American Idiot by Green Day

American Idiot

Green Day

3.77
Rating
31357
Votes
1
4%
2
9%
3
24%
4
34%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 13 of 16)

I wasn't especially taken with these guys at the time but over the years this album has grown on me. It really is packed with great songs and although the band was never groundbreaking or innovative they're really good at what they do and what they do is write and perform great songs.

Another one that is tough to be objective about, as it's been in my life for two decades as of 2024. I got this album when I was 10. These songs were unavoidable, all over the radio, TV, everywhere you'd go. This album was huge. I've heard these songs more times than I can count, to the point where I don't always want to hear them again. But they'll be part of me 'til my dying day. Is this punk? I don't think so. But it's near perfect pop/rock music, jam packed with hooks and fresh ideas. This is the definition of a modern populist classic.

a little hard on the nervous system, all the drum beats & heavy guitars. Did have flashbacks to when it came out? or maybe to movies the songs have been in. there was definitely familiarity.

I usually don't like punk rock, but I genuinely am a slut for a concept album, so I guess this is the exception. I think the only thing about this album I don't like is the song length (not the songs with a "/," but Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming); they both could've been cut down to five minutes and have been better songs in my opinion.

Probably my favorite Green Day album. I ran many miles to this beech in the day.

Love the story. Enjoyed reading more about it and the history of it all. I forgot how many good “independent” songs there are. Also fun listening to it with a 2024 lens and knowing which songs became the popular hits and which ones were slept on.

"Classic" 2000s

This album fucks, then goes on the first date.

Never was a fan.

It's green day. I remember when this came out and how super hyped it was by the normies. It's fine, the melodies and the dynamics in the songs that stand out. The lyrics and themes have not aged gracefully, they felt rather crudely drawn at the time (compared to contemporaries like Desaparecidos or system of a down)

wake me up when this record ends

I don’t remember Green Day fondly, and I think it’s because this album was the first time I really felt a band I liked Changed. I saw them on the tour for this one and it sucked, I almost never listened to them again after that. However, after listening to about one hundred 1960s Brit Rock Operas on this list so far, this actually doesn’t seem that bad.

Not sure if title refers to the purveyors of purchasers of this record, which isn’t terrible by the standards of late adolescent music and no doubt rates highest with low-information voters who fancy themselves politically informed and engaged, but are at least likely to have their hearts in the right place. Can’t tell if it's a poppy punk record or a punky pop record. Either way, it’s pretty bland, being awfully obvious and mainstream-y (if of above- average ambitiousness). Oh sure there is a story arc but – editors take note – one not even remotely in Quadrophenia’s league. Even if the plot line were worthy of a Booker Prize, that wouldn’t solve for the musical meh-ness any more than the decently cool art cover does. Hooks are so broad, if likable, as to suspect R. Rubin was at the controls (alas, no). The political commentary isn’t exactly piercing and not even additive or even remotely worth one’s time (for their being scads of better sources, obvs). The power ballads (“Are We the Waiting” and “When September Ends”) are kinda cute. “Boulevard of broken dreams” — hmmm, where has one heard that line before? That cut/paste – and certainly not mature – songwriting (eh, editors?). Last cut might be best of the lot but it will almost certainly be a coincidence or accident if one ever heard it again.

Enjoyed it more now than I used to. Has their best songs on here.

I thought it was just ok when it came out and my opinion hasn't changed.

Classic punk rock

Phenomenal album. I loved how it’s fully immersed in the story of Jesus of Suburbia. It’s very compelling as well. 5/5 Fav: Letterbomb Least Fav: None

Geiles Album.

I went to a Green Day concert for an earlier album as a 21 yo and was surrounded by 12 yos. Today I listened to the album with my 13 yo son and asked him for his opinion. “Alright, but repetitive” was his answer. Can’t get better than that.

If you only listen to one Green Day album before you die, make sure it is Dookie. But hopefully you have time for two, as this one should also not be missed. Yes, it’s a fairly formulaic pop-punk album composed of catchy riffs and Billie-Joe’s signature vocals but the ambition and creativity to attempt the concept rock opera should be applauded - the segues between songs work well, a few nice changes of pace and instrumental arrangements, and the recurring lyrical themes make you feel like you’re on a journey, not just listening to a collection of songs. Something to make America’s youth think about what was going on in their post-9/11 world without being preachy, but more importantly, packed with great tunes. American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia and Holiday are all memorable but it’s Blvd of Broken Dreams that is the real jewel in the crown. Only loses a point for me due to a slightly weaker second half but it would be an easy 4.5, great start to this project for me. *my CD version must be different to what’s on streaming now as I have a 13 tracks compared to the 9 on Spotify, altho the runtime is the same. 1/1001

Nostalgia Album for me. Head banging thought-out, def more repetitive than i remember but good.

I may be biased based on my childhood songs but American Idiot, Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Wake Me Up When September Ends are amazing songs. And everything else just seems like similar variations of those to me

Great album - just not my cup of tea.

Great memories attached to this album

No. 74/1001 American Idiot 5/5 Jesus of Suburbia 4/5 Holiday / Boulevard of Broken D. 5/5 Are We The Waiting / St. Jimmy 4/5 Give Me Novacaine / She's a Rebel 4/5 Extraordinary Girl / Letterbomb 4/5 Boulevard of Broken Dream 5/5 Homecoming 4/5 Whatsername 4/5 Average: 4,33 Musically this is nothing revolutionary. It's just so damn fun to listen to.

Excellent

Fun listen! Great album.

better than i remember it at the time. prefer old school punk but this is ok.

Good punk rock

Oh man, this really takes me back. I remember early mornings before the sun rose, hopping in my friend Kyle’s car and heading to band practice. Since he drove, he chose the tunes, and this was something he played often. Man… just a different time. The older I’ve gotten the more I appreciate this album and it’s impact on my early challenges to what I was taught. The music has a good beat and there is more than one ear worm. Plus I love any type of story being told across an album. There is a reason this became a musical on broadway.

- Well, I already knew that partially - Interessante Combination of two songs with each other with an overall length of approx. 9 Minutes, but also single Songs combined from many parts (e.g. Jesus of Suburbia) - Songs refencing each other - Overall: 4/5

Great album

Good record, some skip tracks

This album came out when I was in high school so it has an extra star for nostalgia reasons. As much as we're all tired of the radio hits on this, and I would rather go back to sleep as soon as Wake Me Up When September Ends starts, the deep cuts on this album still kick, like Give Me Novacaine, Letterbomb and Whatsername. The two 10 minute long tracks are fun as well.

The 2004 Bush/Kerry election was the first time I paid attention to politics. I was 13 years old and excited to have someone to root for (or root against really). I wanted George Dubya out of the White House, which made me a Kerry voter even though I was too young to cast a ballot. This album came at the perfect time. I felt angry and frustrated about the state of the world and Green Day fueled my fire. The morning after the election, I wallowed in the new misery of knowing my candidate had lost. On the bus ride to school that day, I played “American Idiot” on my Walkman because it felt like the only thing to listen to. I’m so happy to report that the album is still awesome. The first four tracks in particular are fantastic. The epic 9-minute “Jesus of Suburbia” was always my favorite and I get just as caught up in its drama now as I did when I was 13. The other epic song, “Homecoming” is stunning too. Man, drummer Tré Cool is incredible. On the early Green Day albums you can hear him imitating The Who’s Keith Moon (and doing a great job, I might add). He does those thundering tom fills just as well as Moon did. But by “American Idiot,” he’s a beast all his own. He can play big and dramatic stadium rock or blistering punk. A few times, he even brings out the doo-wop influence that hides in a lot of Green Day songs. And since the album features a lot of multi-part songs, he often has to change genres on a dime.

I grew up thinking Dookie was amazing and not really liking much else by Green Day. To me they were like poser punk, and I always thought, "why would I listen to pop punk ever? It's like punk energy and riffs and vocals but without the infamous punk attitude?" But that's changed as I've gotten older. I have come to embrace Green Day and how simply put they are an amazing band that makes good music. I also got to see them a year or two ago at "Sea Hear Now" festival and they were amazing. Even headlining a huge show where they were like hundreds and hundreds of feet away from me, they somehow made the show energetic and intimate and straight up killer. This album I think maybe pushed the band to the next level. "Nimrod" to me was only an alright album, despite having "Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)" on it, it didn't do much for me otherwise. This came out and I feel like everyone and their moms were like "hell yea fuck George W Bush I love this shit". I think this is a good 4. It's not quite Dookie, and Dookie is a 5, but relation aside, it's a strong album with a few select really great standout hits.

Very memorable and encompassed a lot of my childhood. However, a nine minute punk song is not something anybody should have to go through

What a gem of an album...loved it...

muy chido escucharlo todo 10/10 lastima que ya no quieren tocar esas canciones, son verdaderamente geniales! No esperaba disfrutarlo tanto la verdad

Great album. Love Green Day. May have been a little long. But some really good songs.

Great album. Very nostalgic to listening to it non-stop in middle school. Still know just about all the words. Timely for current political environment too. Should listen to more.

I remember when this album came out and it was huge back then. I wasn't really into Green Day even if I was in my (late) teens, because I was more into 70s and 80s rock at that time. I liked this album more than Dookie, some songs sound still very good. Boulevard of Broken Dreams is my favorite. The album album is a bit too long, if it was 10-15 minutes shorter I'd give it a 4. It gets a bit repetitive for this length. Otherwise it is a good album.

You either LOVE Green Day or you don’t. They were never big favorites of mine.

One of my favorite albums.

Realmente um baita álbum, primeira vez que escuto algo completo do Green Day e me surpreendeu

Album 3/1001: early 2000s classic. Many many songs illicit some nostalgia or callback to a time where I didn’t have to pay utitliy bills. 9/10

"Dookie for mums". It's about right. A couple decent hits, holiday will always bounce hard, but a bit of a contrast from yesterday's album.

Angst rock. Occasionally melodic but too one note in sound and themes.

The culmination of "old Green Day" (sneering punks with a bone to pick) as well as the starting point for "new Green Day" (arena rockers who want to say big things). Great record that suffered a bit from overexposure but still holds up.

good late period album from them. Probably last "essential record" they ever did.

Highlights - Jesus of suburbia

It still slaps embarrassingly hard.

I didn't know this album as well as Dookie. After giving it a couple of listens, it's starting to grow on me, but still not as good as the former.

Fine, but would probably have preferred to listen to Dookie, if only for nostaglia.

Pop punk songs where everyone's yelling 'hey!' as part of the chorus or the lead singer shouts '1, 2, 3, 4' are always fun. Pop punk ballads not so much. How does one mosh to 'Wake Me Up When September Comes'?

Very nostalgic. Was fun to go back to this again. Boulevard of Broken Dreams is the standout for me

Such vibes, some misses later on in the album and the songs start to blend together a bit, but at least it’s a nice style I used to play Holiday every day of last day of school, better times 3/4****

Easily the most enjoyable punk band - you get what you expect but it's also what you want.

This is a top 10 album for me. I remember hearing this as an 8 year old and being blown away. Lyrics are amazing and every track is brilliant.

5 stars. Already. Haven't had to press play, been listening to this for almost 20 years. I remember when my parents asked me if I knew what "propaganda" was as a result of this album.

1. "American Idiot" - 9,0 2. "Jesus of Suburbia" - 7,5 3. "Holiday" - 8,5 4. "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" - 10,0 5. "Are We the Waiting" - 9,0 6. "St. Jimmy" - 7,0 7. "Give Me Novacaine" - 7,5 8. "She's a Rebel" - 7,5 9. "Extraordinary Girl" - 7,0 10. "Letterbomb" - 7,0 11. "Wake Me Up When September Ends" - 10,0 12. "Homecoming" - 7,0 13. "Whatsername" - 8,5 TOTAL: 8,16 (82/100)

I thought I would enjoy this less. Songs are too long and a bit grinding to get through at times.

Loved this album when I was a kid but I don't think it's held up very well aside from a couple songs.

An absolute classic, iconic early 2000s rock opera. Easily listenable from start to finish

Amazing album, my absolute fav is Jesus of Suburbia, 3 songs in one.

Meh, I appreciate it for being a pivotal album in the mainstreaming of the last vestiges of American punk, but that's also what I hate about it.

Tristan Pollock all the way from Banff joined my morning commute when I listen to the Green Day album

Green day rockt

As a very fringe Green Day fan and someone who owned 39 smoothed out happy hours and Kerplunk!, this is as good a non-Dookie record as they've made. With half/quarter stars were an option

Absolute classic from the band that got me into music in the first place. My first favorite album 🖤

Classic Green Day, I first heard this album in 6th grade and was blown away that he said the word "mindfuck" and was one of the first songs with swearwords that I'd sing lmao. Love the guitar crunchiness on some of the songs and this album holds a lot of nostalgia value for me

Listened to before, favourite album of all time. Probably nostalgia but idc.

Classic rock album

Beter dan verwacht. Was nooit zo'n fan van Green Day, maar juist de niet bekendere nummers eigenlijk wel goed

Klinkt allemaal best fijn zou t alleen minder snel aanzetten

Ja gewoon goed

Prima rock

Echt een goed album gewoon. Heel de dag lekker rock en punk geluisterd daardoor. Goed nostalgisch voor mij ook

Ja dit is het! Alsof ik weer 15 ben 'Are we the waiting' was voor my een hidden gem

Banger record

There were a few glimmers of hope (Holiday stands out), but save some time and just listen to Dookie.

I found myself enjoying this much more than I expected. The instruments sound really good tonally and the performance is tight. Single tracks contain multiple tunes which is interesting. Well done Green Day.

Excellent!

Great to go back and revisit, lots I didn't remember about it. Solid song writing and instrumentation. I had forgotten it was a concept album?! It's not really my taste these days but it really holds up, a classic for a reason. Billy Joe's voice is actually really great.

Holiday / Boulevard of Broken dreams is so nostalgic. This album reminds me of my 14-year-old self getting into rock music.

Not their best, nevertheless an epic one

Duh nuh nuh nuh nuh nuh nuh nuh

Felt like I was on Holiday listening to this album. You definitely wouldn’t be an American Idiot if you gave this a listen…or would you?

Love this album. One of my favorite bands. Strangely, I've never listened to the album all the way through. Not as many bangers as I thought it would have. More ballads than I associate Green Day with.

Pretty stellar for sure.

Not the biggest punk rock guy, but this is a pretty good album. My biggest complaint is how it can sound repetitive after a while, given its hour long length.

Green Day only has one good album. This album is not Dookie.

You know what you’re getting with Green Day. If you like it you like it. The fact that every time I tried to listen to this album I got waylaid or called away and I still kept coming back is testament to their skills. I was happy to be drawn back and most songs are solid. I lost interest in a couple of them, but my interest was always revived by the next one. Consistently good.

I used to like them a little, and now I like them a lot. The band grew on me. I am really sad that I didn’t get to see the stage production of American idiot.

I've never paid a ton of attention to this band, but I've always thought they were pretty good. Maybe a little on-the-nose for my taste and the punk ethos/sound was never one I gravitated to, but Green Day pumps out clever, catchy, pop-punk songs better than just about anyone, certainly at their peak in the 90s-00s. I had always known this was something of a statement album, their "most important" work, but this was my first time listening. First impression — damn, dude's got a big drum sound. The bass drum leaps out of the speaker, and the toms aren't far behind. So, score a point for the drummer. And I suppose this will take multiple listens and me poring over the lyrics to get the story and put the thread of the narrative together, but my takeaway: these guys write good tunes. They just start sounding the same to me after about six tracks and my interest flags. But it's solid, Billie Joe Armstrong has a knack for a melody and knows how to cut the fat and deliver the goods without a whole lot of fucking around.

Yeah, this was great. I had a copy of Dookie when it came out, and I liked it OK for a month or two, but I got bored of it. By the time this album came out, I was like, "Really? Green Day? How are they still a thing?" And I remember my boss Tony telling me to check it out, but at the time my head wasn't in the right space for it. Anyway, I knew and liked a couple of tunes going into this, but I'd never listened to the whole thing before. Glad I did today. It's ambitious, well-performed, -arranged, and -written punk pop. Dude really has a gift for catchy melodies, which I am always a sucker for. This sounds like an album that will reward multiple listens, and I will be there for them.

I couldn't NOT hear Green Day back in their prime but I never went out of my way to buy the album. Whatever that affectation Billie Joe Armstrong does kinda irritated me. But boy oh boy did I enjoy this listen! They had me at the top with American Idiot and I jammed until September ended. (I think I listened to an extended version or something b/c the tracks did not align with the listing on Wikipedia)

Big change from the opening track 'American Idiot' to 'Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams'. The more I listened, the more I enjoyed it and the more I got out of it. I'm feeling generous. A 4.

Found this much more engaging than I thought. Decent rock album with no pretences.

Takes you back to those angsty teenage years!

Some nostalgic songs, but the ones I didn't already know sounded just like generic 90's pop punk. Nothing special.

So many bangers on this album, but still a bit too much that is middling. If it was trimmed down a bit it would be 5 stars.

A lot better than I remembered! No idea there were so many hits on this thing.

so much childhood angst favorites: holiday

One of my wife's favorite albums. I missed this one growing up, but knew all the singles and a lot of the other songs, just never gotten to listen to it front to back. When you think of "concept album", Pop-punk is probably one of the last genres to come to mind, but it works pretty well here. I probably have the gift of hindsight due to the musical that was birthed from this album, but the punk sound really goes well with the story telling of the lyrics. You can feel the 2004-ness of this album if you grew up around that time. A lot of anxiety in post 9-11 with the war in Afghanistan and other political movements coming to the forefront. Green Day really distilled the feelings into ~1 hour of music.

Heard of green day before but never really listened to them before but it was actually really fun. Slightly weak end though

This is Green Day’s best album. Even though it came out in 2004, it still works in today’s world.

Like a time machine, listening to this sent back to the past, when I was a long haired stoner sitting in my friends car. Smoking weed out of a seashell pipe, I can taste the slight saltiness from the ocean on the pipe. He turns to me and says "hey man, have you heard the new green day album, dude, its actually pretty good" He connects his no-brand discman into his 92 corollas tape deck, I hear the slight click of the disc being placed the snap of disc lid closing over the ocean waves as the sun begins to set and for the next hour I ignore a stunning, glowing tropical sunset as I sit enthralled by what comes out of the speakers. I really feel like this album captures the impotent rage of newly politically conscious suburban teens in the early bush era. Production is nicely polished. Having the balls to come out with a direct attack on American warmongering, anti- intellectualism and jingoism in the climate of post 9/11 America has to be noted. Despite what the 'hardcore' punk fans think, this is punk. 9/10 but 5 stars because I know it'll piss off a NOFX fan.

Not nearly as good as Dookie. Unnecessary in this list.

Undeniably efficient and serves as a solid entry point into (pop) rock. The musicians are quite good, but overall the album seems somewhat bland.

Uno de los álbumes más importantes del pop punk. Con un sonido que definió a una generación completa de músicos, los californianos a cargo de Billie Joe Armstrong se lucen con una pieza conceptual y narrativa que critica al status quo norteamericano de la época. Si me tuviera que quejar de algo, es que a veces se siente demasiado largo y su sonido no envejeció del todo bien.

Quite like the title track but otherwise I found this a little dull. Lack of variation and at times it comes across as a Clash tribute act

Why are all these songs twofers. Seems like 2004 and 1967 are big years on this list. Yeah this is a good album. It's past its expiration date tho sadly. Might come back to it if I need to. But it doesn't hit so hard 20 years after the culture it was written for.

If you were to ask me for my favourite Green Day album, I would probably pick this...unless I was to say Dookie. Both albums, are two pivotal albums for this band, Dookie making them 90's pop-punk icons, while American Idiot was a new direction and possibly more influential. This was the blueprint for future concept albums, a rock operas, and a political/anti-war albums. I think this might be one of the best rock opera's of the 00's (it doesn't beat The Black Parade). One of the biggest problems with this album is the way so many songs appear on a single track! Just separate them for fuck sake! Like I would listen to Give Me Novacaine more if I didn't have to listen to She's a Rebel. Standouts: American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends

I hate green day - I won't listen.

Favorite Songs: boulevard of Broken Dreams; wake me up when September ends Not my favorite Green Day album but two of my favorite songs. Boulevard is one of my favorite running songs. Perfect tempo.

I have this one. I always really liked the hits. I think it's overall quite solid. I'm just not really a fan of the "Nobody likes you" part that comes up a few times. They have a good sound.

Lowkey forgot how much of a "singles band" Green Day are, but it's American Idiot. An album that was a key part of the childhood for pretty much anyone born in the 90s for a reason.

Ridiculously good album. Contains several bangers, anti-war messaging, and an awesome punk/pop/alt rock sound. It’s no wonder why this album is so loved.

I liked the singles the best. It’s a nice time capsule of some antiwar thought from the Bush years.

Way more consistent than I remember. Well written with a diverse sound. Very happy to hear that it’s still a relevant album and sound.

For the genre of that kind of pop relevant punk sound this is a perfect album.

This album was full of bangers, I definitely understand why people were obsessed.

Nice to listen all the way through, also liked reading how the album came together!

Le premier album que j'ai demandé à mes parents d'acheter. Le go-to exemple pour un résumé du rock des années 2000. Les chansons ne vieillissent pas.

Nostalgic

Rebelling against a tedious, pedestrian way of life by writing tedious, pedestrian music.

Album of my childhood

Absolute drivel. It's like Herman's Hermits tried to make a Clash album.

Pretty good, when September ends was very nostalgic

Hey, I’m familiar with this one! This one brings back some memories. It was released after I started high school and at the time, I wasn’t heavy into music. I had a few bands I enjoyed but I didn’t have a familiarity with Green Day. However, most of my friends did and were anxiously awaiting this album’s release. Due to that, I’ve heard this one quite a few times when I was younger and it brought my attention to GD. The album starts strong and keeps the momentum going. I don’t typically enjoy songs longer than 4 minutes, but they work in here and don’t slow the album down any. I’m not sure I’d pick them to listen to in a solitary context. This album is comfort music to me. If I’m sad, it can make me happy, if I’m bored, it can energize me, and if I just want to relax, I can just sit and enjoy it.

Oh man, this album was my life as a teenager. I’m sure if I’d gone the Nu Metal route instead, then this review would have been similar to the Linkin Park one. But I was a punk, so here we go. Todd In The Shadows is on record saying that he thinks the political stuff is the weakest part of the album (which I know other reviews have pointed out, but I quote professional sources dammit 😂) but it’s only really the title track and Holiday that have anything explicitly political to say, and I personally think Holiday is really quite a good political statement. But if we ignore the political stuff, we’re still left with a lot of pretty solid character pieces and representations of disaffected and alienated youth, who in the story are left behind by the Bush presidency and the aftermath of the war or terror, but are actually representative of people from Billie Joe Armstrongs own youth left behind by the Reagan presidency and the aftermath of Reaganomics, but could equally be applied to youth left behind by the Obama presidency, and the aftermath of the 2008 recession, the Trump presidency and the aftermath of *gestures vaguely* or, in my own case various increasingly conservative Tory governments and the aftermaths of austerity and Brexit. The theme of disaffection is universal, and obviously resonates with the young people that the album is marketed towards. But I do think that there’s a lot here that can be enjoyed by everyone. Billie Joe is great at hooks, and a sharp smart lyricist. There’s a really strong showcasing of classic pop sensibility presented within a rock context. It makes a lot of sense that this reminds me more than a bit of The Who. American Idiot is a fantastic album. There is a reason why it continues to be listened to and loved by subsequent generations of young people left behind by an uncaring callous and cruel political system. When you hear it at the right age, it just changes your life

★: \"Jesus of Suburbia\", \"Holiday\",

When Dookie came out, I thought it was pretty good, bringing some energy to the wasteland that was MTV. I won’t call it punk sensibility though. By the time this album came out, I was in my early 40’s and just couldn’t muster the cynical anger that defines this music. Yeah, you think America sucks…. I just can’t care. I do like the Weird Al reinvisioning of Canadian Idiot, at least that’s good humored. Anyway, I don’t hate this, I just can’t muster the energy to share their anger. 3/5

A real nostalgia trip as this was the first album i ever bought and listened to fully when i was about 10/11. Most of the album was still super familiar to me even though I very rarely give it a full spin nowadays. The quality drops a little towards the end, Homecoming being as long as it is doesn't keep my attention the same way all 9 minutes of Jesus Of Suburbia does at the start of the album, and Whatshername is a pretty forgettable closer. When it's on point though, it's a super fun listen, and pretty diverse for a band that was just a fun pop-punk band until then.

Recognisable hits, the rest kinda disappeared into the background.

Love! Amazing drumming! Really sad guy though. Tough lyrics.

I wish I could give this one 4.5 stars because I feel like it’s a standout compared to some of the others we’ve heard recently; however, I’m holding my 5’s for albums that I connect with a bit more. Overall, American Idiot is solid. I love that it’s a concept album, but I never really followed the through line until I saw the theatrical production performed. Even then, the plot is… quite loose. Still, the music is great, including standouts like “Holiday” and “Wake Me Up When September Ends.”

Not a huge Green Day fan but this is a solid album their second best behind Dookie in my opinion.

I think it's a good rock album, kind of middle of the road with some really cool moments! Boulevard of Broken Dreams was great!

This was a good album from my high school days was not as much of a fan back then but it has grown on me over the years.

I liked Green Day back in the day, but never checked this album out beyond a few of the hits. I enjoyed this and listened to it several times. 4.5/5

A trip down memory lane! Not the best album-- or band-- but this record sure does unleashes the inner teen in me.

New to me, and quite good

Album iconique d´un groupe iconique. Malheureusement pas vraiment à mon goût et ne correspond pas à mon besoin de calme du jour 😅 mais à écouter au moins une fois dans sa vie bien sûr

✨ICONIC✨ Il y avait des titres que je ne connaissais pas dans l'album. Ça faisait longtemps que je n'avais pas écouté Green Day !

Les chansons que je connaissais sont toujours aussi bien (Holiday, Boulevard of broken dreams, wake me up when september ends) et j'en ai découvert quelques nouvelles qui sont aussi bien ! Ce sont des chansons que j'écoute de temps en temps car elles m'ont beaucoup plu adolescente et certaines donnent de l'énergie ! J'aime bien le mix de moments plus énergiques avec d'autres plus mélodiques, comme si on volait en serpentant dans une vallée xD

Génial et très nostalgique de mon adolescence. La moitié des chansons sont iconiques.

Lots of nostalgia for this one but it doesn’t hold up as well as it did when I was 12. Production is so clean it hurts my ears and doesn’t have much interesting going on musically. Still an ok album.

No thanks

5555 ****

Super good! I can’t believe how much has changed and how much has stayed the same since this album came out. Their commentary on war, imperialism, indoctrination still rings true today!!! Especially given the current iteration of the Israel-Palestine conflict. Also, I now hear so much more of the Beatles influence that I definitely didn’t catch before. I’m sad that I didn’t listen to this album as a tween/teen because it would’ve been right up my alley then, if nothing else because of the sound.

The nostalgia!!!!

Idiot album

I did not expect to give this four stars, but it won me over.

Not my cup of tea. But while I like it a lot less than I did two decades ago, I appreciate its anthemic and arcebic bite.

I liked this album when it first came out, but it was way over played on the radio

Very nice album, a classic, has sometimes a rock and roll vibe, many iconic songs

Best geinige dwarse punkrock of hoe dit ook maar heet. Cees-muziek zullen we maar zeggen. Met de nodige terechte kritiek aan het toenmalige Amerika, vraag is of het allemaal veel beter is geworden.

Ik kende Green Day uit de jaren '90. Eentonige meuk. Dus hier had ik eigenlijk helemaal geen zin in. Maar ik word verrast. Het is een heel volwassen en gebalanceerd album met volwaardige nummers. Ik had het wellicht kunnen weten met een hit als Wake Me Up When September Ends. 3,5 ster.

Vroeger luisterde ik al veel naar oa Dookie en Nimrod, de eerdere albums van Green Day. Nadat het een tijdje relatief stil was rond Green Day, kwam ineens dit album uit en het was een absolute gamechanger voor de band. Ik ben naar een concert van ze in Ahoy geweest destijds en ze hadden met dit album een compleet nieuwe set fans aangeboord, ik voelde me voor het eerst in mijn leven oud zo ongeveer. Ze hadden zichzelf ook een nieuwe stijl aangemeten met strakke rood en zwarte pakken. En in de muziek hoor je ook ineens een andere stijl. Tuurlijk, het stemgeluid van Billy Joe Armstrong blijft karakteristiek, maar de opbouw van de songs was niet meer het standaard 3 minuten punkpopgeluid. Hier zat ineens een compleet andere opbouw in, Bohemian Rhapsodyesque, meerdere nummers in 1 nummer tegelijk, tempowisselingen, noem het maar op. En je kan het nu zonder probleem weer op zetten, het heeft niets aan kracht ingeboet. Een tijdloze plaat en toch weet je precies uit welke periode hij komt. Fijne 5 sterretjes

I liked Extraordinary girl, boulevard of broken dreams, wake me up when September ends. Another good album! Sound like something that would play at the old welly lol 27/10/2023

Starts pretty good, I get bored of it by the end though. Will I listen to again: 60%

saw it live

Too cheesy for me

Just the best concept album I’ve ever heard. So many poignant songs - like a love-letter to a punk rock kid written by the jaded, older version of the same. It was the album that made me realise my adulthood.

Green Day at their peak. Jesus of Suburbia is like the bohemian rhapsody of punk rock. Other albums like Dookie might have better songs, but this album is just miles ahead of their other projects.

I remember when this came out. I don't think I listened all the way thru. First time today and I think it kicks ass for what it is. I thought Dookie was great. I like my pop punk like this, short, catchy and I can sing along. It doesn't have to be a classic for me to appreciate it. Solid 5 star pick for me dawg.

A slice of nostalgia from my days as a teenage skateboarding wannabe punk. The opening half of the album is still great and the latter half still kind of falls flat. Not going to find anything too deep or profound here. They knew their audience - angsty, anti-establishment teens.

corny ass stem. ik snap dat het voor de pop punk scene een belangrijk albums is. maar niet voor mij.

dit album duurde minstens 1 uur en 45 min en niet 1 uur

Nothing really offensive, just nothing to get excited about either.

It had some feels attached to the 90s, and listening to this a teen. However, it soon became noise 😬 and droned into the background.

Nostalgia bait. Good album, bunch of great songs on here. Don't like the storytelling approach bundling 2 songs together and some of the worse songs also seem to be the longest. Still really like a bunch of tracks though so easy 4 stars.

very happy this came up, although I forgot it had two 9-minute songs and a bunch of others are combined into a single track - still fun!

The mix is a bit overwhelming for me, especially the guitar (as someone who enjoys Oasis)...

Some decent music, interspersed with unbelievable amount of cheese. Jesus of Surburbia was brilliant though. Worth listening to the album just for that.

Great album. Loose concept, but great songs. Took the pop-punk format to a higher level. The song structures, guitar work, and drums are all top notch. Great songwriting and unique melodies and transitions. Too many highlights.

An album that will always likely remain frozen in time, but may never “sound old.” That churning guitar and BJA’s voice are about as 2004 as it gets. Very nostalgic for myself, especially a poignant tune like Wake Me Up When September Ends. Really enjoyed finding the album tracks as good as the hits.

i rly liked the singles from this album as a tween but i’ve never listened to the full album! pretty good. the bush administration was crazy. jesus of suburbia goes so hard

Have heard 1000 tiems ill pass

rocked 6 year old me's world

Classic punk rock album 👍 Was my shit when I was 14 but not something I would go for now. An album choqued full of nostalgia for me, relistening to it I know exactly where I was when I first listened to these songs. Listening to it now, I think up until track 5 the album is pretty solid then it kind of falls off. Faves: Give Me Novocaine, Jesus of Suburbia, American Idiot

one star is just for jesus of suburbia. kind of the jesus of suburbia of our generation

I’m sorry for being a sucker for edgy concept albums

one of my favourite albums, and something that defined my early years of getting into music.

fun, punchy, love how clear the theatrical style and structure is even on first listen. from a purely sonic perspective it's a no-skip album; i do understand the critiques that say as far as protest music goes it's a bit limited in scope and in some songs the anger can seem directionless.

Great: Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Give Me Novacaine Very Good: American Idiot, St. Jimmy, She's a Rebel, Wake Me Up When September Ends (borderline good/fine) Fine: Jesus of Suburbia, Extraordinary Girl, Letterbomb, Whatsername Bad: Are We the Waiting (bad in a way that genuinely pisses me off), Homecoming (not great in a way that brings the rest of the album down) Overall: I've already heard many times and I didn't change my mind on any tracks really. Just a very front-stacked album that gets noticeably less good as you hit the second half.

What McDonalds did to the hamburger, Green Day did to punk rock. I mean this in a good way! Some of my earliest memories are watching the music videos for some of these tracks on MTV with my older brother and sister (particularly Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Holiday, American Idiot, and Wake Me Up When September Ends). Now I work on music videos for a living - reengaging with this every few years helps me measure how much my understanding of the medium has grown. It feels really cool to be able to grow up and appreciate this in the cultural context of post-9/11 Bush-era America. It's perversely stuck in its time, and I can't help but love it for that.

One of the earliest memories of music albums in my personal brain. What McDonalds did to the hamburger, Green Day did to punk rock. Not necessarily a bad thing - accessible, all over the radio, lots of youths clutched onto it. In particular I remember the music videos on MTV the most vividly Hearing my older brother and sister play these tracks growing up was my cultural insight into the post 9/11 Iraq War early aughts (I was five!) Holiday / Blvd of Broken Dreams is a masterpiece

Incredible album. I know every song by heart.

Bangers! Holds up surprisingly well.

👍🏻

Not bad, very energising. I don't know why songs were joined together though. I mean you can do flawless transitions without doing that too, right?

So many singles off this album

Few classic songs on there but whole thing sounded similar too each other to really enjoy them separately. Few songs in there that are definitely worth a re listen

Jet fuel can't burn steel bars

My review is going to be a bit meta. I feel like Green Day was pushed pretty hard by the record label. They aren't bad, but they aren't as good as they should be for the amount of attention they got. Tons of stuff I'd rather listen to, including real punk from the 70s. Now, that said, this gets three stars because it's oddly subversive. I think it's funny they sold their label on a concept album punk opera called "American Idiot" and then managed to tour all over the world on the record. It's even more funny that they got tons of label support and radio airplay. The sense of irony is off the charts.

I liked Green Day a lot as a young teenager, but when this came out I had moved on to \"cooler\" stuff... so even though I recognized it was pretty good, I never really listened to it. Very well recorded, and super catchy! American Idiot was a huge hit... Jesus of Suburbia also really great song! Also Holiday... And Boulevard of Broken Dreams... this song was huge too. Ok this one is really hit after hit. Very ambitious album! Are We the Waiting sounds like a U2 song... a little much. St. Jimmy brings things back to more classic Green Day! A bit of a dip... Extraordinary Girl sounds like a Beatles song. Interesting. Letterbomb is just a catchy pop punk song, could be on Dookie. Wake Me Up When September Ends is a classic Ballad. Homecoming is not great... it's trying to be a counterpart to Jesus of Suburbia but is kind of cheesy and lame. Should have ended it with September. This is at least a 4... it's a super solid, well written, catchy, well produced album. Dookie is more of a personal favorite, but this one is right up there. I feel like it could really have been trimmed down. There are some weird inconsistencies and run-ons as the album goes on. It's ambitious, but gets a little full of itself.

green day is one of the bands that helped usher in the “pop punk” movement of the 1990’s. the early 2000’s brought uncertainty to the band with disappointing album sales, so they tried a different approach… a concept album with more rock influences. while the punk influences are still there, they’re not as prevalent as previous albums. after all, songs over 9 minutes with distinct movements are definitely not “punk”. neither is the concept of deliberately trying to reach a mainstream audience. having said that, “boulevard of broken dreams” and “wake me up when september ends” are two quality rock songs from the 2000’s. this is a solid effort and the album that helped launched the band further into the mainstream.

This album is great. Green Day is like the band that grew up with us. The music has become more refined and sophisticated but the same angst and disobedience remain. The melodic harmonies presenting dystopian lyrics are buying a latte while the world burns. It's the life of their generation.

So, for some reason this one brings me back to 04 and my political history. I was born in 82 so turned 18 in time to vote in the now infamous 2000 election of Bush vs Gore. As a young person growing up with liberal damn near hippie like ideals (in Illinois) I voted for the Green Party candidate Nader justifying my protest vote of sorts as not really mattering as Gore would easily carry IL. So Bush "wins" the 2000 election, I'm bummed but not too worried as what could really go wrong and surely there won't be any giant crisis to be dealt with. 9/11/01 I'm a college freshman and suddenly it matters allot. As a 19 year old I was pretty sure I'd be drafted into the military for the upcoming World War III, luckily that didn't happen. So the chance to use the Goodwill and cooperation of the entire world is quickly squandered as Bush and Co decide that oil and revenge for Daddy is the plan. The misguided and terrible Iraq war is not happening and some "punk rockers" from California decide to write a concept album about it or something. That's American Idiot which I haven't listened to all the way through since that tumultuous era of 2003-2006.

Viele Klassiker, krasses Album auch wenn nicht meine Musik

A classic of course

The soundtrack to me starting high school, picking up a guitar and a skateboard. A diverse album full of catchy tracks which you can't help but sing along with. I still love the angsty teenage tale of Johnny/Jesus of Suburbia. However the 'political commentary' is a bit corny and paper thin. Biased bonus points for being a hugely nostalgic album for me.

I remeber buying this album in middle school. Almost 20 years later and it has stood the test of time. An older green day managed to capture teenage angst without sounding preachy or overly angsty themselves. Personal favorites include "Jesus of suburbia", "extraordinary girl", "st. Jimmy", "whatshername"

I guess I should preface this by saying that Wake Me Up When September Ends might be one of my most hated commercially successful songs. Add in my mostly negative opinion if pop or post punk, and I just can’t enjoy this album. But, I’ll grant it a few solid tracks and it has aged relatively well.

These guys were more subversive when they wrote songs about jerking off.

Man, remember when this album came out and everyone thought George W. Bush was the worst president in history? How naive we all were. Very high nostalgia points for this album, it was a frequent repeat on my iPod mini back in grade 10 and it still holds up decently well. 3rd best Green Day album and a solid 4.4 rounded down

3.8 lots of radio hits on the album. Not my favorite Green day album but for many it is.

some bangers not great overall

A classic and the songs I hadn't heard, live up to the mega hits

I found it mostly generic. It's not bad music, but to listen to the entire album became repetetive and boring, then annoying, because it's very "simple" music. These are songs to play on a party to create the corresponding undertone.

Punk musical?

A punk-rock concept album. Why? Why not?

Green Day consegue manter o vigor punk e adicionar outras camadas sonoras.

first listen i had no idea this was a pop punk rock opera and it's great

One of my favorite albums, hit me when I was still a kid. Great on a re-listen.

I LOVE GREEN DAY!!!!!!

Not their best but it's a good album.

Not a huge Green Day fan.

it's been a while since i listened to this album and it's a classic for a good reason

HELL YEAH MORE MY STYLE, i like that green day sound!

One of my favorite pop punk albums.

So much nostalgia and some really great songs. Cohesive, and one of their best works.

Good, fun punkish rock.

Not amazing but way better than I expected

The production is too much. It sounds hot, bright, and overly sweet. The songs are decent. These Bush-era protest songs are not nearly as good as the Thatcher-era produced but the rock opera format is honored by this album -- for whatever that's worth.

American idiot and holiday/boulevard are amazing as always. Jesus is too long St Jimmy is way too rock opera for me. The first three songs rock but it's quite downhill from there for me personally. Other Green Day albums are way better for me.

Nostalgic, quintessential teenage pop punk, ambitious if still undercooked. Protesting the general state of American life without having any idea what kind of life would be better. Angsty. Production sounds good though.

I love this album. Have listened to it since it's debut. It's hard to put into perspective how much of an impact this album had on music at the time. Not just the album, but the performances Green Day put on for this album were amazing. Great album.

This has all the Green Day songs I know

SYNOPSIS: Very good album, one of my all-time favorites. Listened to it a lot when I was younger so it is rather nostalgic. TOP TRACKS: 1. Holiday 2. Wake Me Up When September Ends 3. Boulevard of Broken Dreams FINAL RATING: 8.5/10

First album (1/1001) Best song: she’s a rebel

Am I the American Idiot?

One of my favorite albums of all time. I grew up on greenday.

Great instrumental; the vocals could be annoying, and it doesn’t need nine minutes because of two songs together. I don’t feel anything about this one. 4/10

what an icon of culture, even me who lives under a rock away from popular music is well aware of this whole album. though, i only really care about the title track, "boulevard of broken dreams", and "wake me up when september ends". the rest ranges from boring at best to making me forget that i like long songs at worst.

I know this probably comes from nostalgia, but after so many years I still find this album impeccable

Love this album. I remember when it came out, back when music used to drop on Tuesdays. I had recently graduated from college and used to meet my friends at a bar in Westwood every Tuesday because they had 50¢ beers. I bought this album on the way and sat in my car listening to the entire thing before heading into the bar. I was instantly enthralled.

Big angsty vibes. A classic

I don't know what's wrong with me, I used to love Green Day and this type of sound. Now it sounds repetitive even if the message still resonates today. Idk. Just get bored listening.

Typical Radio 2 Top 2000 band, and for some reason this particular album is their most appreciated one, and it also shows up in this list. Sounds ok, as in the way I remembered it: some very catchy pop songs while some of the rock songs are a bit draggy, and the album is too long. Cannot say I like it better or worse than Dookie, so 3 stars again.

These are some elaborated - or even epic - songs, which I find relatively boring compared to the more compact stuff on Dookie.

High school. A classic. Wake me up when september comes.

Nogle af trackene er bare larm. American idiot er fin. Boulevard of broken dreams er en banger.

Green Day's Dookie was my 1st experience with this iconic crossover band. They mixed pure punk, rock and added a dash of speed metal to create their unique sound. I'm an instrumental fan at heart and rarely listen to lyrics. While I understand American Idiot is considered a classic for their message and critique of the current state of America it is somewhat lost on me. What I can say is the classic "3 chords" formula is in full force and the band sounds tighter that ever.

The people who said that this didn't age well can shove it. Musically, this album is unbelievable. Just epic from start to finish. The statements made on suburbia, people just going through life existing, American government propaganda, etc are all arguably even more prevalent today than when it was written. Just because it's not treated with the same eloquence as somebody like Rage Against the Machine doesn't mean that the album didn't age well or had a pointless message. Okay rant over. Back to the music. Billy Joe Armstrong really sets himself apart from the rest of the field in terms of songwriting on this album. The fact that Green Day has had *several* eras of relevance and styles is enough evidence of it, but American Idiot was what got that statement to the mountaintop. Jesus of Suburbia is one of the greatest songs ever written. Holiday and Boulevard of Broken Dreams are timeless classics. American Idiot was an unbelievably huge opener. But every other song on the album is special too. The double tracks all work, even when they're wildly different styles. Just an awesome, awesome album that I will never hesitate to listen to. Favorite track: Jesus of Suburbia

The second half is really quite bad.

Better album than I expected, though I honestly can’t listen to American Idiot without wanting to sing the Weird Al parody lyrics.

Just a few days ago I claimed that U2’s The Joshua Tree has one of the best 1-2-3 punches in history, but the first three songs of Green Day’s American Idiot are superior. The opening and title track is as sobering as it is funny with its not-so-subtle callout of the Fox News media machine, and it’s only grown more relevant in the nearly two decades since its release ahead of Dubya’s 2004 showdown with Democratic challenger John Kerry. I have to say I appreciate the algorithm gifting us this album the day after Rupert Murdoch announced he’s stepping down as chairman. In the words of Logan Roy: Fuck off! The second song, “Jesus of Suburbia,” is to Green Day as “Bohemian Rhapsody” is to Queen, chronicling the collective plight of those who live in broken homes through an amalgamation of what could be several different songs. As far as songwriting goes, it’s the best work the band has ever done. “Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams” rounds out the legendary trio, and is a personal favorite of mine for getting fired up. Unlike The Joshua Tree, however, the album goes much deeper than the first three songs. “Wake Me up When September Ends” may have been the first YouTube video I ever saw when the platform launched in 2005 (I explicitly remember seeing “Hello Goodbye” by the Beatles and “Crazy Frog” by, uh, Crazy Frog, around the same time). Songs like “St. Jimmy,” “Give Me Novacaine,” and “Letterbomb” give us a little more context around the protagonist of the album, and would be the top tracks on most of Green Day’s other albums. American Idiot is one of the greatest albums of the 2000s, and shows that the rock operas of the seventies can transfer over to the rock genre of the 21st century. As the magnum opus of a band that served as a cross-millennia bridge, the record gets an easy five stars from me.

3.5 stars. Solid rock album, but more mainstream/poppy than the more punk earlier version of Green Day. More made for radio than I'd prefer, but still a decent listen. Production/mixing isn't my favorite, sounds like Billy Joe Armstrong is really trying to sing over the guitars. Hard to detangle my nostalgic memories of "Holiday", "Boulevard of Broken Dreams", and "Wake Me Up When September Ends" as they were inescapable during middle school years.

Great album So many amazing songs on here that aren't even American idiot that make this an iconic album Fav song: Jesus of suburbia 8/10

biased aber teenage classic hehe

21st September 2023 Listened on the drive home from Norfolk. One of the albums of my teenage years!

Pretty classic, don't think I've ever listened to whole thing through before. Some bangers and a few skips.

Nice album with Nice sound!

Punk Rock Opera Loved it. Some classics in there. Was an ambitious album for Green Day given their earlier stuff before this. But nailed it!

Nice album

I am not a big fan of punk rock but Green Day are the exception + boulevard of broken dreams is so iconic that I feel like everyone knows it (for good reason)

Just a fantastic rock opera. Such a fucking great, energetic album with some of Green Day’s best cuts

Not a fan of the genre, but there were a couple good hits. Rest of the album didn't change my opinion of the genre.

Man, 13 year old me felt so cool listening to this album! One of those albums where my nostalgia is helping it out. But I think it rocks! Especially Jesus Of Suburbia, I always liked that one. This is peak post-9/11 punk

When Green Day decided to “reinvent” themselves and came out with all this black and red branding/dress, high school me was like - fuckin posers. I hated on this album, I won’t lie. I was short sighted. This album is awesome. Although I’d say their second best, it is still a latter day punk classic, and one of the best of the 00s. The punk rock suites they created on a number of tracks are some of the best explorations of the genre and proved that punk was not one dimensional. I get chills every time I hear the “hurricane of fucking lies” line in Jesus of Suburbia, it’s a powerful build-up. For a west coast band it also has a very east coast feel, with a number of songs written or conceived during Armstrong’s time spent in the East Village. It trails off a little on the back end, but it’s probably one of the most enjoyable front to back punk records ever. I’m torn between a 4 and 5 here.

a pop punk masterpiece. its a perfect album from american idiot to whatsername.

One of my faves

I was in 7th grade when this came out. Prime demographic. I didn't like it then and I still don't like it now. Old Green Day is still the best Green Day.

-I KNOW THIS ALBUMMMM -AND this band! -i have only listened to american idiot tho -so very excited to have a fresh listen -forgot how good this song is -remembering the cover 5sos did of this song -liking the switch up in jesus of suburbia -i do really like his voice i’ll be honest -i Do know wake me up when september ends -i honestly think the slurs are the only reason this album isn’t a 4 or a 5, but a 3 (but also because idk if this album is that amazing but it is legendary and very good

kom mér nokkuð á óvart. hélt að þetta væri líkt og hattar, yfirvaraskegg og skata ekki fyrir mig. talsverð áhrif af seventies rokk/poppi. býsna gott bara. 3,5.

There was a time when Green Day was one of my favorite bands. Dookie, Nimrod, and Warning were heavily in my rotation and I still think they're good but I've gotten so sick of hearing half this album everywhere I go to this very day. I'm not even going to listen to it again. Don't need to.

post punk pop. very dynamic

Structurally brilliant. Songs flow in and out of each other, production is incredible. Politically still relevant, and seemingly will be for the foreseeable future.

Pretty good tbf

wake me up when september ends

This isn’t a bad album, just not for me. The constant power chords and unsubtle social commentary got boring after a couple of tracks. The album is too long and I didn’t like the rock opera elements. They never produced anything better than Dookie in my opinion.

Probably one of if not the best rock albums of the early 2000s, extremely political in a way that rock music needs to be

Not my style

When this came out I worked with a guy who was a massive Green Day fan and he loved this album (he generally had very bad taste). We had some similarity in the music we liked, so he used to try and convince me that this was a good album. In the end I agreed to listen to it twice, end to end, uninterrupted and not while I was working. He was sure I would change my mind; I didn't, it was bubble gum pop/punk of the worst kind. My purist mind just couldn't see anything redeemable here. Stupid American 30-somethings pretending to be angry and sounding like Avril Lavigne. Well almost 20 years later and I figured I would have the exact same opinion, but I actually enjoyed this, once I got over the annoying first track, which still grates. It's not really that the music is improved, but I think I must have mellowed a bit. Also, I now understand that this isn't an affront to rock/ punk, it's just soft-rock/ pop that's been mislabelled. Treating it as music with no particular genre, it's actually pretty tight and melodic. So I'm giving it 4 stars.

Not sure how to rate this really, when I was a teenager I would have given it an easy 5, but I've mellowed on Green Day a lot since then, and I find a lot of these songs fairly cringe inducing now. Some of the deeper cuts (Give Me Novacaine, Extraordinary Girl, Letterbomb) though still hold up, maybe because they weren't played to death! A 3 seems appropriate,but maybe I'll round it up to 4 for the sake of nostalgia and cultural pact (which can't really be denied).

Mainly for the nostalgia, but man that first half slaps

Nostalgia <3

I've heard quite a few of the songs in this album already but still enjoyed it. Some good bangers in here!

Fantastic album resonating coming of age album for a society shaped post 9/11 and the Iraq war which still feels relevant today.

This was THE album of my teenage years. Still a hit today and almost time to wake up when September ends

Great comeback album, hangs together well and all the tracks are good

I remember when this album came out, and I wanted so badly to dislike it because it was the Green Day sell out album. But man, it was catchy and cool and I wanted to fit in. Does it hold up nearly 20 years later? Eh, it’s a good time if you’ve never grown in your music tastes since its release. It’s definitely a hit machine if nothing else. I think it’s been talked into the ground, and I have nothing new to say about it. Armstrong’s voice gets pretty grating after a few tracks. You like Green Day and haven’t heard this album? I’d go ahead and do that.

This feckless, pseudo-protest bullshit can fuck all the way off.

Obviously they know how to write good songs, still really annoying to my ears though

I must sheepishly admit that I never listened to this album in its entirety, even during its peak when I was younger. While I've found select favourites within the punk rock/pop genre – with tracks from bands like The Offspring, My Chemical Romance, Paramore, and Fall Out Boy resonating with me – I'm admittedly quite picky. Green Day has always been a more mixed bag for me. Nevertheless, of all the tracks on this album, 'Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams' stands out as my favourite. But I'm also not likely to revisit it anytime soon.