Reviews (page 4 of 14)
279/1001 Yes - Fragile Heard before? ❎ Revisit? ✅ I did enjoy the noodly psych of this and was constantly engaged, definitely one I'd be happy to revisit
Musical masturbating?
Makes for an excellent morning commute soundtrack.
Long Distance Runaround
Wasnt the biggest fan of this album, couldnt really listen the full versions of any of these songs. There is really something missing here i mean the ones that were only instrumental were just repetitive. I wouldnt really listen to any of these songs except "Long Distance Runaround"
Love me some Jojo
I'm not a huge fan of Yes. It was alright prog, but not my particular style.
2 - So Shmedium I really was underinspired Fav Songs: Mood for a Day // We Have Heaven
So pretentious. I typically really like "prog" but Yes has always been a "No" for me... More like a 2.7. I think it's Steve Howe that I don't like.
4.25. This was really good. Pretty sure my uncle (or someone equally as nerdy about this type of thing) told me he used to use Yes albums to calibrate and configure his home stereo.
There were moments of guitar and bass brilliance and Roundabout is an all time song but the album as a whole felt like it was made up more of musical ideas and not complete songs. My dad has been challenging me to learn "Mood For A Day" on guitar for 20 years and I still haven't.
2.5 - I’m not a no on Yes, but I’m not a yes on Yes either. I enjoyed some of the prog rock moments, but not the mixing with classical music.
Good
para comenzar. no me gustó tanto y a decir verdad, no tengo mucho que destacarle a este disco más allá que tiene una interpretación que me agrada. fuera de lo anterior, disco simplón y repetitvo desde el tercer tema. este album es para tenerlo de fondo (y sí es que) mientras haces algo más interesante que buscarle algo destacable a yes y su disco
if you're into instrumental sure, but I did not like this album. struggled to pay attention and cannot imagine trying to listen to the deluxe version
Musically complex, intricately composed, and not for the faint of heart. I've always been impressed and challenged by Yes, and that is on display here. They'll tease you with a catchy hook, and then bury it in layers of prog rock sound. Definitely influential in the genre.
High 4. Some wild stuff and some very classically pleasing stuff. Not perfect but a couple incredible tracks
Not the best Yes album (which I consider either Close to the Edge or Relayer) but very fun record nonetheless.
No doubt they are good musicians and have a distinct sound. However, for some reason, I don't really like it that much. At times, I find it even a bit annoying. I enjoyed Cans and Brahms. Overall, I enjoyed instrumental parts (especially if not overloaded with keyboards). My favourite track is probably Mood for a Day (guitar instrumental). In my view, it gets better towards the end (I also enjoyed the last track: Heart of the Sunrise). An interesting thing is that I believe that the keyboard, which is supposed to be a main element, is what disturbs me. Get rid of the keyboard, and this gets 4 stars.
Classic! Probably one of the greatest albums ever made! This is what good music is all about. So much great experimentation with the writing, arranging and recording of these pieces. I hadn’t heard this in ages and it kind of shocked me how great it sounded so many years later. I noticed so much more happening in the mix! The short pieces showcasing each band member are great little interludes to the epic long form songs. I enjoyed this listen so much I’m probably going to have to put this on again soon!
Just a few days ago, The Residents showed me just how bad art rock can be. Today, Yes demonstrate the other end of the spectrum, and you could really say that the whole world lies between “Duck Stab” and “Fragile.” The latter starts with “Roundabout”—perhaps the quintessential Yes song. I find the album’s concept—linking just four “real” songs with short instrumentals—very compelling, by the way. Of course, “Roundabout,” “South Side of the Sky,” “Long Distance Runaround,” and “Heart of the Sunrise” are what most listeners remember, but the other tracks connect them with such virtuosity and dramatic tension that is rarely achievable in a song-by-song format (Abraxas would be the counterexample). And although a different musician takes center stage each time, everything sounds like it comes from a single mold. In this respect, Yes are even playing in a higher league than the Beatles at this point, who simply failed to pull off this feat on their similarly conceived White Album. In my opinion, this is due to the great virtuosity of truly every Yes member—something very few bands can offer.
There are some great tracks on here, and it’s way more jammy than I expected, but I dig it. That said, a few songs fall flat for me and break up the flow a bit. Overall, I’d put it around a 3.5/5.
BUENISIMO ME ENCANTA livianito de escuchar
On the strength of the very first song this gets a 4. Rest of it is... experimental, shall we say.
No conocia ninguna cancion del album, sabia que existia una banda llamada Yes pero nunca le di bola. Muy buen sonido muy charly epoca seru y maquina. canciones agregadas: 4/9 album muy britanico de los 70 progresivo
I somehow didn't know where that one section from the beginning was from, now I do. The album was very good. I liked the vocals the long instrument sessions.
As I’m sure I have mentioned in other reviews, it took decades for me to get over my innate aversion to prog rock and while I am significantly more open minded on the subject, I remain cautious if not downright cynical. As I have dabbled, I have confirmed that I cannot tolerate ELP and some others, but I have also learned to, first accept, and later embrace Yes. My Yes gateway was Close to the Edge which seemed to transcend prog into a place of pure, joyful celebration of music. My next foray was this album Fragile, and I was initially dubious. Having now familiarised myself with the album, I can see that the issues I was having on early listens are the same problems that still cause me to rate it below Close to the Edge. The band’s “great” idea to give each member their own spotlight at various points across the album’s duration may be something that makes some fans drool over Fragile as unique, but to me these tracks are a cop-out, and I actively dislike some of them. Had they shown the conviction to instead come up with just one more track of substance and left off the indulgent filler altogether, this would likely have been a 5* album. The ones we do get (Roundabout, South Side of the Sky, and Heart of the Sunrise) are all-timers in the Yes catalogue. So, still a brilliant record, but if I had it on CD rather than LP, I would likely skip some tracks.
1/5 MEME SONG LMAOOOOO I didnt like it tho, very dad music vibes…
Fun album, pretty weird but in a good way
Pretty good. A couple of solid songs. Fun explorations.
The keyboards didn't work for me. The bass was fun.
Ba
The first song on this album is so good, get you really pumped up to listen to a... really mediocre album. Songs have bizarre lengths. Why does a 7-minute song go into a 30-second song? None of the songs, besides the first again, are all that memorable or all that good.
So confusing. Sometimes good, sometimes just realllyyy confusing.
Roundabout es joya El resto del álbum disfrutable, siempre sonidos frescos
No
Progressive rock at its finest.
Okayish
Prog rock with complex arrangements and unusual, shifting time signatures. I've heard this before and it's a lot of fun to listen to every now and then but not quite accessible enough to want to put on repeat. Long Distance Runaround is my favourite, but since my last listen I have a greater appreciation for the beautiful acoustic guitar in Mood for a Day.
Top moumoute belle bite
Roundabout is a fantastic song. The brahm's symphony excerpt was unexpected. I just kinda.... Don't think I get it? But of course that's the point lol
Rock progresivo
that one song bruh
Experimental prog finnin parts I like roundabout but everything just feels too long
I always knew and loved Roundabout, being a Jojo fan put me onto the song. The last song is nice, too. I don't really see the point of those < 2 minutes song, they feel like fillers for the spaces before the big ones. Even the 2 - 3 minutes one feel a bit dull when I know what the band is capable of.
No, my second Yes album in under a month. Too much prog rock for me again who needs a nearly 11 minute prog version of Simon & Garfunkle's America? Not me. 2 stars
80/100. Another strong showing by Yes. In my opinion this is some prog rock of the highest calibre, it feels like a band that can truly have fun while being really creative with their sound. It is a landmark album for the genre.
Most solo stuff is ok. Mood for the Day being the best. 5% of nothing is filler. Group songs, my favorite is Heart of the Sunrise.
Very proggy, but too much for my taste at many times, sometimes I'm listening to some nice build-up to a melody and it gets interrupted. It has some standouts but aaah the proggy-ness of it all sometimes makes me like it less. 1. Long Distance Runaround 2. Mood for a day 3. Roundabout
Very interesting to hear true prog rock. It was okay.
Overall a really good album. The bass lines are snappy with good tone. Pick style playing over the bridge for a very metallic sound.
The most prog of all that has ever progged. Kinda annoying tbh
Good vibing music for chilling on the bean bag
Familiar with the first song - honestly a bit tired. Love the progressive rock elements and experimental style. The opera elements and choral singing style in track 3 are a little off putting. Second half of the album was wonderful. Ended up favoriting 4 tracks and 2 that Spotify delivered once album was over. I will be back. 4/5
I didn't realize Yes was around in the early 70s. I first heard them in the 80s with Owner of the Lonely Heart and Leave It. Roundabout was familiar, and I would have thought that Long Distance Runaround was from the early 80s as well. 4
I like that one, may relisten
Pretty good with a catchy base line. Nice album
Nearly made the mistake of listening to the super deluxe edition… the fist song was good vibes and then got a bit bored
I was quite enjoying the first track but it all became a bit too noodly and self indulgent for me later on. The pseudo classical seemed unnecessary showing off really. Very much of its time. 3
Roundabout Long Distance Runaround Heart of the Sunrise
The quintessential Prog album by the quintessential Prog Rock band. Yes really got into their stride here. Their previous albums were good for sure, but this one reaches far above that. It has the variety you'd expect and long for in Prog. From classic rock staple Roundabout, right into a classicaly inspired piece. The album is also just really well made and produced. I'll never get tired of the Bass on Yes albums.
All roads lead back to JJBA.
Just not my genre - this kind of psychedelic rock... Could work for a BBQ, idk
Fun to see where the famous riffs and opener came from!
I repeat from the last Yes album. Only gig I’ve ever walked out on and I stand by it.
I'm a sucker for the upbeat and dynamic acoustic guitar sound, and found this enjoyable, if a bit inconsistent
Lots of memories associated with this album. First introduction to it was in high school by classmates. It’s been a while and only recognized three of the songs. Seemed longer than I remembered. Maybe I had more patience back then. Stoners across the hall in college borrowed it (a lot). lol. Worth the time to listen and will likely stick it back in my rotation.
Great album of course from a super-group. I've heard these songs many times though it's been a while. I was really hoping to pull some nuance that I hadn't heard before but no. The album sounded muffled. It is a known issue with the recording that the re-issues have tried to fix. Oh well. Maybe the 60th anniversary AI edition will fix it!
Desperado goes to the circus. I'm here for it.
Really good album. Roundabout is an all-timer. Lots of really interesting ideas. I really liked Cans & Brahms. About a 3.5 rounded up.
The instrumentals were not really my thing. But I enjoyed the actual songs (ha). 3.5
If you like prog rock, I can't see any reason why you wouldn't like this album. But if you don't, then aside from some iconic guitar riffs, there isn't much for you here. It could be a solid introduction to what prog rock from this decade was, but there's always a certain pill you have to swallow when it comes to this genre. It's nerdy, it oozes nostalgia, but ultimately it just feels too niche to really shine. Highlight: Roundabout (the guitar parts of it)
Roundabout is practically a 5 star album on its own but the totality of Fragile comes just shy for me. Still a fantastic album overall.
I don't think everything on here works as well as Roundabout and Long Distance Runaround (best track on the album by the way) but I love this
I like my music Past Progressive
I expected to hate this - pretentious, noodly, soulless prog. But it had some nice moments when they stopped showing off and noodling about.
Это определенно один из знаковых, значимых релизов жанра прогрессивного рока. И неспроста. Очень воздушный, приятный альбом с замечательным вокалом от Джона Андерсона. Понравилось что некоторые большие произведения на альбоме сопровождаются короткими сюитами и, своеобразными, музыкальными зарисовками, вместо того чтобы наваливать 5-6 треков длинной по 15-20 минут, как это делали некоторые из групп этого жанра. Альбом как минимум стоит прослушивания хотя бы из-за Roundabout, который знают многие, но на Fragile и помимо него есть отличные: South Side Of The Sky, Long Distance Runaround и Heart of the Sunrise.
19. Yes - Fragile (1971) Вывод: как сложное может звучать естественно, а кажущееся хрупким выдерживать любые испытания временем. Пять индивидуальностей становятся одним организмом, не теряя лица. Музыкально он строится на чередовании полновесных групповых вещей и коротких сольных фрагментов каждого участника. Симфонический размах с вокалом Джона Андерсона (я обожаю его узнаваемый голос) парит над всем этим, не вступая в борьбу с инструментами, а дополняя их. Обожаемая мною атмосфера ранних 70-х, когда рок впервые задумался о жанровых границах и сочетаниях. Fragile звучит как идеально настроенный механизм, но с яркой энергией. Это достаточно уверенная попытка удержать красоту в мире, где всё стремится к хаосу.
RYM 3.5
Very much enjoyed the instrumental interludes and the heavy focus on instrumentals throughout, even in the longer songs. Very pleasant to listen (and of course, Roundabout is a classic!)
While some songs do not stand out, the whole project is a great listen. I am not the biggest prog rock guy but this is the best album I have heard in this genre so far.
Tedious and pretentious
Liked the first song and the last song. Unfortunately, there is a double album of well-played but forgettable songs
Definitely a mixed bag.
Maybe if I listened to this more I'd get into it, but it never really caught me on two runs through. A bit too clever and nerdy?
Yes, I'm so sorry I'm not familiar with your game. I really need to be. This rules. I think a couple of the solo tracks are a slight miss, but I'm not going to hold that too much against the album, since it was limited because of money/time, but this album would be so much better if it didn't have them. I loved this a lot more than I thought I would. Even the music, for being rock, is very melodic and developmental. And now I feel like I need to be on the lookout for Yes albums on vinyl. Favorite Song(s): Roundabout, Long Distance Runaround
It's no steely Dan but it's close
1001 albums bizarre adventures
Prog rock just isn’t my thing. There were a couple of good songs on here but I didn’t enjoy the majority of this album.
A great start to the album with Roundabout kicking things off. Very cool guitar licks and a soulful bass coming through to complement the high end vocals and synthesized keyboard. Things were tempered quickly thereafter. One song (Five per cent for nothing) sounded straight out of a video game and I have no idea why that was included on the album. Middle of the road for the rest of the tunes. It’s decent rock and roll, but there is nothing special about this album in my opinion.
Maybe I’m not sophisticated enough to get Prog Rock, but I bet it sounds great when you listen to it sitting alone in your parent’s basement on a Friday night. I penalized them one star for that cover of America. That was unforgivable.
I like prog rock, but I don't "like" like prog rock. Fragile is super proggy prog rock. I like it. Roundabout is an absolute classic banger, always a favorite. The rest is a fun and intersting listen, but not something I revisit very often.
fuckin CLASSIC front to back? listened a million times already. south side of the sky underrated as hell
Purely Yes. Very virtuous musicians. The voice captivate the mood of the song.
It's fine. Probably the prog rock band that I like the most. But just not my thing
One of my favourite prog albums of all time and a clear prog masterpiece this is. Easy 5 stars from me, without too much pondering needed here.
Yes.
Progressive rock.
This was so bizarre. I knew the first song out the gate, but don't ask me how I know it. The rest of the album wildly swung between something incredibly 70's and something that could've been made in the mid 00s. An eclectic album, one that I strangely enjoyed.
Prog rock is absolutely not my favourite. In particular, I dislike self indulgent guitar solos. The voices sound so young! Which was strange to me as I associate Yes with old men. That was the case in the 1970s, even more so now of course.
I’ve always been very fond of Roundabout, but I’ll admit I've never listened to anything else from this album before. I was pleasantly surprised by the variety and the musicianship on display here. The keyboards, bass, guitar, and drums are all outstanding. It was certainly much better than yesterday’s prog rock album, Larks’ Tongue in Aspic, which I somewhat hesitantly gave 3 stars to. I feel inclined to give this 4 stars by comparison, a relatively solid 4 stars though.
Not Great.
Fun vibe/beat. Enjoyed 'roundabout'. Enjoyed the piano moments. 3/5
Definitely an interesting experimental kind of album, but not really something I'd consider a "must listen".
4 Rest of the album doesn't quite live up to Roundabout but it is one of the best songs ever written to be fair. Still a solid album though
Prog isn’t for me, but this was less meandering and 70s fantasy rock than some of their other albums so it was tolerable.
I recognized Roundabout. Great song.
Hard to review this album as I've been listening to it since I was 16 years old. There's quite a bit of nostalgia involved so I may be really biased here but it's one of the best albums out there. But I gotta say this website did help me appreciate this album a bit more. Given that I have one album a day. I really had to pay attention to each song and just enjoy the ride. It gives me classical, experimental while also giving me a sense of futurism that I could never comprehend. It's really an expedition through different genres.
Weird. Like Renaissance Fair rock.
If any of you were planning to get into progressive rock, Yes's Fragile is practically the perfect choice. This album is easy to listen to and not overly complicated. It sounds beautiful, if a bit heavy in places. However, if you start to analyze it in more detail, you realize that none of the parts are easy to play, and yet the musicians have managed to juxtapose them without degenerating into cacophony. Are there any downsides? Of course there are. Of the nine songs on the album, only four are full-length; the rest are short vignettes from each musician, a sort of "talent showcase". Here's a keyboardist arranging a piece from Brahms. Here's a short drum fill. Here's an acoustic guitar number with a medieval sound, and so on... They're all skilled guys, they've proven themselves, there's no denying it, but these performances could have been reserved for live performances only. What else can I say? ⬅️To Be Continued
This album is one hell of an experience, it throws you from prog rock to classical to beautiful instrumentals and back again. I had to listen to it twice through, and once more a bit later on, just to work it out. Some of the shorter tracks aren't the best and a bit forgettable, but the strong tracks are STRONG. My favourite songs were Roundabout, South Side of the Sky, Long Distance Runaround, Mood for a Day and Heart of the Sunrise. Mood for a Day is a gorgeous instrumental track. Roundabout is a classic and Heart of the Sunrise is just as good. My first experience listening to Yes was a very enjoyable one.
9/10 (changed to 5 from 4)
***An ok album, easy listening
banger absolu surtout l'intro et l'outro
it was fine but morning stuck out to me
It was fine, a bit too repetitive
Kende alleen het eerste nummer van tiktok
4.5
Beetje te experimenteel maar wel goed
super cool music, guitar, musicianship, psychedelia.... there are many points where I can really hear where KGATLW got inspired for their early sound. but also, I don't think it warrants 4 or 5 for me as a matter of personal preference.
Although this has easily Yes's most popular song on it, I actually find it more disjointed than its surrounding albums, owing to the structure of mostly short solo compositions sandwiched by the group-led prog epics. It's still a 5 though
Shoutout to the reviewer who said that this was Roundabout and an album full of scrapped Super Mario 64 music and weird experimental jams. They were not wrong, however, I did enjoy listening to it!
I vaguely remember giving multiple attempts to this album at some faraway point in my life, influenced by a certain anime and hunting for more Roundabout-type songs. I suspect I bailed pretty quickly each time when the second and third tracks sounded nothing like the ending theme of my favourite show, because nothing past 'We Have Heaven' sounds familiar to me now. ...This album is excellent. The band takes many sorts of left-field detours, which I've learned is due to every song being written by a different member? But I just chalked it up to your usual prog fuckery, and from a band like Yes that's more than welcome. Maybe that’s just something I’ve grown to appreciate more with time. What’s funny is that the album ends with exactly what younger me was looking for: a longer, proggier Roundabout-type song. It might honestly be the best cut off the album! I now curse my past self for never sticking around long enough to hear it. What a fool 😭 Standouts: Roundabout • Cans and Brahms • We Have Heaven • The Fish (Schindleria Praematurus) • Heart of the Sunrise
This album is good but it lacks the cohesion of Close to the Edge and I feel like a lot of the middle is kind of soft and forgettable. The ends are perfect.
Yes, yeah even. The full-band songs are taking much of the credit here, but those solo songs add to the experience. It's satisfying to hear We Have Heaven reprise at the end (9/10, 5/5 on this scale)
Wow, this album held my attention the whole way through, what a creative collection of pieces. Very cool, much enjoyed.
Saw them in concert when I was 20, they have some hits you forget are them. Decent album.
Brings back fond memories of my college buddy since he put it on often. About a third of it was good, but I have a problem with the rest. Too prog-rock for my general listening.
lol I mean it’s fine? some songs way too long but it is funny how hard Roundabout goes despite its new connotation
I enjoyed it, it was some good fast driving music.
i think i only knew "Roundabout", so this was an interesting listen-- with "Roundabout" in a vacuum for me I wouldn't have guessed this was a mostly prog rock group, and that sound is way more evident on later tracks. we haven't rolled a lot of prog rock (that I can remember, anyway), but this stands out as the best (read: the only good) prog rock album so far. "Long Distance Runaround" was also a lot of fun.
This was a cool album. I'd only listened to Roundabout before, but the whole thing was filled with such an impressive wall of finely layered sounds. What a joy.
I'm not sure what the deal is with this one but it didn't do it for me. It felt like the cry for help of someone struggling with HPPD. 1-1.5
The story behind this album's inclusion on the list is actually quite interesting, as it was intended for the companion book "1001 Albums that Make Brandon Want to Die" but ended up here due to a publishing mix-up. An understandable, though unfortunate, error.
Roundabout fucking rules, the rest of the album has lil’ flashes of brilliance. But I’m learning that’s the prog rock thesis statement: “We’re going to try a whole bunch of wacky shit, and maybe some of it sticks”
Classic prog
Meh. Roundabout is the only somewhat redeemable song and that isn't even very good. The rest of this album was a giant question mark that I didn't enjoy at all.
I love the unique idea of “each band member gets his own song for the album”. It’s a super fun concept that gives the album flavor, though there are better Yes albums out there
Great background noise
A strange album. There are some very cool moments on here, especially Roundabout, but then most of the album sounds like a recorded jam session - and while technically the playing is very good, I didn’t find most of it very interesting.
What an amazing album that I know very well. It's interesting how on this album Yes works well as five masterful individuals and as one cohesive group. Liked Songs Added: Roundabout South Side Of The Sky Long Distance Runaround The Fish (Schindleria Praematurus) Heart Of The Sunrise
ok another jojo’s reference
4 disks, 4 hours running time! FML. Made the decision to judge this off the 1st disc, as the others seemed to be the same songs just remixed. It was ok, not sure if I’d be rushing back
Felt like it dragged a bit
One of the best prog bands of all time. This album is a masterpiece.
Roundabout - найкраща, інші теж добре впринципі
Moeilijk, raar, gedurfd, geweldig! Niemand klinkt zoals Yes hier, zelfs Yes zelf.
Delightfully silly! I used to listen to a lot of prog back in the day and I loved it. Listening back now it does seem like a lot of self indulgent twaddle! But fun none the less.
Really enjoyed it
Its more of like a 3.75 than a actual 4 its good, but not amazballs. It was also weird in the timing of each song it was like 7min song, 1.5min song, another 7min. overall would buy to have on record I think.
I love this album!! The harmonies, vocals and keyboards are perfect.
Strong start, and generally I quite like prog rock, but this was pretty uneven and all over the place.
WUGH. happy and bright and nostalgic 10000/10
03/03/2026 *1. roundabout - more acoustic than i thought it would be... oh my god i've heard this before! bass is great!! really like the vocals :) love the quieter bit about 5 mins in. 2. cans and brahms - harpischord-y? sounds like something off of the soundtrack for a clockwork orange. nice! 3. we have heaven - kindof folsky... love the bass and the drums. love the layering... like the ending! *4. south side of the sky - very atmospheric... why do so many prog songs start with wind blowing. love the drums.... guitar and bass are so great! love the organ (keyboard?) in the back. love the electronic thrumming noise.. 5. five per cent for nothing - ooo liking this :) only 35 seconds though.... nice palette cleanser after a longer song. 6. long distance runaround - reeaaally liking the bass and drums on this album. *7. the fish (schindleria praematurus) - nice! 8. mood for a day - nice as well :) *9. heart of the sunrise - really liking the start...feel like i've heard this before... love it!!! bass is great again!!! <3 great ending.... found out about the song starship troopers literally two days ago and made a mental note to listen to yes and this showed up! really liked it. maybe because yesterday was pink floyd, i don't think i enjoyed this as much as i probably would've if it was a shit album yesterday - but still wanting to listen to the other albums of theirs on this list :)
Me: Mom, can we get the Pink Floyd album Mom: We have Pink Floyd at home This is the album at home ...
Dużo różnorodności, Roundabout oczywiście znałam. 3,5/5
Ultra lange lieder omg Funky i like Bisschen weird/anstrengend ein ganzes album so zu hören Experimentell, wie weniger palatable pink floyd
Eu amei o álbum
I've never really understood prog rock... and listening to this entire album did very little to further that understanding. Talented musicians for sure, I just can't get my head around the concepts.
Unfortunately faded into the background for me after Roundabout, which is not enough credit to the band that went from this album to do "Close to the Edge" (which surely will pop up on this list if this did?) to somehow going on to write quintessential 80s pop cheese in the form of "Owner of a Lonely Heart"
Pretty sure putting a bunch of really good songs surrounded by some filler songs is actually a jojo reference 3.5
not my type
meme song was cool but otherwise unremarkable
Un po' troppo sperimentale per i miei gusti
Ej, this looks familiar! Album, k sm ga v avtu že kar nekajkrat poslušala. Ta začetek z "Roundabout" je fakin amazing. Tko lepo počas, dokler te kar naenkrat ne fukne v najbl hitr kitarski (basovski?) ritem (glih berem, ker nism bla zihr - I guess je to dejansko bas del, v zadnjem verzu zaigran na električno kitaro). "South Side of the Sky" je hud. Prog rock je I guess ful hit or miss za ljudi. Na tem albumu maš skoz vmes kratke komade, k so al variacija na klasiko ("Cans and Brahms"), general weirdness ("Five per Cent for Nothing") ali pa čudovita akustična kitara ("Mood for a Day"). Po pa te 7-12 minutni komadi, k te popeljejo na celo potovanje. And I love it. "Heart of the Sunrise" je insane, sploh prvih neke 4 minut, potem se pa malo umiri. Kinda. Not really. V glavnem, kul.
I found it interesting that a prog-rock album could have moments of whimsy by incorporating folky aspects, perfectly encapsulated by "Mood for a Day". I was completely entranced by the album, I wasn't expecting to like it as much as I did. The groove, weirdness and great composition is undeniably incredible!
Sharp Distance 1001 Albums Generator 238 (3/2/2026) They way that as long as you start and end strong, people will forget if you slumped in the middle? What if you start and end with two of the greatest prog rock songs of all time (and the stuff in the middle aint bad either)? Roundabout is totally a quintessential prog song. It's one of the most famous in the genre, and it showcases a band at the peak of their abilities. From Buford and Squire's insane groove in the verses to Howe's iconic guitar work, especially in the intro, to Wakeman's fun electric piano arpeggios and organ solo, Yes is firing at all cylinders. With that said, my favorite song on Fragile has always been Heart of the Sunrise. Everything that I said about Roundabout still applies, but I think the flow is even better and Jon Anderson's SHARP! DISTANCE! is always stuck in my head. Beyond the bookends, this album is structured really strangely, with lots or short ditties, showcasing that all the members had serious composition chops. South Side of the Sky is the other epic here, and it's great. Long Distance Runaround is a really underrated, gentle track here. I don't have much negative to say about Fragile except that Five Per Cent For Nothing is a little annoying but it's 37 seconds long so I'll allow it. One of my favorite prog albums ever. 5/5. Favs: Roundabout Long Distance Runaround Heart of the Sunrise Least Fav: Five Per Cent For Nothing
No
Domne
I wasn’t aware of this band before now and then the first song came on and I was like yooo the meme song. The rest of the album is a very different vibe from the first track and honestly I’d rather it wasn’t on this album because it just makes me think of instant regret tiktoks. I can’t really blame them for that though. The guitars are definitely the main attraction here, and the other instruments support them well. They know their place and let the guitars take the limelight 90% of the time. There are a lot of shorter instrumental pieces and even when the guy is singing it’s not overbearing, which I’m fine with as I don’t really love his voice anyway. Songs like mood for a day are so stripped back and I feel like I’m listening to a medieval squire or something. And then other songs are more rocky or jazzy but it all feels consistent and flows still somehow. I enjoyed this! It’s so noodly and whimsical and fun.
Being a prog-rock album, Yes's Fragile is full of fascinating rhythms and melodies that create songs with immense depth and incredible energy. It would be impossible to catch every little detail in each song on first listen, which is why it's practically impossible to ever get tired of this album. 4.8/5
i like the first song because of the meme, i like how complex and groovie the songs are, but its not up my alley yet i apreciate them
Very cool
Just from the opening track! YES LET'S GOOO. I got a bit bored further into the album. The fire died down.
UUUUUUUUHHH i wanted to give the time to listen to this. So the that time has come. So they hit you full force with Roundabout and leave you hangin with quirky classical music. I'd hang out with the band integrants, they seem like fun. And they do it again... and again, quirky interlude after quirky interlude, we have bangers.
Très sympa!! bien séquencé, bons morceaux, bons mix, bonne longueur. pas de point haut TRÈS haut, cependant. 3.5+/5
Some great tracks but the personal solo fillers aren't are compelling except maybe Squire's Fish. Still in the top 5 Yes albums though.
JoJo reference; roundabout is peak.
5/10
I prefer my progressive rock to have more bite than this. That memey lick on Roundabout is amazing though.
ACTUAL RATING: 4.5 These characters are NOT teenagers, dude.
Weird but fun. Also, we’ll be right back
Wasn't incredibly impressed.
No
Let's go, this was really cool. Roundabout is iconic, thanks JoJo, but there are some great songs here, including the very sentimental feeling Mood for a Day, which was probably my favorite. It's not as good as the other Yes albums, as there are some strange interludes that seem like the guys just messing around. I didn't mind it, but it does make for a weaker album experience, in my opinion. Heart of the Sunrise was also awesome. Cool album.
Better than Tommy
Massively surpassed (admittedly low) expectations. So many wonderful moments - found it a pretty joyful listen that I’m glad I’ve had (even if some of the keyboard touches sound a little cheesy/dated).
Yeah. OK.
Yes. A thousand times, yes.
There's a tendency to say prog rock is endless, purposeless noodling, but I didn't get that impression from this album at all. I thought it was tight and super inventive. I can hear the influences even in post-rock or post-hardcore 20-30 years later. Came out two years after the Who's awful Tommy that I had to sit through two days ago, and sounds light years ahead (I know light years are a measurement of distance). Fav track: The Fish Least fav: Mood for a Day
Yes, I liked!
Not my style
Todo álbum que começa com clássico, é um bom álbum.
Classic
Glad I know where the audios from now. You know the one. Also some genuinely good rock in here but some that wasn’t totally for me. Cool ending though
Top 3 South side of the sky Long distance runaround
Didn't save any songs but it was fine
Nothing wrong with it at all. Interesting. But I didn’t like it.
Yes indeed. Also just want to acknowledge that for a classic British prog rock album, there’re curiously a good deal of Latin rhythms & flavors going on here.
Not for me.
would be 5 if it wasn’t for all the filler
What a ridiculous album, that opening bassline on Roundabout just kicked me in the balls
I used to like this album a lot more than now. Technically it's impressive and enjoyable but also feels empty?
I really did not like this album very much. I can appreciate the musicianship however, this was not my cup of tea. I’m not a big fan of just endless guitar wanking.
I did enjoy this album more than I thought would. I won’t be listening to it in full again, but I’ve taken a couple songs from it. I also love how short it is. Not my vibe, but not bad at all!
Some really banging music brought down by nonsensical intermissions.
sim FAVS (top 3): roundabout, south side of the sky, mood of the day mençoes honrosas: we have heaven, lond distance runaround, heart of the sunrise MEU DEUS É O ALBUM Q TEM A MUSICA DO TO BE CONTINUED KKKKKKK AMO. tirando isso, legal o album eles arrasam nos instrumentos de corda fez uma baita diferença nota final: 3.5/5
MAGA men.
Roundabout is a grrrreat track. The rest of the album is all flash no substance. Seriously what is the point in the extracts from Brahms - so pretentious. Its great to have this sort of craftsmanship and ambition in music, but I don't think this is it. Yes have better albums. 2.8/5
Release the incredible The Yes Album, tour the world, recrute Rick Wakeman, record and release the at least equally incredible Fragile. All in the space of less than a year. As far as a gameplan goes, Yes got it spot on in 1971. Yes, please!
one of the few i have on vinyl. a classic
Roundabout - 3.5/5 Cans and Brahms - 2.5/5 We Have Heaven - 3/5 South Side of the Sky - 3/5 Five per Cent for Nothing - 2.5/5 Long Distance Runaround - 4/5 The Fish (Schindleria Praemeturus) - 4.5/5 Moddo for a Day - 3/5 America - 3/5 Roundabout - Early Rough Mix - 3/5 3/5
preciso ouvir ainda omg depois eu mudo
Not really sure how to place this album genre. Wasn't bad, but not great either.
Sounded like the nerdiest kids in your music program got together and formed a band. Haha. I enjoyed it mostly but it's not something I'm going to be going back to.
Always fun to listen to a song and be like "Oh that where that meme/trend came from" Anyways, "Roundabout" "We Have Heaven" and "South Side of the Sky" are great, and I enjoyed "Long Distance Runaround" "The Fish (Schindleria Praematurus)" as well.
Yes have influenced several of my favorite bands, and I wish I could get into their music, but this just doesn't really work for me.
Too self indulgent. Minus one star for absolutely butchering America.
Side 1 is about as good a prog rock can possibly be. Side 2 🤷♂️
cult asa woodstock music
Yesss but not their best work
Went in knowing it was a prog rock big deal, and while the musicians are super talented, the genre just isn't my general thing. I dig the technical stuff and that killer bassline in "Roundabout", but the rest of the record was kinda hit or miss. All the experimental bits and those short, solo instrumentals felt more like each member showing off than a good cohesive listen. Overall, it was whatever for me. There are some awesome moments, especially in the longer songs, but the whole pretentious, over-the-top art rock thing made it feel like a drag. It's clearly amazing for people who love that kind of complex, symphonic rock, but as someone who isn't into that whole musical wizard thing, I found it to be kinda forgettable and not something I'd listen to again.
A really strong opening song for an album. It's between a 3 and a 4, but I really love the beginning. We'll see how my feelings change over time Favorite Song: Roundabout
keb maar enkel deel 1 geluisterd want wtf 4uur ma twas wel een vibe 3.5
Zeppeli: "Bastard... How many bland proggy dad rock albums are on this list!?" Dio: "Do you remember how many breads you have eaten in your life?" <----TO BE CONTINUED---|\| Genuinely, when I saw that this album had come up I rushed to see if "Roundabout" was on it - at the time, I thought this was the one Yes song I knew, having not realised that "Owner of a Lonely Heart" was also theirs. I found myself genuinely getting hyped seeing that it was the opening track, and was ready for some JoJo's Bizarre Adventure vibes. "Roundabout" is great. It's way too long, but it's great. It grooves, it rises and falls, it's just a good time. The rest of the album is more eclectic and proggy, and unfortunately every other song is also too long. This results in an album that feels drawn out and unanchored - a slightly torturous mess that doesn't give you a sense of stability for even a moment. Sometimes this would be a good thing - an album constantly keeping you in suspension and holding you there, forcing you to engage as it pulls you further along... unfortunately this isn't one of those. It's somehow both too bland and too nonsensical. It's a shame, I usually like experimental, proggy stuff. It's not completely dreadful, it's just... not great and too much of it.
Phenomenal bass work from Chris Squire. An overall solid prog-rock album. The highlights being Roundabout - obviously - and South Side of The Sky. I also really like the cover of America on the deluxe version.
Not a fan.
Yes! My first reaction upon seeing this album, was No! But then I listened to the album. And now it is Yes. Somehow, I ended up liking this one a good bit, easily the most enjoyable of the three Yes albums we’ve had. “Roundabout” goes crazy and exists as a perfect opening song. Sparks intrigue immediately, has a flare for the dramatic, gets a little tension & release. “We Have Heaven” was a very peaceful little interlude style track. Which would normally be odd this early in an albums track sequencing, but this is Yes doing prog rock stuff, where rules are intentionally thrown out the window. “Mood For A Day” kinda mirrors the same placid feeling amidst a flurry of proggy chaos. Feels like sitting in the sunshine. Then there’s a cover of S&G’s “America” that goes over pretty well. Nothing will beat the original, but this is a refreshing take on it. Can’t believe I’m giving this album a light 4/5, but Yes gets rewarded for locking in a bit more on specific melodies and motifs for Fragile, finally ditching their penchant to switch up the time signature every ten seconds just for the fun of it. That being said, this can be the last Yes album. Three is plenty.
first song on the album is FIRE
Roundabout (Of Course) Lond Distance Runaround Mood for a Day Heart of the Sunrise
It's the Jojo meme song.
8/10
Solid project Roundabout is a feat of music and the rest of the album doesn’t really reach the same heights that song does Feels like a bunch of pretty good or ok songs sandwiched between two prog rock masterpieces
This album rates this highly for me simply on the strength of Chris Squire's bass on "Roundabout."
This is a tough review to write because there was a time when I would have given this a 5/5. In fact, upon seeing this album pop up, I thought 5/5 was within reach! But after giving it my full attention for the first time in 15 years, I feel that even a 4/5 isn't quite correct. In many ways, I love Yes. They've written some of my favorite musical moments—and some of them are on this album. But, like so much of prog, there are also a lot of moments that seem to exist for stroking the band members' egos, rather than contributing to the song. It's maximalist to a fault, overwritten and under-felt. I saw a video of Rick Rubin working with Flea on "Give It Away." Rubin keeps telling Flea to "give it space" and not to be "too note-y." Yes could have really used a producer with that mindset on Fragile. "Long Distance Runaround" is a great and underrated track though. No notes on that one (except for the many, many notes throughout it).
Yes is one of my all time favorites so I was pleasantly surprised that this one was chosen.
So weird. When it was good, it was good. Much needed funk...
At least it wasn’t Too Loud™️
Yuck. Long and boring.
i liked the songs but at times the instrumentals felt like legend of zelda theme music. 8/10
What a great album
Roundabout is incredible, great lyrics, interesting instrumentation, long play time with development over the song. Rest of the songs are more a mixed bag. I would have rated this album higher if 3-4 of the duds were left out of the album and it was just a tad more cohesive between songs.
Not quite. 5 but roundabout is lovable
this band is responsible for the only enjoyable part of jojos bizarre adventures. thank you yes, you're the best
A+
The songs with lyrics are good, but fillers like “Five percent for Nothing” really harms it
There isn't anything that needs to be said about this album. The production is insane for 1971. The three long songs are perfection, and Long Distance Runaround and The Fish together make great companion pieces. ...Alright, I guess there is one thing that needs to be said: do the short indulgences from the individual band members enhance the experience or detract from it? For me, Cans and Brahms and Five Per Cent For Nothing have always been whatever inclusions, Cans doesn't work as an epliogue to Roundabout, Five Per Cent doesn't work as an intro to Long Distance runaround. And I've always hated We Have Heaven. The Fish and Mood For A Day at least stand on their own as good listenable material within the context of the tracklist. I have to wonder, if those three Side 1 indulgences had been cut, would this album be regarded as even better than Close To The Edge? But as it is, it feels like The Yes Album, but with untrimmed fat. I prefer The Yes Album to this. But come one, its still at least a 4/5.
This is the second Yes album for me in this project. And just like last time, I still can't really get into their music. I like the genre. In some ways, the music reminds me a lot of Genesis, a band I love. But still, I can't get into Yes' music. And that was also the case with this album. 3/5
Roundabout
V/Rv
I liked dis one
+ roundabout, baaaass - a lil wacky
Prog blæææh
⭐️⭐️1/2
Top songs: South Side of the Sky
This is pretty good. The first song hit me with a wave a nostalgia. This a 3 but like a good 3, not like these other 3 albums out here
Loveee the breakdown in Roundabout but way too long for no reason. didn't really care for the instrumentals except for Heart of the Sunrise.
This was ok
I've only enjoyed certain classic prog-rock artists, but not all. This isn't quite my cup of tea, even though the first is an all time classic, incredible musicianship and performance. Wish i was into it more.
Comes accross as pretentious, self-indulgent claptrap, including the alleged standout track Roundabout. 'Wanky' should sum it up.
Certified banger. Amazing bass, fun lyrics just a good time
Wow this ones fantastic- Roundabout is a great opener. The rest of the track list compliments each other in motion. I give this a 4.5 but ill give it a 5 here since there are no half stars
Enjoyable, upbeat background music for today.
Just a bunch of noise. The vocals are good. I could barely hear the lyrics.
Long forgotten album. Very nic eto hear it again. I remember well the Roundabout, but also the log distance runaround. Or is this inly a remindrer on the Yessongs Live album?
Heel afwisselend. Heel leuk! Toffe ontdekking
Super leuk en gevarieerd
This was ok, I guess? It had some interesting use of difference musical influences (think I spotted some Latin-style instrumental stuff) but some of these were way too long without actually developing a great deal. Felt like jamming within the confines of a song at times. Bleh
I think I was intrigued for about 20 seconds. I then got the annoying vocals and just to make matters worse there was organ music like it was taken from Brighton pier. Seaside organ anyone. Nope! At times it was also like there was an exorcism going on and could be taken from a dodgy film. I did enjoy the delivery, recording quality and skills, but it was so chaotic and mashed that I failed to engage with it as an album. OK, I could probably find a song or part of it I enjoyed. "Mood for the day" I thought the album had finished and I was listening to a new artist to enjoy. The next and last song was then another shift from the norm which typified the album. It was largely excellent, but it went on too long and had too many elements to it that ultimately ruined it. Interesting experiment I guess but too much I didn't like about it to consider it a coherent masterpiece.
There are three good tracks on this album. 'Roundabout', 'Mood for a Day', and 'Heart of Sunrise'. The rest of the album feels like unnecessary padding. Have I mentioned my hatred of the electric organ? Overlayed with the squeaky vocals, it got quite grating. Also, despite its varied nature, most tracks seemed to be quite shallow arrangements. Certainly not as expansive sounding as other prog rock offerings. The album has a peculiar, very British vibe that somehow remind me of films like 'Willow' or 'Time Bandits'. It's interesting that I just can't imagine anything like this being recorded now. I've always thought that Yes have a pretty middling ranking in British prog rock and this album just cements that view.
Sometimes felt a little bit like a disjointed sampler album (for example, when it stumbles into part of a Brahms symphony...)
First song’s a banger then it kinda fizzles.
Awful. One of the worst things I've ever heard.
The only Yes I know is Roundabout and Owner of a Lonely Heart. One of those is on this album, and it's 8 and a half minutes long and I liked it. The rest of the album is OK, it gets a little too proggy and Jazz Odyssey-y at times. Not bad, not great. I'd rather spend the time listening to Floyd.
Wasn't really expecting the old school vibes - decent listen
Fragile is undeniably beautiful, full of rich instrumentation and those soaring, sky-high vocals feel god damned transcendent. I appreciate the ambition and the progressive spirit, but a lot of it drifts into vibing and fiddling around - great as a background listen, less so if I’m looking to be fully locked in or emotionally grabbed.
Not my cup of tea. I'm just not into jam band type music and this was no exception. As a dear friend of mine once said, "It's like they got ripped to the gills and just stepped into the studio: 'LETS JUST FUCK AROUND, BOYS'"
Seriously though, this is what you get when you let musicians do whatever they want.
Bit over technical for its own good but enjoyed it
4/10
Very interesting.
Well, no-one pops fragile on so thry can specially listen to Tin Cans and Brahms or Five Percent for Nothing. The album really consists of four songs - Roundabout, South Side of the Sky, Long Distance Runaround, and Heart of the Sunrise - with the solo bits and bobs thrown in as, well, not padding, but bonuses. So then; the bonuses. Tin Cans and Brahms is a surprisingly accurate transcription for keyboards of the third movement of Brahms 4th Symphony and, to be honest, is the sort of thing Wendy Carlos did better. We Have Heaven is Jon Anderson being all hippy and cosmic, if you like that sort of thing. The slamming door and footsteps seem a bit Atom Heart Mother to be honest. Five Percent for Nothing is a Bill Bruford drum solo that the band play along with: all tricky time changes and rhythm tricks. The Fish is Chris Squire overdubbing unfeasible numbers of bass riffs. Mood for a Day is a sort of folk flamenco guitar piece.by Steve Howe. They're all short, they're all palatable and they're apparently there to save money on studio time. The other tracks are group songs. This was Wakeman's first outing and he brings a level of virtuosity and classically trained skills that push the band into a new level of playing. Bruford and Squire have two of the most distinctive sounds in rock music, Anderson has a voice like no other (you may think this good or bad) and Howe is a guitar dynamo. Of course the band songs are over the top and the lyrics are pretty dopey and it goes on too long and has pretensions to symphonic grandeur. But these songs rock like Grandma's chair. I put down my hard earned pocket money when i was 14 to buy the vinyl and never regretted it. 4 stars, but only because you need somewhere to go when you get to Close to the Edge.
Prog rock! I definitely enjoy me some Yes. Roundabout and Long Distance Runaround are highlights here. And very cool version of America. Didn’t even know Yes covered it. Love what they did with this. As much as I like much of the record, it does meander a bit. And the a few of the tracks are self-indulgently long. I think there are better Yes albums, but on whole, a quintessential prog rock Yes work.
It’s just not for me. Talented sure and there are moments of greatness throughout, but I just don’t really like it. Most prog rock just sounds cheesy/corny to me and this one is no different. 4/10
Me, a disgusting Zoomer: Holy shit it's the song from that meme... Wait a sec, this actually goes hard
yes
Interesting listen, not really for me but I gave it go
The series of Yes albums in the 70’s mean so much to me. These are the albums which ignited my love for progressive music and which were at the forefront of the genre. Whilst Fragile is an excellent album it does not quite reach the heights of The Yes Album or perhaps their best ever album Close To The Edge. However the stand out tracks Roundabout and Heart of the Sunrise are up there with the very best of Yes and worth the 5 stars alone. 5/5 27/1/26
tijekom: sada sam skontala da je ovo neka Vicina muzika, vec prvu pjesmu Roundabout poznajem i ovo mi je prečudno iskustvo. vidim da neke pjesme traju i po 11 min, cant wait. u roundaboutu je ova gitara PREDOBRA, ovo kao akustično, ja ne znam zašto mi je to toliko poznat zvuk. nažalost sam bila preokupirana učenjem grčkog, no cijeli je album odličan i dobit je 5 zvjezdica, definitivno se planiram vratiti i poslušati opet.
Roundabout slaps, the rest not so much. Really wanted to love this one, alas
- 0 nummers toegevoegd aan MMMM - 0 nummers al toegevoegd aan MMMM
Lots of good stuff, a few medium things that feel kinda cheap
Prog rock, wakeman Roundabout
Nothing to really add to the conversation about this album. It’s a classic for a reason. You might be wary of songs longer than a few minutes but honestly, the longer tracks like “Heart Of The Sunrise” will pass faster than you realize. By the way, the “Deluxe Edition” of this album represented by this cover is no longer available on Apple Music, replaced by a Super Deluxe Edition with a fresh remaster of the original mix, a new remix by Stephen Wilson, and some other tracks (including the band’s rearrangement of Simon And Garfunkel’s “America” and the single versions of “Roundabout” and “Long Distance Runaround”).
I loved the sound of this record, but it definitely gives me a British prog for prog's sake vibe. The music is incredible, but it definitely feels like Yes put their intense musicality first before any intellectual substance. Pink Floyd had its social commentary; Jethro Tull had its vivid imagery, Genesis had its British heritage. What did Yes have other than serious musical talent? I'm just not sure yet. The music is unparalleled, but I need more substance for full marks. Four stars.
Good album
Yeah…actually no.
Respectable ability throughout but nothing jumped out to me that I particularly enjoyed
No.
Used to listen to the shit out of Roundabout from a compilation album I had as a younger lad. The rest of this album is garbage though. And not the good kind. +1 rank for the nostalgia of the only good song on the album.