Tidal by Fiona Apple

Tidal

Fiona Apple

3.47
Rating
30095
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
33%
4
34%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 9 of 15)

The best

For some reason I confused Fiona Apple with some or even several other singers from this era and was thinking maybe I would get bored with this album. I did not. It has that kind of jazzy feel but remains more contemporary in a popish way. It has aged perfectly well and could have been made yesterday so that is a plus. I actually don't know much else about Fiona Apple or where she is now, but than again, the whole music world has been run over by neoliberal ideologies and only a few "known" names are really ever in the press. So be THAT, but it should make me reflect a bit and look up some of these musicians regardless of A list status now a days...

Good background music

Just couldn't get into it

Quite liked it

korreeekt, néhány szám uncsi számomra szóval nagy a kontraszt mert vannak nagyon bombák is, háttérzenének amúgy korrekt meg azért fiona apple egy girlboss kedvenc: sleep to dream

Kedvenc/Favourite: Shadowboxer Valamiért nem vártam ettől az albumtól sokat, de pozitívan csalódtam. Zeneileg nem volt szerintem kiemelkedő, de vannak benne érdekes részek és végig szépek a dallamok. Jól kísérik a szöveget, ami néha pozitív értelemben szíven ütött. Egy-két kivétellel elég hasonlóak a számok, és a legtöbb rövidebben is ugyanilyen jó lenne (azért nem voltak zavaróan hosszúak). Nem elképzelhetetlen hogy több track is a szívemhez fog nőni. For some reason I didn't expect much from this album, but I was pleasantly surprised. Musically, I don't think it was outstanding, but there are interesting parts and the melodies are nice throughout. They accompany the lyrics well, which at times hit me in the heart in a positive way. With one or two exceptions, the songs are quite similar, and most would be just as good if they were shorter (they weren't frustratingly long, though). It's not unlikely that several of the tracks will grow on me.

So dramatic. So many memories.

Here’s one of those albums I’ve been meaning to listen to for a long time and just never made the time. I like it a lot. Shadowboxer and Carrion are a couple of favorites, but I loved Never is a Promise the most.

I haven’t yet worked out yet whether I’m supposed to rate on whether I like an album, whether I think its iconic of it’s genre and decade or whether i think it’s been highly influential for later artists. Not being a pop/rock professional, I can’t really judge by anything other than ‘like’. So …. It’s nice, she’s talented, what else am i to say? Not going to buy it, though.

A cohesive album, sounds like it was written in a particular mood with a particular vibe and it flows well together.

Surprisingly excellent. I knew the name, but this was way cooler than I’d expected. Like a chamber-pop Alanis Morissette.

Would listen again

I’ve heard Fiona Apple’s name so often, and she seems to be of the “your favorite artist’s favorite artist” variety. I found this album really intriguing and I want to look into her more. 4/5

I really enjoyed this one. Really enjoyable style, nice smooth instrumentals, and great vocal work! 'The Child is Gone' was my fave.

One of those "blindspot" records that I am not proud of as I generally enjoy everything I hear from Fiona. Feels like a cooler/smokier version of Regina Spektor who I think came onto the scene later than her or at least around the same time. All really interesting songs that never go in directions I expect but are beautiful nonetheless. Some have great beats, some have jazzy xylophone, beautiful orchestration, general heavy and melodic piano and most have weird choices but that makes them all the more memorable. My top songs are sleep to dream, shadowboxing, criminal, the first taste and carrion.

Not Fiona Apple's best album, but it's truly remarkable that she was a teenager when she wrote and recorded this album. I struggle to think of many more mature debuts.

not a fan. i feel like the lyrics were annoying to me for some reason.

One of my favorite albums of all time!

You would be forgiven for mistaking Fiona Apple's voice for the likes of Amy Winehouse at times, or at others for Patti Smith's. In truth, her powerful, jazz-inspired vocals are really the strongest part of this record, with impressive variations in pitch and tone throughout. This album captures a dark and mysterious mood which is driven by the sullen, meandering piano chord progressions which seem to always take you in a different direction to one you were expecting. However, given the fairly similar tempo and soundscape of most tracks this mood arguably becomes monotonous, with few variations of style to break this up. As stand-alone songs, many of the tracks in this album hold their own and are genuinely unique, but when played consecutively on a 50-minute long-player, I found myself looking for a breath of fresh air.

A great debut album with a solid vibe. It's honest and skilfully done. Doesn't blow me away but solid album and worth a listen for sure.

Some strong instrumentation, vocals and lyrics. The compositions are good but feel safe. The production feels slightly flat.

Forgot how good she is. Need to add this to the breakup rotation

Nice voice, but didn't think the music was that special

I owned this already and have listened to it many times - I'm less of a fan than my wife. I went to college with the guy Shadowboxer was about. That taught me an important lesson - he was a really ordinary guy, likable and attractive, but not, like, otherworldly. So artists are humans with relationships like mine, huh! Everything isn't always dialed up to 11 unless they do that in their art! On relistening, i noticed a few things: -There's a lot of Elton John in her piano. That's great! I love Sir Elton! -There's a lot of hip hop derivative drum work and that's an odd choice. Feels appropriative, and that's not usually a critique I appreciate, because music is like herpes, once you hear music from other cultures, it's difficult/impossible to pretend you didn't. But this feels more like "We set Elton John to some beats we got from the Meters." Very 90s move, one not discussed as often as I'd hope. Natalie Imbruglia did it in Torn, Fiona did it, Alanis did it, Liz Phair didn't that I remember. -In the video for Criminal, Apple was treated like some voyeur's idea of a teen sex victim. That's fucked up. But this whole album has a seductive teen vibe (The Child Is Gone) and I'm wondering how much was engineered into the music as opposed to just the video. -I don't think this album has aged all that well. Was she exercising agency? Was she a teen sex victim? Were the Calvin Klein video visuals a commentary on that or drafting on it? I don't want to have to wade into detailed oral histories to enjoy a record tbh. There's a lot of weird fetishism here, like this sexy Jewish girl doing flirty hip hop inflected jazz, and maybe she breaks free of it on "When the pawn..." but maybe not. In terms of the songs, I think the singles were pretty well selected here, although Slow Like Honey and Never Is a Promise are kind of weak. I like Criminal and Shadowboxer, even though they both make me feel like I should take a shower. I love Fiona's piano playing but don't love that someone found an apparently pretty naive teen and had her do kiddy porn for her music videos.

6/10 There is just some energy missing in this album. Fiona has a beautiful voice, but the album ends up becoming a bit dreary and slow. It loses all its energy on the song 'Never is a Promise' and doesnt pick itself up again. Favourite songs: Sullen Girl Shadowboxer Least favorite songs: Slow like honey Never is a promise

I like some of her more recent stuff but didn’t know this album. After one listen I liked some of the tracks but thought that it sounded more middle of the road than I expected.

Fiona’s debut Tidal is dreary and a bit sleepy. Album starts slow and gets slower as it progresses. Good piano work but some songs are over dramatic. Hopefully, she improves as an artist after this effort. L = (2.3*s) J = (2.1*s)

The name is familiar and I knew 3-4 songs on this album but I'm not sure what happened to her after this release. It's a decent debut but you have to be in the right mood for it because it's pretty dramatic and angry. I do like her voice but I'm only good for 1-2 songs before the glitter peels off. There's a few really slow songs and a couple that sound the same so some skips. I give the sullen girl a 2.75.

Fiona is no sour Apple. I liked this album more than expected. Only song I remember is the hit "Shadowboxer" but most of the tracks are good ones. Pop this on with a nice dinner and bottle of wine. Pure golden, delicious...3.0.

On the frontside of this listen I vaguely recalled the name Fiona Apple but wouldn't have been able to name a song. My curiosity was piqued by the first couple songs. Seemed like a decent 90's sound with a female vocalist. Maybe this Tidal album could be alright? Unfortunately it didn't hold up through the remainder of the playtime. It's not awful, but it mainly devolved into a handful of long boring melodramatic songs. I was completely over it by the end of the runtime. Not the worst of the bunch but nothing I'll ever put on again. Pretty skippable overall. 1.67 stars

can’t see myself ever listening to this again. was it terrible? no, just not for me.

I won't lie, I had try to listen to this album about 4 times before I actually had a chance to sit down and listen to it all at once. As a collective piece, this thing is a masterpiece. The themes of harming a relationship, trying to mend it, and maturing in the process are clear by the end of the album. I really enjoyed it, especially the back half. Best Songs: Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, Criminal, Carrion Worst Songs: NA

Me gusta Fiona

Pre: Criminal is easily in my personal top 100 songs every written list Post: I didn't like it quite as much as I anticipated but I liked it a lot. It also gave me the amazing experience of having my born-12-years-after-this-album's-release daughter walk into my office and immediately say "hey, is that Fiona Apple?"

Nothing against Fiona Apple, but if I’m not mistaken this is the second of her albums on this list. Nothing against Fiona Apple, but I would not have thought her to be someone who produced 2 albums worthy of this list. As for this album specifically, I think I like this album a slight bit more than the other one we reviewed, but again it’s not something that blew me away.

Not for me - not horrible but not my thing.

I'm not usually a huge Fiona Apple fan, but this album is absolutely great. There were a couple of songs early on that I didn't love, but the last half of the album is fantastic (especially the last track, Carrion).

Nothing special

When this came out, her videos got a lot of play on MTV. But they all seemed to fall into the category of ‘lady singers who wriggle around on the floor, singing everything unnecessarily provocatively’. It was just like what Jewel and Britney were doing. Boring, undermining, powerless pickme bullshit. So, I never wasted my time listening to her. It’s a shame. This woman is clearly talented, but she marketed herself as a sexy, defenseless wittle gworl. She should have had a better career. This record is decent, but she lost me a long time ago.

Abwechslungsreich, melancholisch und kritisch. Kann man gut durch hören. Manche Harmonien gefallen mir nicht. 3,5 Sterne

I don't want to say this is a bad album or that Fiona apple isn't a good artist. It's just that I can't in good faith give this above a one star. This is just not my genre at all. I see the laufey comparisons here from the little I know of her and it seems like this is probably what inspired her (my guess idk trust me bro source) but it just is NOT for me. All due respect but this is an album I will NOT be listening to again any time soon

Not my kind of music

Already listen to a bit of modern Fiona apple, but damn, this is a good album. Hasn’t aged at all.

Apple is a very acclaimed artist I've never managed to fully "get". See also: Nick Cave, who this reminded me of a bit, and I also don't really get The lyrics are quite good and there's some nice enough arrangements to certain tracks and the piano playing is alright. I find her vocals a bit monotonous and the songs lack hooks though. Some songs are longer than they need to be, even the hit Criminal Ok but I wouldn't be in a hurry to listen again

I really never listened to this album tho I knew of it and knew it was popular. So I did for this challenge and loved it.

Pretty good. I surprised myself because I didn’t think I would like this album. However, Fiona’s sultry, velvet vocals were quite nice and a departure from her previous album I listened to.

Great voice. Deserved / Deserves the accolades. Not a bad apple ion this record.

First year of highschool. I listened to this album a bunch. I remember when "when the pawn..." Came out and I thought it wasn't nearly as good. But now I like that one more.

Awesome! Took me a couple of listens to get into it, though.

Maybe this was better when it came out but it's a big nothing burger

Never heard of her before, but the first ⅔ of the album sounded like Alanis Morissette. Only not so angry, or good. After that it got a bit samey and dull. It was OK, just a bit meh. Just a 2 from me.

First track was great. Banging bass guitar, angry keyboards and angry vocals. Just got dull after that.

I've seen Fiona Apple in many years' best albums lists, so I was looking forward to listening to this. The first song was pretty good, with its effects laden guitar. Then it all seemed to slide downhill with piano ballad after piano ballad. Things picked up on the last song, but it wasn't enough to lift it out of that rut. Shame.

I was very surprised to read that Fiona Apple was 18/19 when she wrote and recorded this. She displays a lot of maturity through her songwriting and the performances here. Tidal is full of classy, driving piano interplayed with Fiona Apple's husky style of vocals. She incorporates songwriting elements that keep the album engaging, for example the dissonant piano at the end of Criminal. Very cool that she was willing to try a few different things on her debut, and more often than not, they work well. Higglights: Carrion, Sleep To Dream, The First Taste

Not really a fan of these kinds of ballads with no beat. Just not my thing.

A very good songwriter and an excellent singer. It's not as cool and subversive as late era Fiona Apple, but it's still really atmospheric in the main. There are a couple of times when she sounds a bit like that singer who was famous for singing in the bar in Ally McBeal, and one song that sounds like it should be Geri Halliwell's follow up to Mi Chico Latino (when will we get that BTW), but in the main, lovely stuff.

nice, piano-laden songs, "Shadowboxer" the stand-out track

It's a good album, but it's not for me.

A deeply great album. I loved Criminal back in the day and I still think it is a nearly perfect song. Back to back with Shadowboxer on the album makes for an interesting exploration of the roles of hunter and prey. Also I just love her voice.

Like Amy winehouse with none of the soul, boring

If I got a big enough bucket, could I catch a cloud?

Eh, kinda just boring woman music. Sorry ladies 😐

Forgot I was listening to it on the ride home yesterday, became white noise mixed in with the motorcycle.

I always like Fiona Apple, but always forget about her. Once it’s on, it’s like, “oh yeah she’s great,” then I don’t think about it anymore when the listen is done. Maybe just too soft and moody, I have to be in the right spot to listen to.

This probably hit pretty hard on the Lilith Fair tour

Uh. Sure whatever. I really want to like this, but there’s never a point that feels…impressive? Bombastic? Worthwhile? I dunno. I think her voice is let down by the instrumental, which I can only describe as “mid nineties jazzy piano beats to sleep to” it all melds into this singular mass that never gets good. It never gets bad either. A 2.5 all around

Yes please. Fiona Apple is one of those artists that I've been aware of for a very long time, but has never made her way into my music listening in any significant way. I've heard a lot of hype some some specific music content creators and certain people I've met who just rave about her. I can see why. This was a really creative, pointed album. It has such a unique sound, one that feels mysterious, dark, sad, serious, and at times melancholy. It draws you in because you want to know more about what's happening, about what you're hearing. Any album that's capable of this is a winner in my book. And that's not even mentioning the lyricism here, which is top notch. Seriously, it's poetry. This is an easy four stars. Loved it. Standout Tracks: Sleep to Dream, Criminal, Slow Like Honey, Never is a Promise, The Child is Gone, Carrion

Didn’t hit as hard as Fetch the Bolt Cutters. It’s less fierce and more drawly. The First Taste slaps though, and I did enjoy the album in general more on the second listen, so maybe it's a grower. Will revisit eventually anyways.

If it ain’t Fiona apple then I don’t give a good godamn! Love it

Love me a bit if Apple Prefer her 2nd album though

Another girl with a pretty voice singing about love or whatever... 2 stars

Great voice!

Seems like I should have given "Tidal" a proper listen a long time ago, huh? Fiona Apple had always eluded me, back then, when this album could have fit right in after Morissette's "Jagged Little Pill" and my time with Amos' "Under The Pink" and then later, when, here and there incidentally, I caught glimpses of what seemed like a cracking human and I'd had a cursory peek into one of her albums only to not be quite grabbed, kinda genre-wise? But: 𝘨𝘦𝘯𝘳𝘦𝘴 𝘴𝘤𝘩𝘮𝘦𝘯𝘳𝘦𝘴! Happy to redeem this here and today. This is astoundingly great! A magnificient album.

The more closely I listened to this, the more I liked it. At first I was just relieved it's less kooky and challenging than 'Fetch The Bolt Cutters' but then I started to find it samey and wished she'd taken a few more risks after all. Then I listened to it a couple more times and thought, yeah ok. She does a fair amount of rocking out and there's a range of subtly different styles that showcase her fabulous voice. It reminds me a lot of Beth Gibbons but the production isn't quite at Portishead levels. Nevertheless, by the time I'd had a third go, I was really enjoying it. Probably more on me for not really giving it enough attention at first.

Have listened to Fiona Apple before, haven't really got into it. Sort of slow and a bit boring. Gave it two listens. First half is decent, but think it drops off a bit.

Excellent indy alt

Aside from the (few) hits, hard to distinguish between songs, but an amazing performer.

Great voice, album kind of dragged on toward the end, hard to believe that she was only 19 years old when this was released

Fiona has a great voice. Excellent Debut Album.

Nella lista non c’è “When the Pawn…” che è sicuramente il suo album migliore e per quanto non sia corretto darò 5 a questo in onore di “When the Pawn…” (bello anche Tidal però un po’ monotono)

1st ever fiona apple album for me

I wish I could give this a 6/5. I love this record SO much. I can't believe she was only 18 when this came out. I can't really explain how much this record means to me. Maybe to some people it's indulgent or tedious, to me it means everything in the world and more. I don't think I've ever felt so understood by a record or artist. I wish I could bury myself inside this record forever.

I enjoyed it, and would listen again but not something I'd normally pick on my own.

A great debut

This is not a casual album to listen to. It’s heavy, deep, dark and complex. I can see why it got such high critical reviews. The lyrics are complicated and eclectic. The instrumentation is unusual in a lot of the tracks. I actually liked it more than I anticipated.

I came into this album not having a clue about Fiona Apple and having no clue what to expect. I have to say that this is a very unique album and I mean that in a good way. There is a delicate balance between the beautiful nature of the tracks with some powerful lyrics. She written all this in her teen years? Damn. Looking through the reviews, I glad someone singled out Never Is A Promise. I don’t know what it is, but that was my favorite from this album, even more so than the singles (which are still very good). That song was fucking beautiful, a slow and empowering song. Favorite track: Never Is A Promise Other hits: Criminal, Sleep to Dream, Sullen Girl, Shadowboxer, The First Taste

This was a lot better than I expected. I really only knew Criminal, and didn't love that song enough when I was in middle school to seek out this album. Appears I was missing out a bit. 4.5 stars

Pretty decent album, nothing too exciting but I can see people enjoying this pre-2000s. It was alright for a background listen but I feel like it'll be a little bit too meh if you properly focus on it.

First listen. Quite good.

# Notes - I've only came to know Fiona Apple when she released the (amazing) [[Fiona Apple, Fetch the Boltcutters]]. - I've heard a few tracks before, sure, but never a full album. - Very cohesive, consistent album throughout. Great opener, nice mood swing from "Shadowboxer" to "Criminal". - I don't *love* every track, and it gets a bit tiring here and there. She really puts her out singing and it weights on you. - Even if it's not your favorite genre, definitely worth a listen! 4/5

El disco es muy bueno. Tiene una gran calidad. Las mezclas de piano y guitarras es top. Tiene más arreglos en cada tema y varía la dinámica de los mismos.

Very cozy piano songs.

achei q n ia gostar um pouco adele e amy winehouse música pra transar

you are my sunshine Album ok. Lembra uma Adele dos anos 90. nao tenho muito a comentar. Duas Estrelas bem aplicadas. Para quem curte um PSL (o chato para mulher, não o chad PSL Romeno) é um bom album. Nao para mim

eh maneirin

Lovely and lively. Alternative approach to artsy and soulful music. I always knew of Fiona but never gave her the time except for her 2020 album "Fetch the Bolt Cutters". I hear so much influential components here; Emily Haines and Amy Winehouse specifically come to mind immediately but the trail blazing Ms. Apple did on her way up was prominent. She started swiftly with "Tidal". I really enjoyed this one.

This was really good.

I used to put this CD on and sit and stare at those eyes. What a relief. The record does trail off a bit for the last couple songs, but overall really great.

Okay... moody

Certainly a fantastic album. The 90s were some great years for music. Some songs are better than other but, overall, a great album.

This is one of my all time favs. insane debut album. the raw rage and talent with the most powerfull voice. she ate

I don't get it. Fiona Apple seems to have a good reputation, and this album IS in the 1001 Best Album listing, but I only hear a fairly average, over-produced album of OK songs. Nothing special, really. Sorry Fiona.

Great album. Criminal gets stuck on my head every time I listen to it. 7/10

God she's so good. I remember that I listed to so much Fiona before I dropped out of uni. What ever that means, read into it what you will. But as always she delivers, with great lyrics, music and very evident talent. I rate this 8/10

Від альбому хочеться спати. Але можливо це через обставини, коли мені довелося його слухати. Пісні достатньо однообразні, хоча досить якісні і добре поєднуються з вокалом. Нажаль не запам'яталася жодна пісня. Весь альбом слухався як одна велика пісня 3/5

Wow. This was a mind blowing listen. I’ve always been rather fond of Fiona Apple, though admittedly only from the radio singles I’ve heard here and there. I’ve never actively sat down and listened to one of her records, and man am I ever glad I did. This is an absolutely gorgeous record. It’s impeccable from top to bottom. The tone is dark and defiant, it’s introspective and sharp as hell, but there’s this overarching softness and vulnerability to it. Instrumentally it’s excellent, you can tell that the musicians working on it really felt the music, and it sounds like it was a very fun album to record. Fiona’s piano work is absolutely fantastic. “Shadowboxer” stands out as my favourite song instrumentally, its slow and driving piano riff is equal parts smoky jazz hall and film noir waltz. It’s such an intensely dark song, and it’s so beautiful in that darkness. Vocally it’s absolutely incredible, Fiona’s voice is so soulful and deep, and every note feels very intentional in the best way possible. The breathy vocalizations on “Slow Like Honey” are enough to send shivers down one’s spine. Lyrically this album is absolute poetry in its purest and most wonderful form. It’s emotional and sad and powerful, it’s deep and brave and confessional. One listen to “Pale September” and you’ll know exactly what I’m talking about. I truly feel richer for having given this album the time it deserves. I’m looking forward to diving further into Fiona Apple’s discography in the future. I’d give this one 6* if I could.

If I could only pick 10 albums to listen to for the rest of my life, this would be on the list. This is another album that love deeply and have listened to regularly for at least half my life. The very first strikes of the drum on “Sleep to Dream” are an immaculate start to the album, as is the entire track, which is one of my favorites. Most of the other relatively higher-energy tracks are among my favorites, namely “Shadowboxer” and “The First Taste”. When the full instrumental suite kicks in on “The First Taste” is just *chefs kiss*. My favorite track of all is perhaps “Carrion”. Which is not to say the slower, sadder numbers, of which there are many, are lesser songs. The songwriting and lyricism throughout this album astounds me every time I listen to it. To consider that Apple was a teenager when she wrote these songs is genuinely baffling to me. The maturity, emotional depth, and poeticism of her words is far beyond anything I could dream of writing as a grown adult or even what most professional songwriters put out. It’s a beautiful, devastating, flawless, no-skips album. I love every evolution of Fiona Apple’s style and every album she’s put out since Tidal, but for me this debut album is one of those lightning-in-a-bottle releases that achieves something that few albums can. 10/10

Consistently beautiful, often stunning. Fiona is a genius. Very close to a 5, though a couple of the songs are a bit slow for my taste.

Fantastic

This Album is pretty good. Fiona’s voice is really relaxing and soothing. I really like „Never is a promise“. I like the others too but this one was just really the one were I thought „this is it“

Not that great I'm afraid.

This another album I really wanted to like going in, but didn't leave very satisfied. I do see the appeal, I listened through it a few times and can say she's a great songwriter and lyricist. Outside of this though, I didn't feel engaged with a single song here, which felt like wandering through 50 minutes of flat chamber pop and jazz unable to find a single moment of music interest. Some tracks were conceptually interesting like 'Sleep to Dream' but I don't see myself returning to listen, hopefully will like more of her other stuff in the future.

Not bad, but not really.my jam. I see the appeal, but she doesn't stand out that much, and calling her "the best" seems a bit overblown. Very 90s.

Most excellent. This is the gateway drug to Fiona.

I think I liked her album when the pawn... better but, not a bad album

Criminal is a GREAT song. A solid album all around.

Some great songs and a solid album.

Thought I would like this more because Criminal is such a good song, but she sort of sounds like an okay lounge singer.

The 90s were a weird time for music.

Had a much more sultry, lounge singer vibe than I was expecting, but in the end nothing really stuck out to me.

Fiona Apple’s debut album Tidal is a striking statement from an artist who, even at nineteen, managed to express emotional depth with rare poise and vulnerability. It’s an album drenched in complex, heavy themes: trauma, desire, isolation, defiance. Yet what’s remarkable is how accessible and listenable it all remains. She doesn’t dilute the emotional weight of her lyrics, but she wraps them in elegant, often ethereal arrangements that draw you in instead of pushing you away. There’s something spellbinding about the atmosphere of “Tidal”. The production is lush but never overbearing, allowing Fiona’s husky voice to float atop jazz-tinged pianos and slow-burning rhythms. Tracks like “Shadowboxer” and “Never Is a Promise” have an airy, dreamlike quality that gives the listener space to reflect, while still hitting hard lyrically. That ability to marry intimacy with grandeur -to sound almost weightless while exploring such grounded, personal themes - is where the album really shines. What’s especially admirable is how Fiona manages to convey anger, sadness, and longing in ways that feel both deeply personal and universally resonant. There’s a clarity in her writing that cuts through the metaphor, even when she’s at her most poetic. Songs like “Sleep to Dream” don’t just express emotion — they channel it, making it feel tangible and urgent without becoming melodramatic. That balance is difficult to strike, but she pulls it off with surprising maturity. If the album has a flaw, it’s that its pacing can occasionally drift. A few of the slower tracks blend into each other and slightly undercut the impact of the stronger, more distinct songs. But even then, the album’s cohesive mood and emotional honesty carry it through. Each listen reveals more detail, a testament to the layers Fiona worked into her compositions. 4/5

Man, Fiona Apple is so good. I mostly listen to her more recent work, but going back to this debut really illustrates how strongly she started and how she has just gotten better with each release. To listen to this and then realize for the thousandth time that she was under 20 years old writing these songs and recording this album is still so shocking. She has always had a wisdom and weariness that is familiar to any woman but hard to confidently convey. And she was right: this world is bullshit - go with yourself.

I like the way she sings. It feels mysterious and is captivating actually. Makes you want to listen to lyrics even more. 3.5 gonna keep it a 3 but some good reasons for a 4.

Solid. 3.5

Liked it! Didn't hit as hard as bolt cutters but I liked it all the same

Great and powerful album, though it does start to drag a little at the end. The front 3/4ths more than makes up for it though

听完以后会觉得世上或许再也没有这么完美的专辑了…这次返听也比先前多注意到了trip-hop的存在。

- 10/10 songs added to main playlist - An artist I’ve been meaning explore - She has a very interesting (positive) voice - Kind of a blues-y/soul sound I enjoy - Very beautifully album - I think the pop/rock combination really works here. Best parts of each genre + some soft piano. All over the place in a good way - Favorite song: Criminal

Wow - intense debut album stands up 18 years later, Never heard complete, but listened repeatedly today. Sorry I failed to notice years ago. You can hear so many who have been influenced by her - - Applause!

Found it a bit similar to others i listened. Not my style. High 2.

Very jazz influenced vocals, piano chops, and rhythm section, but they’re “pop” songs. Unfortunately, there’s not many pop hooks and the songs are overall unengaging to keep the listener for north of 4 minutes.

snoozefest

This was my Halloween album...and it couldn't be further from a Halloween theme. It also isn't much further from completely unremarkable. Favorite Track: "Sleep To Dream".

Really great and a 90s vibe that is hard to describe. Did get a little stale by the end.

Fiona Apple is a great talent and I love her attitude. I enjoyed Shadowboxer and Criminal but the rest of the album was too samey.

this album dropping when i was the tender age of 0 means i mostly associate fiona with legions of vh1-airplay adult-alt knockoffs of this sound and like, while this record feels clearly successful in its aims of being pop-soul singer-songwriter shit, it is also responsible for some of the worst tunes to touch my ears and some crimes cannot be forgiven

I was astonished to learn how young Apple was when this was recorded. In her vocals, arrangements and lyrics, she sounds wise beyond her years.

Sleep to Dream is in the running for best first song off a debut album. The title is also apt, there's a dreamlike quality to the piano and vibraphone. Sullen Girl is also appropriately named, the vibe fits the title or maybe vice versa. Shadowboxer was the first single and her first hit. It got overshadowed by Criminal later, partly because the video had her in various states of undress. Norah Jones is a pale, poppy imitation of Fiona Apple. The First Taste has a Latin(?) or Middle Eastern (?) vibe that doesn't really fit the rest of the album. But I'm nodding my head to it, maybe it's her big dance number. Never Is a Promise is a beautiful song. Pale September is great too. There's an aggressiveness coupled with a vulnerability in her voice and these songs that is amazing. Carrion too. This album is amazing.

Five of the albums on this list should be Fionna Apple albums. Tidal is the first of them all. Incredible debut. Most would be lucky to make something half as good as this on their first outing. Classic. *Heard before

Solid album, probably won't listen again though

Fiona Apple is amazing. Fan of a few of her other albums, but have never listened to this one other than the hits.

I have very limited experience with Fiona Apple, and I’m glad I got to listen to this. Melancholic and beautiful. It’s hard to believe she was only 18 when this came out.

Really grew on my on repeat listens w headphones!

4☆/5 10.21.2024

Having never heard Fiona Apple previously, it took a few listens for her voice and music to grow on me. Every song on this album brings something different and interesting. A good system revealing the bass instrumentation helps fill her sound out, otherwise a bit thin. Favorites are Sleep To Dream, Criminal and Never Is A Promise which has the vibe of a musical.

Chick rock at it best. Strong energy all across the board. Jams with some serious muscle behind them. A good listen.

Back when this came out it was my first introduction to Fiona Apple's music Shadowboxer Criminal, Sullen Girl and Never is a Promise, were all in a big rotation. It was nice to hear the remainder of the album.

Forgotten how good Shadowboxer is.

Superb voice.

Starts well then turns bland in the 2nd half

Core blimey

This was also nice but not my jam, good vocals. 3*

actually pretty good

Where has this album been all my life? This is exactly the type of thing I love!!! The songwriting, the vibes, the VOICE. I can’t even decide what my favorite song is, I love and am deeply moved by them all. I listened to this twice yesterday and will keep it downloaded and listen to it many more times. So influential to SO much music I love. Sad girl Rosetta Stone.

sad jungle music

molto soft, molto dolce, mi piace. non da ascoltare sempre ma nei momenti di bisogno di relax.

Fiona Apple establishes herself as a clear talent with this one. The music is very technically proficient and really showcases her strong songwriting, and her voice elevates her smart lyrics. 'Criminal' is a masterpiece and actually greatly improves the quality of this album. None of the songs disappoint, but they can sound the same after awhile, leaving the listener a little bored. Still, a great achievement in music.

Not a fan of Mrs Apple.

Apple’s voice is soulful, rich, and perfectly captures the intensity of her lyrics. The production is beautiful as well. There’s a moody atmosphere that runs through the whole album with pianos and guitars weaving together to create a dark and jazzy vibe. It’s not always an easy listen but the honesty, passion, and musicality are undeniable. It is a deeply personal album that demands to be felt as much as heard.

Easy on the ear. Not an essential album though

Great album. Very unique sound to Fiona Apple and to the mid 90s. Has deep singer songwriter vibes. Will definitely listen to it again. First half of the album is better than the second.

Enjoyed but didn’t love

All a bit dull and anonymous to me.

I had a girlfriend who performed a striptease to ‘Criminal’ for me once upon a time. I’m sorry - my impartiality for this album has been corrupted. Also, I love belting out “Shadowboxing” in various octaves with varying levels of proficiency. So yeah, I like this album even if the second half kinda murmurs itself to sleep.

GENUINELY RLLY GOOD STUFF. UNEXPECTED 4/5

Some of the tracks aren't bad, but... not really my kind of thing.

Might be my #1 album from this entire list. There are very few albums where I think every single song is fantastic. I love Fiona's voice. I love the downtempo, the piano and strings, the strong emotion. I love it all.

This album works best when the songs feelnless conventional. When it's all creaks, groans and Apple feels equal parts desperate and menacing. The more traditional songs, usually stripped down to just pianos and strings hold my interest less.

Kind of like Amy Winehouse's debut, Apple's first album shows off her amazing talent while also - in light of the direction her later work would go - showing some attempt to fit into less quirky, more straightforward song structures and genres that her later albums throw off entirely. I don't mind Apple aping Nina Simone or other jazz greats, but I definitely love her later albums more - and think of them as being more 'her.'

I was in high school when Fiona Apple dropped “Criminal”, and I remember just being mesmerized by her voice and the music video. Yet I didn’t fully appreciate the entire Tidal album at the time. As I got older I really started loving the album, and today it is definitely up there as an all time favorite. Her voice just pulls you in and makes you pay attention. Absolutely great entry on the list.

Decent voice, but not really my thing. Got kinda boring towards the end. 2.5/5

I'm a pretty big fan of Fiona's already, but I'm admittedly way more familiar with Extraordinary Machine on, so this is almost a fresh listen for me apart from Criminal and Sleep To Dream which, if you grew up when I did, you couldn't avoid hearing at least a few times. I'm struck by how mature she already sounds here. It's a bit slower than her later records, but this is fucking strong songwriting for an 18 year old. I was quite prepared to see lots of disparaging reviews for this given that female voice = bad here most of the time, but I'm pleasantly surprised. Well done y'all! My main complaint is that there are no other Fiona Apple albums on this list. Wtf. She gets even better than this, so if you like this, go listen to at least the next two albums of hers.

I got tired of this halfway through. And she's slightly off key all the time, which is annoying.

Imagine turning out an album like this when you're only nineteen! Excellent stuff; I enjoyed this more than "Bolt Cutters"

Sleep to Dream, Shadowbox, and Criminal are some of her best songs, so not surprising that the rest of the album doesn't sustain those highs, but still

This one is a bit of a strange one for me. It feels pretty average, maybe a bit above average, but doesn't seem to be super special. The wiki article is very small, critical reception was on but not blown out of the park. I'm struggling to figure out what makes this so important. The music is fine, the first 5 tracks were close to a 4, but then it took a dive on the last half of the album so it lands on a solid 3 for me Standouts Shadowboxer Sullen Girl 3/5

The debut from Fiona Apple is damn good, albeit slightly stuck in the 90s, and clearly positioned her as a notch above her contemporary peers.

Fiona Apple has always been above and beyond. Her jazzy and wonderfully emotional debut proves that.

Real good , only heard 1 of her songs ever but now I'm a fan

I really liked this, lyrically rich and sonically gorgeous. My only complaint is every song being over 5 minutes! This would have been 5 stars for me honestly if it was 10 minutes shorter.

So this was really nice and chilled. I like Fiona Apple’s voice. I should have listened more closely to the lyrics, but I was running when I listened so I probably didn’t get the most out of it, but I still enjoyed it.

#68 - I quite enjoyed this, creatively produced original music!

Great songs, fantastic voice and angry lyrics. I like it a lot. Pop art at its best. Sleep to dream, sullen girl and shadow boxer are great songs and Carrion is a lovely way to finish the album. There are so many good songs on this album 6/10 are / were big hits. Favourite song: Shadow boxer Least favourite: Never is a promise was a little boring. Album artwork: Lovely eyes!!

Not sure i get fiona

Would love to see her branch out and explore her vocal range. Incredible voice, but this is one long continuous song.

The entire album is moody and none of those moods are happy. If you’re into angry conflicted feelings this album might be for you.

9/27/24. Banger of a debut! First time giving this a listen outside of Criminal. Fantastic songs and very unique, great singing and songwriting.

LOVE Fiona Apple 🍎🍏🍎🍏

alot of jazz in those vocals!

It was great when I first listened and it was great when I listened again. Great songwriting but personally nothing I connect with enough to warrant a 5

She's great.

Never locked into this. I like Fiona Apple’s voice. And I’ve enjoyed her songs in the past. But this album didn’t do much for me. 2.5/5

first song was great, rest was unremarkable.

Largement préféré cet album à son dernier que j'ai eu dans cette liste. Elle chante vraiment bien, l'instrumentation accompagne parfaitement sa voix. 8/10

just not for me dawg

After a really strong start, with soulful, jazz inflected songs and the right amount of intricate production and experimentation, Tidal lost steam for me in the second half.

Fijne stem, lekker rustig. prima album om aan te hebben, voor op de achtergrond met andere dingen , maar geen focus. beetje jazzy achtig? nummers voelen wel alsof ze heel lang duren, maar dat valt op zich ook wel mee eigenlijk

Felt nothing :(

Love love love this album. I can still remember the first time I heard Fiona Apple. It was late at night watching VH-1 and the video for Shadowboxer was on. Hooked! I got this album and listen to it on stop. Thanks for the reminder❤️

Good songs, solid voice.

Not bad but a bit down tempo for me (maybe just on that day!)

Sleep to Dream and Criminal feel really out of place in comparison to the rest of the album. They're so upbeat and funky and the rest of the album was this slow moody theme. I have to criticise the rhythm of the melody in Sullen Girl that's overlayed with the instrumental track. It's weird and doesn't sit right. Slow like honey was good, gave me James Bond theme song vibes but then The First Taste was like if James Bond had wandered into a Cuban beach club on a Thursday night and fell in love with the beautiful and mysterious lounge singer performing on stage. However! I did love the percussion instruments used in The First Taste so that kept me from scoring lower. This album just perplexed me. I can't figure out if I love it or if it's weird, or if it's weird and that's why I like it. Another one which would have been better to score using a 10 point scale but oh well.

A bit too melancholy for me. But decent.

Not my type of music.

Not really sure what to think of this, I think it definitely needed extra listens to get my head around it

piano jazzy pop, music i like 😀 Favorite track: shadowboxer other picks: criminal, slow like honey, never is a promise

mjoah, ganz ok

chillige lounge musik aber nicht mehr

Nett. Interessante Stimme

Decent, if unmemorable album. Writing this review a few days after listening to it and I can't really remember any songs, but it was relatively enjoyable to listen to.

Pretty good album that I have never heard before. Some of the less popular songs like "The First Taste" seem really interesting and I would like to listen to them on a better sound system than the one I listened to this on. I'm sure I will be listening to this one again.

i’ve got lots of respect for fiona apple, and this record only reinforces it. her voice is beautiful, and the songs often go in directions you wouldn’t think they would, keeping the music nice and refreshing. i always think of apple as an autumnal album, so this was very apt, given the cold weather. looking forward to hearing more fiona.

Pretty good. Album cover reminds me Sinead O’Connor

4/5 I thought it was pretty good! Very chill and vibey

Like this a lot! Most of the Fiona Apple songs I listen to r from her 1999 album n I think I like those a bit better but she’s so good

4/10 - Gives Mitski energy. It was just kind of boring. I did not love her voice. However, the production was pretty good but a little repetitive.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CkEHikn17eU

I went from never having heard of Fionna Apple to having listened to two albums within a week. This album was definitely better than the last one which was her most recent from 2020. Feels 90s but in a good way? I do think this is the kind of album that teenage girls based their entire identity around and I would love for someone to confirm that. She has a nice voice which touches into a darker deeper side of singing that most female singers never seem to really go into. The background music fits the bill but is pretty shallow as to let her vocals really shine. Overall pretty good album even if its not my preferred style/genre of music. 7/10

Green eggs and ham. I do like Fiona Apple, Sam I am. Always took her for the cut rate Alanis, but what a voice, great musicians and strong songwriting and performance. Damn.

This album is so interesting....Fiona Apple's songs are like Leonard Cohen's songs in that I listen to them for the lyrics and not the music. There are so many honest reflections here. Nothing sugar coated. Nothing idealistic. But the music is...forgettable to me. All except for "slow like honey." A song I will never tire of. Other than that song I'll probably never listen to this whole album again. But it does, holistically, affirm that Fiona Apple is formidable. A perceptive honest voice that's wise without being bitter.

I really want to like this album. I remember watching her speech at the 97 VMA awards. And I find the albums she has done with Jon Brion are far better. I know she was young when this was released and some of the lyrics are great; however, i can’t stop zoning out or letting this album slip into the background. I really try and then after 5 minutes I’m itching to change the channel. Maybe I’m not in the right frame of mind but I still cannot get into this album- lord knows I’ve tried.

I just get absolutely nothing from this. I can appreciate why people might key into it emotionallly ... but there is just nothing in it for me.

Pretty boring piano music, but very well-produced. Just very forgettable.

I knew a bit about this record when I was a kid, and I wasn't sure this was going to age well... but it's pretty good actually. Criminal is especially a total jam and helps put the rest of the album in context, and couple more tracks that had the same kind of mass appeal would make this a really great record rather than 'just ok'

Awesome lyrics!!!!

makes it feel like you're walking through new York

Brought back memories as I hadn’t listened to this since the 90s!

I was only familiar with Criminal on the album. I like some aspects of album, but I'm not a huge fan of Fiona's vocals. During this time (1996) I much preferred Alanis, Beck, Fugees, and Rage. In singer songwriter genre at the time, I preferred Sheryl Crow. Is Fiona more talented? Not sure, and I don't listen to Fiona or Sheryl regularly any more. That said, I'm glad I listened to Tidal in its entirety. Some good, "new to me" music.

Jazz rock and its undertones of love and angst

Beautiful. Contains a lot of pain and suffering.

Ha! And here's another album from HS. This time someone I paid zero attention to at the time. Why would I care about some chick banging on the piano and singing when I'm listening to shit that rocks hard?? Now, close to 30 years later I'm realizing I should have had a more open mind. She's great

Pretty melancholy. Not usually my thing, but it kinda rings with me. I saw her open for Page/Plant in the 90s ish and was, I think, more impressed by her live show.

Moody, angsty…I love it.

I liked 2 songs

If you like moody blues, this’ll be an album for you. But it does start to feel pretty monotonous by the end.

It’s really amazing, pretty car mellow pop aesthetic. 8.01/10. First songs are kinda like ehhhhhh but then it picks up its pace and then you don’t notice so it’s really good.

A hug of an album. Apparently Fiona wants to redo this album a là Taylor Swift because her "voice was too pretty" the first time around. I don't know if that quote is true, but her voice is very good! I guess what a critic in the music biz would call a 'slice of neo(?)-soul'. Good stuff from Fiona! Your arty divorced mum's favourite album from when she met your dad. Somewhere between 3.75 to 4.95 stars. Bada bing, bada boom! :)

suuuch a nice listening experience! i didnt know much fiona apple before this but will be exploring more :) criminal is a fav for me here. indie girls win again! (3-3.5)

High end indie pop/rock with jazzy elements, more than solid songwriting, undeniable talent. Knowing her progress I am aware that she hasn‘t found her Voice, yet. Soulfull affectations and a focus on a sex appeal cover up the true Fiona Apple. Still: Great Album!

Objektiv gut, mir bischen zu intense. Stilistisch vielseitig, genug Musik für 3 Alben

God it’s so deeply 90s -She's got such a great voice but for some reason I've never been a huge fan (even though I fit right in her prime demographic). I wonder if it's because I really like listening to the lyrics and Fiona Apple stretches out the words so much it's difficult to really get the lyrics. A very vibey album.

Man I love the drum grooves on this album. Absolute gem! Listening: During busy period of work - high humidity knackered from lunch time skate. Very enjoyable experience. Favourite: Slow like honey

This was an enjoyable listen. I might come back to Fiona Apple at some point.

Knew and liked ‘Criminal’ from back on MTV but really the first time delving into any of Fiona Apple’s catalog. This was a fantastic album! Really liked each song, great variety but also worked well together. I’ve been missing out! 5/5

Feels like finally understanding where your sister was coming from after all these years Very good but I can't see myself coming back to it very often. Very Come and See-y Best tracks: Shadowboxer, Criminal, Slow Like Honey, The First Taste, Pale September, Carrion Light 8 - Strong 8 Cover - 7/10

Shadowboxer is under-appreciated. First Taste another standout song on this album. Never is a Promise launched her - beautiful arrangement.

A perfect jazzy and chamber pop production. Great lyrics and production.

It is a really good album but she moved on to much better things later in her career

Very solid start

Very good work 4

Went into the album pessimistic for some reason but I liked it. Very pleasant sounding and the voice works too. Does get a little tedious towards the middle/end and wish the songs had a little more variety, but pretty good. 6.5/10 (3.25/5)

There were so many strong female voices in the 90s and Fiona Apple is one of them. I had never listened to this album in its entirety and am impressed by her range and talent.

Fiona Apple's debut album, Tidal, is a bold and ambitious exploration of raw emotion and intricate musical arrangements. The album’s standout feature is Apple's deeply personal and confessional songwriting, which delves into themes of heartache and introspection with striking candour. Tracks like Criminal and Shadowboxer showcase her unique voice and intense vulnerability, setting her apart in the 90s music landscape. However, while Apple's ambition is evident, her style may come across as overly intense and emotionally heavy. Despite this, Fiona Apple's debut remains a compelling and noteworthy contribution to alternative music. NUMBER OF BANGERS - 2 STAND OUT TRACK - Carrion

Didn't really get on with this album, just had me wanting to listen to KD Lange

Didn't resonate with me back in the day, but can see she had some very strong albums in the 90s (and recently)

4.5 rounded down FIONAAAAAA far from her best but its ok. she was a child basically highlights: shadowboxer, criminal, the first taste (aug 29 2024)

love fiona’s words and who she is / what she’s all about. However, the sound of the album, overall, isn’t something i’d choose to listen to, instrumentally. I really like the song the first taste - sounds so different to the rest of the album and a nice way to break the songs up.

Very much enjoyed this album, I'll be taking some time to check out her other albums.

Very sensual. I kind of liked this album. Although, she does smack her lips a bit much for my taste.

A Grammy?????

- i'm generally not big on slower songs (that aren't instrumentals), or at least i'm pickier with them - still, it's nice to have a change of pace once and a while. so this was nice - don't have much to say! - a couple of songs went on my playlist but not too many. not my thing really, but i enjoyed myself! :^)

Pleasant but dull.

Ich höre hier nur weinerliches Geningel.

Started strong and lost energy along the way.

Rock. Normal. Me aburrió un poco. Canta muy bien.

Loved!!!!

Cerramos la semana con disco debut de una artista actualmente en las sombras. En la línea de Alanis Morissette pero más oscuro e introspectivo, es un muy buen primer trabajo, con una Fiona Apple explotando su voz (con toques de Patti Smith en Shadowboxer: impresionante) con su tono y con la interpretación que hace de cada canción, sumado sus dotes en el piano. Todo soñado. Buen fin de semana.

I had discovered her later song A Mistake from a Battlestar Galactica fan video or something like that. This reminded me of a more chilled ‘90s Laura Nyro.

save me white girl a bit stylistically one note for a 50 minute album but u could pick worse styles, certainly ones that are less totally up my ally...pianos, jazzy harmony, and Reflective Teenager Lyrics. my current exhausted self was also very glad how much faith this has in relatively simple structures...easy to parse, easy to get sunk into, easy to enjoy. its not easy to write about anything tho lol im so tapped. great album tho! hope theres more then one of hers on here

A good piano R&B/soul singer/songwriter album.

Admittedly, not usually my first choice but this was OK. Criminal is flat out a solid song. Wish it rocked out a bit more though. I do like that it's at times touch but at times vulnerable. This one might grow on me.

It's a really good album I prefer it to her other album on the list You could release this today and it wouldn't sound dated. There is no way I'd guess 96 for this album. It's a 4 baby

Love Fiona's voice and songwriting. Admittedly she's not 100% in my wheelhouse though.

Great songs; diverse selection; good voice. Only a couple of annoying ones.

Just wasn’t for me

Once again, a pleasant listen. Apple has a beautiful, soulful voice but it all felt kind of samey to me. No bad tracks but very little standouts as well

Hadn't listened to this album but I have listened to a couple of Fiona Apple albums before ( When The Pawn & Fetch the Bolt Cuters) both of which are great, but this album is by far for me better than both. Despite coming across very angry these are well crafted songs every track is great with Shadowboxer & Crimnal being my highlights.

Good album

Only previous experience of Fiona Apple's work was a guest appearance on Elvis Costello's "I Want You". Quite liked that but this album unfortunately failed to impress... Most songs very similar with some verging on sounding like they could have featured in Frozen. Not the worst album ever written and pleasant enough to listen to but not one I'd actively seek out to listen to again.

Been a long time since I listen this one and wow it's good as I remember, not sure why I don't listen to this more often.

This is a solid record. Apple writes excellent songs and accompanies her compositions with a voice that was years beyond her age. Worth a listen every once in a while.