Reviews (page 9 of 15)
s komische torte-album! gimme shelter isch seehr cool und verspielt surprisewarteschlange!!! hä iwie kenni love in vain? chli zuuu country für mich aber sehrsehr schön slidegitarre!!! hahah country honk: de titel lügt nöd hmm bin chli abgschweift, es isch allgemein countrier als erwartet! midnight rambler ischmer chli z lang gange die zweit hälfti vo monkey man isch seeehr schön you can't always get megaaa geile ahfang! joaaa rolling stones werded nie mini lieblingsband aber hans gern gha
Even though ive heard a lot of these songs are LOT in my life, I'm not sick of them. This band never fails to amaze me. Even if I'm listening to an album that's over 50 years old.
Probably the best of the Rolling Stones that I've heard on this list so far. I usually don't have strong opinions either way on their music, and I don't here either, but this album leaned a little more toward good than their albums usually do for me.
- Album #2 in the greatest run of releases of all time .... -
Both of the big hits on here are some of the best Stones songs, everything else is okay at best. Mid 3.
"Let It Bleed" is the eighth studio album by English rock band the Rolling Stones. It continued their more blues-oriented approach while also incorporating gospel, country blues and country rock. Guitarist Brian Jones was fired during the recording due his unreliability from his drug use and was replaced by Mick Taylor. Keith Richards played most of the guitar parts. Commercially, the album hit #1 in the UK and #3 in the US and had rave critical reviews. "Gimme Shelter" starts with those haunting guitars keys, someone singing "woooh" and a piano. The drums kick in and their off rockin." A song with really two lead singers, Mick Jagger and Merry Clayton who absolutely kills it. A great guitar riff by Keith. It's a song about the brutal realities of war- murder, rape and fear. Keith shows his versatility again using the acoustic and slide guitars in the self-titled "Let It Bleed." Jagger with his southern accent makes plenty of drug and sexual references in a song about emotional dependency. The band goes full in bluesy in "Midnight Rambler." Slide guitar and the harmonica. The long song keeps it interesting with multiple pace changes and a chaotic close with Jagger final lines being "I'll stick my knife right down your throat baby and it hurts." Richards' guitar riff and slide guitar highlight "Monkey Man." Nicky Hopkins on piano and the use of the vibraphone. ✔️ . It's a tribute to Italian pop artist Mario Schifano. I never knew that. The London Bach Choir opens the closer "You Can't Always Get What You Want" repeating the title lyrics. You got the organ, congas, maracas and the tambourine. Jagger sings about love, politics and drugs and the initial optimism and the eventual dissolution. The choir responds with the pragmatic answer. Ah, the Stones bookmarked this album pretty well, didn't they? With minimal contributions from Jones and Taylor, this really is the Keef album, isn't it? Memorable acoustic guitars, slide guitars, guitar riffs and layering of the guitars. He creates that down and dirty and sleepy bluesy sound enhanced by Jaggers' lyrics on drugs, sex and war. The contributions of Nicky Hopkins' piano, various percussion, Booby Keys' sax and, of course, Merry Clayton's vocals just add to the fantastic songs. Like yesterday with the Jam, this album is part of the Stones' magical run from "Beggars Banquet" through "Exile on Main St." A true classic album.
Went in excited to hear the album. Listening to the iconic guitar riff of "Gimme Shelter" the awesome low piano bass notes and the anthemic chorus with interesting lyrics got me more psyched. But then the album went downhill fast, more so than bad it just felt average. The Rolling Stones sound like a mediocre blues band for a big part of the album, the lyrics sound poser-ish (blues lyrics cliches delivered with a "bluesy vibe" that doesn't come across as authentic) You just don't believe that Mick Jagger has the blues. The album picks up with Monkey Man, the band does much better with faster paced rocking songs than the mid to low tempo blues. The album finishes very strong with "you can't always get what you want" which has a strong message and an original distinct arrangement as well as of course having a memorable hook. It's a bit painful to give an album with two bonafide classics a low rating, but also hard to give a decent rating to an album that I spent the majority of the time disliking
Classic
Stonkin
Crazy that this is the first time I've listened to a full album by The Rolling Stones. It was good! Diverse. The stereo production was kinda crazy. I lost a little interest in the twangier tracks, and the title track was pretty raunchy, but it was all made up for by "You Can't Always Get What You Want." What a song! This was good, I would say it's a must-listen. #88.
This one was boring. It's two songs on it that are okay, but I don't like Vietnam War draft dodging theme music. As soon as I hear a fiddle on a song from British people, i'm out.
Definitely to the blues scale of the rock/blues scale. Almost country. Hm.
I didn't know "Gimme Shelter" was Rolling Stones. You can tell they were dabbling with a blues/country influence here with the acoustic guitar and piano style. Also their "Country Honk" sounds JUST like Old Crow Medicine Show. But then the album ends with "Can't always get what you want" so this is a weird combo.
Two absolute classics top and tail this and there's some good stuff in the middle too but a few that aren't as interesting.
I really considered giving this a 5, however you can’t always get what you want brings this down to a 4. I love the rolling stones but I do not love that song
Gimme Shelter is a great song, but I felt the rest was pretty average at best. Some songs were fine, others weak, but it felt pretty disjointed imo. You can't always get what you want is not a good song.
Sitä männävuosien rokkia, joka ei itselle tee paljoa mitään. Parit hyvät rallit, kerran kuunteli.
Þetta er ekkert fjarri lagi að ná upp í fimmu hjá mér. Upphafslagið og lokalagið eru 6 stjörnu lög. Glæsileg og geggjuð. Fannst lögin á milli fyrst frekar leiðinleg. Eftir hlustun tvö fannst mér þau fín. og eftir síðustu hlustun geggjuð. Ætla að smella bara fimmu á þetta og segja fokkitt.
Fínt rokk. Nokkur mjög góð lög, en ég er ekki sérstakur aðdáandi honky tonk.
Probably my favourite Stones album. It's phenomenal.
5/9
Best of the Stones albums I've had so far. Gimme Shelter the clear highlight but the pace and tempo is pretty solid throughout. Good length, not much filler
Much like Aftermath (both versions) this is one good song followed up by a bunch of not-so-good ones, in this case not-so-good blues imitation.
okay but not their best!
More soul and blues than I realized the Rolling Stones were. Lyrics and concept seemed more accessible to me than previous records this week. A very listenable album, I’d listen again
banger.
The opener and closer are the best songs the Stones have ever done. The rest is not that interesting. 3.5
I feel like I should be in a shitty dive bar somewhere listening to this, but I'm stuck at work.
One of my favorite songs is on this one.
Some highlights: -Gimme Shelter -You Can't Always Get What You Want -You Got The Silver -Midnight Rambler -Monkey Man
Really enjoyed it. Some really bluesy music sandwiched by two all time greats. Wasn't what I was expecting, but definitely better. 8/10
Gimme Shelter is a stone cold classic. The rest of this is pretty good.
5 seconds in: 5 stars. Final verdict: Rolling Stones good.
Opening with Gimme Shelter is a flex You Can’t Always Get What You Want, one of the all time great songs Everything else was totally fine!
Perhaps suffered from my having heard it so many times so it was missing the excitement factor
Great
Great album
a nice mix of styles and no bad songs
One of the all time greats. So many different styles and it all still sounds like the Stones. No skips necessary
I bought this one on CD before I even had a CD player because I wanted to listen to the guitar riff on Monkey Man on CD. A classic not a track in vain
Really liked Gimme Shelter and Let It Bleed; didn't care much for the rest of the album. I feel like it only made it on the list for the icon status of You Can't Always Get What You Want
Probably more of a 3.5 stars, which feels patently ridiculous to say: this record, among the Stones' opuses, led off by one of the most chilling rock songs ever put to tape... 7/10. To one's own self be true, however. I've never understood how Beatles vs. Stones was ever even a remotely interesting debate. One wrote half of the pop canon by 1970. The other is the recipient of the 2025 Grammy Award for Best Rock Album, whose bassist, by the way, is (quoting from Wikipedia) "his own son's ex-son-in-law, the father-in-law of his ex-mother-in-law, as well as the stepgrandfather of his ex-wife." But what do those extratextual details matter? The album starts with Gimme Shelter and ends with You Can't Always Get What You Want! The seven songs in between vary in quality, but those bookends are enough to make it an unimpeachable classic.
Besides the 3 songs that sound vaguely country, it's an okay album.
Not really interesting, a bit of a chore to get through apart from two, by far, biggest songs. Shame, because I thought I like Rolling Stones.
Gimme shelter: 2.75/5 Love in vain: 2/5 Country honk: 0.5/5 Live with me: 2.5/5 Let it bleed: 2/5 Midnight rambler: 3/5 You got the silver: 2/5 Monkey man: 1.5/5 You cant always get what you want: 3/5
"Gimme Shelter" and "You Cant Always Get What You Want", arguably some of the Stones' most recognizable songs, bookend this album. Sadly, these songs feel totally out of place here, as the rest of the album heavily features more country and blues oriented songs that are significantly less memorable.
4/5. As an album, this is definitely not the best Stones album but it does have some great songs on here that does take to above average. Gimme Shelter and You Can't Always Get take it to a 3 alone but there are some other good songs on here that make the album a solid listen all the way through. Definitely some lazy songs that we can do without but most are great. Best Song: Gimme Shelter, You Can't Always Get What You Want, Midnight Rambler
not bad! I actually like the country & western sound for them, and i think it sounds good in Jagger's voice. there weren't really any songs that knocked me out with how good they were (other than maybe "Gimme Shelter") but I enjoyed myself and I'll probably listen again at some point in the future
So much soul; i had to have a major cultural impact on the western world.
Arguably the best Stones album (either that or Beggars Banquet). Classic songs.
At first listen, it was hard to make up my mind about this album. I didn’t hate it as venomously as other people seemed to hate it anyway, I knew that much. Eventually, I decided that I liked it; like it enough to give it four stars, even. I think what caught me off guard was this faux country/American folk cosplay the Stones seem to be guilty of at times, which maybe I would be more forgiving of if they were actually American and not from London. However, the songs that were good were really good. This record is wedged between two absolute belters of tunes, Gimme Shelter and You Can’t Always Get What You Want. Seminal Rolling Stones songs, absolute stompers. Some people seemed to think the rest of the album didn’t hold up but I quite liked the middle part. I really liked Let it Bleed and Midnight Rambler. I remember this album, unlike a lot of other albums on this list, which counts for something. It was a big improvement from the last Stones album I listened to but so far, The Stone Roses are still ahead in the Stone war.
Enjoyed this a lot more than I thought I would! Love the blues here.
Better than the other stones album we've listened to, but still mediocre
Just a great record
Gotta love the Stones
Do you like white blues records made by English dudes in London during the 60's? Do you like American country rock made by English dudes in London during the 60's? Do you like The Rolling Stones already? If you answered Yes to all three of the above, not only will you like this record but you will fully understand it's inclusion on this list and all other only all time greatest ones. If the answer is no, quite frankly, I reckon this album is going to be a bit of a struggle. To step back for a moment, I think in many ways, this kind of record shines a light on (another) one of the problems with randomly listening to "great" records - context. Listened in it's own original timeline, Let It Bleed functions both as the Stones development thus far, and where it fits into 60s rock story. As a standalone, it is a very different construct and this dichotomy explains scizophrenic Amazon style product reviews whereby people acknowledge it's failings but still give it 10 - because of it's "importance". In isolation and for someone who answered no to the questions posed at the start - over half of this album is as weak as the piss of a person after drinking a couple of litres of room temperature tap water. This is my (semi) second Stones record. I'd be given this at the outset but decided to skip, but about 20 albums in, I went back and started it. Today to finish it off I read my listening notes, I'd mistakenly started been listening to Exile on Main Street. So taking it back a notch or two to Let It Bleed... Gimme Shelter is a fantastic opener, a great groove. It makes you want to love The Stones. That intro is superb, cinematic and evocative. I get the Stones love. The album is then immediately tanked by the Love In Vain and Jagger bleating like a goat over lazy blues and sluggish drumming. Now this is why I get The Stones hate. After a full run through, it is clear to me there are two (maybe even three) different directions this album is being pulled in. The guys of muscular groove and darkness of Gimmie Shelter, Love With Me and the those inspid dicks who think a song like Country Honk (honestly can't believe I had to type something as stupid as Country Honk out) and Let It Bleed are good ideas. I mean, that fucking moonshine fiddle, for fuck sake! Midnight Rambler brings us back Into the zone of "evil" Stones and is again, harmonica overload notwithstanding, is all the better for it but another change of pace within the song pairs it down to it's bare essentials which is a shame because the song is barely essential. The good/evil Stones get back in charge for the ending You Can't Always Get What You Want, and I can only hope if there are more Stones records on this list, those guys are running the show.
Bookended by two absolutely massive songs, with the rest of the album being completely serviceable. As a full package, it's not perfect, but probably the blues-iest and most enjoyable Stones package I've gotten so far on this list.
The ones you always hear on the radio don't do much for me anymore, but I thought the deep tracks on the album were really good. Though, a lot of these songs don't song as good once you hear them live off of "Get Yer Ya Ya's Out."
Good tracks throughout, but what elevates the album is starting with Gimme Shelter and ending with You Can't Always Get What You Want.
I may be alone in having never liked Mick Jagger. I don't like his voice and never was a fan of his style. I wasn't excited to see this album come on. Some classics on here for sure, although I'd venture the classics have been overplayed so much they don't give me much pleasure anymore. Ultimately this gets to a "fine" in my book.
I've heard "Gimme Shelter" and "You Can't Always Get What You Want" through the years. Those are the classics, and understandably have the most listens on YT Music. I was hoping there would be a hidden gem in this album otherwise, but the rest blends together into a forgettable hodge-podge. With that in mind (and given the purpose of this album list), I didn't need to hear this album. 2/5.
Good stuff, albeit not as much as Exile… or …Fingers.
Les Rolling Stones, toujours fascinés par les sons et influences américaines, avec leur petit mauvais genre. Ce n'est pas un groupe qui me rejoint, même si je ne dirais pas que c'est mauvais non plus.
4- Stars (10/15)
Fine
Top 200 album for me. Stones at their best.
A perfectly mid rock and roll album. A little folksy, a surprising amount of acoustic instruments, but much of the songwriting is a bid boring. Gimme Shelter is awesome.
Enjoyed a few songs and liked the different sounds on it, would be a 3.5 if possible
If it wasn't for Gimme Shelter and You Can't Always Get What You Want, I'd gladly give 2 for this. These two songs are stellar, but as with most Stones' records, they work better as part of a greatest hits compilation. As usual for them: two hits don't make a good LP.
Great capsule of their work. Not sure it’s 5 but opens and closes so well, with a lot of meat in between.
Bookended by Gimme Shelter and You Can't Always Get, this is largely run of the mill blues rock, but they do it so well for some British geezers. 3 Stones album in quick succession from this generator. Ive had enough.
"Shelter Me" is such a phenomenon, those backing vocals bring the frisson every time. That alone is enough to catapult this album to at least four stars. The middle of the album is full of good tunes, nothing really stands out. And then the last song bookends this album with another classic. Chef's kiss.
Fuckin exhilarating and exactly what I need on a Friday.
I feel like I'm missing something. It may just be the lack of context, but outside of a handful of songs, this felt like nothing particularly groundbreaking. Not to say it's bad by any means, but I don't get why it's so lauded. I've never found Mick to be particularly captivating on records and the songwriting doesn't compensate for me. Good, not great. Rating: 7/10 Favorite Song: Monkey Man
10/10 Maybe my favorite opening track on an album ever? God bless Merry Clayton for laying down the craziest backing vocals of all time. Having this album bookended by two of the biggest songs of all time obscures the quality of the other tracks which is a shame because top to bottom this album bangs. Overall, this is one of my favorite albums because it blends folks, soul, blues, and that 60s/70s British sound in a compact and cohesive package. Favorite Song: You Can’t Always Get What You Want
A few well known singles on here that are genuinely good, but they sandwich an otherwise pretty mid collection of songs.
Jag har lyssnat rätt mycket på Stones, men aldrig på let i bleed i sin helhet. Det låter som ett Stones i högform, det svänger och det är klackarna i taket. Alltså allt som definierar Stones med den fantastiska Gimme Shelter som öppningslåt. Det går inte sätta låga betyg, men reservera mig gentemot några trista låtar och tidvis kassa texter.
I liked this one. It has a lot of classics that I've known my whole life, but haven't really sat down and listened to the original album. Morning very different than what I expected, but it was pretty solid. Definitely more single hits than a full-scope album experience.
It's ok, but I never really got into The Rolling Stones' music.
Classic Stones. I'm close to loving this album, but there are a couple of tracks mid-album which I’m just not as keen on. EDIT: Second best Stones album so far, behind Sticky Fingers. This too has grown on me. Banger album.
Gimme Shelter is one of the actually good Stones songs, the rest is pretty meh to me. I'll be nice because of the one song though I guess.
Gimme shelter is a belter
This is an absolute classic, and album 2 in the greatest 4 album run of any artist. It's got a swagger to it that nobody but the Stones could pull off; bluesy, country, rock n roll that feels primal and wild.
To be fair, if I had never heard anything besides gospel or folk music before, went to a Stones concert where a stranger gave me acid, I'd love this album too. Crazy to think boomers did that shit then just ruined everything. One has to assume Mick Jagger is to blame.
It's good. Country Mick Jagger is always funny. But they still pull it off somehow.
Songs i knew: 2 Songs i liked: meh I think I've always been more of a led/acdc fan than the stones so this album just all felt a bit watered down. I assume it was a high flyer and groundbreaking at the time but I don't think I'll come back for another listen. High 3.
Fine
This album is a classic
This album is unfuckwithable. Top to bottom. Adore the album art, as well. This album sinks in deep and resonates with some deep deep existential truth accessed through the hearing mechanisms and auditory cortex, in this case. 5 of 5. No notes.
sure, there are big hits here that are almost like cultural touchstones. but most of the album is nothing special compared to what actual blues artists create.
This is the only Stones album I listen to because it's got all you'd ever want on it. Gimme Shelter is an all time banger, the twang in Love In Vain, You Can't Always Get What You Want is a Glee Cast classic ... hit after hit 5/5
This album is nice. Gimme Shelter is obviously a perfect song. You got the silver is underrated and midnight ramble is very solid. I'm at like a 4.5 on this. Imma take the over.
This album is like a bad sandwich where the bread is the best part - the first and last songs are classics, but what comes in the middle is best forgotten.
At the beginning of this album I was convinced I had started a Scorsese movie. Really great record. Love the bluesy rock sound.
i am so confused as to what i thought the rolling stones was before listening to this album
You Can’t Always Get What You Want, assuming what you want is other good songs on the album. And you also can’t convince me Jagger ever stepped foot in a honky tonk.
One of my great musical memories is tied up in Let it Bleed. At probably 19, I was driving from SF up to the Sierras. In summer, the stretch leading from the Valley into the Sierra Foothills is all rolling hills covered in dry golden grass. Gimme Shelter came on shuffle, and that song with the windows down on that road was as perfect a match of music and moment as I've ever had. I like the rest of the album, but it never reaches the heights of Gimme Shelter again. Thats one of my all time great songs. It'd be a straight 4, but it gets demoted to 3.75 (still rounded up to 4) for Mick Jagger's choice to write, sing, and widely publish the lines: "Yeah, we all need someone we can cream on. Yeah, and if you want you can cream on me)" Go to jail Mick, because that line is a crime. Album Cover: (B+) Its iconic, but I dont get the cake.
"Gimme Shelter" is a very famous song that I didn't recognize right away. It's pretty sweet. Iconic vocals. "Love In Vain" is a very different song. It feels like Bob Dylan. "Country Honk" is a great song. I had genuinely no idea the Rolling Stones wrote songs like this. "You Can't Always Get What You Want" is a classic, I like it a lot. This album surprised me. The Stones are clearly more interesting than I thought they were. 8/10
you cant always get what you want
I’m so pissed off with myself that I literally just thought this cover was just a cake with a record next to it!!! I’ll tell you what I like: Gimmie shelter Let it bleed Midnight rambler Monkey man You can’t always get what you want Honestly I know this is one of the more loved ones but I’d rather listen to aftermath’s deep cuts than these ones. I like the stones but if they weren’t so popular/iconic I don’t think their reputation would be that good in retrospect, like they’d be liked but not loved I think 3/5
This is my favourite Stones record. It features some of their greatest tracks, such as Gimme Shelter, Midnight Rambler and You Can't Always Get What You Want. I also really like the country version of Honky Tonk Woman. Beyond the great songs, the album as a whole never bores me for a single minute, and the production is also top notch for 1969.
7/10 this has two absolute masterpieces and a whole lot of listenable stuff. For as much as I say I don't like the rolling stones that much, you wouldn't be able to tell from my scores on the albums I've gotten so far. 1-31-2025
Generally fine, two crackers and then the rest is good as background listening
Great album. Classic
7/10
Up there among the Stones’ best albums. Merry Clayton on Gimme Shelter is incredible.
Was okay but not my type, norwegian wood
Great album - lovely to listen to even wheh running hard reps 😅-wild horses helped me to go faster :)) cheers!
no thoughts. classic rock, not my thing
Mindblowing how an album can start of with one of the best songs ever written and then just contain boring, casual music with barely anything noteworthy
Overrated. Like some of the other 60s ones, some bangers, but lot of fluff
Let It Bleed is one of the earlier Stones albums. Being released in 1969 meant it came out during a time of societal and political upheaval in the US as well as an age of discovery (moon landing). It almost perfectly captures the uncertainty and fears of the time with songs like Gimme Shelter representing the sense of impending doom and a fear so deep that nothing can relieve it. Let It Bleed, the song represents a loss of faith in conventional beliefs and references drug use and friendship among strangers as a new form of comfort. You Can't Always Get What You Want represents the frustrating feelings of unmet desires which were being aired in the public eye at the time the album was released even culminating into a stabbing at the first performance of this album by the Stones. Mick Jagger drunkenly stumbling through the songs adds to the commentary although it may be entirely unintentional. The intoxicated and at times incoherrent way in which the lyrics are presented aids in transporting the mind to the time when the album would have been most popular. Let It Bleed is one of the most iconic and culturally representative albums of the late 60s and early 70s time period and still holds relevance into the 2020s.
Kind of annoying
Fini album, klasik. Tim mi je bilo slađe što imamo tu ploču pa smo slušali na ploči. Nije mi onako da mi srce iskače od uzbuđenja, ali imam veliki rispekt za njih i ovaj album, tako da će biti 4/5, 7.5/10
Ovaj album mi ima posebno mjesto u srcu iz par razloga. Jedan od njih je da mi je pjesma s ovog albuma svirala kad smo išli kod matičara se uzeti (you can't always get what you want), a drugi da smo slušali ovo na ploči. Solidni Stonesi, odrastao sam uz njih, nemam ništa lose reći o ovome, ali mi nije masterpiece. Zato ide 8/10
Honestly, Gimme Shelter rocks, last track too, the rest, I could take it or leave it. I think the guitar playing is fun on a lot of these tracks, but am not a huge fan of the rest of the band. Gimme Shelter at a 5, the rest at 2/5, Ima give this a 3.
Amazing record. C'mon, it's the Rolling F'n Stones !!
Honestly, plain jane blues rock IDK why it's so popular. Times were different I suppose.
3.5/5
Not a huge fan of the stones but full respect.. deserves to be here
Great album! Not every song a banger but some classics!
3.5, gimme shelter is amazing.
I have to use a private session for spotify for any Rolling Stones album, because I am not a fan and there are quite a few Rolling Stones albums on this site. This album has a few classics, then the white guy take on blues that I find grating.
primera vez que escucho directamente un album de ellos especificamente, y me encantó, me sorprendió lo que encontré de buena forma, una mezcla entre rock y blues que funciona, dan ganas de escuchar más de su discografía, muy buen inicio para escucharlos, destaco tmb la calidad del sonido, demasiado buena para la época
Gimme Shelter, Baby !
he’s a monkey
4.4 top album van de stones Beste plaat is gimme shelter
Never liked The Rolling Stones tbh. I'm sure they're rock icons but for the most of time their music is just simple unstandable to me...I can see their influence on so called pop-rock easily I mean when you-never heard rock once-pictured what it's like to sound "rocky" it's the sound of Let It Bleed. However I really don't like them.
A bit too honky tonk, but bookended by 2 great songs
yeah, 3, i see why this was great, but honestly it kinda came and went for me
Pre-listening thoughts: there is a certain song on here that would be really great to play at a car dealership when you accidentally sign up for incredibly high payments on your car and you still can’t bear to listen to the song to this day because you feel salty that the dealership robbed you blind Post/during listening thoughts: I am shocked at how different the opener and closer are from the entire rest of the album. Gimme Shelter and You Can’t Always Get What You Want are crazy good songs and then you get hit with honky tonk 60s country and blues??? It’s like okay but I definitely expected something a little better knowing some of the Stones’ other stuff. 5/10 DID I NEED TO HEAR THIS BEFORE I DIE: no Fav tracks: Gimme Shelter, You Can’t Always Get What You Want Least fav tracks: Love in Vain, Country Honk
10
I thought his would be better based on the name alone, but sometimes expectations don’t match reality, it was a fine album but I was expecting more.
Great opening and ending. Pretty good middle.
It's not Sticky Fingers- Robby For Gimme Shelter and all the bluesy guitar -d
I honestly haven't listened to the Rolling Stones before. They are a little old for my taste, but I did like Gimme Shelter and You Can't Always Get What You Want. Idk. Other than that, it didn't stand out as anything amazing to me.
Brilliant album
This album feels a little bit like a bait and switch. Gimme Shelter goes so hard, then it’s just kind of ok for the majority of the album, and then it picks back up at the end with You Can’t Always Get What You Want. Maybe I’d appreciate it more with another listen. 3.5 Stars
Nothing wrong with it, just not very interesting.
Some really good blues rock but doesn’t quite reach that next level of GREAT until the very end.
Was excited for Stones album. My dad is a massive fan but I’ve always been more of a Beatles guy. This was a great album, didn’t blow me away like the 5 star albums I’ve had so far but thoroughly enjoyed it. The opening and closing tracks are really good. Overall, a great listen!
i really do like the rolling stones, i’m not sure how or why i hadn’t listened to them much before but you can’t beat them. liked monkey man and let it bleed made me giggle
The bookends of the album are great. I'm not going to pretend they're not. The sandwich in the middle is solid blues rock. Does it feel authentic? Not a bit. But I enjoyed it more than most Stones' albums.
3.5/5
great song, boring songs, good song. wow, a real classic here lads
Gimme Shelter is the Stones' best track by a country mile. You Can't Always Get What You Want is pretty decent. Most of the other tracks in between these bookends are fairly run of the mill.
Good start, at the end was just sorta waiting for the end. Country honk was fun though not great but fun. I will say however the closer on this album is beautiful it's what make me feel bad about giving it a three
I enjoy the sound of the Stones' music, though the lyrics of the first song Gimme Shelter being almost impossible to identify upon a first listen had me worried I wasn't going to be able to understand any of the words of the album and would only get this aspect on a second listen through while reading along with the songs. Gimme Shelter is a great song though now I know what it's saying. And fortunately, this turned out to be the only song where I had difficulty in hearing the words. Had actually only fully heard You Can't Always Get What You Want before, though had heard some of Midnight Rambler (the topic of the whole thing was not quite what I was expecting there, though reading about it was fascinating). Honestly, lyrically many of these songs didn't really connect with me. Live With Me for example. Learning Love In Vain is a cover does alter my perspective a bit (not in a bad way). Of the rest, I'd rate Monkey Man higher though I don't necessarily see myself often returning to it even if I were to recall liking the song. Honestly I only listened to it 15 mins ago and it's already escaped my mind. The first sentence of Let It Bleed for some reason repeatedly is reminding me of Kermit the Frog, though it doesn't actually sound like him but I just can't shake it with the 'lean on'. There are probably three songs that I would and it's the predictable Gimme Shelter, Midnight Rambler and You Can't Always Get What You Want, though I suppose time will tell with the rest. Overall, it didn't connect with me massively lyrically across the whole album, but liking the musical style makes much of it fall into the category of music I'd enjoy in the background but not actively scroll though my playlist to find. Maybe one day I'll revisit it and connect with it more, but this rating is for how I've felt about it when hearing it for the first time.
classic rock n roll, not really my thing but I can appreciate the iconic sound that inspired so much of popular music 🫡
Have listened to it before, but couldn't remember much from it other than the big singles that bookend the record. Kinda understanding why I didn't remember them. Never was a huge Stones fan, and especially am not a fan of their slow blues tracks. Not that they were bad, just they don't do anything for me (and honestly, time is starting to get to them). I like when the Stones are more rock than blues, and this album is heavy on the blues. This record for me gets propped up on the strength of Gimme Shelter and You Can't Always Get What You Want.
5* Obviously
3/5
Tell me how only two songs on the entire record compelled me. As Metric once sang, "Who would you rather be? The Beatles or the Rolling Stones?" Answer: The Beatles
I'm more Stones than Beatles, but honestly, neither of them ever really did very much for me. This was OK. Nothing super special.
Long Live Rolling Stones!
5.5/10 Favorite Tracks: Gimme Shelter, You Can't Always Get What You Want Least Favorite Tracks: Country Honk, Live With Me, Let It Bleed
Stones shred
This is my punishment for saying that all Rolling Stones tracks sound like nothing to me yesterday. This album doesn't help. The songs are fine but I still have no idea how people recognize that it's The Stones before Mick starts singing. I feel like I could've heard the same songs on different artists' albums. What a nothingburger. 2/5
Stones catalogue is 95% boring ass basic ass rock and roll I couldn't care less about, and the last 5% are some of my favorite songs ever. I don't know how they do it but it's incredibly impressive.
I like the Stones, but this was bleh.
Cool album, would listen again for e.g. driving or cleaning up 4/5
really strong opening and closing tracks, a little stagnant in between, also not really my type of music
yet another rolling stones album. i wonder if my tracker is dedicated to convince me that these guys are a lot better than i've been making them out to be. this album came immediately after the last one i reviewed. and this one is pretty good as well! similar thoughts i have, it's very pioneering blues and classic rock and i have a lot more respect for mick jagger.
The Rolling Stones - Let It Bleed I had a lot of expectations from this considering that it's one of their best albums. I was yet disappointed to hear that it had that 60's "country-style" rock. There are some good songs on here though, and it is consistently good most of the time, but I did expect a lot more from this. But even with that being said, this is good! 1.- Gimme Shelter = 9/10 2.- Love in Vain = 6/10 3.- Country Honk = 6/10 4.- Live with Me = 7/10 5.- Let It Bleed = 7/10 6.- Midnight Rambler = 8/10 7.- You Got the Silver = 7/10 8.- Monkey Man = 7/10 9.- You Can't Always Get What You Want = 9/10 FINAL SCORE: 7.3/10
Se for pra ouvir blues, principalmente country blues, prefiro ouvir os violeiros negros estadunidenses. Ainda assim, tem uns slides e coral mto bons nesse disco
chato pra caralho apesar da primeira música ser a melhor deles
83/100. A very solid country rock record by The Rolling Stones. The album has a consistent sound and is pleasant to the ears. The only downside is that it loses momentum toward the middle and early end of the record.
A couple interesting songs and sounds
Brilliant album from start to finish, even if hearing The Stones play some "Honky-Tonk" is a little bit weird, they somehow pull it off. This can easily be listed one of their essential albums - a must have for any fan.
Another solid outing from the Stones. The songs always sound like covers of other songs to me, but that doesn't stop the enjoyment.
This is the second album from The Rolling Stones I've generated in the last three days, and this is clearly the better one. It opens up with an anti-war message, and closes with a harsh reality of life. There are also some good songs in between. Favorite Song: "Gimmie Shelter"
Not a fan of monkey man even though it is consistent with the rest of the album
Bookended by 2 huge songs, but the meat of the album was still pretty enjoyable. Hard time rating this, 4.5/5
It starts with "Gimme Shelter" and closes with "You Can't Always Get What You Want", of course it's worth listening to.
A classic. Somehow a band both in transition and at their peak. Probably the album with the most Keith.
Mick is so powerful I wish I was so lucky to see the man.
This has three of their biggest songs and bunch of countryish songs that made me think I kept listening to a different band/album. 7/10
i really enjoyed this album i didn’t think i would enjoy it but my favourites are definitely you can’t always get what you want and gimme shelter. there were a few songs which were more country style but they are still good songs, but not my favs.
Had some good songs
The Stones are my favorite the closer they get to the Kinks. The quirky, catchy stuff. I like this album more than Sticky Fingers. I really can't wrap my head around how a record like Gimme Shelter can be so under developed. They have similar tracks where they're just such a good hook but the arrangement and overall song writing falls short. The Stones haven't ever done much for me.
As far as albums by the Rolling Stones this is one of their best. "Gimme Shelter" is probably one of the greatest rock songs ever produced. The Stones are a fantastic rock and roll band that takes their influences from American music genres and do it in grand style. Fantastic!
wasn’t a fan honest, nothing stuck out to me
Pretty good. Lots of blues vibes. Some songs I recognized. Some I didn’t. Would listen to again.
Started great, 'Gimme Shelter' is just good, but then the next few songs don't match the energy, although they're not unlikeable. I like 'Live With Me' It's much more of a bluesy album than I expected, but it is the late 60s. 'Midnight Rambler' was slightly King Gizz-y Honestly, a pleasant album, but aside form the intial song nothing really blew me away.
Bought this one in the early 1980s, so yes. It's great.
I don’t love or revere The Stones. Great for dancing, of course. 3-4 good tunes here. I’m not sure what the remaster is accomplishing, as the voice is lost to the instruments. But You Can’t Always Get What You Want is true 5/5 gold; see The Big Chill. 3/5 overall.
I dont like mick jagger's voice
Classic album heard most of the songs on here. The early? version of honky Tonk women leaves a lot to be desired, easy low point for me. The title track, Gimmie Shelter, and You Can’t Always Get What You Want are the shining stars of the album, supported by groovy tracks such as midnight rambler and Monkey Man. One of the Stones better albums for sure. Best Track: Gimmie Shelter
It’s an absolute classic, and hangs together perfectly as an album.
This one is significantly better than the last Stones album on here. Gimme Shelter is a classic, and the album has a blues influence throughout that works well for the most part, although a couple of the songs don't need to be as long as they are.
A little more honky tonk than I expected (and wanted). Some solid songs.
classic for a reason
A rocking good time. The jams and the attitude make for a high energy ride. The outro of “you can’t always get what you want” is nice, especially with its iconic choir lead in, but it’s all about the barroom tunes like “Midnight Rambler” for me.
Likely my favorite album of theirs. Really enjoy the country/blues influence. 4/5 Will listen again
Not even the line "you can cream on me" could diffuse the sheer greatness of Gimme Shelter and You Can't Always Get What You Want. What a difference from the self-titled album!
All time classic, although they are a bit boring for me.
classic and timeless
Deep cuts aren't remarkable IMO, while still being good. But, boy oh boy, are YOU CAN'T ALWAYS GET WHAT YOU WANT, GIMME SHELTER, COUNTRY HONK, and MONKEY MAN, worth their weight in gold.
4.3
first track is pretty good
i like this record and always have but oh my god this is the dumbest fucking artist streak ive ever had. a lotta white balls need 2 be chopped off. anyway, this is the only studio rolling stones record where my perception of it hasnt dropped off the face of the earth at some point, and i set out on this listen to figure out why. most likely perhaps is the subtle difference in genre priorities across the stone's Classic period...theyre all rootsy rock music, but of slightly different flavors, and to my ears the biggest contributing sub-flavor here is country. the result is a stones record that is both slightly funnier and slightly more emotive in turn from that which surrounds it, the least capital r capital s Rock Star of their most famous records. i still hate mick jagger lol but this more subdued environment is good for him...he's still often jaggering it up with gross self-parodic white boy blues inflections but for whatever reason ive always found this to be the most likeable studio environment for this. the real problem if i have one is that i find the stones as a whole to be quite boring and stiff performers...but even that doesnt stop them from a rare fully successful Rock Out with gimmie shelter, where the layers and layers of sound build up into a genuine intensity the individual parts couldn't reach alone. and even beyond that track, the songwriting works for me on this record way way more than not, comfy and even colorful. on the whole if i Have to listen to the rolling stones id reach for the suprisingly great classic live album ya-yas, but this is a good pick too. not a fan of this band at all clearly lol but im glad theyre not a total wash for me
The big hits on this album are very familiar to me and indubitably work. The in between tracks are a little muddier, grounded in that era-appropriate hard man style of lyrics and vocals that feels so offputting when served without the dramatic flights of fancy found in the opening and closing tracks.
big fan had heard before
Alright
Meh
a fun folk/rock album and has the classic you can’t always get what you want. not very much to my taste but still enjoyable.
Two great songs, Gimme Shelter and You Can't Always Get What You Want, and a lot of filler between the two.
++*: Gimme Shelter, You Can't Always Get What You Want ++: Love in Vain, Live with Me, Let It Bleed, Midnight Rambler, You Got the Silver, Monkey Man +: Country Honk 9,9/10
Gimme Shelter is so good this album almost gets a 5, but the rest of the album was not that impressive for me. Still, it’s the Stones, all sounds good and very American in a British sort of way.
Beautiful.
9/12/24 It was an okay album. It didn't set the world alight.
One of the classic Stones albums, all very bluesy and I love it, all the albums stands up. As I get old the more I appreciate how great the stones were back in the early days. Bring black / blues music to the UK. The newest album Hackney Diamonds is also really good go check it out. Stand out tracks: - Gimme Shelter - Country Honk - Let it bleed - You can't aways get what you want
Some thrillers. Some fillers.
I thought I liked the rolling stones but I really wasn't into this album
classic, great songs, i love the different sounds on the album
God, I love this band. Their singles are obviously top-notch, but the range they show on each of their albums is flat out addicting to me. This album is no exception. Favorite track: Midnight Rambler
Some really good songs on here.
Best stones album hands down. Bloody fantastic. Nuff said
el classico 👌
I thought the Rolling Stones made a different type of music that wasn't so laid back. Maybe their sound changed over time. This sounds like the Byrds or something. High 2.
Pretty solid, I enjoyed this
6/10 - idk how I feel about the lyric "we all need someone we can cream on." Some of the songs were fine. Jackson likes 2 songs on this album but I still do not get all of the hype. Better than the other rolling stones album.
More Rolling Stones. More mid
excellent
Style is solid and thick from the first song to the last, love this album!
Damn good bluesy rock. Best track - gumme shelter
One of my favorite albums
The stones... you get three stars for Gimme Shelter and that's it.
The Stones released four 5 star records in a row beginning with Beggars Banquet and ending with Exile. This is one of the four.
fantastic
This is of course a great album, with the Stones in their country era. You’ve got Gimme Shelter and YCAGWYW as excellent bookends and the hits of the record. I liked You Git the Silver a lot too. It’s not phenomenal, but it deserves a light 5.
Truly outstanding album. Perhaps the single greatest backup vocal in rock history by Merry Clayton on Gimme Shelter. Of course You Can't Always... and Midnight Rambler are standouts but there isn't a wasted note on this record.
Wonderful all the way through and the first truly amazing album of that 4 album run for me. "Gimme Shelter" is a top Stones, 60's, and rock song for me. What a powerful (and apocalyptic) way to open an album. "Let it Bleed", "Midnight Rambler" and "Live With Me" are highlights for me as well. Of course the final track is iconic and anchors the album superbly. While I was obviously not there, it seems like this album captures the end of the flower power dream and that late 60's descent into madness. Easy 5 for me.
9/10 1969. Blues/Rock/Country Midnight Rambler You Can't Always Get What You Want Gimme Shelter Live With Me
Never been a big fan, but not a complete waste of time.
I'm not a massive Stones fan but Gimme Shelter is one of the greatest songs of all time so that's taken this too to an easy three if not a four
Lots of blues influence and kinda carried by two songs… monkey man is fun though. I don’t think the stones are a great album band honestly
Overall: 10/10 This is (in my opinion) the quintessential album from a band with a long history of hit or miss albums. Every song is great, they take risks without straying too far from their established sounds and they honestly just sound like they're having a great time making music together. If you're gonna listen to any Stones album, it should be this one. Fav Song: Country Honk Least Fav Song: Midnight Rambler (Oh god every song is so good this hurts)
There are strong influences of classic blues as well as bluegrass that make the album an interesting listen. While it is an interesting blend of genres, the group ultimately fails to move ahead, in a more creative and unique direction. It feels that the artists were content to re-hash traditional, american sounds and blend them into a more accessible package. 7.2/10
I've never been a big Stones fan but this album is too good to let go - some super super bigs hits and the rest fit in nicely too. Very assured, and well produced, this oozes class. A solid 5*****
Death, taxes, the cast majority of The Rolling Stones being 2.5.
makes me realize how much music there is in the world that i don't like
Some tracks not my vibe but others I like - mixed bag
Someday I should look into how an English rock band nailed an entire album of American honky-tonk sound. Also Merry Clayton performs the best backing vocal track of all time on Gimme Shelter, with her voice cracking with emotion. Frisson every time.
Probably one of the best ways to spend 42 minutes I can think of 5/5
Can blue men play the whites? Oh yeah!
Not the hugest fan of the Stones - Gimme Shelter is a 4 and there are a couple more songs I like, but overall a 3 taking into account the familiarity effect, I think.
First time I’ve ever listened to this album all the way through, although many of the songs are familiar (they’ve been around so long, their material permeates western musical culture). As a collection it’s quite decent but perhaps not an outright classic
3.5
When you're on death row and they let you play one last Stones album as I assume is your basic human right in every nation, the album you select is very revealing: 12x5 - sad that you're still trying to prove something Goats Head Soup - only child? Some Girls - high on your own supply Tattoo You - starfucker Exile On Main St - a bit obvious Beggars Banquet - almost Let It Bleed - retrial warranted
Although there are simply too many Rolling Stones albums in this collection (and this is only #2 of 6 total, sadly), I'm appreciative that this is a strong Rolling Stones album at least. It's bookended by two great classics in "Gimme shelter" and "You can't always get what you want", while the remainder in between is largely new to me and pretty uneven, which is about what I expected. "Midnight rambler" and "Monkey man" are strong songs (and possibly part of their repertoire? They sound familiar, in any case). Thankfully, there aren't too many stinkers in the lot, although "Love in vain" is pretty painful (and also surprisingly Dylanesque, although I now discover that it's a cover of a Robert Johnson song from 1937), and I'm not really sure what to make of "Country honk", as it's clearly the same song as their classic "Honky tonk women" but this version is weirdly thin and not very Stonesy (I wish they'd dropped this version from the album and included "Honky tonk women" instead of releasing the latter as a standalone single, but I'm sure that was a money thing). Likewise for the title track, which starts off feeling like some weird saloon version of itself--is this really the version that got so much airplay for years afterward? I'm not sure why this Rolling Stones album in particular made me feel particularly aware of how much (blues) appropriation they profited from (it could have been all the reviews talking about how "authentic" they sound), but it does, and it's hard to unhear now that I've noticed it. It also makes it hard to know what to rate this album, but misgivings aside the number of classic songs means it's probably deserving of four stars.
I'm not sure when, if ever, I last listened to this whole album, so this was a treat. Gimme Shelter is one of my favorite Stones songs, and it was awesome to hear Keith's vocals on You Got the Silver. I love the recording too--very lowkey at times (Country Honk?!--title?!).
It’s gritty, soulful, and a little bit dangerous, like the feeling of being on the edge of something wild. The rhythms swagger in a way that brings Creedence Clearwater Revival to mind, but with a nastier, more defiant streak. The harmonies feel both reckless and intimate, like they’re barely holding together. It’s unpolished, but that’s what gives it its punch.
I think the stones are overrated. This is the one album that makes them in my opinion. Good blues, great riffs, micks voice actially works here but he has a horrible voice. This album is really good from start to finish. You can feel the blues and how they copied the american music and made them their own
Gimme shelter is pulling a lot of weight here. Good album though
Let it Bleed This really reminds of university, graduating from Greatest Hits to the albums from their imperious pomp. At that time it was probably my favourite of the Beggar’s Banquet - Let It Bleed - Sticky Fingers - Exile on Main Street axis, and while I would probably tend towards Exile nowadays it’s still up there as one of my favourite albums. Back then I don’t think I really appreciated how much country there was on it, and listening today it’s interesting how nearly every song has some country touch or influence on it. I know their country influences are obvious, but I would probably tend to think songs like Jumpin Jack Flash, Honky Tonk Women, Gimme Shelter and Brown Sugar are emblematic of this period, but so much of their stuff around this time was very country. Alongside the totemic Gimme Shelter, Midnight Rambler and You Can’t Always Get What You Want at the beginning middle and end, there are some of their best albums tracks, the country blues of Love in Vain, the hoedown of Country Honk, the propulsive and rocking Live with Me, the loose, druggy, not so subtle sexual euphemisms and barroom feel of Let it Bleed, the cracked, careworn and satisfying You’ve Got The Silver and the paranoid, sinister absolutely fantastic Monkey Man. Like all of their albums of this period the playing is great, and is probably in the sweet spot of the tightness of Sticky Fingers and the looseness of Exile, Charlie as always is great, particularly on Midnight Rambler and You’ve Got The Silver. Bill’s bass playing is excellent, a great tone and while not showy there are some great touches and moments, particularly on Let it Bleed. Keith’s playing on here really is exceptional in between Brian withdrawing and Mick entering, so many great lines and phrases, always adding to the songs. I love his playing on Monkey Man especially. Mick’s vocals are particularly sweet too, it might be the best of his singing voice. And the cast of additional performers is incredible, Merry Clayton, Leon Russel, Jack Nitsche, Al Kooper, Ry Cooder as well as their stalwarts Ian Stewart, Jimmy Miller, Nicky Hopkins and Bobby Keys. Hopkin’s piano really is fantastic, particularly on Let it Bleed. I don’t think I could ever get tired of Gimme Shelter, and I’ll definitely never get tired of that break in Merry Clayton’s voice with the woo in the background. If this was just Gimme Shelter 9 times it would be a 5. If it was just Gimme Shelter, Midnight Rambler and You Can’t Always Get What You Want it would be 5. If it was those 3 songs plus all the others it would also be a 5. So basically anyway you slice it, it’s a 5. 🎂🎂🎂🎂🎂 Playlist submission: Gimme Shelter
Already knew this epic album
Definitely an influential band, just not for me. The lyrics are crass and borderline vulgar without making much of a point with it, and the country thwangs make me hesitant to listen more. The stand-out hits are the only ones you need in this album.
Great beginning, great ending, but how is this a great album? The middle songs were forgettable and Mick Jagger's voice is grating as ever. I'm starting to feel the only way I will actually enjoy the stones is if some "greatest hits" album comes along. Too much chaff.
it's alright, would be better if they cut it down to 2 songs
good album but i thought id actually enjoy more songs, i was only really enjoying like 3 songs so i was a bit disappointed
I mean, it's the Stones. Ok album, but Mick. Also, Trump's usage of You Can't Always Can't What Your Want immediately downgrades the song.
Gewoon relaxed
The best Stones album in a walk.
Pretty nice, but only the first and last track are really good, the rest I don't know too good and sounds a bit boring on first listen. 7/10
Gimme Shelter 💪
Merry Clayton on gimme shelter u will always be famous
Gimme Shelter is a solid song but the rest range from ok to meh.
This is an example of what makes the Stones great. Solid record.
Schönes Album.
I was never a great Rolling Stones fan. In my age group there was Sones v Beatles debate and I came firmly down in the Beatles camp. Whilst there were Stones tracks which I really liked I never bought any of their music apart from a greatest hits CD. That is until recently when I have become a music collector again and deciding that in addition to my all time favourite albums I also need to include classic albums not necessarily to my taste. So it was only in the last month that I obtained this very album for it to become my first purely Stones album I have ever owned. This was not by choice. Rather than Qobuz began to offer HiRes DSD downloads for the first time. The catalogue they were offering was very limited but Let It Bleed was included and appeared to be the best choice. So I have listened to this album quite a bit even before it appeared on this list. The DSD version is something to behold and sounds out of this world. But I don’t want that to cloud my judgement as any old bit of Muzak would sound fantastic given the DSD treatment. For my tastes 50% of the album is good. Gimme Shelter and YCAGWYW speak for themselves and are classic tracks. The title track and Monkey Man are also good standouts. The rest are OK and instantly recognisable has Stones tracks but for the reasons which I must have formulated when I went for The Beatles all those years ago I can take or leave. 3/5 13/11/24
propped up heavily by 2 outstanding tracks
Hit and run raper in anger song is good trust jake is a monkey man who can't always get what he wants
I'll cum all over you, I'm called the hit-and-run raper, in anger.
Absolutely magnificent collection of songs ! Some of the very best work of the Stones, in a legendary and heart-breaking context that fueled the songwriting talent of the Jagger-Richards duo.
Flawless. Threw this on the old record player for an immersive listen. Good as ever, and cohesive in a great way. Love listening to this like watching a good movie or reading a good short story. The cacophony of sound that lifts you to the fucking rafters at the end of You Can't Always Get What You want is just such a great ending.
Torn between a 2 or 3. I would say a low 3 ranking probably. "You can't always get what you want" is a real banger.
I have really conflicting feelings about this album. “Gimme Shelter” is perhaps one of my favourite songs of this whole era. It’s just immaculate from start to finish. The instrumentation, the vocals from both singers, and everything else about it is incredible. The rest of the album verges on unlistenable. Keith Richards attempts at bluesy vocals are just so annoying. “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” is a decent track to close off the album, but it pales in comparison to the opener. This record is like a sandwich where the first slice of bread is an incredible and soft homemade sourdough, the toppings are nothing but expired hamster food, and the top slice is some wonderbread. Gimme Shelter: 5* Tracks 2-8: 1* You Can’t Always.. : 3* I think that averages out to 1.666666666* so we’ll just round up.
You can’t spell Mick Jagger without “ick”, which is what I get from him and his lyrics. Musically, it’s derivative and repetitive. Ugh. 4/10
The Good: Rolling Stones sharp as knives The Bad: Knives can cut, and it seems we need to Let It Bleed… The Ugly: That we are celebrating this bleeding with a cake and a record… What is there to say, that hasn’t been said before? One of the greatest Rock n Roll bands ever… yet, on this album, on one too many songs, they are trying to be a straight from the Mississippi Delta, and that just hasn’t aged well. Gimme Shelter and You Can’t Always Get What You Want are on most people’s Top 50 Greatest tunes ever, which means 4* It would be 5* if there was more cohesion and less trying to be something they are not...
A classic album for a reason. Really good stuff on here.
My second Stones album on this journey and a second example of them opening with a magnificent single ('Paint it Black' on Aftermath), surrounded with some forgettable noodling around. 'Gimme Shelter' and 'Can't Always' carry this record.
Brits trying to be yanks... How sordid
Very much a record of two half’s. There’s the first and last tracks then everything else. Very very uneven. But Gimme shelter is worth the album price alone. 4 stars for shelter.
Let's face it, we know Exile on Maine St is the most accomplished Rolling Styones record but, by god, this and Sticky Fingers are the most enjoyable to listen to.
It’s The Stones, so you know it’s good, but it’s not their best album. A lot of filler here, bookended by two bangers. Shows the blues side of the band.
This is the fourth or fifth Stones album I've gotten, and probably my favorite one yet. It's got a more chill vibe, kinda southern bluesy or even a little gospel or something mixed in there. Really good
Bookended by two of the best songs to begin or end any album, I have to admit it goes from four to five stars based only on those two songs (but it’s a short album, so that’s a good ratio).
Can't miss with this album!
Generally like rolling stones but this album was too much blues influence and I wasn't feeling it at the time. 'You can't always get what you want' is a top stones song for me and great note to end on.
Ok album. Pleasant to listen to but nothing major for my own tastes. Definitely would recommend to anyone who likes classic rock.
I’ve spent many years trying to get into The Rolling Stones. I knew many of their hits, and liked them. Suddenly a handful of years ago, I sat down and listened to this album. When I did, and Gimme Shelter started, it clicked. That song is an absolute masterpiece, and I began to appreciate the band more. There are, though, a little too many honky tonk songs on this album for my taste. This album is one of my favourites by the band though, but Sticky Fingers is the one that hits it home
2.5
I never seem to be disappointed with the Stones albums when they were good, so like the 60’s and 70’s. I get why they were so popular. Gritty blues, acoustic rock, harmonized jams. I’m just confused as to why I say something like I just did and not dig deeper into them. This album flows nicely, keeping the tempo riding along at a pace you could road-trip in. This is the type of album you could have a conversation over and not get pissed at the other person for talking over your favorite part. I will say, this album doesn’t make me what to return to it like a 5 star album would, according to me at least, that’s the only fault in it. Choice cut: Gimme Shelter
8.1
I think this is about Sticky Fingers level.
Yeah this is a bit more solid than most stones albums / any rock album of its time. I think the biggest standout on here is the moments of restraint mick and the band use on some arrangements - they know when to go crazy and Gimme Shelter it, but they know when to pull it back and You Can’t Always Get What You Want it
I forgot how great the early stones were! Their blues influence really shines in this album
This has two of the best songs of all time. Some of the best backing vocals ever as well. I won tickets in college to see Crosby & Nash after identifying a snippit of monkey man. 🤷🏻♂️ Some of the songs are filler, but most of it is solid. A strong 4.4!
Imagine putting this album on for the first time in 1969 and experiencing Gimme Shelter right out of the gate. Stones are a hit machine, starting with this album.