American Idiot by Green Day

American Idiot

Green Day

3.77
Rating
31357
Votes
1
4%
2
9%
3
24%
4
34%
5
29%
Distribution

Reviews (page 2 of 16)

I hate to admit it, but this is a damn good album and one of the best from the 2000s.

Don't think I have ever heard this album in full, the known hit songs obviously stood out since I have heard them so many times in my youth. Can't say I have ever been a fan of green day, but either because of nostalgia or maybe the songs are just good that I was vibing with this album.

This album was pretty much the soundtrack to my teenage angst, so I've heard it thousands of times. Several of the tracks were also played endlessly on the various music channels at the time. I still know most of the words now. Although this is classed as punk, I don't think much of it is overtly political, realistically the majority of it is (since this is a concept album and tells a story) a commentary on being a young adult at the time - probably a fair amount of it would still resonate today with those audiences. There's some great tracks here, and plenty that I could happily still listen to. I enjoyed the re-listen of this album after all this time. There's a couple of tracks that I'd probably skip on a revisit, but some classics that I think I'd always enjoy. Not quite a 5, but would have been if I was rating it back when it came out.

1st song is really good but I don't really remember anything after that. I remember vaguely enjoying it tho

"Whatsername" sums this album up pretty well: a weird intro leaving little room for hope followed by a serviceable second part with your standard catchy "useless in my mind" repeating line. The album's very uneven. "Jesus of Suburbia" was a disappointment with those weird vocals remaining neither fish, nor fowl as the singer tries to be half-punk, half-metal or whatever but also has this standard pop singing, leaving the voice just cringely distorted or something. Even with the music, it was way boring. I've known "Bulevard of Broken Dreams" and "Wake Me Up When September Ends", as these were hits in the 2010s. The former is one of the best tracks on the album, along with "St. Jimmy" and "Extraordinary Girl". These are examples where they do not sound boring, too pop or boilerplate-ish and bring in some worthwhile music or energy. As far as the rest of the material is concerned, it was mostly enjoyable to a certain degree but not outstanding. So while the band seems to possess an ability to create popular music, their flirt with some metal or otherwise hard genres elements was unsuccessful and I'd consider the tracks good enough to be radio hits (as they have become in reality) but not worthy of the 1001 list. P.S. Shortly after writing this review, I learned that we now have a list of 1102 albums instead of 1089.

Thought I would hate it but wasn't bad.

pop punk greatness

Yep. This is my jam. Probably a top-25ish album for me.

Overall: 7/10 Green Day was probably my first "favourite" band ever, as I was a huge fan of there's in elementary school. This album was always a weird one for me, as I always really enjoyed it but felt that some of the songs weren't up to the standard that I enjoyed from Dookie or Insomniac. I like the rock opera feel of it, but it can be a bit bloated. The real stars of the show are the big suite songs, those two songs are probably the best thing Green Day has ever done. Fav Song: Jesus of Suburbia

Fully willing to admit I’m stupid for this rating, but this is the album that first got me to care about albums in the first place. A pop punk opera should never work, and for a lot of people it doesn’t. But it worked for me. I’ll never forget my friend getting me in trouble as a kid for singing to lyrics to “Homecoming.” Is it the greatest album ever? No, I probably wouldn’t put it in my top 200. But it is still so fun for me to listen to today over twenty years later. Nostalgic favorite.

Alright this hit so hard in high school it does less now but alas

OBRA MAESTRA

Well better than I expected! Of course not as good as "Dookie". But overall a nice album. So: 3/5

I love this album.

2.8/5 kinda goyslop listening to it now but mayb it’s just ruined by how overplayed these hits r

my 150th album!!! another one from my parents' cd collection!!! grew up emo and obviously heard the singles but somehow never got around to listening to this in full... i was still an angsty whiny teenager only two years ago and probably would've self inserted as whatsername as cringe as it sounds so this made me feel seen… loved this

Aż skręciło, bo GD przez jakiś czas miał u mnie nienajlepszy status. Ale eeej, jaka to jest dobra plyta. Pamiętam ją jako dobrą płytę i nie zestarzała się nic a nic. Dobra historia się z tego układa i dziękuję mojej mamie, że kupiła ten album kiedy wychodził.

American Idiot is not my favorite Green Day album (that distinction goes to 2000's Warning) and it doesn't feel as distinctive and important as Dookie (also on this list). It's still a good album with some strong hits that brought them back into the public eye and gave a simple political message that was refreshing. Surprisingly long tracks (though some of them are really two songs mashed together) for a punk band but they didn't feel long in the way that jam band tracks drag on ad infinitum. Do I think it should be on this list, probably not. It's not enough of a departure from Dookie to feel like something new, though the band has matured and improved, and if I was going to put a second Green Day album on the list it would be Warning, but that's purely because of my deep abiding love for every track on that album.

There are a lot of bitchy 1-star reviews of this album that complain that the politics aren't sophisticated. Dude, it's a Green Day album. The music is pop rock with a punk veneer, and the lyrics are about attitude more than political science. These are good songs - energetically played, more sophisticated than they sound, and well-produced. It's not gonna change the world, but it sounds real good. I know Billie Joe Armstrong's voice annoys some people, but I'm not one of them. And Mike Dirnt is low-key an outstanding bassist.

Classic album, have listened to it before. Love the two songs in one theme

that early 2000s sound i enjoy

No notes.

So glad I happened to wear a hoodie today, as it's the peak outfit for this album. Angsty, loud, over-the-top, and so of its time. American Idiot is an admittedly great song, but the rest kind of pales in comparison and feels like attempts to recapture the energy of that song, but just never quite hits the mark. Favorite Songs: American Idiot, Letterbomb

Always thought this was a post sellout appeal to the youth album. But it’s basically back to back bangers

Gran álbum, muy consistente con su temática y sonido sin volverse repetitivo. Me gusta mucho que gran parte de las canciones sean doble-tracks y que no se sientan eternas.

generic pop

You just can't argue with these melodies.

Favorite Green Day album.

Не зря считается классикой, да хороший апльбом, но пожалуй,я продолжу слушать только в формате "биг хитов"

When I was a teen, I thought U2 and Green Day were the lamest bands on Earth. Now that I'm an adult, I can appreciate U2 but Green Day is still really fucking lame.

OK. Not my type of music but not as bad as I thought it would be and I liked a few of the songs that I'd heard before – Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends. Heard it before? ❌ Listen again? ❌ Rating out of ten? 4️⃣

Solid Green Day at its best

Huge nostalgia factor from 2000a but these songs got overplayed too much that I can’t score higher

I remember quite qell when this came out, and as a teenager at the time I think I was the main target audience then. I liked the titled track and the sisngles back then, but I think only Boulevard of Broken Dreams aged well. Tli like the concept of the album, mixing politics with the story of Jesus of Subirbia but the whole thing was really bad executed: the story is quite shallow and juvenile and the politics are even more shallow with slogans about revolution etc. Listening to this after 22 years was not a good experience and even the song here is a poppy Ramones with a few of Green Day twists. I can tell the album is here because it was popular back then, but it did remind me Simple Plan most times, and even Warning was a best album than this. I love Dookie though, but this is a 2/5

Awful awful awful

Huge fan of this album and all the layers of narrative and culture that you can analyze, especially as a non-American. I can and will talk your ear off about my perspectives of this album but don’t have time to type them all out. I had the privilege to see this entire album played front to back on Green Day’s 2024 tour celebrating the 20th anniversary of American Idiot and 25th of Dookie. Truly a special concert.

Dä Beat isch guet und vielfältig, d Lyrics und so isch chli wiederholend. Trotzdem recht guet für zwüschä durä:)

There are a few ok songs but I have never been too keen on this one.

A good ol' Greenday album. A song like American Idiot has only gotten even more relevant with the time. Once that has been said, it's Green Day and as such it's punk just a bit more convoluted than the others. Favorite Songs: American Idiot ; Jesus of Suburbia ; Boulevard of Broken Dreams

Even better than i remember, so nostalgic

A 9 track album and I couldnt wait for itto be over. I dont understand the love for this dogwater band

I like it - but even though its more complex and probably a better album than Dookie, I still prefer Dookie.

Great album. Probably their magnum opus, although I like a lot of their albums personally.

It’s the stand out pop punk album for that decade , it’s hard not to listen to this and think of childhood for me . Love it

Ett helt fantastiskt album med i stort sett inga dåliga spår. Fullträff!

Vilka minnen! Älskar detta. Trallvmvänligt, bra låtar osv osv osv.

I enjoyed this more than I expected as I have not listened for years. 1. Boulevard Of Broken Dreams 2. Wake Me Up When September Ends 3. Homecoming

Hatte ich gar nicht so geil in Erinnerung. Aber das ist auch nach den ersten 4 Bangern noch richtig gut!

Starkes, mutiges Album. Bisschen lang, aber nur ein bisschen.

Not my thing

Nossa senhora... Só de ver a imagem já vem imagens da adolescência... Imagina tu comprar o CD no lançamento e já ouvir essa pedrada. Mesmo ouvindo até hoje 200 mil vezes por ano, dar um play aqui com um outro olhar chega a arrepiar. Os caras já metem uma música de 9 minutos em segundo... ousados. Mais um álbum que o cu artístico dos caras tavam virado pra lua. 4 hits sequenciais. Ainda vem Wake me up when September ends... justamente no dia 01 de outubro kkkkk. Que timing. O álbum todo é bom, vai tomar no cu. Foda. Dá pra ouvir todo ano e ainda arrepiar.

Gear: INAWAKEN Twilight-DS Artwork: ️🫀🧨🤡 Production: 🔊⚠️😮‍💨 Music: 📻💅✊ Rating: 🍊🍊(🍊)/5

I’m not a huge fan of Green Day (or much of a fan at all), but this album directly links me back to being 17 and being sick and tired of hearing Wake Me Up When September Ends. So that’s something!

This album is a masterpiece! I had a copy and when I was a teen boy o used to listen to it everyday after school

A well-known band, well-known songs, not bad at all. Three stars...

Earlier during this project I referred to the White Stripes’ Elephant as “my generation’s Sgt. Pepper.” Well, that makes this my generation’s Tommy. A tighter narrative structure, with all the drama and theatrics of its predecessor. I have to thank my sister, who rushed to the record store to pick this up the day it was released. Back in the day when people still did that.

Albums My Mother Showed Me My mom picked me up from school in 2005. She had just gotten a brand new car, very exciting. She sat my sister and I in the back and said “look in the seat pocket” as we each revealed a CD she picked out for the both of us. I got American Idiot, my sister got something by Usher. Sign o the times. This is my favorite Green Day album for several reasons. The foremost reason being the flow. The message it portrays, the musicianship that the band exhibits and the creation of St. Jimmy are some others. Sign o the times, sign o the times…

Have I listened to this album before No How familiar am I with this album Pretty familiar How do I feel about this artist? I like Green Day Pre-Listen Thoughts: This is one of those albums where I know most of the songs but I’ve never listened to them all together, I’m excited for this one Favorite track(s): Wake Me Up When September Ends, Homecoming Post-Listen Thoughts: This was good, nothing surprising, but it all flowed together really well.

sonido de infancia

I was supposed to listen to this album yesterday, but never got to it. I think that's because I heard this album for the first time recently, and didn't really enjoy it too much. I didn't hate it, but I didn't love it. And after a second listen thanks to the album generator, I don't think my opinion has changed much. I'll preface this by saying I already don't love pop punk. So I wasn't expecting to enjoy a whole hour of it. The songs really just blend together (the deluxe version literally merging half the tracklist doesn't help). It feels very repetitive at times. There are some cool moments, though, such as the coda of "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" and the intro to "Extraordinary Girl." I also don't love the lyrics. Maybe I'm not emo enough for this album, but they just come across as cheesy most of the time. And that's without mentioning Billie Joe Armstrong's apparent obsession with a certain slur. Meh. Listen to it if you like pop punk, otherwise it's just okay. ----- #0012 Heard on: 29 Sep. 2026 Rating: ★★★★★☆☆☆☆☆ (182 / 332) Favorite track: Extraordinary Girl Least favorite track: Boulevard of Broken Dreams

Green Day is the black-eyelinered face that launched a thousand emo ships on the seas of MySpace, along with its cousins MCR, Blink, Evanescence and FOB (some of the strangest missing items from the list, probably as a consequence of its original publishing dateand the anti-emo rockist sentiment in vogue in '05). For the span of a few years Hot Topic T-shirts bearing that iconic bloody grenade-heart were the budding millennial's Nirvana tee. I remember having this record loaded up on my beaten-up second-hand iPod nano to accompany my first ever bouts of angst, so the call is definitely coming from inside of the house on that one. There's definitely something to be praised about American Idiot that despite inspiring 10,000 copycats like some Computer Age Velvet Underground and Nico (or maybe a more tryhard Nevermind), Green Day probably remains the best to ever do the pop-punk schtick. The singles off this album are worthy of the oodles of radio time they've received since release. A month ago I went through Dookie again for this list, and it's interesting to hear the evolution - what has changed in GD's sound and what hasn't. American Idiot is certainly just about as polished as pop-punk gets, completely shaving off that razor-edge of capital P-Punk that still lingered in Dookie despite 'selling out' to the major labels. American Idiot still carries some of that Minutemen-ish Pistols-esque DNA but it's alsmost been diluted out. Both are definitely great albums on an even keel tip to toe, so it ultimately becomes a matter of taste between the raw, honest bandroom sound of their earlier Dookie era and their much cleaner aesthetically-polished Idiot period. Personally I think I prefer Dookie's more hot-sauce vinegarish 'kick' to the more accomplished sound of American Idiot (and the former is definitely more interesting lyrically, it must be stated), but I wouldn't fault one side or the other. Fav tracks: American Idiot, Holiday, Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Wake Me Up When September Ends

I am not a fan of this band but this is as good as it gets in their field - pop punk college band. Love the drum sound on this. The rest is tight and to the point. I suspect they wanted to write a hit album and by all measures they nailed it.

Is it "real punk"? Probably not, though "real punk" is an incredibly vague term that no two punks would ever be able to agree on a definition for. Is Taco Bell authentic Mexican food? No, of course not. But a Cheesy Gordita Crunch is still delicious.

Один из любимых альбомов, прекрасный панк/поп-панк 10

Classic pop punk record with lofty ambitions and an interesting reflection of a turbulent time in America's history. Key tracks: Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday

admittedly i kinda forgot that this was like a concept album when i was listening to it but that certainly didn't hinder the experience for me really just a well written really enjoyable rock album. i wasn't sure how much i was going to enjoy 7-9 minute green day songs but they were actually great, along with basically the rest of the tracklist. favourite songs: boulevard of broken dreams, give me novacaine, homecoming least favourite song: are we the waiting

Doesn't hold the same power it did 20 years ago for me, but it's way too personally important and cozy to not love.

Kind of a 3.5 but rounding up for nostalgia

I was dreading relistening to this, a fixture in my middle school years that I feared hasn't aged well. I'm kinda shocked to report how moving I still find it, and how fun and punchy it still plays. Is it perfect? Not by any shot, it's still guilty of the Green Day chintzy punk sensibilities, and i hate tracklists that rely too much on medley, which this is really indulging in (although the medleys are all pretty good for the most part). But it's a work of messy brazenness in a messy, brazen time. I don't owe it brownie points for being valuable in its political moment but i do appreciate that about it. I also didn't realize, I genuinely remember every single sound in this album, even if I didn't recognize all of the track titles.

The hits on this album are phenomenal. The album tracks don’t have enough steam to carry their long run time.

It's too theatrical to feel wholly punk if you ask me, but who cares when the melodies carried by simple power chord progressions are THIS good. Faves: American Idiot, Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams, Give Me Novacaine/She's a Rebel,

Green Day have their place. And that place is 1995.

Manages the classic double of being bad and annoying.

Derivate nonsense. If you were producing a film featuring a high school band who were just starting to write their own songs, the songs might sound a bit like this. Manages to rip off Bryan Adams and (err) Travis in the first four songs. Seems happy with ableist slurs, seems incredibly pleased with itself. Not for me, Clive.

New to me, pretend music, 1 star. Tom.

I mean. The songs were stuck in my head before I even started listening for the day.

Ah, nostalgia. Take me back. Spiked hair, skateboards, baggy jeans that soaked up all the rain, walking in a certain way so your cd doesn't skip, twisting the headphones so the loose connection isn't a problem and freedom. -------------------------------------------------------------- I can't believe how many hits were on this album. Holiday is the pick for me with it's rhythmic bounciness. The drums and bass through are tonally perfect whether that be the more punk rock style of songs like st Jimmy or the rock opera of homecoming. Those tom fills demand attention. There's a lot of depth here musically, something I didn't appreciate on release. Back in the day this wasn't heavy enough for edge lord me, but now? Hits just right. The vocals are distinctive and well delivered. Sure the messages are a bit ham-fisted but you can't deny the enduring quality of American Idiot. It's not quite a 5 but it's getting a 4 with distinction.

If you were in 6th-8th grade in 2004-5, this was one of THE albums, and there’s no questioning that. It felt like every third song on the radio was from this record. It being Green Day and I being in the Portland metro area then, it had major crossover appeal. I listened to this on a whim pretty recently (by that i mean within the past 2 years) and the super-saturation of Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Wake Me Up When September Ends was still fresh enough after decades that i skipped both. This time i threw in Blvd and i can say again that i do like it. Letterbomb is an incredibly slept on (by me) Green Day song Homecoming > Jesus of Suburbia don’t @ me Overall? This album holds a really special place in my memory, and it might be nostalgia goggles a little bit but i still think it’s a very solid one. I enjoy it a good deal, but i wouldn’t say it’s GREAT, you know? A 4 it is!

The 3/5 rating could mean a few things. It could be because the album is merely okay, maybe with a couple of catchy songs without ever really wowing. It’s not boring, it’s just not that good. It could also be because the album contains a few total bangers, with a few true stinkers dotted in. A mixed bag. American Idiot definitely falls into the second category. I really like Green Day’s 90s stuff. Short, catchy guitar pop. I even like some of 21st Century Breakdown. American Idiot is the most divisive in my mind. Let’s talk positive. The title track, Holiday and Give Me Novocaine are great songs. She’s A Rebel is short and catchy. Maybe the most Green Day song on the album. However, nothing can come close to Whatsername. It is surely one of the greatest songs ever to see out an album. An epic lament of noise and angst which never spirals out of control. It may be loud, but it is coherent and structured. Fantastic. But there is some garbage here too. Are We The Waiting will always be in the conversation for Green Day’s worst song. Wake Me Up is cheesy and saccharine. The two 9 minute tracks are repetitive and pointless. Pretentious and unremarkable. St Jimmy is too silly to be taken seriously. In conclusion, there is some great stuff here, some okay stuff too. But when nearly half of the runtime is self indulgent rubbish, it’s hard to give more than a 3/5.

Better than Dookie (though the odd way the Spotify deals with tracks running into eachother on this is far worse than the CD. All Green Day CDs have tidy track markers and are well mastered)

Fake vanilla overdone punk for the masses who don't know good music. Too much makeup, too much fake angst, too much whining, too much everything. I resisted this album when it came out, and was hoping that maybe I was just trying to be too cool by not liking this album then... But I can safely thank my too cool younger self for steering away from this one. I still love Dookie, but they just tried way too damn hard on this one. Corporatized rock/punk that just hurts my soul.

I didn't pay much attention to Green Day or their 90s pop punk peers back then. I wasn't really dismissive or anything, just had my head in other things. I'm familiar with the radio songs of course. I'm warming up to this band a lot more lately even before I got this album. The deeper cuts are damn good tunes. It does droop during the ballad-y songs so I will be skipping those on future listens.

This is one of those nostalgic ones for me; I think this literally goes back to 2015, when I was first dealing with ocd. Give me novocaine really connected with me at the time and still does. Whatsername killed me then and does now. Those two nostalgia bombs out of the way, the storytelling and degenerate energy of the entire album is incredible. Just look at the song titles - Jesus of Suburbia might be my favorite.

A really good album. Solid songs and great sounding.

No. Not for me. It deserves a 2, and I am sure is a 5 for some. But for me, no.

Love this album. The power ballads are a lot less lame than I remember. There’s some bside stuff that’s a little too cute for its own good and only used to shoehorn the concept album lore, but the bangers rip. Was going to say 3.5 but got the extra .5 because the album forces you to listen to it like an album. Want Boulevard? Gotta sit through Holiday sucker.

I was expecting to hate this album. I dislike the singles and think Wake Me Up When September Ends is one of my least favourite songs of all time. So I was shocked by how much I enjoyed it. Songs that feel bombastic or sappy on the radio make sonic sense in context. Don’t get me wrong, Wake Me Up When September Ends still isn’t great but other songs made up for it. I especially liked Are We the Waiting and the glockenspiel on Homecoming.

literally every song is good. 4

listening to this while cleaning my gross as hell bathroom 😍🥰🥰🥰 boulevard of broken dreams is my fav so far i think why'd he say the hard r in this album do not like we are the waiting that much.... too chill and repetitive i like extraordinary girl

I didn't realize this album had such long songs and so many of the hit songs are actually joined together on the album. I appreciate that ambition from it. I think there's plenty to like here for this well done album, but I just don't like the palette. I'm not a pop punk guy, and this feels like the safest poppy version of it. Not a lot of particularly interesting or inspired choices from what I can hear. The ambition from the album comes from the length of the songs and willingness to be more grand and big sound rather than leaning into an angry punk edge. I wasn't paying super active attention while listening, and I don't feel like I missed out.

Average, very overhyped band

Gréât album! Holiday, boulevard of broken dreams, wake me up when September ends

Can’t separate my feelings and my life from the music here, which is fine. Realistically, this is probably more a four star album. Good, and important, but not great and some parts have aged clunkily. But for me, this is my early teen years. This has gotta be one of the albums I listened to the most in my life. Had a burned copy of it in my first car. Played it constantly. I remember in 8th grade, getting a friend to lend me his copy of the album and then going home and printing out all the lyrics for the album (slowly copy pasting them into a word document, printing it took forever) and then following along to the lyrics as I listened to the album. I didn’t want to miss any of the “story” (sure it’s just Fight Club for pop punks but it was mind blowing for an 8th grader). I remember how seismic the singles were. Genuinely inescapable. Green Day WERE the biggest band in the world for a moment there, and it was really cool. As a burgeoning teen I was starting to become politically aware - I also remember 2004 was the first year I started staying up and watching The Daily Show - and this album was speaking directly to me as I began to realize, “Hey, I don’t know if I think Bush is a good guy, and also war is bad.” Which, tbf, is also the pretty shallow politics of this album - but it was a big deal at the time! This was only 3 years after 9/11, and artists like The Chicks had already basically had their careers terminated for deigning to say “Bush is not a good man.” Yeah, love this album. Means so much to me.

A classic

You know, the idea of a punk rock opera is fine and all, but this album never quite stirred the pot for me. The songs are fine, fairly catchy even, but the concept isn't anything special, and the whole thing feels a tad long.

nah american idiot aight ig

Kinda like but i wouldn't listen to it make me feel like phinieas and furb and horrid henry

dont really mind but dont really like

Fantastic!

Despite quite liking Green Day around this time I never owned this or had heard it start to finish. The singles I obviously knew and they still get played on the radio. It's not but I can't say that on this listen I got much of the 'concept' and I don't know that I'd give it another spin any time soon.

Wall-to-wall bangers. Loved it then, love it now.

Need to be able to rate it 4.9 so I can have Dookie higher.

4.5 I feel like it could be a 5; I am unsure why I'm holding back from giving it 5 stars.

pop punk’s last hurrah.

This is the album that earned my respect for this band. They’re no longer a bunch of entitled suburban derivative punk wannabes. This album made them rebels with a cause, and the noblest and most patriotic of causes. Because it’s Green Day, half of this album is still pretty one-star stupid (and derivative), but there are some five-star songs here, ten years into their career.

Of course I had heard a lot of this. Personally enjoy Dookie better but I think that’s because it means more to me in my personal life.

okay, day 2 i listen to this album my favorite song is american idiot, wake me up when sept end, whatsername,

Tykkäsin ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Lapsuuden yks kulutetuimmista. Hyvä lätty.

I’m not a pop punk fan but this really is worthy of its reputation. Similarly, ‘rock opera’ might not give you great cause for optimism, but it really does nail the experience of being a teenager in the politically charged times of the early 2000s. More than the typical emo/pop punk themes of arguing with your parents or having a wank, this feels genuinely substantive and important in giving a portrait of American suburban life at that moment. The Jesus of Suburbia and Wake Me Up When September Ends are the highlights in showing how that has genuine musical quality too. A bit long, but otherwise great.

Green Day are another album that represented something of a musical blindspot, though I was of course familiar with 'American Idiot' and 'Boulevard of Broken Dreams.' Overall, I was impressed with what I heard. The aforementioned two tracks are obvious highlights but my pick of the punch might be 'Holiday.' 'Jesus of Suburbia', 'Letterbomb' and 'Wake Me Up When September Ends' are other highlights.

I usually don’t get on with pop-punk, but this album is absolutely an exception. The lyrics perfectly capture a sense of teenage frustration and disillusionment with the politics and culture of 2000s America, and the music is brilliant too. It’s just banger after banger, but if forced to pick some highlights, I suppose I’d go for the obvious classics: ‘American Idiot’, ‘Jesus of Suburbia’ (perhaps my overall favourite), ‘Boulevard of Broken Dreams’, ‘Wake Me Up When September Ends’. I’m still not the biggest fan of Billie Joe’s voice, but it’s just too good to give anything less than 5 stars.

Green Day has always been a bit of a cringe band for me, going back to their Dookie days when my neighbor blasted it for what felt like 23 hours a day. Beyond that, they’ve long been the poster child for everything I dislike about commercial pop punk, especially their aggressive, punk driven tracks that just don’t click with me. Take American Idiot, the title track is so annoying I can hardly stand it. But once you get past that song, a lot of the other tracks on this album aren’t actually that bad. Over the years, I’ve found their more melodic songs, like some on this record, to be pretty catchy, and I think Green Day would’ve been much better as an alternative rock band than a punk band. On a side note, I’ll give them credit for their influences, particularly Devo, who inspired them so much that some members formed a synth-pop, new wave side project called The Network, which was a fun little venture for what it was. All that said, Green Day has always been, and probably always will be, a bittersweet band for me. Some moments I enjoy, but others I just can’t get behind.

Like it 3/5

Album : 18/1089 Songs known going in : 9/9 Favourite song : Jesus of Suburbia Cover Art : minimalist but cool Rating : 5/5 Notes : I can't pretend I don't already know and love this album. This is incredibly nostalgic for me. It was one of my mums favourite albums to play in the car when I was younger.

Perfect pop punk!

Very energetic, not the kind of music that I would hear a lot OR everyday, but a perfect album to hit the gym (some song of it at least).

Leuk. Iconisch

I went into this already very familiar with “American Idiot,” “Boulevard of Broken Dreams,” and “Wake Me Up When September Ends,” and all three still sound great more than 20 years later. I’m pretty sure I’ve heard the full album before, but it never really stuck with me. It definitely did this time. There isn’t a weak song here. I love the music, the storytelling, and the message, which still feels remarkably relevant today. The album plays almost like a Broadway show, with “Jesus of Suburbia” introducing the main character and the story continuing through the rest of the record. Even the nine-minute songs never feel long because they move through different sections and musical ideas. The deeper I got into the album, the harder it became to pick a favorite discovery because I loved them all. “Are We the Waiting,” “St. Jimmy,” “Extraordinary Girl,” “Letterbomb,” “Homecoming”...every song brings something to the story while keeping the album moving. Twenty-two years later, this one absolutely holds up. No duds, no filler, and definitely one I want in my vinyl collection.

Being a millenial I am too overly familiary with the majority of these songs. The singles in particular are overproduced, however that was the style at the time of course. However there are a number of decent tracks that I wasn't familiar with beforehand like Are We The Waiting, Letterbomb and Whatshername

Este es el primero que de verdad me gusto muchisimo. cada cancion tenia un estilo que me encantaba y a pesar de ser larguisimas no se sentia. alfin se de donde salio ese tema de I walk on a lonely road. 10/10

I am very familiar with this album. It is one of my favorites. 5 stars all day long.

5/10, l'unica che mi è piaciuta circa è novacane qualcosa

I enjoyed most of it. Nostalgia bumps this up quite a bit.

Still relevant as it was when it came out. Songs are great on their own but really shine in the context of the album.

a rare punk rock concept and thematic album. Nice story about a band on the verge of breakup who reconcile and collaborate to make a great album.

One of the best bands of the 90s, some classics on this album.

Good album!

Maybe 3 1/2. I appreciate the anti-fascist lyrics, but too much drum crashing for me.

I like a good protest song! 💪

Algunas canciones me gustaron, otras no. Le doy 3 estrellas.

One of my favorite albums.

Ka es fuckoju ar teenage movie soundtrack tipa dziesmam

Man nepatīk pop-rock vai whatever šis rock žanrs saucas, bet šis albums ir labs

Lead single that gives the album its name is indeed as fun as it ever was. Lyrics do be hitting, too... 9 minute songs??? Pretty cool for what it was. Is that a saxophone?? Holiday and Boulevard are more pleasing sonically than I remember/expected. Governator for example is annoying, and it's kinda like the default I envision when someone mentions punk/punk rock. Too Much Too Soon is kinda similar, but in a better way (not annoying; neat; nothing that really moves me or stays any for a moment longer after it finishes playing). Letterbomb is a step up further for that, noice. I appreciate the inter-song references. --- As a whole, it's pretty good. Didn't deep dive into the lyrics but what I could "get" on the first few listens was good and helps provide more depth to the experience. About as good as it would get for my appreciate of punk rock, I think - unless there's some hidden gem I am not aware of - wherein I liked it musically/sonically more than The Black Parade. Interestingly, though, both the first listen of the album in order and the shuffle listen later on was quite more enjoyable than I expected - I genuinely enjoyed this more than Nirvana's In Utero and even Pantera's Vulgar Display Of Power, which is quite shocking for me. Perhaps I am indeed evolving my tastes through this experiment. Can't give this a 5 as ultimately this is an exercise in subjective listening, and this does not spark the same joy as some of the hidden gems we previously got in this experiment, nor as some of my favorite music, but it does do much better than I thought it would, and than I remembered it for. Strong 4+, or 4 with an upside. Probably better overall than most of my 4s and even some 5s, but lacked the extra spice I like.

I've gone back and forth on writing a review for this album a few times. It's one of my favorite albums and it made me want to be a rockstar as a kid (even if that never panned out), I can say that much without thinking about it. It can seem quite straightforward when it comes to concept rock operas coming off the back of stuff like Pink Floyd's The Wall (the last album the generator gave me) but even still I can't not love this more when I'm part of this album's generation. I do believe it really is a generation defining album owing to it's punk rock coming of age story with some general political sprinklings here and there, but it's really not about politics to the extent of direct criticisms to any political idea or party, at least in my interpretation. It's more about the general state of culture that Millenials and Gen Z were born into at the time and that still resonates today; to borrow a quote from The Sopranos: "It's good to be in something from the ground floor. I came too late for that and I know. But lately, I'm getting the feeling that I came in at the end. The best is over.". I feel like that's what the album is about. Are we the waiting? Of course we are - every generation is - but I don't think that until the new millenium came did we collectively become so pessimistic about the future. That's what the Jesus of Suburbia represents in my eyes. Whatsername represents the collective optimism that was previously had and the nostalgia and longing for it whereas St. Jimmy represents the carelessness that comes from hopelessness. When you're so saddled by the sins of the collective past, it's way too tempting to just numb yourself with Novacaine. Now of course, this is just my interpretation obviously, but I know there's plenty of others out there, and that's the beautiful part of how this album is written. Some see it as a political album, some see it as a punk rebel album, others see it as a coming of age story; all are equally valid really. Pair all of that with rocking punk riffs and delivery from Billie Joe, genuinely fantastic instrumentation from Mike Dirnt and Tré Cool, and Rob Cavallo's massive, arena-ready production, and I genuinely consider this required listening for anyone interested in rock music. The fact that it also marked such a massive comeback for Green Day only adds to the story behind the album.

Твердая 8.5-9/10, интересная история которая тянется на протяжении всего альбома, понравились переходы в песнях. Boulevard of broken dreams и Give me Novacain прямо в сердце.

Favorite Track: Are We the Waiting / St. Jimmy

Although not a huge fan, I think this is a great album, fun to listen too and has some great hits. I understood the importance of it when released but I think the world is worse than it was and now the protest sounds "vanilla" or tame

Охуенный концептуальник, 8/10 поскольку пока не фанат панка. Но зная саму суть альбома - 8 поскольку концетуальники я люблю.

- The title track is not a “bad” song, but I remember it being the best on the album and that is setting quite the low bar for me. - It’s not that I disagree with the politics of this album. I just don’t find this version of Green Day to be particularly listenable.

Не люблю Green Day. Але буду слухати.

It's enjoyable music. It's funny thinking back to the mid 2000s and how sure we were that things were awful and couldn't get worse.

I've never listened to the full album before, I was 20 when it came out. Knowing a few of the songs that were hits off the album, I enjoyed the nostalgia of it. I hadn't realized it was a punk-pop rock opera. Jesus of Suburbia was a highlight. A couple of songs went for too long, but I can imagine set to a storyline, it probably wouldn't feel that way watching it on stage. Not sure I want to own it, but I do think it deserves 4 stars.

Musically wasn't really my thing at the time, and that hasn't really changed. Points for committing to a concept album though

it was the modern concept album. some great songs

La verdad buen álbum pero no soy tan fan de green day

Green Day knocks it out of the park with more bangers. I loved the two long tracks on here, plus how most of the songs came in pairs and blended together. This was pretty much all of the same positives as Dookie, which I was given about a week ago, but even better. Favorite Track: Homecoming

Prinz horror Poppunk zeit. c

Already heard it. Not bad but not my style-too noisy.

Not particularly impressed - but then I never was. Not sure what all the fuss is about really, just the end of grunge.

American Idiot : 4 Jesus of Suburbia : 5 Holiday : 3,5 Boulevard of Broken Dreams : 3,5 Are we the Waiting : 4 St. Jimmy : 5 Give me Novocaine : 3 She’s a Rebel : 4 Extraordinarily Girl : 3,5 Letterbomb: 4 Wake Me Up When September Ends : 5 Homecoming : 2 Whatsername : 3,5 American Idiot is a good album. Problem is, I’m from that generation when it came out, and it was all over the place. Even today, Holiday and Boulevard of Broken Dreams are still heavily played. There’s a couple of songs that reminds me of the old Green Day, like She’s a Rebel and Letterbomb. Don’t get me wrong, that’s a solid album, but the second half isn’t as good as the first. 4/5. Been a while since I’ve listened to it, but probably my next listen will be in a while too.

Feels like college

I’m behind the ideas this album is built on, and GD always kills it on production, but no matter how epic BJ wants to be, he still writes with a rich guy’s caution (even when throwing in the F word completely unnecessarily). I think he thinks they can be The Who and Bad Religion at once, and I don’t think that’s possible, because The Who Sold Out. Dookie is an infinitely better Green Day record, and NOFX’s The War on Errorism is an infinitely better anti-capitalist concept album.

in a world of incredibly polarizing views on this record, i will maintain my Musical Objectivity and admit that my thoughts on this album are just "it's ok".

Wasn't looking forward to this but in the end... Not bad. I was just critical of Queen II for being guilty of "Excess" and I guess the same could be said of this but at the same time where Queen was yelling their story at me, Green Day here were actually narrating. I can understand the praise it got, and even though I won't go back to it myself it won't complain if someone else puts it on.

hay muy buenos hits pero se llega a hacer aburrido, aun asi creo que vale la pena 4

Pop punk and alternative rock feeling like being pulled into a protest march where everyone around me is shouting the same slogans, jumping, pushing forward, and feeding off the collective energy. The guitars, drums, and Billie Joe Armstrong’s forceful vocals make the music feel immediate and confrontational, while the album’s rock-opera structure turns the whole thing into a larger story of alienation, rebellion, and escape. I’m not standing outside the crowd here; the music keeps dragging me along with it, even when its slogans and repeated anthemic gestures start to feel almost too deliberate.

Bra album, men traff ikke helt stemingen i dag.

Another whiny classic. I like it.

I involuntarily heard enough of this album 20 years ago that I never want to hear it again. Hard pass.

For me it isn't a great album, a good one but it quite misses something. I feel like it tries to much to be sand 3/5

Leuk album en ik snap waar de hype vandaan is gekomen toen der tijd. Flinke stempel voor een hele generatie 2 bangers

I never really liked Green Day and after hearing this, I still don't really like Green Day. I can't believe they made a Broadway musical based on this album. That must have been hell.

It seems I know more songs from this album than I thought I did: I was singing along to quite a lot of it. Really enjoyable rock music.

I'm not a huge pop punk fan. I can appreciate the drumming, and it's got its catchy and iconic moments.

This is very much another case of. This album was so good everyone started copying it, making it retroactively worrse, or at least makes it feel overdone. The music is actually well made, and they do at least try to be punk in their lyrics and themes. But there exist another 100 (worse executed) post-punk rock albums from mid to late 00s. Which sadly do negatively affect this album.

Again not a bad listen but didn’t really blow me away either. I can appreciate it

Maybe I AM the faggot, America. 🤔

Good stuff, but not as good as Dookie

meh I only kind of liked Dookie so this is deffff gonna be a no from me dawg

Honestly I was wrong, pretty fly for millenialslop

Loads of tunes

pretty good ngl 7 out of 10

I didn’t want to love it as it is one of my Dads favorite albums. Turns out my dad has taste. Sometimes. Shit rocks.

Is there more than 5

The mega melodic monster that reinvented this band. For a particularly effective example, see "Boulevard-" a song I'd offer as one of the greatest, most recognizable melodies of the century. Maximalist pop rock production with agreeable presentation and equally agreeable instrumental performances, especially by a three-piece.

Blast from the past. Absolute bangers from start to finish. Aged like fine wine, too. Some people think Green Day is lame for whatever reason, or that this album is too refined or blah blah blah whatever. This shit rules.

I’ll admit to having been a bit of a snob about Green Day - I mean I was already in my 40s when this record came out, so I’ve never really been their intended audience. But hey, I’m kinda enjoying this. It’s not very adventurous, musically or lyrically, and the social criticism is mild, but still, much of it is better than I’ve always assumed it would be. “St. Jimmy” is probably what I liked most on here. The music on this track is a little more frenzied, and the vocals not miked so prominently. To me the best punk rock is a bunch of short songs that are a big wall of noise and you have to work a little to figure out what they’re saying.

Always thought this album was great. After new listening I still feel that way.

Some bagers, Songs are really long but good

I can understand the popularity of Green Day’s album Dookie, the videos were on heavy rotation on MTV. What I can’t understand is the success of American Idiot, by 2004, MTV rarely played music videos. I enjoy the hits from this album, but I cannot endure a full album of Billie Joe Armstrong’s voice. It sounds like an imitation of a British punk singer with a cold.

American Idiot is not a perfect album about America. It’s a very good album about being young, angry, alienated and desperate to escape—with America serving as the environment that produces those feelings. And that’s why it has lasted. The politics date. The Bush-era references date. The pop-punk aesthetic dates. But the central feeling doesn’t: “Something is wrong with the world I’m inheriting, and I don’t know whether I should fight it, escape it, or become part of it.” That’s why American Idiot remains powerful.

I wonder if most Republicans are going to not like the message and give it 1 star and Democrats are going to give it 5. Rating it on just the music there are some really great songs on this album. I generally love concept albums but there are some not so great tracks. If l was rating based on enjoyment it probably would be 3 stars but the effort put in to making it a cohesive album earns a bit more respect from me.

Classic. Album from my childhood. Could be harsher.

Didn’t even need to listen to this to know it’s a 5. I listened to this album on repeat in high school when it came out. Such amazing memories. But I happily listened to it again today and it hit even deeper 20+ years later. Love Green Day so much!

This isn't bad. If I'd been in high school in 2004, I would've grooved on it. As it is, I appreciate the ambition, the multilayered production and the various rock 'n roll pastiches (especially on Homecoming). But if I'm being honest, if we're going to go for this level of theatricality, I prefer the batshit OTT-ness of My Chemical Romance.

This album surprised me. I’d always associated Green Day with corny 2000s punk rock, but there’s something genuinely nostalgic and melodic about this one. 7/10

Green Day were one of my first favourite bands. Dookie changed my life when I heard it as an 11 year old in '94. It was one of the handful of albums that set the trajectory for my tastes and identity for my entire teens and into my twenties. I was a very different 21 year old when I heard this for the first time. Much more jaded and into far heavier punk and hardcore. To that 21 year old this was at best a cutesy novelty and at worse a gross, overly commercial betrayal. It certainly signalled the end of Green Day being one of my favourite bands. Revisiting it for the first time my opinion has softened. It's a lot of fun! Billie Joe seems like a good guy, ambitious and earnest, more in the lineage of songwriters like Paul McCartney and Paul Simon than Lou Reed and Jello Biafra. He has a strong grasp of rock n roll structures and melody, and he swings for the fences here. The biggest touch points on this album are, of course, other rock operas, most notably Tommy, but there are little referneces and easter eggs littered throughout to classic rock. There are some moments that haven't held up, most notable the two 'balleds' the turgid Wake Me Up Before September Ends and Boullevard of Broken Dreams. The upbeat numbers are a lot of fun, and the multi song pieces are enjoyable in their composition without overstaying their welcome or being too clever. This album was definitely the moment Green Day left behind any remaining punk cred and fully embraced their theatre kid future. 21 year old me was furious, but I've changed. It's good to change. Green Day changed and acheived one of the most successful second acts in modern rock. Good job guys.

#424 Having not listened to this in a good 20 years, I kind of assumed I didn’t like it enough. I owned it at the time and even went to see them play on this tour but I probably drifted away from Green Day after this. I thought this would be a bit bloated and overlong, however, I enjoyed my listen today and it certainly didn’t outstay its welcome. I also don’t think I appreciated at the time that this was a bit of a concept album / rock opera, the latter would certainly put me off usually. Heard before? ✅ Would I revisit? ✅ Listen before you die? ✅ Fave track(s): Jesus of Surburbia Rating: 7/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

didnt age too hot. 2.5

Liked this way more than I expected. Good album.

As far as I am concerned this was the very peak of pop-punk 14 year old me would be outraged if I give this anything less than a 5. Luckily that's not who I am anymore. That said, I still know a not-insignificant chunk of the lyrics to Jesus of suburbia a full 22 years later, and probably at least 12 since I last listened to it. And the meme-status of boulevard of broken dreams & wake me up when September comes are worth at least some extra points. So maybe I return to a 5 regardless? Not because I strictly think so now, but because some tribute must be paid to the teenager I was.

One of my first experiences with the more counter culture side of music. Welcome to Paradise may not be on here but it is one of my favorite nostalgic songs

Eu achei que não conheci Green Day tão bem assim.. e esse disco me provou o contrário. É quase que uma trilha sonora da adolescência. Isso que na época em que esses caras explodiram eu tinha muito pouco acesso a música em geral, sem internet, sem celular, sem computador, apenas uma televisão e programas estilo MTV que passavam tudo aquilo que fazia mais sucesso. Mesmo assim bandas como Green Day, Simple Plan, Fall Out Boy sempre estiveram marcadas na mente com músicas e músicas que marcaram a época. Boulevard of Broken Dreams é uma das minhas músicas favoritas da infância, e é engraçado que cresci ouvindo mas demorou muito pra eu realmente entender o puta soco na cara que é a letra dessa música. Na verdade, muitas das músicas dessa época nós crescemos ouvindo sem saber que eram hinos repletos de críticas sociais. Holiday, Jesus of Suburbia, WMUWSE.. esse disco é praticamente uma coletânea de tão bom. É pesado, consistente, marcante. Uma obra prima que atravessou 2 décadas e continua sendo extremamente influente.

This wasn't it for me. Needs an editor, these songs don't need to be doubled up, and don't need to be more than 3 minutes. Get back to your punk roots.

didn't age as well as I'd hoped. very corporate punk, almost?

Green Day is a guilty pleasure for me. I generally don't like the "pop punk" genre. This album has a few longer, more ambitious songs, and some of the singles are pretty good. But it's not a good album start-to-finish. There's quite a few skipped songs on this album.

Bra punkskiva. Lättlyssnad. 7/10

Music is so formative. This album was everywhere when I was 16 and my mind instantly goes right back. The first half is a greatest hits album. I don’t really understand the stylistic choice to couple some of the songs up - makes listening unnecessarily cumbersome but otherwise I love it.

I have previously only heard the album "Dookie" by this band, and compared to that, this release is more mature both musically and lyrically, though that's not saying very much. The album's political and social commentary borders on superficial, but thankfully the music is good. The songs are diverse for punk rock, ranging from shortish, sub-three-minute tracks to minor epics approaching ten minutes in length and comprising multiple sections. The early tracks are particularly good, but the quality doesn't really drop towards the end, either.

A record stuffed with inescapable hit singles, I'll admit to having listener fatigue with many of the songs here due to how often I heard them as a youth. That does not mean they aren't great songs, as they blew up for a reason. Green Day could have just put out Dookie soundalikes and would still had a decent career but instead they choose to do something that is incredibly ambitious. The pop punk is still here, it's just more grandiose with songs like "Jesus Of Suburbia" hitting 9 minutes and featuring vastly different sounding sections. The album runs its course once the emotional ballad "Wake Me Up When September Ends" finishes up as I don't think the final two tracks added anything that wasn't already there and the generic "Whatshername" feels like a rather limp way to close such a bombastic record. I think that My Chemical Romance is did the whole pop punk rock opera thing better, but I will give Green Day credit for doing it first.

I knew this was a good album, and it is a little better than I thought. 4 stars or B+.

Can't stand it so boring

ist Green Day im perfekten Adrenalinrausch: politisch scharf, melodisch treffsicher, jede Hook sitzt wie ein Schlag ins Gesicht. Das Album hat denselben Generationen‑Punch wie Nirvana – nicht dieselbe Verzweiflung, aber dieselbe Wucht, denselben Abdruck im kollektiven Gedächtnis. Ein moderner Punk‑Rock‑Meilenstein und ich bin ein Jahr älter .. when September ends 😊.

The pop-punk opera we never knew we needed.

"American Idiot" and "I walk alone" are the ones I knew well. Hadn't really taken the time to listen to the entire album. It's good. Great, well I don't know. I think a four for being a great album, but nothing feels particularly innovative or original.

Easily one of the best rock operas written by one of my personal favorite bands. I’ve been listening to this album since its release and saw the stage show when it came through town years ago. Telling the story of Gen Xers/older millennials at the time of the illegal war with Afghanistan and Iraq perpetrated by the Bush administration. A true protest album to the state of affairs calling out the war and the folly of youth. Filled with themes of rebellion and regret, drug abuse, and tragedy. But, in the end, those that survive will move on with life, occasionally remembering those who were once a part of it. It’s such an incredible album that it was just recently featured at the Super Bowl over 20 years since its release. Impressive songs, impeccable pacing, and outstanding writing. I relish the excuse to listen to it again.

Одна из величайших рок-опер и наверное главный альбом Green Day. Не сказал бы что я огромный фанат группы, но отрицать величие этого альбома не могу. Он монументальный, с отличным развитием и динамикой песен. Особенно классно звучат монументальные композиции типа Jesus Of Suburbia. Вобще однозначно гениальное, но для меня не на 5/5

Listening session: august 19th, while getting ready in the morning Listened to before: heard two songs before Thoughts: fun album with a few recognizable songs, but I still like Dookie better Favourite tracks: American Idiot, Holiday / Boulevard of Broken Dreams & Wake Me up When September Ends

I'm glad it's been a while since I've listened to this. Gave me a clear mind to rate this. Their best album, hands down, even though Dookie was my thing in high school. Let this album pass me by in my early post-college years. Love it. 5/5

Absolutely a 5 star album! Love that this came up shortly after I saw the musical at the Straz.

I have never been a fan of Green Day. Not sure why. Boulevard of Broken Dreams is fun... other than that this is whatever. I just don't like Green Day that much.

A pop-punk staple (and a formative record that I actually grew up with.) Hard to ignore the cultural impact of this one.

It's just great

First time listening on proper gear to this record. Pleasantly surprised by the production and details.

it has its appeal to a certain audience. this type of American rock is not really my cup of tea, but there are some ok songs that i could listen to. I have given it the service to give it a second objective listen and my opinion remains pretty consistent. There are a few notable songs, Whatsername was the best song. I was going to say Jesus of Suburbia was the worst song, but then Wake me up when September Ends came on. 3.5 stars, but not enough to make it a 4

Jesus of Suburbia better than I remembered

I liked it way more than i thought i would, but it still didn't blow my mind. I simply am not a very big fan of pop punk.

The album that put them back on the map as a big league rock band for the millennium. I'm sure John Lydon had a lot to say about a punk rock opera and it makes you think how powerful the satire and protest is compared to the political climate of now. It certainly is very tuneful and they do sound quite familiar at times, even having the character of the recent Scooby Doo TV theme! Although bits of it are a but clunky, I'm not a fan of the penultimate song, but many of my GCSE students have been assessed playing the title track, wake me up before September ends and Boulevard of broken dreams over recent years. A good effort and a grammy winner no less.....

I like Green Day when their songs are short. Good hooks nonetheless.

There's not a lot new songwriting here compared to the kerplunk to nimrod era, but it's still solid work

A frustrating album: there's plenty of fun but everywhere - from production to songwriting - things are flubby and unfocused. one 9 minute song in a pop-punk album is a fun dare; two is hubris, and falls on its face.

musically feels a bit like mcdonalds, tastes alright but devoid of anything interesting billie joe armstrong's voice is nails on a chalkboard unbearable i appreciate the whole political punk rock opera thing (theatre kid (derogatory)) but it does ends up feeling very cheesy

(4/5) This is the best Green Day album, IMO. The music is a bit more polished and mature and their songwriting is sublime, compared to earlier stuff. In fact, that's really the draw -- the earnest messaging and writing. Our list group chat for this project effectively pondered (.. I'm paraphrasing and adding a bit..) "Who would have known it was Green Day of all bands that would adequately predict our stupidest dystopia?". Plenty to like. So, the cons of this album? The sorta Green Day/pop-punk sameness of the arrangements, it's on the long side, and it was frankly overplayed in its time. I didn't get into and appreciate it until well after the hype died down. When it was on top of the world, I wasn't a fan. I didn't actively hate it, I just didn't care. That's why it's **good** (maybe really good) but not **great**.

I had Green Day fatigue by the time this came out, and the avalanche of pop-punk impersonators (Blink 182, Sum 41, Good Charlotte, etc...) didn't help. There's good material here, surely, but it also tends to sound like all of their other good material. Add in overplay, Broadway productions, talking heads jabbering about its optical messaging, and generally too much exposure, and you have an album I was happy to dodge when I could. Listening again more than twenty years later, it's good but not great, despite the messaging being predominantly in my wheelhouse. It rounds up to a 3/5, and you can wake me up when this album ends.

172. American Idiot - Green Day (2004) 8.13.26 Variety: 3 Adequacy: 5 Listenability: 3 Uniqueness: 2 Emotionality: 2 = 3.0 "He steals the image in her kiss/ From her heart's apocalypse" I've never been the biggest Green Day fan ( I gave Dookie a 3.2/5) but their hits were damn solid, and I liked them enough. After Dookie, the next few seemed to have diminishing returns as far as hits go, though "Good Riddance" was and still is pretty huge. By the time American Idiot came out the strongest reaction from me would have been something along the lines of "oh they're still making albums? Huh." When I heard the big single, and read some of the press about the thing, I was a bit more intrigued, but a train wreck sort of way. The idea of a concept album with such very earnest and seemingly well-intentioned but possibly naive ideas did momentarily fascinate me enough to realize I did not want to listen to it. The whole idea had the stink of a massive overreach, and seemed like the sort of clumsy, if admirable take that your average politically responsible highs school sophomore might have. If the term had been in style at the time, I might have said it seemed to be very cringe. It got a lot of critical acclaim though, and though I think I probably align pretty much politically with these guys, it seemed like maybe some of this positive reaction was focused more on the ideas, ambition, and less so on the actual music. When it later hot adapted for the stage, it turned me off even more from wanting to hear any of it, and aside form the two big singles, I'm not sure I've ever heard any more of it. Well into middle age, I find myself a lot more forgiving of this sort of blazenly earnest material, but I also place a lot more value on the quality of the songs as entertainment. Will the melodic content of this balance out the messaging? I like brussels sprouts just fine, but if someone is lecturing me about how good they are, and browbeating me for not eating more, it just makes me want to go eat a steak. THE TRACKS "American Idiot" - The opening track is just as catchy and energetic as I remember, and it's a fine distillation of the band's previous work, cleaned up and performed with a bit of slickness that I appreciate, but that I can't blame some fans for despising. The whole "they sold out" thing doesn't really exist anymore, but I think was probably still hanging on enough at the time. I'm sure the band had been dealing with that nonsense since Dookie though. As an added bonus we got the Weird Al parody "Canadian Idiot" out of this, so... "Jesus of Suburbia" - This was fine. It seemed like a pretty coherent and cohesive song suite instead of a Frankensteined cobbling together of leftovers which these things usually feel like. I noticed an apparent lift of or nod to Bryan Adam's "Summer of '69" near the beginning which was unexpected. I really liked the 50s and 60s throwback elements like the opening drum beat, and the harmonies and xylophones later on. Weirdly it seemed that the bass was VERY low in the mix here, which sucks as that's one of my favorite things about the band. The piano ballad ending was pretty awful, and while I won't be focusing on the lyrics too much ( maybe a little more than normal given the nature of the project) they are pretty uniformly awful. "Holiday" - This is one I do vaguely recall. This feels much closer to the sort of thing I like about the band. Very catchy and punchy, though still missing the giant bass sound I like so much. I tried playing this back at 1.25 speed and it sounds even more like their old sound. "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" - I remember not caring for this when it came out. It seemed too nakedly self-absorbed and self-pitying, despite the undeniably catchiness. I think at the time I likened it to similarly bluntly oversharing stuff by Third Eye Blind. Listening to it now, the lyrical content does not bother that much, and is not that much clumsier than a lot of other very good "woe is me" tracks I could think of. "Are We the Waiting" - The pounding echoey drums on this put me in mind of something I might have heard on a Brice Springsteen album. The slow pace and the chanted chorus probably makes for a good excuse to get those phone lights out at the arena. It's ok, but has a bit too much "Rattle and Hum" U2 about it for my tastes. "St. Jimmy" - Another throwback number, this one's a blisteringly fast and full of that old punk energy. Unfortunately it's lacking in any memorable melodic hooks. Pints for the speed and vitality though. About two-thirds of the way through is gets a bit Who-esque with the harmonies and drumming which was nice. "Give Me Novacaine" - I appreciated the change up here with the acoustic sound at the beginning, and the contrast of the full on balls to the walls chorus work well enough. It's still pretty characterless aside from Armstrong stretching himself a bit in the vocal melody. "She's a Rebel" - Possibly the most generic song on the album so far, this one feels like the band got stuck on autopilot and just keep playing the bridge of another better song over and over again for the duration. I do hear what sounds to be some handclaps WAY down in the mix, barely audible. This could have used some more silly poppy touches like that. Imagining this as a 60s garage pop song and I could see it working. "Extraordinary Girl" - The opening of this one with it's world beat drum loop is unlike anything I've heard on any Green Day track. And wow... speaking of a 60s sound, this is maybe the most blatantly power pop the band has been. This is a sound I could really get behind, and it's a very successful take on the genre. Give me a whole album of stuff like this. Recognizably Green Day, but with a seemingly loving nod towards stuff like Matthew Sweet or maybe even the Exploding Hearts. And you can actually hear the handclaps on this one. Thumbs up. "Letterbomb" - Maybe I'm still coming off the high of the last song, but this worked incredibly well for me as well. Cleaner and poppier than their old stuff, but with the same level of energy and speed that I love. This is like if Weezer ( a band I mostly like) had some real balls. "Wake Me Up When September Ends" - oof. Sincere AND soft is not your strong suit, Mr. Armstrong. It only works on "Good Riddance" because of the nasty message buried within and the S-tier melodies. This kind of thing is best left to acts like the Goo Goo Dolls. It vastly improves when the guitars kick in, but loses none of the schmaltz. "Homecoming" - Where the earlier suite sounded more cohesive if a bit bloated and too long, this one does indeed sound like several partial song ideas that were cobbled together, and is far less successful as far as this sort of thing goes. It reminded me of a lot of the stuff I didn't like about the Who's Tommy. It makes the stage musical easier to understand I guess though. "Whatsername" - I did not expect Green Day to drop an 80s new wave rocker on us. This was pretty damned great. I was reminded a little of the Cars, a little of Weezer, and maybe a few other things. And yet it still sounds like Green Day, and not them trying to do a pale imitation. A great closer to a very uneven album. HIGHLIGHTS - "American Idiot" - "Holiday" - "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" - "Extraordinary Girl" - "Letterbomb" - "Whatsername" MIDLIGHTS - "Jesus of Suburbia" - "Are We the Waiting" - "St. Jimmy" - "Give Me Novacaine" - "She's a Rebel" LOWLIGHTS - "Wake Me Up When September Ends" - "Homecoming" FINAL THOUGHTS Being a dyed in the wool progressive/leftist myself, I find the political messaging, and social commentary here to be on point, and still largely relevant. It's the rather blunt, and unartful packaging of that message that turns me off though. The thing that made the band great in my opinion was the slightly edgy, fuck you attitude that infused their super catchy, tightly played, hooky punk pop gems that got in and out quickly. They had a lot to say even on Dookie I'd argue, but they did a much better job of couching their views in great punchy songs that were enjoyable listens. While there were highlights, it mostly felt like a slog. I don't want to feel like I'm doing homework when listening to music, and this comes as close to that as anything we've had on here yet. Armstrong is no Bob Dylan ( not many are, including latter day Bob Dylan) but at least it's admirable that him and the other guys were willing to make their opinion heard, and it likely inspired a lot of young people to get be more politically motivated. Just in the years since then, my inner pessimist seems more and more willing to admit that this sort of thing, if it eve =n does mobilize or inspire, has a very limited shelf life as far as influence goes. The giant boot that's been stamping on the face of humanity seems to have just gotten bigger, and it's pressure much worse. Which makes something like this feel naive and ultimately pointless in the face of the ruthlessness, and aggressiveness, of the never ending push by the chuds in power to maintain that power. Protest music in general always seems like a great idea, and the best of it is full of the kind of subtle craft that implants ideas and makes you recognize hard truths. When I want to listen to a powerful screed against power, corruption, greed, I'll always choose someone like Stevie Wonder over something like this, as the medicine goes down so much easier. And seeing as I'm far too set in my middle class ways to ever help enact any sort of real, lasting change, I'd much rather spend my remaining years enjoying what few pleasures we have left. Musically, this is a mixed bag. The band is matured for sure, and it's very professionally put together, but it feels sapped of the raw energy and fun that Dookie-era Green Day had on a good half of the album, with some glaring missteps, and some very welcome unexpected treats. But I get why it's on the list as a cultural artifact. On a whim I played "Holiday" at 1.25 speed and was pretty surprised at how much better it sounded faster paced. Went back a relistened to the first four tracks that way, and had the same effect on me. Even "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" works really well like this. This is an album for young people who need the ideological reinforcement Armstrong and company can offer, and it entirely missed me when I would have theoretically been its target audience some 22 years ago. What I appreciated most about it was the great playing, and the willingness to occasionally venture outside their formula. It'll never be in rotation for me as an album, but there are several great tracks on here which I'll definitely be revisiting, and their strength, along with the ambition on display are enough to lift it up into a like for me. PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - Those highlights make a pretty great EP's worth of tracks FURTHER LISTENING - Tommy by the Who - The Wall by Pink Floyd - Sandinista! by the Clash - Rattle and Hum by U2 - Guitar Romantic by The Exploding Hearts

“During the Vietnam War... every respectable artist in this country was against the war. It was like a laser beam. We were all aimed in the same direction. The power of this weapon turns out to be that of a custard pie dropped from a stepladder six feet high.” Here we have the face of the anit-Iraq War/ Bush Era music. This is essential listening for historical purposes no matter your opinion on Green Day. “Dookie” was the 5th album we had on this project and it got a 5 from me. I was a high schooler when that album dropped and it was custom made to appeal to me. Between “Dookie” and “American Idiot” was the graduation staple “Time of Your Life” and “Brain Stew (The Godzilla Remix)” off the soundtrack to 1998’s Godzilla. It was awesome in that they just took the regular Green Day song “Brain Stew” and added Godzilla roars to it. Best track on the album, believe me, I owned it. That stretch of years from teenager to middle 20s is one of the longer ones in your life, and Green Day had faded from my consciousness over that time. So believe me when I tell you I was not prepared for political commentary in the music of Green Day when they reemerged. I was prepared to enjoy the punk sound, and remember liking Green Day. But they surprised me. “American Idiot” is their “I didn’t know they had that in them.” album. I didn’t know they had it in them to address such weighty topics. (Boulevard of Broken Dreams) I didn’t know they had it in them to write 9 minutes songs. (Jesus of Suburbia; Homecoming) I didn’t know they had it in them to pull such pop psychedelic sounds. (Give Me Novacaine; Whatshername) I didn’t know the band best known for having mud fights with the Woodstock ‘94 crowd would become the face of popular resistance for my generation. (American Idiot; Holiday) And what does that say about us? I enjoy most of this album, but not as much as Dookie. Its a 4/5. Its a must listen but for me its too tied to its specific era of 2004 and all that was happening in the world at the time. Sadly, we’re still dealing with the consequences of that time period now. Wake me Up when September Ends.

You know what, I've never enjoyed pop punk, but this album is actually doing something, isn't it? Granted, it's got the typical pop punk curse of never having enough enough distinction to differentiate one song from another, but it makes some great choices, like pairing a few songs into these great medleys. Obviously there's no denying that the singles from this are solid, solid tracks, in spite of them being played to death in my childhood. Maybe my only issue with Green Day and this era of pop punk is that over exposure I had to endure before I really had a taste in music. Anyway, any album that's willing to do a fast "1-2-3-4!" In a tiny break of the drums is worthy of a three stars in my book. Take it or leave it, Billy Joe

Idk why I just don’t really care for Green Day, good music just don’t care much for the tone

I have a core memory of going to Best Buy with my dad after school one day to buy this CD, loved it then and still love it now.

my problem with the album is that although gatekeepers wont call it "Real Punk" like how they would not call linkin park "Real Metal", every part of this album is bombastic and grandoise and it perfectly functions as something that i would like. like, holiday and boulevard of broken dreams has went triple platinum in my household. 5/5!

So easy to listen to! Longer than I remember it being...I'm still a fan even if things start to blend together in the last few songs.

As someone who grew up in the 2000s, I cannot deny the crossover appeal American Idiot accumulated. Even before I formally got into rock music, I was enjoying singles like "Boulevard of Broken Dreams" and "Wake Me Up When September Ends" on mainstream radio. Then once I formally got into rock music and started going through Green Day's discography, I came to realize how well this record held up in their catalog, long after they first broke into the mainstream with Dookie. The neat part about a record like this garnering such mass appeal was that it was made without compromising the band's ambition here. Let's be clear, this was not the originally intended follow-up to Warning. That album was not well received at the time, even if in hindsight it's an underappreciated gem. But because of the reception at the time, the members of Green Day decided to make a more straightforward return to the fast-paced punk music they began with on what would have been known as Cigarettes & Valentines. But the master tapes for that follow-up were stolen, so after consulting with their longtime producer Rob Cavallo, the band ended up working on a new record from scratch. The new direction the band took would be to write a "punk rock opera", inspired by the rock operas that The Who and David Bowie had done before. Now, it's not the first time such a concept had been done for punk - Hüsker Dü's Zen Arcade springs to mind. But given the reach Green Day built and Billie Joe Armstrong's disdain of America when the Iraq War was underway, there was potential for such a format to ascend. Boy, did it ascend, right through the roof. I think what worked in American Idiot's favor is its accessibility. For as much as it is meant to be an "opera", the songs still maintain that approachable pop-punk songwriting that the band had fine-tuned up to this point. That much should be evident from the 3-minute fervent explosiveness of the opening title track. From there, the mood is set for the 9-minute "Jesus of Suburbia", introducing the antihero of the story through a series of movements that can go in some intriguing directions while being easily dissectible, like the jaunty piano-driven "City of the Damned", the almost ballad-like "Dearly Beloved", and the anthemic closer "Tales of Another Broken Home". Even when songs are paired together, like with "Are We the Waiting" into "St. Jimmy", or are multi-movement like "Jesus of Suburbia" and "Homecoming", the individual components can be enjoyed on their own and in unison. Also adding to the accessibility of this record is the story's intentional vagueness. Sure, there are characters in this narrative, with the aforementioned Jesus of Suburbia, St. Jimmy, and Whatsername. But those characters serve more as archetypes to resonate with. It's a risky move, but it allows the themes of this album to shine - the disenfranchisement, the isolation, the frustration towards what's going on in the modern world, and striving to survive in it; concepts that feel universal and managed to maintain relevance. The one exception to the loose narrative and theming would be the melancholic ballad "Wake Me Up When September Ends", chronicling Billie Joe's life after his father's death. It's a rather touching song, coming from a rather earnest place. If I had to nitpick, it would be in a manner that, weirdly enough, reminds me of how I felt about John Grant's "Jesus Hates F-----s". From the get-go on the title track, Billie Joe uses that f-word in his vulgar language toward the mass media's orchestration of public hysteria. But he did establish his bisexuality as far back as "Coming Clean" off of Dookie, and he directs that word unto himself, so he gets a pass in my book. That said, the use of that r-word in the "Dearly Beloved" segment of "Jesus of Suburbia" hasn't exactly aged well. But that's one bold word in a sea of them, so it's not enough to take me out of the experience. Finally, I'd be remiss if I didn't point out how largely subdued Mike Dirnt's basslines have become over the years. By this point, he more or less follows Billie Joe's guitar lines across the board, even when Dirnt's bass becomes noticeable, such as during the bridge on "Holiday". But considering the guitar parts are already amazing, I'll let it slide here. Overall, I adore American Idiot. This record has surprisingly held up over the years, as Green Day managed to reinvigorate themselves. The band would continue with the "punk rock opera" format for 21st Century Breakdown, before becoming creatively spent with the 2012 trilogy and subsequently returning to their straightforward punk roots with Revolution Radio and Saviors (the less said about Father of All..., the better). In any case, I'm glad that this album exists, as such a tenacious statement towards the modern era.

The titular track, "American Idiot" is just the song of an entire generation. Some songs are staples of their zeitgeist, this is definitely one of them for the early 00s. The iconic power chord set, the megaphone vocals... despite being political in nature, it is just super fun. Those telltale guitar chords associated with the band (and I think would be for many more years to come) are present in "Jesus of Surburbia", used in a cool way with the a triple slam of the chords prefacing the chorus. Despite all the variation with the piano sections and the more anthemic vocals around the 5min mark and beyond, this track was a little long in the tooth for me. Then comes the more depressively romantic "Boulevard of Broken Dreams". Between it's pianos, consistent bass, ringing guitar chords and Billie's vocals... it makes for something I've always found truly special. It's another track that definitely bears the mark of it's time, but it's still a great track. The way is breaks apart in the end with it's sinister guitar also delicious. "St. Jimmy" is arguably more punk than what came before, that machine gun guitar riff at the beginning and thrashy chords after really bring the energy. From memory, the rest of the album plays on these tone shifts from something fun and punky to melodically somber; from "Letterbomb" to "Wake Me Up when September Ends". Also really enjoyed: "Holiday", "Extraordinary Girl", "Shoplifter". Overall, it's hard to deny how much I loved it when I first heard it in 2004 when I was a teen; one of those gateway albums that delivered me from Eminem and Electronica into a world of modern guitar laden music. In many ways it still holds up for me, especially as it represents a sound I'm hearing less and less of with the release of new music from new artists.

Yep, definitely a classic and easy 5 star. If anything I don't listen to this album that much these days just because I've listened to it so much before and the songs were EVERYWHERE. But certainly not a fault of the album.

Hall of fame album that has a ton of bangers on it. 8.6/10

A lot of bangers. but for me, the lesser known songs hit hardest. the transition of Are we waiting/St. Jimmy was awesome. Great album.

Top tier pop punk… 3.9

Couldn’t believe how many hits there were on this album. It’s packed, and even the songs between the hits are pretty solid too. Helps that it was a big part of my late teens. 8/10 Most Excellent

7/10 There is no doubting BJ Armstrong can write a tune, and this features some great ones. Paired with the rather excellent punk sensibilities of the bass and drums, this is a top record. However, I care not for the medley nor a rock opera, and both of those have a strong presence here

green day = bad album day. 2

It’s a bit over-long, and a bit self-satisfied and self-important, but it’s a good record. The story in the concept doesn’t really hang together, or have any real direction, but that doesn’t really matter - it’s more of a mood piece imo, and as such it does display the anger and disaffection of the time. And, let’s be honest, that’s only got worse over time, hasn’t it?

So much of this is super heavy-handed, way moreso than I remembered from when I first heard it as a teen. I suppose that makes sense though, for a couple of reasons. First, the post-9/11 era caused everyone everywhere to become pretty stupid, and it really was that ridiculous. Second, I was a teen in the target audience, I highly doubt I would have picked up on any kind of subtlety, especially in music where I wasn't particularly looking for it. Still, it's good for what it is.

This was probably the biggest album of the time when it came out, it was everywhere. Everyone seemed to copy that whole black shirt red tie thing. Seemed to give Greenday a resurgence, and really elevated them beyond the usual pop punk status. I loved this at the time, but find it quite tedious now. I was never a huge Greenday fan anyway, but find this a bit more irritating than their other stuff. It’s still canny, decent pop punk classics on there; but it aint for me anymore.

This album landed at absolutely the right time for me to be obsessed with it, after listening to pop punk for a few years something just slightly different (also ese blink-182s self titled) was very interesting. Wore a few black shirts with red ties to college, good times. Haven't listened to it in a good few years but it was a lovely nostalgia trip. Jumped out to me how lacking in humour it is, which was a departure from Green Days previous stuff. Dead Kennedys (which GD clearly love) showed you can do political stuff and still be funny, so it's a shame they didn't take this a bit less seriously, think it would have benefitted. It's a bit too dramatic and musical, I definitely listen to dookie and Nimrod every so often so this definitely didn't stick with me as much. This was a great listen though and my younger self would be giving immediate 5s.

I don't think there's enough pop/punk/rock on the list. American Idiot was massive when I was younger, and I was the perfect age to be influenced by it. Hearing Holiday played from tinny old phones in the school canteen, and watching the video for Boulevard of Broken Dreams are two pretty strong memories from my youth. American Idiot is a great first track, would say it is more Blink-182 -esque. All the other tracks hit just right. Just a really, really good album. Big fan, I'd love to see them live. Fall Out Boy next, please!

This would've have been after my final Green day album, which was "Warning", so I've probably never heard this. I was surprised to see this on the list, but looking at the amount of plays some of these tracks have had on Spotify suggests this is their most successful album..... In my opinion, this is definitely past their peak and is catering for a much wider audience than their early (much better) stuff. That being said, I enjoyed it mostly. "American idiot" and "Holiday" are the best tracks. I can leave wake me up when September ends. 3.5, but probably closer to 3. Give me dookie over this any day

good album loved the song it can be my favorite

The music is still a little bubblegum-goes-punk, but I like it a little more than Dookie. There’s more edge. 3.5?

wake me up when september endssssssssss

I completely missed this when it came out (checks notes, lol) about a quarter century ago. Always kind of had my back up against these guys since they were so obviously being sold as The Next Big Thing in the early-mid 1990's, when I was most prone to getting my back about stuff like that. This was good - much better than I was expecting - though everything by them still sounds pretty much the same to me.

Top 3 of theirs .

I used to own some green day cds and have some sense of nostalgia for them, but this is just neutered pop punk. I listened to Nimrod after this one, and was reminded this band used to be better. Also their songs used to be like 3 minutes long

It was really difficult to decide on a rating for this album. It's definitely one of the more tolerable things that my mum plays in the car but I can only listen to so much Green Day. The first couple of songs are great to listen to after a long time though so its a 4.

I really like this album. It made me happy to see the cover when I woke up this morning. Green Day are pretty cool.

I was still a fan of Green Day when this album came out. I was with them on Dookie, I was with them after Warning, I left the ship when they wrapped themselves in the flag.

I was not allowed to listen to explicit music growing up, which meant owning this entire album was right out, so it probably took me a few years longer than it should've to discover it. The first time I heard any Green Day song, I was about 8, riding in a friend's car, and the song American Idiot came up on his mom's playlist. I was enthralled and found the whole album on YouTube as soon as I got home. Then I convinced my parents to take me to the American Idiot musical. For 10 years until I got Spotify I listened to this album over and over again on YouTube. Wake Me Up When September Ends later became the first song I asked to learn when I started taking guitar lessons, and the first song I asked to learn when I started taking singing lessons. This album is deeply ingrained in my life. I don't even need to re-listen to give it an instant 5 (but I will).

Don't love that they use the R-Slur in Jesus of Suburbia. Boulevard of Broken Dreams still gives me chills though. That opening feels so ominous and achy. One song left so I figured I'd wrap up my thoughts and as always, I enjoyed this album. It's truly a classic. I love anti-establishment in music. Its always a BOP.

Epitome of punk

Serious nostalgia! But the songs outstayed their welcome

Sad that we don’t learn the lessons from the Bush administration GD calls out and are repeating so many mistakes for the second time with Trump. Plus new insane corruption!

I have 100% heard this album. I had it on CD and listened to it non stop when I was a kid. Who doesn't love Green Day?! I am also obsessed with how they combined songs. I've only ever seen that one or two other times. It's basically a choice to say "you HAVE to listen to these songs back to back". What a cool way to pair some songs together. Makes me look more deeply into how they fit together or contrast against each other. The art is iconic, the songs are iconic. Somehow, as someone who hates long songs, I love the almost 10-minute insanity of Jesus of Suburbia. I also love how all the songs self-reference each other. It makes the album such a cohesive story. I am very grateful for the Green Day resurgence that has happened in the past few years. Also you know this album is iconic when it's what they titled the musical they wrote with their discography! That allll being said, there are real bangers on this album and then... there are others. Extraordinary Girl is so. boring. It's a 5/5 for me in terms of nostalgia but a 4/5 for me in terms of actual listenability. Then again, artistically I'd say it's a 5/5.

i thought i was prejudiced against green day until today. i really enjoyed it and would give 3.5/5.

a genuine treat. haven’t listened to this since i was a kid

I’m not a huge Green Day fan, but this is a solid album and I can see why it is so popular.

I’m not a Green Day fan, but I have to say that this is a well-produced album. Fun, high energy rock encapsulating the youth of the 90s era. I liked the Holiday to Boulevard of Broken Dreams transition. Also, the last song, Whatsername, is my favorite on the album

Amazing album, it's always been one of my favorites.

This album feels very strong from the start, but loses some magic halfway through.

Well put together

A good old classic album. Got nothing more to say.

A classic for me

I loved Dookie, but this album does nothing for me. Also, there are a few songs that have been so played out that I find them unlistenable.

A bit heavy for me but still an absolute vibe

I agree with everything Sebastian said and have nothing really to add. One minor note is I basically zero ear for production/mixing, but this one is kind of weird. On the one hand, that clean, crispy sound was a revelation to little me. It sounded like something from the future, and I just can’t shake that association. Nowadays, though, I’ll compare it to, like, Dookie, and it just sounds kind of bad.

7/10. rounded to 4

1. Jesus of Suburbia 2. Give me Novocaine / She’s a Rebel 3. Whatsername

Got bored after holiday

This album is loaded with hits. I get that the pop-punk (emphasis on punk) can get a little stale, but you cannot deny the staying power of the popular songs here. Plus, Jesus of Suburbia is an INCREDIBLE song. I'm gonna give this a solid 4 for those reasons.

Don't like it Too noisy

I'm incapable of rating this album without bias because, for me, it represents that period of time when the rose coloured glasses you wore as a child fall off and you’re forced to confront the idea that the world is kind of terrifying and unfair, actually (can you tell I'm a millennial whose defining historical memory of elementary school is 9/11?). I don't tend to listen to a lot of Green Day but this album is unique. It really captures this moment in time accurately and feels kind of haunting to listen to again in full so many years later.

I once enjoyed this type of punk rock but associate it to a particular boyfriend and as a result greenday now gives me the ick

Still amazed that this album one-shot like a third of my generation. I feel lucky that i had already gotten into better political music by the time this came out. Listenable for the most part, but really has not aged well. Was disappointed that so many of the reviews on here are either completely uncritical 5/5 best album ever from nostalgia addicts, or 1 or two stars from people still doing the "this isn't real punk, these guys are sell outs" discourse 20 years on (of course it's not, it's Green Day). Or people somehow missing that it's a (pretty weak) satire. I liked Dookie/Nimrod fine but this has never clicked for me and I don't think it ever will. I'd recommend Anti Flag's The Terror State for a better iteration of anthemic Bush era pop punk with an actual political stance instead of just vague suburban ennui. Or even My Chemical Romance if you want more of the theater kid/mall goth side of things. Although maybe the ennui and bad satire WAS the point.

I think this is the rock opera concept album for the millennial generation. So many bangers, the first 4 tracks are flawless.

A little more polished than my favourite Greenday Album (Dookie) however still adequately provocative and uncooperative to not feel like a sellout . 4 Segue songs on an album is surely unprecidented with Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams generationally iconic

Green Day was my favorite band when I was 13. By the time American Idiot was released, I had moved on and I had never given this album a legitimate chance. I guess it’s true what they say about your favorite bands at age 13 being your favorite bands for the rest of your life. I can’t escape my love of Green Day. I’m actually a little surprised by how much I enjoyed listening to American Idiot. I was not expecting to fall in love with this album. Vocals are extremely fun to sing along with. Guitar absolutely rips. Rhythm is tight as always. Lyrics are very interesting. It’s certainly ambitious. It shouldn’t work as well as it does, but the individual pieces are so strong it makes up for the overall structure being a bit wobbly. It’s kind of like if The Decline by NOFX was an hour long. If Billie Joe Armstrong set out to write about coming of age in 2004, he wrote this album about my peers. I know these people. We’re a fucking mess.

A modern classic if you ask me, the best songs are superb and the rest ain't bad either.

'Now everybody do the propaganda / & sing along to the age of paranoia.' It's almost inconceivable to think of just how depressing W Bush's America had been given the current state of affairs, but if you need a reminder, this 'punk opera' is a good place to start. 9 tracks, but really closer to 14 or 15, American Idiot is a time capsule at the personal, national, & political level - it's pretty remarkable just how embedded in my unconscious each & every song here is, even tho I don't think I ever sat down & listened to the whole record. In that way, it's a rousing, almost disturbing, success. But it's also preachy, sophomoric, repetitive, &, for lack of a better phrase, it could be better. Anyway, for me, American rock from '01 to '05 is The White Stripes.