Is This It by The Strokes

Is This It

The Strokes

3.81
Rating
31542
Votes
1
2%
2
8%
3
25%
4
36%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 6 of 16)

Tienen un estilo muy marcado que ocasionalmente se vuelve hostigante. Me cuesta diferenciar las canciones. Todas suenan muy parecido. Aún así reconozco su relevancia musical actualmente. Tiene grandes totes.

Mid, not listened at full attention but didn't get my attention that well.. and proof is that finally a song got my attention and I was like oh I love this and then see that the album finished.. so yeah..

When this album first came out, I somehow assumed The Strokes were a British band. At the time, I was deep into The White Stripes, and The Strokes felt a bit too light and breezy for my taste, so I didn’t really give them a proper listen. I came back to this album later, though, and realized just how much it influenced UK rock in the late 2000s and beyond. Personally, I really like “Juicebox” from First Impressions of Earth.

Typical early 2000s album. The hits are good, filler is filler.

Classic indie 2000s - def worth listening to and good overall vibe. I'm feeling generous so will say it's more like 3.75*

normally not my style, but was pulled back to 2018 me when I was very much into the strokes for the summer. just overall good and great listen

good album

I’ve never cared for or about this band, largely because they seemed fake. It’s also a time and place thing for me, they were too mainstream for where my tastes were (and mostly still are.) Aside from Last Nite, I wasn’t familiar with the album. How did anyone make it through this album with that terrible opener? What I hear is a Velvet Underground influence filtered through late 90s indie rock. I’d rather listen to the Velvets or actual indie rock. Last Nite is still catchy, and Hard to Explain was nice. They should have kept New York City Cops on the album. Otherwise not very memorable to me. Not a keeper.

A couple good tracks ('Alone, Together,' and pieces of a few others) but a pretty boring record overall. Good vocal performances can't save stale songwriting.

Gostei da primeira música. Terminei o álbum, confesso que deu uma vibe meio anos 90/00. Gosto de coisas assim. Scooby doo kkkk

I liked it, but a lot of the songs sound the same…

I can't believe I didn't like this album when I first heard it. There's a kind of warm and familiar sense that carries the tone of the whole album, especially on songs like Barely Legal and Hard to Explain. Apparently this album got sanitized for the US release so I had to spend 15 minutes looking for how to listen to New York City Cops because god forbid we make a song with New York City in the title after the September 11th Attacks. The US really is a heavily propagandized country and most people don't even notice it. Anyways, it's a good record and I do prefer the US album cover to the international one, but New York City Cops is so much better than When It Started. I'm now going to close this review by joking about the thing I just ranted about. What's the difference between 9/11 and a cow? You can't milk a cow for 24 years.

1. Is This It - “We’re not enemies, we just disagree”; an interesting start to the album, sounds similar to what would be found closer to the end of most albums. Reminds me a lot of a conclusion, with the repetition of “is this it?” sounding so weary- so it being the starting track is different. 7/10 2. The Modern Age - “Start to pretend, stop pretending,” (isn’t that so real!!). Feels like the summer of 2020, not much else to say. Similar to “Everybody Talks” by Neon Trees. 6.5/10 3. Soma - It’s alright. Having no personal experiences with drug addiction (Is that what he’s talking about?) I didn’t personally connect. 5/10 4. Barely Legal - “I should’ve worked much harder, I should’ve just not bothered,” (basically me?). I really like the conflict in the singer’s actions in this song. Plus the key change in the 2nd verse makes the song memorable. 7/10 5. Someday - “Promises, they break before they’re made,” I’ve actually heard this before!! Like the guitar and bass in this song. 6.5/10 6. Alone, Together - “He knows it’s justified to kill to survive / He then, in dollars, makes more dead than alive,” My favourite song on the album!! Has a more gritty and different sound compared to the rest of the songs on this album which I find a little plain. First guitar solo of the album too? Went hard. 8/10 7. Last Nite - Bit of a whimsy switch up after Alone, Together. It’s a nice song, don’t get me wrong, just not wholly memorable. 6/10 8. Hard To Explain - “I say the right thing but act the wrong way,” I like this song - again, a bit of a switch up in tone/key compared to the rest of the songs and style of singing, which i def prefer! A nice song, especially the end of each chorus where the singing speeds up. 6.5/10 9. New York City Cops - “Darling, I’m somewhere in between,” This reminded me that The Strokes are american (they feel like they should be british…). Like the bass line in this song even tho it simple. Sometimes traditional is best!! 6.5/10 10. Trying Your Luck - Can’t say much negative about this song; was surprised to see its C major key, it feels pretty minor, especially the whole “No harm, he’s armed(…)” bit - that’s js the way that it’s sung though I think, which i think is one of the best bits about the song. 7/10 11. Take It Or Leave It - Feels like this should be swapped with the opening track, but it makes the album more unique this way. The song is ok, nothing too interesting for my personal taste, apart from the “He’s gonna let you down (…) gonna win someday.” - this bit was a nice change from the rest of the song. Plus, 2nd guitar solo of the album!! Can’t go wrong. 6.5/10 Overall: This album was inoffensive. Not my personal music taste, I think - I do love indie music, but for me this album felt very same-y, with my highlights being Alone, Together and Barely Legal mostly because they escaped the framework that seems to make up most of the songs on this album. That said I can see why people would like this album - it’s definitely not bad. Overall rating: 6.5/10

No geral o album é gostoso de ouvir, uma vibezinha muito boa, eu gostei bastante das músicas ~Is This It, Barely Legal e Last Nite~ as outras são boas mas não me deram a vontade de salvar pra ouvir depois, porém no geral é um album bom e se aparecer qlqr música dele em uma playlist aleatória eu não passo :)

i LOVE IT.HIT ME RIGHT IN THE SPOT

Not bad, not exciting but okay

Every song is the same and none are note worthy. Why is this on the list... 1,5

freshhhh

About time I listened to this in full, never will again. Horrendous, absolutely baffled how it’s popular

I could easily listen to this on a drive to work.

Very tinny, awkward sounding album. Similar sounding songs played over multiple times, avoid.

This indie band signature sound it present from the first chord to the last. The distinctive industrial and boppy guitar riffs give this album a major lift where variance and comprehensible lyrics kind of falter. Their hits are great, but their songs all sound alike to the point where they blend one track to the next. Without reading the lyrics, I genuinely don’t know what most of the songs are about, though I think the through line is about an unhappy relationship(s). Not a bad album by any means, but I’ll probably stick to their hit songs and consider that enough.

didn’t finish the album but i thought it had a great nostalgic feel. i’m not a fan of the strokes but i love their sound and vibe. i see why this album is so iconic and i found it relatable.

It wasn’t what I would usually listen to, but it was nice & I liked almost all of the songs. Good background music for doing BA’s

Good, stripped down rock 'n roll. Some really nice guitar interplay. I liked this despite a kind of sameness, a little lack of diversity, but good stuff.

One of my favorite albums growing up. Made me feel really cool whenever I listened. Still does!!!

have this on cd. looooove this album perfect sunday chill songs. i love hard to explain. thought they were a british band for the longest

Classic decade defining sensational

Perfect start to finish.

Way more fun than I expected. Also for some reason I thought that The Strokes were a 70's classic rock band. Well, it was a surprise. Nice.

Really enjoyed this album! Great songs and super catchy. Some proper throwbacks on here! It really captures the indie era that I loved so much I was shocked that firstly it came out in 2001, and secondly that they aren't British because I only discovered this album in 2007 when it did the rounds over here 5 ⭐️

I like pretty much all the Strokes albums, even the ones that were less well-received than this, but this is fairly undeniably the best of them all.

I think this album is ok it's not mind-blowing to me but I do enjoy the songs and it's a nice easy listen.

Absolutely brilliant album. Nostalgic of my youth/university days

This album may have been a victim of its own success - it spawned a lot of mediocre indie bands. Listening to it now though, I remember why so many people wanted to be the Strokes.

Score 5/5 Top Songs: Someday, Alone Together, The Modern Age

Haha jag tänkte så sent som häromdan att vi skulle få den här skivan. Och jag tänkte på att hur jävla bra "Modern age" är. På rak arm tror jag att det är den bästa debutsingeln jag hört så länge som jag varit medveten om musik. Suedes "The drowners" var grym, Oasis "Supersonic" också men "Modern age" är fan ett strå bättre. Det var verkligen en käftsmäll när den kom. Dom efterföljande singlar som finns på albumet ("Hard to explain", "Last nite" och i synnerhet "Someday") är också jättebra även om dom aldrig når "Modern age" och dess närmaste chockverkan. Som album betraktat gillar jag soundet skarpt, de är sammanhållet och relativt simpelt, inte massa onödiga pålägg och utfyllnad av en ganska tunn ljudbild och den låter så rakt igenom, smakfullt. Utöver singlarna finns det en drös låtar som är bra och också några som inte riktigt når fram. Sen kanske man måste nämna estetiken eller egentligen hela auran runt The Strokes år 2001. Dom var det perfekta New York-rockbandet, snortighta skinnpajer, kedjerökande, ovårdade frisyrer, en arrogant hybris och en låt emot ordningsmakten. Rubrikerna basunerade ut "Rockens räddning"(ännu en gång). Det levde dom förstås aldrig upp till, dom blev bara markant sämre efter denna debut. Men dom gjorde "Modern age", den är nästintill perfekt och just där och då var den nog fan rockens räddning. Snubblar mellan trean och fyran nen snubblar rätt

De skapade verkligen en ny våg av garagerock med det här albumet. Många ville låta som The Strokes i början av 00. Och bandet är väldigt mycket sitt sound. Utan det hade det varit - ja, rätt okej melodisk rock, men nog inget att skriva om i en bok. De bra låtarna passar egentligen bäst som singlar. Tillsammans på ett helt album låter allt väldigt likt. Ändå bra nog för en stabil trea.

00-tal och amerikansk indie. Förväntar mig standardettan av Perna. Själv gillar jag det här såväl när det kom som idag. Strokes låter helt klart annorlunda än mycket annan dynga inom genren som kom vid den här tiden. Inget nyskapande men flera riktigt bra treminuters rockalster. Enkelt och medryckande. The modern age, Last nite, Barely legal och New York city cops tillhör favoriterna. En stabil fyra.

Känns som det var ett gäng rockband som kom fram vid den här tiden som lät rätt snarlika; the strokes, Franz Ferdinand, the hives...ok rock, inget unikt, inget som faller ur ramen. Mest spännande låter de i inledande titelspåret som också är skivans bästa låt tack vare den fina basslingan. Tack vare att Zeppelin finns färskt i minnet klarar de en trea.

Lyssnade inte hela, inte min typ tror jag

this album feels like a one long song

One of my favourite albums to come out of the 2000s. Many indie rock bands aspire to this level of greatness. Tight rhythm section, too cool detached vocals, angular guitars. All tasty.

A bit monotonous at times but I enjoyed most of the songs.

Meh. It's a pretty boring album. Drums, bass and guitar are boring and the singer sounds like he's singing from behind 12 inches of cloth. 1 or 2 memorable/good tracks despite that though.

Is this It Is this it Repeating is this it, is something ending or starting? The background repeated notes feel like a build up, love this song The Modern Age Similar with repeated strong building up beat, Soma I like the clean transitions between songs, much more intense gritty singing Barely Legal Love this, very catchy and fun but not the most fun topic ig Someday Like this song, talking about the future in title but feels focused on past or own flaws Alone, Together Themes of longing, especially for a person in this whole alblum tbh, catchy guitar?? Last Nite They dont understand, sad and misunderstood but in an upbeat vibey way Hard to Explain Feel happy listening to this, interesting stop in the middle thought my phone was glitching When it Started Like you're reaching for something Trying Your Luck Like this guitar again, feels sad and missing something Take it or Leave It More aggressive, has the same stronger grittier singing that Soma has, like this song

Iconic early 2000s New York rock scene music. Iconic because of its influence on many 2000s bands, advertiaing and movie sound. Too iconic not to like.

Fun, vibey. Recognised some tracks. Remus Lupin approved!

Was not a fan of this album personally

Gonna be a 5 from me, dawg. Love the strokes

This is an absolutely amazing album. Need to listen again sometime and really listen not tack a shower at the same time but what I did was amazing.

This album got a lot of plays to and from work in the early 2000s. The title track is low key one of my favorite openers of any album ever. I would happily put this album on at any time and misses being a 5 only because I save those for one of a kind albums. In other words a very strong 4. 4/5

Apesar de não ser tão meu estilo, me agradou bastante. As músicas são envolventes e contagiantes.

Great for the 2000’s

Ive listened to this album many times and I loved it when I was about 21. But I think listening to it now it felt kind of repetitive. I still like a lot of the songs, especially New York City Cops that’s a new favourite.

A teenage classic. Very much to the point, zero filler across the running time. Struggled to understand the appeal a bit when I was younger but makes complete sense now.

Nothing outstanding, but all quite reasonable. A mediocre 3

Fun, quirky and simple.

These lazy sounding New Yorkers who took the world by storm in the 2000's with their effortlessly simple songs were never on my must see or listen list at the time. I've played this several times over the years, but its never made me go Wow. Unlike fellow New Yorkers, Interpol who's debut is so much better. But this was just merely average.

Always come back to this album, a cornerstone of the early noughties.

it's ok for background music, only kinda like one song only - last night

The last album released 2020 is 5 stars, here they have just played for some months.

I picture someone listening to this while drinking a cup of coffee as they watch the end of the world 🌎

Should probs listen again, didn’t really absorb

Really solid! Could be a bit more adventurous

Naturally had to give this album a 5 stars - teh impact this album had on rock music after it was released genuinely cannot be understated! I also have a special place in my heart for this album and it was one of my most played albums of 2025, I LOVE THE STROKES!!!!! favourite tracks: new york city cops, barely legal, trying your luck

I remember when this came out I was a little confused about the simplicity. After a fresh listen, I have a better appreciation but it’s still a bit mid. My favorite sections are the bass licks. 3.0/5.0

Las cosas como son: qué bueno es este disco. Cuando todo el mundo esperaba que el siglo XXI nos trajera la novedad al indie, ya desgastado después de unos 90 frenéticos, llegan The Strokes y se ponen a hacer música de garaje, nada sofisticada, desnuda de artificios, como grabada en una sola toma y despreciando todo lo que no fuera guitarra, bajo, batería y voz. Todo suena con una cruda eficacia como si quisieran reivindicar los orígenes del rock. Es tan pretencioso que parece honesto (o al revés)

a fun listen. will it be something i regularly think about or go back to? probably not! but it was fun and (to me) sounds like what being in your 20s in the 00s in nyc would’ve sounded like. favorite tracks: is this it barely legal last nite hard to explain

this was a fun one

This album is actually quite a bit better than what I remembered. I listened to it when it came out and thought it was OK. I think if these guys weren’t from New York City, it probably wouldn’t have been as big of a deal. Apple Music has it is one of the top hundred albums of all time which I think is a stretch but it’s still pretty good.

Álbum bastante plano a mi parecer. Tienes éxitos, sí. Pero el resto de las 8 canciones suenan muy parecidas, no hay mucho experimento y se entiende porque es su primer álbum de estudio. Aún así, si se escucha completo de corrido se hace un poco pesado y monótono a mi oído. Destaco que está muy bien plasmado el sello de la banda, si escuchas las canciones automáticamente sabes que es The Strokes y no precisamente por la voz de Julian Casablanca. No me genera mucho el sonido en cuánto a emociones y la letra me dio paja

Buen disco, muy regular, lo escuché harto este año, disco de esos que marcan épocas, fue la vuelta del rock con guitarras a la escena, muy influyente en el género. Regular, sin muchos puntos altos ni bajos. Me suena un poco repetitivo en cuando a melodías y ritmo pero con muy buenas canciones, sin nada muy complejo en lo lírico ni musical pero fresco. En términos de producción no me parece la gran wea, sonido bien crudo, simple, enérgico, como buen disco de indie. Del resto: bajo, batería y voz al centro y guitarras una a cada lado. Su trabajo en las guitarras es de las cosas que más me gustan de the strokes, el tratamiento y juego entre ellas, cada una con un sonido bien diferente, brillantes, metálicas, un poquito de distorsión y nada más, menos es más, sin grandes riffs ni solos como el rock clásico, una rítmica cortante y arpegios que se entrelazan muy bien. Y algo que me gusta en todos los álbumes de la banda es el sonido de la voz de Julián y ese efecto como si estuviera cantando como por un megáfono y su actitud desganada o a veces desgarradora con su voz rasposa. Uno de mis discos fav de the strokes Canción favorita: Alone Together (de hecho fue mi canción más escuchada este año) Para mí realmente es como un 3.5 pero no se puede esa nota:(

Didn't really do anything for me. Is this it? 3/5

Two albums in a row here on 1001 that have been pretty good. Like the title track. The rest is a bit same samie, but ok.

I am trying to not give as many 5ers on this journey. But this deserves every pearly bright twinkler in the universe. Easy...5 sky- diamonds

I love this album

Classic of the era. Mostly holds up but it was explosive when it came out

Coincidentemente escutei hoje sem saber que apareceria aqui. Enorme em todos os sentidos. É impressionante como entrega tanto em canções relativamente simples e em menos de 40 minutos. O rock do século XXI começa com Is This It.

Tight as two coats of paint yet somehow mellower than I remember

Yes, this is it

I mean this is decent. I'm not sure it's aged all that well. But I think a lot of that about a lot of the albums I rate that I've heard so many time. Still giving a 4

Good sound, a classic album of the early-to-mid 2000s. I admit the whole thing runs together a bit for me, though. Not one I see myself going back to frequently, but good enough.

Luci - Hard To Explain, Alone Together Lizzy - Trying Your Luck, Alone Together

Great album - I enjoyed revisiting it. I love Julian Casablancas voice and the guitar work on this album is good. This album made a huge impression on me when I was younger and I remember having a physical copy of this cd in the glove box of my first car

The best thing about the Stokes's album is when the ads played between the songs. I really enjoyed those.

Love the strokes

Solidi Büez, doch isch mer nüm so viel blibe und da ich biz ufhole mun magis ned nomal es Zweitmals lose. Würdis nüm lose aber gstört hets nöd. Alli guete Durchschnittspünkt sind 3

Eich scho na geil. Gueti gittarr riffs und e guete drive. Klassische fall vum ne 3.5er Hüt rundi mal ab, sorry strokes But keep öp

aaaaah darum hani us'm don neduzen sim zimmer am mentig indie gitarrekläng ghört – macht scho meh sinn… hed er ja erst gad chürzlich sin hate gäge the kooks bekundschaftet. anyways hallo zämme, ich bi's de noah :) sorry für mini absenze, lose ih letschter ziit bim schaffe vermehrt podcasts und han irgendwie gmerkt, dass s'läbe z'churz isch für mediocre musig (was es ih letschter ziit recht oft de ihdruck gmacht hed) – aber ich versuech wieder chli meh dri z'lose <3 the strokes: iconic band, iconic album… mittlerwiele gfallt mer nümm jedes lied, aber es spriessed grad paar neui pickel bim lose will's mi so fescht ah de teenie noah erinneret 3 röhrlijeans + 1 paar converse = 4 nietegürtel

I feel like this album gets a ton of hype, but it's just bland same-y early 2000s rock. It's not terrible, but certainly not great either.

I really did not like this album. Every song sounds the same. There aren't any songs I would listen to again genuinely.

One of my favorite albums of all time and the first one I've heard already!

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻✅

i like it good band will continue listening

A good, fun album that’s held up well. I’ve enjoyed most of it ever since it came out.

Really like the sound of this and a cool vocal style. 4 stars

I’ve forgotten a lot of these songs. Still jams though.

is this is - so summery the modern age - nostalgic, love the distortion soma - funky beat barely legal - melody reminds me of something someday - i ain’t wasting no more tiiiiiiime alone, together - 😎drums last nite - ugh nobody understands meh hard to understand - perfect now mash it with cliche by 2hollis when it started - he don’t gaf trying your luck - groovy take it or leave it - shaking hips aggressively ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5

Really monotonous, the constant strumming is almost headache inducing. The lyrics are charming, but the arrangement of the vocals makes them barely audible. Honestly i expected more especially from the hype ive heared about this album and since i do like their newer songs.

One of my all time fav artists and albums, sooo many good songs on here

Only giving this a 4 because Julian Casanovas is an industry plant

ok album

had already listened some of it

this album is good but not much diversity going on. like how simple the songs sounded like and the writing is nice. overall just a nice and simple indie rock album.

Absolutely no skips, made me feel like rebellious teen who is enjoying sneaking out to go skinny dip

Feels like 2012

I have to be in a particular mood to really like this. Some songs were automatic skips but others I added to my playlist already

One of the best albums from one of the best bands of all time. One of my all-time favorites and I'm glad I got to listen to it again.

Didn’t feel it.

obnoxious, just like it was in 01/02

Yesssssssss. El mejor disco de la historia. Vale igual me pasé. Pero es que es un disco que marcó muchísimo mi adolescencia y a través del cual hice bonding con mi bestie, y sobre todo este verano tuve momento de volver a escuchar a los Strokes a tope y buf es que increíble me encanta lo es todo. Es increíble que en esos años estuviesen compitiendo en los grammy con peña rollo Korn. Cambiaron el panorama completamente. Sigo sin entender del todo culturalmente lo que supusieron en ese momento. Este disco es todo bangers y es divertidísimo y me encanta. Me gusta más Room on fire tho. Y The New Abnormal me cambió la vida cuando salió. Julian Casablancas te amo.

Wanted to give it like 4.5. lacked variety, but the lyrics - dude was going thru some relationship shit and it hit hard.

GOING IN: Hopeful FAMILIARITY: Know a song or two SKIP RATE: No skips (played straight through) REPLY VALUE: I’ll play it again DISCOVERY CURVE: Liked it straight away, surprisingly ALBUM ARC: Consistent throughout VERDICT: Liked it more than expected FAVOURITE TRACK: Hard to Explain Good solid 3/5

Ladies and gentlemen….THE STROKES 🗣️🔥

- grundgy - almost too much bass?? - fist impression not great - very confessional

It was good kinda sounded like a teenage boy wrote it in his moms garage

Everything sounds the same. After short intros that sound a lottle bit different, when reaching the refrain it is the same sound as the previous song. Sonically the voice sits to far in the back to listen to the lyrics.

3.5! Enjoyed it.

Very strong start, tailed off a bit in the end

The Strokes were one of those bands that seemed to materialise fully formed - cool sound, cool look, and decent songs to match. Of course, their influences were easy enough to trace, but they threw angular guitar interplay, upbeat drums and overdriven vocals together in a way that made their sound fresh and important in 2001. I never quite fell in love with them, though. I remember picking Last Nite apart in my head and thinking it had the same energy as This Charming Man did nearly 20 years earlier - the kind of song that made you want to leap up out of your seat as soon as you heard it - but somehow it didn't feel like it was speaking to me once it had me by the collars. And that, I've come to accept, was simply a result of me, probably for the first time, being just a bit too old to be the target audience of "the next big thing". I'd been there for The Stone Roses, Nirvana, Oasis, et al, but this somehow didn't seem like it was meant for me. Now, with plenty of hindsight, it is clear to see The Strokes' influence still reverberating through almost every guitar-led alternative act worth their salt. Is This It is probably the band's most satisfying record too, and still stands up today.

I went into this only knowing Last Nite, but you know what? Hell yeah.

This one is totally stamped in time for me. When it came out, that fun indie-rock vibe hooked me immediately. I loved Julian Casablancas - his voice especially - and the way the whole album pulls you into this little journey. It felt cool, effortless, and exactly right for that moment. It was a bit of a soundtrack for a while…makes me me my iPod!

Just meh. Not very interesting, at least for me

Love this raw take of the original Strokes. Realised I knew a lot of tracks from the album but not the whole album. Enjoyed the nostalgia from again 15 yo Ninske. Still love this music <3

Everything kinda sounded the same

Perfect garage rock album. Truly defines the early 2000s for me. Standouts: The Modren Age, Someday, Last Night, Hard to Explain

Fun but vapid.

Amazingly simple record. Selfless is the track!

NYC dive bar legend

Some much effort and polish to sound 'raw' - has some great tracks and some filler.

fun and poppy

Really liked, "New York City Cops" But maybe, not my type of album

Is this it? Al ono fakat pitam. Koliko sam čula pohvala za ovaj album mislila sam stvarno da treba biti nešto spektakularno. A ne da je svaka pjesma praktično ista. Nije loše ali je sve isto i ni sekunde genijalno.

I guess the album is important for its role in reestablishing the garage rock sound in pop culture along with making record labels sign the “The” bands at a rate on par they signed bands from Seattle in 1992. It’s a good straightforward rock album, I appreciate the lack of fat and and how it’s right to the point but in the end I think i just want to listen to the original garage rock bands.

I remember how big this album was when it came out. Copycats popped up overnight but never really bothered to listen to it. ‘Last Nite’ is a tune but the rest of it is bland as fuck. As I was listening to it I kept asking myself; ‘Is this it?’

Good album

This album transports you into a small, grimy venue nestled somewhere in NYC...cigarette smoke lazily wafting & drinks clinking at the bar. You're not sure if the guy taking cover at the door was an employee or not. A distorted voice is cutting through the noise, the bleary-eyed singer crooning into a dented microphone that's been duct-taped to the stand. The simplistic, gritty guitar riffs seem to indicate that these songs weren't exactly intended to be played sober. The old wood floor is sticky, but it doesn't stop the people from tapping their feet. The rest of the evening may be a bit of a blur, but the pieces of the night you do remember are special.

Soundtrack to my memories of Middle School…

the goat

Used to love this one when I was a wee lad. Knowing what The Strokes are about now I find this kind of boring and pretentious. The hit still hit and I'll throw this one on when summer hits for sure.

A little boring and repetitive, very of a time and place. It's fine music, just not my jam.

Passable facimile of bands that influenced them like Television, Iggy Pop, etc.

One of the best guitar albums of the 2000's to date

Some good and recognizable songs (Someday!) that I found quit enjoyable. Not too fancy with the guitars and drums, but overall interesting melodies.

What an album cover. One highlight song and then just your usual stuff from that period. Prob alright to hear live.

1 tracks worth a re-listen. not for me.

Enjoyes a d recognised maybe 1 tune, and the rest were mostly a blur. It ain't it

Is this it? I hope not

It's unfair, this album came out when I was 14 and I was just getting into alt- indie rock. It's still great, but I can't separate myself from the hours of listening to it from my youth to give it an honest downgrade.

I'm familiar with The Strokes, but not this entire album. Thankfully, that changes today! The title track has a cool, funky bass line which loops through the song, and the guitar solo in "The Modern Age" proves these guys are no hacks. The whole album is a treat and a really strong debut. Solid 4 stars for me.

Such a great album. Maybe it's nostalgia, but this always reminds me of my early 20's, crashing through relationships, trying to figure it all out. It seemed chaotic and uncomfortable at the time, but looking back at that time, it was fun and exciting. I just didn't know what I had going on. This music reflects what it was like to be that age in the post 9/11, pre-recession world.

Heard it before. Never understood the hype for this album/band. There are two tracks here that I like but in general it's just not a very remarkable album. Having not one but two nepo babies in one band should just immediately make you a poser and lame 2/5

This was fine. Pretty middle of the road meh rock.

It’s ok

Is this it

It’s hard, looking back now, to remember just how fresh and different this sounded. The world has moved on but this album is still full of the cocksure swagger of people too young to know better. I don’t feel like I can give this an objective rating. So I won’t.

Yeaa, one of the first albums that got me “into” music. The strokes. 5/5

Hmmm well alright, at first I wasn’t too sure about this album but it’s growing on me a bit as it goes along. It’s some sort of lo-fi rock music and I can’t help but think that there are many other bands that have come before who pull it off much better than this. Although a bit too friendly sounding, it still sounds fun. A lot of the guitar work is also lacking balls and is a bit one dimensional but they do play competently through some mildly interesting arrangements. I think this album might click with further listens but for now I’m a bit ambivalent about its inclusion on this list but it’s ok enough to not be a complete write-off for now.

Basic rock

It’s a pretty good album. I just never got into the strokes outside the hits. But it’s fine.

Love this album!

This is definitely a top 10 album all time for me, maybe top 5. I have learned every guitar part on this album. This is just a magical record and I didn’t even listen to it until like 2012. The strokes are so locked in creatively that you can overlook the nepotism. Julian’s voice on this record is perfection, the vocal processing they do (keyboard amp mic’d with distortion added) is so sick. Albert and nicks interlocking guitar parts really changed how I approach writing in bands where there’s two guitars, they’re just so tight and similar but so distinguishable at the same time. Hell, I bought a Riviera because it’s what Nick plays, sounds damn good too. That P90 tone on a semi-hollow body matching a strat both with minimal effects is just so tasty. Also a case where the bassist, Nikolai, is really writing some unforgettable, honestly critical to the song bass lines that have such unique groove and melody. Fab can’t be overlooked either on drums even if he is considered the weakest member, he does such cool hi hat and tom work throughout that has definitely been ripped off entirely since. This is definitely my favorite debut album of all time (sorry zeppelin), I can’t fathom getting together for your first go and writing something as strong as this. There’s not a single song on here that I don’t love every second of and it feels silly to go into a play by play because I’m just going to gush over all of it. It is just a perfect album, not a single guitar solo, bass groove, snare hit, or shout is wasted on this thing. If I could vote higher than a 5 I would. I can’t imagine there’s an album on this list that I love more than this one.

Best debut album, probably? A band that delivered on the hype imo and still stands above so many of the other garage rock revival bands. Great songwriting all over this thing and holy shit they have a bass player you can hear. So much of the melody is carried by the bass on this, just listen to when it started. Anyway 5/5 duh

I liked this one a lot; great millennial-era indie rock with some punk influence and sometimes a bit of a Velvet Underground flavor.

Fuck it. Rules.

Gives me flashbacks.

You can say I have basic taste, but this album is fun.

Ahhh, in many ways this album makes me miss the good old days… someday. I was a too young to catch the hype of this album at the time of its release, but soon caught up in my teenage years and it’s an ‘all timer’ for sure. I wish I could summarise how much love I have for this record, but it’s hard to explain.

I remember when this album was considered to be so edgy and new, and now it just sounds like indie rock. That's not a bad thing, mind you.

An easy 5 stars. Yes, some of the songs sound similar but they just sound so fucking good.

One song that everyone knows and a droning tone that makes all the other songs blend into one.

A fun little pop album. Every song is uptempo and earnest. It is all a bit one note, but sometimes that’s ok when the album is so short.

Frábært rokk á tíma þar sem rokkið var í mikilli lægð. Nu rokkið og kid rock. ojj. Strokes eru frábærir og þessi plata er alveg tímalaus. Alltaf hægt að skella henni á.

Frábær plata. Einfaldleikinn í fyrirrúmi, bassi gítar tromma. Vonandi á rokkið svona endurkomu aftur fljótlega.

Viel besser, als ich erwartet habe. Eigentlich ganz angenehm. 3 1/2.

Good solid rock and roll

Whyyyy is this on the list? It sounds like he's singing into a tin can the whole time. Nonetheless, I liked Someday and Hard to Explain.

I am a sucker for rock bands with a really unique style, and The Strokes are definitely one of those bands. This is basically a perfect album, 35 minutes of non-stop back-to-back bangers. A lot of really great guitar playing, catchy melodies, and great vocals. High 5!!!

One good song. Typical of the early 2000s slump.

Quality throughout. Enjoyed it all

Right up my alley! Så mycket attityd. Dubbla gitarrer, avskalat, tufft. Ok, känd men ingen klassiker? Borde vara?

Pretty fun, a little repetitive, but a fun sound!

Good listen kind of repetitive but a classic

Some strums that feel familiar but it's not my vibe. Is this like 90's Britain maybe?

A classic in early-aughts alt/indie rock. Definitely a nostalgic listen. It's not my favorite from that time period but it was a ton of fun to revisit. 3/5

THis is it! Awesome!

Dank every time

Not a patch on First Impressions of Earth from 2006

Good guitar based rock. I am not convinced by the songs but very listenable

A really good debut album.

This was pretty solid. I liked when the vocalist leaned more into the grit with his vocals, which doesn't happen in many of the songs on the album but it was great when it did. This was a nice introduction to the band. It was a good, clean album.

4/5. A very likable Indie rock record. This reminds me of a long lost time that has since become nostalgic for me.

The songs that are good are INCREDIBLE. Timeless classics like Someday and Last Nite. The problem is that the bulk of the record is pretty boring and forgettable. 3/5.

Very good album, very enjoyable, played twice over

haven’t heard this album for years and it still sounds so good. what a debut

I'm a big fan of The Strokes and this album introduced me to their music. There isn't a song on here that I don't like and at one point in time, I think each one was probably my favorite off the album. The radio hits like Last Nite and Someday are good songs, but I've listened to them too many times at this point.

Solid. Enjoyed more than I expected. Edgy alt rock with a bit of a hook.

that song. sad? voice sound?

This album may not sound particularly revolutionary now, but for its time it was quite the change in sound.

Absolutely love this album. Feels both incredibly influential and timeless. Love the hooks and the production level here.

Ok - not really my thing though.

It’s not a bad album. But definitely not the album I would listen to again

one of the more palatable albums but still not my style

I’ve spent a lot of time listening to this album over the years, not least as it’s a good one both while driving and while running/jogging. The Modern Age, New York City Cops and Last Nite are all great songs, but the whole album is really solid. Pretty sure I once read that Julian Casablanca’s raspy vocals are achieved via a microphone effect but, regardless, they’re distinctive and they work really well on these songs. I regret never having seen The Strokes live. They’d be brilliant in a small to medium sized venue.

I hadn't knowingly heard any of The Strokes music before. I'd wrongly assumed from their name that they were a punk band - not one of my favourite genres. I was pleasantly surprised to find that they're a rock band Musically this is a good album. It has the rhythms and guitar playing you'd expect from a rock band. Unfortunately not quite so memorable that as I write this 12 hours after listening I don't recall any stand out tracks. What spoiled it for me was the vocals. The lyrics were fine, but their delivery was odd. I don't know if it's just this album or a band style, but the vocals on every track sounded like they were being sung through the inner sleeve of a toilet roll with the end covered in tissue paper. Not quite full kazoo but getting there. I found this fuzziness distracted me from fully enjoying the album. This album was ok to listen to, but in my opinion not up with the upper echelons of the all time greats.

always good

I'm a creaky oldster, but this is an album that had the power to break through to me despite all my attempts to be blasé about new music in the early 2000's. Now nearing a quarter century old and still bursting with power and energy. I'm still in love with this whole album.

Not too bothered.

has been a soundtrack to many trips and was an album that opened to the door for so many mediocre and some great bands

It’s fine am just not a massive fan

Not something I’d listen to regularly but it’s not the worst 2000s alt emo boy band album that I’ve listened to

One of my favorites

hashtag loe the strokes alr know this one

I may be in the minority but this to me isn't very appealing. Quite same-y, simple songs that all sound the same. Not much variation. Doesn;t really do much. Sounds very hard like you're trying to be cool and make very stylised vintage music out of a private school.

It’s hard to imagine my life or modern indie without this album. I’ve listened a ton, and I will continue to listen a ton.

So incredibly monotonous. That singer can fuck right off too. It JUST gets a two because some of the songs towards the end of the album I enjoyed a bit, like Trying Your Luck. I suppose repetitive doesn't matter as much when what is being repeated isn't terrible. Very generous 2.

My kids had this CD in the car, it was pretty good

What a great first album. It's fun and easy to listen to

Classic sound from The Strokes, great for studying in a cafe or dancing in your teen bedroom

Josh- I like the opening so far! I feel like I knew some songs from this album tho. "Someday" is easily the best track, but am also a fan of "Hard To Explain" I love how hard the closer goes "Take it Or Leave it". I can see how influential this album is to the modern alt-rock scene. They're the prototype to Arctic Monkeys, The Killers and such. Will definitely revisit the album. Fitting for a first album -- New York band to go with Zohran winning. 3.5/5 Phoebe - Someday and Last Nite are the songs I knew and already loved, so they were still the standout songs for me. I love this classic fun indie rock sound sm, very easy listening for doing work or dancing alone in your room. 3.5/5

6 - AVERAGE

This album came out in the prime of my "too cool for school" years, and even then I had to give them a nod. Listening to it with fresh ears, this is a great record, hands down. The melodies and the slight garage quality of the production go hand-in-hand. If anything, I'm just mad that I didn't go all-in on the early days of indie-sleaze.

Is this the greatest debut album of the 2000s? Probably for a rock band. It's one of those rarities without a single skip song. And it still holds up. Sounds as fun and energetic and fresh as it did the first time I listened to it.

Decent tunes but not outstanding - happy to sing along to the ones I knew

I don’t like the distorted vocals (tell me your singer can’t sing without telling me your singer can’t sing) but I otherwise love the sound

I like the whimsical songs Edit Apr 16 2026: 4 --> 5. I have really been loving this one

Amazing album, catchy song after catchy song.

It's cool and all but very similar to itself throughout. Didn't love it like everyone else.

Great work

Les Strokes me font penser à mon frère. Grande influence sur son jeu de guitare du début des années 2000. Il aurait pu se joindre au band. Je n'ai pas lu le livre de Lizzy Goodman mais j'ai vu le documentaire Meet Me in the Bathroom (2022) de Will Lovelace et Dylan Southern qui est basé sur le livre. Intéressant. The Moldy Peaches, The Strokes, the Yeah Yeah Yeahs, LCD Soundsystem, Interpol.

Très agréable de ne pas trop se creuser le coco en ce samedi. Du rock droit au but, dansant, énergique. Une grande influence pour l'alternatif début 2000, ça me replonge dans l'ambiance de mon adolescence, bien que je n'aie pas spécifiquement été fan des Strokes à l'époque ! Leur apport pour des groupes comme Franz Ferdinand et Jet est indéniable.

Je pense que je donne plus 5 étoiles pour ce que l'album représente que pour la musique elle même. Celle-ci est excellente avec des classiques du début du millénaires, mais je la trouve somme toute assez répétitive sur la durée de l'album. J'ai du plaisir mais je n'y reviendrai pas tant. Par contre l'album représente ce retour aux sources du rock début 2000, après le Nu Metal de la fin de millénaire. La scène new yorkaise était foissonante, ce faisant je doit dire préférer Interpol. Justement j'ai hâte à Turn On The Bright Lights, probablement un top 10 all-time personne. Par ailleurs il y un livre qui me semble fort intéressant "Meet me in the bathroom" un récit de cet époque et cette scène. Quand j'aurai le temps de lire un livre (dans quelques années), je m'y attablerai. Longue vie au rock!

Not really my taste, though I enjoyed the heavy amount of nostalgia these tracks offered. My favorite was "Someday." Adding a point to my rating because I do think it's a strong project regardless of me not being a huge fan of it personally, and I admire how influential The Strokes' sound and aesthetic has been, even if I don't particularly resonate with this album. It would be foolish not to note that they heavily influenced later groups that I adore (and are more my era), like The Killers and Arctic Monkeys.

It's...alright? Reeeeeally don't get why this is so well regarded. Extremely simple, repetitive, and at times, grating. I even tried to focus on the lyrics, thinking that must be the appeal -- but the mixing is such that it's almost always incomprehensible. I don't know. Not for me, I guess. Fave tracks: - Someday - Alone, Together - When It Started - Trying Your Luck - Take It Or Leave It

Absolute love it since forever

I definitely like where these guys were going at the time and if I was more into modern music in the early 2000s I probably would have this a little bit higher i didn't really fully hear this album until many years later. They remind me kind of the White Stripes would be doing at the time if they were more of a slick band rather than a garage band. But I can definitely see their influence on the aughts' indie scene influence the likes of The Killers. (9.2) ★★★★½

Some cool songs, but mostly run of the mill 00's indie rock. 3.5 stars

Great album that really kicked off the indie rock boom in the 00s. "Barely Legal", "The Modern Age", and "Last Nite" are the highlights for me. 4.5 stars.

A real true early 00s rock n roll classic with a lot of swish, slickness n swagger plus some decent songs too although Julian Casablanca’s’ cheap, compressed tannoy vocal stylings are a tad annoying. Someday, Last Nite, Hard To Explain and Take It Or Leave It are great. The rest I can… take it or leave it. 3.5 stars.

Nothing new or radical here, but they were, along with The Hives and The White Stripes, responsible for bringing guitar bands briefly back to the forefront of mainstream radio play in the UK, so I won't hear a word against them. Not a 5-star album, but close.

Thought I would love this one a lot since I’m a big Strokes fan. As much as I love some of their songs, hearing the full album feels different. The highs are great, the beats hit, and it has that indie sound I’ve fallen for over the years. But overall it feels mid. Maybe I missed the cultural moment that made it special, because right now it’s just okay. A few amazing tracks surrounded by a lot of same-sounding ones. It has sparks of what made them great, but not the fire yet. My favorite track is Trying Your Luck because it captures the softer side of their sound

Really talented at ending songs. Two absolute favourites on here. The rest is better than I remembered it,but a bit samey.

Classic.

One that's actually part of my library already. Possibly because it was the first thing from The Strokes that I heard, but I'm still partial towards First Impressions of Earth instead. However, Is This It is still great and will continue to have a place in my library.

its alright

This feels like 1,001 albums you won't believe got a record deal I'm not sure how this band got out of their garage. No catchy tunes, no inspiring tunes, no "I get that feeling" tunes. Just random blah blah blah with piss poor singing and almost good musicians. You could easily get this quality by walking down the street and listening to random garages ... I got song 8, but I'm just going to listen to my toilet drip now instead of the last 3 songs.

I don’t really get it. I mean it’s not terrible. I don’t hate it, but no one will ever convince me that the strokes are amazing. Anyone can make music like this. It seems easy and lacks depth. I guess it’s kinda cute but it sure feels dated

All very similar but I do not believe in too much of a good thing.

Clássico The Strokes... já foi minha época, hoje só algumas específicas por nostalgia. Me parecem todas as mesmas?

Yeah fair enough is pretty mega. Only criticism is it started to feel a little samey by the time I got to barely legal, however Someday makes up for this and keeps it fresh. Proper no skips album.

4.5 - Great

I was around when the Strokes were the big new band on the scene, the band that was changing rock. I was more of a Kings of Leon fan, due to them being Southern mostly, but they certainly put out great music. I always looked at the Strokes as a band of pretty, rich boys that wouldn’t last the test of time. That kind of came to fruition, in a way. While the Kings of Leon were producing steady content, the Strokes had hiatuses and side projects. The KOL had rehab stints that curtailed their output as well. In other words, in 2001, I wasn’t impressed with the Strokes, though this was still the time when you had to invest in your music by buying CDs. I was already buying KOL CDs, so the Strokes lost out. I was also annoyed by the lead singer, Julian Casablancas, always having an effect on his voice. Like he was singing through a Hardee’s drive-thru microphone. It just irked me. But, surprisingly, it never once bothered me today. Now, having listened to Is This It? in 2025, I loved it. It’s good jangly rock that’s fun to listen to or even dance to. As I listened to songs like Last Nite, I realized that this was essentially an updated version of rock, the likes of what Tom Petty was making in the early 80’s. It’s not hair metal with guitar wankery, it’s just solid riffs with cool hooks to get you singing along. What else could you ask for? The album also changed music at the time, once Is This It? came out, probably before it came out, you had all these Strokes clones popping up, especially out of the New York scene. It was kind of another scene like 70s New York with punk and new wave. In fact, there’s a great oral history about this 2000's scene and the music called Meet Me In the Bathroom by Lizzy Goodman. It’s a great companion piece with Please Kill Me: An Uncensored Oral History of Punk by Legs McNeil, focusing on the punk and new wave movement in New York in the 70's. Again, I digress. After listening to Is This It? a few times, I’ll admit, I missed the boat and should have been on this band at the time. Luckily, I have the 1,001 albums list to correct my ways. Though after slogging through Wilco, I wonder if I’d have liked anything put in my earholes? Check out Is This It? It’s just cool rock that makes for a good time. The music is good and the lyrics are kind of a time capsule of what was going on in that music scene at the time. So, you can kind of relive it without all the sex and drugs.

Meh... Just meh meh meh... Didn't hate it, all I can muster is a meh...

Great sound, love the vocals, all songs sound very similar.

Some catchy tunes, but mostly felt like noise. Not my cup of tea.

Couple of familiar songs. All started to sound the same towards the end.

Banger album, no bad songs

A cultural icon for a reason. The honesty and rawness with which it discusses the unearned challenges faced by millions of Americans every day is sobering. The simple, acoustic accompaniment only goes to highlight Tracy Chapman’s beautiful voice and the message of her songs. Although the musical tone isn’t always my personal style, I can appreciate the artistry and skill behind the execution.

A new take on urban rock

- Garage/Indie rock | Post-punk revival - Enjoyable, fun, upbeat, head-bopping album - Enjoyed more than The Stooges (previous album rec)

I like the Strokes. And this album has Last Nite and Someday. Good album if a little uninspiring. Obviously there's a few really great songs on here, the album is just lacking innovation.

It’s hard to overstate the cultural bomb this set off with Gen X’ers who thought rock was dead, with teens who had been fed a steady diet of late 90’s pop punk and boy bands. The Strokes dared to throw Television riffs into perfect radio songs and sing with a mid-fi production in a time where everything had to be boosted to the max. It was probably a bit pretentious but at the same time it was a breath of fresh air, and it still feels that way today. Granted, there’s about 1/3 of the album that feels like filler, and yeah everything kinda sounds the same. But this is still a damn fine record, and should still have “New York City Cops” on it.

no thanks

gasa gasa!

Me ha gustado mucho, tiene clásicos a los que ahora les pongo cara como "Someday" "Last Nite" que van para la lista de favoritos.

Only bangers, great album. I think sonically it's a little too samey for it be one of my favorites, but the songwriting is stellar.

Great album

Really liked ‘Last Nite’ from this album, and “12:51’ from Room on Fire just after it - had both as a suggestion from a friend in high school, but would be lying if I said I’d explored much further before now. Gave several listens through throughout the weekend and recognized/enjoyed Someday and Soma as potential standouts. This bad has a unique sound I enjoy, but I didn’t give too much into lyrics or meaning this go round.

Why this is supposed to be it?

Their debut album. Rock / Indie. One of the great debut albums and one of the most important of the new millennium. Is This It, The Modern Age and Soma are three brilliant tracks to open with. For me, guitar, Indie music had gotten pretty bland on the whole by the late 90s. The Strokes came along and breathed some fresh air into music. Their energy too. The was a big album by a cool band again. So many good songs on this album in addition to those first three Someday, Alone, Together, Last Nite, Hard To Explain and New York City Cops. Yeah, I love this album.

The Strokes just stroked the fuck out of my ears for 35 minutes JEEEEEZZZZ!

Still the lean fun buzzy record that made me feel cool in high school

Like it 3/5

One of my favourites.

Big fan. Girls liked.

This was a fun album that I'd not heard before and it is a proper fun up-beat guitar band collection of songs. I guess I'll give it a 5 as it was overall a pleasant listen for me.

Bravi, absolute cinema

I was prepared for a pretty mediocre album since I'm not huge on their singles but this was much more enjoyable than I expected.

Great cover, hard-hitting, catchy songs with lyrics to scream and riffs to tap your toes to. Sub 40 minutes with no filler. Absolute winner.

I was expecting a bit more. It's not a bad album, in fact I enjoyed a lot of songs, but it felt like something was missing in a lot of other tracks. I'm no music expert in terms of composing but it felt like there wasn't even a bass player half the time. There wasn't rhythm, especially at the start. Still some great moments though.

Couple of good songs that sound just like the rest of the album. Not that impressed