Horses by Patti Smith

Horses

Patti Smith

3.3
Rating
28590
Votes
1
6%
2
18%
3
32%
4
28%
5
16%
Distribution

Reviews (page 9 of 13)

Very unusual style but there's something that truly captivated me. Her vocals, especially. I'll definitely listen to this again. I might change my rating in the future.

1/16/24. First time diving into Patti Smith, I like her sound. Very interesing lyrics too, poetry driven!

Jesus died for somebody's sins, but not mine.

I think this is pretty great. Hard to pin down the style, but it's creative and cool. It's kind of art rock without being too noisy. It sounds good. It's just a cool expression and it lands. Great debut.

This is like if the Clash wanted to be poets instead of musicians. The first two songs (one of which is a cover) are actually pretty good. The rest of it is spoken word with a crescendo/decrescendo pattern over and over. Birdland just doesn't end. Land: Horses... just goes on and on and on. I'm just not in to it. I cant' give this a 3 because I decidedly did not like it, but it's more of a 2.5 than a 2. I realize this probably influenced a lot of albums and artists that I do like but you can say the same thing about a lot of music that sucks.

This was an easy listen. Really interesting. Kinda punk, kinda classic rock, kinda folk. Someone should tell her songs don't need to be 9 minutes long but other than that enjoyable. Seems ahead of the times for what it is.

I know of Patti Smith and this album, but I’ve never listened to any of Patti Smith’s work before. I know Horses is supposed to be incredibly influential and groundbreaking, so I’ve been looking forward to the chance to review it. Here’s hoping that it will blow my socks off! Well, my socks are still firmly on my feet, but I did enjoy this album. I think Horses did a great job of pushing against the preconceived notions of what punk rock can be, and it was really interesting to listen to. The two longer songs, “Birdland” and “Land,” were really well written, and it was really cool to see longform storytelling be adapted to punk music in this way. Even though the songs were long, I didn’t find them boring. I think Patti Smith’s usage of creating peaks and valleys in the tempo of the music really helped keep these longer songs interesting and engaging. I really loved how “Gloria” built to a really chaotic crescendo towards its end. The backing vocals and Patti’s chants of ‘G-L-O-R-I-A’ were incredibly energetic and one of my favorite parts of the whole album. Patti’s ability to control the energy and tempo was probably her biggest asset on Horses, and she used it well throughout the course of the album. In my opinion, Horses is one of those albums where the sum of the parts works much better than the individual pieces; it would be hard for me to enjoy a lot of these songs without having the context of the sound of the whole album. While I wasn’t blown away by this, I thought that it was really good from an objective standpoint. I don’t know that I’d be quick to return to this album, but I wouldn’t mind checking out more of Patti Smith’s work.

I have to give this a 5 admittedly it's not just for this particular album, it's for the artist. In one word... authentic. You really feel like it's the artist communicating to you. Musically, it's good (nice song writing, some punk-like emotions), lyrics are great, but the combination surpasses both. Also definitely a "must hear" album because of its legacy.

A minor classic. Still rocks !

I have heard of Patti Smith before... pretty strange but einzigartig so far this might be my first 3/10 or 4/10 lmao just not my type of music at 6AM I only listened to 2 songs, sorry, was busy

Quite strange. I wasn’t expecting this punkish vibe or harsh vocal delivery. Not for me.

Bra, fiilis album. Kräver vidare lyssning

Suena como un inicio del female punk qué eventualmente se vuelve blondie. Gran album

Love this album - definitely a good collection of songs :) Gloria being a stand out

Gloria definitely the stand out. Rest is ok.

Wow! You can see why this is always on the list of greatest albums.

The lyrics are awesome. Female-fronted punk music is epic. This is an influential album.

I like this album, eventhough it took 2 listens for me to really get it, and 1 more for me to vaguely enjoy Land. Patti Smith's voice is unique and very punky. Starting your career with "Jesus died for somebody' sin but not mine" is crazy tho. Fun story is that I had to look up if she's into women after that first song, and I was very disappointed to find out she isn't. But dear God, this album cover changed my brain chemistry forever. Fav track: Gloria (I love this one so much), Redondo Beach, Birdland, Break It Up 4/5

Cool, un peu gossant sur les bords, mais correctement punk tout de même

Wow. I have been missing out! I had of course heard of Patti Smith and I guess knew she was someone I should get around to listening to but just never had. This one will be added to the rotation, that's for sure!

Il y a des disques qui sont des photographies. Pas celles qu'on prend avec un appareil, mais celles qui capturent l'âme d'une époque, l'énergie d'une ville, la naissance d'un mouvement. "Horses", le premier album de Patti Smith, est l'une de ces photographies. C'est le cliché en noir et blanc, granuleux et sublime, du New York de 1975 : fauché, crasseux, dangereux, mais vibrant d'une créativité électrique qui allait bientôt mettre le feu au monde sous le nom de "punk rock". Avant "Horses", le rock était encore largement une affaire d'hommes, de guitar heroes et de chanteurs à la virilité plus ou moins affirmée. Et puis Patti est arrivée, ce n'était pas une chanteuse, mais une poétesse. Une artiste chétive à la dégaine androgyne, qui a pris le rock'n'roll par le col et l'a forcé à écouter de la poésie, à lire du Rimbaud. Elle n'a pas demandé la permission, elle a défoncé la porte. Et quelle entrée en matière ! L'album s'ouvre sur les quelques notes de piano de "Gloria", et la voix de Smith, tranchante comme un rasoir, qui déclame : "Jesus died for somebody's sins, but not mine". "Jésus est mort pour les péchés de quelqu'un, mais pas les miens". La messe est dite. En une phrase, elle balaye des décennies de conventions rock et religieuses. Le morceau explose ensuite en une reprise sauvage du standard de Them, transformé en un hymne à la libération sexuelle et spirituelle. C'est ça, la magie de "Horses". C'est un mélange de poésie, de spoken word et d'énergie musicale brute. Produit par le grand John Cale du Velvet Underground – et ce n'est pas un hasard, car on sent ici l'héritage direct du chaos arty du Velvet –, l'album a un son primitif, urgent. C'est le son d'un groupe de garage qui aurait répété dans une bibliothèque. Les thèmes abordés sont crus : le sexe, la religion, la mort, l'aliénation. Patti Smith ne chante pas, elle prêche, elle crache, elle incante. L'album est un voyage et on passe du reggae funèbre de "Redondo Beach", qui raconte une histoire de suicide, à la transe épique de "Land", un morceau en trois parties qui monte, qui monte, jusqu'à une explosion quasi hendrixienne. C'est un disque qui prend des risques, qui n'a pas peur d'être déroutant ou même un peu bancal par moments. Et c'est peut-être là que se situe la petite réserve qui justifie le 4 sur 5. "Horses" est un album d'une importance capitale, un marqueur dans l'histoire du rock. Mais est-ce un album parfait ? Pas tout à fait. Son côté brut et sa structure parfois très libre, où le poème prend le pas sur la chanson, peuvent le rendre un peu ardu. C'est un disque plus cérébral que physique. On l'écoute avec une admiration intellectuelle pour son audace et son intelligence, mais il n'a pas toujours l'efficacité mélodique immédiate d'autres classiques. C'est un album que je respecte plus qu'un album que j'écoute en boucle pour le plaisir. Quand je l'ai découvert, adolescent, bien après sa sortie, il m'a fasciné. C'était la clé pour comprendre d'où venait tout ce que j'aimais dans le post-punk. C'était le chaînon manquant entre le Velvet Underground et Television. Mais je dois avouer qu'il m'a fallu du temps pour l'apprivoiser complètement. Un beau 4 sur 5, c'est la note d'un album majeur, un disque qui a changé les règles du jeu et a ouvert la voie à d'innombrables artistes. C'est le son d'une révolution, capturé à l'état brut. Il n'est peut-être pas parfait sur la forme, mais son esprit, lui, est d'une pureté absolue. Un disque essentiel pour comprendre que le rock'n'roll peut aussi être de la grande littérature.

Wat een raar album weer... Het begint echt lekker, Gloria is vol met energie en een stevige rockplaat, maar Birdland klinkt alsof Patti in paniek raakt, met de muziek er achteraan. Altijd fijn een paniekaanval die is opgenomen en op een album terecht komt! Gelukkig herpakt Patt zich weer met Free Money dat gewoon een lekker nummer is , beetje Blondie achtig? Zelfs een klein beetje Fleetwood Mac dat je er in hoort! FAVO: Gloria, Free Money, Land Horses

Love how this sounds

Still love the opener, plenty of intriguing tracks but never been an album Inreturn to regularly

App not working

This album had great feeling. Patti Smith knew how to evoke emotion with her music.

patti🩵 so good, cant not give 5stars

Must have been pretty forgettable. Here we are 20 hours after listening to it and I don't remember much.

This album's amazing. That's the start of the review. I'm running out of ways to start these things. This is Patti Smith's 1975 debut album Horses. I love it. This is definitely a landmark album in some ways. The fact that an album like this was released in 1975 is astonishing in the best way possible. The sound is excellent. The general feel is consistent, but each song's theming is distinct in a way to make each song stand out. Speaking of which, the writing of these songs is really good. The enjoyable sound is balanced by personal writing about things like growing up poor in the song "Free Money" or her younger sister in the song "Kimberly." The album's opener "Gloria" is just great. The singing is quite good. The progression of the album is perfect. As far as 70s debut albums from art punk acts that got their start at CBGB, I do prefer Television's Marquee Moon just a smidge, but there's no denying that Horses is an amazing first showing and an excellent proto-punk album that really stands out in a list like this. Horses is great. 5/5.

Patti’s class mind, enjoyed returning to this record after a long time away.

Wow I actually really like this, why have I never listened to Patti Smith before?? Land is my favourite.

A stable effort

I've nothing to add. This is a permanent one.

I wasn't too impressed by this album.

Excelente

I like the live version better. Not sure I totally get it but I see how it kickstarted the alt rock of the rest of the 70s

While I like "Because the Night," there isn't a single song on this album that even comes close to it. Not my jam.

I did not care much for this album. I am running out of novel things to say, so I can’t really say anything but that her voice is offputting

I liked the Van Morrison cover, but I’m not really a fan of Patti’s singing style.

I'm a "music-first, lyrics-later" person, and accordingly, I've always had trouble enjoying the most theatrical and conceptual cuts on this album (like "Land" or "Birdland"), whether as background music or even as in more focused listening sessions -- probably because harmonically speaking, the music is very linear, or not very sophisticated when it comes to the chord sequences. After all, the first section of "Land" is basically a rehash of the album's opener, and it's not particularly striking music on paper. Likewise, Patti's voice can be grating if you're not entirely focusing on her lyrics. I've just played it while we were eating as a family tonight. And it was more static in our ears than a provider of an enticing mood for everyone involved. But maybe that's all for the best that this music still sounds inadequate in a bourgeois or "normative" setting decades after it's release. Because when you *do* listen to Patti's words and performance, oh boy, it becomes a one-of-a-kind epic, poetic adventure. Rare are the albums when the difference between the two listening approaches is so telling. And then, as far as the music is only concerned, the one on opener "In Excelsior Deo" (which I mentioned earlier), followed by the iconic cover of Van Morrison's "Gloria", definitely manages to equal the original source of inspiration, which is no small feat. Because as "unoriginal" as this music is, it also displays an energy that sounds like no other one on Earth. And so does the one of "Free Money" or "Break It Up". There, what might sound annoying or even grating on casual listens becomes a mystical experience. Especially Patti Smith's fascinating vocal performance. I mean, the line opening the album says it all, doesn't it? And so do the last moments of eerie closer "Elegie", filled with a sense of dread about the dead that borders on mysticism as well. Here was a new sort of prophetess, and you just can't deny that what Smith attempted to do on this debut was bound to be high art first or never exist at all. So yeah, maybe this record has been a tad bit overrated by the "critics" when it came out. But it's still so distinctive, and such a harbinger of so many great things to come -- mostly for female-fronted rock and punk bands -- that absolutely, it's got to be in this list. And also mine, I guess. 4.5/5 for the purposes of this list of essential albums, rounded up to 5. 9.5/10 for more general purposes (5 + 4.5) Number of albums left to review: around a hundred, as I've gone over the 1000 line and this generator is including albums from all editions of the book Number of albums from the list I find relevant enough to be mandatory listens: 441 (including this one) Albums from the list I *might* include in mine later on: 260 Albums from the list I won't include in mine: 319

I've listened through this album probably 4 times now and I respect it more than I enjoy it. It's basically spoken word poetry with musical backing. It gets an extra star for historical importance and the cover.

medium debut

Vanguard music for it’s time

Was not into it at first but as it went on I appreciated it more. Still not my thing but I totally see the hype.

second best album with a black and white cover that came out in 1975 (may end up regretting this and decide it's third best lol)

Unique, interesting sound, love the poetic lyrics too

Maan i love the 70s

I did not expect to find her singing so insufferable. Stand-out: Break It Up

I think I had preconceived ideas about the talent of Patti Smith as all I knew was the name. But I’m not sure. I quite enjoyed

By all metrics i should love this album. It ticks so many boxes as punky, poetic and honest. The opening track is a classic and i found the rest of the album seemed to be perfectly respectable, but i did a foothold to go from mild appreciation into the heart of the album. Ill be coming back to it when i can to see what ive missed.

I've listened to this before and I'm not quite sure why I haven't listened to it more. The album starts off really strong and doesn't get much weaker after that. Gloria and Land are the stand out tracks, but it's all good.

Strong opener

Such a sensational album, can't believe I'd never heard of it before!

Quite Nice, good guitar lines, made me travel but I wont listen to that everydays

Tell me that someone else can replicate even half of the frantic creative energy that Patti Smith put into this album and I’ll know you’re lying. She wears her influences on her sleeve and outdoes them in the process

A masterpiece of underground rock! Every song builds up to a utopic climax of singing, and guitar. Favorite Track: "Gloria".

Nein. Nichts besonderes.

Was excited for Patti Smith but really was just giving “OIL SPILL OIL SPILL” vibes the whole time

As addictive to listen to as (what I imagine) sticking a needle of heroin into your arm or doing a shot of cocaine is like. Album is banger after banger, Gloria, free money, land and break it up are my favourites. Birdland I’d call the most notable track but it’s not a favourite as of yet. Not a bad song tho 5/5

I’ve tried to like Patty Smith…I know she’s really influential in the punk scene and all that stuff. She just doesn’t do it for me. Some of this was ok, some definitely not.

Horses. Horses. Horses. Horses. The emergence of an important voice. Patti Smith is a human treasure.

Some okay songs

I would give this 3.5 if I could, slightly better than average but not up with some of the 4 stars

the name of the game is attitude. by no musical standpoint would i really consider Horses to be an actual punk record -- the guitars are pretty conventional for their time, the vocals aren't harsh, and the closest thing i'd say it has to a contemporary is Television, who had one song out at the time, and neither Television nor Smith sound like they're inventing what we know to be punk. really, what i think people find punk about Patti Smith is her combining of surrealist, rebellious poetry with an evolution of frat rock -- you can't imagine Them breaking into rants about girls humping parking meters or anyone who covers "Land of a Thousand Dances" slipping into imagery of slitting your own throat, and its this juxtaposition that makes the record such a pioneer in its genre. what is punk if not making the rock of the past utterly hideous? i don't think i'd play any track from "Horses" in the car with my family. good. it's not for the car. it's not for anyone, except maybe animated helium ravens.

Not a fan. Very 'whiney' with her timbre. Instrumentally unimpressed as well. Don't love the spoken word parts. Fav Track: Gloria: In Excelsis Deo

Schöne Stimme, gefällt mir

This was unique and interesting, I’d give it a 3.5 probably. Different is cool

Hmmmm. Either genius or garbage. Her biggest selling song was written by ‘much easier to get a handle on’ Bruce Springsteen. The best track on this is the cover of Them’s Gloria - clearly worked up over hundreds of bar gigs. The other best track is the cover of land of 1000 dances. Which for someone who is supposed to be a songwriter might be an issue. The originals. Ummm. The band is good. It doesn’t help that so much wadical wevolutionary bullshit has been attached to this album. Gag me with a spoon. Zappa gets justifiably criticised for his adolescent attitudes. Yet Patti gets praised. Maybe that’s a strike for feminism. * and also to be fair one can’t blame the artist for what is said about them. On the plus side - a strong woman using her voice in a male dominated industry. On the negative side - I don’t think it’s very good. ‘Jesus died for somebody’s sins/but not mine’. What does that mean? She believes in sin but is not a Christian? She’s a Christian who doesn’t think she’s saved? Or she’s a pretentious blowhard whose depth would struggle to get wet in a small puddle? It is a must hear. If only to understand the so called punk or new wave movement in New York at the time. But once is probably enough. It has a cult following so if that’s you, go to it and continue enjoying it and digging out the nuances and love every tape squeak and breath and all of it. It ain’t me babe. Poets. God save us. * this is not meant to be an anti feminist creed. I try to support feminism as best as my social cultural and political habitus allows.

It's hard to believe that Patti Smith was the first CBGB artist to get a major label deal. 'Horses' is the first proper full-length document of the New York punk scene. In the early 90s I picked up a copy of 'Shots from the Hip', a collection of Charles Shaar Murray's journalism from the 70s, which was pretty influential on some of my musical opinions, even when he was comically wrong. He published a few pieces on the New York punk scene in 1975, including "1975: A scuzz odyssey" (https://archive.org/details/shotsfromhip0000murr/page/124/mode/2up), in which he surveys a bunch of CBGB's bands (Blondie: cute but no star power; Johnny Thunders: might actually be a terrible guitar player, but he's so stoned that nobody can really tell; Talking Heads: Tina Weymouth is awesome; The Ramones: best band on the scene but nobody will ever give them a recording contract). And he totally digs Patti Smith (https://archive.org/details/shotsfromhip0000murr/page/92/mode/2up): "Patti Smith has an aura that'd probably show up under ultraviolet light. She can generate more intensity with a single movement of one hand than most rock performers can produce in an entire set. On the face of it, it's an unlikely act... A lady poet, backed by a band who don't even have a drummer, sounds like an improbable expression for any kind of definitive rock consciousness. But Patti Smith is in the rock and roll marketplace and she knows the ground rules. More important, she knows how it works." This record has a lot of aspects that I really like in rock and roll: it's a dangerous and unpolished performance that could go horribly wrong at any moment, but doesn't (cheers to producer, John Cale, who keeps it just on the right side of disaster). I think it exemplifies the school of 'low technique, high IQ' rock and roll that I really dig. It's smart and visceral, alive and poetic, a bit dangerous, and not fussy or over rehearsed, which was pretty revolutionary at the time. Have other people done it better since? Well, yeah, including Patti herself. Truth be told, I prefer her Easter album (because it's louder). So, really, this is probably a three star album for pure listening experience but I love the doors this album opened for punks, for women, for poets, for musicians with something to say but not a lot of chops. I'm giving it an extra star for that. Post script: Patti Smith's memoir 'Kids' is the best written book by a rock musician ever. It is a beautiful memory of her youth in New York City and relationship with Robert Mapplethorpe. Highly recommended, go read it.

I think it's kind of overrated but I still like it. It's got it's time and it's place.

Starts off slow then gets a bit shouty (x8). Not for me

This is yet another artist that I’d certainly heard of, but hadn’t actually listened to before. If nothing else, I’m thankful to this project because it exposes me to a lot of artists that I should’ve listened to, but have not yet. In any event, I did enjoy this album somewhat, But at times, I’m not crazy about Patti Smith’s vocals. Sometimes they are just a bit too out there for me. But all in all, I found this album to be an enjoyable experience. I’ll give it three stars.

It's alright. Maybe in the right mood I would want to listen to it. But just was never the biggest Patti Smith fan, but that's just my opinion!

There’s a bit of smoke and mirrors at work here. But you can’t deny the energy at work here.

A really good album, so many good songs My favorites were Birdland and Elegie.

Hit or miss throughout. Sometimes it was really annoying.

Classic album and it influenced a lot of artists that came after her. A lot like Velvet Underground it hits fairly empty for me. I enjoyed quite a few songs on here but I don't know if I would listen to this one again. Some of the songs are just too long and may have felt more revolutionary at the time. I would give it five stars based just on influence, but I'm not sure I can do that since it was mostly just "good" for me. This is another album I think those who were directly influenced by it are going to say they liked just because they are supposed to like it.

Started out strong but got a little too artsy for me. She seems cool af though

Love CBGB era music, but Patti Smith ain't it for me. 2/5

Just really plain and boring.

One of the all time greats. Beautiful. Uses voice very creatively, like an instrument. Punk and avant-garde apparently. Some songs are quite theatrical. Very varied album, high re-listenability factor. Every song is different and interesting, twist and turns. Theatrical, surprising.

Interesting combo of lyrics and sound. Not just an artist with a shit backing band. Thoroughly enjoyed, by not sure what situation would warrant a relisten.

Although I’d heard of Patti Smith, I’d never listened to one of her albums and didn’t know what to expect. I’m having a hard time summarizing my thoughts on the album, but it was very interesting and I enjoyed it overall. One to revisit. Favorite: Land

Jesus died for somebody's sins but not mine. I love Patti Smith, especially Redondo Beach

Impactful. Not my favorite overall, but you can hear influences back in time and how she has influenced others.

One of my all time favorites. It’s big and theatrical and crisp as much as it is chaotic and messy. I love it.

This was a decent album, but nothing to get excited about.

“You’re not Dylan Thomas, I’m not Patti Smith. This ain’t the Chelsea Hotel, we’re modern idiots”

Overall I thought this was really good, I'm a fan of Lou Reed and I feel like she was similar to him. I'll go find more Patti Smith to listen to, apparently Because the Night is popular of hers, but not on this album. I liked: Gloria Birdland Free Money Land: Horses/Land of a Thousand Dancse/La Merde Pretty solid 4 star album for me.

Reminded me a lot of Lou Reed. Her voice was generally more pleasant to listen to than Lou Reed, but the album was still an unpleasant listen. I'll give it 2 stars since it's better than Lou Reed's "Transformer" that came up a while ago.

A little raw in terms of production but ten track debut albums should all be this good.

Good fun, and lively. I liked it..

Day285 - real raw rock and roll

"Young Parisians are so French They love Patti Smith ..." And so do I. Thank goodness for the Patti spirit: feedom; expression; poetry. Where would we be without the souls that decide to do their own thing? An album that actually doesn't fit a time, place or thing. So just listen and enjoy the shape of things it moves. A kaleidoscope. I will listen to this more an more.

Literate, original, impassioned, imaginative, intelligent, compelling, beautiful, challenging, brave, rambling, fluid, spontaneous, unabashed, unique, influential. What a great album. Who else was doing anything like this in 1975? I knew I loved 'Because The Night'. I knew I liked 'Gloria' and 'Dancing Barefoot', I knew lots of the artists I love were influenced by her but somehow I'd never heard this before. I had to play it twice, read the lyrics, read about their meaning. In 1975 (for context) punk hadn't kicked off, the most popular poet, and one of the most popular 'entertainers' in England was Pam Ayres. Thankfully people like Patti Smith provide an alternative to all the shite.

Eek. I’m with Sam on this one. I’ll give it points for clearly having a creative spark behind it, and not being soulless, but for the most part this was pretty unlistenable. The song about someone’s Dad passing just didn’t come across as in good taste at all to me, the use of so many strange ways of delivering the vocals really devalued the significance of the story. I won’t listen to this album again, that’s for sure.

It’s not completely unlistenable but I honestly couldn’t name a single thing I liked about this album.

No, this is not for me. My brain just doesn't do 'poetry' and the very intense and very serious and very theatrical spoken word-ish presentation doesn't help. I like songs and melodies. Not endless freakrock work-outs with caterwauling vocals. I am a bit puzzled why this is always classified as punk. Apart from the shout-y vocals, it doesn't really sound that punk. The band just sounds like any sixties or seventies rock band. Maybe a bit wilder than average, but not that much.

Not for me

Groundbreaking

Totally had Patti Smith and Patti Labelle mixed up. This was not what I was expecting in the best possible way! This might be the best find of this project so far (around 400 albums in). 4.9

Gloria (part one: In Excelsis Deo / part two: Gloria (Version) 4 Redondo Beach 3.8 Birdland 3.3 Free Money 3.4 Kimberly 3.2 Break It Up 3.5 Land (part one: Horses / part two: Land of a Thousand Dances / part three: La Mer (de) 3.5 Elegie 3 Score: 3.4625

Don’t like her voice sounds fake and forced

Before I started I felt like I didn't have time for it but I decided to give it a chance. I was so wrong - loved every bit of it - I'm almost annoyed at how good it was.

I mean, it was alright…

I can hear the punk in there, but it isn’t enough for me.

This reminds me of Jack Black making ridiculous sounds in School of Rock, but it’s actually good. 10/10 instant favorite.

I know it’s influential and stuff, but I don’t really enjoy it as much as others. I’ll still give it an extra star, though, because of its influence and uniqueness.

Gloria is a banger, but this is just not for me. I'm not saying it was not important or influential. It's just not for me. Because when you're checking the length of the track list during the third song to see how much longer you have to commit to an album, it's just not a fit.

Very experimental

Not a great background listen. I feel like I couldn't really appreciate this in detail. I will have to revisit while looking at lyrics another time. I can see there's a lot going on underneath the surface and the experimental nature of it makes it difficult to judge based on aesthetics. 3 for now as I wasn't captivated, but I will need to come back to it.

Powerful singing / vocals, I really liked it

Was about to form the opinion that the 70s were a pretty bland decade musically, but this is actually pretty neat.

A very engaging album which feels both polished and raw in a great way. I really like Smith's energy, voice, and odd delivery.

Didn’t think I was a fan of Patti Smith’s voice but I actually quite enjoyed this. An easy listener, and a cool sounding record for its time.

A super diverse album reflecting that music is more than just one style and can be more than the usual stuff you hear in the radio. Like a musical rebellion reflected in Patty's unique and distinctive voice and the lyrics of each song. Definitely not an album you listen to whilst doing the dishes (it's a concept album)but an album you will listen to for a specific emotion. Great and refreshing, and so different towards a lot of music!!!

Interessantdoenerige zingzegmuziek van iemand die zichzelf heel creatief vindt en een jengelbandje om zich heen heeft weten te formeren. Speciaal gemaakt voor mensen die destijds graag ook heel interessant en creatief wilden overkomen.

Krachteloos. Wat doet dit nou weer in de lijst?

Een kruising tussen Velvet Underground en Joni Mitchell. Maar ook Blondie meets All Saints. Man man man, het zit niet mee deze week. Dat gekrijs van Patti is niet om aan te horen. Op zich klinkt de muziek bij de meeste nummers nog wel ok, dus ik zal er een 2 van maken.

Een beetje een vreemde vrouw met saaie liedjes. Nee, het wordt tijd voor een leuk album.

Pretty powerful and a seminal album in the progression of the genre. This is New York underground rock and paved the way for many women performers to come.

Ok I totally slept on this album. Just awesome.

I listened to this once years ago. None of it sounded familiar when I heard it today. I know critics love it, but I found it just OK. Sort of punk, but not quite energetic enough for my taste. Favorite track: Gloria

best album ever

I generally like Patti’s voice. Her lyrics lost me at times because she is more poet than traditional songwriter. It gives her music a different quality more like Bob Dylan. Thankfully she is a better singer than Dylan. I prefer the songs where she doesn’t drone on stanza after stanza for what feels like forever before hitting a musical break or chorus. Gloria is a little tiring to me for that reason and Horses definitely hits me that way. Great playing by the band. I just wish some of the songs were a little shorter or more sparse lyrically.

Nice enough

Just plain sucked, she still tours tho

What does a Horse and Patti have in common...... They both can't sing. How is this one of the top 1001 albums.

Yeah was aight. Cool poetic punk. I bet she got some nice armpit hair

Jim Morrison would probably really dig this The arrangements were quite nice and her voice is very pretty, but American prayer already has my heart.

I'm a few steps behind Andy on this one. Admire it for sure. Not quite with it yet.

I appreciate elements of this album, but can't get past Smith's anguished bleat of a voice. The lyrics are superior, the garage rock backing is energising and there are some genuine moments of sublimity here. But when it doesn't click, Horses has the potential to harrow.

dear Patti, Jesus did die for your sins, and for everyone’s

Teatral pocas canciones pero largas como piropo de tartamudo

“Jesus died for someone’s sins, but not mine”—I mean, god. Out of all the punk to come from the fertile garden of CBGB, no one had quite the poetic bent of Patti Smith.

This I defintiely need to listen to again. Not what I was expecting.

In my opinion, New York has never thrived more from a music point of view than when it was knee deep into the punk era of the 70s. And its underground scene was led by the momentum from the incredible CBGB music club. Patti Smith was one of the glowing stars from that club who ushered in a new level of creativity to rock that hadn’t really been seen yet. It’s unfortunately rare to see such an electric female figure in a scene like punk. But when they hit it right, you get someone as cool as Patti. What an interesting person. It really feels like you learn a lot about who she is just from these 8 songs. Her lyrics are personal, but also incredibly cryptic. So it may not be immediately apparent what she is speaking on. But so much of her personality just emanates from the lyrical content and delivery. I’ll admit, I do find it a little hard to speak on the actual music here. I was listening to it and thinking “What the fuck am I going to write for this?” I can’t really pinpoint what I like and dislike. It was difficult for me to wrap my mind around. But I know that I liked what I heard. Punk has never been my absolute favorite thing. And the roots of it don’t do much for me. Like for example, I think The Stooges are cool. But proto-punk really is just a devolution of something I’m already not big on. What I can get behind is what I’m hearing here. It’s the proto to the kind of punk I actually like. This isn’t at all a conventional punk album. In the same way that Marquee Moon very much wasn’t. Birdland isn’t my favorite song on this record. But it is undoubtedly a stunning performance from all parties involved. That combination of the uncompromising energy of punk with the avant-garde side of rock is what makes this a noteworthy album. Maybe not my favorite record ever, but I can’t take away what all of these beautiful people gave us in that city all those years ago, and everything that it led to. Rating: 7/10

This had a very "overstaying it's welcome" vibe. It wasnt terrible but I found myself starting to proverbially looking at my watch a lot.

Maybe I didn’t give it a fair enough shake, but I really just didn’t enjoy this album.

Great album. Uncomplicated, simple, but also complex and deep. Enjoyed this a lot.

This was pretty good overall, but a little uneven. Will probably try to listen to more of her work.

Patti Smith sounds like a drunk girl at a karaoke bar trying to sing Fleetwood Mac songs.

Another example of where the music is fine but the vocals are unbearable. Like Neil Young.

I’m sorry but I just don’t get what all the hype is about

Not interesting and way too pleased with itself

Enjoyed this will listen to more.

I have heard of Patti Smith before, but I only know one of her songs, which wasn't on here. I won't be listening to any of these songs again. Each song was too long, I could have saved 5 minutes if they were the correct length.

This was just really good. I love how many female artists I’ve discovered doing this who are bloody brilliant.

One of the few albums that I already knew and loved. I listened to Horses after reading Patti Smith’s book Just Kids. Its no surprise that she’s an amazing writer. Her spoken work rock and roll music is unique, badass and truly worthy of her legendary status. Patti deserves all the praise. The fact that she is a genuine and good person is just a cherry on top of an already incredible career. 🤘🏽

Spoken word over mildly interesting guitar and piano.

Didn’t like it at all

Velvet Underground gave birth to a punk child.

Aressting, singular and powerful. Not my thing.

Unbelievably first time listening to this 49 year old album. Good sound.

Jedan od najboljih debija svih vremana

I first listened to Horses about two years ago. Patti had once worked at the Strand Bookstore in New York, and so had I about twenty years after, so I felt some sort of arbitrary necessity to become familiar with her music based on that tenuous connection alone. I remember being really enthralled by the album, with the raw power and poetry, the transcendence of Birdland, the mashup of her own poetry with rock classics, like in Gloria. So, I was excited when this came up as my album of the day. Today, though, I must not have been in a receptive mood. What I’d interpreted as transcendence two years ago felt like forced transcendence this time around. Her voice which I’d found interesting last time, grated on me this time. I still enjoyed getting caught up in the surrealistic sweep of Horses (the song), and I understand this album’s place in punk history, but it’s certainly not an album for all occasions. Must the greatest albums be for every mood? No, of course not. But this one involves a patient mind who’s also ready to rock, and I was neither today. Maybe next listen this will be a five? Right now, it’s a three in my book.

An all time classic. So many owe so much to Patti Smith.

Interesting music for it's time I guess. Kinda reminiscent of the velvet underground. Doesn't do much to distinguish itself for me. Medium 2.

As a Brit, I always have to remember that the American definition of "punk" is far, far different from what I would consider to be punk. We had an anti-intellectual/ anti-establishment, far younger (late teens), rawer approach to this genre. The American scene was made up of older (late 20s) people who made music that was more "edgy" than "raw", often about subject matter that British punks would openly sneer at. Putting that aside, if I just consider this to be "garage rock", then it makes that slight annoyance easier to bear. It's a great album for sure, interesting to listen to, musically diverse, maybe even seminal. I hadn't heard anything from this album before, which is quite a disgrace I suppose. My one reservation here was that I was constantly being reminded of Nick Cave. But where Mr Cave's albums are often overwrought and lack any form of subtlety, this album was far more measured. I don't think I can quite see my way to rate this 5 stars, but it's an extremely strong 4 star album. I will probably grow to regret this decision on future listens, but my opinion today is 4 stars.

Gloria Free Money Kimberly Break It Up Land: Horses/Land of a Thousand Dances/La Mer (de)

Patti Smith’s Horses is a compelling testament to raw emotion and musical authenticity. Despite Patti Smith’s unconventional vocal style, which might not be technically perfect, her expressiveness and engaging lyrics command attention. The band’s performance shines throughout and the walls and signal flows of Electric Lady Studios treat them well. The track “Redondo Beach” stands out with its ska/reggae rhythm, adding a dynamic layer to the album. “Birdland” offers a droning, meditative exploration of a simple idea, emerging as a personal highlight with its introspective storytelling. “Free Money” impresses with its Velvet Underground-meets-Neil Young vibe, driven by a chugging three-chord progression that builds to a crescendo. “Kimberly” showcases a more intricate chord structure and benefits from the subtle addition of organ, giving it a thoughtful, well-crafted feel. Richard Sohl’s piano work on “Elegie” is another album highlight, demonstrating impressive skill and emotional depth. Overall, Horses remains a significant and influential work. While it may not be an album I frequently revisit, it continues to offer a profound listening experience and a valuable place in musical history.

This one was alright, but I did get annoyed with the vocals after a few songs. I liked it better when she straight up sang. Birdland and Elegie were favorites.

The variety on Horses is remarkable. From the New York punk of "Gloria : In Excelsis Deo" to the reggae of "Redondo Beach" to the almost spoken-word building fever of a performance in "Birdland," we see many sides of Patti Smith, and that's just in the first three songs. Like The Doors, the band is able to follow the ebb and flow of the lead singer's performance and match her point for point. A passionate work by all. "Break It Up" is a melodic highlight, and one can imagine the "Land of a Thousand Dances" section of "Land" sowing the seed to grow a future Karen O. This is performance art captured and preserved forever on tape.

Well this was sort of challenging. I know I'm supposed to appreciate this, but did I really enjoy it? There were some songs that I enjoyed more than others, like Free Money. When I followed along to the lyrics, I could appreciate the poetry of them. She's an evocative writer. The band was good. Her energy and spirit was punk, kind of wild and feverish, even if the music didn't have a lot in the way of established punk conventions. I suppose in 1975, punk conventions hadn't been well established yet. I didn't enjoy a lot of her singing, although there were times where I didn't mind it. I've heard other songs from her's that I also didn't mind the singing, so I feel like when she pulls back a bit on the vamping and just sings it straight, it's better for me. All in all, I'm glad I made the time to listen to it, because I know this was groundbreaking for its time, and highly influential, so now I have it as a reference point.

Patti Smith is another singer that I've heard of for years,.but never really listened to. She has an interesting voice but this album didn't really grab me. Redondo Beach had an interesting Blondie type reggae-ish vibe to it. The sound is pretty stripped down, but I think that's one of the reasons it didn't grab me.

Yup. 5 stars just for Gloria but the album keeps going and actually stays great.

A diferencia de otros discos de esta lista, aquí sí puedes escuchar la influencia que repartió hacia el futuro.

I wanted to like this one more

I honestly don't even need to listen to this to review, but I'll gladly listen to it again. Probably the 20th time that I've revisted this album this year. Patti Smith's "Horses" is a raw, poetic masterpiece that transcends genres. Her cover of "Gloria" isn't just the best version, it's a reclamation, a bold statement of female power in a male-dominated rock scene. The album's fusion of spoken word and rock paved the way for proto-punk and cemented Smith's place as a vital influence on generations of musicians, especially women in rock.

I liked it quite much, especially her raspy voice. It must have sounded so bold and different in the mid-1970s.

4☆/5 08.11.2024

Couldn't get into this. Can hear her influence on others, which was cool. But not really a great listen. 2/5

The only memorable thing about this album is her horrid singing style. I read about her and it says shes punk. Usually when something is punk I expect to be more annoyed at the topic at hand than whoever is singing, not that I can even discern what the topic is outside of the title. I dont get the hype.

I'm a little familiar with Patti Smith from her contributions to the likes of Bruce Springsteen and Blue Öyster Cult. She's a singer/songwriter/poet who's considered an influential underground artist, with Horses being her debut album. Listening to this album, Patti's style is more "art punk" than "punk rock" with the added poetry and improvisation. For example, songs like "Gloria" and "Land" are medleys with covers interlaced between free-form compositions and spoken word. They still generally rock but take a more off-the-cuff approach to how they're presented. Other songs tend to experiment with style shifts such as reggae with "Redondo Beach", proto-punk with "Free Money" and "Break it Up", jazz with "Birdland", and the somber requiem closer of "Elegie". Patti's lyrics range from past experiences with family members to dedications to deceased musicians she knew like Jim Morrison and Jimi Hendrix, all well penned. The only aspect of this album holding it back is how bizarre and esoteric it can get at times. It's probably a bit over-ambitious for a debut album. Also, the spoken word could have been integrated better in some tracks. Still, I enjoyed Horses overall and give it a solid recommendation for those curious. Update 1/28/2025: I ended up listening to Horses again after over 200 albums into my journey to see if this album has grown on me. I will say my issues with this album were not well-articulated for the time. To say a debut album was "over-ambitious" does admittedly come off as a backhanded compliment. I was thinking about the song "Birdland" at the time when I was trying to figure out why this album wasn't immediately clicking for me, and now I realize that the challenge is kind of the point. Patti Smith's lyrics are meant to be a challenging listen, where her integration of poetry and musings on sexuality, death, and emotional connections are written in such a mostly abstract manner that still leaves enough breadcrumbs for the listener to follow along if they're paying attention. This sort of close listening is not a habit I usually do when I'm working in the office. If anything, my problem now with Horses is how the instrumentals sound basic for some songs. Again, Patti's words are more the focus without being overwhelming in the mix, but it would be nice for moments such as "Birdland" and "Break It Up" if the rest of the group could match the energy and intensity of her words. Still, this is rather impressive for a debut album from such a prolific singer-songwriter and I'm glad to have revisited it.

These songs were too long and boring for me.

Reminds me of some of the stuff from PJ Harvey. Overall I would say 2.5.

BL: completely blind listen, aware of one track from the Patti Smith Group but never listened to any of her solo work. AL: I liked this. This is absolutely an album experience, I don’t think I’d see myself coming back to many of these tracks on their own, but I will certainly be coming back to this album and dissecting it further. I think it did start to drag a bit by the end, there is only so much spoken word drone rock I can muster. But the overarching story provided compelling and the overall experience would totally be spiritual to hear it blasted out of a venue PA with rising instrumentals. FT: “Gloria”, “Land” 4/5

Thought this was good, but not great until Horses/Land of a thousand dances / Le Mer (de) I love what she's done with it.

I wanted to like this album much more than I actually did. Seemed to go on too long and wore out its welcome. 2.4

I really liked this one but probably wouldn’t revisit very often if ever

I did not like it

Another overrated NY Art Punk act that was far less about punk… or music, or art. Just yuck. I mean, in the 70’s, New York was such a shit hole, inhabited by overmedicated, self-indulgent brats. Give me California hippies any day of the week over these filthy fakes. Otherwise, not a bad effort.

I loved it, it is exactly my vibe. I love love the music and the music and vibe of the lyrics are fenomenal. I really liked it and had so much fun. female rage type thing

I enjoyed this and it was deep and interesting. It seemed more poetry written to music, and not necessarily songs. I would like to listen a few more times and really pull apart the lyrics to get more of the deeper meaning.

I know that Patti Smith is a legend but I've never sunk my ears into her until this project. Glad I did! Expressive, original, creative and poetic songwriting. Especially liked Gloria and Free Money.

This album was pretty great. I love her voice and her energy and the music is cool and creative.

New album for me. Really really enjoyed and saved to favorites.

i don't fully get it but i'm open to listening again. it was a nice experience!

I can only imagine what it was like to listen to this album back in the mid-’70s when it first came out. It was truly one of a kind. I like this album because it has a laid-back feel overall. Despite being laid back, it has a stripped-down, raw energy that gives it a punk aesthetic. I also love the piano, which definitely adds depth to the music.

I really disliked it, the style didn’t interest me at all. It was like bad karaoke.

Patti Smith proves that Punk isn’t about the music, and all about the attitude. The snarling, acerbic intellectualism of the lyrics and music create an atmosphere that’s just as rebellious and anti-authoritarian as bands like the Pistols or the Dead Boys. Plus, and this really shouldn’t be a side note, Horses is just a fantastic collection of songs taking in everything from blistering lead guitar lines, to mournful piano, to funky reggae-inspired bass lines, all paired with Smith’s poetry. It’s a pretty unforgettable experience, and I really don’t listen to it enough

Classic! 5 stars Favorite track: Birdland (jazzy number in a punk album) other picks: Gloria, kimberly, land

A classic

how i wish how i wish you wouldnt miss me

It's an okay album. I didn't hate it, but I wish there was more nuance and diversity of sounds. It felt like she was following a similar formula with most of the songs here. The instrumentation was good, and the lyrical content was vast. Although her voice is a bit wild, it adds uniqueness and personality to the album. Best - Gloria: In Excelsis Deo, Redondo Beach, and Land: Horses / Land of a Thousand Dances / La Mer(de) Worst - Kimberly and Break It Up 3.00-3.25/5

Pazzesca

Good foundation for the great PJ Harvey, but not my bag. Not a fan of the voice

I don’t get the appeal

70’s rock

When I resumed my vinyl collection, one of the first ones I got was “Horses”. Impeccable. Raw. Timeless.

Enjoyed this but not huge.

This is the moment in time when we start to see punk morph into something more serious. Though aligning with the CBGB movement, Smith is really in the same vein as Bruce Springsteen or Jim Morrison - a rock and roll poet. Lyrically, she is like the new wave artists (think Television and Talking Heads) who were artists first and, hence, whose lyrics were about more than cars, girls, and not giving a damn. Musically, however, she has all the rough edges and sonic boom of the punks. Her next two albums, Radio Ethiopia and Easter are more accessible and, arguably, better. Horses, however, is the first time punk dared take itself seriously.

I love Patti and I respect her art so much. I truly admire her, to the point that Just Kids is one of my very favourite books of all-time. But to be honest, I think I'm more drawn to what Patti represents as a cultural figure than what she has done musically. Sometimes it's great, other times not so much. All of her albums are worth it for a few good songs and Horses even has some iconic ones, but all in all I am more inclined to read her than to listen to her.

I had a good time, but I already forgot most of the songs. Good stuff nonetheless.

That's undoubtedly a classic that deserves its place on this list. However, I have a hard time getting into Patti Smith's music. I love her attitude and delivery, but the music isn't doing anything to me.

Interesting, but not amazing. Reminiscent of Siouxsie and the Banshees - she must have been a big influence on them.

"Anyone see the old hippie banging on a tambourine last night? Horses, horses ... horseshit" Johnny Rotten

She is pretty badass, but her music really isn’t for me.

Hell yeah dude, this goes hard. It's so raw and punchy yet also feels like there is so much musical depth to it, I love when punk music does that.

Love her bad voice

Começo do punk! Mas n gostei!

The storytelling on this album was excellent, which is probably one of the main reasons people love Patti Smith. The style reminds me of Bob Dylan but more punk inspired. I thought the vocals were mixed loud at times and some parts I found annoying. I do think that she definitely brings the passion and the energy that sells her storytelling. The fact that this is her debut album is crazy to me. Great record, but not for me.

She’s so cool, this album rocks

This will be a lame review because I heard the album 2-3 days ago so I don't remember it that well. On the whole it was fine but didn't grab me especially.

Glad I listened to this, even though it felt too spoken word to really be my thing. And I appreciate the through line to other artists I appreciate, like PJ Harvey.

interesting minimalistic album. Enjoyed the edginess of it.

I appreciate and respect Patti Smith but this album does not appeal to me at all.

Is this the same sort of 5-star album like "Thriller"? Absolutely not. This is more a cultural change put to tape. I don't put this on so I can dance around the room ("Thriller") or rock out ("Marquee Moon"), but instead to peer into a moment in time when music somehow changed--I listen to it to seek that one thing where it all pivots. I haven't found it yet in this album, but I know it's here. Punk was born in this album, but maybe it just sounds like so much 1970s singer-songwriter stuff that came out around 1975 to some people (maybe even worse). But Patti Smith's authenticity and earnestness as a poet combines with New York musical grit on this debut. This is an OG punk and her band shoving off from shore and trying anything, as long as it's real.

i like her energy and her style is certainly unique but unfortunately i think her songwriting is mediocre. 6/10

Listen, I get it. She's a punk icon and a poet, changed the world for so many young people. Doesn't mean I need to like her songs though.

While not personally a fan of Patti Smiths vocals I can understand this albums place in history as a revered album. On paper this album should be right up my street but there just wasn't much, in my opinion, that grabbed my attention and held it for longer than a few seconds. Patti Smith is undeniably a great lyricist but sonically this album didn't really do it for me and overall felt like it dragged on a bit and teased you with a potential musical break but never really delivered sadly.

Not for me.

Went much harder than I had anticipated.

A bit country but not bad.

She's so cool. Her band is amazing. I really appreciate this, but I'm probably not going to grab it for a casual listen. I don't have much of a penchant for the dark, goth-y punk sound.

- i cannot stand her voice i’m sorry

SNOOZEFEST

mun betra en mig grunaði.

It's clever and controversial and raw. All the things I usually love. But I've always intellectually loved this album, but been emotionally cool on it

Because the Night!

I had a hard time getting through it, but managed. I can sort of see how it might appeal to a certain group of people, but not enough to see how it would show up on a list of albums one must listen to before they die...

It's not really my thing, but I appreciate the musicality and historical importance of Horses. Having said that, it's really not my thing.

I hadn't heard any of these songs before, but I quite like them! It's a bit strange and the lyrics paint some interesting pictures. The overall package is fairly enchanting. Favorite track: "Birdland."

Had a great time with this! I’ve known of Patti Smith for years but have never listened to her before. I’ll need to remedy that as this is mostly my jam. Two or three songs go on for too long. But half of this album is a complete banger. 4/5

Energetic music, but not really a fan of Patti's voice

A bit boring

Had some nice moments

Discontinuity between raw punk lyrics and various folk, pop, rock melodies.

I have read that Patti Smith inspired many, but this one was a bit of a slog.

This album is absolutely incredible. Not only that Patti is one of the greatest landscape creators in rock and roll history, and not only one of the best writers, she is also a captivating performer. The band is absolutely killing it as well. But above all the great things I've just said, the most important part is the emotional level. This album touches the heart like no other.

Not too bad after all these years

Good stuff, Patti. Good stuff

Very strong, this is the female version of Bob Dylan / Velvet Underground 4.3

Surprised. Celeste would love it

I'm having to skip most songs

Cool concept and it’s definitely raw. Not sure I love her voice for some reason.

Pattismith is ahead of her time, her music is unique and provocative and outspoken.

It’s simple: you mention horses, I’m IN

I thought she was a knock off of the Talking Heads, but turns out they’re a knock off of her

I forgot how wild this album is. It’s hard for me to make out Patti’s lyrics on most songs, but I’m assuming she’s casting spells and hexes. And it’s great.

Absolutely one of the coolest albums out there. Not perfect, but pretty damn great.

This album wouldn't work with anyone else. Patti is just full of energy and charisma and passion on here and it works perfectly. Could write a million words about every song on here, the blueprint for punk before the Ramones or Sex Pistols came along.

A pretty stunning mix of rock n roll, punk and new wave. It’s a blend that doesn’t sound quite like anyone else. Patti Smith is a bold, wild performer. The production captures a raw, live feel. Looking at the credits, John Cale from The Velvet Underground produced the album. I can hear their influence on the music. Patti Smith’s style of rock is untamed and experimental in a way that reminds me of The Velvet Underground.

Soft, smokey, cool sound right to start, and great first lyrics. I've never listened to Patti Smith but she's been in the pop media world right now. I don't know the details but something about some wildly popular pop star saying that she loves Patti Smith and then Taylor Swift comes out with a record and name drops Patti Smith, in some kind of crazy cult fan base speculative antagonistic way towards the other pop star? I don't care to know the details but I know there's drama going on and I wonder if Patti Smith would have humored that mindless bs back in her day? Just by hearing her sound I can tell she has a cool devil-may-care attitude; one that wouldn't give a damn about the trivialities of today's pop music drama. There's something about her delivery that makes it hard for me to connect with and really understand unless I'm very actively listening. It's almost like some of the songs have music that is repetitive and laid back ("Redondo Beach", "Birdland"), but her vocals don't necessarily match that and are more in-your-face and edgy. It's not a bad thing, but something I noticed.

Honestly, this album started off pretty bland, but Free Money onward was a revelation. Patti Smith channeled the Velvet Underground on songs like Kimberly and then amped up the ante with her own style on Land... and Elegie. While it starts slow, it ends hot. Best Songs: Free Money, Land..., Elegie Worst Songs: Redondo Beach

Shes so cool

Not for me. It is too incohesive and too meandering regarding lyrics and music. No one star because of Gloria.

Mér finnst ekkert mikið til Patti Smith koma. Hún er allt í lagi en mér finnst alltaf talað um hana eins og hún sé í guðatölu. Þetta var allt í lagi albúm sem ég gæti hlustað á aftur en ég mun líklegast alltaf velja mér sjálfur eitthvað annað til að hlusta á af því að ég mun gleyma Patti og þessari plötu.

It’s a good album, and an iconic sleeve. Some great tracks but I feel the album got a bigger reputation than it deserves.

Just the female bob dylan? Music is alright but could not listen to the singing

I don't have too much to say. But this is a one of a kind record. It had a significant impact on me as a young kid discovery punk. Really opened my eyes to what being punk could really mean. One of the best album covers.

Agree fully with Charlie on this. SUPER fucking unique. I’ve never heard anyone go this direction before, other than maybe someone like Rickie Lee Jones, and even then, not this far and this much insane energy. Kind of iconic. A lot to digest here! I saw her play last summer, got this INSTANT regret that I was unfamiliar with her music as I IMMEDIATELY knew that I would be kicking myself, years later, that I enjoyed the show with far less context than I should be having. So it is! Wish to death that I had heard this beforehand. Musically really all over the map. Sometimes kind of intimate and beautiful, other times raucous and intense and very indulgent but in a way that doesn’t alienate you, just mystifying. She has a power over me when she delivers some of these lines. A missing puzzle piece artist for me if there ever was one! 1975 was a good year. There’s nothing really exactly like this, as intense and wordy and unapologetically Lou Reed-esque beat poetry but also aggressive and bluesy and fun. I’m gonna have to listen to this way more to get under the skin of the lyrics, but it was a WOW for me. Hedging my bets here that it’ll be a 5/5

Gear: Meze 109 PRO Album-Art: da habe ich mir doch glatt keck die Ärmel meines Business-Hemds hochgekrempelt - ich alter Rebell *tihi* Mix: klingt wie Caro-Kaffee bei der Oma Musik: pseudo-intellektuelle und -rebellische Lyrics mit uninspirierter Instrumentierung zünden so gar nicht bei mir Wertung: 🧷(🧷)/5

Patti Smith as a NYC icon is much more interesting than Patti Smith as a recording artist

Refreshingly ambitious, while a little unpolished. Regardless, he punk-style belting is a fun mix with the light accompaniment of instruments. Stripped to bear essentials, this is a powerful expression. Worth a revisit.

"Horses" is the debut studio album by American musician Patti Smith. The musical genres listed are punk rock, art punk and garage rock. That's about right; I don't know if it neatly fits into a single genre though. The music on this album is known for its simple chord progressions and propensity for improvisation. The lyrics are personal often intermixed with imagery and dreams. Patti is the vocalist with Jay Dee Daugherty on drums, Lenny Kaye on guitar, Ivan Kral on bass and Richard Sohl on piano. The album was produced by John Cale. Commercially, the album hit #47 in the US. It was widely acclaimed and, in 2009, it was put into the National Recording Registry by the Library of Congress for its artistc significance. The album's opens with the two part "Gloria." Piano and Patti's famous statement that "Jesus died for someone's sins but not mine." The first part "In Excelsis Deo" starts slowly and builds intensity. They eventually are rocking out and a go into version of Them's "Gloria." Maybe, her biggest song. The band moves in a jazzy way in "Birdland." Piano and a jazzy guitar which gets rockin with a wah-wah style at the end. The song tells the story of Peter who's at his Dad's funeral and imagines getting carry away at the end by a UFO with his Dad as the pilot. "Free Money" is worth mentiong since it is the album's most rockin' song and another interesting story as Patti tells of growing up in a poor family and her Mother dreaming of winning the lottery. "Kimberly" opens the second side. Bass, drums and a droning keyboard sounding very much like Suicide. The lyrics describe Patti's younger sister visiting Jim Morrison's grave and dreaming of a winged Morrison trying to break free. The album ends with the stark "Elegie." It's a tribute to Jimi Hendrix. An appropriate echoing guitar. Patti has a distinct style singing, talking, and rapping and being edgy and emotional. Most of the songs tell stories with most being in a dreamy state. Patti's poetic voice and lyrics are the focus of the songs with the music following. In most cases Patti's voice and music build to the end. This is a great album, worthy of all its accolades.

Pure punk brilliance. Favorite track: Break It Up

This list continues to convince me that I don’t like punk music ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I've had high hopes for this album, and I'll be honest, I'm not totally sure why. Perhaps because I like the album cover, or the outfit Patti Smith is wearing, but I hardly knew anything about the music itself. So, going in and realizing it wasn't totally my cup of tea did hurt a little, as I really wanted to like this, but it never really grabbed me, save for a manic display of songwriting power here and there. It is good though, I can recognize that, it really does feel like "stream of consciousness" the album, and that can be a blessing, and a curse. However, as someone who generally fails to get passed the intial barrier of entry for proto-punk, you can do a lot worse than this.

As punk as slam poetry [read: not very punk]. A younger version of me may have been more convinced by this, but sometimes, an album comes into your life too late. My frontal lobe is too developed to fall for this, although there's moment that I do understand her role and her importance, and I can't help but bob my head, especially "Gloria" in its second half. Mostly, though, this album is a chore. Ironic, because on the surface, a punk queen who claims she's "beyond gender" would be my style, and maybe with time, it'll grow on me. But for now, smack dab in the middle for me.

Yo, this goes way hard. I've been sleeping on Patti. 4 boys sipping tea in the hallway out of 5 ☕☕☕☕

The title song was the only decent song on the album. Rest of them were painful to listen to.

I'm the person I am today because of this record.

Those who say this isn’t punk have a very narrow view of punk. Part poetry part coffee shop part shouting in the street. Patti’s pretty cool. Songs added to Spotify: 2

Definitely important, you can here the influences on rock music for the next 30 years. Amazing voice/emotion/power. A little too experimental for my taste. Glad she made it, I am unlikely to choose to listen to it.

Listened to the first song and it is a no for me

I like Patti Smith’s voice, and the overall sound, but I don’t actually like a lot of the songs individually.

Loves it. Raw and didn’t seem to have a lot of production. Gloria was a great intro to set the mood

Great listen but i've never really come back to this album over the years. can't imagine this changing any time soon either

What an interesting album. I'm not sure I'd say I love it, but I respect the heck out of what I just listened to. It's pretty all over the place both lyrically and musically, but it's incredibly well-done. It's not something that'll go into my regular listen rotation, but I'm glad I got to listen through it. It was a pretty unique experience.

Pretty good.

There are some points of the album when i wanted to stop listening. I know she get a lot of props for this album. Maybe at the time it was influential but…Not a fan.

Different.

Ms. Patti is an acquired taste, to be sure. It is easy to get turned off by her singing style. It’s certainly not intended to be easy. Ultimately, she sings with raw emotion; whining, raging, growling, snarling, and howling. Her voice can be as abrasive as the squealing guitar that often accompanies her. Her voice feels like tasting something bitter. First few times, it’s terrible. But after a while, you kinda love it. For as off-putting as she can get, her style and sound were liberating for young girls everywhere. Somewhere on YouTube there’s a video of Patti performing and talking to an audience of high school girls, from back when this album was released. It’s interesting to see how they responded to her and how tender she was with them. Anyway, this one is important, whether you like it or not.

Not for me