Reviews (page 9 of 14)
Very catchy songs, happy to finally discover country music ( i think it's country ? ). I find the music a bit childish but it's nonthenless great.
Cowboys hiya chevals chapeaux youpi vive le grand Ouest. De la country mielleuse.
Thought I'd scan through the reviews as I listened to this. You really get a sense of the overwhelming lack of empathy from what I assume is mostly younger folks. Might not be younger folks. But the crowd that uses "I hate country" and "this is cheesy" and "I'm not a cowboy so I can't relate" and so on as their justification for dismissing this album are curiously bereft of any ability to connect with anything or anyone outside of their narrow range of interest. Even the video game crowd can sort of only connect with the one song that was in that video game they play. Isn't the point of going on this "1001 records" journey to be exposed to records from different genres, different cultures, different time periods? It seems as though many are seeing it as an opportunity to talk about all the ways they managed to be offended by a record. And then there's those who want to compare this to gangsta rap thanks to the subject matter. Some of the songs on Robbins' album are old traditional songs written back in a time when the west really hadn't been settled yet, and the world was an entirely different place than, say, '90s Compton. And recognizing the huge cultural impact this and subsequent albums, tv shows and movies had... the "western" was ubiquitous back in the day. This record absolutely deserves to be on this list for any number of reasons. For me, ultimately, I see his perfectly clean suit and shoes on the cover, and hear the beautifully sung music with no rough edges other than the words themselves, and it feels like a museum piece... unlike the feeling I get when I hear Hank Williams Sr. "El Paso" I've known since I was a kid, I don't remember where I first heard it, it's lilting melody belies the dark story... "Big Iron" is great and "Cool Water" I know from Sons of the Pioneers. I can do about 4 songs on this before the production start sounding samey. Beautiful, but samey. I just encourage people to see the beauty in the world, see the beauty in the records you are unfamiliar with, learn about the artist or circumstances around the recording the album or its cultural impact... practice finding something positive to say.
Yeah... not my cup of tea. Not much of a gunfighter or in need of a trail song. This seems to be the kind of music that rock and roll rose up as a counterpoint to. The only situation I could see liking this music would be in Frontierland at Disneyland.
I was bored after 3 minutes of track 1. A minute into track 2 I was irritated. A minute into track 3 I gave up. Not my kind of thing. 1/5
He has a lovely voice and some really pretty harmonies. I really really don't love this genre, the stories are all basically country and western stories of stealin' girls and shootin' bad'uns and rustlin' horses. I can see the charm and I didn't hate it, but it's not really for me. Tip of the cap for El Paso, though, which is a brilliant song and immediately brought me back to watching Breaking Bad.
1st song is the best in the album.
5/5 no notes. Big Iron, they're hanging me tonight and the master's call.
All the sounds were about the same thing. No variation at all.
pretty fun for what it is
Nej tack. Rätt trist country. Inte min kopp te alls.
Det här tycker jag var en kul överraskning som var lätt att tycka om. Så här ska cowboy-country låta!
Enjoyed - smooth vocals. Only problem for me is that cannot really relate to Cowboy songs about horses so kinda washed over me with no emotional hook.
Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs I really enjoyed this, putting me in mind of The Big Lebowski or a very watchable western on TV on a Sunday afternoon. It’s an interesting genre, Western music, I do like it, mainly as I like a lot of the 50s and 60s western movies. It has probably been subsumed by Country and Country & Western, but I really like its Spanish influenced non-fiddle folk feel, and that it’s immediately evocative of a specific time and place, however mythical that world may be. He has a very 50s voice, almost like a crooner, and he has a great sense of small scale drama that really suits the relatively simple backing and the themes and well constructed stories of the songs. I particularly liked Big Iron, Cool Water, They’re Hanging Me Tonight, The Strawberry Roan, Running Gun and Utah Carol I could happily listen to this all day, it’s on the cusp of 3 and 4, I’ll tip over to 4 as I’m sure I’ll revisit this more. 🤠🤠🤠🤠 Playlist submission: Big Iron
The production sounds great compared to many contemporaneous efforts - reverbed, Everly's-style harmonies, nicely mixed. It's the sound of the Western plains, and it is more Western than Country. Overall, I thought this a great embodiment of this tradition, interesting, excellently produced, and with some great originals, and excellent playing and harmonies.
Wie aus einem Paralleluniversum. Ungenießbar.
I was in a 60s mood today. After listening to a random 60s playlist, I remembered this project and came to find a 60s album. Unfortunately this one didn't really hit the spot.
4.5
Easy listening.
When you say that you like country, you are talking about modern pop country. When I say that I like country, I am talking about this kind of country. We are not the same. The storytelling of the songs is just incredible. I'm nearly in tears listening to El Paso. The vocal work of the entire album is really good. The harmonies are phenomenal, and it's a joy to listen to Marty sing. Everything about the album is simple (as it is music from '59), but I think that just adds to the charm of it. I'm not overwhelmed or absolutely in awe of the album, but it is very good from beginning to end. Favorite Song(s): Big Iron, The Master's Call, El Paso
65. Pleasant but it all sounds the same. Good for a night drive or to listen indoors looking at a foggy day outside.
Old
They're hanging me tonight felt more 50s sock hop them cowboy. Overall not bad just not my thing. There is some beauty in the storytelling in the songs. It's straight forward but it's also a good reminder of folklore and story telling traditions through song. Makes me think of some of the songs origin and the cowboy lifestyle long ago. Not wanting to go back but just good examples of a time gone by.
Nope. Couldn’t get into this. Not my thing.
This album is another example of the universe sending a wink. I recently watched an interview with my current pop obsession, Chappell Roan, who is truly freaking awesome btw, saying she chose her name by combining her grandfather’s last name and his favorite song: The Strawberry Roan by Marty Robbins. Lo and behold, here we are. This is the version of country music that I’m 100% in love with. Melodies! Talent! Simplicity! As a kid I would’ve balked hard at this, but age sometimes brings maturity through experience and keeping a mostly open mind. That open mind comes from chilling to grandma’s country records after she passed away 10 years ago, and connecting to her soul through the music she loved. This album wasn’t in her collection, but some of these songs, recorded by similar artists, were. There's not a skip to be had on this.
There was nothing offensive about this, and it was relatively pleasant to my ears, but I just can’t relate to being an old-timey cowboy.
Really good western music. I have heard some of these songs before but listening to the whole album was pretty cool. I'm not sure I would listen to it again but it's classic western type music that I enjoyed. I don't think that I would seek it out to listen again though.
I was familiar with "El Paso" but nothing else. Interesting to read that "Big Iron" had a viral moment because it was included in a video game in 2010. I find this kind of music ages a little better than other genres.
Fun and charming, but also feels kitschy by today's standards. Also telling that people complain about rap being too violent, meanwhile this album might as well be call "Jaunty Homocide."
Quaint and not unpleasant to listen to, but not anything I'd go out of my way to go back to.
Real talk, the best thing the Fallout games did was introduce old-ass bangers like this to a new generation. I wouldn't have given the album much thought without them. This kind of slaps? It's an album full of skits, sung with rich harmonies and twinkly Spanish guitar. What's not to love?
Fun country ballads! Not something I would seek out though
I was once in a semi-fictional band called Nevermind Mr Bear, and this is what we aspired to be. Unfortunately we lost all our music when MySpace ‘accidentally’ fucked up their data migration. This is good at first and then every song is the same!
Classic sounds from old westerns, yes, but must hear? No.
It’s country, but not the kind I hate. This is bearable.
What I expected to hear: cowboy music What I heard: cowboy music, I did recognize El Paso If you like cowboy/country/western music you will love this album. I don't, so this was a tough one to get through.
It was alright for a western type album. But only 3 stars.
Not for everyone, but for people who like this era of music and feeling like their in fallout it's good fun
Nasal sluggish vibrato country western. Not for me.
еми изкефи ме
Tem a importância por apresentar "Big Iron" que boa mesmo é na versão do Johnny Cash. No mais, foi esperar acabar os 40 minutos restantes.
Western, country music. I can't say it's bad, but couldn't make it to the end of the album. 3/10
Great old tunes from a master song stylist! Instantly recognizable voice, and catchy classic country songs.
I’m surprised how good this sounds for being receded in 1959. I really enjoyed this one, added it to a couple playlists and I’m gonna go further into his catalog.
Ha! I listened to this one a few months ago when I was in El Paso. Great Western music with nice harmonies and storytelling. Definitely a classic. El Paso stands out as a favorite. 4 on this one.
The vibe of this album reminded me of those songs from old Disney movies with the chorus of session singers - - I guess coming out of the same era there are certain common hallmarks of the songwriting, arrangement or production, and it's all delivered in Mary's warm, rich baritone croon. The effect is that even when Marty is singing about putting notches on a pistol, casually taking a bullet to the chest, or describing the charms of Mexican women, everything sounds sort of smooth and sanitized and jaunty to my modern ears, which is kind of amusing. This album delivered exactly what the title promised: musical storytelling about the Old West. Everything here was perfectly executed, and I can't find fault with any aspect of this album, which clearly comes from that era when musicians had to have overt raw talent and ability. I just want to know what Felina did to be continually called wicked. God forbid a girl have dark eyes and dance in cantinas! 💃
Wow. I enjoyed this one more than I thought I would. My dad was a Marty Robbins fan, but as a kid I just never really got into any of Robbins's songs and was only familiar with El Paso. The first song on here was killer. Good story telling, cool background vocals and despite the simplicity it was a really interesting song. I ended up listening to Big Iron probably 3 or 4 times. Marty has a rich crooner type voice and his singing sounds effortless. He reminded me a bit of the Everly Brothers, Roy Orbison and Buddy Holly. Halfway through the album I found myself thinking 'how in the hell did country go from this to what contemporary country music is now'? This album is almost cinematic in a way and has good fundamentals.
💜
An extraordinarily pleasant surprise! Beautiful voice, and delicious irony of such a smooth sound belying such sad tales. Interesting, compelling, fascinating.
I absolutely loved this one! The story telling and lyrics were compelling and the accompanying music strummed along perfectly. Now i probably wouldn’t listen to this one regularly, this is one of those albums that surprised me in how easy it was to enjoy.
the formula of singing 8 songs about murder and then 1 or 2 about jesus never fails to crack me up. this music sounded great and he has a really good voice.
There's like 3 song templates on this album and then there's like 3 or 4 versions of each template, but thankfully they are pretty good
yeehaw
Fallout: New Vegas OST
Awesome!
Yeehaw
El Paso is one of the greatest songs ever. The rest were some very good country and western songs too.
"Gunfighter Ballads And Trail Songs" gave me a feeling that few country albums give me. It's a bit of a cheesy album, you could say, but I felt my guard down while listening to it, and for some unknown reason it made me smile. I may not own a gun, but this album made me feel like I did. And somehow, that made me relate to the story of the album.
nice sound, i love when an artist tells a story with lyrics like this. feels like a lost art, you dont hear this sound or type of lyricism that much nowadays, but its a fun one!
Now country in general is not one of my go to genres. I have a bit of exposure to much early country music as well, having grown up with it to a large degree. It just never entered my soul, as such. But I would not say that Marty Robbins, or this album is quite the same thing. Most of the country I am used to is short, tragic tales of down on ones luck, hard drinking, gambling, I don't know... But this is more like stories being told. Hard luck? Not so much, more about choices and the fate that brings. I found I had to pay attention to the songs as stories and did not pay attention to the music as much. I actually really enjoyed some of these ballads, regardless of how different from my own life they are. PS: being a gunslinger might not be the best choice of career.
7/10
love this so much... so smooth... big iron! they're hanging me tonight dude.... dude.
Y'know, I've liked a lot of the traditional country music my group has gotten, but I'd never been particularly "WOW"ed by any of it. There's a place for it in my heart, but when you put it next to country music from the 90's... Traditional country music just doesn't seem to have as much going on. Like, I'm a sucker for that kind of over-production and high pop-ish energy. So all this spare guitar strumming and close harmony vocals just doesn't hit **as** well for me — unless you're Johnny Cash, but that's the typical exception. So here along comes an album which... Honestly, for the longest time, I'd kind of avoided listening to? Specifically because its opening track, "Big Iron", was such a big meme. Which, that sort of thing isn't unique to this album, by the way; there's a lot of stuff I've been turned off to 'coz I encountered the memes of it first. Look at Scott The Woz, for instance. And it's not even like I'd heard any of the "Big Iron" edits, by the way. I just saw the thumbnails with the album cover all mangled up and I was like, "No thanks." Unsurprisingly, I had nothing to worry about. This isn't just good country; I'd go so far as to call it **classically** good country. The bedrock kind of country music so much afterwards is built on; the kind of country music you think of when you think "traditional country music." And it's all about the story-telling — and I don't know if the stories here are really any more or less interesting than the ones I've heard on other country albums, but whatever the reason, I got pulled into this one way more. And, like, I'm not sure if I can even go into any more detail than that. It's just really good playing and singing, relaying good stories that are easy to follow along with. (And if there's anything **I** need, it's stories that are easy to follow, goodness.) I can give it a 5, easy. Maybe I'll look back and think I'm too generous, but, hey, all the last few traditional country albums my group got could give me were "good beer on the porch songs." I'm happy to get anything with a little more depth to it than that. And, hey, if the "Big Iron" memes helped introduce people to this music, then I can hardly be too mad at it, now can I? (Especially since I never even heard any. Goodness, my occasional inclination to dislike popular things, I swear...)
While the first track on the album is legendary thanks to a certain Nevada-based game which I will try to not name as a challenge, the other songs on today's record do certainly hold up on their own regard, with The Master's Call being a highlight for me. Pretty solid 4 in my book.
I’m at a 5. It’s just great storytelling, man. Every track here just nails it. I know I harp on “old country” a lot, but this goes a bit beyond that – this is a fabulous showcase of music as a device for pure storytelling. I think sometimes it’s very easy to get caught up in neat instrumentation, melodies or vocals, and I’m as guilty of that as anyone, but this is just pure storytelling. Yes, his vocals are great throughout this album, and his higher registers are stunningly emphatic, but what makes this album work is in the simplicity of it all. Most of these have really easy vocal patterns in the verses & choruses, really basic instrumentation in the guitar, and all the strength is laid out in the lyrics, which have more of a poetic scheme to them. It’s very easy to follow along to, and it is a reminder that music, as an art form, was originally made for stuff that sounds like this, at its very core, because it was made to be easily digestible, teachable, and shared to the masses. I really liked it – it just clicked wonderfully for me, and it does make me sort of yearn for music to be this “simple” again. OK, well, maybe not this simple, but I’d love to be able to just sing a song without having to feel like I need to hit a whistle note like Mariah Carey or anything. It is pure country music, plain and simple, and it should be up there within the standards of the genre itself. That’s just how you do it; easy 5.
Buster Scruggs the musical.
Pas pour moi...
I had never heard of Marty Robbins, I am not interested in western vibes of music. I was shocked that I knew a song from the album “Big Iron” and that was pretty catchy. I probably won’t give this album another listen, but maybe it will be good small talk with my grandpa
Like fallout and rdr2 had a baby
I'm not a fan of country music and thought I was going into this blind. Turns out that I already knew a couple of the songs. El Paso was in Breaking Bad and I've heard a cover of Big Iron, although I didn't know it was a cover until now. The storytelling in this album is top notch. I love the vivid imagery that each song paints. Most songs on this album are brilliant, although I feel there a couple that fall a little short.
Macho music that boosts confidence.
Grateful Dead has covered El Paso, so when I heard it, it was the Leonardo DiCaprio meme. Good listen, not in my normal wheelhouse, but that’s why I’m doing this challenge. Would listen to some of the songs again.
I like the content, although the songs are pretty monotonous
Hard to track some of these stories but damn if I don't like some of these melodies. I wonder if D'Angelo listened to this while writing SDM.
Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs by Marty Robbins is pure cowboy poetry — smooth, nostalgic, and packed with Western charm. But let’s be honest: if you’re here giving this album five stars, there’s a good chance you wandered in from the Mojave Wasteland. Thanks to Fallout: New Vegas, tracks like “Big Iron” and “Cool Water” have taken on near-mythic status. Hearing Big Iron kick in while patrolling the desert with a revolver and questionable morals? Unmatched. Suddenly, Robbins’ rich voice and storytelling aren’t just old-school country — they’re the soundtrack to dusty showdowns and wandering loners trying to do the right thing in a broken world. Outside the Fallout connection, the album is still a gem. Robbins was a master storyteller, and songs like “El Paso” and “The Master’s Call” hold up as classic narrative-driven country. But it’s the pop culture revival that makes this record feel alive again. So yes, this is five stars — not just for the quality, but for the sheer atmosphere it brings to anyone who’s roamed the Mojave with Big Iron on his hip.
5.0
Bra för att vara den genren men tråkigt. 2+
It's fun, and Big Iron is great, but it's really hard to take this album seriously.
Yee haw. Quite the vibe. Sunday morning TV stuff
Big Iron. It's a chill time, I guess if anything harms my enjoyment is that I'm not a country guy but somehow this album feels familiar with the tejano influences.
Clean, well produced and sparse. There are just a few instruments and you make out each instrument and they never trample over the vocals. The songs tell stories and if you listen you can imagine what's going on as the vocalist weaves his tale. A C&W masterpiece.
frekar skemmtilegt bara. hlusta aftur. 3,5.
This was great! My Grandpa is a huge Marty Robbins fan but I've never really bothered to listen to him. A great album. Great songs, great musicians, what a voice! And these songs really tell some great and even dark stories. I got chills when I heard "They're Hanging Me Tonight". This is the best new album I've discovered on this list so far.
Great voice (if a bit formal and over-trained), crisp and professional delivery. Not the most darkly-delivered murder ballads, but the rich smoothness of the voice and polished playing contrast intriguingly with the grim content. However, there is a paradox in hearing a condemned man and one dying of thirst voice their plights in such balanced, even polished, fashion. Personally one likes the close mixture of thanos and eros especially when there's a backing chorus that seems to sing for uplift (e.g., "The Hanging Tree). A true piece of Americana, this, and quite worth hearing, even if it's not exactly outlaw country.
Just wasn't my thing
Rätt lyssningsbart faktiskt. Några oväntat bra låtar.
... but my felinas shoot me with 12 gauge rounds
It was good, but... same ish?
Flo sounds based ngl
Really fun listen but got a little repetitive towards the end. Big iron is a jam.
Va duro.
Big Iron is a certified hood classic (shoutout fallout new Vegas). The rest of this album is rootin…and certainly tootin
There’s an unhurried grace to these songs, a kind of quiet confidence. It calls to mind the storytelling style of Willie Nelson, but more grounded and direct. The melodies are timeless, and the lyrics are vivid, like stepping into a sepia-toned memory.
I loved this so much more than I was expecting to. His voice is truly lovely, and the backing vocals complement him so nicely. And not only is the storytelling great, the lyrics flow like water, the meter a perfect match for the melody. And the melodies! One of my favorite moments is that climb and fall on the word wind in El Paso. Delightful. This is what I'd been hoping for when I had my Waylon Jennings album, which, while still good, just didn't leave the same impression that this did. When I listen to country music, this belongs in the rotation.
Really great. Enthusiastic and candy like while cartoonishly dark and morbid. What a fun piece of history.
I don't really like it but my horse kinda likes it so it's a 2
good western country, not mine
My initial reaction was “uuuugghh no thank you” but honestly, embarrassingly liked it. Catchy and sweet
This album might more properly be called "Songs About My Own Violent Death" but you gotta give credit to Marty Robbins, he writes a hell of a tune. It's crazy that this album was recorded in 8 hours. His voice sounds great, and his ballads are all fun stories (that generally end in his violent death) 4/5
Unique and perfect for this list. The voice is impeccable and the story telling is top notch
Favorite Track: El Paso
Very fun, reminds me of playing Fallout. 3.3 stars
Kinda fun in the same way that watching movies from that era is kinda fun, but not anything I would play on repeat.
I can get behind county like this
Coming into this one with a bit of knowledge about the album beforehand. This is the peak of western music and contains some of the greatest country songs ever made. Get me a pint of golden water and a cowboy hat - yeeeeeeehawww
4.5 Outlaw country. A couple epic songs: Big Iron, El Paso
This album is ICONIC. It is basically the epitome of western country music. Marty Robbins was a master of story-telling, and his voice fits cowboy ballads perfectly. As someone who grew up in the "west" this album makes me nostalgic for an era that Marty didn't even experience. I don't know what magic was put into this album, but it deserves its spot in the annals of history. Best Songs: Big Iron, Billy The Kid, El Paso, Saddle Tramp Worst Songs: NA
Some swell guitar picking and singing.
How do I rate a collection of songs that I personally do not care for or about but recognize the importance of to the broader cultural landscape of this country?
This is what I would be if I was a cowboy. Just four part harmonies with my boys, posing, and singing lil story songs.
favourite song - the little green valley favourite lyric - but the weight upon the saddle had not been felt before / his backcinch snapped like thunder and he fell by lenore / picking up the blanket he swung it over his head / and started cross the prairie, "lay still lenore" he said cover - 5/10 album overall - 4/5
Jaah respekti kolmosta
Nice and gentle and sonorous and not at all for me thank you very much.
Not a single skip I fear……
A selection of soft country western songs with each song telling a story.
Breaking Bad reference!
Yup
A little samesie, but I won't knock Marty for a-knowing what he knows.
A cool record filled with descriptive, scenic, and catchy country songs. Prior to hearing this record, the only song I knew by Marty Robbins was Big Iron; But I’m learning that even outside of that track, Robbins has knack for storytelling through his music and seems to do it through relative ease. And I love the artistry displayed in the guitars. Those and the singing accompaniment compliment Robbins’ singing so well. Definitely a great find to have on this list and is very unique compared to what I’ve heard so far. Favorite track: They’re Hanging Me Tonight
i hate country
11/11/24 A brilliant album and each song tells its own story.
Classic. Know most of these by heart. I love the storytelling of all of these songs. Just the type of country that I enjoy. One of my faves is "El Paso" and "Utah Carol"
Omg so fun! The lyrics tell like dreamy story of the west full of gunsligers and outlaws... Immediadly starting with Big Iron put the expectations high, a few songs were kinda repetitive but still good. I think only thing is like this music is for certain kind of feeling but you could argue that all music is Quality also great, Marty sings kinda well?? Am i crazy for saying that?
One of my favorite country singers. This album is truly phenomenal. Hard to even pick a favorite, when most of the album was truly amazing.
I love storytelling in songs and this album is bookended by two really nice ones in Big Iron and El Paso. But most of the rest of the album is really dull prewar type melodies which I cannot stand :(
The man with the big iron on his hip featured on this album. I didn't know it was so legendary, but it was a great listen.
Not my favorite type of music but I understand the appeal. Good for background music. Probably will not listen again unless a special circumstance arises.
I have listened to this record for over 40 years. It somehow makes the violent, tragic, and hopeful world of the old west in the US come alive beautifully. I am a fan of Marty, and even enjoy his Hawaiian music. Check it out!
El Paso is a fantastic song. More of the same on the rest of the album. Not really my style though.
Made me want to be a gunfighter. Tons of fun.
I thought this album was cute. Fun to listen to an album from the 50s. I enjoyed my time 3/5
Loved it. Knew Big Iron from Fallout: New Vegas. Just love this kind of music, and Marty Robbins is an amazing singer. The large group version of E Paso was the cherry on top. Standouts: Big Iron, They’re Hanging Me Tonight, Cool Water, The Strawberry Roan, The Master’s Call, The Hanging Tree, and El Paso.
trotos
Nice enough. Sometimes it got a little repetitive, but overall there were no tracks I actively disliked.
Great voice
Actually suffers a little from being listened to as an album - every song is solid but they lose impact sat right next to each other.
Aika erikoinen täällä seassa, tai siis taidokas lajissaan ja vaikuttavaa laulua tämä on, mutta en voinut olla kuuntelematta tätä soundtrackina (olemattoman elokuvan). Vähän liian kiillotettu paketti. El Paso on kyllä hyvä.
Kitschiä mutta kieltämättä viihdyttävää. Osuva sovitus ja tuotanto korvaa yllättävissä määrin biisinkirjoituksen yksipuolisuutta. Big Iron on ainutlaatuinen - myös siitä huolimatta, että pari biisiä tälläkin LP:llä kuulostaa ihan samalta.
I enjoyed this, it sounded like every country song ever to appear on a Tarantino soundtrack.
Não sabia que tinhamos um country progressivo. Muito boa as letras e a voz do Marty Robbins. Big Iron é um faroeste caboclo melhorado..
Was ist ein Sattelschlepper im Wilden Westen? Ein Cowboy ohne Pferd xD Fand das Album cool
Bangeralbum.
Interessant angefangen, aber dann nicht unbedingt interessanter geworden. Das Albumcover ist einfach lustig schlecht Songs der Playlist hinzugefügt: Big Iron
Całkiem spoko jak na country
This starts off with a -1 star rating purely because of the goofy ass album cover. I joke of course but wow it's awful. Anyway, this is half an hour of songs about the wild west and gunslingers. It evokes imagery of being in a saloon with duelling pistols at dawn going on outside. I wasn't expecting to enjoy this, but Marty Robbins' voice is like smooth liquid gold and the tracks are just catchy and fun. 'El Paso' swings along nicely. The vocal line actually sounds like a gallop. 'Big Iron' is the most famous apparently and I can see why. This and 'The Masters Call' are the best offerings. They sound very similar, you could probably sing one over the other and it would fit. They both have this rhyming couplet thing going on where the first line ends with a higher tone and the second line ends with a lower tone. It gets stuck in your head. Overall it does start to get a bit samey towards the end, but I can't believe I enjoyed this as much as I did. I'm glad it's on this list and I was able to discover it!
I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. Very different vibe than today’s country music. Enjoyed his voice and the more direct storytelling style, even if the stories were mostly about people he needs to shoot.
I actually really enjoyed listening to this album
Pure classic!
Third slice of pure Americana thrown my way in this project. Can’t say it’s growing on me but this wasn’t the worst thing I’ve ever heard either.
Enjoyed a few of these, like Big Iron and The Master’s Call
I find Western music generally easy to listen to, this album being no different in that respect. Nice tales with harmonies splashed here and there.
Good stuff. Some nice tracks on there with some great stories in them, some of which I'd heard before. El Paso was not good enough to appear twice on the album though!
Clearly Marty Robbins is a legend for a lot of people in the US who grew up listening to him, I can tell he's admired and loved; the western songs are cool and the man himself is talented and well deserving of the people's respect. I wouldn't listen to this album again, but it was pleasant to listen to the heroic tales sang with great vocals and nice harmonies.
I'm not very into country music, but if someday I need some ballad for a gunfight, I'm sure that now I know where to look for it.
I mean some decent story telling if you like the same story of a cowboy gunning people down 15 times. Or not. I’m not sure I only made it to song 7.
I was ready to take this piss out of this album, but I ended up quite enjoying it. It's very samey, so the enjoyment wore thin towards the end of the album, even though I don't think the later songs were any worse than the earlier ones.
A lot of samey songs, but when you like them, it’s fine. It’s formulaic, but Marty Robins’ voice makes that fine.
Aww, reminds me of my grandma, she loved this guy. I think he's okay. Also, the replay I did when I heard this part of The Strawberry Roan: He's about the worst bucker I've seen on the range That was not what I thought he said. Be a lot cooler if he did, tho. 3/5
Listened to this while playing Isofarian Guard. The music totally and game pairing was super weird, but also worked with all the battles. I enjoyed this a whole lot more than I was expecting to.
The juxtaposition of dark lyrics against upbeat music on some of the songs such as El Paso is masterful.
Fun ballads. 45 minutes is enough. ;-)
High highs, but guitar story telling gets a little old after a while.
To me this is proper music. Stories well told set to great melodies. El Paso is a song so good the Dead played it over 400 times and Breaking Bad based their entire final episode on it. To top it all off Marty Robbins became a NASCAR driver. What a life. Hard to fault 4.75/5
noise vomit.... hehe i kid just not for me, howdy!
Great story teller, some classic songs. The guitar gets a bit repetitive
The 50s really loved their Westerns. This album is full of outlaw tales and it's honestly great. Marty Robbins is an awesome story teller. Big Iron is such a cool opener, with a tale of Texas Red vs the Ranger. A lot of the album is similar, but Marty's voice is compelling enough to drive the album for it's whole length. Other standout is obviously El Paso, but I also liked The Master's Call and The Hanging Tree. Would definitely listen again if driving through any dusty old towns.
Marty Robbins, one of the coolest crooning cowboys in classic country. This album is just wonderful. Big Iron is a song so good that it may be more popular now than it was when the album came out 65 years ago, if that’s not evidence of its excellence, then I’m not sure what is. This record is such a great mixture of uptempo cowboy tunes, deeply depressing western ballads, Spanish guitar, and incredible vocal melodies and harmonies. Easy 5 stars.
Does what it says on the box, and does it better than anyone. Just a delightful collection of tunes regaling you with stories of a bygone west. Marty Robbins has a beautiful voice. What’s not to love?
Not my thing. I’m sure it was a bop 65 years ago.
I've listened to this before! I love outlaw country and I like a good story song, even though these are gruesome. I remember playing this at home and my mum asking me to play anything else after listening to how violent these are. You do get a bit tired of the same sound, but I generally find this a pretty pleasant listen. I love the strong Mexican influence. 4/4.5
Too violent. No wonder we have so many gun nuts today
Fine - not my sort of thing. Exactly what you’d expect from the album name and cover.
Got a bit samey after a few songs, but I kind of enjoyed the old-times Wild West feels for what they were.
Solid G-rated murder ballads
'50s country is so much more palatable than a lot of what will come later. Not something I will ever love, but this is pleasant and well-preformed. Reminds me more of hornless mariachi than what I think of as "country", but I also know the relationship between the two is pretty tight, so it makes sense.
Can country sound like this again, please?
I don’t hate this album. It just isn’t for me. I can recognize the artistry of its time and Marty is great at his craft. The time in which this album came out saw country music as a great means of storytelling and this album delivers on that. Some fantastic harmonies and for its time, great production value. I can’t tank the ratings because it doesn’t speak to me but I can’t give it high marks on a personal level because I just don’t feel like it is right to give a high rating on something you aren’t drawn to just for the respect of its artist. I wish I could give a 2.75. Just dropping it below the 3 mark cause I respect it but again, not for me.
Howdy , I’ll never listen to this again . Yeee haaaaw. ! 1
I don't exactly know why American culture is so obsessed with cowboys and Manifest Destiny, but it is, and this album epitomizes both. I've never heard of Marty Robbins and I've never heard any of these songs but I see the through line from this to modern country and some pop crossovers (looking at you, Sting). The voice is beautiful but the songs idolize terrible acts.
A great listen. This is why I like the Albums Generator, as I'd have never come across this otherwise!
It was xhil
He’s got a formula for sure. And it seems a little anachronistic since most of the cowboy fandom had been out style for a couple years, but I have to admit, this guy knows how to lay this down. I’ll return to this often.
I loved this. Adding it to my Spotify library right now. Great stories, perfect tempo, heartfelt singing. Flawless. This guy loves a valley!
Simple and fun
Kinda liked this one, actually. 3.2
Westerns distilled with an awesome voice. I cannot imagine a better execution of the concept, not my thing but glad it exists
Not for me
Love and guns. He has a great voice and the albums is for easy listening. Sounds very pure.
Some sorta Western vibe to it.
Country isn't really my genre but I did appreciate the quality of voice and the storytelling in the music initially. However, to me there wasn't much of variation in the songs and after listening to 5 tracks I lost interest. 2*
Cowboys and Mexicans, the album
This may not be everyone’s jam in 2024, but I think it’s an amazing country album. Everyone hopefully knows El Paso, and it’s great, but all of these songs are expertly sand by Robbins and each contain an interesting, often thrilling story. It’s not something I’ll listen to every day, but I don’t think you can make a better western outlaw country album than this. El Paso and Big Iron are the highlights.
wow, okay one of the better country sound that pioneered the Western sound of the 50s.
wow, really liked this one !
Yuck. Just about the blandest most terrible version of country, a genre with a huge capacity for bland terribleness. I've picked the first song as my favourite, but that was only because I still had hopes and dreams then.
Good
Loved the outlaw tales, especially the first few songs. The novelty wore off a bit in the second half but still a good listen.
Times have changed. Cowboys song about killing, loving, or the country. Nothing else.
Great start to an album. Death and guns everywhere. Then some songs get a bit samey and I lose interest in the story telling. Important album as I believe it started to paved the way for outlaw country. Big iron on his hip
Good album. I liked his voice and the stories but as I wouldn’t listen to it again it has to be a 2 from me.
The original true crime podcast
Some real nice songs in there. My notable favourites were “they’re hanging me tonight” and “el paso”. This music gives me memories of 1950s cowboy movies shown on a Sunday afternoon growing up.
With it titled Gunfighters ballads I was expecting a slightly more grand bigger aggressive sound. However what I did get was a very easy listening honky-tonk genre. None of the tracks really jumped out at me, but there is no questioning Marty Robbins talent and his vocal range
Actually really enjoyed this little time capsule. It is a good sounding record that sounds really nice and full. Marty has an amazing voice. It sounds like it has just come fallen out of the wild wild west. Absolutely wild.
This will be a sequel to my review of John Prine’s self titled album: Country music is like those Super Mario and Zelda games released for the Phillips CD-i. It’s that ‘Gollum’ game developed by Daedalic Entertainment the came out in 2023 (so bad it put them out of business). It’s the equivalent of being forced to play ‘Superman 64’ on the Nintendo 64. It’s the ‘WWE 2K20’ of the WWE 2K annual series. It’s like being forced to play ‘Rogue Warrior’. Or ‘Battlefield 2042’ at launch; oh yeah, that game. Have you ever tried to suddenly move with a broken shoulder? That’s what country music is like. When you stub your toe on the corner of your bed? That’s country music! You ever had a migraine so bad that it makes you vomit and confines you to your bed because any form of light just makes it worse? Yeah, that’d be country music. Back pain? Country music. It’s like getting severe leg cramps due to lack of potassium. Have you ever been shown an overly long YouTube video that your friend, who is right beside you, thinks is hilarious; but it’s 2 minutes too long and you have to sort of fake laugh so you don't offend them? Then you think “well that’s that”, but they unfortunately show you another one? That’s country music! Listening to this album was like pouring milk into your cereal, but the milk is well past its sell-by date and is just a gloopy and smelly mess; completely ruining your morning. It was like being stuck in highway traffic with your kid having a meltdown in the back seat. It’s like watching the first season of ‘The Office’. It’s like watching the last season of ‘Scrubs’. It’s like watching the entirety of ‘Grey’s Anatomy’. It was like having my toddler scream in my left ear, and my cat screaming in my right ear. It was like watching ‘Kick-Ass 2’ right after the original. It’s like watching every mediocre spaghetti western on the planet (and they’re all mediocre). Hell, you’d do better to listen to a Wesley Willis album than this. It was like eating chicken that you thought was cooked properly, but you realize after a few bites that it could have used another 10 minutes in the oven and now you possibly have salmonella. It's like that time my toddler got hand, foot and mouth disease and passed it onto me. It's like my psoriasis when I have a bad flare up. It's like that time I fell and fractured my ankle. Fergie's rendition of the American national anthem at the NBA All-Star game a few years back is better than listening to this. Phew. I did listen to it, by the way. All the way through. And I hated it. It's just cowboy nonsense and country clichès. I have yet to come in contact with a country album that makes me even consider turning my opinion around on the genre. 1/5
Day 47 - October 7th, 2024 ROOTIN TOOTIN COWBOY SHOOTIN. 4/5
A true classic. The listener is immediately transported to a bygone era of classic cowboy heroes who go out into the Wild West with nothing but a six-shooter and a hunger for adventure.
Not my cup of tea
Cowboy shlock lol
For this review, I will not be factoring in the bonus tracks included in the CD reissue. I’ve heard of Marty Robbins before as a country singer-songwriter, often cited as a pioneer in the subgenre of outlaw country. The one song I knew from him prior was “Big Iron”, which not only serves as a strong opener to this album but it has since gained a wide resurgence in popularity from its inclusion in the Fallout: New Vegas video game soundtrack. I’d say the rest of my enjoyment with Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs is about on par with that opening track. Marty had such a knack for effortlessly crooning and singing baritone whilst strumming away on his guitar, as him and his backing band run the gamut through tales of the Wild West with a fair amount of cover songs played decently. Probably the only complaint to be had is that the album is rather one-note. Most of these songs are standard tempo and sticking to the Wild West aesthetic. It’s certainly pleasant to listen to, though outside of “Big Iron”, “El Paso” and his cover of Curley Fletcher’s “The Strawberry Roan”, there’s not much else here that uniquely stands out. Still at the end of day, I had a good time with Gunfighter Ballads. If you like your country western, or need a good soundtrack for traversing a retrofuturistic nuclear wasteland, then this album comes with a strong recommendation.
Fallout New Vegas! First track is obviously a classic for that reason, but the rest of this was nice too, and I don't generally do country. Only negative I can think of is that a few of the songs do sound like similar, eg: Big Iron, and The Master's Call, that I swear also have the exact same vocal melody. Still, nice stuff.
Big Iron brings this up to a three.
His voice is pleasant actually and the music is pleasant enough, but after a couple of songs it just gets boring.
El año de Kind of Blue y Time out, el bueno (y polifacético) de Marty publicó este disco pionero del Outlaw Country. Hubo discos mejores ese año, los citados y otros como los de Berry, Wolf, Ray Charles o Ella Fitgerald, pero tal vez no tan influyentes. Jugada maestra y 6º disco más vendido de la década con un género que estaba ya entonces pasado de moda. En este disco además de estupendos temas como Big Iron, está El Paso uno de sus clásicos (y ganadora del Grammy ese mismo año). Hoy en día suena como sonaría entonces un disco de Gangsta-Rap pero eso no le resta valor. Berry Is on Top – Chuck Berry, Chega De Saudade – João Gilberto, Cliff Sings Cliff Richard, Come Dance with Me! – Frank Sinatra, Ella Fitzgerald Sings the George and Ira Gershwin Songbook – Ella Fitzgerald, The Genius of Ray Charles – Ray Charles, Go Bo Diddley -Bo Diddley , At large y Here We Go Again! – The Kingston Trio (que arrasaron por esos años), Hymns by Johnny Cash – Johnny Cash, Kind of Blue – Miles Davis, Moanin' in the Moonlight – Howlin' Wolf , Ritchie Valens – Ritchie Valens, The Shape of Jazz to Come – Ornette Coleman, Time Out – Dave Brubeck Quartet, Heavenly-Johnny Mathis, Peter Gunn- Henry Mancini, The Lord´s Prayer- The Mormon Tabernacle Choir, Exótica - Martin Denny, Sonrisas y lágrimas, los Sing Alone de Mitch Miller, Conniff y Mantovani...
Solid!
Late October 3rd, 2024 HL: “Big Iron”, “El Paso”, “Cool Water”, “The Master’s Call”, “Utah Carol”, “In the Valley” If not the finest country album I’ve heard on this list, definitely in the top 5 Shoutout to “Billy the Kid” & its flipping between A major and A minor
very good, I knew some of these songs
One of the most American sounding things I've ever heard. New quite a few tracks but never knew who recorded them. I doubt this will be something I listen to often, but I enjoyed listening through it once.
Easily the greatest country album ever made. The storytelling is unreal, Robbins truly paints the picture in your head clear as day. I don't think many other albums come close to how strong this one is. It's unimaginable that a song like "Big Iron" is arguably the "weakest" on this album. As there's no way anybody could top that perfection. But Marty Robbins does. Each time I listen to this record a different song stands out to me and becomes my new favorite (for this listen it's "The Strawberry Roan"). There isn't enough good things to say about this album, it's iconic in every single way and has stood the test of time by still being quite popular today.
Such a cinematic country album. Definitely sounds like a classic cowboy album. And El Paso has the Felina breaking bad reference! I'd say don't judge a book by it's cover but in this case you really get the image on the front for this.
Интересный альбом, в духе своего времени, каждая песня как мини вестерн
I love it!
YES DUDE!!!!!! YEEHAW!!!!! highlights: a hundred and sixty acres, they’re hanging me tonight, billy the kid, el paso (dec 19 2024)
Reminds me of my dad and road trips as a kid
It's really similar to songs that are played often where I'm from, and I barely like those
cowboy
El Paso - They definitely killed him for yoinking that horse and not for shooting the dude Big Iron carries this.
The music is slightly better than the album cover. Good voice but no thanks. Also he’d be cancelled for singing about a “hanging tree”. Meant to be played on vinyl- El Paso on there two times…
That’s a no for me dawg
Thoroughly enjoyed that album. The Masters Call was my favorite song.
western elvis
Like a boring Western soundtrack. Every song just sounded like I left a Western movie or TV show from 60 to 70 years ago playing in the background. There’s an audience for this music, and most likely people who think Gangsta Rap is too violent and black.
more of that true, classic outlaw country music that we americans have seemed to abandon, especially after 9/11. the opening track, big iron is a historic staple of country music from this time. besides that track though, not too many tracks held my interest for that long. is this good western music? absolutely. is it for me? not really. but i can at least appreciate its significance in music history.
Kind of fun time capsule listen but I don’t think I would listen every day.
Country music is so violent! But for real, I loved this album.
Este es el álbum de canciones del Oeste por excelencia. Incluye canciones de amor y clásicos anónimos de la tradición americana. Sus historias son las repetidas una y otra vez en la gran pantalla, pero cantadas con una emoción, como en "Big Iron" o "El Paso", que las hace especiales. Me gusta, quizás por su evocación fílmica, "The Hanging Tree", escrita precisamente para la película de 1959. También "Saddle Tramp" y "The Master's Call.
Corny but upbeat. Fun listening especially while doing chores. Helped me to move faster. 😆
This is just brilliant country music. Can't beat it.
This album is simply awful. Nonsence cowboy music. Favourite song: There really wasnt one Least favourite: All of them Album artwork: Very American
a little classic country & western rarely comes amiss
Oh cunt this shit got me feeling wiggly and jiggly
Great story telling. Was probably a fantastic album by 1959 standards. But every song quite literally is the same song with different lyrics. Would not listen again
Great album, lovely sound
Ol Marty ain't have to go this hard
Really enjoyed all of the references that go back to this album which was very cool and weirdly coded for Grant and me. A really pleasant listen though. I actively said while listening that I never would consider myself a fan of the genre but I enjoyed listening to it a lot
NGL, kind of a vibe. Old-school gangster, "shoot someone who's talkin' to your girl at the saloon" shit. Years of accumulated useless knowledge from Wikipedia rabbit holes also yield the following easter eggs/ fun facts. Big Iron: famous as a meme from the radio on Fallout: New Vegas The Strawberry Roan: Namesake for Chappell Roan (her grandfather, Chappell's favorite song) El Paso: Featured in Breaking Bad finale "Felina," as the story echoes Walter's arc in the final season.
Such a fun album, makes you feel like you're listening to an old-timey radio. Also why are there two versions of el paso lol, did the extra 19 seconds really warrant a "full-length version"? (not complaining tho, i don't mind hearing that song twice)
I’m one song in an obsessed 😍
Big Iron // El Paso //
If you like twangy, old time country this is the album for you
Soft, very 50’s feel
FALLOUT NEW VEGAS AMKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
That was a bit hard to listen to. Far too country and western for me.
ковбой марльборо епт , игого
big iron on his hip For the rare moments where I wanna listen to outlaw country, this is a good album for it Although I prefer sturgill simposn
what a delight. like everyone else, i knew Big Iron from FONV, and while that's still my favorite on the record, there are tons of other gems here. what a voice! what storytelling! just very immersive, very fun music. yay!
yee-FUCKING-haw!!!!!!!!!!!! i've been waiting for this album since i saw it was included like eight months ago. like many people my age who are aware of this album, my first introduction was to Big Iron on the Fallout: New Vegas soundtrack around 2010. That song is still my favorite on here, but there are plenty of other great tracks. this album is exactly what it says on the tin. the songs are fun, the stories well-told and engaging, and everything comes together nicely in this package. there's also a sequel album for anyone looking for more. also, Marty was a NASCAR driver. he drove so goddamn fast. never did win no checkered flags but he never did come in last. favorites: big iron, a hundred and sixty acres, they're hanging me tonight, billy the kid, the strawberry roan, the master's call, running gun, el paso, saddle tramp, el paso (full version)
Supercoozy themed album with beautigul vocals. The chords and song melodies does repeat on some tracks though
My dad would love it more
Escuche la mitad, muy local
Favourite song - Big iron
Memes aside, this is great fun. It does its thing and it does it well. I kinda thought the track about him getting shot would have made a better ending track. Weird how you can sing along to bits of it without having heard them before.
A fun listen. Liked it more than I thought. Will listen again
this was okay, big iron is great and some other tracks were good, not something i’d be gravitated towards but it was nice
Not Bad. Just a little too "cowboy" for me.
Good songs, well-recorded. Like a musical version of diner food. Nothing unexpected or brilliant but a solid, comforting meal if slightly boring.
Big iron 😂
2 stars only because country isnt my type.
Oh, man these bring back memories, I remember hearing these on the radio and hearing the stories in the songs on the long drives when growing up on the classic country station.
Love this one, a classic for me.
Pleasantly surprised with how much I enjoyed this one. This list has showed me that I enjoy older country music.
This was fun. Better than "murder ballads," but at some points it reminded me of that one.
This was delightful and i wish the lust showed me more unknown corners of music. Good voice, good guitar, good, good stories, good cowboy nonsense
Delightful.
This is the sound of my father's childhood. He would sing these songs often.
A pleasant voice but you don't get the same feels as you get from other country voices like Patsy Cline or Johnny Cash. I personally don't find the stories that interesting either.
Fun songs, many familiar but I didn’t know Marty Robbin’s at all
Country, 1959 -> 2
Interesting storytelling and I like Marty Robbins’ timeless voice. Not my scene, but my grandpa used to love this stuff. Songs I liked: Big Iron, El Paso, The Master's Call, Hanging Tree 3⭐️
Charming. Will I return to it? I don’t know, maybe not, but listening to this truly felt like getting a little treat
Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs is the fifth studio album by Marty Robbins, originally released in 1959. This album is already so legendary, so there's not much I can really say to drive that point in. Something that really surprised me is that they recorded the entire record in one 8 hour session. It's a pretty damn polished work for that short of a recording session. The lyrics on here throw you into the wild west witnessing love, tragedy, and of course, shootouts. Lots of shootouts. Seriously, some of the lyrics on here are dark. Overall, this is just a perfect example of outlaw country. Now where's my horse and my damn pistol?!
This is deceptively dark. The melodies are white bread and sound happy while the content is dark as any modern rap album. Old school country is so much better than the pandering red neck shit we have today.
After big iron, they drag you through a pile of utter shit just because everyone want to hear El Paso.
You get exactly what the label says. That's always a plus in my eyes. In this case, even in almost the right dose. Album's a little too long for my taste, but it doesn't get annoying. What the label doesn't tell you is that shit slaps, yo. Bonus point for the unexpected Breaking Bad reminder.
Yes
I enjoyed it.
Big iron on his hippppo
I didn't have high hopes, but I thoroughly enjoyed this album. Every track was fantastic
Ah, I wanted to like it more. Some of the songs are really oddly overwritten (looking at you, Utah Carol), and he sings every song the in the exact same tone, never mind if the protagonist is about to be hanged or in love. Prefer my cowboy songs with a bit more edge.
How did he make those songs boring?
9.5/10
Me pareció aburrido, las canciones son bastante indistinguibles entre si y el album pasa a un segundo plano. Lo recomendaría a gente que le guste el country o los western de Henry Fonda o John Ford. No es para mí.
Very fun listen.
Does exactly what it says on the tin
About half these songs have the same rhythm as each other, but it's nice to have something like this on the list.
Given the genre, I definitely enjoyed this album more than I thought I would. I could imagine myself with my Big Iron out in the Wild Wild West. Favorite Track: "Big Iron"
Albumi #23, 19.08.2024 Kunnollista western-countrya 50-luvun lopulta. Pieninä annoksina kelpaa kyllä.
I like the 3/4 rythyms with the guitar, It is not my style but IS interesting.
It's hokey, it's sexist, it's dated....but it's awesome. Such tightly written songs with vivid lyrical imagery. The music is performed flawlessly too. I am a sucker for old timey music and this was no exception. A really fun listen.
Country guy, western type songs seem to be bread and butter - first track slapped then fell off