Is This It by The Strokes

Is This It

The Strokes

3.81
Rating
31542
Votes
1
2%
2
8%
3
25%
4
36%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 8 of 16)

3.5 rounded down consistent ! but maybe that’s not always the best thing …. too much of a good thing or something like that highlights: last nite, hard to explain, take it or leave it (sep 11 2024)

I came out with a headache but the album is cool. 3/5

Rather monotonous

It is what it is, which is pretty good.

not sure what to say about the strokes. i feel like i should really like them, but they're just kinda ok. they definitely have a sound. they found themselves. they have some big hits and recognizable songs. i'll give it three stars for quality music with the caveat that i wouldn't listen again without some prompting.

They remind of the Velvet Underground. They also remind me of Railroad Jerk if Railroad Jerk wasn't trying so hard to be hard to listen to. It's fine. I want to give it 2.75 stars but I guess I'll round up.

I remember when this came out and people freaking out about it, but I never quite understood the hype. "Last Nite" is great, and I like "Hard to Explain," "New York City Cops," and "Take It or Leave It," but this never struck me as a generation-defining album or anything. It's fine.

Had to go into my EQ and make sure I hadn't accidentally shelved everything off at 5khz. There's a weird master choice for the the first four songs of the album. I can hear this band's influence in other stuff from the next decade. The guitar stuff going on is fine. Vocals aren't my jam. At least they made sure it's not as annoying as it could be by sitting it so far back in the mix and rolling off everything that's not 1-3khz. Can't decide if this is a 2 or a 3. Everything but the vocals and mix is fine, probably 4 quality. The master gets better partway through the album. The vocals stay awful the whole time. No song sticks out as the hit here, my chosen marker for a 3, but there's enough consistent good across the album, if you ignore the vocals, that I guess it combines to a good song. A 3.

Iconic album that defined a genre for a generation, tight 38 minutes with no skips and catchy songs all throughout. The re-listening experience is laden with nostalgia but there's some real artistry to be found in this album. Songwriting is great, bass lines and riffs are immediate ear-worms, and the up-tempo drums are infectious. This album has energy man.

Overhyped. Maybe it "reignited" jangly alt rock at the time, but the actual music just good, not great

Great. Edgy at times , great vocals and a couple of breakout tunes

Ok so most of the songs on the album sound very similar but if they’re good does that actually matter? A really enjoyable listen with not really any poor song in there.

An easy one for me to rate as it is probably in my top 10 albums of all time. The Strokes just ooze coolness and this album effortlessly combines that raw garage sound with flawless production. The songs are short and snappy with their trademark swagger, punchy guitars and growling vocals. So many good tracks that it is difficult to find an average one. There is a case for any of them to be the lead single. I am aware that there is limited variety in the songs, but what variety combined with the shortness of the songs and album make this the perfect debut album.

Never enjoyed these guys. Nothing other than I find their music incredibly dreary. Sorry, not sorry.

Boring, boring, boring. The annoying guitar ugh. They sound like those School of Rock kids bands that you have to struggle through at sumer event's

Not a bad song on the album really. This hit at a musical peak for me so I’m totally biased but it’s a killer album and still holds up. My faves: “some day”, “take it or leave it”, “New York city cops”, and “last night”.

This album knows what it’s about.

I remember the hype when this came out and it still holds up pretty well today. Solid stuff and I do think a turn to a more natural, garage rock sound would be needed today.

This was boring. Some catchy stuff here and there, but really not that interesting.

It may be nostalgia that accounts for the fifth star, I can't be sure, but this album is an all-timer. Very of its time, yet the melodies and and hooks are so dialed in, I think it has entered and deserves its place in the rock canon.

I really enjoyed this album. I thought the singers voice would get tiring after a while, but it really fits with the crunchy guitar riffs.

Absolutely classic. One of my favorite albums, have spun this hundreds if not thousands of times all the way through. Never gets old for me.

Love this album. I might be biased, but I think it's a perfect alternative album. It has multiple hits: Last Nite, Someday, Hard to Explain, and Soma, and the songs in between are great too. Well produces, great sound all around. Have listened many times before, and it made me want to get back into the Strokes.

This is another great album I remember listening to a bunch back in highschool. A few stand out tracks with an up beat and energetic flow made this a joy to come back to. Listening to it from start to finish has been enjoyable also. Someday, Soma, and the modern age are my favorites and to me really encapsulates what this whole album was for me.

I enjoy Strokes songs individually but I find it a bit samey to listen through a full album. Still, it's snappy and distinct.

Groot fan. Het hele album lang genieten.

Legendary! Modern day classic

This was good. A solid 3.5. It started slow, but really caught fire at the end. Is it just me or does their singer always sound either flat OR like he is peaking the mics or both? I don't like his voice. The rhythm section and Instrumentals are GREAT tho. This was a solid listen. The last two songs may have been the strongest part. Liked Songs: "The Modern Age" , "Barely Legal" , "Someday" , "Alone, Together" , "Last Nite" , "Trying Your Luck" , "Take It Or Leave It"

liked songs: Sometimes, Last Night The vocals being "not trying very hard" but also clipping every time it gets loud is grating after a while. Otherwise not bad. 3.25

Someday is a certified banger. Awesome album really enjoyable! 7.3/10

good stuff

Okay not a big fan

This is solid, ‘00s post-punk/garage rock revival. I like their combo of indie emo, propulsive drums, and rocking out. But it’s nothing super compelling.

Not tooooo captivating, not much material standing out to me??

Strokin!

They really defined a sound that for years everyone tried (and failed) to follow up on

I am sorry for sleeping on you The Strokes. I had no idea. Please forgive me.

Didn't like it much at the time, and prefer „The new Abnormal“ by far.

Really enjoying the first few tracks. Never listened before to the whole album. Sounds like Gang of Youths, a favourite.

Some great songs and some just sound the same.

35m49s of sheer unadulterated joy.

Lightning strikes behind the BDO MainStage. Is this it?

That's a solid album. I've heard bits of it but never the whole way through

yes. it is it (highly overrated)

This album was the soundtrack to late teens. Many a drunk nights in clubs and just sitting in my car solo screaming the lyrics, guitar solos and bass lines all by myself!

It’s so classic. Julian Casablancas has such a unique sound, and nobody was doing this at the time. Sounds so NYC. Great record, love revisiting it.

Неплохой альбом. Alone, Together и Trying Your Luck достойны внимания.

i convinced myself i hated the strokes. i was wrong best track: take it or leave it worst track: hard to explain

Ben niet perse heel hyped

Wiffs of velvet underground and joy division, what an amazing debut album to skyrocket to fame with… Features very highly on “music connoisseurs” list and in many topster but never got further than a few of their hits. Even though the song structure is not always very complex and the album is only 35 mins long, this was an amazing listening experience. The music that “liberated” millenials. Absolute banger 5/5

Did they put an ass on the cover because I the Strokes it to ass

Great album. Have always loved this one.

Always knew about this stud

love this album, very formative for a guitar player in the mid to late 2000s. room on fire is the better album by a slight margin - if only because Last Nite got overplayed and i find that track a little annoying... when that bass comes in on Is This It though....

Like a bleached white roman replica - perfected the form in every way and with greater emotionally resonance highs: hard to explain, soma, take it or leave it lows: mayybee trying your luck?

A great record start to finish

This felt like basic radio rock: nothing overly groundbreaking, but also quality craft. But personally I just wasn’t feeling it - not something I would choose to play much again.

Is This It is often praised as a landmark album that helped launch the garage rock revival of the early 2000s. With its tight production, short and punchy tracks, and effortlessly cool attitude, it’s become a modern classic for many. But for me, it doesn’t quite hit the mark. Julian Casablancas’ vocals, which some find iconic, come across more irritating than engaging. The distant, filtered sound feels monotonous over time, and I miss a sense of warmth or variation. Musically, it’s tight and stylish, but also a bit too slick and repetitive for my taste. There’s no doubt about the album’s influence and significance, but personally, it leaves me a bit cold. 3/5

Before listening to this album, I was relatively familiar with The Strokes, especially their singles. 'Is This It' was an interesting listening as it was me experiencing a lot of the material I'd not heard by them. First thing to mention about the album, I love the production. Simple, stripped back, the subtle distortion on Julian's voice sets a great tone. Next thing is how good a set of musicians The Strokes are. That may seem naive of me to say, but for a debut album they lock into their parts. No one gets in the way of each other, the bass lines are playful when the guitars are simple, the drums are on point. Overall, this was a great listen. The tracks that stood out to me were 'Soma', 'Someday', 'Last Nite' and 'Hard To Explain' as each of these very clearly outline the identity of The Strokes in their early years. 4/5

I’m not a hater but this album feels so outdated

Much better than the last time I listened to it. I do think its a very pleasent listen and it deserves to be called a modern classic. Its just not music I go back to often.

A band that mastered their sound from the first album. Appreciate the conciseness. 11 songs in 35 minutes. The Velvet Underground is always brought up as a major influence on early Strokes, and I would agree with that when it comes to their image and general NYC attitude, but musically they sound much more indebted to New Wave and Post Punk. I honestly hear a lot of the Cars in them.

really good

I feel like I've tried to listen to this album multiple times in the past and could not get into it. And what's weird is I flat out don't remember it sounding like this. Dunno what it was, but I would have given it a 3 back then and just be done with it. But what's nice about doing this project is it allows you to revisit stuff and realize albums you didn't get into before are absolute bangers. For some reason, this album is just hitting hard for me. It's fun, bouncy, sunny, happy. Everything you want in a great album. Honestly, I think the reason I'm able to get into it this time is me gaining a deeper appreciation for post-punk through this 1001 album project. Not that this album necessarily sounds like the other post-punk on this list (maybe closest to New Order, which their album Technique is easily my favorite post-punk record I've discovered on this project), but there's just something there that kinda unlocked my appreciation for this record. Great record. Will have to listen to it more to figure out what to playlist. (Whoever decided the original cover was too risque for the US and made them make a new one needs to be shot, lol)

Pretty boring in my opinion.

In theory this should be a nostalgic ride for me, but the album is inherently intertwined with the cultural mess that followed 9/11. It's a really solid album and it's important to realise how unusual this sounded coming along in the midst of all the bright Millennial pop. Sometimes you just need something a bit grimy that sounds like it hasn't slept in days. Alone, Together is the best track.

Such a cool little album. Great sounds all the way through.

This app needs 1/2s

Solid but waaaaaay over hyped

I am not a huge Strokes fan but there are a few tracks on this album that I appreciate.

so many fun tracks, love the spunky guitar

Similar to Meat is Murder, while I love the band, this isn't my favorite album by then. I'll take Room on Fire, First Impressions of Earth, or Angles over Is This It. Nevertheless, this album is a fun listen and Last Nite is an awesome song.

Fun story: A girl I had a crush on in high school was big into the strokes. Once on an orchestra field trip, we got talking about music; I broadly acquitted myself well, and she told me I had to listen to an album she really liked, passing me her ipod and headphones. I don't remember what happened after, but it was accidentally set to repeat song, so I only heard the one song (Macchu Picchu) on repeat for half an hour before we discussed further. I didn't have much interesting to say. Anyway, this is less repetitive than that. Moreover, it's pretty good! This band was rightly beloved by indieheads in the 2000s. For whatever reason, it doesn't quite move me the way I want from music, even as I recognize that everything here is very well-executed. So it goes. 3.5 rounding up.

The Strokes have one sound. Don't get me wrong. It sounds good, but I wish there was more diversity to their sound. 3.5 stars, rounding up to 4 just because, again, it is a good sound.

there are very few albums i love more than this one---enough that it is in my spotify top 5 every single year for the last 10 years. i don't know what it is about this album, ostensibly there's nothing truly magical about it in the same way that other albums are in this list. and yet, and yet, and yet,

Someday und Is This It sind durchaus ganz cool, der Rest ist mir zu hart

Absolutely iconic album.

Excellent album! But for what I’m feeling these days just ok

Ehhhh. There's like 2 or 3 popular songs but this is really all just the same song remixed like 16 times. Good background music. Still fun tho.

Same song every time

not bad. i liked the popular songs. album got repetitive and was hard to finish.

First song, not a huge fan. A bit too monotone for me. Does convey existential dread pretty well so if that’s the goal it’s done nicely. TBH the vibe is good but I don’t feel any itch to listen to it again.

Enjoyable listen.

Came out when I was 16 and was listened to by those who didn't just go for pop music. They feel like another wave of New York effortless cool. There's a lot of fun riffs/sections; really liked the singles and the opening song.

Accomplished, lots to love!

Solid uniform sound, everything you want in an indie album

Even better than I remember. Kind of makes you want to get your guitar out and play along.

There’s enough hits on this Strokes album to sustain 4 albums by regular indie bands - and not bad bands either. It could sound like a greatest hits, if it didn’t have such a singular vision. The guitars have an addictive quality. Every song has a strong theme / concept but without sounding gimmicky. A perfect album.

Exactly as good as I remember it being.

Somehow I missed the hype around them when this came out, but it is nice to be able to listen to it quietly. I really like the hit songs, it was fun to watch the videos of them, and want to hear this album more often. Even though the last few songs are a bit less brilliant and repetitive i’ll give them five stars. I just want this album in my top list.

Very enjoyable album, a new favourite, does not feel out of place in this day and can hear how a lot of modern indie rock artists are influenced by this album. Definitely one I’ll be revisiting quite often.

thought i'd like it more

volim iako nije moj žanr više

I really don’t like to listen to the strokes. I don’t like the wealthy art school vibe, I don’t like the put-on chill guy listlessness. I don’t like the way it’s recorded, I don’t like the distorted vocals or the jangly guitars. The experience of listening is one star to me. But also I made the mistake of reading reviews before doing my own. It stands out how much people viewed albums from this time as representing a rock revival. I was still pretty young when this one came out, still enjoyed radio butt rock etc. If I had been five years older at the time I bet this would have felt like a breath of fresh air. Still sucks though.

When the first song started I didn't like the music, when the vocals started I liked it even less. I had previously heard the song "Last Nite" but even the familiarity of that didn't make it listenable. I didn't much care for this at all.

An album that sometimes suffers from the same fate as Seinfeld, of all things, as its impact, while still noted today, has been diminished to the point where I see many state that this is just the same as every other indie rock album from the time, or even that this is lesser than what came before it. I can't see it, this album has too much weight behind what it did for music to the point where, sure, much of the music spawned from it was radio fodder and even a "pleb filter," whatever that means, but this album still is like doing a complete 180 to the music that preceded it. Mainstream rock had only gotten angrier and angrier in a post-Nirvana world, and while there were calmer acts to keep the world at bay, they flew under the radar for most mainstream audiences, and Nu-Metal reigned supreme. Then, this album came along and flipped everything on its head, leading to a musical boom that some may look back as obnoxious, but I for one, quite enjoy, and even if acts like Vampire Weekend, Franz Ferdinand, or even the Killers don't do much for you, I struggle to see how there wouldn't be something to enjoy here. Julian Casablancas, instead of being an idiot hotshot, is a seemingly shy asshole with a lot on his mind, and while some of it may come off as a little whiney, it fits perfectly within the anxieties of the next generation. The world was changing, and no longer was rap rock in-charge, but rather anxiety was at the forefront of society, and this album exemplifies that perfectly. Hell, it even seemed to predict the coming war on terrorism, as the song New York City Cops was replaced by When It Started by the time of its US release for obvious reasons (and honestly, it's for the best, as NYCC is probably the weakest track here, while When It Started may be my favorite) which only proves my point more. This album was the future of indie rock, and while now for some it can come off as tired, at its release there was a reason everyone copied it. For the music, OH MY GOD, IT'S SO GOOD. The Strokes are the masters of the chorus and bridge, nearly every one here is some of the best in its genre. They're catchy, brilliantly condensed, and don't sacrifice any amount of Julian's nonchalant tone to get their feeling across. He knows when to get angry, and he knows when to hold it back to create an incredibly charming experience where there's a satisfying tug-and-pull throughout. The riffs, both guitar and bass, are also superb. It is clear from the first track that the bass playing will always be immaculate, but paying attention to the single but raw guitar allows each song to truly blossom, and matches the deadpan tone perfectly. The whole album can only be described as concise and never a dull moment. You're hopping from one hook to the next, and not a single song suffers from overstaying its welcome. It allows for a constant, albeit subtle, change that is thoroughly great. This may not be my favorite rock album of all time or anything, but it's hard to deny its greatness, even sans context. It deserves its praise, and I only can hope in the next decade or so it will receive the mini-Renaissance it deserves.

It was good, but not good enough to be like an album I need to hear

I've listened to this album a lot and I still really like it.

know it . love it.

Was not into this at all really at the time of release, it felt like just too simple “made for radio” music. I appreciate it a bit more now looking back. This really is a great album, nothing wrong with it, I just don’t love it enough to give a 5, 4/5 it is.

Somebody turned me on to this album a couple years after it came out and I immediately loved every second of it. One of my favorite albums ever and I would recommend this to anybody that hasn't heard it before.

really boring. didn’t care for any part of this album.

Better than expected

Esse disco, que já foi apontado como a "salvação do rock", foi responsável por um boom de bandas pau mole e, na época que ele saiu, eu só ouvia metal, então com exceção de "Last Nite", o álbum passou batido e só fui ouvir recentemente. E esse jeito mais "despojado", pra não dizer preguiçoso, principalmente do Julian Casablancas cantar, é legal quando não se ouve à exaustão por várias e várias cópias que surgiram depois. Esse disco tem muitas músicas conhecidas, bons refrãos, tudo é bem simples, mas divertido. Vale a importância que tem.

One of my favorites. Been listening to it for 15+ years, and not likely to ever stop. Soma, Someday, Last Nite, all great songs among the rest of the album which are all stellar offerings.

THE indie rock

another masterpiece. This one came out right at the perfect time for me. In college and trying to figure out where I was heading. The video for “last night” played allll the time on mtv2 and I was here for it!

would give 2.5 if possible. it was a fun listen but i wished there was more variety of sound on each song. they kind of blend together. not always a bad thing this genre is just either a hit or miss for me

Bored from the opening

Парни играют в гараже. Простой ритм. Классное гитарное соло на The modern age.

Freshly classic. 7/10

A classic of 2000s indie, which I would maintain is one of the peak decades for the genre. Vivid memories of sweaty dancing on sticky dancefloors to Hard to Explain and Last Nite. 5*

Clearly a very influential album on the world of indie rock. It's minimalist and tight, with simple and effective instrumentation. Fun basslines, catchy guitar riffs, upbeat and basic drums. The vocals have an interesting distortion effect, and the album has a nostalgic feel to it; helped by the lyrics dealing with young adult life, love, and angst. All of the songs are catchy and concise and pleasant to listen to; it's quite repetitive, but since I like the sound of it, and it isn't too long, I enjoy its distinct style. My favourite track varies, but right now, it might be 'Last Nite'.

An alltime classic

Boring and Monotone. Didn't realize the album finished until something more dynamic came on afterwards.

Fine for 2001 but I really don't need to revisit this.

The Rock Revival

Classic early 00s indie rock. Perfect album that gets in, makes it's point and gets out leaving you wanting repeat listens.

Pleasant overall. Liked every song. Some songs would definitely listen to again. If I put in some time listening would probably find some playlist worthy songs. All songs sounds quite similar so blends into one a bit. Heard one song from this album before but don't know where. Reminds me of an American artic monkeys, but I think that the strokes came first.

Probably my most-listened album ever. From age 16 to now. One of the best!

AAAH INCREIBLE INCREIBLE

This album came out on my 18th birthday. I didn't much like it then and thought I would give it another go. I still don't like it much. Every song sounds "same-y" and I don't "get it" I got through it, thankfully its not a long record.

Probably one of the greatest alternative records of all time. I truly am envious of anyone who hasn’t listened to this and gets to listen to it for the first time. From the first notes of the first song, it’s catchy, fun and innovative. Genre defining, era defining.. I don’t have enough praise for this album. Top tracks are Is This It, Soma, Someday, Last Nite and Hard to Explain but truly every single song on here is incredible

Decent, but not a classic. Sound pattern gets a bit tired about halfway through the album.

I remember this album was popular when I was an exchange student. I thought I hadn't heard it before, but I'd actually listened to almost all of it with the exception of Take It out Leave It. I liked this one!

Favorite: Hard To Explain

A couple good songs

A great album. Probably The Strokes best. Favourite tracks: Soma, Last Nite, Hard To Explain, New York City Cops.

Listened before?: Yes! A millennial classic.

Great album, never in doubt about it's quality. Cool backstory, and easy to mistake this for a 70s rock band.

This record saved rock & roll. 5 stars.

Best Rock album of its decade

Dosta lejm album, baš mi apsolutno ništa ne radi, dosada živa. Čak mi ne paše ni kao ono usputna, pozadinska glazba, možda samo nisam receptivna danas za ovakav BS 😁 1/5, 2/10

Хорошая музыка

Ferdig snakka

Hadde litt glemt hvor stas denne plata er

Høsten 2021. Skål og snakkes.

Last Nite is a good song. Other than that it's a bit boring. Not awful, but not really my cup of tea..

Really enjoyed revisiting this album. I wish it had more variation, but at the same time, it does not get boring because of their very original take on garage/indie music.

Solid album Given the time it came out, it has aged really well compared to temporary music!

I'm not really into this band and their ilk, but the aren't as obnoxious as don't of the others. It all kind of blends together, but it's not bad as background music.

Apart from Last Nite which I remember from when it came out and is a great energetic track, this album just left me a bit cold.

I can remember the media hype around these when this album first came out. I didn't take to them then and still don't now. I just find the Strokes a bit soulless, the understated singing doesn't help either. That said, after listening on repeat a few times, I can warm to, 'is this it' and 'last night' admittedly does have a very catchy hook. I was going to deduct further points for 'barely legal' but can't really make out what it is on about.

Like I really want to give this album a five but somehow it always kind of disappoints me when I listen to it. It feels like a five but it’s just not there

Great Album, 8.5/10. Favorite Songs: Someday, Late Nite

I love the strokes, nice throwback for me.

I'm so blinded by nostalgia

Favorites: Barely Legal, Someday, Hard to Explain While over time I have appreciated this album more for what it has done to define indie rock and its more revolutionary sound in the 2000s, I still find that, seven years since I've heard it for the first time, it's not my cup of tea. There are more songs that I've come to appreciate with time and I'm sure the record as a whole will click for me someday (lol). Unfortunately, it's not today.

The Good: Who doesn’t like a question that isn’t The Bad: Giving it an answer that isn’t The Ugly: Realizing the above is like a dog chasing it’s own tail… The Strokes… what are they stroking? It is fair to say that I really enjoyed this album. I knew 1 song, and am happy that I’m now familiar with the other 10 too. For ones, a 2000 album that I am glad to have listened to. Also, please do note that I am tired… so I will just play the album again and enjoy, and dish out 4*, maybe I should stroke something too?

Titular track is the best on the album and it kinda fades from there but overall good album

Oh come on..... just fucking amazing

This is a great album

Pretty decent

I've never been a fan of The Strokes. I find their music too muted, and I always preferred other bands from the same time and "era" such as Interpol and White Lies who have more variety, dynamics, and do more exploration in their music. However, I'd give this album a 3.5, as it is definitely not bad, and I do understand why people like it. I just still don't think it is a 5 star or absolutely outstanding album when taken into the larger musical landscape and context.

The only decent song on here is last night. The rest is garbage. 1001 album worthy: no - 83/151

Pleasing enough indie garage-rock. Part of the early noughties indie rock revival that included The Hives, Rapture, Franz Ferdinand etc. Darlings of the NME at the time, there’s very little to date it.

Liked it, no notes.

Amazing… this is just incredible.

One of the best things on this hearth

The only issue i have is his vocals, they are a tad tedious

One for the ages

It cannot be overstated how much of a juggernaut this album and band was when it came out. That raw garage band sound. The upbeat rhythms so sorely needed in the shadow of 9/11. But I never could REALLY get into The Strokes. There was a sort of NYC It-Band Pretentiousness that seemed to permeate their image and the hipster crowds that ate it all up. A silly reason to dismiss a band, but it all just kind of annoyed me. Listening back I appreciate their upbeat tempos, syncopated lyrics and general rawness, but it's still the type of record I'd borrow a few tracks for a mix tape, and not the kind of record I'd spin from front to back. Someday and Last Nite were the radio hits, but for me Hard to Explain is the absolute standout on the album.

Is it this? This is it? It is this. This it is.

Really great rock album, I feel like it was maybe the end of an era. I struggle to think of any rock albums since this that compared. Certainly not many with commercial success.

This album changed my life in high school. I love the Strokes so much.

Back to basics rock. Influences seem to come from early white rock. Very New York attitude and sound. Pleasantly listenable.

Is it groundbreaking? No. Is it very enjoyable rock? Yes! No need to overthink it. No need to get into a silly argument about whether they deserved to be called "rock saviors". Who cares? Just listen and appreciate it for what it is: great rock 'n' roll.

One of the saddest, most uncomprehending days of my life was towards the end of high school when I discovered that some of my friends who had been listening to Tool, Radiohead, QOTSA, etc had fallen for this gaggle of talentless, derivative, rich kid hacks. The soundtrack for a million transplant hipster shitheads who ruined NYC, driving up the rents and whitewashing any remnant of the culture that had already been dismantled by Giuliani’s reign of terror. Fuck The Strokes to hell. Negative one million stars. And yes I listened to the whole, abhorrent, goddamn thing. (The bass playing actually wasn’t that bad tbh.) I hadn’t realized it was released on 9/11. Makes it even more emblematic of the violent, painful transition away from the NYC of my childhood towards something colder, shallower, more disingenuous, whiter and more sanitized.

i mean its one of my favs of all time

Between 3 and 4. With a bit more heft I'd go 4, but instead, 3.

An undoubted classic of the indie rock scene of early 2000s. Simple, catchy and straight to the point, without any pretentiousness or self-indulgence to muddle everything down. The sound of a bunch of blokes messing around and having a good time doing it.

Watershed, sure, but not so sure this album, or era for that matter, has much staying power. Similar to my thoughts on Wilco, for lack of a better term, there's a contrived 'cute' or 'cool' layer that I don't care for. An 'act' isn't necessarily a bad thing, some artists can pull it off, but it seems like the exception. This is 100% judgy but I actually wonder if Julian Casablancas would be capable of anything else coming up exposed to "Elite Model Agency" life. Can you get more superficial? I guess I do appreciate the fun of it all. PS I only just realized just realized Someday and Last Nite are two different songs. 3.5

00s in de USA, zo klinkt dat. Wat een plaat! Vette nummers, originele sound

is this it?

Found it a bit samey, easy to listen to but didn’t find it holding my interest the whole way through.

This early 2000's new wave of American indie rock bands were a real breath of fresh air, after the period where all indie rockers wanted to sound (and look) like Oasis. Strokes are among the top indie bands on this side of the millennium.

Boring and dull singing, no hooks. once again.

I keep thinking The Strokes is the The Hives, confusing the bands. So I was very excited to see this album come up, but was quickly reminded that this is "the pop version", sort of American version of brit rock and not that hård hitting garage rock från Sveden. It's not a lousy record and there are tracks here I do enjoy listening, but it also has a lot of too lazy strumming.

I own a copy of this on vinyl. It's a good listen.

Have loved this album for a long time, still holds up.

Pretty all the beats under the songs are really good, but i don't like how the voice was changed. Overall really chill songs.

The singer couldn't be arsed to go to the studio, so someone held a phone up to the microphone. And he phoned it in. The songs are too similar. Tempo, texture, and the constant, busy, busy, busy rhythms combined with monotone singing. This band was part of the early 2000s glut of plural-noun-named bands trying to reinvent The Kinks. Not much to see here. Just go listen to The Kinks.

1 of 2 hitjes, niets bijzonders

I had a hard time emotionally connecting to the music, but it seems like it would be a fun time live. Reminded me of The Killers but this music feels like hearing loud busking on a beach boardwalk on a sunny day while slightly inebriated while most Killers songs sound like midnight confessions in the dark. I would put a dollar in the guitar box.

5/5 obviously. was one of the albums that founded my music taste when i was a teenager. thanks stern!!

fun album!!!! 3/5 #musicsky #albumsky

Great distorted sound on both vocals and guitar. Some nice songs on the album but some songs also didn't speak to me as much, a mixed bag.

It's fun, don't have to think too much while listening. Sometimes that's all I need.

I don’t love this band, but the album itself is pretty good. 3.4.

For its time, I’m sure it was a breath for fresh air. The New York indie rock scene of the early 2000’s was a throwback to the ‘70’s vibe. Upon further review, it’s kind of eh. Great guitars, good lyrics but a mish mash of production taking what is supposed to be a raw sound and just turns it muddy. If this is what I cut my teeth on as a teen, I’m sure my outlook would change, but it’s just not my thing.

I know The Strokes as the band that had the hit Last Nite.. and from nothing else. This is the first time I was listening to their whole album and the results just came back - I don't like it. I understand that they revived the garage rock genre, but was it really necessary? We were doing pretty well as a humanity without bands like that. Honestly though, it's a very boring album, slow and uneventful, with a vocalist that is slowly drilling a hole in your head. Nothing I really hated, but it was definitely an unpleasant album to listen to.

I really don't like this genre of rock that's characterized by singing/droning into a soup can and lo-fi guitars. This is especially frustrating to me because I know just how good of a voice Julian Casablancas has. I never found myself tapping my foot during this album. For me, the best part of the album was the clean guitar in Trying Your Luck, but mostly because it reminded me of Weezer. This was BAD bad, but I'm glad it was only 36 minutes long. I used the extra time to listen to Julian Casablancas sing something I like on Random Access Memories

it's fine. nothing fancy, but easy to enjoy.

I knew a couple of these songs pretty well between so much and modern Age. But I don't know that I've ever listened to the whole album all the way through.

Obviously class

The Strokes know how to keep it simple and just write good songs. Throwback sounds make this a fun listen and Last Nite is a certified hit. 3.5⭐️

Didn't like the whining vocals, especially on the opening title track "Is This It". I liked "Alone, Together" which was reminiscent of The Teardrop Explodes, and "Last Nite" which reminded me of Tom Petty and The Heartbreakers.

There are very few debut albums that can top this one. One of the most delightful listening experiences you'll find, either in the international release or the American release. I first picked this one up shortly after Mic the Snare's Deep Discog Dive on the Strokes, and it's quickly risen to be one of my favorite albums in general. Tows the line between downer and fun expertly: the lyrics are pretty depressing, but god DAMN if the songs aren't fun to jam to. I really can't express my love for this record in words yet, it's just a really good listen that set the stage for many to follow. No doubts about the score.

Another album with great instrumentals slightly spoiled by grating vocals. Really snappy though

What if the Velvet Underground’s songs all sounded alike and also they were fronted by a dime-store knockoff Lou Reed with no vocal range and less ability to carry a tune? I made it about halfway through this unlistenable mockery of a rock ‘n roll album before giving up entirely.

Great album.

A milestone of garage/grunge rock from my formative years.

I be Strokin' my shit to this

Consistently boppable. Catchy guitar melodies. Sort of a consistent style, but I wasn't bored. I didn't like the songs where he sounds like he's singing through a walkie-talkie.

The songs in this album are better than listening to British pop. My favorite song from this album would be "Take ir or leave it." It has some replay value.

Saw them live on this tour in a small club before they blew up and now I won't shut up about it every time their name comes up. Haven't kept up with them but this album remains tight AF.

One of the best rock albums of the 2000s

Getting strong feelings of meh.

Some cool tunes. I can imagine most of these songs being in a movie soundtrack. Gritty vocals and catchy guitar riffs. Sound is consistent throughout but can get quite repetitive and monotonous.

First time listening to the album, yeah I know. I really like the raw, energetic and stripped down sound. Love the lofi production and the gritty feel. Will definitely listen again.

I've heard all of these songs separately over the last 20 years, but this is a tight album all being said. I enjoyed it quite a bit, I think I would have enjoyed it more if I had heard it for the first time

All songs sounded the same, but it was really fun. There are some standouts that make the album really good.

One word can describe my experience listening to this album: meh. It's fine, there isn't really anything offensive about it; the songs are fine, the playing is elementary but fine, the singing is fine. I am struck by how simple the recording sounds, but on further reading it sounds like that was very much on purpose. 3 mics on the drums is pretty impressive for a more modern album, but overall the mix just sounds too thin and empty to my ears in a lot of songs, particularly in the front half of the album. I guess you could say I'm asking myself...'Is This It'? Again, I get that's the point, and it was supposed to be a modern take on more simplistic garage rock of the 60s and 70s, but it just doesn't really do much for me. I do certainly understand the impact it had on music at the time. I mean, you couldn't go anywhere for freakin' years without hearing the singles from this album, along with countless other and equally boring copycat bands. I can't really talk much shit about this album, it just doesn't really vibe with what I'm into. The Strokes are your favorite band? Cool, that's great, I probably won't roast you for it. Compared to most other pop music of the era, or even today? Yeah totally, I can get down with listening to this, no problem. But that's a pretty low bar I don't care to set. So these songs will likely only continue to be heard by me in hipster bars and other public places, where it's perfectly fine and acceptable background music that won't worsen anyone's public experience. Certainly won't enhance it much, either.

Flawless

Slightly biased as it’s my type of music and I like the strokes already. It was an album that I enjoyed listening too, but for me it didn’t have too many memorable songs on it

Really fun and energetic album with really catchy songs. Literally doesn't waste a single second of your time every song is just perfectly made 10/10 Favourite: Take It or Leave It Least Favourite: None

This is #day260 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… "I just wanted to be one of The Strokes," right? This is one of those snapshots of an album whose role in the early '00s post-punk revival is undeniable. There's something peculiar about what you hear on the band's debut. It feels like it's meant to sound vintage. There's this great mix of '70s punk and garage, but with a distinctly modern indie rock twist. Guitar pop begs the description. Sure, you can complain about the production and the buried vocals, but honestly, I don't mind that. In fact, I think that's part of what makes this album. It is what it is, a little rough around the edges. There are so many great tunes here: the title track, "The Modern Age," "Someday," "Last Nite," "Take It Or Leave It," and others. Is this it? Yes. And this is a 5 out of 5. Looking forward to #day261.

I never really understood The Strokes. The guitars and drums are extremely repetitive with distorted singing on top. There's barely any tempo changes and the rhythm stays the same. It sounds like a typical indie rock album. The good part is that the album is fairly short.

Un buon rock, del bel ritmo ma nulla di spaziale.

Maybe there was a lot of hype, but I still like this album. Another of the few times that NME didn’t lie to us.

Lots of great songs on this album, including The Modern Age and Alone, Together. There's a very specific sound to this album which we appreciated.

A bit too whiny and LoFi for my tastes. Today was not a good day for me for listening to music like this. Nursing a post promotion (C’mon Leeds) party hangover. Where’s Brian Eno when you need him to sooth? 2/5 22/4/25

Boring? Not my jam! I can see why people find it as thrilling as watching paint dry. 2/5 stars for the excitement!

Great front to back. All bangers.

Last nite is the only good one I really know. Legendary album but okay

Classic bouncy fun rock

Really solid throughout!

I love the minimalism of this album.  This is low-fi at its best.  The two guitar players work so well off of each other.  It still seems fresh and raw after all of these years. Liked Songs Added: Is This It Barely Legal Someday Last Nite Take It Or Leave It

Always feel that The Strokes are one-note and overrated. This full album made for some decent background music while working in the car shop waiting room.

Fantastic album. Hard to believe that this album cover was considered taboo back in 2001, as well as NYC Cops.

All the songs sound the same.

I really, really liked this. I’m not surprised — it’s been a favorite among the guys I’ve dated lol. I just never gave it a chance myself. Even so, it’s 4 stars for me. It would be a 5 if the vocals were a little farther forward in the mix. As is, they’re too garbled and hidden behind the baseline — bummer.

Great album, consistent themes in songwriting and tone. I should listen to this at least once per year. It’s against like fine wine

So impressed with this album. These guys are on top of their game. A plus. Incredible music.

Thes guys fuck

Great album from top to bottom. One of my faves!

I really liked this album!

Brings me back to the turn-of-the-century where guitar rock made a good comeback. Some classics on this and some ones that I haven’t really listened to for a long time. Muy solid

Damn so many jams!! Iconic albums from the 2000s.

I remember the early days of the current century. When a band emerged to save Rock and Roll. That band was The Strokes. So much hype surrounded this album and band. Which is a shame because It can't hold the weight of all that. Hell as a young one I tried to bounce hard off this band because of all that hype. But I gave it a chance and thought it was excellent. It's an enjoyable record. It's fun. It was a breath of fresh air after the years of post-grunge and nu-metal. Ultimately it didn't save Rock and Roll but it did lead a charge of similar sounding bands. Looking back you can hear this sound in other artists of the time.

Me encanta

I think there's a reason that they had nearly no success outside the English-speaking countries. They are simply too generic, with no real appeal to them. I can't understand the hype.

I like it

Phenomenal sound. Heavily addicting. 5 stars. But what are these lyrics?? Still 5 stars.

This IS it. Not too much, just some nepo babies who put together a bar band, used their connections to flash onto a scene that was a little boring at the time. Here we are.

Possibly the last rock and roll album.

This album really came and went for me. Nothing about it was bad by any means, but it quickly became inoffensive background music to me. None of the choruses or instrumentals stuck with me after multiple listens. I was very meh. The ratings don't use half ratings, but I'd give this a 2.5/5 to be more accurate

Loved this album.

Já tenho imenso gosto por esse álbum desde a minha adolescência. Há nele grandes bangers e clássicos que escuto até hoje. Esse disco definiu em muitos sentidos o caminho pelo qual o indie se desenvolveu nos anos seguintes, muito influente e com razão de ser - 10/10

Not really my taste, the voice is a bit too raspy for me.

It was fine.

Some good / great songs, but really let down from their 'signature' vocal production.

Really great indie rock. I do wish the production was a little better. 4

Onhan tämä oman aikansa tuote. Harmillisesti bändi ei ole saanut yhtä hyvää plattaa sen jälkeen. Ilahduttavaa kuunnella. 4/5

Onhan tämä paikkansa ansainnut 2000-luvun alun indierock-eliitissä. 4/5

Yeah, I had a Strokes-fangirl moment, is that obvious?

1. Is This It - 8.5/10 2. The Modern Age - 8.4/10 3. Soma - 8.5/10 4. Barely Legal - 8.5/10 5. Someday - 7.5/10 6. Alone, Together - 8/10 7. Last Nite - 8.4/10 8. Hard to Explain - 8.5/10 9. New York City Cops - 8.5/10 10. Trying Your Luck - 8.2/10 11. Take It or Leave It - 8.5/10 8.5/10

Str8 fire easy to listen to all songs sound similar but unique energy best 35 minutes of my life

Very solid and easy to listen to. Short and sweet with plenty of really good moments to make this a great album to sit with or dance to. No real low spots, but nothing that demands to be listened to. Top tracks: Is This It, The Modern Age, Barely Legal

I liked it a lot. I really like the style and listen to it when practicing guitar. I checked out their other stuff and really liked Selfless.

Amazing of course

ett par ordentliga bangers som bär plattan, ikoniskt altrock-sound men inte riktigt min grej i helhet. kan få en extra halvpoäng.

Jävlar vad det svänger! Hade varit klockren femma om Reptilia var med, nu är det gränsfall men känner mig generös. Lyssnade flera gånger.

This was a good album.

What can I say, I'm a millennial who grew up listening to The Strokes so obviously I'm sentimental when it comes to that band. This one's probably their most acclaimed album, but it's not my personal favourite, as I feel the production on their tracks improved massively over the next few records. This one's still one of the most cohesive albums in recent history though, and just a solid effort overall. 4 stars

First time listener to the Strokes. This is a very solid album. They’ve continued the long tradition of gritty New York underground bands like Velvet Underground, New York Dolls, Television and the Ramones. I like the muddy, LoFi feel to the production. Good lyrics, catchy riffs. New discovery for me. I’m a fan!! Solid 4⭐️

Awesome album. I really enjoyed it. A bit shorter than I would've liked but overall this was banger after banger. "Barley Legal" was fire. 4/5

Still a killer! Hard to believe it came out 24 years ago!

I bought this record shortly after it came out, there's a couple of good songs on it that got fairly popular. That said, the vocal quality gets annoying after a while, and I don't think the album has held up very well over time. It's just not all that interesting.

One of my fave albums growing up in my indie rock phase

Nice , poppy album

Important to note how much this album helped changed music and aspects of culture. Ushered in a new type of alternative music. Instrumental in creating hipsters and bringing back skinny jeans (for better or worse). It sounds like a lot of music of that time but it was one of the first. Casablancas comments on brunch are pretty funny considering when I think of that time period and the music and culture he helped to usher in. Boozy brunch is one of the things that really pops into my head. Not his fault but yea, this album is exactly of a certain time and maybe type of person. It's great though.

I wasn’t really that into The Strokes even tho I had a few songs from them that I really liked like calli it fate,call it karma. Even since I hear this album it has been on repeat The modern age must be my fave truck on there

YESSSSSSSSSS FIVE STARS

Pretty damned solid stuff. The last couple of tracks drag a little bit -- but it does what it was meant to do: A shoutout to the music that Julian Casablancas' evil father had on in the 70's in NYC. Straight line from the Velvets to the Strokes.

Ich habe beim Hören nicht wirklich bemerkt, wo ein Lied aufhört und wo das nächste anfängt. Es klingt nicht schlecht, nur halt etwas monoton.

one of my favourite albums of all time

british “people” strike again

This was like one big song. In a good way of course.

This albums fucks. May have to get on vinyl

Det er sku ikke lige min kop te men point for album cover.

The whole album captures more or less the feeling of road trips. The sound I simple and consistent throughout and conveys a feel-good attitude. Seems like this more or less set the sound of indie rock music for that century. Following up with bands such as Arctic Monkeys and Cage the Elephant.

Lyrics were cool. But the music itself - not my jam! 🥲 The instruments were a bit too overpowering for my tastes - both in terms of its volume and texture! Album rating: ⭐⭐

Forever one of my favorite albums by one of my favorite bands. Love this one.

Monotonous but kinda hits

Stone cold classic. Effortlessly cool. Blazed a trail at the beginning of the new millennium without looking like they even cared. Not only the music but suddenly the fashion on the street changed. There was a buzz again about guitar music. Scuzzy, rough and beautiful. One of my top albums

Didn’t enjoy, didn’t even finish the album