Reviews (page 5 of 15)
This was a surprise. Good album.
• White Winter Hymnal is a really beautiful sounding song. I don't think I've ever heard the original version before, but the acoustic guitar and booming drums really elevate the vocals. • Ragged Wood is another nice sounding track • The vocal harmonies have been amazing throughout the album. Quiet Houses feels like the culmination of that • He Doesn't Know Why's chord progression feels familiar, but I'm not sure where from • Heard Them Stirring is a nice (mostly) instrumental While I got a bit tired of the album towards the end, it was a really nice listen. The vocals are the obvious highlight through the whole thing, but the gentle instrumentals are all very pleasant. This is only the second album I've gotten from the 2000's, but I think it'll stick out as one of the more unique ones of the era. Favourite song: White Winter Hymnal
Thoughts before listening: I like these guys. Folky indie rock with lots of harmonies and Robin Pecknold's high pitched vocals. Some songs are better than others, but I definitely think this is one of the better albums and band software the 00s/10s. Review: Starting this album today I was immediately reminded of just how good it is. I think in my mind these guys get lumped into the Mumford and Sons/Lumineers/Avett Brothers camp, and while there are similarities, the melodies and harmonies are just so much stronger with this one. Also, there is a My Morning Jacket/Band of Horses style indie rock quality to the songs that really helps them to stand out. I'm leaning 5-stars here.
Great
Classic Coldplay.
Meadowlarks is the only kind of filler song on this album, and it's instantly followed up with my favorite fleet foxes song soooo
Beautiful, simple sound. Kind of like Beach House, but more acoustic, makes me feel all warm and comforted inside :)
amei, faz muito meu tipo
Fav tracks: sun it rises, white winter hymnal, ragged wood, tiger mountain peasant song, your protector, meadowlarks This album was a pleasant listen as this winter storm barrels down on my town. there’s curious whimsy and melancholy intertwined, yet it also feels soooo tumblr-hipster 2011 like crazy. Nostalgic and warm, I didn’t realize how folk-inspired this album was. The rhythm/percussion section is evident in their folk roots. Glad I had the time to really listen to this album !!
Solid 4
This basically passed me by when it came out and probably for good reasons. It's deathly boring save for a couple track, it feels sloppy in an attempt to be "earthy". A revival of folk that was better as it was.
I liked the indie folk scene this helped blossom. I’ve heard this many times but I was as a little bored on this listen.
I’ve listened to this three times over the past few days, and each time I like it more. Until now, the only Fleet Foxes tune I knew was “White Winter Hymnal,” which remains my favorite track. But this record works well for what I hope to get from an album: an artistic statement, charismatic world-building, and a strong cohesive palette that ties all the tracks together. This album accomplishes that, from the Bruegel cover art to the harmonizing vocal rounds. That’s why even though not all of the individual songs are standouts for me, I feel like rounding up to a five star rating. Also, I’m not convinced that this isn’t Jim James doing all the vocals.
The harmonies riddled throughout this album are a blessing to any person's ear. While sometimes it can be overtly poppy (Ragged Wood, Quiet Houses) and overtly vocal (many points throughout the entire album), Fleet Foxes self titled debut delivers a feeling of nostalgia to anyone interested in humanity's folksy past of living off the land somewhere deep in the woods with nothing but some oxen, a pig and whoever else belongs to your religious cult of choice. Post Script: I once had the pleasure of getting stoned in an art studio while someone loudly unwantingly sang "He Doesn't Know Why". I haven't seen this person in over a decade, but I'm still annoyed.
What's this? A post-2000s band that uses actual instruments? And writes their own music? I'm a bit shocked. I'm also pleased, this was quite good. Not sure I'd go back to it often, but it was far better than most of the other "modern" titles on the list.
So this is Fleet Foxes ... well its better than Grizzly Bear.
🥇white winter hymal 🥈ragged wood 🥉he doesn’t know why HM: your protector this was a nice album to listen to as a whole but not as many of the songs stood out to me individually
7/10
A classic 2000s, it's ok but the folk rock sound got very stale, although not there fault 3.5*
It wasn't bad but didn't blow me away either. Solid all around.
This is very great, but the inclusion of this album is funny to me. Fleet Foxes went on to make Helplessness Blues, which is an even better album. That album has way more memorable songs and better arrangements, by a long shot. Yet this is the band's (only) entry on this list, which is just weird.
I am well aware of this dorky band. Very much not my thing. Fuck off with your folk hymns. I acknowledge that it's well made for what it is I guess.
Muito interessante. Gostei. Sonoridade leve e suave, não me sou agressivo aos ouvidos. Surpreendente
Wonderful vibey album. Winter. Mornings. Coziness.
Love ‘White Winter Hymnal’ Easy listening! Nicee
I have nothing good or bad to say about this, very far outside of my normal music
Their chamber folk stylings were a great counter to the “stomp-clap” indie folk of the late 2000s. That said, gosh, I’ve never found this to be that good either hahah.
not bad, liked a few
Це легка п'ятірка для мене. Люблю цей гурт, їм вдається зробити якийсь просто неймовірний звук на всіх їх альбомах і на цьому зокрема. Ну і вокал теж прекрасний. Один з кращих дебютів ever. Маю на касеті, вчора переслухав і кайфонув.
Всім альбомам фліт фоксес я ставлю 5 за замовчуванням. Прекрасний гурт.
I know wanted to like this more than I did. It’s very accomplished, and quite an achievement for a debut album, but it’s good, not great. The only one I’ve heard Brie is White Winter Hymnal, which I think is the stand out track.
Maudlin British folk infused stuff? Don't mind if i do! This was stellar, honestly, and i don't know if it caught me on a good day but this is going on my regular list :)
Need to be in the woods and a millennial to listen. It was still go juts not my thing
I loved the album when it came out and played it incessantly. I still listen to a few tracks somewhat regularly. A classic.
This album is what I imagine plays in a white woman's head as they shop for artisanal good at a farmer's market.
Great album, not my favorite from fleet foxes but there were a lot of new listens for me in this one. Very whimsical and upbeat.
Easiest 5 star. The soothing harmonies complimented robin pecknold's wonderful voice, while the instruments bring the folk sounds to life. While not quite as good as their next album Helplessness Blues in my opinion, the first album stands the test of time. The sound and production are spectacular quality, and this album helped lead Fleet Foxes on their journey to creating some of my favorite songs later on. I can understand if this isn't necessarily your genre, but to call it a bad album or mediocre music is tasteless nonsense as everybody should at least be able to understand why many would enjoy the flowing melodies and harmonies. Remarkably consistent in quality across the entire album, this is probably my favorite album we've hit so far
I embrace the perfect cliche of a Washington-resident who listens to Fleet Foxes while driving their Subaru to the Cascades, and I enjoy it every time. Nothing prepares the spirit for a trip into the backcountry of the North Cascades like the Fleet Foxes, and this album is thematic of all the sights, smells, and feelings that come with such an adventure. The instrumental arrangements on this album immediately transport me to memories of driving down Highway 20 along the Skagit River, Ross Lake, and Washington Pass, on my way to explore a new and spectacular region of these beloved North Cascades mountains.
I know it's an excellent album, but it's never really done it for me.
Its fine, Mumford and Sons without the banjo, good background music at a summer BBQ that runs from a blazing afternoon into the night....
Some good songs but can be a bit slow
Some of the most gorgeous vocal performances put to record, such a strong album
Je m'attendais à rien et même j'allais insulter l'album car je déteste les albums qui portent le nom du groupe Et au final c'était un super album !
Très bonne surprise !
Genre: Chamber Folk Man, this was sort of the artsy offering in the stomp/clap era in the aughts. A debut that was very popular and very well-received, and White Winter Hymnal was absolutely everywhere when it came out. Going through the album, it certainly has its moments of real beauty, and it's one of the easier to listen to probably in the entire book, especially out of the modern offerings here. I would recommend this to others, and even re-listen to it, but in the same breath, I don't know how essential this is. A good record that has its place, but I don't know if this before-you-die type stuff. Good album. 3/5
White Winter Hymnal // Ragged Wood // Quiet Houses // Blue Ridge Mountains //
I suppose this would be nice for someone, but way too mellow for this cat. I will say they are good musicians, just not my thing
One of those gems I had forgotten about
Good for background music while working.
Cabin music
BOM e honesto album
Pika
4.5
Indie rock honesto
Very whimsical, I felt joyful like I was outside feeling the wind and sun. Fav song was either white winter hymnal or blue ridge mountains.
ta album mi da tok upanja, topel je, poleten ampal hkrati zimski, pogreje me in mi pove, da bo vse v redu.
Love this album
Like a blanket that’s slightly too thin
Still like the album, but I feel like this one was overproduced. A few mistakes and/or feeling would move this up from a four to a five star album for me. It just sounds too clean!
If Coldplay meets Folk Music
boring
This is a delightful album - a springtime paradise of breezy indie folk, alternating between more melancholy songs and absolute bangers. Very much appeals to many of my musical sensibilities.
Overall this was pretty solid. Not something I’d seek out and listen to on my own, but solid. Worked well as background music, though I’m sure there’s a lot I’m missing. I enjoyed their singing. Definitely can’t understand how it made so many people in the reviews so extremely angry.
Pleasant listen! I can't say the vocal performances really do much for me, but I love the way the album so vividly evokes nature through its lyrics and instrumentation. It's such a unique atmosphere that I'm considering revisiting and seeing if the rest grows on me over time. Standouts: Sun It Rises • White Winter Hymnal • Ragged Wood
Thought this was an instant 5 from previous listens but unfortunately I believe it is actually a 4. There is a spot in the middle of the album that I think is fairly weak and I actually found it feeling a little samey in places. Still great.
weak 2.5
sounds like a crunchy childhood and an america that no longer exists
What sets Fleet Foxes apart from their contemporary folk groups is that the compositions they write and production is actually interesting. I do wish some songs were better shaped though; Tiger Mountain Peasant Song for example has an amazing progression and melody throughout the verse, but approaching the chorus it ruins it by too harsh vocals and a bland vibe. Will be listening to more of them though. Album art is fire
It was great loved blue ridge mountain
only thought about chorus
a classic that I used to listen to in college! Love this album except for the last song lol
Better than I recall
This is very mediocre music. It feels like I've heard it a million times before. The sound is very ordinary, and there's nothing special about the lyrics, music, or vocals.
Pretty solid Winter Hymenal was the best song
loved this!!
Really did not vibe with this record. None of the tracks really stood out to me. It also feels like a less gritty and less rock-infused Band of Horses record.
All rise for the millennial white guy’s national anthem.
it's wonderful. very cozy and perfect to have listened to while walking to the library this morning in the 30-degree weather. White Winter Hymnal is a classic, none of the other songs stood out as amazing but the entire album as a piece of art is great and so cohesive
I forgot about this album for a while, happy to hear it again. The album is not as cozy (so not as 'folk' folk) as I remembered, but it still hits for cold fall/winter days.
Just beautiful
it was hard to not give this a 5 based on pure reactionary tendencies. i saw we rolled Fleet Foxes, i got so excited, i fucking *love* this band, so i wanted to click 5!!! it is a great album!!! but then i remembered that for me, Helplessness Blues is a 5, and I like this one less, so it can't be a 5. sad. but it's ok. a 4 is still great. not to be annoying about it, but this was one of my Formative AlbumsTM. i had a close friend in high school whose older brother introduced me to Ragged Wood (and by extension the rest of FF's catalogue). he also introduced me to St. Vincent, so that's cool. i must have listened to this album backwards and forwards a hundred times in the coming months. he drove me home one night and was like "u gotta hear blue ridge mountains dude it'll change your life" and like yeah that's dramatic but it also isn't incorrect Ragged Wood became one of the first songs i learned how to play (with my friend's brother no less) that really filled me with some zest while playing. other songs i was like yeah cool okay here's how to play this, but Ragged Wood was just so much fucking fun to jam out to, especially with another guitarist in the room! the energy is this album is, to me, fairly unique. each song taken individually isn't doing a whole lot to raise the roof, but taken together, i think this album is full of momentum, dynamism, and compelling instrumentation that ranges from church hymnals to folk to alt rock. this band is so talented.
I really liked this one. Taylore always plays White Winter Hymnal and I think that song is gorgeous, which led me to listen to this album for the first time about a week or two ago. I'm also a fan of Oliver James. I normally do some reading about the artist or the history surrounding the album when listening to them, but this time around I did not. That being said, idk much about this album or artist but I really enjoyed it.
I really expected to love this but I found myself a bit bored. It has a lot of the stuff I like in a folksy album, but it just didn’t reel me in all the way. A few too many of the same ingredients, I think.
Because of Bob Weir's passing, I've been thinking about bands I enjoy that are influenced by the Dead. Fleet Foxes came to mind pretty quickly (I feel like they were unfairly left off of the 'Day of the Dead' covers album from 2016). There are some pretty obvious allusions to the Dead throughout this one. RIP Bobby. Side note, my brain gets overtly confused by the seasons this album makes me think of -- it's part winter, lots of spring, and a little bit of summer all in one.
Please don't send me to listening group jail but I am very much not at all fond of the whole 2000s/10s twee and quaint wide-brim-hat-core indie folk thing. Unfortunately, Spotify seems to think it aligns with my general taste, so it routinely throws it into my playlists. The upside is that I have developed Spider-Man-like reflexes over the years in order to hit the Skip button as quickly as possible when I hear " I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOOLLLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOOOLLLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOOOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOOOLLLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOOLLLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWWWING THE I WAS FOLLOOOOWING THE I WAS FOOOOLLLLOWING THE I WAS FOOOLLLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE IWASFOLLOWINGTHEIWASFOLLOWINGTHEIWASFOLLOWINGTHEIIWASFOLLOWINGTHEIWASFOLLOWINGTHEIWASFOLLOWINGTHEIIWASFOLLOWINGTHEIWASFOLLOWINGTHEIWASFOLLOWINGTHEI WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING FOLLOWING FOLL I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE I WAS FOLLOWING THE" I hate that song.
One of my all-time favorites. It’s the twinkle of acoustic guitars, golden timbre of Robin Pecknold’s vocal harmonies, and bright, swelling crescendos that keep me coming back. Blue Ridge Mountain is a standout for me. This record hits me like a steaming-hot soup on a frigid day.
Felt like it started off good but really lost interest after a song or two.
One of my personal favourites of all time, it’s not perfect but I don’t care. Only 4 instead of 5 as it does get a bit samey towards the end.
Everything old is new again. Some stellar songs in here.
Not bad at all! My prejudice kept me waiting for the worst, because I don't dig that folky style, but the Brian Wilsonesque vocal harmonies made me keep listening and even enjoy the tracks (at least most of the first half of the album). Definetely will listen to it again
Feo.
Pleasant
This is the sort of stuff i like to hear on the list - just something different. it's got lovely vocal melodies with nice folky instrumentation. though some of the songs are just a littleist of bland for my liking
This sounds like the music that I'm sure my girlfriend would really enjoy, but for me, not at all. This sound really dominated the early 2010s as easy listening to folk music, and for that reason, I'm tired of this genre of music. I'm sure this album deserves to be on the list as a staple of this genre. Definitely shooting it over to her, though.
Near the peak of indie music and brings an old school chill classic rock sound
not feeling that indie vibe today i guess
- etheral soft folk, i love it, ça donne envie de se promener et danser dans les bois - les harmonies sont sincèrement hypnotisantes - parfois répétitif mais still a vibe et je réécouterais plusieurs des chansons - meilleure chanson: sun it rises, white winter hymnal
I enjoyed this sound, mix of old and modern styles.
Very good sounding album with great songs. No real bangers though, but I definitely had a good time.
This music transports me to another place, very nice
So beautiful, reminds me of a long road trip, very nostalgic inducing The piano at the end of He Doesn't Know Why!! Favourites: White Winter Hymnal, Your Protector
tiene unas cuantas canciones guays pero se me ha quedado muy sin mas la verdad, pero siento que simplemente no estaba en el mood para el
Wasn’t sold after the first track, Ragged Wood piqued my interest pretty quickly though, as did He Doesn’t Know Why. Quite liked the majority of this, even if it isn’t something I’d listen to normally.
I enjoyed this album but I can't say I remember a single song next day. Admittedly, I had it on in the background while working so that might be my own fault. Strong 3
Low key and mellow throughout. Nothing absolutely brilliant, nothing bad either.
i wasn’t expecting to like this as much as i did, lots of fun and i forgot the main singers name but he has a great voice, i might listen to one of their other albums
god it feels like everyone is wearing flannel and a beanie again
Not really sure what they were going for. Like it felt like they were going for weird but got too poppy. Im not saying its bad. It would be wrong to say its bad. Just not accomplishing much.
This was very good. I enjoyed the songs and the groups sound.
Did not expect i would like this, but i was wrong. This album really surprised me
I was surprised to not hate this. My brain had a negative association with this band but I couldn't have told you why. It turns out I had the misfortune of hearing the first single and wrote them off after that. The song writing and production were actually really good even if this still isn't something I'd ever choose to listen to.
Gostei.
Started of really slow and i thought i wasn’t gonna like it but it gradually started flowing. The lyrics we’re really good too
This sounds like the soundtrack to Lord of the Rings.
The late 00’s indie acoustic music is very far away from my wheelhouse for music - that said, this was some of the better music from that genre. Rather calming, and I appreciate the music on this album. Just not for me.
Folk classique, bien arrangé mais les voix sont pour ma part très lassantes.
Riktigt trevlig platta. Många harmoniskt roliga detaljer vilket gjorde lyssningen intressant. Den här kommer jag spara och lyssna på igen!
Mer min stil, men ändå lite tråkigt
Det är lite duktigt, präktigt nästan men det är inte dåligt. Tycker Winter Hymnial är störig men resten av albumet är faktiskt inte så dumt. Genom hipster-stämmorna hörs ändå en kärlek till 70-talet på flera sätt. Trummorna låter för jävla bra!
En genre jag alltid haft mycket svårt för och stört mig på. Till en början var det här dock en intressant lyssning, fin produktion och inte lika tråkigt som jag förväntade mig. Höll dock inte hela albumet ut men roligt att höra att det var bättre än jag trodde/mindes det. En stark tvåa!
Nä jag drogs inte med i hypen då och inte nu heller. White Winter Hymnal är ensam om att få mig lite upphetsad, och då lyssnar jag ändå med perfekta förutsättningar på en mörk snötäckt skärgårdsö i fleecetröja. Tönt-hipster-USA när det är som sämst?
Trodde jag skulle vara rätt uttråkad, men icke. Tycker det här är väldigt vackert. Jordigt och 70-taligt, de hatar inte Crosby, stills & Nash. Blir fan 4a igen här.
Fin sång men inte min smak längre, skulle nog gett en fyra för 10 år sen
var besatt av det här albumet 2010…. såg dem live på way out west och blev fullkomligt trollbunden…… femma då, fyra nu
White winter hymnal är en gammal vahettere... Christmas guilty pleasure för mig. Så var rätt laddad på att kliva på albumet. Men inte ens den låten når fram och penetrerar mitt skal byggt av Sepultura och Ian Dury. Jag verkar ha kvävt den delen av mig som var "indie cute" I sömnen. När något siktar på att vara så här mäktigt med reverbdränkta mansröster finns risken att det faller platt. Som en pannkaka ungefär. Ser mest såna portland-hipsters framför mig. Trodde det skulle vara mer komplicerat än det är. Enkla arrangemang och harmonier. När jag skriver så kommer ändå Tiger mountain peasant... På och det är väl en bra låt fram till slutet. Sen He doesn't know why Är Ju också bra. Men de hade återigen kunnat avsluta sina låtar bättre. Ska man dra upp det till en trea? För hemfriden? Nä. PS. Tack för ett underbart jubileum!
decent, good to get into the work day and mellow me out a little bit. it did all sort of blend into one, though. i wanted a bit more, it got a bit boring and samey and at times i thought i would end up loving some tracks just for them to not reach a peak
who knew I knew more than one song!
I've saved songs from this album in the past. Overall, I like it but it's not something i'd look for daily
Listened to the tracks and they had a nice new sound for me. Overall the album was fine not really my kind of sound but some of the tracks definitely were added to the playlist in the future.
I had heard a lot about this album, specifically good things and rave reviews, but hadn't listened to it, or really anything by Fleet Foxes, until encountering them on this website. My first impression is that it's a folksy, gospel-inspired sound, which isn't necessarily bad, but this is also a sound done by so many other artists I imagine it's hard to stand out or make something uniquely good. The first track didn't really capture me, but White Winter Hymnal is amazing, and helped me lock in, until Ragged Wood outstayed its welcome, and the rest of this album continued to disappoint me, save for Heard Them Stirring and Blue Ridge Mountains. It's not the most complex or lively sound, the music is moreso mellow and simple, without sounding trite, and at rare times beautiful. At the end of the day, I don't see why this lit up so many lists and garnered such rave reviews, as I don't think this is anything revolutionary or new, it just simply sounds good and doesn't do anything that could be seen as offensive. Maybe my ears are broken, or maybe I just don't like this brand of hippie folk, but I likely won't listen to this again. Solid 6/10 thanks to 2 really good tracks, and one pretty alright one Favorite Tracks: White Winter Hymnal, Heard Them Stirring, Blue Ridge Mountains Least Favorite Tracks: Tiger Mountain Peasant Song, Your Protector, Meadowlarks, Oliver James
I really really like it! Favourite song: Ragged Wood
Perfect album. An all time favourite of mine.
This is so unbelievably good, especially for a debut. I’d always heard of them but sad I never gave them a look in before.
i love fleet foxes <3 ♡: Sun It Rises, He Doesn’t Know Why, Blue Ridge Mountains, Oliver James, Quiet Houses, Ragged Wood
Quite boring but I can appreciate the musicianship in the tracks. Album is at least listenable. I won’t be revisiting any of these songs, too folky for me. Lead singer has a decent voice too. Despite the sleepy and uninteresting lyrics I’ll bump it up one from 2/5.
A little slow, but i dig some of the songs
Don’t think I’ve finished it, but was pleased to find some familiar tunes. Very mellow and nice background music
Fleet Foxes are a band that I like listening to but never consider putting thought into actually choosing to listen to them. It's just kind of there.
I liked this one!
Was forced to listen to this album on repeat for about a month while working at Borders Books. Unexpectedly, this resulted in me loving it.
This is a bit of Harness. Low 4 from me. (Mostly) enjoyed it.
Found it a bit boring.
Arcadian
Listened to it twice. Enjoyed it
Very quiet fancy melodic folk pop album.
Really liked it. Was surprised I had not heard of them or this album. Nice acoustics and calming vibes.
It was just okay
3.95
Respect the harmonies, solid musicians, but this is bland.
un severo 2 (che sarebbe anche un 2,5 verso il 3) perché nonostante l’album sia piacevole da ascoltare, non ci ho percepito nulla di speciale. hanno un po’ quel velo di romanticismo artificiale dei coldplay, per cui non mi arrivano particolarmente. però comunque ci sono vari pezzi belli
Bello peró perchè scegliere questo e non un altro album folk degli anni 2000? Cos’ha di speciale??
First time I have listened to this artist, and my goodness, it is fantastic! Stunning songwriting, immaculate melodies, and a very high-quality, yet somewhat comfy production. It feels exactly what a modern folk album should be, with a vast amalgam of influences and modern sensibilities. You do kinda listen to it with some high-quality headphones or speakers, as it is very nuanced, and I am not certain it would translate to a phone speaker or a TV.
Nostalgic, perfect for drawing 5/5
9/10 big surprise
not my cup of tea
0/11
Folk My Morning Jacket should really work but kinda didn't. 5/10
1/1 Haven't listened to much folk music before but I really liked this album. Good autumn vibes with it and I'll definitely pick up a vinyl copy of it
Ta album pa kar dobro poznam. Fin začetek novega leta. Fajn chill začetek s "Sun It Rises". Ful je dreamlike. Drugi komad, "White Winter Hymnal" je moj najljubši. Zmer so mi bli kul tud te seamless prehodi med komadi. Smo že v "Ragged Wood". V bistvu so teli prvi trije komadi kot a medley. Od Pecknolda vokal mi je ful lep. Če hoč koheziven album v zvoku in tematiki, brez, da ti vsi komadi zvenijo isto, je to to. Medtem, k pri R.E.M. se mi je vse zblendal together. "Your Protector" je hud. Je pa vajb totalno nekak isti k naslovnica - to ma smisel, k slišiš to musko.
Great way to close out 2025 and year two of the list. Love the fleet foxes, but I think helplessness blues is a better album.
Yes.
Sonically, I suppose this is a well made album. However, it doesn’t do anything for me. Except maybe bore me. It’s almost too dense for folk music; there’s just not enough space. Also, it all sounds the same. I had heard someone else make this complaint about Fleet Foxes before, and the response was that’s because if bands have a sound, their songs will sound the same. But there should still be some diversity between songs. If I were to walk out of the room with this album playing, I would be hard pressed to guess if what was playing when I came back in was the same song or a different one. Any good band should be able to have a distinct sound but still create songs that are easily differentiated. Led Zeppelin did that, the Beatles did that. Primus, White Stripes, and on and on. But these are all the same. Now, it was an appropriate soundtrack for my dark drive into the city on this traffic-less New Year’s Eve morning, but that doesn’t mean that I really enjoyed it.
Super mellow Friday vibes. College me would approve
So calming
Quiet horses is clearly very repetitive lyrically, but with all the vocalizing and different pronunciations, and styles to the same words gives a variation you wouldn't ever expect from reading the lyrics. The fact this is a number one charting right out the gate is impressive. Love the minimalist percussion and simple yet full music that results. Blue ridge mountains is probably my favorite track. It transports me back to the lonely little campground in Tennesse.
I loved my sister's take: this is nature in music form. LOVED this album, need to own it!
Soooo 2008 - it’s been a long time since I’ve listened to anything with this specific sound, enjoyed revisiting it a lot, but not sure if I’d go back any time soon. I would’ve liked some of the highs to be higher, some extra variety would have gone a long way.
Really good album - enjoyed it - mellow, tuneful, folky
7/10 zbog ovakvih albuma sam poceo da radim ovo mix medieval + folk + pop + mystical deluje kao da je soundtrack za neki film nmp isk sta pricam al je bas crazy da su ljudi pravili ovakav album 2008, nije mi nesto predobar al respect
A lot of the user reviews for this album are either saying this is perfect for them or there is not much to say other than awesome cover art. That about sums it up for me as well. This is a nothing burger. Well produced but everything is just middle of the road tempos, fake-folky vocals and it all sounds the same. No sharp edges to be seen sonically. It’s fine for short bursts in a commercial or in a movie soundtrack but that’s about it. No reason to ever listen to this again. But great album art! /s
Reminds me of being in my car in the winter smoking cigarettes - album starts strong and trickles off at the end
While indie music can be relatively hit or miss for me, Fleet Foxes do a good job constructing a vibe. As I've listened to this over the years, the highlights have only gotten better and the lowlights have stayed "meh". 3.7/5 -> 4/5
Probably the best folk album to come out of the 200’s
First time listener to fleet foxes. I think they could only have come from the USA with this sound. Layered guitars and layers vocals. When the keyboards came in, I was reminded of the keyboards in Peanuts/Charlie Brown. I mean this all in a positive way! I think the lyrics may be less uplifting than I’m feeling from the music on first listen.
One of my favorite albums when I was in college, a millennial folk dream. Super creative and influential songwriting
modern folk
3.5
Decent album, nothing hard to listen to, but also not much that makes me want another listen.
Better than Coldplay
I used to be into this hipster folk stuff... It's not bad though, but there was some garbage albums from that era.
I like it. The only major issue with it is that with every good thing there is to say, there is always a "but," statement. It's gorgeous, but you can find this exact sound in so many other albums. It works, but I would never reach for it when there are other albums that capture these exact emotions in a more powerful and captivating way.
Great harmonies, kind of folksy.
very interesting… kinda granola but kinda in a good way! has amazing moments but overall not my thing/ wouldn’t reach for it
Was expecting a lot more from this as I know some very cool fleet foxes fans and the album cover is gorgeous. I was underwhelmed.
This is a great album that would hold up in any decade. I'm not sure I want these guys with me in a gang fight, but I'll sit calmly and listen to them any time.
I wouldn’t be surprised if this music was playing in an elevator somewhere
Vibes: 5 Instruments: 3 Production: 4 Emotional Value: 3 Storytelling: 5 AC: 1 Stand Outs: White Winter Hymn, Oliver James Overall: 4.2 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I feel like I'm dancing in the forest through this album. Though the individual songs feel somewhat unremarkable, I kinda vibe with it.
More like a 4.5 but rounding up to a 5. Absolutely love this album, and the sound. I listened to it a hundred times, and it made me a fan of their other albums too.
Easiest 5 star. The soothing harmonies complimented robin pecknold's wonderful voice, while the instruments bring the folk sounds to life. While not quite as good as their next album Helplessness Blues in my opinion, the first album stands the test of time. The sound and production are spectacular quality, and this album helped lead Fleet Foxes on their journey to creating some of my favorite songs later on. I can understand if this isn't necessarily your genre, but to call it a bad album or mediocre music is tasteless nonsense as everybody should at least be able to understand why many would enjoy the flowing melodies and harmonies. Remarkably consistent in quality across the entire album, this is probably the most complete album I've crossed on this list so far. It's night and day to that godawful Mekons British punk country album I suffered through the day before, that's for sure
Occasionally threatens to be interesting. The things they reference are nicer. Sort of soft folk(ish)
Pretty stellar
Fantastic album! I love fleet foxes! So good!
Just good old fashioned background music with one banger
I really liked this one. In all honesty I did listen to it in three bites and probably would have found it a bit samey if I hadn’t, but it feels like a good little find that is now in my rotation.
One of the most beautiful albums ever
Slow. Renaissance faire music.
This album has not aged at all, still sounds like it is from 1428. I will never not love this album.
Kinda mixed on this one. I feel like it's that quintessential alt folk sound, hell they might've even created it, but at some point it felt a little repetitive. How many times do you need a few guys harmonizing in a hallway? It was fine, I enjoyed the White Winter Hymnal, and I'm not even sure if that's their hit but feels like it might've been. Moving on
so cute
Et album jeg hørte på da jeg først begynte å utforske musikk, og ikke har hørt siden. For det første; for et albumcover! Det fortjener fem stjerner i seg selv. For det andre; for en vakker samling av sanger! Jeg er normalt sett ikke særlig begeistret for folk, så Fleet Foxes fortjener ros for dette. Top 3: He Doesn't Know Why, Blue Ridge Mountains, Ragged Wood/Your Protector
i could see how this would hit on a mountain roadtrip white winter hymnal will always be iconic
not my type of sound
Good I guess. I wasn’t wowed by any of the songs or the album as a whole. I’m not sure why it made the list but alright.
Fine. Feels like id listen to this on a road trip staring out the window at the sunset. Not something Id explicitly come back to.
Brilliant!
Very comfy one. It reminds me of sunshine on tree leafs while i was laying on my hammock reading a fantasy book. It also has medival vibes which is great. On the other hand i wouldn't call it a masterpiece. Song's have rather repetitive main theme, however some are really unique. I will definitly come back to this album and add it to my reading-music. Overall 5,5/10
It's okay. A bit too folky for me, no doubt inspired people like Mumford or Mountains/Men. All a bit samey.
Sweet and soothing without being saccharine, makes you think of times and places
Just a bit dull
Sunday morning vibes. Hannah gives it a 4
I have been sniffy about fleet foxes in the past and had to open my mind to get through this album , unfortunately my view on this band is still unchanged and I don’t like it
I like it. very chill
A hugely well received debut album which was the definitive statement in the burgeoning indie folk scene. A lot of 60s/70s fans would’ve been taken by the Crosby stills, Nash harmonies. Sounds fresh now.
White Winter Hymnal was already a favorite/the reason I’d heard of Fleet Foxes. Together Mountain Peasant Song and Blue Ridge Mountains were other standouts and this was a pleasant listen overall.
White Winter Hymnal has been turned into a scary tik tok sound. Interesting album!
HELL YEAH just what I needed today
Så fint album elsket det
Meh
Nice. I already liked this album from around when it came out. It's got a great relaxing folksy sound to it. Only one song that's very catchy though imo.
If I could do decimals, this is a 4.2. I like it, good music, put me in a good mood. How often will I go back to it? Not sure
I loved it. So folky & mystic it was fun to listen to
Love this album!
Woahhhh I actually really love this
love albums that feel like fall and this is one of em. i listened to this a lot back in 2008-2013 or so, and it holds up imo.
A folk/classic rock hybrid with a splash of prog makes for an interesting if slightly long LP from the Foxes. One of those albums you might pull out occasionally especially of you like chiming melodies and harmonies. Worth a listen.
2,3/5
This album was pretty... pretty boring! Honestly, it was both beautiful and monotonous. White Winter Hymnal is of course really catchy and enjoyable, and it's not often you hear a round on a contemporary album so I'll give Fleet Foxes that much. By the end of the album, though, all of the tracks had sort of blurred together.
Already loved this album, perfect for a chill day
Fleet Foxes sounds sort of floaty and transcendent bringing a pretty unique sound. Personally I find this style of music boring. It’s great if you don’t really want to notice it playing in the background.
Saw these guys at Winnipeg Folk Fest a few years ago now, sat in the rain with my poncho and mini lawn chair with my mom and a family friend out in the fields of bird hill park, had a great time even though I was soaking wet! It stopped raining by the end of the show, and was able to dry off back at the campsite. Anyways that was a good time, and so was this album. I may have searched for some of their music back then, but never sat down with an album. Which I definitely should have sooner! Would be an even better album within a certain chill setting, maybe involving some rain or a cloudy day, next to a fire of some sort, maybe cup of tea in hand. Who knows! 8/10
Very calming and relaxing. It has a peaceful, earthy, and warm feeling that I really appreciate. The harmonies are stunning, almost hymn like and the acoustic guitar has such a natural texture that it feels as though the music was recorded in an old wooden cabin in the mountains rather than in a studio. The album feels folk inspired but also modern indie. There’s something very comforting about it, soothing but not boring, mellow but emotional. I can see how influential this sound became later on for indie folk bands in the 2010s. If I had to describe the overall feeling, it’s the perfect album for a rainy day, hot chocolate with the heater on, and the rain tapping against the window. It’s like being wrapped in a blanket next to a fireplace while it pours outside. Very calm, and beautiful. The album cover is beautiful. It captures the folky, pastoral vibe of the music, very rustic, and almost storybook like. It feels like a piece of classic art you’d find in an old European gallery, filled with tiny scenes and characters you could stare at for a long time, just like the song “The Fairy Feller’s Master Stroke” by Queen. My favourite tracks are White Winter Hymnal, Ragged Wood, Tiger Mountain Peasant Song, Quite Houses, He Doesn't Know Why, Your Protector, Meadowlarks, Blue Ridge Mountains.
Can appreciate the album but ultimately this genre of music is not for me
I moved to Washington a little over 10 years ago and I've surprisingly only heard the name "Fleet Foxes" come up two or three times since – certainly not enough to pique my curiosity and make me dive into the Seattle band's music. That said, I was happy to finally have an excuse to check them out and went into their self-titled debut album with an open mind! I honestly can't think of a ton to say about this one. It wasn't unpleasant to listen through, but the songs rarely spoke to me. I'd certainly prefer listening to more of this over some of the "stomp clap hey" indie acts of the early 2010s and the sense of melody/harmony came across quite well (reminded me a little bit of Simon & Garfunkel and Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young), which is probably the best thing I can say about it! Spotify auto-played "Helplessness Blues" after it ended and that made me kind of wish that song were this album's closer. Weirdly, the album also made me think about how far Imagine Dragons has gone downhill since their first album – probably because Robin Pecknold has similar vocal inflections to Dan Reynolds here and there. Perhaps they'd be making albums more similar to this one if "It's Time" ended up being Night Visions' biggest hit? How wonderful that we get to live in the timeline where "Believer" has over 3.5 billion streams. Sigh... Highlights: Ragged Wood, Quiet Houses, Your Protector, Blue Ridge Mountains
Pleasantly interesting but did not hold my attention to the whole album
such a good album cover. There’s so much to look at. The harmonies are beautiful, this album is produced and mixed to perfection. Everything sounds so atmospheric. There’s some really great moments in this album, but also some that fall flat. There were certain songs I HATED, but other songs that I added to lots of playlists. I don’t know if I’m the biggest fan of the modern folk sound so I think this is 3.5 stars
Sun It Rises: 4/10, I like the vibe of this song, it reminds me of a renessance fair WHICH WE NEED TO GO TO. White Winter Hymnal: 9/10, I love the guitar in this song and how all of the instruments fuse together, it makes me want to connect to nature more Ragged Wood: 5/10, I don't really like the start part, it's too much noise that doesn't really go well together in my brain, but after 2:50, it really slows down which I like Tiger Mountain Peasant Song: 3/10, it's giving vegan moss skipping in the grass sitting in a tree reading a political book Quiet Houses: 8/10, funky:), this is a really good feel good song that reminds me of childhood in a way made me tear up a bit, I like the little piano solo near the end He Doesn't Know Why: 3/10, sounds like 2 other of the songs in this album, like cmon dude switch it up a bit? this song is giving Joy Division mixed with hatred and love Heard Them Stirring: 8/10, Tarzan? I like the big drum and how they fade into soft singing, it reminds.me of church hymns. it also sounds like Arkells somewhat? Your Protector: 10/10, I think im floating, im speechless. it's going in the liked songs for sure. Meadowlarks: 2/10, it sounds like Clay Pigeons by Michael Cera for a bit, which is why I gave it a 2, but it's a kinda sad song which I don't quite like Blue Ridge Mountains: 4/10, changes from slow to fast too much and I overall just don't like this song Oliver James: 0/10. nope.
This album's cover art is absolutely gorgeous. Even though I'm not the biggest fan of this style of music, I'd be lying if I said that the vocal harmonies and multiple layered guitars aren't anything but undoubtedly stunning. The vocals on "White Winter Hymnal" are absolutely beautiful. Listening to it during Christmastime, it just seemed to fit the mood and weather and everything so well (shoulda covered it in our band lol :P). It gives this feeling of relief which feels like being at home, comfortable and warm, sipping hot chocolate (or EARL GREY!!), despite it being freezing outside. I love the instruments (especially that 6/4 guitar part and the organ) near the end of "Ragged Wood" "Tiger Mount Pleasant Song" and "Quiet Houses" both sound cool and really fun to play and learn on guitar. Big fan of the fingerpicking patterns on these and a few other songs. The only things that dock this album down for me are the receptive nature of it and the fact that some of the songs (later on in the album) just sound like average stomp clap music that would probably be played in a millennial burger joint. However, I really love the closer. I love how it calls back to a lot of the earlier songs in the album. How it ends with just vocals left me in awe when I first heard it. Fav: White Winter Hymnal, Oliver James, Sun It Rises, Ragged Wood. Dislikes: not any in particular, but after a while, a lot of songs just seemed to blend together.
I liked it. like a 60's Mumford and sons.
Pretend folk music. Almost a little churchy. I might actually like the album if there was some depth to it. 2.5 but rounding up to three.
Good to start with, but as it went on it sounded more and more like the beach boys. This is not my cup of tea.
Excellent LP! Start to finish a classic!!
6/10 Favorites: Your Protector Oliver James
This is a very ‘ nice’ album. Nice music, nice vocals, just nice! I think the first half is better than the second as it seems to wane towards the end. Also I do prefer Birdy’s version of White Winter Hymnal. Overall it’s quite good, a nice listen. Haha
Helplessness Blues is infinitely better. But White Winter Hymnal is so damn good that it makes the whole album worth it.
Felt like I was whimsying through a forest
I could see getting into this album a bit more. I have heard one of these songs before. It's not the vibe for me right now.
My understanding is that this is super high-quality modern folk. Technically, I get that: we have good production, decent arrangements, and relatively skilled musicians. It's just so boring, though. Any yes, folk is generally boring, but none of CSNY would recognize this as folk. This band has nothing to say (to a non-WASP, suburbanite audience at least). It's kind of as if a Stepford wife made a folk album. Just really boring. Influence 3. Quality 3. Intangibles 1. Sleepy go night-night 1. I'm giving it 3* because this album is so middle-of-the-road in every way imaginable.
meowy my baby
A nostalgic album for me. I listened to this a lot with my family while growing up. And it very much holds up to the nostalgia. It's just kind of the perfect indie pop album. The vocal work is incredible and might be the highlight for me. "There's noooothiiiiiiing I can saaaayyy-ay-ay-aaayyyy" that would be bad about this album. Favorite Song(s): Ragged Wood, Quiet Houses, Meadowlarks, Oliver James
I should love this more than I do. Interesting melodies, sweet instrumentation and wonderful echo to the production. It also sounds like all of the other "retro folk" groups that came out around this time. Great background music while cleaning the house.
I enjoyed this. Good chill out album
6/10
3.5/5
Does it feel a little "indie-folk-by-numbers" sometimes? Sure, but that's because they were the originator of a lot of that! Even if these songs aren't always the most memorable, they've got harmonies that are almost on par with those of the Beach Boys! Easily one of the prettiest indie albums there is.
i forgot a bout thus!
Not for me
Ah nice. Always a bit novel to see the modern end of the list and never really given these a concerted listen across an album… It feels such an original sound, and especially at its release. But there is also something of it being a little repetitive or variations on a theme. Pretty good songwriting and great atmosphere and depth, but the songs can sound pretty similar and ultimately using the same sound and approach. Was pretty done by the end and got the gist (3.5)
Pleasant listen, but nothing mind blowing. This era of highly produced indie-folk always feels a bit insincere.
Food album, folky. 4/5
etheral forest trippiness
5.7/10
Listening with no background knowledge whatsoever. Let's see how I do. Folky start. 60s Steeleye Span feel. To start with at least. Production seems too clear and even to be 60s though. 60s band loved to overuse Stereo didn't they? Ok so how wrong am I! For a start they are American. And it's 2008! Quite mellow. Nothing I want to 'move about' to or that makes me want to listen to again more deeply. Could be any folk band of the last 50 years. Not bad though.
My goats
i can’t deny that it’s good, but this really isn’t my style of music at all. there’s some songs i like quite a lot, but it just still isn’t a sound i connect with much. it goes for a very “natural” and acoustic sound, and i think i’d like it a lot more if it wasn’t so clean and almost overproduced. final thoughts; it sounds like cishet ethel cain
Extraordinary debut with such well developed sounds and songs.
I haven’t listened to this in a long time. Beautifully written and unique
So nostalgic of 00s indie
I like indie music but this one was a chore to get through. Every song felt the same like it was one long continuous track.
An entry in the brief but massive "stomp clap" genre. From this distance, they tend to blur together. It's fine, but not notable.
Decent. Not amazing. Early on, I thought this album was pretty boring. Some nice harmonies and decent music, but nothing spectacular by any means. Later on, I though this picked up a bit. Heard Them Stirring and Blue Ridge Mountains were my favorites off of this. A good record, worth the listen. Not anything I would come back to regularly though.
nope
The epitome of "Stomp Clap Hey" music- part of the wave of Folk re-re-revival around 2010. The album is good for a debut- they have a nice sound and it'a pleasant to listen to. Overall- 3.5/5
Har sett dom urtrista live några gánger kanske påverkar det omdömet omedvetet. Dom bästa låtarna från denna tid finns ju faktiskt på "Sun giant" ep'n, i synnerhet då “Mykonos" så albumet blir lite av en besvikelse och ganska jämntjockt utan riktiga toppar. "winter hymnal" och "Blue Ridge mountains" gillar jag bäst. Det finns nåt hos FF som stör mig väldiga, kanske är det delvis stämsången men inte enbart. Det finns nåt närmast fromskt och frireligiöst över det. Det låter som Pingstkyrkans fria musiktimme, provocerade oförargligt på ytan men hjärntvättande en bit under densamma. Den känslan har stört mig från allra första början hos FFnoch gör fortfarande. Klarar tvåan
Jag förstod inte hajpen om Fleet foxes när den här skivan kom i skäggrockens år 2008. Det är ett hyfsat band med hyfsade sånger, hyfsad stämsång. Mycket mer är det inte. Och jag har ungefär samma åsikt när jag hör den i dag.
Det var inne med stämsång å skägg vid den här tiden. Gillade det då och märker att det håller förvånansvärt bra fortfarande. White winter hymnal och your protector är i en klass för sig men även övriga spår låter sig lyssnas på utan att det gör ont. Stabila fyra solar.
Jag gillade detta skarpt när det kom. Hade det som trea på årsbästalistan. Normalt är jag inte så förtjust i stämsång, men här funkar det för det mesta. Några starka låtar (White Winter Hymnal och Ragged Wood) men också flera rätt trista spår, särkilt de tre avslutande. Inte lika förtjust idag som 2008.
A solid outing in the indie-folk renaissance of the late 2000's/early 2010's. I prefer Of Monsters and Men and Mumford and Sons, but Fleet Foxes was a pioneer and is still pretty good stuff.
Just all around good.
2 out of 5. Pretty album art, and one or two songs here were nice to listen to.
Is this considered Americana? It’s a good album
Really enjoyed.
Cosy!
Somehow sounds massive and intimate at the same time. One of my favourites
I’ve come to terms with it… The way I rate music is irrational. So much of how I feel about albums is tied to where I was when I first heard it. 2008 was awesome. So is this album.
Paying attention to this reveals a lot of finely crafted melodies. It's also not produced in an overly clean fashion like some of the following folk rock of the nest decade will be.
Väldigt bra sånginsatser. Fina melodier. En fyra
Sometimes the hipsters are right about things. A perfect album for fall going into winter. Favorite track: White Winter Hymnal 3.5/5
really enjoyed
The worst of that wave of mid 2000s folk revival we had to endure. Just feels incredibly phoned in and without any real heart at all. I’m glad Father John Misty jumped this ship when he did.
Little bit boring.. 3/5 max eher 2/5
boring
Listening to this is like listening to a good preacher's sermon. Even though you can tell they have the talent, it's super boring and a little part of you wants to die the whole time.
Found out after listening to half this album that this is the indie/folk band who did "Mykanos" - This (earlier) album sounded a bit "echoey", and less melodic/more "whiney" than I had hoped given how much I like the sound of Mykanos. Yeah I could throw a song or two from this album into a broader playlist (such as "Your Protector") but those echoey backing vocals are something I would struggle with for a repeat listening of the full album.
Have always loved this album. Wonderful for a Sunday morning.
Fleet Foxes is perfectly pleasant, but it's like being in a coffeeshop with good vibes, and you enjoy sitting there with your book and never ever look up who's playing the music. 3.5
3/5
Good, but not as good as the critics thought
I was part of the maddening crowd that bought this album when it first came out based on the song White Winter Hymnal. When I heard the entire album I slipped it back into its cover and never listened to it again. It’s difficult to identify individual songs because I’m never quite sure when one song ends and the next one begins. A calculated soulless affair.
Been ages since I’ve heard them. Time for a revival?!
Occasionally more Pet Sounds than Pet Sounds. And almost more CSNY than CSNY. I should love this album but it somehow doesn't quite make an emotional connneection. So as it stands it's notable mainly for those pub quizzes where you have to name 3 drummers who can sing and write songs...