568
Albums Rated
3.23
Average Rating
52%
Complete
521 albums remaining
Rating Distribution
Rating Timeline
Taste Profile
1950
Favorite Decade
Metal
Favorite Genre
US
Top Origin
Wordsmith
Rater Style ?
51
5-Star Albums
29
1-Star Albums
Breakdown
By Genre
Top Styles
By Decade
By Origin
Albums
You Love More Than Most
| Album | You | Global | Diff |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Talking With the Taxman About Poetry
Billy Bragg
|
5 | 2.96 | +2.04 |
|
Will The Circle Be Unbroken
Nitty Gritty Dirt Band
|
5 | 2.98 | +2.02 |
|
Armed Forces
Elvis Costello & The Attractions
|
5 | 3.09 | +1.91 |
|
At Budokan
Cheap Trick
|
5 | 3.1 | +1.9 |
|
Pyromania
Def Leppard
|
5 | 3.13 | +1.87 |
|
Fisherman's Blues
The Waterboys
|
5 | 3.2 | +1.8 |
|
Rum Sodomy & The Lash
The Pogues
|
5 | 3.25 | +1.75 |
|
If I Should Fall From Grace With God
The Pogues
|
5 | 3.33 | +1.67 |
|
Elvis Presley
Elvis Presley
|
5 | 3.37 | +1.63 |
|
Come Away With Me
Norah Jones
|
5 | 3.38 | +1.62 |
You Love Less Than Most
| Album | You | Global | Diff |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Blue
Joni Mitchell
|
1 | 3.49 | -2.49 |
|
Aja
Steely Dan
|
1 | 3.47 | -2.47 |
|
Pretzel Logic
Steely Dan
|
1 | 3.39 | -2.39 |
|
Bitches Brew
Miles Davis
|
1 | 3.3 | -2.3 |
|
Countdown To Ecstasy
Steely Dan
|
1 | 3.28 | -2.28 |
|
Chicago Transit Authority
Chicago
|
1 | 3.2 | -2.2 |
|
Hejira
Joni Mitchell
|
1 | 3.14 | -2.14 |
|
Heavy Weather
Weather Report
|
1 | 2.98 | -1.98 |
|
Gris Gris
Dr. John
|
1 | 2.88 | -1.88 |
|
Picture Book
Simply Red
|
1 | 2.87 | -1.87 |
Artists
Favorites
| Artist | Albums | Average |
|---|---|---|
| Beatles | 5 | 4.6 |
| The Clash | 2 | 5 |
| The Pogues | 2 | 5 |
| Nirvana | 3 | 4.33 |
| Black Sabbath | 3 | 4.33 |
| Bob Marley & The Wailers | 3 | 4.33 |
| Led Zeppelin | 3 | 4.33 |
| Beastie Boys | 3 | 4.33 |
Least Favorites
| Artist | Albums | Average |
|---|---|---|
| Steely Dan | 4 | 1.5 |
| Joni Mitchell | 3 | 1.67 |
| Public Image Ltd. | 2 | 1.5 |
Controversial
| Artist | Ratings |
|---|---|
| Miles Davis | 4, 1 |
| David Bowie | 3, 5, 2, 3, 5 |
5-Star Albums (51)
View Album Wall
Popular Reviews
OutKast · 2 likes
3/5
Just too damned long. There were elements here and there that were enjoyable and sometimes even whimsical, but the overkill on stupid interludes made it challenging to get into. Speakerborrre.
Billy Bragg · 2 likes
5/5
One of the coolest surprises so far in this exercise. And I’m sure it’s one of the more polarizing ones. But when this cassette fell into my hands in high school it quickly became part of the soundtrack of my youth. Activism, romanticism, and a wit all wrapped up in a punk rock delivery. And it’s probably safe to say that his message and popularity would not have survived if it weren’t for the voice. But 40 years later songs like Help Save The Youth of America and There is Power in A Union still seem relevant. Billy continues to this day to be an active performer and smart activist voice for so many.
Fugees · 1 likes
3/5
I wanted to like this more, but nothing really changed my score. I can appreciate the in between banter from a storytelling standpoint showing that the album needs to be listened to from front to back as a single piece to understand the full picture. But the overall length and overuse of the banter became more of a distraction than a compliment. Killing Me Softly is a good song, but is out of place as it really doesn’t fit the narrative of the other songs that are dealing with some tough topics. I understand the cultural impact this record probably had when released, and it was probably even more important to see a 90s hip hop artist achieve this level of success without Dre being involved. But today I just found it a somewhat boring and repetitive listen.
Amy Winehouse · 1 likes
3/5
Don’t get on Amy’s bad side if you’re a dude, ‘cause she’ll definitely be singing about all the ways you wronged her in her songs. Impressive that she was only 19 when recording this album. I can appreciate the fusion of old and new to make a modern jazz/pop/soul sound, but it all pretty much sounds alike outside of her cover of (There Is) No Greater Love. I was never a huge fan of her stuff most likely because of the clinched vocal delivery, but this was a fine listen. Most likely only making this list because she’s a member of the 27 Club.
Steely Dan · 1 likes
1/5
I hated Steely Dan then and I can’t stand them now. I would yell from the back seat of our Ford Grand Torino wagon to change the radio push button as soon as these songs reared their head, and as an adult I still never got past the first measure without turning the dial. Known for taking forever to record their records while in pursuit of sonic perfection, SD ironically produced pieces of work like Aja that are simply boring as hell. I would expect my rock n roll friends to punch me in the face if they ever heard me listening to this yacht rock drivel. In 1977 there were so many more exciting bands happening from Cheap Trick to The Ramones, The Sex Pistols, Elvis Costello, The Jam, The Police. Hell…too many to name. The single one positive on this album is the bass being provided by Chuck Rainey whose list of albums and artists is also too long to name.
1-Star Albums (29)
All Ratings
Elton John
3/5
I was never really into Elton. The first two tracks are obvious bangers and probably lean me further into the realm of enjoying his stuff if listening to a single song in passing. But listening to this front to back I was surprised how much it all sounded alike. The back half had a few surprises, good and bad. The mandolin on Holiday Inn helped, but Indian Sunset? Really Elton?
Supertramp
2/5
The only crime of the century was having to slog through this. While I can appreciate the production and ideas, I felt I was listening more to a new musical only because “Jesus Christ Superstar” was sold out. This was as if ELO and Moody Blues had a kid but deep down probably wished Meatloaf was the father. Clearly an example of all the concept albums happening at the time. I was always a much bigger fan of their later stuff like “The Logical Song”, or “It’s Raining Again” or even “Give a Little Bit” (which oddly enough was covered nicely by the Goo Goo Dolls).
Harry Nilsson
3/5
Clearly a good songwriter and even more clear that he was influenced by the early 70s Beatles sound. Interesting that a number of these songs made there way into American pop culture too whether it be TV or movie montage scenes. And while I can appreciate the balance of quirky with serious…not my bag. An appropriate album title for my taste.
Jimmy Smith
4/5
A very nice listen. Clocking in at just under 44min with only 5 tracks, and yet the songs and entire album pace well. Even though saxophone seems to be more prevalent throughout, all players feature nicely adding to the listening experience. Just four dudes in the same room pushing play on the record button. Dig it.
Sonic Youth
4/5
Like listening to one long stream of consciousness I imagine this is what the inside of Thurston Moore’s head sounds like. Although I was more a fan of their 1990 album Goo, this album had regular rotation for me in the 90s. The experimental, moody, hazy and moments of discord clearly give a nod to SY’s influences like the Velvet Underground. And it’s hard to mention bands like Nirvana without giving a proper nod to this band and album as it clearly became the model which multiple bands in the 90s drew from. While not an album that would get repeat listens from me today, it definitely deserves the higher score simply based on its influence. Avant garde art rock at its best.
Beatles
5/5
This album was always my favourite Beatles album. An easy 5 score especially because of the stylistic variety between the songs. And yet that variety does not take away a cohesion.
Television
4/5
This was a very pivotal album for me growing up, and much like an appearance on The Simpsons…when a world renowned band covers one of your songs, then clearly you’ve “made it.” Check out REM covering the track See No Evil.
PJ Harvey
3/5
I’ve tried mightily to be more into PJ over the years, but alas I just never really got her. When it comes to female art rock artists I will almost always lean way more towards those placed in the same category as PJ, and who I find way more interesting: Bjork, Mazzy Star, Siouxsie and The Banshees, St. Vincent, etc. I did find the production on this album quite interesting though. Still, her 1993 album Rid of Me probably deserves way more credit. 2.5/3
Jethro Tull
3/5
It’s hard to imagine this album being over 50 years old given its somewhat timeless storytelling feel. With obvious religious imagery woven throughout along with odd time signatures, unique song structure, and melodic folk rock stylings, it’s strange to think just how impactful this cerebral concept album was. And yet no matter how many times he presented himself as the codpiece wearing wild eyed court jester, Ian Anderson made the flute cool. Or did he? Hard to say. The guitar work by Martin Barre is very progressive for the time and the flute solo alone on Locomotive Breath gives the song the banger merit it deserves. But when Ron Burgundy whips out a flute in Anchorman and plays Aqualung in an impromptu moment, is that just good music direction…or further evidence that Tull were never taken seriously? Probably the latter. I actually now prefer their follow-up album Thick As a Brick more, but this album deserves its place due to influence alone.
Nirvana
4/5
This album generates lots of emotions. It was ubiquitous for many months I imagine based on the release timing right after Cobain’s death. But damn this was played everywhere all at once. Especially “The Man Who Sold the World.” While not really an unplugged album (more of a live acoustic one) it’s pretty cool to hear new and different sensibilities in the songs. Proof that the songs are just that: good songs. The stripped down feel also allowed for pure raw feel in the vocals which was cool. And there’s also some musical happy accidents that occur which only further cements the human aspect on display.
2/5
I had trouble getting through this one. And while I was familiar with earlier hits like “Spill the Wine” when Eric Burdon from The Animals was involved, I’m mystified at how this album was Billboard’s top seller that year.
Prince
4/5
This album generates a lot of memories for me. Whether it be sneaking in to see the movie at AMC when clearly underage, or slow dancing a little too close to the title track at my 8th grade dance and not giving a sh*t what the nuns thought. This whole album oozed sexuality, and laid the foundation for teenage fantasies as well as future parental advisory disputes with Tipper Gore. From back to front every track is solid. And it’s fascinating to know that the last three songs on it have many tracks that were kept from live shows. Especially the title track with a lot of content apparently taken from a 1983 performance. 80s synth pop at its best.
The The
3/5
This is the day…that I admit to owning this on cassette. While the music itself is pretty light, when coupled with more literary heavy themed lyrics it makes for a more interesting tension-driven sound IMO. I place this more in the category alongside bands like Soft Cell (“Tainted Love”) or even early Love and Rockets or New Order. And I’m sure I broke curfew at underground dance clubs with this playing in the background. The variety of instruments featured (especially the accordion on “This is the Day”, and the piano on “Uncertain Smile”) indicates an even wider variety of influences, and yet the album doesn’t stray and remains in tact. Sm(art) synth pop that is essentially a debut solo album. Great band name too.
Dr. John
1/5
I’m sorry to say that this album needs way more gris gris to help it be less shit shit. Hell…yer gonna find way better sounds of ‘Nawlins listening to zydeco of Beausoleil, Zachary Richard, Wayne Toups, etc. or frankly just walking in a haze down Bourbon Street or catching pop-up street players in the Frenchman Street area. The secret to a good gumbo is in the roux, but if you don’t keep stirring, it turns into a clumpy mess…which this is. Random noise to accompany a ritual voodoo sacrifice I guess? I have no idea. Regardless, the fact that it made the top 500 of all time list is laughable. I’d rather listen to Dr. Teeth and the Electric Mayhem.
David Bowie
3/5
I had never listened to this all the way through front to back. Really dug it. The feel of it clearly continues where Suffragette City left off, only more so. And the noted American influence is interesting given it was his US tour that provided the backdrop for when the songs were written. This is a velvet goldmine of glam bliss.
Alice In Chains
3/5
With A in C making waves on the Seattle scene before the rise of Nirvana, it’s surprising to me how little I listen(ed) to this band. I was more a Screaming Trees fan. But…they definitely created their own style with the droney vocals and guitar stylings, and yet it’s those very things that had me struggling to get through this one. Most songs sound very much alike outside of the hits Rooster and Would? Due to its influence alone this one still gets a 3 from me.
Michael Jackson
4/5
Definitely a taste of what’s coming soon, albeit with more disco and funk. Other than a few songs 2/3 of the way through that aren’t as strong, the album still cooks. I always liked this one, especially since it provided the soundtrack for me during many nights at the roller rink. Terry cloth shirt: check. Pocket comb: check. Speed skates: check. Infectious grooves: check.
Frank Ocean
2/5
Orange you glad you only had to listen to this just once all the way through?
Abdullah Ibrahim
3/5
While an overall decent sounding album, the production and arrangements for some songs definitely speak to that 80s sound. A little too much sax here and there. And on more than one occasion if I closed my eyes I could’ve sworn I was listening to a montage scene from any mid-80s romantic comedy like Romancing The Stone or similar. Interestingly the title track was not available for listening. I didn’t wanna run away listening to this, but it also didn’t wanna make me get up and make that 2nd classic martini of the night. 2.5/3.
Bob Dylan
3/5
For 5+ decades we’ve been told that Dylan is an amazing artist and because of that we’re supposed to like him. Yes he is a great lyricist and songwriter. But a singer he is not, and listening to an album of his front to back proved that. His “style” is grating when you hear it for 60+ minutes. When EVery SOng HAs that SAme EMphasis ON EVery WOrd he SINGs. Nothing short of annoying and it takes away from the musical landscape of the song. Plus, settle down on the use of harmonica. I like that this is one of the three full band albums he made that gave the proverbial finger to all his folk purists, but it really only earns a 3-star for its influence on other artists.
Marvin Gaye
4/5
So basically this album provides the template for the four rules of life: a.) to get it on b.) To keep getting it on c.) to learn how to ball in order to maintain one’s on getting and d.) because if not, you sure would not have kept one satisfied. What else does one need?
Duke Ellington
3/5
It’s a long way to the top if you wanna…play jazz. But this album is a great example of what many artists can’t do: perform live! The commentary in between was interesting and made you feel like you were there. And the players were top notch. Like cool, daddio!
Dirty Projectors
2/5
We’re gonna need a bigger boat to reel this whale of forced art rock in. Some cool production here and there gets masked by too many elements colliding leaving very little breathing room to find melody or hook. If a Jackson Pollack painting made sound I imagine this is what it would be like. I’ll find my indie art rock elsewhere with the likes of The Talking Heads, XTC, etc.
k.d. lang
3/5
I’ve been a fan of k.d. since the Absolute Torch and Twang album that was just one year after this. While clearly the song choices speak to a sub-genre, she has always been able to bring these old school sounds into a more popular market while at the same time embodying Patsy Cline. And her vocal control is masterful. Recognising this is probably a hard sell for most folks, you can’t deny her talent.
Marilyn Manson
1/5
I was wanting to like this, but I found the screamo vocals just annoying. And the compressed guitar sounds were predictable and now quite outdated. I’m truly dumbfounded as to how this album and artist received such attention throughout the 90s. While the lyrics are pretty effed up, today they would probably just pass as adolescent. I imagine this is the music you use to take hostages or torture people to. Shock rock then, schlock rock today.
Joan Armatrading
2/5
After a solid first track I really wanted this to be eligible for higher rating, but the following tracks don’t really stand out. It’s a decent listen, and the production is quite good. But alas…
Black Sabbath
4/5
If you build it they will come. Clearly the album that influenced so many future bands. This thing is so beautifully perfect in its imperfections. Tempo waivers, string drags, vocal cracks…and yet who cares. And the way it was recorded live from the floor makes it even more badass. Close to a 5 in my book.
Crosby, Stills & Nash
3/5
The three part harmonies are of course the standout, and they make it sound effortless which is not an easy task. The hits are hits for a reason. They’re memorable and very recognizable. The other tracks while pleasant are not as. Still, an iconic album that opened the door for so many more artists of that famous Laurel Canyon sound.
The Louvin Brothers
3/5
Taking a page from the book of Irish/folk tunes of yesteryear, these guys continue the practice of providing happy melodies with words of sadness, loss, tragedy and murder. I mean who doesn’t love a good yodelling murder ballad? A little repetitive sounding all the way through, but enjoyable nonetheless. I almost wanna give them a 4 based solely on their album artwork from 1959’s album Satan is Real.
Charles Mingus
2/5
Known for being a volatile dude with an angry temper who believed in collective improvisation, Mingus gives us a good example of art imitating life on this one I suppose. Maybe I would’ve enjoyed this more while watching the ballet for which it was written. Too erratic for my taste.
Black Sabbath
5/5
And on the 8th day God created Black Sabbath Paranoid. He looked at his work, smiled and then rested knowing there would never be another.
5/5
A super sex laden space journey of rock n roll genius. This is just any amazing album from front to back and its relevance remains over 50 years later.
Pixies
3/5
While a bigger fan of Surfer Rosa and Doolittle, I think this album still paced well. It was nice to hear more melodies and tempos amongst songs and you can tell by this 3rd outing the band had really come into its own. They remain the kings of the loud-quiet-loud model for song crafting.
Queen Latifah
3/5
Ignoring the obvious 80s style and production here, I actually found myself enjoying this one. Clever use of some samples and sounds. But damn, I don’t need to be told that you are the Q-U-E-E-N on every song. I get it. Still, it’s a nice statement record and it clearly opened the door for future female rap artists.
Steely Dan
1/5
I hated Steely Dan then and I can’t stand them now. I would yell from the back seat of our Ford Grand Torino wagon to change the radio push button as soon as these songs reared their head, and as an adult I still never got past the first measure without turning the dial. Known for taking forever to record their records while in pursuit of sonic perfection, SD ironically produced pieces of work like Aja that are simply boring as hell. I would expect my rock n roll friends to punch me in the face if they ever heard me listening to this yacht rock drivel. In 1977 there were so many more exciting bands happening from Cheap Trick to The Ramones, The Sex Pistols, Elvis Costello, The Jam, The Police. Hell…too many to name. The single one positive on this album is the bass being provided by Chuck Rainey whose list of albums and artists is also too long to name.
Solomon Burke
3/5
I had no idea who Solomon was until hearing this one. At moments sounding like Sam Cooke, Otis and Aretha all wrapped up in one, it’s interesting that his popularity has not sustained like all those other contemporaries of the time. Even more fascinating is the amount of record labels he was signed to: 17.
Elliott Smith
3/5
It was nice revisiting this one again. I’ve been an Elliott fan ever since his song placements in Good Will Hunting. I like his earlier stuff like Either/Or better but this one still holds up. An added bonus is having one of my favourite drummers (Pete Thomas of Elvis Costello & The Attractions) featured on three songs. It’s so interesting to see how such a troubled soul could produce such lovely tunes.
Beach House
3/5
I’ve only heard songs here and there over the years from Beach House and always found them enjoyable. Listening to their album front to back confirmed for me that their whispy, dreamy synth rock remains pleasant, yet strangely forgettable. This album will probably find its way into my background music catalogue.
Rush
4/5
This was the Rush album I grew up with. Hearing Tom Sawyer and Limelight on the radio was an everyday occurrence. They were ubiquitous. And yet the band itself remained somewhat mysterious. Playground discussions of Peart’s drum solo on Tom Sawyer and the morse code opening of YYZ were routine. Some interesting nerdy production choices on this one: every time Peart grabbed a drum roll, instead of mixing/panning the toms traditionally from left to right, they were mixed/panned from right to left almost as if to match the visual of what would occur if the listener were watching him live. Masters of their instruments, it’s still pretty mind blowing today to know that these sounds were being performed by a trio.
Suede
3/5
The only song I ever knew from this band was in fact the lead single “Metal Mickey” off this album. And the rest of the songs did not disappoint. I thoroughly enjoyed this from front to back which I have not said much about other albums in this exercise. Strange how this and many of their other albums did quite well in the UK, but didn’t have near the impact in the US. And yet their fellow Brit-pop contemporaries Oasis, Blur, etc. did not have the same fate. I will definitely be visiting more of their catalog.
Tracy Chapman
4/5
I remember buying this on vinyl when it came out so full disclosure, much of my review probably leans heavily on nostalgia. Still, the 1988 timing of this album is pretty pivotal right at the peak of hair metal. And yet 3 months later it was already platinum. Don’t get me wrong, I loved rokken with Dokken like the rest of ‘em, but there was something that always stood out for me with this one. Most likely rooted in its simplistic approach, both in songwriting and production which completely went against the over the top glam of the time.
The Rolling Stones
3/5
It’s been a long time since listening to this one. The variety probably speaks to the come-and-go style that the recording sessions took on, with the entire band rarely playing together. Or maybe it was all the heroin that Richards was using. Either way there are still some straight up rockers on the front end, with the back half sounding a bit slow in places. Still probably places in my top 3 Stones albums behind Some Girls and Tattoo You. 3.5/5.
Simply Red
1/5
Simply confused. How did this white guy/jazz/RnB easy listening make it so far? I distinctly remember hearing “Holding Back The Years” everywhere. And it definitely took up much of my already limited time watching MTV just hoping I’d hear Twisted Sister just one more time. But in all seriousness, this reminded me of the much better debut by Terence Trent D’Arby that would come two years later, and I’m betting makes its way into this 1001 list. 1.5/5
Steely Dan
1/5
An aptly titled album given the twisted logic it would take to convince me to like this. Better than the Aja album, but still lingers in the WTF category for me.
Robert Wyatt
3/5
If I ever fall out of a window and become a paraplegic, I hope I can make music like this. The opening track is strong and the album as a whole feels like he took up residence inside the mind of Frank Zappa complete with odd arrangements and chord choices yet also containing a tongue n cheek feel in places. I’m not even sure what I listened to, but I dig it. I found it strangely interesting and even beautiful in places.
Adele
3/5
The vocal performance alone puts this on the higher side, but at times the songs all start sounding alike. Whether that be a patterned approach where every song has her starting soft only to then jump to belting it out, or the dramatic production. It sure would be nice to hear more with just her and a guitar or piano like on “Send My Love” as her voice is quite suited to that stripped down intimate feel. The last track “Sweetest Devotion” was one of my favorites. Still, overall a solid album that I will probably eventually forget about.
The Band
2/5
The Bland. While yes their music might make the listener feel right at home on a sweaty porch drinking a Dixie beer or as Kevin Kline’s understudy in The Big Chill, but I simply never got it. And this collection of sound-alike songs of southern snooze rock did not change my mind nor make me reach for that second beer.
Bob Marley & The Wailers
4/5
I will always be a Marley fan. Whether it be active listening or playing in the background, his music knows no boundaries. While I am more familiar with his Uprising album, the social and spiritual aspects of his music are the common thread throughout his catalog, and they are ever present on this work too. Pass the doobie from the left hand side and enjoy these positive vibrations.
Iggy Pop
3/5
Seeing Iggy Pop in 1987 on the same bill with The Smithereens, Ziggy Marley, Guns N’ Roses and INXS is hard to top. Unless of course he were to wear see through clear cellophane pants the whole show, which of course he did. A departure from his highly influential Stooges period, this album overall did not disappoint. “Turn Blue” was a bit of a slog, but the rest I found enjoyable. Especially “The Passenger” which would be covered most excellently ten years later by Siouxsie and the Banshees. The biggest puzzle to me is the cover art photo, which looks like something you’d find on an employee badge for someone who didn’t finish his TPS reports. Still, I’ll be revisiting this one.
T. Rex
4/5
This is how I like my glam rock. Short and to the point songs covered in a power pop glaze. I had never listened much to T. Rex outside of their hits like “Get it On”, but I really liked this album. There’s some sonic similarities with fellow contemporaries Ziggy Stardust and Roxy Music which is not a bad thing. I see now why T. Rex is cited as an influence for so many artists.
Queen
4/5
This was a rockin good album. I was pleasantly surprised to hear as many hard rock guitar forward riffs and runs and no doubt Brian May’s sound is noticeable immediately. As is the clear talent of the other members. There were a few songs that felt like filler but overall this is just a solid rock album.
R.E.M.
4/5
As a fierce REM fan, I remember the day this major label debut dropped. We were all mortified that they had left the cool indie world of IRS Records to jump the shark into corporate rock of Warner Bros. These wounds were softened a bit when I learned that they did not choose the highest bidder, but instead chose WB due to maintaining 100% creative control. Still, with this move I had to accept the fact that the whole world would now know about this little band from Athens, GA. One of my favorite bands would no longer be an underground hidden kept secret. Seeing them from the front row on this tour made me like the album more and even today Green probably sits just outside my top 5 REM albums. It’s a really eclectic album that was known to be the result of the band trying to write some “dumb pop songs.” And on tour Stipe was adamant about introducing “Stand” every night as “the dumbest song ever written.” An irony lost on a lot of folks. “World Leader Pretend” was always my favorite song and was interestingly used a lot during the ‘88 Bush/Dukakis presidential run. A song that is probably even more relevant today.
Soft Cell
3/5
This album would’ve been on heavy rotation in the decadent club scene of the early 80s. Influential then yes. Relevant today? Probably not. Hell, I probably heard Tainted Love for the first time after sneaking in to Dallas’ famed Starck Club. Impressive that it was all made on a shoestring budget using a few synths and drum machines. Still, I don’t think the album holds up as much today. Outside of the obvious hit track, there were really just a few others that were my go-to. Say Hello, Wave Goodbye is one, and David Grey does a really nice cover of it too. A 2.5 rounded up just for memory sake.
The Fall
3/5
I was always aware of The Fall, but somehow missed them. Which is even more surprising given they had 31 albums from the time they began thru 2017. Clearly operating as a true underground cult band. I found this album a bit scattered, most likely due to the caustic and erratic vocal stylings. But did enjoy its simple post-punk feel overall.
Elvis Presley
3/5
Can I get a partial Amen? This was a nice listen and one I’ll probably return to. The hits remain the standout. And while I did like the country, gospel, soul mix of sound, it’s just a few short of earning a full Amen. You can hear the change in sound starting of what would eventually become Vegas residency Elvis, but unlike Elvis himself a few short years later, it’s not quite overblown (and overweight) just yet.
The Rolling Stones
3/5
Speaking words of wisdom…let it bleed. The bookend hits on this one are timeless, but some of the tracks in the middle seemed a little repetitive for me this time around. Interesting to see that the fiddle on Country Honk was provided by Byron Berline, a well known player in the Texas style fiddle scene, who would later find success as part of the Flying Burrito Brothers. You can’t always get what you want on a Stones album, but at least you do get some solid rock n roll.
Thin Lizzy
3/5
Outside of the hits I had never really listened to Thin Lizzy. On the controversial topic of whether this was truly a live recording, I would probably side with the producer. Unnatural crowd fades as well as moments of no noise at all during songs with space kinda support the fact those parts were studio overdubs. But it was still an enjoyable listen. And the twin guitar’ing really defines the band. More like…Somewhat live and somewhat dangerous but still rockin’.
Penguin Cafe Orchestra
3/5
Interesting album artwork. Even more interesting sounds. I enjoyed listening to this record. You can definitely tell that it has Brian Eno’s hands on it, no doubt why it probably gained more attention. If this is the music featured in life’s cafe I’d definitely like to go there.
Lou Reed
4/5
Outside of Velvet Underground, I never paid much attention to Lou Reed solo. But this was a very cool listen. Perfect Day and Satellite of Love were nice re-visits and the Bowie/Ronson production is very apparent given some similar sonic styles appearing here just like the Bowie albums themselves during this same time period. An easy 4 for its uniqueness, influence and staying power.
Eels
3/5
A pretty enjoyable listen. More so on the front end than the back where I thought the album was a little tired. Overuse of sampling and occasional F-bomb drops I think make this venture slightly into pretentious land, but that was probably a sign of the 90s time.
Elliott Smith
4/5
It’s nice to hear how much this album still has staying power today 25 yrs later. Many artists today can take a page from Smith when it comes to making records with a minimalistic approach. The production here is interesting and many times uses empty space itself as an instrument. Even more impressive that Smith plays all instruments on it. Remains my favorite album by him.
Snoop Dogg
3/5
This was a listen down memory lane. Overall it’s the music and beats that drew me in and really do show Dre’s production talent. But the unnecessary overuse of certain “words” in every song makes this a pretty tired album that wouldn’t pass by today’s standards. It’s clear that Snoop had lyrical talent with creative rhythmic delivery and word choice, and it would’ve been nice to see that more here.
TV On The Radio
3/5
I never understood how this band routinely received such high reviews, and this listen did not really move that needle for me. There were a few standout tracks, but for the most part the album lacked cohesion and really just sounded like randomized sounds being thrown together. I will probably continue to find my art rock elsewhere.
Cheap Trick
5/5
When a 9-year old kid rides his BMX bike up to the used record store with the intent of buying this album and KISS Alive…and succeeding, I’m not sure what else matters. As one of the greatest live albums of all time, Budokan became the musical foundation for so many youths including myself. It’s hard to be brief when discussing this album given its incredible influence, and because it would set the stage for bucking tradition and offering such a large alternative to the disco and yacht rock of the time. The live versions of “Surrender” and “I Want You To Want Me” upped the irons more than their studio cuts. And the fact that “Hello”, “Big Eyes” and “Goodnight” still get played today with the same freshness only solidifies this band as leaders in the power-pop pantheon. This record simply speaks for itself and is a true banger knowing it was performed by four dudes in their late 20s. The Beatlemania these guys experienced in Japan is so strange given that they were only together 5 years by the time of this recording. And then only to have their success boomerang back to the US who didn’t give them much attention to begin with. A perfect story for a band carving their own new territory. Robin Zander’s pipes were and always will be amazing. And Bun E. Carlos’ drumming is clinical. There is not a weak song on it which is why Cheap Trick remain to this day one of the most fierce and tight touring bands.
Barry Adamson
2/5
If Sophocles were a music producer no doubt this would be the theme music of Oedipus Rex. You can just imagine him walking around Thebes with this playing and him saying “yeah, I killed my father and mounted my mother! You fuckin plebeians got a problem with that?” Still…this was a tough listen and certainly not worthy of making the list. Interesting yes. Strange yes. And I appreciate the Nick Cave connection with Adamson being a former member of the Bad Seeds. But nothing I’m gonna repeat listen. Schmoedipus indeed.
Sarah Vaughan
4/5
This is my kinda jazz. Melody, melancholy, wistfulness and a bit of wit all wrapped up into one nice package. All the while sipping on a classic cocktail. A great entryway into exploring more of her material.
Led Zeppelin
3/5
It’s essentially impossible to measure up on a complete album when the iconic Immigrant Song is your opener. Probably one of my least fave LZ albums, but I still found it pretty interesting from an artistic standpoint with obvious growth of the band venturing into more acoustic instruments and style. Some numbers were way too bluesy for me but I did like the use of mandolin and banjo, etc.
The Cult
3/5
When I bought this album the week it came out I had very high expectations and hopes. Primarily driven from my love of the band’s previous efforts. Most notably their 2nd album “Love” which produced such timeless numbers as “She Sells Sanctuary” and “Rain.” But I was confused then and remain confused today why the band would make such a drastic stylistic change given the breakthrough success of Love. Billy Duffy’s guitar work is always great but I think this was a failed attempt to change their sound and probably only makes the list due to the Rick Rubin tie in, who was known for literally matching the guitar tones to those of AC/DC and Zeppelin when the sessions were underway. Giving it a 3 because admittedly they did rock on these numbers when I got a chance to see them live.
Shack
3/5
This was a solid album. Good songwriting and nice melodies make it standout amongst Brit pop/rock. Twelve songs with a total run time under 48 minutes and a good variety ranks it even higher for me. Makes perfect sense that they have label connections to the Lightning Seeds and Noel Gallagher as some moments in their songs definitely lean into that sound which is not a bad thing at all. One of a handful of bands so far on the list that I knew nothing about, but that I will be revisiting.
Echo And The Bunnymen
4/5
It’s clear that by the time of this album the Bunnymen were nearing their peak. And some would argue that peak would not be reached until three years later with Lips Like Sugar. But The Killing Moon remains to this day a top song on many “best of” lists including my own. The variety and expansion of instruments on this one elevates it and further cements it and the band as one of the more unique standouts at the time. Ian McCulloch’s voice continues to be one immediately identifiable and in a sea of 80s new wave, punk, hair metal this album set a new standard and rose to the top as a true alternative.
Ramones
5/5
The question is: in 1974 how much more punk could you be? And the answer is: none…none more punk. Especially because you invented it with this album. Simple. Short. Influential. Legacy. The fathers of punk rock, and a blueprint for so many future bands in punk, indie, rock, metal, you name it. Anything other than a top rating would be punk rock sacrilege.
Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers
4/5
The opening track almost serves as a passing of the torch. You can hear Roger McGuinn passing the jangly Rickenbacker right into Tom’s hands which would go on to become Petty and crew’s signature sound. The two radio hits alone merit high marks for this one. A great debut for one of (if not the) greatest American songwriters of our time.
Underworld
3/5
I liked this and I’m not even fully sure why. While it was a little too long for my taste, I did like the production. It’s almost as if it takes the listener to a place you’ve never been before while simultaneously asking the question: did you ever leave in the first place?
Death In Vegas
2/5
Add another one to the “why did this make the list” category. I mean I guess I liked it because it incorporated some real instruments with electronic, which added a more human aspect to it. But the music was forgettable. What happens in Vegas will definitely be staying in Vegas.
Led Zeppelin
5/5
Following Mike Damone’s five-point plan from Fast Times at Ridgemont High:
1. "You never let on how much you like a girl. 'Oh, Debbie. Hi.'"
2. "You always call the shots. 'Kiss me. You won't regret it.'"
3. "Act like wherever you are, that's the place to be. 'Isn't this great?'"
4. "When ordering food, you find out what she wants, then order for the both of you. It's a classy move. 'Now, the lady will have the linguine and white clam sauce, and a Coke with no ice.'"
…and most importantly…
5. "When it comes down to making out, whenever possible, put on side one of Led Zeppelin IV."
Lauryn Hill
3/5
I guess I’m experiencing my own miseducation on this one. While there are a few songs that rise above most of the others, there were not many major standouts. It’s a bit long, most of the songs hang at the same tempo, and the overuse of the teacher v. student classroom samples I think helps lessen the impact of the intended message. Still, it’s obvious how talented Ms. Hill is and no doubt future female hip-hop/rap/soul artists would not be where they are without this record.
Bob Marley & The Wailers
4/5
It makes sense that this one runs a close second in popularity to Legend. The vibes are very much alive here and the two Peter Tosh sung tunes were also a nice standout. Hard pressed to rate any Marley album lower than 4 stars. The fire has been caught and is burning bright.
Mudhoney
4/5
These guys sometimes seem to get lost in the conversation about the Seattle scene with the meteoric rise of Nirvana, Pearl Jam and Soundgarden, but they clearly were setting the stage before anyone with this first grunge album. You can definitely hear them channeling everyone from Black Flag to Iggy Pop to Sonic Youth to even some Hüsker Dü sprinkled on. The drums alone drive this sucker and the album seems so much bigger than just 6 songs. Sometimes you don’t need anything else than some fuzz and muff in order to rock.
Def Leppard
5/5
1001 listens to an album you must hear before you grow up. This was one of the first cassettes I ever bought and helped me realize how uncool I was…until I of course went to Chess King and bought my own sleeveless DL Union Jack t-shirt, checkered bandana and parachute pants to complete the rock n roll package. After that my path to coolness was just fine. Upon relistening I didn’t realize how much synth was actually used on the album, and along with the signature shotgun snare sound I was immediately transported back in time. Yes Mutt Lange’s meticulous style of recording seems to have stripped away some of the grit and edge of the previous two albums, but it’s hard to argue with any track. Just an amazing influential rock album complete with banger after banger played by tight musicians. And to think that drummer Rick Allen was only 19 when they recorded this. Just plain sick. Rock for the Ages? You betcha.
Dolly Parton
4/5
Damn I forgot how much I love these voices. I own solo material from all three of ‘em, so it’s only natural that when three of the most amazing singers combine it produces this angelic perfection. Three uniquely different sounding voices that somehow become one. Not a style or choice that is a routine go-to for me, but when I do go there with this collaboration all I know is I don’t wanna leave. This is real raw talent. This is the real country music.
The White Stripes
4/5
Revisiting this one 20+ years later definitely makes for a different listen. There’s some great variety throughout and learning more about the primitive recording process using pre-1963 gear elevates this elephant even more. It’s also important to note that the White Stripes would most likely not exist if not for the influence of mid-80s The Flat Duo Jets whom White speaks highly of in the documentary It Might Get Loud. I will stop short of debating whether Meg is a great drummer, but she is definitely great at serving these dirty, imperfect, raw, gritty, unapologetic songs in this powerhouse duo. It’s rock n roll. And I like it.
Fela Kuti
3/5
I have no words. And apparently neither does Fela. Obvious strong musicianship and really great drumming are at play here. I’m not real sure what I was listening to, but the Afro-jazz blues funkalicious grooves on this made for a much more enjoyable experience while high on allergy meds.
Bee Gees
2/5
I’m not sure if I was listening to an ambitious yet failed attempt to try and be The Beatles, or the Queen’s coronation…or Spinal Tap which for once is not a good thing. I can appreciate the variety, but this thing is all over the map. Maybe the mysterious lost ship should remain lost.
R.E.M.
4/5
This 5th album from the band is very much a statement record. Not only an expansion in sound with more guitar heavy tracks, but also some heavy topics from McCarthyism to the state of America under the Reagan administration. This would be their final album with I.R.S. but seeing them perform it live in ‘87 only cemented my love for the band. Finest Worksong is a great opener and Disturbance At The Heron House and King of Birds still rank high on my all time REM faves list.
Nirvana
5/5
It seems silly to leave an in-depth review on this one. Time, longevity, production, songwriting, cover art and cultural influence all dictate where this record stands in the library of rock importance. And so to me I think that…oh well, whatever…never mind. It speaks for itself.
Jack White
4/5
When this album arrived 12 years ago I did not give it its fair share. Most likely because I was still somewhat narrow mindedly thinking Jack was only a one-trick White Stripes pony. Re-listening to this now confirms how wrong I was. The stylistic variety and genre bending really shows how he spread his wings after the Stripes and is enough to rate this high for me. Add to that the old school production of only using an 8-track recorder, really allowed some space and air to exist in the songs while also showing that with so few tracks available the players really had to be well-rehearsed. A very cool listen this time around and one I will for sure be routinely revisiting.
Fiona Apple
3/5
While it’s a little sleepy on the backend, this album is a very interesting listen and would fill a number of mood moments. The production is progressive enough that this album would fit just fine if launched in today’s musical market. It’s also understandable that Fiona often gets associated with other like-minded and like-sounding female artists such as Tori Amos, but surprisingly I find Fiona’s sound a little more enjoyable. And to think that the shells of these songs were written by her as a teen and the album in full was released when she was only 18. Incredibly impressive.
Fugees
3/5
I wanted to like this more, but nothing really changed my score. I can appreciate the in between banter from a storytelling standpoint showing that the album needs to be listened to from front to back as a single piece to understand the full picture. But the overall length and overuse of the banter became more of a distraction than a compliment. Killing Me Softly is a good song, but is out of place as it really doesn’t fit the narrative of the other songs that are dealing with some tough topics. I understand the cultural impact this record probably had when released, and it was probably even more important to see a 90s hip hop artist achieve this level of success without Dre being involved. But today I just found it a somewhat boring and repetitive listen.
Massive Attack
2/5
I can appreciate that this albums starts the creation of the new trip-hop sub genre, but overall it was a pretty boring listen. Some of the sounds and grooves were interesting, but guest vocalist Horace had a vibrato so wide you could drive a semi through it, which was more annoying to listen to than some of the slow tempos. I’ll pass. More like passive attack.
Mott The Hoople
3/5
The Bowie similarities are uncanny here. From the vocal style delivery all the way down to the music and production. Makes sense knowing how much Bowie was a Mott fan and that he wrote some songs for them. And with Ziggy Stardust released just one year earlier it can’t be coincidental. Still, outside of the opening track none of the songs really stick or have memorable hook. An ok listen but definitely Nott part of my hoople.
Blondie
4/5
With so many hit singles, and with such a unique mix of punk/rock/synth pop, this record helped set the stage and usher in the new wave. Ironically it would be the disco leaning Heart Of Glass that would help squash the disco movement for good, signaling a drastic change in the music world just around the corner. Debbie Harry’s voice is both strong and sexy and arguably one of the most immediately identifiable. While Clem Burke as one of my top 5 drummers is unmatched in his delivery and style. An overall solid listen.
Radiohead
4/5
Definitely in my top 3 RH albums just behind OK Computer and The Bends. And it for sure leans more into the sounds and production of OK Computer. Not a bad song on the record and listening on headphones definitely allowed for an alternate feel, from dreamy and airy to downright strange and tension filled. All the feels you want out of a Radiohead album.
Richard Thompson
4/5
Thompson and his previous band Fairport Convention, along with other Brit-folk bands of the time like Steeleye Span were quite influential to me when forming my own band due to their Celtic/folk sounds. Listening to this back to front some 25 years later only confirmed why. Other than being a major multi-instrumentalist, Thompson also has a great ability for minimalist playing when needed while providing a humanistic approach to the music. Would I call this a masterpiece? No. But an excellent timeless listen? Yes.
k.d. lang
2/5
I tried very hard to like this album, but nope. Outside of Constant Craving which seems out of place on the record, the record’s slick and very dated production did not hold up. I much prefer the country-tinged sound of Lang rather than this pseudo cabaret style. Even her smooth and silky voice couldn’t save it. Felt like I was listening to the Lawrence Welk show or some made-for-TV special.
Heaven 17
1/5
After listening to this, I contemplated jumping out of the window of my penthouse only to land head first on the pavement below. Actually that thought occurred AS I was listening to it. Regardless that these guys shared members with the Human League, how the hell some of these albums make the list is beyond comprehension. Even if heaven existed in 17 different realms, I’m sure this album would not be included in any of them.
Kanye West
3/5
Bat shit crazy artist meets crazy good art. Like most people I’ve always had trouble separating the art from the person when it comes to this nut job. But objectively speaking this album was surprisingly good. A bit too long though. Cut 3-4 songs and the album would still stand up.
Kraftwerk
4/5
The level of influence this band and album have/had on so many artists downstream earns it a high rating. From bands already experienced on this 1001 list like Underworld and Soft Cell, to so many others like Depeche Mode, New Order and especially the more recent Daft Punk. The scarcity of lyrics mixed with more simple sounds only supports the intended theme here of humans and their relationship to technology. And the fact that these German robot dudes also built many of the instruments and units used to create the sounds is pretty amazing. Life imitates art.
Sonic Youth
3/5
As Thurston Moore sings: “Flies are flaring through your brains.” That’s pretty much how I felt listening to this. The album started the bridge of the band moving into songs with more structure and actual hook. But not much of that here. There’s only so much art rock noise one can handle. Granted, the bonus track Master-Dik espousing “I’m the royal tuff titty and you gotta taste my love” while sampling KISS’ “Strutter” was pretty sweet.
The Black Keys
4/5
This was a solid listen, albeit a little too long. It probably ventures into 5* territory if there were some songs cut since it did start to sound repetitive on the backend. Still, I can dig the analog production which plays perfectly for two guys known for jamming in the garage.
Led Zeppelin
5/5
I mean c’mon! An album this good for your debut? It’s just not fair. All those other bands and critics who say (and said) otherwise can stick a lead balloon where the rock n roll don’t shine. And to think that this sucker was recorded mostly live from the floor in just 36 hours of studio time. Anything less than a 5* would be rock sacrilege.
Bob Dylan
4/5
At least I can say I liked this better than Blonde On Blonde. Shorter length, more sonic variety across the songs were definitely contributing factors. But his monotone vocal delivery will always unfortunately overshadow the poignancy of his lyrics which remain culturally and politically important.
Billy Joel
4/5
I always thought Billy Joel’s music was safe and comfortable for people who don’t like to color outside the lines. Me included on some days depending on mood. But hits are hits and no matter how soft and somewhat cheesy his songs can be, there is a timeless aspect to his tunes that definitely remains. Even if we refuse to admit that we actually do know the lyrics and can sing along. Five out of nine songs that saw heavy rotation gives this a high number.
Black Flag
4/5
This album saw regular rotation for me during my skate punk years right alongside other albums by The Circle Jerks, Dead Kennedys, 7 Seconds. No doubt I was singing “TV Party” on my way down the ramp after pulling a decent backside grind. Chalked full of all the topics of the day from antiestablishment to depression, this gem also has a tongue in cheek humor to it on some songs. And Black Flag were some of the first to strike that balance which influenced many others down the punk rock line.
Antony and the Johnsons
1/5
If only this bird would fly away. But no. Instead it decided to take up residence in the throat of the singer fluttering away like a caged vibrato hummingbird. This has got to be one of the 1001 you must hear if only to serve as a reminder to never listen to it again. Annoying from the first downbeat. Who knows if the piano driven arrangements were any good since I never got past the grating voice. And to think this album received high rankings from supposedly well respected rags like Pitchfork. Nope.
The Temptations
4/5
Just good soul-driven music with solid grooves that makes you forget about life for awhile. Runaway Child ironically seems a bit out of place here due to its length and jam vibe when compared to the rest of the tracks. But it doesn’t take away from the overall enjoyment.
4/5
I enjoyed this. It was an unexpected surprise and a long way from “You Really Got Me.” Proof that Ray Davies is a good songwriter and can stand at least in the vicinity of that era of Lennon/McCartney.
Janis Joplin
4/5
I wasn’t expecting to like this as much as I did, but it was a very solid listen. The production while quite slick for the time still maintains a slight rough-around-the edges feel and only emphasizes just how great a singer Joplin was. Hard to imagine that this was just her 2nd studio album ever recorded.
Morrissey
3/5
A clear shift in style from previous indie pop to a more hard rocking vibe with not near as much of his moany whiney feels. Still, I peeled away from Morrissey after his solo debut Viva Hate, and am still a bigger fan of The Smiths, but overall this was a decent album.
Morrissey
2/5
Two days in a row of Morrissey might be too much for anyone. Interesting production on this one due to Steve Lillywhite known for his work with U2, Simple Minds, The Pogues, etc. That plus the lead single “The More You Ignore Me…” are still not enough to move it up the rating scale. Just another sad moody experience with not much stand outs.
Brian Eno
2/5
I get it. Let’s throw some musicians together who might not normally gel, only to see what transpires. Art for art’s sake. But oof this was tough listen. There were some sounds here and there that I did like, but this exercise is not about 1001 Sounds You Must Hear Before You Die. Eno should’ve stuck it out a bit longer with Roxy Music.
Pixies
4/5
With 15 songs and a full run time of under 40 minutes you gotta love it. Add to that the fact that 4 of the tracks were charting songs. Clearly a more slick and structured production on this moved the band into the more commercial realm, and yet has many Pixies purists over the years gripping Surfer Rosa all the more tightly. Whether intended or not, this album cemented the loud/quiet/loud format as the model of 90s alternative music which Nirvana et al gladly picked up and became famous for. Influence and legacy alone earn it high marks. Smells Like Doolittle Spirit to me.
King Crimson
4/5
Man I so wanted to give this a 5-star, but a slight downgrade most likely due to long moments of space or too much avant-garde here and there. But still, it’s impossible to argue that this band and album were not part of the foundation for many prog bands soon to come from Jethro Tull to Gentle Giant to Rush to Dream Theater and beyond. The precision and execution are truly mind bending. The drumming alone on 21st Century Schizoid Man merits its own discussion. And what many have probably written off as pretentious and random overall is anything but that. It’s calculated next level stuff that at many times is hard to comprehend.
The Thrills
3/5
This was an ok listen. I always thought of these lads as being the Irish Jayhawks just not near as good. The songs are quite pleasant yet strangely forgettable other than “Say It Ain’t So”, which was a nice standout due to its upbeat tempo. So much for thinking this album should be on this list.
Minor Threat
3/5
A short run album by a short-lived band but with a long reach influence across the entire hardcore movement. This album deserves a shared lane with their D.C. punk rock contemporaries Bad Brains and contains a lot of the same dynamics and tightness. Punk was not dead then and upon relisten is not dead now.
Tim Buckley
2/5
Interesting that his last show was in Dallas. Even more interesting…and to quote journalists reviews from some of his future albums: “this is not even good sulking music.” I mean…everybody likes a little sad guy music along with a good cry, but damn this was a somber listen. And that’s after two straight days of Morrissey last week.
4/5
This was really nice surprising listen. One that I liked better than earlier stuff and one that also flowed better than some of her later stuff. Covering all the moods and dynamics, the album is also much more melodic than other of her works which is probably why I liked it more. And the Thom Yorke duet was a cool standout that doesn’t take away from the overall feel of the album.
The Beach Boys
5/5
Every time I listen a whole new series of sounds are discovered. A true masterpiece. Nothing more needs to be said.
Le Tigre
2/5
Le Boring. Le Missed the Mark. Le Forced Art Pop-Rock. Le Annoying at Times. Le Nope…
Madonna
3/5
I thought I was gonna be like a virgin when listening to this one since I really don’t know much of her songs outside of the hits. But then around track six I heard that stupid Cher-inspired autotune vocal modulation effect and I realized I wasn’t being touched for the very first time. I liked the acoustic meets electronic element on some tracks, but outside of the two known singles it all just started to sound the same.
B.B. King
3/5
Usually cited as one of the three “Kings” for founding the blues sound, B.B. is in full swing on this record. And yet while this was a pleasant enough record to listen to, I don’t understand why this one in particular makes all the top lists. The more upbeat boogie woogie numbers were much more enjoyable than the slow paint drying 12-bar blues ones. B.B. doing B.B. Just not a style I will seek out nor return to.
Deep Purple
4/5
It’s funny what certain popular songs do to a band’s reputation…even though said song doesn’t really sound like the rest of the band’s catalog. Smoke on The Water is a perfect example of this. And upon hearing it as a kid and a million times since, it clearly did not provide an accurate description of this band’s talent. The rest of this album did though. Complete with blistering guitar work and really good tone on the drums for the time only made it that much more enjoyable. This was a really good rockin album and makes me regret that I did not give them that much ear time growing up. That will all change now.
Stevie Wonder
4/5
This was a commitment to write and produce and just amazing that Stevie did this all at the age of 24-25. It was also a commitment to listen to in full and probably my only complaint due to its length. But damn…hard to argue against its cultural and industry relevance. A genre-spanning work that has some cheesy moments but overall grooves its way into forever top lists for a reason.
Metallica
3/5
Albums such as this are quite epic and probably gain higher marks if heard while watching the show. Still, while way too long, it’s pretty impressive that this was 25 years ago and that Metallica found a way to fuse their style with a symphony. Not an easy task. Production and execution by the band could easily place this today with the same staying power.
Taylor Swift
3/5
I didn’t want to like this. Most likely because of her ubiquity. But this album shows that Tay Tay is a good songwriter and lyricist, and I overall enjoyed the listen. To me, this more quiet whispy airy minimalist style fits her voice and lyrical themes way better than the over produced stadium crap. And while I do like the production for the most part, there are too many times where the tricks overlap which IMO actually starts to homogenize the album as a whole taking away from each song’s individual sound. I am clearly a member of the Tortured Taylor Department who’s probably just tired of hearing about her everyday. But this is a nice album and an easy go-to for chillaxin.
Elis Regina
3/5
I can bossa my nova with the best of them and this one was an enjoyable listen. On the front end the sound seemed more traditional and immediately transported me to a dark sweaty club in 1960s Rio. But the second half of the album seemed to jump straight into smooth jazz sounds of the 70s and made me feel like I was listening to the Brazilian version of Soul Train. Not a bad thing when you have a voice such as hers…
The Temptations
3/5
I was expecting this to be much higher than it was. I love brevity when delivering a musical point. Eight songs coming in under 40 minutes is great. But when 12+ minutes of that are taken up by one overly long song? No thanks. Papa shoulda stopped that stone from rolling about six minutes in. The rest of the songs are ok. But overall this one went in too many directions for me.
DJ Shadow
2/5
I mean…sure…I guess. I can admire the thought process that goes into multi-level sampling, and all on a single device…but hard pressed to agree with its placement in this list.
Devendra Banhart
3/5
This was another nice surprise. Obviously not a style that many people flock to as further supported by pretty low sales. But so what. Good music is good music. And I particularly enjoyed some of his acoustic stylings which clearly show a better depth and command of the instrument. Overall an enjoyable listen.
Prince
4/5
You can definitely hear the seeds that would eventually become peak Purple Rain. But after the first three tracks which were bangers then and still hold bang status today, the rest of this one is just not quite as strong. Still rounding up to a 4 on innovation and staying power alone. 3.75/4.
Sinead O'Connor
4/5
While I’m a bigger fan of her debut The Lion and The Cobra, this album really represented her voice well and brought it to the forefront as a true instrument. It’s impossible to hear her voice and not be moved to some sort of emotion. There’s a nice variety of songs here, but I Am Stretched On Your Grave and The Last Day of Our Acquaintance were always my favorite tracks.
Beck
4/5
It’s interesting revisiting this album that incredibly is almost 30 years old. And yet if made today I’m convinced would fit right in line with the current music industry. Most likely because Beck has an incredible knack for fusing many genres into one unique style that in some respects cannot be defined or pigeonholed, and yet at the same time remains familiar. Throw in his quirky lyrics and tasteful production and you get really good records. A well deserved 4-spot most likely as I’m holding out hope for more Beck releases that I prefer that much more such as Sea Changes or Morning Phase.
Portishead
3/5
A lot of this sounded alike, but the vibes to chill out to were still abundant. Better than Massive Attack. Best when listening with headphones.
Aphex Twin
3/5
Background music to chill to. Interesting story about how it was all compiled from old cassette recordings. Seems to bridge the gap between the Kraftwerk era and what’s to come with modern techno bands. I can dig it here and there, but definitely situational sounds for situational moods.
Love
3/5
This was a pretty nice surprise. Mainly driven from the opening track which I recognized immediately due to the fact that it was covered by English punk rock band The Damned in 1987…which I owned on cassette. Overall this had a very 60s vibe with similar sounds to The Animals, The Kinks and early leanings into what would become that CA Laurel Canyon sound. The use of horns and strings was pretty interesting and the production quality was really a standout for the time.
Missy Elliott
3/5
There were a few standouts on this, but overall just not my jam. And maybe Ms. Elliott knew something at the time the rest of us didn’t by hilariously mentioning in her outro that we might not like the record or “maybe somebody shitted in your cornflakes.” Still…a decent bowl of cereal in the end.
Peter Gabriel
5/5
I’m betting this is gonna be one of the albums that spans the gamut of reviews across the team. So (literally)…I’ll just get it out of the way up front. A full 5 hands down. Most likely due to “where was I when this first came out” memories. Yes, some of the production is a bit dated (it was the 80s after all)…but the musicianship is next level. And the ability to fuse world music influences with pop sensibilities is well ahead of its time. Something Gabriel had a pulse on long before most artists. Throw in the feat of having 5 of the 9 songs landing on some charts, along with a pretty long legacy stay power and it’s hard to deny this unique record.
Arcade Fire
4/5
I remember buying this album as soon as it was released. And while a bit lengthy, it is a really good record. I think for me it’s the sonic implications and production of why I like it. There are a lot of similar sounds and techniques that even other bands at that time were utilizing (like Of Monsters And Men). Which seemed to be the feel of many indie artists then. But this one has more, and it’s the subtle ideas here and there that elevate it (the extra beat added to the front half of the verses on “Modern Man” is just great). Overall just a more “soft”, blended, round feel to it. An easy 4+ for me.
Bobby Womack
2/5
The number of collaborations on Bobby’s resume is incredibly impressive. But…even with only 8 songs on this album, I found it a slog to get through. Most likely b/c some of the songs were 6 plus minutes. Oof. What I found more head scratching is this was released in late ‘81/early ‘82 when disco tinged styles like this were already way dead. Yet, this album was still top of the R&B charts when the rest of the world had clearly moved into punk, indie, new wave. Who woulda thunk it? Not me.
Boards of Canada
2/5
I guess there’s a time and place for everything, but this album being included in the list is just silly. Sound loops and samples. No real structure to songs. And way too long.
The Coral
2/5
An album chalked full of contradictions. Late 60s psychedelia meets ska meets folk rock meets klezmer meets sea shanties. They sure do love their sea themes, but man…this coral should’ve remained at sea.
Creedence Clearwater Revival
5/5
I always forget just how many hit songs CCR had. And then this album pops up only to remind me more. A band who truly bucked the system at the time and found their own sound. Amazing the amount of good songs for such a short lived time together.
3/5
Muse is a band that fits a very mood-specific listening situation. And while I have fond memories of this album when it was released, i always felt the music in general was a bit overly dramatic in what appears as a constant striving to be cacophonous or epic. Add to that Bellamy’s overly dramatic vocal delivery and I think you have a band that slightly gets in their own way. Still, there are some really good songs here and even more cool rocking moments, but my preference would be to dial back the bombastic and add in some more subtle moments.
Neil Young
3/5
I can dig it. A good album title for doing that very thing: chillin’ on the beach. The front end of the album had some more interesting stuff. Backend was a bit slow for my taste, but still worth the listen. It’s nice to hear Young’s voice in a more folksy intimate vibe.
The White Stripes
3/5
An obvious change in style and production from the band’s previous efforts. And while I enjoyed the less gritty approach and interesting use of more varied instruments. it just didn’t quite grab me as much.
Beatles
5/5
George’s opening line count-in says it all: one, two, three, four. Just add one more.
Yes
3/5
I have distant memories of hearing “I’ve Seen All Good People” on the radio sandwiched between bands like Rush and Kansas in the late 70s, but I missed the Yes train altogether. Even by the time their ‘83 album 90125 came out with the ubiquitous “Owner Of A Lonely Heart”, I had moved on to punk and new wave. Still, this album had some really interesting sounds on it and excellent musicianship.
Fatboy Slim
3/5
I can dig the songs that made regular rotation and most likely will up my number here, but overall this was just too much of an assault on my senses. Too repetitive, a bit annoying and not my thing.
Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan
3/5
I found this quite enjoyable and oddly hypnotic. This dude only lived to the age of 48 but recorded 125+ albums. Pretty amazing. And more props to Peter Gabriel for the release of this album on his Realworld label. I can appreciate its inclusion in this list given it’s out of the norm world music.
Jeff Beck
4/5
How can you not dig this? I mean, blues ain’t my go-to bag…but with ‘ol Rod providing vocals it simply elevates it into a much higher realm. Beck has always been an under appreciated guitarist too. His licks are tasty and he knows how to serve the song. Rock n’ roll doesn’t have to be complicated when you have the firepower of these players.
Two days in a row of Rod is a good thing. Stay With Me is the obvious standout, but there were other high points too. And with Ron Wood moving to guitar duties from his bass position in the Jeff Beck band it clearly sets the stage for why he was a soon-to-be perfect fit for the Stones. With a resume and collab list too long to name, Ian McLagen on keys is an unsung hero on this too.
The Clash
5/5
When I first heard this record in the 80s I really only knew the band’s pure punk styles as heard in “White Riot” and “Police and Thieves” from earlier records. So I didn’t know what to except given the power of the opening title track alone. It would quickly become one of my top fave albums and has remained as such. Too many songs and styles to dissect here, but the legacy, influence and audacity of this record can never be touched.
Little Richard
5/5
If you build it, others will follow. And whether you like the music or not, or agree that much of it sounds alike is not important. When you create something that has downstream influential effects for so many future musicians…while lasting over a half century, it is no wonder you are given the title of the architect of rock n’ roll.
The Byrds
3/5
My most vivid memory of hearing “8 Miles High” took place while inside an MRI tube, and so the frenetic guitar didn’t exactly groove well with the machine pounding. Definitely made for an interesting experience. Still, there are some good songs here; just not as good as earlier efforts where McGuinn’s signature Rickenbacker seems much more prevalent. A nice surprise was hearing the Celt-folk trad number “Wild Mountain Thyme”, but overall just an ok listen.
LTJ Bukem
2/5
Music like this is fine and all if listening in the background, or if you want to get stuck in a constant loop of being in a David Lynch film…only to realize you’re never leaving. I just find it perplexing how many albums like this have made the list.
Marvin Gaye
4/5
Knowing the history of what inspired this record as well as the challenges faced with label heads to get it made makes it all the more interesting when listening. Ranked as the #1 album of all time on Rolling Stones 2020 “500 Best of” list I think is a bit of a stretch, but it does rank up there. Some of the extra long jams are probably the determining factor that drop it down for me.
Guns N' Roses
5/5
I was fortunate enough to catch these guys live in the summer of ‘88 as part of a 5-band lineup that included the Smithereens, Ziggy Marley, Iggy Pop and INXS. They were one year removed from this album’s release and were at their drama-filled dysfunctional peak. All of which was on full display during this show that ended with Axl kicking over the sound system floor monitors and walking off stage 45 minutes into their “support” set before headliners INXS took the stage. And even though this wasn’t my go-to listening choice at the time, I still recognized how good this album was, especially for a debut. I was always more of a fan of the deep cuts on this one too, particularly Mr. Brownstone and Rocket Queen.
The Cure
4/5
I love me some Cure. But even though this album seems to return the band back to the dreamy, droney, luscious sounds of their early early stuff…I can only be mopey for so long. Pictures of You and Lullaby are nice standouts and while I get its inclusion on the album for overall balance, Lovesong was so overplayed I’d probably be ok never hearing it again. The album is just a bit too long, and most likely gets a lower mark on the hope that their 1985 album “Head On The Door” makes the list and earns the top rating. 3.75/5
Super Furry Animals
2/5
A very appropriate title given the reasoning and direction the band chose to make this album. Just when I get hooked with some short n’ sweet power pop glam feels, the next song would be slow Syd Barrett-esque left field weirdness. From an artistic standpoint that is fine I guess, but from a listening experience side of things it was totally lacking cohesiveness. Too many genres and sounds competing, which ironically made me forget all of it.
Weather Report
1/5
I can recognize the talent of the players involved here. But damn…it felt like I was in a non-stop montage scene from a late 70s movie or at times trapped in the opening credits of an 80s sitcom that didn’t get renewed for a second season.
Nitty Gritty Dirt Band
5/5
This one I’m rating out of straight nostalgia and legacy influence. I was raised on this record and their next even better ‘74 album “Stars and Stripes Forever.” It goes w/o saying that without this album, so many artists that followed would not exist. The fusion of folk/rock/grass was very much against the grain for the times. To most folks, on the surface, this music might seem basic, but in fact it’s quite high level. Especially on the instrumentals. What’s more interesting is this was the first time many of the collaborators/guests were meeting each other and the band for the first time. As a result, they just pushed play and recorded most of the songs in 1-2 takes. Only negative is it’s a bit too long (it was a triple LP upon release). Fun trivia side note: as an avid banjo player Steve Martin would routinely showcase with this band in the 70s because his manager was Bill McEuen (producer of this record) and brother of Dirt Band banjo player John McEuen.
The Flaming Lips
4/5
It’s funny reading interviews surrounding this album’s release and how it was noted as not being a concept album. When it’s conceptual ideas front and center that have allowed this great band to sustain for so long. This is a really good record that holds together nicely due to conceptual cohesiveness.
Eminem
3/5
I can see the relevance of this one if I place myself in the year 2000 of its release. It hits like a wrecking ball. But nearly 25 years later, it doesn’t hold up near as well. I get it…angry much? Mr. Mathers is much better when he takes a less obvious or humorous approach to the lyrics as he does here and there. But the blatant misogynistic, homophonic and violent lyrics are tired and seem elementary nearly a quarter century later.
Aretha Franklin
4/5
I was a bit surprised at how most of the songs fall into the same slower tempo. But it doesn’t matter with a voice like Aretha’s. Preach.
Linkin Park
4/5
This album was a gut punch then, and surprisingly still has some solid moments 20+ years later. Most songs sound pretty similar in tone and feel, but their short n sweet length inevitably doesn’t really detract from an overall homogenized sound. Obvious standouts like the ubiquitous “In The End” put these guys in a class of their own unlike other cheesy nu metal acts like Limp Bizkit or Papa Roach, etc. Rating up due to ingenuity and influence.
Motörhead
4/5
I first saw Motörhead perform in 1984 on the British comedy show The Young Ones. Even then I always considered them more hard rock/punk rockers rather than the mislabelled heavy metal. Revisiting this album continues to confirm that. Short, no frills rock n roll songs made for the sole purpose of having fun, drinkin’, smokin’ and screwin’.
The Smiths
4/5
I imagine this album will be pretty divided amongst the group. Chalk this band up to one of ‘em that probably has to be experienced at the time. And in 1985 this band and album received heavy rotation in my high school angst ridden soundtrack. Was always a huge fan of the Smiths. Such a short-lived band that was producing some of the more unique non-synth pop sounds of the time. An ever bigger fan of Johnny Marr, a very underrated guitarist.
Iron Maiden
4/5
I was not familiar with much of the band’s material in the pre-Dickinson era. This was an overall enjoyable listen and I really liked the simpler basic production on it. The guitar work is pretty bad ass, and when coupled with melodic bass it really elevated this for me. A bit cheesy here and there, but it was of the time. And there are moments here that also hint at what the known powerhouse these guys would soon become.
Soft Machine
1/5
Shit Machine.
Coldplay
5/5
A strong follow up to the really good “Parachutes” debut. An exceptional album wrought full of emotion and urgency, this album dropped right in the midst of me experiencing my own rush of blood to the head in life at the time. It will always be linked to me because of that. The songs speak for themselves and became the catalyst for a new chapter. Revisiting the songs today confirms that the story happened the way it was supposed to.
Rush
4/5
There are only 88 more years until the Solar Federation takes control. Plenty of time for people to realize this album. A bold effort in 1976 from the band to make a concept album, but props to them for sticking with their guns even though their label was threatening to drop them. Listening front to back is almost a must in order to get the full experience. Only negative for me is Geddy’s macaw-like vocal delivery which seems extra squawky here, only to soften more in later albums.
Black Sabbath
4/5
This is a surprisingly kick ass album. Maybe not quite as great as their first two, but really good throughout. From face melter riffs to unique time signature switching to ballad feels on songs like Changes, the band really starts to spread their wings here into the sounds that they would eventually be known for. Rock n roll indeed.
Radiohead
4/5
An overall solid listen, that technically could’ve been called Kid B. Knives Out is the clear standout, and a number of other tracks have some interesting production. Definitely a few songs here that were unnecessary filler, which bring the cohesiveness down. Doesn’t make my top list of RH albums, but still good for the right mood.
Yeah Yeah Yeahs
4/5
A band that somehow got bypassed by me. Most likely during the time when the digital floodgate opened. This is good stuff. And certain moments even sound a little like Debbie Harry, Siouxsie and the Banshees peeking in with their own added edge, which is very cool. Depending on the day and my listening mood this might get a lower score, but today I’m rating up. Yes. Yes. Yes.
808 State
2/5
I’m sure I heard this in my techno club phase while attempting to be cool. But I forget. Unfortunately listening to it this many years later proved two things: I’m still not cool, and it still is mostly forgettable.
Travis
3/5
This album really only partially holds itself up thanks to the catchy song Why Does It Always Rain On Me? which I knew quite well. I was hoping the rest of the material would also standout, but unfortunately it didn’t. I mean it’s all fine, but I felt like I was listening to a Radiohead knock-off band filtered through the band Keane with a bit of Oasis peppered in. And then my hunch was proven when I saw the album was produced by Nigel Godrich, longtime collaborator/producer of Radiohead.
Moby
4/5
I remember buying this album based on hearing Porcelain and South Side. Over time I realized that I had heard many of the other tracks, only to learn that it was because of their appearance in other shows, commercials, etc. Reading the backstory of this album and the unprecedented licensing for the songs to gain listening attention is fascinating. All 18 songs licensed multiple times. Rating down due to its length. 3.5/4.
Arctic Monkeys
3/5
Whatever people say I am supposed to like, that’s what I’m not always gonna like as much. Good post-punk feel that was an overall enjoyable listen. But the songs just weren’t as distinct as I expected and they started to run together. I wouldn’t turn the dial if this came on again, but probably won’t be seeking it out much more either.
Spacemen 3
2/5
Just one long strange drug trip of drivel. I had hopes of liking this when the needle dropped, but no such luck. I’ll seek out my trance-like, guitar-driven, droney sounds elsewhere with bands like Galaxie 500.
Cream
3/5
With the first two tracks/hits I was expecting this to be better. But the cream starts to settle midway through and by the backend becomes a little stale. The fact that they recorded this in 3.5 days is pretty amazing, but not enough to help the cream rise to the top.
Big Star
3/5
As a pretty big fan of this band, this last effort of theirs just didn’t do it for me. And apparently didn’t do it for them either, as they essentially walked away from it and it wasn’t released until four years later. A very erratic group of songs with some bright spots here and there…it’s essentially an Alex Chilton solo record but very erratic, no doubt a direct reflection of the mounting life troubles the lead singer and songwriter was experiencing. For a better snapshot of the band’s legacy, check out their first two albums. As the star does shine a little bigger on those.
Red Hot Chili Peppers
4/5
I had peeled away from listening to the RHCP after Mother’s Milk and Blood, Sugar, Sex Magik, but this album overall holds up upon return listen. I was a bigger fan of their earlier stuff including Uplift Mofo Party Plan, and while this effort expanded their sound into the more commercial rock feel, rating down solely on over saturation and length. There’s def 4-5 songs on here that are filler material and if it had been presented as a solid 10-11 tracks probably would’ve upped my rating. 3.75/4.
Beastie Boys
3/5
I caught the Beasties on this tour in ‘94 and it was cool to see them playing live with real instruments, including having the drummer from Suicidal Tendencies backing them up. It furthered my respect for them and their abilities. The Sabotage video alone almost earns up ranking here. But while this album is a pretty wide gamut of styles and vocal numbers vs. instrumentals, it’s a commitment to get through in one fell swoop. I’ll always dig the boys, but will no doubt check my head at Paul’s Boutique as my go to album for them.
Dexys Midnight Runners
2/5
I think Dexy needs to keep searching. With an over the top exaggerated affected way of singing along with way too much horns just for the sake of being horny, this one fell flat for me and at times was slightly annoying. For a better representation of soul punk horn sound check out The Specials. “Come on Eileen! You can’t get here soon enough!”
Talking Heads
4/5
A strong debut. Art students making quirky and smart art rock. No doubt many bands like Violent Femmes, Weezer, Vampire Weekend, etc probably do not have as much success without these doors being kicked open by the Heads. I found myself wondering what’s next throughout this listen which is a good thing.
Cypress Hill
3/5
These dudes sure do like weed. Interesting sonic feels here and there that compare to some Beastie Boys sounds which makes sense given they ran some tours together. Most songs on this album seem to sound and feel alike though given their similar tempos, with some others thrown in for filler. An ok album, but not a revisit for me.
Keith Jarrett
3/5
Running through the fields of a non-stop montage scene from a movie…listening, hoping, reaching, searching for that special someone or something that left you…only to realize that it never really left in the first place. This must be what improv jazz is like.
Creedence Clearwater Revival
4/5
Gimme a cold Dixie beer and slap me on a hot sweaty porch in the deep South. Listening to this sure does make one believe that we were all born on the bayou.
Sonic Youth
4/5
This album really shows Sonic Youth coming into their own. It received regular rotation by me while I was DJ’ing on our college radio station. And seeing videos for songs like Dirty Boots on MTV’s 120 Minutes sure does take me back. The first 2/3 of the album is really good and then there’s some stuff on the backend that speaks more to earlier “experimental” SY stylings. Still, not enough to down rate for me due to some nice nostalgia.
N.E.R.D
2/5
At first, I thought this sure does sound like a band trying to emulate Prince and Lenny Kravitz, only to then see that two tracks feature Kravitz. Those songs probably keep it out of 1* territory. But as I paid more attention to the ridiculous elementary lyrics I thought this must be what Spinal Tap would sound like as rap band. Tough listen. N.O.P.E.
Sonic Youth
3/5
Pretty skeptical about this exercise now with this being the 4th album by SY to make the cut. It is pretty cool to see the incomparable Mike Watt in his post-Minuteman/pre-firehose days playing bass on a few tracks. And while you can hear seedlings here throughout that definitely lay foundations which other bands take from later, this effort doesn’t merit a placement in the 1001. Some moments are cool, but noise for noise sake is a bit much.
Stevie Wonder
4/5
The three hits remain solid standouts. And the rest of it was also a really good chill and groovy listen. The use of Moog/synth layerings to create orchestral fills and groove ambience is pretty revolutionary for the time in 1972, and just another level of how talented Stevie is. The fact that he played most instruments on this, was a major hand in the production…and all at the age of 22 is pretty amazing and equally hard to comprehend.
Pearl Jam
5/5
To quote the song “Jeremy”, this album continues to “hit me with a surprise left” every time I listen to it. While understandably linked to Nirvana due to release date proximity and being part of the Seattle sound blender, it really isn’t a grunge album at all. Just a really good hard rock sound that still presents new nugget discoveries each time listening. I always thought it was cool too that this time for the band also has some interesting Dallas/North Texas ties with drummers that joined them just after the Ten sessions: both Matt Chamberlain (New Bohemians) and Dave Abbruzzee (Course of Empire). 1991 was a major year for releases that also included Soundgarden, Dinosaur Jr. and Screaming Trees among so many others. In the end, seems kinda silly to even question Ten’s well-deserved top star rating given its influence and staying power.
Run-D.M.C.
4/5
I really liked the sonic simplicity of this. Totally forgot that three big hits were all on this. No doubt that bands like Beastie Boys, Public Enemy, NWA, etc. would not have reached their level of popularity and relevance without these guys. And the collaboration with Aerosmith stands as one of the most pivotal genre-mash up partnerships. This album and band broke down walls figuratively and literally (see video for Walk This Way) that continues today.
Digital Underground
2/5
I never thought I’d be saying this, but dayum…the sex lasted way too long. And still no climax. While I can somewhat appreciate the whimsical approach here, the overall listen was just simply dated, boring and utterly forgettable. The two charting songs are the only thing keeping this out of 1* rating.
The Rolling Stones
3/5
It’s hard for me to rate this higher than a 3. Even though Paint It Black and Under My Thumb are banger classics, and this was the first record of the band recording all original material, it would be tough giving it a 4 based solely on the hope/possibility that we’ll see other albums of theirs that are better. They sure do love their women. But, they sure don’t as well (hello Stupid Girl). I guess a stone stopped in its track equals a woman scorned.
Ray Charles
4/5
The link to listen originally brought me to a version with only 6 or so songs. After searching I was able to find that this was actually 2 separate albums recorded in 2 separate sessions, each totaling 12 songs for a total of 24 songs. Pretty incredible that the recording sessions for each were only 3 days apiece. And with an 18+ member orchestra too. Yes the orchestral and background singing is quite dated, and of that Lawrence Welk time period. But to hear the re-interpreting of these old C&W classics into a more jazz big band style is pretty cool, and never really tiresome…even with 24 songs. Timeless indeed. No doubt due to Ray’s voice which clearly drives the show here.
Buddy Holly & The Crickets
4/5
I swayed between a 4 and 5 on this one based on legacy alone. I mean the percussion on Not Fade Away was indeed just a shoebox. That alone is badass and so rock n roll. Keep in mind this album doesn’t even include other hits like Peggy Sue or Rave On which probably keeps it in 4* territory. Still, Holly made regular rotation by my parents in our house growing up, and I probably did not fully understand the downstream influence he had on rock n roll until I saw the Stones in ‘94 open with that same song Not Fade Away. For a really well-presented bio of him, check out the under radar 1978 movie The Buddy Holly Story that earned Gary Busey an Oscar nomination before he went crazy.
Peter Gabriel
3/5
An ambitious debut album clearly. Completely forgot that the standout Solsbury Hill went this far back. The musicianship is top notch, but other than the Hill single the rest of the album lacked cohesiveness given every song essentially exists in its own silo. At times I felt I was listening to Bowie run through a Danny Elfman blender which is not necessarily a bad thing. Just a little too avant-garde for me.
Kanye West
3/5
Probably the biggest challenge separating the art from the man when listening to Kanye. I didn’t want to like any of this, but ended up being surprised, probably due to the obvious shift away from gangsta style. A pretty strong debut. Rating down because of length, overuse of chipmunk pitch-shift vocals, and inclusion of unnecessary talking tracks that IMO actually take away from poignant messages being delivered in the actual songs.
The Zutons
3/5
I found this to be an overall enjoyable listen. Maybe better than their label mates the Coral. With vocals strikingly similar to Eric Burdon and Ray Davies, I kinda felt like they are a modern day version of The Animals and The Kinks with an edge. There’s a variety of styles going on here, but it still works.
Supergrass
4/5
I really liked this. Definitely recognized a few of the songs including the lead single. You can for sure hear influences like The Kinks and The Jam peeking through, and the production choices seem to complement the style too. Nothing contrived here. Just really good Brit-pop.
Duran Duran
4/5
Quintessential 80s right here. While I was never really a huge Duran fan, it was hard to ignore the impact of this record, let alone how much the songs were played. It skyrocketed them to fame and made them an early beacon in the MTV movement. The first four tracks alone merit its high rating, and even learning after reading the role keyboardist Nick Rhodes had in the writing and production, to me it was always bassist John Taylor who was the driver of many of their songs.
The Police
5/5
An excellent last album from a short-lived group of master class players. As an up and coming drummer at the time who was obsessed with Stewart Copeland, I of course owned this cassette. With the majority of the songs all playing a part in helping to define the 80s, it would be hard to rate down here. A few tracks for sure are not needed (the excruciating Mother), but Synchronicity I and II, Every Breath, King of Pain, Wrapped Around Your Finger, Murder By Numbers all are bangers. Definitely some world music seeds being planted here too of what would become Sting’s new solo life.
Arrested Development
3/5
I remember this circulating around campus during my college years. And while my go-to rap/hip hop of that time would’ve leaned more into the Beastie Boys or Public Enemy, I still like the overall vibes. A lot of this does kinda sound alike but I can appreciate the grooves and sampling selection while also recognizing the positive side of things they were promoting.
Roni Size
2/5
I can see this music being beneficial if you ever need to force hostages to talk. Or maybe in the background if white noise is not available. I can appreciate the drum n bass sub-genre, but this was simply too long and too repetitive.
Michael Jackson
5/5
I forgot how synth-driven this was. And while I prefer Off The Wall and Thriller wayyyy more, it’s hard to argue against a top rating for this given the strength and number of singles, not to mention its legacy alone. I was not a fan of Liberian Girl and honestly the production is a bit dated and cheesy sounding. But not enough to move the needle downward. Does it speak to the level of cheesy 80s because I remember Weird Al’s parody (“Fat”) more than the actual? Hard to say. Shamm-on, Ham-on, ham on whole wheat, alright!
Pulp
3/5
This was a perfectly fine listen. Moments here and there were enjoyable. I liked Common People and Something Changed. But outside of those most of this sounded pretty similar with not a lot of ear-turning standouts.
Wild Beasts
3/5
This album was included in the 2011 version of the 1001 book and I’d be surprised if it made later cuts. The music and arrangements across this album were interesting and at times unpredictable which is cool. Thankfully lead vocal duties were shared across two guys because that falsetto was not my bag, and at times simply too annoying to listen to.
Van Morrison
4/5
I was never really that much of a Van fan outside of his collaborations with The Chieftains and his contributions to the multi-artist Long Black Veil project. And growing up he was not really a go-to for me. But the chill timeless nature of this album can’t be denied. The first five tracks alone still survive this many years later. The backend, while still good, doesn’t have quite the punch. But…an overall peaceful easy feeling.
Goldie
1/5
More like time’s up. Gimme 30-45 minutes of this, then maybe. But 2 hours? Nope.
The Allman Brothers Band
3/5
I’ve always felt that when it comes to listening to the blues, you gotta get in and get out pretty quickly. Unfortunately this album is probably not a good litmus test for that. Live recordings are very hard to pull off and these guys do it well here. The band is tight and some parts where both guitarists are harmonizing are pretty solid. Those reasons probably earn it as 3-star for me. But damn…do we really need 20+ minute jams? Clearly a listen where if you leave to get a beer, only to return and realize you probably didn’t miss much.
Funkadelic
3/5
A very timely title. We need more groove in our lives these days and the funk factor on this one helps. I really dug this listen. The following lyric samples alone deserve a mention:
-“A musical bowel movement designed to rid you of all mental diarrhea”
-“the fear of being eaten by a sandwich”
-“ ice cream is the reality”
A good balance of Truth and Soul.
The Offspring
4/5
This is a really good record. Outside of the two radio hits I had forgotten how straight up punk this album is. The songs are tight and brief and to the point and the overall feel is a nice tough group of songs. And to think it was all done with a $20K budget is impressive. I also had no idea that these guys were on indie Epitaph Records for this release which makes it even better, seeing that so many great bands are associated with that label. From Bad Religion to The Vandals and Descendants to Social Distortion to Flogging Molly and Dropkick Murphys. A perfect fit at the time. And revisiting this album confirms it is still a perfect legacy fit today.
Sepultura
3/5
Not a genre that I ever really explored. And probably won’t after this listen. Incredible to read that these guys have sold 20 million records worldwide. But, admittedly, even though every song pretty much sounded alike, this was a decent listen due to some nice tempo shifts and slow downs and some occasional face-melting guitar work. The drumming deserves its own call out as it is pretty sick. I also recorded my fastest average pace bike ride after listening. Not coincidental. Arise indeed.
Dwight Yoakam
3/5
A really enjoyable listen. Always dig Dwight. And have always liked how he bucked the Nashville machine and carved his own path his own way. This is a strong 3+ rating. Interestingly enough my favorite tracks were the collaborations with Buck Owens and Maria McKee (of incredibly underrated Lone Justice fame).
The War On Drugs
4/5
I’ve always enjoyed this album ever since it was released. Over the last decade I found myself returning to it more than enough times to merit high ratings. And yet strangely it’s still hard to hum or distinguish the tracks. Except of course for “Burning” which is an obvious modern day steal of Rod Stewart’s “Young Turks.” Other influences are also obvious, from Dylan and Petty, to The Waterboys and Orbison. Overall the production is progressive, pleasant and chill, but unfortunately a bit too homogeneous. And yet I will probably still find myself returning to this as the mood calls since it is a really good record still.
Santana
4/5
I was surprised at how much I liked this. Normally my reaction to Santana is an immediate change of the dial which even includes the early 2000s duet with Matchbox Rob. But on this one, the Latin/world vibes carried me through. Interesting that so much of this was instrumental too which is very cool. Even more surprising is that this album went to No. 1 in the U.S. While I normally will seek my vibes of this nature with more trad groups like Sergio Mendes and Brasil 66, I can still dig this.
Basement Jaxx
2/5
I can dig me some EDM. And while this album is much more listenable than some of the prior ones in the genre, and especially some of the drum n bass ones…I find myself asking: are there really this many EDM/dance albums that I must hear before I die? I’m starting to think: no, there are not.
SAULT
3/5
(In)appropriately timed album given the state of the union. The act of writing protest songs or albums was a badge of honor back in the 60s/70s, and so it’s interesting to see this being done on this effort as recent as four years ago. I think the voice over parts really just acted as unnecessary filler to the songs themselves that still deliver the intended message. In the end it was just too long, but still a decent listen.
Burning Spear
3/5
I’d always known about Burning Spear, but never really experienced the music outside of a few tracks here and there. This is a solid album that deserves to be in the same conversation with Marley, Peter Tosh, Jimmy Cliff, etc.
Boston
5/5
Arena dad rock at its finest with all eight tracks charting. And the first 4 are simply classic. The backstory of how this album was made and recorded is fascinating. Timeless songs that still rock today, nearly 50 years later.
Nas
3/5
A solid debut from a young artist at the time. I can appreciate the album more based on brevity. Many artists in this genre think more is better. This album disproves that. I also liked the choice of of sampling which is subtle, yet helps tie together old world influences with the new. My only real complaint is the overall feel of each song, with every one feeling like it was written at the same tempo.
Leonard Cohen
4/5
This was a really cool yet haunting listen. And with his vocals mixed up front and center it made it all the more vivid, almost as if he’s sitting right beside you. A lot of similarities in tone and feel with Nick Cave, but the minimalistic arrangements made this even more stark. Will probably re-visit a lot more of his material.
Echo And The Bunnymen
3/5
I’m a huge Bunnymen fan and Ian McCulloch’s voice is arguably one of the more distinct ones out there. “The Cutter” and “Back of Love” are great songs and were on regular cassette rotations during high school. They help lead off a pretty strong first-6 on this album, but my fence-sitting was always due to the back 4 songs that I think are not as standout material. The backstory on the state of the band during this recording IMO is probably why the album is a bit imbalanced. A strong effort that just doesn’t reach what would soon be accomplished on their next two releases, 1984’s Ocean Rain and the self-titled from 1987.
The Zombies
4/5
I find it interesting that these guys are mostly ever referenced for the song “Time of Season”, when this album shows a much more deeply talented group. This was a great listen and came close to being a 5 for me. Strange how they get forgotten in the top band discussions of the late 60s when clearly they deserve residence alongside some of the bigger recordings of that time (Beatles, Beach Boys). Even more strange is after their short-lived career, there were copycat bands popping up claiming to be them. One of which included Dusty Hill and Frank Beard of the soon-to-be ZZ Top.
Simon & Garfunkel
3/5
I will always appreciate their level and ability to harmonize, and can for sure understand their placement in the industry at the time as presenting a style that was new and different. But outside the few tracks on here that were the more well-known, the rest of it didn’t do much for me. I always felt S&G walk a fine line between serious and somewhat cheesy. Probably an observation that is further supported by their music placements in both “The Graduate”, and Will Ferrell’s collapsing into the pool in “Old School.”
Fela Kuti
3/5
Aside from the tragedy, death and destruction experienced as the result of this album being made, it didn’t quite live up to the earlier live Fela album on this exercise.
The Cars
5/5
Power-pop synth rock at its finest. With 7 of the 9 songs charting and getting routine radio play it’s hard not to rate this all in. An incredibly strong debut that at the time had some saying it should’ve been called “The Cars: Greatest Hits” given the massive appeal. I’m sure this hits home more for those that grew up with these songs, but the strength of them still holds today. And who could forget the iconic scene in Fast Times at Ridgemont High with Phoebe Cates emerging from the pool with “Moving In Stereo” playing?
Johnny Cash
4/5
Although I’m a bigger fan of the At Folsom live album, this one was still enjoyable. Johnny’s effortless banter with the inmates was great, and the fact that he wrote and debuted a title song for this event was an even better touch. It was also this event that produced the now famous middle-finger photo which is just great.
Aerosmith
4/5
Revisiting this completely surprised me. Not just the hits, which arguably are not even their top ones, but some of the other tracks too. An overall fun listen, this is a really tough rockin’ album. Steven Tyler and Joe Perry are one of the best rocking duos, and that dynamic continues to shine here. At a time when the rock/hard rock/pop landscape was trying to define itself with bands like Def Leppard, Motley Crue, Poison, etc. Aerosmith separated themselves and continues to hold one of the top positions. Just good ol’ rock n roll.
Bruce Springsteen
4/5
Hearing the title track play regularly as kid definitely affects my review here. Not just b/c of nostalgia, but mainly due to it being a great song. I was surprised to hear how piano-driven the whole album was, and while the other seven songs have standout parts, the album probably rises in rating on the title track alone. I was shocked to read how long it took for the album to be completed, no doubt due to Bruce’s unwillingness to let the reigns go. But when you’re the boss…
Jurassic 5
4/5
This was a really nice surprise and provided a good backdrop to an otherwise dreary day. The simplicity throughout is great with not a lot of filler. The beats, clever sampling and lyrics really get a chance to standout as a result. Dig it.
The Black Crowes
4/5
I played the hell out of this album when it first came out. Listening to it again definitely made me shake my own money maker. With obvious comparisons to the Stones and Faces, it’s still a really strong debut with tons of bangers. A couple of non-hits were also pretty solid. Doesn’t quite make the top rating, but pretty darn close.
Holger Czukay
1/5
das ist echt beschissen!
U2
4/5
I remember how excited I was to get this CD in my first order of Columbia House, only to be somewhat confused upon first listen. This was not the U2 we were all used to. Which was the point I later learned. The industrial and metallic production is bleak, hard and desperate, very much like the songs themselves. The band was on the verge of breaking up at this point, and their decision to ditch the all-for-one sound of unity for which they were known, for a more introspective dark sound proved to be the reinvention they needed. It’s no Boy, War, Unforgettable Fire or Joshua Tree, but it’s a great album of a band who finally learned that their best stuff comes when they don’t take themselves quite so seriously.
Cocteau Twins
3/5
I always preferred the band’s earlier albums most likely due to them being more lyrically indecipherable, which left a little more to the imagination. And while this was a more straightforward direction in sound with admittedly somewhat dated production, it was still a pleasant chill listen.
Pixies
5/5
I always feel like I’ve just completed a successful workout after listening to this album. And that’s a good thing. There’s a lot to unpack here and I love how schizophrenic the record is. One music journalist called it “beautifully brutal”, which is a perfect description. This album was on regular rotation in college for me, ultimately culminating in my band even covering “Gigantic” which has always been one of my favorites by the band. Legacy, influence and unique style all play a part here. And how could you not like Where Is My Mind?
The Mothers Of Invention
2/5
Well…when you name your kids Dweezil and Moon Unit (Zappa), that pretty much sums it up. I can appreciate the sardonic approach here, but overall it falls flat. Ranking up from the bottom based on sheer bizarre factor.
Dexys Midnight Runners
3/5
Come on, Eileen…you gotta give me more than that. I was hopeful that this album would present more than the one hit wonder it probably is, but it came up just average. I do like how the band incorporated fiddle/strings into the lineup more. And with the horn section still solid, the songs have an upbeat ska feel…before ska was cool. All in all, an ok listen with very danceable numbers that unfortunately I’ve already forgotten.
Siouxsie And The Banshees
4/5
Man this is such a good album. And it was a great trip down memory lane. Spellbound and Arabian Knights were on routine play mix tapes for me back in the 80s, but the rest of the songs are great too. The bombastic drumming and guitar stylings are unconventional, so unique and make for a great pairing with Siouxsie’s vocal delivery. No doubt setting up a sound that remains all their own to this day.
Herbie Hancock
3/5
My only experience with Herbie growing up was his incessantly played 1983 hit “Rockit”, which was all over MTV. Interesting that this album pre-dates that by 10 years, but was clearly laying some new foundations for jazz fusion. There were even moments that had some prog feels, and yet it’s just jazz to me. But not the jazz I’d seek out. Fine to listen to, but nothing much else to grab onto.
Neil Young & Crazy Horse
4/5
With obvious highlights like Cinnamon Girl and Down By The River this feels like it should be top rated, but I can’t quite get there. Probably because of the few way too long jam tracks. Still, this deserves major credit knowing that the guys only knew each other for a few days before recording. And even more so because it was cut to tape live from the floor which really captures the feel of the songs.
John Coltrane
3/5
I mean…it’s jazz. It’s Coltrane. It’s a lot of next level improvisation. Supreme? Hard to say. Impressive still? Of course. But…well…it’s jazz.
Gene Clark
3/5
This was a really nice listen. Like most folks, I always thought Roger McGuinn was the main dude of the Byrds. Probably due to his signature jangly Rickenbacker sound. Come to find out, Gene was the main songwriter behind their classic hits. Sad that this album never gained much traction, because if you close your eyes the downstream influence is everywhere. From Tom Petty to Peter Buck and many in between. It all started with the Byrds. And that influence continues here.
The Libertines
3/5
Obvious influences from The Clash, The Kinks, The Jam and even The Sex Pistols. I can appreciate the lo-fi production as it honors the style. And even though the songs are short, they simply just aren’t memorable. This was a perfectly fine listen, but far from unique or great. I’ll take my post-punk from the original bands listed above any day over these guys.
Dolly Parton
5/5
Here she is indeed. Ten songs coming in under 30 minutes is all that’s needed to hit all the feels here. That voice. That pure sweetness. And all before the age of 25. Begs the question if I’m feeling this because of her recent resurgence? Or did Dolly never really go away at all…because the colors on that coat seem to shine more brightly today than ever before.
The Go-Go's
4/5
Distant memories of this album on repeat blaring down the hall from my sister’s room only prompted me to dive into it myself during the 80s. Not a go-to for me then, but outside of the two big hits songs like “Lust To Love”, “This Town”, and “Skidmarks On My Heart” were real standouts and showcase a style that definitely layed the post-punk new wave foundation for many other bands, female-driven or not. Just a really good pop punk vibe here.
Brian Eno
3/5
At least it was better than Here Come The Warm Jets. But when you credit some of the instruments as choppy organs, spasmodic percussion, club guitars, uncertain piano, restrained lead guitar and unnatural sounds…I think that says it all.
Ray Price
3/5
Who doesn’t like a little twang? This was a fine listen. But with every song clocking in at nearly the same tempo and vocal delivery, it was pretty repetitive. Making it sound a bit watered down for my country tastes.
Neil Young
3/5
I can appreciate the “just push play” approach with many of Neil’s recordings to capture the moment, but this one was just average. It definitely doesn’t belong in this list.
Simon & Garfunkel
5/5
Timeless sounds and timeless memories associated with this one. Ironically I never thought the ubiquitous title track was the strongest, but the whole album is stocked with really good songs. It sounds as fresh today as it did in 1970. Probably sits between a 4 and 5 for me, but rating up due to legacy.
Depeche Mode
3/5
As a much bigger fan of their earlier work, I had already moved away from DM by the time this album came out. Revisiting this surprisingly did not reveal any surprises. Outside of the really good “Strangelove”, the rest of it was pretty forgettable. And the end tracks were simply annoying filler. Ranking in the middle on the strength of Strangelove alone. 2.5/5
The Sonics
3/5
A fun listen. I can appreciate the basic two-track recording technique used, and can definitely see how this band has been cited as influencing bands like the White Stripes. But in the end the other guys are just better: gimme The Dave Clark Five, Chuck Berry, Little Richard and The Beatles over these lads.
Various Artists
4/5
Recognizing many of the songs from other holiday playlists over the years, I enjoyed hearing them all together. Still…it’s hard to rate this a 5 when you have the Elvis Christmas album lurking nearby.
LCD Soundsystem
4/5
The first 6 tracks are really good. Interesting production and clever sounds make for a non-repetitive listen. The back three lack the same feel and are therefore somewhat sleepy and non-engaging. Still, overall a pretty good record. 3.75/5
The Stooges
3/5
Seeing Iggy Pop live in ‘87 was an incredibly memorable show. Perhaps it was the memories of that show that set up some higher expectations here. I wanted to like this a bit more, but it just didn’t quite hit home for me. Interesting that this album was mixed three times at various moments both by Iggy himself and during the early years by Bowie. An easy 3 for influence.
Nick Drake
5/5
This album got me through many times in my twenties, but dayum does it still hit today. Harder even on some songs. In Drake’s brief career I’m sure his Pink Moon is probably the more recognized, but this is the one for me. Five sips left was all that remains in my whiskey glass after listening to this. Just a great debut record.
N.W.A.
4/5
The true and first anti-establishment punk rockers of the rap world. That alone merits high(er) ratings here. The front end of the album is hardcore right outta the gate, but admittedly the backend gets pretty sleepy due to repetition and just not quite having as strong of songs. Still a classic.
The Cure
3/5
I was surprised to see this one make the list. It’s a good listen and you can definitely hear the band moving into their more signature moody tortured sound, but there are better albums in their discography that deserve placement instead of this.
The Saints
3/5
I was a late bloomer to The Saints with their mid-80s albums All Fools Day and Prodigal Son which were more representative of their move into an R&B pop type sound. But this effort was still an enjoyable listen too. Very similar feel to bands like The Damned and even a little Generation X. It’s interesting that these Aussies don’t really get mentioned in the discussions involving early punk rock because they have moments that put them in the same school as The Clash and Sex Pistols.
Janelle Monáe
3/5
It’s really hard to cross pollinate genres without sounding forced. And to do it across a single album is even more difficult. That is the biggest strength here. Janelle does a great job interweaving genres that most likely don’t belong together by injecting some modern production and themes as connecting tie-ins throughout. The Fritz Lang Metropolis nod is cool, but outside of a few really good songs, this one is overall just too long and did not rise to the level I expected. Still, very impressive for someone in their mid 20s.
Public Enemy
4/5
In college there were 3 albums that were routinely played at every party we attended or hosted: Beastie Boys “Paul’s Boutique”, Jane’s Addiction “Nothing’s Shocking”, and Public Enemy “Fear of a Black Planet.” Pretty much sums it up for an album that made its way with little or no radio play, and took sampling to a whole other wall-of-sound level coupled with two of the most distinctive voices in the genre. 4.25/5
Deee-Lite
1/5
Maybe this album mattered in the dance music world at the time given its apparent ability to be inclusive, but it ruined all the parties I attended back in the day. And it almost ruined my day today after listening to it 30+ years later. The only groove in my heart is the one this crap album permanently took from it.
Kate Bush
4/5
When this cassette was circulating around our group of friends back in ‘89, I found it hard to grasp at such a young punk rock age. And re-listening today I’m still challenged by its complexity. This time in a good way. Her music has always defied any pigeonholing or genre-specific descriptions which is what makes it so special.
Muddy Waters
4/5
There’s not a lot of over-complication to unpack here. It’s the blues. Wash. Rinse. Drink. Repeat.
Dusty Springfield
3/5
Growing up I really didn’t know much about Dusty other than her duet with the Pet Shop Boys in ‘87. And then later as part of the crowd that got reintroduced to her when “Son of a Preacher Man” was included on the Pulp Fiction soundtrack. That track alone helps strengthen this listen. An overall really enjoyable album.
The Strokes
4/5
The album title prompts the question. And the answer is just a simple: yes. This really is it. Because sometimes in life you just need a dose of simple garage rock. Nothing more. A great album to answer the question.
Prince
4/5
I find it pretty ironic that the cover art features a full-on drum kit front and center, when real drums were really only played on 3-4 of the songs. And while I found the overuse of the drum machine along with the pitch shifted vocals somewhat annoying after awhile, the album is still pretty strong. It’s no Purple Rain like many journalists have written, but the talent across multi-genres and styles here can’t be ignored.
Stan Getz
4/5
I bossa’d my damn nova ass off on this one. The well known first track speaks for itself, but the subtle, soft, restrained feel of all the other songs too simply makes me want more. Just like the crowd responding to the girl from Ipanema walking by, when I dropped the needle on this one, I simply said…Ahhh!
Roxy Music
4/5
With Avalon and Siren being my favorite RM albums, this one is not far off. A very cool listen with a lot of stylistic stuff going which at the time was pushing the envelope in the glam/rock world for sure. And how can you not love the iconic album cover.
David Bowie
2/5
Mid (2.5/5)
Eagles
3/5
There’s no doubt that these guys wrote some pretty timeless hits, three of which appear here. And while this is a pretty strong debut for a band not together very long, the other seven tracks although average were pretty forgettable. Maybe if I dropped some peyote like they did during these sessions it might change my mind. Their 3 and 4-part harmonies should be recognized mostly here, along with their influence on the industry in general with helping to solidify that Laurel Canyon movement.
Circle Jerks
3/5
The soundtrack of my youth as I skateboarded all around the ditches of Dallas. And while I think their later efforts are better (Golden Shower of Hits from ‘83 and Wonderful from ‘85) this album still deserves some credit in the overall punk hardcore scene. Seeing them live again in 2024 as part of a triple bill that also featured The Descendants and The Adolescents was both cool…and somewhat sad, as they were just dialing it in while the Descendants didn’t miss a beat.
Adele
4/5
Not my cup of tea for go-to listening, but the talent here is undeniable. And at such a young age. Clearly she’s got the pipes to sing, and with at least three solid hits here…that combination alone deserves high marks.
Ryan Adams
4/5
Another round of having to separate the art from the artist. I was a fan of his since his days back in Whiskeytown, and his ability to release so much music at a prolific rate is astounding. Seeing him live in 2017 sold me on his songwriting abilities. And even though he’s such an asshole and accused sexual harasser, as much as I don’t want to admit it…this album, although too long, is still littered with good songs.
The Clash
5/5
Probably falling in line just behind London Calling, this is a great debut by the definitive British punk rock band. This original UK release definitely flows better and delivers a better punch than the US release of two years later where 5 songs were switched. The combination of genres and dynamics mixed with the balance of Strummer’s vocal snarl and Jones’ softer singing style is just great. It deserves placement right up there with other fellow Brit albums of the time from the likes of Elvis Costello and The Jam. Just a great album.
Neil Young
3/5
Another day. Another Neil album. While definitely better than “Tonight’s The Night”, the number of his albums being included in this list is bordering on silly.
Radiohead
4/5
Doesn’t quite rise to the level of In Rainbows where I think the band was at their sweet spot when it comes to electronic/non-rock compositions. And while it takes an about face from their previous album OK Computer, it still lands in the same territory of quality. And the production alone on this effort deserves its own rewards.
Astrud Gilberto
3/5
Listening to this I was immediately cast in a montage music scene of a late 60s B-movie, driving the coast, lounging on a beach having nothing to do with the movie at hand, only to have an impromptu meet-up with Austin Powers…just before the whole vibe gets wrecked by a marching band.
Louis Prima
4/5
Man this stuff is great. If you don’t jump, jive, wail and even scat a little while listening to this…well…you just ain’t human. Solid memories of watching him as King Louie in The Jungle Book also bring this home for me.
ZZ Top
4/5
It’s been a long time since I gave these dudes a full listen through. And although I came into the ZZ Top fold around the El Loco album, this one was a real cool listen. This is more than just 12-bar snooze blues. This is riff-driven dynamic stuff with some pepper on it. Pretty timeless.
Joni Mitchell
3/5
I’ve never really understood the hype around Joni Mitchell. I imagine it stems from her music being part of the larger folk movement hitting at the right moment during post-Vietnam times when the country needed a change. And while I always thought hearing a single Joni song here and there was pleasant enough, listening to an entire album really confirmed for me how much I don’t prefer her voice. So, I get why this album received such high praise. But outside of songs like “Raised on Robbery” and “Twisted” which are standout tracks, most of this just sounds alike.
Kate Bush
2/5
The Sensual World? Yes. Hounds of Love? Probably. This album? Not so much. I always dig the uncommercial and very experimental stuff. Impressive that she was producing this at such a young age too. But this one was just annoying to listen to. If I had a choice between this and other female driven art rock, I’m definitely choosing Bjork, Siouxsie and the Banshees, St. Vincent etc.
Steve Winwood
2/5
Outside of the opening track, the rest of this album is still caught up in 70s cheesy soft rock that is boring with songs that are way too long and drawn out. I never liked Winwood and was always a hard fast dial turn away whenever his stuff came on the radio or MTV. Even though I can appreciate the level of talent here given he played every instrument and engineered…and produced, I still don’t like it.
Hugh Masekela
2/5
I can flugel my horn with the best of them. But this album was just to long winded. Better than some of the jazz efforts already received here, but end of the day it’s just jazz to me.
Pink Floyd
4/5
Doesn’t quite rise to the level of Dark Side of the Moon or The Wall, but comes close. The title track alone helps push it there and to this day is simply timeless.
Van Halen
4/5
I was always more of a fan of the earlier VH I and VH II albums, but the global appeal of 1984 can’t be denied. Upon relistening I was surprised at how much synth there actually was on this album. And the fact that Jump, Panama and Hot For Teacher ruled the airwaves and were played incessantly on MTV is further testament. There are some nice prog nuggets here and there too, and the level of musicianship of both Eddie and Alex is just plain sick. Still, while this album shows a focus more on songwriting rather than just the hard rock power they were known for, a few of the songs don’t quite rise to meet the four hits.
Merle Haggard
4/5
An outlaw singing about being an outlaw. Love this stuff. When country music sounded like country music. And who could forget him sharing the billboard in ‘78 with fellow UK outlaws the Sex Pistols at Dallas’ famed Longhorn Ballroom.
Buzzcocks
4/5
Smart, dynamic, at times witty while also containing the right amount of social commentary…and just a kick ass rhythm section. It’s no wonder these guys were tour mates with the Clash. And you certainly don’t get other power pop/punk bands like the Plimsouls, Replacements or Hüsker Dü without these guys.
Drive Like Jehu
1/5
This was not good. It’s as if Primus, Rage Against The Machine and Offspring had a 3-way that did not end well.
Beastie Boys
5/5
To have the ability to incorporate samples from Led Zeppelin, Black Sabbath, CCR and Mr. Ed while featuring Slayer’s guitarist…pretty much says it all. A great debut and definitely one of the greatest rap albums of the 80s. Setting the stage for their next album that would be their masterpiece. 4.5/5.
Kate Bush
3/5
Doesn’t quite rate as high as The Sensual World, but definitely proves that her album The Dreaming did not need to be on this list. Continued props for such high production and songcrafting at such a young age (27). The back 7 plays more like the soundtrack to a stage production, which makes sense given the Irish arrangements were done by future Riverdance composer Bill Whelan. I think I’ve had my fill of Kate Bush for awhile.
Os Mutantes
2/5
This must be what it sounds like if you intended to drop acid listening to the Velvet Underground, but somehow ended up in a psychedelic Brazilian fever dream. A long strange trip indeed.
Jerry Lee Lewis
3/5
With only 8 of the 13 songs available to listen to (I’m assuming due to licensing or contractual reasons), it’s hard to give a full review. That being said, for 22 minutes I was reminded just how bombastic and rock n roll this guy was, only to be reminded how creepy he was by marrying his 13 year old cousin. This is still a good listen and the primitive recording methods of the time really do present a rough raw in-your-face experience.
The Pogues
5/5
This is not your grandfather’s Irish music, but yet it nods appropriately to a more traditional time. From the flat out bombastic to the somber and sweet. Shame on those who think this is a green-beer once a year St. Paddy’s Day excuse to be Irish. You’re missing the point. This shit hits hard right outta the punk rock gated teeth of Shane and crew, and lasts year ‘round. From trad tunes to raucous originals Shane’s eloquence and delivery is like no other, proving there is no other band like The Pogues. This album was a major graduation in the band’s sound and Shane’s lyrical abilities, only to be shown further on their next LP If I Should Fall From Grace With God. An amazing time for the band.
Red Hot Chili Peppers
4/5
It could be argued that the band hit their peak with this album. And while there’s lots of good tunes throughout, it’s just too long with at least 5 of them sounding alike. Shave it to 12 songs and it probably works its way into the top. From Uplift Mofo Party Plan to Mother’s Milk to this album: a solid triumvirate that clearly helped lead the 90s alternative movement.
Bob Marley & The Wailers
5/5
With so many albums to his credit I’m sure many people treat this like all the others. And while yes the overall style and vibe is a common thread throughout all of them, this one hits differently. The more mellow and laid back production helps this one rise to the top backed by a bevy of some of his strongest tunes. Add to this him surviving an assassination attempt during this time and it easily moves into some of his best work. A great listen.
Public Image Ltd.
1/5
People who are not familiar with PiL will no doubt never pursue more of their catalog after listening to this crap record. Which is really unfortunate since the band has some really good ones down the line and really came into form on Album (1986) and Happy? (1987). But this one only prompted me to say never mind PiL…here’s some bollocks!
Tom Tom Club
2/5
Always thought of these guys as a novelty kitschy act, and this album kinda confirms it. Maybe that was the point. A few good tracks here, but for the most part Tina and Chris were much better served when they were putting their energy into the Talking Heads.
Bruce Springsteen
3/5
I’ve always appreciated the love, hope, strength feel of Bruce’s stuff. I’ve just never really been a huge fan. This album has some nice surprises on it and his songwriting stands out. And I can also see how it became an unintended rallying cry for many folks right after 9/11. But much of it does sound alike. Shave off 3-4 songs and it might rise higher.
Garbage
3/5
The two radio hits are definitely the standouts here. It was a fun trip down memory lane, but listening front to back I was surprised at just how much all songs sounded alike. Not much else to say.
Derek & The Dominos
3/5
The album title should be called Layla…and other assorted way-to-long guitar jams that go on…and on…and…on…
Rating based on Layla alone. The rest is utterly forgettable.
The Smashing Pumpkins
4/5
This was such an ambitious undertaking for the band at the time. And although there are many songs to like, even outside of the ubiquitous hits…it’s just too long to earn the highest marks. Listening to it 30 years later, Corgan does seem extra whiney and self-indulgent but not enough to bring it down. Now I’m gonna go dust off their debut “Gish.”
Nitin Sawhney
3/5
What a strange yet interesting listen. Really liked the world-beat songs especially. And the use of space within the songs really helps deliver the message and is a nice nod to the production. This one left me wanting more only to confirm like one song said: that life is indeed like a puzzle yet to be pieced together.
Radiohead
3/5
I like this one a bit more now than when it was first released, but even though they brought some rock instrumentation back into the mix it still didn’t quite fully grab me. It’s impressive that they knocked this out over a brief two-week period as opposed to the years long process of earlier efforts, which confirms that they truly operate in the extremes. Other than that, it sounds…well…like Radiohead.
Buena Vista Social Club
3/5
A great album to transport you to another time and place.
The Verve
3/5
The ubiquitous opener is the obvious standout and I was amazed to learn how many copies this album sold for such a short-lived band. Some other good tracks here and there, but a bit repetitive throughout.
Pet Shop Boys
3/5
Wasn’t a huge fan of these guys back then, and not really one now. But I can appreciate their sound and influence within the 80s dance/pop world. Enough hits on this to keep it in the 3-star rating, and “It’s a Sin” still stands out this many years later.
Les Rythmes Digitales
1/5
I know. Let’s come up with a song title, throw some beats down, then proceed to repeat the song title throughout the song as essentially the only lyrics. Whatever.
Germs
3/5
A nostalgic listen for sure and I imagine its inclusion here is anchored by its year of release, no doubt having influence on yet-to-be other bands arriving a few years later. The band has stayed in relatively current conversations based on Pat Smear’s membership in Nirvana and Foo Fighters, but I’ll always find my hardcore punk preference in better bands like Minor Threat, Fugazi, Circle Jerks, 7 Seconds, etc.
Joy Division
3/5
Love of this album might not tear us apart, but it might make us take a break from each other for awhile. I get it. Without this band you don’t get the much more successful New Order. And while the production of this album is the real winner, as an overall listen it was just ok. Nothing really stood out. Much like my view I’ve always had of this band. Rating a bit up due to influence and the iconic album cover art.
Metallica
3/5
Man this was a tough one to rate. Obviously a landmark album that moved the band into stadium land, but geez…these guys needed to understand how to serve the song. Their abilities are clearly there, but you don’t need to pack all your tricks into every single song just to make overblown 8-minute facemelters. And while I would normally make this an easy 4, I’m purposely rating down for the egregious mixing that completely removed the bass from the mix. Not a great welcome to the band for newbie Jason Newstead, and a really thin result that takes away the bottom end punch that their sound requires.
5/5
I imagine this album (and band for that matter) will produce a wide variety of reviews and opinions, myself included even as a die hard U2 fan. Whether that be the age-old arguments of Bono taking himself just a bit too seriously, or the Edge really not being a great guitarist. But you gotta give it to these lads for truly creating a sound all their own that clearly had tidal wave downstream influences for so many other bands and the music industry in general. Still, I get it. If you didn’t grow up with them and therefore this album, it’s understandable if it doesn’t hit home. And while I personally prefer the previous four albums leading up to The Unforgettable Fire, the impact of this album can’t be denied. Some of their most anthemic songs. Seeing them perform it live front to back in 2017 only reinvigorated my teen years love of the band. IYKYK.
The Divine Comedy
2/5
Are we sure this isn’t Spinal Tap masquerading as a horse loving chamber pop group once they realized their idea for a rock opera Saucy Jack was a failed venture?
Bert Jansch
3/5
I was only distantly aware of Jansch as a member of Pentangle, but this solo stuff was a nice pleasant listen. A good chill change of pace.
Miles Davis
4/5
At first I wasn’t really into this. I know we’re supposed to like it, but I can only handle so many moments of saxophone cat-strangling solos. Still, as it went on it improved and I really liked the back three better. More mellow. “Blue In Green” and “Flamenco Sketches” were both solid, most importantly IMO due to the use of space and allowing the piano to feature more. Overall, the purposeful use of certain modes only in recording and improvising is some next level shit that hurts the head to think about. But impressive nonetheless. At the end of the day…this album remains well respected, but it is just jazz to me.
Amy Winehouse
3/5
Don’t get on Amy’s bad side if you’re a dude, ‘cause she’ll definitely be singing about all the ways you wronged her in her songs. Impressive that she was only 19 when recording this album. I can appreciate the fusion of old and new to make a modern jazz/pop/soul sound, but it all pretty much sounds alike outside of her cover of (There Is) No Greater Love. I was never a huge fan of her stuff most likely because of the clinched vocal delivery, but this was a fine listen. Most likely only making this list because she’s a member of the 27 Club.
Bob Dylan
3/5
Listening to Dylan for 45 minutes straight can be rough, but over 70 minutes for just 11 songs? C’mon man. Overall this “comeback” album is not bad. But many songs coming in at 7+ minutes is just too damn long. And that last song at 16+ minutes is just dumb droney nonsense. The real winner here is producer Daniel Lanois for making Dylan’s voice not so annoying and for providing an airy modern soundscape which rivals what he did two years prior on Emmylou’s “Wrecking Ball.”
Raekwon
3/5
I can appreciate the concept here, but in the end it all just runs together and is too long. And I guess if you’re ever stuck for lyrical creativity, just throw in yet another “know what I’m sayin?” and it’ll fill the void. Know what I’m sayin’?
Tangerine Dream
2/5
Listening to this I was the protagonist in an indie Euro film only to realize it was just a dream. And just like a dream, it was soothing yet utterly forgettable.
Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
3/5
You pretty much can always bank on knowing what yer gonna get with Nick & The Seeds: a strange odd rocking group of songs. This effort falls right in line with that. The biggest bummer unfortunately is that it’s just too long. For a shorter yet still odd journey, check out 1990’s The Good Son and Henry’s Dream.
Bruce Springsteen
4/5
This album was everywhere when it was released. And I mean everywhere. From constant radio play to non-stop MTV presence to mentions by government leaders praising the patriotism, only realizing later they missed the message entirely. Probably why I was never a huge fan of it. And while the overall impact of this was massive for Bruce and the record industry in general, it was not enough to convert me into liking the boss anymore than I already had at the time. This was a very big sounding record for a very big time in music, and sometimes I just wanna chill out to some of his tunes and not have to always reach for the stars with big anthemic numbers. Luckily there was enough on this one to do that. But not quite enough to make me give it top ratings.
Beatles
4/5
One of many albums in dad’s collection I grew up with, this one is pretty timeless. And while it would be easy to go 5-star on every Beatles album that makes this list, some albums can’t quite rise to the level of Rubber Soul and beyond. This is probably one of those. As the first full album of all originals, the songwriting for sure needs to be recognized, and there are some numbers that definitely show signs of the musical growth and creativity the band would soon be known for. A real enjoyable listen. 4.25/5.
The Slits
1/5
Talk about an album cover not aligning with the style of a band. As this played out, I was convinced this was the soundtrack to a bad stage play with the petulant character Veruca Salt from the original Willy Wonka singing.
Joni Mitchell
1/5
I took my own hegira after listening to this. A full on exodus from ever having to listen to Joni Mitchell again.
Aretha Franklin
5/5
This album demands R-E-S-P-E-C-T!
David Bowie
3/5
I bought this on vinyl when it was released. And while the production does lend itself to that medium, revisiting it in full still brings in a solid ranking. It’s not his best work but it does provide a really interesting listen, with each round revealing a little more each time.
John Martyn
2/5
An example of an album where I was continually hoping for something, but it just never arrived. Some interesting production here and there made for an ok listen, but in the end while hoping for folksy, I got cheesy new agey.
Pet Shop Boys
2/5
Very very ordinary. And very very not needed in the listing here. Fine for what it is, but not as pivotal as Actually.
The Auteurs
2/5
I turned it on. I tuned in. I dropped out. Decent sounds. Utterly forgettable.
The Cure
3/5
Clearly one of the biggest stones being laid in the goth rock road, but not their best. It’s a fine listen, but I’m holding out hope for their “Head On The Door” album to appear on this list.
Al Green
3/5
Kind of hard to top or follow the opening track. And although I can dig the more upbeat sounds, the rest just didn’t quite rise. All the songs on this effort are good, but were just not as memorable as the timeless title track. Maybe I’m being extra critical too, now knowing his history of routine physical abuse towards women. Damn. A hard case of trying to separate the art from the artist. Kinda taints the view I had of him and his music.
Baaba Maal
3/5
I dug this. Definitely a mood setter to be enjoyed in the right setting. And interesting to see how his music served as an influence for the soon-to-be formed and really good Afro Celt Sound System.
Emerson, Lake & Palmer
3/5
Didn’t like them then. And after listening to this…I still stand by that. The main reason: this is the type of pretentious prog rock that turns people who like cool prog rock off of prog rock. There is no doubt the level of musicianship and concepts being displayed here, and I will rate up because of that. But as one journalist wrote: “How do you spell pretentious? E-L-P.”
Finley Quaye
2/5
Some of this: sure it’s fine. I can appreciate the progressive spin on reggae, but this sucker was simply way too long. And its inclusion in this list is puzzling. There are way better overlooked reggae artists that (so far) have not been seen here.
Frank Zappa
3/5
A movie for your ears indeed. I really enjoyed a lot of this. Some of it was a bit over the top or left field, but that’s Zappa. Each song almost plays as its own soundtrack which depending on the setting can be a welcomed change.
OutKast
3/5
Just too damned long. There were elements here and there that were enjoyable and sometimes even whimsical, but the overkill on stupid interludes made it challenging to get into. Speakerborrre.
TV On The Radio
4/5
This is a band I haven’t always cared for, but I really enjoyed this one. Much better than their debut which appeared earlier in this exercise and in my opinion can be superseded by this one.
Youssou N'Dour
3/5
It was cool to see this pop up as I knew some of his work through his collaborations with Peter Gabriel on “In Your Eyes” and “Shaking The Tree” from the late 80s. I appreciated the style and overall spirit, but after the first track it kinda leveled off for me. Still an enjoyable listen.
Adam & The Ants
3/5
I remember liking this more then than I do now. Consistent feel and spirit throughout, but pretty repetitive sounding. Antmusic is a clear standout no doubt why it was a chosen single. Jolly Roger was a funny surprise that helped break it all up. Regardless, you gotta give it to Adam and fellow ants first creating a sound that is truly unique.
CHIC
4/5
Terry cloth shirt: check. Pocket comb: check. Speed skates: check. I definitely made out with a chick with this playing in the background at the roller rink. Or at least that’s what I thought. Probably more so me just hanging at the KISS pinball machine drinking a warm coke in a wax-laden cup.
The Mamas & The Papas
4/5
Wife swapping and dysfunction. All the proper recipes of the hippie generation to make a great record. The songs and harmonies on this speak for themselves. They are timeless and helped defined a new generation. But it’s hard to overlook the incestuous relationship John Phillips had with his daughter. And while that had yet to occur at the time of this album, he was one sick and twisted man.
Brian Eno
4/5
I was hesitant to rate positive on this one given the previous two Eno records already heard. But after listening was pleasantly surprised. A much more listenable record than other Eno selections on this exercise. And songs like King’s Lead Hat and Backwater have sounds and dynamics that reminded me of bands like XTC which is a good thing.
Judas Priest
4/5
An obvious foundation layer for so many bands that would soon come. It’s probably safe to say that bands like Metallica, Anthrax, etc. do not achieve their level of success without this album. I wavered between a 4 and 5, but either way this is just some good ‘ol rock n roll that shouldn’t be overthought as you reach for the dial to turn it up to 11.
The Byrds
3/5
The amount of band members and players that came and went (and came back again) to make this record rivals the amount of Spinal Tap drummers. The signature harmonies are still as timeless today, but there was less jangle and a slight overuse of studio effects. Still, this was a fine listen that it seems is probably more of an influential bridge to other artists than standing out on its own.
Steely Dan
3/5
As much as I don’t wanna admit this, I actually didn’t mind listening to a Steely Dan record. While two previous efforts of theirs in this exercise earned low ratings (1 and 2), this one was stronger. Maybe because it was their debut. Maybe because it was more on the rock side before they moved into soft snooze territory. Fueled by three radio regulars it definitely stands out.
Metallica
5/5
Normally I’d be rating a record down due to its length. But even though the back end of this gets a bit repetitive, this gets top billing. Its influence, accessibility, popularity, legacy and overall level of game-changing rockness can’t be denied. To quote lead guitarist Nigel Tufnel of Spinal Tap: “How much more black could it be? And the answer is none…none more black.”
A sure fire banger across the board.
Bob Dylan
3/5
Of all the albums by Dylan so far on this exercise, interestingly this one was the easiest to listen to front to back. I really liked the full band feel while also keeping his foot in the acoustic folk side. A better balance than some of his other works.
The Stooges
2/5
I really wanted to like this given the energy and just overall wackiness of Iggy after seeing him live. But outside of the first two tracks, the rest of it was kinda dumb and just seemed like one long jam or recorded rehearsal.
David Crosby
3/5
It’s a totally fine listen. But if I could only remember…why this was included in this exercise…
The Who
4/5
350 albums in and we finally get our first Who record. And on the same day they announce their farewell tour. Hmmm. I’ve always dug the Who. And what I do like about Tommy was it was written and recorded to be played live. Other mammoth amazing records around that time like Sgt Pepper’s or Pet Sounds stand out for other obvious reasons. But Tommy stands out for its live performance factor. And while forming a storyline centered around a deaf mute and blind man playing championship pinball seems thinly plausible and pretty silly, the quality of many of the songs survives due to the unique ability to stand out on their own while always serving as a connecting thread into the main storyline.
Carole King
5/5
Her catalog of hit songs written is truly astounding. And this album chock-full of ‘em is just a small sample. So many quality numbers here. Just a really great example of top notch songwriting, melody and hook. Timeless.
Country Joe & The Fish
2/5
I’m sure this was an important album for the time, but to me it was pretty boring. A few songs stood out, but overall just some snooze psychedelia. There were much better bands performing in this genre back then.
Elvis Costello & The Attractions
4/5
This one is in my top 5 Costello albums, but it just doesn’t rise to meet the level of his debut or Armed Forces or This Year’s Model. But the production on it is great. And the collision of styles even greater. Not to mention his lyricism, which has always been outstanding. I mean, c’mon. Can you ask for a more perfect opening?
“History repeats the old conceits
The glib replies, the same defeats
Keep your finger on important issues With crocodile tears and a pocketful of tissues”
System Of A Down
3/5
I’m sure there are some important messages being conveyed in those lyrics somewhere, but it’s hard to determine through the gargle screaming. Still…on a positive note, this one definitely helped me get more reps in at the gym while working out.
Bob Dylan
4/5
Definitely the best and most enjoyable of Dylan albums dealt here so far. And I think that’s due to the utter simplicity. Just a dude sitting on a stool strumming away with wavering tempos, string drags, and not perfect at all. Yet, ironically the quality lies in the imperfections. I think I also relate to this album on the strength of hearing so many of the songs being covered by other well respected artists. “Blowin In The Wind” (Peter, Paul and Mary), “Hard Rain…” (Edie Brickell featured in Oliver Stone’s Born on the 4th of July), “Don’t Think Twice (Mike Ness of Social Distortion). A really good listen.
Norah Jones
5/5
I’ve always had a soft spot for this record since it was released, and especially given her ties to North Texas. Normally I’d be rating down due to its length, but man…hard to argue with much of this as each song really does live on its own. An excellent example of less is more, with minimalist approach to instrumentation and production which allows air, space and breath to also exist as their own instruments. All wrapped up behind the really great vocal control of Norah. Just a really great record that bridges the gap between traditional and modern. 4.75/5
Solange
3/5
Does this album deserve a seat at the 1001 table? Not a bad listen, and it’s clear she’s trying to stylistically separate herself from big sis. Still, every song clocking in around the same tempo really helped this one become utterly forgettable.
Steely Dan
1/5
Countdown to never having to listen to a Steely Dan album ever again.
5…4…3…2…and 1.
Cornershop
2/5
I can appreciate the variety here, as there are a lot of styles colliding. And even though I recognized a few tracks, the overall lack of cohesion between the songs made for a messy listen. Almost as if the band couldn’t decide if they wanted to be an indie-pop band or a world beat trip-hop outfit.
Elvis Presley
5/5
As a major supporter of other African American artists, Elvis was known for citing the importance of black artists on the foundation of rock n roll while openly recording many of their songs to help promote a colorless world of music. And while majority of songs here were indeed written by other artists, I decided to go all in based on unique style all his own, not to mention legacy and influence.
Neil Young & Crazy Horse
4/5
I think this album makes it 6+ appearances in this exercise for Neil either as a soloist or as part of CSNY. That’s just silly and way overrated. Ironically it’s this album which does deserve to be here and definitely outshines some earlier efforts. One would think that the half acoustic/half electric model would be imbalanced, but the production and song choice really make it a well balanced listen. I really dug this. And it’s easy to see why bands like Nirvana and Pearl Jam have cited this record as a major influence.
Laura Nyro
2/5
Her three-octave vocal range and musical abilities are impressive, and the tempo shifts (albeit overused) helped make this a somewhat better listen. And no doubt you probably don’t get further strong female artists like Kate Bush, Tori Amos, Rickie Lee Jones, etc. without going through Laura Nyro first. Still, this was a pretty annoying listen. Rating slightly up due to ability and influence.
The Chemical Brothers
3/5
The right sound for the right setting. Mid-day lunchtime listening not advised to give it a fully honest and measured review. Still…I can dig this when my next rave comes a callin’.
Paul Weller
3/5
Many critics of Weller’s solo work seem to expect his stuff to sound like the days when he was in The Jam. Nope. And while I’m a rabid Jam fan and fair weather Style Council fan, I’m pretty hit or miss with Weller when it comes to his solo stuff. This album has a number of nice moments and the production is excellent. Still, it leaves me searching for more. Regardless, Weller remains one of the best songwriters and wistful lyricists out there today.
Pink Floyd
5/5
I put this up there with Dark Side of The Moon. Yes it’s long. Yes it’s overblown and pretentious in places. Yes it has a lot of really good songs that have stood alone for 40+ years on various radio stations. And yes…it’s still pretty awesome.
Tears For Fears
4/5
With four of the eight tracks being certified hits, this album was played everywhere all at once at all times during the latter half of the decade. And although I wasn’t a huge fan of the band then, I remember enjoying the album. And it still holds up.
Justin Timberlake
2/5
This is not a good album. Doesn’t really hold up 20+ years later. At some points I honestly thought I was listening to Flight of The Conchords doing a parody. And then I realized, no…this really was intended to be a serious album. Oof. Justifiably forgettable.
Lupe Fiasco
3/5
Better than a lot of the other crap-hop we’ve already been served throughout this exercise. Which is still not saying much. Kick, Push and Daydreamin were standouts, and overall production was tight in spots. But that 12-min outro is just bloviating b.s.
Iron Maiden
5/5
Simply put: this album is one big metal machine of face-melting awesomeness.
Fleetwood Mac
5/5
I grew up with this playing in my parents living room. So these songs still hit on so many levels. All of them strong. And listening through for the millionth time still presents some cool sonic surprises. One of the best selling albums of all time created under some of the most effed up inter-band drama, along with a lot of cocaine. For some extra behind the scenes looks into the drama I recommend reading the book “Making Rumours” by engineer Ken Caillat. Pretty fascinating.
The Dave Brubeck Quartet
4/5
I’ve always enjoyed this record. Even with the odd time signatures (5/4, 9/8, etc.), the album still has nice grooves, hooks and melodies to not get lost between the lines. This is my kind of jazz.
Elvis Costello
3/5
I like that on this album there was a recaptured energy and at times rawness with Elvis’ return to working with The Attractions, but this was a slog to get through. Only to learn that we’ll have six of his albums as part of this exercise. That’s just ridiculous. I will reserve my high marks for the ones who deserve it. This unfortunately is not one of them. And that’s coming from a die hard Costello fan.
JAY Z
3/5
Jay-Z’s Ego is a more fitting album title. Same old stuff with the same old braggadocio and often misogynistic lyrics. Every song coming in around the same tempo doesn’t help either. The duet with Eminem was a real top tune, but rating up as the true standout here is the production and clever choices of sampling.
The Beach Boys
3/5
It seems sacrilegious to rate this where I did just a day after Brian Wilson’s death, but it just didn’t quite reach the level of what I had hoped. It’s cool to other members performing their own songs, but the absence of Wilson during some of the production is apparent. And even more so, the presence of vocals. The gorgeous 3 and 4-part harmonies that the boys were known for are either absent or thin at best. Til I Die and the title track are really nice, but overall this was an interesting listen and probably the beginning of the end for the Pet Sounds era of the band and Wilson’s involvement.
Yes
3/5
A lot to digest with this one. The musicianship is obviously top notch, and for me the opener is probably still the most enjoyable. Plenty of other musical surprises peppered throughout, especially a very original and different take on America. I was wanting to like it more, but it just didn’t quite get there for me. It’s still quite good, just not the next level I was hoping for.
Johnny Cash
4/5
This was my first trip into the Cash live prison series, so I always liked it best. San Quinten is also good, but on personal taste this one is just a bit better. The banter between songs and even within songs makes it that much more interesting and authentic. A truly “live” record. And today IRL I learned that “25 Minutes to Go” was written by famed children’s author Shel Silverstein? Wow.
The Soft Boys
4/5
I really dug this. The influential effect it had on bands like REM, Television, Replacements is very apparent. Was always a Robyn Hitchcock fan. Makes perfect sense that Robyn Hitchcock and his new band were slated as openers on REM’s Green Tour in ‘88-89.
The La's
3/5
This was a very perplexing listen. The 60s-esque influences are obvious (Kinks, early Who, etc.) and they definitely started laying some foundation for 90s Brit-pop. Short, pleasant somewhat catchy songs that in the end just weren’t quite memorable. I wanted to like this more, but outside of the obvious hit…it just left me hanging.
3/5
Another hopeful album that IMO falls a bit short. It was enjoyable to listen to and there are some cool moments here and there that clearly exhibit the musicianship. But, I found myself during each song hoping for a next-level that just never came. Its inclusion here is a bit of a head scratcher as there are other bands in the style and genre that are better and more memorable.
Sade
3/5
Man, this one takes me back to high school. Yes it’s dated now with a pretty high cheese factor. Yes I owned it then, and yes I probably thought dropping the needle would make the chicks dig me. Note: that didn’t work. Once I realized that, I probably retreated to my room and played some sad Smiths records.
Soundgarden
4/5
Impossible to think of the 90s without this album or band. Admittedly I did not give this album a fair listen when it was released, most likely due to the over and over and overplaying of Black Hole Sun. I mean that song was everywhere. Upon revisiting, I found the album pretty darn awesome. Great musicianship, interesting tunings, and even more incredible lead vocal delivery. As a drummer, I especially dig the odd time signatures throughout. Their ability to play an effed up time sig all while still maintaining groove is pretty hard to do. The biggest negative I have is overall length. Shave 3-4 songs and this probably becomes a 5er.
Rod Stewart
3/5
This was a perfectly fine listen. Rod doing his thing with raspy swagger. Nothing hugely stood out, but you can tell seeds were being planted for his next effort…the much better Every Picture Tells a Story. Rod is good and I’ll never turn the dial when he struts on in.
The Lemonheads
4/5
Man, this one still holds up. I played it routinely on my college radio program throughout ‘92-93, and it sits up there with Westerberg, Soul Asylum, and similar as one of the more prominent albums ushering in the alt indie rock scene. It didn’t hurt that pretty boy Dando was voted into People’s “50 Most Beautiful” list. No doubt contributing to his cameo in 1994’s “Reality Bites” film. I was fan of Evan and crew since 1989’s album Lick that featured a really good cover of Suzanne Vega’s song “Luka”, and was lucky enough to see them at their sweet n salty candy peak a year after this release on the Come On Feel… tour. Will always have a soft spot for these guys.
Jeff Buckley
3/5
This was a very difficult and thick album to get through. It’s genre-defying and incorporates a lot of styles. Sometimes simple and stripped down, and at other times pretty bombastic. And while not necessarily my cup of tea I can appreciate the depth here. Sad that we’ll never know what else he was capable of given his untimely death.
Jimi Hendrix
4/5
Impressive that this album was released just seven months after their debut. While more expansive in sound and songwriting, some of the production techniques are overused and therefore distracting at times. Way too much panning. But, it makes sense given the times when the studio was becoming an instrument itself and multi-tracking was a whole new world. Still a solid listen overall.
The Pogues
5/5
I snuck into a club in Dallas to see this tour and never looked back. Seeing them live that night confirmed for me the brash brilliance of this band. From the title track to Turkish Song of The Damned to Fairytale of New York (which to this day remains the best Xmas song ever), this effort really sees the band at their peak firing on all cylinders. The Pogues have the amazing ability to kick you in the balls, help you back up then hand you a pint and tell you how much they love ya. Poignant lyrics. Bombastic jigs n reels. Poetic frontman. Lots of craic. Sláinte Shane! I got the next round…
Fever Ray
3/5
The comparison to artists like Kate Bush are somewhat merited, and the minimalism should be mentioned too…but overall this one leaves a lot to be desired. Pretty good in some spots. Pretty bad in others. Pretty unforgettable. Pretty average. Pretty sure it doesn’t need to be included in this list.
Living Colour
3/5
I remember this cassette circulating in high school. It seemed to have come from left field, and at the time was a breath of fresh air. A different sound for sure. And while the intentions were good with the spirit and messages being delivered (especially songs like Open Letter and Which Way to America), outside of the banger Cult of Personality…it really doesn’t hold up. Revisiting this many years later I was pretty surprised at how much 80s cheese was here surprisingly. Rating up based on musical ability and the ubiquitous Cult of hit.
FKA twigs
3/5
Apparently there were 10 separate songs on this, but in the end it all just sounded like one long stream of avant-pop. I guess this serves the right mood at the right time, and it wasn’t bad to listen to per se. I’m just not really sure what else I can say since I don’t remember a thing about it.
Count Basie & His Orchestra
4/5
I really enjoyed this. Most likely due to its heavy swing and big-band sounds instead of just plain old jazz. A great soother with cocktail in hand.
Elvis Costello
4/5
I imagine Elvis and this album are divided amongst many folks. Love him or hate him, this album deserves to be in the discussion as one of the more enduring debut albums. The songwriting, lyrics and fusion of so many genres is just great. Hits that became hits later. And all at the age of 22. Add to that the fact that it was recorded in just six 4-hour sessions with the entire thing mixed in just five hours! Brilliant. Not quite 5-stars, but that’s only because I’m holding out for his second and third albums which I’m assuming will be in the cue soon. 4.5/5
Talking Heads
3/5
I’ve always appreciated the Heads. Their attention to artistic detail from the music down to the cover art…and everything in between has always been top notch. They truly are students of art. But from a musical side, their stuff was always hit or miss with me. You can very much tell that Eno produced this album too given the sound of things. Outside of a few songs though, much of it didn’t quite hit for me. I can appreciate it. I just don’t know if I like it. The album is still deserving of a 3 based on influence alone.
The Prodigy
2/5
Music to help me get through my workout a little faster. Other than that…rave on I guess.
CHIC
3/5
Not quite as good as C’est Chic, but still serves its disco-y purpose. Long jams that no doubt were written for all the sweaty studio 54s and roller rinks worldwide. Death before disco. And I suppose if I were on my deathbed, and was forced to choose a disco album to go out on…I wouldn’t necessarily complain if it was this one.
The Who
4/5
This was a really cool listen and a very strong debut. It had been a long time since I first heard this, and revisiting didn’t disappoint. The rough raw stripped down feel made it even more special. Very punk rock for the time. Right alongside fellow Brits like the Animals and the Stones. Such a stark difference from what they would soon be churning out just 5-6 years later with Tommy and Who’s Next, only adding to their reputation as one of the most influential rock n roll bands.
The Velvet Underground
3/5
It’s pretty amazing to think that this album is from 1969. The sounds, production and overall feel could have it being easily mistaken for an indie band of the last few decades. Pale Blue Eyes continues to be a top track (check out REM’s version on their 1986 b-side and outtake compilation Dead Letter Office). But there were other chill surprises too. That being said, an automatic downgrade due to the 9-minute attempted artsy drivel Murder Mystery track.
Eagles
4/5
I was always a bigger fan of earlier Eagles material when Bernie Leadon was in the band, but the magnitude of this album can’t be denied. The title track alone merits solid ranking, but with three other hit tracks also onboard, I’m begrudgingly pushing it into higher territory. Maybe because my 7-year old self hearing these songs everywhere as a kid wanted my current self to like this more. The front half of the album is more rocking, but I was surprised to hear such banal dad rock on the latter half. The Eagles abide…
AC/DC
5/5
I was gonna hold back on this one based on the obvious top rating of the next album. But then I shot that down in flames and realized you really have to treat AC/DC in two chapters: the Bon era and the Brian era. And when you do that, this powerhouse album shows the band firing on all cylinders at the height of Bon’s time. Let there be rock indeed!
X-Ray Spex
3/5
A surprisingly enjoyable listen. This was a band I never paid much attention to in my teen punk days, but I kinda regret that now. Definitely hearing some feels that remind me of early Blondie, Siouxsie, and X all mixed in Sex Pistols blender. And although short-lived, they clearly had downstream influence on the riot grrrl movement of the 90s and arguably even some ska stuff of the 80s thanks to the sax inclusion. I usually run the other direction when a saxophone gets pulled out, but I think it works here. It’s quirky, dirty, used appropriately and far from perfect. Which is to say it’s perfect for punk rock.
The National
3/5
I can respect the hell out of these guys for continuing to release albums on their own terms and their own sound. I just never really understood the hype. It’s a totally fine listen that probably hits better in the right mood. But for moody, ambient, melodramatic indie pop-oriented sounds I’ll probably push play on bands like Nick Cave and War On Drugs that do it better.
Beth Orton
2/5
I had high hopes going into this one. Especially seeing that a few tracks were produced by Ben Watt from Everything But The Girl. Man was I wrong. I really wanted to like this. I just couldn’t get past the vocal delivery and overall cheesy feel that seems quite dated now.
Ryan Adams
3/5
A pretty robust effort for a solo debut. Good variety, but a little long winded with 15 tracks. Too bad 20 years later it would be widely known what an abusive a-hole he was/is, because he is a good songwriter. Too Be Young and Come Pick Me Up are nice standouts, but the rest is kinda average.
Gang Of Four
4/5
Post-punk goodness at its best. A great debut from an often overlooked band. Smart lyrics coupled with sharp edgy sounds. Pouring an extra one out here in honor of bass player Dave Allen who just passed away in April 2025.
Doves
3/5
I guess this is what it sounds like when doves cry. And while this was a pretty ambitious effort with some of the songs being too lengthy, it still didn’t detract from the overall vibes and was a very cool listen. Definitely a mood setter that probably sounds a bit better during late night hours with a cocktail in hand.
Chicago
1/5
I had really high hopes for this one. Then I realized it contained a number of songs that I hated as a kid. Ones that I would immediately dial-change in hopes of hearing something even remotely better. I didn’t like it then. And I don’t like it now. It might even suck more than Steely Dan. Long winded and bloviated boring crap.
Aerosmith
4/5
This is the album where you really start to hear the band forming that rock n roll swagger that they’d always be known for. The title track, Sweet Emotion and Walk This Way are timeless and give it near top rating. And other tracks should not be ignored either. There’s good variety throughout. A solid rockin’ good album.
The Monks
3/5
This was a hilarious and pleasant surprise that at time was comically enjoyable. And the story of how these guys formed is even more fascinating. Drums with no cymbals. Six-string banjo in place of a rhythm guitar. Gotta love it. Nothing more punk rock than that. And all taking place in 1966. It’s as if The Animals, Paul Revere and the Raiders, Iggy Pop and The Kinks had a future baby and named him Johnny WhiteStripeHiveStrokes.
Queens Of The Stone Age
2/5
This is some pretty generic power chord middle of the road rock. It’s not bad. But it definitely did not standout as memorable. There were some interesting drum dynamics on songs, but the guitar work and vocal delivery is pretty bland. A band trying to be like other bands that are better.
Grateful Dead
3/5
Those who dig too deep into the criticisms of whether this band is highly overrated are probably missing the point. No doubt these guys became more cemented as a cultural band (brand) rather than an amazingly musical one, but this studio effort still shows a skilled band with solid songs. And the fact that this album was in regular rotation during college years right alongside artists like Jane’s Addiction and Beastie Boys supports that theory. Yeah, you can take drugs watching any band…but if you tune in, turn on and drop out at a Dead show chances are you’re gonna have a much more memorable experience.
3/5
This was not a great sounding record, but that’s not really the point. And while I think others like the Stooges and Velvet Underground were more interesting, I can understand its placement in the proto-punk pantheon due to its unabashed attitude and power. No doubt it became a template for future punk bands.
Nick Drake
4/5
I remember being pretty stunned when I first saw the 1999 VW commercial featuring Pink Moon. Not sure that’s where Nick envisioned his music, but from an artistry standpoint it did kinda work. All that to say that I’ve always felt his work to be timeless. And beautiful. And vulnerable. And mysterious. All at the same time. To know that this album was recorded in just two late night sessions gives it even more credit. I only wish it were longer.
The Monkees
3/5
In high school me and my friends jumped the fence and snuck in to see The Monkees as part of their 20-year anniversary tour. We got caught by security who ended up letting us stay. We left after three songs because the band sucked. It was a far cry from “I’m a Believer” and “Last Train to Clarksville.” This album was fine. The songs are ok, with the NeSmith-penned ones holding up better.
The Stooges
2/5
While I’ve always liked some of The Stooges material, I’m realizing that I was probably more so liking the idea of them. Their pre-punk influence on so many bands is of course important, but this album clearly does not deserve a place in the list. It was a noble effort to capture the band in their element, but I’m betting these songs presented themselves much better in a live setting with Iggy struttin’ and sluttin’ around. With only 7 songs, most of them come off as extended jams, and the last one attempting to be hip and cool just comes off as annoying.
Dr. Octagon
1/5
I’m betting this album wins out for the most mentions of the word rectum. While you ponder that, I’m gonna go dial 1-800-DOO DOO like Dr. O encourages, because that’s what this is: complete and utter shite.
Emmylou Harris
4/5
An angelic voice that simultaneously comforts you while also giving you something to hope for that might not even be realized yet. Just a timeless singer. And many of the collaborating players here like Linda Ronstadt, Bernie Leadon (banjo/Eagles), Byron Berline (fiddle) and Herb Pedersen (The Dillards) should also be recognized as they no doubt help elevate this record.
Todd Rundgren
3/5
It’s as if Frank Zappa and Salvador Dali decided to make a record with Rundgren turning all the knobs in a hallucinogenic drug fantasy world. Just a weird listen overall. And while the creativity here is pretty amazing and should be recognized, it’s not something I’ll return to.
The Dictators
3/5
Categorizing this as punk rock is a far stretch. More like quirky comedic power pop. I liked moments of this and can appreciate the lighthearted often silly approach here. Does this album deserve a spot here in the list? Doubtful. But it was a nice reprieve from some of the other crap.
Silver Jews
3/5
I knew David Berman from a distance, which is to say my sister was friends with him and other artists in the late 80s/early 90s growing up in Dallas. I was only familiar with earlier Silver Jews albums, and so I probably lean more in that direction. But this record still delivers on enough tracks. Overall the music is more of a background to his evocative lyrics and storytelling.
PJ Harvey
3/5
I imagine my younger angst-ridden 90s self would like this more, but I just never quite understood the appeal of PJ. I’ve given her catalog a fair amount of listen and it never hit home for me. This might be her 3rd album received on this exercise and again nothing really stands out. I know this album particularly received a lot of praise and is probably the best representation of music style being portrayed as it should due to the raw edgy production style of Steve Albini. And I can also appreciate the band’s musical abilities mixed with unpredictable time signatures, arrangements, etc. But in the end, it’s not enough for me to revisit.
Arcade Fire
4/5
It’s pretty impressive that this was just their second release. The instrumentation and production are really cool and quite interesting, but I found that most of the tracks followed a bombastic baroque pop feel which at times is a little thick and overwhelming. And while I prefer The Suburbs, the efforts here have to be recognized and no doubt will present new sounds and depth each time you listen.
Big Black
2/5
This was a pretty polarizing album when it was being passed around in high school. You either liked or hated it. I fell into the latter category. Even as a self-proclaimed punk rocker I found the lyrics too off putting. But I can appreciate its musical influence and lean-in to other bands like Ministry or even NIN. It makes perfect sense that Albini would make the pivot from harsh raw edged playing into harsh raw edged production that would become his known style.
Stephen Stills
3/5
There are so many albums in the CSNY world of both group and solo efforts that a lot of it starts to sound alike. This one has those moments, but there is a nice variety. It also has some nice standouts, especially the folk-fiddle driven numbers. In the end though, it’s the overall length that marks this one down for me with the backend really dragging.
Pere Ubu
1/5
After the first few tracks I can definitely see how this band might’ve had influential effects on other artists like REM, Hüsker Dü, etc. And I had some hope that this might be a cool listen. But alas, by the time track three rolled around with random cat juggling noises…I realized it was another example of an album that should not be on this list. I can appreciate weird bands doing strange stuff, but this is just dumb noise.
Paul Revere & The Raiders
3/5
I put these guys up there with similar bands of the time like The Animals, Dave Clark 5, etc. thanks to my dad’s record collection. Any Friday night I might hear their other hits like “Just Like Me” or “Hungry” blasted down the hallway. This was a solid listen as well with Kicks and Stepping Stone as obvious standouts. Outside of the last track which was just silly, the rest of the songs made for a good listen too. A sound truly indicative of the times.
TLC
3/5
It’s probably a fair question to ask whether TLC were more impactful with their effect on pop culture in general rather than the music industry itself. But, the success and ubiquitous presence of this record can’t be denied. I mean there’s nothing too deep going on here. Lots of sexy time lyrics and mid-tempo grooves that I’d probably rate higher if the interludes were shaved down. Still, you gotta appreciate or at least chuckle at lyrics like this from Red Light Special: “I’ll let you go further if you take the southern route.”
Syd Barrett
3/5
The inclusion of some of the songs with stops and starts is interesting. And then it kinda made sense reading the up and down backstory of the making of the album along with Syd’s demise. These were probably the best takes captured. I actually enjoyed this album quite a bit, and it was more put together than many reviews were reporting. I had no idea how much Syd was the main creative driver of the early Floyd. Pretty sad that his musical abilities faded away into a life of drugs, depression and…gardening.
Björk
3/5
I tend to shy away from Björk songs. But this was actually a nice surprise. Yes there are moments featuring her love it-or-hate it vocal delivery, but overall compared to other albums of hers…it was a really interesting listen that I will for sure re-visit. The use of natural sounds in the real world to create beats and ambience was also very cool.
William Orbit
2/5
The amount of albums in this style and genre being included in the list is staggering. And it seems that the more that are added, the more my ability to discern differences between them decreases. Who’s to say this bleep is better than that bloop, or this ambient chill is better than that soundscapey feel? This album continues to tick all those boxes. Background music that in the end is…well…fine.
Funkadelic
3/5
I can funk my delic like the best of ‘em. And this album was a fun listen especially with the middle finger to the industry right outta the gate with a 10-minute guitar solo. The tough sounding Super Stupid could probably be renamed: Here Lenny Kravitz, hold my beer. But the last track? That’s what bowel moves this one down a notch.
Goldfrapp
3/5
I enjoyed a lot of this. Felt like I was the understudy listening to the soundtrack of a James Bond film. It was definitely more pleasant than some of the other ambient sounding albums on this exercise.
Waylon Jennings
3/5
This was a fun listen, and a nice departure from some of the more recent albums here. Just good ‘ol boys singing good ‘ol outlaw country songs.
Paul Simon
3/5
This seemed like an album that bridged his signature softer 70s sound with what would eventually become Graceland. At times Simon’s music can be simple and literal, and at other times pretty complex and challenging. He writes some of the most beautiful melodies too. This album has all those moments, along with one of the dumbest songs ever written in Cars are Cars. At times the production is way cheesy with 80s techniques, but it’s still a fine listen.
Fiona Apple
4/5
This at times seemed like one long stream of consciousness but I liked it. Interesting use of unconventional percussion throughout which ironically overshadows the piano that Apple is known for. Rating it higher as a drummer myself and as a nod to my childhood friend who produced it.
Jacques Brel
3/5
Another nice surprise and reason why I enjoy this exercise. Definitely a record that I would’ve not discovered otherwise, and an example of one that thrives due to the atmosphere being captured live. I just don’t think it would’ve translated as well in the studio. Makes me wanna open a bottle of wine and go listen to my Serge Gainsbourg records.
Big Star
4/5
Unfortunately this album (and band) suffers from the fact that it was not discovered until later bands who were much more successful cite it (and them) as a major influence. It’s probably safe to say that you don’t have Tom Petty, R.E.M., Cheap Trick, etc. without this record. Early power pop at its finest from such a short-lived band with a nice balance of tougher more rocking Chris Bell numbers and the softer more beautiful Chilton songs. As the great Paul Westerberg of Replacements fame writes in the aptly titled song “Alex Chilton”:
…”I never travel too far…without a little Big Star!”
Iggy Pop
3/5
This was such a departure from the Stooges era that I had to do a double take. Clearly Bowie had his hands all over this and I’m surprised it was never billed as an Iggy-Bowie collaboration album. Makes even more sense that Bowie used these sessions to immediately jump in and make his Low album which definitely has the same feel. There was a lot to like about this. Probably not quite as good as Lust for Life, but still deserves good marks.
Ramblin' Jack Elliott
2/5
I totally get that you can’t really talk about Guthrie and Dylan without mentioning Jack Elliott. And while I can appreciate his tongue in cheek approach and delivery, these songs are just mediocre at best. While there might be some pickin’ and a grinnin’ here and there, there’s also a lot of…well…ramblin’…and that’s about all I can say.
David Bowie
5/5
Man…the more you sit with this, the more you realize just how brilliant Bowie was. Hard to believe it took four albums for most people to even know who he was. And while this album is a bit more soft and subtle compared to Ziggy, it fits right in with it. A definite mood setter and announcement to the world that he had arrived, which carries right on into the next album. At first listen an obvious 4* would be the way to go. But as you dig deeper, it would be a major misstep to not put it up there with Ziggy. Timeless. Completely unique. Nothing like it then. Nothing like it since.
Miles Davis
1/5
If your music comes with the instructions of “trust me…you’ll eventually like it”, or “give it multiple listens, and then I’ll think you’ll get it”…you’ve already lost. This album fails for those very reasons and is a good example of why jazz gets a bad rap, regardless of how good the players are. There’s a lot of good jazz out there, but this snooty, sanctimonious, cacophonous shit ain’t it. Now…I think I’ll go drink a proper brew.
John Cale
2/5
I thought I was listening to the B-side outtake sessions of Spinal Tap’s Cups And Cakes/Flower People era…and then I realized this was written as a serious work. Yikes.
Taylor Swift
4/5
I enjoyed this. Not a lot of depth here, which appears to kinda be the point with her shift into this more synth-pop style. I think overall the songs are not amazing and do pretty much sound the same. But a good consistent spirit seems to help this whole collection along. Tracks like Style and I Wish You Would stood out to me this time. And while it’s easy to harsh on Taylor, credit needs to be given for an overall good listen. Shave it down 2-3 songs and the album probably jumps higher.
Leonard Cohen
3/5
A perfectly fine listen and a good debut from someone who was just finding his voice, long before it matured into what I know Cohen to be. Most songs had the same feel, but I particularly liked “So Long, Marianne” with its instrumentation and 3/4 waltz time.
Björk
3/5
Understanding that this album was written in response to and surrounding a break-up she was going through helped the listening process. The album seems to define the arc of a failed relationship very nicely with early songs being more calm, mellow and airy in tone…only to gradually build in tension, anxiety and eventual chaos at the end. A good example of art depicting real life. I’m not sure if I can say I liked this, but I can definitely appreciate it.
Emmylou Harris
3/5
This was a very cool…yet, well…fine listen. I really like the production as that is what makes this more of an interesting listen. Still, I prefer her previous album Wrecking Ball produced by Daniel Lanois. Maybe ‘cause that was one of her first leaps into fusing modern sounds with her folk songs. Still…her voice is so darn good and distinct regardless of the presentation. The title track was one of my faves, and it was cool to see her covering Patty Griffin on “One Big Love.” Biggest surprise was the “My Antonia” duet with Dave Matthews who sings in a normal register for once, unlike his nasal DMB style which I can’t stand.
Madonna
4/5
Probably not the album to listen to if you have daddy issues, let alone big daddy in heaven issues. Still, this was when Madonna ruled the airwaves and the public eye. Overall there is a surprising amount of variety and style-collision here which made for a good listen. I do think the back half of the record starts to lag, right around Dear Jessie/Oh Father tracks. But the high rating is deserved based on the front half of the album alone.
Slade
3/5
This was a really fun listen. Glam and metal before it was cool. Sweaty swaggering street rock that was clearly a foundation laying for so many bands that arose in the 80s. And how can you forget Quiet Riot riding their highest wave of success on the backs of two Slade songs: Mama Weer All Crazee Now and Cum on Feel The Noize.
The xx
3/5
A band that I had not dug deep into and really had only heard in passing. But a focused spin really made me like them more. The duel-vox sharing is a nice balance, and you can also definitely hear influences like Yaz, Cocteau Twins, Siouxsie and even some Everything But The Girl popping through. All filtered through a modern Tycho-like lens. This was a very chill listen and of course situation specific, but something I’ll return to. I dig it.
George Jones
3/5
I never really cared much for George Jones. Perhaps it was because growing up in the 70s the only songs I heard of his were the ones like this album that were drenched in sappy slide guitar and overuse of strings. But, I will say that his voice is instantly recognizable and all his own. Utterly unique. Still, this album just seems like he’s singing the same song over and over. Same feel. Same tempos. And while the title track is the clear standout, once I got to the end of the tour I realized I didn’t remember any of it. A fine listen in the end, but not near as exciting as reading about his drug-ridden booze-soaked personal life.
Billy Bragg
5/5
One of the coolest surprises so far in this exercise. And I’m sure it’s one of the more polarizing ones. But when this cassette fell into my hands in high school it quickly became part of the soundtrack of my youth. Activism, romanticism, and a wit all wrapped up in a punk rock delivery. And it’s probably safe to say that his message and popularity would not have survived if it weren’t for the voice. But 40 years later songs like Help Save The Youth of America and There is Power in A Union still seem relevant. Billy continues to this day to be an active performer and smart activist voice for so many.
Michael Kiwanuka
4/5
An artist that I knew very little about. This was a really nice surprise and very cool listen that seems to defy genre. It weaves seamlessly from old to new and retro to modern all wrapped up in a soulful delivery. Dig it.
Sam Cooke
4/5
How incredible it would’ve been to be there in that club. This a great snapshot in time of how true live albums should be made. It’s full of swagger, improvisation, sweat, smoke and raspiness. It’s perfectly imperfect. And what a crime that the record label waited two decades to release it. This is great stuff.
Bonnie "Prince" Billy
4/5
This album benefits from listening in the right environment wrapped in solitude and a really good cocktail. What little I’ve heard of Will I always liked. And hearing this one will definitely make me wanna delve deeper into his stuff. It’s a really good record that survives because of its minimalist approach. A perfect example of using air and space as instruments themselves to serve the songs which only helps round out the melancholy moods. Add to that his use of unconventional, clever and at times witty lyrics and you get a really good listen.
Bee Gees
3/5
I’m not sure why I liked this, but I did. Probably because it was delightfully sappy. Would probably rate a bit higher if a few songs were shaved. But overall it was still a pretty enjoyable listen.
Hüsker Dü
3/5
I was surprised to see this one included here since it definitely is not one of their top efforts. Would it be more impactful had it been released as two separate albums? Maybe. Yes, tracks like “Ice Cold Ice”, “Could You Be The One” and “Too Much Spice” are clear standouts, but with 20 songs all sounding pretty similar it’s hard to get behind its inclusion here. I fear that many non-Dü fans are gonna determine whether they like the band or not based on this record, but they shouldn’t. Instead, check out the earlier catalogue like Zen Arcade and even Candy Apple Grey to help change your mind.
The Specials
2/5
Another head scratcher as to why it was included in this list. Tough to listen to, and loses all the edge and freshness of their much more deserving debut which I hope makes the list. Nothing special at all here.
Tim Buckley
3/5
It’s clear the apple does not fall far from the tree when listening to Tim and then later his son. Knowing the overwhelmingly sad story surrounding their lack of relationship probably makes these songs hit harder and a bit deeper. But at times the sound is a bit dramatic and even kitschy with all the kings n queens n jesters n dungeons imagery. At times I felt I was at a Ren-faire being asked to dance around the maypole. An ok album in the end, but nothing really stands out.
Hot Chip
3/5
You really gotta be in the mood to commit to an entire album like this. The 80s-synth pop influenced sounds are obvious and definitely give a nice nod to many of the actual bands of that time. Still…a song here and there is cool, but an hour solid of it probably notches it down for me.
Bad Company
4/5
A solid debut from a band that falls into the category of quintessential 70s classic rock. I remember hearing many of these songs on the radio in heavy rotation, and they still hold up today. These guys liked two things: rockin’ and screwin’. And not always in that order. If you couldn’t get enough of their love, by God they were gonna rock you steady enough until you were finally ready to love. Not a lot to overthink here. Just good old rock n roll that still survives today.
Pulp
3/5
I generally like my musical juice pulp free. This album is quite misleading based on the cover art alone. In the end, just an average set of ok songs. I guess I’ll settle for medium pulp. 2.5/5
1/5
Musical masturbation for guys who think they’re cool…played by guys who probably got their asses kicked a lot. Insulting to the ears, and insulting to the listeners on this exercise being forced to even acknowledge its existence. More like shit vs. shit. If only there were 0 stars.
Patti Smith
3/5
I’ve listened to this album at various life time points over the years, but it still never really lands for me. I can appreciate her place in the story of punk rock given the attitude and delivery here, but I’ll always be a bigger fan of her fellow NYC/CBGB contemporaries like Television and The Ramones. The album and her sound is definitely unique for that period with the combination of rock music and poetic lyrics, but at times she seems to be in a poetry slam competing with herself. Still, with so many bands citing this album as a major influence (REM, Siouxsie, Johnny Merr, etc.) it’s hard to discount her influence.
4/5
A really cool inclusion from an often overlooked band. More than just a punk rock band, X achieved success with their lyrical content as well as incorporating country and rockabilly into their driving songs. All wrapped up with their signature lead vocal trade-offs and harmonies. Getting to see them live a few times only solidified my love of these guys. And while I’m more a fan of their Los Angeles and More Fun In The New World albums this one still ranks up there. Even cooler to see the original four members still out there touring today.
Faust
1/5
More like shitrock. I’m all for weird left-of-center when it comes to music, and at times they nearly changed my mind with the injection of humor here and there into the songs. But overall it was just a Faustian waste of time.
Booker T. & The MG's
3/5
Admittedly I really only knew the title track ever since it was featured on the soundtrack to American Graffiti. I was hoping the rest of this album would rival that song, but it just doesn’t quite measure. And while I always put these guys in similar company as The Ventures, they just never reached that same wave level. Overall, a perfectly fine listen.
Orbital
1/5
Where tolerance becomes a loop
Where tolerance becomes a loop
Where tolerance becomes a loop
Where tolerance becomes a loop
Where…
Input translation: tolerance not achieved…
The Mars Volta
3/5
Concept albums can be hard to pull off. And while the musicianship is very top notch here (especially the drumming), the vocal delivery can be a bit annoying. There’s some creative and unexpected dynamics and time signatures which keeps it unpredictable, but unfortunately the wall of sound onslaught makes many of the lyrics indecipherable which is what tells the story. I was never really into this band, but have to recognize their abilities.
George Harrison
4/5
I always thought he was underrated as a Beatle, and this album overall doesn’t disappoint. It’s just too darn long. The variety of styles here while maintaining quality is pretty amazing. But because of the length, it really does drag over the last third or so. Particularly the long drawn out instrumentals. Still, lots of good stuff on this one.
Beastie Boys
5/5
I got more stories than JD’s got Salinger when it comes to this record. It hit at the right time for me and was in regular rotation at every party in college. It is a true masterclass in sampling, and I imagine would not be possible today given rights issues for sampled songs. But the creativity mixed with witty lyrics is just outstanding and set a high bar for hip-hop and music in general. Still holds up today.
The Divine Comedy
2/5
This guy sure does like to write about horses. And while this is not quite as bad or annoying as A Short Album About Love, do we really need two albums from this band on the list? This one follows the same feel as the other, which places the listener inside what appears to be a tongue n cheek musical. But I’m not so sure he’s doing it with a wink and a smile. And that is what’s even more frightening.
Britney Spears
2/5
I had higher hopes for this one based on the first three tracks. But then it really falls off into homogenized pop schlock territory. I’ll give it some props for legacy and influence. But this was a tough and utterly forgettable listen overall that really is no different than what had already been done 15 years prior (ala Debbie Gibson, etc.). Wash, Rinse and hopefully not Repeat.
Dr. Dre
3/5
The production on this one is still the biggest standout. But overall this album hasn’t aged well lyrically. Outside of the released known singles, most of the other songs just cruise along without reaching that level. And at times it becomes a tired listen. Without Snoop I don’t think the album would’ve made it as far.
Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band
1/5
When your album is cited as one of David Lynch’s favorite, you’re already starting from a placed called WTF. And just because certain polytonal sounds are possible when combined, doesn’t mean they actually sound good.
Simon & Garfunkel
3/5
A strange mix of songs and spoken word skits here. But I think what helps this concept album along is the use of crossfades from one song to another to help tell the story. America, Mrs. Robinson and Hazy Shade of Winter remain the big standout tracks, further supported by how successfully they’ve been covered by other artists (First Aid Kit, Lemonheads, Bangles to name a few). But man there is some thick cheese here and there too, no doubt the result of all the hash Paul was smoking while writing the songs. I guess we’ve all dreamt of being a cornflake and English muffin at some point in our lives. Props to Simon too for that pre-mod haircut on the cover.
Ice Cube
3/5
Receiving this one the same week as The Chronic made for an interesting comparison. A much more in-your-face edgy delivery than the laid back style of Dre/Snoop. At times it even sounds industrial. Crazy that the two albums were released within a month of each other. Interestingly I think it’s Cube’s style that cuts right to the bone and probably helps deliver the message better. But I put this one and the same camp as The Chronic.
Stereo MC's
2/5
It’s as if Deee-Lite and Smashmouth had a kid that turned out to be slightly smarter and cooler than their parents. Slightly. Or at least enough to move this into slightly fine when listening as a background filler.
The Go-Betweens
3/5
This was a fine and pleasant listen. But like 30+ years ago I most likely won’t return for another listen, and instead continue to focus on much better Aussie bands like The Church and The Hoodoo Gurus.
The Avalanches
2/5
Another day, another electronic album. I can appreciate the multi-genres being sampled, along with their tasteful placement in the production. But repeating the same phrase over and over in each song, along with throwing in overused scratching just seems a little lazy. Background music for sure.
MC Solaar
3/5
This must be what Serge Gainsbourg sounds like if he were a rapper. And I gotta admit…I kinda dig it.
John Prine
4/5
Always been a Prine fan. This one really survives based on the very clever, witty and pertinent lyrics. He’s really an excellent story teller with each song spanning a gamut of emotions. Good stuff that is still very relevant today.
Big Brother & The Holding Company
3/5
A little too bluesy for my tastes, but the sweaty, swaggery delivery of Janis is pretty great. Instantly recognizable, and yet this album is probably somewhat forgotten given her untimely death just two years later. A small window into what might’ve been.
Grateful Dead
1/5
Man, this is a crap listen. And its inclusion here doesn’t even merit a creative answer…it’s just dumb. I’m a fan of the Dead and can get behind albums like Workingman’s Dead, American Beauty, etc but this was a slog. I guess I would’ve enjoyed this if hearing it live for the first time back then under the influence of some serious drugs without a care in the world. But damn, when you’re a “jam” band, it’s probably a good idea to have some moments of linking up with your band mates rather than just randomly noodling in your own musical silo which is what each member seems to be doing.
Leonard Cohen
3/5
Seems to be somewhat of a continuation in feel from his first album, although more stark and stripped down. A perfectly fine listen with some interesting production choices. Jew’s harp anyone?
Sister Sledge
3/5
There’s nothing to overthink here. The music is sexy, seductive and simple in its message, and was written for one purpose: to have fun. And sure I definitely took to the roller rink floor when some of these songs came on. But outside of the way overplayed title track, the rest was pretty forgettable. Except for the guitar work of coursevbwhich is signature Nile Rodgers. So, I guess that really just makes this Chic, part 2.
Caetano Veloso
3/5
This was an interesting collision of cultures and sounds. Some of it was more fun than other parts. Not a bad listen overall. If I listen again, it would definitely fall into the background music-for-me category.
Giant Sand
2/5
A chore to listen to indeed. Another completely unnecessary and forgettable inclusion on this list. Elementary lyrics mixed with overall boring and unoriginal music makes for a nice arrangement of drivel. Only rounding up due to some interesting production sounds.
Neu!
3/5
Two vastly different albums in one. No doubt a direct sign of how these two dudes couldn’t get along. From chill electronica on side A to a more in-your-face post punk electronic style on side B. And yet the album still has a well-balanced arc to it. It’s no wonder this one is cited as influential to others like Bowie, Sonic Youth and Thom Yorke.
Spiritualized
3/5
This was a really cool listen that at times presents some nice sounds and feels that help it rise above shoegaze. Almost as if the Stone Roses are meeting Galaxie 500 in a world of chill airiness that keeps things moving forward without ever becoming boring. Shave some of the length off, and it probably rates higher.
Bruce Springsteen
4/5
A nice departure from the large anthemic sound that Bruce is more known for. Even cooler is how this was unplanned and almost accidental. Just a dude in his bedroom using a 4-track recorder. A very polarizing album for many fans and critics, but I dig it. Listening to it in context front to back paints a more dark, bleak and not so joyous story through the lyrics and it made for a really good listen.
Butthole Surfers
3/5
Growing up in Dallas in the 80s it was near impossible to not have these guys come up in routine conversation about the music scene in Texas. Knowing how nuts they were, at times it was hard to wrap my head around what they were doing. And even more hard to wrap my head around lead singer Gibby Hanes being the son of famed children’s show character Mr. Peppermint. I seem to recall seeing them in ‘87 at the long defunct Theatre Gallery in Dallas, only to walk away more stunned. It’s hard to describe a Surfers show, but I recall bombastic drumming, fire, naked girls and films showing circumcisions. I think. That alone merits a slight uptick in rating here.
Small Faces
3/5
I had some hope with this one. Front half of the album had some cool moments, but questionable production and mixing choices made it hard to fully listen (hard pans of drums in one side, only to be swept to the other; other instruments being panned as well). But then what seemed to be Dr. Seuss as narrator kicked in for the back half. I’m all for concept albums, but for a band who wanted to be taken seriously, expecting listeners to buy in on Happiness Stan, half-moons and large flys…is…well…
Manic Street Preachers
4/5
A nice surprise and departure from a lot of the other 90s stuff, this was a band I knew of from a distance but never really listened to. There were definite influential sounds a la The Jam, Wire and Buzzcocks, but also some new wave and late 80s feel…all wrapped up with 90s drive. The dreary lyrics (oof) and tragic story of the lyricist/guitarist only adds to its intrigue. Still, there were a lot of interesting non-predictable moments and guitar tones that really help this album successfully bridge a lot of gaps between decades.
Jah Wobble's Invaders Of The Heart
3/5
I had high hopes for this since I was familiar with Jah’s stuff working with Lydon and PiL. I can always dig cross-cultural world beat collabs, and there are some groovy musical moments on this here and there. But damn…overall this is really dated and probably more deserving of overhead music while shopping at World Market. I’m only rating up based on the opening track alone because Sinead’s voice always elevates a song.
Grizzly Bear
3/5
I’m flummoxed how a band can deliver 12 songs that on the surface are pretty good…yet contain not a single hook or memorable chorus. I’m sure at the time of release this was considered unique and new, and the production here is admirable as there are a lot of layers, etc. But why bands think it’s hipster cool to record drums and guitars on every single song as if they’re down the hall and underwater I’ll never know. A pleasant chill listen that was enjoyable enough at the time, but I can’t remember much about.
Joni Mitchell
1/5
Just when I think there are moments where the songs might sound good…she chooses to venture into that cringe-worthy falsetto. Another overrated album from an overrated artist.
The Band
3/5
I was hoping for some of the songs to be on par with The Weight due to how overplayed it is, but none really presented other than a decent cover of The Long Black Veil. Still, as a singing drummer myself I gotta give props here. Overall just an average listen.
Primal Scream
3/5
A band that I only knew of from a distance and never listened to that much. This was a perfectly fine listen with some interesting sounds here and there, but not very memorable in the end. Rating up a bit in honor of bassist Gary “Mani” Mounfield (formerly of the Stone Roses) who passed away just two weeks ago.
The Rolling Stones
2/5
Every band has to start somewhere. And while it’s cool to see their admiration for American R&B, I’m much more likely to go drop the needle on the original artists of the songs or similar a la Chuck Berry or Bo Diddley. It’s obvious that this one would never be included on the list if their name wasn’t The Rolling Stones and it’s for sure taking up filler space from some of their more deserved albums that come later.
The 13th Floor Elevators
2/5
I can appreciate these guys for setting the stage for psychedelic grunge rock. It’s raw, dirty and imperfect while still delivering an in-your-face banshee howl sound. But holy shit that overused amplified jug is annoying. I thought I was listening to Curly from the Three Stooges running around in circles trippin’ balls on acid. Unfortunately that kills any hopeful vibes.
George Michael
4/5
I never liked or listened to this then, but with 5 of the 10 songs being played on airwaves everywhere or MTV that year it was pretty hard to avoid. Revisiting this today I was surprised at how dated it actually is, but still chalked full of catchy hooks. The front four songs alone boost this up into higher ratings. After that it kinda falls into sound-alike territory.
Earth, Wind & Fire
3/5
A decent enough listen. But in the end…too much earth and wind, and not enough fire.
CHVRCHES
3/5
Although I became more of a fan of these guys with their second album, this one is still pretty solid. I remember hearing The Mother We Share and Recover across a number of mediums when they were released. Which makes sense as they are some of the obvious standouts. A lot of this does sound alike, but still..their take on 80s synth pop with a new edge provides a lot of good ear candy.
Animal Collective
2/5
I wanted to like this more. No really. And just when there were moments of cool and interesting sampling sounds tastefully layered, they had to go and muck it up with more homogenized hipster drivel. It’s this imbalance that keeps this in a lower rating for me. I can appreciate the ambitious production here from a band who is sticking to their guns, but if My Girls even though being a decent song was Pitchfork’s #1 song that year, that might speak more to the state of indie music in general at the time.
The Jesus And Mary Chain
4/5
This was a nice end of week surprise. Always liked JAMC, and in my opinion they’ve always been underrated. But these lads deserve to be in the same conversation as similar leaning bands that get more attention like Joy Division, Psychedelic Furs and Echo and The Bunnymen. Shoegazer noise pop before it was cool. Very cool listen even 35+ years later.
Neil Young & Crazy Horse
2/5
Another day another frickin’ Neil Young album. Look, I get it…to a degree. But this is probably 6+ albums for him at this point. There’s gotta be a more measured approach to this list when no doubt other well-deserved artists are losing a single placement due to stuff like this. Ironically, I liked this album more than some of the other earlier Young inclusions due to better production and more cohesive song structures. I felt this was a fine listen, but who needs multiple 10+ minute songs with unnecessarily long guitar jams.
Dennis Wilson
4/5
This was a very surprising listen. Lots of variety in sound and genre throughout. It’s probably pretty hard to disassociate from his Beach Bros. given how popular they were, but he does a really good job of it with this ambitious effort. And of course, there’s that whole Charles Manson association that is nothing short of bizarre.
The Disposable Heroes Of Hiphoprisy
2/5
I think the intent was good here, but unfortunately doesn’t quite deliver. I’m all for social consciousness wrapped up in tasty beats and grooves, but in the end this falls flat. I felt like I was auditing a class on social awareness while being lectured to. It’s as if listeners are being called to attend class at Public Enemy University, only to find out that Professor Chuck D was absent and replaced by a much less qualified substitute teacher in Michael Franti.
Kid Rock
2/5
Being forced to listen to this the week before Xmas really crapped on my holiday spirit. I’ll give credit to the first two tracks for being hits, but over an hour of this was simply boring and painful. For a guy that comes from a reasonably affluent background to present himself as having it rough is just silly. The music is generic, and the lyrics when not being insulting are elementary and sophmoric. There were other artists around this time that were clearly better at delivering rock/rap performances.
Ute Lemper
2/5
I mean c’mon. This is just silly. Schmaltzy overly dramatic cabaret music that is for a musical that never gets produced only to be pitched again for a James Bond film that never existed in the first place.
Depeche Mode
5/5
This was a nice listen after the week of crap leading up to it. I had already peeled away from DM at this point, but with over half of it being top notch songs in heavy rotation at the time…and since, it deserves a full rating. Some nice flashback memory triggering too.
Marianne Faithfull
3/5
This was really cool listen. I was more familiar with pre-drug pop gentle voiced Marianne, but after hearing this I’m a fan. There’s a punk rock edge to it while being run through a new wave blender with whiskey-soaked post-drug raspiness. A comeback album if there ever was one. Hard to imagine other female artists like Cyndi Lauper, Debbie Harry, Pat Benatar or even Annie Lennox sounding like they do without borrowing from this, knowingly or not. Good stuff.
Napalm Death
1/5
I don’t know which is funnier. Getting this album dealt to me on my birthday or the sheer fact that it was included in this list. Sounds like a band that tried 28 times to record the same song. I mean hell, if you read the lyrics it sounds like they might’ve had something important to say. But you can’t understand a word in this one dimensional sludge. Might as well’ve had Cookie Monster come in a record the vocals “Me like cookie! Me like cookie!” over and over again.
5/5
One of my earliest Beatles listening thanks to my dad’s pressing from the 60s. Probably comes close to being the OG of concept albums. So much to like about its innovation from the technical, to the production to the songwriting. Simply great.
Amy Winehouse
5/5
I never paid much attention to this album when it was released as I was living in my own rock n roll world. But after a full listen through now it’s really a great record. In addition to Amy’s timeless vocal style, the production really deserves high credit here too. It really bridges a gap between two worlds helping to create a new modern sound that draws on the past. A modern day Sarah Vaughan. Such a sad story of walking a fine line of tragedy vs success, with tragedy winning out like so many others in the 27 club.
Frank Sinatra
4/5
It’s hard to imagine where this album falls in Frank’s catalog seeing that he recorded 59 studio records. But it sure does seem that he’s firing on all crooning cylinders with this effort. Just brilliant. Optimistic. Timeless. Even more difficult to imagine is the fact that it was recorded 70 years ago. And yet it feels just like yesterday. Drop the needle on this anytime, any place and life just gets better.
Johnny Cash
4/5
I bought this when it came out almost entirely on intrigue alone. How was a producer like Rick Rubin gonna bring out the best in Cash? The result is pretty admirable. Some obvious standouts here (Hurt, Personal Jesus), but also some other decent representations. Probably all proof that good songs are good songs regardless of how stripped down or changed they are. Shave off 3-4 filler tracks and it becomes a bit tighter. Still an enjoyable listen that fits a mood.
Sparks
3/5
An interesting discovery and I dig it. Calling it quirky alone does it a disservice given that there are some complex arrangements that are quite theatrical. It’s as if Queen, Siouxsie and the Banshees and They Might Be Giants were all unknowingly invited to the same party hosted by Rodgers and Hammerstein.
Korn
2/5
Other than the more ubiquitous radio played singles from this album, my only connection to this band at the time was discovering the lead singer being a bagpiper. I wasn’t a fan of this album then, and upon relistening now…man…it’s still not good. There is a lot of filler and some even more wince inducing songs. What’s more surprising is this peaked at #1 on the Billboard charts. Let that sink in.
Coldcut
2/5
I’m not sure which is more sad. The fact that this album is on this list or the fact that I actually remember it being played at various college parties. I always thought it was a band trying to sound like C&C Music Factory or Jesus Jones. Which is never a good idea.
Incubus
3/5
This was a cusp one for me. I remember liking it a lot more when it was released, most likely due to the strength of the singles, especially Drive. Hearing it again today, it’s not bad. It’s just kinda one dimensional. They do a good job of separating themselves from other fellow bands at the time, but in the end the lyrics are surprisingly kinda elementary and the scratching starts to be gimmicky. Still, this album definitely stands out as one that ushered in the 2000s. I think I grew a bad goatee just listening to it.
Lloyd Cole And The Commotions
3/5
I’ve always been a fan of Lloyd n crew. Probably more so by the time their 2nd album hit. Still, this is a pretty impressive debut for a band. It plays just fine now, but it for sure played better back then as its jangle rock style was such an antithesis to so much of the cheesy 80s pop being circulated.
The Police
4/5
This was always one of my favorite Police records. And I always dug the instrumental title track. Even played Its Alright For You in one of my high school bands. Hell…it could even be argued that Copeland’s hi-hat work alone makes it an automatic 5. But there are a few tracks thrown in for filler that overall notch it down for me. Still an amazing sophomore album for an uncompromising band.
Richard Hawley
4/5
This was one of the more surprising discoveries since starting this exercise. I really liked it. A very cool record that crosses a lot of genres and in the end defies a singular style…all the while maintaining a timeless cohesive feel. Will definitely be returning to this one.
The Sugarcubes
3/5
I can appreciate weird, odd, quirky, strange, and at times borderline bonkers. This album definitely fits all those descriptions and I remember it being passed around on campus. I even occasionally spun Birthday and Motorcrash on my program as a college DJ. But as unique as it was, I just never could quite get into these guys, nor take them too seriously. Which in the end, was the band’s goal apparently.
LL Cool J
2/5
I can dig the more minimalistic approach with production here. And sure…some of the lyrics are witty, clever and even articulate at times. But then it got cringy and rapey. When are these hip hop artists gonna learn that longer and more songs does not mean better. Outside of the title track, there wasn’t much to remember here.
Dusty Springfield
3/5
This was an enjoyable listen. Almost sounds like it’s from the 50s rather than mid-60s. And perhaps I would’ve rated higher had it been presented much earlier on in the exercise because her vocal performance is passionate and pretty top notch. Hard to not think of Jim Carrey (Lloyd) singing Mockingbird in Dumb and Dumber too. But with the album being cover tunes I just can’t go any higher.
Teenage Fanclub
4/5
I forgot how good these guys were. A great jangle power pop alternative. Up there in the same conversation with Matthew Sweet, the Lemonheads and Dinosaur Jr. The Big Star comparisons are complimentary and well deserved. And Kurt Cobain himself was known to name drop them in interviews as the best band in the world. Maybe there was something to Spin naming this album as better than Nevermind? Ha. Not really. Oh well, whatever, nevermind. Still a great record.
Christine and the Queens
2/5
I feel like I’ve heard this before…only done better, by way better artists. It’s not bad. It’s just utterly forgettable. At times even venturing into muzak land. Not sure why it was included on this list
The Undertones
3/5
I could always take or leave these lads, but their impact on future punk/post punk artists should be noted. The songs here are short, catchy and to the point while not taking themselves too seriously. Still, the album is a bit too long. Shave off some songs and it probably gets a higher rating.
The KLF
2/5
I place this in the IYKYK category. And clearly I did not know. I assume this is some of the better euro-trance out there. But again, what do I know. What I do know is how fascinating their story is. No doubt one of the more unique. Apparently jokingly wrote about how to achieve a hit song, then actually did it, then disbanded, burned all monies from it, destroyed their records and disappeared into obscurity. High concept art I guess.
Scritti Politti
2/5
When someone asks you to play them something good that is quintessential 80s, this not it. Yes it checks all the cheese boxes from that era, but it was a painful listen then…and pretty much remains that today. It’s repetitive and not at all memorable. Except for Perfect Way, which actually came on the radio just the other day. To which I quickly turned the dial.
The Waterboys
5/5
The title track alone is an all time banger. I remember actually hearing it on Dallas’ famed Q102 rock station and I was stopped dead in my tracks. And I loved it. I couldn’t believe this was the same band that had previously produced such great albums like Pagan Place and This Is The Sea. It was such a pivot in sound. And this Celtic/folk/rock combo would become a huge influence on me and my own musical career. The collectors addition is definitely long in the teeth, but the original release is just an amazing record.
Bob Dylan
4/5
I was never a huge Dylan fan, but his abilities as a songwriter and lyricist have to be acknowledged. And that definitely shines brighter on this record than some of the others. The songs have more maturity and structure, and the production definitely helps with this being one of the more listenable from front to back in his catalog. I’ve always liked Shelter From The Storm, but If You See Her, Say Hello was also a nice surprise. Overall an enjoyable listen.
White Denim
4/5
I’m not sure how I missed following these guys, but this was a pretty kickass listen. One of the more surprising finds on this list. Good songwriting, tight and unpredictable arrangements. And excellent musicianship. Will definitely dig into more of their catalog. D…ig this for sure.
Deerhunter
3/5
I knew of this band loosely. Which is to say I knew their name and had heard a few of their songs. This was an ok listen. At times a few tracks stood out. But much of it just seems bored. Even the band themselves must’ve been bored when writing some of it. Clearly I’m not hipster enough to fully like this. And I don’t have a beard.
MGMT
3/5
Outside of the three obvious standout singles which admittedly are somewhat catchy, the rest of this was pretty forgettable. Would I turn the dial if this came up on a playlist? Probably not. Will I be digging deeper into this band’s catalog? Probably not.
Van Morrison
2/5
This being called an album is a stretch. More like an improvised moaning stream of consciousness. Yes Van the Man has a unique voice and way of “singing”, but with very little song structure and even less melody, it made for a pretty forced listen. Props to the session players hired to try and follow this rambling.
Traffic
2/5
It’s always a slog making your way through traffic…even if there’s only six stoplights along the way.
Muddy Waters
4/5
To be a fly in the mud for this show would’ve been cool. Really dig the way this paces. Slow and soulful to warm up the crowd, gradually building to some rousing moments. The piano also gives these renditions a nice touch. Enjoyable listen for sure.
Julian Cope
2/5
I always knew his previous successful song World Shut Your Mouth, but not enough to make me dig deeper into catalogue. This was really no different. Some ok songs and cool sounds here and there, but not enough to standout. On top of that it’s way too long. From hope to nope.
Elvis Costello & The Attractions
5/5
At times both beautifully melodic and furiously political, this album completes the trio of his first three albums which are all great in their own unique way. I’ve always felt that this one strikes a really great balance. It hits that sweet spot of Costello where he really started coming into his own, and it’s one of my all time favorites of his.
Leonard Cohen
2/5
Surely this can’t be serious. I mean it’s just not good. It’s also unfortunate when artists who are clearly established and have carved out their own unique path think they have to pivot to sound like a certain other decade and genre. Pairing his haunting and soulful voice with Casio-like synth sounds was not a good move and immediately cheapens it all. Everybody Knows is the only salvageable song here, and the rest is simply a cheesy, misguided 80s attempt to be someone he is not. Yikes.
Mariah Carey
2/5
Pretty much what I expected. A great voice mixed with some exceptionally cheesy 90s production. And having to listen to Mariah for an hour in any situation can be a challenge. Interestingly one of the more standout tracks is the cover of Prince’s The Beautiful Ones.
Thundercat
2/5
I’m all for quirky genre-defying collisions, and this seems to check those boxes. Unfortunately, it gets in its own way by relying too much on those. The inclusion of Kenny Loggins and Michael MacDonald was a funny nod to 70s yacht rock, but doesn’t really boost it into higher rating for me. Shave the album in half and it still delivers the message and probably earns higher ratings.
Public Image Ltd.
2/5
Having this album and the next one (Metal Box) included on this list is a major head scratcher. I get it: Lydon really wanted to separate himself from the Sex Pistol association, and he does so with this next venture. But, outside of the song Public Image, it’s just not that good. There are much better post-punk albums than this. And it really isn’t until the albums This Is What You Want…, Album, and Happy? where PiL really start to come into their own with a stronger and more unique sound.
The Killers
4/5
A pretty incredible debut for a band that definitely carved out their own unique sound. I forgot just how loaded the front half of this one is with full on bangers that are both catchy and unpredictable. The back half drags a bit compared to those first 5-6 tracks, and is probably the only reason it doesn’t make it to a forever 5 rating. Still a really solid listen.
Stan Getz
4/5
I usually proceed with a cautious wince before pushing play on a record with jazz in the title, but this was a nice surprise. Like I’ve said before, I can bossa my nova with the best of them, and if you throw some samba sauce on it, well…I’m all in. I was immediately transported to the back room of the copa, where the drinks are heavy poured and the smoke in the air is even heavier. This record can make any cat feel more hip, even if just for 33 minutes. An overall really fun listen.
Ravi Shankar
2/5
I can’t say that I enjoyed this, but it was interesting from a learning perspective. Hard to determine a beginning, middle or end, which may be the point. Pretty repetitive, and yet strangely hypnotic at times too.
The Smiths
4/5
I was surprised to see this one on the list. Bought the cassette when it came out, but never quite liked it as much as the previous album The Queen Is Dead. Revisiting it this many years later I was surprised how much I liked it with its expansion of instrumentation and songwriting. A great way for the band to go out. Morrissey’s self loathing, mopey and at times cheeky singing is on full display, which gets tiresome as usual. But the rest of the band are really firing on all cylinders, especially Johnny Marr who is just a badass.
Echo And The Bunnymen
3/5
A really strong debut from one of the more unique post-punk bands. Ian McCulloch’s voice is instantly recognizable and Will Sergeant’s guitar work is great and often overlooked. Rescue remains a banger song with Do It Clean (U.S. version only) also solid. I put this one as better than Porcupine, but not rising to the level of Ocean Rain. 3.5/5.
3/5
The title track alone merits mid-level rating on its own. The rest is pleasant and pretty standard. Not bad. Not amazing. Just right for the right mood.
Peter Gabriel
3/5
Didn’t really melt my face off, but I liked it. The experimental feel to it is pretty impressive, and his adoption of the “no cymbal” policy is equally interesting from a production standpoint. Definitely opens up the percussion allowing it to thrive and drive differently. Pretty cool. Games Without Frontiers and Biko still remain the most solid tracks.
The Fall
2/5
More intriguing than the fact that these guys are on the list more than once, is the process for how this exercise consortium decided on the albums to include…given the band has 30+ in their discography. I mean…why were albums #8 and this one (#15) chosen? What makes them standout? Musically I liked this one. But the monotone speak-sing vocal style remains as annoying if not more than the previous album we were dealt. Probably explains why I bypassed them in the 80s.
Willie Nelson
4/5
Really enjoyed this. The songs were brief and to the point, and the album overall survives due to its minimalistic production and instrument approach. This is in the sweet spot of Willie which I think rounds out a bit better on his 1978 album Stardust.
Paul McCartney
3/5
This was a tweener for me. I’m all for a dude just pushing play on his 4-track recorder to capture songs. And so the stripped down non-polished result is a cool opposite to what the Beatles were doing leading up to this. But that being said, some of these tracks are really just that…ideas or improvised blips. Still, I can appreciate what Paul was going for here and the story surrounding its release makes it that much more interesting. 3.5/5.
Rage Against The Machine
3/5
A very timely listen for today’s climate. Musically this album is a powerful house of hard driving sounds. Dynamic, unpredictable. Lyrically, ahead of its time, and sadly probably more relevant today. Politically/Socially: see above. But vocally, this is where my rating falls. Hearing one offs like Killing In The Name Of, as well as others over the years…allowed for more intake and understanding of what the message was. But listening from top to bottom, I found myself being more annoyed at the monotone scream style delivery itself, rather than hearing the intended messages within. It ends up having a homogenizing effect on all the songs. My raging fist is still raised, just not as high. 3.5/5.
Q-Tip
3/5
This one surprised me. Was never a Q-tip fan, but this has some really groovy sounds played by real instruments. Not to mention some good sampling and also a good combo balance of singing and rap vocals. A nice change of pace for the rap genre that helps it standout.
Beatles
4/5
I was raised on the American version of this one via my dad’s collection, so it has a special place in my playlist heart. Interesting the amount of cover tunes on this that were not on the U.S. release. Can it be argued that this one doesn’t belong on this list given the amount of more mature material from the band yet to be heard? Possibly. But there’s more going on here with certain arrangements and use of chords that might not be as noticeable to most. Which makes for a solid listen.
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young
4/5
I liked this one better than the debut surprisingly. Dang, such good harmonies. Reading the backstory I was surprised that almost the entire album was recorded in solo sessions with each individual principal songwriter rather than as a group. Four part harmonies lead to four part egos I guess. And I might duck while saying this, but some of the Neil Young songs stood out more to me. Overall, there’s quite a few hits on it that I had forgotten about but immediately remember hearing as a kid once the needle dropped.
Donovan
3/5
Title track and Season of the Witch are the obvious ones to like. The rest of it while pretty forgettable probably deserves some credit for its early use of instrumentation like the bouzouki and sitar which was pretty new for the times. And while it’s hard to take songs like Guinevere seriously, let alone the overall feel of the album that could easily be inserted into Spinal Tap’s Flower People era, there’s enough influence here to go mid rating.
Nirvana
4/5
Any band faced with the task of following up an album as big as Nevermind is a tall order. So I like the way this one carved its own path. Most likely due to Albini’s production style. It’s more dirty, more rough around the edges, more sharp and abrasive…yet still delivers. The three tracks that were mixed by Scott Litt are definitely noticeable as they have removed the edges and sound more glistening. Still, a really good record that in the end sounds more like the band live, which is probably the way they should be heard.
Lynyrd Skynyrd
5/5
If you’re questioning this record, just reference the ridiculous yet hilarious commercial from 1987.
“Hey man, is that freedom rock?”
“Yeah, man.”
Well, turn it up man!”
Enough said.
Love
2/5
Another example of an album that shouldn’t be on here and is taking up space for another deserving band. There’s many WTF moments here from forced unnecessary production decisions (simply throwing in sleigh bells and harpsichord outros) to a ridiculous 18 minute final track jam of drivel. The only thing keeping this out of lowest ranking for me is the song “7 and 7 is” which is performed way better by artists like the Sidewinders and Billy Bragg.
Iron Butterfly
3/5
It’s impossible for me to not think of the pure gold Simpsons episode when hearing this. The one where Bart switches the church hymn music, from “In The Garden of Eden” by I. Ron Butterfly to this. It’s brilliant. Does that cultural relevance make it musically relevant as well? Hard to say. I’ve never listened to Side A of this record, and it appears I wasn’t missing much. The single side 17-min back half is the obvious standout. Probably more so if I was high as kite. As a band, if you get featured on the Simpsons…well…what else matters.
Motörhead
4/5
I remember seeing Motõrhead for the first time belting out Ace of Spades when they made an appearance on MTV’s 1984 broadcast of the Young Ones. I had no idea what to make of it other than sheer amazement watching Lemmy. It’s pretty ballsy for them to come right outta the gate in this album singing their most well-known hit. This is a relentless record with a rock n roll barrage of face melting goodness. Lemmy lived a hard n fast rock n roll life. All others who think they’re rockstars should take note while worshipping at his feet.
The Gun Club
4/5
Another band I was aware of, but somehow missed listening to in the 80s. I’m always down for some cowpunk/punkabilly, and so I liked this more than expected. Reminded me of some other under-the-radar bands of the same period like the Rave Ups doing similar stuff. Only these guys had more of an edge. Fun listen.
James Brown
4/5
I rarely say this with records on this exercise, but…gimme more. I felt a little cheated on this one as it was over just as I was starting to feel it. But it was still a good listen. Men want to be him, and clearly women want to be with him as exhibited with lots of swooning going on. Lots of legacy with this album and the man himself. From the Apollo to appearing in Rocky IV just over twenty years later. How’s that for a career arc?
Shivkumar Sharma
3/5
I dig me some tabla!