Reviews (page 7 of 14)
Marty Robbins may be a name you may only recognize from his 1959, but honestly I think that's a damn good reason to be known for even if its' the only thing notable in his multi-decade career. This album is pretty by the books in terms of late 50s Country music, but I think what sets this album apart and makes it such an iconic piece of music from its' time is the story telling and world building. This album makes you feel like you are the cowboy of each story. The songs here each feel like their own spaghetti westerns with the whole movie fitting into the 2-5 minute runtimes. There really isn't super interesting about this album, but it just does a really solid job at being this perfect capsule of Western/Cowboy culture. Not bad by any means but solid on all fronts.
It does what it does well. Solid proto outlaw country though my predilections is more towards cash, jennings and nelson.
Near-perfect country music, there's just something about this old school style that works for me every single time.
Yah most people will know this music from a few Fallout games (or maybe it’s only in one, I didn’t fact check) but its also the greatest exception to “don’t judge a book by it’s cover”. This album IS the cover. It’s literally a cowboy album! What’s not to love!?? Well actually here’s the small list of negatives. The first being it’s an album from 1959 so variety isn’t a word that existed yet. The whole album sounds like a western movie, and yah that is either gunna sell you on the album or completely turn you off. Like after the very first song you are gunna know how u feel about the rest of the album. The only other negative thing about this album is because there’s not a lot of variety in sound, the album could be grating to some. In fact, the songs that are not the massive hits can get totally buried by El Paso and Big Iron ( also while we are on the subject, why the fuck is there two versions of El Paso with no distinction between the two in title and only small differences in the song itself?!). For me personally, the only songs that I didn’t save on this album that didn’t really blow me away were the mildly religious songs and the slower songs just cause I always struggle with slower songs and religion. But regardless of those small issues, this is an album that 100% belongs on lists like this one. Now excuse me, I gotta go play through FNV again for the hundredth time.
Dont enjoy country
You can't really go wrong with this one
Läste precis att han var ultrahöger och blev mer höger när folk protesterade mot Vietnamkriget. Columbia vägrade även att publicera hans mer politiska musik. Det passar in i musikstilen också. Inget för mig men är väl helt okej country. Väldigt töntigt med allt snack om cowboys. Romantiserar en hjärndöd tid i USAs historia
Giving Johnny Cash. I do like actually, but feels very dated.
This one is great. Old country but fun to listen to.
Who could possibly not like "El Paso"?
Nothing like wandering through the nuclear wasteland with a big iron on your hip. Yee haw pardner
- jo auch ziemlich launig, kann ich nicht leugnen. Scratches an itch, nochmal werde ich es aber wohl nicht hören 2-3/5
🤠 fun outlaw country
Really like westerj music. very easy to listen to. also didnt hurt that i already knew two of the songs.
I listened to this album when I was on my trip this summer and it was a total vibe, especially because there terrain was fully relevant to most of the songs. I can’t say I don’t enjoy it, because I do enjoy it. (there’s another phrase for you all)
Not groundbreaking but enjoyable, it’s got some nice ballads but it’s also got some what could be parody of the genre songs that I can’t help but laugh during
No like
My type of country music, doesn't do too much but still packs a punch! 3.5
A blast from my past. This album is dear to me, but it’s soooo freaking fun and good. I hope everyone enjoys it. My heart is healed and lighter hearing this again
6.5 Yee haw!! Next time I’m riding a horse I’m putting this one on the aux
got it
OMG, Fallout New Vegas! Breaking Bad! Outside of those pop culture bangers, actually a nice western album, would watch tumbleweeds tumble to this. 4* Highlights: big iron, el paso
I’m not generally a fan of country music, but this was so different than what is typical of the genre. I knew the song “El Paso” and have liked different versions of it, including the original. I mostly enjoyed the outlaw story songs, and didn’t care much for the ones with the harmony vocals up in the mix. Overall a pleasant surprise, but I won’t be seeking out more of his music.
Beautiful voice, but some of the songs are very Lawrence Welk-esque. Probably best taken in small doses, but obviously a major inspiration for all kinds of people. (Yet another rightwinger, unfortunately.)
This is kind of an interesting novelty, but it's so archaic. Whatever. He's got a nice voice, the sound is interesting if a little thin, and I enjoyed it well enough. Probably never going to listen to it again, unless I found myself at some kind of cowboy-themed party.
Yeehaw
Big iron on his hip~ It belongs in a Mojave Desert. But not in a bad way this time
old and uninspiring in the present time
Base - really nice depth
red dead redemption
Total Listens: 1 Not super feeling this. Big Iron is of course great, but as an album it just feels a bit too samey to really love. Some other quite good songs here, but overall feeling pretty lukewarm on this.
Marty takes us on a cinematic journey through the old west in a musical style we just don't get much of these days. Sure, it's a bit of a one-trick pony, but the album's all about ponies...or horses...or something like that.
It's hard to think of a better album recommendation for anyone desiring a healthy dose of American West romanticism and cinematic idealization than this one right here, partner.
Yep. Yee haw indeed.
Absolutely perfect story telling.
Liked it much more than I thought I would. Might need to buy a cowboy hat and a revolver 🔫
Loved this - definitely an inspiration for Sturgill's "Ballad of Dood and Juanita"
You can see why people went mental for Elvis after listening to this stuff.
Fundamental stuff I guess. I don’t care for it though.
Good stories, just not at all something I want to listen to a whole album of
It's interesting to listen to a genre of music that didn't really survive long after it was popular. I really enjoy the flair and unabashed earnestness of it and, man, does that guy have a voice on him. I am going to search him up some more to see if he ever did anything outside the Western thing. Most of the songs are told, basically, by the ghost of someone who just got shot, hanged, stampeded or otherwise snuffed out but instead of dread or depression they seem to accept their end and reaffirm the choices that brought it on. El Paso is a masterpiece and all of the other songs play catch up. Big Iron is just so great and Cool Water is pure longing. What an album out of time but still up to the task.
I feel like the lyrics for this album really saved this one. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed this album for what it was. It’s a nice collection of outlaw songs and other tales of Western debauchery. Seriously, between this and At Folsom Prison, I’m starting to how sad old country is. How did country music transition from this to Cadillacs and beer and shit? My main problem is that the album’s very repetitive. Given the somber mood for most of the songs, most of this album sounds pretty much the same. Still, this wasn’t nearly as bad as a slog as I’d thought it be. Favorite track: Big Iron Other hits: El Paso, They’re Hanging Me Tonight, Billy the Kid, Utah Carol, The Master’s Call
Great classic country album. Very enjoyable.
Uhhhh....I expected to hate this, I mean look at the damn cover lmao...but I'm kinda fucking with this... All the songs are relatively short, so a 45 minute run time isn't too bad, but 40 minutes would've been perfect for me. Apparently there's a 35 minute version and that version didn't have "They're Hanging Me Tonight" so maybe the 45 minute version just is the best version.
Great cowboy ballads. This is from the era of good country music, we it told a story and didn’t just repeat the same crap about having a beer on a Friday night and such.
big iron is great but they're hanging me tonight is perfect
Classic
All songs sound the same
Definitely judged this album by its cover and thought it wouldn’t be for me. However, I’ve always enjoyed country music and this is no exception, great album and reminds me a little of Elvis if he did country
It's me, Arthur Morgan and John Marston against the notorious Micah Bell and the charming Dutch van der Linde.
Evocative, pleasant, repetitive.
The sort of tunes that appear in a Tarantino film. El Paso is the best track here (and appeared in Breaking Bad) but all the songs have merit. Great example of why this site is so valuable. I wouldn’t have listened to this album in a million years otherwise. Very much of its time but great stories in each song. Enjoyed it.
the music of mythic westerns. Really enjoy for what it is. Almost more of a movie soundtrack vibe than regular listen however.
3.5
I got that warm and fuzzy feeling from childhood when I watched western movies.
Awesome
2.6 It's good to be forced to listen to things like this. I'd never ever put it on normally. I never will again, but appreciate that at the time it was probably pretty banging. Too many weak tracks to make it enjoyable, although there were a couple I saved down. 40 mins probably double what I could handle.
It’s got some great old songs. It’s not everyone’s cup of tea, but those people can suck it.
I have like 2,000 hours on Fallout New Vegas and I listened to this album a month ago. 5 stars or the game was rigged from the start. I love when I mod the game and add all the songs from this album to the radio.
Accidentally listened to the 44 minute version instead of the 35 minute one. FML. Anyway I was shocked by the amount of this album I recognised while listening, clearly a sign I watch too many american sitcoms. Not much to say, its very one note lol but its not bad. Made me want to buy a gun, shoot the man my girl is cheating on me with and get hunted down by johnny law.
I enjoyed some of the guitar work, the vocal harmonies, and the lucid imagery provided by the lyrics that would pair perfectly with any John Ford western of the era. I did not like the constant verse-chorus-verse-chorus structure with overused repetitions on hooks/song titles. It’s a decent album and I enjoyed it more than I’d have expected to. Big Iron (8/10) A Hundred and Sixty Acres (7/10) They’re Hanging Me Tonight (7/10) Cool Water (6/10) Billy the Kid (7/10) Utah Carol (6/10) The Strawberry Roan (6/10) The Master’s Call (7/10) Running Gun (6/10) El Paso (7/10) In the Valley (7/10) The Little Green Valley (7/10) The Hanging Tree (7/10) Saddle Tramp (6/10) 6.7/10
One of my all time country records. Not like all that mainstream shit that’s peddled as the genre that gives it its deserved bad name. The storytelling, the voice. Can and have on occasion just had this album on repeat all day, and then they went and used it in Fallout, so many more hours listening there. Did I mention the storytelling the lyricisms, it’s like watching a movie in 3 minutes, with such a voice that gives you all the emotion. Don’t think Marty gets his props enough nowadays, as you can see his genes in a lot of music, that’s not country. Stone cold killer 5 Star
It’s not my thing but an easy listen and clearly an influential record for its genre.
Bonafide classic
One of my favorite country albums.
Can’t beat a bit of outlaw country. Hadn’t heard of Marty before but I’m firmly a fan now.
3.5
This is an album that has been with me all of my life. In fact my father's mono copy now adorns my collection. I can remember loving this album as far back as four years old. (10) ★★★★★ for me. Honestly one of might even be in my top ten country albums of all time for me... top 25 for sure.
Very cool and bleak stories. Very evocative stuff. 4 stars
I first heard Marty Robbins the same way most people under the age of 70 did -- playing Fallout: New Vegas. This is a pretty fun album, and I've always liked these story songs from the 50s. This album definitely walked so Nick Cave's Murder Ballads could run. Highlights for me were "Big Iron", "El Paso", and "They're Hanging Me Tonight". 4 stars.
Somewhat good for a country album but still not totally that good and also ploughs the same furrow quite a lot. Tracks sound pretty similar and are mainly about outlaws, being hanged or pining for some Mexican gal. Low 3.
Country music is a genre I’ve historically had a little apprehension about, of course there’s plenty of amazing country and the greats are seriously amazing but country (especially in its modern form) is a little too far into that MURICA vibes I’m not into. That said I really like most older country I’ve heard and that’s no different here. A broadly fun and interesting country album with cool lyrics and some great harmonies. The vocals are generally very good here, I enjoyed myself.
He does both kinds of music. I thought bug iron was my favourite. They were a bit like short stories set to music.
My great great grandfather was a horse thief who came to Alberta because he was no longer welcome in North Dakota. I think if I were alive back then I would have mostly been a coward. A real yellowbelly
5/10
A good collection of songs on this one. I didn't love it, but I did enjoy it overall.
Hahaha I LOVE Marty Robbins!! This record is a masterpiece and it deserves more recognition! I found this album because of his song El Paso some years ago! ❤️
Fantastic album, lots of cool stories. I generally hate country, but Ive learned that I enjoy it when it is about western or outlaw topics.
Initially infectious then boringly repetitive.
This feels like an album that would have been sold on late night television at one point. This music did not age well, I bet it sounded old six months after it came out. Billy The Kid is super corny. I would have thought El Paso was the big hit but apparently Big Iron is the more popular song from this album. Never mind, it was in Fallout so its got a bunch of listens due to gamers. This album was the definition of meh.
So much RDR2 vibes in this as someone who beat it yesterday omg
It's that real Western '50s voice, which is nice but doesn't do much more than that. Good for the era, but a bit lacklustre now.
Beautiful country album Tracks to Track: El Paso, Billy the Kid
Okay for a couple of songs but too much thereafter.
Charming!
I don't hate it. I think 3 stars for this one.
Huge fan of this. Easy to listen to, love the sound, sonically amazing.
A wholly enjoyable time with classic country, not something I’d necessarily come back to a lot but I can’t fault it for what it’s meant to be
Call me a cowgirl because I liked this way more than I thought I would.
Even though I wouldn't choose to listen to this again, it's a decent album for the genre and time period.
There’s a time and place for this music. But not in my regular rotation. His voice is nice for sure. 3/5.
Yeehaw
This type of storytelling music is my bread and butter. The instrumentals are lowkey, but add to the story.
Fun and weirdly nostalgic sounding album. Guests at my house for dinner were digging it, too.
I like this for the origins and nostalgia perhaps more so than the recordings themselves. I know many of these songs because someone else covered them (Cash, Mike Ness, the Dead, etc.) or from movies (my dad is a big fan of westerns). The music itself is fine, I prefer most of them when done by other artists as Marty Robbins’ style is a bit too polished for my tastes but I’m going to be generous and say 2.5 rounded up to 3 stars.
Terrible album. Just nothing to like. Mike Ness covered Big Iron and it’s a thousand times better. Every song was way over produced and there was too much added in. Also, the Grateful Dead covered El Paso a fair amount in concert and it’s always a skip for me.
Big Iron carries hard
The worst thing abt this site is waking up and finding out you gotta listen to some bs like this
One of the few Dead songs I like is El Paso.
Not my style but some catchy tunes.
Nej, jag gav det ett försök. Hade varit nice om jag diggade den berättande delen, alltså låttexterna, men jag tycker det mesta låter lika dant. Har lyckats lyssna förbi 6 låtar ändå😀
Not sure if I've heard any of these songs before. Certainly I have not heard the album proper. I'm very excited to give it a spin. Track 1 by far the most played song on the album. Its jaunty with a great story. A+ Track 2 slows things down with a song about his land. Just okay. Track 3 is a ballad lamenting his upcoming demise via the rope. Somewhat similar to Cash's 25 Minutes To Go. I like this one as well. Track 4 isn't for me. I don't like the background singers singing at the same time. Just give me Marty. Track 5 another slower paced one about Billy The Kid. This one works for me. Good storytelling and straight forward vocals. Track 6 is a peppier little number. A nice follow-up to the last track. Track 7 is an ode to a horse. This album is growing on me. Track 8 depicts a crime going down. Another solid track. Track 9 one of the more upbeat songs, as much as a gunfight can be upbeat. Maybe the best track since the first one. Track 10 is the most famous song, even though it doesn't have the most plays. I've heard this one plenty of times. Not sure I'd remember its Marty Robbins though Track 11 slows things back down. Disappointing after the last one. Track 12 nice bounce back. Wish they didn't layer the voices again but they stop halfway through for a bit at least. Track 13 this is a funky song. I like this one a lot. Good story and a bouncy beat. Track 14 is just okay. Mid-tempo but not super interesting to me. Track 15 is El Paso again. Its still good. I'm glad I got to listen to this, but there are only a handful of tracks I need to hear again. 2.5/5
Cheesy as fuck. 2.5 stars.
The instrumentation reminds me of mexican ballads but i dont like his voice.
This feels like an album that would have been sold on late night television at one point. This music did not age well, I bet it sounded old six months after it came out. Billy The Kid is super corny. I would have thought El Paso was the big hit but apparently Big Iron is the more popular song from this album. Never mind, it was in Fallout so it's got a bunch of listens due to gamers. This album was the definition of meh.
I don’t play video games nor do I live in the Mid-West USA. This album doesn’t have anything to appeal to me. Country music is not for me, but this isn’t the worst example of the many, many country artists on this list. So this raises it from what would be a one to a two star review. It’s better than the other shit country music, but that’s it.
Classic story telling country music. The music isn’t much as it is more about the vocals and the stories.
Old school country that didn't really do it for me. Inoffensive 3
Oh this is COUNTRY country, I quite enjoyed it! Good storytelling and voice, but probably wouldn't go out of my way to listen to it again though. Highlights: Big Iron, They're Hanging Me Tonight
Surprisingly good album, uplifting tunes
Oh boy how boring was this 💤 Why are we making music pretending to be a cowboy in 1959?
Look at that stance. I’d draw on this guy faster than you could say PIG iron. Which, if you think about, is much cooler. A hog smelting factory?? For the record, I mean a smelting factory owned and operated by large Berkshire pigs, not a place where swine are smelted into weaponry. And my gun? I’m glad you asked, full of bubbles. So when Marty and I draw, and I’m left dead in a c’oud of smoke, rest assured that in about 32 seconds, he’s going to get the soap stinger of a lifetime. Checkmate, Marty, checkmate. Big Iron - This song is more associated with a comically sad looking basset hound than I will ever be, and that’s a true tragedy. I think I hate all songs that end up in short form content, but as a full song? This can’t be denied. The background singers really make this. Very cool storytelling track. Hell yeah. A Hundred and Sixty Acres - Is this the “Trail Songs” portion of the album? Hoss mentioned. Great word. They’re Hanging Me Tonight - This sounds like a love song they’d play at prom and it’s about getting hanged. I mean that’s pretty cool. Every hanging song rules. I don’t make the rules, I’m just an observer. Cheaters get the pistol though. That’s always cool. Cool Water - Speaking of cool, this song ain’t all that cool. Gunfighter ballads, Trail songs and divining rod epics. Billy the Kid - Uhh is this the same story as Big Iron? He killed a bunch of guys, recorded it crudely on his pistol and the n ultimately lost a duel to a sheriff. Cool, but this is a worse version of the first track. Utah Carol - This sounds like an anthem for lifelong bachelors and roommate best friends from that era. See that was before being gay existed, so we cried over blankets that killed our cowboy partners who were also our best friends and NOTHING ELSE. The Strawberry Roan - Chappell? Oh damn I thought he was going to rhyme “fuck” with “buck.” That would be cool. Not the best thing going bere The Master’s Call - Oh, it’s Big Iron again. Pretty much the exact same melody. Am I insane? Running Gun - This is the best version of Big Iron since Big Iron. This should’ve been the sequel. El Paso - Oh god. The El Paso mamacita had a hold on old Marty. In the Valley - I’ve checked our close personal friend, RYM and it has determined that this track list is all wrong. I hate that. I don’t hate this song though. The Little Green Valley - See are these separate valleys? He was there, now he’s homesick for it. Or, are these distinct. Is one a different geographical structure. A coulee perhaps? The Hanging Tree - Hanging songs can’t miss. Well, maybe a small miss. This sounds like it’s from a different album, and honestly? An album I pray we don’t have to hear. Saddle Tramp - Who’s the saddle tramp? I will not be listening to the El Paso redux. Come on. In solidarity, I shall watch Eddie Guerrero vs Rey Mysterio Jr. for Halloween Havoc ‘97. ‘Tis Stampede season here in Calgary, Alberta. Heaven for alcoholics, adulterers, and adult costume wearers. Hell for prison populations, allergy experiencers, and intelligent people. It’s a time where it’s ok for 46 year old account managers to hit on 18 year olds having their first beer, because everybody is in a fun hat! I like some country-tinged music, but the time of year makes it hard and the album length was overkill. A lot of sameness to the tracks and that’s a recurring theme with these 50’s pop records. Good music, but overstays its welcome. Roll on fall. Rid me of the cowpoke scourge. Marty, you can stay, just don’t be so long-winded. 2.5-3 HIGHLIGHTS: Big Iron, Running Gun
Great storytelling and songwriting. Classical country album unfortunately just not for me
A cool Country album.
A really pleasant surprise. Some really enjoyable, memorable tunes that I'll find myself listening to again!
I forgot about El Paso! We used to play that with our band! This sounds like a classic
When people say they hate country music, it’s because they’ve never listened to this masterpiece. The five isn’t even ironic.
An old time Western on a record! I had limited time to listen to this but it was worth a spin. Big Iron, El Paso, and Cool Water were my favorites. A tip of the hat to Marty for being a surprisingly good singer too.
Voz muito boa, e eu gosto das histórias que ele conta. Surpreendemente, é um disco bem relaxante de ouvir casualmente. Eu gosto de country assim. A instrumentalização também é muito boa, apesar de simples. Bom álbum.
The only time I recall hearing the name Marty Robbins before this was on Endless Wire by The Who, so I wasn't sure what to expect. This record was badass. I'm an instant fan after hearing it.
Yeeee haaaww
Maso
I am not the biggest fan of country, but did enjoy this storytelling version of country far more than the current stuff. Still not my favorite though.
J’aurais pu mourir sans l’avoir écouté et sans avoir de regrets
Easy listening
I'd rather get a red rider BB gun and risk shooting my eye out than listening to this album. It's not my genre. In fact, I am not sure it still is a genre. Regardless, I got through it. It is fine, but it feels out of another time. I am sure that in its day, it was fine. Now, not so much.
Yeah it turns out that this simply cannot be rated in any meaningful way, because if you listen to this while smashing through the Lakes as the sun's going down on a train home from Glasgow then there is literally nothing finer to have on. Best song: Big Iron. But that was the opener during a particularly idyllic stretch. And A Hundred And Sixty Acres is a bit crap, so it benefits in retrospect from that.
I recognise a lot of these songs as Johnny Cash covered them afterwards. Not the worst album as some songs are moody and well written, but not the most "up my street" album. Probably won't choose to listen again
What I thought would be just a collection of cowboy songs turned out to be a masterclass in narrative songwriting. This album pulls me right into the saloons, deserts, and gunfights of the old west. I'm from El Paso, so listening to this made me homesick for chile relleños and dust devils.
Huge New Vegas vibes!
You know exactly what you're getting from Marty Robbins and an album title like that. Classic country.
Really solid album and sets a tone, nothing wrong with it and never really steps out of its lane and doesn’t take a lot of risks, yet still holds up really well 8/10.
Some good some meh.
Dripping with atmosphere and great songwriting. Wonderful stories in all songs, very enjoyable .
Great old style country western
Das hat irgendwie Spaß gemacht. Schräg, aber es macht das, was es soll. Unterhaltsam.
"With a big iron on his hiiiiiip" :D Ihan hyvää cowboy country outlaw kamaa kokonaisuudessaan. Tarinavetoisia kappaleita joista lyriikat meni kummiskin vähän ohi taas. Tää levyn kansikin on kyllä niin meemi :D Parhaat: Big Iron, El Paso, The Master's Call
Fallout vibes
FUCCKING TREMENDOUS
Giddy up
Straight up one of the best country albums of all time. Marty Robbins voice is crazy pleasant to listen to, and every song on it will just stick in your head totally rent free for the rest of time in a way that you'll find yourself belting along to them in the car every time you relisten to it.
(closeup shot of a tumbleweed) (the reviewer holding a gun, two legs open like in a western film's duel scene with Marty Robbins standing opposite them) Reviewer: Sorry, Mr, Robbins. This favour of Western is not my go-to choice. And also, i prefer other ballads, like pop ballads, rock ballads, and... MURDER BALLADS. (gun shot that happened so swiftly so that marty robbins was shot before he can draw) the critic from the future, looking at the dead body of marty robbins: im sorry for what i have do in the past like big iron is kinda fire. so the scores are increased by 1 and its now a 3/5 album. 3/5
Good performances, but each track blended together a bit too much. This had some fun moments though.
😂
I only knew about Marty Robbins thanks to New Vegas. None of his other songs are as good as Big Iron, but the more upbeat one are pretty good. I was tempted to give this 2 stars but it is really easy to listen to.
Badass western music. Not bad
01) Big Iron - 8,5 02) A Hundred and Sixty Acres - 8,0 03) They're Hanging Me Tonight - 7,5 04) Cool Water - 8,0 05) Billy the Kid - 7,0 06) Utah Carol - 7,0 07) The Strawberry Roan - 7,5 08) The Master's Call - 7,0 09) Running Gun - 7,0 10) El Paso - 8,5 11) In the Valley - 7,5 12) The Little Green Valley - 7,0 13) The Hanging Tree - 8,0 14) Saddle Tramp - 7,5 15) El Paso (full lenght version) - / TOTAL: 7,57 (76/100) Current ranking: 257/598
Quite the body count for light entertainment....
Hit me on the right day. Couldn’t stop listening. Loved it. Country from way back, before country went proper shit. Original gangsta rap? 4.75
Good performances, everything was too similar. Forgot about his song being in a Salsa or Taco kit commercial back years ago
Without a doubt, one of the singular most important country music albums of all time. Some of the most well known songs of the genre appear on this album. Not a skippable song on this one I feel. Also, who doesn't love to sing along to big iron while wandering the Mojave wasteland of New Vegas
Classic country album
This was a great introduction to this style of songwriting. As a historical document, I found it to be compelling. The production was surprisingly crisp for the era, even if this isn't my favorite type of music. Tough to say I'll come back to this, but I appreciate it for what it is.
one little kiss and felina goodbye 🔥
first country album ive ever appreciated this much. never been someone that hates genres as a whole but I have ignored some, country being a big one. this is really good though beautiful voice and guitar work best track: they're hanging me tonight worst track: in the valley
Interesting, but no.
I've mainly heard "El Paso" and "Big Iron" throughout the years. The whole album is great. Marty can sing the lights out.
Like most of my generation, my first exposure to Marty Robbins was through the medium of video games. His songs are good fun.
Nah
Great storytelling. Not too long of an album, so that gets a +.5 for me. Probably 3.5, rounding up.
How did country music go from the great melodies, performances, and story-telling of Marty Robbins to the utter travesty to music that is Morgan Wallen? If nothing else, this album demonstrates just how terrible modern country music is, and that's a shame. 5.0/5.0: Iconic
Great country album
BEST SONGS: - They're Hanging Me Tonight - Running Gun - The Hanging Tree
yess
I have a definite soft spot for old country that only came about in the last 10 or so years. This was a fun album to find. I knew the hit of El Paso but the rest were new but yet felt comforting.
What an absolute joy! A must for singer songwriters. A clinic on storytelling trough harmonies and melodies. A must for any good record collection.
Poking around online, I find that this album garners some extremely high praise. Something along the lines of “the significant piece of modern western music”. One can certainly trace the lines forward into today’s music. I found myself tapping my toe. And “El Paso” is a song that my family used to sing at get togethers when everyone who could play guitar would and the kids would get a washboard or rhythm sticks or a jug to play along. Definite sentimental value there for me. I’m struggling to rate this, thinking about my two scales. Sticking with 3.
Hell of a voice. This one could keep rising for me. 4/5
I should have used a private spotify session for this one, but I forgot. Nothing wrong with this album, it is what it says on the tin. I just can't imagine listening to it on my own volition.
hold up..! his writing is fire?
Starts off kind of fun.. I kind of like big iron. But really quite monotone and samey throughout the album. Very easy to start listening to the album but actually quite difficult after a few tracks
Not the typical genre I would listen to, but the song writing was really solid for it's time.
I’ve heard El Paso near 1000 times when Bob Weir sings it with The Dead. Cool to hear the original. I enjoyed these old western cowboy tunes. Great song writing about a time that’s long past us. Takes you there with his storytelling.
buf i dont know
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 1001 ALBUMS- # 60 🤠 Who knew ‘50s country ballads could be this entertaining?! Grandpa was onto something 🤠 The only familiarity I had to Marty Robbins and this album was with the track ‘El Paso’, which was perfectly placed in the Felina/Finale episode of TV’s masterpiece Breaking Bad. However a pleasant surprise here as the full song list is just as enjoyable! In the late 1950s, American popular music was in transition: rock ’n’ roll was gaining ground, Nashville country was smoothing its edges, and folk revivalists were stirring. Marty Robbins, already a successful country singer, decided to take a bold step: a concept album centered on the mythic American West. This album is a masterclass in narrative songwriting. Each song tells a vivid, self-contained story—often about cowboys, gunslingers, and the harsh frontier life. Robbins’ deep, expressive vocals lend gravity and emotion to tales of love, betrayal, and redemption. The production, arranged with classic western instrumentation—acoustic guitars, subtle harmonies, and occasional strings—is clean and timeless. The backing vocals by the Glaser Brothers add depth, and the arrangements never overshadow the stories. 🎧 Classic Track: El Paso 🎧 Deep Cut Gem: They’re Hanging Me Tonight 🎧 Personal Favorite: Cool Water 🎧 Memorable Standout: The Master’s Call Musically, Gunfighter Ballads is rooted in traditional Western stylings—acoustic guitar, light percussion, and echoing vocals that mimic the open plains. The Glaser Brothers provide subtle harmonies, while the production keeps the arrangements clean, never overshadowing Robbins’ storytelling. Each track feels like a self-contained scene, yet the album as a whole unfolds like a carefully constructed narrative. Even slower or more sentimental songs like “A Hundred and Sixty Acres” or “Little Green Valley” serve a purpose: they humanize the gunfighters and rangers, reminding listeners that beneath the bravado lies a longing for peace, love, and home. 🖼️ Album Artwork: Draw🔫 Themes of Morality plays: Good vs evil, justice vs vengeance, and spiritual reckoning appear in nearly every track. The cowboy mythos: Robbins is playing into and shaping the romantic idea of the lone gunfighter and rugged individualism. Death as inevitability: Nearly half the tracks end in death, violence, or existential resolution — tying into traditional balladry, where every tale has a moral. Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs isn’t just an album — it’s an American folktale in LP form. Marty Robbins’ warm baritone and precise storytelling elevate it far beyond genre convention. It’s simultaneously a nostalgic time capsule and a timeless work of art. Even today, it remains essential listening for fans of country, Americana, and lyrical songwriting.
This is so dope.
Eat shit and die
My goodness this makes me think of my grandfather. Such a good, classic album
2/5 besides big iron (which is a masterpiece) the other songs all sound similar and aren't very good.
Interesting wild west like music, lots of the same style
Definitely not for me. Just sounds like any other old western style music I've ever heard.
meh
Wow, very pleasantly surprised. Great harmonies, great lead voice, catchy melodies. I was worried it was going to be all old-timey.
Overall: 9/10 I used to play a lot of Fallout: New Vegas when I was in high school and the song Big Iron played on one of the radio stations you can listen to in that game. It was always my favourite song and years later, I found this album in a CD store and bought it as a joke just because Big Iron is on it. I ended up listening to it on the way home and fell in love with it. The best songs on this album are the ones that tell a story about outlaws. Storytelling seems to be Marty's biggest strength. I also love the harmonies. I don't listen to a lot of country but this is my favourite album from the genre that I've heard. Fav Song: Big Iron Least Fav Song: The Strawberry Roan
Someone had to make music for Saturday westerns in B&W. Roy Rogers and Dale, Tex Ritter - does this genre even exist anymore?
7.5/10 Really good. My favourite country album so far? This was no pretension, honest, simple music. Stories told well with minimal fuss. Best: Cool Water
I already love Big Iron, guitar riff in the background is great not my favourite
Howdy pilgrim… Fav:-
A bit boring for my taste…
Not what I’d usually listen to but I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. I like the harmonies (bass goes crazy) and resonant vocals. Seems like an album that a crowd would sing along to. Makes me want to sit around a campfire and sing lol. Great storytelling.
I feel like this whole album screams Fallout vibes (obviously, Big Iron is one of the most well-known songs from the franchise). That being said, this also means that the album is very one-note. There are multiple times where nearly the exact same tune appears in different songs, which I didn't really care for. This album was fun but nothing to write home about.
I kind of liked this even though it's not my cup of tea, it's almost ridiculously cliché and represents a cartoon (one could say childish) version of Western and Cowboy Life. It's well sung and played - no artistic gymnastics here but just plain Country and Western. Oddly, the music all sounds kind of the same (and quite fun), whether it is about being in love, or feeling the bullet deep inside his chest, and anything in-between. Not a Work of Art, but I'm happy for this to exist and I suppose it would have sounded different in 1959.
This album is perfect for what it is. Unfortunately given the current cultural cache of this music from fallout video games to tick tock trends I grow weary
Wow, I really loved this. so much nostalgia for this actual badass country music. His voice is absolutely amazing too
Great country singer, loved songs like El Paso, Strawberry Roan and Running Gun. A few others sounded like filler but as a fan of Johnny Cash, I enjoyed the outlaw vibe.
Can totally see how influential it is and deserving of cult status. Just not my jam.
Great stuff. Wears a little by about song 5 but really solid
Really enjoyed this album. Robbins has a great voice. I can see how many of these tracks have influenced other artists such as Jonny Cash. Big Iron my favourite.
To be honest I like the vibes, feels like you are at a campfire and listening to a story.The difference is the story is singed 3/5
Not my style. Competent for what it is
fun to listen to. good lyrics
This album deserves to be every bit as iconic as it is. Most records from the 50s sound so badly produced and, with the exception of jazz, tend to have aged incredibly badly. As such it’s compliment enough to say that an album from a musical era so bygone is listenable, and even enjoyable. It’s a joy to listen to a collection of songs from a time when my grandparents were children and get so much out of it. The songwriting too, particularly from a storytelling perspective, is very strong. For these reasons, I don’t at all dispute the album’s consistent placing on ‘1001 albums you should hear before you die’ lists, and the like. Having said that, by the end of the album, I did begin to find it repetitive. I acknowledge that it was limited by the technology of its time and higher production values were not available, or even in-keeping with the intentions of Robbins for that matter. However, there are many albums with just a voice and an acoustic guitar that manage to keep me on my toes for longer than this manages to. ‘Big Iron’ is the standout. It’s a great opener and one of many engaging storytelling moments on the record. The rest follow in a similar vein and by the end I grew ever so slightly tired of the same themes in every song (I know that’s the point of the album, but that doesn’t mean I have to enjoy it). Nonetheless, like I said, it’s highly regarded for a reason; its lyricism, vivid imagery and character painting having a great influence on many future songwriters.
Kivoga låtar med kivoga melodier och bra lyrics. Allt låter dock ganska lika. Bästa låten: Big Iron
This album has been memed to death, but it really is great. Proper storytelling cowboy songs, American songbook kind of shit. Leave your scepticism at the door and this album is nothing but a great time.
schun gonz cool, jo
Heck yeah. Great, easy-listening country tunes. Wish I had bought this on vinyl to listen first, feels like it needs some crackling to feel truly authentic
Enjoyed it
okie dokie. Not sure what to say about this music.
This is one of my favorite albums period. 5 Stars - great writing/storytelling and remarkably performed. My Step Father-In-Law introduced me to Marty Robbins and for that I am thankful to him for doing so.,
Surprisingly good, listened to it walking home in the rain Masters Call was especially good
El Paso Big iron They’re handing me tonight
Overly cheesy. Not for me
I have listened to this album so much due to Fallout New Vegas. It's not actually amazing, but very good.
I may not be a fan of this kind of music, but I liked it)
Це один з класичних кантрі альбомів минулого, який для багатьох буде занадто мінімалістичний. На відміну від більш сучасного, скажемо інді чи альт кантрі, тут не буде різноманіття інструментальних партій, складних абстрактних філософських тем та якоїсь експериментальної глибини. Він покладається на традиції класичної американської фолкмузики та має за ціль розповісти вам душевні історії, під невигадливі акустичні мелодії. В історіях зрештою і полягає його сила. Здебільшого це кавери на інших кантрі виконавців, або традиційні фолкпісні які є або оповідями про розбійників, або присвячені буденним проблемам. А зворушливий вокал Марті тільки додає їм імерсивності. Якщо ви любити кіно, то точно згадаєте сцену з фільму «Мерзенна вісімка», коли Дейзі співала піратську баладу граючи на гітарі. Так ось увесь цей альбом справляє таке саме враження. Звісно, в наш час його напевно що можна вважати «застарілим» та далеко не всім він через це сподобається, але ознайомитися з цією класикою точно варто кожному хто цікавиться сучасною музикою та хоче розуміти її історію.
Pretty solid overall, actual songs about gun fighting.
I enjoyed some tracks, but most tracks felt like a chore to get through. Once you’ve heard the first couple songs on this album, you’ve heard it all.
Hell yeah
Good old timey country ballads.
I just heard of this a couple weeks ago (I can’t remember why…) but I’m so glad it popped up bc I was excited to listen! It rocks!!
Came here to say this was goated and sauced but someone beat me to it
quite goated i suppose ... yes yes... with the sauce indeed
This is when songwriting actually meant something. Every instrument speaks to the subject matter of the song. Great stuff. Glad I finally listened to this.
Fun to hear these old cowboy songs. This album came out towards the end of Hollywood’s westerns obsession, ensuring a big audience. For all its quality it shows its age.
I am not the target audience for this album.
“BIG IRON ON HIS HIIIIIIIIP” Music like this taught me that I don’t hate country music, just the modern iteration of it.
really well written / good storytelling. felt like i was in a clint eastwood movie lol
Enjoyed. Some classics.
Weirdly fun album. I love this type of music, idk what it is called
The storytelling in these songs is fantastic, backed up with a great voice. Surprised by how much I liked this.
Pretty racist
Classic, Big Iron alone puts it as an instant classic, El Paso and Cool Water are equally strong
Rating: 3 Notable songs: big iron Really nostalgic and tranquil feeling listening to this. Gave me the proper feeling of a different time. Made me almost feel like I was in the fallout games. I would listen to similar genres and time period as this, but as a whole its was just fine.
The lyrics say “outlaw”, but the music doesn’t reflect that in the slightest.
Fantastic album. "Big Iron" is undeniable. Other gems on this are "They're Hanging Me Tonight", "The Master's Call", "El Paso" and "Saddle Tramp". Barely misses being 5 stars as it is a little monotonous in parts. Amazing voice though adn the songs are good. Really good stuff.
Just a classic. The platonic ideal of this sound.
I had no idea such a thing could exist, and my world is now better for it. So great it makes me want to make a Quentin Tarantino homage film.
Talk about taking me back to a place and time. I used to listen to Texas radio in the late 60s staying up later than my bedtime under the blankets with a transistor radio.
classic shit.
I feel like its a rite of passage to listen to this album if youve played fallout new vegas. The songs have really good storytelling and put you into the atmosphere of the album really well. I just dont listen to this album enough to really enjoy it as much as id like. 7/10 Favourite: El Paso Least Favourite: A Hundred and Sixty Acres
Not much a fan of country but this is legit. This is real country music. Stories.
moc kantry
This ruled
quite literally a bunch of wild west ballads that are mournful and sad and often involve suffering and sort of the Appalachian ballad type of songs of death and lost love
Tedious.
8/10 super fun, but a little too repetitive, every song sounds the same but the western genre is amazing, and this is arguably the most iconic example
Divertidísimo, nostálgico, genial. Cuando me salió un disco llamado "Baladas de pistoleros y canciones para la vereda", pensé: Esto puede ser lo peor o lo mejor que he escuchado jamás. Y qué manera de pasármela bien, de divertirme y de meterme a un saloon, darle unos besos a una dama ajena, empezar una balacera y luego reflexionar sobre mi vida mientras espero en una celda a que llegue la hora de la horca. Así de bueno es este disco.
Marty BOBBINS more like!! (wasn't actually that bad)
Surprisingly enjoyed this
Kind of enjoyed the storytelling in the songs
I think Erwin and Bob would’ve fucked with this music back in the day
Not convinced he’s an actual cowboy 🤔
A bit cheesy.
Cowboy Elvis.
Uf - isch das sozialromantischi Musig. Hät aber schöni Harmonie und Backgroundgsang.
oh wow big iron isch jo suuuuper sini stiiimm und d bgvs AAAH wooow. a hundred and sixty acres isch country wini vor paar johr schlimm gfunde hett und jetz findis no cool und stimmig. theyre hanging me tonight isch heeeavy hobla als text. musig mega cute afoch höhö. billy the kid isch npt bsunders er isch afoch am gschichte verzelle jetz bi utah carrol au. running gun au wieder sehr cool. aber s goht etz biiitz a mir verbii. in the valley isch fantastisch, country harmonies ouuuuyeeeah. the hanging tree harmonisch jo huuuere geil whatt. er singt immerno fantastiiisch.
uuuh big iron findi reeecht cool? er het iwie so e fründlichi stimm mengisch auchli wie de elvis? wow unnötige flex mit dim real estate they're hanging me tonight isch recht krass aber halt au...schön? FUCK CHANER SINGE hahahaha es isch mal es meme worde? weg fallout? the master's call isch unnötig schön???? gnueg christlich aber naja DAD ALTE HAUS VON ROCKY DOCKYYYYY also es het mich zumindest ah das erinneret lol el paso findi naja für das, dass es sin berüehmtist song isch ah nvm jz ischs natürlich big iron hahahah muss immer mindestens 1 person sterbe ih sine lieder? sorry de marty het würkli kein grund zum so banger ah banger annenand z reihe FOIFOIFOIFOIF
What is David Schwimmer doing with a big iron on his hip? (big iron on his hiiiiip)
Far more enjoyable than I anticipated.
Full of foundational texts, but it all starts to blend together into a single Ur-song after you've listened for a while.
This album gave me nostalgia for my grandparents. And then I heard “El Paso” and realized I’ve certainly heard this before.
A perfect concept album for degenerates like me who belong on a cross
Do you like Big Iron? Well here's 14 other songs that also sound like Big Iron. Great voice from Marty Robbins though.
Interesting but not for me.
🤠
The previous album to this one for me was Gram Parsons, which I didn't mind, however now listening to this album it blows Gram out of the water. Really great storytelling, I could see myself revisiting this one.
Pretty good album. Enjoyed the lyrics and very catchy. 4/5
Not my taste. But good singing and good songs overall. Respect for its significance in the genre.
eu, uma 10mm fudida e uma estrada empoeirada enquanto dou fuga de um deathclaw q saudade de fallout nv pprt
IH eh a música do fallout new vegas! country da melhor forma. é bom? não. mas escutável
Every song sounds like one continuous ballad because the singer is a one trick pony, and certainly doesn’t sound like he is or has ever been on any trail. Who ever put this list together wasn’t qualified
Favorites: Big Iron, Cool Water, They're Hanging Me Tonight, El Paso Before listening to this album as a whole, I was only familiar with Big Iron, as it was one of the first 7" records I added to my collection. This album is chock full of fantastic western and early outlaw country standards, with each one having its own personality and flavor, which I really appreciated. Robbins's career is storied and long, but I imagine that this record, which left a lasting impression on country music as a whole, stands out as his absolute best.
Not really my type of music but it is quite enjoyable, there's some good songs here like Big Iron
Lots of hype - ok album
i feel like i’ve been transported to texas with this kind of music and honestly i’m here for it.
album vo 1960 so country style (?). eis lied no nice gfunde de rest esch halt eif ned so min stil. und es esch eifach no recht sexistisch gsi was chli wtf gsi esch
red dead redemption type music
what was going on in American culture that this became a thing? Cowboys and such were well done by the 1950s...nostalgia? Amazing voice, although I'd prefer hearing him harmonize with someone else than himself.
1959. Country. Western. 7/10
Big Iiiron
Surprised at my enjoyment of this…
I quite enjoyed this, storytelling from the old days
Let's take a formula and refine it and polish it to perfection. Marty Robbins is a master and telling the 'old western' tale.
Knallsterk start. Blir dessverre veldig mye likt etterhvert. En og to innimmellom gjør seg, men ikke hele albumet i ett kjør.
Varmt og godt
Reminds me of Johnny Cash, paints a solid picture with lyrics and is a good story teller. It was alright.
I'm surprised by how much I liked this, being I'm not a Country person at all. But I guess this isn't exactly like other Country music. The arrangements are fuller and the songwriting is just so smooth. More true cowboy vibes than we usually get from this kind of record. Key tracks: Big Iron Cool Water Billy The Kid El Paso
Really enjoyable. Well written songs which tell folk tales set to complimentary music. Somewhere between a 4 and a 5, but Big Iron is always a banger and deserves the rating.
OG Outlaw. Marty Robbins my beloved, murder ballads my beloved, songs about cattle my beloved, this album brings me so much joy, Marty's voice and lyrics are always so precise and paint such a clear picture to follow around. For fun bit of info Chappell Roan gets her name partially from the Strawberry Roan song (her grandpa's favorite song). Personal favorites : Big iron, They're Hanging me Tonight, The Master's Call, Running Gun, El Paso, Saddle Tramp. Basically any song where someone dies. To add to the list the Colter Wall version of Big Iron is one of my favorites - the whole Western Swing & Waltzes is a masterpiece and falls into the tradition of this kind of album.
Marty has an angelic voice, but some of these tracks are straight from real hell, like "160 acres" or "strawberry roan", which have that creepy obnoxious cadence that "happy" by pharrell williams has (goddamnit i hate that song). Some pluses: has some nice lyrical storytelling, I like the background vocals (especially that bass voice), and there are some nice, less creepy (more sad) songs, like Big Iron and El Paso. I can see the clear influence Marty has had on country and culture today (including obsession with guns?).
There's something relaxing about simple gunslinger stories over soft acoustic and rhyme scheme. But I've never been a fan of the Johnny Cash / Nick Cave style of idealizing violence behind some masculine machismo. That being said, the whole album felt like a dark spin on something Andy Griffith would sing to Aunt B on his porch after dinner, and the vocals on El Paso were impressive. I can see me picking up this album when I need some light and breezy music. 3.5 rounded down seems reasonable.
I love this album. The overly schmaltzy vocals are a bit much, but this simple, earnest album is pleasant and works with it. Big Iron is a riot. Only major complaint is that it’s too long. But it also doesn’t quite rise above the masses, so it’s a solid 4 stars from me.
i liked this album a lot. reminded me of an older era of musicianship
It's like being in Fallout !
Big Iron is iconic and El Paso is solid too, nice simple storytelling songs. There is about two songs worth of material in this album. Marty Robbins is a fine singer and a pretty good performer in general, and nothing really sticks out as particularly bad. But most of these songs sound the same, and song after song of the exact same cowboy-themed mush is not a lot of fun. I also don't really like the background singers, and the instrumentals are very dull, repetitive, and best ignored. This album certainly provides quite an authentic cowboy experience - really transports you into the saddle of a horse in the wild west, watching cows walk across miles of featureless grassland.
If Elvis was a cowboy. I don’t mean this in a good way.
Loved this album. Love the story telling in this album. I have many fond memories of Marty Robbins.
. Pass
WTf!
It was fine for what it was