Reviews (page 11 of 13)
Patti is a well respected writer from the mid 70’s.
This album was so good that I don't even care that 2 songs are over 9 minutes. I very much enjoyed it and couldn't even tell that they were that long
Nah. The list is bloated with this kind of nonsense and I get so frustrated by it. "Horses" is poorly written and even more poorly performed. The songs are wandering, overly-wordy, self-indulgent, and often nonsensical. And Patti's performance is so over the top try hard. She actively works to sing poorly because... she thinks it's a cool vibe? Weird for weird's sake is never going to cut it for me. It's not cool. It's just bad. Stop chewing your words and just bloody sing.
Not for me. Don't enjoy vocals that sound really distant and weak, a recording technique or the mic tech of the times?
Bah, no me ha encantado. Un poco igual y gritona sin ritmo.
Very good
100% Classic! This album saved RnR when it was released. It is as historically as important as the 1st Ramones album and just as good (in a completely different way. It takes elements of The Velvet Underground and Bob Dylan and completely updates it to something that is still relevant today.
Rockin’ poetry
What an astounding piece of creative expression. Free, fiery, and avant-garde, this has every justification for it's towering reputation.
I hate how much I love the Warhol/Velvet Underground crew.
Can’t quite pick where I land on this one. Something about her singing voice didn’t resonate for me and the songs are too long imo. However, I love the music and the way her voice goes with the music. I enjoy this sort of bluesey folksy rock and it’s really well executed
I feel like I would have enjoyed this more if it wasn't set to music. I like the punk aesthetic and the poetic quality of the vocals, but the repetitive backing band was tedious.
I didn't expect the rawness and almost punk nature this had, but it was appreciated. However, I just didn't really vibe with this at all. Really didn't care for the two longer spoken word numbers and found them really to be long stories with the background music kinda forgettable. I did like some of the other tracks like Kimberly somewhat.
What a horrible music
I couldn't get into it. But might have been sick.
I want to like Smith more than I do. I just find little to enjoy here - the words are smart but maybe too smart- a case of overthinking at times. And same goes for the music. It’s done well, but perhaps too well to get across any real passion. It doesn’t move me. I guess all the elements are there but they just don’t stick, for me. I find it interesting that this gets mixed into the punk soup of the time - to me this is more about the old rock order of groups like The Doors, given a 70s update. I prefer this to The Doors, but it feels like a step - rather than a Great Leap - forward.
I know I should adore this album. Everyone else seems to. But I find it a little meh. I get the raw energy, but the songs sound half-finished to me. It's not exactly a party floor filler, either. Sorry.
This is one of my first punk rock albums I’ve listened to.There wasn’t a song that I outright hated. Fav redondo beach Least fav Break it up
like if television and a more urban sylvia plath made an album together
Awful. There are no ideas here. It's the same song for 45 minutes. And the song sucks.
Verkar good voice, gloria and horse very good songs but the rest of the songs mayby not so strong.
Patti Smith's debut is impactful, exciting and colorful. From the artwork to Smith's songwriting and style: everything is well-balanced and influential.
Weird.
First couple songs had me not liking the album at all, but the next 4 were fantastic
Album 49 of 1001 Patti Smith - Horses Favorite Track : Redondo Beach Rating : 5 / 5 I love this. Have to give extra points for it being a debut album and the influence it must have had on some to come after. Will be replayed many times.
I didn't know what to expect with this album, I've only heard of Patti Smith's name and that's about it. I liked that the punk-ness of the songs didn't overshadow her voice. It would be really easy for this to be yet another screamy punk album, but it was more singing than anything.
WHERE HAS THIS ABSOLUTE QUEEN BEEN ALL MY LIFE
the best
This is certainly an influential album, both in terms of the punk/new wave records that followed, and also in Patti's vocal style which can be heard in Debbie Harry's singing, among others. That said, I didn't hear much here that was particularly captivating and certainly nothing to match the majestic Because the Night. while the cover of Gloria was different, I didn't feel it was a patch on the original
She seems to do a lot vocally without much skill - in way that might appeal to some people but not to me. Super influential and ahead of her time though.
HEYYY! I used to have this album! It's been ages since I've listened to it. My favorite was Rock n roll Nigger, but of course that is no available on Spotify, found it on YouTube though. Listening to that first. I could have sworn it was on Horses but I guess it was on Easter. I guess my first time hearing her was from the NBK soundtrack! Pure gold that one!
Patti Smith was unlike anyone else at the time. Still is unlike anyone, in many ways. Her songs flowed and rocked , but largely lacked direction. Perhaps she was too forward-thinking, even to this day, but it occasionally feels like the band is jamming around her poetry.
"Gloria" y "Free money" me han gustado, pero lo mismo no era el día porque me he aburrido bastante. Lo siento pero van a ser 2 estrellas aunque lo volveré a escuchar.
pretty happy about this record actually. Def heard Hole/Courtney Love/Liz Phair (even Sleater-Kinney) in here so it's neat to draw a line back to the 'origin' of that. Would def put this back on some time. I didn't LOVE this - it wasn't 100% my 'jam' - her vocal delivery is not super beautiful/moving to me, but I see why it would be to some. 4 stars but barely
This didn't really float my boat.
Some good songs, definitely influenced a lot of bands
I appreciate the direction and novelty of the album, but I found it a bit grating at times.
I like this more every time I hear it.
"Jesus died for somebody sins but not mine" What a way to open.. Gloria is just unreal.. Great album.. Birdland gets a bit long is all. I mean 1975, post punk before punk.
Gloria is a classic and the energy palpable. But I just don’t like her voice. The music is really good and the lyrics are fine. I can even take some of the spoken word, but nope, I just don’t like her vocals. I get why this is on the list though.
It was better then i expected.
I really liked the raw vocals of Smith and enjoyed listening to this album.
I get why it’s influential but it just does not grab me.
With an immortal opening line in the groove and Robert Mapplethorpe on the opposite side of the photograph, Patti Smith made rock and roll her muse, her landscape and her bitch. Cutting an aesthetic that was as much a kick in the door as well as a breath of fresh air, the aspirant 20th Century Rimbaud wound up making an album that can very well be placed amongst the greatest debut albums ever and the greatest albums of all time. What else can be said other than that this is a sublime example of the zeitgeist aligning just right, the moment when poetry and rock and roll coalesced into a mighty diamond shining ever so brightly. If she had never made a musical note after this, no one would have blamed her; for this album places her amongst legends for eternity. So young, so goddamn young.
Very haunting for a punk album particularly with Elegie closing it out. I enjoyed her voice and would like to follow up on more from her.
Call it a 3.49. Gloria, Free Money, and Land are absolutely perfect. The rest... eh.
I Don't like Patti Smith but this is the best album from discography her.
um dos albuns de punk mais livres que eu ja ouvi. ja conhecia mas nunca tinha escutado de verdade. a maneira como as letras evoluem pra ficarem mais fortes conforme a musica avança é muito inteligente. a rebeldia do instrumental é algo que não se vê tanto nos outros albuns de 1975.
I've always liked Patti Smith as a person, author and activist...but her music has never hooked me.
This was very artsy. Which is often code for, I am not really sure if I fully get it. And honestly, I not a big lyrics guy. There are songs that I have heard 100 times that I don't know the lyrics of. My simple brain just pays more attention to the music than the lyrics. This album is lyrics forward and tells a troubled story. I just wasn't able to follow along while doing my work and I hope to be able to go back and listen again being able to focus on the lyrics. All that being said, I can most definitely hear inspiration for music that followed, which is seriously something.
Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine. What a great line. Just from the first song you see where all the female artists from the 90's got their inspiration. It all sounds like musical theater. As a theater guy you figure I would like it more.
Allt í lagi en náði mér ekki við fyrstu hlustun. Áhugaverðar pælingar, vil hlusta aftur
Progressive, great drum production, too avant garde for me.
really not my style, and i didn't really like it
I love Patti Smith
I never got into patti smith. I know I'm supposed to like her. I just don't. I've tried many times. 'break it up' is good.
Meh
This was bit of a rollercoaster for me. Still can't decide if I like it or not but I can totally see how a lot of people were influenced by this record if that's a thing that happened. 2.5 really...
It’s not my first listen and I don’t know if my mood was just exactly right or if I get it now when I didn’t before but I loved it this time. Loved it.
stupendous
Enjoyed this, first ever listen, will be returning to it.
Discazo el de hoy.una grande del rock (LNB) No conocía esa versión del Gloria y me ha gustado, y todo lo demás también (PSP) Muy buen disco (LNM)
Not for me.
It was good but nothing that notable about it. I didn’t like birdland unfortunately. Wouldn’t bring to island with me
Gave me flash backs to Kate Bush but it at least had a couple of songs that were listenable
I hope Patti Smith is in a better place mentally now. This album was a whirlwind.
Importante conhecer o começo da história de quem marcou fortemente o som do punk.
It is a punk rock. It is not that good. I found it annoying. The Gloria cover was bad. I never really got into it.
Highlights: "Elegie," "Redondo Beach," "Break It Up" Depending on how you count it, it's way way ahead of its time. Something about the production as well as the 'minimalism' is the kind of thing that would get anachronistically called post-punk or new wave. The case against that is to look back at Velvet Underground, which also has a lot of that going for it in 1967 -- the dry, ungospelled Warhol Factory vamping. Smith's main "contribution" to that is to take away the cold, understated observational lyricism of Reed and replace it with a rumpus fusion of Captain Beefheart and Yoko Ono. The lyricism has this promising scene-setting and characterization that rapidly degrades over the course of the vamp. Maybe what's good in it mostly owes to the source material, because she's usually cribbing. No wonder critics vaunt this circle-jerk hero worship: one's about Jim Morrison, one's about Hendrix, one's about Burroughs, one's about a book on psychoanalysis. Rimbaud has to keep hearing beatniks use his name to dignify unedited transcripts of LSD-induced free-association. I don't get much out of her saying her baby sister's soul is a network of spittle and glass balls in streams of cold logic that she's waiting for lightning to crack open. I don't think it warrants the degree of repetitive fixation it gets. But she has to do that because that's the generic convention she's set for herself. "Experimentalism" is as much a convention here as any bestselling Serious Novel about a stuffy academic's sordid affair. But if we ask ourselves "what was the Library of Congress thinking inducting this," I think this was the period where po-mo naivete was most justifiable, and Smith is readily able to *account for* and *expound on* her artistic choices, which is all a postmodern artist needs to be taken seriously. Any incoherent or ridiculous idea in a song can be explained away as occupying another point of view or redeeming from the pawnshop of pop culture or simply exploring the limits of language. The question is who's still buying that.
I didn't expect this from the punk and rock tags but I still liked it. Every song was unique and seldom boring. The first lyric in the first track blew me away. The anatomy imagery in Land was also pretty interesting, in a good way. Also cool album cover. Fave track(s): Free Money, Kimberly
Terrible
I heard this once a long time ago and I honestly forgot what it sounded like. I'm glad I got to revisit this, though. It has this singer/songwriter style that's a little artsy, but also kinda punk. It's very unique. It wasn't entirely great for me, but I did enjoy a good chunk of it
Patti Smith is punk as fuck
An epic album, especially considering the time is came out. I'm not sure how much insight I can add that has been said by countless reviewers. A great album that kept returning to
Don't really get it
I like this album, but didn't love it
This was a really great listen. I feel like I need to come back to it again and dig in deeper. It is so different than other things with the punk label(maybe it’s more about a time and a place and less about musical elements or even aesthetics?) . You can also call this art rock or electric folk music- It’s a great album and she’s definitely a totally unique artist. I would’ve loved to see her live @CBGB’s in the 70’s.
Lyrics and songwriting are so great. I love Patti smith as a writer and artist, she’s so cool and so creative. I enjoyed listening to the album but wasn’t really moved by much of the music. I’m usually not super into punk or folk and I feel like this is simultaneously both of those things
There were parts that were really cool. I really appreciate the rawness of this. Love a lot of the lines. Break it up was my favorite.
But know Patti Smith was cool. Part of the hip scene there in the 70s But this album sucks. And it’s not that I don’t appreciate raw sounding music that is not too over produced: in fact I love stuff like that usually. It’s that Smith’s voice is grating. I hate it like I hate Joni Mitchell’s similar bullshit.
Not a real fan of this. But it’s miles better than that George Michael’s album that was on here the other day.
2.5
I've listened to this album so many times and it somehow just never hits for me. like i know it's good, and i want to like it more than i do, it just doesn't hit my brain in the right way or something. sorry patti!
Not bad but not for me
Fav track: Gloria, Redondo beach, Land
I like the album, her voice is nice and it has a punk kind of melody. I like the way she experiments with her lyrics but its hard to understand a bit. I think its cool so many artists were inspired by her, and I feel like I would listen to this album more.
Can tell this is a trailblazing album for female vocals and rock in general. Nothing catchy, lots of deep lyrics. Could be worth a relisten when feeling like following along with the lyrics.
Not bad, would have to see if Patti came before allanis morisette because that’s all I heard in this
left me somewhat cold
It took me awhile to appreciate Patti’s work. Too histrionic to be consumed without the adequate preparation. This is her opus prime; however, my favorite songs are not here. It is a solid work regardless!
This was interesting. It's certainly a creative album, and Smith's got a great voice, which is why I was a little disappointed by how much of the album was closer to spoken word poetry than actual singing. Nevertheless, the album certainly belongs on the list, and I suspect I'll be seeing more of her, which I'm totally okay with.
This is good stuff! It's like punk meets spoken word with hella style. I'll be listening to this again.
Though I'm totally familiar with the contributions Patty Smith has made to rock and roll history, I've never really sat down and given her a listen. I'm sorry for that now. This was great.
Muutama ihan ok mutta monen kappaleen pilasi improvisoidulta kuulloatanut laulu. Birdman erityisesti rasittava
Solid album in MOR 70's style
Would say this is more on the folk rock side, maybe even teasing at some early Ska. A very interesting take on punk music for sure. Patti Smith is joining the National on their upcoming tour which is very curious indeed
Never listened, despite all the accolades. Turns out its ok, just not my lane really
It's clear Smith can write and play interesting guitar parts, but that means little if she can't get her vocals out of the way. I'm all for experimental singer-songwriter approaches to liven things up a bit, but the tricks, gimmicks, and downright annoying vocal mannerisms across this thing just kept me from getting into the flow of the album.
Amazing opening track, the rest of the album is a little inconsistent but it's still very good.
God i love being a bad ass queer bitch
3/5. Okay respect the originality and the straightforwardness of it. In your face yet complex and smart. However, not a listenable album really. Definitely an experience and may be better the more I listen to it. But from the get go, hard to not switch at some points.
There's some songs that are good and more punk-ish like Free Money but then there are those that are extremely barebones and a chore to listen to. I could've died without listening to this album
“Jesus died for somebody’s sins but not mine.” GodDAMN what a way to kick off an album. The opening song continues its quiet crescendo from that line until it explodes into a primal cover of Van Morrison’s “Gloria,” surpassing the energy behind Morrison on his rendition. Through and through, “Horses” is pure punk, beating the Sex Pistols to the punch by a few months. Though the raw sensibilities of Patti and her band are joined with the strangest choice of producer: John Cale of Velvet Underground fame. His production allows Patti to spread her wings more into the artsy-side of music; the result is one of the first art punk records, and its influence cannot be overstated. Even with a little bit of sag on side-B, this is a great album to turn up and scream to, even if it’s not as wild as the Sex Pistols.
I liked three of the songs (Gloria, Redondo Beach, Land) but didn't care for the rest.
This one didn’t do much for me.
Ненавижу хиппи. Что это блин за голос. Леваки ненавидят красоту. И откуда я знаю этот альбом, где каждая песня звучит как предыдущая? I hate made-up voices Это невозможно слушать Когда начинает себя бить в грудь, просыпается желание убивать. Ноль звезд
Favoritas: -Free money -Break It Up
Siento que en partes muy gritado y con poca producción, no me pareció nada del otro mundo
The only people I ever heard praise her to the heavens were rock critics and media friendly musicians, so I was always somewhat skeptical. I was only familiar with her version of a song Springsteen gave her, and a song she collaborated on with R.E.M. on their last album with drummer Bill Berry. Turns out I should have jumped in sooner. This has one of the all-time greatest album opening lines (on a debut, no less. It tells you everything you need to know about the artist and album you're about to listen to), two incredible covers, and a style to that builds in unexpected ways. Patti Smith may always be a bit overrated in my book (she doesn't exactly have a vast body of work, just this album and a handful of follow ups). As great as this album is, I'm not ready to rank it as one of the 100 greatest rock albums, a hill Rolling Stone is apparently willing to die on. But Patti Smith gave us this album, and inspired PJ Harvey and Michael Stipe. So I'm fine with any accolades she receives.
There was a period in my life in the late 90s in college when I listened to this record at least once a day.
Much respect. Just not my thing almost 50 years later.
I love Patti Smith! Happy to see this album on the list :D
i love horses, best of all the animals, i love horses, they're my friends! https://youtu.be/lA13V84zOPI
Pat my cock. The whispering seduction makes me leap out of my leather trousers and into the paddling pool. She can touch my neck hair with her vulva.
A thunderclap of mediocrity
Never listened a full album, it´s however like i expected, solid, raw, passion. And indeed... like a renowned reviewer already mentioned, it´s a bit like PJ :)
Patti Smith made many great albums but this is still her best in every aspect.
The raw sound reminds me of PJ Harvey.
I love this record. In particular I love the version of it that I have which includes the live recording of My Generation with John Cale. I've listened to this album numerous times and the thing that struck me this time around is that, while I truly enjoy this record I never went beyond it with Patti Smith. Sure, I've heard a few other tracks of her's here and there—things that would just be in the culture by her. But while this album is compelling, it did not elicit a curiosity or desire to hear more, different records from her. Was it complete enough in its own right? Does one just need a single Patti Smith record for life and this was mine? Did she draw me into her world in such a satisfying way I needed no more or did she not draw me into her world enough? It seems that I have more questions than answers with Horses.
It is the best album in the world. Poignant.
Had a lot of hopes with the first track. Clear voice, right amount of instruments. Then the next 5 tracks sounded just like track 1... Nothing memorable
Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine.
Didn't mind it the first time but then listen the next day with Patty and I did not enjoy it nearly as much. Little too much talk singing. Definitely a bit experimental. A few of the songs were okay.
Didn't recognize her name, but did recognize the top track! (Gloria). Next track was unremarkable and I had to skip Birdland after 3min. Talking is not singing. So much talk singing. Not really enjoying the rest of this album.
Good groove but I really dislike her style of singing
Hell yeah. Great songs and great vocals. She is another artist I've only heard the hits from and have slept on. I need to dive deeper into her discography.
Vill gilla detta. Vissa låtar låter bra men överlag inte bra tyvärrrrrrr
Screechy. Overrated.
I loved this album, and now understand Patti Smith better
Great album, Patti Smith really on top of her game
Album merits at least four stars for the opener alone
Ne razumem, kaj je tu tako dobrega. Mogoče je preprosto prezahtevna glasba za moj povprečen okus.
what an interesting album. i didn't really have much time to listen to it as it was a busy day, but i managed to squeeze it in at the end of the day while doing my physiotherapy for my fucked up knee. that doesn't really have anything to do with the album though does it. this girl has a fantastic voice. beautiful, especially with the poetic nature of the lyrics as well. i really enjoy this vibe. gotta say though, not ALL of these songs did it for me. it was a it hit or miss - good enough that i think it averages out to a 3/5, which is fine. a bit hard to follow some of these tracks since they don't always get broken up in the way you would expect a song to, they just sort of go on and on and on. i don't hate that! i actually really like the ones that get a bit structurally weird. like the one called "Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de)", which just seems to involve her rattling of lines of a poem for almost 10 minutes while someone pumps a bass underneath it. no fucking clue what it's actually about, i'm sure it's something cool lmao. according to wikipedia this album has 8 tracks, plus one bonus track from a cd reissue, plus an entire additional bonus disk with the same 9 songs but performed live this time. i didn't really have time to listen to the bonus tracks unfortunately, so i guess i'm basing this just off of the original 8 tracks. hope that's not a faux pas of some sort. oh well. fave track here is Break It Up.
This was pretty great! A great punk rock journey with some amazing songs, long but never boring. Favourite: Birdland
3.5/5
I loved this. I think it's absolutely amazing.
I can see some talent here. I bet some of her other albums are amazing. This one... not so much.
Couldn’t finish. Not mine.
She has a great voice, just found her lyricism and general song creation peculiar.
This. This is the Album where the first track caught me off guard, Confused something there. But now its gonna get a better rating than before and thats just as i wanted it.
Fell asleep to it. That doesn't say a lot, or maybe it does. I don't know, she was embracing that punk energy, but didn't feel like she had the chops to back it up. Maybe it was just me being tired, but it didn't hold my interest at all. Next.
Damn. Patti Smith is the male version of Bob Dylan. Forget all this first punk stuff. Yeah, I hear a bit of that, or a bit of precursor to Elvis Costello's sound, but even more I hear the indie sound of Velvet Underground (thanks John Cale?) and wicked lyrics combined with solid but subtle instrumental harmony (i.e., Bob Dylan). I hear PJ Harvey and Courtney Love and countless others that probably owe part of their style and success to Smith's trailblazing. The instrumentation could use some more depth or quality, but her lyrics are second to none. And her delivery is so raw and electric. The album has holes, but Patti Smith is badass.
This album really wasn’t my thing, but I can see how it would have a big impact on the early punk movement. I put this on twice, hoping that it hit me a little more the second time around but no such luck. I kind of liked “Redondo Beach” and “Free Money” so I’ll be generous and give this a 3-star rating since there wasn’t anything I really hated about the record.
Expected to love this and I didn’t
Dogshit, unfortunately
Started well but overall nah
Not good
Some cool songs, others not so cool - 3 stars
I'm sure I've tried to listen to Horses from Patti Smith before, because others have cited this as an influential album. I don't enjoy listening to Smith sing. I might like "Kimberly". It reminded me a little of the Talking Heads, but as if Gordon Gano sang about half of the lyrics. "Horses" was flirting with being "okay" too. I'm not mad that I listened to the album, but I don't want to do it again.
Another classic
Enjoyed. Have forgotten already.
eh. maybe im not in a good mood today?
I listened to a good bit of punk when it was happening and current but somehow I never got to this album. It's a small regret in a lifetime of them but this one's a keeper. Adding it to the collection.
I did not find this that enjoyable to listen to. The songs did not really seem or sound a lot like music to me.
muy buen álbum punk, ni se nota que es de los 70. quiero ser amigo de patti smith
Not a single horse
Quite interesting
67/100: Not a huge fan of this album. It didn't sound all that unique, and definitely won't stick out in my memory. Honestly, I can't even recall any songs that stuck out in my mind. Overall, incredibly forgetful, so much so I think I've already forgotten it. I certainly will not revisit in the future as I likely won't think of this album ever again.
Simply stunning - the drive, the propulsion, the energy. Smith’s evocative lyrics, elusive but absorbing, encourage repeat listening and then music is pulsating the whole along. The inspiration this album provided is extraordinary. Is it punk? It’s too focused for that. Punk breaks things. This inspires and leads.
This was a strange listen. I couldn't tell if this was derivative or ground breakingly original.
Not half as punk as I thought it would be. Some cool moments but mostly not my bag.
A bit too weird for me.
Interesting, weird but emotive. Not life changing but goes somewhere. Has great examples of vocal chord versatility. Solid 3 :)
Patti is an icon but I dont like this album that much
Thought it was quite good, didnt blow my mind though or anything
Patti SMITTTH G L o R i Aa
really enjoyed it - gonna give it another proper listen and hopefully I can change this review after : P
What a solid listen from start to end
ok. Cannot see what is so amazing about this ...
Blah
wow! it's like The Doors in a woman, perhaps because of GLORIA, but lovely. so glad to hear her album, never woulda found it except this site
Who doesn't love a song where they spell out the lyrics for you? R-E-S-P-E-C-T. Didn't care too much for the carribeanesque Redondo Beach. A little bit too far out there for me.
Passionate and raw. A beat poet mixed with punk attitude. Entertaining and snarly. Found this to be really engaging, with good pacing and variety that carried throughout the album.
Punk de arte (sí es un subgénero) que es una clara referencia y origen de artistas como PJ Harvey y Savages además de ser un referente en general de la música. Este disco suena atemporal, pues podría ser de la década de los 80s, 90s o de hace 3 años porque seguro hay alguien haciendo música semejante. Aunque el punk no me encanta, este sí es uno de esos discos que creo que todos deberían de escuchar alguna vez en la vida por toda la música y artistas que de aquí se descuelgan. Aunque la música no me vuelve loco, sí se merece una calificación más alta de lo que le pondría por su importancia histórica, aunque no a todos los discos de esta lista me nazca aplicarles el mismo criterio. 3.5 que sube a 4.
Es un disco adelantado a su época y cuesta trabajo pensar que es un disco debut. Adelantado porque, aunque podría ser catalogado como Punk, seguro en su momento causó conmoción y sigue siendo influencia de qué y cómo suenan hoy las mujeres que quieren hacer algo distinto al Pop. Hasta la portada se ve como algo más nuevo que 1975. Rifadísima la versión de Gloria. Por otro lado, el que sea Punk o innovador no lo hace fácil de masticar. La verdad es que hacia el final se pone tedioso. Con todo, le alcanza para un 3.5 que redondea para arriba.
Independent, rule breaking, punk AF, majestic voice. I get it and love it.
Ok. I really wanted to like this album because it's so influential. But I just don't do well with meandering lyrics and song structures. It makes sense that she toured with Dylan a lot as they both have very poetic styles. I do like her voice, so maybe I'll try a few other albums to see if they have more structure.
What a voice. So raw, authentic, so undeniably evocative of the person in the era. I’ve never listened to this, even though I’ve heard about it a lot.
4th November 2022 Listened in the day while getting the house ready for Surfrisday to come and stay. Loved it, Patti Smith is raw energy and fight and this is epitomised here.
Great album. I love the poetry.
Good blend of genres
I always thought Patti Smith was awesome, but never could find a record I liked much - so much so, that I started dismissing her - until I absent-mindedly drifted to a show of hers - and whoa... her live shows are wonderful - poetry with teeth, powerful music and Patti oozes charisma like no one else - even today. The record still don't capture and bottle that wonderful fleeting moment of watching a Patti Smith show - but now I can see them in context. Obviously Horses is the quintessential Patti Smith album - and once you know that she is a deeply talented poet with a backing band - it all makes sense. And the context in which this album is released and her grip on the rock'n'roll canon is impossible to ignore. This is a great album.
What an album! This review comes from an oftentimes punk hater and a major lyric enthusiast. Patti is clearly the godmother of punk and a genius at combining poetry and punk. That opening track and even opening line is absolutely glorious!! I don't know how but she makes me love punk and as a result love her. What an exciting, spicy, punchy album of twists and turns and well under an hour in length, what's not to love?!
'Gloria' strikes such a chord in me
Well I have to admit I don't know Patti Smith that much and whilst I enjoyed a good section of this, I have to say I didn't some of it. I guess I could see where it was going and the style but it just wasn't all my bag. Maybe it needs a relisten. Soz James don't @ me
Well it's a bloody tour de force isn't it. One of my all time favourite albums. Just phenomenal. Birdland is beautiful, long and excellent. Gloria is just excellent. I love Free Money, always gets me going. What an album.
Nervig.
I’m not really vibing with this album, but certainly has a vibe of its own. I’ve been in a place to really appreciate this, but it’s not right now. A few more plays of this…I feel like it would grow on me.
weird and gay, i liked it
I love this album from the very first line that "Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine". The excitement in this music is still vibrant. The poetry and emotion and raw rock. Free Money and Redondo Beach are favorites but the whole record sparkles and crackles.
I've never heard of this album before not really my kind of thing but i can respect it feels like it could of been made today
It's interesting that Patti Smith was among the first, if not the first person from the New York punk scene to put out a successful album. It's easy to see how her style was influenced by the other bands in the scene, despite the fact that it would be hard to label this album as punk now. It has a really cool stripped down style that compliments her lyrics and vocals well. Having John Cale from the Velvet Underground certainly helps the album, as the production is excellent. The album flies by pretty fast. It doesn't feel like there is any filler in the album. 4/5
how do people actually listen to this hoyl shti
I hear Gwen Stefani meets Lou Reed.
Some great highlights and some below parity.
Very experimental with good energy in places.
-S Tier- Birdland -A Tier- Gloria Free Money -B Tier- Kimberly Break It Up Elegie -C Tier- Redondo Beach Land: Horses AVG SCORE: 3.25 / 5 - - - Patti’s voice is just haunting. Birdland brought me to tears.
Weinerliche Stimme
Great sound. Great lyrically. No criticism.
Somewhat similar album to yesterday's Minutemen record - very original, experimental, but at the same time it doesn't lose any of the value by trying to be over the top. Entertaining release by Patti Smith, who is a very unconventional singer in my opinion and for sure someone that can be very divisive in how she's perceived by others. For me it was 50/50. In some songs, like in opening "Gloria", her voice sounded amazing together with funky/rock work from her band, fast-flowing, very upbeat. But at times, in longer tracks, her voice sounded too mundane and was even irritating, like in the 9 minute composition "Birdland". Instrumental-wise, the album is rather simple, but it works really well with "more complicated" style of Patti. It's a really nice album and I can understand that it was some sort of an innovation, or a setting stone for a new generation of music.
The OG punk poet priestess whips is all into an ecstatic state. May not be a repeat listen, but essential nonetheless.
Somehow I'd never listened to Patti Smith before. I don't know if I'd listen to this again but I did enjoy it. "Gloria" was the standout track for me.
CD
Punk
Patti Smith rules. I had never listened to one of her records before and this just seriously rocks.
The nice thing about this website is that I’m getting an opportunity to listen to albums that have been sitting on my radar for too long. Horses is one of them. I’ve been aware of it for years and it should’ve been right up my alley: I love the 70’s NYC art/punk scene (Television, Richard Hell, Ork Records), The Frogs aped the cover of Horses for “It’s Only Right and Natural”…more than enough reasons for me to have checked this out. Now here I am, 41, wondering why no one sat me down and forced me to listen to this record A Clockwork Orange style. It’s that good. I’ll put it this way, if you were to listen to Horses and Television’s Marquee Moon back to back, you’d automatically be the coolest person in whatever room you walked into afterwards. If you like the NYC art rock scene (Velvet Underground, Sonic Youth, Television) and haven’t heard this record…don’t be like me, go listen now. Horses is one of the rare records on this list that I hadn’t heard and actually needed to hear before I die.
brb listening to a whole bunch more Patti Smith
Fricken badass
Genius version of Gloria. Indeed this is all good and also interesting. Overall I enjoyed it more than I expected too, especially the first and last songs. 3.5 rounding up for the perfection of the album cover art.
This was incredible
Definitely not my thing.
Patti is so damn cool.
Gotta give it up for Patti
I like her vibes and her politics but jesus you can smell the condescending arrogant "I'm cleverer than you" new york art scene of the 70s bullshit dripping off every one of her tracks.
Really boring. Bizzare songs with bizarre lyrics that last forever and feel like they're about nothing. Would be a 1.5 if I could give it that.
Slayed
It was wack
Apparently very good punk rock? I don’t hear it
I can see the influence, and love the crooning. Not so crazy on the poetry.
Listened to it a few times in the past and a relisten today confirmed that this album is not for me. Most songs are too long and however much of a poet Smith is, I just hear moaning.
This is great early punk some really weird song structures
C’est moyen pour etre franc. Precurseur du punk… pascertain. 3
The album is interesting but doesn’t really hold you or make you really pay attention. Nothing inherently memorable.
totally put off by the vocals and not a fan.
Its, soso...1
I can see a lot of modern acts that have been influenced by Patti Smith. With her powerful rock/punk to the punchiness of her spoken word, she is definitely a seminal artist in the punk rock scene, particularly in New York - even beating The Ramones on this release by 5 months. Patti's style has never gone out of fashion, and has set the tone for smart, unbending female rockers of generations since, and undoubtedly will into the future. Best: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo Worst: Elegie
It's great how most of the tracks start quiet and build up, plus there's plenty of punk attitude in the vocals. A decent album that probably needs a few listens to be truly appreciated.
Great proto punk from the Patti meister. Can hear a bit of PJ in there as well as all sorts. Patti has a great way with words and being pissed off both things I enjoy.
Great album, full of punky anger and eloquence
Pleasant
Enjoyed this much more than I thought I would. Giving it a 3.5, but reckon further listens would bump it to a 4/4.5.
Big fan of all of that
bit too spoken word-y for my taste
not my kind of thing
quite liked this album, favourite track: Kimberly
Horse Girl Rock - twisted
Nice early Saturday morning album to accompany a cup of coffee and the latest awful headlines from the frontlines of neo-liberal collapse. A pleasant soundtrack to observing the early stages of an unfolding apocalypse from a relatively safe distance. Punk poetics.
Started the first track and it's pretty cool but my head hurts so much right now I gotta come back to it after painkillers.
I liked the song Gloria - definitely in the rock category
This was good, 3*
Really enjoyed this. a high 3 or low 4. Probably wouldn't be a 4 usually but feeling generous.
Don't like anything on this album.
she slayed on this one
Okay some speak singing stuff and fun guitar stuff. but I am not as into the abstract stuff without really interesting instrumentals.
Not bad by any means but it really didn't impress me much
This was interesting. Not exactly my cup of tea, but also not that far out there for me. I think this is a good album. But other moments had me thinking "I'd be happy to never hear this again". Maybe another listen would do it more justice. But I also wasn't compelled enough to consider another listen for the future.
Straight-up overrated, though the great opening line raised expectations perhaps unfairly. Being ironic about things like "Gloria" and "NIght of a Thousand Dances" really isn't that ironic, much less arch; and if it's a deconstruction exercise, is it worth the time? How this is an advancement on punk is just not clear. Would we feel differently about all this if Mapplethorpe hadn't shot the cover? Passion and commitment only get you so far.
that sucks
Couldnt do it. Her voice killed it for me.
Dark and lively, jivey kind-of-goth. Emotional to bits.
Just didn't interest me.
活力のある女性シンガーという印象。時代の最先端だったんだろうな、と思う。またゆっくり聴いてみたい。
Klassík. Snilldar plata.
Great Album, My first ever 12" single was "Gloria in Excellsis Deo" CW "My Generation" what a great version which I think at least equals Van's original with "Them" and The "Who" version I am sure Townsend was pleased when he heard this revamp. Love it to bits. Absolutely right for this list my favourites the aforementioned "Gloria" "Redondo Beach" and "Break it up"
Patti Smith is a fascinating artist. This album showed her punk and gentle sides, which I thought was cool. The album had a definitive late 80s and 90s vibe.
discazooo also el primero que me toca de una mujer así que perdón si soy biased pero puntitos extra por eso. 8/10
I really want to like this one. Patti is a serious rocker, and a couple of tracks (Gloria) show that off. Nevertheless, most of the material here is simply not for me. I don't understand most of them. Why is Land of 1000 Dances done this way? No idea.
Yeah aight
Bit shit
I rocking little number!
I can see why this sounded fresh at the time, so I'll give it an extra star for that. But this album was a nothing-burger-with-cheese.
I prefer music that is less atonal. It works as it is intended and it makes sense that it is included here. Just not my taste.
Punky Patti has a pretty keen poetic vision that translates loudly and proudly on her debut produced by the great John Cale. I prefer the more structured bits over the long two-chord rambles.
I was excited to finally give this a listen, but ended up respecting it more than really loving it. Somehow it stands apart from the music came before it (despite not really introducing any new sounds), and had a massive influence on what came after (despite not really sounding like what ‘punk’ eventually became). It also very clearly inspired Razorlight - make of that what you will. I like the energy and there are some thrilling moments but also lots of meandering in between. I don’t feel compelled to keep returning to this album. 3 / 3.5 for influence or whatever.
Eh
I love her energy.
You gotta really be ok with Patti Smith's voice to get through the entire album. I prefer it over Janis Joplin, but I can understand a similar criticism. Notable tracks: "Gloria", "Redondo Beach", and "Free Money".
I can hear a lot of bands that came after Patti in this album.
great
Not a fan of Patti Smith
Enjoyable, kinda mellow punk, the live version of my generation can get in the sea but overall enjoyed
The way that Patti sings "Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine" is the best opening line ever. Patti is cool but her music is a tad overrated.
I love Patti smith
What can I say? It's grunge, it's passionate, it's noise, it's sometimes tuneless wailing. At its best it's deep and meaningful, at its worst it makes you think about opening a vein.
Glorious!
Punk's poet laureate, with her savage voice.
the instrumentals are nice
Aliens, sacrilege, stolen money, apocalypse in a major key, drowning sisters, a jet plane, I IV V chord progressions galore, and horses, horses, horses, horses. A masterpiece full stop. This SHOULD have been a late genre Post-Punk great, except for the fact that it predates even the Ramones' first album by half a year, leaving this artistic fever dream of Rock n' Roll ephemera as a crucial cornerstone of all Punk and anything Alt to follow.
Huge overrated and not nearly as powerful, poetic, passionate as it desperately wants to be. It works in moments, but not in any sustained way and it just sounds raw and exhibitionistic and overly emoted now. Who cares enough about "Gloria" to search for the irony or the deconstruction? Same as the imagistic dream of "Horses" morphing into "Land of a Thousand Dances." Its reputation seems vastly overblown all these years on.
I see why it's a classic, but it didn't hold my interest all the way through.
The longer tracks are great.
Meh, didn't do anything for me.
Definitely some interesting and important ideas that are communicated concisely and intelligently but the musical stylings didn’t totally do it for me
there’s something compelling here, but i found it hard to focus on the lyrics and didnt love the production.
Wasn't all that interested in, whiney voice.
Better each listen. Great mix of genres.
I am simply not a fan
Cut like 12 minutes off the runtime and this is at least a 4. Too many of these songs drag on way too long. Even still, a very good record
One of the most influential albums in history. Patti Smith is a poet, and although there's not much relation to the punk sound, her music represents the spirit of everything punk stands for. Immediately in the opening "Gloria", we get one of the strangest covers in history. Starts off with a poem with some truly iconic lines and use of pathos in her word choice. Jesus did not die for her sins: straight away we see how free spirited and expressive she wishes to be. There are references to her androgynous image by the ambiguity of the subject. And of course the only actual part of the song they cover is the "GLORIA" chorus. One of the most influential songs in punk for sure, be whoever you want, express yourself however you want, and fuck society's standards. "Redondo Beach" is a bit of a strange one. A favorite if only because reggae sounds cool. But it's reggae a couple years before Bob Marley made it mainstream, so seeing a reggae song here is out of left field. Ska and punk have a strong relation, and I guess this is where it started. But besides that, reggae music sounds happy, yet this song is about a girl drowing at the beach. "You'll never return to my arms cause you are gone gone" jfc "Birdland" is a disturbing 10-minute poem expressed by a piano, distortion, and her distraught voice, based on Steve Reich's Book of Dreams. "Free Money" starts off soft but immediately becomes the hardest song on the album, displaying her ability to swap between loud and expressive (very punk-like) and melodic and controlled. "Kimberly" is probably my favorite song, a very early example of New Wave with the groovy bassline and uplifting organ. "Break it Up" has Tom Verlaine on the guitar, which is why it sounds like something from Marquee Moon. By far the most chaotic track. John Cale worked in the production, and apparently he wanted strings. I agree with the decision not to, I can't imagine this to be a Paris 1919 copycat. "Land" is a 10-medley that serves as an ode to early rock n roll. I personally think this is the best song in her discography, excellent work on Cale's part between the use of two track vocals and the instruments coming in and out, having a strong garage style. I also enjoyed the solemn nature of the closer "Elegie" and the intense wild nature of the bonus cover "My Generation". Horses embraces itself in its minimalistic instruments, but I consider that to be its greatest weakness. The chord progressions and simple, which ties well with the punk diy model and puts emphasis on Patti's vocals and lyrics, and there's nothing wrong with that, but I wish the simple instrumental they did choose could be more interesting. This is more problematic in the first half. Otherwise, her lyric writing skills rival that of Dylan.
6/28/2022 - ALBUM #152 Today's Album: "Horses" by Patti Smith - This is hailed as a pioneer for it's influence in the history of punk rock music and it's avantgarde approach to songwriting and I have to agree with that report. This album did not impress me upon first listen. The simple chord progressions and eclectic vocals made the first song feel like a strange amalgamation of dramatic country and cracked up Alanis Morrissette. However, once I learned this was produced by The Velvet Underground's John Cale, I took the time to really listen to this album deeply and appreciate the subtle minimalism of this punk album. The way many of these songs start with dramatic and rich piano chords, but build with sailing guitars and melodic bass make each song have this punching impact that is only pushed further by her cracking and whining vocals. The track Birdland demonstrates this very well by telling this extremely strange story of a boy seeing his dead father in the belly of a ship and wanting to crawl inside of it. It's a really long experimental piece that is quite frankly hard to listen to, but it has such this chaotic and impressive build to it. I do think sometimes her vocals don't completely live up to the sound she is going for, but I think that also sometimes adds to the experience. I think the thing with punk rock it I would really like it more if there were absolutely any vocal effects added, but I believe it's part of the genre to have very raw vocals. It's something I really wish I could accept more than I do, but it does take away from many of these tracks that I just have to sort of tune out her singing to really enjoy it. The band is going absolutely insane on many of these tracks and as much as I would try to give that credit to John Cale's production, I think a lot of the fun of this album is found within the songwriting, which is all Smith. I love the soundscapes that Smith builds. though, with the end of Free Money ranking pretty highly in that regard. I like the sailing guitar lines on the track Break it Up as well and some of the percussive hits before the last chorus are captivating. I do think the track Land: Horses... is very impressive, but I also think it goes on just a tad long to be very enjoyable on an attentive listen. It's definitely more of something you put on in the background to observe casually. This album is pretty lucky that My Generation - Live is included on the first disk, because I think it acts as a way more exciting closer than the track Elegie, which kind of just ends the album on more of a shrug. My Generation is an incredibly fun and lively cover of The Who's My Generation and I think it exceeds the original by a lot. It's a great way to end this ultimately mixed punk album. Overall, this was a very good exercise in tolerating some pretty difficult, yet rewarding music. If you have the time to give this album a listen, maybe try to give it a few more spins if you don't immediately like it. It seems very clunky and awkward at first, but by my third listen I really have grown to respect what this album is going for and trying to accomplish. Give this one a listen if you want a challenge. Highlights: Gloria in Excelsis Duo, Redondo Beach, Free Money, My Generation - Live Score: 7/10 A strange and awkward punk album that grew on me over time
1975 - Punk rock; art punk; garage rock
I normally like unique voices but I just can't get into Patti Smith. My third time listening to this album and it still just feels like loud wailing and wavering from a voice that isn't super great to begin with. I get that a lot of people really love her, but it isn't for me unfortunately.
Альбом драйвовый и необычный. Круто звучит.
Ihan semi ok levy ja toisena päivänä olis vaan 2* mutta tällä kertaa taipuu kolmoseen.
Pattitudee, ihan jeekkis levy
Well that's interesting. Previously I've never enjoyed Patti Smith's work, but this time round I like it enough to add to my library. I might even like this a lot now.
Pretty good. I reckon PJ Harvey is a fan!
Not really a fan. I liked a couple of songs though.
One of my favourite albums of all time. It's an easy 5. If the ratings went any higher it'd be a 10.