Reviews (page 4 of 14)
- Geieeel, sooo lange nicht mehr gehört und ich frage mich gerade WARUM?! - Sufjan Stevens habe ich 2008 oder 2009 das erste Mal (wie viele geile Indie Mucke damals) durch O.C. California entdeckt. - „For Widows In Paradise“ von dem Michigan Album ist kurz darauf über Jahre hinweg zu meinem absoluten Lieblingssong geworden - da kamen auch Linkin Park, RHCP, Blink oder die Foo Fighters nicht ran. Nach wie vor unter meinen Top 5 Songs OAT. - Ich habe mich dann auch in andere Alben von ihm reingehört. V.a. Seven Swans und ab und zu auch Illinoise. Letzteres hab ich aber (for no reason) nicht so häufig gehört, wie die anderen beiden. Umso schöner, der Platte hier mal wieder zu begegnen. - Einfach unfassbar toll, kreativ und leichtfüßig (und das obwohl auch immer eine gewisse Melancholie bei Sufjan mitschwingt) - Die Art und Weise diese Melancholie zu transportieren bekommen wenige Künstler meines Erachtens so gut hin wie er - Tolle Instrumentierung auch - Chicago natürlich ein absoluter Hit - Alles auf diesem Album wirkt wie der Soundtrack zu einer geilen Indie-Tragikomödie à la Sideways, Garden State oder Little Miss Sunshine Rating: 4,5/5
- Meiner Meinung nach Sufjan Stevens zweitbestes Album. - Diese Platte ist so unglaublich kreativ und lebendig. Jedes mal wenn ich sie höre entdecke ich was neues und verliebe mich neu in bestimmte Songs oder Parts. - So viele geile Banger dadrauf: Chicago, Concerning, John Wayne Gacy Jr., The Man of Metropolis uvm. - Es wundert einen überhaupt nicht, dass dieses Album vollkommen zurecht eine Musical-Adaption bekommen hat. - In seinen Interludes teilweise etwas avantgarde und auch manche Songs enthalten manchmal ein hauch von zerfaserten Klangteppichen und sich überschlagenden Patterns - Das Album wirkt auf mich gleichzeitig so groß und imposant und dennoch so klein und detailliert. Lässt sich schwer beschreiben. Ein Ausnahmekünstler, mit einer außergewöhnlichen Geschichte und außergewöhnlicher Musik 4,5/5
- joo, richtig gut - hat mich sehr zum Tagträumen eingeladen, während ich meine Knieübungen auf dem Boden liegend gemacht habe - abwechslungsreich, tolle Ideen und sprüht einfach vor Kreativität
Well, I'm just impressed, that was such an experience! Loved the lyrics, the instrumentation, the concept and everything about this album. It might feel a little bit long by the end but every, but it doesn't get to affect the general experience. Rating: 4.8
A bit too much filler, especially since it feels too long. When it hits, it hits hard and it does so quite a lot!
Sufjan Stevens takes us musical journey that evokes vivid imagery.
This album really makes you FEEL like you're in Illinois. For real though, this album's phenomenal. Illinois by Sufjan Stevens is one of the most critically acclaimed albums of the 2000s. My expectations were very high for this one. Fortunately, my expectations were met. There's really something special about this album. It's a concept album, and an excellent one at that. The focus on the state of Illinois is something that could be too narrow in scope for many artists, but not Sufjan. Despite the overarching setting, each song feels completely different from the last and they're all great. You have bombastic songs that exemplify the fun of the state like "Come On! Feel the Illinoise!" that fit in with the theme. And yet somehow a song like that is perfectly balanced by some of the most gut-wrenching songs you've ever heard like "Casimir Pulaski Day" and "John Wayne Gacy, Jr." and it works. Of course, you also have songs that find a nice point between the two like "Chicago" as well. Again, all of these songs are amazing, even the instrumentals. On top of the theme of Illinois, other themes like religion also seep their way into the writing. Speaking of which, the writing is amazing. The biggest reason as to why the concept works is because of how good the writing is. The sound is incredibly varied as well, but once again, it's all great. I really like Sufjan's singing. It fits the vibe of this album amazingly. I really cannot praise this album enough. This is one of the finest, most ambitious albums I've ever listened to. It kept me captivated for the whole 74 minutes, and I am very glad to have finally listened to this album. 5/5.
Already love this album <3
Enjoyed this a lot, pretty unique.
Big nostalgia album for me - listened to this and other Sufjan in college, and in Chicago after graduation. I think he’s just super talented as an arranger, and love hearing some pretty simple ideas develop. Only complaint here is the end of the album feels like it drags and doesn’t explore much new space. Frank, at the same time you nailed it. I listened to this while cleaning the kitchen with my wife this evening, and we had a very full compost bag.
5/5
I was already a big fan of this album before it came up. I love it, it feels like a complete album with every song being part of a larger whole. I love Stevens’ voice - it’s soft and gentle and has a depth to it that really appeals to me.
Both the names and the runtime are far too long, but it's still incredibly well made, well written, well performed, and well produced.
A stunningly personal album despite all its extravagance and ridiculously long song titles that sometimes last longer than the songs themselves. I’m more of a Carrie & Lowell guy but this is definitely Sufjan’s magnum opus in terms of sheer scope and impact. 48 more states when?
I didn't want to give out 5's easily, they have to deserve it. It's only my fifth album of this journey and dammit this deserves it! A really lovely opening which sets the tone for the rest of the album. 'Casimir Pulaski Day' was the best, an absolute treat. The Man of Metropolis teases you thinking it'll be more upbeat and it eventually is, as it slips in and out of a great bit of rock guitar. I feel like this is what every wanky, indie, acoustic, breathy artist WANTS to sound like but doesn't get anywhere near. Nothing bad on this album, every song a delicate delight to listen to. The song titles are stupid though.
Very creative and unique. The instrumentation is amazing. Love all the horns and strings. I honestly can’t say I understand everything he is singing about but still a great album.
Phenomenal album. Wish he stuck with his 50 states project, but Sufjan has constantly pumped out some extraordinary work since. This will always sit at the top.
For what would wound up becoming known as a joke (and a mighty ambitious joke at that), Sufjan Stevens' Illinois not only packs a walloping punch but it weaves a stellar tapestry of anecdotes, tales, sounds and emotions. Listening to this record makes me feel as though I'm partaking in a tour of the state itself, learning new things each time. It never ceases to scale the heights of what was imagined and ultimately achieved, such is the end goal of Illinois. Although it is a shame that he never followed through with his 50 States series (understandably and frustratingly so, for such endeavors would swallow up his career), Illinois somehow evades the trappings by standing on its own gargantuan, at times exhausting, weight. Come on, feel the noise...
Perfeito pra se ouvir durante uma crise dissociativa não agitada. Psicodélico no sentido de muito instrumento fazendo barulho diferenciado. "Oh meu deus KD tu meu deus sou pecador aaaaaah"
Concerning the UFO sighting near Highland, Illinois - 7/10 the piano intro is so pretty and emotional. although the vocals kicked in a little unexpectedly i still love it a lot. it sounds ethereal The Black Hawk War, or, How to Demolish an Entire Civilization and Still Feel Good About Yourself in the Morning, or, We Apologize for the Inconvenience but You're Going to Have to Leave Now, or, 'I Have Fought the Big Knives and Will Continue to Fight Them Until They Are Off Our Lands! - 7,5/10 intense, just like the title Come On! Feel the Illinoise!" (Part I: "The World's Columbian Exposition" / Part II: "Carl Sandburg Visits Me in a Dream") - 9/10 such a vibe i love it. it gets better the further in the song you go. i also realised this song is perfect to think and do philosophy homework so im gonna do that now John Wayne Gacy, Jr. - 6/10 the beginning feels a little boring. it's a generic sad guitar song, maybe it just feels like that because i haven't heard this song a lot yet. Jacksonville - 8,5/10 i love love love the intro its so good. the rest of the song should be boring to me because of the repetetiveness, but i still love it. A Short Reprise for Mary Todd, Who Went Insane, but for Very Good Reasons - 7,5/10 i forgot to actively listen lmao Decatur, or, Round of Applause for Your Stepmother! - 7/10 unexpected but pretty good Chicago - 7,8/10 its got a really pretty chord progression but idk it feels a little boring over the end of the song Casimir Pulaski Day - 8/10 idk what to say i just think its a good song To the Workers of the Rock River Valley Region, I Have an Idea Concerning Your Predicament, and It Involves Tube Socks, a Paper Airplane, and Twenty-Two Able-Bodied Men - 9/10 it sounds like some sort of melodic soundscape. its so pretty The Man Of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts - 7/10 it goes from energetic to calm. its pretty good :D Prairie Fire That Wanders About 10/10 - such a cool intro, when the vocals start it gets even prettier A Conjunction of Drones Simulating the Way in Which Sufjan Stevens Has an Existential Crisis in the Great Godfrey Maze - 5/10 a little boring idk also not meant to be a song, but as a transition which is pretty good The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades Is Out to Get Us! - 7/10 not very different or unique from the rest of the songs, but it's not bad. also the layered vocals at the end of the song sound so pretty They Are Night Zombies!! They Are Neighbors!! They Have Come Back from the Dead!! Ahhhh! - silly title. also the blong bling sounds are very nice with the bass and then the violins are so good ok now i dont feel like giving long commentary on songs anymore ill just decide if i like them or not Let's Hear That String Part Again, Because I Don't Think They Heard It All the Way Out in Bushnell - 6,5 i didnt hear it well enough idk In This Temple as in the Hearts of Man for Whom He Saved the Earth - 7,1/10 The Seer's Tower - 6,5/10 The Tallest Man, the Broadest Shoulders" (Part I: "The Great Frontier" / Part II: Come to Me Only with Playthings Now) - 7,5/10 very cheerful Riffs and Variations on a Single Note for Jelly Roll, Earl Hines, Louis Armstrong, Baby Dodds, and the King of Swing, to Name a Few - 6/10 woah thats one very long note Out of Egypt, into the Great Laugh of Mankind, and I Shake the Dirt from My Sandals as I Run - 8/10 solid way to end an album overall i really loved this album. it has a very unique melancholic and ethereal feel while still sounding fun and catchy on some songs.
One of my favorite albums of all time. Nothing else really to say.
Fantastic! Musically and lyrically and atmospherically a revelation, again. Yet another album from an artist who I’ve heard of but haven’t listened to previously and now will make my way through their oeuvre. Listenable yet affecting from start to finish, Stephens manages to do that thing that true artists do, making the whole more than the seeming sum of the parts.
One of my all-time favourite albums, and one of the best albums of the last 20 years. Is the soundtrack to my early adulthood. Listen to this with the kids in the car so much they know every song off by heart. I love the orchestration- lush at times and then cartoonish and then sombre and then joyful. Amazing that there is a song about Wayne gacy on the same album as a song like Predatory wasp but the whole album is still cohesive and works. I think it’s Sufjan Stevens masterpiece although there’s still several other of his albums that are phenomenal. Every time I listen to this I am blown away by the songwriting. Casinos Pulaski day still gets me every time.. and he takes and he takes and takes.
Sufjan is someone I've heard of plenty but barely ever listened to. This album shows me I should have listened more. I feel like I can just say the album is "beautiful" and leave it at that. I don't know what else to say about it as a whole. Just wow to Chicago. Such a good song. Best on the album. But The Man of Metropolis Steals our Hearts is a real close second.
Very calming and relaxing, nice rhythm in all songs. 4.5 thru 5 range
9/10. Very clever album that flowed extremely well from song to song. Added 4-5 songs to the playlist as well.
Già dalla terza canzone stavo considerando di dare 5 e mamma mia non mi è sceso neanche per un momento. Un bellissimo arcobaleno di strumenti e ritmi, momenti strumentali incantevoli e quando poi partono i cori…wow
Very very good, and of my times.
I was so mesmerised throughout the whole thing!
Cerramos otra semana de discos o artistas desconocidos. O ambos. Desde la primera canción se nota la voz dulce de Sufjan Stevens, que le da otros toques a las búsquedas musicales de éste laburazo, sumado a los títulos de las canciones: un delirio buenísimo. Muy lindo trabajo, orquestado, folk, indie, lleno de buenas vibras. Me encantó.
This is one of my desert island records! Key tracks are Come On! Feel the Illinoise!, Chicago, and They Are Night Zombies. The best way to describe this music is concert band + indie. There really isn't another artist quite like Sufjan. I just wish he'd finish out his 50 states project and make some more coole records. I want a Colorado album. I did see him on the Carrie and Lowell tour. (BTW - Carrie and Lowell should be the Oregon album). He was incredible! It was one of the best shows I've ever seen. We still talk fondly of that show often. Anyway, give me Illinois forever and I'll be happy.
Such a beautiful whimsical piece of music. It’s a sprawling, epic whirlwind of full sounds and it’s all wonderfully produced. Emotional and weird at times and Stevens vocals are perfect, the backing vocals really fill things out. They really went all out with the composition, Illinoise is filled to the brim with horns, keys, bells, it’s clear that so much thought and care went into this and that makes it all that more special. What a piece of art. 5 stars
There have been some Sufjan Stevens songs that, in the past, have found their way into my ears and my heart (awww) (seriously, his rendition of O Come O Come Emmanuel makes me tear up a bit) (maybe they were all from the Christmas Album) so I tried to listen to more of his work and it never quite worked out. Maybe because it's mostly not Christmas. Could be. And so I'd never been in the mood for this kinda gooey, pastoral, cutesy but serious music. I might be now & today, though. I'm liking this a lot.
The second and last album of his prematurely ended 50 State project. Lovely and earnest baroque and chamber pop. Lots of spiritual themes throughout.
Most likely the greatest album of all time. Do I need say more?
Come On! Feel the Illinoise! John Wayne Gacy Jr. Chicago Casimir Pulaski Day
I feel like someone should have said "Hey, you should give Illinois by Sufjan Stevens a listen" to me by now.
This album will always have a special place in my heart because of the personal memories I have of moving to Chicago at the time it came out. But even without that, Sufjan’s delicate aural filigree, his gift for indirect, oblique communication, and the unique soundscapes he presents make this an undoubted 5/5 for me.
so gorgeous
Impressive, big, yet intimate album. Maybe too jangly at time or repetitive in tone. It's long, be prepared for a journey, not a jaunt.
Absolutely stellar record.
Great find
Beautiful. An all time favorite. I would say just about everything Sufjan Stevens does is a masterpiece, and this legendary album may be his absolute biggest one.
such a beautiful album. Truly Sufjan's best work.
Beautiful, enjoyable art with a vision AND execution
I’m feeling the Illinoise! Let’s face it, Illinois doesn’t get a lot of love, so the fact that this entire album is inspired by it just warms my little heart all up. I was pretty familiar with the album already thanks to my cousin, and we even saw him live around the time of this album. I’d forgotten how beautiful it is. So many of the songs just keep building into these orchestral feeling masterpieces. There’s kind of a magical quality to it. Love!
This was the sound of 2005 indie folk-y rock at its absolute zenith. It has everything you could possibly need, a cohesive narrative, both the meta "an album a state" project and indeed the Illinois stories that made up the songs. And for a brief shining moment, it seemed like Sufjan Stevens was your favourite artists favourite artist, even getting name checked songs by Snow Patrol (that felt so mid-2000s to even type), everyone loved it, NPR, Pitchfork, Stereogum, Rolling Stone, and every blogger with a pulse. And, most importantly, it still holds up nearly 20 years later. a true timeless classic.
Love this album. I listened to it a lot while working on a farm in Scotland so it brings back great memories for me. Love sufjans voice and pretty much every song on this album.
The first Sufjan Stevens I ever listened to and still my favourite
I'm still blown away by the songs and the performances on Illinois.
cool fresh
This is a dope album
Picture the classic Mothers of Invention albums such as “Absolutely Free” or “We’re Only In It for the Money” or maybe even “Apostrophe.” Now adjust it to something more serious, more epic, and more poetic. That’s what this album is like, maybe. This surely isn’t for everyone but it displays tremendous talent. If you’re prone to skip, at least slow down and take in “Casimir Pulaski Day,” which is not very much about Casimir Pulaski Day.
I’m a millenial who dug deep into the hipster aesthetic. I can’t be unbiased. 5/5
top album, echt heel leuk, ga hem zeker nog wel keer luisteren, mooie titels ook
Comunque Chicago di Sufjan Stevens è il progenitore di End of Beginning di Djo: qualcuno ha detto malinconia per la città di Chicago? A parte questo, ragazzi, ma di che stiamo parlando? Delicato, profondo, sperimentale al punto giusto. Bello bello. 5/5 così, bam.
Già dalla terza canzone stavo considerando di dare 5 e mamma mia non mi è sceso neanche per un momento. Un bellissimo arcobaleno di strumenti e ritmi, momenti strumentali incantevoli e quando poi partono i cori…wow.
A sprawling indie epic. This album has so many layers to it. The sheer complexity of researching the history of Illinois and building an entire album around the state is impressive on its own. Throw in the fact that the arrangements are so imaginative and rich, and this thing is filled with catchy songs front to back. It’s a joy to listen to. I get chills whenever I hear John Wayne Gacy, Jr., Stevens captures the tragedy of that story so perfectly, and reflects it back on all of us. It’s a long long album, with long long song titles, but it keeps you engaged the whole time. Someone could craft a college course on this album. Really wish Stevens did continue the states series. This is a masterpiece.
Best album, Sufjan Stevens uses a lot of instruments and sounds to really full out the sound. This is all sad in the best way.
А чёт балдёжно. Волшебный альбом, очень нежный и приятный саунд, хор кайфовый санктус доминус. По ковер арту я думал что будет ЭЙНТ ДЭТ Э КИК ИН ДА ХЕЕЕЕД а оказалось прям волшебное путешествие.
Love this one
This was a splendid gem. For album number 1002, this sort of thing will keep me going. Having lived in Illinois for four years, I loved all the references to its history. Perfect perfect perfect from beginning to end.
I don't have a single complaint about this one.
The internet keeps showing me ads for the new Broadway musical based on this album. Such a musical makes a lot of sense --- "Chicago" is a showtune if ever there was a showtune --- but I cringe at the thought of the forced earnestness that musical theater performers are likely to bring to this material. This album already works as a piece of theater with evocative imagery and complex orchestrations. It's an impressive piece of work. A favorite.
Yet another entry in the albums-my-ex-played-a-lot-that-I-should-have-appreciated-more files. I wish my state had such a fantastic album dedicated to it. There is so much to love here. Just the right amount of clever with a range of instruments and songs that never got boring - this is fabulous!
Funny that this album came up in the 1001 queue while I was visiting Chicago. I absolutely love this album. The song “Chicago” never fails to cheer me up while I’m feeling down, but paradoxically gives me a sense of nostalgia and melancholy if I was already happy. It’s my comfort song and my comfort album, something I can return to to revel in the brilliance of the human mind. This has been one of my favorite albums since I first heard it. When I first created a top 100 albums chart, it was ranked #4, and in over a decade since then, it’s remained in slot 2-3 while other albums have come and gone in the #1 spot. I have a vision of a film version of The Devil in the White City (the nonfiction story of the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair), or perhaps a musical or a ballet, which is set to the music of this album. The architects and engineers dance around their table to “Come On! Feel the Illinoise!” H. H. Holmes paces the hallways of his murder hotel to “John Wayne Gacy, Jr.” The first Ferris wheel is constructed to “The Tallest Man, the Broadest Shoulders”. Holmes reckons with his murders to “They Are Night Zombies!!! They Are Neighbors!! They Have Come back from the Dead!! Ahhhh!” Daniel Burnham surveys his great white city to “The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts”. I guess the Illinoise musical will have to do, along with whatever film ends up being made by Leo Dicaprio since he has the rights to adapt The Devil in the White City.
I always enjoyed this when it came out but I didn’t appreciate it until now. It’s so good! It’s so DIFFERENT. It feels so big and grand, yet is so far removed from some big budget major-label production. Just a group of young people who were good at stuff just made this. I’ve really tried to think of similar artists/projects but nothing has come to mind, at least nothing on this level. Somehow the actual work got overshadowed by the “he’s going to make an album of all fifty states!” line that was in every article and review at the time, but no matter. This 100% holds up and has gotten even better with time.
I really liked this album, it had great sounding songs but what were the names??
been putting off listening to sufjan for awhile…… why i don’t know
Sufjan was planning on doing an album for every state but has only done Illinois and Michigan. My favorite album by him. Illinoise has also become a musical. Almost as good as his Christmas music.
An incredible album.
Haven’t revisited this one in years, but I was obsessed back when it came out. Still definitely holds up, love the sweet nostalgic lyrics married to the Philip Glass scores a Charlie Brown special arrangements. Need to break out the Sufjan more often.
One of my favorites. Every song sounds the same but the whole album is just touching and memorable
Lots of great songs , lots of styles, great musicianship and great production. What’s not to like
Extremely pretty album with a grandiose sound, and a very fun concept tying in references to the state throughout the album. Really enjoyed it
I thought this was going to be twee, self-indulgent millennial bullshit, but damn it's so good.
That was awesome! Glad to add it to my rotation
I've listened to this more than enough times to know that it's a 5 for me. Checking it out quickly, but besides the fact that it drags a bit towards the tail end, it's beautiful, fun, haunting, whatever it has it all while keeping a clean, consistent vibe which is a fantastic work of love tribute.
This is definitely in my top 5. Have always loved Sufjan.
5/5 This album was very dense to begin with. It has a lot of information and historical background that to the average listener would be lost in. After I overcame its beefiness, Each individual track was really enjoyable, and I felt rewarded diving into lyrics. As far as concept albums go I was really blown away with the care of the album. The album art and the order of track listing really built on a story of Illinois from the perspective of history and artist. TLDR: Dense album, tracks are full to the brim sonically and lyrically
Reminds me of Belle and Sebastian. I think the alternate universe me that stayed in high school theater would love this. A friend from a long time ago was super into this album, and I see why. I accidentally didn't leave this review until 1:45am on Monday 5/13, but I've had "Chicago" stuck in my head for an hour. This is an easy 5-star for me.
4.5
A magnificent and wonderful album beginning to end. "John Wayne Gacy" is one of the most haunting songs I've ever heard. A perfect album.
I remember buying this album in Adams Morgan in DC on a beautiful sunny day. I remember thinking that Sufjan was actually going to do an album about all 50 states. Amazing album.
Emotionally charged music with silly lyrics. Coldplay meets Owl city. Great swells and full sound. Really liked it though. Want to listen to other albums.
I've complained in the past about overly long albums, but Illinois totally earns its running time. This is an easy five stars for me.
Wow: Cum On Feel To Illinoise Super Album, moins downer que Carrie & Lowell
Loved this one! The harmonies, the instruments.
Tobeymaguriecrying.gif
Wonderful. I did nlt know this artist but rallye fantastic music. Good vibrations
Some of the best music listening experiences of my life have involved this one. I used to have to travel to central Illinois for work, and I listened to this album while driving between Decatur and Peoria in the snow and for some reason it was sort of a transcendent experience. This is one of my go-to road trip albums because listening to this album is a journey in itself. Chicago is one of my daughter’s favorite songs, Predatory Wasp is one of my wife’s favorites. I love it from beginning to end. I’d go as far to say it’s one of the great works of art from this century. It’s one of my favorite albums ever, but I think objectively the execution on such an ambitious project and the quality of the writing, the performances, and production make it truly staggering. It’s an album I’ve listened to dozens of times, and every time there are new nuggets I discover, both in the lyrics or music. I usually prefer shorter albums, between 30 and 40 minutes is my sweet spot, but occasionally an album’s long length can benefit the project and this is one of those rare occasions to me. It’s a midwestern epic, and should be considered an American classic.
All hail Sufjan Stevens: King of the Twee Indie Artist! The engineering on this album is a tremendous achievement. Feels like you're in the room with the performers. The songwriting is stellar. The track names are deranged, but Stevens set out to do a thing, and what a thing it is. I get that this may not be everyone's thing, but this is peak "indie folk artist," for what it's worth. Casimir Pulaski Day is singularly melancholy. Breaks my heart every time.
Least beautiful Sufjan Stevens album
Absolutely love this album, 5/5.
a wonderful album
Give me more stuff like this. Awesome. Gentle. Passionate. Sufjan Stevens found his place in the world of music. And I hope he keeps his style.
Ez masterpiece
Nadat ik de theatraliteit van een album als ''The Wall'' aanwees als grote reden waarom het nooit helemaal gaat klikken, is het toch wel ironisch dat het bombastische van deze plaat juist een significante rol in z'n aantrekkingskracht speelt. Het was bij uitstek een album geweest om in de diepte te analyseren, maar dat gaat me vandaag helaas niet lukken. Om direct met de deur in huis te vallen: dit is gewoon een 10. Het ontroert, het zweept op, het laat je nadenken. Het kan niet dat je ''Illinois'' luistert, en dat het geen één indruk achterlaat, die je mogelijk voor eeuwig bijblijft. Of het nou de waanzinnige chemie en dynamiek is tussen de sessiemuzikanten, de zielroerende penkunsten van Sufjan zijn, of juist de orkestrale explosies die je daarna weer opbeuren, deze plaat heeft voor iedereen een medicijn. Het neemt je in 75 minuten mee door heel de staat Illinois, wat in tegenstelling tot het vorige album echt voelt als een versnelde tour. De kleine intermezzo's vormen geen irritante en overbodige detours, zoals ze dat vaak wel doen, maar laten het album juist beter voortglijden. Één mini kritiekpuntje is dat de laatste 2 volledige nummers een beetje misplaatst lijken, en niet echt de afsluiting realiseren dat het album verdiende. Daar had echt een banger moeten staan van het niveau van de werkelijk waar legendarische reeks van 'Come On! Feel the Illinoise' tot en met 'Casimir Pulaski Day', een zestal indie-folk meesterwerken. Dat was echt even de ogen dicht en muziek in al z'n pracht en praal tot je op laten nemen. Maar waar veel platen leven op één sterke fase wat lekker doorvloeit, is dit album daar echt niet afhankelijk van. 'The Predatory Wasp', 'The Man of Metropolis', 'They Are Night Zombies', en bovenal 'Concerning the UFO sighting near Highland, Illinois' zijn allemaal op zich zelf staande steunpilaren. Het was pittig om highlights aan te wijzen in een Himalaya van een plaat, maar de song die m'n ziel altijd brandmerkt is 'John Wayne Gacy, Jr.'. Wat een hartverscheurend naslagwerk over een enorme engnek, op diepintieme wijze vertolkt door Sufjan. Waar ik vaak vraagtekens had bij de oprechtheid van Roger Waters, is deze vocale prestatie echt close to the bone. Griezelig echt. Aan de andere kant van zijn wonderlijke spectrum vind je 'Chicago', wat juist een baken van hoop is. De song waar de toch al bijzondere groepsenergie echt tot z'n kookpunt komt. 'Jacksonville' zit ook wel echt bij m'n absolute favorieten, en laat zien dat de bij tijd en wijle introverte zanger ook echt wel schwung heeft. De blazers excelleren volledig. 'The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts' krijgt als laatste de stempel 'highlight' toegewezen, omdat deze dan weer laat zien dat Sufjan niet alleen kan ontroeren of kan zwingen, maar ook zeker aardig kan rocken. Achja, zelden was het aanwijzen van hoogtepunten zo'n momentopname als bij deze plaat, waar ik zeker weet dat ik morgen 4 andere had kunnen kiezen. De concurrent is moordend op dit betoverende kunststukje. Ik heb het innige en dieppersoonlijke 'Carrie & Lowell' ook zeer hoog zitten, maar dit album is mijn inziens volledig uniek. De cultuur-historische verhaaltjes, de orkestrale productie, en de verscheidenheid aan instrumenten laten zien dat folkmuziek geen eendimensionaal en passief genre hoeft te zijn. Een ervaring die ik in de bijna 20 jaar die volgde nog niet heb herleeft bij het luisteren van een ander album. 10/10 Highlights: John Wayne Gacy, Jr. Chicago Jacksonville The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts
De sound van Illinois is zo uniek en herkenbaar, het voelt als thuis komen. De hele korte repetitieve melodielijntjes blijven onwijs plakken en zijn ook nog eens heel catchy (Come On! Feel the Illinois). Zeker als daar ook nog een blazers worden ingezet, nou heb je mij hoor. Illinois is een krachtige plaat door die alle geluidjes en melodietjes maar draait eigenlijk misschien nog wel meer om de sfeer. Zeker door het gebruik van blazers en violen krijgt de plaat een orkestrale laag. John Wayne Gacy jr. gaat al meer naar een song die op Carrie and Lowell zou kunnen staan. De meer ambient kant van de singer songwriter. Het prachtig en voegt een mooie laag toe in de plaat. Nu voel ik eigenlijk niks bij de staat Illinois en kan ik dus niet zeggen of Sufjan het juiste gevoel op roept. Maar als dit het niveau is had Sufjan wel 50 platen mogen maken over de US. Dat zal niet meer gebeuren. Dan zetten we Illinois of Michigan nog maar een keertje op. 9/10 Highlights Concerning the UFO Com on! Feel the Illinois part I John Wayne Gacy jr Chicago
Casimir Pulaski Day is one of the greatest songs ever written
i really liked it, peaceful
Uskomaton kokonaisuus kappaleita joista on tehty upea teos jonka teemana yhdysvaltojen osavaltio illlinois.. ymmärrätkö.. Soundi on vapaa mutta jokaisella äännähdyksellä merkitys.. KÄSITÄTKÖ.. Biiseissä on vapaata siimaa mutta koukussa ollaan.. Ei sätkitä karkuun.. Tunteet soivat oudoilla tavoilla pakko hyväksyö artistk viisaampi kuin kuuntrlelija.. välillä ymmärrä mitä haetaan ellei lyriikoiden kanssa aleta leikkimään..
Already a big fan of this album! Going to Illinois is December gave me a whole new perspective on the album. This work feels emotions like I do, big highs and big lows.
4.5/5
A singular vision of complex and beautifully arranged songs, while often teeteingr on the edge of twee self indulgence, end up feeling like an immense artistic achievement. His hushed vocals could have been just that but he often adds a musicality to his lines imparting a richness that indie pop musicians usually don’t achieve. I think the album is startlingly varied and inventive. This helps keep it a joy to listen to even well into the album. The upbeat songs are so enjoyable I craved to hear them again.
I should have been expecting this album at some point, but it totally caught me off guard when I saw it. I really love Sufjan's music, and this has long been my favorite album of his (though Carrie & Lowell is fantastic too). Of course I listened to it in full again, and it's as beautiful as it's always been. The Sufjan 50 states project (this is the second and last part of it) was a pretty hilarious gimmick, but the depth of the Illinois-related songwriting here is honestly so impressive. He manages to take this incredibly niche concept (Illinois history) and create some absolutely devastating songs. I first came across Sufjan around 2013 when I was a senior in high school and I stumbled on a mashup of "Chicago" and Coldplay's "Clocks". This was fairly early in the days of my expanding musical taste (Coldplay was probably the first band that I really dove deep into the discography) and I really liked this mashup. I probably listened to this album around that time, and was just blown away by this weird concept album with the long song titles. It's as great today as it was 11 years ago. I've already touched on the lyrics, but I'm just always so impressed that he managed to create such incredible lyrics within the confines of the Illinois concept. I love so much of this album, but "Come On! Feel the Illinoise" is probably the most reference-dense song on here, "John Wayne Gacy, Jr." is so haunting (especially with the narrative turn at the end), and "Casimir Pulaski Day" is just a devastating story of a cancer death and questioning religion (which is something Sufjan explores a lot, and has been a big topic in contemporary Sufjan discourse). Beyond the lyrics though, this album is also just so good musically. It's one that I often just put on in the background while I'm doing other things, which is pretty impressive for an album that also has the lyrical strength that it does. There's just such a wide variety of instrumentation and the sound is so dense, and my understanding is that Sufjan pretty much records all the instruments himself. It also manages to stay consistently interesting over the course of a 74 minute album, which is rare. I obviously love this album, so I'll wrap up. Sufjan is such a unique voice in modern music, and I'm so glad this exists. An incredible work (the album cover is super iconic too) from an incredible modern talent. Favorite song: Chicago Other: Concerning the UFO sighting..., The Black Hawk War..., Come On! Feel the Illinoise!..., John Wayne Gacy Jr., Jacksonville, Decatur..., Casimir Pulaski Day, The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts, Prairie Fire That Wanders About, The Predatory Wasp..., They Are Night Zombies!!..., The Seer's Tower, The Tallest Man... 3/27/24
The only thing I don't like about this album is that you can only listen to it for the first time once. One of the greatest of the 21st century, so much to love about this and not just because I'm from Chicago. The stories are so layered that you can easily put yourself there. The instrumentation is unexpected. Watch the concert from Austin city limits and it's even better.
This is really good. Better than I expected.. I added it and am going to check out his other stuff too
LP
I found it grew to a point of real beauty upon multiple relistens. I had to pause this project for a fair while to have enough time to properly understand this album. Overall, I think the arrangements are quite Disney-esque which isn't really my jam but, I mean, you just can't not appreciate the majesty of the instrumentation none the less. It doesn't quite scrape 5 stars for me based purely on subjective takes but I have absolutely no problem understanding its placement on this list. I mean, some of the songs here... Casimir Pulaski Day? Fuck. Me. Just... utterly soul-crushing and beautiful. Sitting down to properly pour over the lyrics made me feel like someone was squeezing my fucking wind pipe. It's the way the lyrics so brilliantly demonstrate the narrator's youth and naivity. It brings to mind Bowie's Five Years and how the emotions of a tragic event is made so much stronger by having them described by someone young and ignorant. You feel such an aching sorrow for them. I also do appreciate that even a overtly religious song comes nowhere near to proselytising. It's just frank and earnest and beautiful and harrowing and therefore equally powerful for everyone, from a heathen like myself to a devout Christian. Oh what am I doing? Five stars. Has to be. Well done, Sufjan, well done.
Loved this album
Nog nooit van gehoord, maar wat een plaat. Heerlijk muzikaal met klassieke instrumenten en elk nummer (met allemaal bizar lange titels) gewoon ontzettend fijn om naar te luisteren.
Such a great album and Sufjan is an amazing songwriter/ composer. This album was big for me when I was in college but it’s been years since I’ve listened to it through. Kind of heavy emotionally, definitely a lot of sadness in some of these songs. Favorite songs: Come on feel the Illinoise Chicago Casimir Pulaski Predatory wasp Pretty long album but feels tight and interesting through and doesn’t have any filler. Love the Steve Reich- esque minimalism at the end.
This really brought me back, loved this album in high school but was really nice listening with fresh ears. Total masterpiece and stands out among other indie folk records of that era. Somehow it feels really minimal while still being pretty orchestral. The last song feels very Philip glass inspired.
I really enjoyed this. It was very early in the morning when I listened and I found it pleasant and interesting. Would def listen again.
Gear: Meze 109 PRO Mix: unendliche Liebe zum Detail Musik: Jeder Aspekt ist für sich großartig - Lyrics, Vocals, Orchestrierung, Konzept - zusammen einmalig. Wertung: 🐐🐐🐐🐐🐐/5
so beautiful
Banger
Absolutely stunning album. It's been one of my favourites for years and still grows on me with each listen. 22 tracks is a lot, but somehow the quality holds up from start to finish.
All-encompassing
Fantastisch album, gek genoeg nog nooit geluisterd. Iets te lang
Great, but too long to listen the entire album in 1 go. That's the only weakness. Sometimes the music is quite complicated, but it sounds very natural. Favorite song: the man of metropolis.
Thoughts before listening: Another of the 00s indie folk albums that has proven to stand the test of time and remains as a standout of that era. While Sufjan's overly ambitious plan to release an album about each state stalled at 2, he would go on to put out a wonderful body of work spanning 3 decades including last year's Javelin. Still, Illinois remains his masterpiece. Review: This is simply one of the most fun, joyful albums I've ever heard, even when the subject matter is dark i.e. a song about John Wayne Gacy. Orchestral pop ditties with thoughtful lyrics and melodies that get stuck in your head. This came out when I was 24 and has remained in my rotation for going on 20 years. Favorites from this album include "Come On! Feel the Illinoise!", "John Wayne Gacy, Jr", "Jacksonville", "Decatur, or , Round of Applause...", "Chicago", "Casimir Pulaski Day", "The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts", and "They Are Night Zombies". My only complaint is that the instrumental orchestral pieces between songs can be a bit much, but they do help to tie all the songs together as a whole cohesive work of art. Easy 5-stars for me.
Gem 💎
Frábært verk. Góðir textar, geggjuð lög. Sufjan er helvítis meistari.
Fullkomin plata í mínum huga sem hentar við öll tækifæri. Falleg og skemmtileg með mögnuðum textum. Hann spilar sjálfur á öll hljóðfæri, elska óbóið í lögunum enda er hann lærður óbóleikari.
Ok, hear me out.... I think this checks all the boxes of a perfect album for me. It has an overall theme and sticks to it. The songs are varied and unique without feeling out of place. The lyrics can be funny while still tackling serious subject matter. I don't know who else could make a song both fun and haunting about John Wayne Gacy. It's well composed with clean audio and a voice that's beautiful and easy to understand. It even has a "big song"! It may not be a radio hit, but "Chicago" is used in Little Miss Sunshine, The Bear (S1E7 opening), and sampled by Chiddy Bang. This is the definition of an album working as a whole rather than a collection of individual songs. I didn't think an album like this could do it for me, but I think this is very deserving of 5 stars.
Oh man. One of the greatest albums of all time. Give this to me every day of the week.
Whiny
One of my all time favorites. I've only listened to this album about 100 times. 5/5 Sometimes I'll look at the reviews on here before posting my own just to see what some of you think. I'm always surprised to see 1's on albums that I absolutely love so I'll check out their profile and see that one of their highest rated albums is kid rock without fail. Then it all makes sense.
amazing album and now there's a musical in chicago. way to go.
Why do I think this will have a Dion vibe, which would be a disaster, I hope the best, because the album cover is veery weird, but unique too. First song, apparently it's baroque pop, one of my favourite genress. It's slow with a piano and another instrument playing (flute thingy). Background voices are in the song too. Well umm it was too short to rate it, but I'd say 7.9/10 since it was melancholic and the I love piano. Second song, it's instrumental? Much better with the headphones on, different instruments are playing, trombone and some nature like sound thingy(flute maybe) in the left ear. It was epicore vibed and had a classicalness into it. Liked it quite a lot. 8.2/10, I don't even need lyrics at this point. Third song, what fun beat, it's looping, he has a Rufus-like voice. The production is amazing, women joined in and they sing fast. Trombone came in, different version of piano in the right ear. It's so satisfying, the whole vibe and the way melodies flow in such a fun way. I'm deeply amazed. The instrumental break is tbh same just within lyrics. Only piano now with some instrument's riffle sound. Flute thingy in the left ear slightly. Glitchy sounds now, might be electric piano. The jazzy part is as well magnificent. I repeat production is undeniably perfect. I'm feeling so many emotions now, it's sad, but the beat and the instruments are fun in a downtempo way still. It's getting to the end while instruments are less loud. The women's voices is a cappella almost and I love it. It was 10/10 song, definitelyyy loved every second. 4th song, this is sadder, and with a piano. His voice is right in the middle I love that. Idk if I said, but the names are so interesting, they suggest good lyrics too already. There is faint woman voice in the right ear. Guitar is in play now. It's about John Wayne's crimes I suppose. Definitely Rufus Wainwright vibes again, but obviously with differences. Because this was slow Imma rate if 9.5/10. 5th song, violinsss, and piano now, weird guitar like sound in the right ear, but the main guitar is in the middle(one of them sounds like banjo). It's not particularly sad, but not upbeat either. The voice echo effect(not exactly tho) he does that greatt. Trombone came in(I'm not good with instrument names btw). This is not as great as the other ones, but I'm getting it. It's permanent wave in the best possible way. it ended repeating the same lines I think. Not as good as I've said so 8.5/10. 6th song, oop it's an interlude, violins I hear. And that's itt. Not even a transition to the 7th song, but that's okay I guess. This one has a banjo again I thinkk. Two voices I hear. The beat is normal, nothing unique yet. BTW his voice is soft and great to listen to. What are these names, they are sooo much different from what I've seen on other albums ever. He sings a little and then that guitar-like instrument is the main attraction(though it's always playing). This didn't stand out I'd say 7.5/10. Oops clapping sounds I missed, and instrument was breathing.( Just checked and this was another song soo 8th song this one is) 9th song, of monsters and men like violin and best use. Got slow and he started singing. I love full songs and this is one of them. Women sings the chorus. I will definitely check his other albums, so many of them, goood. It was loud and got slow suddenly with him starting singing after the break. Long the songs are btw. Choir like sound I hear. The champer popness is feeling here as well. Outro is chill and choiry. I'd say 9.8/10, the instrumental break was Unforgettable and veeery baroque pop, arcade fire-ed. 10th song, loving the start, it's relaxing and the way he sings is enjoyable. Weird instrument came in. Constant beat is by the guitar. Oh, I hear banjo again. It's monotonous, which is not my vibe, but it's Sufjan so I can take it. Little trombone joined. It's instrumental break with a woman's voice, loving itt. 8.9/10 seems fair. 11th song, what a piano start. It's a short song tho. So beautiful. The instruments are totally with eachother. It's ordered chaos. Well not as amazing so 7.9/10. 12th song, um hello punk rock?! Nevermind it's piano mostly now. Why did it start so metal-y. Choir joined. He finished singing the soft and relaxing one, AND PUNK BEGAN AGAIN, FEELS LIKE TWO SONGS AS ONE. Little trombone joined in the right ear. Exactly same happened, soft voice to punk and choir singing while punk, just to say it is so unique in many ways. Vibe is fully different now, it's slow and more acoustic than ever. Oh, I hear the rising choir voice, it came and stopped for a veeeery short time then perfectly transitioned into the(9.7/10) 13th song, I love this. It has a familiar notes taken. Choir is the main attraction, Sufjan sang a little too. Christmassy vibe now. And it ended differently too, 14th song is an interlude so both of them were a solid 8/10. 15th song, good transition again. It's slow and melancholic now. MY GOODNESS WHAT IS THIS INSTRUMENTAL BREAK I'M FLYING. The verses are fins, not basic, however, not different either. Trombone break again, more emotional though. WOW THE BEAT DROP AND WOMEN VOICE CAME IN, UNEXPECTED. Even more arcade fire vibes. It's progressing, getting louder and more chaotic. Chaos stopped and he sings, left ear I hear a woman. This is a masterpieceee. 10/10 alreadyy. Outro is interlude-y, and has this loud thing going on. 16th song, last song stopped quickly and this one's beat came in. It's so chill and so funn. The violin, I'm so happy what is this, it's so perfect. Woman singing, I think she's pronouncing something, Sufjan joined, but no as main, now he did. Guitar is in the right ear. I repeat the start instrumentals were unexplainably amazing. I love the woman's part. It's chaotic with three voices all together, like what an adventure. 10/10 againn, couldn't have been better than this, plus the name is immaculate. 17th song, violin start oops it's an interlude. Well it's not bad. Umm pardon? Another interlude into the 18th song, there was a transition too, this one's choiry, it ended weirdly, but it transitioned into the next song perfectly. 19th song, it was a piano start, and it's still going just with him singing. It's very satisfying, especially the choir slightly existing in it. Oh it changed the way of singing, it's more full because there is woman in the right and man in the left ear singing along. Back to original alone, soft singing now. Outro is expected, it's with little "ooh"s. I'd say 7.9/10 it didn't give the vibe. 20th song, clapping fun start, trombone, I hear constant beat in the left ear too. 7 fucking minutes? And I feel like there's no lyrics. Well I do am liking the instruments. Oops lyrics came in. Production as good as possible. Women came in they are more upbeat and choiry, they have a musical vibe. I feel blessed. It got slow, and it's the best part in the song, the trombone is beating whole he's singing in the best way with the violins. Clap-clap. SUCH CHAOS. Drum sounds I heard. Cute piano solo, clap-clap, violins. Trombone, gibberish singing along. Oh, it stopped fully, it's totally slow now. Beats increased and downtempoed instantly. Sufjan and the woman are singing together softly, with the not upbeat version of instruments. It's getting progressive I think. YESS IT'S SO MUCH BETTER NOW, MORE FULL. This was just too good 10/10, didn't even notice it was 7 minutes. 21th song, it's interlude and I love it, the trombone is breathing fast, especially in the right ear, both ears experience the same sounds one after the other. 22th song, progressive start. NOO IT'S THE LAST SONG, I'M HAVING SO MUCH FUN THOUGH. I hear piano mainly and some constant beat by unknown instruments to me. As I said it'd getting progressive, louder too. No lyrics for this one I think. Feels like a happy movie ending sound, and it technically is an ending to a beautiful journey. Idk the instruments, but they are eating itt. Because of no lyrics Imma say 9/10. It stopped with a soft note. OBVIOUSLY 5 STARS, HANDS DOWN ONE OF THE BEST ALBUMS HERE. I didn't expect this goodness from this, I'm honestly in shock, and 22 songs went on like little 5 songs, it was so good. I will definitely check more of his albums.
I love it. The creativity of the titles. Very chill listen. Loved it a lot. Found a new comfort album
One of the best ever
I've never been to Illinois in my life, but after listening to this album...I still have no idea what Illinois is about, but at least I have experienced a great record. Usually music categorised as baroque pop is very low on my list of favourite genres, but Sufjan Stevens' music has to be an exception. Honestly, even few of the 20 seconds songs are amazing. I love the instrumental parts, which may slightly overuse banjo, but Sufjan's vocal is also very good and a highlight of the album. Also, it's not often that a record starts strong, but only gets better later, so another point for SS. I'm looking for LP straight away.
I've always absolutely loved this record. Between Sufjan's beautiful, subdued vocals, thought-provoking lyrics, and the simply gorgeous instrumentation, this really is a 10/10 record for me. Special shout-out to the ridiculously long track titles. Favourite tracks: all of them. It's a coherent piece of art that should be listened to as a whole.
I only had a minor knowledge of Stevens due to his Michigan album from the early 2000s. I was glad to come across this album as it made me interested in hearing more of this singer-songwriter. Jake has been a big fan of his for years and I can see why. Only a talented songster can make a song about John Wayne Gacy sound calm and introspective.
Sufjan is one of my all-time favorite songwriters of this generation. I think he would be up there as one of the best, but his catalog is so big. Also being a Michigan-born dude, he holds a special place in my heart. Seven Swans got me into Sufjan but Illinois was my favorite early album from him. AND Javelin's release this year was another top-5 album of the year for me. This album is so full of beautiful songs and poetry. The guitar work, the lyrics, and the musicianship, are all flawless.
This music elicited an emotional response. That’s something powerful. The production value is incredible. Such an impressive melding of instruments and vocals that weave in and out exceptionally, peaking and dipping in a jazz formation where they do not battle each, but instead allow the other to flourish. The singing can be soft at times, but it’s never boring, always beautiful. The concept aspect is fun, the titles are silly, and the filler songs are unique flows that have their own cosmic flair. Truly a beautiful album on the first listen.
Sufjan Stevens can sometimes be a little hit-or-miss for me some of his albums can feel a little too out-there, even for me — one of the biggest fans of weird-ass weirdo shit but many of his albums are the perfect blend of weird and accessible, and this is probably one of the best examples of that a perfect 10/10 in my eyes I can’t decide which song is my favorite probably The Tallest Man, The Broadest Shoulders just because I can’t get that absolutely legendary 11/8 flow out of my head it moves as an interchanging flow of 5/8 then 6/8, then 5/8 back to 6/8 and that sounds weird, but it’s so goddam catchy for this pretentious prog-rock/math-rock nerd
The soaring melodies create an ethereal experience. There's a sweet charm reminiscent of Charlie Brown, adding a nostalgic touch that feels like a comforting embrace. Listening to this album is like having breakfast in Downtown Camper in Stockholm – it's a moment frozen in time, triggering vivid memories. I can't help but feel a bit silly for waiting so long to discover this masterpiece. The emotional resonance and beauty of Illinois make it a personal treasure, and I can't recommend it enough. NUMBER OF BANGERS - 13 STAND OUT TRACK - Come on Feel the Illinoise
Always known I should dig into Sufjan, this album is always recommended as the jump off point. Have really enjoyed listening to it to be honest, really nice production and music Giving it a 5 cos I want to listen to it again and again
Perfect. Beautiful. Important.
An album that immediately feels nostalgic and simultaneously is nostalgic.
Complete package of an album, the music is beautiful, the idea is original and executed perfectly. We need more albums about states, Sufjan!
Incredible
This album isn't even 20 yet, and I feel as though it's reputation will only continue to grow in decades to come. While its precedent Michigan was fantastic album in its own right, I believe this is the record that cemented his reputation as one of indie's most intelligent, melodic, and heart-wrenching songwriters. From the wonderful orchestration to the captivating storytelling, this ode to the Prairie State captivates in spite of its long running time. Some may find it a little twee, others too grandiose. But for me, it's perfect.
one of my favorites sonic palettes ever. Choirs, mallets, brass, sufjan's voice. The best combo
I’m a huge Sufjan Stevens fan, and I love this album. It’s just so good, I know these songs so well, I think I’d rather die than give it less than 5 stars.
I've heard a few songs by Sufjan Stevens and I enjoy his sound. I'm looking forward to this. I'm only on the first track but I love the sound so far. Track 3 is almost 7 minutes long...usually this would bother me, but it's so interesting I don't even care. Oh wow...track 4. This is so intriguing. Dang this is such an interesting idea for an album. I'm having a blast with this. 5/5. Although this was really long, it was so interesting to listen to. I loved it. I want to go and listen to his Michigan album now.
Absolutely great vibe
Great album, very calming. It seems like he really knows what he is doing. Lot of great songs with unique sounds, I was considering giving it a 5. Edit -- I changed it to a 5.
totally not what I was expecting... haven't really listened to sufjan Stevens but I have a friend whose obsessed and I thought I was gonna be sobbing through the whole thing but it wasn't too depressing. I really liked the music and the variety in instruments and I felt like the whole album was curated very nicely. big fan 9/10
8.5/10 - Extremely interesting with every piece sounding completely different. I read part of the wikipedia article about this one and it was interesting to see a bit of illinois history in music. One last whoo hoo was just a crazy piece also.
This really encapsulates the spirit of lake forest lake bluff. The song names are wonderful and the music is very good. 9/10
This shit slapped. What was I thinking
I am a little biased, but I basically grew up with this album and it has always been my favorite.
Illinois is not my favorite Sufjan album. Out of the two state albums, I prefer Michigan, which also isn't my favorite album overall of his. However, Illinois has so much breadth and depth does showcase his abilities to write meaningful, affecting lyrics and complex compositions.
Super
It's almost classical in its beautiful arrangements and ornamentation, yet somehow manages to also be heart breaking earth shattering pop too. A work of true genius. And this review is still shorter than some of the song titles.
Very pretty albulm
One of the best indie albums of all time
BL: Illinois was one of the first proper albums I listened to the whole way through. So many of the tracks hold close memory associations and are very near and dear in my heart. “The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades is Out to Get Us” is a personal favourite of mine as I remember singing it with a girl I had a crush on in acting school when I was 12 or 13. This album is completely linked to who I am as a person, and I’m sure my love for it will only continue to grow on a relisten. AL: this album still holds so much emotional weight and memory to me. But as I grow older I do realise this album does suffer from having a decent amount of filler. While 80% of the album flows amazingly especially in the last few tracks it almost completely peters out. That being said, just for how strong the influence the album has had on me is. It’s a solid 5 from me. FT: “Concerning the UFO sighting near Highland, Illinois”, “John Wayne Gacy Jr.”, “Casimir Pulaski Day”, “The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades is Out to Get Us!”, “They are Night Zombies!! They are Neighbours!! They Have Come Back from the Dead!! Ahhhhh!” 5/5
Oops I've been missing out my whole life
One of the most beautiful albums ever. Sufjan’s voice has that amazing, airy timbre and the instrumental arrangements are so distinct and layered extremely well. The aesthetic of the album is so unique and the concept is so rich; I have not heard anything like it since. This thing is dense as hell without ever getting old. So many songs, especially Predatory Wasp, truly move me every time I hear them, and I can’t say that about a lot of albums. This thing is close to perfect. Easy 5.
wow!!!! just wow. this album just sounds like childhood, it brings me so much joy. i almost teared up when i heard the upbeat trumpet with the accompanying soft lyrics. i adore this album so much.
I anticipate the following review to be a hot take but here it goes. This is the first album so far that I already knew well and I love this one. Well rounded, pretty, kind of jazzy, with some of my favorite instrumentals and interesting, well-researched lyrics. I know some people think a concept album all about a state is silly and excessive but I think this album is great. Would give it a 4.5 if I could as it's definitely not a perfect album, but 5 stars to distinguish it from anything else I've rated 4 so far. Best song: Chicago, The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades Is Out To Get Us!
Fantastic album. The songwriting and backing orchestral instrumentation are the big highlights on this album for me. It feels like Sufjan has made use of almost every instrument in the orchestra throughout this album, and each track has a distinct vibe based on the instruments used. The album does such a good job of immersing you into this world of Illinois created by Sufjan. It takes through through a journey of highs, lows, and UFOs. It's a beautiful thing. Fave tracks: John Wayne Gacy, Jr., Chicago, Casimir Pulaski Day, The Predatory Wasp..., They are Night Zombies!! They...
This is an epic album. It is taking concept to the extreme, jam-packed with references both personal and cultural to Illinois. The scope is truly mind-boggling. The songwriting is also extremely well done. Beautiful instrumentation and varied, experimental sounds that still form a cohesive unit. Also the song titles are a real joy. Despite all of this - I personally feel this album does not fully emotionally resonate with me in the way a lot of other great albums do, but I do still appreciate as an exceptional work of art nonetheless. Perhaps I just need to dig a bit deeper. Fav Tracks: Chicago, The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts, The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades Is Out to Get Us!
❤️
Fantastic. Never had gotten around to it but everything people said is true
What an interesting album. Not something I would’ve ever listened to before. Such a moody album. A lot of it is very somber and low-key but then there are some crazy jams with electronic equipment. I would definitely listen to it again and also recommend it to someone else. Definitely not something I would listen to a lot but once in a while, maybe.
I remember the first time I heard this album. Somebody had mentioned it was really good and I sat down and had a very similar experience to today "Is this background music?" and then somewhere in track 3 you just get swept up in the sound. It's big while maintaining a subtlety. There is a lot going on for something that is whisper quiet at times. Also, John Wayne Gacy, Jr. is still as haunting as it ever has been.
Such an insanely brilliant album. Thinking that Sufjan could easily be a classical composer if he wanted to...the arrangements are that amazing. Biggest highlights are Come On! Feel the Illinoise, Predatory Wasps, Casimir Pulaski. This album has been such a huge part of my life for so long...such a shame he abandoned the 50 States project. Would be amazing to have an Indiana entry. 6/5
i’ve always seen him around and have listened to like 1 song before and i’m mad at myself for not having listened to more cause i really really really like this so much. and i will listen to everything else and see if it’s the album or actually sufjan, but yeah, this was right up my street.
Skön vibe. Några låtar in, men 6/10 får den
Sufjan Stevens is one of those artists that I kinda of knows exists and I dig his music but never went beyond his bigger “hits”. I knew of, and very much loved “Chicago” from this album but never listened to the whole album. We I loved this album. I was hanging Christmas lights on Black Friday and I listened this album on repeat for the entire 5 hours it took me.
Wow I liked this much more than I expected. I've always been a sucker for concept albums, but even without the concept, the music itself is amazing.
Their album has become one of my favourite.
This is not the first time listening to parts of this album or Sufjan. So, I know already that I really like his sounds, and know to brace myself for some of his weird instrumentations. High key, this is an incredible album. A little artsy (but what Indie album isn't), but full of character.
Finally one of my all time favorites! Strong 5
Concerning the UFO Sighting Near Highland, Illinois Come on! Feel the Illinoise! Part I: The World's Columbian Exposition Part II: Carl Sandburg Visits Me in a Dream John Wayne Gacy, Jr. Decatur, or, Round of Applause for Your Stepmother! Chicago Casimir Pulaski Day They Are Night Zombies!! They Are Neighbors!! They Have Come Back From the Dead!! Ahhhh!
a beautiful fun sad epic folk album
Incredible. Everyone from Chicagoland, Illinois should listen to this album. Beautiful, moving, excellent lyricism and inspiring melodies
This was a staple of my early 20’s and I haven’t really listened to it much since. I forgot just how good it is. I love a record where it feels like every little detail has been considered, and this is one of those for me. Everything feels so intricate and well thought out. It has everything I like: great lyrics, well (but not over) produced, lots going on musically but never overly complex, heartfelt. My only slight gripe is it long, but then again it’s packed with great songs. There’s two 5 star albums here, but strangely 5+5=4.5. Dont ask me why. I think this was the record that catapulted him to ‘indie God’, and his releases since have mostly been at the same calibre or in some cases even better received. 4.5 rounded up to 5, and it’s back in my regular rotation
I really, really like this album. I have no idea why or how I got into it, all I remember is that I've been a fan of it for at least 10 years. I've bought it on CD on two separate occasions, and it currently sits in my car. Expansive and yet introverted and intricate. Lovely range of melodies to the whole thing, but a coherence to it all. I'm thrilled that a lot of it is in a minor key, so when this changes, the "joyful songs" are that bit more joyful. I can recognise a lot of religious elements too, which maybe adds more grounding to the music, which can admittedly leap into a bit too ethereal at times. My favourite songs are: John Wayne Gacy Jr. -- possibly the sweetest, saddest song written about a serial killer. The true highlight of the album. Casimir Pulaski Day -- I like the banjo. The song changes throughout but sort of doesn't. Concerning the UFO sighting near Highland, Illiniois -- An epic introduction to the album. The Seer's Tower -- Dismal and dingy, how I like most of my music. They Are Night Zombies! ... -- A bit daft but original and memorable. The Tallest Man, the Broadest Shoulders ... -- Soaring orchestral nonsense. I have listened to his other stuff and, whilst good, doesn't captivate me the way that this does. I also didn't realise that he played the majority of the instruments on the album. Good stuff. "I see the fire, I see the end". Just some nice writing.
relaxing
Love this record.
I remember the first time I heard this album. Somebody had mentioned it was really good and I sat down and had a very similar experience to today "Is this background music?" and then somewhere in track 3 you just get swept up in the sound. It's big while maintaining a subtlety. There is a lot going on for something that is whisper quiet at times. Also, John Wayne Gacy, Jr. is still as haunting as it ever has been.
Easy to listen to, interesting stories within each song, with some really beautiful instrumentals and harmonizing. The lyrics got me thinking, this artist is a real poet. I enjoyed the whole album. The John Wayne Gacy song, that was quite an interesting take on/ portrayal of a serial killer. 4.5
I owe you an apology, Mr. Stevens. I wasn't really familiar with your game.
I didn’t have much of an idea what to expect from this. I think he’s more popular in America. I loved it though and I am sure it will reward more listens. Still hating the fact there are only 5 stars
New artist for me and I really enjoyed this.
Emotional indie album, euphoric highs, low lows
Loved seeing this album on here. I have always found Sufjan's music to be haunting and intoxicating. Really enjoyed sitting and listening to this again.
Classic.
first album in this generator experience that I got that I have a history with. One that has had a profound effect on me and my musical tastes. Chicago is just a classic song from this album. Casmir Pulaski day and predatory wasp bring me to tears no matter how many times I listen to it. John Wayne Gacy leaves me uneasy. Man of Metroplis just makes me want to rock out. There’s a song for everyone on this record. But when put all together it leaves you with a dynamic, fun, tear jerking 1 hour and 14 minutes. So glad this album was included on this list.
"Illinois" is the fifth studio album by American singer-songwriter Sufjan Stevens. Also known as "Sufjan Stevens Invites You to: Come on Feel the Illinoise," as shown on the album cover, it is a concept album featuring songs referring to places, events and people related to the state of Illinois. It was his album based on a state (Michigan the first); he jokingly said he was going to do an album on all fifty. Indie folk, chamber folk and indie rock are the appropriately listed genres. The recording was done at multiple locations in NYC using low-fi equipment. The album was widely acclaimed for its well-written lyrics and complex orchestration. Commercially, it made it into the US Billboard 200 and has been his greatest success to date. Piano and a flute open the album in "Concerning the UFO near Highland, Illinois." Nice vocal harmonization which continues throughout the album. And yes, about a reported UFO sighting near Highland, IL. "Come On! Feel the Illinoise!" ( two parts) has a jaunting piano. Horns are added. Great arrangements. The songs builds with the vocal harmonies and piano. Illinois did hold the World's Columbian Exposition in 1893. Boy, some of these songs have ridiculously long titles including this one which I cut in half. Strings and a vibraphone create a loud intro for "Chicago." Strings remain the background with multple instruments. Stevens whispering and telling the story of road trips (one to Chicago) which he uses as an analogy for making mistakes and starting over. A great horn interlude and just a fantastic vocal chorus with harmonies. No doubt, one of the best songs in the 2000's. In the next song, he ups the ante in the an even more compelling song "Casimir Pulaski Day." It's slower with an acoustic guitar as tells the story of visiting a lover who is dying of bone cancer on the Casimir Pukaski state holiday. Religious overtones. It builds to a musical climax with horns added. Woah, what a song. "The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts" brings the rock with drums and an electric guitar riff. Always of a fan of the soft-loud-soft dynamic and this song pretty much defines that. Vocal harmonies carry the wonderful chorus as they sing of Superman (actually from Metropolis) with comparisons to Christ. A glorious harmony ending. This is a great album. Fantastic orchestral and harmony arrangements. The lyrics are very clever and at times very emotional as he ties actual events, people and places to his own personal experiences. Not many artists have successfully done that. I counted no less than 23 instruments played by Stevens and he uses a number of them to carry the melody throughout the album. Sufjan Stevens has at least four or five must listen to and must have albums and this is one of them.
So much more than I had always given it credit for. Very emotional and beautiful throughout.
There are a lot of songs on this album, but fortunately I really liked the majority of them. There is some meandering music on there that almost brought me down a star, but I am feeling generous this morning.
I feel the Illinoise
Old favorite
excellent record, first half dwarfs second half, but strong effort overall
I can definitely feel the Illinoise!
this is not folk, this is actually interesting to listen
Great compositions here. Sufjan made some great smooth melodies while still including a lot of depth. Loved the use of a small choir
stand out track - Casimir Pulaski Day
slaps
I love this album so much
Perfect album.
cool
As someone who has lived in Illinois my entire life, and hasn't left it much, it was inevitable I listened to this album at some point. I would like to say I am pretty qualified to review this. And I get it now. Sufjan Stevens is nothing short of a genius. This is a compositional masterpiece, and beautiful in every sense of the word. The orchestration and arrangements are something I've never heard captured in a bottle like this before. It is like the Goldilocks of singer-songwriter music. Considering how ambitious the scope of this album can seem to be, never once does the music overwhelm the listener. Never once do the people playing their instruments try too hard to impress you, or make it obvious that they want to blow you away. They do it so subtly that it sneaks up on you sometimes. This album is filled to the brim with some of the most gorgeous and luscious sounding instrumentation you will ever hear. Even if the other 48 state albums will never come out, it is clear that Stevens did his research for this one. This record is laced with references and lyrical themes based on the history of Illinois and its cities. From John Wayne Gacy, to The World's Columbian Exposition, anyone local to the area will find something to connect with. The centerpiece that ties everything together would have to be the song Chicago. It takes all of the elements spread throughout the rest of the album that make it so amazing, and combines them all into one masterfully executed song. Now, from the titles, to the somewhat long track list, this album can seem daunting to a first listener. But most of the longer ballads are separated by much shorter songs that are closer to interludes. Some are as short as 30 seconds, and some are a little over 2 minutes. None of them are super notable, which doesn't seem like the point, but my favorite would probably have to be Prairie Fire That Wanders About. If we are speaking purely about the actual songs, then this album basically has no bad songs. Each one is individually unique, but also conceptually similar, and it makes for a wonderful and easy listening experience. I love the occasional elements of repetitive minimalism mixed in. The closing track Out of Egypt feels like it would fit right in on a Steve Reich album like Music for 18 Musicians. The Man of Metropolis is on the heavier side, and the fuzzy thumping guitar lead fits this sound surprisingly well. And parts like the syncopated piano on Feel the Illinoise!, or the bass on They Are Night Zombies!! could get stuck in my head for hours. I was really excited to get the chance to listen to this album before Sufjan's new record comes out in a few weeks. And consider me hyped, because I am officially a Sufjan Stevens fan. This album really blew me away, and I fell in love with its breathtaking production. It finds so much beauty in simplicity and feels like a road trip across the state of Illinois.
Whimsical. Kitsch. Wes Anderson set to vinyl. I love it.
"lush" orchestration and assembly. chill but complex. reminds me of the steely dan pretzel album in this sense, but different in terms of sound
9/10
Very chill, folkish. Mucho enjoyo
HL: "The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades Is Out to Get Us!", "Come On! Feel the Illinoise!", "Prairie Fire That Wanders About", "Casimir Pulaski Day", "Decatur, or, Round of Applause for Your Stepmother!" Not that it's my favourite track or anything, but it took until "Out of Egypt" for me to really embrace this album. Since at a certain point, the length (of the album & the individual songs) was weighing on me a bit. I tried getting into Sufjan Stevens a few years ago (with this + Carrie & Lowell) with mixed results, but I think I'm ready to call this a mastapeece. Love the orchestral arrangements. Love the odd, quirky song structures. I've been spoiled with mid 2000s gems recently. September 6, 2023
One of the most important albums that helped shape my tastes. Since I first heard this in high school, I've listened to it in full hundreds of times and it still retains its magic. 5/5
i cried :(
GOAT!!!! FAVORITE TRACKS: ALL OF IT 5/5
great!
cute! very agreeable
Trumpets! 2005 - Indie rock, Indie folk, Indie pop, Folk rock, Baroque pop, Experimental rock, Folk baroque
This album is beautiful. Absolutely gorgeous and I am so glad to listen to it. I will listen and listen again.
For some reason, this feels like an album that people would say should be on the list but it isn’t. I don’t know why, it’s got that quality of being super popular on RYM and similar stuff, but overlooked on best albums lists by big labels and publications. Anyway, it’s a great album. I mean, I like indie pop. This is one of the biggest indie pop albums. It’s good.
Never heard of this album or this artist. Spectacular.
One of the greatest albums of the early 2000s
A 74 minutes long concept album in an unfinished series of concept albums, with song titles so long that they take half the song length to scroll past on Spotify - there will definitely be people out there who hate this. I'm so glad to not be one of them. Oddly first got into him through his loads of Christmas singles. Carrie and Lowell will probably always be my favourite, an absolutely breathtaking album, but this is a close second. Really enjoyed listening to this today. Yes, obviously it's too long, not going to stop me giving it 5 though.
Casimir Pulaski Day made me cry at work, and the rest of it was amazing too. One of my new favorites for sure. It's nice to hear that the whole album lives up to how good the couple songs I already knew were.
I get it, I get why this was on everyone's iPods in middle school now.
Chills from the very first note. Best song: Come On! Feel the Illinoise! John Wayne Gacy, Jr, Chicago, The Seer's Tower are also fabulous.Simply amazing album, I think with a couple more listen it could be 5 out of 5. Right now 4,5/5.
One of my ALBUMS
What a beautiful album I don’t think I’ve ever listened to it
Still Sufjan's best, I think. An album I keep coming back to
I love this album. It came out when I was in high school and I still have the memory of my friend playing it for me in his car. Then, I went back and checked out Sufjan Stevens' earlier records and was a big fan. Really beautiful songwriting and fun concept album. Standout Tracks: "Concerning the UFO Sighting near Highland, Illinois", "Come On! Feel the Illinoise!", "John Wayne Gacy, Jr.", "Jacksonville", "Chicago", "Casimir Pulaski Day", "The Man of Metropolis Steals Our Hearts", "The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades Is Out to Get Us!", "The Tallest Man, the Broadest Shoulders", "Out of Egypt, into the Great Laugh of Mankind, and I Shake the Dirt from My Sandals as I Run"
There is no such thing as "the best album of all time", because of how subjective music is. That being said, I don't know why, but this album feels like if there ever was an "objectively best album", this is the closest we've come to it so far. I wouldn't even call this my favorite album of all time, because I don't really share a deep emotional bond with it as opposed to albums like "The Holy Bible" by Manic Street Preachers or "Animals" by Pink Floyd, but I can't find a single flaw in it. All songs are beautiful and heartfelt both musically and lyrically, there are exactly 0 filler moments, Sufjan, the Illinoismaker Choir and all the backing vocalists have voices of angels. There's songs that will make you cry, there's songs that will make you dance, there's songs with song titles longer than the Constitution. Man. Sorry for gushing so much. I could probably go to an uncontacted Amazon tribe, play "Chicago" to them, and they would love it. Gonna have to give this album the rare 6/5. I'm 532 albums in and this is the best one so far, save for maybe "Wish You Were Here".
Ooh, what a masterpeice. I will always enjoy another relisten. Such a unique sound
Wow!! Amazed by this one!! Did not expect anything and this is one of the most surprising album I have hear recently. The instrument composition is very unique making musicalities seem like they are new instruments. I am not too found of the themes or rythm of the album but it is wayyyyy overshadowed by some incredible music crafting. Very strong 4.5/5
One of the greatest albums of all time… If you’re not a sour old grinch that hates a little bit of whimsy.
Illinoise by Sufjan Stevens is an amazing album that tells its narrative very well with provoking tracks such as Chicago, John Wayne Gacy, Jr. & Come On! Feel the Illinoise! Easily one of the best albums of the 2000s and a benchmark in the Folk Rock & Indie Pop genres Illinoise is just one of those albums that gets better with each listen because each track has a place in the overarching concept of the album, Illinoise is a perfect puzzle of enjoyability 5/5
Str8 fire. Sufjan can do no wrong
I have been listening to this one for years. I'm a big fan of Sufjans work and this is my favorite of his. Such an incredibly well executed concept for an album.
One of my all time favorites
Sufjan always plays a fine line between being actively irritating and brilliant. The sheer ambition and scale of some of these songs wins the day here. Some very complex harmonic arrangements in the more orchestral songs are spell binding.
A classic. Love it a lot. There was a song in Little Miss Sunshine
was very excited to see this album pop up. I gave it a try a couple years ago, but got distracted and never got around to really finishing it. I’ve always loved the song Chicago, as well as the other tracks I’ve heard, but listening to it in full was a fantastic experience. It is brimming with nostalgia, despite me having no nostalgia for Illinois or this album. It just feels timeless in that way, as well as being one of the most cinematic albums I’ve heard in a long, long time. Definitely feels like it could be a musical, especially with the big-bandy instrumentation and the frequent use of ensemble singing. Favorite songs are definitely come on! Feel the Illinoise!, Chicago, predatory wasp, and zombies. No complaints, brilliant album.
I went to visit some future family in the late summer of 2005 or 2006. I was chatting with a wee fella who was in a band, musically inclined. I asked him for an album recommendation and he suggested this album. This being before the streaming era, I waited until I had a chance to listen to it many weeks later at a music shop. I remember being so excited based on the description of what lie ahead. But when I sampled it, I was not impressed. I’ve had a disappointed view of this album ever since. Using my 1001 rating scale, I probably would have given it 2 stars based off my memory. Well my disappointment has been transposed from this album onto myself. What was I thinking?!? I have missed almost two decades of appreciating Illinois. Maybe I just wasn’t ready for it yet. I’m down with the indie, chamber folk sound. I especially appreciate the variety of instruments, like the trumpet, Wurlitzer, and banjo. Sufjan’s vocals fit the music so well too. While the recording equipment were low-fidelity, a sound I appreciate for this album, the song titles are not. Across 22 songs, there are an average of 14+ words per title (309 total). Track 2 (shortened to The Black Hawk War here) comes in at a whopping 53 words. Jacksonville, the lone 1 word title, is a slacker. It’s as if Sufjan’s ability to intelligently delete layers is offset by an inability to succinctly encompass a song through its title. The album is long, an almost certain complaint from me. But not here, I enjoyed every minute.
Got to see Sufjan on tour for this album! So good. Hadn't listened to it in AGES, I had to listen to it like 4 times in a row lol. And then some of the singles on repeat the rest of the day. Anyway, this one is an easy 5, so easy it's making a lot of my 5s not seem so hot anymore lol. One of my favorite albums ever, top 10 depending on the day I think. A good amount of Philip Glass influence on this album I think, which is obviously amazing. So well orchestrated, arranged, produced. Love it.
Even on a list like this, this is a rare perfect album. The concept is admittedly gimmicky but the breathe and depth of the music and variety of styles makes up for it. Not a single bad track.
i don’t even know why but this just sounds perfect. not sure what it has to do w illinois yet but i’m excited for some more listens
this album is a wonderfully fantastical journey of musical. it made me think of what an album written by kurt vonnegut would sound like. heavy recommend
I loved this at the time but have rarely come back to it. So it was lovely to return to it. It somehow sounds like the original Willy Wonka film. I have very little to back that up, but I promise you. Best song Jacksonville .
Wowza, first time listening to this masterpiece. It is just so beautifully strange, I really really enjoyed this. The names are so long and making them at some points so funny, but also still have a meaning behind them all through the self titled state. Painting such a vivid picture in my head of what he is portraying in the songs with his incredible voice, hitting straight to the core in most songs.
I really, really enjoyed this
”Illinois" by Sufjan Stevens is a masterpiece of folk and indie rock. Released in 2005, the album showcases Stevens' songwriting skills, his unique and soothing vocal style, and his ability to weave complex stories into his music. The album's 22 tracks are named after different cities and stories from Illinois, and each song explores the history, culture, and mythology of its namesake location. From the infectious pop hooks of "Chicago" to the haunting introspection of "John Wayne Gacy, Jr.," Stevens takes the listener on a journey through the heartland of America, offering a unique and personal perspective on its people, places, and stories. Stevens' arrangements are lush and intricate, featuring a wide range of instruments including banjo, trumpet, and strings. His lyrics are deeply poetic, with a rich sense of imagery and metaphor that draws the listener into each song's world. And his voice, fragile and intimate, is the perfect vessel for delivering these powerful messages. Illinois sets apart from other albums is its emotional depth. Stevens tackles weighty topics like death, grief, and loneliness with a raw honesty that is both heartbreaking and inspiring. He doesn't shy away from the difficult aspects of life, but rather embraces them and uses them to create something beautiful. It is an album that demands to be listened to from beginning to end, and one that rewards the listener with something new and profound with each subsequent listen. Simply an incredible experience.
Certified indie Classic Listened to best during autumn
That's very good. Very different from what I was expecting, but good nonetheless
Heaven Music. Every sound every word touches my soul. Whether alone or in a crowd, SS comforts me.
Revisiting this record was a treat. I remember feeling a bit confused by its length and overall concept at the time of its release, along with the sprawling details of its orchestration. Turns out *Illinois* aged like fine wine, actually, and that what's most important in it are the heartbreaking melodies and sheer poetry of the lyrics. Not that the concept behind this album is not aptly conveyed as well if you pay a little attention. What struck me the most in that regard is the influence of Steve Reich and Philip Glass over many arrangements here, and how fitting such influences are when you want to write an elegy about American popular culture. Yet, I repeat, the album doesn't only work in "intellectual" ways. In spite of their lush arrangements, many songs in this record actually foretell the pure emotions of the pared-down masterpiece *Carrie And Lowell* (released 10 years after this one). And without such emotions, this sort of grand project would be pointless. If you delve into Stevens' discography, it's quite obvious that he is not always consistent in the way he channels his instincts and incredible skills as a musician and a songwriter. But the two LPs we're talking about here are essential for sure. And it's not the opinion of Bon Jovi fans (such as the one responsible for the "review" currently heading the responses to *Illinois*) that will convince anyone they're not. Once again, this is not a matter of "low-brow" or "high-brow" tastes (that sort of dichotomy is broadly the only point that this Sufjan Stevens hater is expressing in that review of his--and honestly, it's a little misleading.). What matters the most is discerning what good songwriting is. There's a lot of good straightforward songwriting in albums that are supposedly "low-brow", of course. But that doesn't objectively mean you can't find any similar straightforward qualities in works that are far more complex or intricate at first glance. And *Illinois* is a perfect illustration for this sort of situation. Number of albums left to review: 654 Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 174 (including this one) Albums from the list I *might* include in mine later on: 82 Albums from the list I will certainly *not* include in mine (many others are more essential to me): 96
Fantastic album, I'm finding it hard to think about things to say about it, because this one runs really deep for me. "Casimir Pulaski Day" was one of the first songs I learned on guitar back in the day. Some just devastating songs that will make you cry, in particular "John Wayne Gacy, Jr." and "Casimir Pulaski Day." I mean, several masterpieces: "Come On! Feel the Illinoise", "Jacksonville", "Chicago." Is there some fluff on here? Does it get to long? Of course it's 77 minutes! But it's more than worth that time spent and it deserves its place in the canon.
5 stars. What can I say.
I admit to not really being able to get into Sufjan's style ever in my years since hearing about the guy. After years of associating "Chicago" with a pretty rough relationship back in high school it was hard for me to hear these songs without immediately dismissing them for one reason or another. Sufjan falls into the camp of music that sounds like it's made for the stage, made for a "show" so to speak. That is a camp of music that is so hard for to mesh with (as I have written about now in numerous reviews). However, this time upon listening I realized how naive I was to just write this off and never give it an honest shot. So this album review club gave me a chance to try it. And man I am glad I did. This album is a masterpiece. So many stories that go deep into the history of Illinois, so much creative musicianship, so many beautiful little moments (one of my favorite tracks is "John Wayne Gacy, Jr." talk about a beautiful moment about something so disgustingly terrible). From start to finish there are tracks that seem deliberate, tracks that contribute to the Illinois ethos. I admittedly only listened once with a few songs on in the background while cooking, but even that one single time is enough for me to realize the importance of this album. It's works like this one that most definitely belong on this list. This album can be enjoyed by damn near anyone and DESERVES to be listened to by damn near everyone given the amount of effort Sufjan clearly put into it. This dude is on a whole nother level. 5/5 from me.
So great! Absolutely loved the sound and I have nearly no complaints, especially with how cohesive it feels as an album.
Joey said it best in several texts to me today: 12:38p OK musically this album is super well done but i feel like I’m watching schoolhouse rock or something 12:47p John Wayne Gacy, Jr. damn. What a beautiful and dark track 12:56p Ok maybe this album is extremely epic and is one of the most important singer songwriter works of the 21st century 5/5
I mean. It's spectacular. Ambitious. An artist who took the idea of "concept album" and ran so hard his legs fell off. Insane to think that he wanted to do one of these for each of the 50 States. It's too long! But... damn. Small sacrifice for such a complete work.
Illinois is lush with instrumentation and literate lyrics. Without demystifying the breath and depth of topics Sufjan covers, often grandiose anthems about petty statehood historical trivialities, it would be neglectful to not mention "Casimir Pulaski Day". The song offers a heart wrenching tale about a girl with bone cancer, augmented with only Stevens' raw emotion and a banjo. "John Wayne Gacy, Jr." which is a ballad about a serial killer, is performed with somber finger picked guitar. Its muted narrative offers no defense for this murderer's exploits. But suddenly at the end of the song, Stevens muses, "And in my best behavior/I am really just like him," a heart wrenching admission. With that said, there is the unshakable feeling that those song titles, as long as they are, come off as a pretentious artist decision. I can't give it a perfect score singlehandedly because of it. In addition, the 74min runtime is a fair endurance test. Both are minor nitpicks. But it remains amazing. A singer/songwriter achievement.
Immaculate
This shit is ethereal. So so beautiful, well put together, and just perfect. So many little hidden piece of information in the lyrics. The pipes, drums, guitars, keys, the background singers, all of it just perfectly working harmonising gracefully together making the best of the best music. THIS is what theatre kid music is and its brilliant. It almost made me feel sad and almost cry of John Wayne Gacy, but then quickly reminded me of his atrocities, whiplashing me in feelings. Easily has become one of my favourite albums and I will check out more of his stuff. 10/10
This album is fucking marvelous
Sufjan Stevens makes timeless music that manages to be super clean but full-sounding at the same time. Chicago is one of my favorite songs.
Wow. Imagine if Sufjan had done this 50 times.
Love this album, so full of musical variation and meditative lyrics.
This is a wonderful album. Each to their own and if you prefer loud Indy, Rapping or Thrash then I suggest this isn't for you. It's quiet, introverted and orchestral in places. I like Indy, Rappers and Thrash but I also like this.
one of my favorite albums ever, love the production and the lyrics are amazing
Song #3 was good
Used to listen to this in highschool
Just a beautiful album with so much depth, hooks and range.
One of my favourite albums, just fantastic
I adore this album, everything about it is just utterly gorgeous.
An eclectic masterpiece. I'll die salty that the 50 States project was just a publicity gimmick
Beautiful poetic lyrics sung with a wonderful harmonic voice. Lush arty melodies and arrangements. Over and hour long but flows by effortlessly.
I would have to say that Sufjan Stevens is my favourite indie artist. And although he has quite a few doozies out there, Illinoise is probably my favourite album of his. His brand of chamber indie pop is marked by quirky lyrics, weird time signatures and the judicious use of horns, strings and vocal choir that produces a chaotic disjointed sound, but somehow it all flows together so well. Like a good wine with complex notes and multiple layers his music may take a few listenings to get into your head, but once it does, its remarkable.
Htjela sam ga poslusat par puta da se uvjerim da je petica.
Brilliant
Great album. Great lad. He clearly loves Jesus very much!
excellent album. Definitely want to listen some more to this one.
The mid-late aughts were the absolute peak of indie rock and this album is a perfect example. A TITAN of the genre. So much instrumental variety but all so beautiful with witty, deep lyrics throughout.
Hadn’t listened to this one forever. Love!!!
This is the quintessential Sufjan Stevens album
I liked it
Another of my favourite albums, but I'll try and give it a closer listen to see if I hear anything fresh... Wow, I'm really glad I did give it a full and fresh listen, because I just realised that I've been neglecting the second half of the album for a while now. I had forgotten how beautiful "The Predatory Wasp of the Palisades" and "The Tallest Man..." are. Not to mention the last song, which was weirdly the first song I ever listened to from this album, on my sister's iPod shuffle if I remember correctly! There are too many fantastic songs ( and their titles are too damn long) on this album for me to list them all here. But I will say that Jacksonville, Decatur, and Casmir Pulaski Day are some of my favourite songs ever. I often get snippets from these songs (and others from this album) randomly stuck in my head as I go about my day. The instrumentation, vocals and harmonies throughout the album are all delightful. The historical references in the lyrics are so specific that its often hard to get the full meaning without looking things up, but that just adds another element for me. Over all a perfect 10 album, in my opinion.
Great one!
Love it!
Really enjoyed this whole album. Light chill music with a variety of instruments. stevens has a great soft voice. I liked the use of the piano and flute
- Already own on vinyl - Best Sufjan album - Top 10 album of 21st century
Sadly goated. Sounds like you're in a small town in the corn fields of Illinois
One of the albums of all time PREFS: TOUT MOINS PREF: RIEN
Nice concept album, that is a welcome surprise in this 1001 albums generator. An instant classic for me.
I fucking love Sufjan Stevens. Subtle vocals, subtle guitar. It all comes together in such a wonderfully done package. It’s 90 mins that flies by.
I have loved Sufjan ever since a friend put "For the Widows in Paradise, For the Fatherless in Ypsilanti" as her MySpace song in 2006. I prefer his Michigan album for obvious reasons, and I think basically all of his work is brilliant, but Illinoise remains his biggest "hit". Hard to pick a favorite track, but John Wayne Gacy Jr. has some of the most fucked up lyrics I've ever heard.