If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears by The Mamas & The Papas

If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears

The Mamas & The Papas

3.43
Rating
29992
Votes
1
2%
2
12%
3
40%
4
34%
5
12%
Distribution

Reviews (page 9 of 15)

Very nice. Good gentle harmonies. Overall a great sound and good music. Really liked it

Are these albums really randomly generated? Because the first track on this album seems like the perfect starting track for a daily album challenge... "Monday, Monday." Always have love "California Dreamin'" and have heard other various Mamas and Papas songs over the years, but this was a first time I sat down and specifically listened to them in one big chunk and my reaction is kind of "meh." The end of the album snuck up on me and all of a sudden Spotify was playing "For What It's Worth" by Buffalo Springfield. I guess it just because background noise. All of the songs just started to sound the same.

another sweet gentle country folk album, It's a comforting listen.

They had a great vocal sound, really full and punchy harmonies combined with some decent (mainly) upbeat songs that makes this kind of music joyous and uplifting. You could say their sound is comparable to the Beach Boys, who also used the wrecking crew, but a bit more folky and possibly a bit more groovy. I saw one review describing them - positively - as scooby doo music and to be honest you could say that about a lot of the mid sixties pop groups, especially in the US. The saturated sound and dense production is pretty cool to these ears.

Calforonia was dreamy the rest, nightmarish

Apart from California Dreamin' this bunch of harmonising hippy grocers don't bring much to the party. Apart from their apostrophes, obvs.

Delightful harmonies and classic covers. Really really enjoyable. I listened to these guys and girls a lot over the years.

Enjoyed much more than I anticipated. I liked the 60s pop, faux-innocence and heart-warming harmonies.

Even if every song on the album sucked, except for California dreamin, it’d still be a 3 because that song is still great. Good album overall. Would listen again. 3.5⭐️

Lovely. I overlooked this album at first due to the title track being a bit dull, but I loved this!

It kind of puts me off when more than half of an album's songs are covers, but California Dreamin' Go where you wanna go and Monday, Monday are enough on their own to elevate this album to a solid 7.5/10. The beautiful harmonies don't hurt either. Fave track: California Dreamin'

Very much of its time

Very decent, classic album with smash 'California Dreamin', which is just one of the best 60s songs.

Ik heb wat in te halen door de Tijdloze Countdown en de kerstvakantie, waar ik dit wat heb laten aanslepen. Dit is het eerste album en mijn god, wat is het typerend om met 'Monday, Monday' te starten op de eerste werkdag. Het klopt allemaal. Luisteren naar de deprimerende teksten over de meest sombere weekdag terwijl de verblindende kantoorlichten weer voor het eerst in twee weken op mijn gelaat schijnen. Ik heb welgeteld zes keer mijn muziek moeten pauzeren om 'beste wensen' te zeggen tegen mijn collega's met de bijhorende, licht geforceerde glimlach. Heerlijk. Gelukkig Nieuwjaar. 3.4

Okay but a little boring. Probably didn't age well

It’s hard to listen to the Mamas & the Papas’ debut with fresh ears; the music sounds like it was produced so many years ago (close to 60 to he precise). In total it If You Can Beliebe Your Eyes & Ears sounds like the house band for Laugh In - groovy music from a former time. It does however contain two of their strongest compositions- “Monday Monday” and “California Dreamin’” which make it worth the trip down memory lane.

Wonderfully dreamy

A few standout tunes, beautiful harmonies and Cass Elliot's velvet voice are all worthy features but as a whole this album doesn't wow me.

One of my most enduring childhood memories is listening to “Monday, Monday” on repeat during Monday morning school runs with my dad. It became our quirky tradition, thanks to one of those sprawling ‘60s compilation CDs he mailordered. Although the collection included a gazillion tracks, we always gravitated toward the one disc featuring two The Mamas and The Papas’ hits. That early exposure gave me a sense of the band’s velvety harmonies and Lou Adler’s lush production, which shine throughout If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears. The album captures the decade’s initial pop idealism, blending folk, pop, and jazz elements into sophisticated arrangements. From the melancholic, harmony-rich waves of “Monday, Monday” to the timeless charm of “California Dreamin’,” the high points remain exhilarating. Cass Elliot shines on the lively “Somebody Groovy,” and the dreamy “Got a Feelin’” shows off the group’s vocal interplay. I even admire the audacity of covering a Lennon/McCartney song (“I Call Your Name”) so soon after The Beatles’ original release. The Wrecking Crew’s tight rhythm section underpins these songs with precision, elevating the orchestrated production and emphasizing John Phillips’ knack for polished yet emotive songwriting. However, not every track has aged as gracefully as others. Songs like “Go Where You Wanna Go” and “You Baby” feel a bit more like period relics, with the instrumentation and arrangements sounding somewhat simplistic and dated compared to the album’s more timeless tracks. These moments lack the same level of sophistication found in the stronger songs, which feels especially evident when placed next to contemporaries like The Beatles or The Beach Boys, who were pushing the boundaries of production and songwriting during the same period. Adding to the album’s intrigue is the tension simmering beneath its polished exterior. By 1966, the group’s interpersonal dynamics were already fraught. John Phillips’ perfectionism clashed with Cass Elliot’s ambitions, and Michelle Phillips’ affair with Denny Doherty caused deep rifts within the band. These internal struggles undoubtedly affected the creative process. The band’s output may have been more consistent or successful without these distractions, but it’s also possible that the tension fueled some of the emotional depth in the music. Remarkably, this chaos didn’t infiltrate the recordings, as the group’s voices remained perfectly synced, with each member’s distinct tone contributing to a cohesive whole. While some tracks may feel tied to their time, If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears stands as a defining moment of ‘60s pop, a testament to the power of harmony—both musical and, fleetingly, personal. It’s a lush and heartfelt snapshot of an era, emblematic of its idealism even as the reality behind the scenes told a much darker story. Did/Do I own this release? No Does this release belong on the list? Sure. Would this release make my personal list? No. Will I be listening to it again? For sure.

Fantastic album.

I really liked this! Maybe not perfect, but a cool album for some good mood music.

i love this album :>

super awesome. straight shootin.

It's pretty good, some good songs

Album 630 of 1001 The Mamas & The Papas - If You Can Believe Your Eyes & Ears (1966) Rating : 5 / 5 They are a long time favorite and I can't really find anything negative to say about this album. There are other genres I get into more but anytime is fine for this. Good harmonies and melodies will get me every time.

This exceeded my expectations. I thought the harmonies were often beautiful and the melodies solid. I won’t seek it out, but new respect to them M&Ps

Solid album with some good songs but they’ve never been a group I’ve listened to a lot. They helped organize Monterey which brought Hendrix back to the US and I met Denny Doherty when he came to speak to my class at Dal so for that I’ll give them a 3.

There were some certified bangers on here but also a few duds. Overall enjoyable.

couple of tunes I already knew but not worth another listen.

The three singles—Go Where You Wanna Go, California Dreamin’-and Straight Shooter are quintessential 60s flower pop. The rest of the album is filler and the covers are done better elsewhere.

Not a fan.

Dreamy, folky, beautiful harmonies. Very beach boys esquié, not in a bad way. It’s music I feel comfort in even though I wouldn’t revisit very often. Wish the mono was released and California dreaming is gold

Harmless. Pleasant enough, and, for the time, not that odd, but it’s very much a product of its time. A couple of odd bits - I call your name sits oddly, there’s some experimental stereo stuff going on, and those bloody apostrophes are ridiculous. Some OK bits as well - I enjoyed Straight Shooter and the hits are obviously well known enough to do the job. But it is all a bit harmless. And feels longer than it is as a result - it just sort of wallows in beige and, sixty years on doesn’t excite me really. I’ve heard worse from the sixties. A lot worse. This is perfectly pleasant, in a polite sort of way.

So I always associate this band with the Zombies and both with standard summer of love fare - but while the Zombies have better singles, the records I heard of theirs were quite terrible, while this band has the singles AND the album fitting quite well together. So far out of the similar contemporary artists, this probably is the best representative record of the genre.

Don't remember much about this other than California Dreamin'

Great music and vocal harmony, takes us back to earlier times. This type of music needs to make a comeback!

Iconic Americana, but had me wishing it was the beach boys instead

Not for me, but I get its historical place.

I’ve always liked the Mamas and the Papas. Such tight harmonies and a dreamy quality to their music. This album contains my favorite, Spanish Harlem.

Stämsång, annars låg verkshöjd.

Det låter så gammalt,! Första ettan!

Best Song: Straight Shooter Worst Song: Spanish Harlem

Beautiful voices and harmonies, half of the tracks I loved, half of them I would skip on a relisten.

So so so so good.

Ну типо, дебютник зе быдлз, но пол и джон стали трансвеститами. Приятный альбом, но ничего примечательного.

Pretty good, I liked this. I’ve heard a couple of their songs before but this was good

I like the Beatles too

Not really my style.

Mamas & The Papas are ALL about the HARD PAN. It was so striking on "Monday, Monday" that I had to research. According to reddit this is the answer: "John Phillips kept bouncing the mixes down to another track each time he’d overdub harmonies. Its the same reason the first Crosby Stills Nash album isn’t a sonic marvel. Bounce downs made the sound weaker and also limited mixing options, which is why the backing tracks are often confined to one channel only." 1950/1960s was also apparently the early days of stereo mixing and professionalizing audio engineers. In early days they could only pan 100% L or R. I know this is incredibly snobby but if I could get my hands on the mono recording it'd be a 3.5 but this stereo recording hurts my head. If I ran the Mama & Papas estate I'd make this my top priority to get my mono recordings to replace this trash.

The uniqueness of the M&P's sound reminds me of Pet Sounds. Not because they’re from the same era in LA, but because they both create an alluring world. Both were complete fabrications and the reality was a lot more drug fueld and generally fucked up, but still a fun listen! Overall love the Mama's and the Papa's and this record. Straight Shooter is a good encapsulation of the paradox of the hippie movement. Its all fun and games/peace and love until you're addicted to heroin. Not so fun fact: Mama Cass died in the same apartment (Harry Nilsson’s) that Keith Moon would die in 4 years later.

Most of this sounds dated, especially the schmaltzy instrumentation. That's not necessarily a criticism of them, just my own taste I guess. Still, other than California Dreaming, many of these songs sound like imitations of Beatles songs of the era that I like better (Straight shooter sounds just like Paperback writer to me) or Beach Boys songs that have stood the test of time better, for whatever reason, maybe just because they were more iconic. Maybe its because the lyrics to these songs tend more toward cliche. While the singing and harmonies are obviously well-executed, harmony for harmony's sake can have the effect of de-personalizing the tone, as it sounds like a crowd of people singing to you rather than the voice of one person telling you how they feel.

I have an undeniable love for late 60s music and The Mamas & The Papas are one of my favorites. Its very rare to find music like this after the 60s/70s. I love the incredible vocal harmonies and instrumentation. Pop Goes The 60s is a fantastic youtube channel for exploring the history of bands like this. Check out part 1 of the series on the mamas and papas: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dcks6j3FXcw

I love the Mamas and the Papas. Such gorgeous harmonies. Some obvious hits on this album that already get this to 4 stars for me, but also loved some deeper cuts I hadn't heard (e.g. Do You Wanna Dance) Miss you Mama Cass. God damn that ham sandwich

Kind of wrote this off on first listen as a corny, generic sound like the Monkees. But on second listen, there’s more complexity to the tunes, some interesting chord progressions and overall spooky 60s vibes. Really playing with the stereo panning and reverb. I love it and this is definitely getting some replay. Highlights, hard to choose: Shooter, California, Groovy, In Crowd. So cohesive as an album. Barely on my radar as a group, but now know they were huge in that Laurel Canyon scene. Really interesting to read and learn about. One thing worth sharing: When Elliot Cass died of a heart attack with no drugs in her system, her manager told the press that she died by choking on a ham sandwich so no one would wrongfully say she died from an overdose. I watched a doc on Laurel Canyon today as well - a must watch for anyone into CSNY, Joni, etc. - paternity leave is a beautiful thing.

Like so many of these bands from way back I mostly know them through their hits. I've always liked 'California Dreamin' but for some reason I've never listened to pretty much anything else from "The Mammas & The Papas". Now that I have it turns out that I actually like it quite a bit Standouts California Dreamin' Somebody Groovy The "In" Crowd 4/5

So nostalgischer Klang und viel Chor, klingt so gut

8/10. California dreamin is one of the best songs ever written. The album encapsulates the sixties movement and is a nice easy listening album to throw on during a nice summer evening.

This is a prime reason why pop sucks. It gets SOOOOOO dated. 1/5

I have never listened to this album prior, but I was familiar with California Dreamin’, of course. My favorite song on the album is Monday, Monday and my least favorite would be Got A Feelin’. I would listen to some of the songs again. I love the album cover.

Loved the back to back 60’s albums. Again, there wasn’t a song I didn’t like so I won’t list the stand outs. All in all it was a great album if you like this era of music

Something I quite liked about this, which was unexpected. If I was around during the 60’s/70’s in America, this would probably have been the soundtrack to me joining a desert cult in California or Arizona. I’d like to think I’d get out before the killing and mass suicide years, but with nice music like this I’m not totally convinced I’d have had the autonomy to call it quits. If I did do something terrible, at least the soundtrack would have been lovely and warm. The above was written before I’d even got to California Dreamin’. I’d have definitely been culting for the long haul.

If lemon Fanta was an album, this would be it. Light, fun and almost sickeningly pleasant to listen to.. and before I knew it, I'd drank the whole 2 litre bottle. I went into this album without any prior knowledge or expectation.. but happily basked in the audible warmth of this sunshine pop.. almost to the point my skin started to crisp, and I wanted to get in the shade for a little bit. You can absolutely tell this album was made in the 60s, a more carefree and liberating time.. before Tom Hanks brought MAGA caps and AIDs to America decades later. This album felt like the musical equivalent to Fuaadh. In the unlikely event anybody reading this doesn't know who Fuaadh is, I'll briefly explain. Fuaadh is someone who has won the lottery of life, in the sense that he genuinely and sincerely, always seems happy. He's a boy born with a puppy's brain.. and I mean that in a totally complimentary fashion, and not as the title of a failed Channel 4 documentary. He likes humping stuff, chasing balls and is always happy. This album, is akin to just that. Now admittedly I'm too self-deprecating and predictably miserable by comparison to appreciate an album that is this objectively happy, in its absolute totality. From time to time I like a more sombre or introspective change of pace. More of a me problem than The Mamas and Papas.. although, it is just easier to blame your parents for your inherent shortcomings, and so, I'm rating them 4/5 stars.. they just cuddled and high-fived me a little too much throughout this album.

Very forgettable. Not don't understand why it made the list. Two decent/good songs in 'Monday, Monday' and 'California Dreaming'. Wasn't shit. Just wasn't good either.

When I was a kid, California Dreaming and Dream a Little Dream of Me seemed like the most white bread, wholesome ditties from across the pond, and if you take them purely on their own merit, they are. But once you start to delve into the love triangles, and the drug addled, sex crazed, debauchery of the group, a dark shadow is cast over their otherwise whimsical pop legacy. Monday, Monday, California Dreaming, and In Crowd are all stand outs. Well written pop of the highest order. Got A Feelin’ is almost a lullaby with it's tiny bell chimes, and ticking clocks. You Baby has some great oohs and ahhs, it's Beach Boys-esque. But let's address the elephant in the room. Incest. We all know you did it John. A close friend said he'd like to drag John Phillips out of his crypt and kick the crap out of him. The story goes he desperately tried to stop his daughter's wedding the night before, and that's when they started their sickening 10 year union. The M’s and The P’s had a song called Young Girls are Coming to the Canyon, Michelle Phillips used to say “yeah and you've fucked them all John”. I'm sorry but it's all too horrible for this listener. If I want nice harmonies and whimsy, of this era, and in this rudimentary style, I'm picking The Monkees. Davy Jones and Mike Nesbitt would never defile their daughters.

didnt realise how weird that guy richard was

# Playlist Track - California Dreamin' # Notes - What is the deal with that cover?! 😁 - Cool vibes, impressive harmonies! - A pleasant listen through and through. Super cool that is their first album, too!

California dreamin’ is a 100000/10 song maybe higher, it’s one I attribute to an ex crush, I don’t know why but it’s just interesting how music can bring you to a certain time and place in your life. Hey girl and go where you wanna go were other highlights to me , Monday Monday is good but I don’t think it’s amazing the key success to the mama’s and papa’s is Mama cass who has this iconic haunting voice which makes every song work. It’s easy to group this in the same group as all the other iconic 60’s albums but considering the best bits come post 67 this is good for it’s time, a bit dated but solid 4/5

Good in places

can trust it.

Very nice, very 60s, comfy musics!

It's fine to take your daughter to the fairground or buy her some shoes every now and then, but maybe leave it at that.

like i guess. good background noise

It was pretty alright, nothing jumped out at me but it’s an enjoyable listen for sure. California Dreamin is an absolute all timer. Do you Wanna Dance beach boys cover??

Love Monday, Monday, BUT, is it too long of a song? Very short album too!

A lot of good radio songs

Some classics for sure and great harmonies

The use of stereo is interesting but at risk of overdoing it in this. There's a couple of memorable tracks but nothing totally novel you'd be richer for hearing.

I hadn’t listened to a whole record from the before. I got more and more into it as it went along. One of those bands that I know from just a song or two that were overplayed but are better when you listen to the bigger output.

if I was getting kidnapped and tortured, I'd want this to be playing

Trite 60s pop made by at least one absolutely terrible person. California Dreamin' is a pretty good song and I can see why Monday, Monday was popular.

1966. Los Angeles. Folk rock, sunshine pop / pop rock, pop, soul

Those harmonies, my god. They elevate even the most middle-of-the-road cuts.

Really nice Californian style with great harmonies and arrangements. This was their first album and they had not quite realised what they had with Mama Cass so it is focused on the male voice with mainly female backing harmonies except for a couple of tracks. The harmonies aren't really "backing" since they are so much part of the songs. Some nice and some bad instrumentation choices but generally a really nice album.

Great album I enjoyed this a lot. Very warm, the craft and care of 60’s songwriting coming through. For 1966 this feels quite innovative - certainly up there with some of the Beatles studio work. Love the layers, they mean every second.

The hits — “Monday Monday” and “California Dreaming” — are among the best songs ever, but most of the rest drag a little. Still, with those two it can’t be less than a 4.

Playschool music. Pom pom pom pom. California Dreamin is nice.

A classic, always a good listening, like in every classic :-)

This is a signature sound. You can see the times, the place, and the sweet hopes and wishes…

This album serves as a bridge between Motown and the hazy psychedelic influence of the 60s. The production is what sets this apart from being just another sunshine pop album, integrating the reverb and swirls of psychedelia. 3.5 / 5

A few good tracks but not a huge fan of the 60s sound.

One of my favorite albums of the 60's, whether you can see the toilet or not! (IYKYK)

There's a couple of iconic songs on here (Monday, Monday... California Dreamin'), but otherwise I found the album pretty forgettable. Not bad, but I won't seek it out again.

The harmonies of the four members are just out of this world. The way that their voices blend with one another, whether it be standard three or four-part harmony with a lead vocal, or the call and response between the two male singers and the two female singers, such as on California Dreaming, is just incredible. I'm not sure if there has ever been a better matched vocal band group out there.

22/11/24 It was an alright album.

Another one of those albums that I had heard the singles, but never heard the album, and honestly didn't even know who the artists were. I quite enjoyed it while riding my bike to and from work and will listen to it again

12 songs, 34 minutes, yes please! 11 of those 12 are not bad, but California Dreamin’ is great and earns this a 4 all on its own

California Dreaming is a choon. You can’t not bop to that. Not much else really grabbing me. But a nice solid 34mins. So can’t complain too much. Simpsons: No

California Dreamin' is brilliant. The rest was OK, and a lot of covers I believe.

I listened to this ages ago and forgot to rate it; a second listen doesn't help it. Thankfully, it was quite short

Solid 4, maybe it's nostalgia but I like the vibes. California Dreaming is one of those songs that sound timeless

I enjoyed both singles and Mama Cassé letting rip on “The In Crowd” but the rest sounded pretty twee to my ears.

1. monday - 2 2. zhooter - 1 3. feeling - 1.5 4. name - 1 5. dance - 1 6. go - 1 7. california - 3.5 8. harlem - 1.5 9. groovy - 1 10. girl - 1 11. baby - 1 12. in - 1.5

Love California Dreaming, but the rest is twee and bland. The vocal separation to different channels is understandable for the time, but it really sucks. It's well sung I suppose, but the material and musical arrangements are nothing special. I'm going with 2 stars, as I didn't hate it, there were one or two good tracks, but I'm never going to listen to this again if I can help it, and the remaining 10 tracks were just an instantly forgettable blur of saccharine nonsense. Some of it felt like it would belong on a parody album, which I think I would have given a higher score to, maybe a 3.

Está guay...

Warm, enchanting, earthy, nostalgic 60s romance

The music of the 1960’s and 1970’s emphasized musicianship, songwriting and vocal excellence and harmony. It’s not easy to be great in all of these aspects but this band was. This album exemplifies these qualities and produced a signature sound and hits that have lasted close to six decades and still inspire young musicians.

I'd never listened to an entire album by these guys but found myself enjoying it quite a bit!

The album has its moments, but it doesn’t quite live up to its iconic reputation. While "Monday, Monday" and "California Dreamin’" are undeniably catchy, much of the album feels repetitive and lacks the same spark. It’s fine as a piece of 60s nostalgia, but it doesn’t hold up as a must-listen today.

I remember my mom having this album when I was very young. I thought their name was hysterical, and the songs just horrible. Listening to this album now I can truly appreciate how huge this must have been when it was released. Powerful vocals and timeless harmonies.

Beautiful Album filled with masterpiece songs.

Enthält zwei Super-Ohrwürmer: Monday, Monday und California Dreaming Sonst ganz gut, melodisch, Flower-Power

Great vocal harmonies throughout, at its best when the songs have some bite

Ah, the siren’s song of the hippie movement. Hard to hate this one. Mama Cass was a treasure. She’s the best thing here. What’s funny is that this record is essentially just a jazzed up Peter, Paul & Mary. It’s all super pretty harmonies, gentle orchestration and classic covers. Nothing even remotely radical. It’s lighter than liteFM. It’s what the parents of the hippies would have liked. It’s music by kids who grew up watching Lawrence Welk, and then smoked some reefer in high school. How this managed to inspire a generation to throw off the shackles of a nice, secure middle class life, I will never understand. But here we are. Thanks for ruining everything, ya filthy hippies. That said, this is fine. As per usual at the time, the guys sing too much.

monday monday isch huuuere geil. sie so guet im badaaa badaaaa mache aber echt. ich weiss nöd was sie meined mit straight shooter. aber song slaaaappt. got a feelin fallt chli ab noch dene zwei banger I call your name isch au chli harmlos jetz im verglich. do you wanna dance. jo s goht gad. aber de song isch no cute. sie mega stereo time. nüt isch ide mitti. go where you wanna go isch coool. ALL THE LEAVES SIND BRUUUUUUN. automatischs vieri de song. ziitlos. hammer. spanish harlem arschhhh hahahah. aso cute aber jääääh. somebody groovy sehr cool und uuuultra 60er haha e person als groovy bezeichne chönt nöd 2 johr früener oder spöter sii. hey girl isch au chli arsch lol. aso sie singed super. aber jooo. you baby isch etz au keis meisterwerk. in crowd wieder super, lieb de bass. drums au geil und sie singed geeeil.

ahh e ziit lang han ich das album huere gsuchtet hahahah monday riese bop every other day every other dayy overy other day EVERY OTHER DAAY OF THE WEEK IS FIIIIIINNNNE YEAAAAAAA straight shooter hani immer mega beatles gfunde got a feelin hani garnümme ufem schirm gha I call your name isch soo geil es isch nüt komplizierts oder so aber eifach de taktwechsel findi suuper iwie schaffeds halt au ihres acappella züg nöd zu cheesy z mache (find ich?) do you wanna dance mega beach boys hüfig hend sie au eifach en part wo für mich megaaa ussesticht wie zB YOOOUUU DON'T UNDERSTAAAAAAND bi go where you wanna go jaa california dreamin isch halt en riese hit ANNELIESE BROWN hahahs mis mami het spanish harlem gaar nöd gern, ich cheggs au aber ich LIEBS somebody groovy git denn wieder chli meh gäse würkli das album isch eifach happiness pur you baby isch megaa cheesy, halt mega de 60er pop "they say candy is sweet but it just can't compete with you baby"😭 d lieder sind echt ultraaa churz und flüged ah eim verbii the in crowd lauft mier so hüfig na wenns um ingroup gaht (brubaker) joo ich lieb das album, git waahrsch es 5i, sehr fest us nostalgie gründ aber ich finds halt würkli es mega churzeiiligs und guets album

Не понравилась такая музыка.

I kind of get sick of the sort of folk bubblegum pop from the 60s. It's just super lame. I mean I guess I see the appeal of it as something that's easy to listen to and won't challenge you at all but that's not really something I enjoy much. This being hailed as one of the best albums ever recorded is so strange to me - it sounds like countless other albums from the mid 60s. I was glad when it was over. 2/5

Monday, Monday: Very interesting, accurate since I am listening to this on a Monday, kinda folk music, actually kinda cool

A lot like ABBA, who I also don't really like. Too upbeat and groovy for my tastes, and I don't mean groovy like "has a groove" I mean it like 60s.

Folkish sunshine pop from the mid-60s but behind some of the easy sounding songs, there is some looming melancholy which I like. The music is just ok, but the vocal harmonies are amazing and so pleasing to listen to. The two megahits are outstanding, 'California Dreamin' is still one of the signature songs of the decade. It's a fun and good listen and a very good debut album by the band. Other songs I enjoyed a lot: Straight shooter, I call your name (a Beatles cover), Go where you wanna go, Somebody groovy.

This band is weird. Melodically is a bit repetitive but their voices are amazing together (we all know why). I appreciate their music a lot.

Classic, good album. Didn't leap to my feet or anything but it was good

Great album, awful people.

I guess I always assumed all The Mamas and the Papas songs would be as good as California Dreamin' but I had never really listened to much else. Well unfortunately the rest of this album anyway didn't do much for me. But oddly enough for the first time in my life did I accidentally hear "and I pretend to pray" instead of "and I began to pray" and apparently it was originally supposed to be "pretend" but Mama Cass sang the wrong lyric. I'm not sure how I heard "pretend" but it's strange that I did and then read about the lyric switch.

Good classic music

Simple, happy music, good harmonies but needed better engineering.

Really liked this!! I feel like there’s always some darkness behind this sunshiny kinda music, and I like that a lot - California Dreamin’ is prime example of that! Also never knew that Jens Lekman’s Maple Leaves was built on a sample but I learned that listening to this! And that’s one of my all time fav songs!

I had the same Jen's Lekman realization that nick did! Cool album!

it is really pretty but does get a bit boring and repetitive

One of the GOATs

These arrangements are upsettingly beautiful.

California folk rock.

Groovy ✌️

Fun. Nostalgic. But a little too old-school for me.

Go Where You Wanna Go

If it were for pure nostalgia, I'd give this a five. But apart from the two standouts and the singers' performance this is an overall average album, with some covers that are close to terrible. Unfortunately, this kind of music soon became carrier for all kinds of memorable advertisements, which makes it hard to listen to without spontaneous imagining of toothbrushes. Has ages pretty badly.

Fun folk rock

Not a bad album, but only a couple of songs I really got into

It's a classic. I don't know if it's possible to dislike those harmonies.

Niin pehmoista menoa, että huomaa kyseessä olevan ns. vanhan albumin. Ei kiinnostellut mikään kappaleista.

Monday, Monday 3.8 Straight Shooter 3.6 Got a Feelin' 3.4 I Call Your Name 3.6 Do You Wanna Dance 3.8 Go Where You Wanna Go 3.5 California Dreamin' 4 Spanish Harlem 3.4 Somebody Groovy 3.5 Hey Girl 3.6 You Baby 3.4 The 'In' Crowd 3.5 Score: 3.591666667

California Dreamin' is obviously great, but the ret was just okay.

Classic California folk rock album. John Phillips is a brilliant songwriter and it shows on this entire piece of work. Song Highlights: Monday, Monday Got A Feelin' Go Where You Wanna Go California Dreamin' Spanish Harlem 4.5/5 which turns into a 5.

One of the oldest sounding oldies groups for sure. I find their music mostly boring, but California Dreamin is really, really good. I also really enjoyed I Call Your Name, a song new to me.

jukebox bangers, nöd alltagstauglich though california dreamin aber en absolute banger

60s folk pop sounds of its time but still just as great. All beautifully written, very Beatles Esk twangy guitar lines and a cover of I Call Your Name. Stand out tracks: - Monday Monday - Straight Shooter - California Dreamin' - Somebody Groovy - The "In" Crowd

Enjoyable with the classics thrown in

First off……what a horrible album cover. Could they have at least cropped out the toilet?? And the facial expressions certainly tell a story…..only Cass looks happy. And John looks pissed off at the world. The three classic songs aside…..much of this album sounds like bad elevator music. Ick.

Well crafted 1960’s record honestly one of the best vocals groups to ever do it. Hits constant throughout, the flow moves perfectly through the tracks. Could have never been better.

A group I know and like.

Trist skiva som går i slowmotion. Inte ens California Dreamin är speciellt bra. 60- talet är inte speciellt bra. De orkar inte ens få till peppiga Yeah. Det låter som de tycker det är lika tråkigt att sjunga musiken som det är att lyssna på den. Det räcker nu!

CD är ju snorbra. Även den andra hiten, Monday monday är bra. Resten. Nej, som vanligt är det milsvida skillnad. Fattar inte.

California dreamin’ är verkligen svinbra och fanns en eller ett par till hyfsade dängor, men i övrigt var det inget som väckte särskilt mycket inom mig. Det är inte dåligt, men bara så slätstruket sextiotalstrist.

Yeah kind of nice but nothing stood out for me

I liked it. Mainly California dreaming

Not the kinks

милые и знакомые, впечатляет сколько из них хитов пошло. но надо намного больше слушать чтобы зацепило

They sound so wholesome!

Unmemorable, beatles soundalike

Magical nostalgia of a time I didn’t live

3/5 Liked California Dreamin

A good debut album. Two lasting orignal hits in Monday, Monday and California Dreamin'. The plentiful covers were okay - their versions didn't do anything better than their respective original versions.

Favorite songs: California Dreamin' I Call your Name

Really good! Pretty, and sweet. Strange listening to such a pretty album knowing some of the crazy stories about the band that created it. My top 3: 3. Go Where You Wanna Go 2. Straight Shooter 1. I Call Your Name

love it when hits hit after hit

Me encantó, me pareció un discazo y que además es de estos que te transmiten a la época. Me hizo sentir el final de su década a todo lo que da, con la llegada de lo nuevo y el abrazo a lo clásico. Amé.

Beautiful vocal harmonies, warm production and fun. This album is better than most other 60's records I've heard thus far. Really happy with the runtime too.

California Dreaming and Monday Monday are definitely the standouts here. The rest of the songs I could kinda take or leave. Definitely not the most impressive or innovative 60s record

3.8 - Easy listening goodness, but not much more than that honestly.

Fine, but a bit too clean. California Dreamin' is clearly the stand-out as expected. The rest of the tracks have some nice moments but really nothing special. 3.3/5

This is just one of a million different lame mid-sixties folk groups that happened to hit it big by tie dyeing their beatnik wear and hiring the Wrecking Crew to play super dumbed down easy listening electrified folk rock behind them. This is just slightly less lame Sonny & Cher. The only counterpoint to that is the fact that "California Dreamin'" and "Monday, Monday" are undeniably great songs.

I Think it was Nice and obviously well made. It had some good ones not all will be my kind og Music. I Think there was something about it when they sang together that made it Sound very old. Still good tho - no sending that.

Nice pop rock sweetness

Solid album! I think that I am a fan. I can't imagine what the world was like when this came out.

Some good classics

How perfect for this to be dropped on a Monday.. with the first song being “Monday, Monday”!! Love this album. Definitely a classic. Easy listening and catchy tunes.

Good album.

maybe white ppl can make music 10/10

Giants of my youth. Gotta admit that I was fascinated with Cass’s size. She was perhaps the fattest famous person I’d ever seen. Why that bothered my 5 year old self is beyond me, but I’d stare at the album cover for hours. My dad was a big fan, and these stoners helped usher in his hippy days. We went from crew cuts to shoulder length overnight, and I was complaining. My dad loved to harmonize along to the music. It seemed to be some of his happiest moments. I’m not really a fan, but it’s always nice to trip down the old brain lane.

This is the type of music I think of when I think of the 60s.

Some classic songs, but not to appealing overall.

Love it!

Now this I can get down to listening to during a afternoon or cooking…

This captured the best Beatles vibes but better as there are women. Favourite track: Straight Shooter.

I LOVED this. These guys aren't new to me, but I haven't heard this full album before. So iconic. I didn't realize The Beach Boys' song 'Do You Wanna Dance' was actually written by Bobby Freeman and covered by both bands. Very cool Love both versions. There were a couple of songs that felt less strong but I can't remember what they were because I listened to it yesterday.. but what I did remember was great.

Man this is a fucking classic I've had an absolutely mental couple days but holy shit does this feel like a warm hug to get back to. I'm not gonna name specific tracks, it's too consistantly good and im way too delirious.

Monday Monday and California Dreamin - mega influential. Beatles-like in some ways, but the two songs at the top are there for a reason

This isn't exactly the kind of oldies I go back to regularly (more of a Motown and classic rock kind of guy) but I'd be liar if songs like California Dreamin' and Straight Shooter aren't classics. The harmonies and production are on point but it doesn't change the fact that this isn't my thing.

Surprisingly good. First time hearing to this band. Favrorite track: California Dreamin other picks: straight shooter, spanish harlem, somebody groovy

Good vibes.

beginning was beatles vibes. Then it got to california dreaming and vibe totally changed.

Okay I get it this album is 58 years old, the songs are well crafted, but I prefer the Ramones cover of Do You Wanna Dance. Overall it fine, but a little too poppy for me.

“California Dreamin’” is a great song, the rest of the album doesn’t do much for me. Super saccharine stuff, way too many orchestral flourishes for me.

Ugh, I have never liked the Mama's and the Papa's. This album is no different.

2024-09-04...

Fun listen! Faves: Monday Monday, Go Where You Wanna Go, California Dreamin’, Spanish Harlem

Just good, clean fun.

Bullshit

Better than I expected

Not its fault, but it's very dated/old fashioned. No real concept of the album being one cohesive unit.

Thoroughly enjoyable

Good asf

Clean harmonies that ring out, that whimsical psychedelic atmosphere, and lyrics with a bit of a subversive undertone. About as good as 60s groups of this time get for me. California Dreaming is so representative of the sound and feeling of the era. The album offers a lot for only 35 minutes of your time. Very well put together.

Lots of classic songs on this. Not bad at all.

Wonderful.

Started out ok but ended up liking it a bit less close the the end. Besides the big hit, 2 more songs were saved.

Only added two songs to my Playlist.

Not my type of music.

"California Dreaming" is the best song on this album, and the rest are only ok. Beautiful harmonies but meh songs overall.

An outstanding 60’s record. Monday Monday and California Dreamibg are two of the best singles from the era, and every track is at least great.

Måske ikke den mest spændende Nick Cave

Didn't really listen that intently but boring, 2.1.

reminds me of growing up and hearing my mom play The Mamas & The Papas on the stereo while she was mopping <3 i really liked it!

this was decent but i had absolutely zero nostalgia of this group to fall back on. california dreamin' is the best song on here by a country mile, but at least the others were fine and fairly short. also, this album cover is driving me crazy. why on earth would you pluralize mamas and papas with apostrophes???? favorites: monday monday, california dreamin

Pues muy bueno. Con Monday, Monday, California Dreamin' and Spanish Harlem. Además de otras canciones que he añadido a mis favoritas. Un 5 en toda regla.

Such a strong debut album filled with awesome harmonies! Nobody ever quite wrote songs and performed them quite the way the Mama and Papas did. They do a fine job of walking a very careful line between somber and self-reflective and never fall entirely into the entirely too easy morose. An album filled with hooks that leave you humming all day. Undeniable all-time classics in "Monday, Monday", "Go Where You Wanna Go", and "California Dreamin'". Fantastic takes on covers of "I Call Your Name" by Lennon and McCartney, "Do You Wanna Dance" by Bobby Freeman, and "Spanish Harlem" by Leiber and Spector.

Classic 60’s songs, with Mama Cass’s amazing vocals. Loved it.

They're okay, but too sixties.

man this was awesome. really unexpected

One great song, one very good song, and the rest... simply good with a lot of covers. 7 out of 10, rounding down.

Pretty enjoyable. No notes

The hits are very good. They seem to be of two minds here. Some neat progressive modern harmonic songs intermixed with more dated sounded bubblegum hymnal type music

Love this album. Such a 60s sounds that hold up after all these years

I think instead of these four, Mama Cass should make her own kind of music!

Good album

I was expecting more from such an established name in music history. Regardless can't change my rule that all child-fuckers get 1 star.

Otroliga vocals, men blev lite repetitivt efter ett tag. Bara California Dreamin som sticker ut

Great album love it

Classic.

Really nice little album - 60s acoustic vibes

This album is really boring im sorry

I was familiar with this album and have played California Dreaming on repeat! But other than Got a Feelin’ I can’t say I like the album, even as much as I enjoy the band’s style of music and harmonizing. It is really redundant and gets old rather quickly.

It's okay

90% do álbum é música de fundo pra viver a vida, os outros 10% são músicas ok, mas que você ouve e depois já esquece. Melhor Música: Spanish Harlem, You Baby. Pior Música: N/A 2.0/5

Can totally appreciate the writing and arrangements on this record. Just of a different time period and prob not much that would bring me back for a second listen. California Dreaming is going on the 1001 playlist though

Wonderful harmonies!!!

POV: you're a hippie taking a roadtrip throughout the US in the late 60s/early 70s. Favorites: California Dreams and Spanish Harlem. Monday, monday is good too.

Sounded exactly like what I expected it would

Enjoyable.

Ummm… so, this was an interesting listen! I can totally see how it was popular in the 1960s; it really is twist-your-leg type of music. However, unfortunately, it has not really survived the test of time! California Dreamin’ is iconic and really provided a midway through pick me up. However, the rest of the album was boring, a bit cringe and just not my vibe! I don’t think I’d really mind if I never heard any of these songs again! Feels harsh but #sorrynotsorry 🫣😂

Very Fallout vibes. This is how I imagine most music before The Beatles! Some cute songs, Monday and California dreaming

Fun album! Lots of their classic hits here.

Thankfully short. Hard to believe this was considered hip at the time.

superb throughout Monday Monday and California dreamin the big hits never failing to hit the spot, only down in the album was do you wanna dance prefer cliff Richards version but great album.

If you had to demonstrate what the 60s sounded like to an alien you might choose this. Classic 60s vibes bottled up. But they sound great and they are the banner holder for a reason. Constantly toying with the R/L stereo kind of fucks me up. Calfornia Dreamin’ is my go to track for making sure my speakers are both working. I enjoyed this more than I thought I would though.

let’s copy the beetles and beach boys at the same time

76% Best: Monday, Monday; Straight Shooter; California Dreamin'; The "In" Crowd Must-Hear? Not quite

Lots of album separation quite nice - just a mellow album. Not really very memorable.

Not really my thing, but very well done even so.

One of the best album covers in existence

If you can believe your eyes and ears, The Mamas & The Papas are here to assuage your fears. People often forget how much of a groundbreaking group they were, in large part due to what happened to most of them afterward, damning or otherwise. But this debut record encapsulates what they were all about in the midway point of a decade of incredible change, when any and all things seemed possible. The Mamas and The Papas, regardless of how you may have felt before, would certainly make you believe in the sights and sounds. Favorites: Monday, Monday, Straight Shooter, Do You Wanna Dance, Spanish Harlem, Somebody Groovy, Hey Girl, The "In" Crowd.

This is decent, but John Phillips is probably a sex pest, so 2.5 stars for you!

don’t listen but love them

Got some good hits. 60s classic

Monday, Monday

The Mama's and the Papa's successfully blended folk and pop in an era that seemed to be dominated by either the Brit invasion sound of The Beatles, the surfer sound of The Beach Boys, or Motown. While there are a few tracks on here that are sleepy and boring, you can't deny their incredible harmonies and the absolute the genius of what is clearly their best song, California Dreamin'.

This is the stereotype for hippie flower child music. It was ok

It was a lovely throwback - unfortunately I was having an autistic meltdown while listening to it. That may have coloured my review slightly.

Enjoyed this. Saved for listening again.

Excellent debut album by this group with a troubled history. Four talented vocalists and some great, timeless songs on this album including "California Dreaming" and "Monday, Monday" Some good covers too like "Spanish Harlem". A 4 rating just because of the timeless songs.

it opens with monday, monday <3 Love me some mamas and the papas, but never heard an album of theirs as a whole. Very sad all the shit that was slung at Mama Cass. A few covers here, which was happening a lot in the 60s, but loved hearing the harmonies these guys added to these songs; fresh takes. 4* Highlights: monday monday, california dreamin, go where you wanna go, spanish harlem

A surprise for me: that the album that contains "California Dreamin'" and "Monday, Monday" is otherwise pretty dull.

Ratings: 5: I will happily play this album anytime 4: I may occasionally play this album of my own free will 3: I will happily listen to this if someone plays it in the background 2: I will tolerate this if it is playing in the background 1: I will leave the room if someone plays this in the background I wouldn't say every song is a banger, but Monday, Monday and California Dreamin' alone push this to a 4 for me. Love the harmonies on both of those. The rest of the album is pleasant enough and it clocks in at just over 33 minutes so it doesn't wear out its welcome.

Go Where You Wanna Go was already a favorite, along with California Dreamin' and Monday, Monday (though the latter is a tiny bit too dreary for me). It was fun to discover a few more that I really enjoyed, especially Straight Shooter. The rest of the album did drift fully into dreariness, although the gorgeous harmonies make the full album listenable, even if not every song is a favorite.

Fun oldies album

the parents made some hits!!!

Some really great tunes and some “meh”. Great vocals all around though!

Incredibly dysfunctional as individuals incredibly harmonius as a group. Nice record probably 3.5 stars

Just heard Jimi Hendrix and now the Mamas and the Papas. It’s a time capsule. They had such great harmonies and such good songs. this genre is more in my wheelhouse and I like it much more. I also feel like it is just as relevant as Hendrix.

I mean I can't believe how much I enjoyed this. It felt like something I wasn't going to like, but I kept enjoying the next song.

2.5 Cass Elliott is better alone

3 really good, recognizable, timeless songs. The rest sound okay, but haven't really aged as well as the hits.

Big sound and singing talents.

excellent album....

Hard to say anything bad about these beautiful harmonies. I instantly felt like I should be on a beach having fun. The songs themselves are pretty formulaic but it’s still an enjoyable listen.

Vocally this is fantastic - the two female voices are quite different but equally distinctive, and they just complement each other perfectly. Musically I found it quite sparse, but maybe that was intentional to let the voices do the talking (no pun intended). Plenty of classic tracks, both originals and covers. It's easy to see why this album is so highly lauded by lots of people.

I thought that this was going to be a really boring and forgettable generic sounding 60s album, but turns out it's actually a really fun and enjoyable generic sounding 60s album.

Yea it was alright, some of those 60’d harmonies I’m not a fan of, but it was fine.

It's always a treat to hear "new" music from bands/artists you enjoy, and most of these were new to me, besides the singles and the Beatles cover. I love the vocal harmonies - Mama Cass is the standout voice here. The guys have that generic bubblegum pop voice it's hard to describe, and over-enunciate sometimes. Hey Girl was the weakest track, but I loved everything else. Favorite track: California Dreamin'

It's okay, but seems a little generic; I'd rather listen to Buffalo Springfield. "California Dreamin'" is a stone-cold banger, though - enough that I may listen to the rest of the album again.

It was fine, but I didn't think there was anything special about it. I liked "Monday, Monday" but the rest was a blur.

Classic, but not my style

I wanted to get eviscerated by soft spoken harmonies but this thing is just kinda dinky. Has its moments. 2/5

This ranged from corny to just ok for me. It’s not bad but it’s not great. Two notes, the Ramones version of Fo You Wanna Dance is infinitely better than the one on here. And I can’t hear California Dreamin’ without thinking of The Dead Milkmen and the sketch from the Kelsey Grammer Sketch show (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1v9cRhT8Gno&list=FLUEiFsihiBtiiqTbVRZMiWw&index=2&pp=gAQB)

If You Can Believe Your Eyes and Ears is a near-perfect snapshot of 1960s sunshine pop at its peak — warm, melodic, and packed with lush harmonies that still hold up decades later. The Mamas & The Papas blend folk, pop, and soul with ease, delivering an album that feels effortless but is full of rich vocal interplay and polished production. “California Dreamin’” is the undeniable standout — a timeless anthem of longing and disillusionment, wrapped in a perfect arrangement that captures both the warmth of the West Coast and the chill of winter. It’s one of those rare songs that feels both deeply personal and universally resonant. Tracks like “Monday, Monday” and “I Call Your Name” show the group’s range, while their soulful cover of “Spanish Harlem” adds texture and depth to the tracklist. Every song is delivered with confidence and charm, making this not just a great debut, but one of the defining albums of its era. Golden harmonies, sharp songwriting, and undeniable vibe — this one’s the real deal. Favorite song: "California Dreamin."

A lot of these songs still hold up