Reviews (page 4 of 13)
4 Wasn't expecting to be belting out Christmas songs on the way to work on a May morning haha. Enjoyed this
This is a great fun listen. Not my favourite Pogues album, but still good. Caused me to read about the Birmingham Six and the quote from Lord Denning rejecting one of their civil cases go any further is staggering: "If the six men win, it will mean that the police were guilty of perjury, that they were guilty of violence and threats, that the confessions were involuntary and were improperly admitted in evidence and that the convictions were erroneous. ...This is such an appalling vista that every sensible person in the land would say: It cannot be right that these actions should go any further." Genuinely couldn't conceive of police corruption.
I really like this album haven't listened anything as unique before with the Irish mixed into rock but it's hard because I won't listen to this kinda music in my free time so with that I'm giving it a 4.
The Pogues are always the first band I think of when I think of Irish music. This album is a good indicator of that being the truth. Traditional Irish sounds throughout the record, including couple of traditional songs like The Rocky Road to Dublin and the Irish Rover being done on this one. A Fairytale in New York is one of the greatest songs ever written. Felt a little odd listening to it in May but was still quite happy to to hear it on the way to work today.
А это неожиданно, очень звучное сочетание оркестра
MacGowan’s vocals present a risk of causing secondhand drunkenness, but it’s worth it.
Music to drink to.
awesome! punk. celtic. energy. fun.
I absolutely loved this album! It’s so much fun and surprisingly eclectic.
Good stuff. I prefer the instrumentals but they're all pretty good.
Pretty good but an hour is a lot of fiddling
This is the kind of punk rock my brain accepts more than, say, Germ
Very early Dropkick Murphys-esque which makes sense because it’s from essentially the same time.
Loved the whole vibe here. Could listen to this straight through. Love the creativity and style!
Listening to Shane MacGowan is more like drinking whisky than drinking whisky is. It's almost so Irish as to feel appropriative, except it's authentic, it's actually Shane and Co. On previous attempts with the Pogues (mostly the other album that is almost assuredly on the list), that deep Irishness has been a roadblock, because of how it imbues the sound of every track. Maybe I'm in a better mood or more open, or maybe this is just a better album, but it isn't really hurting it this time. Maybe that's in part due to Fairytale of New York, the down-on-luck anti-love-song that manages to be one of the few tolerable Christmas songs AND few tolerable songs including casual homophobia. Kirsty MacColl probably goes a long way there. But the Celtic throughline mixes with so many other sounds… latin vibes, eastern influences, spy movie soundtracks, and of course, plenty of punk cutting through it. It doesn't sound like trite drinking music like so many other Irish punk (and especially Irish American punk) bands… Shane definitely always sounds 8 sheets to the wind… he was basically Amy Winehouse before Amy Winehouse as that goes… but he has something to say through that busted mouth of his. This album is frontloaded, for sure… the weird vibe of Fiesta, not to mention the medley, or ending with Worms, makes the second side weaker… but that first side makes a super strong case already, so I think i feel comfortable keeping this at a light 4*. I'll be keeping a lookout for this in the crates.
i assumed this was going to be obnoxious but it showed restraint and was actually really good
Oh hell ya
A unique mixture of global music, that all seemed to revert back to jigs.
A number of these tracks are on various holiday playlists of mine. But I don’t think I have ever listened to the album. About half way in, I thought I might need a break, but I am glad I saw it through. I would never throw this on. But I loved it all. I do believe it is best kept where it is, spread out over my holidays with Fairytale of New York nestled nicely between Bing Crosby and Mariah Carey. Boolean: yes, definitely glad to have heard before I die.
Well I’ve really enjoyed both Pogues albums on the list now. I didn’t know any songs bar the obvious, and it was strange listening to a Christmas song in May, moreover, it’s kind of strange having a Christmas song on a studio album but I enjoyed nonetheless. I liked the variety on display here and the energy makes me want to hear them live, even if it is probably too late for that now.
A raucous record with punk-influenced Irish folk/traditional music. Lots of banjo, accordion, tin whistle and other traditional instruments overlaid by Shane MacGowan's signature enthusiastic drunken, slurred vocal delivery. The record opens with the title track and two more fun foot-stomping dance-inducing tunes, but then slows the pace with the famous Christmas-themed ballad "Fairytale of New York". The subsequent songs' quality don't always quite reach the excellence of those first four, particularly when they venture into other ethnic styles, but overall a fun collection. The Recruiting Sergeant / The Rocky Road to Dublin / Galway Races medley is magnificent. Great songs, and except for some slightly dated 80s tinges on bits of some songs, great production.
One of the best irish music albums I've listened to and in spirit, this sounds like a punk album and it works. I've had a lot of fun with this. It's not the greatest album I've heard, but it's great. Strong 4/5
Mad that I didn't get this on St. Patrick's Day. 3.5/5.0: Very Good
the precursor to flogging molly, this was a super fun listen
I hated the title track with a passion. But by the time I got to bottle of smoke I was laughing.
This was a great folk-punk album. I had never heard of these guys, but being a fan of the likes of Flogging Molly and Dropkick Murphys, this was a treat. It was maybe a bit long - Apple Music only offered the expanded edition - but I really enjoyed it.
"Fairytale of New York" is my all-time favorite secular Christmas song, and it has been since before I knew that the track just appears in the middle of a non-holiday album. Shane MacGowan was a treasure in his own way. The cover photo makes them look quite respectable.
Features one of the best Christmas songs of all time, along a bunch of other fantastically written and moody songs! I very much enjoyed listening to this!
I had a lot of fun listening to this album I really liked it it was full of joy and whimsey.
I prefer the other Pogues album on the list, but this was a delightful change of pace and a nice listen too.
1. "If I Should Fall From Grace With God" 2. "Fairytale of New York" 3. "Thousands Are Sailing"
3.8 I was getting quite into that. Album ended at the perfect time, as I was starting to think that these songs are staring to sound the same, and then Brand Majestic Shannon came on which is basically a carbon copy of Fairytale. Never realised Fiesta was by the Pogues! One of the weaker tracks anyway, the fast paced Celtic bits (which to be fair were most of the album) was were the real highlights sat. I'm ignoring the bonus tracks as I think the album was a good length in its original form.
I loved this album. I wish I was drinking a pint and singing along at the pub. The album went much better for me when I switched on the Karaoke/lyrics tab on Spotify and could understand what the Hell they were talking about.
fun album. My favorite track is Worms I'm definitely biased because I've been listening to a lot of Irish music in the past two years. There are a few bangers on here and also enough variety to keep it interesting. I used to be put off by the lead singer's voice, but not so much now, I guess
Jes! Pogues maistuu aina, vaikka omissa papereissani tämä onkin vasta toiseksi paras levy Rum, Sodomy & The Lashin jälkeen. Ote on aika paljon popimpi kun sillä, mutta ei se nyt varsinaisesti haittaa. Tosi mukavaa kuunneltavaa ja helvetin hyviä biisejä, kirkkaimpana kruununa tietysti Fairytale of New York joka on aikalailla ainoa joululaulu jota kuuntelen vapaaehtoisesti - aivan huikean upea biisi. Ehkä tosiaan kokonaisuus on hippasen verran tylsempi kun viiden tähden RS&L:llä. Sen vuoksi neljä tähteä, hyvin vahvat neljä tähteä kuitenkin.
The music is polarizing, and I'm on the love side vs. hate. I get that it'd be tough to listen to this day in day out, but it's a nice change of pace, and I like the energy and the lyrics of many of these songs. Fairytale of New York is enough to give this album a 4.
Very entertaining
Oh my god, this was DELIGHTFUL. I'm already a sucker for Celtic Rock and Punk, so it's a wonder I've never heard this album before now. I've always been aware of The Pogues but for whatever reason I just never checked them out. I'm glad that's been broken, because holy crap. This album is a lot of fun. Upbeat and eccentric with lots of different approaches to the style, fantastic songwriting and McGowan's voice is perfect for this style. Even the Christmas song near the beginning of the record is done superbly and doesn't at all feel out of place. RIP Shane, you were a hell of a musician and The Pogues are a band I can't wait to dig into more.
Lovely album.
Labadoux vibes!
Muy interesante para escuchar, mezcla de música de piratas y de taberna. 8/10
An utter masterpiece, but must be knocked down one star due to my seething hatred of Fairytale of New York, a song an old roommate once (intentionally?) put on single song repeat, turned his stereo up to 11, locked his bedroom door, and left for hours and hours.
Didn’t realized I got the extended edition. Probably didn’t need that, was a 3 star for being too long. Changing to a 4 mostly because of a a Fairytale of New York
A friendly reminder that no one is happier to rebel than the Irish
A few all time classics on this album. I love Shane MacGowan.
Rating:★★★★ Never heard of this band before, but I dig the Irish folk/punk thing they have going. Music that makes you want to dance and think about what they're saying at the same time.
I have not listened to The Pogues much before this album, but it's way less gimmicky than I thought it would be.
I have no idea if this album is good or not. I was probably grinning the whole time listening to it though.
(5/7) fun stuff
Strong Irish vibes
Ziemlich cool aber nutzt sich auf albumlänge schnell ab.
Punk wasnt dead
Fun, not what I’m always in the mood for, but enjoyable when I am
4.5 Irish drinking songs. Fun, crazy that there’s a whole album of them. Feels like I’m sitting in an Irish pub and it’s raining out and there’s a band in the corner. It would get a 5, but there a few instrumental songs
Enjoyed since I literally just got back from Ireland!
I like the way his voice and Irish accent sound
Celtic folk punk gets points for the immaculate vibes. I suspect I liked this one more than most would There's songs like "Metropolis" which play on my deep love for brass sections where they don't typically belong. "Sketches of Spain" has these immaculate vibes which make me smile. "Fairytale of New York" in April feels a little sacrilegious but it doesn't matter because it's still the best christmas song. The folky songs work for me, slurred vocal performance and all.
Celtic rock is so damn fun
I knew I'd like this album, but not as much as I did. Such a brilliant collection of songs, a fun, drunken, folk-punk ride. RIP Shane MacGowan. Favourites: If I Should Fall From Grace With God Bottle Of Smoke Fairytale of New York Medley The Irish Rover South Australia
vraiment bien bonne ambiance change beaucoup, authentique
Cool Irish-style punk. Tends a little more traditional than the Dropkick Murphies, and probably served as an inspiration for the latter. Nice listen. Would go back to. 4/5
Loved it! Exactly a vibe I've been needing!
Oh cool! It's that song from the Guardians of the Galaxy Christmas Special.
Mais c’était super cool ! Du rock/punk joué avec des instruments irlandais, c’est du génie !
I normally don’t need a full album of Irish music, but this was good. Also Fairytale of New York is starting to become one of my favorite Christmas songs, and I’m not even sure if it counts as a Christmas song
My initial take is that this is gonna be fun but exhausting. So far the fun part is 100% right. Actually even better than I thought. Some of the songs have an almost Chris de Burgh vibe to them which I didn't expect.
Still a delight to listen to.
It's not my style, but I think objectively, this is considered good? Went a little long though
Any album that produces "The Fairytale of New York" gets an extra bump.
No insight, just praise.
Like staggering out of the Shamrock Bar in Benidorm after 15 pints of porter and remembering you are on holiday for another week. Slainté!
not my fav type of music, its just ok for me
Great album of Irish themed pinkish material with flavours of other European music filtering through
The MacGowan led Pogues at their most…mature? I think Shane may have been on the follow up as well but in a much diminished (in the full scope of the word) capacity. Could be wrong. But anyhow, a four for not being quite as ramshackle as their first two.
This was a really fun listen! Celtic Folk-Punk was a welcome treat, and there was unexpectedly some mariachi elements throughout the record in the form a brass section. One song was literally called "Fiesta." My two complaints are that I didn't enjoy the song "Worms," and the song "Fairytale of New York" used the f-slur. Maybe a band member was allowed to say it? I don't know. Anyway, good album!
klasik
Can hear the prototype of Flogging Molly’s Salty Dog in Bottle of Smoke, and the prototype for the Dropkick Murphy’s Bastards on Parade sprinkled throughout. Being only versed in the Pogues album about Rum and Sodomy, this was a welcome adventure, and I liked the first handful of songs quite a bit. I do feel a lot of this could’ve been pared down otherwise though, and even though Wikipedia praised this album with being more cohesive than their earlier works, I found it extremely not cohesive. We randomly have two Dubliners duets in the third quarter, for instance. While welcome, what are they doing here?
#313/1001. Fast song slow song Irish song classic song Christmas song, sometimes many or even all together. Gets a bit sing-a-longy when the Dubliners enter the stage, I don't know if that was a bonus or something, but then again after just visiting Ireland I suppose it could be like that at least somewhere very far from Dublin's Temple Bar.
Nunca había escuchado tantos instrumentos juntos en un solo álbum. Le pongo 3 estrellas porque no es algo q escucharía siempre
This tapped into some weird unexplored drunken angry Irishman side of me I didn't know existed.
FUN STUFF, and to hear Fairytale of New York in a regular album, non-Christmas context was pretty rad!
They're really good and it really isn't for me. My God it all sounds the same and I hate the primary singer. But if you're into Irish music with great skill this is for you
If we’re going to call this “punk,” which I understand might be a bit reductive, this is the best punk album yet by a *wide* margin. This is properly good.
Muito energético e uns quantos clássicos
Uma boa noite de copos. Começa com aquela energia da cerveja, depois ao fim de alguns temas a clássica canção bêbada da meia noite que leva ao inevitável falecimento seguido do ondasetrom da resurreiçao e recomeça de novo. Via fácil um concerto. Não leva 5 que ao fim de algum tempo fica repetitivo
Es como si los músicos, de la escena de Titanic donde Rose va a bailar con los pobres, se volvieran loquitos
A chance to listen to Fairytale of New York outside of Christmas? I’m in!
Such riotous energy flowing from this one. Made me want to leave work and go to the pub.
Maakt me niet uit wat anderen zeggen; dit is piratenrock. En blijkbaar vind ik Piraten rock goed te beuken. Het is verdomde snel, maar dat lekkere Ierse accent houd wel de aandacht er bij zeg! Hahah fucking fantastisch, ik denk dat ik een nieuw favoriet kerstnummer heb gevonden met Fairytale in New York. Wat een hilarisch nummer weer. Denk dat dat ook is wat me aan deze band trekt, het is Piratenrock, maar ze hebben er overduidelijk ontzettend veel plezier in. Dat scheelt echt een hele hoop op een album als iedereen weet dat het niet het meest serieuze album allertijden gaat worden. Dan helpt het voor dit genre dat een zanger niet goed hoeft te zijn, alleen een dik Iers accent hoeft te hebben en dat het muzikaal retestrak in elkaar zit. Tsja, soms kan muziek toch ook heel makkelijk zijn.. Merk wel dat de eerste helft van dit album duidelijk de sterkere helft is. Of misschien ben ik piraten rock moe, dat zou ook heel goed kunnen. Gok dat dit een album is dat een makkelijke 5 sterren is als je 6 rum/whisky diep in een kroeg staat. Lullaby of London is dan weer totaal niet mn nummer, dan komen de mindere kanten van de zanger meer naar boven. Ik wil wat dat betreft liever nog 10 snellere nummers dan nog 3 van deze lullabies/ballads. Maar: het heeft me niet weerhouden om uiteindelijk ook de nummers na Worm te luisteren, ook al staan die niet officieel op de tracklist(sowieso goed idee, de nummers met The Dubliners zijn heel dik) Dit is gewoon wederom een heel erg lekker album, niet perfect, maar absoluut goed. Ahoy mateyy!! FAVO: If I should fall from grace with god, Turkish song of the Damned, Fairytale in New York,
Great folks crossover. I taste a pinch of lounge, a smattering of punk and a heaping spoonful of swagger. Really fun.
Day809 - i would kinda like to join the church of the pogues. the title song rocks and fairytale of new york is just a beautiful composition
One of the biggest surprises in this list so far. This album is awesome. Incredibly unique and great musicianship. I mean a Celtic folk instruments with a phaser? How can you not appreciate that. I think my favorite thing about this record is how re-listenable it is. So much variety and energy. 4.25/5
I am already predisposed to like this album. Fairytale of New York has been my favourite Christmas song since I was 5 years old. My parents will admit it's a weird song for a 5 year old to like but I couldn't get enough of it.
Een aantal zieke classics. Niet per se fan van, maar iconisch
What a banger of an album... I suspect it's worthy of a 5/5 once you've had a few drinks to loosen you up and take the rough edge off Shane MacGowan's voice... Sadly I listened sober, but it's still very close. "Fairytale of New York" is legendary. A well and truly deserved 4. Éirinn go Brách!
Only knew them from the Christmas song they do but this was a great listen. The fusion of punk/folk/rock is perfect.
Listened previously. Expectations: High - Verdict: Great - This falls right on the cusp of all time great status for me. I adore The Pogues and I think they made better albums than this but the songs are just so good and the energy so infectious.
Super.
𝘐𝘧 𝘐 𝘚𝘩𝘰𝘶𝘭𝘥 𝘍𝘢𝘭𝘭 𝘧𝘳𝘰𝘮 𝘎𝘳𝘢𝘤𝘦 𝘸𝘪𝘵𝘩 𝘎𝘰𝘥 is where traditional Irish folk and punk attitude come together most naturally. Fiddles, banjos and whistles collide with the energy of a rock band, creating a sound that feels both chaotic and deeply rooted in folk tradition. At the center is the unmistakable voice of Shane MacGowan, whose rough delivery somehow fits perfectly with the band’s rowdy yet often surprisingly emotional songs. The album jumps between wild drinking anthems and more reflective moments, giving it a lot of character. It’s messy, loud and full of personality — but that’s exactly what makes the record so enjoyable.
Such a great voice, especially when he's belting. Gets a little fiddly at times. There is a sense of humor amid the gloom, which I appreciate. A good time listening to this one.
Fun and energetic while also having some melodic and more soothing tracks this was a great listening experience. Love how they can shift from soft to vibrant while still keeping the overall theme the same. 7/10, Favorite Song: South Australia
7/10
The masters of Irish punk/folk. Has to be high up in ratings for having 'Fairytale of New York' on it, but the rest is pretty good, too. Although Macgowan's vocals are a bit rough around the edges at times, it lends a charm to proceedings that fits with the overall vibe.
If i should fall from grace with god - 4 Turkish song of the damned - 4 Bottle of smoke - 3 Fairytale of new york - 5 Metropolis - 3 Thousands are sailing - 5 Fiesta - 3 Medley - 4 Streets of sorrow / birmingham six - 4 Lullaby of london - 3 Sit down by the fire - 3 The broad majestic shannon - 4 Worms - n/a
Great stuff. Not a genre I’m ever interested in, but The Pogues are an amazing exception, and this gem is produced by Steve Lillywhite.
Very fun to listen to and as an Irish person this made me feel very patriotic. Love this album☘️🇮🇪
great bagpipe
7/10 Nice Irish music
I like their sound quite a bit. Fairytale of New York was a great song. Quite a different sound than what I'm used to listening to.
the music of my people 😌 so good
I really enjoyed this one and more than I thought I was going to. I also realised some of the bands I listen to are definitely inspired by their sound and Shane MacGowan's style of signing. Standout tracks are 'Medley: The Recruiting Sergeant / The Rocky Road to Dublin / The Galway Races', 'Fiesta' and 'Sit Down by the Fire'.
A folk-punk album? Well, this is fun!
Great fun!
Some are good, some are okey. I kinda like it 7/10
Well lad, now I know the prefect album for Saint Paddy’s Day. I couldn’t listen to this all the time but there were some great songs on here. Drinking songs I might add…cheers.
brilliant. 4 and a half
Haven't listened to this as much as the first two albums for some reason. Great bunch of lads.
Pure class.
unreal
Ready to fight 1000 Unionists outside an Ulster pub. We got a foot of snow yesterday so good timing for Fairytale of New York!
Is this a Christmas album? Very fun, had a great time!
Not how I imagined spending my Friday, but I enjoyed the vibe of this album and the instrumentation. This album made me want to tap my toe.
derry girls never should have ended
fun and versatile with a few classics.. nice
good
It’s pretty annoying that streaming services don’t have the original albums available. I don’t want or need extended versions of albums I’m listening to for the first time. Apple Music can póg mo thóin
Tremendous fun to listen to. Not a bad song on it and I ended up dancing round my living room while listening. So why isn’t it five stars? Fairytale Of New York. FONY isn’t a bad song, in fact it’s probably one of the best Christmas tunes ever written. Problem is I ran an offy for 10 years and we had an in store radio that couldn’t be changed, believe me I tried. All throughout December I heard that bloody song in work at least 3-4 times a shift every day cause obviously it’s good drinking music if you’re getting a carry out. I have heard it enough times to last me several lifetimes. Top Track - Turkish Song Of The Damned
This was another surprising one for me. I had never heard of The Pogues, and man, was I missing out. I really enjoy this rambunctious blend of punk and traditional Irish music. It also has a good range of moods on it, going from the raucous tracks like "Bottle of Smoke", to some with interesting global influences like "Turkish Song of the Damned" and "Fiesta", to Springsteen-esque ballads like "Fairytale of NY". Overall a great showing, I still feel as though the back half loses a slight bit of luster due to a lot of the medleys and more traditional tunes starting to feel a bit same-y. Still, the latter half has some standouts like "Mountain Dew" and "South Australia". Giving it a solid 4. Favorite Tracks: "If I Should Fall...", "Bottle of Smoke", "Fiesta", "Lullaby of London", "Mountain Dew" Least Favorite Track: "Worms" I suddenly have a strong desire to get blackout off of like 15-20 pints of Guinness.
Fantastic album. Almost perfect
Extremely enjoyable. Fairytale of New York is obviously a highlight, but I love the album as a whole. When I listened to it in the past I often skipped the instrumentals which I really shouldn't have because they're just so good.
Good band
More albums need random Christmas songs
Dug it. Fun listen. Love irsh folk songs with a rock twist. Im sure they influenced Dropjick Murphys and Flogging Molly.
Are you a fan of alcohol? Or smoking? Somehow this music sounds like both. How about being a fan of songs about the motherland while you toil away somewhere far away and songs are all sad and nostalgic, yet energetic? Do you like violins, flutes and/or accordions in your songs? How about being a fan of getting all drunk and emotional, and then throwing glasses at the wall or breaking dinner plates over your head while trying to slash your wrists with plate shards as feelings overwhelm you? Man, then can I recommend this album to you! Other than getting drunk somewhat occasionally, I'm not a fan of a single thing of what I've written above. However, I do recognize a lot of people are. This type of music should not work for me and yet... This *is* a good album.
This was so close to 5 stars but something, a little something is holding me back... One bloody solid blinder from the Pogues. I was already familiar with a few songs on this album, but hearing the entire things have given me many new Pogues favourites! This is flabbergastingly good celtic music. This thing could turn anyone pro-IRA. I've had "Thousands are sailing" on repeat for several days now, a stunning song that's blown my tits off. Lyricism, melody, everything is perfect. That song alone is 5/5 stars. In fact, the album run from 'If I shall fall from grace with God' to 'Fiesta' is 10/10 perfection. Great consistency, no song there is bad or boring. After Fiesta, the quality dips quite a bit. There's still a few gems in there though. I reckon if some of the fodder had been shaved off this could've been a perfect album. What we have already is bloody beautiful though. I hadn't thought this was the pogue's best album when I first went into it, but now I'm seriously considering changing my mind...one of the best listens I've had so far.
The celtic sound got a little tiring after a bit but a very fun album
Makes you wanna get some pints with them lads at the pub
Mate
The vibes are insane the fun is too strong
If it’s Irish shanties you are looking for, this is certainly the album. For what it is, this was a really good album, but I’m not sure how often I’m looking to listen to music like this not on St. Patrick’s Day.
I find myself having a recurring phase with celtic music, so this is right up my alley. Sort of has a Flogging Molly feel, actually had to google to see if it was the same singer (it’s not). Really liked this one. Standout Songs: If I Should Fall from Grace with God Turkish Song of the Damned Bottle of Smoke South Australia Fiesta Sit Down by the Fire
Irish folky punk is so the perfect way to start a Monday morning. This was a blast - a lot of foot-tapping hurdy-gurdy bangers, a few Spanish sounding songs (random but it works), a christmas classic and a song about worms. What is there to dislike? Ok half the lyrics are impossible to understand but it's a lot of fun. Bottle of Smoke, Medley, Sit Down by the Fire and South Australia are all fantastic.
7.0/10 Sounds like a party
Man I heard the first song and was like woahhhh I think Im gonna hate this cos all the songs will sound so folk-y. BUT BOY WAS I WRONG!!! I found out who wrote Thousands Are Sailing, an epic song from haslemere childhood. Fiesta is a bangerrrrrr!!! And just overall so many great tunes and a fabulously cohesive album that makes me proud of my Irish heritage woo
Insanely catchy and fun. This is the type of music that just makes me want to grab a pint (or five) with my friends down at the pub. A joyous and explosive record that is not without its emotional and deeper moments, namely the famous Christmas lament "Fairytale of New York". All the ingredients are here. Highly recommended. Key tracks: If I Should Fall from Grade With God Turkish Song of the Damned Fairytale of New York Fiesta
I feel like Tim Armstrong (Rancid/Op Ivy/etc) borrowed from this guy's vocal style. Not all of it, but certain things they do match up pretty close. I've heard "Fairytale of New York" before because a pro wrestler sang it with Mr. Blobby on a British indie wrestling show. Wrestling is fun. But I digress. Starts off a little slow but gets better as it goes on. Pretty fun album to listen to. "Metropolis" is a fun instrumental. "Thousands are Sailing" is great too. Love a good bit of Irish music every now and then. 🇮🇪
I listened to more than half of this, it's a pretty long album and I wasn't quite in the mood for over an hournof Irish alternative music. Pretty good, though.
Definitely a little lengthy. I did however, only find the extended edition. The blend of classical jigs and a Dropkick Murphy style punk vibe was interesting. I enjoyed it most of the way through. I don't think this is an every day type of album I could listen to regularly though.
Great Irish punk. Can’t believe that this is basically Flogging Molly, but 15-20 years earlier. Had no idea there were bands like this in the 80’s. Really fun music, however the album overstays its welcome. Definitely could have trimmed some tracks.
This was fun. Pub music. This album needs drinking to go with it. If you're looking for a soundtrack to your Irish Pub Night themed dinner party, well, you've found it.
Made me realise Mariachi and Irish folk tunes are aren't too different
If I Should Fall From Grace With God by The Pogues is an 80s is a folk punk album that is unlike anything else of its time. This band manages to incorporate many sounds and instruments that are not typically heard in punk, such as the banjo, harmonica, mandolin and so many more. The length and large amount of songs might be a bit much for some, but the way The Pogues merge different genres is interesting enough to keep the listening experience fun.
Cheesy but I live them
Thank you 1001 for reminding me of the Pogues and an extra star for the best ever Christmas track.
Irish music is great...tempted to give the album 5 stars for "Fairytale of New York" alone, one of the best songs ever written. It's a good mix of Celtic folk, with a punk attitude/aesthetic, and melodic enough to demand your attention. "Bottle of Smoke" is a highlight. It's admittedly a little repetitive, but they are also kind of the best at it? Its exactly a 3.5 but at the time of writing this, I am still determining if I am going to round up or down...
I do love me some Celtic folk punk and these guys are the OGs. Similar to how I can hear where some of my favorite melo-death bands were influenced by At the Gates's "Slaughter of the Soul," I can hear where some of my favorite Celtic punk bands were influenced by this band. As a cohesive album some songs hit more than others, but the overall experience was enjoyable enough for me to give it a 4/5. I think the only way this could have been made better is if I got it on Saint Patrick's Day.
Definitely a pretty sick album. There were some songs I didn't love. But overall the instrumentation was pretty awesome
Didn't love this one nearly as much as Rum Sodomy and the Lash. Still was a pleasant listen through, just not as polished and not as much variety. Kinda stayed on a similar wavelength front to back, that joyous either fast or slow paced classic Irish folk sound. Plus 1 star for the song about worms though, that was a banger.
harsh voice, varied melodies, interesting
There are some really good songs on this album. Maybe it's my ears or a combination of the accent and speed but the lyrics can be difficult to make out from the lead singer.
Wenn alles keinen Sinn macht, die Pogues irgendwie schon? Krass das in Fairytale eigentlich am wenigsten passiert - und das sind eigentlich schon zwei Lieder. Ich muss über pogues immer lachen, aber ich weiß gar nicht sicher über wen.
" Described by a friend of mine (pejoratively) as a band pirates lead by a drunken Muppet. While my high school self agreed but I took that as a positive. Who doesn't love the Muppets. While you can definitely jump up and down to this album (see Bottle of Smoke and Fiesta) there is so much more to the Pogues (Thousands are Sailing seems especially relevant in this moment). The band is smoking. Production exquisite. Good times have been had. Thanks for the fine (if a little blurry,) memories boys.
Solid album. I’m not exactly an Irish folk music guy, but you can sense how fun it would be to see this band live.
I was hesitant going into this album having not really understood and liked their Christmas song. But the rest of the album slaps and has infectious energy. The guy can't sing and has less teeth than a baby. But it works
Irish folk punk. Politically engaged lyrics, deep Irish folk roots, raw punk energy.
An Irish classic. Fantastic mix of Celtic craic and cynicism. I’ve grown an appreciation for the Pogues in recent years, I really enjoy listening to this album.
Ireland
However I try to say it, I can’t help but feel I’m parroting Partridge. Specifically a moment in the scene most famous for Alan’s “Sunday Bloody Sunday” blunder. “Dares mahr tay Eirelund den dis” he hisses, drowning the table in a gaseous aroma resultant of his indigestion. So yeah, dare’s mahr to The Pogues den “Fairytale…”. I was surprised by just how much: “Turkish song of the Damned” (a song written to suit the name) charms; “Bottle of Smoke” caterwauls and brogues; “Streets of Sorrow/Birmingham Six” gently, soporifically opines before lurching into ecstatic rebellion; “Sit by the Fire” raps and scraps thrillingly; while “The Broad Majestic Shannon” answers the question of what would have happened had the couple in “Fairytale…” have stayed in Ireland (broadly: positive). It’s all distinctively The Pogues, all completely elevated by the inimitable Shane MacGowan. There’s a joyfulness at the heart of this record that’s difficult to resist (as the kids bopped away, Fleur remarked that you can hear the influence on the soundtrack of “How to train your dragon”) so I don’t resist it. Instead, I let it confront and correct an internalised Partridgism I hadn’t even known I was holding onto. Slainte.
Não esperava muito desde álbum, porém ele me surpreendeu bastante.Seu ritmo me fez lembrar de um clássico pub britânico, e isto me fez gostar bastante deste disco que traz o clássico estilo musical britânico a tona
Good album
good album
Good news: Shane McGowan is a poet Bad news: He needs lyrics/subtitles by default Good news: it’s a good album. Bad news: a little of it goes a very long way. I was burned out by track 8.
Playful like a kick in the teeth
A fantastically unexpected love. I had literally only heard that one very famous Pogues song so didn’t have any expectations from the album. But the Celtic jauntiness with meaningful lyrics and some real passion meant I really enjoyed this album.
album is a little long. start was a bit iffy. but it got better
When I saw this album I was ready to give it a 1-2 star review based on my dislike of Irish folk punk. However when I was listening this album it warmed my cold, bitter heart. This is a fun album filled with great musicianship, heart, and melody. I’m not all the way there with this style of music, but I feel like I could be on the cusp of accepting this album at least into my heart, and fully enjoying it. I still have my mental roadblock but I hope that it’s made of ice and the warmth this album brings melts it away because I want to love it fully.
Fairytale of New York has always been one of my favorite Christmas carols. The rest of the album is fun, fast and furious. I like the instrumentation and the songs. Overall I enjoyed the collection of songs.
For the last few St. Patrick Days, I check to see if Shane MacGowan if playing anywhere, even though he’s been dead for several years. If you’re a fan, it would surprise you in no way if he rose from the dead at some point. I know every note on the album by heart. My question about The Pogues is what role he served in the band, given that he was not really a gifted musician, and I keep coming back to the answer that he was everything. I’ve heard The Pogues described as an Irish punk band, which is so off the mark because there was nothing punk about them. They played traditional Irish music with a lead singer who embodied everything about his culture: tragically funny, painfully self aware, pessimistically optimistic. I could nitpick this selection as being their most musically diverse but lacking the staple Irish banger that all their other albums have, and “Fairytale of New York” comes off as almost an Irish “Grandma Got Run Over By a Reindeer” when you’ve heard it a zillion times, but whatever. Liking The Pogues is DNA legacy for Irish Americans.
IRELAND :fire: :fire: :fire:
this was awesome
Excellent album. Favorite song: "Thousands are Sailing"
Surprisingly good
Great fusion of punk and Irish trad
Whenever you want Irish traditional with a sneer and a punkish spin, these are the guys to turn to. McGowan was a great front man and the one most responsible for their sound and spirit. The firsr half, especially, is fantastic with the title song, "Turkish Sing of the Damned," the all time great Christmas song "Fairytale of New York" (much credit due to Kirsty MacColl), "Thousands Are Sailing," "Bottle of Smoke," etc. The second half drops off a bit but not much. Steve Lillywhite also deserves a lot of credit with his production work.
The Pogues are terrific. This one isnt quite the masterpiece that is Rum, Sodomy and the Lash, but it has a lot going for it. The band would not be exceptional without Shane MacGowan. His roguish, punk energy is all over this on songs like Bottle of Smoke, and he's a great songwriter too, telling stories of people falling through the cracks. This has maybe the best modern Christmas song ever with Fairytale of New York, and the expanded edition is worth it too for the Irish Rover alone, great trad song with The Dubliners.
I really enjoyed this one - very upbeat, very happy, very pub music style. If I went into any bar in Ireland, I would expect this to be playing and everyone to be singing along, very catchy as well which I appreciate. Don’t usually listen to this stuff but I got a lot of enjoyment out of this one.
Really makes you wanna grab a pint with yer mates at the local pub
It’s the Pogues, it’s fantastic
Very fun. Liked a lot of the songs and it reminded me a lot of Great Big Sea. 3.5
4.5/5! fav song: hard to choose! defo fiesta though Its sooo close to a 5 there’s just a couple songs i dont particularly vibe with so unfortunately they bring the rating down. a very fun album, must listen more!
I don't know what I was expecting but certainly not this. Very fun listen!
solidddd album ✊🏻
As a teenager I loved Megadeth more than any other bad in the world. I think this experience has given me a tolerance for non-conventional vocalists. An enjoyable romp, which despite its hour long run time never outstayed its welcome
The Pogues. What else.
Thought this album was a lot of fun. Loved the folk-punk vibes. I understand not liking his voice but I thought it fit the style. Was jarring to hear Fairytale of New York now it’s January, but felt like a nice change after the first 3 songs. By the end of the album I’d maybe had enough, but overall I really enjoyed it. Fun to hear some Irish folk standards as well, especially Rocky Road to Dublin. Fav song: If I Should Fall From Grace With God - also liked Fairytale of New York, Medley: The Recruiting Sargeant/The Rocky Road to Dublin/The Galway Races and The Irish Rover Least fav: Worms
A tad odd to have a Christmas song just on the album but apart from that I enjoyed the general vibe. Slightly biased because I used to work in an Irish pub so would hear the Irish rover all the bloody time. Really don’t like worms Specific rating - 4.1 Fav song - Fiesta Least fav- worms
Ngl it felt a bit weird to get ti fairytale of new york on the basis of its not christmas anymore, but other than that I enjoyed the album
Now THIS is Irish music. I was a little awestruck honestly, don’t think I’ve ever heard traditional Celtic music mixed with punk rock before this. Vocals take a bit to acclimate to and I wasn’t expecting a Christmas song to be thrown in the mix, but this whole style was nonetheless fresh to me. That’s not really something I’ve been able to say recently either, after about 650+ albums through. This is a pretty fun one that you shouldn’t overlook.
This was fun and refreshing!
British made Irish folk
This album is so interesting! I really liked how Irish it was, it wasn't what I was expecting
Me gustó harto, mudica de titanic pero no lo escucharía diario.
Solid Irish fun! Slainte’
Давно не слушал группу, почему-то не знал, что она довольно влиятельна и признана критиками.
Most of the tracks are upbeat, featuring banjos and accordions; Irish folk music predominates, and it could easily be the soundtrack to a film set in that era, but I would’ve liked to hear whole ballads too and not just snippets of ballads in songs that then turn upbeat. The lyrics are very descriptive, with storytelling elements, and the music is quite varied yet cohesive. I was particularly surprised by how dynamic the instrumental tracks are. Fave tracks: Fairytale of New York, Streets of Sorrow / Birmingham Six, Worms, Sketches of Spain.
4/5
One of the most unique sounding albums on the list. I did really enjoy this album, but I feel like I would have loved it if I was more Irish. Mid 4.
Good fun, great sound.
Maybe not so for the average American, but I got this album and thought "I don't know who this is" and then I saw Fairytale of New York and went "oh never mind yes I do". I appreciate that I got this in December, my Christmas has been pretty void of the classic happy tones that would usually get me excited for the season. That being said, immediately I was nodding my head and tapping my foot. The musicianship on this album is excellent, for a band this big the fact it all feels so tightly wound and written is very impressive. Also worth expressing that the mixing is perfect, the way certain instruments take steps forward and back but they never feel like they're drowning each other out. The energy of this album is pretty electric, so much so that as much of as a classic as it is, Fairytale of New York sort of puts me off? I would much rather the album was just breakneck with its pacing from start to finish. Equally I must say, every time I hear it I do think "God his voice is awful" and somehow I still think that, but only on that song? Otherwise I find it pretty charming and endearing, and I think that might be the energy. Slow him down enough and he just sounds like my drunk uncle but when everything else around him has some pace I can't help but smile. I wrote this while listening and then we got around to "Streets of Sorrow" which is slow and yet his voice is totally appropriate and extremely endearing and then he turns on the energy and loses every third syllable? That means it's a creative choice and might not be one I love. I like this album, I don't love it and I see the criticism that the soundscape it creates can get a little samey but ultimately I had no issue listening to this album top to bottom and liking lots of what I heard. The energy is good and fun but I do lose the occasional word. Best songs: If I should fall from Grace with God, Turkish Song of the Damned (really good one two punch) Worst songs: N/A Rank compared to everything else so far: 17/28 (below Boston, above Play)
Like the album but moby is a twat
Best Christmas song ever
This album has been interesting. Had no idea what to expect, and the album cover made me think I was going to abhor it. It sure is dumb fun, even if it goes a bit long. 3.5 / 5
I imagine this is what they play in Italian hell. When its St. Patrick's day everyday.
Great irish vibes. Easy listen from start to finish.
Some very very good songs here, but when they try to branch out from the formula they fail. Otherwise this would have been an easy 5.
Surprisingly good
This was a really fun listen. You can’t help but feel good after listening to it.
First time listening to Celtic folk rock. The album was great, it was a fun listen. The instrumentation was beautiful and upbeat. Definitely going to come back to this album in the future.
Honestly so solid
This is super fucking fun! Irish Folk Punk Rock, whoda thunk it? If you can get over the fact that you can't understand a word Shane MacGowan says, it's even better. As an aside, I think "Fairytale of New York" is the best Christmas song in existence. Somehow, I only heard it in the last 7 years or so, and it's a piece of music I'm so, so happy is in my life.
Dope shit
Celtic/Irish folk rock/jazz. Fun album. Favorite track: fairytale of new york other picks: If i should fall from grace with god, worms, bottle of smoke
Pretty good It's fun listening to new genres 7/10
Something about his voice brings me in like a moth to a lamp. This is solid work and probably my favorite thing Elvis Costello has been a part of. I know comparison is the death of creativity, but every once in a while I want to hear them let loose like Flogging Molly.
3.8 // irish folk rock. We love The Pogues, we love shane macgowan
this was fun to listen to. fairytale of new york is one of the greatest songs ever (and my favourite christmas song) 4.5
Ah, I really enjoyed this! There’s just something about the Celtic folk rock sound that I find engaging and endearing, expressing a lot of pure “rock n roll” energy, but always with a sincere human touch. Really excellent songwriting all across this record. I’m only dropping a star because of some of the more polka-ish stuff like “Fiesta.” Must-listen #253.
This is fantastic. I hadn't listened to a lot of the pogues before, but this was really interesting. His voice is great and the musicianship is brilliant. Made me realise why Irish parties are so much more fun. They are all dancing to jigs and we are listening to agadoo.
Lots of fun sounds on this one
Never listened to The Pogues before. Really enjoyed the album. Best Christmas song ever on this album. Also enjoyed the Spanishy songs and the Thousands are Sailing
Not my favourite Pogues album (that'll be Rum, Sodomy, & the Lash) but it served as my introduction to them, with Fairytale of New York and Fiesta being the first of their songs I heard. This feels more 'pop' than their first two albums - slightly more polished, with fewer rough edges but the songwriting and storytelling are still great.
Generelt fan af alternativ rock generelt fan af skotsk/irsk folkemusik. Ja det bliver sgu nød til at være 5/5. Forsangeren drak sig åbenbart stiv hele tiden, så han blev nød til at indspille om natten fordi han først var velfungerende efter 23:00
So much fun. Folky and punky and dancey. Such great energy throughout almost all of it. (not a fan of the skit at the end but I'll give them a break for that)
Hard to not hear them all as Christmas songs and I LOVE IT
Great album
Timeless
I mean cmon, it’s The Pogues. Nothing brightens your day quite like them.
I love the energy, I love the sounds, I love the Fairytale in New York song! What a fun album and what a great band 3.8
Classic
A lot of it sounds the same but I actually really like the style!! Irish punk
Fairytale of New York is one of the only Holiday songs that you can listen to all year round. Great song. The rest of this album was very good, too.
عرس في إيرلاندا و الشراب للركبة
Leans a bit more punk and slightly less folk compared to the previous album, with a few touches from other genres like jazz. But it’s mainly remembered for Fairytale of New York, which is a massive Christmas song in the U.K. but hardly acknowledged in my part of the world.
I appreciate the craftsmanship but Celtics punk for an hour is a bit much for me. One to maybe three songs at a time is sufficient.
Is this fun? Absolutely. Does every song sound extremely similar? Also yes. This is a solid 3.5. Liked Songs: "If I Should Fall from Grace with God" , "Turkish Song of the Damned" , "Bottle of Smoke" , "Metropolis" , "Thousands Are Sailing" , "Fiesta" , "The Broad Majestic Shannon" , "The Irish Rover" , "Sketches of Spain" , "South Australia"
Highlights: If I Should Fall From Grace with God, Fairytale of New York, Fiesta, Streets of Sorrow/ Birmingham Six Lowlights: Metropolis, The Battle March Medley, Shanne Bradley Traditional Celtic folk music meets punk. I had heard If I Should Fall from Grace with God before but didn’t know who sang it (I think maybe Mariya had shown it to me before). The Singers unconventional voice really adds something to this, especially in the opening to Fairytale of New York. In the opening of that song there was moments where his voice grated without the backing instruments but it added something to it. Made it feel like a slice of life, made it feel more real I guess. The tracks without his vocals are musically proficient but they seem to be missing something for me which largely is why Metropolis fails to move the needle for me (is that a 007 theme play in the middle of the song??). The occasional screams and yells that he does are so visceral and enjoyable to listen to for me. Though those seemed to happen more in the first half of the album. The slower songs surprised me and quickly rose to the top of my list but honestly most of this album bangs. It's a longer album with a longer track list and I never got bored besides a little in the tracks with no vocals. Which aren’t bad, they just aren’t good enough to keep me interested The tracks where they mix all the instruments with his quick plucky voice are the heart of this album and are what make the quieter moments shine in my opinion. All in all this album has too many instrumental songs to hit a perfect score but it was really close and I really enjoyed this album. 4 out of 5 Rock and Rolls to Dublin
So hyped for this record I smashed a whiskey bottle over my head, slurped it up off the floor, and stole my grandmother’s car. Now I’m in jail in an unfamiliar city. Does this happen to anyone else?
Another good collection of Irish folk songs mixed with punk energy. Between the two albums on this list, this is the better release. If for no other reason than the fact that it has one of the best Christmas songs of all time (despite the unfortunate slur).
Album No. 0041 on my list. I've been aware of The Pogues' existence, but for some reason have never listened to them. "If I Should Fall From Grace With God" is a decent album however. Excluding "Fairitale of New York" as a Christmas song, there are some nice songs on this. I like the sound, I like the attitude, I like the lyrics. My personal favorites were "If I Shozld Fall From Grace With God" (the title track), "Streets of Sorrow", and "The Broad Majestic Shannon". The colabs with the Dubliners were pretty nice as well. I'm oscilating between giving 4 stars (because some tracks were really, really good) and 3 stats (because not all tracks stuck). But in the end, I'll stick with the higher rating. 4/5 stars!
Liked this more than Rum, Sodomy and the Lash, and Fairytale is clearly star bait.
*If I Should Fall From Face With God* Bloody good Irish fun... With a wee bit of social commentary. I'm not the biggest fan of "Fairytale", but in context of the album it's great... Could have done w/o "Worms". (I prefer Poe's version) (8.75) ★★★★
I'm not totally sure if I like this as much as Rum, Sodomy, and the Lash, but it's very good nonetheless. Very cool punky Irish jams. The first half was a good bit stronger for me with the title track, "Turkish Song of the Damned" and "Fairytale of New York" being the big standouts for me. 4 stars.
Neat record. Reminds me of a handful of different things. Firstly punk bands with this Celtics leaning from my childhood, flogging Molly and silly old dropkick Murphys, although those guys are at best Irish Americans. And then second my first job washing dishes in an Irish pub. And my boss getting hammered on ironicly American beer, budweiser, and doodling away on that little Celtic flute. Interesting memories. But this crop of tracks is pretty damn good. Very folky and not only Irish coded either. Fiesta is very spanish and also a highlight for me. That gravely and harsh vocal delivery is so damn good. It just gives the peices some real grit and slot in perfectly in my opinion. My biggest gripe is its a hell of alot of a good thing. An hour on the 03 remaster is too much. Almost 20 tracks. But there are alot of gems in there. I'll never turn away from the punky eff off type vibe that some tracks bring. And even the straight folk stuff is wonderful too. A great one to put on in your local pub and mosh to.
My junior year of high school, my dad took me on a trip to New England to visit colleges. We were late smart phone adopters and didn't pay for satellite radio, so FM radio was our primary entertainment. As we channel-surfed through the Berkshires we stumbled onto a radio show called "Irish Power Hour". It was one of those moments of serendipity that don't seem to happen in today's algorithmically-driven world, and I can only imagine how much the Pogues, and this album, inspired the show. Much like that radio show, this album was a rollicking good time. The Pogues take a traditional Celtic sound and amp it up with what feels like the sort of gleeful irreverence you should expect from a good punk band. They convincingly spin tales of gambling, drinking and all other manners of debauchery (yes, even in their Christmas song!) that make you wonder how they lived long enough to make it through a recording session. Fiesta, a Latin and polka-inflected tune yielding musical blends I never thought to consider, is a particular standout to me. For all the fun, the album isn't perfect in my eyes. The Pogues sound begins to blend by the end of the album, and outside a couple exceptions (Thousands Are Sailing, a touching ode to Irish emigration to the United States, and Streets of Sorrow / Birmingham Six) the lyrics lack much in the way of depth. However, the album makes it very clear that the Pogues aren't too interested in making profound personal discoveries, and you shouldn't be either. For what this album is trying to be, it hit its mark in no uncertain terms.
Vibes: 4/5 Instruments: 5/5 Production: 4/5 Emotional Value: 4/5 Storytelling/Lyrics: 3/5 Stand Outs: Fairytale of New York, Birmingham Six Overall Rating: 4
A pretty engaging and interesting listen. Definitely a precursor to Gogol Bordello. 3.5/5 - 4/5
4/5
A mix of Irish folk and punk rock that was a pleasant listen.
Good fun. Memories of my childhood.
Very solid 4.
Good album! 7.32 avg rating. Fairytale of NY (8.5) and South Australia (7.7) were my favorites. Nice upbeat crossover punk/folk style that I liked a lot
voglio bere una birra e ubriacarmi male mentre ascolto questo
4.5 stars This was a good find and a surprise. Infectiously fun, this album is full of anthems that made me want to do a drunken jig throughout. But seriously, it was enjoyable all the way through.
This was cool. Way more eclectic than I expected. Some favs were Metropolis and South Australia
Not sure how to rate this. Not something id probably listen to often but i enjoyed it and the guys voice is cool
*Great sounding band but got a little similar sounding over the course of the whole album. *I didn't realize how much Dropkick Murphys borrowed from these guys a decade earlier. *Fairytale of NY continues to be such an interesting song.
Good time album If I should fall Fairytale of new york Thousands are sailing
El mejor hasta ahora (creo que hubo dos mas ahre) Nota: 3.7
I very much enjoy the Pogues. Prefer RS&TL as less keen on the more global sound of this album - so that makes this a high 4. Favourite song "If I should fall from Grace".
It's the sort of album that you don't need to pay much attention to, and yet it speaks to your feet. They feel obliged to tap along with every beat. The titular track to open, banjo, fiddle, high-pace - it's a classic but irresistible formula. It doesn't exactly stick with you, but is enjoyable every time it comes round. And so it is with the fucking filth-laden 'Bottle of Smoke', and the traditional 'South Australia'. The centrepiece remains 'Fairytale of New York'. Relistening for the first time in at least 9 months, it remains one of those Christmas songs that's near impossible not to love. It has everything: an uplifting Xmas jig, profound yearning, anti-Christmas excoriating lyrics, (which is the best thing about it) it's not about Xmas at all, and one of the best lines ever (I could've been someone; well so could anyone!). I think I preferred the rougher edges of 'Rum, Sodomy and the Lash', but this remains excellent quality with two outstanding tracks in 'Fiesta' and 'Fairytale'.
Great album - some very familiar songs, but lots I’d not heard before, loved the folky sound
I've never expected to like a celtic rock album as much as I did. In fact, for the last week, I've been constantly wondering if I should give this 5 stars, but I ended up giving it 4, and I'll explain why in a second. First of all, I loved the energy of this album. It is super fun and charming. Almost every song feels like you are in a party (see what I did there? hehehe) in a pirate ship or in a pub. With my first listenings, I was laughing and grinning from ear to ear. But there's also tracks that are way more serious like 'Fairytale of New York' or 'Thousands Are Sailing'. Futhermore, I liked how energetic the performances are and how super exagerated the accent and the attituted of the singer are. The only reason I'm not giving a higher score is because, after so many listens, I started to feel that the last songs are a bit derivative. Still very enjoyable, but they drag the album a little bit.
Was surprised by howul much I liked this whole album. Will definitely revisit
This was a fun album, ngl. Might be my favorite celtic punk album ever
I really like it. Has great energy and somehow nostalgic
I quite liked this, the Celtic style alongside punk sensibilities makes for an enjoyable record. I really liked “Streets Of Sorrow/Birmingham Six” and “Fairytale of New York”. I like Shane MacGowan’s vocals as well, they have an odd quality like he’s literally drunk while singing and it adds a good element to these songs
No lubię taką muzykę. Wydaje mi się być szczerą, blisko korzeni, radosna. Taka ludzka. Nie jest ambitna, skomplikowana ani przeintelektualizowana. Jest ludzka. Porywa do tańca jak na wiejskiej zabawie. I ja to szanuję. 7/10
I used to enjoy listening to celtic music, but I haven't done so for a long time. I thought I might enjoy this album more. I enjoyed a few of the numbers, but others failed to move me. I don't know if that means I've lost my taste for traditional Scottish and Irish music, or if it's just the Pogues' style that misses the mark for me. I wanted to like it, but MacGowan's vocals are perhaps an acquired taste, and I haven't really acquired it. It's still a four-star album, but I wish I could have made it a five.
A fookin' quality album
What a spirit. RIP Shane.
This is a really good album and is fun to listen to. Several familiar songs. Pitchfork: n/a Rolling Stone: n/a Best Songs If I Should Fall from Grace with God Fairytale of New York Fiesta The Broad Majestic Shannon Sketches of Spain
Frickin' awesome.
Love love love this album
There's no one like the Pogues and there's nothing like this punk rock Irish folk album
Never knew I needed Irish folk punk, but this was fun. Not something I’d listen to on daily basis, but it was a curious new experience.
My first thought is Flogging Molly owes these guys some money. So far this album is great. I didnt think I would but the international sounds through an irish glass are quite fun. This album was fantastic! Really great!
I like Irish music, and punk isn’t bad either. This is a great fusion of the two. Lots of fun songs with more musical depth in soul than you would originally expect.
If I Should Fall From Grace With God is a raucous, spirited blend of Celtic folk and punk energy. The album brims with character, from the rowdy title track to the bittersweet charm of “Fairytale of New York.” It’s full of grit and poetry, balancing wild energy with moments of aching beauty. While a few tracks don’t hit as hard, the record as a whole captures The Pogues at their most inventive and memorable.
Energetic. Rousing choruses for drinking.
Who says punk can't be jolly? The Pogues certainly know it and do it well. Their blend of Celtic folk and punk make for some great pub songs. McGowan has a unique voice carried by his growling and sloshed Irish lilt. Makes me wonder if Tim Armstrong is a fan. If you love a frenetic shanty, then this album is for you.
Actually really liked this. I can picture jamming out hard to this in an Irish bar. Also seems like it was pretty influential.
This was kinda fun
Great mix of tunes that make you want to dance, traditional Irish folk songs to swoon to and Shane McGowan's amazing lyricism. Has both the greatest Christmas tune of all time and the greatest Irish song (on the extended version anyway). Couple of dodgy tunes 'Worms' stands out but otherwise very enjoyable. Fave Tunes: The Irish Rover & Fairytale of New York.
Lots to love here
Its refreshing to hear the worlds of punk and celtic folk collide in such a carefree way. The Pogues are political but never preachy, nostalgic but never cloying. They want to remind us that music is allowed to be fun. I wish they were a bit better known beyond their Christmas hit, because they deserve it!
Rating: 9/10 Diverse and catchy Celtic-punk album that is quite diverse in style. Great vocals, lyrics, and infectious instrumentation. First half is five stars easily and it drops in quality a bit after that but still great.
Fun, catchy, high energy. Some of the songs sound very similar, but they're all enjoyable.
Rachel and I had a jolly ol’ time listening to this on our drive up an AWD dirt road in her tiny sedan. It was actually hilarious to have this strange Irish soundtrack on as the car bottomed out several times
I listened to the expanded edition. I do love me some Celtic rock, and I like how they mixed in a little world music with it. Was slightly confused when I got to a Christmas song, but it worked. Listened before? N Saved to library? Y Favorite track(s): Turkish Song of the Damned, Fiesta, Sit Down by the Fire ⭐⭐⭐⭐: Really liked it. Saved a bunch of tracks and even added a few to my instrumental playlist for work.
Fun romper. The Irish accent is great for punk. I still don’t fully understand all the love for the New York Fairytale song AS a Christmas song. As a song it’s great, but for Christmas?