Metallica by Metallica

Metallica

Metallica

3.76
Rating
30829
Votes
1
3%
2
9%
3
24%
4
35%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 5 of 16)

Great album!

Metallica just doesn’t hit for me as much as other metal/metal adjacent bands of their time. I don’t like their singer that much at all and their power cords sound almost generic (although this may be the Seinfeld effect). They just seem like the background music/target album/EA video game soundtrack choice from thrash metal — the most accessible but least special

I have listened to 'Enter Sandman' and 'Nothing Else Matters' a lot in the past, so situating them within the album as a whole was interesting. 'Enter Sandman' is such a brilliant opening track - naming it as brilliant doesn't suffice for the way it propels the album forward and bursts onto the scene. 'Nothing Else Matters' is AMAZING. STUNNING. NO NOTES. For me, however, this meant the rest of the album blended into one. My prior experience with both of these songs meant they outshined the other tracks upon listening to the album as a whole. Maybe if I listen again this might not be the cause as, don't get me wrong, I really enjoyed listening to the album, discovering its overall sound, and delving into the journey it takes you on. It's just that all I was left with was 'Enter Sandman' and 'Nothing Else Matters' (I guess they are popular for a reason!), leaving the rest to fall to the back of my mind. Rating: 3.5

Before listening to this album, I did have high expectations as to the quality and energy of the music production. And honestly Enter Sandman was an amazing start to the album. That thrashy yet deeply emotive vibe of the song was so different and unique, and I was hoping to feel something different with their music. Later songs, like Holier than Thou, had impactful lyrics which also brought a new sentiment to the album, as well as the constant discussion of religion. But the music in a lot of the songs had similar vibe - I think if I heard it individually, I would’ve appreciated it more.

This still hits like I first listened to it as a kid. Some gems hard and soft. And some of those guitar solos 🔥🔥🔥 11 year old me is digging it

Well damn. Obviously a classic with having heard just about every track. Had no idea the album STARTED with enter sandman. What an intro, can only imagine metal heads listening to this on release. They’re the masters of putting together simplicity and making it sound heavy and hard. Sad but true is a strong follow up to sandman, holier than though a little faster and heavier, feels much more like classic baby thrash metal, most like their earlier stuff. Classic vocals. Loved the outro, bass going ham into a heavy riff. Unforgiven is such a cool slow down. An epic piece. Wherever I may roam takes its time building speed back up, then we’re back heavy. Bass drum, snare, repeat. Don’t tread on me goes a little pantera, but falls short. Through the never is more penetrating and marauding, good enough for your first mosh pit I’d imagine. Nothing else matters.. ballad, and really a beautiful song. Ups and downs, a gentle ride, feels like a passage through time in a way. Melancholy, reflective, feels like a lullaby. even though idk what the lyrics are saying. Of wolf and men, does NOT warm you back up slowly. Heavy intro, another shout out to earlier Metallica with more modern vocals. Not a great song imo. God that failed, cool intro but then feels like the most generic Metallica song you could come up with. Bass, snare, bass, snare. My friend of misery started out with so much promise, but then a little boring, vocals not doing it for me either. Went on waaaay too long as well. Album closes out with a little speed again after an awkward little marching bang intro. Man this album really is buoyed by a few bangers for me, 3.75/5.

I could do without The Unforgiven but every single other song is so good. I love them.

With some of these albums I wonder if my rating would be different if I was hearing it for the first time and didn’t have such a nostalgic connection to it.

Not necessarily a genre I completely embrace, but some massive riffs and excellent playing. Probably wouldn’t revisit, except for Enter Sandman, but don’t hate it either.

I don't normally like heavy thrash metal, normally it's not melodic enough for me. This however is great, absolutely love "Enter The Sandman" and "The Unforgiven". This could be a 5 for me, but I'll settle with 4, as I'm not a100% sure.

Metallica for the masses. Great Album, but not as good as the ones before. Fav: Wherever I may roam

Nah not again. The guitar tone is the same on every song and it just doesn't do it for me.

Amazing album. OG Metallica fans like to complain that this is where they went commercial, and that may be true, but this album is still amazing.

Es un álbum interesante pero no llega a conectar del todo

10/10 me moldeo como persona a los 15

Ich war nie Metallica-Fan hab mich aber für RaR 2012 damals intensiv mit dem Album befasst. Hatte irgendwie in Erinnerung, dass es hinten raus ein paar Längen hat und hatte von Anfang an die 4 vor Augen.. aber ganz ehrlich, das ist von hinten bis vorne einfach ein starkes Album. Kann man nicht meckern.

Meilenstein und von Anfang bis Ende grandios. Schon krass, dass es das fünfte und zu dem Zeitpunkt vielleicht sogar (geteilt) schwächste Album ist - es sich aber trotzdem um einen absoluten All-Timer handelt.

Hab kurz überlegt, ob ich auf die 4 gehen soll, weil die Thrash-Phase davor mir insgesamt doch besser gefällt, aber abgesehen von "My Friend of Misery", das abgesehen von schönen Gitarrensoli am Ende nichts mit mir macht, sind hier eigentlich auch nur Banger am Start. Die springen einen abseits der großen Klassiker - von denen es hier ja auch dutzende gibt - zwar nicht so direkt an, aber wachsen einem mit den Jahren doch ans Herz. War auch schön damals am Ring, das Album in Gänze zu hören.

Für mich ein glasklarer Fall von: All Killer, No Filler. Von Anfang an bis zum Ende quasi nur Hits. Natürlich irgendwo auch overplayed, aber dafür nicht grundlos! War damals neben AJFA mein erstes Metallica Album, dass ich mir mit 14 gekauft habe. Absoluter Meilenstein einfach!

Was für ein Meilenstein, den ich auch nie genug würdige. Gilt auch für My friend of misery - völlig unterbewertet. Jason Newsted wird wieder mal nicht zuteil, was er hier auch beiträgt. Unterm Strich das Ding, das Metallica nochmal richtig in den Mainstream gedrückt hat und Metal richtig salonfähig.

Ich würde auch eigentlich 4 rechtfertigen können, da auch viel Leerlauf vorhanden ist. Aber angeseichts der Stärke der übrigen Songs (und damit meine ich nicht ausschließlich die, die alle kennen) kann ich das nicht rechtfertigen.

Das mMn beste Metallica Album, was zwar eine sehr mainstreaminge Meinung ist aber ich bin ja auch ein sehr mainstreamiger Metallica Hörer. Was mich bbeim Hören allerdings gestört hat ist die wirklich große Menge an sehr langsamen Songs. Das hat mich immer etwas auf die Uhr schauen lassen, was kein gutes Zeichen ist.

I personally prefer the raw thrash of the early albums, but this is probably their tightest and best produced album

Enter Sandman

I've never been much of a metal guy but this rocks. Only a 4 cause I feel like the end isn't as strong

Not really something I'd come back to because it's not really a genre I vibe with. But I appreciate the artistry and craft.

Unforgiven and enter sandman are good, not loving the rest unfortunately apologies to the fans. Solid but likely wont come back to it a ton.

About what I expected. Nothing on here I would ever want to hear again, but not absolutely horrible. Just not my cup of tea.

I have never taken speed

3/5. “The black album” is the moment where Metallica went from being big for a metal band to being one of the biggest acts on earth. If you’ve ever tuned into rock radio post 1990, you likely have this albums singles burned into your mind. And with the first leg of the album, it’s easy to see how it was such a huge success. But as the tracklist goes on there is a number of lesser tracks in my opinion such as “don’t tread on me.” And just being blunt I vastly prefer thrash Metallica and the radio overplay of this albums singles has worn them down for me (even if that’s not the fault of the songs.)

This is album that brought metal mainstream. Whatever your opinion of the culture it engendered, musically, the album is outstanding. Influence 5. Hits 5. Quality 5. Intangibles 5. Not even my favorite Metallica album, but it's a really good one 3.

Stupid kids banging on guitars pretending they are 14 again. Fuck off. Wankers.

An accidental experiment has been done on the state of Metallicas catalog today. I accidentally told Emma to play the album “And Justice For All” instead of this self titled album. Something interesting occurred. So here are my thoughts on And Justice For All: “It’s no Master of Puppets” - me, and probably most other people. While this album is no slouch, I just don’t think it holds a torch to its predecessor. There are some moments worth listening for here, like the really chunky, slower “Harvester or Sorrow” which slows down its powerchord formula to a pace that makes you feel the thump of the drums and guitars. Then the obvious highlight on here is “One” which is truly among the best metal songs you’ll ever hear, if not the singular best. Metal will never be my in my powerhouse, but I can still appreciate this album in the same way I appreciated MoP: incredibly clean production and composition that stands the test of time, an instantly recognizable sound, and solid storytelling/imagery. Sadly, a point down for this being too similar to MoP. Now here’s my review for THIS actual self-titled album, in direct comparison to MoP: It’s mostly the same. Self-titled has a bit more variety and well-roundedness, but I am left with the same feeling of power chord wall of sound fatigue by the end. “Enter Sandman” is this albums “One”, though I fear One is not only better, but placed at a more refreshing place in its respective albums tracklisting. Or Self-titled felt like a slow devolution after the peak of Enter Sandman. I wince a bit at the potential group of guys that took “Dont Tread On Me” as their personal anthem. “Nothing Else Matters” proves that Metallica’s only other note to hit is the solemn plucked guitar melody-turned-anthem. And again, with the knowledge of the song “One” out there existing in the universe as a superior song, it just feels a little too according-to-script. I am left with but one logical conclusion to this experiment: Metallica is best enjoyed as a vibe, as an attitude. Need a hyper-masculine soundtrack to push day at the gym? Need motivation to drink 6 beers in under an hour? Need to strikeout the side to close out an AL East rivalry game? This is it. I hope this is the last Metallica album, and variation on their delta listed sound can be left for the heads. MoP got a respectful 2/5, so will this album

Stellenweise sowas von stark, aber wie JEDES ihrer Alben seit diesem: zu lang.

The production is super polished and the mix is crystal clear but it honestly gets a bit repetitive after a while. Some tracks definitely feel way too long and that loud snare drum can be pretty exhausting for your ears by the end.

Came out while in college and was the Metallica I really listened to.

Not a metallica fan...personal opinions aside, this is their best album. However most songs were overplayed.

I don’t like metal. There’s maybe two songs on here that I can listen to.

Great talent, v uplifting thx!

My entry point into Metallica. Brilliant album, these songs are constantly on my playlists 😍

Almost a perfect album The God that failed and Of wolf and man not really me thing The rest is sublime 4/5

Metallica really feel like they know what they are doing. They nailed down a specific style and specialise in it. There is enough variety to feel good, but it all slots together very well.

4/5 Ahh, Metallica. Always a joy to listen to. Their albums always feel so... complete. Well-rounded. Good album.

Classic metal from the 90s, done well, even if Lars is a dork.

Even if Lars is a dick Enter Sandman is one of the GOAT

Fucking incredible. Sandman, sad but true, nothing else matters, what is there to even say about a run that iconic? Drums, guitar, vocals, bass, it's all so good.

This is a monster of an album. It marks a significant transition point in Metallica's journey as a band. The album is more hard rock than thrash metal but it is still brilliant. There is banger after banger on the album.

If Lars can be the 5th most successful drummer of all time, you can do anything <3

I listened to this because I'm a completionist, but I did not need to hear all of it to know how I feel about it. It's one of the most important metal albums ever, and contains several of Metallica's all-time classics. Sadly, it's impossible for me to divorce my feelings about the music from my feelings about the band, and can only care for Metallica from a musical anthropology perspective. To that end, I watched the VH1 Behind The Music more times than I could count when it came out in the late 90s, but I've never owned a Metallica record. As a guitar player, the only things that ever interested me about the band are the classical guitar intros that they like to dabble in (I also mentioned this on my "...And Justice For All" review). In this case, that's primarily "The Unforgiven" and "Nothing Else Matters". The enduring impact of this record forces me to rate it higher than if I were rating purely on personal preference. One of the longest hour long records in recent memory. My review of "...And Justice For All" said that I wasn't really annoyed to listen through that record, but I don't remember if that was just because it caught me on the right day or what was going on. I certainly feel a little annoyed to listen through this today, so I'm gonna price that in.

They're clearly enjoying themselves massively and if you like this genre at all you're going to love this. Unfortunately heavy metal is perhaps the genre I dislike most of all. But I'll score it relatively highly to allow for this being probably the best in it's class.

Not my favourite Metallica album (Ride The Lightning takes that spot and would undoubtedly get 5 stars), but this launched them into superstardom. More refined than their earlier work, it remains one of their strongest: musically varied, lyrically accomplished, and well-produced.

Day 1 — Metallica — Metallica (Black Album) (1991) Listened: Feb 23, 2026 Genre: Heavy Metal / Hard Rock Vibe: Haunting, aggressive, melodic Highlights: • Enter Sandman • The Unforgiven • Nothing Else Matters Impression: Giant sound. Very melodic for how heavy it is. Good balance for my tastes and makes heavy metal palatable for me. Rating: 3.0/5 Keep songs? Yes Revisit album? Yes

El álbum en general cómo un todo es muy bueno. Si noté en algunas canciones que la guitarra y la batería se pisan, lo que hace que se escuche como muy comprimido. Canción favorita: the unforgiven

not for me

Nicht meins

Buen álbum, un poco sobrevalorado a veces pero todavía bueno 8/10

Excellent!

Hard and rock

2-2,5 Denk dat we er al uit zijn dat Metallica niet mijn ding is. Nothing else matters stond op deze plaat

21/02/2026 1. enter sandman - guitar is nice i guess? technically good, just not for me :/ seems very long... not a good start for an album that's just over an hour. 2. sad but true - not a fan. just figured out i've been listening to this album on shuffle, so if the writing seems a bit disjointed, it's because it's not actually the order i listened in!!! 3. holier than thou - nothing more to say lol. sounded exactly the same as the rest of the songs. 4. the unforgiven - same as prev. cannot wait for this to be over... 5. wherever i may roam - like the guitar at start... sounds a bit orientalist though.... not a fan of the riff after it gets loud though. 6. don't tread on me - america!!!! not american so i couldn't care less. even if it's ironic, considering what the singer has said about the use of his music in torture at guantanamo bay, it doesn't come off great. 7. through the never - this is more what i was thinking when this album showed up. somehow it's gotten worse from the earlier songs! 8. nothing else matters - obviously metal, but sounds more toothless and mainstream than any of the other metal albums this has made me listen to? really boring.... 9. of wolf and man - boring.... 10. the god that failed - bass is nice at the start. shame about the rest of the song. 11. my friend of misery - this bloody album is misery... 12. the struggle within - so glad this is over!!! did not like this at all, metal is absolutely not for me, not spending any more time on this.

Album 115. Metallica (https://open.spotify.com/album/37lWyRxkf3wQHCOlXM5WfX?si=lVuFs19wTKq95TESJD_T5A) — Metallica (1991) I walked through gigantic snowdrifts while listening to Wherever I May Roam. It was hilarious and absurd. I may remember that moment for a long time. Classic. I want to give it the highest tier, but metal is not exactly my music. Not for every day or every mood. Today is a good match for metal. Fuck, I didn't really enjoy Don't Tread on Me. Dunno how it's possible🐍 What a disappointment. 4/5 Liked songs: — Enter Sandman — Sad But True — The Unforgiven — Wherever I May Roam — Nothing Else Matters

okay i like enter sandman! i know that one!

i’ve heard some of these songs, but never listened to the whole album at once. it’s pretty solid. can’t believe how popular this was despite every song being over 4 minutes. “Enter Sandman” always reminds me of Mariano Rivera RIP (he’s not actually dead, but is a huge MAGA supporter so he’s dead to me)

God, I struggled to listen to this, not for me

track 1 side 1 intro.....and we go ! :)

Much prefer this album to Master Of Puppets. To me it feels far more polished, complete & impactful, with standout tracks blended amongst an interesting variety of heavy, well-written hard-rock tracks. There were definitely times during this listen that I switched off from it a bit though - can’t put my finger on exactly why, but I’d probably have enjoyed it more if it were 3-4 songs shorter.

Büro, Heidenheim, Deutschland. Schon so ein bisschen überbewertet.

One of the all time great Heavy Metal albums. Run's a little long. 2 or so tracks could have been cut for a tighter album. 4.5/5. Raising to 5. PS I'm just over a quarter of the way through this list now. I'm all for expanding my music knowledge/taste but my feeling is there is more disappointment than gems to be found. Starting to believe there isn't 1001 albums worth listening to before you die and this list could seriously be condensed. We'll keep trucking along though.

im an huge metallica fan and while its not like every song on this album is well known its still an great album for me

Could easily be the best album of the 90s. This album brought rock back to life for me after the land of the lost 80s. After watching the video Enter Sandman on MTV I bought the album then backtracked before the release of Load. What this album offers is what the band was and where they were heading over the next 3 or 4 releases.

I knew only two of these songs (the very well-known ones). The riffing is semi-decent (crunchy texture), but there are almost no off-beat rhythms, why is it so square? And I'm soon tired of the vocal style - I am quite open to cathartic music, but this is almost always shouty/angry, boring. So, Nothing Else Matters is great (better dynamic range), some other songs could be okay as one-off workout songs, but I wouldn't play this again as an album. I will keep choosing heavy rock / metal (eg Living Colour, Agriculture) that doesn't have this tedious shouty tone. Feeling generous, I say it's "Mix of Good and Bad", 5/10.

A metal classic, seen as some as the beginning of the end for Metallica, but was my first steps into heavier metal after growing up with Black Sabbath and Ozzy.

Хороший

I finally got around to this, been putting it off. It was alright, 3 stars. definitely some catchier moments here and I've heard a lot of these tracks before but I've always steered clear of Metallica before. My view have softened to them in recent years but not super impressed with this album.

This album is the beginning of the end of my interest in Metallica. I loved so much of this album when it came out, but I was also not thrilled with the move away from thrash. This is the last album of theirs that i liked. There are flashes of the Metallica I loved, but they had obviously turned a corner. "The Unforgiven" has always been iffy for me. I didn't hate it, but it wasn't my favorite on the album. and my opinion of it just ketp getting worse with each new installment of it. "Don't Tread On Me" is one of the low points on the album for me. "Through the Never" is a high point. It would have felt at home on AAJFA. The last 4 tracks of the album feel like them purging the last vestiges of AAJFA Metallica. 4 stars

The most uninteresting Metallica record. At least with Lulu, I can laugh at how absurdly misguided it is, and at minimum, St. Anger has a fun story as to why it’s so scuffed. This is just Metallica selling their souls, put to tape.

This has been my first listen through of a Metallica album, and it was an interesting listen but a little disappointing. The tone/timbre of everything is perfect, the drums are pounding, the vocals have that great gravelly quality, and the guitars sound perfectly chunky and electric... But the songs themselves just failed to wow me. Enter Sandman is of course a great track, but by the time I'm in the second half of the album my attention is really wanting, which really sucks because those other elements feel so great. I know Metallica has other albums that are held in a little more higher regard so I'm keeping my hopes up for when I get to those. Fav Track: 1 - Enter Sandman Best Three Track Run: 1, 2, 3

This album generator has been about expanding my musical horizons, but damn if I haven't had a long string of 'great' albums that I really didn't like much. Metallica's Black album is a familiar album. One I listened to many times over the years. This album was more or less my intro to Metallica, I wasn't familiar with their previous work when Enter Sandman blew up on radio and MTV when I was about 10. After familiarizing myself with everything from Kill Em All to And Justice For All, I can see how some people would find this an abrupt change to the sound of Metallica. Nevertheless, I love this album, there are so many timeless songs, from the aforementioned Enter Sandman, Whereever I May Roam, The Unforgiven Nothing Else Matters, this album is a powerful introduction to Metallica of the 90s.

Maybe 4.5? Enjoyed, but felt a bit same-y by the end. Would listen to more by them, though

This one feels like what I think of when I hear “metal.” The songs kind of all sound the same a little bit, but they’re good. I definitely played some of them on guitar hero

Glad to hear more of this iconic band - a whole album felt like a lot to me, personally, but I can recognize the mastery.

A little on the long side for not-my-preferred genre. But full of easily-recognizable hits.

BANG BANG BANG!!! YELL YELL YELL!!!! SCCCCRRRREAAAAAAAAMMM! yeah... I'll pass

top of the top

I’ve never been a huge Metallica fan, but this is the era I think of when I think of them. Great album. Probably my favorite that I’ve heard from them so far. Solid 4.5 stars

I liked Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters prior to listening to the album fully. It's not typically a genre I listen to, but it was a pretty enjoyable listen to be honest.

Heard Before? Duh. Notes: - dazzling guitar solos sounds pasted in from a better album. - ham fisted drumming and crawling tempos really help the stupid lyrics and overwrought singing stand out. - dull, obvious production accomplishes the "let's blend in with the worst of rock radio" goal. - yet another album on this list entirely bereft of interesting sounds. - I love metal and hate Metallica, but at least Master Of Puppets meant something to someone, unlike this dreck. Verdict: What if Metallica but bland riff rock? Listen Again? If only it were avoidable.

Some iconic songs and iconic sounds but songs like ‘tread on me’ are so cringe and proves how much Metallica sells out. I like my music to prioritise art of capital

Has a lot of great songs. “Enter Sandman”? Energetic opening. Then followed by “Sad But True”? Hell yeah. And then “The Unforgiven” and “Wherever I May Roam” makes it calmer. Also, “Nothing Else Matters” is very calm.

Bought this on cassette on the day it came out

Still not a group I reach for, but this album finds a way to transcend its genre without ever pretending to be anything but metal. It's quite the showcase of range and talent, and at the end of the day, it just straight up rocks.

I have no capacity to be objective about The Black Album. As soon as I press play, I immediately become 11 again. I think it's pretty good? I couldn't tell you for sure; the critical part of my brain is offline because of all the headbanging. Has a kickdrum ever sounded more ferocious? Not to an 11-year-old, I'll tell you that much.

Very nice

Riffs, Riffs and more F***ing Riffs! Too many of the songs are too long and the album seems to sit at the same tempo too much for me, but that's nit picking really, would be a 9 out of ten. The production and mixing are immaculate, as good as heavy guitars can sound really

The dads are right about this one, really good album for the gym and some really iconic songs, would listen to again even though heavy metal tends to sound samey to me

Без оценки

It's metallica and it's good but I don't love metallica

Sweet! I've been in a Metallica mood recently. While the Black Album is definitely not as good as their stuff from the 80s it still kicks a ton of ass. Sometimes its ok for a band to make a "sellout" album as long as its full of bangers like we have here. It definitely has some cringe moments like "Don't Thread on Me" and I've never been able to take "Sad But True" seriously for some reason. Also "Enter Sandman" is a good song but its wildly overrated, far from the band's best work. Overall though, this is a respectable addition to Metallica's catalog and I would even argue it's their last great record. Favorite track: The Unforgiven 3.5/5

This was okay. A bit too long for me.

Teenage me was obsessed with this. Brought back some great memories.

Does this album need to be on this list? No. Groove metal Metallica really doesn’t need much dwelling on. That said, Sad But True is one of the platonic ideals of groove metal, so this album is worth listening to for that.

The same six minute song on the whole thing. Besides enter sandman which is alright.

Not my usual but I liked it

A fantastic and pure metal album.

I liked this album a lot more than I thought I would. My few encounters with metal have not been great, so this was a pleasant surprise. A fault that I think can be found in every album of this genre is the monotonous sound throughout, which can, and did, become tiresome. And I know this is not an original thought, given it's their most popular song, but 'Enter Sandman' is great, I loved it. Three stars. (Favorite track: Enter Sandman.)

Cool, found 1 new song Whenever I may roam. Liked the snake on the cover :)

drums really slap. great album

Sometimes I think I might be unfairly harsh towards Metallica, and then I listen to their self-titled and nah I'm completely justified. Mid.

Metallica’s just one of those bands I can’t get into like most. Wasn’t a fan of this one or Master of Puppets, but maybe someday it’ll click.

вот это круто!!! 🔥: don't tread on me, holier than you бешеная

Nope another overrated band....0-2 so far smh

Great album; great band. This album was full of hits from; ‘enter sandman’, ‘nothing else matters’. And my favourite is, ‘the unforgiven’. Could listen to this all the way through and enjoy every second.

Quite a few good songs on this one compared to the last one. I really liked Nothing Else Matters and My Friend Of Misery. It could be a little same-y though

Peak Mettallica IMO. Nothing but bangers on this album. To see them play this album live would be a treat. Definitely a defining point for metal and metal popularity

A good metallica album, though I miss their thrash days. Solid, but I might not come back to this.

I am surprised to say the least, but this is album is so well put together and thought out that i enjoyed it from start to finish. I don't love the excessively noisy solos and the incessant presence of the guitar, but damn this record knows when and how to pump energy and when to slow down with grace. Very nice experience.

By Far, Not their Best

I am more of the raging thrash heaviness of the first four Metallica records, rather than this big top 40 one. But I guess Enter Sandman and Unforgiven are poppy hits.

Um, a very masculine production is my first thought, in both fine and not so fine ways.

Metallica, Metallica ⭐️⭐️ Album #8. I cringed a bit when I saw this come up this morning. I’ve known Metallica all my life. I wouldn’t say I’m a fan. I like and borderline love a few of their songs, but they’re a small doses band for me. I was anxious at the thought of listening to the whole album. Turns out I was right. I have a few major gripes with this band, chief amongst them being their sound. Not the music, not the composition or the lyrics, it’s the fucking sound. Horribly compressed, like it’s playing from within a resonant box, sucking in on itself, completely devoid of dynamics. I hate it. This, to me, is not heavy. It doesn’t feel loud. It feels artificial in a majorly bad way. Secondly, it’s the rhythm section. Much of this stuff has been meme’d to death, but it’s still worth pointing out. The bass is so undefined. It’s just a low end splat in the mix. And Lars. Before today, I actually felt the criticism he gets was unfair. But my God. I’m sure these drum parts were meticulously crafted, but they’re played so rigidly. I’m a drummer myself, admittedly not part of a billion dollar band like Metallica, I’ve never made ten quid in music, but these parts are played so boringly and lifelessly that I feel you’d get more soul from a drum machine. What earns this album a second star for me is Kirk Hammett. His playing is class. His solos elevate every song on the album, particularly The Unforgiven, which is by far the best track here. One of the only songs with a real dynamic range, and where James ditches the trademark snarl and actually sings a bit. I also like some of the faster songs, like Holier Than Thou. I know this album is a departure from their thrash metal roots, so maybe I’d like the earlier albums more. I may get slated for this, but I don’t get it. By the end, I felt pulverised. Maybe that’s the point. I’ll probably never listen to it again.

Who would have expected West Side Story to pop up - camp!

3 and a half. Enjoyed this more than I thought I would

Hell yeah brother

Hell yeah this ruled

About half the songs slap enormously, and the other half are guff. Lars is the world's worst drummer

Started off good. The songs all kind of sound the same to me.

cool, could be cooler. 4/5

It was fine.

enter sandman is truly one of my favs

So close to a 5!

i feel like a fraud

not my thing

My favorite album from Metallica. This was a staple for me in high school and I still love it.

This was a big childhood moment for me so there's a nostalgia factor for sure. It's a massive record, full of hits, the latter half does have some relatively forgettable stuff, but the hits are so good. Lars is really playing the same 4 on the floor beat for 90 percent of this one eh? I'm more of a 'first four records' Metallica guy, but this is an amazing record.

Never listening to them again.

A lot of bangers on here. Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters. The rest is okay, but nothing incredibly special.

Found myself frowning a lot. Kind of music that helps your dad process his divorce.

It got worse from here for one of my favourite 80’s bands

This is very cool, albeit really, really repetitive. I like metal, but it all sort of tastes the same after a while. This still rocks hard and is a hell of a lot of fun to listen to, but I feel like we need some more peaks and valleys here to make it more musical. Regardless, Metallica fucks. Perfect band name.

Metallica the best

I definitely enjoyed this version of Metallica a lot more than the version that created "Master of Puppets". Thrash metal is very much not my thing. I don't understand the appeal at all. But the music on this album is more focused on melody, and less on thrash elements, and ultimately it ends up being a much better piece of work. Thrash still sneaks in, but when surrounded by the more heavy rock sound, it actually works really well. "Enter Sandman" is a classic song. Everything about this song works so well from start to finish. It's dark, theatrical and foreboding, and the idea of turning the sandman into a horror story is pure genius. "Nothing Else Matters" is the other classic on this album. The opening acoustic guitar riff became compulsory learning for budding guitarists in the 90s, even if you weren't a Metallica fan, and for a good reason. The decision to soften the heaviness with orchestration is what makes this song, and coupled with that great chorus vocal, it's a different side of Metallica: restrained and refined. But, the songs surrounding these classics are where the album falls. Thrash sneaks in for full songs here and there, and a lot of the other songs don't really go anywhere, making a good chunk of the album feel quite forgettable. But, all in all, this side of Metallica, the side favouring melody over mindless thrashing, is one that I can actually listen to and enjoy.

Stand-out tracks: Enter Sandman, Sad But True, The Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters, My Friend of Misery I'm generally not a fan of heavy metal so I knew going in that I wasn't going to like it apart from the few tracks I've already heard before. I've noticed that I'm a much bigger fan of the tracks that mix moments of high octane energy and moments of slowness and just instrumentals without the harsh vocals. Tracks that are just at a 100% from start to finish tire me out really quickly. In that sense only about half of the album is ok to me while the rest I won't be going back to, hence the average rating.

Highlights: Enter Sandman, Sad But True, The Unforgiven, Wherever May I Roam, Nothing Else Matters Interesting how their whatever-th album is a self titled one (and not a debut), but it all makes sense when you look at it through the lens of the entry point for the normie edgy metalhead - which it is. But hate for the annoying fans aside, I found the record to be very good too. It has this edginess to it, but it is also very approachable to the general masses because it takes on some elements from 80s rock hits. It's great for what it is and I wouldn't mind playing it more often if it wasn't made by Metallica - a bunch of twats who act all edgy and cool until you download their music from Napster. The lyrics are a bit too edgy for my liking so I didn't pay much mind to them. I really don't get how this shit gets infinite praise while nu metal gets slammed for the same reason. The record for me was therefore heavily carried by its sound, which did make my head bop. I have heard more interesting tracks from their other records, so I guess this wouldn't be my favourite record of theirs based on that. This record was a bit more on the tamer side of metal. That's why I'm saying it's normie friendly. For instance, does Unforgiven even count as metal? Half of the material is more of a ballad type. I won't be revisiting this record as a whole, but the highlights will definitely remain in rotation.

Better than Coldplay

I love this album. Great riffs and solos and so many songs end up on the orchestra collaboration album S&M.

The more melodic songs probably better suited to me. I did like Metallica pretty well when I was younger. 3/5

A few strong tracks. Not my thing.

This is the right time in my life to start listening to Matalica. I'm glad that I’d been schooled in Black Sabbath beforehand because it gave me a route into old school Heavy Metal. When I was younger I would have rolled my eyes at some of this - especially the vocals and lyrics which are at points joyfully silly. I’m now old enough to appreciate rocking out on the guitar, crunching chords, drum fills, projected vocals. There's drama, there’s shock and awe. My whole life I’ve wondered why certain grunge and heavy rock artists strain their vocals in that particular way, and now they know - they’re copying Metallica. What sounds overwrought from other singers, sounds electric when done right.

Low 4 for me on Metallica. Really enjoyed the overall vibe and have been meaning to listen to them for a long time. Not my kind of metal but lots to love for me here.

WoW.. This is greatness

Revisiting this album after I last listened to it in high school. Quite nostalgic and if I remember correctly it was of my introductions to heavy metal since Metallica decided to take the more commercially accessible route with this album.

Excelente

Heavy metal.

Classic metallica songs. I like this but 50/50 on owning the album.

Another solid one. No complaints.

The bus should have fallen on Lars

The Black Album may not be the favorite of die-hard fans, but it's not hated either. Metallica's transition from thrash to a more MTV friendly sound made them household names. Bob Rock's production, killer hooks, and zero filler introduced the band to a whole new audience that has carried them through to this day, whether the old school thrash fans like it or not.

este estilo a mí personalmente no me gusta, a la gente que le guste si pero a mí no

What an amazing vibe this album had

Absolutely BUZZING for this one, I really like Metallica and this album, I’ve always wanted to listen to more. Man icl I didn’t really like any of the songs other than the ones I already knew. Fav song is ‘Nothing Else Matters’.

Nigdy nie przepadałam za Metallicą, ale po przesłuchaniu tego albumu, myślę że będę do niego wracać

Not fond of metal in the slightest but this was a good listen.

Solid enough in a stodgy, plodding sort of way. Dark enough to be vaguely interesting to a non-Metallica fan, but lacking enough to disappoint thrash Metallica fans.

Just not my jam.

Now that's what I'm talking about

I C O N I C 5/5

I was surprised at just how much I disliked this. It tries so hard to be big and epic but ends up sounding like a whole load of nothing. No feeling, no emotion, nothing that invokes any sort of reaction at all. It all sounds the same and it all sounds like nothing.

Not my vibe Like nothing else matters

I already knew this album was going to be 5 stars as soon as I saw it pop up. This album is one of my top 10 all times so suffice to say, I love it. Sorry, to every other future album, this one is the gold standard and that’s just Sad But True.

Classic. It’s not my favorite metal, but this album is undeniably in the canon of the genre. Great listen, plenty of hits.

This is probably Metallica’s most accessible album and contains most of their well known tracks. I have this, S&M and Master of Puppets all in my collection and I see no real need to have anymore. This is the album I return to most probably because of the excellence of Enter Sandman and The Unforgiven. A solid album well worthy of this list. 5/5 1/2/26

It’s hard not to listen to this with jaded 55 year old ears and not hear tinges of parody. At the time this was a serious hard rock/ metal that would have at fist had a very distinct audience. As it softened like warm butter, or the world hardened this became a mega hit. Kudos Metallica for teaching future generations how to rock.

Ugh. Enter Sandman is cool. Some good instrumentals. But couldn't wait to get through this one. Because I'm behind on daily listening, I can see that I have ANOTHER Metallica album up next. I hope I like it more.

It was just pretty boring to me. I think Metallica is about a kind of dark, macabre vibe. But all the lyrics seemed like Hallmark card level aphorisms and cliches. Stuff about "carrying the weight of the world on your shoulders", or "sad but true". It was tough to take seriously.

I wasn't into Metallica when this album came out, and when I started listening to them much later in life, I didn't seek out the Black Album (and still don't). So it's crazy how familiar these songs are, particularly the first half of the album. I get why it's both their commercial peak and the beginning of their creative decline. There's plenty to like on here, but I prefer thrashier Metallica. Rounding up to 4.

I'm a huge fan of Ride the Lightning and Master of Puppets, with And Justice For All being pretty fantastic too. I would choose any of those albums over this any day, but man this thing is stocked with riffs baked into my life and transports me back to early high school. Never owned the album but didn't have to as the Blitz 99.7 in Columbus still plays half this album in heavy rotation to this day. Unforgiven and Dont Tread on Me are standouts.

Does absolutely nothing for me in any way but I kinda get it

Haters gonna hate. This is a great album full of bangers. All these haters will never sell as much albums as Metallica has. Eat shit, mofos. 🤘🏼😂🤘🏼

New running album

Contains two of their better known songs but the rest is pretty average

i really liked exactly half of the songs and absolutely hated the other half. truly the most 2.5 album to have ever 2.5'd

Brought out the jack black in me

No 10 minute 'where did the melody go' thrash marathons here. In fact I was 7 tracks in before I heard any of what I would call 'thrash' at all. This as an album of polished growling melodies that you can hum in the shower (I did), but still heavy enough to rattle your teeth. And it has 2 absolute classic rock tracks in Sandman and Nothing Else Matters. I think this was the best thing Metallica ever did.

Heard some songs many times; 4; Huge singles with tremendous, heavy riffs. Favorite Track: Sad But True

I need to listen to this more. Great album from start to finish.

Good, but not great. The album is only as good as its drummer... The big songs are MASSIVE but the album tracks are just meh. I wish I liked this more and I'm surprised I didn't!

I like Metallica, I can see the appeal of the album. It's a little too pop oriented for most of it and forgettable for the rest. It's no Master of Puppets!

Shitty drummer don't like the singing style

Some classic songs on here. Impressive guitar and drums.

6.5 - Some decent tracks. Def prefer older Metallica.

It's metallica. Not them at their creative peak, no way. But it's good. Probably won't return to the full album, but a few songs are legendary.

Fan fucking tastic album hearing this live in its entirety in reverse order when the first time i saw them at the festival was amazing. Lars still cant drum for shit though

4 stars - WHAT MORE CAN I SAYYY CLASSIC METALLICA DAD ROCK

Ugggh I LOVE the electric guitars! I have heard some of the songs before and wherever I may roam is one of my favorites!! So maybe you can call me a rock lover now?

The hits rip and Enter Sandman is on any reasonable short list for most kick ass song, but I was bored with the rest by the end.

Listening session: january 27th, while commuting from and to internship Listened to before: listened to some songs before Thoughts: I have to admit this is a classic and while I do like most of this, it has its repetitive moments Favourite tracks: Enter Sandman, Holier Than Thou & Wherever I May Roam

Just what I needed at 7am on a Tuesday at my desk job. 5/5

I have a couple of Metallica songs on my favorite list but I haven’t listened to a whole album. Solid rock album all the way around. A great listen.

A lot less abrasive than I was expecting, definitely kept me awake on my drive to work this morning. High 3

Lots of classics on this album

Man I hope it’s a long time before we get another Metallica album

This album is too loud oh god turn it down shit it’s still too loud oh god so loud turn it down oh my god 3/5

A seminal masterpiece that will forever have a place in the debate for one of the best metal albums of all time. James Hetfield’s personal songwriting, combined with some of the band’s most iconic riffs, spans from the defining singles that inspired the rebellious phase of countless generations to deeper cuts that still pack a punch, such as “The God That Failed” and “My Friend of Misery.” This feels like Metallica at their absolute peak.

I've gone back and forth on Metallica over the years - times when I really liked them and times where I haven't. On the Black Album, I think the better songs save the rest of the meh songs on the record. Overall they are extremely important to the genre, have some great songs and an overall strong discography. While this is no Ride The Lightning or Master of Puppets, it's still worth a listen and a pretty easy entry into their genre of metal.

never really given metallica a chance and i will continue not to. i think most of the popular late 80s/early 90s classic metal scene doesn't resonate with me because men hadn't discovered emotions other than anger yet, the riff driven stuff really doesn't do anything for me at all and without any sense of irony at all this is largely music for school shooters. hetfields vocals are fine but he's got one tone and doesn't do anything interesting with it the unforgiven is the first track i really sat up for, there's some guitar work here that gets interesting but can't save the album. wherever i may roam is so unnecessarily long. don't tread on me is BORING! c'mon how're you sporting the gasden flag and have literally nothing to say! nothing else matters is a well-written song (high point since the opener) but there's probably a hundred artists who have put more soul into this and at +6 mins is a slog in metallica's hands got to of wolf and man and checking how long's left, not been bored like this since U2's Achtung Baby. A one note album, does nothing for me at all. I'll say that Metallica are very, very good at what they do if that's what you want but it's really, really fucking boring to be honest - no dynamic, no highs, no lows, just a constant muddy sludge to trudge through 2 stars is being generous - 1.5 tops

Good but not great Very consistent There are 3 or 4 better Metallica albums 7.2/10

my VT heritage demands "enter sandman" by my favorite off of this album, but so many bangers , best version of "whereever i may roam" i've ever heard

some songs are alright i guess

Best Metallica album in my opinion

"You think one day some fucker's gonna tell you, 'You have a number one record in America,' and the whole world will ejaculate. I stood there in my hotel room, and there was this fax that said, 'You're number one.' And it was, like, 'Well, okay.' It was just another fucking fax from the office." -Lars It's a perfect album. Not their best album, but definitely best sounding. Props to Bob Rock. James's voice is consistently consistently used as a musical (rather than blunt) instrument.

Listening again reminded me how huge this album was when it was released. It's almost comical to imagine a metal album having the same cultural reach today.

Better than I expected

Yeah, this rocks. Though I still like S&M more

Metallica get bored of ruling the thrash metal scene and decide to take over the world. This is a cleaned up, shiny version of thrash. It's the metal album that even people who don't like metal know and for better or worse it changed rock music. Best Tracks: Enter Sandman; The Unforgiven; Nothing Else Matters

The Good: We get Metal! The Bad: of the Lica kind… The Ugly: Metal player wearing Licra… What? Okay, so anyone growing up in the US in the ‘90s has heard the hits… fucking monsters! I forgot how massive this album was, and how important it was for metal music. Now, I am sure that the purist out there view this album is pop, but I don’t care…. I banged my head to this music, saw them perform live 3 times in the ‘90s… and all the time I was viewed as a preppy by my friends. So, needless to say, I had a lovely time thinking about those care free days back in the ‘90s, when all I had to worry about was passing an exam with a C and hoping to get laid over the weekend! Nothing Else Matters… 5*

I didn't like this as much as S&M but I knew a lot of the songs. Metallica has kind of a hokey reputation, but I like them!

I liked it

For me it’s a 3.5, which says a lot considering I almost never listen to metal. That said, it’s really good—I saved four songs that are now part of my daily listening. This was a first listen, so it’ll probably take some time to fully grasp it. The sound quality is great, and there are a lot of dynamics I’d love to steal for my own music :) hahaha. P.S.: This project is going great—loving this generator so far.

Took me back to high school. Metal isn't really my jam, but enjoyed this album all the way through.

Absolute dross mostly. Heavy plodding and Nothing Else Matters as the ballad. Not a fan of the singing. Whenever a track started off more promisingly it soon deteriorated. Usually when vocals started. Sad but true. Which coincidentally was probably the worst track, though lots of competition. Hard to get through it all, Struggle Within indeed. 1. Enjoyed Sepultura more.

Obvious influence on In Pain, but apart from Enter Sandman riff and Nothing Else Matters, a hard pass on the rest.

Okay, so it’s taken me three metallica albums to truly understand how to make listening fun. I will confess, there are maybe three decent songs on this album. Nothing else matters once again shows that Metallica have potential, but too often they default to paint by numbers, formulaic power cords for the bulk of their work. The unforgiven was kind of alright , and then we have Enter Sandman, which is obviously a popular and well regarded choice, though typically it showcases the dearth of lyrical talent that this brand bring the party. Cutting to the chase, it’s like some pubescent 13-year-old has penned the words to every song. So how to overcome that? Welcome to Kelvinos’ random lyric generator! You basically play the track, and instead of listening to the words, you make up your own which must involve references to darkness, night, the mind, pain, evil powers, tortured souls et cetera, et cetera. By the end of the track you will realise that your word salad is equal to if not better than the word salad that Metallica have just spouted. Try it, it’s a far better way to spend one hour and two minutes of your life.

Surprised I’ve never properly listened before

I was pleasantly surprised that I liked this. Added “Enter Sandman” to my playlist.

Great highlights and overall solid album

It's good, but not as good

Having never listened to a full Metallica album before, I thought it was pretty good. I didn't realize so many of the songs I know by them are from one album. I guess they are more accessible here than on some prior works, but I still thought they felt and sounded like their usual amount of heavy. Having more background catalog knowledge likely would have impacted my listen, I guess. I don't really love thrash, so the emphasis on slowing down appealed to me. I enjoyed the way they went with a few different styles over the course of the songs. There were quieter, acoustic-led moments on some tracks. There were orchestral string accompaniments that added nicely while not becoming too overbearing. Then, of course, there was the heavy metal riffing that makes the songs what they are. Hetfield's vocals can be a bit over the top, but it wasn't too noticeable here. The pieces came together to keep things interesting over its lengthy runtime (65+ minutes). Really, though, the runtime was too much. This didn't have to be 65 minutes long. Too many of the songs followed the same formulas to need them all on the same album. It just got tedious as it kept going. While there were a bunch of good songs on here, there were at least a few that could've been left off without losing much. Also, I kinda hate the artwork. It's Smell the Glove-esque black with a No Step on Snek-ish image slapped on. It just makes me think of all the middle age dudes with faded tribal or AmTrad tattoos, wrap-around sunglasses and leather vest/jean jacket. (I guess that kinda tracks, since I feel like I see plenty of people in that group who love Metallica.) It's probably a 90s thing that didn't age particularly well. Regardless, I thought this was a pretty good album. Aside from the length, I found it to be an enjoyable listen all the way through. I did find it a little less good than AIC's Dirt, which I got yesterday. Still, it's right around a 4 for me. Overall: 3.9/5

I grew up as a metalhead, so the accepted opinion around me was that this was the worst piece of music ever recorded, a crime against heavy metal and western civilization. This was Metallica’s selling out album, also their mainstream breakout. I mean yeah after they spent four albums making their songs more complex and longer this album does focus things. It features some of James’s best singing and they actually let us hear Jason’s playing and even let him write My Friend Of Misery which is possibly the best song in here. This is a great album, it makes Metallica’s sound somewhat simpler but very very effective and makes for some of their greatest songs. Some songs here are fillers though like The Struggle Within, something I can’t say for the previous three albums so giving only four stars.

Pretty good album. Understand why it was a classic Started off with a banger and held strong until about halfway through the album, when it kinda fell off in the middle of "Wherever I May Roam". "Of Wolf and Man" and "The Struggle Within" were two standout tracks, but everything after that just didn't do it for me. Almost feel asleep while listening to "Nothing Else Matters", don't know why that song even fits in with the album. Docking a star for the formulaic nature of the songs on this album, as well as the length of some songs. Overall, production was peak, and some songs really moved me. James Hetfield vocals were excellent, and Metallica is cohesive and talented as a band. However, this album may just be overhyped in terms of quality.

i already listened to this one

Its not my style but its good

187/1089 Enter Sandman is just pretty great, especially as an album opener. it’s a fine album but still suffers the issue i often have with this and similar genres, which is that i just don’t really need an hour of it. the songs i liked were good and i’d listen to them again, especially in a movie/tv context. Otherwise i’m just fine to have this one listen. Similarly, i once again find that i prefer metal music when there aren’t vocals (in particular, i often don’t love male vocals in this style) S&M remains my fave Metallica project (ironically considering it’s length) but i prefer this over Justice faves: Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven, My Friend of Misery 64/100

Personally, I checked out after …And Justice For All. Whilst it not may be the Metallica that I grew up on, it’s still a good record. The Bob Rock production still holds up and there’s no doubt the songs are there that cemented the band’s popularity.

My experience with Metallica has been fleeting, listening to some of the biggest and best from them over the years, but never have I given an entire album the attention it possibly deserves. Beginning with that sinister and mysterious guitar riff, swiftly backed by drums and additional heavy guitar, "Enter Sandman" is one of those incredibly memorable tracks and a strong track to start an album with. "Sad but Trues" intro is really fun, with the power chords slamming in time with the cymbals. The epic chorus elevated this one for me, something that feels great to sing along to. What I find apparent with Metallic (at least in this album) is that they are very lyrical and the lyrics are easy to hear and follow, without sacrificing the anger in delivery so typical of this genre. "The Unforgiven" helped me to realise this. Other tracks I loved were "Don't Tread on Me", "Nothing Else Matters", "Of Wolf and Man" and "My Friend of Misery". Overall, this was a great album. Will definitely be listening to it again in future.

90s metal. Move away from trash metal to slower, heavier sound. Their bestselling album, contains tons of hits. Obviously very good.

Points for nostalgia but the songs all sound too similar

I never listened to much post-80s metal/rock until this album came out. Changed me. I'm not a Metallica fan, but I love this album.

4.8 too long

Some great tracks! Political things?

Just a great album start to finish. I've listened to it once before and honestly it was better this time around. Not Metallica's best work but definitely their most iconic 8.5/10

Amazing album. Really good lyrics with meaning behind them and very melodic for metal. Definitely exceeded my expectations and was a very enjoyable listening experience. Favourite track- The Unforgiven

Uno de los mejores álbumes de Metallica, con temazos icónicos. Metallica Sound.

After a bit of deliberation, I have decided i'm not going to be re-listening to the black album. I'm not really overly fond of Metallica at the best of times these days, and the black album is kind of a culmination of the issues I have with them. That being said, it's a reasonably fine album, and I can't knock it entirely just because it's fallen out of favor with me. Used to mess with it back in the day.

Had a few banger I’m familiar with like Nothing Else Matters and Enter Sandman. But everything else on this album is also amazing. The Unforgiven and Wherever I May Roam were both highlights for me. Excited to listen to more Metallica

Pretty bangin'

Great metal album

OHHHYEAHHAAAHH!!!!

Hahahahaha. I’m not gonna make it through this album. Sorry, gang. Weirdly, I like “The Unforgiven” and “Nothing Else Matters” more these days. Sad But True: all I can hear is Snoop Dogg singing this as he walked through the audience with terrible hair during MTV’s Icon. Woof!

Ok, hear me out… this album is ridiculous, but it is also sooo nostalgic. If you were a teenage or pre-teen boy growing up in America in the 90s and you didn’t own this record and know it back to front, there was no hope for you 🤣. Metallica was to the 90s what Zeppelin was to the 70s- pure machismo butt rock that was so catchy you couldn’t help but bang your head to it. It had been something like 20 years since I’d listened to this album in its entirety. Probably not gonna go back and revisit it anytime soon, but ai appreciated this opportunity to hear it again and giggle at how much we all LOVED this band back then. Lars is still trash.

One of the great albums of 1991! Classic!

Very typical of its time and genre, band members having a battle to see who is the loudest.

Oh my, I'm so happy to get this here! One of my favourite albums, and among Metallica's greatest - and they have lots of great albums. Love every minute of it. True classic.

Teenage me would have rated this album 5 stars. Adult me has a harder time giving this album more than three.

play it loud

Heard this album many times. Bit overplayed for me. Reminds me of my uncle 😅

Makes me wanna play guitar hero real bad!

Daleko od toga da sam najveći ljubitelj Metallice i generalno thrash metala ali ovi odavde hitovi su vrhunac metala koji se probio u komercijalu. Nema nijedna loša pjesma na albumu, sve mi je barem ok a ništa nije pregenijalno. Nepopularno, meni je Wherever I May Roam najbolja pjesma. Edit: j*** te apolitičnost Hetfieldu

This album was part of the suggested to my teen years. Unfortunately, the ratings are artificially lowered by people who think it's cool to hate on Metallica - bitter at their success in an era and genre defined by defiance.

The quint essential Metallica album. It's doesn't get better than then even for someone who doesn't listen to metal. Certified bangers.

The Metallica album I’m familiar with. Some good songs, but not really my style.

Before: "Metallica" by Metallica. I'm assuming this was their debut? I was never a fan. The closest thing to metal that I liked back then was Ministry, who were one of my favorite bands back in the day. In fact "The Mind Is a Terrible Thing to Taste" would definately be in my 1001 albums list, and probably be in my 101 albums list. Alas, it's not in this list. So let's get started with Metallica. During: "Enter Sandman", yep, I don't like this. Too simple, formulaic, and totally uninteresting. Ministry is not really like this at all. OK, maybe just a little, but it is reminding me of White Zombie who I did like a lot for a brief period in the early nineties, but they were groove metal. OMG, "Sad But True" is even worse. After: I mostly listened to the album while I was doing other stuff and skipped through several tracks. I don't care for this style of music and I don't like this album as a whole. It's very simple and boring. Apparently it was their fifth album. Looks like I'll have three more opportunities to listen to them. I get it they were very influential but I have to give this one star.

Okay...I'm going to say something a little controversial depending on who you are...I don't love The Black Album. Don't get me wrong, some of Metallica's finest songs are on here. 'Enter Sandman' is probably their best-known song, and a classic 'first song to learn' for budding guitarists. Then you also have 'Sad But True', 'The Unforgiven', 'Nothing Else Matters', 'Wherever I May Roam'...they're all great songs; well-produced and catchy as all hell. But, I can't help but feel like The Black Album is a bit of a let-down after three straight albums of perfection in 'Ride the Lightning', 'Master of Puppets' and '...And Justice For All'. 'The Black Album' is clearly Metallica going for a more commercial sound, no ifs and buts about it, and it worked for them as it's not only their best selling album, but one of the best selling albums of all time (over 30 million sold). And the musicianship is perfect. James Hetfield's voice is ferocious as ever (as well as tender when needed for 'The Unforgiven' and 'Nothing Else Matters'), and he and Kirk Hammett's guitars crunch through the mix like wrecking balls, and they're solidly backed by tight rhythm section of Lars Ulrich and Jason Newsted. But is this album too perfect? The beauty of what came before The Black Album, at least to me anyway, is the noted imperfections to Metallica's sound. Kill 'Em All through 'Justice' are all their own distinctive beasts and have something unique and interesting to say, while also marvelling in the their raw, unpolished and chaotic sound. 'The Black Album' strips all that rawness away in favour of polished gloss and studio perfection, which to me dilutes Metallica's style and sound in a big way, and it's more or less been their style ever since, despite the obvious misfires in Load/Reload and St Anger. I don't find myself revisiting The Black Album as much as I do the three records that came before it, because to me, Metallica don't sound as inspired on it. It clearly sounds like an album they did purely for commercial success, and you can't argue with their reasoning. Bob Rock had just come off turning Mötley Crüe into megastars ('Dr Feelgood') so was the right guy to do the same with Metallica, and the success of The Black Album is the very reason Metallica merchandise is everywhere you look in society. But I like to think the greatest thing about 'The Black Album's' success is it made more people aware of the groundbreaking brilliance of Metallica's 80's output. Best songs: Enter Sandman, Sad But True, Wherever I May Roam, The Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters

Did not expect to like this as much as I did - I knew I liked Unforgiven and a couple others, but really don't like Master of Puppets. However this album really resonated with me

j'ai grave kiffé, franchement banger

Not as good as I thought it would be

quite fire prolly give it a 4

I knew some of them already unexpected. Bot a metal gal to it was a bit grating to listen to. Too much build for all the songs with too little singing. I'm not crazy on instrumental.

My friend of misery: excellent guitar riffing. Sonically sounds great. The struggle within: loud fast metal, has some slower parts but still a good listen. OVERALL: not a huge fan of Metallica just based off this album

Não é um estilo que eu amo, mas deu pra entender quem gosta. É um ótimo album.

Es un disco que me apasiona y me satura a rachas. Debo reconocer la calidad de las canciones, pero soporto regular la voz del cantante. En cuanto a la producción, es realmente impresionante su sonido.

The first song on this album is Severance to me 😊. I can't tell how many songs I recognized from vaguely hearing them before and how many were familliar from my very late at night preliminary listen. Iconic but kinda drags.

I listened to this album while patrolling around GRPSTC, a training center for firefighters and police officers, and while driving around the desert roads surrounding it. I looked at pictures of firefighters on the walls and I thought about my father. While I don't have enough experience with metal to make any declarative statement on my feelings towards it, I can at least feel pretty comfortable saying that this Metallica album just represents a version of metal which doesn't do much for me personally. There are of course some incredible songs here, and I can respect and appreciate the power and atmosphere of this entire album, but I still find myself feeling a little left out by metal as a genre. We'll see how that relationship changes throughout this list. It also seems to be a coin flip as to whether or not I'll find the lyrics of any given song endearing and catchy or kinda hokey, and while that doesn't completely make or break songs for me, it definitely doesn't help. Though with all that said, Enter Sandman is still an all-time song. Highlights: Enter Sandman, Sad But True, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam, Of Wolf And Man

Naturally we all have our problem genres - country, jazz, 80's. For me the big one is classic metal. Great production on this album, every word, note, drum hit crystal clear, love the war drum throughout, and I rarely turn down a screaming guitar solo, but the damn music, yeah, no. One of my hopes and goals over the next 900 albums might be a respectful appreciation for a couple high water mark metal albums, this one included.

I used to listen to Metallica in high school - mainly Ride the Lightning (my favourite album of theirs). I definitely listened to Enter Sandman many times back then too. They are talented, but I find that I really don't connect with their music all that much as an adult and just can't get into it now. I still enjoy some of their songs though, like Nothing Else Matters. Miley Cyrus performed the song with Metallica a few times ~4 years ago and absolutely killed the vocals!

If I would have gotten a tattoo when I was a teenager. It probably would’ve been a Metallica tattoo. Well I’m glad I didn’t do that. I still really enjoy their music. The black album is full of classics that I found sent me back in time. I owned this album on CD and would have played it on my school bus with my friends with my disc man and portable speakers many times. Personally I’m a bigger fan of their albums that were released before this one. But you cannot deny the mass popularity of practically every track on this album. I look forward to listening to the other three albums Metallica has on this list with you all.

Phenomenal album. Some very high highs on here, those being Enter Sandman, Holier than Thou, and my personal favorite Nothing Else Matters. That song gets a 10/10 from me, love the melancholic sound, then slowly building into a sort of righteousness and then in comes this epic ballad of a guitar solo later in 🤘. The one thing I really liked about this compared to other Metal of the same genre and age is that Metallica knows how to push n pull, which makes those forceful driving guitar sections drive so much harder than if they were going at it for the duration of the album. Compared to someone like Judas Priest, where it felt like there was only one speed, a 40 lb boulder taped to the gas pedal sort of speed. Juxtaposition and range adds a LOT to an album, and this album had both, although, I was still wanting just a bit more range by the end of things. I think what's holding me back from giving this 5 stars is that lack of diversity, as some of the songs did seem to follow a similar formula. But I could potentially see this album growing into a 5 with more listens. There's something about the album art and song names that I also really liked. It all had an ominous vibe to it which added to the overall packaging of the album. 8.5/10

If I was eating the music, this would be a solid 4. It's good, but I don't know about 5 good. With that said, this is arguably the most influential album in metal history. The talent is there and it shows a side of metal that was well ahead of its time.

Metal is not my favorite genre, but for me this feels just like the type of rock I usually listen to. It's not so metal that it's unlistenable, but it is distinct. I already knew a few songs and they are as good as ever. The album as a whole is amazing. The singing is really good and the instrumentals are amazing. Just a really good album.

it's not bad but i personally don't like it (( all songs sound almost the same

2 or 3 songs are forever burned in my brain thanks to KROQ always on in my dads truck as a kid. Still not my thing

I've heard almost all these songs before, but somehow I missed out on hearing the album as one thing. It's so good, so well crafted and diverse for the genre. Easy listening today. It's written intelligently, performed well, and despite the long songs it doesn't struggle to maintain my attention. The tones are so good. The guitars have such a dynamic range and it works so seamlessly. Everything has the space to shine in the mix as well - very well produced. There are only a couple songs that aren't total bangers, and even those are still darn good and sound as good as anything else on here. I'd never heard Through the Never before and it surprised me, I love the melody in that song. 4.4/5

This was an album that I came to fairly late when getting into Metallica, and it's perhaps resultantly one that I don't have as much enthusiasm for compared to others in their catalogue. I'm loathe to be one of those "tHeY WeNt rAdIo MeTaL" types - there are undoubtedly some great moments on here amongst the more mid-tempo, groovy floor fillers, but there is a fair amount of fat you have to hack away at to get to the juicy innards, and I'm consistently left wanting for the breakneck speed and unpredictability of their earlier works. When the album does opt to pick up the pace somewhat, the attempts to do so feel somewhat misguided, lacking and/or forced, and much of the rest drones on a bit too much for my liking in a homogenous fashion.

Album #24: Metallica Genre (W): Heavy metal Singles: Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters, Wherever I May Roam, Sad but True I have heard ES, TU, NEM, WIMR, SbT, and Of Wolf and Man, but I have not listened to the full album. Thoughts?: What an iconic album to listen to, I can’t wait to hear the deeper cuts on it. Enter Sandman is one of the greatest metal songs of all time! One of my favorite parts about Metallica is their riffs and solos, plus the tight and intricate compositions behind their music, especially heard on this album. Even though it’s softer than their other albums, I feel as though that was for the best, because as a result, they gained more knowledge about their music. Wherever I May Roam has the best intro, by far. This is one of my favorite albums so far! On top of the others I gave a five star. Favorite songs: All of it!!

Chill af album already listened alot

I'm an old metal head & love Metallica. But because of commercial overplayed I haven't listen to this album in it's entirety in 20 years. I kept my "no skip" word & listened to it. & I'm glad I did. It's a great album. It still stands on its own. I was reminded that there are some hidden gems in here you don't hear anywhere like the god that failed, my friend of misery, Of wolf and man, Through the never. Plus Kirk Hammett kicks ass all over this record!!

Kinda fun as a collection of dumb metal tracks, but a little weaker as an album. Everything on here is very formulaic structurally, but the formula is strong enough to keep it afloat.

To me Metallica died with Cliff Burton. This is a solid, but bit boring hard rock album. Seems like the band lost their edge after ...and justice for all... (which of course was done without Cliff, but his spirit still seemed to linger around).

This album still works simply because I love it. Which actually made me wonder why I haven’t listened to it properly, front to back, in years. I did consider knocking off a star out of pure habit—the idea that albums you played to death back in the day should be punished for it. But honestly, that logic falls apart the moment this thing starts playing.

Metallica lost me at ...And Justice. It was already not what I expected, feeling like stadion oriented hard rock instead of the aggression that got me hooked on to the band in the first place. This is just more of the same, but in even more polished fashion, all of the edge gone and rough as fine porcelain.

When this came out it was a shock to those of us that were already Metallica fans, the long, intricate arrangements were gone - which sucked, but the album sounded so good. Ultimately, I think everyone came around to the greatness of this record - much credit to Bob Rock for the production.