Reviews (page 2 of 12)
I don’t know what to say about this album. It’s as bland as matzah. Production sucks. I feel like there’s only an idea of Taylor being sold on this record. There’s nothing giving me indication of who she actually is. Just sounds like a lot of the pop of the era with specific artists I can point to that she’s modeling. If not having been released in an era of Millennial Optimism, I have a feeling Swift would’ve gone the way of Jojo Siwa (who we Stan). I’ll admit I was predisposed to hate this but really it just made me feel nothing throughout 99% of it. Formulaic and no surprises. Bummer. Music should do better.
This has some of the strongest pop songs written, but it does lag at the end and has a weak finish.
As far as pop albums go, this one ticks on the boxes for me
Perfectly good for what it is. Not really my thing, but absolutely perfectly crafted. Her music is more appealing to me just listening to it, rather than watching amidst all the teenage fandom. When it comes down to it, the songs are excellent.
Like a lot of pop albums, heavily front loaded with singles and then crammed with filler at the back end. The singles (Blank Space and Shake It Off in particular) are really good pieces of modern pop. The rest of it, pretty forgettable. Compared to Melodrama by Lorde it is a very lightweight but I do like the singles so I won’t be too harsh.
A saccharine album inspired seemingly by anemoia, but ignores the shit that also came out of the 80’s, filtering it through rose tinted glasses instead. Yes, it’s filled with catchy hooks, but I suspect it is the influence of Max Maritin’s hand rather than exclusively Swift’s. It’s also the kind of thing that even if you have sweet tooth, by the 6 or 7th piece of cake it’s all just a bit much. In terms of influencing the cultural zeitgeist, it’s undeniable, but just wish the was more of an edge to this like some of her 80’s contemporaries. If this was closer to Kate Bush I’d probably be raving about it instead, it’s just too afraid to embrace the weirdness and instead plays it entirely straight.
This album ranges from some great emotive pop songs to some utter flops (in my opinion). I wouldn't say it has turned me into a Swiftie but it was interesting to listen to a Taylor Swift album in its entirety. A mixed bag. Favourites: Blank Space Wildest Dreams
Ностальгия по хорошим временам. Хитяра за хитярой, бэнгер за бэнгером. Out of the Woods просто ахуй. Умела же делать мясо… это вам не Кливленд.
Не мой любимый альбом тейтей, но всё же именно тоь, с которого я начинал её слушать. Style всё ещё топ 3 в её творчестве, и несмотря на нелюбовь к шейк ит офф и бед блад, не могу поставить ниже
возможно у меня просто были заниженные ожидания, но вообще неплохо - 3.5 этот альбом точно не blank space
I like these songs, but so many of them are so overplayed I am over them. I enjoyed more the ones I hadn't heard before.
If this album was a flavor of ice cream it would be a very good vanilla.
Production just sounds cheap. The Jack Antonoff tracks are alright. Don't get me wrong some good songs (nostalgia helps). Love wildest dreams. Whole album is so fast.
For being insanely poppy, it manages to be pretty tolerable when I don't really go for that at all. Pretty fun, can't remember but I think I liked the other one more
I never know how to properly rate TSwift albums because some tracks grate on me as much as others are undeniably catchy. I will say for sure though, the girl knows how to write a good bridge.
Her hits are genuinely very good pop music but album construction is poor. Just feels like the songs that weren't popular are included just to fill the album and that there's no point to them. Good album overall though
Muy bueno
Generally enjoyable and credit to a generational artist. Splitting my vote between wife's rating and mine. I think I dig more of her folky joints more, but this is still considerably appealing.
I’ve done this before so I’m opting not to relisten to rate. It’s fine, and the singles are great. Often times I stay up too late too Taylor
Obvious skips and obvious bangers - still a great album
gotta separate the art from the artist
I'm really not a fan of breaking up with a boyfriend songs
Wow, was really not excited for this one. I haven't heard it in full for probably a decade, and I remember thinking it was fine back then. But over the decade since, the Taylor Swift overexposure has done a number on my opinions on her catalogue, even the parts that I thought were, well "fine". I used to like Blank Space! I used to like Shake it Off, Style, Wildest Dreams, Clean! Like not just in a "yeah, they're not bad" way! The production has dated nastily, the throwback synthpop parts have been done WAY better by other artists since. And her lyrics have always been bad. There's far worse Pop out there, especially by Taylor. But it doesn't feel like the standout it once did.
It’s pop music. It’s Taylor Swift. My daughter liked her when she was younger so I was familiar with many of these songs. It’s okay. I just don’t routinely care for it.
Not my genre and she’s a bit annoying but ignore the marketing around her and being objective, this is top-notch pop.
Whiplash listening to this and Melodrama back to back. The hits are undeniable and sometimes powerful but the nots are very not. You either die Lorde or live long enough to see yourself become TS
eh, kinda good and catchy, many tiktok-popular songs that i didnt even know they were taylor swift's.
Послушать этот альбом - как съесть чизбургер в макдаке. Да, ты что-то проглотил, наполнил желудок, и в целом, это даже было довольно вкусно. Одним словом, закинулся и пошел. Вощемта, таким образом, я для себя оцениваю и этот альбом, да и в творчество Свифт в целом. Это конкурентоспособная, качественная поп-музыка, музыкальный фастфуд созданный продюсерами и менеджерами на миллионы евробаксов, который приемлемо включить в машине, кафе, клубе, дома, на работе, музыка которая растворяется в атмосфере, поскольку не требует от слушателя ничего, ей достаточно просто звучать и заполянть пространство, словно мебелировочной музыке. При этом, при желании, вы можете вовлечься в этот "уютненький фандомчик" поразбирать там текстики про бывших, повосхищаться ещё каким-нибудь фансервисом про шарфик, печенки и прочее. Но продакшен который породили исполнители навроде Свифт и похожие ей - мне столь опостылел, столь въелся несмываемым пятном в голову, что я просто не могу это слушать и получать какое-то искреннее удовольствие которое ловят от него свифтис. Я не буду ставить этому альбому "1" или "2" поскольку, объективно, он этого не заслуживает, но для меня это не выше 3, однозначно.
50000000 Taylor Swift fans CAN be wrong.
This takes me back to a very specific moment in time - summers spent cleaning pools while I listened to Style on repeat - and I love any album that conjures a specific era. This unfortunately isn’t a five. (Style is a ten star song, quite possibly a perfect pop song, and there are some other strong tracks here too.) It’s too uneven to be a real five. It’s also not the greatest pop album of all time*. There are a too few many twos and threes for this to be consistent enough for the five. Every song about how cool New York is is uniformly terrible, Shake It Off was a sign of worse things to come, and I’ll never like How You Get The Girl. Style, though. God that’s such a good song. Anyway, a four. Absolutely the album from Taylor that belongs on this list. (This and folklore. not evermore!! folklore. ) * the greatest pop album of all time, of course, is queen Carly Rae Jepsen’s masterpiece E•MO•TION
Good song writing 80s synth production influential no doubt but not my thing.
Does Taylor Swift deserve an entry on the list? Of course. She is, for better or worse, the most successful pop singer of her generation. But is this a good album? I don’t think so. Competently produced, for sure, with catchy hooks, but the thing I’ve never liked about Taylor Swift is all over this album: her shameless emulation of every other successful song and artist, not out of appreciation, but for pure commercial gain. She is a vulture of pop, and a very successful one at that. There’s nothing interesting in these lyrics, there’s nothing original in these songs. “Welcome To New York” sounds like she walked around Times Square and heard “Empire State of Mind” everywhere, and decided that she wanted to be that. I will never understand the sycophancy around her. And, despite some effective moments (“Shake It Off” minus “this sick beat”; and “Clean,” which is actually good), I don’t like this album.
I'm not a Taylor Swift hater. I think she is very very very okay to slightly good. Anyone who thinks she is the best artist of our lifetime is a liar, anyone who thinks she is the worst is also a liar. Taylor Swift makes music for weird white girls. That being said, I think that there is SO much more potential for this to be good. The lyrics are so corny, and 50% of the songs are too goofy. This can be a great album, but it just never gets there Best Song: Out of the Woods Rating: 6/10 Stars: 3
Very poppy obviously. Really catchy though and the production is nice.
went in skeptical but its interesting to know she did in fact have the sauce at some point. still dont really see the genius in her that a lot of fans seem to though. the synths are veryyy of its time but i do think her lyrics were pretty decent on this one,,,, at least compared to now lmaooo
Oh god my ears are bleeding and I haven't even gotten 2 seconds in. How did this bitch get a record deal, she can't sing
I’m not the biggest fan of Swift, but even I can’t deny that this record has some bangers on it. 3/5
People seem to like her…..
I was pleasantly surprised by Taylor Swift. For years I had been able to avoid listening to her music, but I listened to this twice and was impressed. Will I go out and buy tickets to her shows? No, but I understand why others might.
Simple music for simple folks. If all you want is catchy, repetitive tunes, then this one is for you. If you want to scratch even the slightest bit beneath the surface, then this ain't it.
честно, одна из очень немногих тех музык, которые я просто не могу слушать. послушал 3 песни, понял что дальше просто не могу
I'll start off by noting that my wife is a major Swift fan. I'd never listened to the whole 1989 but am familiar with most of the songs. Some of the songs are hits when played at a wedding or with a crowd, but don't go as well as part of an album. I don't get the hype for this album, there's plenty of other TS songs that I think are better.
This album (or the big singles at least) were inescapable when it came out 12 years ago. While I’m definitely far outside the target demographic, I can appreciate this album for what it is. Out of the Woods and Bad Blood were easily the most grating, didn’t care for them. Style is catchy as hell, unironically something I’ve found myself listening to a time or two over the years. Production is cool, watered down synth pop engineered to appeal to the lowest common denominator. Not groundbreaking, but I don’t think it really needs to be tbh. Taylor Swift’s songwriting is very hit or miss for me. There are some songs with catchy hooks or interesting verses, but all too often you get absolute roses are red, violets are blue shlock that just kills any chance of me ever revisiting this album in full.
What an album! Honestly life may have peaked here. All absolutely bangers and I cannot believe people don’t like this. This almost makes up for the lack of Dua Lipa on this list (WHERE IS FUTURE NOSTALGIA)
It's a really stacked first half of an album, regardless of what you think of Taylor's clearly capitalist mallcore pop style. It's not relatable at all to me but it really doesn't matter with the vibe songs like Style bring.
I loved this album when it first came out and assumed this would be an easy 5....some of these songs are so bad though. Bad Blood? Shake it Off? Corny as fuck. I almost regret listening and ruining my opinion of this album.
I’m not too cool to give this a 5
Wasn’t as bad as I thought it would be, some pretty iconic songs in here actually. I’m realizing now that Swift’s lyrics are just not very good though
music is love
Taylor Swift is a terrible, terrible person
absolutely perfect
Oh shit, I didn't even consider I'd have to stoop this low. So, I gave it a fair crack. I'm not the target audience for this but hats off. The hits hit, the filler fills. If she wrote the pop bangers on the album solo, even more impressive as it sounds like pop written by focus groups with decades of data to lean on. Not as bad as I feared, but not for me as I'm neither a lonely adult or hormonal teen.
Some solid pop bangers on this one.
People hate Taylor Swift because she's a successful woman musician. Not me, I just think she's an average billionaire nepo baby. Why getting into mysoginy when you can just stick to class conscience? Regarding the music, she doesn't seem untalented or bad, but it's so plain. It's basically an output to the prompt "write me music for a large-scale engineered bland pop world success from the USA". I guess someone can think of this as an achievement, but for me it's just uninteresting. Some tracks are kinda nice, but overall it's indistinguishable from all the other stuff that was on the radio back in that days. And it's like the third woman I get on this website, which is otherwise dominated by average (but for some reason critically panned) male musicians, I just hope that there will be some picks from the very large pool of good, worth-listening-to, recent female ones.
bring me back to middle school. still know all lyrics to blank space. also making me realize i like her newer songs better but i can see how you ger me loved this album
Bangers after bangers, filled with energy and spunk. A tad over pop-y (but I guess that's the point). And somehow, my favorite song is Shake It Off. If you ignore how entirely overplayed it was a decade ago, then it could be yours too! If deluxe version is allowed then New Romantics is up there aswell.
Great album! Welcome to New York / Blank Space / Style is such a strong start. Shake it off is one of he best songs ever. Overall just a really strong pop album.
Is the sick beat in the room with us
My generation's Thriller as in the way it was inescapable for about a good two years in the pop culture landscape. Not to say it's as good as Thriller, but it was still insane in 2014 - 2016. Taylor Swift was already a huge deal with media coverage and chart-topping hits, but this album just took that and multiplied it by a thousand percent. If I remember correctly, I can clearly recall the album's roll-out and hype. Shake It Off dropped in August 2014 and made a splash on the Pandora Today's Hits station immediately. My first thought was that it was a song about shaking crazily like during a seizure. I was 8 years old, that's how silly I was. When the album came out in late October 2014, I went to a Target store with my mom, aunt and grandmother for reasons I don't recall. As was usual, I told my mom that I'd go to the media section at the back with all the books, DVDs and electronics. So off I went and - I didn't find anything I remembered except the TV that kept repeating an advertisement for the brand new Taylor Swift album. 1989 was a part of that last stretch that would drop earlier in the week rather than Friday. This must've been on Tuesday, October 28th then because the NBA season started that night and I was ecstatic. Anyway, I left the media section to go look for my mom and that's when I got lost. For the next 20 minutes, I circled around Target 5 times and every-time I passed the media section, Taylor fucking Swift was playing. I grew weary and anxious and eventually ran to a worker crying. My mom did eventually meet me at the front of the store and I went home safe, but nowadays, I treat that horrifying moment as a relic of a massive cultural shift in pop music. Months would pass into 2015 and every few months, it felt like there was a new Taylor Swift song on the radio. That song would get huge, be played on repeat, and before you knew it, a new one would come out and the cycle began again. Most of the singles on this album hold a special place in my heart with the exception of Bad Blood though the music video made a difference. 1989 was so big that all her other albums directly afterwards felt weaker (until Folklore). There was a standard that album set that was so high, it felt like she'd never reach it again (which as of 2026, she...has surpassed...but for other reasons). Which brings me here today: I've never heard the original album in full outside of the big singles and Welcome To New York during the Secret Life of Pets. I can actually listen to it ethically now because Taylor does own the masters again. Rambling aside, 1989's deep cuts range from uninspiring to incredibly moving. Sometimes it does feel like a generic ass pop song and just that. Other times it feels like a generic ass pop song that has some nice quirks to it. The arrangement may take an uncommon approach, the sound selection, the little things. Clean is the best of the non-singles on this album, with a second place award going to I Wish You Would. Those two are outstanding in what they provide rhythm and melody wise. The weaker spots go to How You Get The Girl and I Know Places, but there's always going to be those meh songs on an album unless it's Purple Rain or something. Singles-wise, Style has aged the best in 2026. Apparently people also agreed with me in 2015 which is cool because it's probably her best song. Out Of The Woods also had me impressed because when it came out, it didn't do as big as the other singles. So then my young pop-music brain assumed it wasn't as good - but he was wrong and this is one of Jack Antonoff's better jobs as a producer and song-writer. Also say what you want about Shake It Off, but it's a lot of fun! It's positive, it's sassy, it feels true to the message it's going for. Fuck the haters, she just gonna shake, shake, shake. Bad Blood on this album is the worst song on here. The remix is miles better, but that's probably because Kendrick's on it. That music video might've been one of last hits of an era where we still cared about the VMAs. 1989 might not be a perfect pop album, but for its influence alone, it deserves recognition. I believe the only other records to rival its hype and success are Beyoncé's Lemonade and Adele's 25. But those didn't feel like they followed me around. 1989 is a statement that highlights a world before everything seemed to combust. A world where we were sane. And if anything else - great job, Kanye, you made that bitch famous. OH and this totally stole the Grammy from Kendrick Lamar (7/10, 4/5 on this scale)
This may come as a surprise but I'm not that familiar with T-dawg's discography. Only really knew Shake it Off which is weird when I see some of these songs have 2 billion plays. Given that I was a 37 year old man when this came out I guess that makes sense. But all in all very good.
The hits are bangers and are super fun to listen to. I probably never would have listened to this album all the way through if I wasn't raising a daughter in the 2010s. But the non-hits just don't land for me, and by the time "Clean" rolls around I'm ready for this to be over. Anyway, it doesn't make a difference what a cranky old dad has to say about this album.
This album was made by a twentysomething woman obsessed with relationships for twentysomething women obsessed with relationships. I was deep into my 30s when it came out, married, and with a pre-schooler. Not the target demo, but I I appreciated the undeniable catchiness of the hits. They were inescapable at the time (especially in NYC), marking Swift's transformation from pop-country star to pop superstar. A dozen years later, she's so overexposed that I kinda can't with this anymore. That said, the opening four songs are all bangers, and everything here is catchy. Thematically it gets repetitive, but again, I'm not the target demo.
ptn je peux pas faire l'aigri c'était vraiment super cool...
C'était vraiment très cool, mérité, mais je trouve que les taylors version méritent encore plus, battante :muscles:
Well, that's it. If I don't love 80s synth pop Taylor Swift I'll never love Taylor Swift. There's some great pop on here, including Shake It Off, Style and Bad Blood. But you know what I was left with? I don't think I could pick her voice out a lineup with 5 other generic American female pop stars. It's too... clean. And the music has that quality too. I get it, I really do. And this is a bizarrely negative review despite me giving 4 stars. But for all the raving, this is probably the best Taylor Swift album I've heard and I'm not that impressed.
As with most of her albums, not everything is fully my cup of tea, but almost everything has at least one part where i go “ah this is just really good isn’t it?”
This is a brilliant pop gem. I think it might be my favourite pure pop album of all time. So many of the songs just build so well and music suits the lyrics perfectly. Yeah, it's just bloody great. Her vocals are great, the songwriting is great. Love it.
So sweet it feels like I’ve eaten 12 doughnuts in a row..
# An In-Depth Review of Taylor Swift's *1989* Released in October 2014, *1989* marked a definitive turning point in Taylor Swift's career—a full embrace of pop music that would transform her from a country star into a global phenomenon. The album is a masterclass in reinvention, yet it is not without its trade-offs. ## Lyrics and Themes: Self-Awareness and Liberation Lyrically, *1989* represents a significant shift from Swift's earlier work. Where albums like *Speak Now* and *Fearless* took romantic dramas to "Shakespearean heights" with grand, sweeping narratives, *1989* celebrates a new, more liberated phase of life . The focus moves to the excitement of "flings, weekend getaways, and the kind of cool confidence a younger Taylor Swift was too passionately involved to grasp" . The album's thematic backbone is one of self-awareness and playful defiance. **"Welcome to New York"** serves as a symbolic declaration of independence, announcing her departure from the constrictions of country music and Nashville . **"Shake It Off"** is a lighthearted dismissal of her critics and public image, while **"Blank Space"** offers a brilliant, self-aware parody of the media's portrayal of her as a "serial dater," managing to "make light of her gravest and most well-protected subject: Taylor Swift" . This sense of play and rebirth is a central theme . However, some critics argue that this shift came at a cost. The album is often described as having the "least romantic inclination" of her catalog, largely forgoing the deeply personal and intricate storytelling of songs like "All Too Well" in favor of more concise pop narratives . The album also includes a streak of positivity and empowerment, which some view as a form of "fancy pseudo-generosity," a mask for the pressures of fame, rather than pure vulnerability . ## Music and Production: A Sonic Rebirth The production on *1989* is its most defining feature. Swift collaborated with a powerhouse team including Max Martin, Shellback, Ryan Tedder, and Jack Antonoff to create a sound steeped in 1980s synth-pop . Despite not being born until the decade was ending, Swift uses the nostalgic sound not to look back, but "to move ahead" . The result is an album of "big beats and shiny surfaces" that is both a commercial and artistic success . The melodies are consistently strong and catchy, with songs like "New Romantics," "Blank Space," and "Style" being praised as some of the best pop melodies of the 2010s . The album also features boundary-pushing collaborations. The closing track, **"Clean,"** produced with Imogen Heap, is a highlight; its "cold and airy harmonies" and poetic lyrics are considered by many to be the album's lyrical peak, successfully blending indie sensibilities with Swift's signature melodic hooks . However, the album's sonic shift was a point of contention for some long-time fans. Critics felt that the heavy use of synthesizers and pop production often "cluttered" the arrangements and made the melodies feel simplistic compared to her earlier, more acoustic work . The song **"Out of the Woods,"** for example, was criticized for being overly repetitive and "annoying" . For some, the focus on creating radio hits made the album feel more like a "product made to make money" than a sincere artistic expression . ## Influence and Legacy *1989* was a monumental success, not just commercially but critically. It appeared on numerous "Best of 2014" lists, including *Rolling Stone* (No. 10) and *Time* magazine (No. 4) . It cemented Swift's status as a "world-class pop icon" and is arguably "the definition of the perfect album era" . Its influence is undeniable. The album's success created "the Taylor Effect," a modern phenomenon where a celebrity's every move is tracked and imitated by a massive, dedicated community . It was a pivotal moment of "artistic rebirth" that paved the way for her subsequent work, demonstrating that a bold pivot in artistic direction can create "ripple effects on culture" . The album's era also saw Swift cultivating a famous "squad" of models and celebrities, a highly visible aspect of her image that added to the album's cultural footprint . ## Pros and Cons of *1989* **Pros:** - **A Masterful Reinvention:** Swift successfully transitioned to pop, creating an album that feels both fresh and artistically sound . - **Exceptional Production:** The synth-pop production is sleek, vibrant, and highly polished, with catchy, well-crafted melodies throughout . - **Clever, Self-Aware Songwriting:** The album showcases a playful and confident side of Swift, most notably in the self-deprecating humor of "Blank Space" . - **Cultural Impact:** *1989* was a defining album of the 2010s, launching Swift to a new level of global superstardom and influencing the pop landscape . **Cons:** - **Loss of Vulnerability:** The album often prioritizes pop hooks over the deep, intricate storytelling that was a hallmark of her earlier work, making it feel "less adorned and least romantically inclined" . - **Potential for Repetitiveness:** Some songs rely on repetitive hooks and phrases, which can feel lazy compared to her more complex lyrical past . - **A Polarizing Shift:** The full departure from country music alienated some long-time fans who preferred her more acoustic, emotionally raw sound . - **Calculated Image:** The thematic focus on empowerment and confidence, while effective, can sometimes feel like a carefully constructed "mask" for a more complex reality, bordering on a "fancy pseudo-generosity" . In conclusion, *1989* is a landmark pop album that showcases Taylor Swift at her most ambitious and commercially savvy. While it may sacrifice some of the raw vulnerability of her earlier work for the sake of a more polished, radio-friendly sound, its influence, production, and self-aware songwriting solidify its status as one of the most important pop albums of its era.
I can’t lie this was better than expected
No album has thrown a better pity party than this one, though it has taken me a decade of occasional listening to recognise it as such, a minor but very real subcategory of human comedy. I returned to this expecting the hits and some filler, but found little of the latter; it all has stick. I still don’t understand what her trick is. She seems to downplay the choruses a notch, but make all the others parts a lot catchier.
My kids played this to death, with no objections from me. At least as good as the treasured Madonna albums from my youth. WIldest Dreams in particular is a banger.
need to give yourself permission to like it, then it's quite catchy and enjoyable. it's definitely well done. it's also extremely bland at the same time. marty robbins is probably what this sounds like to her core fans.
my name is grimble grumble
I’ve tried giving this a go a few times, the first right when it was released and I was only a mild Taylor skeptic. Now I’m a full-blown hater, but I like to think I can put my bullshit aside and extend some grace or at least patience to appreciating something that millions of others love. I’m still a fan of a range of pop music, a lot from the 80s, some (although not many) of the Swedes’ other productions but there’s a basic quality to Swift’s compositions and melodies that even they can’t improve. For millions, that is probably the secret sauce that makes them fans. For me, it’s a glaring, here we go again formula that is pretty much everything I hate about a certain kind of music.
Not my thing
Oh to be a white girl at the Eras tour The final boss of the 2010s charts, polished to a total sheen, decade-enduring anthems. Obviously not the pinnacle of pop, and Taylor Swift is very uninteresting as an artist, but it was all steadily uphill for her (popularity wise anyway) from here after this, and she hardly shows any sign of slowing. Can’t rate this any lower given the catchiness and longevity of these songs. I've not heard any of her albums in full before this aside from maybe Folklore, but I feel like most of them after 1989 had like 2 big hits max? This has like at least 4, and I'm sure there's some Swiftie growers I'm disregarding
Some of the best written pop songs, with some serious slop also I think that wildest dreams may actually be one of her best (if not best) songs The other editions outside of the base album are way way too bloated though 3.5
Decent enough, but it's pop. So that's not a huge achievement.
Plenty of highly polished 4-chord songs. As entertaining as necessary for your daily commute and backyard party but not my favourite. The moment I hear evidence Swift was not an exception to the rule that all billionares end up that way through openly screwing people over, this rating gets revised.
Taylor Swift is, quite possibly, the worst thing to happen to modern music, and the fact that so many (SO MANY) people love her so blindly, and champion her brainless music, baffles me. What the fuck is so interesting about this album? Half of the music sounds like it was recorded with a drum machine and a Casio keyboard, and the lyrics are so banal I can only assume Taylor Swift thinks we all got lobotomized. What Taylor Swift did when she became so monstrously popular is reset the bar -- only, she set it down. On the floor. What we're left with is a whole world of music and artists, desperately aspiring to clone her sound and success, pissing on the zeitgeist with minimally thought-out, appearance-focused, radio-hit-desperate recycled garbage-crap. And by the way, how much money does Taylor Swift make? How much does she have? Shouldn't we be hearing about her generosity and philanthropy way fucking more? Shouldn't she be one of the biggest donors in the history of planet fucking Earth? But no. Her claim to fame is riding in a private jet more than anyone, ever. Fucking great. Not to mention, when will she EVER use her vast, sprawling, unthinkable influence to make a political statement? Even just once? Maybe just to try gently steering us in a better direction? But who gives a fuck, right? Because that would mean fewer fans, and fewer fans are fewer sales. So let it all burn. Now listen. I have been informed that hating Taylor Swift can only be perceived as hating all women. That it is not an opinion I should have, nonetheless be insistent on. To that I say: I do not, cannot, will not, ever give a fuck. Give me Dolly Parton. Give me PJ Harvey. Give me Amy Winehouse, or Lauryn Hill, or fucking Adele. I was glad to see this album for one reason only: that I am officially done with seeing her show up on this list for the rest of my time.
-this is really well made, candy-coated, Max Martin produced pop music that somehow pulls off the trick of convincing the listener that Taylor is maturing, and that this is a post-hipster early-Instagram work of poptimist art. But that is ridiculous. This album is basically children’s music; it is so sugary and easy to consume. Every song has a title like “Bad Blood” and then it ends up being about having bad blood with someone and there’s a big screamy sing-along chorus you could imagine a child repeating all day after they saw it placed in a movie on the Disney Channel. -my favorite track is probably the first, “Welcome to New York,” which has a kind of millennial rumspringa single ladies doin it for themselves in the big city Girls (HBO) vibe to it. I tend to enjoy this kind of story, so it sits well with me. It's exactly the kind of thing people are preoccupied with when they’re 17-27. But it also has a bit of an “urban playground” feel to the lyrics, where the protagonist is so thrilled to see (shock!) gay people, because the big city is a place of whimsy and has no history and is not a space where people live. -I also like Wildest Dreams; the way it builds contrast and transitions between verse and chorus is just insanely satisfying. This is Britney/NSYNC levels of maximalist pop perfection. -ok, Style is probably a cutesy wink to Harry Styles, but it's also a pretty weird, unsettling, and unsuccessful bit of gender norm revanchism. -I’m not even sure if I like this or not anymore; at one point of my life I would have described this as my “favorite Taylor Swift album.” But now TS has ascended to a level of fame, wealth, and power so overwhelming it feels impossible to have a real human connection with this music.
Fun to listen to Taylor chart her path to being a superstar. The difference between her work then and now is remarkable.
Taylor Swift is certainly a phenomenon. She makes solid pop music. The attention and popularity she receives are self-perpetuating. Her music is so watered-down and streamlined that it slips effortlessly through your ears into your brain and leaves again without any resistance. The aftertaste is like a bad perfume: sweet, cloying, and slightly repulsive. I don’t like Taylor Swift. I don’t like her music. As I played through the album, I was startled to realize how many of her songs I know. However, I also noticed that I don’t miss any of them. I’m not going to make a conscious effort to listen to her music anymore. Still, I’d be giving her too much attention if I didn’t acknowledge the quality of her music. 3/5
Much better then expected, some great songs on here. Bad Blood, on the other hand, is terrible.
Well produced pop, but I don’t get it, I just think it’s really dull
boring. so very boring. and over produced. is she using a drum machine?
There really are tons of songs on this album that you will have heard before if you've been alive the past ten years and listened to the radio at least once. Most of these songs are quite catchy, and some even feel like modern classics already ('Shake It Off', 'Blank Space'). She really has a good sense for coming up with catchy lyrics. Still, listening to this I have a real hard time associating this with anything else than the absolutely most played thing on the radio, seeing as she's probably the biggest music phenomena of this past decade. Her songs almost feels like the definition of "currently most played on the radio", so it's all so extremely worn out by now. I saw a pretty intimate acoustic concert she did with some of these songs online, and it really stunned me how good her singing paired with the guitar was. She really is extremely talented and a good performer, no doubt. Which is attested by her many many albums she's released since she started. But when I listen to the album, I kind of just want to turn it off because I've heard it so much already. I just can't rate this album in an unbiased way. I wonder how it would've felt if I had heard it the first time just now. Was going for a 3 yesterday, but then again this feels way better and more impactful than some other 3s we've had on the list. Weak 4 it is!
I had a hard time getting excited about this one. The first track really felt like a Max Martin production and, ironically, it’s one of the few songs that doesn’t actually feature Max Martin. I also couldn’t shake the feeling that the album sounds quite dated. Maybe it’s stuck in that awkward valley between new and retro, where the style just ends up feeling a bit tired rather than nostalgic. I tried to put it in context with other albums from the time. Lorde released Pure Heroine the year before, and its aftereffects can definitely be heard here, though they aren’t yet in full swing. This album still has one foot firmly planted in the past. In general, it’s just a very 2014-sounding pop album. I really enjoyed “Shake It Off” and “Bad Blood”; both songs are just so much fun. 3 stars.
Standouts Blank Space Style
It's hard to rate this given how many of the songs were singles that I've heard a million times. It's just simple, hooky synth pop with a real focus on the vocals. I don't love how bare some of the backing tracks are and the lyrics are very repetitive, but songs like Blank Space, Shake It Off and Style are undeniably catchy.
Good voice. Pop
Back when I reviewed evermore, I mentioned that I used to be a Taylor Swift hater, especially with her transition into pop. Those feelings were largely due to the singles I heard in passing. For 1989, the full-on rebirth of her sound into this genre, it was "Shake It Off", "Blank Space", and "Bad Blood" from what I recall. Since then, I formally got into Taylor’s music through her folk ventures with folklore and evermore, came to appreciate her as a pop star with Midnights, and along the way listened to the “Taylor’s Version” re-recordings of her earlier output, including 1989. Then, at some point, I got a hold of the original album through my oldest sister, cause she’s more of a Swiftie than I’ll ever be. So, after originally dismissing Taylor’s first foray into straight-up pop music over a decade ago, I can now come around and say that I like it, for the most part. It’s probably a double-edged sword that I can recognize the influences Taylor had for 1989 from purveying indie and pop artists of the early 2010s that were bringing back synth-pop and other retro pastiches. Opening track “Welcome to New York” has a prominent synth line and strident vocal cadence that reminded me of CHVRCHES. Cuts like “Style” and “Wildest Dreams” brought more energy to the appropriation of 60s pop stars than Lana Del Rey did, with the former having the added boon of that rollicking disco-esque guitar line. “Bad Blood” felt eerily reminiscent of Avril Lavigne’s brand of pop rock juxtaposed with Lorde’s sparse instrumentation. In fact, "I Know Places" with its snappy snare beats would've fit onto Lorde's curated soundtrack for one of the Hunger Games films at the time. Then you check the liner notes, and find that Jack Antonoff co-wrote and co-produced “Out of the Woods” and “I Wish You Would”, which sound straight out of the Bleachers playbook. A similar case can be made for “Clean” with Imogen Heap’s backing vocals and more intimate production that melds organic instrumentation with the electronics. In a sense, Taylor, with the assistance of Max Martin, Shellback, and other outside songwriters and producers, acted like a chameleon, masquerading in other artists’ styles while providing a lot of the charisma and presence with her voice. That’s not to say she’s perfect at doing it; I’ve never been bought into “Shake It Off” in its attempted kiss-off to the “haters”, complete with her trying to emulate Kesha’s talk-sing cadence, and it’s utterly baffling. But more often than not, I dug her style dabbling through most of this record. But therein lies the issue - for as much as I do enjoy Taylor’s emulation of other artists in places, it’s hard to discern much of her personality or unique instrumental quirks on her own album. The closest I get to fitting that description are the more guitar-driven “All You Had to Do Was Stay” (with the admittedly shrill utterances of “Stay” in the chorus), the bubblegum pop sheen of "How You Get the Girl", and the atmospheric soft rock ballad “This Love”. Though those songs also happen to be the only ones on the album with any real instrumental warmth. This will happen when most of the sound is defined by drum machine usage, to the point where melodies are often carried by the vocal line. The closest Taylor gets to making that style work wonders is with the closing track "Clean", but that's due to the masterful production work of Imogen Heap compared to Max Martin, Shellback, and Ryan Tedder. But, as always with a Taylor Swift album, the main selling point is the lyrical content. Aside from the aforementioned "Shake It Off" and some underdeveloped symbolism like with the chorus of "This Love", there is an implied narrative of her moving to New York and the dissolution of an ill-fated relationship. Now, going for a more straightforward autobiography isn't a bad choice, as it allowed her to be more nuanced in the framing and highlight how said relationship's failings fall on both sides. The guy may be a cheater and unreliable, but Taylor herself admitted to also being just as bad. It's very telling from the get-go on the bridge of "Welcome to New York", where we have the lines, "Like any great love, it keeps you guessing/Like any real love, it's ever-changing/Like any true love, it drives you crazy"; she embraced the drama that came with the relationships and her role in contributing to it. This approach does sacrifice relatability, as Taylor was moving on from the "girl next door" image she cultivated from her early work, and maybe also glamorizes drama-overloaded relationships, but the songwriting does shine in showcasing enough self-awareness on her part; how much of this is her failure to get over this guy and instead keep taking him back. More importantly, this is Taylor taking a more assertive role, admitting to the culpability and how she made the bad decisions for the wrong decisions, and then at the end, she does move on from that relationship. At the end of the day, I have grown to appreciate 1989 as Taylor's first full-on foray into pop music. I personally feel she would come into her own as a pop artist with Midnights, but there are still some merits to be had with this record.
I'm a 56 year old man, who likes metal, rock, jazz and prog. This...? Isn't for me. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ half the album Revisit ❌️ ★★☆☆☆(3/10) Total reviewed : 419 Already owned : 93 Purchased : 21 To buy : 5 Nope : 300
So many hits
Fully expected to dislike this but actually enjoyed it a decent bit. Didn't realize so many radio hits came from this one album. She definitely has a talent at making popular songs. Definitely few cringe-worthy songs but overall a fun album
I can now say that I've heard this. Enjoyed "How You Get the Girl," "Bad Blood," and "Clean."
i can’t i’m sorry, i just feel nostalgia to shake it off
Big 3
Every now and again I'm exposed to mainstream American pop music and for the past, I reckon, 20 years it's all just sounded exactly the same to me. I have no idea about which artist is which and oftentimes it feels that for majority of people it doesnt even matter; they just need some easy, instantly gratifying background music while they're at home doing whatever. It's the case here too: well-produced (as in absolutely harmless and as non-offensive as possible) pop music that I might've heard playing at a grocery shop or something but would have no recollection of, since, like said, all American pop music has sounded the same to me for at least 20 years. So in short, it's well-made music, but have I personally any reason or desire to listen to this ever again? Well, no. I don't hate it the way some of the albums here have made me actually upset; I just feel completely indifferent about this.
This is more of a 1.5. It literally sounds like badly made AI music. The other album from her on this list was better, which says a lot about how bad this one is.
Muy lindo, pero de repente aburre. Las estructuras armónicas se repiten mucho :(
MADRE TAYLOR TE RECONTRA AMO
She's a pop queen
Serviceable pop music
I don’t understand why this is the TS album that seems to make it onto these lists. I get that it probably has the highest concentration of her pop bangers but imo is not her best album. Didn’t realise quite how reverb soaked some of it is though, I do appreciate the dreamlike qualities and some of the songs (the less radio played ones) I do have a soft spot for
as vezes é sobre se conectar com a mulher branca dentro de nós… style pop perfection mas algumas músicas meio enjoadas aí no meio
Destaque pra Blank space Style Wildest dreams
No creo ser el público objetivo de este tipo de música, me gusta el pop, me refiero más a ese tipo de música que parece ser creada con el unico propósito de ser escuchada en un auto junto con otras personas y tener un momento tipo película gringa sobre estudiantes populares... demasiado específico pero es lo que se me ocurre, "buuhhh no me gusta la diversión y los mensajes de positividad buhhhh!!!", puede interpretarse así y estoy de acuerdo, la verdad no soy alguien a quien le fascinen los encuentros sociales, supongo que ese es uno de los factores por los que no me gusta. No juzgo negativamente canciones/artistas por sus letras, mi inglés no es perfecto, entiendo a un nivel decente de lo que hablan algunos temas y no me forma ningun otro pensamiento que no sea "esto suena a la canción anterior", claro, con otro sombrero, así que por ese lado no opino nada, está vacío y no me llegó ningun mensaje. Por otro lado, no, musicalmente tampoco me llama la atención ni un poco, el climax de cada canción no me transmite nada, no siento nada, no me dan ganas de tararear porque simplemente no le encuentro el hilo, son canciones planas y secas, bastante rudo decir esto sabiendo que se trata de un género pop, pero dioooooos mio, ni siquiera pienso decir que son repetitivas porque es un patrón que siento que es algo positivo dentro de una compocisión musical, por este punto es comprensible. Supongo que se lleva 1 estrella unica y exclusivamente por Shake It Off ya que es la única que logro ubicar gracias a la película de Sing, muy buena película, amo el personaje de Rosita! Sinceramente antes de ver que canciones incluía no sabía que esta canción le perteneciera a Taylor aún despues de tantas veces de escucharla cuando estuvo de moda, es un buen hit, pero no algo tan grandioso como para obsesionarme. Tampoco voy a mencionar que el álbum sea malo por sonar comercial, aunque si, lo pienso, suena y es bastante comercial pero no sería justo basar todo en eso, es malo por x y bueno por y, yo que se, su voz es normal, no la distinguiría como "oh, es taylor swift", la verdad no. Ni siquiera es que odie a Taylor, soy indiferente a ella como artista y a su trabajo, no pienso incluir demasiado de lo que he leído o escuchado sobre sus opiniones y sus vuelos privados a la tienda de la esquina por un galón de leche. No encuentro el mensaje que hace que tanta gente caiga a sus pies para pasar a defenderla a capa y espada. Me siento un poco tonto por no lograr verlo, siento que me pierdo de algo y no me siento precisamente mal por estar fuera, no quiero ser parte de eso. Es un "no, gracias" ajaja. No me subo al tren de fans de Taylor, pero tampoco me subo al otro de hater. Prefiero quedarme en la estación y ver como ambos trenes se estrellan y explotan a lo lejos. No me interesa discutir y solo escribo esto para entender bien que es lo que no me gusta de su música, es buena forma de ordenar pensamientos y opiniones. Conclusión: 1 estrella porque Shake It Off sale en Sing :) No hay otra cosa positiva que pueda resaltar.
Surprisingly one dimensional, which isn’t unusual for out-and-out pop, but I thought given Swift’s immense fan base there must be *something* good or different about her music. Nope. The only track I enjoyed was “New Romantics”, which on reading about the album I discover wasn’t even included in the original release FFS. Gets a token 2/5 because I didn’t actually dislike it… there’s just nothing on here of any merit to justify the adulation she seems to get.
It’s processed, synthesised, synthetic pop. But it’s rammed with bangers and I had a great time, would go again
Lots of hits, high quality all the way through. Not entirely my style though. 8/10
🐐 talk. Hit after hit after hit. This album had the radio in a chokehold for a long time. Might be time for me to listen to all of her albums and become a full blown member of the movement, bracelets and everything. They don’t all land, but there are some gigantic song on here. Sometimes the surrounding poppy music can distract from how incredible her songwriting and lyricism is. I like her early country stuff a lot, and of course her hits are in the lexicon but I haven’t gotten all into her…like I said, maybe it’s time.
Many of the songs that aren't singles are BAD, and some of the singles are, but it has a couple alltime fantastic songs in Style and Blank Space. Some of the lesser known ones have decent parts like Clean, but overall the good just barely edges out the dredge on this album.
If your dad bought a stake in a record company in exchange for signing you, then hired Jack Antinov and Max Martin to write and produce for you, you'd hope to end up with a couple of solid earworms
70
not a Swiftie. Solid work - therefore 3
Pop - meh. Shake it off is catchy but the rest are pretty forgettable.
#413 It’s a well crafted pop album, she is good at what she does but I’m not sure it’s essential listening unless you are her target audience, and I’m not sure that’s me. Heard before? ❌ Would I revisit? ❌ Listen before you die? ❌ Fave track(s): Shake it Off Rating: 5/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️
AYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY YO RE SWIFTY MALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL TE AMO TAYLORRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR palo sos increíble y me alegra mucho saber que aunque estuvo todo tan mal, gracias a esta página que recomienda música, seguimos en contacto. no sabes cuanto esperaba tus reviews, me hizo reír mucho la del álbum en vivo. te quiero con todo mi corazón paloma te lo juro por mi vida
Setting aside what I feel about Ms swift as an institution, there's no doubt that she is in a league of her own. There were a couple of songs I adored, notably Style and Wildest Dreams. Some I disliked intensely, Shake it off chief among them. The production is sometimes a bit much, I generally like her folkier stuff.
I am not Taylor's target market, but I am well known as a synthpop obsessive. That makes 1989 strangely appealing to me, even though I've never really followed mainstream pop trends. The hooks here are saccharine sweet but undeniable and infectious all the same. There's not a single stinker in the bunch and I have zero shame saying that 1989 is a good album (I would call it great but the second half just can't compete with a juggernaut Side A). Taylor chose her production team well for the transition from pop country into a more conventional pop presence, though I do wish she'd dabbled longer in synthpop. It suits her, but hey, what do I know? I'm writing this from my couch and she's amassed over 128 billion streams on Spotify alone without my advice 🤷♂️😂
Taylor hits her stride on this album with a tight collection of pop cuts that deliver over and over.
Well ......no
I'm not as big a fan of the poppiest of T. Swift's stuff, which is what she's got going on this album, but the girl can surely write a song.
Taylor Swift blocked off the streets of MSG for thousands of New Yorkers and requested the cameras inside be turned off and not track attendees for her wedding, but doesn't do anything to help the regular attendees.
I am shocked anyone over 12 enjoys this. Total bubblegum garbage.
I don't care what you "I'm only into UK punk form 1983" fools think. Taylor Swift is amazing. And this album is just chock full of incredible bangers. I know most of the songs were primarily written by someone else and she just took writing credit. I don't care. I don't care that she's overexposed. Good music is good music, man.
Good, not the absolute best of her, elix is still RED
Welcome to New York - 3/5 Blank Space - 3.5/5 Style - 4/5 Out of the Woods - 3.5/5 All You Had to Do Was Stay - 3/5 Shake It Off - 3/5 I Wish You Would - 3/5 Bad Blood - 2.5/5 Wildest Dreams - 3.5/5 How You Get the Girl - 3/5 This Love - 3/5 I Know Places - 3/5 Clean - 3/5 I forgot how everywhere this album was when it came out: 3 top 100 singles and pretty much every single off of here charted in same way or another. And then I realized when listening to it that Taylor Swift is writing these lyrics and immediately realize why I would rather listen to other, more interesting pop acts. I don't really hate any of the songs off of here (except for Bad Blood, which definitely led into the even worse "Look What You Made Me Do" an album or two later) but most of them are pretty vanilla. Style is a good retro-ish throwback that this album was trying to go for while there are a couple that feel like they should have some staying power. The others can be forgotten. Overall: 3/5 Favorites: Style, Wildest Dreams
Kinda know what you're getting with this one....but it is kind of the ultimate TSwift experience. Some decent (by 2014 standards) pop earworms, some cringe metaphors/lyrics (imo), well-produced, etc. Probably not one I'll come back to a lot, but heads and tails above a lot of the obscure British electronic and left field albums on the list. "Wildest Dreams" is a cool song...whatever
cuando decidió entra al mundo del pop copiándose de lana del rey, nada más que decir
Je pensais chier sur Taylor Swift le premier son était vraiment très mauvais. Mais entre les classiques et l’instru de Style un peu synthwave c’était pas si mal, en fait je me suis vraiment régalé même si ça me fait mal de l’admettre…
This was the album of 2014. It was on the radio 24/7. 12(!) years later I think it’s pretty good. I just can’t get myself to listen to Shake it Off, Blank Space, or Bad Blood from beginning to start.
I am by no means a Swiftie and in fact I don't really like her in general. However this album just has so many bangers. Hearing nostalgic music from my childhood is what I imagine the rest of this 1001 experience is like for old people. 5/5
Soulless overproduced pop slop made for mass appeal and not artistic expression. It does what it’s trying to do very well, but I’m just not interested at all in listening to music that was made purely for profit and not as art
Pop en los 2000; inofensivo y olvidable.
Taylor Swift and Aaron Dessner are close musical partners. Dessner, a member of the rock band The National, helped write and produce Swift's albums Folklore, Evermore, Midnights, and The Tortured Poets Department. They have recorded over 60 songs together since 2020. I don’t like any of her other records. The songs on here are not bad as the cover album by Ryan Adams has proofed however not really my thing. I like the disco moroder style of “Style” however.
I lost my hate it, but I gotta respect it. Also my two girls (6 and 3) wanted me to share THEY would give it 5/5. Shake it Off rocked when it came out. Generally though I just feel it’s so very lame. Taylor going on and on (for decades!) about her stupid love life. Marry him, dump him, who cares! It all feels so self-absorbed. Can’t argue with the hits though. Lotta those.
My 6year old daughter’s favorite album. Looked in the car mirror to see her rapping along to the cheesy breakdown in shake it off this morning and it made my heart hurt. Taylor might be everything that depresses me about our culture, but she still gave me that moment, which is more than most artists I like ever have. Also there is just an undeniable amount of hits
I aint too proud Tried to imagine myself as an alien that hasnt heard any of the BS associated with Taylor before putting it on. The thought came to me half way through this that I think I would’ve liked this a lot, but theres just been too much pain… of having heard some of these tunes at EVERY college party in 2014 😂 So here we go. I found a few newbies that were fun enough. Style and Clean were enjoyable. How You Get The Girl is the weakest link. I also think theres a universe where Jack writes Shake It Off for a different artist… the tune sounds like Macklemore couldve rapped over this
New to me. Difficult to score when the artist has become such a pop behemoth that listening to her music is almost secondary. I can hear hits galore . I imagine every song has hit #1.
Сара није слушала Марко 4,5
Surcôté. Des tubes connus qu'on a entendu 1000 fois à la radio, j'imagine que ça doit être son album qui l'a fait percer jsp
M’oui Je capte pas Taylor Swift La première track était vraiment moisie à mon sens et n’était pas représentatif du reste… 2-3 sons cultes, elle chante bien mais ça ne me touche pas du tout dans l’ensemble Je suis sympa en mettant 3, car bon… elle fait partie des plus grosses artistes, donc c’est difficile de dire que c’est de la merde en boîte alors que ça nous touche jsute pas
Quelques morceaux iconiques mais c'est de la pop de base... J'ai du mal a comprendre l'engouement autour de Taylor Swift
I'm not proud of it, but it is what is is.
I liked this way more than I thought I would.
I liked this more than I thought I would. I am familiar with a couple of these songs because I exist in the world, but I don't really listen to pop music. However, a lot of this is fun and the lyrics are good (not insipid like Kacey Musgraves). It would be 4 stars if she didn't sound like a robot. Way, WAY too much autotune. I listen to a lot of the '80s synth music this was inspired by, and autotune didn't exist when those songs were made. You could actually hear the human vocals above the synths. Maybe this is just "old man yells at clouds" but the robot sound strips out a lot of enjoyment in listening to music for me.
After almost a year here this is that first album I've actually already listened to, I distinctly remember seeing this on a CD in a thrift store & thinking "ah what the hell". It's Taylor at her peak, the absolute best from the biggest pop star to exist yet. Easy 5 star
7.5/10
not as good as Joni Mitchell’s Blue
Great, catchy tunes
Such a fun summery album. Not my favourite from Taylor, but it does what it does really well - it is a damn good pop album.
One of her best.
Never listened to Taylor swift before. What is this. How is she a cultural phenomenon? The terrible cheesy lyrics and terrible overuse of synths are so poorly done. Man that was a tough listen
Finally got the TS album from here and despite never wishing to listen to this again, its a pretty well made pop album from the 2010s.
I'm astonishingly indifferent to Taylor Swift's music. I'm not a hater, there's different kinds of music for different people's taste. There are hundreds of artists like her vying for listenership. The thing that stands out to me is the runaway success of Taylor Swift. Her catalog is worth approximately the same as Bob Dylan or Bruce Springsteen. It's worth about half of The Beatles catalog. This provides some art-to-numbers basis for comparison. Am I to believe that Taylor Swifts musical output to date is something to compare to Badlands, Nebraska, Darkness on The Edge of Town? Probably not it's just a completely different demographic with a different set of ears. It got me thinking about what is the equivalent album that has Taylor Swift fans complaining about the same things as me: - Why do people want to hear some variation of this song over and over, she has a well identified formula I could just predict the next part - Why should I care about what she is singing about? - I guess it is her knack for pop sensibility, otherwise I just dont understand it My current stab at analogy is Guided By Voices. I'm aware enough of the formula. I just don't care, I love it. My wife loves Taylor Swift and can't get through a single 90 second GBV song.
I don't like her recent albums nor her persona. I also think her fans overhype her lyrics, specially for her latest albums. however, I gotta be honest, this albums has some pop bangers that I do like for what they are. She may not be the musical genius nor the poet they claim she is, but she does have some good oldies which are still fun. Some lyrics do sound corny, so I guess it's always been like that
Music for people obsessed with drinking enough water.
Yayyyy
“you could've been gettin' down to this sick beat” <insert white girls clapping> i do actually think this is a pretty solid pop album. but that part is hilarious. i’ve heard all of these songs before but not these versions (ryan adam’s cover album).
The beginning of it all, the anthems still stand out, the B-sides... not so much. Good album overall.
My second time listening to a Taylor Swift album.(Thought it was the first but looked in my history of this project and there was a forgettable one 600 albums ago). Interesting, as a woman far too old to be in Taylor’s demographic, but who has younger family members who are big fans… It’s really all about the lyrics, isn’t it? Her voice is thin and some of the melodies are actually irritating. But she really is a genius at tapping into adolescent romanticism. And her voice not sounding trained may actually work in her favor, as she sounds like she could be your friend from next door singing her heart out. In fact, I think the combination of lyrical genius and bang-average musicianship is precisely the secret to her incredible success. Any young girl who has had her first heartbreak is going to feel seen by these lyrics. That’s a big market. Good for her I suppose. I’m going to go back to grownup music now.
I’m not much on pop radio but the woman can craft great pop songs. I prefer Taylor Swift’s voice when she’s not reaching for the higher notes, but it’s a strong album.
Trying to put my bias of dumping on Taylor’s insanely generic music aside, this album gives me insane PTSD from high school. The record opens with a song the genuinely feels like it could be AI. In fact, that’s a common theme i feel throughout the entire record. This record is such a product of its time. It’s a common theme with a lot of the pop stuff in the 2010’s. But Jesus I hate how synthetic and non human most of the popular shit from this era is. I don’t know dude the more I try and follow along with this album, I try and put myself in the perspective of a swiftie. I want to hear what they hear, because I can get why this sound is appealing to kids, but for any normal functioning adult all I’ve learned is they have shit music taste and should probably be confined to a padded cell. Like how can you listen to a record like this and genuinely take anything away from it? How do the build a relationship with such a lifeless personality as this? Idk man. Cult vibes have been confirmed. I find this very cringe to listen to as an adult man.
Taylor swift is 10 years older than me at all time yet why does this feel so current. She created the sound of the 2010’s that all the pop stars emulated yet it feels so fresh. It’s boom clap music but it actually plays itself so sincerely and honestly does some interesting things sonically with Taylor’s voice. A lot of glitch vocals which I like. Taylor swift is one of the most influential voices in music ever, she has sold more guitars than any other artists and gotten more people to listen and appreciate music even in the modern era. In the age where everyone listens to singles Taylor swift has made the album experience just that an experience and this was a window looking in. A story of healing and becoming a new person, a new love. The music is great it’s catchy and it’s so well written. I like this it’s not my typical style but I respect her so much now. A modern album that is a must listen to understand the mania of her music this is her thriller her purple rain her it’s so unusual and it works.My day is finished and I keep thinking about it I listened to clean on the way to the train and saw an old friend who didn’t recognize me so funny. Songs are weird when you listen in the best ways
Taylor Swift is a pop star I know exists, that she is popular, but I had never listened to an album of hers until now. It's not entirely my thing, but it doesn't disappoint.
Pleasant pop, even if it's formulaic. I find her voice too saccharine sweet.
This is the aural equivalent of the uncanny valley.
Taylor Swift is simultaneously the most overrated yet overhated artist ever. She's just fine. She's got her moments. I think people go overboard with disliking her in response to those annoying people who glaze her too much.
A solid album for sure. Not really my genre of music but hard to deny that these are well crafted, well performed and produced songs.
This music isn't made for me, but I can tell that it's good
This album is full of pop bangers as T-Swift fully transitioned away from her early sound into a more polished pop sound. My wife loves this album and actually owns it on CD.
Wasn’t my thing when it first came out, still feel the same way. I don’t understand why everyone thought it was so era defining. Its just the same Pop that everyone else did and still does
Liked this more than I anticipated. Some of the lyrics are beyond cringe, but some bangers to be found.
Album 1080 and it's a banger. I'm not into power pop or dance pop but this is pretty excellent for what it is. Tons of hits and there's no drop off from the non-single tracks. I'm never putting something like this on and probably would have never listened to it without this project, but this album totally deserves a place on the list.
É inegável que se trata de um álbum bem produzido e pensado, isso não quer dizer que me agrada. Achei uma experiência muito genérica e que não me causou impacto algum. Me parece uma tentativa de ser algo para agradar a todos (e os números da artista mostram que alcançaram o objetivo), mas ao tentar agradar a todos sempre restam alguns que ficam indiferentes. E esse é o meu caso. QoA Vesper.
I like Welcome to new york. First year me would have loved that. Blank space is iconic. I like style as well. Out of my woods is one of my favorites as well. All you had to do was stay hits a bit too close to home. Same with I Wish You Would I like shake it off as much as the next person. Bad love is really great! Shoutout to that music video. I also love wildest dreams. Its a really great album. I think its a 4 star album. I don't really like I Know Places. Clean is also really good. Also close to home.
Great album 4/5
Some of the least inspired pop music I’ve ever heard.
I feel like purely based off of the fact that I know a good amount of songs in this album it needs to be rated above the average. This album made a lot of waves when it released, it was everywhere. Absolutely a defining album and paved the way forward. I'd say 3.5 because it's personally not my thing, but I can appreciate how massive it is/was.
When I first listened to this album it was being performed by cancelled country singer Ryan Adams and it was incredible and I was like "wow Taylor Swift is a genius". Then I listened to (Taylor's version) and was like "wow Taylor Swift sucks this is some 2014 glossy pop bullshit". This time I tried to forget cancelled country singe Ryan Adams' version and forget how annoying Taylor Swift's fans and also Taylor Swift are and I accidentally walked down Cornelia Street, a street which Taylor Swift wrote a not very good song about, and I thought it was pretty good. This was when she was still trying to appear mature and smart so her songs are a little like when a toddler wears heels, but it's better than her current persona where she's in her mid-30s talking about high school prom to impress Republicans (to extend the metaphor, those songs are like when an adult wears a diaper for sexual reasons). Blank Space and Wildest Dreams are truly unimpeachably good. Shake It Off is silly but fun. Out of the Woods feels like divorced producer Jack Antonoff took a catchy song and made the drums fucked up until the song turned bad. Welcome to New York is so embarrassing it's incredible she was brave enough to make the rest of the album after that start - I'd have to go home and hide. In conclusion - it's great.
Sounds like your average highly processed pop music. Don't get the hype that has lead to her farting around the planet on her private plane.
I knew some of the songs already and the remainder were ok. Not my cup of tea but I can appreciate why it's so well regarded.
Insipid
Imagine how joyless you’d need to be to write a dozen paragraphs here about how superficial you find 1989? Well done, guys, you’ve won, no joy shall ever puncture your forcefield of real music. Seriously, though, Style and Blank Space are unalloyed Great American Songbook entries at this point, and there’s plenty more to love besides. (A point off only really because, next to her writing elsewhere, some of the lyrics are a little boilerplate. Is Folklore on here…?)
I think I was expecting this to be better then it was, not that it was that bad... Taylor Swift is one of those artists I have gone back and forth on over the years. She obviously has massive appeal and huge staying power, which makes me fairly skeptical, but I know she also has won the respect of lots of music critic and musicians who I like. All that said, its almost hard to try and create an honest, uninfluenced opinion about this, which leaves me feeling a bit underwhelmed by the whole listening experience. There were the songs I knew and had heard a million times, and then a few others that sounded largely the same. I don't hate on this being here, it's obviously very deserving but mostly I think I don't get what the fuss is about?
In general I'm not a fan of modern pop, but I do have a bit of a soft spot for Taylor Swift's newer, pop oriented albums for two main reasons. The first is my wife who is a huge fan of her music, so I have heard all of these songs countless times. The second is her collabs with the National's Bryce Dessner on Folklore and Evermore, which are easily her best albums in my book. I was a massive National fan in the past, so Folklore dropping in 2020 was a surprising melding of my music with my wife's and it worked really, really well. I don't like 1989 nearly as much as I do Folklore, but it's still a very well produced, well written, and catchy pop album.
I wasn’t exactly thrilled when Taylor Swift showed up in my random album queue today, but I’ll give credit where it’s due: she knows how to write an earworm. 1989 is an incredibly catchy synth-pop album, packed with polished hooks and immaculate production. As a 50-year-old guy who paid virtually no attention to Swift during either her country years or her transition into pop, listening to this felt a little strange. I’m clearly not the target audience, and yet I completely understand why this album became the phenomenon that it did. Will I ever intentionally put it on again? Probably not. Then again, stranger things have happened.
It's unbelievable that this album is 12yrs old now. While there are always haters for any music, this album crossed boundaries like nothing had in a long time. Think Michael Jackson's Thriller, Fleetwood Mac's Rumours, Stevie Wonder's Songs in the Key of Life, etc... It's an album that was culturally ubiquitous. EVERYONE was exposed to it and even if you WERE a hater, you recognized how undeniably catchy and well crafted the songs were. This is a pop masterclass and a really enjoyable listen.
Ohne Vorurteile gehört und für gut befunden. Taylor macht ihr Ding seit vielen Jahren und das ist zu respektieren!
Most songs sound like they were made for an animated film about a plucky giraffe. It’s just … meh, with the exception of Shake It Off. 2.5
I'm still a sucker for a good pop album. And this is a good pop album. It's easy to see why she is so huge in 2026 that even her wedding gets massive news coverage, but her songs now sound very much like her songs then so I'd have expected a bit more development (conversely why kill the goose!).
Well, the swiftness have a point
Bue.... Es Taylor Swift, no me gusta, si es de este tipo de música, prefiero a Britney Spears
Even here in Finland, you couldn’t escape the news about Taylor Swift’s wedding for days. Surprisingly, escaping her music has been pretty easy. I hadn’t actually heard any of these tracks before. I don’t know exactly what I was expecting, but I thought at least one of these songs would be catchy or make me feel something. "1989" is just harmless, recycled 80s pop. It’s not terrible, but I have absolutely no need to listen to it ever again.
Oh boy...It's not bad but I'm not the target audience. Shake it off was the only song i had heard before and I can't say I was missing something.
Whatever you think of Taylor personally, this album slaps harder than Will Smith
Please. Music for 5-year old parties. If you're older than 15 and vibing with this you need to broaden your horizons
Went in with an open mind on this one, as we all know who Taylor Swift is. Her music isn’t for me at all, have heard of the hits through general life. My thoughts are the entire album singing about one thing, there isn’t any variety in the songs whatsoever, I suspect the other albums are like that too. God forbid this wedding doesn’t work out or that bloke will find himself another three albums written about him
Могу дать балл за её талант писать попсовые треки
no soy mejor q una swiftie pero es q este es un tremendo álbum pop. 4.5 pero acá queda en 5/5.
Hard to make it through the whole LP
Un álbum de ingeniería pop impecable donde muchas de las pistas ya las había escuchado debido a su enorme impacto cultural. En el plano formal, la producción destaca por una claridad absoluta; los sintetizadores y los ritmos pegajosos se entretejen muy bien con una precisión matemática que sostiene la energía de principio a fin. La verdadera grandeza del disco radica en su equilibrio conceptual: aunque girly tienen mucho sentido sus letras para reflexionar y también para tomar con humor las situaciones difíciles de la vida. Su destreza narrativa refleja autenticidad y madurez, convirtiendo éxitos como "Blank Space", "Style" y "Clean" en piezas de gran lucidez. El viaje sónico opera en un balance perfecto, funcionando simultáneamente como un agudo llamado a la conciencia y un reconfortante refugio lúdico-nostálgico. Un documento conmovedor, crudo y real respaldado por una fuerza y autoridad superior en la composición, cuya contagiosa sensación de paz y fluidez rítmica lo vuelve óptimo para múltiples usos diarios, destacando para el ejercicio o para activar el trabajo creativo.
I'm not a Taylor missionary. Oh great another pop crossover genre mashup. Evermore and Folklore are my favorite TS albums. Okay fine this album is a banger and I hate saying that as I jam out in my living room by myself.
My lord and savior Taylor Swift has graced us with her presence and genius with this album. While I may be biased and definitely a fan of her work. I was interested to see what a full listen through of this album would do. Especially since I've listened to it so many times before. This is a no skip album for me. Even when the beats are a little bit more poppy and "girly", the lyrics hit you like a ton of bricks. This is the reason why she was inducted into the Song writer's hall of fame this past month. This album made me feel so many things while I was on my hike. I've heard it said many times that "If you don't like Taylor Swift, it's because you haven't needed her yet". So maybe with my past couple of years and relationships, and really understanding what she and so many others are going through just made this hit so much more. And being someone that's been in the public eye and so many rumors that this album is about Harry Styles, you can really see her yearning for someone that will stay and love her. My favorites are Out of the Woods, Style (That opening guitar rift always makes me ascend.), and honestly shake it off.
Putting aside she married Travis Kelce and has never really scratched my itch… album is a banger. 4.4.
Taylor’s music isn't always to my taste. But damn, this album is filled with bangers. There’s some filler that doesn’t get playtime and I was less familiar with, but the singles are good enough to carry the album. She’s extremely talented, and I’m glad she made it on the list in subsequent editions. 8/10 Most Excellent
Perfectly mid pop. Nothing exceptional and even the bits that get close just miss. Lord knows how this is the most famous pop star in the world. And methinks she doth protest way too much about “haters”. The more you try to convince us you don’t care, the more you clearly do.
Yes, this is insipid pop crap in my estimation, but it is so much better than the first TS album I endured (Ever...something). Were I into pop, I'm sure this would hit differently. But it still holds no appeal for me.
I’ve always been a defender of T Swift because she does damn good pop storytelling. Turns out that doesn’t mean she makes great albums. This is the only one I’ve fully listened to, but just a lot of love songs that aren’t as good as her hits. There’s a couple interesting songs, but as an album it’s pretty redundant and makes me glad I’m no longer 25 years old.
You think she’s offer him yet? Funny - I am listening on her so-called wedding day…7/3/26___923/26
A couple of fun tunes. She has a talent for writing catchy melodies, and I like her occasionally staccato vocal delivery. But the production is bland and repetitive, and her lyrics are pretty cringe-inducing.
Taylor Swift is a master of big hooks and earworms and her songs connect with her audience.
I’m probably biased (Eras tour attendee), but this is an almost perfect pop album. Aside from a few corny lines (Shake it Off and Bad Blood being the main offenders of this), this album has held up extremely well overall. Then again, this album came out my freshman year of college so that may be my bias showing. Either way, I enjoyed this back then and I love/appreciate it even more now. Especially bc Taylor’s newer stuff is ass.
no me gusta taylor swift
I appreciate Taylor Swift but it’s just not my kind of music. 2
We all know it. It's a perfect pop album. I listened to it critically this time and it's still a great pop album. Slightly tales of in the mid so it doesn't get 5. But still a classic
Her best by far.
I am pretty sure that this is the best TS can do. The singles are good pop even though Shake It Off is a rip-off of Hey Ya.
This is one of the very few Taylor Swift albums I've already heard. The hits are good, but they don't do all that much for me. The rest is okay, but also doesn't do anything for me. Not one of the 1001 greatest albums ever made to be sure 2.5 rounded up
She pisses off the right people, is going to be Jason’s sister in law, but mostly she brings joy to my daughter.
No
For me, the definition of lowest common denominator pop. Also something something private jet something something billionaire whatever. I think generally the songs can be catchy but her posturing as a true songwriter/poet does not sit well based on the content of her lyrics.
Debated between a 3 and 4 because it is quite good, even if it’s not something I typically go to or will give many re-listens. It really is a solid album in just about every way, and probably Taylor’s best work.
Good
I’m not a Swifty, but I get it. This is world class pop and Swift’s billionaire status proves it. I’ve heard these songs in dance parties, grocery stores, poolside…, any occasion suits them.
*listened before the project* Stop playing with me, ok? It’s the worst even in synth-pop. When I first heard “Shake It Off” in high school, I almost threw up. What’s that burp-like beat? Pretty gross. And the lyrics? Better not to mention. Cut: Blank Space
There is too much of what feels like filler to me, and the brighter spots aren't bright enough to make me want to listen again. 2.5/5: Coin flip between a 2 and a 3.
Taylor Swift describes a world I have never lived in. It's female sexual empowerment veiled through a monogamous lens which is honestly my biggest issue with the album. Taylor seems to want to celebrate women's sexual autonomy (great!) but still frame it in a way implying you're supposed to be in a relationship to enjoy it (why?). This album will either age extremely well or bad, but I'm not sure which way it will. There is a little bit too much of disdain for the men Swift pines for on the album, which comes out as a bit narcissistic, though I see it more as a defense mechanism than a genuine hatred. Either way, it's a time capsule into that cultural time a smidge before the Me Too movement. Shake It Off is a banger.
I admit I wasn't expecting this even if 1989's inclusion makes all the sense in the world since I've never been a serious Swiftie, but I enjoyed her singles. I don't have anything against her personally either, from what I've seen she always gives kudos to artists that deserve it and to her fans, ravenous as they are. The biggest gripe I have with her is bringing Paramore with her on the Eras tour and effectively pricing me out of seeing them live. Anyway, 1989 is a fine album, even a good album. I definitely enjoyed the singles I already knew (Blank Space, Shake it Off), and even found some new songs I enjoyed (All You Had To Do Was Stay, How You Get the Girl). The lyrics are broad and generic sappy love tales and Taylor really won't go down as one of the best singers ever as I'm sorry to say, but this album has energy and charisma the whole way through, which is something I really have to give props for.
not for me but undoubtedly a classic
I feel the furious ghost of Steve Albini glaring down (or up?) at me for even giving this a middling rating, as it is very much gross, overproduced corporate pop, but the problem is the songs are excellent. Still, melody / songwriting is only half of the puzzle, and this sounds grotesque, oppressive, fascistic even, the sound of Microsoft and Amazon and so forth grinding your soul into dust. Still, it’s catchy. Comparing this to Britney Spears’ Baby One More Time is instructive in helping you to understand a slaved-over evil pop record versus a half-assed one. Poptimism was a cancer on society, yes, but I suppose it’s harmless to have some fun with the best iterations of it before all the interesting music we love is steamrolled by AI and we are all ground into red paste to help make more billions of dollars for our corporate masters and alleged social betters. Best track: “Wildest Dreams”
No regrets, this was enjoyable. Not my favourite Taylor Swift album and kind of signifies a fall into more poppy stuff.
A good, not great, pop album.
I’ve tried, Lord how I've tried. I just don't hear anything here, and I know that makes me a grumpy old man but whatever. Not a single strong vocal, not a single song that isn't a weak hook surrounded by “boy troubles”, not anything resembling anything unique or original. Just bang ordinary pop churned out by the Pop Factory, in this case Swedish mega hit maker Max Martin (look up his wiki if you don't know the name). I listen to this drivel and wonder how this can be so beloved while folks like Santigold and Caroline Rose are making actually great pop music in obscurity. This one avoids the dreaded One because I have to admit Shake It Off is a minor bop.
Chicken sauté with white rice on a plastic plate.
3/5, clearly im not the target audience
Some great melodies, let down by mediocre vocals and amateur lyrics
Absolutely brilliant album. So many hits, so many good songs that weren't hits. This is TS at her best. Found myself singing Shake it Off all day.
I feel like Taylor Swift is an artist either hated or adored. Those who don't like this album are likely to label it "formulaic", "boring" and for "mass-consumption"; those who do like it will appreciate its generally catchy melodies, its nod to the 80s, and the fact it doesn't really have any fillers. I'm a bit in the middle; its simplicity and polished production is the source of its greatest strength and greatest weakness. I don't hate listening to it but I'm not challenged in any great way or encouraged to listen to this regularly.
When I went to pull this album up on Qobuz, I got 1989 (Taylor's Version) instead. I figured one version of TS was as good as another. The album itself is fine. Plenty of hits. The lyrics make me cringe in spots, but it's a decent pop album. Did get me curious, though -- so I pulled up the original version and had a listen to at least a few of the tracks. Chat, the production on the original is *so* much better. Everything on the Taylor's Version sounds flat -- there aren't any of the marks of craftsmanship you see on the original. Anyway, listen to the album as it was meant to be if you want to get the full effect.
Noen kjempehits, noen ordentlig dørgende, noen som føles veldig... disney?
I’m very familiar with Ryan Adam’s cover of this album.. but man, I was not expecting to like Taylor’s version this much. This album SLAPS cover to cover
I am a believer? Never thought I would take to Taylor's music but it's charming. She's a talented vocalist, set up perfectly against smart arrangements, great backing band. I wouldn't be in the car I'd be in the audience with my screaming daughters!
Honestly these are perfectly crafted pop songs. The mega hits still sound mostly fresh, even after hearing them too many times. And the non-hits were just as good. I especially enjoyed Out Of The Woods I can see why she is the icon that she is
Look, she’s not my bag.
01) Welcome to New York - 9,5 02) Blank Space - 10,0 03) Style - 10,0 04) Out of the Woods - 9,5 05) All You Had to Do Was Stay - 9,5 06) Shake It Off - 10,0 07) I Wish You Would - 8,5 08) Bad Blood - 10,0 09) Wildest Dreams - 10,0 10) How You Get the Girl - 8,5 11) This Love - 9,0 12) I Know Places - 8,5 13) Clean - 8,5 TOTAL: 9,35 (94/100) Current ranking: 30/936 After all the folk, psychedelic and jazz shit I've endured, this is like a ray of sunshine on my face. I know this doesn't deserve to be so high on my list, but who cares. After all, it is my list, not yours! Haters gonna hate, and I'm just gonna shake, shake, shake...
Poppy, too poppy
The wiki entry for album mentions that this record is supposed to channel the pop synth sounds of the 80s. I don't hear any of that, this is all 2010s pop. This is the quintessential pop sound of the 2010s, built from the Swedish masterminds of the maximum pop sound. Taylor Swift is one of the biggest names in music in the last decade and a half, and this album shows why. The music is bright, loud, and easily accessible.
Ein Album Taylor Swift und ich habe erstmal für ein halbes Jahr genug von den ewig gleichen 4-Chord-Songs. Shake it ist wirklich gut, der Rest wie gesagt immer gleich.
Fair to say that as a fifty-something bloke, I'm probably not really in Taylor Swift's key demographic and if I didn't have two young daughters, she'd probably have passed me by completely. It's easy to be sniffy about what appears on the surface to be just chart-friendly pop music but the Taylor Swift story is pretty inspirational. If the kids are going to look up to a pop star, they can do far worse than looking up to this one. This really is an album brimming with perfectly formed pop toons - it isn't something I would normally listen to myself, but I get it and I'm glad I listened.
If you ever needed proof that popular does not necessarily equal quality, I present T Swift
This album is terrific. The hits are outstanding, fun dance music, and heavy well utilized beats and lyrics. This is just a really good album.
This album made me do a self-inflicted challenge: listen to Taylor Swift's entire discography. Had never listened to her before properly, beyond the radio hits. Was interested to see what was going on. Her first few albums were pop country, nothing too interesting although I guess a teenage girl singing about teenage girl stuff in country was somewhat unique at the time. Then came Red: I mean, Swift's pop sensibilities were already well established before this album (Love Story, for example, is hardly country), but apparently this made the press and her fans go a bit wild. Red was fine. Then came this, her full move to pop. Many of the songs I was very familiar with already, due to them being played to death on the radio over the years. A quintessential pop album, not anything special for me. Then came reputation, apparently her attempt to address the fact that her reputation was not very good at this point in time (a certain story that came out that, despite her saying she didn't give Kanye permission for *those* lyrics in Life of Pablo, a video showed she had in fact done so, with full knowledge of context?). Anyway, Reputation did not go hard and fell short of expectations. Then came Lover, barely worth mentioning for me here. The two standouts came from her work with your man from the National and Fun, folklore and evermore. Decent "folk"/singer songwriter albums with some absolute highlights, surely her pinnacle - but would like to see her do better. They'd probably get 3.5 and 4* respectively for me. Then back to the pop - Midnights was forgettable, Tortured Poets was fine, Death of a Showgirl was fine too, not sure why Swifties don't like it. Anyway, I spent way too much time on this challenge but now I feel at least I understand/know this much spoken about artist quite well at this point. Also finally was able to speak to women about Taylor Swift, although I'm not sure that's a great thing for a straight man.
I’m not usually a big Taylor Swift fan but this thing is an absolute hit parade. Beyond its 4 or 5 massive hits, most songs are still hugely recognisable, likely from this record’s complete dominance of the charts and for good reason. Probably Swift’s most consistent album with no real misses and one most could easily enjoy.
My daughter rated the last T Swift album a 5. She said this is is awesome but not quite as awesome, so it’s a 4.
bruh
Это было сложно, но я смогла.. Всё слишком одинаковое, но Bad Blood у меня лайкнута, поэтому 3
This is a tough one for me to review * All the songs sound the same (but I don't listen to a lot of synth-pop) * There are moments of clever lyricism * TS is a formidable business person defending herself in a notoriously predatory industry * It's obvious from this why she is so popular * I didn't really like this album 2 + 1 for meeting notability guidelines
Dear lord, its so boring, that was rough and im glad its over.
Goddamn it. I liked this.
Hey yall, Taylor swift here. Due to a packaging error we cant sell 3000 Le Creuset cookware sets so I'm giving them away to my loyal fans for free.
Guys I liked it…
T swift can drop some heat (or at least she used to be able to before she started dating that FREAK from kansas city) But I do like this album a bit and it has so many of the t swift songs I would choose to listen to (blank space, style, shake it off, bad blood, wildest dreams, how you get the girl)
I loveeee this album. It really is a perfect pop album
I fucking love this album I'm so sorry. It's really good. Without all the deluxe songs it's just a really tight well-crafted pop album with a lot of bangers, a lot of cringe of course, but an overall amazing vibe. I can't bring myself to give it a 5 so this will do.
Synth-pop.
I don’t hate it, but it’s not for me. I liked some songs, Blank Space for example, but many I had forgotten by the time the next song started.
An album of complete filler with the odd bop thrown in.
Trying to have an open mind, welcome to New York not a good start, I had to stop listening this music just is not for me. Nostalgic though
I was surprised by Evermore and enjoyed it very much - this brand of pop pablum with its electro synth and drum machine driven dance rhythms is more what I was expecting. Mot at all my jam, but not entirely annoyong either.
I admit it... I'm something of a cave dweller. This was the first time I'd ever heard anything by Taylor Swift (even the singles (half the album???) were new to me). So, that is to say, I'm reviewing this from a place of true, non-nostalgic neutrality. The verdict: Eh. Right off, I thought the opening synth on 'Welcome to New York' had potential, but it never got off the runway. And that's how I would describe my general feeling with this. Like I was indefinitely taxiing. Waiting in vain for some transcendental experience that never materialized. Nice guitar riff to open 'Style'... never takes off. Nice opening synth on 'Wildest Dreams'... never takes off. Etc. Etc. Etc. And the lyrics? "Vapid" would be putting it mildly. But that's not to say, however, that this hasn't any value. Far from it. I live with a gay bear who, when he's doing yardwork, can draw enormous amounts of energy from this music (or music like this, at any rate... most ultra-produced modern music sounds the same to me, honestly). At any rate, it definitely exudes plenty of catchy, clubby vibes that get the blood pumping. Plus, it's a fairly easy listen if you don't listen too closely or set your expectations too high.
I am not a swiftie, never listened one of her album. But i still got to give her credit for this. Every song is a hit. This is definitely an album that shapes an entire age group.
p938. 2014. 2 stars Shiny and plastic millennium pop with zero passion. Just because something sells well doesn't mean it is good.
Good production.
to me, this album is functionally identical to melodrama. idk if it's bad or if it's just not for me, but either way i really just don't fuck w/ it. although having said that, melodrama did at least have a few interesting instrumentals? this one is playing it woefully safe throughout. for what it's worth, "shake it off" and "blank space" are pretty good. but i did think the latter was by lorde until now, which i guess really isn't helping me separate the two albums in my mind. oh well....
Everything sounds the same
Remember when Taylor Swift was making fun pop music and wasn't just phoning it in?
Probably the highest variance of any album I’ve ever listened to. An incredible amount of amazing singles … and basically everything else is terrible. Enjoyed the one non-single of I Know Places which was a preview of Reputation. Find it really hard to grade … overall a 3 but do I give more credit to the incredible highs and absolute bangers. Lean more towards a 3 given just how bad most of the songs are (welcome to New York may be her worst song?). But an incredible pivot / achievement that led to much higher highs down the road. 3+
Better than Coldplay
I thought one Taylor Swift album was pushing it but now 2?! Wtf?! Is this just the albums teenagers should listen to before they turn 20? Even that's pushing it.
definitely not as bad as i was expecting it to be
Listen have I listed to half of these song a bajillion times against my will. Yes. Did that hamper my enjoyment of the album? Without the aid of alcohol, also yes. I actually did not mind the songs I didn’t know. Unfortunately I am unable to separate my feelings on the matter.
Welcome to New York is a top 5 pop song of all time.
Y'all, it's good. Four flat.
The album was fine and I liked it fine. Taylor Swift's early pop work is likable and his a good turn of phrase. The difficulty I had with this was when it came out. 2014 was supposed to be my time and I feel like I wasted it, and I don't know what to do with or about that. It's heavy and sometimes I feel so numb about it.
Say what you want about Taylor but this is a perfect pop album. The second half is slept on. This Love has an all-timer bridge.
2.5/5 https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/taylor-swift/1989/ Can’t even say I really hate this, as it has its moments (always had a soft spot for Blank Space). But every song just goes on for about one chorus too long, and many of the lyrics are just poor (or, more nicely put, not for me). Also crazy how some songs are just outright copying Robyn, Lana or Haim.
The GOATed industry plant, this album is so shallow and boring. Overly produced and mechanical sounding, lacks any depth or soul. Maybe if I was a teenager this would resonate with me but I am far from the target for this slop. It is just inoffensive over produced radio pop, I know she is a mega star but this is pretty boring
So many bangers… who knew I was a swifty
Probably my favorite Taylor Swift album? I like Style and Out of the Woods
A stone cold classic. Taylor is importantly enough to have more than one album. Not all of them. But this certainly fits the bill. And shake it off is one of the greatest singles of all time.
I look forward to reading reviews by people who've never heard this. Perhaps they were in prison or exiled in nature. Its pop music mastery - propulsive tracks, romance, longing, anger, intrigue, and confessionals, and all so danceable and well sung and that all American smooth twang to a rich full timbre (thanks Taylor for dropping country and perms). Its pure happy pop, memories and energy. Reminds me of the best times and parties and the best childhood moments of our daughters in Erlenbach and it played heavily on our Ischgl holiday to pump the sleepy kinds up in the boot room. Always uplifting. Even when heard through a bluetooth speaker. Everyone knows all the words. the moves. the mood. Side note: there's an edge. I remember her twisted romance stories are slightly concerning - her apparent satisfaction of psychologically torturing her lovers and creating drama revealing the darker side of female jealousy, aggression, attachment and malevolent control. All this makes for great storytelling.
She's pretty impressive Taylor, a shape shifting career, songwriter and what seems to be an extraordinary live performer. Like the other 10 billion homo sapiens walking the planet I know and love Shake it Off, a great ear worm pop song. Listening to a whole album a couple of times, nothing else really stands out, so outside of the pop cultural phenomenon that she is, its just another album of pop songs. Nothing to listen to before you cark it.
Younger work colleagues have teasingly asked me what my favourite Taylor Era is, expecting the middle-aged male to fumble for a relevant answer. But I do have a favourite Taylor Era which is her Pop Era. I was aware of her earlier work but did not relate to her country ingenue records -- they just didn't speak to me, not that they needed to, nothing wrong with that -- but 'We Are Never Getting Together' and 'I Knew You Were Trouble' really caught my ear. I love pop music, and this was really great pop music. Cleverly crafted, upbeat and catchy as hell. I was really pleased when her next record, 1989, leaned fully and explicitly into pop. And wow, what a pop album it is! Ironically, the pop genre allows Swift to be more authentic. She can be a young woman (as opposed to her previous slightly naive ingenue persona, which was starting to wear thin); sexier (without going full Britney or Christina) and more urbane (welcome to New York, indeed) and also more ambitious and no longer willing to be underestimated: “I never miss a beat/ I’m lightning on my feet/ and that’s what they don’t see.” Pop music is by nature artificial, but to be really great it needs to _feel_ real. You have to _believe_ the singer. I would argue that this is the genius paradox of Madonna; I believe every word she sings (her credibility makes her a surprisingly great ballad singer), but almost nothing she says in interviews. Similarly, I believe Taylor Swift on this record. Not necessarily the literal autobiographical truth of every word -- this is a (melo)dramatic narrative containing fragments harvested from her life, but hardly a roman a clef -- but the sentiment is real. She presents here as an ambitious young woman hitting the town, and it rings true. And sounds like enormous fun. She has moved on to explore other directions since this album, which is her artistic right. I'm just glad she made this one complete, genuine, unapologetic, outstanding pop album that I could listen to any day of the week.
Max Martin at it again.
This is Tay Sway's peak. "Shake It Off" is a millennial anthem. "Style" is my favorite from the album. There's some songs I don't like very much but you can easily understand the album's popularity. I could be wrong in my perception of it but this seems to me to be the last time she actually put herself out there as a /singer/. Her singing is a lot softer, a lot less bold, a lot less specific, and she very rarely belts on her later albums the way she used to. Stylistically there's nothing wrong with this. But her artistry seems to me to have become more about "I'm a huge star" than it is about "I'm an impressive singer," to the point where it would be almost startling to hear her do a vocal run today like she does in the lead in to the chorus after the bridge in "Shake It Off." (I have not listened to The Life of a Showgirl so I could be startled!) I'll end with my thoughts on "Wildest Dreams." "Say you'll remember me" is absolutely crushing. The sentiment that she hopes she's remembered by a former love is devastating and relatable. And immediately undermined by the next line and the rest of the chorus, where you realize that she wants him to remember her as hot and perfect and wants to be the star of his wildest dreams. It's so much more profound to admit and exclaim a fear of lost love, a fear you won't be remembered, than it is to dare an ex to realize they messed up by letting you go. And there's a good set of lyrics that can come out of the woman scorned story! Many great songs have come from that. Here, she disguises that desire within a line that evokes the more powerful, vulnerable sentiment of fear and love. For a moment, I hear that pain in the way she sings "Say you'll remember me." And for a moment, I could cry about it. And then it's gone. And that's the real tragedy.