Reviews (page 8 of 14)
Love the gunslinger/crooner genre. Fun stories, but the songs became a little redundant and monotone after a while. Still pretty cool album.
Great listen. Always valuable when you find songs you didn’t know were originals. Prime example is Big Iron. I never took the time to check the song credits. I thought Colter Wall was the original. Good choice to be in this list.
Oh i can't be arsed with this project man what the fuck is this. I guess I stand to be pleasantly surprised? I'm gonna put in on the living room tv so everyone can see I'm listening to cowboy jams ig. Oh i know this! You know what I'm not like astounded but it's sunny and I'm cooking a nice flatbread and this is setting a mood. I am ready for something else like but nah respect this. Sometimes timeless is timeless. I've not really heard any of the lyrics so apologies if they're less timeless. 'I'm ready for something else' sure jan how many songs into the album radio are you
Sounds interesting for a hike in West Virginia.
i have yank fatigue
Old timey country western. All a bit saccharine, you can see why up and coming artists rebelled against it.
Fine if you like that sort of thing I guess, it gets an extra Star for Big Iron but everything blends together to the untrained ear after a while. All in all I didn't hate it, but it's not converted me to the side of country.
No le conocía. Los 50 son una decada muy muy floja. Se salva algo de jazz y Elvis
Some good ol’ fashioned outlaw country. It’s fun but definitely not for every day. The guitar work and bass lines are prototypical early country though.
Great voice
i love this old cowboy shit. the pride and ego of men in the old west, facing death and violent consequences for their misplaced love and jealous rage. a lot of morbidity in these stories but it serves a purpose, the lyrics wouldn't make any sense without it. honestly there's a lot here that's still relevant to so-called alpha males today.
Suddenly I was hit with the urge to hunt down that local outlaw and make him yee his last haw. A rootin', tootin', gunshootin' piece of western romanticism. Does exactly what it says on the can. A perfect soundtrack for when you wanna dust of that ol' cowboy hat and spurs while ridin' down the lonesome prairie into the setting sun. Big Iron Behind every song that eventually became a meme is a good song, that's at least the case with this one. A really catchy and captivating piece of storytelling with an easy to follow narrative which paces itself elegantly. Great voice, great backing vocals and bouncy and fun composition with a cute little bassline and picky guitar. Fantastic. 5/5 A Hundred And Sixty Acres Paints a romantic and idealized version of rural living. A positive and appreciative depiction of a man who's spending his time caring for his homestead. A cute fantasy. Good. 4/5 They're Hanging Me Tonight A very charismatic and believable vocal performance. Full with drama with a hint of theatrics that really sells the depressed/doomed cowboy trope. Very cliche, but charming. Decent. 3.5/5 Cool Water Don't be thirsty, stay hydrated! Dramatic storytelling. Builds a lot on a simple concept, hits a lot of the desert tropes while sounding fairly unique. Decent. 3.5/5 Billy The Kid Cowboys, famous outlaws, sheriffs, exactly what you expect to hear from a an album called Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs. He has a mournfulness in his voice that really sells the story, and while its content is quite predictable, there's a lot of charm to something so simple. Decent. 3.5/5 Utah Carol Typical story song, even has that token vocal melody style which has later been parodied many times. The story itself is pretty easy to follow and remains interesting througout. Musically it lacks anything remarkable outside the fact that his voice is pretty pleasant. Would definitely be monotous if it went on for any longer. Fine. 3/5 The Strawberry Roan Seems really easy to find a job in those times. Kinda funny that a random guy just approached him, judging him by his look and then just giving him a job. What is this eldritcht being he's describing? Sounds sketchy to me. It's a bit weaker than other tracks on the album, the narrative jumps around a bit and the pacing is odd. Feels a bit difficult to follow along with. Average. 2.5/5 The Master's Call I like the progression a lot. Each sentence ends in a very memorable way. God is a scary vengeful being in this song, very striking imagery. Feels like a campfire story. It's a fun and engaging story though the moral lesson isn't believeable enough to have much value. Still powerful and passionate. Pretty spectacular and grandiose at times. Fantastic. 5/5 Running Gun Fun tempo with a plucky and crisp guitar in the background. Simple but effective. Cliche and tropey song, but works for what it is. Decent. 3.5/5 El Paso Evocative and vivid, really love how descriptive each line is. Written charismatically showing an extreme appreciation of the genre. Has a very infectious vocal melody which is fun to song along to. A classic fantasy when you endulge in the narrator's delusion. Tropey, a bit cheesy and very charming. The great delivery and the smooth archetypical cowboy country voice really seals the deal. Fantastic. 5/5 In The Valley A brief but sweet mournful love song, which while never doing anything too special delivers well on its premise. Great vocals once again. Decent. 3.5/5 The Little Green Valley A standard piece on this album, probably straying towards being one of the more forgetable songs on here. Pleasant enough, just doesn't really do anything exciting. Average. 2.5/5 The Hanging Tree Spaghetti trumpet. Feels like the hanging tree in question has a double meaning, which really becomes apparent throughout the song. Decent storytelling with a unique concept for a country western love song. Decent. 3.5/5 Saddle Tramp Again, a very solid piece of romanticism. Pays homage to the idealized image of the lonesome drifter without a care in the world. A cute little piece of music. Good 4/5 El Paso (Repeat) Mono version with a few minor tweaks from the previous one. NA/5 A very fun album which satisfies the craving for some tropey cowboy action and simple to follow along with stories on a western backdrop. Stays in its lane, delivering exactly what is promised on the packaging. Never strays off theme even when taking on different topics, and while some might be repeats the presentation usually makes up for it. Marty Robbins has the perfect voice for this, believable as a traveling narrator figure who goes from one dusty town to another performing his stories. Love, death, drama and even some god fearing horror, all performed with charisma and grace in a classic country style. Really feels easy to listen to, and while it has some songs that feel a bit average they never really derail the pacing enough to ruin the experience. The stellar highlights more than make up for the fairly significant lows. Definitely something I'll throw on occasionally when I'm feeling like drifting into a western fantasy land. Great recommendation. 4/5 Fave track. The Master's Call Least fave track. The Strawberry Roan
I liked this more than I thought I would. An album full of cowboy country songs. But this really is the rap music of the 50s, but I bet they held their pistols correctly before they filled them full of lead.
82% Best: Big Iron; They're Hanging Me Tonight; El Paso Must-Hear? Sure
Cowboy songs from the late 50s, nice
It was just okay.
Meh, old
Big Iron being iconic aside. Marty Robbins is a phenomenal singer and story teller.
To the town of Agua Fria rode a stranger one fine day Hardly spoke to folks around him, didn't have too much to say No one dared to ask his business, no one dared to make a slip The stranger there among them had a big iron on his hip Big iron on his hip It was early in the morning when he rode into the town He came riding from the south side, slowly lookin' all around He's an outlaw loose and running came the whisper from each lip And he's here to do some business with the big iron on his hip Big iron on his hip In this town there lived an outlaw by the name of Texas red Many men had tried to take him and that many men were dead He was vicious and a killer though a youth of twenty four And the notches on his pistol numbered one an nineteen more One and nineteen more Now the stranger started talking made it plain to folks around Was an Arizona ranger wouldn't be too long in town He came here to take an outlaw back alive or maybe dead And he said it didn't matter, he was after Texas Red After Texas Red Wasn't long before the story was relayed to Texas Red But the outlaw didn't worry, men that tried before were dead Twenty men had tried to take him, twenty men had made a slip Twenty one would be the ranger with the big iron on his hip Big iron on his hip The morning passed so quickly, it was time for them to meet It was twenty past eleven when they walked out in the street Folks were watching from their windows, everybody held their breath They knew this handsome ranger was about to meet his death About to meet his death There was forty feet between them when they stopped to make their play And the swiftness of the ranger is still talked about today Texas Red had not cleared leather, for a bullet fairly ripped And the rangers' aim was deadly with the big iron on his hip Big iron on his hip It was over in a moment and the folks had gathered round There before them lay the body of the outlaw on the ground Oh, he might have gone on living but he made one fatal slip When he tried to match the ranger with the big iron on his hip Big iron on his hip Big iron, big iron When he tried to match the ranger with the big iron on his hip Big iron on his hip
Beautiful melodies paired with Marty Robbins soothing voice. Really a great listen.
Once again, I love this. It sounds like my Gramps singing songs and sharing stories around the campfire. It sounds nostalgic and familiar, it sounds like home. My Dad's side of the family always loved this Western music, and I'll continue to love it too.
Old school awesome
This roots and toots in equal measure.
hella western, feels a lil performative though
A very strong start with Big Iron, which I've heard covers of, and generally my current vibe. I enjoyed the whole album, it was very pleasant, I'd would listen again.
Perfect example of what this project is all about. Likely never would have found this on my own and now I have a new favorite record of classic cowboy songs.
Yeehaw guns woo boom boom bang bang. No thanks. Rating: 2
Classic, slower, old-timey country, road-trip songs. -Big Iron -A Hundred and Sixty Acres -They're Hanging Me Tonight -Cool Water -Billy the Kid -Utah Carol -The Strawberry Roan -The Master's Call -Running Gun -El Paso -In the Valley -The Little Green Valley -The Hanging Tree -Saddle Tramp -El Paso
Classic c&w
Liked this more than expected. Good storytelling.
not my stuff
Does only one thing. Does it perfectly.
good vibes
I caught wind of this guy and album by chance. Listening to a gothic country playlist on Spotify . They’re Hanging Me Tonight was the song and I was hooked to the feeling of it. I was let down to know that it was the best song on the album. There is one theme to this album: Sorrow It’s one tone. You won’t be hitting the dance floor to any song but you may wish that you were a cowboy back in the day. Choice cut: They’re Hanging Me Tonight
Marty Robbins' voice was smooth and aided his storytelling habits. Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs does a good job making a difference between country and western, though Robbins dabbled in both genres. I did think the album went on for too long, but then I belatedly realized I listened to the lengthened 1999 version, not the original from 1959, so I won't hold that against Mr. Robbins.
Marty Robbins has such an intriguing voice. It's definitely not what I think of when I think of "country" music, but it's nice to listen to. Despite not being my typical idea of a "country voice", he definitely understood the assignment when it came to writing country lyrics and telling a story. When people use the term "country western music", this is why. As someone who is not typically a fan of classic country, I was surprised to find Robbins quite palatable.
pretty dope
Much more fun than expected. Hanging me tonight was a standout
I like these old western cowboy songs, but an entire album of them is a bit much. There's also a lot of similarity between some of the songs. But pretty much any of these songs I wouldn't mind playing onesy-twosy, just not the entire collection again. 3/5
Listened to this for another list. It's just ok. I didn't care for the little interstitial story bits before each song. 2/5
Not bad. I kinda of like this old country western music.
I love this. What a fun vibe. Very poetic. OMG Utah Carol 😭 why am I crying (I am legit crying and upset haha). I actively loved this album. This was such an engaging album!
Not my style, but fun. Would never listen to on my own.
Not my vibe.
That was a trip… to the heart of the old western movies.
I, unexpectantly, liked this album!
The problem I have with this is not the music at all. It’s pretty good. My problem is there is no reason I can conceive of that I would listen to this again. This falls under a case where I can’t say I don’t like it, I just would never listen to it again.
This album is so much better than present day country music. I will return to this album for sure.
I listened to this while making a cake for my Mom's birthday. It is very 1950s country and I heard little bits of early Elvis too. I didn't know any of the songs before listening, but the opening track "Big Iron" I have heard before, but I don't know where. Might have been on the oldies radio station back in the day? I don't know that I will revisit this one again but I enjoyed it. I certainly would consult it for a future spaghetti western I would make in another lifetime.
Not listened before Fav tracks: Big Iron, Cool Water
The vibe is strong on this one.
Not bad but pretty dang ol’ fashioned
I like the storytelling but the style of music isn't my favourite
One of the greatest albums & country albums ever made. Way ahead of its time & nearly an entire zero skip album
Delightful
Yeehaw. His voice is gorgeous, reminded me of Roy Orbison, songs got a bit repetitive so better in small doses
I'm in a film, on my horse, wearing a cowboy hat, watching the sunset. All v romantic. The lyrics are great, each one is a little story in itself. I lost interest after a while though, a whole album of this is a bit much...
It does what it says on the tin of chewing tobacco. Tells a story, voice is nice, good rhythm. Not for me in large doses, but it was a fun change.
I really enjoyed this! Such a story.
Kept expecting the Jebediah Springfield song to turn up on this.
I’m kind of shocked to admit that I liked this as much as I did. The songs are simple and easy rhythms. Lyrics are great and voice is good. All in all nothing too stellar but I’ll listen to this over and over going forward!!
smooth voice and melancholy lyrics, but just as a whole not my thing
This album feels like stepping into a Technicolor Western—dusty saloons, lonely deserts, and gunslingers with tragic pasts. Marty Robbins has a rich, warm voice that brings these cowboy tales to life, especially on the iconic El Paso, which is still a masterclass in narrative songwriting. The arrangements are simple but perfectly suited to the storytelling—acoustic guitars, gentle harmonies, and that classic Western shuffle that makes the whole thing feel like it’s playing over the end credits of a movie. While a few of the songs blend into each other and lean a bit too far into sentimentality, there's a charm and sincerity that carries it through. It's not trying to be cool or clever—it’s just really well-crafted cowboy music, full of heart and wide-open landscapes. Not quite perfect, but a high-quality slice of Americana that still sounds lovely today.
3.5. country!!! tells story through the lyrics.
Reminds me of my Dad. :)
Proper old fashioned country, some good tracks.
i really love marty’s voice… it reminds me of orville peck. this is my brand of country music, seriously
Very nice storytelling.
Look, it's a western album because it was the 1950s and everyone was obsessed with the wild west for some reason. Marty Robbins can definitely sing! El Paso and Big Iron are pretty solid. But it just isn't my jam. You can hear the western/Mariachi influence, but the weird cowboy falsetto work and edgy lyrics make it out as something distinctly not for me.
you know what this wasn’t actually so bad. i probably wouldn’t ever listen to it on my own (certainly not as a complete album) but i do ultimately love a good story-song, which almost all of these are, and i also really like that style of super precise background harmonies (à la the everly brothers i guess?). yeehaw!
That was actually pretty cute. But here’s something about this kind of voice that makes all the songs sound the same to me, like almost too smooth and neutral, and it feels like the whole thing has been painted over with the same wash if that makes sense….like going over a painting with a single shade….i am so tired right now and don’t know if my paint analogy is making sense…
The storytelling in this is amazing, not really the type of music I'd go out of my way to listen to but I enjoyed this a lot more than expected.
It was pretty cool and fun to listen to but not playlist song
Awesome experience
Not for me
Balala
This was so good! I loved it!
This was fun lol, liked it a lot. 3.8/5 Fav song: El Paso
This ruled. I love the rockabilly folk genre and I've been waiting for something before 1968. He has a great voice and I love the simplicity of the arrangements. 4.3/5
got through one song. eh
Good storytelling, kind of texas swing, Country music. 3,5 Stars. Will relisten. Wasn't Sure entirely if I dislike its softness.
Interesting, liked it more than I thought I would.
Not sure what to rate. The stories were nice to listen to, but I certainly wouldn't listen to it again. Big Iron is a banger though. If you only listen to it once it's a 4, otherwise I would probably give it a 2.
Fun and enjoyable. But country music is not my type.
The title of the album couldn’t be more accurate. It’s a bunch of stories about gunslingers and cowboys sung as if narrating an old western. A lot of the melodies are repetitive, but the stories are pretty interesting so that makes up for it.
Nice country record. But not mindblowing.
Loved this
I have loved 'Big Iron' by M. Robbins for a while. I think after Fallout: New Vegas release. I have a soft spot for classical voice singers of 30-60, so it wasn't a new performer for me. In general album is great, I won't listen it much but 2 songs will be in my playlist for sure. The second is the original 'Cool Water' that has an absolutely beautiful cover in Cohen's almanac: The Ballad of Buster Scruggs.
I enjoyed this much more than I thought I would, though the stories got a bit repetitive after a while. Cowboy shoots someone, doesn’t the girl, dies and so on and so forth. Seems like a good album to listen to while playing Red Dead Redemption or maybe Fallout
I enjoyed this; it was a pleasant surprise, and I felt a bit disappointed when the album ended. However, I just found out that he released a second album of Gunfighter Ballads, so I know what I'll be listening to later!
I tried to listen to this whole album but it just kept playing Big Iron. 10/10 would recommend.
Um álbum country fantástico, sendo eu um grande apreciador de westerns, para além das fantásticas soundtracks de Ennio Morricone, este álbum provou ser um ótimo transporte para aquelas cidades desertas repletas de duelos e saloons cheios. Diversas histórias muito divertidas e interessantes de ouvir, fantástico!!
The title of the album pretty much says it all here--you get exactly what you came for. Classic cowboy movie soundtrack plunder on this track list.
Favorites: - The hanging tree Tot nu toe Nadines favoriet xP Altijd leuk om je een cowboy te voelen.
Leuk, grappige muziek en even wat anders
Sure
Country at its simplest.
A short dose is OK. But this is too much. Different though
Hell yeah. Huge iron.
A classic, love the whole album. This town is big enough for both of us, Mr Robbins
Get your cowboy boots on and holster your big iron because we be cowboys today. Excellent country
Fun, gunslinger music. Great atmosphere if your feeling all wild west like.
you fucking ass
Can. Not. Listen. To. Country.
Not for me. 1/5
More songs about horses and dying. I don't have a logical reason to not like this. I just don't. It doesn't feel authentic to me and all of the songs sound the same.
This is real country music! Not by ant menas great music, but sturdy, solid well played. What you see is what you get. A few more spins, and I’ll find myself humming along to quite a few tracks here
Cool, but just ok.
Big Iron is one hell of a song, but then the rest isn't really my style. (24 known/46 new)
Masterpiece!
Cowboy style songs. Fit for a very narrow niche of listeners.
I like this style of music for the usually interesting story telling. Nice vocal and overall, a good album.
Look at that, the greatest ever country album
Somehow this album manages to create some genuinely amazing stories that really keep me captivated. There's even a lot of emotion in the vocals in some moments which was really unexpected. Overall definitely enjoyed this one a lot more than I anticipated.
I mean, if you like Big Iron, this is a whole album of that. Can't complain, personally. Gotta be in the mood, but it definitely scratches and itch.
Not for me
yeehaw
yee haw babbyyy les go to new vegas deliver a chip
Highlights: El Paso, Big Iron, The Master's Call. In a nutshell: rolling rolling rolling...raw-hide! You can't help be drawn to Marty singing tales of the Old West. It's kinda romantic and it doesn't shy away from telling us how rough that era was. The composition is repeated throughout (I guess that was the style at the time) but focus on the lyrics. They are magnificent. Overall: 7/10
I grew up on Folk and Country, thanks to Dad. I'm going to show him this album. The captivating storytelling over sweet country instrument arrangements is always a good time, even if some tracks could be mistaken for one another. El Paso is the best example of this recipe's charm. My first experience of Marty Robbins was that edit of a chihuahua with a hat and pistol costume in 2016. I also had a really fucking annoying coworker in 2021 who played this song relentlessly, which temporarily spoiled it for me. She quit, so I can enjoy it now. I don't think I'd listen to this on a regular basis, but I would be sure to savour it every time I do. The next time will be whenever I drive to Toowoomba. Special mention to The Master's Call, what a hauntingly beautiful ballad. Goosebumps. This album is a treasure, Marty Robbins would have been 100 years old this year. May he rest in That Little Green Valley far away.
This shit makes me wanna play Red Dead 2 with this on in the background. I love the vocals on this thing. Reminds me of O Brother Where art Thou - full and crisp 👍 You won’t find me talking about lyrics too much - they’re just another instrument to me on first listen. But since orchestration is so simple, if I wanted to review anything I had no choice but to read along while listening to Marty’s cowboy cries. Not sure what 1959 Marty knew about the wild west, but something tells me he had some John Wayne posters in his bedroom. Taking with me: El Paso (latinas), Billy the Kid, The Hanging Tree
This shit rules. Songs to listen to with my grandmother.
I was very excited to get an old western/country album. It's a breath of fresh air from the garbage country music that Nashville has been pumping into my ears (Gavin Adcock). I can't relate to anything that Marty is singing about, but it feels like I can. Storytelling is great, music is great given the time period. Healthy 4/5
For an album old enough to be pulling social security checks, it holds up pretty well. Marty Robbins lyrics center around 3 themes: God, guns, and dying. The songwriting is straightforward, guitar fills in the space that Marty isn't using. Album cover screams clearance record bin. Nothing spectacular, but this is a good record if you're looking to do some driving or relax by a camp-fire somewhere. ------------------------------ Highlights: Big Iron, Cool Water, The Master's Call, The Hanging Tree, El Paso Stinkers: None of them are that bad, maybe Billy the Kidd. -------------------------------- My Rating Scale: 1 - Trash. Why is it on this list? 2 - Mostly disliked, some good/great tracks 3 - Mostly liked, some exceptions 4 - It's great, with one or two misses allowed 5 - Masterpiece
Genuinely entranced by gunfighter ballads like an 8 year old in 1955 watching Davy Crockett, my god some things never change.
Best album ever made
There's no way to honestly review this without admitting that, yes, I've played Fallout: New Vegas. Multiple times. With mods. With a lot of mods, including radio mods, that add more songs to the in-universe playlist. And despite playing most of the Fallout games (again, with radio mods), Big Iron in New Vegas is the best use of music in the franchise. The only other one that comes close is "I Don't Want to Set the World on Fire" by the Ink Spots. In fact, it might be the best use of existing, diagetic music in gaming. The rest of the album is more of the same. Solid ballads, good storytelling, over some 50's country music. It's got a lot of good ballads on it, but the ones I liked best were El Paso and Billy the Kid.
Very traditional. Certainly well sung and performed, but not my cup of tea.
dit album zit saamen met bruce bij mijn top albums allertijden. Ik ken het helemaal uit me hoofd. de verhalen die worden gezongen zijn prachtig, de gitaar er bij maakt het helemaal af.
Good
I'm pleased that "The Ballad of Buster Scruggs" helped me recognize some music on this album that I would have had no touchstone for. Big Iron was a certified banger.
You give this album a better name than "Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs." Every song encapsulates that title. Robbins nailed the formula of a great country/outlaw ballad and every song on here had me hooked. While I will say a lot of them sounded the same, I did not care; he found the winning recipe and a gobbled it up like a fat boy at Golden Corral.
Big Iron and El Paso are classics. Some of the songs are sleepy but I appreciate the simplicity and stellar vocals.
Actually ok.
What a romp thru the prairie
There's just something about songs about Guys committing crimes of passion then getting captured and hanged that I can't get enough of. This was really good. 4 Stars
3.5
This has to be the best sort of Country to listen to. Very listenable with some great storytelling allowing the listener to place themselves in the songs they’re listening to. Didn’t think I’d enjoy it but I did.
Moderatly fun, mainly novelty.
I feel like a bit of an idiot now. There was I thinking the glamourising of gun violence was the fault of the late 80s gangsta rap crowd, but dear old Marty here had kicked it off 30 years earlier. It’s also got a similar but old fashioned sort of mysogeny insofar as shooting any man perceived to be trying to woo your ex, wife or somebody you’d just like to be your girl. Not so much bragging about how rich you are though, the vibe seems to be more about being lonesome and free (while crying a bit sometimes, which seems oddly mindful and open for those times). All in all though, I enjoyed that. Some good old straight up story tellin’ from another world (albeit bleakly romanticised somewhat). Some nice subtle guitar work too.
Big Iron and El Paso are the only good ones
Classic Country and me are simple incompatible. 2/5
The harmonies, the instrumentation, the tales of heartbreak and revenge, the pastoral nostalgia, this album is just an absolute treat to listen to from the first moment to the last.
I really love "El Paso". The other songs were ok, some quite nice, others not so interesting. But overall a decent album.
Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs ist ein klassisches Album von Marty Robbins, einem US-amerikanischen Country-Sänger und Songwriter, das 1959 veröffentlicht wurde. Es ist ein bemerkenswertes Werk, das sich mit den Themen des Wilden Westens und der amerikanischen Pioniergeschichte auseinandersetzt. Das Album wurde in verschiedenen Studios in den USA aufgenommen, unter anderem in den legendären RCA Studios in Nashville, die für ihre hohe Produktionsqualität bekannt sind. Das Album bietet eine Mischung aus traditionellen Country-Balladen und Western-Songs, die oft dramatische Geschichten erzählen. Besonders hervorzuheben sind die Songs „El Paso“ und „Big Iron“. „El Paso“ ist ein epischer Song über Liebe, Verlust und Rache und gilt als einer der bekanntesten Titel von Robbins. „Big Iron“ folgt einem ähnlichen Erzählstil, in dem es um einen revolvertragenden Helden geht, der einem Gesetzlosen gegenübersteht. Beide Lieder sind für ihre starke narrative Struktur und die charakteristischen Melodien des Country-Western-Genres bekannt. Das Genre des Albums lässt sich klar dem Country zuordnen, wobei es auch starke Elemente des Western-Folk und der Balladenmusik aufgreift. Robbins, der aus Arizona stammte, brachte seine Heimat und die dortige Kultur in seine Musik ein, was zu dem authentischen Flair beiträgt, das das Album auszeichnet. Insgesamt ist Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs ein wichtiger Meilenstein in der Country-Musik und ein frühes Beispiel für die Verschmelzung von Country mit Western-Narrativen. Marty Robbins gelingt es, die Geschichte des Wilden Westens auf eine Weise zu erzählen, die sowohl zugänglich als auch tiefgründig ist. Das Album bleibt auch Jahrzehnte nach seiner Veröffentlichung eine prägende Sammlung von Songs, die das Bild des Cowboy-Mythos in der amerikanischen Musiklandschaft mitgeprägt haben. Fazit: Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs ist ein solides Album, das einen prägnanten Eindruck von Marty Robbins' Fähigkeit gibt, Geschichte und Musik zu vereinen. Es bietet eine interessante Mischung aus Erzählkunst und musikalischer Handwerkskunst im klassischen Country-Stil.
Super tacky, but I love it
I think the most important thing I'm figuring out with all of these albums is to consider what they are by themselves. Comparing this record to basically anything else in its list is a moot point. This was never going to be the best album on the list. But that doesn't matter at all. Let's consider the facts: Is it goofy? Yes. Is it a bunch of similar tracks? Absolutely. Is it fun as hell? Definitely. This record is not groundbreaking by any means. It is fairly standard country fare, with very little else going on. But for 44 straight minutes, Marty conjured images of cowboys and bandits on the trail and made me yearn for my own mustang and ten gallon hat. That, in and of itself is an achievement I can admire. Marty's voice is fantastic, the recordings sound great (especially for this time period), the songwriting and storytelling is ridiculously fun, and I can't help but love it. There's not a single skip to be seen on the whole runtime, but there are a ton of gems (Big Iron, They're Hanging Me Tonight, Billy The Kid, The Master's Call, Running Gun, El Paso, The Little Green Valley, The Hanging Tree). Yeehaw. 10/10
I quite enjoyed listening to this throughout the day. Good ol' western music. It's not something I'd put on regularly but it does what it does very very well
1. iron - 3.5 2. acrez - 1.5 3. tonight - 2 4. uuater - 1.5 5. kid - 3 6. utah - 1.5 7. roan - 1.5 8. call - 4 9. gun - 1.5 10. el pazo - 5 11. valley - 1.5 12. green - 1.5 13. tree - 1.5 14. tramp - 2 15. el pazo too - 5
Not really sure what to say other than I enjoyed it. Reminded me of Johnny Cash
Not something I'd have picked up to listen to ever. I quite enjoyed the tone of the recording and the storytelling in the lyrics
Great voice and story telling. Kind of feels like it should be an album for kids in the 50's.
He’s pretty cool marty robins/ musician and race car driver. Also pretty fit ngl Big iron is pretty great/ so is they’re hanging me tonight. I honestly worried it was going to sound like the last chance saloon song on dr who. (You’ll get why I dreaded that of you’ve watched the gunfighters). 4/5
I really love this! Such great storytelling through song. And when you pair Marty Robbins' golden voice with Grady Martin's incredible playing, you have a glorious gunfighter ballad album.
Wel lachen, maar voor mijn gevoel was het ook veel hetzelfde. Het is ook wel de jaren '50/60, dus ik kan ook niet heel veel verwachten haha
Really don't know Country well at all. Glad this list is showing me the way. Marty Robbins, a man who released 52 studio albums in his 57 years on this earth, provides an interesting listen. Big Iron and El Paso are deservedly classics. El Paso is very Spanish sounding, can really hear the influences of a range of music backgrounds. Hadn't made the connection between Country and Mexican, Hawaiin, even Irish music before. Country may be more musically interesting than I had previously thought. Cool Water, Strawberry Roan, Little Green Valley were also memorable. Definitely still have to be in the right mood for an album like this, but after ignoring it yesterday, I'm glad I gave it a try today. Going on a country exploration now - my favourite part of this list, inspiring musical rabbit holes.
Pleasant cowboy music with a few notable songs about getting shot.
Bit shit but different
This one's cut from a different cloth. It's not actually the oldest album to come up for our group but it definitely *feels* the oldest. Maybe a little bit one-note, but it's a pretty good note.
6/10. The songwriting on this album is quite nice. However, this album just isn't for me. Sorry!!!
Listening to this felt like a ceremonial victory lap because I already knew it’s my favorite album of all time. In my opinion there is not a single bad song and it contains some of the best songs ever recorded.
I just this album recently and it’s fantastic.
Classy El Paso
surprisingly enjoyable. wouldn't mind having a copy of this one on my shelf.
Hell yeah.
Great cowboy music, transportive and with a great voice. But it's still cowboy music from the 50s - some of it sounds like it belongs in an old movie about killin' lawmen, some of it sounds like it belongs in an old movie about being in Hawaii, somehow. Nice artifact.
All timer
Sviđa mi se rockabilly vibe koji se tu i tamo pojavi, ali to je i dalje country. Ne mogu reći da mi je užasno jer imam ogroman respekt prema tom razdoblju glazbe, ali mi je mlaki filing kad slušam jer nema ničeg preuzbudljivog. Zbog toga će biti 2/5, 4/10
I just cannot believe I had such a gap in my country music knowledge, ignoring the existence of this man. This is some amazing music. 8.5/10 Fave track: Big Iron
Interesting
He's got a fine voice, and it's a good representative of its genre, but this isn't really my kind of thing. The lyric "He's about the worst bucker I've seen on the range" made me double take when I (mis)heard it.
A truly entertaining listen. Storytelling at its peak! “Old western” style country music where horrific tales of violent death are set to a jaunty tune.
Pretty good, surprisingly.
Takes me back to the wasteland.
If I could have given this a zero I would have - soz Martyn
Дед прослушает, батя оценит, а сын пройдет мимо. Я не знаком с творчеством Марти Роббинса, и этот альбом (как я понял, сборник хитов) стал для меня первым в его дискографии. Мне было действительно интересно погрузиться в атмосферу дикого запада и послушать его звучание, а оно здесь достаточно примечательное. Первостепенно в песнях с этого альбома воспринимается вокал в стиле Фрэнка Синатры. За ним слышен инструментал, и он звучит так, будто The Beatles после дебютных альбомов решили замедлить темп своих песен и уйти в минимализм, оставив лишь акустическую гитару и пару тройку духовых инструментов для припевов. К тому же в песнях присутствует замечательный бэк вокал, он играет достаточно важную роль в их восприятии. В этом альбоме слушатель не найдет ничего экспериментального, каждой песне с альбома присутствует уникальный мотив, который многократно повторяется на протяжении трека, что делает почти все песни однообразными и незапоминающимися. К слову, однообразность песен определенно положительно сказывается на прослушивании альбома в качестве фоновой музыки (если вдруг обычные lo-fi стримы с ютуба надоели). Я прослушал версию альбома с 27 песнями, хотя в оригинале их количество составляет 12, и хотелось бы мне конечно же сказать, что альбом затянутый, но нет, 27 баллад подряд звучат как одна большая история в стике кантри и воспринимаются как настоящий концептуальный альбом. К сожалению, отсутствие настоящих хитов и конкретно устаревшее звучание (в отличие от битлов, которые всего через несколько лет покажут классику рока) не дают мне поставить высокую оценку данному альбому. Послушать его хотя бы раз безусловно стоит, но на постоянной основе я это сделать не смогу. Ковбойские 3,5/5 (3/5).
I have a particular fondness for albums that transport me somewhere else, and Gunfighter Ballads… does this with abundance. From Big Iron onwards I was whisked off to a Wild West film set and each song felt like another step on a journey that saw me riding through monument valley or recounting tales of love and adventure round a campfire. Each song was a joy, each was a story and I could listen to it over and over. 5 stars.
Classic record, have listened to this hundreds of times.
Peak.
Saddle up pardner
Not really my style, but I love that every song is about murder
I had this album on vinyl. It burned in the fire. I loved it. I’m not sure if it’s really 5 stars, but I love it anyway. My favorite was listening to this album with my dad, who is in his 80s, on the way to IKEA. As a lover of western movies, He was blown away. Look, just listen to it. It’s got some bangers and I am a sucker for the clean sound of Robbins’ voice-like a teen idol, but it’s all songs about killing dudes in Rosa’s Cantina.
Oldschoolowe country. Jak z Radia Pogoda. Ma to swój urok, ale w pewnym momencie staje się bardzo monotonne. Każdy kawałek jest przyjemny, bo każdy jest taki sam. Na jedno kopyto ten koń jest kuty. Mimo tego nadal całkiem nieźle się bawiłam przy tej płycie. 6/10
Of its time, music romanticising the old Wild West. Quite popular with the generations that preceeded mine. Can't doubt he's got a good voice and the lyrics are well crafted as vignettes. The sort of music my late mother and her generation seemed to love
First listen. Impressive, most impressive!
Yeah
El Paso is a classic
Even if you imagined what the epitome of old school country sounds like, this would still blow it out of the water. A bit too twee for me
I know cowboy is having a moment and objectively his voice is lovely - but I simply could not bring myself to engage with this.
Smooth country swing
Very linear, over-explanatory storytelling. Also has a strange fixation with geography. Idk, this was a weird one. Like if Lawrence Welk was doing Johnny Cash.
I'm not sure how to rate this! I liked it and thought it was good at what it was going for. So, 3 stars?
Oldies country pop. Some songs sound like an old TV theme song, and that's just fime by me
This is truly one of the greatest albums of all time. This is the sort of thing that makes me wish I could give 6 stars. Incredible from end-to-end.
I'm a sucker for songs that tell a story and that's this whole album. Great.
first “i have no idea what this is” album of the project but it was fun! Robbins doesn’t have quite the same cultural foothold as, say, Johnny Cash, but it definitely speaks to something timeless about this album that so many of its songs have been used in modern media. Shoutout Breaking Bad
I’ve always enjoyed this sort of stuff. Classic, simple, super singalongable even if you’ve never heard it before. Reminds me of Burl Ives who I listen to a lot with my sister as well as others of that era and ilk. Makes me want to pick up the guitar again. (3.5 stars)
Won't lie, I thought I was going to hate this from the cover. But it was actually good fun! The songs felt a little same-y is my only complaint.
Love this album. El Paso is a staple.
Shout-out to El Paso for it's place in Grateful Dead songbook. Otherwise not really a fan of the smooth, straight-ahead, and of it's time nature of this music.
I liked the palate and story telling
Yee haw. This is going on regular rotation.
I liked this way more than I expected. Reminded me of a Quentin Tarantino movie. Looking at the cover it was exactly what I expected. Great storytelling, pleasant melodies - I really liked the vibe surprisingly. I’m giving this 4 stars sorry not sorry.
Gunslinging perfection…
maybe the most classic of all classic western albums. this album puts the western in country and western music. the songs are short, sweet, and catchy. marty robbins' voice is so great and pleasant to listen to. to be honest, i think marty robbins was the vocalist early elvis was most trying to be when he sang ballads. just a really solid album.
Considered a classic this is just too far outside my wheelhouse to really enjoy.
Country western songs from the 1950s. A little bit Cash-Style, not as dark. Happier.
Sometimes things can get a little too yeehaw for my liking. I do enjoy country music, and the tracks in this album are a full reflection of the album's art, but my problem with it is that almost every song sounds the same. There are some highlights, like The Master's Call, but most of them were as catchy as the same cords over and over again in a track can be. Enjoyable, nothing mind-blowing.
О кайф это знаю и люблюю Песня молодости
3/5
It was okay, nostigia-type feeling while listening to it. But nothing that would make me wanna think or vibe to.
2 Stars (5/15)
Totally good, but very repetitive to the point of songs blending together
Was almost a western storybook album, made me laugh in places and surprisingly I didn’t hate it.
Yee-haw I want to play New Vegas now
Johnny Cash and Elvis and... Marty Robbins!
Surprised with how much I enjoyed it. Not a fan of country, but I do like the classics like this one, and the more popular stuff from the 70s and 80s
Surprisingly pleasant, actually.
Decent
Just about the only country music I can listen to
Hits
Big iron on his hip
I own this vinyl, bought used in the 80’s. Transferred it to cassette, and loved cranking Big Iron as I roared across the desert Southwest in my old Fiat ragtop. The Spider is long gone to the scrapper, but the outlaw ballads still gets regular PT in my space. God Bless Marty Robbins!
yeehaw cowboy outlaw sheriff !!! good lyrics on this one
YEE-HAW
not for me
A big iron on his hip
oh helll yeaah
I liked it! Breaking Bad vibes. :)
A classic and Often listened to album at my house Not just because of Fallout
Its kinda fun. The songs start to sound the same to me. Its not really for me, but it was a fun listen and the stories painted were kinda fun lol. "Big Iron" and "El Paso" are classics. I think this is actually like a 2.5. Liked Songs: "Big Iron" , "Utah Carol" , "The Strawberry Roan" , "El Paso" , "The Hanging Tree"
liked songs: I definitely recognized Big Iron. I can't say I'm a big fan of this genre (cowboy country??). 1.75
When I think of old country music, songs like this and Hank Williams Sr come to mind. This sounds like the soundtrack to every old western movie. I think it’s great and sounds more authentic than the shit that is passed as country today.
Who knew Marty Robbins wrote the original Hanging Tree song
i really don’t know what or how to rate this. the songs were fine but with this genre i can’t tell them apart, they all sound the same to me
Made me feel like I was sitting in a rocking chair on a porch in a big ranch house drinking bourbon and smoking cigars
I'm of two minds on this one. Is it as good to me as the other 5 star albums on my list? No it isn't so I feel like I should rank it lower. On the other hand, I can't really find fault with it, I liked every song. For what it is, gunfighter ballads and trail songs, it is stellar. Great stories, great songs and Marty Robbins soothing voice.
Giving this a 3 because I can’t really imagine ever seeking this out to listen to it again but I actually enjoyed it. Great story telling, simple but complementary music, nice voice.
I am now trans.
Great!
Fun
Not my thing generally; too plodding. But Cool Water has nice harmonies. "The night's are cool and I'm a fool" is great.
Simple, elegant, charming 5/5
This was nice. Cool. Interesting. I enjoyed it and will definitely come back to it.
they all kinda sound the same, but thats not really the point. Quite alike Johnny Cash, which is great. cool storytelling. Favourite songs: Big iron, a hundred and sixty acres, Utah Carrol, El Paso, the hanging tree. Overall around 7/10
I suppose if I was going to go out to an old-timey western-themed restaurant.... well, I think I would still get pretty tired of this after just a couple of songs. My tolerance is even lower in my own home. I can tell it's got some merit to it, though, so I'm not giving it the dreaded one-star rating.
Artiste inconnu. Très répétitif, donc très ennuyeux. Rien de bien intéressant, j'ai arrêté au 4eme morceau. =>1/5
Hell yeah brother What else can I even say here
Marty Robbins is like the Homer of country or frontier folk, whatever you’d call this. I could listen to the man spin a yarn for hours. That’s not even mentioning his phenomenal backing on this record - the backing harmonies and guitar fills are absolutely perfect.
Solid and consistent El Paso is on the album twice for some reason.
This is a pretty typical cowboy album - or perhaps prototypical. It's fun, often melancholy, and a great listen. Favorite track: "Big Iron"
4/5. Bardzo przyjemne i kilka piosenek zapisałem.
Country music, cowboys in the Wild West - Voice is smooth and deep - Pretty boring for melodies, lyrics, and instrumentals
I almost would have liked to hear the band play without Marty’s vocals on several of these songs.
I love Marty Robbins voice, and storytelling songs are so great! Sad songs with bullets
This was a really, cool old school country album! It was interesting to listen to this and hear what a country album was like from the tail end of the 50s overall it was an interesting addition to this!
Not my cup of tea
Classic country.
Great album if you’re not a Mexican broad or a horse
Audio sounds amazing, songs are great lyrically. A lot of effort went into making this album great, but it never takes itself too seriously
An absolutely essential country album that adds a soundtrack for the US obsession with the myth of the Old West that took hold in the 1950s and 1960s. I could listen to this all day.
This was quite a pleasant listen
Pretty decent album, but Marty Robbins was MAGA before MAGA was a thing, so fuck him.
Wish I had a big iron on my hip.
I actually really like music like this, though I hardly ever listen to it. The story telling always makes it feel like an action movie. As an album, it's not coherent but thats to be expected for 1959. I will certainly explore this sound more
A little too much country 4 me
Gunslinging ballads aren’t my jam
Love it. It’s like being transported back in time to a Western Movie. I could have this on in the background all day.
Starts out like a gunslinger; quick and sure. But tumbles down into the little green valley faster than a wild mustang being chased by a runaway wagon wheel. OK finish with Saddle Tramp and El Paso, none the less it’s still old country. Overall, the album feels dated and a bit hokey. Limps in at (2.1*s)
I don't know what's stranger: the fact that I recognized a few songs on this album or that I actually enjoyed it all the way through. I expected to rate this very low but to my surprise it was really fun and engaging. I also like how this is considered "Pop" for 1959; catchy strumming, detailed stories, and a copper voice make these bonafide foot-tappers. You're damned if this doesn't make you wanna grab your boots and go herd cattle. It definitely evoked feelings and scenery in a very tangible way. An easy 2.35 for the cowboy waltzes, now go watch The Ballad of Buster Scruggs.
Some jaunty cowboy tunes from a bygone era. Marty my boy can spin a good yarn about the gunslingin' west. Little surprised it was written and released in 1959. I was quite caught up in the ol' saddle tramp's story telling, despite the repetitive themes and it being country music. "El Paso" and "Big Iron" were best tracks. Much more enjoyable then I expected...2.39.
From the onset of the first note I was worried that this would be a struggle. I expected a collection of outdated country western songs with limited appeal. While that's pretty much what I got it was a little better than my initial judgement. Classic western country is pretty far from my personal taste so I won't be coming back but I didn't struggle with this as much as many other entries on the list. I'm sure there was an era and a setting when this was appealing but as a coastal city boy it just doesn't resonate with me in any way. You can throw one of these on in a late night saloon every now and then but otherwise I'll mostly skip the entire genre. 1.57 stars
Great driving album, a gem of American west
I've been patiently waiting to review this album, and now, on the eve of my 700th album, I'll finally get my chance. The title of this album, combined with the cover, paints a pretty vivid image with a small canvas, and that's what's made me so excited to listen to it. I'm not sure if I'll love or hate this album, but at least I'll have a unique experience! This album definitely lived up to the hype that I built for it in my head. Every aspect of it was done exceptionally well: the songwriting, the singing, and the guitar playing were all top-notch. I wasn't expecting for most of these songs to be such downers, but all of the sadder songs carried their emotional weight exceptionally well. I really loved the songs that had backing vocals, like "Big Iron," because they really fulfilled that stereotype of a trail song. The guitar playing was really great too, especially on "El Paso." The instrumentals on this album were sparse, but they were all done exceptionally well. The thing that really outshone the guitar playing though was the singing. I really loved Marty Robbins's voice on all of these songs, and I thought he sang everything really well. This was a really fun album to listen to, and certainly a unique experience. I'm glad it lived up to my expectations!
Great singer - kind of an Elvis vibe. Even though it's old and not really my style, I definitely appreciate the musicality.
This album makes you realize how really radical the Beatles were in 1962.
Beautifully atmospheric, luscious instrumentation, superb songwriting and soaring harmonies. This has everything you need to be nostalgic of a time you've not experienced. Best Tracks: - Big Iron - Cool Water - The Master's Call Worst Tracks: N/A Rating: 9.5/10
Classic american western feeling album!
Really enjoyable. Vocals were amazing, melodies were great, some of the songs were brilliant. But generally some songs felt too slow or like filler so I have to mark it down a point
El bodrio del country no termina. 1.5
I enjoyed it. Not the type of music I'd go back to but it was a good listen.
Sorry, not for me, I skipped it after a while! I guess it's a cultural thing, I don't know; for English native speakers I understand the storytelling can be fabulous but for me, meh... let's just say, doesn't make my type ;-)
Morgan “Jelly Roll” Wallen could never.
Perfect album. I love all of it from front to back! What I always find funny is that the music is all a complete anachronism but sounds so perfectly “western” - it’s like the country music version of a spaghetti western
Classic
I’d give Marty Robbins a role in the sack.
I can see why something like this would be on this list. It's very pleasing on the ears. Light, fun, simple, great melodies. Just not my daily listening preference, but glad I am now familiar with it.
A true body of work, in the sense that eyolf olstrem on dylan chords said about world gone wrong. Everything serves the whole: the lonesome wail, the perfect leads, the stories, the murder, the redemption, the love. It sounds like all of american music and nothing else at the same time. In the glory days of napster my roommate downloaded a couple of these cause his dad had listened, and I'm grateful to be let into this. What an album.
This yee do be hawing, ain't it right, fellas?
++: Big Iron, Cool Water, Billy the Kid, A Hundred and Sixty Acres, They're Hanging Me Tonight, The Master's Call, Running Gun, Utah Carol +: The Strawberry Roan, In the Valley, The Little Green Valley +-: El Paso 7,9/10
I listened to this multiple times over the course of several days and it just kept growing on me more and more. I love the old West aesthetic and the timeless sound. Each song was very distinct for the time, each having it's own unique hook that on relistens I was excited to hear. I can't wait to go on a road trip through the plains and blast this album. 5/5
I enjoyed the bad boy vibe and some of the country sounds, but it's a product of its time and just sounded a bit too close to eat listening for me
This was an amazing album. I’ve never been much of a country guy, but this album has everything I would want in a good Western country album. Every song has a strong narrative, telling a story that draws you in and makes you feel like you’re living it.
achieved exactly what it set out to do. very repetitive but not a bad listen. nice to hear the original (?) recording of El Paso but weird that it’s on the album twice
The album overall is great, old country. I've only recently discovered any country music that I like. The stuff that I do like that's contemporary, has an older feel to it, harkening back to music like this but more rich (given that it's written more recently). I'd give this album a 4/5.
Lay still, Lenore, I'm coming? Big iron, indeed! 3.5
Bruh yes x1000. One of the vinyls I am most proud I own
Fun, but a bit too country for me
Fun and nostalgic
It wasnt as bad as I was expecting, although it was exactly what I expected. They're of a time and they do really make you feel like you're watching an old cowboy film.