Reviews (page 8 of 15)
Fiona Apple has been on my list so this was fun to finally check out! "Slow Like Honey," "Criminal," "The First Taste," and "Carrion" were my highlights. This was a great top to bottom atmosphere with unique instrumentations.
Solid album. Better than what I remembered 30 years ago.
Fantastic debut. I still listen to it often.
Not sure I get it. Musically, there's noting there that pulls me in. Lyrically interesting at times but otherwise drab.
Generally nice vibe, but I was bored about halfway through this album.
Better than fetch the bolt cutters...Still not so great. Highlights were first taste and criminal.
First time listening to Fiona, quite the treat. Nice tones and an easy feel
Really really good if you are in a melancholy mood
Great voice, but not up there with the best. Kind of sounds like an Adele album, but not quite as good. This came before Adele though.
I could not get into the songs.
She was 18-19 when this came out. I was 21 so it didn’t seem weird then. It does now.
Gorgeous album, Fiona Apple has such a powerful voice.
Really nice. Buttery singing. Smooth. A little jazzy piano. Very satisfying. A little haunting.
One of the sassiest, most vulnerable, haunting, and consistent albums I’ve ever heard. Didn’t pay too much attention to the vocals on first listen but excited to revisit several times
Moody. Have listened twice. Very good
It was a fine album but really not for me.
This is an absolute masterpiece and one of the best first albums ever made.
Apple's debut album starts with a dark tone, very intriguing, and that's the mood for the album. It's brooding and introspective. It's full of self loathing and spite at ex-lovers. Makes sense with some of the events that occurred prior to her recording this album, and you can tell Apple is pouring some of those thoughts and feelings into her work. She is a great pianist. Her vocals are not perfect, often raspy and rough, but that's what makes each track intriguing and I like that. There's also some really cool synth under some of the tracks (e.g. "Criminal") and nice guitar parts on others ("Carrion") and I'm all about that. I want to sit in a dark bar and have a whiskey and listen to "Slow Like Honey." "The First Taste" is very exotic and a nice departure from the previous mood. There are a few songs that are forgettable on the second half of the album. Highlights for me were: "Sullen Girl," "Slow Like Honey," "The First Taste," and "Carrion." I actually really liked this album. It's dark and gritty and would be great to put on when you're kinda down on the world but want something approachable and smokey and smooth to seethe along with. Pretty strong 4/5 for me. If the album hadn't let up a little down the homestretch and had veered a tad away from being a bit one dimensional, I'd be really tempted to put it at a 5.
Vom Genre her ned ganz mis, aber trotzdem voll okay.
Sehr toll! Ein variables Album, das ich sehr genossen habe. Ihre Stimme ist schön rauh und badass, aber auch sehr wandelbar zu einer brustigen, gefühlten Führung oder einer luftig-melancholischen Stimmung. Die Songs sind sowohl bezüglich Rhythmen als auch Harmonien interessant und enjoyable. In Sleep to Dream gefällt mir der Wechsel von reiner Drums-Begleitung zu Harmonien in Synthie und mehrstimmigen Singstimmen. Der Wechsel zu Sullen Girl gelingt durch die akustische Klavierbegleitung, weniger Perkussion und einer Wandlung ihrer Stimme von dunkel-wütend zu luftig-traurig. Shadowboxer gefällt mir auch sehr gut, mit seinen jazzy-Harmonien und mit ihrer brustigen, triefenden Stimme. Criminal ganz anders, die Perkussion, Stimme und Lyrics frech, Harmonien passend dazu und teilweise überraschende Wendungen. Insgesamt etwas mehr Rock‘n‘Roll Vibe. Slow like Honey ein ganz anderer, verlangsamter Trott und ihre Stimme wieder eine andere, ein sexy-melancholischer James-Bond-Vibe im ganzen Song, ich liebe die dissonanten Harmonien. Ich bin der Meinung, ab In the First Taste fällt das Album etwas ab. Allerdings finde trotzdem in jedem Song noch etwas, das mir gefällt oder mir zu Denken gibt. In the First Taste klingt ihre Stimme sehr trocken abgemischt und der Song entwickelt sich zu einem wiederum sehr anderen, poppig angehauchten Stück. Sowohl dieser als auch der nächste Song ist schnulziger, langweilig-poppiger. Aber ich finde trotzdem so beeindruckend, wie ihre Stimme in jedem Song etwas anders klingt, in Never is a Promise z.B. sehr poppig und luftig in der Kopfstimme. The Child is Gone finde ich weiterhin etwas langweilig, dafür gefällt mir in Pale September der verminderte Akkord sehr gut. In Carrion finde ich den Takt- und Rhythmus sehr positiv überraschend.
This album is stunning. I remember having it on a loop for years. I forget about Fiona Apple sometimes but I’m always excited to be reminded.
Album 764 of 1089 Fiona Apple - Tidal (1996) Rating : 2.25 / 5 I've had this in my CD case for nearly 30 years and not sure I had ever really listened to it. I didn't miss a lot. It was meh but not up to par with other releases of the same genre during that period.
Fiona Apple kind of passed me by until I listened to Fetch the Bolt Cutters a lot during the covid lockdown (it was released in 2020, but it also suited my mood). I've been meaning to go back and listen to her earlier stuff so it was good to get this one - it's less distinctive than Bolt Cutters but it's still a great debut. I should have got on the Apple train a lot earlier.
Rather pleasant
Not the worst but nothing really grabbed me. I preferred Fetch the Bolt Cutters
Love this album! Still stands up after nearly 30 years.
Fine, but annoying.
Fiona Apple - Tidal Probably a light to medium 4, already a fan of hers and I like all of this but I could go for a couple more tunes as good as Carrion to make me surer of my rating (Idler Wheel and When the Prawn are both more consistent albums for me). ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Not for me.
Mostly piano-led singer/songwriter fare with elements of trip-hop and a dash of jazz thrown in. A pleasant listen, well produced with some nice touches, but never really blew my socks off. Standard bluesy vocals throughout probably let it down melodically, which is a shame.
I enjoyed the first half more than the 2nd half. Overall I enjoyed the album though, will be listening to some more of her work.
I understand the importance of it but it's not really my cup of tea. sleep to dream is good though.
My forever girl
Minus pop main Streamlinie, plus Jazzy!
Oh, she sang _that_ song (Criminal). Incredible voice. Both the rock-ish and somehow the jazz tracks sound quintessentially 90s, but in a good way. Favorite track: Pale September
Pretty similar to the goldfrap one. Doesn't destroy my ears so its ok I guess but dont really enjoy this kind of music. Doesn't exite me.
Good at what she does.
Very Joni Mitchell, but a good listen.
Would listen again. I loved some of these songs so much - sleep to Dream is just one of the best, and criminal and shadowboxer are great too. Overall, there are some parts that drag for me, but Fiona has such a cool voice. I give it a strong 4. Fave songs are the singles and carrion.
Enjoyed it. Surprised I had never come across it.
I can't believe I waited this long to listen. This is the perfect rainy day album
Nice and sensual songs
Heard before. I like her voice. Laid back, bluesy, sensual. Liked a lot of songs. + Sullen Girl + Shadowboxer + Slow Like Honey + The First Taste + Carrion
This record starts off really great. The singles are singles for a reason. It gets very durge’ish as it goes along.
Lyrically interesting, but melodically missing the hooks that characterized her peers of the time.
Partially listened before Fav tracks: Sleep to Dream, Criminal, Shadowboxer
Lots of piano! Some moody 90’s music, reminds be a little bit of Alanis Morissette
Not bad. Not my type of music to listen to for enjoyment.
I like this one pretty well, holds up well as a decent 90s female vocalist album. Impressive for a debut album, but unfortunately I got it just a couple weeks after Jagged Little Pill and it pales next to that one.
Love the cover, but just didn’t connect with this sonically or lyrically. Perhaps with more listens, but when does that become beating a dead horse in hope of a glimpse of life? I appreciated some lyrics, but I didn’t find myself wanting to hear anything again. Gave it a few listens, wouldn’t skip it if it came up again, but unlikely to ever go back to it. I found it a bit dreary and monotonous, dragging my mood down. It didn’t feel enjoyable or a pleasure to listen to, but more like a burden or even, dear I say, a punishment. I didn’t hate it, but I wouldn’t ask for it again.
Rainy late night drive from a murder mystery party. Slow like honey and the first taste brought this up
Good voice!
My first full Fiona Apple album. The songs were all rather long and it became a bit of a chore by the end with no respite, but some gems to be found too. Sullen Girl and Tastes Like Honey were my favourite songs. Overall, interesting accompaniment for the most part, and Fiona Apple's attitude added a bit to the performance. High 3*, probably 6.8/10
It definitely sums up the sound of the era. Not my taste though.
Great album! Takes me back to my youth. 4/5
It's a 4.5, but come on, love her. Iconic music video from the era and a unique voice in the world.
One of my favorite albums
The album is sexy as hell. I remember seeing the video for Criminal back in the day but never fully appreciated Fiona until this moment.
Really annoying voice. Couldn't get through it
Eher nicht so mein Fall, etwas zu langsam
Super cool album, love the instrumentation, Fiona Apple has a great voice and style, always kind of dismissed this as a "chick" album when I was younger but appreciate it much more with older perspective. Will def be busting it out on fall/winter Saturday mornings. 4 - will definitely listen again
3 estrelas
Didn't find to much in this one that stood out to me. A lot of repetition and all the songs are five minutes long (please there's neither the vocals nor the instrumentals to warrant that length). Her vocals worked okay with the first half tracks where they're a bit more upbeat and the vocals are almost more spoken word but I didn't think they worked in slower songs when she tried to go higher/sing more sustained notes.
This is her 2nd album in the T1001, the other one BLOWS. This one I knew from it's release in '96. It had hits, it had videos, it got airplay and she was smokin' hot & could sing. "Sleep To Dream" was always on the radio but the real gem was "Criminal" which got her on everyone's radar and sold her a bunch of CD's! The disappointment to most of the purchasing crowd is that the radio songs didn't mesh with the sleepy-jazzy mix of filler songs and her perceived image. She was pushed by her label to make a few hits, and she delivered. "Shadowboxer" was the third track that got some airplay but I don't remember her having another hit after that. If you have a hard time sleeping just throw on the last 5 songs on this album, it'll help! Not T1001 for me, but "Criminal" & "Sleep To Dream" are top 90's songs without a doubt and you still hear them today. 3 stars for hits, impact at the time and longevity, the but back half of this album is a giant miss.
Oh this ate down real bad. It just had such a melancholic yet edgy feel to it I can't explain. The instrumentals and the lyrics were so good and perfect for each other. Kinda slow at times but I might just not be in a sad mood today idk.
This album bangs. The lyrics and production is so powerful, not a single miss on this album. How is this not mainstream??
I still really like the song, Criminal, but the rest of the album is a little slow and boring for me
Bloody lovely
She has such a voice especially in "Shadowboxer" or "Never Is a Promise" really profound, really touching but I'm not a huge fan of the music like that sounds weird which actually sucks because she sings pretty nicely !
Felindra cherry - Wavy
I was 12 when the video for "criminal" came out. I didn't exactly know what was going on but I was very interested. This album is absolutely solid and I find myself listening to her more and more over the years.
Meh. The couple of hits still hold up but the rest of the album is pretty repetitive.
I listened to this album I think twice before, the first time it floored me how good it was but the second time I felt kind of underwhelmed by it, both when I was still in my teens so that makes it kind of fuzzy to remember what even went on this album, so having a chance to listen again is great as always, even more when the album is still just as good as I figured it would be. I guess mainly the fact that it's not simple piano rock with very strong vocals (but it is mostly that), but the additional instrumentals, beats and ideas that are brought which elevates the album into something even more interesting and enjoyable than I imagined. it's also that Fiona is such a charismatic vocalist that it's hard not to feel something at simply the *way* she sings and enunciates things. All around, wonderful album and I hope I can get more from her sooner rather than later
Not bad at all for a debut. The album with like 54 words in the title gets pretty far ahead of this one, but the Criminal video was a gift.
I expected to like this album a lot more. Criminal is a song I've always loved and I kind of expected more of the same, but it was much more subdued than I thought it would be. Not a bad thing, its still a good album with the right mood and setting but not something I would rush back to listen to very often. Standout tracks are Criminal, Sleep to Dream and The First Taste. 6/10
Through listening to this pretty decent album I realised that Fiona Apple is absolutely capable of producing something I love, because this is the kind of music that really appeals to me. However, as of yet that potentially 4/5 star album is unrealised. Maybe the next Fiona Apple album will be kino?
Remarkable. This is the 2nd album by Fiona Apple in this list. I had bad memories of the first - newer - one. So I wasn't expecting much. But I was surprised. I liked the album, quite a lot in fact. Did I perhaps do Fiona an injustice with her previous album? I'm listening to it now. No. I don't like the new album, but I do like this one. 4/5
Still like Criminal the most. Rest of the album was easy listening, but no other standouts for me.
Challenging and rewarding! Chock-full of artistry!
First timer for me here, this is sick. Kinda assumed it would be based on reputation. Lives up to it.
Wrong time, wrong place. Was incredibly tired when I listened to this and it didn't help the situation. Didn't hate it but it went by uneventfully
Icon
sleep to dream isch jo huuuere geill de wummrig bass. ihri bluesige vocals d chords d produktion wo easy busy isch. booah s klavier wo sochli inefadet. geili bridge. wow. hammer afang. sullen girl viel zruckhaltender, ruhiger aber super schön produziert au sehr geil. sie isch 18ni uf dem?? unglaublich riifs songwriting und stimm. slow like honey maaad cool. ich find mit de ziit ischs biitz easy listening für mich aber s isch alles uf uhuere höchem niveau. never is a promise zb suuper schöni strings und d chords mached saache. suuuper song. the child is gone au pedal steeel gitiii. ui carrion au suuuper, giti druf uuuhuere geil ide mitti. wowooo. he sehr guets vieri, ide mitti hets mi biiitz verlore aber es isxh scho huuuere guet
sleep to dream het sehr cool ahgfange! hans denn aber leider chlii langwilig gfunde jaa weiss nöd, chan wenig degege sege ussert "meh" sue het e cooli stimm, s album isch bis jz rechr villsitig aber macht echt wenig mit mier slow like honey het sehr e intimi atmosphäre, mega schön the first taste het en geile rhythmus!! au wenns schad isch, dass es sich eso wiiterzieht aber cooli abwechslig never is a promise isch sehrsehr schön! die sanfti giige als understriichig wauwiii! bis jz glaub s beste pale september au schön langsam ihlullend, die zweit hälfti, bzw. chli die langsame trurige holed mich meh ab hahaha s gitarresolo am schluss isch scho gad echli cheesy he ja. ide zweite hälfti paar seehr schöni lieder aber allgemein ischsmer chli zu seicht gsi
Good album. But the second half of it clears the first half
Its nice as background music but not to actively listen to
Really pleasant listen, a lot of really good songs and not really any bad ones. Nothing that blew me away though
The First Taste, Never Is a Promise and Carrion all top tier
Probably one of my favorite albums of all time. Like many 90s kids I was totally in love with Fiona. Between Pantera and other heavy stuff, I ran this CD and her followup in HEAVY rotation. Almost every song is a musical masterpiece. There are so many layers and musical embellishments. I still love this album so much.
Not my thing.
Fiona Apple is a fantastic artist, really good debut album
It's good, just not for me. Helps to be an angsty teenage girl, the ton and lyrics probably more relatable then.
Heard it before. It seems like her most recent album became THE Fiona album for lots of people but to me nothing beats her first two records 4/5
very nice album. i was very impressed with the production and the range of sounds. this album has a combination of catchy pop melodies, powerful lyrics, and beautiful vocals throughout. fav song: the first taste
“Her voice is annoying.” Are y’all high?
Very sad girl 90s. Strong piano. Not sure at all what is special about this album. I guess criminal (I've been a bad bad girl) is a decent song and a bit of a classic, but don't think it supports the rest of the album. Maybe if I was into jazz this would be good?
Trage zaagplaat - zeer gemiddelde stem
This was nice. I can see why Fiona Apple is so highly regarded. This was fantastic. Will be listening to more
Awesome debut!!
Great old school indie vibe
Criminal is a classic, not too shabby from this lady
Getting mind-blown by this album. I'm getting Sade vibes here and there.
Inte min grej
who hurt fiona apple 🤔😡🤬
No estoy segura de si estoy triste o enojada; Fiona Apple tampoco.
Sleep to Dream and Criminal are great, the rest didn't really land with me.
Arrangement wise, probably her weakest album, but still a masterful songwriter and singer.
A fav for me in the 90’s Reminds me of good easy art times.
I only knew two things about Fiona Apple; she sang the song, Criminal, and gave a cringe-worthy speech at some award show. That being said, I was surprised by this album as it is full of songs that reminded me of old torch songs. It’s very mellow and does not at all sound like something a teen would produce. I am especially impressed as it appears she wrote most of these songs.
Liked this one more than I thought I would, solid vocals and 90's rock. Not my preferred genre, but an ok listen. Best song: Sleep to Dream
e num é que a menina é boa mesmo? letras belissimas e a voz da querida é forte e bem expressiva. já é madrinha aqui em casa!!!
More alt-girl cool rock. Or cool girl alt-rock. I can dig it, but don't love how inconsistent the style and mood are across the album. This record is best when it gets dark and quiet - when it lands, it lands really well! Favourite tracks: Shadowboxer, Slow Like Honey, Pale September
There are some really good songs on this album, and I’m positive if I listened more, I would grow to like them more. This style just isn’t in my current listening tastes.
All the teenage feels!
No question 5 out of 5. This album made my week. Other than the live cover of “I want you “by Mazzy Star with Elvis Costello AND despite all the accolades for the new album, nothing else compares to Tidal…
Great first album! I enjoyed all of it.
7/10 fave: the first taste
3.5
One of my all time artist... Though I do absolutely love this album, I still feel When The Pawn... would have been a better selection over this. I'm glad Fetch The Bolt Cutters is still to come. (9.1) ★★★★½
Nothing I would particularly seek out, and a bit boring. 3 stars
While this is Fiona's most commercially successful album, it's also the least representative of her, and the least essential. There's some good stuff here -- "Criminal", "Sleep to Dream", "Carrion", and "Sullen Girl" are the highlights for me -- but, she hadn't really found her groove in terms of songwriting yet, and a lot of the rest of it is just merely okay. 3.5 stars.
So I do find Fiona’s voice pretty annoying for the most part and the songs on her debut aren’t really the full Fiona whack which is probably a good thing considering how much I dislike all her later stuff I’ve heard. There’s some chill 90s grooves here but not too many memorable choons except for the first minute of Criminal (I’ve been a bad, bad guuuurl). The First Taste rides silkily along a nice undulating Latin beat and is the closest thing to a favourite track. 2.5 stars.
Not one i'd come across before, lets go. Ok, all the pieces are here, voice is ok, nice drums, piano is good, strings are good, why am i not enjoying this? I ended up listening twice as i couldnt grab it. It sounds like an AI album where everything should fit but it just doesnt, a jigsaw picture made of lots of different puzzles that dont quite fit and the effect is very jarring. I kept getting a nice beat or a hook and then it would disappear without any development. Very strange
Right album. Right place
Iconic debut
Suck it
Lovely piano
One of the first albums to genuinely surprise me - not that she hasn't given me reason to be skeptical, but I went into this album with something in mind that was different to the actual product. This album is far more reigned in and 'radio-friendly' than I would have expected considering Fiona Apple's other releases. I'm happy she's expanding into a field that is more uniquely hers, but I was pleasantly surprised by this album.
really hard to relisten to the album because i listened to it once before in such a dark time in my life. but this album is in my imaginary list of best albums of all time…like if i had to choose 3 albums this would be on there. fiona apple is just a genius and this album just proves it all. sullen girl will always be my favorite song. bless her and this album, i don’t know how i would have made it through high school without tidal.💙
I usually listen to each album that I review once, but this one got two listens as the first time round was with a car full of people so it didn’t really get any of my attention. When relistening today, I found it to be quite a lively, calming, chilled out album. There weren’t any tracks that I recognised, so I’m not sure which were considered the bigger hits, but Criminal stood out to be as the best of the track list here. I doubt I’ll be returning for another listen, but I did enjoy my time with this album.
I like her voice the songs are generally pretty good but nothing ascends to greatness.
I only knew criminal (which is one of my favourite songs) coming into this Did the rest of the album live up to that mark? Yes, and with quite a bit to spare Not a bad track on here
Never listened to fiona apple before and was suprised in a good way. The lyrics were heartfelt and clever whilst the sound patterns were unique and well constructed. Overall impressive stuff, looking forward to seeing more in the future. Favorite track: shadowboxer. Overall score: 7.9/10
I find this quite enjoyable. Nice indie music and a nice voice.
Never cared for her.
It’s good!
Not bad, not great, just... a thing? I don't really get it, I guess. Pop-rock with a side of jazz, I'd listen again, but only if someone else suggested it.
Very good
90s lady pop music of a jazzy variety.
Powerful….
one of the most genius writers of the modern age
Owned this one back in the day. Great voice. Great debut.
10% banger
Decent voice but my god it's boring
Lovely album full of great ballads and songs. I really like the instrumentation and singing here. Fiona Apple's songwriting is also great as well, much better than the pop girlies that followed after. I really like how a lot of the songs change in sound throughout the song itself, every note here feels like its really thought out. Shadowboxer and Sullen Girl are my favorites here.
A less slutty version of Lana Del Rey
Pretty good album. Has a definite 90s vibe.
Respectable piano and drum dramatics.
Kinda mid, overhyped 3/5
A solid debut from Ms. Apple but a work she would only grow from
One wonders how Camille Paglia would feel about this record, not to mention one's theory of this (along with Alanis M's records) being female fantasy – full empowerment and open sexuality (one's all for that) and owning the mensfolk (which is some [perhaps most] circumstances is totally fine). It feels a little overdone in this direction and not as good as Tori Amos, say, or the criminally underrated Toni Childs even though the full-on commitment that FA shows is mostly to be lauded. "First Taste" and "Never Is a Promise" are strong. Slightly begrudging 4 here.
Man, I remember when this album came out. It was all over the radio everywhere and rightfully so. I think it also holds up today as a really well written, performed and produced album. Some of it is a little dated sounding. For example, the jazzy groove of The First Taste is very mid 90s. I could say Criminal is also very mid 90s sounding, but that's because it was THE song of the mid 90s from my memory.
fiona apple good at music
not my favourite fiona record but still SOLID. her writing is great and how young she was when she wrote this makes me feel bad about myself
Wow. What a swell re-listen. She’s a poet.
Great album. This was one of the first artists that made me fall in love with a female front woman!
Good album, but it should be played when raining.
I do not like Fiona Apple's music. There I said it. There is something about this album that feels off. Something about the vocals and the music do not mesh. I think the vocals are too loud. And I also don't think her voice is good enough to be put over the instrumentals chosen for this album. It is off-putting to me.
Bunch of songs are way too long. The slow ones were putting me to sleep toward the end. Did enjoy the originality though. She's basically a more punky Regina Spektor.
Incredible. Tear jerking and passionate. Can’t believe she was 19 when she made this. 9/10
The first depressed woman in music (4)
This is really good. I love how diverse the instruments can get, every outro and instrumental moment has interesting details.
mostly great, pianos as the main instrument in rock/pop often comes off very cheesy (meat loaf) but I think this does it well. I think this is better than the bolt cutters one by a little, but probably a little worse than the pawn one, as I think I like the more experimental stuff on there. Some of the more pop ones I like less though. Favourite songs: sullen girl, shadowboxer, criminal, slow like honey, the first taste, the child is gone. Overall around 7/10
Some pretty good songs on this album. She has a great voice and the different instruments they use to layer the songs sound great. Added a few songs to playlists and when in the mood this feels great as background listening at an afterparty while cooling off.
Probably our parents' dream girl
Shit
I like her style. Most songs are cool and soulful. Some are fragile and beautiful.
2+ Stars (6/15)
Wow was whatever when it came out to me li d of didnt get it but mow I feel its a masterpiece. Aged better with time. Fiona is greater than great. Super blown away with listening to this after about 20 years later a new meaning. Loved every single song.
i don't really like fiona apple but i really liked this. mostly cause it got a lil bjorky
Y'all, Fiona Apple was 19 when she wrote this. This woman lived a life through song that no body twice her age has lived. This is such a powerful album that I forgot about because this poor child was being pushed around by the media when she first broke, it's amazing she's sane today. 4.5/5
I spent a lot of time with this album in the early 2000s and still like it a lot. I never found Fiona Apple to be particularly relatable but her voice is so good and the album has a good amount of variety of production to keep it moving. Listening now, there is maybe a tighter 40 minute album within this. 3.5 rounded up.
i think i heavily disliked fiona apple because she was interrupting my very rude alternative rock and grunge airwaves in 1996, but this is pretty good throughout
This mind this body and this voice cannot be stifled by your deviant ways!!!!! I've read my fair share or more of interviews with Fiona Apple and while she can be cringey/pretentious/annoying at times, I really think she scores highly on being intelligent and talented enough to far outweigh it. This could have been another album penned by a teenager that is followed by not-so-great work because they seemingly used up all their good ideas, but I think her work continued to be great, which makes this shine even more. "Pale September" feels like a little transportation capsule every time I listen to it and I'm sure I don't need to talk about "Criminal" here. However..........as an album, I think some of the tracks being so excellent means that tracks like "Sullen Girl" and "The First Taste" wind up feeling forgettable even though the listen-through experience is still good. 4.5 rounding up
Really enjoyed, even listened to more of her albums after
Man I really wore this one out back in those crazy late 90’s. Really, Fiona Apple hasn’t put out a bad album in my opinion. I’d say this one, When The Pawn Hits…, and her newest release, Fetch The Bolt Cutters are my favorites. She’s just such an interesting songwriter and has such a distinct voice. If you enjoy this album then I think you’ll really love WILLOW’s album “empathogen.” She has a similar progressive and jazzy take on pop music much like Fiona. Go listen to that now you won’t be disappointed!
Such a cool album. Smooth music with powerful vocals and lyrics. I tell ya, I loved the videos, too. Super sexy. I have never listened to any of her albums after this one, so I'll need to do that. I was 16 years old boy when this came out, but my favorite was always, and still is, Sullen Girl. I like the piano. Slow Like Honey is a throwback. Great tune. I guess she was 18 or 19 when this came out. This doesn't sound like someone that young, but she nails it. Classic album that I like start to finish, so I'm giving this a 5.
Languid and jazzy, sometimes meandering and low-every. My favorite new-to me track was The First Taste--Sade vibes. The greatest strength is her poetic, emotive, lyrics.
This stuff is not particularly my thing, but I do recognize that Fiona is indeed talented. She is a small person with a big voice. Some of the songs are edgy. I am interested in seeing what her other albums are like.
Rigtig godt album. Synes ofte sangene har nogle gode outros. Blender jazz pop med chamber pop. Chamber pop er lush Sound som blander rock og pop. Der er orchestral Sound og strings. Top 25 debut albums of all time i følge Rolling Stone Magazine.
Nice and soothing, a tad bit boring. This album definitely has some impressive songwriting and is sequenced very well.
Pretty good, liked a bunch of the songs
Strong voice, sad I’ve avoided her. Perfect for the 90’s lovey, heart broken, free and independent feel. What a great time for music really. She cemented herself amongst the top females of the era.
Played it, remembered a few songs from when they were originally released then went back to what I was doing. Didn’t really do it for me then, nothings changed I’m afraid.
Brilliant debut album. I love every song on this disk. Shadowboxer is outstanding as is Criminal. I bought this when it was first released and still love it today.
Listenable but not my thing
не так тяжело как остальные альбомы Фионы, но грэмми я бы не криминалу дала (дженерик) а другим не похожим на её творчество (номинация песня не похожая на творчество Фионы)
Well yes!
Fucking awesome
really pleasant listen. remembered me a little bit of michael buble
Um dos melhores álbuns que já ouvi, tenho em vinil 🤠
It's a nice enough album. The artist has a nice enough voice. But there are not many songs on here that I would ever seek out to listen to again. The album also tends to wander too much across different styles, which might be a plus for some, but is not so for me.
This is nostalgic, and I like her smokey voice. Quite nice.
perfect
I think I dozed off a couple of times
Strong album with punchy tunes. It's a feminist album without being obvious about it. The entire thing is bubbling with talent, definitely something special. She's the next Kate Bush to me. Not because she copies Bush (her style is completely her own) but because she is authentic and clearly an excellent song writer. Here's a break down of some of the songs: Sleep to dream is a banger. Slow like honey showcases Apple's luscious, haunting vocals. A slow, dark banger of a song. The last two tunes were quite dull to be honest, the album would have been better without them. However, the strong songs make up for it. I love the rarity of finding a genuinely original, talented female song writer baring her soul to her listeners. Real glad I found this!
Pretty good, a few I enjoyed. Somewhat alt rock, nice voice.
I've listened to one other Fiona Apple album (Fetch the Bolt Cutters) listening through it once, and remember it as being quite strange. This one is from an entirely different era, so I have no idea what to expect. Sleep to Dream Dense production. Interesting verse structure. Transitions suddenly. Strangely catchy. Concludes solidly. Great. 4/5 Sullen Girl Stylistic shift from the previous track. I do enjoy the ocean imagery, fits well with the deep piano playing. The instrumental evokes a wave effect alongside the drums, adding some beautiful rhythm. Passionate performance carries throughout the track. Surprising. 5/5 Shadowboxer Deep moody vocals, sounds almost confrontational. Great tempo. Chorus feels a bit weak on first impression. The strings sit oddly in the mix. Slightly jazzy. Enjoyable. 3.5/5 Criminal The writing seems very of the era. A bit boring instrumentally. I don't really like the chrous, comes across as cheesy. I do like the synth(?). Fine. 3/5 Slow Like Honey Slow, calming. Not sure about the mix, especially the bass. I appriecate the measured vocal performance. Lyrically solid. Great. 4/5 The First Taste Sparse, intimate to start. Quite different instrumentally, though I'm not sure it works. Conflicts with the vocals, is too loud in the mix and feels distracting. I like the structure of the song. Has issues, but ultimately seems decent enough. 3/5 Never is a Problem Subtle. Well written lyrically, descriptive. Fantastic chorus. Beautifully performed. Fantastic. 5/5 The Child is Gone Nothing really comes to mind immediately. I think the lyrics are interesting, she has a particular writing style that seems to carry over throughout the album. Not to interesting, but above average. 3/5 Pale September Sullen and vulnerable performance. Slightly unclear. I enjoy the progression of the chorus. Sort of makes me sleepy, though not necessarily a bad thing. Enjoyable. 3.5/5 Carrion The subtle guitar is nice. The instrumental shift in the chorus is too loud in relation to her voice, drowns it out. Flat performance. I don't think the closing instrumetation has the punch it intends to have. Disappointing closer. 2.5/5 Great effort for a debut at 19 years old. The songwriting is obviously great, it's perfomed splendidly and there are some moments where the vocal melodies are absolutely fantastic. While it is hard to evaluate lyrics on a blind listen I do recognize their consistent quality and a signature style throughout the album. However there are moments where the production choices do let her down. I also think instrumentally there really isn't too much interesting going on. I feel myself more attracted to the songs where it's less instrumentally dense, and I do think that the weaker tracks are the ones where they go overboard with it to the point of it being distracting. While I do think it is well performed it isn't always that it works for me. I don't find every track on here engaging, finding it slightly difficult not to drift off at times. Still the tracks that work, really work, finding myself enamoured by them. Some making me exlaim my appreciation for them aloud to myself. I find myself wanting to check out more of her discography after this. Inconsistent but still good, would recommend. Fave Track. Never is a Problem Least fave track. Carrion
really enjoyed this. great songwriting, and Apple has a beautiful voice
8/10 She killed this out of the gate. The voice and song writing are masterful. The best songs are classics and the worst are simply listenable. 3-06-2025
I wouldn't say i've actively avoided listening to Fiona...but it's never been something i ever sought out. Nothing personal - nothing targeted. Just never really fell into sync with my listening profile. Let's see what this is about! Ok - Criminal fuckin rips. Wow. I'm gonna play it back again because it was so good. Shadowboxer is also right up my alley. B Side definitely does slow down a bit - but still lyrically beautiful. Overall very surprised this falls right up my alley given that I've honestly never given it the time of day before. Could be something that i've aged into the taste, or just a classic case of I've never heard of this before!
It’s aight’
Sort of what I expected it to sound like, not a genre that will ever be a go-to-listen for me, however it's genuinely very good, some great compositions and her voice is excellent.
ive already listened. 4
She has an amazing voice and great melodies. The lyrics have so much emotion. I didn't love the entire album.
Not that bothered.
This album was such a pleasure to listen to. It's sultry and jazzy and beautiful and NOT what I expected at all from what I've heard about Fiona as a person over the years. I tried listening to fetch the bolt cutters when it came out and I really didn't like it but this album is a lot more accessible. I really enjoyed it.
I have some deep nostalgia for the first half of this album (up to and including criminal), but feel like the second half kinda drags a bit. She’s got a great voice and solid song writing.
I'm a big Fiona Apple fan, and on balance this album does hold up, but I wouldn't say it was her best. It does have a tendency towards morose teenage angst and some lyrics which could have been improved - but seeing as she was a literal teenager when she wrote it, I think that can be excused. Also, you get the feeling that some of the low notes are a little out of her natural range. That said, I think every song has something to offer, and several are top tier. Shadowboxer, Never is a promise, Carrion, Criminal, Sleep to Dream - I loved them as a teen and I love them now. A low 4, but still a 4.
insubstantial
Nine Apples out of ten.
OK, 3/5
really nice
Surprising and compelling album.
-ahh tidal… this was my intro to Fiona Apple last year, i got into a bunch of songs from it but never listened to the full record until now -it’s really beautiful and well-done especially for a debut album. a perfect showcase of her talent with so many standouts… god i love Sleep To Dream -Favorites are Sleep To Dream, Criminal, and The First Taste
Love this album. Late to this album, but blew me away that its the blueprint for a lot of music I enjoyed growing up like Regina Spektor. Love the production as well; i wish I could make my piano sound as good as fiona's. I think she would go on to do even better work with Pawn, especially with the inclusion of Jon Brion, but this is still an INSANE debut.
Mellow jazzy pop, enjoyed more than expected. A high 3.
Great voice, the songs left a bad taste in my mouth though. Just... not for me, I suppose. Some interesting bits but nothing I want to bring into my future. Not relatable enough for me and toward the end everything started to sound a bit the same, with a couple exceptions that I don't really care to review.
She lives up to the hype
2025-02-16
Still amazing. Still know every word.
Nice voice and piano. Always heard the name but never listened to anything. I knew the opening lines to criminal. Overall it was an enjoyable listen and left a favorable impression of the artist
This album is wonderful! Musically sophisticated, lyrically insightful beyond her years. Stellar through and through.
Good groove, felt kind of sassy. Definitely liked some songs a lot and others I didn't care for
I’m sure someone liked it, just not sure whomst
like it best so far vibing with a few of these
Favourite tracks: sleep to dream; shadowboxer; sullen girl; criminal; never is a promise; pale September; the first taste
Ihan ok taustamusiikkina, muuten ei kiinnostele.
Finde es gibt noch bessere von Fiona Apple, aber sie ist einfach toll ♥️
Puh, auch langatmig. Vllt hat mich ein Song abgeholt.
sleep to dream banger
big meh
An album of contrasts. Some of the most important songs written in that era in the first part of the album, followed by less good stuff in the back end.
Its so down, but so good. So many of us have felt all these songs and felt completely overwhelmed by life and who we are. Hearing them is so gut wrenching yet beautiful. She also has such a beautiful unique sound. Its not perfect, but that is part of what her appeal is. Her ability to story tell and share such deep emotions is intensified by her voice and he music.
I'm a big fan of a few of Ms. Apple's songs like "Fast as You Can" and "I Want You to Love Me" but those aren't on this album. Cool to give her debut a listen. At age 18/19 she's clearly writing poetry with emotional depth and complexity well beyond her years. I had to give this several listens and really put my jazz ears on to appreciate the artistry. Favorites: Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, Criminal (no matter how many times I hear this one it's still so good), The First Taste, The Child is Gone. Great instrumentation and love how her voice and piano flow together over some great beats.
Tidal pops up and my heart sings. This review will write itself. Fiona is a one in a billion musician. Her honesty and truth speak so loud and clear and beautifully, and I find that to be the rarest of qualities among the vast majority of popular musicians that are crammed down our throats by the media these days. She’s special. BEYOND special. This record was made by an emotionally damaged yet fierce of soul 18 year old girl who had already lived some shit. Sullen Girl lays it out. She’s sad beyond her precious years because some asshole took from her the most prized possessions she had; her youth and innocence. I can’t imagine how many girls who’d been raped found this and healed by simply having someone put a real voice to it. Fiona comes with that voice and poetry so powerful it can move mountains. My first thought in 1997 was “who is this amazing black girl with the voice of a warrior?” When I saw she was a frail looking white girl, I was astonished. Shadowboxer lets that husk come to the forefront. It has an old school jazz vibe that wraps the package up in a big beautiful bow. Criminal is the big, still uber cool hit with hip hop earnestness and hyper confident delivery. On the other side of the coin, the piano melody of Never Is A Promise sounds so fragile it feels as if a feather could break her, but again, her voice is the powerful reckoning to the trauma inside her. This may not be a perfect record in terms of each song hitting its mark exactly as some songs drag on unnecessarily, but it is a perfect record in tone. It’s a perfect record of introduction to a force of nature in pop music. Fiona can take 8+ years between albums now, if she even feels like making anything at all, because she’s got nothing to prove. When she does drop an album, it’s a titan of modern art. 2020’s Fetch The Bolt Cutters is just that. She was the real deal in 1996, and she still is now.
Ah, Fiona’s debut, brings back memories! I love how a lot of the songs start slow and simple, and then the layers build into a big emotional energy even as the pace stays similar. Criminal and Shadowboxer are standout hits, and Never is a Promise is a favorite on here too. Just really beautiful music, I love her.
I definitely understand why she's controversial. I'm not going to take sides. 3.
Un pò troppo vacuo per i miei gusti, troppo blando e slavato
I hadn't heard this before. She has a lovely smooth voice and it's an accomplished debut, I'll be seeking out more of her work.
I do like a good gutsy female vocalist and this fits the bill. I will be looking for more of her stuff
Decent but not my cup of tea, like I wouldn't turn it off if it came on in the car
Easy listen. Nice and soft. Powerful vocals and you can really tell how much she influenced modern pop sound.
A sultry mix of soul, jazz, and rock. The personal tales are riveting
Strong 6- light 7 good production but some bad vocals and a bad start as well gets better in the middle.
did not care for it, it insisted upon itself
Great singer no doubt. The album as a whole feels a bit of the same from track to track.
In Fall of 1995 I went off to college. In the dorms at college I was randomly assigned a roommate. That roommate was a dude who was absolutely obsessed with Debbie Gibson. Posters, yearly birthday cards, the whole thing. So he was primed when Alannis released Jagged Little Pill. I probably heard that album 500 times over the course of the first school year, blasting out of our shared CD player. The next year when Fiona Apple released Criminal as the first single off of Tidal, that song (along with the evocative music video) became his new obsession. I worked at the Walmart electronics department at the time and had to watch the first 30 seconds of the video on loop for every 6 hours shift so I friggin' hated that song. With 30 years of hindsight, I can now appreciate the quality of this album, even if it still isn't really my jam. Fiona Apple resides somewhere between Tori Amos and Alannis on the female dark quirky pop music spectrum. She has forged a long career for herself that I would not have predicted while I was hating on the Criminal music video during my shift at Walmart all those years ago. This album is well written and well performed, but maybe a touch to 90s cheesy for my tastes.
Omppunaiselle 3... Aikoihin... Jo on.... & Elettty
To jest female rage w najczystszej postaci. Ulubiony przeze mnie gatunek Pani z gitarą/fortepianem w nieco odważniejszej wersji. Idealne na dni, kiedy świat daje ci kopa. Fiona jest wybitną tekściarką i tak, jej płyty zmieniały muzykę. 8/10
Good album
com todo respeito à voz e letra da Apple mas esse disco só não acabava
A fuller voice than many, with good and varied music around it. Quite the piano player as well.
Nice easy listen 3/5
Quite ok. Nothing great. Not offensive that's for sure. Three.
It was a solid listen, just didn't really stand out all that much, even after two playthroughs. Maybe a 3.5 rounded down. Certainly was a massive upgrade from listening to Napalm Death.
A pretty strong debut for the most part. Fiona Apple sounds like a seasoned vet despite being only 18-19 during recording. A lot of the tracks venture a bit in an artistic sense (which is very noticeable at the end of almost each track), but the overall theme of self-discovery and angst stays consistent I guess. This is one of those albums that burns brightly early and leaves you a little fatigued after the halfway mark to be honest.
3.5. Hi ha hagut cançons que m'han encantat i n'hi ha hagut algunes que se m'han fet una mica pesades. Overall, m'ha agradat bastant el "flow" de l'àlbum i és un tipus de música que gairebé mai escolto però que aniré ficant-me més sovint
Any Fiona album gets a 5. Such an insane debut album. I’ve always thought the back half was a bit weaker but they hit me a lot harder this listen. Also is my favorite album cover of hers. I sadly ranked Fetch the Bolt Cutters at a 3 star but it would be 5 star if I had to rate again. Hopefully one of the other 3 albums are on here as well. It's impossible to rank her albums; genuinely any could be my favorite that day. Rating: 4.9
Nice music. Sometimes like Joan Baez. Mellow and peaceful.
Can’t imagine too many mellotrons were used in 1996
Bad apple
Heavy jazz influence. Some songs are faster in beat but the piano is the focal point in a lot of songs and brings a sense of intimacy.
Liked her other albums more.
If you take away the "can you believe she was 18 and 19 years old when she made this, her debut?", and just focus on the music, you're left with a different vibe. I never listened to this record in 1996 or after, but probably brushed up against a couple of the singles here and there... "Criminal" was hard to escape for a bit there. So it's interesting to hear this disembodied voice and production, removed from its time period and context. It certainly sounds great, with a jazzy, '70s singer-songwriter undertone... seventh chords and melodies clinging to the blues scale when she runs out of melodic ideas... this was also the period of time when rock songs, even 'pop' songs, were at their longest on average, and this record is caught in that snare... "Criminal" is groovy and catchy but it's 5:42, "Shadowboxer" is 5:25... you REALLY have to be patient with these songs. I don't get why the people in charge would allow "Slow Like Honey" and its plodding, meandering ilk to make the final cut... it's like a lounge singer who has been playing standards who told the audience "I'm gonna play one of MY songs now" and puts everyone to sleep... it REALLY pulled me out of the record, and the nineties bossa groove of "The First Taste" couldn't get me back. In the end, for me at least, the production, the voice, the musicianship, is all far better than the actual songs. That may be enough for some, but it wasn't enough for me.
I became a Fiona Apple fan later and was a bit lukewarm on her stuff in the 90s. I really enjoyed the re-listen and it's a great album--almost a 4.5, but going with a:
Ihan keskikelpoa poppia. Vähän semmoinen jazz ja rock fiilis tässä on. Parhaat: Criminal, Shadowboxer
Couldn't get the overall appeal for this album, to me, it sounded like a person who made an album that hasn't honed in on their sound and hasn't quite figured out what they're going for. I did enjoy a single song off this though and it was "The First Taste", so the album wasn't a complete wash. Perhaps its because its the most pop sounding tracks.
3*
Good album but outside of criminal I can’t see myself listening to it much.
9/10 Favorite Tracks: All of them Least Favorite Tracks: None
i don't get fiona apple sry
Pre listen: Hell yeah. I've been meaning to listen to more Fiona Apple and going into this Criminal is a banger! Post: Big fan but not as good as other work I've heard before from her. Feels like a less extravagant Regina Spektor style singing even if the music style is heavier. Highlight: Never Is a Promise
Another new one for me - this was real mellow to have on in the background and I wasn't really focused on the lyrics, but I sense that if I were to listen to this more, I'd really get into it. Definitely the kinda atrist I like so a new one on the listen list
I have one or two Fiona Apple track in my favorites (from earlier albums), but I had heard good things about her 2020 album Fetch the Boltcutters, so I was excited to hear a full album from her. I wasn't disappointed. She has a fantastic ear for melody and her vocal range is excellent. I hadn't heard Criminal in years, and it brought me back. Fav Tracks: Shadowboxer, Criminal
I love love love this album. I just picked it up a couple of months ago in a depression, not knowing the depression was about to get worse. It was an album I had loved in the past with a partner, this and Extraordinary Machine together. With that breakup, I had to put them away for a while. This was YEARS ago and I've had breakups since then where I could reclaim those musical memories faster. But I'm back to Fiona Apple. And I'm grateful. I think this is good sad-boy music, but this is something that also says "it's okay, not everything is your fault, and there may be an end to this." Also, Fiona, if by some weird chance you read this, I'll run into traffic for you. Just saying.
I liked this. Not usually a piano-focused music guy, but this has some very interesting songwriting/structure and beautiful vocals. This would certainly a be mood-inspired relisten, but I could see it happening.
Very nice. For you, for me and my squirrel. Very nice.
"This world is bullshit" - Fiona Apple, 1997 MTV VMA Awards Every generation seems to have its own real-life Howard Beale. That said, in true Gen-X style, this album is less about anger at others and much more about angst in one's self. Alanis Morrisette comparisons are tempting, but Fiona feels much more put-together, both in her incredible piano playing and in her withering putdowns. Feels like the cool girl you were too intimidated to talk to in class - except Fiona's poetry was actually pretty good.
Much of this album feels like a soundtrack for a deep, dark, menacing piece of baroque film noir. At times, it sprawls. And then, it's right in your ear and your ear alone. I'm a sucker for a 6/8 swing, and this album has a few. The rhythm sections, including drums, base, and often, Apple's piano, is sublime. So many brilliant musicians on this album. String arrangements are pristine. This album is an achievement and, while the three hits are perfectly rated, perhaps the album, as a whole, is actually underrated.
I love Fiona Apple, especially after regular plays of Bolt Cutters, but never to listened to Tidal in full. I understand why she was frustrated by Criminal overshadowing a lot of solid songs. It’s a good listen.
Every song sounds like Phil Spector was given the reigns and he said more strings and swell effects. Repetitive.
So great and a sign or even better things to come.
And it’s a sad, sad world.
mixed feelings. definitely good but almost felt boring by the end
This was a great discovery. There's a risk of over-reacting after a run of slightly disappointing albums, and from the joy of discovering something new, so I'll only give it 4* to be safe.
Great music to put in the background when you’re trying to get that hippie chick.
Boring
Ganz nett, mir blieb aber nichts besonders in Erinnerung - Musikalisch für mich mittelmaß, vielleicht sind die Texte ausschlaggebend
Boring
a masterpiece.
Another appropriate early January listen.
I've seen other complaints about this and wanted to get it out of the way. Yes, the songs go on a bit too long. If there is anything we know about Fiona Apple is that she doesn't do anything just halfway. I was surprised about the jazzy feel of this album at times. I didn't think Fiona Apple would sound like a lounge singer, but she does, especially on Slow Like Honey. This is probably on me for assuming but Fiona Apple isn't as angry on here as I thought she might have been. There are good songs on here and I like this better than Fetch the Boltcutters. I didn't listen to this album back when it came out and I appreciate the sound but probably isn't an album I would re-visit.
Muy buen álbum. Increíble que alguien con 19 años pueda escribir poesía de este calibre. La música no es nada especial, aunque su minimalismo está hecho con muy buen gusto y complementa muy bien las letras melodramáticas. Le daría más puntuación, pero la segunda mitad se me ha hecho un poco tediosa. Sin embargo, los primeros 5 temas son buenísimos. 3.5
HAHAAA fiona apple my bread and butter. E ngoj tash apet kejt yessss.
3.5
Favourites: Sleep To Dream; Shadowboxer; Criminal; The First Taste
Not really my thing, couple of ok songs, quite morose, nothing particularly standout or influential about the album, very bland
Slow like honey...
Great song writer, easy listen, can imagine my wife being an angsty teenager listening to this.