Reviews (page 4 of 15)
Definitely some good songs on here. Would listen to again (maybe skipping the maid song WTF)
love this album. feels like a warm hug.
who is neil and how did he make the songs i didnt know i needed to hear the full versions of
the dads of the world may have been right about this neil young guy, huh? also - why does neil young have two separate albums called harvest and harvest moon???? i think it was reasonable to expect harvest moon to come up on an album called harvest but my hopes were DASHED
Pretty good, not quite enough walk it home guitar solos but put me in a good mood all day.
Such a talented artist. His music sounds like a warm hug. I love me some calming hippie music !! Fav song is ‘Old Man’.
Neil Young at his best. This album has some amazing songs and no weak spots. An easy 5 for me.
Neil Young is one of the greatest to ever do it. Harvest demonstrates his skill perfectly. 5/5
Not his best by a wide margin but still has a couple of classics.
Perfect record. No notes
Great singer song writer stuff.
not full listen
Like it so far, nice ambience.
not rly my style
"I fell in love with the actress. She was playing a part i could understand." Future Mr. Daryl Hannah
There’s a lot of Neil Young on this list but I’m glad this one made it. Beginning to end it’s a lovely album.
An absolute classic album that I find beautiful. I can totally see how people would not jive with Young because I was one of these people for many years, but at one point it clicked for me and the little things that annoyed me faded away. Since crossing that line, I’ve explored most of his music and see him as a visionary who was constantly exploring musical boundaries. Harvest was Young’s breakout album, and it is easy to see why it popular when it was released. What is more remarkable is that it doesn’t sound dated today. The orchestrations create a large sound that envelops the listener. The harmonies are outstanding. For those who don’t like Young, that is perfectly okay. However, quit bitching about his inclusion on this list. He is among the most influential artists to produce music and not including several of his records on this list would ignore Young’s important contributions to modern music. This is probably among the best country-rock albums ever made. I have listened to this album many times in the past, but it’s been a minute. I really enjoyed revisiting the album.
Owned Beautiful
I don't know if another album in Neil Young's catalogue beats this as his best/most representative album.
Not his best. Still brilliant.
An album exploring the disconnect between his desperate need for emotional intimacy and emotional unavailability. Some of his best songs and some throwaways, almost all produced and sequenced in such a way as to make the each track feel disconnected from the next
Heart of Gold is so good. But Neil Young is so boring.
Just feel like Heart of Gold and Old Man stand head and shoulders above the rest of the album. But they also stand head and shoulders above most music that's ever been written, so what are you gonna do?
Old man and heart of gold are the quintessential wartime ballads from this album. I hadn't heard this album prior, only the greatest hits. At the time, im certain there could have been deep meaning gleaned from the folksy overtones and impassioned lyrics. Through the lens of hindsight, the sentiments this album conveys come across as disingenuous or hypocritical. Although that statement is probably more aimed at the generation this artist and album are targeted at.
A classic… 3 singles I love The song, “Alabama”’s guitar sound is top!
What a lovely album this is. The simple production enhances the the songs to an extra level. Raw emotion through the whole album in Young's voice and playing elevates it further. A must listen
This is probably the most simultaneously decent but dull album I’ve listened to in a while. The instrumentals & vocal delivery are strong, and the song-writing definitely feels coherent and well put together. But overall it completely failed to grab me. I found the whole thing ultimately quite boring and dreary, as if it needed a spark of energy with a couple of more upbeat tracks. 5/10.
Country Rock modesto que infelizmente não é pra mim. A voz de Young não me irrita tanto quanto a de Dylan, pelo menos, então o disco não me causa nenhuma irritação ou frustração. Alívio. Os instrumentais são simples, seguindo ornamentação de folk, com elementos de country e umas pitadas de rock. Uma canção ou outra possuem um maximalismo bizarro e deslocado, mas vou só presumir que foi resultado de cocaína em excesso, típico da época. Pra mim, falta excitação. Gosto mais de Young quando ele está acompanhado da banda Crazy Horse. Eles trazem uma empolgação que dilui bem a melação típica do lirismo e da voz de Young. Mas não posso negar, é um disco bonito. Por mais que não seja minha pira necessariamente, ele possui um certo conforto e uma certa familiaridade agradável. Há defeitos suficientes para diminuir a nota, mas não deixa de ser uma inclusão aceitável à lista e uma escuta inofensiva e relativamente gostosa. E Alabama é uma puta música ótima. Muito boa mesmo. Queria que o disco inteiro tivesse o mesmo nível de qualidade. Mas é inconsistente. 3.5
I liked this album more than I thought I would. The production is great. Really wild that this was from 1972. It would work today.
A Classic peace that always deserve a new listen
Love it. Mellow gold.....
I had been avoiding listening to this album for a couple of weeks as I find that even though Neil Young is an incredibly talented singer, songwriter and artist. His voice is terribly sad and so filled with sorrow that no matter what he sings it feels very depressing. And I was entirely right. This album is an old fashioned country/southern states ballad album that is very much focused on sorrow and regret. The theatrical sections for example in "A Man Needs A Maid" lift feeling of the album a little. But it is still very sad. The big hits from this album are "Heart of Gold" and "Old Man". (3.500)
Just a nice album really. Some good song and was torn between a few for a favourite. Wouldn’t listen to it in full again, think it’s just not a genre I lean towards but did enjoy my listen
I’ll cave and give it 4 stars. This kind of music is really a 3 1/2 star for my taste but I recognize the brilliance behind the songwriting and vibe Neil Young lays down.
I can see what Pearl Jam saw in Neil.
One of the best
Dang. Just can’t get into Neil.
Greatest album!
I don't think I love this album very much. It's not bad but I didn't like the overall vibe.
I enjoyed!
It's awesome and has stood the test of time
Heart of Gold, Old Man & Damage Done - that's a solid 3 stars right there I tend to tune out the rest, so cant quite get to four stars Still, a pretty good rating for a style of music and a singing voice that I dont really like!
Here it is—the album everyone knows Neil Young for, but God if I know why. I finally saw Young in concert last year, and met an older couple at the show and asked them what their favorite Young album was. They simply said, "We only know Harvest!" This same couple left the show halfway through when Young decided to wisely wade through his borderline doom-metal compositions from *Greendale*. Such is the paradox of Young—fans know him for his dark, brooding folk ballads, noisy Crazy Horse guitar distortion, and political rock, but everyone else just knows him for *Harvest*. I can't say that I blame them. This album is filled with fantastic songs: "Heart of Gold", "Old Man", "Alabama", and the harrowing, disturbing folk ballad "The Needle and the Damage Done". There are some other great moments as well—the meandering, intimate "Out on the Weekend", the sublime wall of sound from the title track, the distortion fest "Words (Between the Lines of Age)" and the dumb but fun "Are You Ready for the Country?". The rest? Overblown, schmaltzy, annoying stuff, such as "A Man Needs a Maid" and "There's a World" (which I cannot listen to AT ALL). And yet, I can tolerate even the most brutal moments of *Greendale*. So, maybe I'm not wired like other music listeners, or even fans of Young, but I simply cannot accept that this is still his most listened-to album when he's done so much better and more impressive stuff. But he surely can't complain about the success it's brought him, and it was gleeful to see the meta-like performance of him playing "Old Man" and having the crowd complete the chorus at times. 3.5 stars, only because it's still a good, if inconsistent, listen.
This is something Woody from Toy Story would listen to but unfortunately I'm a Buzz Lightyear kind of guy.
Love it
This is THE Neil Young album for me. It has (almost) all the iconic tunes I associate with the best parts of his solo career, and taken as a whole this album is a sampler platter of the various styles that epitomize that career. There’s the poignant solo acoustic ballad (The Needle And The Damage Done), the riffier acoustic band jam (Heart Of Gold), some proto-grunge electric rocker with his signature dirty guitar sound (Alabama), a little country (Old Man), a piano ballad (the beautiful but perhaps problematically misogynistic Man Needs A Maid), and, yes, some ill-advised though moderate use of a harmonica (Out On The Weekend). There are a few dull spots here and there but that’s probably the album’s worse sin, being slightly less interesting in spots.
Aside from Jack Nitzche’s obnoxious orchestral arrangements on two songs, this is one of Young’s most solid albums.
I have never listened to Neil Young before, and I wasn't expecting much. Absolutely incredible album, that guitar was excellwnt.
Neil Young ei varsinaisesti ole ollut mun tietoisuudessa kauheen läsnä. Tiedän että on todella suosittu country-rock artisti ja suosituimmat levyt ovat 70-luvulta. Albumi vaikuttaa rennolta ja oikeasti hyviä kappaleita ja ymmärrän niiden suosion. Samalla levyllä kuullaan huuliharppua, joka sopii hyvin folk countryrock levylle. Mutta silti albumi ei ole puhutellut mua sen erikoisemmin. Old man on kyllä levyn parhaimpia biisejä.
pretty chill, not exactly my style but some bangers nonetheless. favs would be heart of gold, old man, and the needle but positive is that it’s unlike anything else i’ve listened to, which is the whole point :)
P Young
A masterpiece.
Liked words
vind dit wel lekker, beetje country, beetje rock, ineens twee tunes met london symphony orchestra.
Lekkere muziek met een paar knallers
Old Whiny, Kermit voiced Neil Young. Love it, sucker for Neil young and this album is like being dropped on the plains, with a guitar and a bottle of whisky.
Buenas cosas. Me gustó el sonido, aunque no soy muy fanático del Folk-rock. Igual like
Meget bra.
Le di play a Harvestde Neil Young y honestamente no fue para mí. Se me hizo bien largo y no conecté con casi ninguna canción. Entiendo el appeal del sonido folk y tranquilo, pero en mi caso se sintió demasiado lento y no logró engancharme en ningún momento. Eso sí, la armónica está cool y le da un toque distintivo al álbum, pero no fue suficiente para salvar la experiencia completa. En general, no es un disco que volvería a escuchar. 1/5
My least favorite album that features Neil Young so far. I still like his voice, though.
Bland for my tastes.
Puedo entender a Neil Young, pero definitivamente no es un non-skip
Recently I've found out that I enjoy country music quite a lot. Early sunsets, yellow leaves and apple pie. That's what I saw when I heard this album for the first time. Old man is such a beautiful song and this album has ultimate autumn vibe.
I've been on a string of albums which have been great, 5-star records. Thankfully, Neil came along at just the right time to crush that momentum. Ok, that's unfair. This is a fine record, even great itself at times. Old Man, Alabama, and Heart of Gold are all excellent tracks, especially the last of these. But too often this album has a touch of bore to it. Worse, songs like A Man Needs a Maid just seem out of place for ol' Neil to be singing about. Hey, I'm insecure, maybe I don't need an actual relationship, maybe I just need a maid. Some would say this is just him being honest, others think it is chauvinistic. Me? I just think it sounds stupid. Some hits, some misses. The peaks are great, but the valleys are just as deep. Adds up to an average album.
I think it's all been said hasn't it? Great songs about longing and coming to terms with aging
This didn't live up to how I had it built up in my mind - I'm sure it's great but there's a number of tracks that I don't connect with.
Didn't do much for me.
Full Album Thoughts: Album Rating: 4.5 (A+) I guess I like 1 Neil Young album? Which is a weird thing for me to say? I still cant get past his singing voice, but its used more deftly here. For some reason we had a couple orchestral tracks, and a more electric guitar sound. I didnt think this would come out to be as high a rated album, but its song writing bones are there! Track Thoughts: Out on the Weekend 00:04:35 A This grove is giving me raconteur vibes, which is great until I remember what Neil Young singing falsetto sounds like and I am bracing for impact. And then it never gets that bad? No, I hate to say it, but this is actually an All Timer in my books. Wistful, haunting, and vivid. Harvest 00:03:03 C No we are back to generic country. Sorry this is the same ol sway back and forth, and its too simplistically structured to be anything but cliched. Thankfully the singing and the slide guitar arent overpoweringly twangy this time... but still not something I will ever actively seek out. A Man Needs A Maid 00:04:00 A HEY NEIL CAN YOU SPEAK UP? YOURE SINGING FROM THE OTHER ROOM! Oh heck we get a whole dang Orchestra! Could a piano ballad like this work? Yes absolutely, if it was literally any other singer. This is just a song from a musical. Its meandering in structure (said approvingly), and has such breadth of instrumentation as to be constantly engaging! I just wish there was a stronger lead performance, that is all that is keeping this from being an S tier song. Heart of Gold 00:03:05 A This has escaped containment. And I cant even hate on it, this is excellent almost rock song writing. If they swapped out the slide guitar for an electric with a bit more bite, I think this would be ready to be a staple in my rotation. Oh and yeah, I still cant stand Neil's voice, but for most of this album he is at least staying lower in register. Like I was about to give it an A- and then the final vocal chorus came in at the end and dang if I am not a sucker for that. Uhg. Back to an A, under protest. Are You Ready for the Country? 00:03:21 B This would fit in with "One of the weird Beatles songs" category. You take any other lead singer, you even the slide guitar is good in moderation, but something about the over use of both these tones... it just saps my enjoyment. This is a very wrote song structure, so you gotta do SOMETHING fun to keep it interesting. As is, it actually feels a bit sparse? Old Man 00:03:22 A+ "The old know what it is like to be young, but the young do not know what its like to be old." I think this maybe has escaped containment, but I cant place my finger on where I've maybe heard it before. I really love the laid back bass grove accompanied by the finger picked banjo. If it weren't for Neil's singing voice ESPECIALLY when he tries to belt, this would again be an S tier song! There's a World 00:03:00 C+ Hello uh... Some Final Fantasy Track? This is introducing the Evil Empire vibes. I really was not expecting the full orchestra on this album. This sadly has less drive to it than "A Man Needs A Maid". At least there is no slide guitar, so points for that. Alabama 00:04:02 A+ Ah, now I too have heard what old Neil has said about you! This is such a wild dark full sound for the album! Still cant escape the slide guitar, but paired with the actual drive of the electric guitar it helps fill out the space more appropriately. I think OF THE TWO SONGS re: alabama... I prefer this one? The Needle and the Damage Done 00:02:00 A Okay so a thing I love is a finger picking style like this where you hold the same note and then slide down the chords, its such a vibe. This as a purely single guitar and singer focused song, it actually works... you can imagine this as just 1 Dude On Stage, overhearing this while you are paying attention to something else in the bar. It doesnt overstay its welcome either. And of course the clapping HARD CUT OFF is a choice. Words (Between the Lines of Age) 00:06:42 B This didn't need to be a 7 minute long ender. This is bombastic and really builds initially, but idk if its earned. The noodling guitar solo is a bit over indulgent. But then again, nothing in the song (beyond Neil's voice as usual) is offensive.
It's Neil and it's lovely. Really good but doesn't move me the way Harvest Moon does.
Solid album
Episkt
This is a good album and will always be a fun listen.
Hate to say that but country makes me peaceful. Sometimes.
i mean its not the most exciting in tyool 2026 but this is iconic classic rock. Heart of Gold, Old Man, Alabama are all-timers. Also doesn't get too self-indulgent like so much other rock from this era. Ten tight songs clocking in at under 38 minutes....perfect
His best album ever. Firm favorite in my collection
Endelig et Neil Young album der virkelig hører til på listen
Mit hotte Neil Young take er at det her ikke er en top 5 Neil Young plade, men der er satme stadig nogen lækre numre på!
The songs are so good. I could hear a lot of other artists I like that has been inspired by this.
i like it i feel at home, this is something i would play at my ranch house or something. relaxing, so emotional sometimes
y mas menos che, la verdad que no me volo la cabeza y me quede dormido mientras lo escuchaba en el tren
Some nice songs, but I never cared for his voice much.
actually do not enjoy, I like out on the weekend, heart of gold, are you ready for the country strong dislike Words, A man needs a maid, there's a world. terrible songs
No es mi disco favorito del bueno de Neil Young, pero es uno de los primeros discos que escuché de él y me sigue poniendo los pelos de punta. Siempre me acuerdo del momento en que tocó Old Man la primera vez que le vi (el infausto Rock in Rio de Madrid, donde NO VENDÍAN CERVEZA y nos tocó tragarnos antes al puto Manolo García dando una turra impresionante), cuando llama al viello que tiene de pipa para tocar el banjo. Acojonante.
Ok
opening and closing tracks (out on the weekend / words between the lines of age) are the most listenable and ... least questionable in terms of subject matter in my opinion this is one of his weaker albums DON'T shoot me. i just think after the gold rush and rust never sleeps are better as whole bodies of work over harvest. sorry neil young but rust never sleeps was a generational run
wow, 30 years since i've listened to this? "a man needs a maid" is still my favorite song from this album. nothing profound except the sadness.
loved this one
Celente
Great album
I've been a big fan of this album for years, so I was glad to see it pop up for today's album. I know a lot of people take exception to Young's unique singing voice but I've always enjoyed how he sounds, and he's in top form on this album; the chorus in Old Man is one of my favourites in folk rock. I love the variety in the instrumentation on the record as well. I'm a sucker for some tasteful banjos. The only song on here I don't really care for is A Man Needs A Maid; it's just a drawn-out, dull dirge. It's an easy skip but the rest is top drawer stuff. Favourite Tracks: Heart of Gold, Old Man, Harvest
Decent instrumentals. Did not like the vocals. Questionable lyrics.
I like Neil Young, although I didn’t need 2 in one week. I enjoyed this. His songwriting is always good and this has some of the best songs. 4/5
Not bad. Not great. Not offensive. Not memorable. Don't quite get the hype.
Lots of slide and a heart of gold.
me gustooo
Now one by Mr. Young is much more up my alley. It's a peaceful folky album that contains a few of his best known songs. I enjoyed listening through this one far more than the previous Neil Young album I had on this list, I may even grab it on vinyl!
When I think of Neil Young, these are the songs I hear.
This album can be summed up in two words: it’s alright
I didn't remember his vocal range being so high.
Whew, finally.
(7/7) not sure how he got involved with the symphony orchestra but it seemed to work out
Out on the weekend - 8/10 Harvest - 7/10 A man need a maid - 3/10(I only liked the ending) Heart of gold - 0/10 Are you ready for the country? - 0/10 (didn't finish it) Old Man - 10/10 There's a world - 10/10 Alabama - 5/10 The Needle and the Damage Done - 9/10 Words (Between the Lines of Age) - 4/10
Great album, lyrics are powerful especially on old man and needle. I've always found neil youngs voice grating, but the songs here are good enough to look past that
Finally caught up, just in time for Neil Young's fifth swing at the ball. Ol' Neil has technically struck out after a at least three whiffs but much like an uncoordinated child on the t-ball field, we've afforded him a few more swings. I had high hopes for this as it lurched into gear. His nasally voice works well with the slower, more folksy stuff and when he's not doing overblown DAD BLUES. Accidental CAPS lock there but it seemed to fit. I've left far worse things in this accursed box blinking before me on previous occasions. This still kind of sucks, I'm sorry. God. I wanted to like this one a lot. The maid song was sort of funny as an absurd ballad, but it overstayed its welcome and led into more boring/horribly sung songs. This is better than previous Neil Young efforts, but I just can't get behind this guy. BACK TO WINNIPEG. 2 HIGHLIGHTS: I give myself the Grover falsetto and sing constantly. Can I be a pseudo-folk icon?
Fuck this too
I’ve never heard of a pro vax hippie before but he makes some good music
Vive Neil Young
Franchement très bon album. Pour ma part, j'ai trouvé l'ambiance entre Rock et Country extrêmement plaisante à écouter, melant des sonorités très calmes et classique propres à des artistes comme Bob Dylan qui viennent apporter une base stable durant tout le projet, laissant par ailleurs d'autres élements plus singuliers se glisser dans le panel de propositions de l'album. On retrouve alors un jeu très propre au niveau de la guitare acoustique et electrique qui agit comme un pillier à la fois extrêmement stable en accompagnant constament la batterie (particulièrement puissante sur certains morceau comme "Words" ou "Heart Of Gold"), et en marquant une rythmique bien construite comme dans "Harvest" ou "Heart Of Gold", mais aussi en sachant se détacher du reste pour proposer des licks bien placés qui viennent apporter de la matière à l'atmosphère des morceaux comme dans "Words" et ses lignes de guitares saturés et segmentées. De la même manière, on retrouve des élements propre à l'héritage Country classique comme la présence de l'harmonica sur "Heart of Gold" ou "Out of the weekend" mais aussi les ambiances faites au bottle-neck qui apporte sur tout l'album un coté très planant à l'encontre du coté très direct de la guitare sèche ou de la batterie marquée. D'autre part, on a une réelle singularité dans l'album de Young qui surprend énormément dans les premiers temps, avec beaucoups d'élements très surprenants comme la présence de la harpe dans des morceaux comme "There's a World" qui vient appuyer un coté très volatile, en constate total par rapport à l'introduction du morceau, très puissante. Il y a aussi la présence de drop de batterie sur certains titres comme "Words" qui viennent littéralement briser le rythme pourtant très stable la majorité du temps. Enfin, la voix de Young constitue aussi un marqueur d'une identité unique, avec un ton très planant dans des aigus très rond qui brise avec les clichés country type Johnny Cash. En résumé, l'album constitue un complet amalgame d'éléments très propre à son style d'origine, qu'il parvient à maitriser à la perfection en marquant des hits intemporels comme "Heart Of Gold", tout en y ajoutant des éléments propres qui fait se détacher l'album de la grande masse de projets du même style.
Lo country no es lo mío, si le gusta este género musical a alguien, este sería el album perfecto
Neil young is actually pretty good. Who knew.
I just really enjoy the mood that this album brings. Very strong album throughout. There’s times where I’m not too keen on Neil’s voice as it comes off a bit weak or frail, but maybe that’s just a sign of honesty and vulnerability making their way through his voice. Overall, the album is very good.
Lives up to the hype, if the hype is only scoring around 7.5/10. This is my first listen to it as an album instead of just some of the singles. Solid from beginning to end. It’s also influenced so many other albums/bands that it’s really hard to judge it in a void.
It's nkt that bad
not for me
First time I've heard anything from Neil Young. I was expecting something very stripped-back and minimal. And that was my impression for the first few minutes of the album. But once "A Man Needs A Maid" came in...oh my goodness. That beautiful, lush orchestra. And then later on in the album, when The Needle surprises you with thunderous audience applause, cutting straight to one of the few electric jams on the record. The production on this thing is immaculate, despite presenting itself as so toned down. Harvest actually sounds quite a bit like the album cover. The font itself is flashy and detailed, but outside of that, there is almost no color or any frills at all. The album, both sonically and visually, is exactly what it needs to be and not a bit more. For that, I really appreciate Harvest.
Hadn't heard this in years and it's still pretty good. Some of the best Neil Young stuff on here. Best song is probably Heart of Gold.
Probably the one Neil Young album that actually should be on this list.
Fun and Canadian that reminds me of the codeine song
This was a good album. I liked this Neil.
A very good album with the couple of weaker songs more than compensated for by the larger number of classics.
Sure
got so many vinyl records from my sister’s dad in law who passed away last year and this is one of them. i always think of him when i see an album i only know because of him.
enjoyed for the most part - a couple of standouts - some bits felt redundant/same-y but overall decent album for me
Enjoyed on a lazy morning in bed! Nice to be reminded of it's existence
Actively disliked, don't think I even managed to finish it
Relaxing. I liked it
Some classics like old man and heart of gold but a bit dull otherwise
bien
Yeah it wasn't bad, you win Neil!
*1972. *There are some weird songs here (i.e. A Man Needs a Maid and There's a World), but most of it is classic Neil Young. *Harvest, Heart of Gold, and Old Man are all on here. RATING - 8/10
Pretty nice overall. I can see it becoming something I come back to every one in a while. It does feel a bit disjointed from time to time, though
I've heard it before and liked it
Heart of Gold
A record deserving of the term 'classic' in that period when the album was the key form of musical expression by artists that took it seriously. Seen by many as his finest musical statement with the post 60s hippie hangover meeting the cynical Watergate era. It was the biggest selling album of 1972 and contains all killer and no filler with use of orchestra standing out at certain moments. Timeless yet evocative.
una iglesia con buena musica
Cool, pero no me hizo sentir cosas
Pretty slow, very good though. I like the instruments.
Nice listen, but a bit too old school for me
4/5 https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/neil-young/harvest/ Nice lil Neil Young album. Not super familiar with the man, aside from some albums and some hits, but I've been trying more recently. I know he has albums I like more than this one, even tho this one of course has great songs like Heart of Gold and especially Old Man.
Slow to white for my taste
Really surprised me. Very interesting and complex compositions after deceptively simple set ups. Feels like a spiritual predecessor to Father John Misty
A great album with a ton of classics.
Hpnestly, i still find the guy’s voice annoying, even though in general i like singers with this tone of voice, like Thom York, but he just sounds like a 10 year old choir boy, who tries to sing after crying for an hour. That being said, this is probably as good as he gets. I’d have still given it a strong 3 altogether, if it wasnt for the incredible sound/mixing of this record, like wow. Even on worse gear, this one shines.
Ik snap het, maar het is mij toch iets te rustig allemaal. 3
favs — 'a man needs a maid', 'heart of gold', 'alabama'
was fairly good tbf wouldn't listen again 4/10
From its beginning thumps to its fading guitar/piano chords, a genuine rock classic. Even if I'm partial to the 3-album down-n-out classics (On The Beach to Zuma), Harvest was a genuine high-point in Young's oeuvre, seriously rivaling Dylan's more-lauded and influential early work. So, yeah one of rock's better (and influential) albums (yes, Alabama pissed off some southerners). 5 undeniable points of night-light.
I'm not a big fan of pure Country, although this album was interesting and I understand it's popularity by listening to the songs. It is just not my cup of tea.
When someone says “classic Neil Young” this is what they mean.
Not sure how I feel about there’s a world. And I prefer the live at Massey hall version of old man. So maybe should be a 4, but think it’s still a 5 because it has a handful of my all time favorites songs on it. See the lonely boy out on the weekend….
The album to come back to what’s real in life
2 bangers the rest is mid
I liked this album more than I thought I would!
Great, simple, chill album. Never was the biggest Neil fan but there's a lot of bangers on this one and it's a beautifully produced album
One of my all times faves. Top 20 for sure.
second half of this album is just so strong - Alabama is UNDERRATED !
Like a warm hug
Tellement bien !! Mon premier 5/5
Uno de mis discos favoritos de toda la vida, que adoración que le tengo, siempre regreso a él, a mis viajes a Motupe para la feria con la familia, esas épocas de un joven que solo era una esponja músical. 1000 de 1000
Gosto muito do estilo Neil Young, bem pra pensar na vida. Heart of Gold é uma clássica. Old Man também é muito boa. Álbum foda, 2 músicas hit dele, acho que as mais famosas mesmo. Me conecta com meus 20 anos, dá vontade de explorar o mundo, principalmente a natureza ouvindo esse álbum. 4*
= the Beatles
Don’t even need to give this a listen to give Harvest full marks. My parents brought me up on Neil. They brought me up right.
lindo álbum son 8 los puntos
Rock again... who do they think I am?! An old white man?! Give me some electronic please :( Let me actually listen to this all the way through tho for day 2...
It’s a calm, almost fragile album, but it hits deep if you sit with it. The songs are where everything really shines. Heart of Gold is simple but perfect, one of those tracks that just stays with you forever. Old Man feels warm and reflective, like a quiet conversation with yourself. The Needle and the Damage Done is probably the most powerful moment—raw, painful, and real in a way that’s hard to ignore. And A Man Needs a Maid… there’s something about it that feels uneasy but emotional at the same time, like it’s exposing something vulnerable and complicated. Overall, the album isn’t trying to impress—it just tells the truth, and that’s what makes it so strong.
The big singles from this are incredible. “Heart of Gold” is probably my favorite Neil Young song, particularly the harmonies at the very end. I will listen to the whole song just to hear that. The album as a whole is interesting- it’s mostly acoustic folk, but with lush orchestration on some songs, a live, stripped down version of “Needle,” a couple of electric guitar work outs- it’s pretty varied. My biggest issue is that the languor represented here is just not something I want to dip into all that often. On the whole though this is a very strong 70s record. FOUR STARS
There are some legendary songs here. However, though it's a great album, I found other albums by Young from this period a little better. Still, a strong 4/5. Young is truly one of the greatest songwriters, who always stayed true to himself.
Soft country, okay maar niet geweldig. Heart of gold van otis redding maar dan niet de versie die ik ken
Es un álbum que me hizo sentir varado en un espacio donde estoy flotando y estas en calma, es como si la única compañía que necesito es este álbum y mi propio ser... Es como ver un paisaje oscuro y hermoso mientras todo lo demás esta suspendido en el tiempo. Mi tema fav. del álbum es "Old Man - Neil Young".
Fue un álbum muy chill, no tanto de mi estilo pero me gustó. Agregué algunas a mi playlist.
no es la gran cosa, muy tranquilo para mi gusto
Such a lovely little album, I knew ‘Old man’ going into this and I love that song, so I was hoping the rest of the album could reach that same vibe. I think that it delivered on this with ‘Heart of gold’ and ‘Out on the weekend’ and the overall vibe of the album matched it which I enjoyed. I liked how a couple of the songs like ‘Alabama’ brought in more of a rock sound, there was enough of a bit of variation to keep things fresh whilst listening to this album. I liked the good amount of emotion in the songs, I feel like you can really hear it in Young’s voice which I think pairs nicely with the country style music. It’s a simple formula but well executed with the vocals and quality instrumentals; a great album is created and one that I will be adding to my vinyl Wishlist.
it’s fine i guess? i liked it at the start but got boring by the end
Not for me
понравились последние 2-3 трека, альбом ну НОРМАльный альбом, прослушан с удовольствием
Great album with some of Neil Youn’s best songs n it- although I was disappointed that Harvest Moon wasn’t on there- it’s my favourite and I assumed it would be there because of the title. Some truly wonderful, timeless song writing on this album. I do slightly prefer the live at massey hall album with a lot of the same songs though if I was going to choose- it’s great hearing the audience react to these.
Ok that kicked ass. Was meh on the earlier Neill Young album but this one was so good. Heart of gold is an all time great song, but so many other amazing tunes on this album. Loved it. Feel like I finally get why he’s so beloved.
Better than I remember but still a 2.5
This was badly produced and poor guy can not sing. Not for me at all.
Very enjoyable listen with less grating vocals from previous albums.
Amazing
This is a great record that also contains two absolute stinkers, A Man Needs A Maid and There's A World, just schmaltz covered nonsense. The rest? Out on The Weekend, Harvest, Heart of Gold, Old Man, Alabama, Needle and the Damage Done, some of Neil’s very best songs
Great album. 'Heart of Gold' , 'Old Man' are highlights
I’ve heard this before and I own it. And I went through my Neil Young collection within the past couple of months unlike everything else on this list. Always a good reason for a relisten though. So this is a classic and is jam packed with bangers, but the two songs with orchestration in them are too melodramatic, especially A Man Needs a Maid. That song also rubs me a little wrong even though i understand it uses “maid” to refer in part to a housekeeper in current terms but in most part to a woman in old fashioned terms. It’s enough to keep it from a perfect 5 rating.
Mellow bruh.
I see Neil, I give 5 stars.
Easy 5. The Needle and the Damage Done is an all timer.
I’m not a fan, and not the audience
I enjoyed it more than I thought I would. I never thought of myself as a Neil Young fan but I thought there were some good songs on here. I might listen to this one again.
delightful, evocative of so many feelings and memories
enjoyed the ones i recognised but wasn't too fussed about the rest
Really smooth all the way through, aside from a weird dip in A Man Needs a Maid. I mean, it’s got Heart of Gold on it. I do like me some Neil Young.
47#
I just don't like Neil Young's voice....
Oscillating between twangy banjos and grungy guitar distortion, Neil Young's "Harvest" stands as one of the most enduringly influential releases of the 1970s. While "Old Man" is the indisputable highlight, the entire record is an journey through flannel-clad yearning, grief, and love.
Album Review 094 Harvest by Neil Young (1972) Rating 3.5/5 I don’t know much about the background to the album, aside from Young’s being burned out from touring and unable to move freely due to a back injury, but what this sounds of is someone who is tired, lost and feeling fragile. Harvest has strong set of songs, some of which over-polished, others under-polished and raw sounding. The only song that doesn’t fit is There’s a World, which is orchestral and sounds out of place, but does act as a good break between the softer earlier tracks and the heavier electric ones to follow.
4.5
I enjoyed this, not a perfect album but some interesting things going on (11/8 ftw) low/mid 4
Harvest is a total classic, no doubt. It's got this nostalgic, down home vibe that just hits the spot. The pedal steel and harmonica are awesome, giving it that cozy, campfire feel, especially on "Heart Of Gold" and "Old Man". The production is fantastic, mixing that stripped down folk sound with some big, orchestral moments... But, and this is a big but, it's *still* a Neil Young album. While the songs are amazing, his voice… it's a bit of a mixed bag. It can be cool, but sometimes it's just a little much. It's a shame, because the instruments and lyrics are so good, but his vocals are a bit of a hurdle for some folks. Still, it's a must-have record. I just wish someone else was singing these songs sometimes.
wasnt my favorite i fear. 1972
Absolute classic. Not a bad track on this record.
#73/1001 🇨🇦 Neil Young is the artist who commands the most space on my shelves and whilst this isnt my favourite of his records, its easy to see why its his best known. The first album that i got into was Sleeps With Angels in the early 90s and from there i've been on a journey going back through his catalogue and also enjoying his more recent works. This is a fine record throughout, A Man Needs a Maid being the only track that bothers me. Heart of Gold is maybe a little overplayed - its the only one of his tunes i ever hear on the radio. Best tracks: Old Man, Alhabama, Needle and the Damage Done, Words.
q letering babado FAVS (top 3): a man needs a maid, theres a world, alabama mençoes honrosas: out of the weekend, the needle and the damage don, words eu curti o album mas nao tanto como eu deveria, o album é bem curtinho otimo pra relaxar e o fim é definitivamente a melhor parte nota final:3.5/5
i love neil young
I suppose I should like Neil Young but I could never understand what people see in him, and I find his voice rather grating. Sorry and all that.
I think some of the backing musicianship on this might be good to great (?) but it is sooooo hard to tell because of his pathetic, soft, nasal and annoying vocals.
Never heard of Neil Young before. Some songs were good, great music if you need something moody or for thinking
Absolute masterpiece! It's one of the ones buried in my record collection & I'm glad its on the list! Buried no more!
In the multiverse NY put out a version of this album without ‘A Man Needs a Maid’ and I rated it 5 stars.
Este es el álbum con más reconocimiento de Neil Young en toda su carrera, y se entiende si lo que se busca en su música es la raíz country que le da de beber y a la cual vuelve de tanto en tanto. Más adelante ha hecho cosas más eléctricas, sobre todo cuando ha firmado junto a Crazy Horse, pero su esencia está aquí. Tengo una cuestión personal con Neil, y es que su voz no me gusta, y a menudo imagino a otros cantantes sacando más provecho de sus composiciones. Para mí es un poco ni fu ni fa, pero a los amantes del folk y del country este álbum seguro que les chifla.
God I love Neil Young. Heart Of Gold, Old Man, and The Needle And The Damage Done are 3 of the greatest songs ever written.
Really enjoyed this album. Great suggestion.
Love me some Neil Young. I think I preferred the previous record as a whole but this had some great high points. Really enjoyed Old Man and Alabama.
Glad to have heard the songs they don’t play on the radio. Good stuff.
One of the best Albums ever! So good, don’t get old!
I’m at the point, almost 100 albums in, anything I enjoy listening to and don’t swear, skip a boring song, is getting a 5.
Such a brilliant album that I hope I will listen to in full more often now. 'Old Man' is an exceptional, stand-out track for me, but it doesn't diminish the others. "Harvest" just has such a charm to it that makes for a great listening experience. Other than this album and 'Harvest Moon' I haven't listened to much Neil Young, and perhaps I should, but this album is certainly a great way to start. Rating: 4.5.
Been meaning to check this album out for a hot minute since I see so much praise for it everywhere. The only thing I've knowingly heard of Neil Young is Sufjan Stevens' cover of There's A World, which I of course love so I'm not expecting to be let down around here. Out on the Weekend - Not at all how I imagined his voice was going to sound. Vaguely western Ben Gibbard sounding. Pretty solid song though. I appreciate the slow build up throughout. Ready for more of a pay off in the next track maybe? Harvest - Certainly not a pay off to the build up in the last song, but that's okay. I'm realizing that it's maybe not that sort of album. Hearing quite a lot of small indie artists that I cherish in this song specifically. Interesting that this album has become so acclaimed when it's not really a sound that has remained extremely popular within the culture. Low key, but I'm digging. A Man Needs a Maid - Wow, all of a sudden we've got huge instrumentation. I'm experiencing a bit of positive confusion about the sudden shift in drama with the LSO here. Huge change in mood and structure from the previous two, but why? Heart of Gold - Got a bit of a blues rocker going on with this one. Again, a massive change from the first two songs and the third. All four have been solid tunes so far for sure, but I'm getting whiplash between styles. Still having trouble divorcing myself from the thought that this album is not going to be just a collection of songs, but it may in fact be. Not sure how I feel about it. Are You Ready for the Country? - Okay, another blues rock track. We're sounding like Dylan. I'm getting more grounded in what I'm supposed to expect here. Groovy number. I like the funny slidey guitar throughout. Old Man - Like this one quite a lot. Straight forward and a great tune. Nothing mind blowing going on, but there doesn't need to be with the bones as good as this. There's A World - Well, okay, the LSO is back. I mean, the song is great, the lyrics are lovely, and the orchestration is phenomenal. Really makes the lyrics seem incredibly majestic. It's just so different from everything else on the record. Feel like I'm being an asshole and should be able to turn off my desire for cohesion, but it's so widely distractingly different. The last second of the track with the stage sound is pretty interesting though. I fear that Sufjan did not set my expectations up properly here... Alabama - Not a huge fan of this one. Sort of plodding, lethargic rock instrumental that is so rich and full that I'm just sitting here with indigestion and ready to be done with. The sarcastic shady lyrics are quite amusing though. The Needle and the Damage Done - Cute little acoustic number. The lyrics are poignant and the swung chords accompany them well. The live version reveal is done well and the hard cut to the next track really works with the thematic content. It just makes me think again though, that there obviously is some sort of ALBUM statement going on here. But what and how??? Words (Between the Lines of Age) - Shreddin guitar solo going on at the end there. I'll be honest and say this is what I thought the whole album was going to sound more or less. Having heard it, I'm glad it doesn't all sound this way, but that's not necessarily a dig on this one. I'm so confused by this album. Obviously there is some quality song-writing going on, but I can't tell if the disparate musical styles herein are due to some attempt at cohesive eclecticism or just at a total inability to be cohesive. I am sort of leaning to believe the former right now. A perusal of the Wikipedia page doesn't really give me an indication of what the artistic intent is meant to be here, so it's really hard for me to accept this as a body of work that is helmed by an artist looking to create a body of work. There is genius in the lyrics for sure. I had to pivot to paying more attention to them when I realized that perhaps there was more merit in them than in the composition. But there are some moments in the production that make one think there is meant to be more attention paid there. Hard to wrap my mind around this one, and I'm sort of boggled at the reputation this album has. Strange strange strange.
Awesome. Now this is music. 4.5 Rounds up to five. Need more Neil young in my life.
Heart of Gold and Old Man really carry this album but I found it to be really an enjoyable listen.
🤣👍
Too country for my taste. And look, as a foreign woman, this is the sonic equivalent of watching a cowboy stare into the sunset or an old man parked in a rocking chair, replaying every mistake he ever made. Relaxing? Sure. Overwhelming? Never. So I won't drag the production, it's competent, safe, inoffensive. But boring is a good definition. The orchestra is the one thing that made me sit up, beautiful, dramatic, actually interesting. Loved that choice. Everything else? Didn't connect. Didn't care. Didn't engage. It's not bad enough to hate, not good enough to love. It's the musical definition of "whatever." I'll forget it. I know it's supposed to be this big confessional thing. Didn't hit me. The only tracks I'd maybe spin again are "Heart of Gold," "There's a Word," and "Words (Between the Lines of Age)."but I probably won't. Reminds me of generic mid-70s folk. No one specific, because it's too forgettable to even bother making the comparison. Rate : 2 (maybe 2.5, but I'm rounding down and honestly, 2 feels generous)
I'm giving it a 5, there are 1-2 songs I don't love (man needs a maid) but there are so many classics. Easy listening, great repeatability.
Harvest was the first Neil Young album I really got into, so it will always have a special place in my heart. That being said, I'll try to be as objective as I can, and objectively, out of the 6 albums from the seventies that can usually find their to the top of Neil's discography, Harvest has to be the least consistent one, boasting songs that are near the top of his catalog, while also having some of the weirdest ones from this period. And as others have pointed, and I agree, it has to be songs with the loud and over the top string arrangements. You can feel it's sort of a PR move, and that Neil doesn't fit in a song like There's a World, and A Man Needs a Maid (which I'll give credit to, is a decent song until the whole orchestral part), But man, Harvest simultaneously has some of his best and most memorable tracks ever. Out On The Weekend is a great opener and instantly paints that pastoral picture of a mid-summer day on the porch, Old Man and Heart of Gold have that classical Neil Young wisdom, while The Needle and the Damage Done is a glimpse into the what the future holds for Neil. And if I'm being honest, Alabama and Words can be added to that list as well. Those are some great fuzzy hard rockers. It's a good album, but those few tracks for me lower the rating. A shame really, because he couldn't quite achieve the mix of commercially and artistic viability he achieved on here until maybe the 90s.
Won’t be revisiting but was nice to listen to. I appreciate how older music is sure to incorporate some live instruments. Love that tbh.
12/03/2026 Favourite Songs: Out on the Weekend, A Man Needs a Maid, Heart of Gold, Words. Score: 3/5
Not my cup of tea
love this album -- fun fact -> James Taylor and Linda Ronstadt did some of the backing vocals
I’m a bit conflicted here. I love Neil Young but I don’t think it’s one of his greatest albums. This is probably his most commercially successful album with Heart of Gold possibly being his biggest hit. Thing is that Young is at his best when he’s rugged and unfinished, showing his vulnerability and fragility to the world. This is probably his most produced and polished album which makes for a diminished experience. Still The Needle and the Damage Done is an all time great Neil Young tune and it’s a good listen and important to his discography. Call it three stars.
Mér þykir mjög vænt um þessa plötu, fékk hana gefins frá góðum vini á síðustu öld og féll fyrir henni strax. Hún stenst tímans tönn og vel það.
Скукота пиздец
Приємний альбом, десь на 4-4.5. Heart of Gold - хітяра.
А оце хороший Ніл Янг, як я люблю.
Standouts Out on the Weekend Heart of Gold Are You Ready for the Country Old Man The Needle and the Damage Done
I'll search for comprehensive information about Neil Young's "Harvest" album to provide you with an in-depth review. # In-Depth Review: Neil Young's *Harvest* (1972) ## Overview Released on February 14, 1972, *Harvest* stands as Neil Young's most commercially successful album and his only #1 record on the *Billboard* charts . Yet this mainstream breakthrough emerged from circumstances of physical pain and creative fragmentation—Young was recovering from back surgery that prevented him from playing electric guitar in his usual manner, forcing an acoustic approach that defined the album's sound . The recording process was famously scattered: some tracks were cut in Nashville with session musicians dubbed "The Stray Gators," others in London with the London Symphony Orchestra, and the devastating "The Needle and the Damage Done" was captured live at UCLA's Royce Hall . --- ## Lyrical Analysis ### Themes of Vulnerability and Isolation *Harvest* explores what critic Jimm Cushing identified as Young's "guts to be romantic"—a willingness to expose emotional fragility that was rare in early '70s rock . The lyrics navigate the tension between solitude and connection, often through the lens of Young's then-new relationship with actress Carrie Snodgress (whom he'd met after his roadie insisted he watch her in *Diary of a Mad Housewife*) . **"Out on the Weekend"** opens with a man literally running away from connection ("Think I'll pack it in and buy a pickup"), yet the song reveals this escape as a mask for deeper longing. The narrator's retreat to a "place in the country" becomes a metaphor for emotional withdrawal rather than genuine peace . **"Harvest"** (the title track) uses agricultural metaphor to explore relationship uncertainty. Each verse begins with a question designed to gauge mutual vulnerability: "Will I see you give more than I can take? / Will I only harvest some?" The "change of plan" line—possibly referencing Snodgress's mother's suicide attempts—functions on multiple levels, applicable to divorce, family upheaval, or any unexpected life alteration . **"A Man Needs a Maid"** remains the album's most controversial lyric. The title suggests patriarchal convenience, but the song actually charts Young's terror of intimacy: "To give a love, you gotta live a love / To live a love, you gotta be 'part of.'" The narrator considers hiring help to avoid emotional entanglement, only to recognize the impossibility of such detachment . **"Old Man"** transforms a conversation with Louis Avila, the elderly caretaker of Young's newly purchased Broken Arrow Ranch, into a meditation on generational commonality. The bridge—"Old man, take a look at my life, I'm a lot like you"—dissolves age barriers through shared loneliness: "I need someone to love me the whole day through" . ### Political Consciousness **"Alabama"** functions as a sequel to *After the Gold Rush*'s "Southern Man," though Young later expressed regret about its execution. In his 2012 autobiography *Waging Heavy Peace*, he admitted the lyrics were "accusatory and condescending, not fully thought out" . The song nevertheless sparked one of rock's most famous dialogues—Lynyrd Skynyrd's "Sweet Home Alabama" responded directly with "I hope Neil Young will remember, a Southern man don't need him around anyhow." Despite the apparent conflict, Ronnie Van Zant often wore Neil Young t-shirts onstage, and mutual respect persisted between the artists . ### Addiction and Loss **"The Needle and the Damage Done"** stands as one of rock's first direct confrontations with heroin addiction. Written about Crazy Horse guitarist Danny Whitten (who would die of an overdose months after the album's release), the lyrics avoid preaching while bearing witness: "I am not a preacher, but drugs killed a lot of great men," Young noted in *Decade*'s liner notes . The live recording's spontaneity—complete with audible applause—creates documentary immediacy that studio polish would have diminished. --- ## Musical Character ### The Nashville Sound Working with Nashville session musicians including pedal steel guitarist Ben Keith, drummer Kenny Buttrey, and bassist Tim Drummond, Young achieved what he called "the Nashville sound without the Nashville attitude" . The Stray Gators provided supple, empathetic backing that honored country conventions while maintaining rock's edge. **"Are You Ready for the Country?"** and **"Words (Between the Lines of Age)"** benefit particularly from this ensemble's loose precision. ### Orchestral Experiments Producer Jack Nitzsche arranged two tracks with the London Symphony Orchestra, creating the album's most divisive moments. **"A Man Needs a Maid"** begins sparely—just Young's piano and voice—before exploding into symphonic bombast that even Young admitted was "overblown" . **"There's a World"** fares worse; thundering timpani and sweeping strings overwhelm slight material, creating what one critic called "Porgy & Bess from pork butt" . ### The Acoustic Core The album's enduring reputation rests on its stripped-down material. **"Heart of Gold"**—featuring harmonies from James Taylor and Linda Ronstadt—became Young's only #1 single, though he famously reacted with ambivalence: "Oh no! I've made a hit record! We can't have that now, can we?" . The song's harmonica riff and straightforward structure represented accessibility that Young would spend subsequent albums complicating. **"The Needle and the Damage Done"**'s solo acoustic performance demonstrates Young's ability to command attention without embellishment—its power lies in restraint rather than arrangement. --- ## Production Elliot Mazer, Henry Lewy, Jack Nitzsche, and Young himself shared production duties across disparate recording locations . The patchwork nature of the sessions—spanning January to September 1971—somehow coheres into a unified statement, though not without seams showing. The transition from "The Needle and the Damage Done" into "Words" feels abrupt; the orchestral tracks sit uneasily beside the Nashville material . The 2009 remaster improved the balance on "A Man Needs a Maid," though nothing could fully reconcile the tension between Young's reedy voice and full orchestral backing . Recent archival releases—including *Harvest Time* (2022)—have allowed reassessment of the creative process, revealing alternate versions that sometimes surpass the original choices . --- ## Cultural Impact and Influence *Harvest* defined "country-rock" for mainstream audiences, influencing everyone from Eagles to contemporary Americana artists. Its success paradoxically pushed Young toward more abrasive, less accessible material—*Time Fades Away*, *On the Beach*, and *Tonight's the Night* constituted a deliberate retreat from *Harvest*'s commercial achievement . The album's influence extends through: - **Elliott Smith** and **Built to Spill's Doug Martsch**, who absorbed Young's guitar approach and lyrical directness - **The "unplugged" movement** of the 1990s, which *Harvest* anticipated by two decades - **Addiction narratives** in popular music—"The Needle and the Damage Done" preceded similar explicit treatments by years Retrospective critical consensus has shifted dramatically. While *Rolling Stone*'s John Mendelsohn initially dismissed it as "a disappointing retread" of *After the Gold Rush* , the album now ranks #72 on *Rolling Stone*'s "500 Greatest Albums of All Time" (2020 revision) and was named the #1 Canadian Album of All Time by Bob Mersereau in *The Top 100 Canadian Albums* . --- ## Pros and Cons ### **Strengths** | Aspect | Assessment | |--------|------------| | **Emotional Directness** | Unprecedented vulnerability in rock; established template for confessional songwriting | | **Melodic Craft** | "Heart of Gold," "Old Man," and "Harvest" rank among Young's most enduring compositions | | **Musical Versatility** | Seamlessly blends country, folk, rock, and orchestral elements | | **Historical Significance** | Pioneered explicit addiction narratives; sparked dialogue with Southern rock | | **Vocal Harmonies** | Strategic deployment of CSNY, Taylor, and Ronstadt enhances without overwhelming | | **"The Needle and the Damage Done"** | Arguably the album's greatest achievement—raw, prescient, and timeless | ### **Weaknesses** | Aspect | Assessment | |--------|------------| | **Orchestral Overreach** | "A Man Needs a Maid" and "There's a World" suffer from overproduction; the latter is "skippable" | | **Lyrical Inconsistency** | "Alabama" lacks nuance; "There's a World" approaches banality ("You live in the world... so look around") | | **Pacing Issues** | The album's second half grows darker and heavier, creating tonal whiplash | | **Vocal Limitations** | Young's "thin, reedy voice" struggles against orchestral arrangements | | **Self-Imitation** | Early critics noted similarities to *After the Gold Rush*; some tracks feel like retreads | | **"A Man Needs a Maid" Title** | Dated even in 1972; creates unnecessary barrier to appreciating the song's actual content | --- ## Conclusion *Harvest* endures not despite its flaws but because of them. The orchestral misfires, the occasional lyrical heavy-handedness, and the tonal inconsistencies create an album of human dimension—ambitious, wounded, occasionally misguided, but ultimately sincere. It captures Young at a crossroads: commercially triumphant yet artistically restless, physically constrained yet emotionally expansive. The album's greatest legacy may be its demonstration that mainstream success need not require artistic compromise—though Young himself would spend the subsequent decade proving he could survive without such success. *Harvest* remains essential listening not as perfect artifact but as document of an artist negotiating fame, pain, and creativity at the height of his powers.
Lisää Neil Youngia ja sehän passaa! Harvest on lempparini ukon tuotoksista (läheskään kaikkia en ole kuullut) ja se taitaa myös olla Youngin eniten myynyt levy. Harvest edustaa enimmäkseen leppoisaa country-rockia, mutta mukaan mahtuu muutama särövoittoinen veto ja kaksi sinfoniaorkesterin säestämää mahtipontista balladia. Vaikka nuo kyseiset biisit eivät aivan saumattomasti sovi kokonaisuuteen, muu materiaali on niin huippua, että tälle kuitenkin uskaltaa antaa viisi tähteä.
A classic. Ever listenable, and iconic sound. "A Man Needs a Maid" is, however... unfortunate.
Throughout the experience, this album, I was treated with many features and great artist that collaborated with this man. It was amazing to see his heart bleed through his songs.
Hillbilly hip-hop. Out on the Weekend and Old Man are both in my top 20 Neil Young songs. Some great songs here, performed beautifully.
Fantastic
I started listening to country music in sense after i played Red Dead Redemption 2. In my mind I’ve always conjured up an image of loneliness and being lost in large landscapes of mountains and nature when it comes to picturing how country music makes me feel. This album does carry a lot of those same qualities, although it does also contain rock elements which help give it a sense of uniqueness to me at least. At points it drags on though and bores me but with the song structures containing elements of Electric Guitar, Banjos, Harmonica tapped off with grandiose string sections in songs such as “A Man Needs a Maid” it blew expectations for me for what a country song or rock song from the 70’s could be. Its an interesting album but I fear I wont really revisit it that often because i did not find as much replayability in it as I thought I would. Final Score: 6/10 Favorite Songs: Alabama, Heart Of Gold, The Needle and the Damage Done
I have already listened to this before. Neil Young is one of my favorite musicians and Harvest is an all time great country rock album. Every song on this record is great and old man is probably my favorite.
Was a good album with some old stand-by's worth a relisten on occasion.
This is one of my all-time favorite albums. I have played it to the point that I almost can't play it anymore. But it's perfect.
To je to moje prekletstvo, da ko dobim album ki ga poznam od prej, mi je ljub in mam šanso ga poslušat na plošči, s super zvočniki - bom dobila ta album na dan, ko mi ne bo zneslo tega naredit. In sm prisiljena ga poslušat v avtu, prek mobitela, prek compressed bluetooth zvoka. Oh, ja. Še zmer - what an album! Včasih me presenet, glede na to, da mi grejo določeni vokali na kurac, kako mi kakšni objektivno potencialno nadležni vokali (torej, Neil Young) ne grejo na kurac. Favoriti: "Out on the Weekend", "Heart of Gold" - itak!, "Old Man", "Alabama" in "Words (Between the Lines of Age)".
Neil Young album #3 here. There are a couple tracks that I like better, like "Are You Ready for the Country," with the funky piano & arrangement and obscure lyrics; "Old Man," where the guitar & banjo are more interesting than on some of the the other tracks here and is interesting hearing it now as an older person, and "Needle and the Damage Done," which is very raw and intense. However, this one also contains one song that I actively dislike ("A Man Needs a Maid"), a song I've heard so many times that just seeing the title without listening to it now has it stuck in my head ("Heart of Gold"), and a bunch of other songs that are pleasant but not a standout. So, I probably wouldn't ever go back to it, and therefore, 3 stars.
Just don’t get it. I don’t like his voice and the music’s okay
i can't believe this is how i find out neil young sucks
Before: Well, this is my second Neil Young so far and my first repeat artist. Never was a big fan but it looks like I'll have plenty of opportunities to get better acquainted with his music over the next 2+ years. During: Starts off with a nice tune, kind of sappy, but I like it. 4 Out On The Weekend 2 Harvest 1 A Man Needs A Maid 5 Heart Of Gold 2 Are You Ready For The Country 4 Old Man 2 There's A World 2 Alabama 3 The Needle And The Damage Done 3 Words (Between The Lines Of Age) ----------------------------------------- 2.8 AVERAGE After: There are way too many Neil Young Album's on this list; however this is supposedly considered one of if not this best. For that reason I'll give it a 4 for suitability for this list. For relevance I'll rate it a 3. 3 - my personal rating 4 - suitability for this list 3 - relevance ------------------------------ 3 - composite rating
A superb album probably Neil Young’s best.
This is really good, no notes 8.5/10
I liked listening but it didn't strike me
Timeless and achingly human. Old Man and Heart of Gold are the obvious entry points but the whole album rewards the time spent listening. Neil's voice has never sounded more unguarded, and the sparse production lets every word land exactly where it should. A Man Needs a Maid always stops me in my tracks - the way the London Symphony Orchestra arrangement sweeps in under one of his most vulnerable lyrics, and it's just devastating every time Ive heard it in the last 40-some years.
Uncle Neil is the Godfather of Grunge. Lyrically and vocally, Harvest is the start of that glorious genre (I don't think Uncle Neil did it musically until he went electric and upped the distortion with Crazy Horse). From the best-selling album of 1972, we get "Old Man" (f you, Skynyrd) and "Heart of Gold." My personal favorite has always been "The Needle and the Damage Done." Great classic album that everyone absolutely should listen to before they die. Influence 5. Hits 5. Quality 4. Intangibles 5. Good stuff 4.
Enjoyable but not markedly memorable
Typische Neil Young Sound. Klingt ein bisschen angestaubt, nicht stört aber es begeistert auch keiner der Songs so wirklich. 2/5
this album is great! it’s not the kind of music i’d usually listen but still, it’s super chill and relaxing. I love Neil’s voice in this and the instruments and background music? it’s amazing!
A little bit of Neil goes a long way. The old standards are great, but after a while that voice grates on me.
Neil. Nuf said
There are nine Neil Young albums on this list (if you include Buffalo Springfield Again and CSNY’s de ja vu). If I had to listen to only 9 Neil Young albums before I died Harvest wouldn’t be one. I think that’s because the best songs - Old Man, Needle and Damage Done have better versions on live albums like Live Rust. Listening again I enjoyed the orchestral arrangements and some of the guitar playing was excellent.
Had a couple of other Neil Young albums through this and wasn’t that impressed - thought this was good though - Harvest is a great track
I like it
Really pleasant with a surprising amount of orchestral ambition
Fav tracks: Heart of Gold, Old Man, Alabama, Words (Between the Lines of Age)
a good album! the back half is very solid and i really enjoyed my multiple listens. while the orchestral bits were a bit much and a man needs a maid was weird af, there’s a world grew on me on second listen. if i have to pick just two faves which no one is making me do but myself, i gotta say old man and words.
What a great record. Beautiful songwriting. The more orchestra heavy songs aren't landing for me as strongly as the rest of the record. Old man and Words are incredible songs. Listening to this, the influence many of my favorite artists take from Neil Young is abundantly clear. Wilco, Jason Molina, etc.
Quite good! Definitely the best album we've gotten so far. Sufjan Stevens must have really liked Old Man Fav tracks: Old Man, Heart of Gold
Idk man neil young is just annoying. I really don't like his voice. It's not even crooning it's just grating tbh. Like shut up. I don't wanna hear you. Like I really do not gaf. This is not for me. Why does he say his vowels like that. It's annoying af. I don't like this. Why does this sound so evil. Disney villain sounding ahh. I like Alabama you can't really hear his voice. Favourite: Alabama Least favourite: There's a World
This generator loves Neil Young and the rest of CSNY. Still a really good album. Some beautiful vocals and acoustic guitar and iconic songs
I have a disease where I can't rate Neil Young albums less than five stars
My rating 3.2. 3rd Neil Young album. Want to listen to the three I order of release. Again, this is ok. Hit songs (Old Man and Heart of Gold) worth the price of admission but rest of album. Meh.
Utterly simple music. I do not like you, Neil Young.
It is a consistently strong album. I prefer his later work, which has a bit more anger, but this still has his trademark sense of melody and harmony.
Really solid album and there are some great individual songs on it. Just let down slightly in my eyes by some of the odd song with overblown orchestration of ‘there’s a world’ that don’t really fit the vibe of the rest of the album.
I actually recently discovered this album this past fall, and fell in love with it! Still in the honeymoon phase here but I think this record is beautiful. The songwriting is strong, the instrumentals are gorgeous, and the lyrics are timeless. Great album.
Here's an album that brings me back to childhood. My parents had this in the van's CD changer pretty frequently, so I heard it a lot. Do I like it because of nostalgia or because it's actually good? Hard to say, but it's a nice listen.
Plenty of pompous lyrics, irritating harmonica, and bloated production all over this record. Neil Young’s voice has grown on me over the years, but I can’t say I enjoy what he’s singing about. The London Symphony Orchestra stuff doesn’t suit him at all. Are You Ready For the Country is pretty wretched. Old Man is part of a good song but it’s ruined by the grating backing vocals. The 2nd half finally has 2 minutes I enjoy without reservations. The Needle and the Damage Done is just a great song. Telling that it’s just Young and a guitar. The final track didn’t bother me but I was ready for it to be over by then. I think there may be a Neil Young recording out there I’d enjoy, but this ain’t it.
C’est l’album qui m’a ouvert les yeux sur le vieux folk rock américain. Un grand album de A à Z.
Classic.
Bien en general
Not too sure about There’s a World and Alabama, but other than that this was a really enjoyable listen. Old Man is such a perfect song; a definite Top 100 track of all time. I also love how the guitars, keys, and drums opened up in proper rock style on the closer, Words. What a solo! Neil Young has a lot to say here, and gets his emotions across to the listener extremely effectively. Thanks to the lovely Harmonica, Banjo, and Slide Guitar accompaniments, I’ll be gladly going back to listen to him again.
Never been a huge fan of Neil Young but this is a good album. Lots of great songs and few weak points. A nice relaxing listen
Nice 🌾🌾🌾
pop sound, lett å like men fanger meg ikke hundre prosent. noe med vokalen som ikke treffer for meg.. Lander på svak 3
stunnin'
Pretty sick, good ol folk American music from Neil. Not much more to say
I really liked this one! Had some unexpected more orchestral arrangements which was fun. His voice is not great but in a way that is really endearing and tends to heighten more emotional moments.
cool
I don’t know, man. I was a Neil Young hater coming into this - or at least I thought I was. You have to give it up for the songwriting though, the guy is a beast. These are gorgeous songs and the record is a classic clearly for good reason. I have a hard time still with his voice, though.
Classic Neil Young. This was perfect to listen to while driving. At times, quiet and soulful, other times almost cinematic.
Great album, surprised me
I love Neil Young, one of my favorites. He’s an incredible song writer both musically and lyrically and he’s equally great playing both acoustic and electric. This album is one of his best for sure, full of classic Neil Young. For me, the only miss on here is There’s a World, but the rest is still strong enough for a 5.
Although his voice is iconic, I find it hard to say that Neil Young is a strong vocalist. His rock music is fantastic, and I even like his lyrics, but his vocal power comes in a distant third in this competition. Even when the guitars are blaring he’s melancholy at best in delivering his lines. I say all that to get to the point that this is a fairly good album and Neil Young is an excellent musician.
I love this album … one of my all time favorites. It is peak acoustic Neil on some legendary songs … Heart of Gold, Old Man, Harvest, Alabama, Needle and the Danage Done. But, it’s not perfect. I can’t get it to 5 when Are You Ready for the Country and A Man Needs a Maid on the track list. It’s as solid as a 4.5 gets on this list and I want it to be a 5, but it’s not. It’s in my personal top 10 albums of all time but, alas, that doesn’t make it immaculate. A live Neil Young album is always better lthan a studio session anyway.
I like Neil Young fine. He writes amazing songs and, oddly enough, I like his voice but he's not a favorite. That said there are some amazing songs on this album, old man being my favorite, Heart of Gold and Alabama not far behind
Short and sweet album with some classics
Another genre-definer, every track is worth its weight, his best album in my opinion.
I want to give this a 5, but I'm going to go 4.5 and round down because Neil is one of my favorites and he has other albums I like more. Still a classic tho
Un pur bonheur ça transpire l'humanitude🙏🙏🙏
my canadian king