Reviews (page 11 of 15)
I enjoyed it :) don't really remember that many of the songs
Pop radio ready, pop choir here and there; other than the covers, there's pretty much just one song here, David Gray-like. Three versions of that sound were big hits. Half a century later, it's still kind of a yawn.
Couple of good songs but they just sound so old. I can't really get behind listening to them a ton. Appreciate their classics but that's all it is to me.
This is my moms JAM. I feel like I'm 8 years old, driving to harmony house.
Their harmonies are unparalleled, and the hits here (such as "California Dreamin'" and "Monday, Monday") are flawless snapshots of the '60s. That said, there are some filler tracks in there, between covers and otherwise less than notable numbers. Overall, though, it's a cozy listen. Too bad the monster that is John Phillips is involved.
The good ones are sublime, the other ones are good. Mama Cass and Michelle Phillips are amazing vocalists 🤩
Really chill pop music, also nostalgic
A Solid pop album, nothing more.
Muito agradável, atemporal e com músicas extremamente agradáveis sonoramente. Contém o clássico que circula pelo tiktok mas tem outras que são extremamente chiclete que chegam a animar o ambiente
Went back and forth on whether to rate this a 3 or 4, but landing on 4. I can hear mom singing along to California Dreamin’ - major nostalgia factor here!
I was hoping this was better after seeing the initial track listing. A really solid Side 1, and a much more lackluster Side 2. The covers weren’t as good as I expected (Do You Wanna Dance, Spanish Harlem, e.g.). Catch a clip of them on YouTube either at Monterey or on The Ed Sullivan Show. Pretty cool group.
I appreciate, but don’t love, their singing.
It's good, some bangers🔥🔥 I enjoy silly 60s songs ngl
Solid mid 60s album that is unfortunately marred by what we know about the band mates.
There’s some individual songs I like, but not really an album I’d listen to all the way through
From folk-pop hits to messy and disturbing relationships, The Mama's & The Papas music embodies a lot of the culture of the 1960s. While the album feels old now, you can't deny that they made plenty of hits on their debut "If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears". Best Songs: Got a Feelin', California Dreamin', Somebody Groovy Worst Songs: You Baby
very nostalgic one for me.
Some classic songs, and amazing harmonizing. California Dreamin' is an all time great, but other tracks in the first half also have their share of good songwriting and better singing. The album ends on such a terrible note for me though, with 2 of my least favorite songs here ending the album, and the 2 before it being not very memorable
the panning on this music is interesting - guitar and drums on left, lead vocals are central, supporting vocals and strings are to the right - very loud vocals compared to the rest of the sound;
Goes alright. Not my scene, but can respect the impact this music had in its time.
This album really didn't stand out to me. I'm sure it's amazing for it's time, but not for me.
typical hippie shit. 2.8
This has great 1966 energy. You can’t help but like it.
Surprisingly pleasant album. Nothing remarkable but enjoyable throughout. Decent 7
Good feeling oldie music
Boy, this just did not work for me. I tried to get in the right mindset, thinking... "oh these harmonies are good. Oh, the fellow playing the organ has skills..." Nah, never cared a lick about what these people thought about Mondays or California.
1 star rubbish/full 3 stars alright good back ground 5 stars it really caught me, a great experience
I knew a few of these songs going in and was pleasantly surprised. Very good. Not quite a 5 for me but I did consider it.
Pretty cozy, not hooked tho
Classic M&P
Fucking hippies, great album though.
Mama Cass really holds this album together. There are some good arrangements here and the hits are massive. But it’s Mama who makes it gold.
3.5/5 Best Track: California Dreamin'
Einige Hits! Sehr oldschool
Gewoon lekkah
This was good. Easy listening. Great harmonies. I have always wanted to hear more than their big songs. Choice cut: California Dreaming
Pretty cool. I have heard of this artist before, never listened to this album. I do respect them very much, enjoy some of the music.
Man, they did record some amazing pop albums in the 60s!
My mom was born in the year this was released. The Mamas indeed.
This was groovy and had a nice sound! Might return to it.
Not bad, a few songs I recognised!
Hit or miss. Mostly hit though
Great group, great album!
Feels like California Dreamin’ single-handedly got this album on the list, which I can’t argue with - it’s a fantastic song. The rest of the album isn’t bad, but nothing stands out like California Dreamin’ does. It’s perfectly fine, but there’s nothing here that hasn’t been done better elsewhere, imo.
The harmonies are amazing. Very dated now, but it's hard to argue that this is poorly done, even if it's not my favorite thing.
God stemning og relativt kort. Meget Beatles vibes
Bit hippy happy for me California dreamin’
Straight Shooter Got a Feeling’ Do You Wanna Dance California Dreamin’
i cant hear mama cass the same after the snl skit https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2710NcijHY album was fine, i didnt particularly enjoy or dislike it
That's a fun 60's vibe right there. I'll go 3 stars with California Dreamin' doing a fair bit of lifting
Well produced hit making album. 👌
Perfect album. Great musicality and harmonies. Varied influences in their songs. Can listen to whole thing each song is a hit.
Quality AM radio fodder. I appreciate quite a few of their songs, but never got around to formally adding them to my collection. Take a moment to enjoy the light and breezy vibe that comes with the times and try not to get distracted by all the behind-the-scenes weirdness. You'll be fine.
CALIFORNIA DREAMIN
So-so, very dated and not wearing well
6.5/10 Impeccable 60s vibe Clearly influenced by Beatles and Beach Boys Excellent vocals throughout Musically quite split: either uptempo, propulsive, excellent, or somewhat dreary and maybe boring Best: Go Where You Wanna
Mellow album that you can enjoy during a road trip!
Eccellent album overall with the old time classics, Monday Monday and California dreamin'..... Good listening.
Cute, doesn't grab me
Low 3
Cult music vol. 1
Not a fan of music to murder to
Liked this more than I expected to. It’s more mid 60s jangly folk rock but the songs are solid, catchy and I’m a sucker for a harmony. Discovering so many contemporaries of the Beatles is also making me realise more how special they were, considering they basically pioneered this movement and achieved what they did in just 5-6 years. But I enjoyed this one twice and will keep a few highlights on rotation.
Really just one good song. They do have great vocals.
Very classic 60s music. Very enjoyable. Didn't notice how much it sounded so much like the 30s style of music.
Great harmonies and a very unique style.
3.5 I'm a sucker for a good harmony but 2.5 bangers out of 12 tracks does not a masterpiece make.
Pretty good!
💗
The album was NOT mixed for headphone gurlies 😩 (which, I mean, it wasn’t so that is no one’s fault) I really enjoyed the sound of this album - beautiful harmonies, fun melodies, sone really good songs. California Dreamin just simply is an all time classic!
60s fun in the sun vibes. Didn’t loveeeeee it, some songs were pretty boring. Harmonies on every single song slay the boots House down. Liked Monday, monday, and Somebody groovy. California dreaming is obviously one of the best songs of all time Like will listen everyday all day.
Sure some of their hits are great but Ive never been a fan.
Greatest hits with cover filler. Sounds more dated than some of its 1966 peers
Stellar moment in pop history but too soft and too old for me to listen to it regularly
I remembered many of these songs from my childhood. They did not age well. I’ll admit their voices harmonize well. However, their original songs were all pretty whiny about how miserable their life and loves are, and their covers of songs like “Do You Want to Dance,” and “Spanish Harlem” are downright lethargic. Muzak would do a better job. I could listen to a song or two again, but not more without falling asleep.
California Dreamin' - best thing on this album. Thought the rest of the album would be great. Nope. Pedestrian in places, leaning too heavily on Beatles and Beach Boy influences. The harmonies are obvioulsy technically perfect but it doesn't make the best of the women's voices, especially Cass's. Where the Phillips and Doherty's voices are forefronted you get that dead-behind-the-eyes-stalker-nice-boy boyfriend sound which I guess was popular of the time, but not for me. Phillips questioned whether Cass should join the band as he thought her voice might be wrong and her weight would kill their branding. Ironic, that she was the only one to carry on with a decent solo career.
Plastic people. Oh baby now you're such a drag. This is so shiny and polished and bland and happy and superficial and inoffensive. So much so it made me angry. It is also derivative. Do you find the Monkees a bit edgy? Are the Beach Boys a little subversive for you? This is the album for you. Just the most banal, lightweight, pointless un-engaging sack of piffle. 'California dreamin' is a bona fide hit but still a pretty cheesy and jaded one. And how did they mange to such a gutless, souless, off tune version of the usually crisp and jaunty 'The In-crowd'. They should have all got in toilet not the bath.
Interesting journey of the folkies. These cats lived ludicrous lives. Cool harmonies and tight wrecking crew? Backing. I think its big hal blaine on drums. CA dreaming strong non-tull case for flute rock
definition of "okay"
It's a pretty fine album overall that's **really** elevated (by a whole star, even) by the presence of "California Dreamin'". Like, imagine how this album would play without it; imagine if Barry McGuire **did** end up recording it—and y'get it, right? I mean, if all the hype sticker covering the toilet had to bring up was their cover of "I Call Your Name"...
A nice, simple, and groovy collection of pop tunes that have some lovely vocals. Short, but oh so sweet.
The very definition of a 3 – I think all the songs here sound really nice, but there’s only a few real standouts. I think it suffers from the general thing that ‘60s albums tend to do, which is really weird panning that kind of sacrifices the original vision of a song, but it doesn’t make them bad, necessarily. It’s a solid listen, but there’s just not enough to really warrant coming back to a lot of the tracks.
Perfect 60s music with big hits on it. 9/10
Harmony. 9/10
2 gigantic movie hits in California Dreamin and Monday Monday but I also really enjoyed the energy this album brought. 60's albums that manage to bring that happy go lucky vibe while singing about serious subjects are always great. 8/10
Two absolute bangers that defined the 60s and a bunch of wholesome tunes. 7/10
Pure ear candy that doesn't matter.
3/5
Fun album - folksy with songs we all know.
I love "California Dreaming" so so so much but I never want to hear "Rose in Spanish Harlem" again, so it's a tough one to rate. The singing is great. 3.5 rounded down to 3.
Spanish Harlem was incredibly unsettling to me as a child and I never really clocked why and yep as an adult it’s still a kinda creepy song. Everything else is great except The In Crowd
This album is just so comforting! I could listen to it on repeat. Those backing harmonies are so locked in, and the entire recording has a warm feeling to it that really works.
Awesome.
I loved the Mamas and Papas as a teen and still love their sound. Cass Elliot's voice was so pure she could carry the group. They were a power group with fantastic soft rock sounds that still resonate well today.
Great vocals harmonies with nice folk rock backing
Hit parade.
I knew the name and I knew I liked what I'd heard, but I had no idea how many of these songs I knew!
No longer contemporary and not very inspiring except for the two three well-known songs.
Fint album.
❤️❤️❤️
Major slay
I think this album showcases the greatness of The Beatles more than listening to one of their own records does. This album came out in 66' and in my opinion, more or less sounds similar to a lot of the sounds going on in some of the earliest Beatles works. But the thing is, those records came out a few years earlier, and by 1966, the Beatles had released Revolver, and Rubber Soul the year before that. Just compare a song like Taxman, Eleanor Rigby, or Got to Get You Into My Life, to any of the songs on this record. They sound way more modern and varied than anything on this first Mama Papa record. I know people hear The Beatles and they don't hear anything innovative. This is what I'd point them to to compare to. What would you rather listen to in 66'?
California Dreaming is a banger, rest of the album is boring
Classic 60s album!
The Mama’s & the Papa’s represent an era and a whole genre of music from the 60’s. Their music, which can be considered folk-rock and sunshine pop, is iconic for the California hippie vibe. “California Dreamin’” and “Monday, Monday” are smashing hits from this album.
I can understand the importance of this album in music history, but to me it belongs to the past. It will not get a place on my playlist anymore.
About half of these songs have aged into cliche, but just because they’re pretty good.
This album is perfect 60s folk rock, and like so many of their contemporaries, their debut is essentially a greatest hits.
This album answers the question “what if they still wrote doo wop music in the 60s”
Catchy as hell. Great harmonies. But knowing what I know about the group makes it difficult to fully enjoy this album
Not really something I'm gunna revisit, but it's not bad. 60's pop music kinda like the Monkees?
Beautiful vocals. Classic 60s sound. Iconic Album
Great 60s album
Schöne Zeitreise in die 60er.
Slick, easy listening
Apart from the two well-known singles, it's middle 60s pop, nothing to be excited by.
California Dreaming is sublime. Rest I could take or leave.
Beautiful voices, melodies, harmonies
two great ones on here
100 albums be so US dominant caste. The "In" Crowd: nice Motown sound...another appropriation. Sounds different from the rest of the album. This is another one that can play in the background while I work. Won't 'favorite' this or listen again voluntarily, but don't hate it.
hoe lief en poppy het ook mag klinken, wanneer de 34 minuten aanvoelen als een uur (is het album nou nog niet afgelopen??? Nog een nummer????) dan kan het geen goede score opleveren.
Best een leuke plaat. Immens vrolijk maar is dat wel echt zo?
Great album. Monday, Monday being one of my fave late 60's songs. Just ace.
Couple good tracks, but this is just so pedestrian.
An album with both Monday Monday and California Dreamin deserves a decent rating even if the other songs are rather forgettable.
great album. became one of my favourites in 2023 actually! really love the mix of vocals and the sentimental nostalgia it gives me even though i'd never listened to it before. I'm a little sad mixed vocal groups aren't more popular! ps.. just read up on the history of the band........ why can't people just be normal :(
Catchy album. Didn't know them outside of California Dreaming, but there's great harmonies across the board. And cool changes of style from the 60's pop vibe, to a swing.
Classic '60s sound with the harmonies etc... Love this!
Love those harmonizing voices.
Pretty good stuff though some of it didn't age as well as other bits.
B+ Monday, Monday 5 Straight Shooter 4 Got A Feelin' 5 I Call Your Name 5 Do You Wanna Dance 4 Go Where You Wanna Go 3 California Dreamin' 5 Spanish Harlem 4 Somebody Groovy 3 Hey Girl 3 You Baby 3 In Crowd 3 This is a classic 60s album and one of the few albums on here that I own on Vinyl. Hip, hip, hooray!
Very good album definitely represents the 60s sound. California dreamin is one of my favorite songs.
not bad
Westcoast Pop der 60er, schön anzuhören und man kann erahnen, wir unsere Eltern ihre Jugend erlebt und ihre Freiheit genossen haben
It's okay
One of the best!
California Dreamin' is still great, but the rest I find tedious
There wasn't anything wrong with the individual songs, but as an album I didn't get it. I also don't feel like I have an idea of who they are as a band. One minute it feels like 1950's, then 1970's then almost country, and 1960's female blues ballads. But even the cover of the album confused (and made me laugh) me so I guess it all makes sense now...none of it is supposed to make sense!
Wud have gotten a 5 star. But their best is the 16 greatest hits. We know greatest hits aren’t really albums per se. But that one is awesome😀
Banger album. So good when doing chores. Fav song straight shooter
This makes me think of the opening soundtrack to every beach blanket bingo style movie shot in a monochromatic sepia tone, with the band of carefree hippies driving along the PCH in their VW van and bouncing around the beach in the summer sun, playing guitar, throwing the frisbee and smoking weed, just days before the women are brutally slayed by an unknown serial killer who loves to leave calling cards with symbols or word play that the cops can’t figure out. I dig it. Groovy, man.
Unoffensive and..nice. That is not bad qualities for an album but in the end this is very timebound bubblegum pop. A few tracks like California dreamin has a haunting quality that is interesting.
Monday Monday and California Dreaming are great songs but I didn't care for the rest of them. I did not know that this is the original Do You Wanna Dance. I like the Ramones version better. This band is groovy but there are many flavors of groovy. This groovy is a little too vanilla for me or something.
Ah the sweet life giving harmonies of the Mamas and the Papas. I know most of these songs from a compilation I bought a few years ago. Timeless perfection.
Feel-good 60s hippie pop, a pleasant palette cleanser after a week of full-bodied flavors and textures.
I’ve never been a fan of theirs
Oh my word. The harmonies............... THE HARMONIES. A bunch o' messed up people, sure, but what an album. California Dreamin is obviously an automatic 5 - yes, yes, we've all heard it a million times, but it's still as stunning as Michelle.
Pretty good
Pretty enjoyable! I can definitely see my self revisiting this in the future.
Could only recognize california dreaming. The rest is just white noise
Bangin, production, writinng, melodies, tracks, slappin
Some nice harmonies and orchestral arrangements, but this is a miss for me. One revelation: Jens Lekman sampled “Do you wanna dance” in his song “Maple Leaves”.
I can’t believe my eyes quand je vois l’affreuse pochette. Qui affiche ses chiottes sur son premier album? C’est la plus grosse faute de goût d’un album qui en contient très peu. L’inusable “California Dreamin’” assure déjà un beau score à l’album. Le reste est fort sympathique, une ballade dans une atmosphère cotonneuse d’harmonies vocales et d’orchestrations tout en douceur. “Monday Monday” en ouverture, Mama Cass charmante sur “I Call Your Name”, reprise des Beatles, la douceur retro de “Do you wanna dance”. Lovely.
Two very good songs: Monday Monday California Dreamin'
Probably would have been a 4 if I was in a different mood.
It's got that really dated 60's sound that's hard to get past
needs more doo wop
Didn't really like it :)
Not my favourite but good
Great harmonies. Alfa Beatles cover. California Dreamin’ is amazing.
California dreamin' mostly but I've given worse a 4
Enjoyable 3.5
A classic, many hits, pretty dark lyrics on a bed of jangly hippie tunes
Nobody Papas like The Mamas
Excellent album full of recognizable hits.
favorites: monday, monday, got a feelin', do you wanna dance, california dreamin', spanish harlem forever will associate this album with the memory that one of the guys my mom dated gave her this album to culture her with some classic music. i have heard this album more times than i can count
Album #4 Almost 60 years later the harmonies of this group hold up to the thief of time. I have been listening the Mama's and Papa's my entire life and did not realize that Cass Elliot was the vocal powerhouse of this group and the rest were her back up's. I had not listened to this album before today and enjoyed the simple lyrics that represent the era. Post JFK but still holding onto the utopia of post WWII and before the beginning of the end with the onset of Vietnam and the slow steady slide of the US. The harmonization creates an ambiance among the lyrics that gives each song a fluid movement that makes each one unique in it's own right and can hold it's own in the track listing. Each song could have charted if allowed to enter the charts by the music industry but only 3 songs from this album charted, the ones we still hear in the elevators and grocery stores to this day.
Voices and harmony front and center on this one.
Classic 60's sound. Love California Dreaming and recognized a few others, several being covers of other bands. I give it 3 stars.
Good album. California Dreaming is one of the all time best
Personal opinion 4 stars, but I see why it’s a big deal for the time. Cool music overall
loved this album
I can’t believe my eyes and ears bc this album was toooo gooood! Didn’t expect much but absolutely loved it.
Enjoyed 3.2
Muy buen rollero, muy de los 60. Me ha gustado identificar canciones que conozco y así ubicarlas.
Stellar. Made me fall in love with a 300-pound woman. What a voice.
The hits still stand out. The grove is alluring. The harmony is joyful. The sound marks a particular moment in history. How can you not listen to this album and not think of the west coast idea of freedom?
I had high expectations and the harmonies are gorgeous, the two huge hits are evergreen, but overall it has dated and is just another 60s pop album, albeit by talented arrangers and singers.
Very produced. Know some of the songs because of the Ramones.
Horrible band name, terrible album cover-Is a motel bathroom toilet the best backdrop you got? But fantastic harmonies, great arrangements, great album
Hard to rate something this old and pre-rock with today’s ears. 2 really good songs, and another above-average one, great harmonies. Would probably lean to 2.5 if it was an option.
Sounds like every 60s album ever
6/10 California dreamin still a 10/10 song
Nice tambourines in the background - hippie and folky.
There was a song or two that I liked, but overall I found this album really repetitive and boring- which isn't good because I don't really like their sound to begin with.
So very 60’s!
Good album with a couple of great songs
A bit creepy but had a few good songs
Unexpectedly fun.
I listened through three times, and this is the definition of easy listening music to me. That’s not a bad thing, it was great to have on while I worked, the music is solid and the vocals, especially the ladies in the group, were fantastic. Unfortunately it also suffered from not having anything that really stood out to me, while easy listening is a blessing it’s also a curse. The album eventually turned into clichéd 1960s prom music in the background of my activities. While enjoyable, not one of those albums I’d find myself reaching for out of random want.
8/10
Would it be fair to call this a pop album? Really catchy stuff, it hasn’t aged itself too much thankfully (for better or worse. 3.4
I liked it. This album is from my generation and there were a couple of songs that I do net recall ever hearing before.
Classic. I’m still stuck on the three stars though
Pretty songs. I love sixties pop. Beautiful vocal harmonies and absolute classic Wrecking Crew backing tracks.
I really like a lot of the music from the 60s. Simple melodies and easy to listen to. Mamas and Papas had great harmony. Some really good music on this album like California Dreamin and Come Monday.
I admit to having owned this album already for many years, though I think my version had the toilet censored with the graphic box listing the songs within. Overall a great selection of strong melodies.
About what I would have expected. Good album, easy listening. Some well-known classics in there.
Not like I remembered. Definitely could smell the Haight Asbury heroin scene now, not back then though.
Enjoyed it. Felt like it epitomized the 60s. It was a “mood”.
Nice piece of history, doesn't hold up.
Not a big fan
Took me back to my teenage years Lots of classic hits
I liked it!
Songs about sad hippy relationships. It was weirdly enjoyable.
It was nothing astounding but it was a nice album to have on.
Fun listen
Felt like a mix between the Beatles and Todd Rundgreen but also could have just been the sound of that era. Cool but probably wouldn’t listen to again
Fun listen, and some food tunes. Probably won't seek it out, but wouldn't kick it out of bed for eating crackers.
this had their bangers so there’s that. could i write poetry to this? n
Pretty groovy! A subversive call to the Flower Children, wrapped in lush vocal harmonies. Also notable for the presence of "The Wrecking Crew", the studio musicians who actually played the music.
I thought I actually liked The Mamas & The Papas, but boy I did not. Just some real hippy dippy bullshit. Mama Cass has a good voice though.
I was excited when this popped up, thinking it would be a 4 or 5. But after listening to it, it turns out I only enjoy the radio hits and the rest is... Meh
Nice one
they made their time
This doesn’t do a whole lot for me outside of California Dreamin. The harmonies are lovely, of course, but I find the songs to be pretty trite and cover of Spanish Harlem is pretty whitewashed.
Very chill, great harmonies Definitely an album to come back to
Super derivative of beach boys and other pop sensations of the time. Their songwriting is not nearly on the same on this album. I thought a lot of the songs hit a level of irritating as it’s trying to be sweet. California dreaming is good and a classic. 1.5/5
Songs sind z.T. Klassiker. Melodien eingängig. Wieder LMR-Mix. Schlecht für Kopfhörer. Mix so lala.
1960s albums often fall into one of two categories, trying to be the Beatles or sound like a music for a distance time before the Beatles (and the music that influenced them) existed. If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears in the latter. California Dreamin’ is great, one of the most famous songs of all time. The rest sounds like it could be from WW2. Even Monday, Monday isn’t good. 4.3/10
Wonderful 60’s pop. A few tracks are a little dated but most of it is still charming and fun. I love the song “Do You Wanna Dance” and I love hearing ‘new’ versions of it that I didn’t know existed. The Mamas and the Papas do a lovely version. It’s slowed down a bit like the Bette Midler version, which is my personal favorite. “California Dreamin’” is a classic song. It’s an original here but it’s another one of those songs that’s been covered dozens of times. A few years back I got into the Jose Feliciano version. I also really liked “Somebody Groovy” and “The ‘In’ Crowd.”
I love the sound of this band, I always remember them as sounding more cinematic than the standard fare 1960's pop music that was out there. Like the way the first chorus of "Monday, Monday" comes in- it doesn't start on the downbeat of a measure, it's just some perfectly early pick up note that makes the chorus super memorable. It feels slow but in a good way. It feels more organic and less produced, like someone said "let's make the chorus like this because it sounds good", instead of "let's make the chorus like this because it's nice to sing it like this". "Do You Wanna Dance" is a nice version but I think the best is the Beach Boy's boppin version. If you're asking me to dance you better be playing for me some music to bop to. I don't know if maybe this was the version that made the song popular though. "California Dreamin'" is another example of a cinematic sound for me. Maybe because I think I heard it in movies and TV shows and commercials when I was growing up but there's some special quality to it. It's a nice album. I think it's one of my mom's favorite bands so there's no surprise that I like it so much.
Fun, vocal harmonies, magical.
AJ: harmonizing hippies!
Vond t eerste nummer (Monday, Monday) erg toepasselijk brak in de trein 1 januari op maandag ochtend haha. En California dreamin is natuurlijk een banger. Maar de scandal wtf…
Pretty good album with many well-known songs! I feel in general like they must've been a bit behind their time though, this feels more like late 50s music in some ways to me. Another downside is that I get a bit tired of their formula after a while, but it's still held together pretty well so it'll be a 4 for me!
Surprised how little I liked this record. Found it the instrumentation annoying and the whole thing just kind of bland. "Straight Shooter" sounds like someone just tried to copy "Day Tripper" by "The Beatles". Honestly the only song i really liked is the really excellent "California Dreaming", just listen to that and skip the rest.
Viel Country Rumgeheule Wundert mich nicht; dass man nur "Monday Monday" und "California Dreaming" davon kennt
I’m very underwhelmed, one song stands out. That’s it.
pretty good, standard 60s rock, not a bad listen
Good background music. Couple of standouts but the songs largely blend into each other
I was a fan. I be California Dreamin - 9/10
Sounds like the 60s, so nothing too crazy. One of the female singers on the cover looks kind of like Lindsay Lohan. Listening to California Dreamin reminded me of the California lottery ad that featured a version of the song with a choir. It was pretty good.
Overall enjoyable, there’s a few songs I’ll def listen to again 8/10
Solid but not super unique. I guess maybe they were the first to have this particular brand of shuffle-y folky sound, but idk if that’s true and even if so it was mid. 6/10
8/10 - The panning is crazy in the whole album. I loved the vibes of the whole album and would listen to it again.
Didn’t like like half the songs, but California dreaming is good 6.5/10
Just sounds like exactly what I’d expect from 60s pop I guess. Not great, not bad. 5.5/10
I think I could really dig this if not for the way albums from this era were mixed. Such strange panning. It's kind of disorienting. I'm not sure if it's because they were original mono and then split into stereo later or what. Very easy listen with some catchy bits.
grew up on this
Wow. So many beautiful harmonies on one album. “Monday Monday” and “California Dreamin” are two of the best songs of the 1960s, in my opinion. But “Go Where You Wanna Go” really highlights the dysfunction of this volatile foursome. This is a great example of music where it’s difficult to separate the artist(s) from the music. Even though I adore their iconic sound, I can’t hear a Mamas and Papas song without also thinking about how truly dysfunctional a foursome they were. Michelle is the only one still living, and I hope that she’ll get behind a biopic some day.
There are se timeless songs on here but then some very average 60s stuff. The band seemed to be a bunch of weirdos. Would not listen to this album again but maybe a greatest hits album.
Sounds just like the era which I really enjoy. A good, easy listening, catchy, and wholesome record. Listened to it while I waxed my skis the day after Christmas which felt very fitting.
This really is a great album. The production and performance are outstanding, and its infinitely listenable. Its a little corny/dated in 2023, but I think this does deserve a spot on the list. 5/5
The pinnacle sound of the 60's. I really dig the flower power good vibes of this album but lyrically it's nothing impressive. Undeniably influential though. California dreaming is a absolute powerhouse of a song. That flute solo is iconic.
Let's separate the art from the artist on this one. After hearing this album, my first thought is "Why the hell are they posing in a bathtub next to a dirty toilet." Then I realize it's a metaphor. This album has four good songs that wash over the listener, but the rest of the album is just shit. I enjoy songs on this album, but the rest isn't revelatory or terribly interesting. I have always enjoyed "Monday, Monday" but I also feel like the song goes on 30 seconds too log and it can drag. This album probably belongs in the book, but it doesn't mean it's a good album. Sometimes an album can be of its time and serve as an example to others on how music can improve over time.
Cass Elliot carried this band on her back.
Sappy, basic. May have been creative for its day but not interesting now
Another amazing debut, full of great songs with harmonies that stand the test of time. [0093/1001]
California Dreamin' is a certified banger. That song alone earns these poster children for swinging 3 bottles of lube out of 5. 💦💦💦
Classic 60s hit. Good stuff.
Lots of hits!
cowboy music for boring people
i feel bad for the thicc one for having the most awkward expression, I do not know what straight shooter means, spanish harlem sucks hard but the rest is all pretty good, bit dated I guess,
I mean… They got me when I was 15, and made me want to become a time traveller and a hippie. And even tho it is extremely overlistened from my side, occasionally it can still make me cry.
Pretty catchy and cool
I just remember reading about that this album was controversial because of the album cover with the toilet. Sure it's not a nice toilet but being banned is a bit excessive. Anyway the album is OK. Some original songs padded with covers. California Dreamin' is a banger.
Wow, this one is very typical of the era it was made in. Listening to it, I can imagine what it was like to live through the 60's. Baby boomers in their youth, booming economy, relative peace. At the same time, there was so much civil unrest, with the Vietman war raging, high profile deaths and assassinations, I can understand why something so bubbly, cheery, and harmonizing would be appealing to listen to.
In the year 1977 the fbi exploded all pigeons balls off to get the drones set for the 1980
Altijd lastig, zo'n album waarvan je een paar nummers al 100.000 keer gehoord hebt, en de rest nog nooit. Ik vond deze samengestelde familie altijd een heel fijn geluid hebben, direct herkenbaar en volgens mij nog nooit succesvol door een ander groepje nagedaan. En zelf hebben ze ook niet al te lang bestaan. Het is geen gecompliceerde muziek, maar het is wel een mooi potje samenzang, met het al meer dan een halve eeuw grijsgedraaide California Dreaming als hoogtepunt. Een paar van de andere nummers schieten er net naast (vooral Spanish Harlem klinkt voor geen meter), anders had ik waarschijnlijk wel een 5 gegeven.
Volop variatie! Van naar zeurende muziek als “Got A Feeling” naar gedateerde muziek als “Do you wanna dance” naar ‘Lalala Yeah’ in “Somebody Groovy” naar zoetsappige muziek als “You Baby”. En dan komt er op het einde ineens een geinig nummer. Doet mij wat aan Amy Winehouse denken. Dat helpt het album naar de 1,5 ster.
Sommige muziek is tijdloos, andere muziek is gedateerd. Soms komt dat door de opnametechniek (hier klinkt alles ook weer enorm hol, alsof ze in een lege kerk staan), soms door de vorm van de liedjes (tergend traag, achtergrondkoortjes die op de voorgrond staan, wat lullige instrumenten). Dit heeft dat allemaal. De evergreens houden het nog enigszins staande, maar het overgrote deel is echt simpelweg te oud en heeft de tand des tijds niet doorstaan. Te oud, te gedateerd, te saai.
2/5
Solid listen with some great classics.
California Dreamin' is an all time classic. Apart from that mediocre Pop Folk.
California dreamin' was not good enough to redeem my interest in the rest of the album.
калифорния круто и в целом приятно, но не самый яркий альбом
Мне кажется, я таким классическим группам разучился ставить низкие оценки. Ну хорошая музыка, чё бубнить-то...
бэйз
Pues muy bueno. Con Monday, Monday, California Dreamin' and Spanish Harlem. Además de otras canciones que he añadido a mis favoritas. Un 5 en toda regla.
Tveir bangerar, restin frekar ómerkileg.
Just because it's old doesn't mean it's good. This thing is barely holding together sonically. The mixing is offensive. The stereo split to hard left and right is disgusting. (Turns out there is a mono version that immediately doesn't drive me nuts, though it does peak and hiss like crazy.) This has so many Beatles moments (not a good thing) and the Spanish Harlem cover doesn't really improve on the original. California Dreaming is just shy of 3 minutes, and while great, doesn't justify the syrupy sickly nature of the rest of the album.
The best of their best are here and their distinctive harmonies made you know right away you were listening to the Mama's and the Papa's. I always thought that flute solo in California Dreaming was iconic. It really set the mood and tone for a great song. They definitely made their mark in their time and this was an enjoyable listen.
Pretty nice harmonies & overall rather basic, unoffensive music. It's fine, just fine.
Some classic songs on there
Would not have normally picked this one. Great harmonies and neat to realize they sing California dreamin’
good listen, will go in oldies playlist
This is actually a very good album. You can tell that every song is made skillfully and is catchy yet has some elements that surprise you and can even make a song. Pretty enjoyable listen overall.
Another mid tier funk album. It's good.
Contains some of their biggest hits from the 1960s including "Monday, Monday" and "California Dreamin'".
Some great songs, but slowed down in the middle
California Dreamin jumps out obviously, otherwise I thought the album was pretty basic and suffered a little with dating, the sound not being all that polished. Glad to give it a listen but not going back
4.5
I feel like this is exactly what the mid 60s music sounded like outside of The Beatles and The Beach Boys. Some great songs, some ok songs, some covers that were fine. California Dreamin still slaps. 4/5
Pas mauvais mais rien que je trouve particulièrement intéressant
Bonne vibe qui me rappelle le debut des Beatles
Incredible voices, wonderful songs, gorgeous harmonies, what's not to love.
Groovy!
It's really fun to listen to! Do you wanna dance?
Gorgeous 60s music, with (obviously) beautiful vocal harmonies. Favourite tracks: Monday Monday, Do You Wanna Dance, California Dreamin' (a stone cold classic), The "In" Crowd.
I enjoyed this one for the nostalgic sound of growing up listening to this in my parents' cars. The songs still hold up today, though that bubblegum sound doesn't do a whole lot for me on its own anymore. Favorite track: California Dreamin'
bruh i’m feeling the counterculture
Bunch of classic songs. The stereo mix is a bit extreme
1. It's an album that shows what comes after. And it's simply good music, sung with passion and harmony. Also with a straightforward message. 2. Do I give this album higher score because of "California Dreamin"? Yes.
Good album with sold hits.
Fun and poppy
California Dreaming
Was fine
Grooovay
Fín plata, doldið boring samt með tveimur sterkum lögum. Þessi 60's tónlist á það til að vera doldið basic. Sifjaspellið skemmir þetta band alltaf aðeins fyrir mér.