definitely still dead spots. Ivy's verse on "Never Let Me Down" is abysmal. I can't really find the Conscious Rap message behind the misogyny in stuff like "The New Workout Plan." The super compressed acoustic guitar tracks sound very dated and corny. This album is only really a breakthrough for his personal brand. For pop music, it's more like he'd synthesized all his influences into a strong capstone for the impact he'd already had.
He's gone off the rails lately but you can't deny this album absolutely slaps. Really didn't expect to enjoy this much at all but have to hand it to him, it's a masterpiece.
What a pleasure to be around and enjoying Kanye before he became a complete cunt. Jay really did have classics to his beats. So did Kanye.
This was fine, didn't mind it. Trying to separate the art from the artist and not let the fact that Kanye is a garbage human being influence my rating.
I'm not listening to this.
That was gruelling. First thing first: this album is at least half an hour too long. Second thing second (and maybe most important): this is just an "okay" rap album. Third thing third: this album hasn't aged well. (Kanye himself has aged LESS well.) Lastly (kind of): it's ludicrous that Ludacris was probably paid good money for a bad feature. I remember hearing so much hype for this album for the year or so between its release and me picking a copy of the CD to see what the fuss was about. And even that dozen and a half years ago I did not understand why people were raving about it so much. It's not that great. It's not horrible either, but I think it's quite unspectacular. There are a couple of good hooks, a solid handful of sweet beats and all the requisite and expected features of the era, but Kanye's emceeing isn't revolutionary or particularly exciting and his lyrics ain't really that deep. I came into this prepared to eat crow and maybe find out I'd been wrong about my assessment of this back in '05 and really did my best to set aside my feelings about present-day Kanye while listening, but I still just can't fuck with it.
Honestly liked the collaborative songs better than the songs with just West singing/rapping. Something about West's voice is just grating to me. Jay-Z, Ludacris, and Mos Def made this album better though.
First time hearing this album. It's a great album made by an unfortunate human being. Won't be listening again.
Fuck this guy
Love the album. But godamn it Kanye
I've never heard an album from him before, this one was the first. His music is good, but it's sad to see what kanye became nowadays.
Enjoyed a couple songs, not quite my cup of tea but will listen again
Man I just can’t with this dude anymore.
I was hoping to like this as I quite liked Late Registration, and assumed his reputation came from these early albums. But then the good stuff on LR was by Stevie and Curtis. The fake 'rebellion' while rapping about expensive watches, 'Benjamins' and b*tches. I don't find the vocals / flow that interesting. This was disappointing. And, again, too long. Ye-awn.
I quite enjoyed the tunes and lyrics. It's not my usual style, but there's a lot of depth to explore here. I could do without some of the irritating sketches in-between tracks. But this was uplifting and pretty much hit the spot on an optimistic blue sky day. The gospel overtones were particularly welcome. It's didn't half drag on though. I'm not sure how it all went so wrong for Kanye.
Highlights: Spaceship, School Spirit Skit 2, Two Words, Last Call
Dobrze, że wpadł po sesji, bo niektóre piosenki nie zachęcałyby do dalszej nauki. Nie interesuje mnie co obecnie robi Kanye i nie powinno to mieć wpływu na ocenę albumu.
One of the greatest albums of all time. Shame he turned out to be a nutter.
Some cool beats, multi-layered tracks and interesting guest artists but not an album I'll need to revisit again.
E ben bunu biliyom
I miss the old kanye
Not my thing Better stuff than later material Some decent songs. Nothing rememberable
Unfortunately it slaps
Its Kanye so I can't say I really like it, but I can see the value.
200 years later
Slaps but it aint my fav Kanye album
Nope. Nazi creep.
Sucks he’s a nazi now
Étonnamment intéressant. Comme quoi il y a bien à boire et à manger dans le rap. Là les samples s’écoutent, les paroles ont parfois des choses à dire et certains titres emportent tout, comme “We don’t care” ou “Jesus Walks”. Je ne me fais pas à toutes les intros, skits et c’est franchement écoutable contrairement à 99% du rap de cette liste.
It's sad to hear powerful anti-racist songs when he's become an unhinged antisemite. Then he hits out with misogynist songs and diminishes how great this album should be.
not listening to ye anymore
Ok
It’s alright, early signs of that troubling Kanye arrogance.
Sorry don't listen to Nazis 🤡
Before they were good
nazi 0
It's very rare that I find rap music bearable to listen to, so this being the rare listenable rap instantly gives it a lot of bonus points in my book. Now, the horrible skits and the agonizing slog of the last track take some points off again. And of course the fact that Ye is a horrendous pile of shit -turned car accident is not factored into this rating at all.
gas goat gas goat
I wish I had listened to this before Kanye came out as a Nazi. It feels like it could've been an album I enjoyed, but at this point most of his songs' messages just feel like preludes to his bigotry. 2/5 since I can see the potential if I had listened to the album before he went off the deep end
A surprise for sure. Was not expecting to be wowed by this album — especially considering the recent actions of West — but this album really impressed me. It gave me mental whiplash trying to reconcile the themes and quality of the music in this album from ‘04 with how he speaks and acts nowadays. The beats had me bompin while on my walk to listen through this and I was surprised at the themes present in this album which feels wild bc I’d never actually listened to any of his music before and certainly wasn’t planning on it before committing to listening to every album on this list. Still. He sucks ass as human now and that’s a fact. Antisemitic, egotistical nazi man does not have any respect from me and I was able to find a way to listen to this without giving any money or engagement to this fuck. Never really listened to a whole lot of rap before. My knowledge of the genre is sadly pretty limited. Hope i can find more like this, by better people