Tidal by Fiona Apple

Tidal

Fiona Apple

3.47
Rating
30095
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
33%
4
34%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 15)

I like it's originality.

Complex lyrics, great voice, and style.

Curioso. Me gustó

great front to back

Eh not really for me. 3.1/10

Not really my thing, but enjoyed Pale September

Less than 50 albuns in and this is my second Fiona Apple album (and I think we are done with her, sadly). I really like Tidal but this is the possibly the one I dont like much in her diacography after the scattered Fetch The Bolt Cutters. I find it weird that Tidal is on the list as well, it was clear that she was still finding her sound in this album, so much influence of classic jazz, but even as a vocalist she was not as sure as the other albums. I fell When the Pawn... would be better representation of her sound in her list, as it is her best album. I will give it a 5, as I love Fiona, but itbis not my favourite on her discography

Never heard of this artist before so it was a pleasant surprise. The stars are for the beautiful voice I really enjoyed listening, unfortunately the songs are pretty forgettable.

Originally a 3 but her attitude at the VMAs (??? Mtv??) and the last track bumps it to a 4. SO vulnerably unapologetic. So 90s. Not to mention incredible technically. Cool vibraphone(marimba?) on one of those later tracka. FOUR!

One of the most impressive things about this album is that Fiona Apple was only 18 when it came out. If she really did write her own lyrics based on personal experiences, then she was pretty mature for her age. What I enjoyed most about the album, though, is the music itself. I love the piano and the drumming on this album. The beats have a strong driving force, but they don’t overshadow the piano, which really drives the album. The combination of the two works very well together, and the production behind it is pretty solid too.

started off well, got a little bit like Alanis Morrissetti in the middle, then had a really good song - slow like honey. A very lyrically emotional album. Never is a promise and the child is gone are very real emotional songs, although i find the voice a little bit strained maybe. the last song, Carrion is also excellent. That and slow like honey are the standout songs. Definitely warrants another listen. 4 stars

Pedestrian

Everytime I listen to Fiona Apple, I think "holy shit, this is good music". And that's exactly what I thought this time. The top songs sound better and the deep cuts are still solid.

Alanis Morrisette - should be listening to this album on repeat. Easy listening jazzy

Mellow yet powerful.

I really liked the three first songs, I already knew Fiona Apple but didn’t know this album, so I very satisfied :)

D Fiona Öpfel, Side-Project vom Steve Jobs, macht ganz hübschi musig. Paar lieder dezwüsche sehr guet pässlet, over-all aber biz zu herzig. 3 system updates

Fiona Öpfel Han müsse ufgeh, irgendwie z wenig committment gha zum micht dur de ganz pop-obstsalat-album durezkämpfe, gid 2litrr suure öpfelsaft

ja irgendwie eifach öppis gsi? han glaub s'ganze album glost & glaub au 1 lied wiedererkennt aber isch glaub hintergrundmusig gsi glaub das gid weg em geringe störfaktor es 3? oder glaub doch es 2 willi's nie wieder wird bewusst lose? ja gid glaub 2 öpfelbütschgi glaub

Always forget what a great voice she has and I’ve never listened to the album, but that one was pretty good

Edgy and melodic.

Amazing voice and solid album

I get it—Fiona Apple is great. Her voice is beautiful, her lyrical craftsmanship is sharp, and the production—on this album and everything else I’ve heard—is ingeniously polished. But for whatever reason, I never get hooked. The highlight of this album for me was the pedal steel slides, though I’m admittedly a sucker for that shit. Maybe one day I’ll be in the right mood and her prose will hit me like a ton of bricks and I'll be hooked (hooks is what this is all missing). Once again, today just wasn’t that day.

Можно иногда послушать под меланхоличное настроение. Если внимательно слушать - довольно заунывно. 6 из 10.

I like the vibe. I am not really into this type of music, but I see the appeal.

Not my vibe

Aldrig lyssnat på förut, men inte så dum. Finns gott om nerv här. Det konsekventa pianot och cellon ger en fin sammanhållen helhet, kanske blir dock lite jämntjockt samtidigt och låtarna är generellt lite för långa. Shadowboxer tycker jag riktigt fin och ytterligare ett par spår höjer sig över massan. Känns som att detta är en textplatta, men jag skulle behöva några fler vändor för att få tillträde dit. Det blir fullt godkänt, med potential uppåt

Om man bara ska lyssna på 1001 album innan man dör, varför skulle någon vilja lyssna på detta. Ingenting griper tag. Ointressant sång, helt meningslösa låtar och aptråkig produktion.

En lyssning in var frågan om Fiona skulle orka kravla sig över till en 2:a. Låtar dom inte satte sig och en störig röst (låtsasbas?). Beslutade att ge henne en lyssning till, nu mer koncentrerat, inte mitt i jobbet. Den växer rejält. Störs fortfarande på rösten men betydligt mer intressant än vid första örat. Trean lutar absolut snarare uppåt än nedåt. Vem vet med några lyssningar till hade de kanske blivit ett riktigt högt betyg, men nån jävla måtta får det ju vara på undertecknads ansträngningar.

Varför är det här med på listan? De finns 1001 artister och album så låter exakt såhär.

Surprised at how good this was. Singer songwriter in piano vibes but with a clearly dark ish, grunge feel to it. Makes it sound of the time, but refreshing compared to the bubblegum pop that comes after this

Incredibly mature debut. Striking how good the production is, she clearly had some good support behind this effort. Not my sort of music but respect the effort.

Although not my style of music and roads of depressing melancholy lyrics i give it 3 stars cause it's impressive that a teenager can be so advanced in poetic writing and portray the angst of teenage females.

Soulful vocals and lyrics. Less aggressive and subversive than I expected from Fiona Apple, but in a good way.

78/100 incredible to be fair, always loved my jazz and recently due to artists like quadeca i've loved modern art pop, so to see some of its roots are incredible, inspiring me to listen to more from her in the future 1000%

Eh. Quite melodic, very 90s

Fiona Apple has one of the most gorgeous voices out there, and it blows my mind that she was so young when she recorded it. There is a level of elegance to her delivery paired with a broodiness that women young and old can connect with. The lyrics are eloquently written and complex, and every song is absolutely phenomenal. Truly a masterpiece.

Somekinda poor man’s singer-songwriter version of Hooverphonics? Not really make any real impact to me.

Kind of an boring pop record. Started off as a singer/songwriter type deal with slight edge of promise, but quickly turned stale and I found it boring. I'm also pissed that this is considered rock music by the grammys, after taking a peek at the nominees it seems to be even more meaningless award than I realized (also, this album was nominated in the 1997 awards).

Pretty good sound. Never listened to her before.

I know of Fiona, I know how legendary she is in her own right. Not much of a fan of her music, too slow for me. I definitely know a track of hers but haven't really heard much of her stuff. These are good songs too. The first half of the album better than I thought.

Criminal is SUCH a 90s song. Love it. Not sure the rest of the album is my bag.

Didn't even have to listen to know this is a 5* for me. I had a big Fiona Apple phase in the late 00s-early 10s. While this one is actually not my favorite of hers (It's "When The Pawn and I don't think it's on the list, boo!) it's an undeniably strong debut. The way her emotions are so raw contrasted with her beautiful voice and music has always resonated with me. It was a joy to revisit and I will definitely be adding back into my rotation.

Pretty good, though it felt like a bit of 'generic female singer.'

this was leaps and bounds better than the other Fiona Apple album i listened to from this list. this album came out 24 years earlier than the other one and it makes sense i liked this one more. i think the “songwriter” cares more and more about the lyrics and less about the music over time (see the tortured poets department) and im just so heavily a music-first listener. and the music here was so much better than the other album imo. dark and deep and haunting and just worked so well throughout

não me desceu

musica para garotas tristes nascidas na década de 90!! algumas sao meia bomba, mas sempre teve um aspecto que me surpreendeu. um instrumento, uma letra, qualquer coisinha. achei legal demais

Man, she has some charged lyrics.

Excellent all the way through. Opening track engages you immediately and the rest is such a fun ride through awesome song writing and arrangements.

It really wasn't to my taste. Her voice is incredible, but not one song gripped me. Maybe I wasn't in the mood and missed this one here as she is so revered by all

Pretty good.

Great album: beautiful voice, rich harmonies, sensitive lyrics… nothing negative to say, apart from maybe a tiny lack of diversity… Favorites : - Sullen girl - Shadowboxer (a surprising jazz sound married with beautiful lyrics and a devastating voice: already one of my favorite songs…) - Never is a promise

Brought me back. Love the tracks I love and meh on the tracks I don't. 3.5/5. I'll round to 4 for nostalgia.

So, so good. Holds up well. Unique voice and songs. Lots of great tracks.

Stunning debut album by a teenager at the time. First 5 tracks almost perfect then the energy fell away a little before coming back with Carrion.

Not my type of music

#44 Tidal ~ Fiona Apple There is a world of pop music outside the orthodox definitions of 'pop music' that manifested in the 80s-90s. This microcosm of many sounds mostly developed out of a variety of influences where one would not expect from pop, such as jazz, classical, rock, nascent hip hop or punk: bits and pieces of not-so-commercial sounds or forgotten antiqued genres meshed together by however a musician sees fit. Although slow to get going, out-of-leftfield pop projects only really got a shine outside artist and critic circles and into the public limelight deep into the internet era, where you had a variety of firebrand personalities emerging with their own takes on pop: Lana Del Rey, Marina and the Diamonds, Crystal Castles, Grimes, The 1975, Sky Ferraria, Lorde, etc. Another big result of these sort of artists getting the spotlight is their earlier influences getting more attention. Fiona Apple's Tidal is one such example. Tidal, like most Fiona Apple stuff, is slow burn stuff. It's not instantly gratifying like other albums, but instead smoulders over time, catching by the middle of the album before pulling its most slow burners all the way to the end. As a result, it may take a bit of an open and forgiving ear to get used to Tidal's Broadwayesque numbers and sweeps, but once you catch on, you will find some incredibly luxurious sounding and sweetly enjoyable songs. Much of Tidal's songs are drawn back in instrumentation, mimicking the sound of chamber jazz standards, a love of Apple's. This minimalism serves to highlight Apple's piano playing and her smoky, nearly husky vocals which propel her introspective lyrics of vulnerability concerning past experiences of love. Interestingly enough, much of these lyrics were written long before Apple reached her late teens, which makes her use of metaphors incredibly impressive but also explains a dangerous lean into indulging into sentimentality and angst. In fact, how much she leans into her brutal mix of honesty and drama is the one defining characteristic that characterises the different songs of Tidal, since the instrumentation of each song remains more or les the same, especially towards the second half of the album. Although it comes as a strength in showing the glimpses of her range, from the pounding jazzy stomps of Sleep to Dream and Criminal through honeyed bittersweetness of Never Is a Promise to the misery of Carrion. Tidal is probably the easiest way to approach Fiona Apple's repertoire of not-so-safe pop albums, a showcase of her talent in verbalising complicated emotions of love and pain, and a unique ear for hearty showtunes. Despite not being the most-out-there album to indulge in its variety, nor the most quick-paced to catch on easily, nor the most mature album to tackle broken love, what it is is incredibly solid and sweet tasting honey. And the best way to enjoy this album is how it sounds: sitting by yourself in a comfy spot near something warm and simply relax into the album. Also Kanye West really loves this album, funny that.

Oui China l'écoute souvent. Très bon premier album et en plus la suite des choses est encore meilleure selon moi.

Super belle voix Mme Spektor... euh j'veux dire Florence... euh j'veux dire Fiona. Je trouve que le style chansonnière indie fin 90 - 2000 sonne un peu pareil, mais c'est doux et écorchant à la fois. C'est beau. Il y a quelque chose de blues aussi sur certaines tracks, jazz ou r&b sur d'autres. Chapeau aux girls des années 90, j'aime bien Alanis Morrissette et Tori Amos, mais je connaissais pas vraimenr Fiona, ça pourrait devenir un classique. Pale September laisse présager Norah Jones. Incroyable quand même tout ce talent à 19 ans.

Le temps m’a manqué je devrai réécouter. Mais j’ai vraiment aimé le jeu de piano et sa voix. A revisiter dans un contexte plus calme.

This is just a fantastic album. Fiona Apple's voice is fantastic. The band behind her is so strong. The songs are diverse and so much fun. This is just great. The guitar tones/solo in "Carrion" are GREAT! Probably a 4.25 Liked Songs: "Sleep to Dream" , "Shadowboxer" , "Criminal" , "Slow Like Honey" , "The First Taste" , "Never Is a Promise" , "The Child Is Gone" , "Carrion"

Meh 2.25

The beginning was def stronger

lot of piano

Really loved the 2nd half, even though I did fall asleep to it at one point.

Didn't really remember many of the tracks other than the hits, but this is a really solid album. I wonder if my listening is now influenced by Fetch the Bolt Cutters? 3.5 stars

A very impressive debut album. Great songs, singing, and arrangement. I’m not the target audience of the character who’s singing these songs (seems to be a tough-as-nails, world weary, late-20’s mid 30’s woman, who’s cynical about love), so the lyrics all run together after a while. I wish there was a little more variance in the character. It’s a 4.

The first half of this album is good, the second half is not.

It's ok. Nothing special for me. She sings ok. The music is ok. A solid 3 to 3.5/5.

Fantastisk fin klang i det dype toneleie. Ni av de ti låtene er virkelig bra. Fin stemning gjennom hele plata og kontinuerlig krydret med deilige melodier fra bandet i bakgrunnen.

A fine album, I just don’t see myself ever listening to it again. Strong lyricism, vocals and musical arrangement. Just not for me.

Very cool album. Fiona Apple is a cool singer-songwriter.

Veel gehoord van Fiona Apple, maar zelf nog niet echt ingedoken en ik denk dat ik dat na dit album ga doen. Topalbum! Is dit PJ Harvey's zus? 5.0

My high school girlfriend had this album and she and I both loved it. I have almost all of these songs in my current music collection, so I've heard those many, many times and they are so, so incredibly good. The writing, the performance, the recording, the production -- everything is immaculate. Every single song is one of my favorite songs. Fiona Apple is so, so good, I have a hard time putting it into words. It blows my mind that this was her first album. She came out of the gate so hard and just knocked it out of the park. If I could give six stars, I would. Five stars.

Fantastic debut album, but not her best — that would be EXTRAORDINARY MACHINE in my opinion.

“Sleep to dream” strata so strong like a rocker, then fades into a Beatles song. This is pretty clever. Blended right into sullen girl. I’m really impressed with the production. Still not a fan of criminal, but I like the rest of the record.

Although some songs are dragging and compelling and the singer has a beautiful voice, it doesn't do much for me

Loved Criminal but not so enthralled with other tracks

Love this! Her voice and the arrangements are beautiful. Favorite songs were Sleep to Dream, Criminal, Slow Like Honey, Never Is a Promise, and Carrion.

first song - poor meh

Man the instrumentals are so fire, they really hit. Not only that but there was a coherence and tactility to the album which makes it really stand out as one of her best, combined with the intensity of the jazz chords going on its awesome. My only concern is that there isnt as much breathing room to sit with her spectacular lyrics in between the hard hitting melodies and ornate sounds, but its only a minor quip.

*4.5 Favorites: Criminal and Sleep to Dream. I really enjoyed every song. This reminded me of a calmer and less rock influenced Alanis

The talent and potential Fiona Apple had at such a young age is on full show here, even if the album does feel a bit repetitive towards the end. However, Apple’s performance accompanied with lush instrumentation make this an impressive debut. Rating - 7.6 Top Three Tracks: Sleep to Dream, Criminal, Carrion Least Favourite Track: Pale September

BOOOOOORING

Liked this more than I thought I would but I was primed for a patented one star pan so you could say this gazpacho soup burned my lips.

I had per-conceived notions coming in that were largely correct, but there is more variety here than I expected. It was fine background music to me catching up on work

This is a great album. When it popped up, my daughter screamed “you’re gonna love it” and she was right. Her smoky and rich voice, along with some great piano playing make for a great combination. Of course, I love piano in songs, and one of my favorite modern artists is Sara Bareilles. Apple’s voice isn’t nearly as great as SB’s, but it’s perhaps cooler and certainly strong in its own right. I already knew that Criminal was an excellent tune, but there’s a lot more which is great on this record. Sleep To Dream was released as a single before Criminal, which is too bad, as that probably would have built on or at least consolidated the success of Criminal if it was released afterwards. I loved Pale September too. Her voice sounds excellent on this tune. There’s a series of other well constructed songs as well. Bottom line is that this is an excellent album, especially for a debut. There’s an amazing sophistication about this album for how young she was when she recorded it. Really a great effort.

Fiona can do anything with her voice, she has an incredible range and can evoke any emotion with her voice. Without a doubt she is the best vocalist of her generation. This combined with the unusual chord progressions and a variety of styles, although all piano heavy, makes for an amazing album.

Commercially acceptable Fiona rants aren't that bad, not remarkable but decently catchy. 6.8/10. Strip clubs like Criminal, that's when you know the exact opposite context of her songwriting has been used for the most humorous reason of all time, her MTV music video premiere wasn't really rolled out in the correct manner, I remember the video but additionally understood why nobody within a larger audience would ever care for any particular reason. Much better album releases prior and post. There is clearly emotion there, might be the onset for the rest of her releases, I just don't feel like I'm hearing her quite yet. She held back, I think so.

Never heard of Fiona Apple before - really enjoyed the album though

Individually all these tracks are really solid, collectively they become repetitive and a bit of a snooze fest. I like Fiona Apple and teenage me had a huge crush on her when this album came out. She’s a good poet/songwriter but the album as a whole is lacking. 6.8/10 112/1001

Liked it! Aged well.

The First Taste is fine. Last song isn't terrible either. Just isn't my kind of album, mostly due to vocals.

Astounding voice. Incredible talent. A travesty this is her only album on the list. A 4 star album by a 5 star artist.

This was way better than I expected/remembered.

The great, mysterious, Fiona Apple - waify, alternative, seductress of the 90s that burst on the scene and then seemingly disappeared as fast as she appeared. Tiny girl, deep voice!! She was like the little weird girl from school that suddenly opened up and everyone was like - wow, where did she come from? Sleep to Dream and Criminal were the breakouts from this album and defined the sound of the album pretty well. The rest are mostly slower, sullen songs. Not really my bag, but this album definitely left an impression on 90s kids.

I really liked this to begin with but by the end I was a little bored

Artiste inconnue. Album de chanteur/chanteuse rempli de morceaux interminables et sans intérêt. Je ne suis pas allé au bout. =>1/5

fuck yes

yes i am biased and yes this album is also incredible

This was a good album. I personally don't love it - the slow-paced singer-songwriter isn't my favorite and I didn't listen closely enough to the lyrics to find out if they were great. The instrumentation was diverse and pleasant to listen to in the background. None of the songs were bad. This was a background album for me, and I was bored enough to be looking at the next album by the end, but that's largely on me and not on Fiona. 6/10

Song to cull: The Child is Gone I got this album when it first came out and listened to it constantly. I know all the lyrics. It's one of my favorite albums from when I was younger. "When the Pawn Hits..." is a better more mature album but I still like this one.

First listen to this one, although I was familiar with 'Extraordinary Machine' and of course the single 'Criminal'. What a terrific debut, a surprisingly great and mature jazz pop for an 18 year old, with some terrifically vulnerable and honest lyrics. I understand how she got lumped in with all the 90s alt-rock ladies despite sounding nothing like them.

If so could give 3.5 stars, I would.

Good in the right circumstances. Instrumental during Shadowboxer was quite good. Worst Song: Pale September Best Song: The First Taste Added to Liked Songs: Shadowboxer, The First Taste

Really enjoyed the songs I haven't heard before. Really like her piano playing too since it obviously is so integrated with her lyrics and voice like Tori Amos.

Maybe 1 or 2 interesting tracks, such as Sleep to Dream which has some drums that fell like a triphop song. Not really my taste for the rest of the album

Yeah, this was good. Nothing too interesting or groundbreaking tho

Fan-fucking-tastic, I absolutely love a man hating album, and this one knocks it out of the park. 'Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned', is the phrase that comes to mind whilst listening to the album, from a teenie bit of research I've learned she was 18/19 whilst writing on this album and the teen angst certainly comes through. That being said, the maturity of her song writing is pleasantly surprising, with beautiful lyricism and concise instrumental arrangements. Her vocals are genuine and have a frisky feel to them, the blend between them and the raw energy and minimalistic approach in the production creates a really moody atmosphere (slay) that's consistently present throughout the entire album. I really really enjoyed this album and there is some new additions to my liked songs on Spotify. Bitter women are fantastic. 3.8/5 - HF x No skateboard today - we’re on a big emotional boat with an all-female crew captained by a fucking titan. One of my favourite recent albums is Black Rainbows and you can hear the influence straight away. The clear influence continues throughout and you hear everyone from Phoebe Bridgers to Jorja Smith and Regina Spektor via Amy Winehouse - which is impressive when you consider how genre-spanning that is. Another frankly excellent debut record in an era when every fucker got a record deal and there were some truly forgettable debuts. After years of having to write feminist anthems subtly (what big fat horrible male record label chief was gonna OK feminism in music??) I love going back to the 90s and listening to thumping well-produced records carrying on the good work so many independent artists started coming out of punk in the late 70s. Shadowboxer took me back about 15 years to a wild place in my life but it was a nice little trip. Never is a Promise is a fine example of coming across as so strong but via vocals tinged with the subtle fragility that any true and meaningful singer-songwriter has. Being so in touch with the words in your songs and performing directly from the heart and soul makes for some of the finest records you’ll ever hear. 4.1/5 JF Going into this album blind and I was not disappointed. Definitely a lyrically strong album, from the first track on the album it's very clear in its theme of heartbreak and longing. And that voice, oh my god, at times soothing, others demanding but always a stand out performance and that incredible range? Ooof I need to have a sit down. Tracks like Sleep to Dream and Shadowboxer give a punchy (pun intended) start to this album and it does not let up later on in the album, with tracks like the almost haunting Pale September and the subtle start and enthusiastic close of Carrion. Definitely would give this album another rotation. 3.8/5 MTW

Honestly such a pleasant surprise, not at all what I expected after seeing it won awards for rock but it is just a really good slow pop ballad/jazzy album, loved the piano throughout, good few of these songs going into my everyday playlists. Gonna listen to more Fiona apple to see if I like the rest of her discography now too

Different and I enjoyed it!

8/10… art pop / piano rock

Forgotten all about Fiona Apple. Took me right back. Knew a few tracks, lover getting to know the rest. Best new album for me so far

I'd heard several songs from the album before, but was still somehow surprised by how good it was. Crazy to think how young she was when it came out.

"Sleep to Dream" and "Criminal" come on and I sing them. It's partly familiarity and nostalgia - radio singles from a time when I listened to the radio - but I love both those and I think they're a step above the rest of the album. There's a nice variety to Tidal but I kind of wish she carried the "Sleep to Dream" aggro spoken word jazz fusion style through more songs. "Never Is a Promise" started to catch my ear on relistens though. Bonus round, from a couple years after Tidal: Every now and then I queue up the music video for Apple's cover of "Across the Universe" from the Pleasantville soundtrack. One-two punch of a really great video and a really great cover.

Really solid album, I’ve been looking for more pop music I this vein tbh. Kinda feels like Amy wine house, Billie Eilish in a way. Just vibing music I can sit and listen to for a day, and hearing her albums get better from there is a nice sound. I think this is a low 5, I love it and could put it on just to vibe to. The music, her voice is phenomenal.

Trage jankmuziek, wel mooi

Sultry and good piano songs

the most commercially impactful of her career maybe, but the least of her records for sure. Her voice is on fire here, her perspective surprisingly mature, but the music is informed by its producers and being polished and shined for radio play. it's too bad that as she has gotten more interesting and idiosyncratic she also gets more reclusive; we'll be lucky if we get even one more album from her... If it were her last couple of records- they'd be five stars. albums 2 and 3 from her, 4 stars. so this one gets 3.

Was excited to go back and listen to this but was underwhelmed.

Ik ben fan van Fiona's sound, die op dit album al duidelijk te horen is. Grappig om te horen hoeveel "The First Taste" dan ineens van dit geluid afwijkt. Klinkt meer als een poging om als Sade te klinken.

Oh I loved this so much!

Smooth sultry and great for dinner parties

I’d give this 3.5 stars if I could.

This surprised one surprised me. I remember when this sound came out. I didn't want to like, but I was because I thought she got famous through an industry connection, which was both ignorant and unfair. Listening to this record all the way through, it's impressive. It's not really my thing, but I believe it's really a unique record and probably paved the away / inspired a lot of others.

Highlights: Sleep To Dream, Shadowboxer, Slow Like Honey, Never Is A Promise In a nutshell: “I’ve got my own hell to raise” The comparisons to Tori Amos and Alanis Morrisette are fair but Fiona holds her own on Tidal. Self-penned songs, skilled piano, alternative orchestral pop meets jazz. It was great to revisit this album. Overall: 7/10

I think she has a great voice but her music is too sleepy for me.

Impressive for a 19-year-old, and I think I can finally distinguish her from Ani DiFranco. The songs do kind of all sound the same, but that's understandable.

Cool album

Quite a good album. Didnt know her music but saved some songs to my playlist

altern. rock, 1996 -> 2

I love angry vengeful women and I love fiona apple

This [redacted] couldn't make listenable music if her [redacted] [redacted] [redacted] until [redacted] [redacted] and [redacted] [redacted]. Her [redacted] [redacted] [redacted] [redacted] was simply too [redacted] [redacted] [redacted] for my personal taste and I've tasted [redacted] [redacted] [redacted] on a hot [redacted]. I wish her the [redacted] [redacted] [redacted]. And all y'all [redacted] [redacted] rating this anything more than one star are [redacted] liars who deserve [redacted] [redacted]. See y'all in [redacted].

I imagine this is what people who don’t like Sarah Bareilles hear when they listen to Sarah Bareilles

Love the vocals on this record !!! Lyrics are also really poetic and well written. Just too slow and boring music-wise to make me come back or recommend it. 6,5/10 fav song : Sleep to Dream & Never is a Promise

Good but not great.

I haven't heard this album in a long while. Objectively it's very good, albeit a tad sad - strong rhythms, delicious vocals. She seems to have an "old soul" for an 18 year old. Favorite songs: Shadowboxer, Criminal, Sleep to Dream, The First Taste, Never Is a Promise, Carrion.

There's an intimacy created by her vocals. Both the vocals and songs are well crafted. but lack a little diversity. Well executed, but not a go-to for me.

Solid, but not something I would regularly listen to.

Excellent for the most part

really good very emotional! like ldr but a little more interesting

Great lyricism Some bangers, but most tracks are forgettable

Sultry, bluesy, wonderful.

I liked this! Fiona has a really beautiful voice and a good range.

This just extraordinary great songwriting. And sort of timeless. Sixties singer songwriting or indie who cares. Four plus

What we needed. Such a talent.

Amazing album, I did a real deep dive this weekend. And this morning again. It is maybe 2 or 3 songs too long..

buen álbum de rock que no es muy en tu cara ni trata de hacer nada más de lo que no sabe que no es capaz, magnífico y tranquilo

Great voice. Building to better albums.

heard this many times before today, fiona apple's one of my favs Sleep to Dream - 5/5 Sullen Girl - 4/5 Shadowboxer - 5/5 Criminal - 5/5 Slow Like Honey - 3/5 The First Taste - 5/5 Never Is a Promise - 5/5 The Child Is Gone - 4/5 Pale September - 5/5 Carrion - 5/5 Average score: 4.6/5 (rounding up)

Great lyrics. Cool album. Can't believe I've never listened to it before

This is now one of the albums I've heard in my life. I'm no better or worse for it. It exists

Ok, not my kinda thing.

Not my style but ok music

It's a beautiful album, perhaps buried among other piano pop songwriting in the late 90s. That's a shame if listeners not familiar with Fiona Apple missed this one.

Sounds like a cross between Sheryl Crow and Alanis Morissette albeit perhaps a bit more introspective and a lot more maudlin. There's not much irony or levity to break the heaviness. I can see the appeal, but it's not for me. However, the song "Criminal" proved something of an earworm.

was quite a nice listen

OK but tracks and album a bit to long

Go fuck yourself

Interesting and emotional debut album

Decent, listenable, but not mind-blowing in my opinion. Love Fiona apple but I'm not so sure about this album. Halfway through it feels like I've been on the same song. The First Taste has a whole different vibe, nice and seems catchy def why i voted the album higher. The last songs are more diverse, love it.

I like how this album feels both a bit angry and with lot of attitude (like in 'Sleep to Dream' or 'Carrion') and very relaxing at the same time (like in 'The Child is Gone' or 'Pale September'), while everything also sounds fantastic and very alternative. A great experience.

Interesting, rich, and still fresh sounding in many ways.

This is fine, but I found back then and still now (having read subsequent retrospectives) that there’s a kind of kid gloves treatment Apple gets in this early phase. “Can you believe such a sound comes from such a young thing?” Too much of a gimmick, in other words. But, gimmicks get you in the door, and for that, I thank Tidal. In general, there’s a soul/jazz monotone vocal that Apple returns to throughout Tidal, which she abandoned just a few years later. I mean, she was 18 when this was being recorded, kinda tough to level any substantial critiques. Probably 17 when she wrote half the material. The leaps she would make only a few years later far outshine the crutches she relies on here.

Didn't love it. Didn't hate it.

I see why it was a popular album, but it is a bit to slow and moody for me

Decent album, had a couple of songs that I enjoyed.

A little slow and one-note imo. Not really my thing but her voice is nice and the music is fine

My opinion has largely remained the same on this album over the 10ish years I have been listening to it. First half is really good, second half slows down a bit too much, then ends on a high with Carrion. Lana Del Rey for girls who have more good days than bad. Post by Björk is a great follow up after listening to this. At least for me.

I think you really need to love the vocals for this kind of album. I can't say I do unfortunately. Criminal was a good song though

Great talent, 18 at the time of this album! Precocious percussion throughout, and the outré outro to Criminal sneaks this into 5* territory

Very enjoyable listen. Must confess I was not aware of the artist before this was served up so a good example of why this exercise is a useful process. Not exactly in my wheelhouse, but I’m fully able to appreciate the artistry behind it and there’s some very nice ballads including on the album.

Debut of a really great singer/songwriter. And all the pieces are already there, and a couple strong tracks - I just prefer her later work. 3.5 ⭐

i like fiona apple

I can't believe that she made this at 19, jesus christ

did not enjoy this

Right up to Criminal the album is near perfection after that it just loses pacing. Not that this is a bad album, but maybe just a tad front loaded. https://youtube.com/shorts/Hq-s6YU5ZDc

I was pleasantly surprised, the first side had a lot of tracks I knew and the back half was a chill listen.

10/10 Fiona doesn’t have a single bad song, — let alone a bad album — one of the most talented musicians I’ve ever heard, and the way she grows and evolves throughout her discography without ever sacrificing quality in any way is truly as inspiring as it gets

so random bc i so close to listening to this album yesterday, really liked it, will have to listen to more

I really really wanted to love this album. I feel like I'm the kind of person that SHOULD like Fiona Apple. But all in all this was just a bit too sleepy. It was NICE but I wanted more umpf.

I found this album to be not my usual music, but there were a few tracks to that i found to be quite a smooth listening.

Unique voice, and songs. Made a splash than kinda disappeared. Like so many artists today.

I appreciate Fiona Apple much more now than I did when she came out, but this isn’t m favorite album of hers. Definitely amazing in its own way, though.

Good but not nearly as good as her later albums

Pretty decent

Whew, stunning debut. It is hard to believe she is just 18 on this album. Her love-weary lyrics, husky alto voice, and jazzy piano arrangements drip with hard-earned experience. I was transfixed.

I don’t get why this is enjoyable in any way. She sounds so hurt and scorned that she sounds like an emotional vampire

What a debut, Fiona absolutely crushes this album. Indie alt rock that really stands out against her contermporaries from the decade, there are some absolutely stunning songs here. My favorite is Slow Like Honey, by far, but Sleep to Dream and of course Criminal standout as well. This is a lot better than Fetch the Bolt Cutters, which I still enjoyed, but it isn't on the same plane as this.

Never heard this before. Pretty solid, no complaints. Pale September is fave.

W sumie takie całkiem fajne jak na popik. Smutne... 4/5

I would die for Fiona Apple.

First real dive into Fiona Apple. She has a great voice and style. I know she's a beloved figure in the art pop/ singer songwriter world but I never really went down that road. I'm compelled.

This is one of those albums that I never really listened to much when it came out, but obviously should have. The only modern singer I can think of with this kind of vocal capability and uniqueness is Adele. There are so many other singers out there that come nowhere close to this. The singing in here matches the tone of the music so well; she's got such a great lower registry and all of the feel of a smoky jazz lounge without seeming overly forced. The whole thing is great; there's not a bad track on here.

God she's great. What a voice. A heavy nostalgia hit despite not owning the album. When Criminal aired on MTV... YOU WATCHED IT.

2.6 Not really my cup of tea. The faster songs are alright, album peaks with Criminal. But just too many dull lifeless tracks. 51 minutes is Criminal, more like.

Some nice songs, first song caught my attention. Lost over the middle part of the album. Criminal has a cool opening bass riff

"Criminal" is still great but I feel like expecting the rest of the songs to be like it distorted my enjoyment. Still a solid album though.

Absolutely fantastic album, just not quite in 5 star territory though

Favourite songs: Sullen Girl, Shadowboxer, Carrion* Doesn’t blow your mind by any means, definitely an album intended for a female audience so didn’t much resonate with me… Okay I’ve listened to those three songs a few times now and I’m a much bigger fan after a couple listens, moving my score up from a 6.4.. 7.2/10

Caught me off guard, very good soothing album, gives me Sade vibes

1996 US. Chamber pop, jazz pop. !!!!!

One of the best albums of all time!

I like the sound of this album but didn't stand out as something special to me. Her voice did throw me off a bit as well.

jazz pop, not really my thing 2.5

Loved listening to this album. I knew the song Criminal.

A masterpiece and includes my all time favorite song to sing sincerely to myself.

As far as singer songwriters go, one of the GOATs

This is a good album. Not my favourite.

ethereal experience

Fantastic

I understand what this album is supposed to be, but something about it just does not work for me. I’m not a fan of the idea that the voice is the instrument and the lyrics becoming secondary to just enjoying the husky raspy tones of somebody’s voice. Congrats are having so many singles on this album, but I thought they all sounded very similar, and I don’t think I would come back to listen to this album again unless someone really really begged me to give it another listen.

Great album, great voice and arrangements. I like the jazz feeling.

Solid album. Criminal is a banger of course. Orders of magnitude better than Fetch the Bolt Cutters imo.

When I saw this come up I kind of dreaded it, and put it off a couple of days before listening. I don't what I remembered from the 90s when she came out, but I was pretty much into more hardcore metal, rap and grunge back then. Anyway, this isn't at all bad. Definitely has a groove to it, and a hypnotic personality. 3/5

Stunning debut album. Fiona Apple has a voice that lulls you into a cozy comfort like you know her then all of the sudden she will sing some of the most biting words you’ve ever heard string together. Hearing this and knowing where she goes from here was very interesting. If I have any criticism, it would be that the album is a bit front loaded with all the catchiest songs.

Flott plet

A good album with some nice songs on it. Look forward to hearing her later stuff

Such a talented artist, good starting point but for me Fetch The Bolt Cutters is her magnum opus.

I was late discovering Fiona Apple. Her album Fetch The Bolt Cutters floored me and went back for a listen to the whole catalogue. Tidal is a great debut that hints at directions she would explore later. Not fully cohesive but such a joy to hear again

Fiona Apple walked so Sara bareilles could run.

I just fucking love Fiona Apple, and this album is an undeniable masterpiece. Her vocals are entrancing and the lyrics are both deeply personal and deeply poetic.

A good enough listen but as her debut seems a bit in thrall to Tori Amos' debut...

Pretty good

A very accomplished album for a teenager. A great variety of styles across the set giving the album depth.

I do not know, if I be ever grown-up enough for this kind of music. Fav: The First Taste

I know of FA but never listened to anything by her imagining her music to be some hipster 90s rubbish. So the first track Sleep to Dream was mind blowing..but after this it got very forgettable. Sounds like Macy Gray and others. Not bad, but too much filler for me.

Un po' una lagna...

She seems upset. Sometimes angry, mostly sad. Someone sould dend her some flowers

I guess I like a gal with a deep voice and a piano. ‘Criminal’ is probably one of the weaker songs on here tbh.

Cool music that makes me feel cool. I love her voice and inflections.

was really boring, no special song at all

Lovely tunes.

I don't get it. Like, at all.

This really makes me want to listen to her other albums. I had only heard Fetch The Bolt Cutters which I slightly prefer. Her voice is great, maybe a few too many ballads for my liking on this one. You can really hear the sadness in the songs though. Strong 3

You couldn’t go anywhere in 1996 without hearing criminal. Several good songs and huge debut album for a young singer.

My expectations were low, but I was mildly impressed

ughh her mind

A dark and beautiful album that showcases Fiona Apple’s talents very well. A pleasant surprise for me.

GREATNESS. We love Fi Fi.

Not bad. Gives me Regina Spektor vibes.

Gefällt mir sehr gut. Ich mag die Jazzigen Züge und den Instrumentalischen Hintergrund

Pretty boring, all the songs sounded the same.

Excelente álbum. Solo conocía a Fiona Apple de nombre, pero no había escuchado su música. Percibí varias influencias en su voz como Bjork y Sade. Algunas de las canciones me parecieron bastante adelantadas a su época. Me gustó el uso de la armonía que por momentos sorprende. Un disco que seguramente escuche otra vez

Fiona is an underappreciated genius. She’s still very young here and finding her voice, but she manages to put a handful of perfect tracks down. Sleep to Dream, Sullen Girl, Shadowboxer, and Criminal are just a stellar start to a record by a teenager. If this pace kept up it’d be 5 stars from me. Unfortunately it drags a little mid-record but comes back strong with Carrion. When the Pawn… is where she become a full-fledged classic singer and songwriter in my book.

I tried listening to this in 2021 and I believe I fell asleep. I was tired, it was a 16 hour road trip. I've always liked two of the songs on this: Sleep To Dream and Criminal. The rest, I'm not as familiar with. Sullen Girl took me by surprise and I believe that the slow atmosphere is something that I can understand better at this age. Shadowboxer puts her voice front and center. For her young age, she definitely had a voice that could move mountains. I'm not saying that to be cliche or some shit, I do mean that. What I recognize about these outro sections so far is that they bring in moments of solos from these instruments with "quirks" to their sound before fading out. Just as this album begins to make more sense to me, Criminal comes in and steals the show. This is a good sign. Slow Like Honey is probably the first skip but it's a natural comedown from Criminal. The First Taste brings it back up. It's one along with Criminal where Fiona shows this more ferociously naive attractive side of her rather than just pure anger and piano. I may not even know what I'm saying. Never Is A Promise has excellent lyricism, straight up. This girl can sing, damn. It's such an engaging song that the next two songs don't matter as much to me. There's about 3 skips on this album. That doesn't discredit how impressive this is for a debut at this age, it's just that some of the songs I don't vibe with as much. At the very least, this album has a strong closer in Carrion. Why isn't When The Pawn on this list? 7/10 (but 3 stars here as I feel I enjoyed the MMLP more) (Update: It's a 4, Phil, are you insane?) (7/10, 4/5 on this scale)

I was initially expecting this debut album from Fiona Apple (no relation to Tim Apple) to be along the lines of other singer/songwriters like Alannis Morrisette and Tori Amos, but I ended up preferring this to both of those. This is actually closer to a shoe-gaze sound (with the occasional torch song) and has considerable depth and complexity to it. I then found out that she was just 18 when this album was released and had written the songs during her teenage years. Wowzers!

I've heard of her but was not familiar with her work. She's compared to Tori Amos and the likes (and I really like Amos or O'Connor for example) but it feels like a more "pop" version of the aforementioned artists. It's good, but I wasn't blown away as I hoped I would be.

That's not my taste in music, but ok.

Definitely a lot better than I went in expecting

Incredible debut! Took me right back to my college days where that incredibly sexy video for 'Criminal' played endlessly on MTV's TRL every afternoon. If Tidal has a downfall it's that the back half of the album doesn't quite stand up to the energy of the front half. This a record made for headphones. The production is so vibrant with it's strings and instruments, that's it's easy to not see (or hear) what's right in front of you. Seriously...for those saying this sounds the same, go back and intently listen. You'll be rewarded.

Not too shabby, but probably not something I'll seek out to listen to again.

Enjoyed it more than I thought I would, soulful.

Didn't do anything for me

This album washes over me in a really beautiful way. A beautifully controlled, patient, well composed LP. I’ll admit that the moments that grab me most though are the slight glimpses of freak out jazz pop, like the backend of Criminal. I know on later records she specialises primarily in this more esoteric approach, which is where my interests lie. That aside, the debut provides a series of accomplished ballads from a 19 year old with a phenomenal voice, who sounds several years her senior. In fact, 30 years later her voice sounds exactly the same as it did back then.

I really liked this! Lovely, dreamy, emotional. "Crminal", "Slow Like Honey" and "Shadowboxer" are highlights. Four stars

Didn’t finish it

This is a solid album to start the career of Fiona Apple. Side one is full of some great songs that are well produced with some good lyrics. Fiona’s attitude comes through in the vocals and makes for a biting satire on certain songs but then she settles into a more calm and agreeable tone on others. The second half of the album falters as it slows down and lost me a bit. Favorite songs are “Sleep to Dream”, “Shadow Boxer”, and “Criminal”.

I've heard this one several times before, but not for a while. Some of my coworkers at the record store loved it when it came out, so it got played quite a bit back then. I've always liked the opening track, "Sleep To Dream", but other than that didn't remember much of the album. I've always felt Fiona Apple has a lot of talent, but also has an ego that is much larger than the talent, and that keeps me from paying much attention to her career. Going purely from the music, and laying aside her personality, it's a good album. Solid songs, well produced and well performed. Fave is still "Sleep To Dream", "Criminal" is pretty good. I found "Shadowboxer" and "Never Is A Promise" lyrically pretty week compared to the rest.

Much like Suzanne Vega, I don't feel like these one or two hit wonders are albums I need to listen to before I die.

Arbitrary

Kivoja melodioita mut ei ihan oma juttu

Fiona apple is one of my favorite artists. Her album tidal is a great reason why. The track first taste is my absolute favorite. I love her vocals and creative instrumentation.

3/1001. I listened to this twice with about a week delay, the 2nd listen since I thought perhaps I didn't pay enough attention to the music or something. But no, this music doesn't speak to me. Somehow it sounds like a 17-year old who wants to tell her life story, cry her heart out, but there is not much to tell yet. Nothing too wrong about the music, but the songs roll out one after other without too much variation. I suppose she was one to start or at least to establish a genre, but the ones who came after really mastered it (perhaps her later albums as well). Nevertheless imho a surprisong pick for 1001 albums.

Not the kinda stuff i usually listen to but the highs Were really high. Slower songs didn't really hit as hard since its not my cup of tea.

Ok but nothing fenomenal

Not my style of music, but I can see why she has fan. Her vocals are strong and soulful. The instruments bring a good backing to the music. Criminal was my favorite song on the album, it makes sense that it has the most streams.

Beautiful. Just beautiful till the end. Bravo!

One of my favorites; every single song is good.

A high 2 but despite this clearly being decent, it didn't do anything for me

I love her

I will admit that I’m maybe a little bit biased because I had such a crush on Fiona Apple in high school, but this is great stuff!

"Criminal" and "Shadowboxer" are fantastic. The rest of this, for me, is forgettable.

Can appreciate this but not my taste

I enjoyed this enough to rate it higher than 3 but something was missing for me and I can’t quite put my finger on it. Shadowboxer is a really great record!

Pretty good album. not sure why she wasn't more popular 4/5

shrek orange

Perfect album for this dreary, rainy day. Have always loved her voice and the instrumentation on this record. Great stuff.

OH HELL YEAH. Love Fiona Apple. Oh wow, her voice is capable of being so so buttery, or so so gritty, and you can tell she’s truly a master of control. (Also a master of songwriting). Her lyrics are very poetic and the style of the songs suits it—jazzier than I expected, perhaps, and much more akin to Norah Jones than you’d think. I do love the variation between the songs. Each one is its own unique being, and most are marvelous. In perhaps a rare occurrence, I prefer the second side and find it to be overall stronger. The last two or three songs are just fantastic, somehow even more so than the rest of the album (a feat that seems near impossible!!).

I was in my early 20s when this album came out, but somehow it flew under my radar. I remember the video for Criminal but that's about it. Anyway, this was a pleasant surprise. Fiona is definitely a talented singer and songwriter. Pretty amazing she was 18 when recording these songs. 3.5/5 Album 57/1001

Not for me