Reviews (page 4 of 9)
Zitten een paar goeie bangers tussen, sommige geven mij castlefest vibes.
Makes me want to chug a tankard of ale and mosh on a ship. Faves: Sally MacLennane, A Rainy Night in Soho, The Body of an American
bonne ambiance le nom, très mature
Je suis persuadé que les pirates écoutaient ce type de musique, mais malheureusement j'ai toujours été team corsaires. En gros c'est de la musique de farfadet que des roux alcooliques écoutent en buvant de la bière à 4% en faisant genre qu'elle est forte. J'aime bien leur bière mais j'avoue que leur musique et leur chocolat c'est trop (chocolat au whisky berk qui a eu cette idée de con...). En plus askip c'est ce bon vieil Elvis Costello qui a produit l'album et ça c'est trop.
Its pretty funny, made me feel like a pirate of today london. But thats all, cause taking it seriously wont take you to nowhere. As a joke it is good, and this is it. 2⭐
Très sympa, très The Dubliners, j’ai kiffé
god the singing here is miserable. nails on chalkboard tier, and the instrumentation does NOT help. the album experience of a bunch of drunk lads poorly shouting incomprehensible songs together inside a pub while you walk by on the sidewalk completely sober. it sure SEEMS like there's music going on, and you assume they're having fun, but you probably plug your ears and walk a bit faster. the garish cover art does this no favors either. feels like a prank album mocking celtic music rather than a revitalization of the genre such as is claimed but what the hell do i know when i don't even know when my dad's side of the family emigrated from scotland.
Elvis Costello did the production for this album, he should stick to it he's quite good at that. This album sounded pretty good to me at first but it did get repetitive and old fast. The songs are all very samey and not really a subject matter I care for, it almost feels like a caricature of Ireland with how much they talk about drinking and little else. But I did really like the instrumentation so there is that!
Fun but too much of this is way too much
Not my cup o' tea.
Initial first few songs were a lot more lackluster, didn't grip, but playing it through actually gave this some bite, something that was enjoyable. It wasn't mind blowing, or anything, and I don't plan on listening to this again, but it's a good song to get my feet wet in "Celtic" style music.
I really like this album, but there seems to be some filler. At more than an hour long, they could have made some cuts.
Wild that I got this album today. Yesterday, for whatever reason, the idea popped into my head to listen to The Pogues, so I turn on this album. And it's not like I listen to the Pogues often, its probably been over a year since my last listen. Then today, the generator gives me this album. Wild coincidence, can't imagine the odds. Anyways, this album is so much fun, love it. The traditional Irish folk instruments are exceptional; the flutes, accordions, and what sounds like a banjo, mixed with the drunken slurred vocals makes it a blast to listen to. Every song's got character, this album is truly unique.
did not enjoy
This brings to mind Great Big Sea and a grand kitchen party - I love the sound, although there are a few flat tracks on here.
A great album! Not a dull track. It's a tight but varied collection: blistering, raucous pub songs mixed with instrumentals and emotional ballads. Skillfully performed. It's a great sounding studio album with the energy of a live band. Every song tells a story. It's my first Pogues album. I had no idea what to expect. I loved it. "And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda," is a crushingly heartfelt masterpiece. It's a sober, beautiful way to cap off wild 45 minute adventure.
Who doesn't love rum sodomy? But over an hour of it may be a bit too much. Is it all one track? Is there much of a difference? Is my ear not discerning enough for the pirate folk? The day after listening, I woke up with a bad case of scurvy.
Huh, never heard the Pogues before. Kinda different but gave it two listens and no song jumped out at me.
Very frenetic punk folk that I didn't know I'd be enjoying today, overall 4 stars, I really liked the slower Waltzing Matilda at the end.
This is essentially a Celtic Folk album (pub songs, not fiddle/dance tunes) with a punk attitude. And it works very well. 4 stars.
Not something I would expect to like, but the first 3 songs were impressive. The only issue was as this went on it stayed the same, but was a drop down from those first 3 songs.
It’s cool to get a second Pogues album. This one was at least as good as the other, if not better. Some of the banjo was a bit much, but I really liked the overall album. Favorite Track: A Pistol for Paddy Garcia
Was only familiar with the Christmas song from athe Pogues but I was pleasantly surprised by this. Love the Irish folk punk vibes.
I did not like it or the singers voice but it had a consitent theme.
Pretty solid album. Not really my cup of tea but I can see how this is influential and highly regarded.
Cualquier disco de los Pogues te transporta a la buena y vieja Irlanda rural. Con su folklore, cultura, bailes y canciones de taberna.
Fantastic energy throughout, nice blend of originals and covers. They were very much the best at what they did.
Reconvertir el folk irlandés a algo moderno y agradable, disfrutar de estas canciones que suenan a piratas y borrachos no tiene precio. Me guardo "A Pair of Brown Eyes" y "Dirty Old Town".
Hated it.
Some amusing stuff here. A full album (and especially an extended version) is a bit much, but could have been worse.
Enjoyable. Better in smaller doses.
Irish fun.
Aye Captain! First track is pirate-sounding song with I think country pop as its main theme. I like it.
That was a fun listen. Probably won’t listen again but a great discovery!
A surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.
i mean, you cannot deny this album is doing exactly what it sets out to do. the pogues are doing their own thing and i applaud them for it. i did feel sort of mocked by the bawdy rowdiness of it all while i was stuck in traffic on a slate-gray dull work day, but they'd probably think that was funny. won't revisit but go off pogues. alternate review: this album was so poguerrs
man, i dunno what you want me to say. this album fuckin rocks. it's high-energy, punchy, fun, profound, and emotional. love the pogues, inject this shit directly into my veins. favorites: tracks 1, 3-9, 11, and 13
Meh
Excellent
Enjoyable but the type of music that I would listen to more than once.
Wasn't sure if would like this but was really fun to listen to.
Haven't heard this for a long long LONG time. Decent, but not as good as "If I Should Fall...." or "Peace and Love" which came later.
Not for me. 1/5
oh hell naaah?? priate music nöd so mis
Sounds like a bunch of drunken sailors
I really like this album but I don’t love it. I think the biggest issue is the fucking singer on Jesse James and Gentleman Soldier.
The Good: We get to have some rum! The Bad: We’re not certain about the sodomy… The Ugly: Fuck the lash! What a gem of an album for those who’ve never heard it before and who actually like folksy-punky-bluesy stuff. Plenty of comments referencing the fact that this is best listened to whilest under the influence of a pint or many, and I will agree that a pint or many does make the album more of an experience, however, that doesn’t mean it is the only way to have the experience. So, here’s to me cracking open another can or beer, while I pretend to join in on a merry sing-a-long in a pub I wish I was at… 4 1/2* upgraded for posterity!
No está mal, pero de su estilo me gustan bastante más otros
I really don't like Irish folk...
Love a bit of Irish tunes 4/5
Elvis Costello & The Pogues seemed like a fun collab and I wasn't wrong. I kinda liked it.
I like these guys
Folk punk lives! Seriously thought about holding this album to a 4 just because I wanted to leave room for the later Pogues album on this list that eclipses this one. But that's just dumb. Rum, Sodomy, etc is a definite 5, If I Should Fall From Grace With God just goes to 11.
I enjoyed this album a lot. Wasn’t sure what to expect from the title, album art and the label “alternative” on Apple Music, but pleasantly surprised when it was Celtic Rock!
The Pogues have been on my radar recently because I got really into one of their songs, Fairytale of New York, after hearing Hozier cover it on SNL last December. That tune is on another of their albums, 'If I Should Fall from Grace with God', which is also on this list. This album feels like a drunken night at the pub spent dancing the night away and celebrating life. I appreciate The Pogues's punk twist on Irish/Celtic folk music. Some of the songs are a lot of fun, while others are quite beautiful, and they all tell interesting stories. I love the sound of the traditional Irish band, complete with banjo, mandolin, accordion, fiddle, and tin whistle alongside the guitar, drums and bass. Add in Shane MacGowan's gravelly vocals and it all comes together. Top tracks for me are The Sick Bed of Cuchulainn, A Pair of Brown Eyes, And The Band Played Waltzing Matilda, A Pistol for Paddy Garcia and A Rainy Night in Soho. 9/10.
I enjoyed the songwriting overall but although they did a good job keeping it fresh, I guess I'm not a huge fan of the Celtic sound 6.5/10
The album art on this is wild. I wasn’t super awake and ready for the high energy of this album. It’s hard not to get into Celtic - sea shanty styled music though. Callie was bopping to the beat while smashing toys. Was a fun morning.
This was a weird album. I definitely haven't listened to this genre of music before. But, it was still somewhat enjoyable. Definitely not something I'd listen to on the regular. But still a cool style. There was so much energy throughout the album 7/10
Such a fun listen! What a wide variety in one album, all while still feeling tight knit and similar. I find with the Irish/Celtic sound in their folk music, it can sound very similar, using the same instruments, keys, and musical patterns. But these guys kept it interesting for the whole journey. From the flute, to the random screaming in the background, piping flute, brass and strings, female vocals on I'm a Man You Don't Meet Every Day. Such great elements used as ways to switch up the vibe from song to song. This album feels like a window into a whole other world of music that I don't often find myself listening to, but its a window I'm glad was presented to me. Rum Sodomy & The Lash transports its listeners to grassy hills, irish pubs, and cobble sidewalks, (This is what I imagine Ireland to look like) solely with sound. They paint such vivid pictures, and tell such beautiful stories purely through their music. If you dislike this, I hope the ghost of Christmas past, present and future come to visit you and take you on a journey through time to resolve your traumas. 9/10
I really enjoyed this. Didn’t realize the Pogues sounded like this. I love drunk sailor music.
I can’t believe they’re getting away with this but they are. Charmers.
Makes me want to join a few of me lads in a pub and belt out a few tunes over a few pints.
Best Song: Sally MacLennane Who doesn't like a little Celtic punk music? I was new to them and really enjoyed it. 4/5
Listening to this made me drunk and smelly, great work lads!
Not quite as good as If I Should Fall From Grace (lacks the variation in genres), but I really enjoyed this today.
I liked it fine, but no way an 80s pirate rock album should be on this list.
It’ll be 1000 reviews that are all the same if I repeat the “runtime is too long” mantra, but I’m sorry, these songs are repetitive and each too long. There’s levels of frustration with the length, & this is a lighter infraction, but it keeps good albums from being GOOD albums.
I knew Fairytale of New York but I wasn’t expecting Flogging Molly’s entire schtick to have been lifted. I also love the brutal title when it’s really just music from The Shire
As always, listening to this made me feel crusty and hungover.
Full of toe-tapping tunes. A strong pass of the Old grey Whistle Test.
nomol pooogues. ha s andere vo ihne nöd soo berauschend gfunde. ich loh mich nomol druf iih. erste song najaa bitz punk energy cool aber meh. old main drag watschlet sochli vor sich her. wild cats of kilkenny au afoch irische folk? ich check nume so halbe. d bassistin singt super uf i'm a man you dont meet everyday. a pair of brown eyes seg de hit gsi i guess? tönt scho afoch wie en alte irische song. find alles chli hobbit musig? waltzing matilda het mega schöni blöser. git e 2 i am tschudligung?
GAAAR NÖD READY HAHAHAH jap sorry han zerst denkt vlt chumi inne aber muss zerst nachli schreimusig lose wiso isch eifach so ziemlich jedes bmth album ganz andersch aber trz so fucking guet count your fucking BLESSSSIIIIIINGGGGSSSS alsooo zweite ahlauf okok the sick bed findi jz na funny, v.a. d pfiffe, ischs e tin whistle? aber so ÖÖHHH SUUFFFEEE hani gad eifach nöd so lust OOOMGGG ELVIS COSTRLLO HETS PRODUCEEEDDD LGOISCH MÜND MIER SIN DICK SUCKE sorry de het eifach ganz vill dreckigi gheimnis vo lüt us de musigbranche gsammlet und sie denn erpresst, dass er gepusht wird, ich gseh kei anderi erchlärig also so find s album bis jz easy, eifach nüt mega für mich (ussert ich bin gad mega ide stimmig dezue) frög mich au gad, öb ich am andere album chli e zu schlechti bewertig geh han (es 2), will ich hans nöd soo schlecht in erinnerig poah de walzer kreiert chli e atmosphäre aber es zieeeht sich vlt gits na en stern abzug eifach weg figg de elvis costello vlt heter d epstein files?? ok ich wür mich asi fühle gegebüber de arme ire
Not bad but also not my favorite, respect tho
I’m sure they’re great. Not my jam.
Well that was fun...
I once listened to this album while driving through the Irish countryside. One of those special listening experiences. It’s The Pogues at their best. I’ve been a fan of the band for about twelve years or so now, ever since spending a Saint Patrick’s Day around that time listening to them while pounding pints of Guinness. It’s too bad Shane MacGowan couldn’t temper the drunken Irish troubadour persona that made him and the band famous. He really was an amazing songwriter and had a singular voice.
Excellent Celtic-punk!
Not what I usually listen to, but it was pretty dang good!
Appreciate it for what it is but not for me outside of raucous pub setting
I nearly cried on the last one, and Dirty old town is brilliant. High 3
Some of my fav pogues songs on here, but as an album... hmm. Someone sort out the production maybe. Was a good shout for Armistice day though.
Ah they are wonderful. I really enjoyed this, including the tracks I didn't know.
I started started with low expectations but it was mostly quite good
3.5
hated the name, loved the freaking album.
A pretty good album, I liked A Pair Of Brown Eyes and A Pistol For Paddy Garcia the most.
Third start for "And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda" alone.
They may not be the most authentic of Irish/Celtic Folk bands, but they are probably the most well known, and had a major role in popularising the genre. This isn’t quite as good as If I Should Fall From Grace With God which came after, but it’s still good with some outstanding stuff - And The Band Played Waltzing Matilda in particular. As far as Irish bands go, U2 aren’t fit to sniff the shit on The Pogues boots, and Shane MacGowan had a thousand times more integrity and poetry in one of his rotted teeth than Bluto and The Fridge have in their entire bodies combined.
yes
A delightful romp
A bit like Willie Nelson: quite samey but in a very pleasant and enjoyable way.
Great album.
Rambunctious
With the extended version this isn't far off the best of the pogues and I love the pogues
FUN FUN AS HELL
Ok. Diese Band war mal Kult. Aber ich höre dir heute nur noch mit etwas Befremden.
I feel like I should be inclined towards this music, but in practice I couldn't really get into it. It was nice background noise though.
Ok, wenn ich in einem Irish Pub (1) besoffen (2) auf dem Tisch (3) tanze (4) ist das die passende Begleitmusik. Leider fehlen im Moment (1) - (4).
I hate this music so bad. I hope this is the last Pogues album I ever hear.
Pioneers of one of my favorite subgenres, what I call ethnic punk rock. Yes, the Irish are most people's favorite (Flogging Molly, Dropkick Murphys), but there are many others (Gogol Bordello, Mariachi el Bronx). In true punk style, the winning formula is very simple: infuse a pop-punk band with traditional instruments and the lyrics with your ethnic group's tales of oppression. All that said, this is hardly the Pogues' magnum opus. It's a tic long and lacks any of their bangers. Hopefully, this isn't their only entry on the list; they certainly deserve another. Influence 4. Quality 4. Hits 1. I still love this shit 4.
One of the first albums I ever brought - it still sounds as raw and fresh as the day it was released - a must add to your collection
Meanders a bit near the end which is a shame but still a great album 4.5*
Really? Top 1001 albums? Really.
1. The Sick Bed of Cuchulainn - fast trad/punk tune. Brilliant start to album 2. The Old Main Drag - drunken. Bit boring 3. The Wild Cats of Kilkenny - great bass and guitar. Instrumental belter. 4. I'm a Man You Don't Meet Every Day - Cait's vocals on this are amazing. Shame she didn't sing more for the Pogues. 5. A Pair of Brown Eyes - Catchy ballad. MacGowan in great form. 6. Sally MacLennane - Knee slapper 7. Dirty Old Town - Perfect 10/10 8. Jesse James - Good tune, don't like the singing on this one as much though 9. Navigator - Nice slow ballad. Great lyrics 10. Billy's Bones - catchy wee tune. Short and sweet 11. The Gentleman Soldier - don't like the singing on this one either. Bit weird. 12. And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda - Nice end to the album. Shane's vocals haunting.
I find the accordion one of the most annoying instruments, hence I dislike most Irish music.
So first listen I was hating everything and everyone to the point where I was going to give this one star. Living in Northern Ireland this would have been borderline treasonous lol. I gave it another go later on in much better form and bloody loved it, a proper fun listen. Top Track - Wild Cats of Kilkenny
Great album with lots of good songs. The lyrics and vocal delivery are excellent. The guy was really insanely good at this. I don't think I have ever actually listened to this whole album but its great from beginning to end. Really enjoyed it and will listen again.
All ye naysayers and haters, I am sorry but you haven't done some Irish jigging in a long time and it shows. Let those feet loose for your own sake and the sake of everyone around you. You'll be a much more pleasant person afterwards I promise. I’m also a firm believer all man-woman duets forever and now on should be done like The Gentleman Soldier.
I have a strong personal bond to the first Pogues album (Red Roses For Me), but this one is musically a step up. 'Sickbed of Cuchulainn' and 'Sally Maclennane' in particular encapsulate what the band was all about, but there's no filler on here. Magnificent. Five stars all the way.
Scratches me itchin' taint, aye it does.
The Pogues are one of those acts that I know critics adore, but I haven't found myself able to find the same appeal. Like don't get me wrong, Irish Punk has its time and place, but I can't help for some reason shaking a certain gimmicky element. Wild Cats of Kilkenny is wild and wonderful instrumental. Love the distorted echo effect they are throwing on the guitar(?) -- paired with the flute melody it makes for a slightly off balance sounding song. A Pair of Brown Eyes is some solid song writing as is And THe Band Played Waltzing Matilda. Otherwise, this kind of just breezed by without much notice. As I said up front, its not that I actively dislike this, I just don't actively enjoy it either. For me this falls into a soft 3 territory
A fun listen. Reminded me of a more basic version of the Waterboys. I am not critically acclaiming this album, but it was entertaining for sure. Low 4.
Just a straight up fun Irish Celtic rock album, well at least until the last song that was pretty sad about what sounded like a guy getting his legs blown off in a battle. Remember this band from about a year ago and I liked that album more, but this one still made me also want to drink about 15 Guinness
Just like the last Pogues album, it makes me want a pint. Really loving A Pistol for Paddy Garcia. The rest was some solid Celtic punky stuff with some good stories sprung in. Not really my cup of tea while sitting working but certainly not bad.
Just so much fun
Very well performed and hugely influential. But it was a bit too much for me. Every song that sounds like this kinda sounds the same to me.
A toughie - I appreciate what this album is doing but it's not something I'd see myself listening to again. I can see some similarities to Tom Waits (both are drawing from traditional music styles and have distinctive vocal performances), but I think Waits has a theatricality and uniqueness to his music that draws me in a bit more.
Thoughts before listening: The Pogues are awesome. I only ever owned their greatest hits on CD, so it will be nice to listen to what's supposed to be their best album. Review: Drunken Irish folk songs played with a punk rock attitude. I love it, and these guys went on to inspire a bunch of bands I discovered in my 90s punk days i.e. Flogging Molly and the Dropkick Murphys. Its a fun listen. 4-stars
A'ight this made me crack a wee smile. Good entertainment and you don’t have to overthink it.
Interesting album, tin whistles, irish folk and some punk rock. Good album if you enjoy songs about grief and sorrow, and the common folk.
Some of their best work.
Meeehhh I love Fairytale of New York in December but this just doesn't do anything for me. 2/5
Listened to a 1hour+ Irish Punk album without it getting anoying. That's a win for the Pogues, but they didn't win me over.
I hate this entire style of music and when I hear it I can still smell the drunk, 40-year old skinheads who tried to tell me how great it was when I was in high school.
Phew. The legacy of the Pogues is huge especially in Ireland but not really for me...
A decent album that mixes trad Irish music with punk. Clearly an influence for bands like Dropkick Murphys and The Real MacKenzies
Best Pogues album
had this cd in my car stereo for most of high school
Fun enough but, like the local wine you drink on holiday tasting far better in France or Italy, I think it would sound much better in a lively Irish pub than at home.
we love irish folk music but only that 1 song about getting wasted in the UK cause a flight got delayed
no thank you
I feel the same way about this album as I did the Pogues other album on this list. It's better than I thought it would be but I still have no idea if I would just sit down and listen to it. Perhaps if I were in an Irish pub. The sound is still better than the current Irish punk-rock stuff that seems to permeate a lot of the American Irish sound these days. Whether there needs to be another Pogues album in the book or one album would have sufficed can be argued, as the sound here is very similar to the sound on their other albums. If you hear one, you haven't heard them all, but you certainly would have gotten the point. Really fun album and I had heard "Waltzing Matilda" many times in my life but I think this may be my favorite version.
masterful storytelling and quality musicianship. you can practically smell the cigarette smoke and whiskey as you hear these songs. my brother has been into the pogues for a long time, and if i remember correctly, this is his favourite album of theirs. great listen from start to finish. highlights: “the old main drag” “a pair of brown eyes” “and the band played waltzing matilda”
Don’t even to listen to it today. A masterclass is storytelling and instrumentation.
If i were to sail the seas with me' maties, it would be perfect background music. Very folkmusic, not bad, just not my perfered album. Alestrom if they were not heavy ahah
I loathe these Pogues albums. Fucking hell
I know I should like this more but I just didn’t.
Very basic.
Love The Pogues. Great sound - vocals and music - wit and vibe. 3+
The Irish are the best of us. Listening to this album this morning reminded me of the time I was in Regina for work and I spent the evening sitting at the bar of an English pub drinking Guinness and Jamesons and played “Death of an American” on the jukebox. This happened last week so it was pretty easy to remember. The only decision here was 4 or 5 stars. I was leaning 4 as some of the early songs were a little forgettable, but just as I arrived at the office “And the band played waltzing Matilda” came on. I had never heard it before and I just sat in my car for 8 minutes staring into an early October sunrise holding back tears as Shane MacGowan told me a story of the tragedy of war as plainly and beautifully as I’d ever heard it. 5 stars.
4.5 Traditional and punk at the same time. Would not be a bad addition to any record collection
Was very surprised by this and enjoyed it, some Irishy shanty music
Already a big, big fave of mine. Come back to it time and time again over the years. How they make such chaotic music with such beautiful lyrics is beyond me. Shane’s voice is unparalleled in Irish music. Only criticism is the second half isn’t as good but I also haven’t given them the time of day.
This is a 4 to 4.5 star album for me, but I have to give it a 5 on this scale. It has such amazing songs and really was an introduction to so much of the world of the punk-infused Irish folk sound of The Pogues that is timeless and both brutal and beautiful.
I'm not Irish, but I do love this genre. This one is right up there with Dropkick Murpheys.
Not exactly my cup of tea and not something ill come back to but some parts were alright to listen to in passing
I just cant with this band. One song is enough
For a person raised to dance the reel and jig, this is heart music. Pour us another round and sing us another tale!
Nails on a chalkboard. Truly. Whoever put this on the list should have their voting rights revoked.
Very enjoyable.
Beer, friends, and Irish music makes for a great night
Folk punk huh? I'll be honest, I have a bias against most Irish music. I have nothing against it personally, but I've had so many friends who decided that being 1/16 Irish was their best personality trait and decided to just listen to music like this and drink Guinness, now I'm a bit burnt out. Listening to this brought me back to those days, and I realized I still needed more time to heal and forget.
Great cover, good album: consistently good songs (which is another way of saying they all kind of blend together for me: that must be my English bias)
Esperaba una cagada terrible pero me agrada mucho, muy nostálgico y suena exactamente a su tapa de álbum. Nota: 3.3
That's vulgar.
sobriety, purity, and tenderness
grating, annoying irish music with very poor singing
Exactly what I needed at the beginning of autumn.
Incredibly surprised at how much I absolutely love this.
It was different
the sick bed of cuchulainn- 5 the old main drag- 5 wild cats of kilkenny- 5 im a man you dont meet everyday- 5 a pair of brown eyes- 5 sally maclennnane- 6 or 7 a pistol for paddy garcia- 5 dirty old town- 6 jesse james- omg sick red dead ref. 7 navigator- 5 billys bones- 5 the gentlemen soldier- 5 and the band playing waltzing matilda- 5 i like the idea of punk retellings of old irish folk songs a lot better than the execution. but it wasnt terrible
7/10
I'm sure this is for someone, it's just not for me
Great band, great album.
I like it better than their other album on the list. Favorite song: wild cats of kilkenny
2.9
Good - 4.0
Ach die Pogues, ganz alte Zeiten...schon gut! c
That was fun. Not sure it could be an all the time, any time record. But I would listen to it a lot of the time.
Fun stuff
For the Pogues, it is good album, just not a great album. Enjoyed the more traditional Irish instruments. While’s the last song was certainly a moving tale, it was a bit long at 8 minutes.
A mix of songs that worked surprisingly well
This is one of the bands that makes me happy to have done this little project. It's a band I never would've found otherwise, they're great (not spectacular but great), lot of fun to listen to, and I thoroughly enjoy.
enjoyed their blend of traditional songs & instruments with contemporary sounds.
Great Irish band. Great album. You think of great Celtic music, one of the bands that’s always at the top, The rogues!
Damn imagine tak usiąść i zacząć pisać szanty. Jak na swój gatunek niezłe (chyba, nie mam za wiele doświadczenia), ale dosyć daleko od tego co słucham
This is not fairytales of New York
Day615 - it’s fun it’s different and i would listen again. the exact kind of album i want to discover
A blend of punk, Irish, and drinking songs. It works well, I only think I would listen to this on St Patrick's day or tailgating a Notre Dame Game. Wild Cats of Kilkenny: 4/5 Sally MacLennane: 4/5 London Girl: 5/5 The Body of an American: 4/5
Godt gang i noget irsk folkemusik med punk toner. God lyd
Solid album, not a huge fan of the pogues.
What the hell why not Favorite: a pistol for Paddy Garcia
Ca ne me tente vraiment pas ce matin.
Note à moi-même : à écouter quand j'ai l'goût d'être en criss.
The lack of a comma makes me wonder, is this sodomy with a rum bottle? Rum enema? Just asking. The Pogues rule.
I actually enjoyed this one. It feels like it's got more of the folk side of their sound than the punk side, and despite it being a specific vibe, it doesn't go on too long and get annoying like some of these do.
Fun! I didn't know VeggieTales was a genre of music 😂
Wonderful album, not boring to listen to, I loved it!
Dirty Old Town and 11 lesser songs, to give the album its alternative title. It's very raucous and fun, with McGowan's vocals very much on point - in the sense that they're meant to be. But a lot of it strays too far into trad Irish for my own tastes. And then we have DOT, an ode to Salford, my home town. It's just magnificent as a song, and sends shivers right through me. Obviously the best place to hear it is at 2.58 on a Saturday afternoon at Moor Lane as Salford City come out onto the pitch. I've also got a sneaky feeling it used to play at Old Trafford back in the 90s maybe? Before Gary Neville introduced them to the Roses that is. Anyway, a good but not great album overall, with one transcendental moment.
eh... i'm sure it has a time and place, but this isn't it for me.
Just a classic Irish folk band - not sure I could have picked them out of a folk festival line up 😅
A Pair of Brown Eyes //
3/5
Irish punk, felt kind of pirate-y
Insgesamt ganz stimmig und man schunkelt oft mit, ohne es wirklich mitzubekommen. Aber es ist mal wieder nicht so wirklich etwas bei mir hängen geblieben. 2-3/5, wobei ich eher zur 3 tendiere.
Fuck off
I was irish in a past life
The highs were high but the lows were low. Highs: The Sick Bed of Cuchulainn, Sally MacLennae, and Billy's Bones.
I enjoy a good jig
The Sickbed of Cuchulainn has been on my favorites playlist for YEARS! Of course, I enjoyed the whole album. Wild Cats of Kilkenny had me reminiscing about the days I did Irish stepdancing, and then suddenly I was in the Wild West with A Pistol for Paddy Garcia. I will definitely listen to this album again.
Какой же Москаленко лошара…
Argh
Irkku juomalaulua ja kansallis
I already had If I Should Fall From Grace With God and awarded it one star in spite of it featuring the stone cold classic Fairytale of New York. So what in the world were they thinking adding a second Pogues album that does the exact same shit for another 45 minutes?! It’s somewhere between a barn dance and a renaissance fair and both of those things are a million miles away from being enjoyable listening for me. I will never ever willingly choose to put this on and I maintain there is no need whatsoever for TWO Pogues LPs to be on the list.
this is irish as FUCK boy
Fantastic Irish folk album. The sentimentality, the prose, the mild but full instrumentation. It's like a nice shepherds pie. I wouldn't order it at a restaurant to celebrate or anything, but if it was what was for dinner I would be stoked.
Pretty good. Not my thing, clear influence on Irish bands like Dropkick Murphy or Flogging Molly which I just associate with being a teen. Better with headphones, second listen surprised me by how much I enjoyed. Well done niche music.
An appropriate soundtrack for a crappy Wednesday at work.
Easy to convey the feeling of this one. It's Irish.
Good enough for the Navy, good enough for The Pogues
Rum Sodomy & the Lash sounds like a half-sloshed poet leading a pub singalong. messy but oddly magnetic if you’re in the mood for it.
Shane McGowan and The Pogues have found a special place in my heart, a place of imagined nostalgia for joyful, whiskey fueled nights spent in an Irish pub that I've never actually experienced. But to be honest, even the fancy pub is just a run-down dive bar during the day, and this music is not compatible with a hangover.
Entering a cool Irish pub... nothing I'd put on by myself, but a fun experience
218/1089 - Same as my first review. They definitely know their sound.
The lack of a comma between the first two words of this title paints a picture of alcohol misuse to the extreme. Punctuation matters! As for the music, it’s perfectly acceptable drinking music. But with the exception of “Dirty Old Town,” I’ve heard better singles from this band.
The catch-22 is that the rawness that moves this up to a 4 prevents it from being a 5. Great fun for a whiskey night or a facsimile thereof.
Usually, I can only handle one or two songs of Shane McGowan vocals. But this album is probably the high point of the Pogues, at least for me. Several of the songs really have some heart to 'em. And the singing isn't as argle-bargle as most McGowan stuff. 3.5* and rounding up, partially out of surprise.
This is the kind of thing I would hardly ever listen to just because I think it needs a v specific sort of context to make it work, if that makes sense?? As in I listened to it today while cleaning my kitchen and scrubbing limescale off the kitchen sink and that just didn’t feel like the right context, you know? I think this album should be listened to in a social setting. Anyway that said I will likely not listen to it again for a really long time but I think it’s great, 4 stars, boom.
Had fun, but got tired
I like these guys more and more every time I listen
I still think "Hell's Ditch" is their best album but I understand why this is their most popular. Unfortunately, I'm going to be singing "Sally MacLananne" in my head the rest of the day. Though I will say that "And the Band Played 'Waltzing Matilda'" might wind up in my History curriculum sometime in the future.
⭐︎4.0 中世のヨーロッパ風のケルティックサウンドとパンクロックを融合したサウンドが斬新。 ボーカル曲よりもインスト曲の方が個人的には高評価。
Already listened to this album. Shane McGowan is a great lyricist.
Love the sound. Brings me back to My adolescence
80s folk punk. Fun genre, rowdy and old-fashioned. Irish folk with a punk twist, edgy and wild.
An almost perfect fusion between punk and folk, fluctuating between beautiful retellings of classic folks tunes, and raucous outbursts of energy. There is so much to love about this album.
Catchy Irish Jigs but not something I would listen to in my spare time.
Whats not to like? Happiest album ever?
Day 38 First listen- I am very biased cause I love Ireland. The album was great fun! I NEED to experience this in an Irish pub drinking Guinness. It's a NEED! (3.5/5)
Won't catch be listening to an album like this unless it's St. Patrick's Day.
4 Stars (11/15)
I enjoy Irish music once in awhile, so this was a good listen. But it is what it is, so while I know what I'm getting into, but it's not any more than that.
This isn't music that I would choose to listen to, but I did enjoy listening to it. The album seemed well put together and I'm glad I got the experience of listening to it.
Early on, I was considering a 1. My mind has never been changed so much. Most songs are so fun and happy. "A Pair of Brown Eyes" and "Sally Maclennane" were the songs that made me question my final rating. From there, the songs were mostly great. "A Pistol for Paddy Garcia" is an amazing instrumental track. Finally, "And The Band Played Waltzing Matilda" is such a heartbreaking song. It may seem out of place on an album full of songs about drinking, but I am glad this song is here. All unmentioned songs are fine at least. Only song I could put as worse than fine is "The Old Main Drag." At points in this album, I seriously considered every single ranking.
I know these guys now. I heard another one of their albums on this list. Not my cup-of-tea but I'll listen to some of this.
Really enjoy the fact it’s Irish songs but with good production. One of the downsides for me about trad music is the sameyness of it all, and the album doesn't do that. Really like the different effects. Gives each song distinct character which is lacking in most traditional music. Lyrics are obviously funny and relatable.
Love the Pogues. Maybe not quite as good as later albums, but RS&tL still can scratch that Pogues itch. 4.5/5
what a great band and album
Oof. (26/100)
Punk and Irish Folk at it's finest
What's not to like!
if ya didnt listen, you owe yerself...
6.5/10
Fav: Dirty Old Town Least Fav: The Gentleman Soldier These definitely sounded better blasting from the speakers of the Irish bars
Not my cup of tea but it was the pouges so what else can I say?
I only knew Dirty Old Town on this but that might be my least favourite song on the whole album. Starting off with the banger “ The Sick Bed of Cúchulainn” and ending on the depressing “And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda” is a rollercoaster.
Wish this popped up when we were in Dublin last week
Good at what it does I suppose, just not really my kind of thing. I still think it had a lot of pretty cool and fun moments though.
Quite enjoyable.
ren faire music. (i've never been to one, neither do i live in a country where we have ren faires, but i know people who do, and this is the kind of music they listen to...)
I almost really like this but not quite :-) It gets a bit manic at times.
Not too bad! Some lovely instrumental cuts on there as well. No fan of the punky, irish rock style but this grew on me.
Definitely an interesting album. Has a cool mix of a more folky Irish type and also some rock/punk type. I wouldn't revisit it, but I'm glad somebody is/was doing something different for once. Not an upsetting listen at all and overall a good album.
Ok
Mindre ensformig enn jeg trodde det skulle være. Flere veldig gode låter, men også en del filler.
Would be great fun live. This, not so much.
There are a lot of people who do not understand how much of a piece of art The Pogues and their records are. It is so much more than your ordinary Friday pub sing-along punkiness. It's all about reflection on the why and how societies may end up drinking and singing such stuff, embedded into a rather far-reaching historical reflection on top. Great.
A grumpy day leaves unfair impressions: I’ve been unable to separate record from popular use as signifier of a cliched, anarchic spirit of Irishness in American pop culture, which is funny as most of the band were English. Listenable, forceful, stuffed with tropes I’m tired of today, but that’s not their fault. Placeholder 3, hope for a happy revisit.
Their next one is even better, but if this was their only album their legacy would be secure. Two of MacGowan's finest songs side-by-side surrounded by a glorious folk-punk cacophony captured excellently by Costello in a pretty small studio. Their talent for retrieving the aggressive intent buried within traditional folk was remarkable.
I have seen this album for sale but never bought it because of its name and my preconceptions of the band. So I didn't ever expect to say something like this, But....... I think I may be a closet Pogues fan. I really liked this. His voice though by most standards is not good, really seems to suit these songs. And the band appear to be consummate musicians. I find it impossible to even contemplate giving it less than a 4, but not worth a 5.
I like The Pogues. The tunes make feel happy and I love the story telling.
This was the album which brought the Pogues into the public spotlight. I wasnt a huge fan, probably as im not actually Gaelic. Unfortunately I still have Sally MacLennane as an earworm, its a bloody good song. 'Dirty Old Town' is top drawer too. Now I shall flush that song out of my ear and forget about this album for the next God knows how many years.
I liked it but I acidentally olayed the album twice and didnt even realise I’d already listened to the songs 💀
I‘m just not build for this
I need some rum. This could be on the soundtrack of a pirates of the caribbean movie, or some episode of backyardigans. Not something I'd go out to seek and play on my own time 2/5
This was pretty fun. It's quite Irish sounding for sure which maybe limits frequent enjoyment.
It's nice, but becomes very samey, very quickly. Still, nice.
This was cool.
Great hybrid of punk and traditional instrumentation.
I can only listen to so much Irish drinking music. Nothing here was bad, but goddammit it was all the same song. Hurt my head lol. It was bad as an album but if I was just listening to an occasional song here and there maybe I'd like it more. Actual rating....1.5 Liked Songs: "The Sick Bed of Cuchulainn" , "I'm a Man You Don't Meet Every Day" , "Sally MacLennane" , "A Pistol for Paddy Garcia"
liked songs: I'm A Man You Don't Meet Every Day, A Pistol for Paddy Garcia Not my favorite thing I've ever listened to. 2.25
There are a lot of great Irish folk instrumentation on this album. There are also a lot of mid-tempo drinking songs that kind of crawl by. When the band really lets it rip like on "Billy Bones" it's a great time, and even when the songs are slow the backing music and vocals are always great. The highlight is probably the closer, where the story and emotion makes up for the slower pace. With a little more energy this could have been a great album, but as it is there are definitely some songs worth skipping.
I like the idea of the Pogues more than the music. I have two or three Pogues albums, and play each one or two times a year. This one does not tempt me to add another to my collection, despite it being arguably their best. Go figure.
Some really cool British Isles music... described as "folk punk"... a good album from start to finish... Elvis Costello produced it... highlights are the vocal by Cait O'Riordan, "I'm A Man You Don't Meet Every Day"... "A Pair of Brown Eyes" is a GREAT song by Shane MacGowan... Elvis plays some mandolin on it... side two only has one original on it... but the covers and trad songs are top notch... a great, sparse rendition of "The Band Played Waltzing Matilda" closes out this journey through the sound of Celtic punk... Five Stars.
Kadett, HDH - Patersdorf, Deutschland Nervig auf Albumlänge
sodomy
Not my tempo..
You scumbag you maggot you cheap lousy ahh
The energy on this is through the roof. I don't see anything comparing to this.
Ok 2.5
WAY better than any other punk albums we've gotten om this list. The traditional Irish music works so well with this genre, and its not used as a gimmick either. This held my attention from start to finish. Pogues tapped into something great here and all the pieces fit together nicely. It reminds me a little of Great Big Sea here and there for the more lighthearted songs. Great use of folk music here all around.
Turns out all punk had to do to make me love it was inject traditional Irish folk songs. This album slapped! I kissed the Blarney Stone
Songs to scally your wag
This was pretty cool, but not sure i’d listen to again. Some beautiful and sad songs tho
Absolutely great album. Irish punk might not be everyone's thing but I absolutely love it. Great sound, We wouldn't have Dropkick Murphys or Flogging Molly without The Pogues. Sound still holds up today, Definitely belongs on a list of albums everyone should hear! I'll be adding this to regular rotation.
Gear: Sennheiser MOMENTUM TW 4 Artwork: ⚔️📯🖼️ Production: 🎧🙂👌 Music: 🇮🇪 🧬✊ Rating: 🫀🫀(🫀)/5
Sounds like Rum, Sodomy and the Lash.
pogue mahone
I knew this album because of Josh, who has great, eclectic tastes. He'd definitely give this 5 stars. If it weren't for him, I'd have probably given it 3.5, but previous exposure increased my enjoyment a lot of this. Not to mention how influential the Pogues have been to so many of my favorite contemporary artists. 4.5/5, and I'll round up for Josh.
A style all their (Celtic) own.
This is fun and you really can’t tell the McGowan originals from the traditional songs. Loses a bit for the awful cover of Waltzing Matilda though, definite low point
point0.
Rarísimo. La música de este álbum de los Pogues es una mezcla entre canciones que suenan medievales mezcladas con algo de folk y dos o tres cosas de rock por ahí. No estuvo mal, pero lo pensaría dos veces antes de volver a escucharlo.
Really energetic and lively, but with a punk delivery, which is not my thing. I’m listening to get away from aggressively cynical, this is that. Still, there are some wonderful moments, and the sound is iconic. The instrumental pieces and songs with female vocals, I will listen to again. High quality recording and mixing — everything is clear as a bell and not a muddled mess (I’m realizing how much pop music suffers when the mix is not right for the music— here, it is). I probably won’t listen to this whole album again (usually a 2). But it gets a 3 for creativity, authenticity, energy, the occasional memorable moment, and the quality of the mix.
Man I love The Pogues. Marrying punk attitude and aesthetic with traditional Irish music and lyrics that speak to the soul. Dirty Old Town is just so good. McGowan really had such a captivating voice.
It’s just the greatest.
The pain of losing Shane keeps coming back. What a great lp, one of my favorites
up to date fiddly diddly
I don’t think this is a bad album but it’s not my cup of tea.
I listen to The Sick Bed of Cuchulainn just about every St. Patrick's day; it's an all-time banger. But then the next track The Old Main Drag is damn near unlistenable. This sums up my feeling on this album, and on the Pogues in general: some really great songs (Dirty Old Town is another, though this may be nostalgia talking) and some absolute dreck (Navigator, I'm a Man You Don't Meet Every Day, others). This tends to fall along the high-energy, fast song vs. slow song divide because those slow songs really fucking drag and Shane MacGowan (RIP) is not that great of a crooner.