Reviews (page 8 of 9)
Made me feel weird
I really wanted to like this - the idea of a group of German oddball electronica pioneers doing an album celebrating a railway service is just ace. Evidently a hugely influential album, but had no fun listening to it at all. Prime cut: Showroom Dummies
Semi chill
I don’t have much to say about this that I didn’t say about their other albums. Their music aged gracefully because they played to the strengths of the technology rather than using it to try and replace traditional instruments
Ebic
Pretty dull honestly. Nothing exciting at all. If you want extremely mellow techno beats with little to no variation, this is for you. Otherwise, pass.
I really enjoyed this. Not something I would go to on a daily basis, but I liked it!
Mye kult, men ikke deres sterkeste album.
Magnificence
So weirdly repetitive that it almost put me in a trance.
Well, massive transport is my jam to this is definitely better than autobahn no doubt. The sound is more rich than that one as well.
too repetitive
Most remarkable to me is how this band made all this electronic music in the 70s. Maybe it was more common than I thought, but when I think of 70s music -- a decade with some of my favorite music in several genres -- electronic music doesn't come to mind, probably because I equate it with the Digital Age we now live in. That could be due to my own ignorance, I'm sure. Either way, this is interesting music. Quite a departure from my usual listening fare, which is what this project is all about and I dig that.
Not a fan, very eccentric sound. Old school electronic music, kinda daft punk vibes but not able to jam-out along with it. 3/10
definitely not the biggest fan of electronic music, so keep in mind that my opinion is most likely biased against this album.
So this album has 2 reviews from me. Listened in the morning and didn't really know what to think. Can't say I enjoyed, nor disliked. Definitely different. Liked Hall of mirrors and thought, not for me. Then, on my back porch after a few beers and a few hits of weed, I was listening to music, enjoying the wild life and I went back to this album. With a good, relaxing buzz, this was a decent album. Original rating 1 Follow up 2 to 2.5 May trip on shrooms Saturday and give it another listen. Haha.
4 The dudes at Green Light are huge Kraftwerk fans so I’d heard a few albums in the background working or whatever but I never ended up listening to them on my own. I know how influential Kraftwerk was to house and techno music because of how many artists credit them, hell you can absolutely hear Daft Punk in a lot of this. However when this album first started I was worried again. Worried about an experimental boop boop album with little variety. What I got was a lot more entertaining. The songs definitely ran long but a lot of times I didn’t notice and was surprised that it’d been 7+ minutes. My only complaint is that it could benefit from a low end rework. It’s a little sharp on the ears. Maybe also that I keep thinking the cover is a golf club. The worlds this album took my imagination to were fun, vibrant and a little spooky. Def going to look into these guys more. Turns out the dudes at Green Light know what they’re talking about sometimes. Favorites: Europe Endless, Hall of Mirrors, Showroom Dummies, Trans-Europe Express, Endless Endless
3 This album feels ahead of its time being released in the 70s, and I can see how it would influence a number of artists in the coming decade. In some ways, it felt like a more electronic Joy Division (reinforced when my Spotify jumped to the band after the album concluded), and it's as cold and industrial as I could only expect from German music. Truthfully, I'm not entirely sure how I felt about this one. I think I liked it, but there's not a ton to say as there are really only six tracks if you count Trans-Europe Express and the two songs after it as one song (I do). I could see myself listening again, but I think it's a little too emotionally-devoid to be something I could get too attached to... in this case, I think I'm more of a fan of the artists they influenced. Favorite songs: Europe Endless, The Hall of Mirrors, Trans-Europe Express
Meh. Not fan of electronic music
Ei missään tapauksessa yhtä paska kuin edellinen eikä tällä kertaa korvat alkanut vuotamaan verta. Ei silti mitään asiaa omille soittolistoille joten Krafvärkki saa omasta puolesta painua unholaan.
Ei pettänyt. Tosin pisteitä vähän nosti, kun tajusin, että Planet Rockin sample on Kraftwerkin alunperin
Not a fan of whatever that is? Techno but ill try anything.
Como siempre pasa, viendolo a la distancia suena como un disco muy experimental, de todos modos es un gran disco.
fine
One of the building blocks of electronic music as it exists today. Through repetition and careful choice of effects and arrangements, there arises an interesting texture that really does replicate traveling through Europe via train.
This was god awful. Beyond awful. Beep boop and repeat the same line over and over for 6-8 minutes. So happy when it was over.
Pretty good
I like trains
ikkje lika bra som autobahn
Nesten på høyde med Die Mensch-Machine og Radioaktivität
Zeer typische sound. Je haalt ze er zo uit. Ondanks dat dit niet mijn favoriete genre is, erken ik wel dat dit pioniers in hun vak zijn
If I hear the phrase “Showroom Dummies” or “Trans-Europe Express” again I’m going to lose my mind. Most songs are just the same phrase repeated over and over. Early electronica is pretty important and was influential in a lot of mainstream artists as well as development of synths in the 80’s but the album feels so mechanical and dull. 2/5
Repetitive, detailed, more to it than you get on a first listen. Great!
The first four tracks here average 8 minutes long, probably intentionally to give a feel of droning and dragging. This album is an early venture into electronic music, and it sounds like pink floyd, zelda, and daft punk had a kid. Most of these tracks aren't super exciting, but it makes sense this album was influential ~50 years ago. The final few tracks were very interesting, implying the railway is endless (& the end of the album flows directly into the beginning again). I don't plan on listening again but I wouldn't recommend against listening to this album.
Through the years, I have tried to listen to Kraftwerk, but struggled to get into electronica. I feel now, I'm more patient and open to other musical styles and genres, so I can understand and appreciate the music more than before. Good background music, but my patience is tested after prolonged listening. Solid record.
Weird electronica album. Probably not a repeat listen. Chord changes were occasionally interesting, but the music didn’t draw me in
not for me
Not good - dull droney boring
Still phenomenal.
Does not stand the test of time.
Coooool
meh, is not my style
Kraftwerk proves how to make good train station music. Favorites: "Europe Endless", "The Hall of Mirrors", "Trans-Europe Express"
I just thought this was funny. It made me laugh because of how german it sounded but in no way did I think it was influential.
Honestly it's kind of hilarious; I feel like it's almost a self-parody. "The Hall of Mirrors" really? .... "even the greatest stars....dislike themselves in the looking glahhhss...." LOL. I actually don't hate it - it's just... and i hate using this lazy word but ... BORING. I can't see ever putting this on voluntarily other than when my German former college roommate visits for a laugh. Minimalist electronica - kinda cool at times, but extremely repetitive and too tiring for any active listening. 3/10 2 stars.
Europa Endlos
Holy SYNTHS Batman! Fascinating topic and lyrics. It’s very atmospheric. Surprisingly since it uses REALLY BASIC synths off what seems like a CASIO keyboard, it’s really well produced and doesn’t sound dated. Though the songs are fascinating and have bizarre lyrics, there is a bit of reliance on repetition - I don’t mind that, but I can understand some not liking that - it can make the songs feel quite long compared to your standard 3 minute pop fare. There’s a couple too many songs that are a bit too long and repetitive though… I like this album as it’s so different, but would skip a few tracks on repeat listens 6/10
Somehow, this all works. I get that Kraftwerk is beyond inspirational, and I'm pleased to have listened to this uninterrupted. But I'll probably file this under "Enjoyed, it's good, and I'll probably never seek it out again".
Not for me. I can see the artistic merit in it, but I did not feel cool listening to this. I felt like the kid in highschool who thinks his music taste is so superior to his peers. Highlights were the title track. It’s fine, has some solid moments, but I’m really not sure I will ever come back to this one.
Interesting album but not really my taste - a bit monotone
Repetitive. I get it; it's just not for me.
Trans Europe Express is quirky and would've been well original back when it came out but it's not really for me, it's all a little bit too low key, I want in your face loud bombastic electronica. A high 2/5.
This is a really interesting listen, but I don't really like it. Must've been groundbreaking in 1977, and probably was the grandfather of a lot of music that I like more than this, but it's just a bit too weird for me. It's all very repetitive, and really creepy. I did quite like The Hall of Mirrors for its over the top creepiness, that felt quite clever, but the rest is just creepy without being OTT. 3/5 for me, it's clever, well-done and clearly groundbreaking, but not that enjoyable.
Like a more subdued Daft Punk. Good beats, but not a lot of variety or progression of the melody.
A little repetitive industrial for my taste. Still enjoyable, but in small doses. Full album was a hard listen and I found myself being annoyed at parts.
Inspirational. It’s incredible a couple of people created these sounds almost out of nowhere. I respect what Kraftwerk was able to do, but not my style
One of those albums that set the stage for future artists in multiple genres. An electronic album that showed what was possible with the technology at the time and proved that you could be experimental and successful. Hall of Mirrors sticks out as being incredibly ominous and unsettling but in a good way. Otherwise electronic music is not my forte and I don't see myself coming back to this album.
This is the sixth album from German electronic band Kraftwerk. It continued a transition away from their earlier krautrock music towards melodic electronic music, and this new style of music was polished with a focus on rhythms and minimalism. The theme of this album was tied to the Trans-Europe Express, and the thought that this could be some of the future's music one would listen to when riding on a train across the country. The album has a haunting atmosphere due to the electronic sounds and sparse but manipulated vocals. This album sounds wonderful, is timeless, danceable, and not quite intrusive enough to take the listener's focus away from a task or event. It could be called the birth certificate of true electronic music. Since I have a soft spot for EDM, this album made me feel nostalgic for the times when musicians were first experimenting with these sounds. It's crazy to imagine what would have happened if this music never caught on with the general public. In conclusion, this album is extraordinary and may stand the test of time by being just popular enough to stay relevant forever.
The songs are funky and cool. I might listen again, but I don’t know because the songs feel “endless endless,” the first ones both being 7 minutes long of similar stuff, making it kind of hard to enjoy. But hey, good music to be a robot to.
Loved this techno.... Very clean! Would listen to again
Fav songs: - The Hall of Mirrors - Showroom Dummies - Trans-Europe Express
I love it! I can't believe they were doing this in 77.
It’s totally fine. It’s early electronica that’s well done. It’s not really my cup of tea. I will say for fans of electronic music they’ll find the origins of everything the genre brings.
Not as bad as Autobahn but still not for me.
Nonstop.
fucking amazing electronic I love Kraftwerk favorite song is probably Showroom Dummies, but the whole album’s great - 10/10
Det här kan mycket väl vara det bästa som någonsin släppts. Det är, fulländat.
Haven’t heard for ages. Was good in its time.
Liked this. Didn't love it. TRANS EUROPE EXPRESS TRANS EUROPE EXPRESS TRANS EUROPE EXPRESS I liked some of the songs more than others though. Highlights: Hall of mirrors Showroom Dummies Franz Schubert 3/5
Vocals suck but the electronics are generally really cool. Could see how this was really influential for its time.
Kraftwerk is the shit. I don’t really have more to add besides side 2>side 1 B
considering this is released in 1977 pretty advanced electronic album
I guess you could see this was influential, since Daft Punk and a hundred other clones straight up copied them, but that doesn't make this good. Best track: Franz Schubert
3 stars only because i was starting an astronomy research job while i listened to it and it made me feel like a techy little robot
Another album my brother turned up with in the 80s, no clue how he got onto them. I listened to it quite a bit, over 30 years ago, and not at all since. Surprised to find I remembered it very well, and I think that lasting impression says something about it. It really is iconic, and was a big part of so many foundations of electronica that were set down around those times. I have to dun it slightly for the lyrics being so mundane, even though I think this is an intentional choice.
I can see how that would be groundbreaking electronic music in 1977 that would influence a lot of people to come. Not something I’d ever listen to again though.
I like trains
absolutely delightful.
Заглавная песня и ее мотив интересны. Прослеживаются и в другом треке с альбома. Группа, которая повлияла на многих культовых музыкантов, включая Боуи. Но моё сердце они растопить все же не смогли.
Pleasant electronica, evoking images of a transcontinental journey
Electrónica
I can appreciate the cold, electronic minimalism of this album’s style but I found the repetition of some of these songs grating. I like a nice long song but I need some variation or tension or drama to justify an 8 or 9-minute song length. “The Hall of Mirrors” might work for me if it was half as long. “Showroom Dummies” is a highlight. I like the dystopian imagery of people mindlessly going about their routines. It matches the severity of the music unlike the title track, which is just about catching a train? Haha the tone doesn’t match the lyrics for me. Like, lighten up, dudes. It’s just a train. Cool to hear an album that has recurring motifs but there’s not enough variation for me that I’m happy to hear the main theme come back. It just makes the long songs feel even longer. I can imagine this being an influential band / album for a lot of artists. I can definitely hear Daft Punk drawing influence from them. The other album I hear in this is Kanye’s “808s & Heartbreak.” This album had to have been on the mood board when he produced that album. The mostly instrumental “Franz Schubert” is another highlight. Really beautiful.
Looking at the year of release, this must have been SUPER ahead of its time in the electronic world, and probably disturbed a lot of people (in the best way). I enjoyed listening, and I know that the genre itself tends to be repetitive, and trains have that chug-a-chug-a feel... but I think it was pushing the limits of an intense space train trance and moving into nauseating-spinning-ride-that-won't-stop territory.
I lost my writeup (second time this week!) due to a computer overnight restart and the website not saving my text so this will be short. I liked it, I think the big thing with them is that they were THE pioneers of electronic music. What is cool about this album is that it's actually listenable and easy to enjoy though. I think sometimes pioneers of genres are good at making something new but are not always the best at refining the sound, but to me this album sounds breaks that stereotype and gives us music that is not ONLY experimental or new. The only downside is that it's pretty minimalistic and can get repetitive.
Leip album die beter weg luisterde als gedacht
Love this album, smooth elegance electronica.
Not gonna lie - a lot of this music sounds like the old light parade music at Disney World. There is nothing egregiously bad here. It's just not my cup of tea. I found myself really hoping the album would be done.
I really loved this and can’t believe this was 1977. Hearing the sounds that influenced so many of my favorite 80s bands was a real treat.
This album is kinda exactly like the previous one. I don't find it good, but I know its great. So many bands refer to it as being influential. It was nice background music for my work day. Just not my cup of tea.
Mega drive music
My God that was boring!
I like the ideas and concept of this album. However, I don't really like the sounds or the way they went about achieving those ideas. The synths/electronic part of it sounded really great for the most part, but the rest of it (the voices, samples, etc.) did not agree with me. Favorite track: Europe Endless
Not my favorite Kraftwerk album, but if you like their other albums, maybe you'll like this one too. Highlights: 1, and 2.
1st April 2022 Listened throughout the day while working from home home. Mary Ruth and Stephen came round in the evening and we had biryani. Really liked the opening track and I appreciate Kraftwerk as a cultural institution but wouldn’t sit and listen to hours of them. Would love to see them live though.
Weird but interesting.
Such a classic, influential album. Not something I listen to regularly, but when I do I am impressed every time. Any fan of electronic music should listen to this!
Why, dear God, WHY are there SO MANY KRAFTWERK ALBUMS on this list?! "Trans Europe Express" is easily one of the most repetitive and boring albums I've ever had the displeasure of listening to. The whole album is an endless loop of arpeggiated synths over boring beats periodically broken up by repetitive vocals. The title track is essentially 6 and a half minutes of phase-filtered synthetic drums, people chanting "Trans-Europe Express" and an out-of-context mention of David Bowie. It's mind-boggling to me that this is considered by anyone to be worthy of inclusion on the list. The listening experience was utterly angering.
Not for me pals
The motifs are super catchy on this album, and the songs are quite hypnotic. It's of course very repetitive but feels more carefully structured musically and conceptually than Autobahn for example, which veered off after the title track for me. There's also much more of an emotional range than you get with most Kraftwerk, even though it's still veiled by this robotic coldness
I desperately need some indie video game developer to make a spooky 2D metroidvania using this album as the score.
Okay yeah this album is pretty amazing. I would do a 4.5 if I could, but since I can't, I rounded down in order to preserve the integrity of 5/5. Considering individual tracks (which is maybe not a great thing to do for an album like this, but nevertheless): -Spiegelsaal is my favourite track. Very cool. -Schaufensterpuppen is great, but it is an obvious ripoff of t.A.T.u's song "They're Not Gonna Get us". Very disappointing that Kraftwerk would stoop to thievery. -Abzug is maybe the only track that didn't do it for me.
Solid. I do enjoy Euro electronic. You can clearly hear the influence they’ve had on the genre
Is this what it’s like to live in an 80s video game?
Awwww yiss. I fucking love this album, but I am happy to rediscover that fact.
I don't know why but I love this album. It's great. Fun sounds, cool german accents saying the same words over and over again. So amazing! I think my favourite tracks are Europe Endless and The Hall of Mirrors.
I am a fan of Trance and Techno and even I couldn’t follow this one. Maybe it was cause I was high, but I would argue that if anything it would have had a positive affect. Instead I it felt like I was at a weird NY one man show listening to an artistic interpretation of how someone was on a train.
My ears may never forgive me
Hmmmmm. Cold. Groundbreaking, but ultimately not a great listen.
J'ai évidemment comme vous tous profité de cet album pour régler les périphériques audio de mon ordinateur ASUS. Pour ce faire, j'ai appuyé sur le bouton Windows, suis allé dans Paramètres, ai cliqué sur Son, puis sur le menu déroulant et ai sélectionné mes écouteurs. J'ai ensuite testé le son: « Un, deux, un deux… » Une fois ceci effectué, j'ai téléchargé plusieurs "drivers" via l'onglet Mise à jour et sécurité puis ai redémarré mon ordinateur.
J'ai une histoire assez particulière avec cet album de Kraftwerk que je vais vous raconter brièvement. Il y a de cela 2 ans et demi, je démarrait mon nouvel emploi dans une grande entreprise internationale par une journée d'intégration. Après nous avoir donné deux trois généralités au sujet de l'entreprise et des locaux, du matériel informatique fut distribué à chacun d'entre nous. Une fois tout le monde servi, il était temps de tester le matériel. Tout d'abord l'ordinateur portable, qui après quelques manipulations fût rapidement allumé sur le bureau de chacune des nouvelles recrues. C'est alors qu'un intervenant passa dans les rangs, distribuant le CD "Trans Europe Express" de Kraftwerk à chacun des employés. Il nous fut alors demandé d'insérer le CD dans le lecteur de l'ordinateur prévu à cet effet, et de nous équiper de notre casque audio. Après 40m d'écoute, l'intégralité du systéme audio était parfaitement réglée, et aucun bruit parasite ne venait entâcher l'écoute. Cela fait donc 2 ans et demi que cette anecdote a eu lieu, et je ne déplore pas le moindre soucis acoustique depuis cette date.
Brutal!! Me ha encantado. Discazo
Un dels pics de la protoelectrònica. 'Europe Endless' i el tema títol són dos dels grans temes que donarien força al génere als seus albors. Però és 'Hall of Mirrors' on excel.leixen; tema hipnòtic amb una melodia brillant que tal com la vesteixen t'acaba absorbint per complet. Molt a prop de les 5 estrelles
Listened to the German version. I liked it a lot, it pulled me in and felt shorter than it is.
Beautifully krafted werk! Have never listened to Kraftwerk album before.This felt like a symphony for celebration of Europe constructed on a synth. Really innovative and enjoyable record. Strong 4 to Light 5. Most Favourite tracks: Europe Endless The Hall of Mirrors Trans-Europe Express Franz Schubert
duh
Definitely not my kind of album. Gave me a headache. Pass.
It has some cool stuff in there.
Sounds dated now.
Nah dog thats a no for me
Weird electro shit. I wasn't amused when I saw it opened with 4 songs over half an hour and I couldn't see how I'd make it through, but somehow I did. This gets 2 stars from me. Monotoned to say the least.
Most interesting thing to me is how this influenced the likes of OMD, Soft Cell, Depeche Mode and so on. It's advanced synth work for 1977 but the sparse arrangements make for hard listening.
These guys were so damn cool!
Muito bom.
Smá legacy bónus hér á ferðinni, er betri í sögulegu samhengi en úr því. En samt ánægjuleg hlustun heilt á litið, og titillagið er frábært.
I had to listen several times before I could decide what to make of it. It’s not immediately engaging but after a while it becomes quite mesmerising/almost hypnotic.
Pop con sintetizadores muy machacón y tostón. Un 2.
Un poco monótono, pero bueno, escuchable, electrónico, curioso.
I think this is the first album of this project that I’d actually listened to all the way through before. This is an excellent album, hugely influential, ahead of its time/invented the time. For how stripped-down it sounds compared to later electronic music, it still manages to be really sentimental.
Kraftwerk deserves its place in the history books, but this isn’t its best album. Not that it matters: fine music is made of these.
Sometimes when I listen to Kraftwerk they sound to silly for me, and the album started that way, but they really had me in a trance by the end. The friendliest most seductive robots.
This may be their most refined and engaging album. It feels very conceptually unified as they begin to focus more on something closer to pop song structures with lyrics, at least on Side A. The fluid 3-track song suite of Trans Europe Express / Metal on Metal / Abzug on Side B is like a mini railway version of their masterpiece Autobahn, but with a much funkier beat. Quite a ride. This album is also a big step for them in becoming the robots they were destined to be in Showroom Dummies. And I must say I geek out every time when they name check their real life rendezvous with Bowie and Iggy on the title track. Absolutely historic. They were electronic music pioneers who were so far ahead of their time that they were essentially in a league of their own. You may not dig their schtick, hell, you may not even care for electronic music whatsoever, but, like it or not, these affectless Germans changed the sonic possibilities for music across multiple genres, some of which they nearly single handedly created. Hard to pick a favorite album by them but this just may be it for me.
Iconic. Most people are not aware of Kraftwerk and their ground-breaking electronic style that wasn't really done. The inhumanness goes so far it wraps around and becomes somehow human. Only song I'm not a fan of is "Showroom Dumimes". 4.5 to 5.
Beautiful sometimes uncomfortable listening. How can an album so subdued make me feel so anxious? The layered sounds, pioneering synth lines and monotone vocals of Trans-Europe Express are a master work. This is another album that is so influential I find it hard to imagine what it would have been like to be one of the artists inspired by it hearing it for the first time.
Pioneering
Este album ha sido súper influyente. Esto está... Está guapo
The first track sounds like something that would be in the soundtrack for an indie pixel art game but after that the repetitive basic electronic music got annoying
great stuff. continued listening to more albums.
zovite policiju jer ovo je kriminalno! minimalizam koji toliko forsiraju su pritvorili u monotoniju, divin se sebi jer san poslušala cili album
The Hall of Mirrors tiene sonidos muy interesantes y dado que el disco es de 1977 seguramente lograr todas las piezas de esta obra no fue tarea sencilla. Parece un disco muy experimental y claro que es un referente en la música electrónica. El género no es de mi agrado y sí necesito forzarme a escucharlo. 2.5 estrellas que dejo en 2 porque no lo disfruté realmente.
No es lo mío. Quizá en su momento tuvo su mucho mérito por innovar con las cajas de ritmos y sintetizadores, pero en verdad no lo siento. Mucha repetición en todos los niveles y sin llegar a verdaderos clímax más allá de el acorde que va armándose: tan TAN TAAAAN TAAAAAAAAAAAAN.
Take a ride on the T.E.E. Express. It is retro, but also futuristic. It is idealistic but also kind of unsettling. It is a 10/10 but still not even my personal favorite Kraftwerk record. R.I.P. Florian Schneider
This style of music I just bounce off. I know Kraftwerk is influential and all, but I just can't get into it.
Lovely, dreamy electro pop. Minimalistic sounds but gorgeously layered. 5/5 stars
Very listenable electronic music from some early German innovators.
This is so much better and enjoyable than I expected!!!
I liked it
Never been into Kraftwerk so was not expecting to enjoy this. Of course this was a pioneering time for electronic music and I see this albums place in history but a lot of it sounds like sub-minimalism to me. See what Steve Reich was doing way before this! I did enjoy the title track but not really my bag.
very 80s synthesizer sound.
cool!
Interesting to listen to this right after Radiohead. Definitely a through-line between them. This isn't my favorite Kraftwerk album though...
Mm
Phenomenal, still comes in just behind Autobahn for my favourite of theirs but it's close.
Not too enjoyable, kind of for the same reasons the Royksopp record didn't work for me. Just nothing that I really connected with, and on top of that I found it quite repetitive. Didn't even finish this one honestly.
Ik had 'm intenser verwacht
Pioneering it may have been but it doesn't really stand up today. Repetition underpins this type of music and it comes down to length and the motifs. In both case this album fails.
All these tracks are about a minute too long and begin very similarly. Kinda remind me of iPhone alarms.
Not my taste, but I apreciate the cultural significance.
det er så godt det her
Elektronisk, konceptuelt, hypnotiserende, dystert
..
Listening to this was like being tortured… would rather be tortured than listen to this beeping mess again
Endless Endless is accurate
Great album about J K Rowling's least favourite train
It's ok just a bit dull
2nd time I've tried them. Recognize some samples but overall repetitive and depressing and almost lampoonish.
Noooo! Synthpop... This was the most painful listen so far. Ja ja ja, mach schnell mit der art things, huh? I must get back to Dancecentrum in Struttgart in time to see Kraftwerk.
Interesting and old school.
My kids: this sounds weird
I liked this without loving it. It feels like a darker, more forbidding counterpart to Autobahn. I think I would need to be in the mood for something this downbeat, whilst the serene, gliding rhythms of Autobahn went down far easier.
Knew a few songs from samples and was better than the other techno album I had. I’d maybe give it another listen
Not my cup of tea.
Muy bueno
Very disappointing, everything on it is slow and simplistic, homogenous, boring record. Almost gave it two stars because I started liking a song toward the end of the record and then it just ended. Lame.
Feel like I would have liked this kind of thing when I was in 7th grade so everyone would be impressed with how random I am. As an adult, I liked "The Hall of Mirrors" but everything else was fairly unremarkable.
Not really a fan of this album. It's too electronic for my taste. Europe Endless wasn't too bad though.
Oof Not a fan of this one. Whole album sounded the same. Recognized some of the bops but not my favorite
Not bad listening in the background.
Good electronica
It is such a great album and love the early electronics and rhythms, along with the German flair in Kraftwerk's vocals. Listening to this made me want to catch a train in the middle of the night in the city. A very essential listen. Trans Europe Express to Abzug was perfection and its chant felt like a powerful mantra. Have to say though, the German version was better and in partitcular, so were the live versions of Hall of Mirrors and Showroom Dummies in 1981. Fun Fact: Dr Dre playing a live version of Metal on Metal at the beginning of Defiant Ones effectively prescribed me to Kraftwerk and this album.
Not Kraftwerk's best. Barebones, repetitive, and uninspiring. A very long ride for an album about fast trains...
Bad
Storico
Nice
Cool, hard to believe it was made in the 70s
Kraftwerk are the great pioneers of electronic music, weaving their synthesizers, vocoders, and electric drums to make the sounds of the future, and this album demonstrates that in spades. Intrinsically unique is the group's background, growing up in a unique musical vacuum post-WWII. This pushed Kraftwerk to innovate and developed the gran new genre of Electronic music, embracing the cold, calculated sounds of synthesizers. I love the little ambient arpeggiated synth line in "Spiegelsaal" especially, so cool. There's also Iggy Pop and David Bowie influence on this album, but it's a lot more subtle than other contemporaries of the 70's.
Imponerende men ensformigt
un viaggio, minimale, con uno zaino, in giro per l'Europa, con quei due amici inseparabili. così vedo nella mia mente questo disco
2 Kraftwek albums in a row.... Wtf are you doing to me. These sound exactly the same. Like crap.
Fun background music. Not my favorite thing but good beat and enjoyable to listen to.
Kraftwerk opens this album with sparkly electronic synths reminiscent of 8-bit games that would later be invented years after its release. A display of their visionary status in the 1970s music industry milieu, 'Trans-Europe Express' (album) implements simple beats and minimal production that is perhaps more contemporary and innovative at the time. Despite this, Kraftwerk fundamentally misses the target - static and uniform composition that manages to revel only in its past glory, of being first to experiment with the digital medium.
Not a fan. Except for the trans Europe Express song. This album sucks.
Started out pretty cool but turned out to be repetitive and boring. Kept going and going. Was happy when it ended.
Very interesting look into the then-emerging euro electronic music vibe of the late 1970s. Very omnious and creepy sounding at parts, I can understand why people may have felt off or uncomfortable with the sound. At times minimalist and very formulaic with lots of four-loops and subtle changes and additions to the loop.
I liked it for the first 2 songs! Each song was repetitive and didn't change enough to warrant their length sometimes. I thought the vibe was cool.
TRANS. EUROPE. EXPRESS! Men se sviđa ovaj album, općenito oni su pojava. Drugačiji su bili, glavni u ovom pokretu glazbe. Elektrosintpopičko stvaranje uz mrvice techna. Sitnica koja mi se sviđa u vezi albuma je to što je kraj albuma povezan sa početkom albuma. Isto tako podsjeća na Pink Floydovog Zidnog albuma. Pa kaže: TRANS. EUROPE. EXPRESS.
U 8-bit vlaku prolazim kroz polja Europske prirode. :) ENO TULIPANI! PRODUŽIT ĆEMO ONDA DO FRANCUSKE DO BIG SERPENTA PA MALO ISTRAŽIT. Da, to su mi želje.
Tedious, sterile and joyless. I really don't understand the appeal of this music - except maybe as a background, ambient sound. Felt a lot longer than 43 minutes.
Kraftwerk are pioneers of the electronic music scene and any of their albums merits a spot on this list, without a doubt! The core of the album is the openning track (Europe Endless), and then tracks 4 through 8 ('Trans-Europe Express' through 'Endless Endless'). If you consider those 6 tracks alone and played in order, it's really two musical movements. When I listen to those 6 songs together, I hear it like a musical interpretation of a trans-european train ride. The themes slowly ebb and flow, much like the scenary would out the window of the train. Where you end is much like where you started, but there is just enough variation to make it feel all its own. The other two tracks ('The Hall of Mirrors' and 'Showroom Dummies') are more like single b-sides that were tossed into the album. The seriousness of 'The Hall of Mirrors' stands in sharp contrast to the nearly humourous 'Showroom Dummies'. Both are enjoyable tracks, but they seem a bit out of place. This album provides a great trip through the state of the art for early days electronic music.
Really love the early synthesizer sound. Europe Endless is my fav. Great background music (which I guess is what ambient type music tries to be). Rating gets docked for lacked of diversity...too much of the album is just a riff on the TEE staple. 4/5
it's okay - I just can't get into Kraftwerk....and I like techno.
Stunning example of electronica. Completely game changing - who knew that Germans could be so cool ;)
Put Your Quarter Up! Planet Rock! It's a beautiful thing.
Innovative sounds
What's not to love about Kraftwerk? Groundbreaking electronic music and German accents! I've been a fan since a very young age. The Siouxie and the Banshees version of "Hall of Mirrors" was an important moody college song, but sounds positively jaunty next to Kraftwerk's masterpiece of existential dread, which leads nicely to "Showroom Dummies." We are all showroom dummies; "we go into a club, and there we start to dance." I never had this album, but "Trans Europe Express" was on a Kraftwerk collection I had, and was always a favorite of mine with its funky train beat in the background and (retroactively) futuristic feel. On a sleek, high speed train of the future, speeding through the European landscape, I'm filled with ennui and angst under this façade I'm forced to wear. Timeless perfection.
The music was curious and amusing for me. It works as an album to work by.
There's nobody that quite sounds like Kraftwerk. This is another of those bands that I appreciate and respect more than like. They're good. They're unique. They're interesting. And yet... Their music doesn't make me FEEL anything. I never have the thought, "Oh, I should listen to some Kraftwerk." This album is good. I have a hard time distinguishing between songs but I can tell that things change now and then. I find the affectless German thing quite charming and some lines stick in my head (We look around and change our pose.) I wasn't wishing for it to end but I wasn't all that disappointed when it was over, ya know? Normally, this kind of review would mean a 3-star rating from me but I'm bumping it up to 4 stars because, although I don't love them, my husband does and he doesn't love many things and so the fact that he loves Kraftwerk DOES make me feel something...happy.
I have only heard a song here and there from Kraftwerk, mostly from college friends' mixtapes back in the 80s and 90s. But that and Sprockets on Saturday Night Live were enough to give me an idea of what might be in store here... As anticipated TRANS EUROPE EXPRESS is a musical journey, long on electronic music with limited, repetitive lyrics and melodies. At times this album felt almost like a parody - then I remember that this was released in 1977 and realize that this is the source from whence those parodies sprang. "Europe Endless" takes us out of the station and rapidly zipping across the continent. The first station stop along the way is a meditative one. The reflective "The Hall of Mirrors" juxtaposes our watching ourselves with being watched by others in "Showroom Dummies." Back on the train, "Trans Europe Express" chugs out of the station and continues our journey. "Metal on Metal" continues the song - you can practically hear the train whistles. When "Abzug" starts I realize that we are still on "Trans Europe Express" despite the new song title. These three songs blend together without breaks in the music or the theme. "Franz Shubert" is a welcome change of pace after the previous song trilogy. It's a simple but very meditative song that I found not unpleasant. Like the previous three songs, this blurs seamlessly into "Endless Endless". It seems that our journey will go on... At times this album had me looking over my shoulder to make sure I wasn't being pranked, but the repetitious patterns in the songs became strangely soothing. Once one separates the memes that followed from the original, Kraftwerk's huge contribution to electronic music pull into sharp focus. I enjoyed taking this journey, but like a journey across Europe likely won't be making this a daily commute. Still it might make for great meditation or to lull you away from waking life.
a very pleasant surprise. I enjoyed it!
OK, I wrote my first review below but was still listening to it when driving across town. In the space of a mile, I encountered some staggeringly entitled arsehole drivers. I found that it actually was the perfect soundtrack to staring the patriarchy in the face with a cold, dead, unblinking stare. It's just gone from 1 to 4 stars. ---‐------------------------------------------- Yes, I know, massively influential on the electronic music genre. But this is the musical equivalent of eating 6 crackers without water. Joyless, functional and boring. I couldn't finish it. One star.
Fan of their work, not the best album
Eh, no. I wish I had more but just no.
It's Kraftwerk. Music by robots for us. Or is it music by humans for robots? Or are we all robots? I don't know. It's electronic bubbling with efficient and stern German vocals. Best Tracks: Europe Endless; Trans-Europe Express; Metal on Metal
I can see where 90s 16 bit games got inspiration from Cracking instrumentals and soundscopes!
not good bad
Absolute classic
Always always love Kraftwerk. This album is not their best one, but I love a lot of the melodies. I think I like the German language one better (fyi: every single Kraftwerk song has a German language version). The main "Trans Europe Express" melody gets over-used a lot by the end. Still a damn good time and my ears are happy.
Definitely weird but liked it better than other weird albums we’ve had so far
Awesome.
The track Franz Schubert is what plays when you ascend to heaven
A total classic! Really enjoyable listen despite some of the tracks being quite repetitive.
Have never listened to Kraftwerk before. I get where they have influenced a number of different acts, and Bowie was so big on them in the 70s. But those first couple of tracks went on WAY too long. They easily could have cut out a minute or two from each. I started to think of it as just pretentious, but I eased up and kind of “got” what they were going for. But those first few should have been trimmed, especially “Hall of Mirrors,” by at least a verse. Yikes.
Interesting sound. I had no idea who these guys were but apparently they're set to join the rock and roll hall of fame. I'm not sure I'd go that far but they have some catchy beats. I think I could probably play this as background music for a party or get-together and it wouldn't seem out of place. Not sure I could wear out a cd listening to it though. Europe Endless sort of epitomized the whole album - cool underlying beat but annoying high-pitched or distorted synth layered in. Interesting that Trans-Europe Express mentions David Bowie because I was thinking this wasn't far off from some of his "artistic expression". Not sure who inspired who. Definitely grateful I got exposed to this album and these guys, but not going to be my go to.
When I first got into music I was really into synth sounds. Early computer music (Commodore 64) and synthy TV themes from shows like Doctor Who and The Tomorrow People really appealed to young me and started me on a path of musical discovery that still continues today. You can imagine then how excited I was when I first heard Kraftwerk. I think it was even one of their stronger albums that I first heard but it hooked me right away. This album is one of their greats and really pushed the boundaries of synth music at the time. I like side 2 a little more than side one, especially the Trans Europe song cycle.
I can appreciate how ahead of its time it was, but it sounds a little cheesy today. Decent.
I could see why this wouldn't be for everyone, but i loved it. The second half was particularly good. The vocals were hit or miss for me, but i loved these sparse, iterative electronic arrangements throughout
Kraftwerk is a fascinating band. Sometimes I kinda like how primitive this sounds, other times it’s kinda cheesy. Sometimes this album is calming, sometimes it’s claustrophobic. This album is basically a soundtrack to a doc that doesn’t exist about the dangers of urbanization in Europe. It’s fascinating to think about what it must’ve been like to be born in Germany at the end of or right after WWII and then come of age and be like “wait…we did WHAT?!” It’s also interesting to think of how much music might not have existed if it weren’t for Kraftwerk.
First Listen. 2/5. Typical sound from Kraftwerk.
That's why we had synth-pop in the 80s, techno in the 90s and glitch in the 00s. And today Nintendocore. One of the first albums that charmed me with robotic rhythms and mechanical melodies. (8/10) Favourite Songs: Europa Endlos, Franz Schubert
4.0 + It's impossible to hear those first synth strains on "Europa Endlos" and not feel a swell in my chest! It makes me nostalgic for that optimistic vision of a united Europe that was going to advance humanity towards greater prosperity, peace and peace. Having listened to the English and German versions, I prefer the latter. “Schaufensterpuppen” sounds cooler than “Showroom Puppets.” Kraftwerk’s efficient and minimal production is on display, though sometimes the repetition of song elements feels “endless endless.”
Was kinda neat
There were a few moments on here that really shone- the instrumental intro really stands out. At its best it sounded like the soundtrack for an indie. Still, the vocals and lyrics were both really weak and uninspired, and I feel that it got repetitive in the middle section so I didnt really enjoy listening to it that much. I can see how it was really influential in the development electronic music, so I’ll be generous and give it a 7/10
5/10. I do not want to hear the words Tran Europe Express chanted at me ever again. Based on the title, I would have thought metal on metal would have been the most grating sounding song, but actually one of the more pleasant because I didn't have to listen to them chanting some bullshit. Still, looking past the speaking bits, the music was pretty enjoyable.
Lots of these songs sound like sorting algorithms. Generally boring, droning, and hard to get through. 4
No thank you
Not exactly my kind of music, but it grew on me. I kinda dig the minimalism.
Sehr gut
Sounds like someone dicking around on a keyboard. Almost ten minutes of this shit on the first song. Guh. Like is the fact they say "Europe. Endless." Over and over and play the same shit over and over for 10 fucking minutes supposed to be ironic? Or is it supposed to be a stab at coloratura? Europe is endless and so is this fucking song. I don't find this groundbreaking in anyway. It's sophomoric if you we're to ask me. Pedantic even. I'm not taking the right drugs. I've just seen there's a song called endless. I can't wait...
3.5/5
So supposedly this is seminal and really important but have to say I did struggle. Back in the day this blew minds, but I found it jarring a lot of the time. One or two were OK but PURELY rating on my enjoyment (rather than historical appreciation).... *2 STARS*
Good job it wasn't the Trans UK Express or it would have been overpriced, delayed, busy and the toilets would have been horrible. AMIRIGHT?
Do like kraftwerk but it does get a little repetitive
I tore thru this. I prefer Man-Machine but this album deserves 5 stars.
The opening track is great. It's insane to think that this was released in 1977 which is the same year The Clash and The Sex Pistols' released their first (only) album. Meanwhile, in 1977 the bars I was going to preferred to play that other 1977 release: Bee Gees' Saturday Night Fever. It sucks to be us! Hall of Mirrors follows and seems a little off tempo. Perhaps if I didn't listen to Siousie & The Banshees' amped up cover version first I would not think this. Kinda like how I started thinking Paul Anka's My Way was a little off tempo after hearing Sid's cover. The tempo picks up again with Showroom Dummies and the title track starts off Side 2 and keeps the goodness going. Then, much to my surprise, Franz Schuber starts. Did I lose two songs somewhere? One could say this now sounds dated, but these guys deserve kudos for bringing out these tunes in the late 70s so I feel one of their offerings should get bonus points. Arguably a subsequent album (such as Man-Machine) is more deserving.
I remember watching a hip-hop documentary a few years back and they highlighted Afrika Bambaataa’s “Planet Rock” which samples “Trans-Europe Express” quite liberally. (IMO it’s the only part of the song worth listening to). They went on to claim that this song, especially that sample, launched electro-boogie in the 90s. I remember saying to my co- judge that without Kraftwerk, no one would have heard of Afrika Bambaataa. Maybe an overstatement, but he was one of so many artists were influenced by the Kraftwerk sound. When I listen to “Hall of Mirrors” and “Showroom Dummies”, I can hear a lot of new wave/post punk bands like OMD and Simple Minds. That said, the title track runs on a bit. If you count all 3 parts, it's something like 13 minutes.
I grew up listening to Kraftwerk and it shaped my musical taste profoundly. They were so innovative in the 70s that this sound must have blown everyone’s mind. However the irony is that because they were so influential that you hear this style almost everywhere now so the their unique groundbreaking sound is lost on most new listeners. This album is great but I think Man Machine and Computer World are better so it only gets a 4 from me.
// Favs: Franz Schubert Score: Strong 2 to Light 3
Electronic German music. Synthesizers rock. I dig it.
8/10, spacey, repetitive in the best way possible, very forward thinking, very good. v good.
Agradable de escuchar. Medio electrónico. Sintetizadores.
Light on vocals, heavy on synthesizers. I can get behind this. I hope I listen to more Kraftwerk. Maybe I will. I probably won't. But it would definitely make me cooler. Great music for chugging away at work. Highlights: The feeling of listening to the same drum beat and synth sounds for 6+ minutes, and how that lures you into a trance.
I set out wanting to hate this album, but I really don't. The instrumental pieces just kinda sound like my kids are playing video games in the next room and sounds (at first) like something I could recreate in Garage Band in about five minutes. But - to my surprise - the vocals actually make these seem more like songs, not just guys playing with the synth buttons on their Casios. And - this clearly influenced a lot of popular 80s music and there are remnants of it in more recent bands (Daft Punk). I don't hate it like I thought it would, but it's still not really my bag. "Showroom Dummies" is cool. Ends on a real weird 0:56 song.
I don’t care for electronic music.
Banger and mash
Really innovative and fun. It's repetitive, but there are variations throughout. My five year old developed a dance to Trans Europe Express while wearing sunglasses. 5/5.
This felt "milder" than The Man-Machine album that came up from Kraftwerk already. Maybe more song/melody oriented? Fairly laid back.
Another really great album from Kraftwerk. I think I like this one a bit better than The Man Machine actually, especially in the vocal department.
This one was challenging to listen to the whole album. Grinds a bit on the outside of my brain.
This was an amazing trip.
80s Eurotrash beats, meh
Decidedly meh
Future vibe
Lo escuché un poco a las apuradas, pero es una banda que me gusta Como dijo Betz es un gusto adquirido. Ideal también para trabajar, me permite concentrarme. 5 efes
Een gezelliger album dan ik van Kraftwerk herinner. De moeite waard om nog eens te luisteren.
The grandfathers of electronic rock music. Lots of very familiar beats with moody Eurocentric lyrics. Album has a great flow but some of the tracks are very long and repetitive, even if the motifs never really get boring.
Liked it. respect for the technical challenges early electronic music faced
Odd. A weird, kind of magical journey. I can't quite decipher this album, but it does start to leave an impression. Unfortunately, that impression gets soured the longer the album goes on, and the longer the repetitive sections go on.
Minimalistic electronic from Germany. Sounds like a Pokemon theme track. Metal on Metal sounds like i'm on a train. Alright they gotta stop repeating trans europe express its enough (it went on for 3 songs).
Otro disco que gasté. Hoy no estoy de humor para escucharlo. Me duele la cabeza y digamos que no colabora mucho a que se me pase. Gran disco igualmente. 9/10 ludomatics.
Escuchar Kraftwerk no es sentarse a escuchar musica como haces siempre. Tenés que posicionarte en los 70 y mirar hacia este lado del charco. TEE se hizo cuando acá se cantaba pata pata la escena de la musica nacional se preparaba para explotar. Es inocente, despojada de complejidad y terriblemente exacta. Te dicen Kraftwerk y escuchás como suena y decis "si, a esto me suena la palabra Kraftwerk". Si bien no es mi disco favorito de ellos (Computerwelt y Die Mensch-Maschine por si se lo preguntan), es un disco mega significativo. La tematica de la musica es sobre cosas que cuando mirás para atrás suenan re simples y basicas, pero cuando lo contextualizas, tematizaban con la vanguardia de lo que estaba sucediendo. El Tour de France, la radioactiviad, un tren que cruza todo europa, robotica, computacion... De ahi viene la inocencia con la que hicieron musica y la forma en la que suena. Hoy pasarían como ringtones polifonicos. Inventaron la musica electronica. Sin ésto, no hay Tiesto, no hay David Guetta, no hay nada. And that's something. ...Que increible que en los 70's estos tipos hablaban de un tren que iba a pasar por todo un continente y acá seguimos discutiendo si la emision genera inflacion.
Me es difícil calificarlos. Por un lado me encanta su estética, su estilo y lo que deben haber representado en su época (este disco es de los 70s!) Por otra parte, algunos temas son difíciles de escuchar (a mi gusto): The Hall of Mirrors me pareció pesado. Por otra parte, Europe Endless, Showroom Dummies y Trans-Europe Express me caen simpáticos. Reitero, estos tipos me habrían VOLADO la cabeza si hubiese nacido unas décadas atrás. Pero nací en el 85 así que llego tarde a esto. Si tengo que calificarlos por lo que contribuyeron a la música, seguramente tenga que ponerles un 4 o 5. Pero yo califico según mi gusto o no, y va un 2. Lo siento señores.
I like synth. I even like some Kraftwerk. But this album is so repetitive and boring that it was pretty hard to get through. There's a set of 3 songs that are actually the same song. Rough.
interesting to 1. realize more songs than I know are covers of albums i didn't know. 2. listen to early electronica and see how that comes through in more recent music 3. realize I love the the mild german-accent in english. 4. realize that my only impression of kraftwerk was based on the name, and that conjured a very different sound that reality.
To be honest, this album is kind of boring. Very minimalistic, with songs that chug along repetitively. Don’t get me wrong, I’m sure it’s a landmark of electronic music, but I’m not going to sit and listen to this every day.
Really could not get through it. Understand why it was foundational for its time but unsure if it translates to anything interesting today. Did find out the melody from the title track was used in a Bollywood movie which was funny.
Impressed it came out in the 70's, but not my kind of music
Got better as the album went on, very simple synth and rhythms. Very David Bowie meets disco meets elo meets trance.
Highlights: repetitive lyrics.
great album
A little more in the way of vocals than the previous Kraftwerks album, still DEFINITELY not my thing though.
Beeps and books to move your hips to.
1977 German techno sounds interesting just by the title, but honestly it's feckin boring. Couldn't finish
Very different but kinda fun.
Parts of this album really blew me away. Some of it was repetitive to be sure, but there was a level of energy that was constant throughout that kept me hooked. I really enjoyed this.
Eh. I appreciate it for what it is. Not quite my thing.
3.5
eh
A beyond important project. I’m not too well acquainted with early electronic works. Besides a few acts. But the LP is a illuminating journey into the synthesized world of Kraftwerk. Plunky at moments but the allure and entrancement of such early use of a technology is there.
I would play this album again. The last 4 tracks, from "Metal on Metal" through "Endless Endless", was may favorite portion of the album. The first track, "Europe Endless", felt like the typical sound from Kraftwork to me (in a good way). Track 2, "The Hall of Mirrors", was the weakest spot for me on the album. Perhaps this was because of the almost spoken word portions. "The Hall of Mirrors" wouldn't prevent me from putting this album on again. Between 3.75 and 4.25
Lovely stuff for a summers day. True pioneers. Cant believe this was made in 76!
New to me but I thought it was interesting and put me in a reflective mood
Elektro halt. Wegweisend und prägend aber trotzdem Elektro
Zonde van de stroom...
Solidly boring. I see that it was made in 1977 so this may have been foundational to the music that I DO like but... I do not want to listen to this ever again haha.
This was alright. I found it really repetitive in parts
Otra banda que nunca había escuchado pero esta vez sí fue algo a conciencia jajaja Kraftwerk para mí siempre fue música de gente cool y a ese mundo yo no pertenezco. Ahora que tuve la ocasión de escucharlos, sigo con la misma idea (?). Es un disco muy conceptual que, en ese sentido, lo siento lejano a mí, pero de todas formas sí me gustó, aunque no sabría poner en palabras por qué.
Listening today it’s all just a wee bit flat and tedious. That might appear sacrilegious but it doesn’t change my respect and appreciation for the importance of this album.
this is a lot like riding a train, it's a lot of the same thing for longer than you really want it to be.
Loved it, then I didn’t, and then I liked it.
An important, minimal, almost bare bones effort. The shape of magnificent things to come but just not quite there yet.
Important and influential but leaves me cold