Gunfighter Ballads And Trail Songs by Marty Robbins

Gunfighter Ballads And Trail Songs

Marty Robbins

3.33
Rating
28771
Votes
1
5%
2
16%
3
33%
4
30%
5
15%
Distribution

Reviews (page 10 of 14)

This is good for what it is but really not my thing.

Bit like an extended 50s western matinee

Thank you Fallout Favourite songs: Big Iron, El Paso, Utah Carol, The Little Green Valley, The Strawberry Roan Least favourite songs: In the Valley 4/5

Kind of a novelty album. I have seen this being restocked at my local record store almost weekly, so it is obviously popular. It was fun, but a little too repetitive. 2.5/5 Probably won’t listen again.

This album is very special to me, so there's no chance in me being objective or unbiased, I happily admit that. This album, of which I discovered from New Vegas, but my love further reinforced from El Paso's feature on Breaking Bad. Every song holds on its' own, but put together, it's a masterpiece. Marty Robbins had such a beautiful voice, and his way of storytelling in songs was incredible. I could listen to this album on repeat forever - it's one of my favourite albums ever. It's beautiful, and if you actually give it a proper listen outside of "le big iron" album, you'll find some really interesting and beautiful music. Easy 10/10.

not really my thing but I didn't hate it, it was still fun to listen to, I liked the storytelling aspect of it a lot!

Really enjoyed the short, catchy songs and good story telling

It’s just really cool

This is some cowboy music

As a UK resident living in West Yorkshire this album is of very little relevance to me. Although parts of Bradford do nowerdays resemble The Wild West. But I do appreciate that these songs are of significant historical value to my American friends so do not want to dismiss this album out of hand. I’ll leave it at that with a rating which reflects my own personal enjoyment the album. As a historical document I’m glad the album exists for future generations. 1/5 (over 200 albums in and my stats indicate that the 1950’s are my favourite decade - which it isn’t. This rating has nothing to do with bringing the average down but can’t help hoping that it does so that the 60’s and 70’s rightfully go top!) 9/8/24

Definitley not my Style

Feel like I listened to the same song 15 times.

I had so many albums that I needed to do catchup on that I nearly forgot there was 1 or 2 that I missed before I joined the group. Fun listen nonetheless. Obviously best known in my generation for le funny Fallout NV song but there are bangers throughout.

Ok, so maybe I like country music after all. I really like the stories being told and the visuals they are able to elicit with enjoyable music. Each song is engaging and some are just fun. Poor Felina :(

I have never been a country western music fan. At all. Despite that, I enjoyed the story telling and Marty’s vocals. I can certainly tell how he influenced many future performers and appreciate the significance of this album and genre. Solid work, but not my jam.

El Paso, Big Iron, A Hundred and Sixty Acres = all classics.

Love this album—great storytelling and Marty Robbins is able to get emotional without being sentimental. Particular favorites include Big Iron, They’re Hanging Me Tonight, The Master’s Call, and I generally don’t skip any tracks whenever I’m in the mood for it.

There’s a couple of great tracks here but the rest just falls flat to me. 2.5 stars.

Turns out I really enjoy old cinematic country albums. Best Song: They're Hanging Me Tonight

Bro this is actually so good!

Big Iron isn't bad for what it is (traditional country) Not really my genre but clearly important. Odd that it didn't go platinum until 1986 though. El Paso is also fine and culturally classic obviously. I skipped about half of this because I just really dont like that old school country, so Im giving it 2 stars but really its 2.5

Not a country guy. Nor am I a 50s music guy. When those two things come together, it’s either a recipe for success or a disaster. And thank god it was the former. Man what a good time this is. Big Iron is a certified classic, without a doubt, and immediately took me back to my time playing Fallout New Vegas. Really this whole album reminds me of that experience. This might not be as country as other music I’ve heard. I guess it’s more categorized as western. But I still think it fits under the umbrella of country. And this is country music for people who really care about the genre. Unlike that commercialized slop artists make nowadays. It paints a picture of the western period of the United States. Which is one of the most interesting periods in our history. And to see a piece of that history still hold so well is great. I give music from this time a lot of crap for being too simple. This is one of the only albums I’ve found where the general simplicity of the era actually works to the music’s effect. Again, it transports me to a different world. And this is most definitely aided by Marty’s fantastic lyricism. And really, storytelling. I have heard few artists who are able to tell a story through their songs as well as he does here. Whether it’s about a woman leaving him, and then him being hung for killing her and the man he left him for. Or about being a hit man in your past life, and leaving your lady to becoming a running gun, only to meet your end at the hands of another gunslinging bounty hunter. Funnily enough, a lot of them end in death. Particular Marty himself dying. Tall tales from a time that once was. But each one of them is unique and a joy to listen to. It’s what makes this stand out, so many decades later. And also what makes this an essential country album. Rating: 7/10

Never thought I would like this but I love it and have played it on repeat 3 times since first hearing it, it's so good. Big Iron and El Paso are major highlights but the whole album is worth A listen

Old school country music. Some of the more tolerable country to be honest, but still not my thing.

kinda disappointed, big iron is a classic, the rest is ok NNN

Ha, delightful. I'd never have found this in a million years. Such a time where riding horses, pining after women, being hung for murder, and shooting folk were the common language of being a man. So, let's make a song or 12 about it. Thanks. I'm now a bit more aware of where Johnny Cash came from, and Leonard Cohen, and perhaps even k d lang. Three stars. Two? It could be two. Let's go two. It was nice but not really nice.

Favourites: Big Iron, They're Hanging Me Tonight, Billy the Kid, The Master's Call, El Paso, Saddle Tramp Vocals and songwriting are fantastic, no doubt. Some songs have particularly superb instrumentals, when the bass and guitar work hits just right. Overall fantastic album.

Music for little boys and kitsch honky tonks in the 1950s. It just feels cheap, vaudevillian, and plastic, with its plot-driven lyrics and literal cowboy chords. The best songs are Robbins’ original material (mainly the singles), with a good rendition or two here and there, but that’s not high praise. For the most part, there’s very little variation on this thing. Both sonically and thematically. What you see is what you get; if you want cowboy country, then you’ll be more than happy, but I think the audience for that is basically nonexistent. Gunfighter Ballads is ultimately a trivial record, elevated mainly by its age and critical praise. It seems like most of the adoration around it is tied to the singles and the idea that country “used to be good,” so obviously this old album with a good critical track record falls into that nostalgic interpretation too, right? In reality, it’s kitsch. Sometimes kitsch can be good, but this is far from camp. It was meant to be forgotten, and in a week, I’ll definitely have forgotten that I ever listened to it.

this is a GOOD ALBUM. but i cant listen to it. to my severely damaged, pockmarked brain, marty robbins sounds like dogshit facebook memes about fnv or any video game with a big pistol in it. i cant get it out of my head i have an illness. its so over for me. theyre hanging me tonight is the standout for me and when i close my eyes i see the sierra madre. the tops. gomorrah. its so fucking over bros. this is effectively a 2.5/5 but i literally cant give it a 50%

Patrolling the Mojave really makes you wish for a nuclear winter… Big Iron is an absolute masterclass of western musical storytelling. Beautiful harmonies. Really wish this song hadn’t been memed to death. Songs that are completely unrelatable to the post GFC listener. Wish I had 160 acres in any valley. Just a comfy little tune about livin a simple life. Truly love this track. Old timey country musicians really sang about their impending execution a lot. This album really has some beautiful vocal harmonies. Huge fan of Strawberry Roan. Worlds most retarded horse easily defeats alleged master horse breaker. Paints a really good picture in this song of this janky as fuck old bastard horse. Just lovely storytelling. Masters Call is another fantastic ballad massive fan of this biblical fuck you for being an evil bandit. On the flip side it’s really funny to think of Jesus Christ just exploding cattle with lightning. Running gun is a real jaunty break from the slower paced songs that make up most of this album. Jumpy little guitar tune. Saddle tramp another classic banger. El Paso is a fantastic track. First heard it on cassette or something on this big fuck off stereo my uncle had at my grandparents house when I was like 8. This is one of my favourite country albums for sure. Most of the songs are short and sharp and don’t hang around too long. Nice little stories, there are a few tracks that are a bit forgettable but for the most part it’s a classic.

This album is interesting to me for 3 reasons: 1. I only know it because of NV Radio that basically only plays Big Iron. I really enjoy that song because of that game (and all the memes related). Initially hearing it, I didn't enjoy it at all (I'd never listened to 50/60s music that is remotely in this style, even when playing fallout 3), but it became one of the soundscapes of my Mojave adventures. 2. I never expected it to be here. I would have paid money thinking that this was a very unknown album by an unknown artist that noone had ever heard of unless you played NV. But no, apparently one of the 1001 must listens. 3. As previously mentioned, I have not ever listened to music of this era or genre other than in film and other media. In that context it's different. It's tied directly into the story or theme the film is conveying to you so it for the most part fits and isn't really questioned by me or even really analysed in any real way. But I've never sat and listened to a man singing ballads and trail songs. It surprised me that I enjoyed it more than I thought. I'm not going to pretend that I absolutely love this style of music, or that I would have given it as much time or thought if I didn't know how beloved it is by certain autistic friends of mine, but I'm glad I did. Big iron is a fantastic song, no questions asked. I also enjoyed Cool Water, the masters call and found saddle tramp interesting. I do think largely I enjoyed the stories told in these ballads and Marty Robbins voice more than anything. In that way, even the duds were enjoyable. Will I actively listen to this regularly? Probably not. Did I enjoy my time with it and grow an appreciation and understanding for the songs and the genre? I like to think so.

Phenomenal album. The Master is a Masterpiece, so good it made Running Gun seem way shitter than it was (even though after a couple listens it's still the worst track on the album imo) El Paso II is also a major highlight, type song to give a mf butterflies. Type of album to have so many great tracks one passes by and you gotta relisten cause you think it's an off cut but it ain't it's just as goated as the rest. 9/10 Fav tracks - Big Iron, They're Hanging Me Tonight, Cool Water, Billy the Kid, Utah Carol, The Strawberry Roan, The Masters Call, El Paso I, In the Valley, Little Green Valley, The Hanging Tree, Saddle Tramp, El Paso II Least Fav - Running Gun

Gothboy shit right here. Not bad but fuck me are all these lyrics depressing. Does feel like I'm just listening to the same kinda song over and over again. Great voice, don't makem like they used to i guess. 2/5.

An absolute joy to listen to this whole album finally. I have heard Big Iron and El Paso more times than I've had hot dinners and they still never get old. Highlights from this album besides those two are definitely Cool Water, Master's Call, They're Hanging Me Tonight and Saddle Tramp. Back to back songs both about valleys (at least on spotify which seems to be the CD version of the listing). My favourite song on this album is still El Paso.

Big Iron

Folk storytelling in a country album should be a combination for a very low score from yours truly. Turns out if the stories are being told by somebody with a 10/10 captivating voice and they're being backed by interesting instrumentals, I still enjoy it. Add some conditioning from Fallout, and here we have this album's score. Favorite track: Big Iron

why.. am I kind of enjoying this? I'm confused. Ok I legit enjoyed it. Don't like cowboys, don't understand why it was great, but 4. No notes. Nice catchy songs, great voice. Dated material but... I couldn't hate on it.

This album was better than I was bracing myself for it to be. I thought it would be very hokey patriotic country nonsense. Instead, it was sometimes interesting and often catchy. I can definitely see how it was culturally significant. That being said, will I listen to this one again? Probably not, because it's not a genre style that really does much for me.

Did you ever hear the Gilligan's island theme song and say "Wow, this is a great song but if only this was 2 hours long and about Texas instead!?!" If so, this is the album for you, and it can be all yours for the low, low price of all of your self-respect.

This delivers exactly as promised. Impeccable arrangements, beautifully delivered songs of death and dust, cowboys and lawmen, men trying to live a good life, and men on the run and men facing death.

This rules in dozens of ways.

Enjoyed this western country album. El Paso is such a classic. I did not realize there were so many songs about being killed by a stampede of cattle.

It certainly shocked me. It found a way to tell great cowboy stories over and over. It is something that everyone should appreciate old, old stories

Pretty solid. I thought this album was gonna be a total drag but I quite enjoyed it. “Big Iron” was probably my favorite song so it’s kinda unfortunate that the album starts with that but that’s okay. Reminds me of Johnny Cash at least in his style of writing and story telling ability.

while this is not an album I would normally choose to listen to, I enjoyed it. he's a great storyteller with song choices & arrangements were nice

Well yee-haw, this is some good country shit.

NO WAY I LOVE THIS ALBUM!!! I have listened to this in full before but looking forward to it again. “Big Iron” is so important to me. I think Marty just has a really good voice, too.

I love his voice and his music and lyrics are great. However, a lot of the songs sound similar, so I got kind of tired of it by the end.

A bit repetitive but has fun and engaging lyrics and stories.

Loved this album! He has an incredibly rich voice and his storytelling is beyond compare.

It's solid but not that great!

Howdy. Now I know where to go when I meet a gunfighter and think to myself: “if only there was a ballad playing..”

I'm a sucker for outlaw country, but some of this has no bite. Still cool.

There's a snake in my boot!

I love this era of country and western music and most of these songs are familiar favorites for me. So much so that when I happened to stop in El Paso on a work trip, I couldn’t help but make my way to Rosa’s Cantina to watch Felina whirl. I’ve always enjoyed the story telling that was a staple of this era. And the themes are as old as time itself: love, death, rebellion, redemption, regret. I know this type of music isn’t everyone’s cup of tea, but I’ve always felt like everyone’s got a little cowboy in them, and if you let them, these songs just might speak to that part of you. 4/5

While I was listening to primarily 80s metal, pop, jazz, electronica, and industrial in my youth, it was my Dad who introduced me to this album. My rebellious youth mind wanted to reject this album but my heart betrayed me and opened up completely to this music. "Cool Water" and "El Paso" were regularly played in our house, which was a perfect backdrop between the John Ford films playing on the TV. Marty Robbins always seemed a bit more bad ass than the rest of Country music, except perhaps Johnny Cash. I'm sure the outlaw black cowboy outfit on this album cover didn't hurt, far, far long before Outlaw Country Music was a thing. When you play this album you convey that you are a badass that won't be tamed by anyone's opinion.

I knew a couple of these songs already (El Paso was the big one) - this was a great listen, he had a marvelous voice and the songs are all vignettes about love and violence in the wild west.

I remember first hearing these songs when my father played this record on his reel to reel tape player. Though my main musical tastes have ranged far from Western since then, I love these songs and the smooth vocals from Marty Robbins.

I had no idea being a cowboy was so boring.

My dad owns this lp, and I grew up listening to it. It's good enough

can't relate nor can i say nothing

Nothing bad about it it’s just not really my thing.

This felt strangely healing

Classic - Mart Robbins tells some fun stories but could do with mixing his style up here and there

Señoritas

So repetitive

yee haw?

No comment

I'm not sure I've ever knowingly heard Marty Robbins' music before, so a fun new band/artist for me. "Big Iron" is a great opening track, and I really enjoyed some of the other songs on the album, mainly "The master's call" and "El Paso". The rest sound exactly how I imagine classic "cowboy" country music would sound like (complete with the harmonies in the choruses, and whispers of Gene Autry everywhere), which I enjoy in possibly smaller quantities than this album. But still a solid album for what it is; I just wish there were more original songs by him, as those seemed the strongest of the lot.

this was a lot of fun--a dip into another era of popular music

I did not have barbershop quartet country ballads on my bingo card. But somehow, this album really worked for me. Maybe it’s because I’m a sucker for Flamenco/classical guitar. Maybe it’s because this guy’s voice is beautiful. Maybe it’s because the melodies are simple and catchy. I’m not sure, but as someone who generally hates country-western music (though I might have to revise that opinion given the albums on this list so far) I enjoyed this a lot. These songs are very much in the vein of Johnny Cash in terms of storytelling and Elvis Presley in terms of the buttery smooth vocal performance (and white guy doing the blues). I don’t love cowboy/Western mythology. And the stories told in these songs are very heavy on those tropes. If you close your eyes while listening, you might imagine Ronald Reagan singing these songs, which is an unsettling thought. And yet, I still really like it. It gets a little repetitive because there are so many songs on the album and the melodies and stories all follow the same familiar structures. But it’s really smooth and pleasant to listen to. I wouldn’t listen to it all the time, but I’m glad I heard this at least once. 4/5

Funny Country stuff, cant Listen for more than 20 mins.

This reminds me of home. I can see him riding across the plains and fighting his way south to the border to find his love. It has a gentle, nostalgic tone while delivering a gun-slinging message. It takes you back to when your word and what you did meant something.

Funny this comes on the heels of the Chronic. Both albums mix myth with reality (this one is certainly more myth). Scores are settled. Violence lionized. Gats swapped for 44s. But his time around the music is warm and inviting. Taking you back to another time. Not just to the time this album was recorded but a time long ago. I enjoy the western flavors. Voice and instrumental. El Paso is an all timer.

5/14, 36%

Not my thing but brings back fond memories

..... so good.

Old school country story-telling. Fine if you like that sort of thing, which I don't really

I mean it’s of a time and a place. Neither to which I belong. But it’s testament to its artistry that it’s able to reach out across the decades and over the Atlantic, and cast a mesmerising spell of cowboy boots on the foot, big iron on the hip, desert cacti and cool cool water

While I have heard the song "El Paso" before, I was unfamiliar with this album. I enjoyed this record thoroughly. Simple songs that draw you in and lyrics that tell a story. It was an enjoyable listen.

Repetitive. Did remind me a little of the background music of the old television show, Gunsmoke.

Thoroughly enjoyed this one! I never heard of Marty or this album until I got into collecting vinyl; it’s a bit of a legendary “Holy Grail” acquisition for discerning collectors. I gotta admit I giggled like a schoolboy when I found an original 1959 Columbia Records “6-Eye” Mono pressing at Goodwill in good condition for 50 cents a month ago. Nice to have an historical physical artifact of this gem. Apparently it’s the prototype for visual media cowboy westerns pretty much to this day, and I can see why. I like Marty’s voice; it’s soothing and the harmonies with his background singers is fantastic. The guitar playing throughout is tasteful with just a touch of flair in the short riffs throughout whenever needed. And I’m sure there’s some nostalgia playing into this for me too. To this day, my Dad is THE biggest traditional western movie & TV show fan I’ve ever met in my life and as soon as the first song got going, I started flashing back to childhood Saturday afternoons watching John Ford westerns with Dad. I may have been rolling my eyes a bit back then as I wasn’t into westerns at eight…they’re pleasant memories for me now.

Liked it to start but then songs just started sounding the same.

Happy songs about people being shot, domestic violence, and being stampeded to death

I audibly sighed when I got this album. Great, more boring country! But I was so pleasantly surprised by this. Brilliant Country Western storytelling.

Don Law's influence on American music cannot be overstated.

Great sound to hear if you're into Westerns

STANDOUTS: Big Iron El Paso OVERALL: 4/5; you probably have to be in the MOOD for this, but I thought it was fun!

this came out of left field, the album from the 'el paso' song from breaking bad is awesome! maybe a bit repetitive but great! 4.5/5 rounding up

Love this album. Great singalongs.

just good wandering tracks, sound ther age but impeccable knack for storytelling

Marty Fobbins is just a classic. Great album beginning to finish.

this is just schlager for cowboys

Took me a while to get through but wasn’t bad. El Paso is nice

One of the best. A classic.

The album title says it all, and it sticks to that theme, it could have had 3 songs and I would have gotten the idea. Not bad, but not something I like listening to for more than 10 minutes.

Fantastic storyteller. Absolutely love Big Iron, The Master's Call, and El Paso.

It's hard to argue with 50s cowboy country. I'm a little nostalgic for it by way of my old man, I guess. I'm into it.

Maybe this brand of pone caught me just right, because behind Robbins' lugubrious voice and the sometimes too-pretty arrangements is a cracking western album. I mean, the narrative songwriting of 'Big Iron' (be sure to check out Colter Wall's cover) is streets ahead of most modern pop in terms of sophistication, atmosphere and the ability to paint a vivid picture. Other highlights - 'El Paso', 'The Hanging Tree' and my favourite, 'The Master's Call'. Surely Elvis took a cue or two from Robbins when it came to singing ballads?

Oddly enjoyable only western music, reminds me of Clint Eastwood films.

Not exactly my kind of music but I did rather like it. Did knoe El Paso. Easy 4.

Part of me wants to like this more than I do. It’s thoroughly enjoyable throughout, but never again manages to reach the height that it sets for itself with Big Iron, and although the subject matter is similar to other Country singer that I enjoy, most notably Johnny Cash, there’s something about the style that makes it seem all less consequential than Cash’s great works. I think the problem is that Robbins’ voice is too pretty. It doesn’t have the gravity or drama that the songs need. It’s relaxing, when it needs to be arresting. It should be an edge of your seat event, detailing the various murders and highjinks occurring on the trail, and instead it’s a bit like being told a bedtime story. I feel like I’m being more harsh than I mean to be. What I’m meaning to say is that I thought this was going to be different to how it was. I’m not disappointed in what it is, I enjoyed it. But I can see there being a version that I enjoyed more

This was an amazing album. I’ve never been much of a country guy, but this album has everything I would want in a good Western country album. Every song has a strong narrative, telling a story that draws you in and makes you feel like you’re living it.

This is not Country; it's Western. Probably the most Western of all singers were Frankie Lane and Marty Robbins. This is the best of all the former's music, especially the epic El Paso. All of these songs are staples of the singing cowboys of the 1950s. Some are really cowboy folk songs, others just sound like something a cowboy would sing around the campfire. It doesn't matter - it's all evocative of open plains, cowboys, the Old West, and gunfights. Many ended up as the theme songs for real Western movies. So, put on a cowboy hat, strap on your (faux) six shooter, and listen to Marty Robbins take you back in time to a mythical American frontier.

weirdly I really liked it, don't think listen to it very much though 3.5 stars

BIG IRONNNN BIIIIG IRONNN

Slight nostalgia rating from the first song being sung by my grandpa growing up but man this album slaps if you are into this kind of music. Fantastic storytelling with intertwining lyrics and background music that really highlight the singing. 10/10

Not gonna be a repeat listen for me, but damn this was some good cowboy drama

Solid outlaw rock 4*

Ultra classic cowboy country. An absolute must listen!

I don’t know if I could defend it, but I enjoyed the album plenty.

Eh paid is the only song I liked

Pleasant to listen to, and the storytelling is good. There are no songs I particularly want to come back to, however.

(goes to reviews expecting many Fallout references) Seriously, his voice is incredible and very well suited for this type of storytelling album. I really enjoyed listening to this, which is a very, very rare statement for me with country albums not by Johnny Cash

Makes you feel like a real cowboy

Peak country. Starting your album with 'Big Iron' and then ending it with 'El Paso' is like a cheat code for a good time. Also have to mention 'The Master's Call' which gives me chills, a masterclass in storytelling. Marty's voice is perfect for it all too. Banger.

Need to catch that bounty fr

That was quite a lot of gunslinger ballads. I started very interested and loved the stories but after awhile I felt like there was no way that many characters had 20 notches on their guns. The storytelling was still the most interesting part. The music itself wasn't bad per se but after a few songs it sounded a bit repetitive. The western music genre has had a resurgence of popularity due to its use in popular media, and that's a fine place for it, but I don't think I would sit and listen to this album again.

2.5⭐ The thing I love about country music is how often the songs are just fun stories about chasing baddies and riding cool horses. Sometimes the songs are about shooting women though so ya know... Not my thing usually, but I can't deny that I enjoyed listening.

"Big Iron", "They're Hanging Me Tonight", and "Cool Water" are solid tracks. Marty Robbins has an accomplished singing voice, and a dated but still cool western film soundtrack balladeer style. 3.3 stars rounded down.

I've never really understood why people go so crazy for this album over others of a similar sound that were made at the time (although while writing this I'm realising this probably came first lmao), but still this is definitely a fantastic album that just perfectly paints pictures of desolate, hard-done towns where so little is there that every heartbreak and pain feels like your whole world. Fuck fallout fans are annoying though.

Super not my thing. I find westerns to be painfully trite and the music here is equally repetitive. It’s someone’s thing, but it’s not mine.

The most Ronseal album title of all time. Rating: 3/5 Playlist track: Big Iron Date listened: 16/06/24

As someone who dislikes 90% of the country music he hears, I was not excited to get this album. It was much better than expected, most of the lyrics were fun and told old western stories. It's exactly the title of the album. Early Johnny Cash vibes.

Now Gunfighter Ballads And Trail Songs is how you do country music in the 50s. As you can guess from that statement, this album does what it wants to do as well as it can. The main thing that stuck out to me was the lyrics which just show that Marty Robbins is quite the storyteller with his songs telling stories in some pretty interesting ways. The music is alright albeit nothing special. It can sound good sometimes but other times, it can get pretty forgettable. But even then its not exactly what i would think of as the main selling point of this album. Its the stories that it tells that are and this album does those well. Best Song: Big Iron Worst Song: Cool Water

I've never really been much of a Westerns (apart from Red Dead Redemption) guy, so I don't have a lot of context for the lyrics on here. Nothing to complain about here though really, some of the songs were a bit samey, but all very pleasant to listen to. Production is good, it sounded really clear coming through my Pip-Boy...anyone got any spare Rad-ex?

its high noon

Listening to this album is like expecting a serial killer to perform their craft... Enjoyable listen, more for way way background music.

Delightful and nostalgic. Living in the west - and a frequent visitor to El Paso - I’m almost obligated to give this a high rating. I almost went for 5 stars, but hesitated because some of the songs started to sound pretty similar…it’s on the edge, though. Favorite tracks: Big Iron, Cool Water, Billy The Kid, El Paso

Cowboy songs

Es música bien yankee de recitado y banjo. No es mala, pero es monótona y aburrida, no puedo agregar de esto a la playlist.

big iron

Bumping this from a 3 to a 4 👌🏻

The really old stuff can be hard to rate, and the really old country stuff even more so. No one calls it this, but these old Western albums are basically just early concept albums. Maybe it isn't one story throughout, but this is all just historical storytelling related to the outlaws of the wild west (Marty was born in 1925, it definitely wasn't still super "Wild West" at that point). Here's the thing, this is actually really enjoyable. He's got a really nice voice, the vibes are solid, it's very decent. I'm not super into outlaw music overall, but I can get behind the concept when the overall sound is good. Everyone freaks out about Johnny Cash (and don't get me wrong, he's great), but this is at least as good as the two Johnny Cash prison albums on this list. Marty seems to have had some really shitty politics in his life, but it doesn't come through here so I'll give him a pass. This is just pure Americana, and maybe I'm overhyping it but I think it's good. Side note, but it's pretty hilarious that his real passion was racecar driving, and he used his singing wealth to become a NASCAR driver. Favorite song: El Paso Other: Big Iron, They're Hanging Me Tonight, Cool Water, Utah Carol, The Strawberry Roan, The Master's Call, The Hanging Tree, Saddle Tramp 6/10/24

Badman cowboy tunes from rightwing jutcase who inspired Johnny cash and other basically cool guys. Really enjoyed it, made me feel strong, powerful, male and edgey. Who could want any more?

A true storyteller. Made me pine for lazy summer days, reading Louis Lamour or watching the Lone Ranger. I’m hungry for some Tex-Mex.

Finally, a country album I like! Genuinely really enjoyed this one, great storytelling on the tracks, if the instrumentals did get a *bit* samey at times. Fav tracks: Big Iron, The Hanging Tree, El Paso

A Lot of the same but I kinda enjoyed it

Enjoyable, i love old music and i was happy bc i felt like i was listening to elvis a lot of the time but if you took a shot for every time he mentioned killing someone you’d be wasted. I suppose it fits the name of the album though

decent 3. it was a fun album but many of the songs were very similar to each other. i really liked the storytelling in some of these songs tho and just the whole vibe made me really feel like i had the big iron on me hip 1. El Paso 2. In The Valley 3. A Hundred And Sixty Acres

Would never have found or listened to it on its own. Production is great for the time period. El Paso is timeless.

6/7/24 wasn’t expecting to enjoy this but not bad. good background noise. starts off with the classic “big iron on his hip.” most of these albums so far have been “oh so that’s where this song is from.” pretty neat 4/10

Lots of stories of lonesome men, grief and a certain degree of idiocy. Not a whole lot of musical variety.

I enjoyed it. Nicely recorded and a bit different from other stuff on the list.

This album specifically made me go back and boot up fallout new Vegas

can’t believe this dude’s whole shtick is being a straight orville peck (I thought I’d hate this album but it actually ruled)

Suspected I liked outlaw country but I didn’t expect to like it this much!

yeah this rule. fun to imagine being a cowboy while you listen. shout out to dj for mentioning big iron in an earlier review!

A bit of a fun album to listen to. Not something I'd want in high rotation but good to reminisce about my gunslinger days. It's hard to pick a favourite they all have their little charms.

Oh cool - I previously had Johnny Cash's "American IV: The Man Comes Around" on this project, and "Big Iron" was one of my fave tracks from it - it's great to head where that came from! I enjoyed this - definitely prefer this style of country to the pop country nonsense the genre evolved into. All of these tracks would drop nicely into the soundtrack of a Coen brothers movie. Fave tracks - as well as "Big Iron", also dug "Cool Water", "The Strawberry Roan" and "Saddle Tramp"

Fun stuff

Love this album

Have to be in the mood but its really good

Not bad but definitely need to be in the mood

absolutely fantastic. 160 acres is a new fav.

6/10 I was a young man when i voted on this albummmm...it was a predictable novelty but not without its charmmmm...now I ride the planes aloooooone 5-31-2024

I don’t have the words to describe how this record makes feel other than familiar and comforting. I love it. Five stars!!

Nice one

Wasn’t in the mood for this and never understood the obsession with cowboys. That said, it wasn’t grating or hard to just let it be background noise.

This is the guy Pete Townshend wrote about when he wrote “God Speaks, of Marty Robbin’s”? Huh ok. Gotta look into that more…kinda looks like him, too… I can appreciate this as a piece of history, a time capsule when the USA was obsessed with western this and cowboy that. TV shows like “Gunsmoke,” “Wagon Train,” and “Bonanza” were massive, practically dominating American television. This album, I assume, did incredibly well, as it fit into that trend of American popular culture. So if this is on this list purely for its impact, and to give Marty Robbins a place in history, I am more than ok with that. This album is pure Americana, as we see it today. Romanticized stories of the old west, tales of adventure, love and loss, and gunfights. This is what you’d expect from an album with this cover and name. The music? Well that’s also what you’d expect, except that it’s actually…good. For what it is, anyway. I’m not claiming this to be the best ever, but as a country western album, it’s a sterling example. Well produced, with interesting stories and a good backing band. But what shines the most is Robbins’s voice. He plays the part of lonesome cowboy so, so well. He fits into the archetype perfectly and with little effort. It feels like he’s always been this guy and will keep on being this guy, even if he didn’t live in the old west. It’s easy to admire the tone and style established here. Everything about the production backs up that tone and style. It’s a marvel to listen to. As a whole, I liked this a surprising amount, especially given what I’d see other people rate this album when browsing other people’s pages. I assumed I’d be giving it two stars but I honestly have to give it three for its place in history, its production, Robbins’s performance (both musically and as a character), and because it’s an excellent example of its genre. And stuff like this probably inspired “Rocky Raccoon,” so that’s cool. Standout tracks: Big Iron, El Paso, The Master’s Call, Running Gun

The most accurate title in record history. Yee haw!

Mmm, there are definitely some gems, but overall all the songs sound kinda similar and at some point it felt like I was listening to the same song over and over again…

not my style of music

Before starting this list I would’ve never thought to enjoy country this much! Great way to find out, excited for more!

An all time classic. I wish my Dad was still around to know how much I have grown to appreciate this.

This is some killer old school country. Big Iron and El Paso are classics, but the album is good all the way through. Very enjoyable.

This cowboy novelty record has one good/maybe great song in “El Paso”, surrounded by infantile fantasy.

You don't hear enough "W" these days. El Paso I know, which drifts into The Wild Rover in my head if you let it. Highly enjoyable, with hints of earlier Elvis, although it can sound like a Mexican restaurant at times.

4.5/5. My best friend who grew up in a small rural town loves this album. I’m inclined to say I love it too, almost as much as I love her.

Biggest Iron only hits 4 sadly

Good stuff!!!

I couldn't ask for a single aspect of this album to be changed. Not to mention the album cover! This is prime pre-mustache Marty at his peak-- with 2 cuts of the great El Paso for good measure. That track has long been an obsession and the rest of this album does not disappoint. Not only are the arrangements and production smooth as a gallopin' mare, but each track is narratively cinematic in a way that just takes you there. Marty Robbins forever. Anyone shortin this good ol' gunslinger a star is as wild as the west Texas wind.

Oh so good. This dude's voice is so warm, and his readings of these songs is just excellent. The music is deceptively morose despite the seemingly happy singing cowboy overtones. And the tales are mostly DARK AF. I've already ordered the vinyl and can't wait to hear this over and over. Four stars.

I love old western music like this. My family used to go out west on trips and my dad would always play music like this (only Big Iron from this album) so this one has some extra nostalgia built in for me to push it up to a low 5. Rating: 4.6

Big Iron, good story musical pace was nice.

"Man, I'm gonna hate this." I thought when this album was recommended to me. But when I listened to "Big Iron", a song I was familiar with, I knew I was about to listen to a bunch of fine hits. The songwriting on this album is fantastic. It's definitely one of the best 50s albums. Step aside, Sinatra! Marty Robbins gets my approval. 5 stars for this memorable classic.

This took me by surprise a now I’m completely in love with it. I think I’ve listened to the whole album 6 times today already. Even though I’ve never listened to it before it brings back so much nostalgia in me I want to cry. When I look back to my childhood, one of the happiest memories was definitely watching Westerns with my dad every Sunday at noon, right after coming back home from church. The way each song on the album tells a different western story takes me back to those times. I also enjoy the musical layer. Marty has a beautiful clear deep voice and he uses it perfectly to underline the drama in each song. The voice is obviously the most prominent instrument here, but it’s very well supported by the crooning male backing vocals. I’d have never picked it up if it wasn’t for this challenge!

Oh yeah babyyyyy. I knew I was gonna like this one. Look at that album cover! And a guy named Marty. That’s awesome

Pretty darned good!

Classic Country album

Howdy y'all! (I'm sorry, I had to.) If there's one thing that you can do to feel like a badass cowboy, it's busting out some Red Dead Redemption 2 with Marty Robbins playing in the background. Unfortunately, I don't own RDR2, so I guess I'll just stick with the Marty Robbins. Gunfighter Ballads and Trail Songs is an absolute classic of an album. It's just a nice collection of, as the name suggests, gunfighter ballads and trail songs. The songs are all quite similar to each other, but I choose to look at this album less as a repetitive collection of similar songs and more as an early concept album pertaining to cowboy life. If you envision the cowboy singing this with a guitar, then the album feels very atmospheric and almost like a journey of sorts. The singing, by the way, is great. The tone of the singing is just perfect for this kind of music and the multiple layers of the singing aids in making the sound as good as it is. The instrumental sound also fits the vibe perfectly. The writing and storytelling is quite good. Of course, the album's opener "Big Iron" is the biggest highlight for me, but the other songs are also of a similar level of quality. Overall, this album is great and serves its purpose extremely well. High 4/5.

I'm happy to believe this is as good as the genre gets, but unfortunatly it's not a genre that particularly excites me. It's fine, but I can't imagine I'm going to want to listen to it again.

Classic!

It is a hopelessly dated sound but I found it a very nice listen from start to finish.

Great album to enjoy while roaming around the Mojave Wasteland

Big Iron !!!

Dang, that VOICE. So rich and smooth. And Grady Martin on lead guitar plays such a beautiful counterpoint that belies the simplicity of the arrangement from the rhythm and bass. Elements of classical guitar and maybe even fado? Big Iron is such a perfect opener. Although I had heard El Paso before, I didn't know anything about Robbins before today. I was full of skeptism when this popped up, I think I actually laughed outloud when I saw the cover. Big Iron immediately made me sit up, pay attention, and reconsider.

Sounds like early Sun-era Elvis. Robbins’ singing is impassioned and delicately controlled, with subtle backing vocals that add an eerie texture to these tales of western murder and romance. Big Iron and El Paso are definitely the standouts, but overall it’s an enjoyable listen front to back. Most of the songs exhibit a simple beauty with strong vocals mixed with minimalist guitar and percussion. I know this was influential for outlaw country, but I can also see how indie bands like Pixies could have cribbed from Robbins.

Literally impossible to not love. Basically every song is a banger and is rivaled only by Johnny Horton for this style of western music. Not much else to say it’s just 40 minutes of pure joy.

thank god i wasn’t consuming music in 1959

I love this. We thank you for helping make cash, Nelson and the other highwaymen possible!

got a big iron on my hips

Big Iron Billy The Kid El Paso

Big Iron and El Paso are great but tbh, I got a little bored about halfway through. Not bad though!!

Darn good rootin’ tootin’ cowboy music!

Pretty cool

Loved this. Reminds me of something my mom would have listened to and can see myself coming back to this.

Is there poetic license at work here, or did Marty Robbins actually kill all these men he sings about?

I love a song that tells a story, and that's this whole album. Makes me think of my grandpa and the music he would listen to and the westerns he would watch.

3/5. It's like Country music yet definitely has 50's ballads throughout. It's a solid collection of songs, not sure all of them work for me though. Don't get me wrong, Marty has a wonderful and beautiful voice but the same rhythm and style of singing is exactly the same through at least 5 different songs. The songs are heroic and sad but I've heard better country outlaw albums and songs. I respect the vibe of the album but definitely not perfect. Best Song: Big Iron, They're Hanging Me Tonight, El Paso

Shouldn’t like it as much as I do

I don’t like country music, but this one took me by surprised, good story telling

Super cheesy. Gorgeous recordings. What a voice. This is one of those, "yeah, but it just makes me smile" albums.

It's a certified cowboy bean eating banger.

I liked a few songs individually, but listening to the entire album in one go is a bit much. A lot of the songs sound the same with different words.

Elvis style voice with Johnny Cash style lyrics, this went hard. I recently got back to playing Fallout 3 and these tracks were grade A wasteland music (3.5/5)

Ensformigt

Its the year of yeehaw so this hit well

I feel like every song on this album would kill at a campfire.

As soon as I listened the kind of music in this album, I was like "Oh, let's see which is the song I know from a movie or whatever". That moment never came.

El Paso is a good track

Good stuff.

classic cowboy tunes

Cowboy cuddles be still my heart. This hits that sweet spot nostalgia of a 50s version of Western that existed in the American imagination. Confection.

It occurred to me while I was listening to this that this type of music goes against my normal preferences by virtue of being singing-heavy and music-light. However, I love this type of thing. I could listen to this all day. I'm not sure I'll keep this album on my phone since there are other albums from this era that I like more, but this was a very strong 4. 4.5 if I could.

Surprisingly great for its age. Marty Robbins is an unbelievable vocalist and the guitar shows flourish from track to track. The album as a whole suffers from the necessary simplicity of song structure and theme from the time, yet it is still clear to see why this record would be considered a classic.

Great album and fantastic voice. I already know about Big Iron (such a favorite) but also found Saddle Tramp (so good) and El Paso. Will definitely be listening to this again.

This album is like those Men’s Adventure magazines (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men%27s_adventure), but with someone singing you the stupid cliched stories with generic Western music playing in the background instead of you reading them. Despite that, sometimes the dumbest things in the world can catch lightning in a bottle. This album should have been one of a million other bits of late 50’s early 60’s pop culture detritus that was forgotten almost as soon as it got home from the record store. But something about this album really works. Maybe the generic Western music is played perfectly, maybe it’s the singing. Who knows. Life is funny sometimes cowboy. 🤠

too young to sing songs about being a lone wolf and getting hanged in the old west just old enough to sing along to this slapping shit.

Dit is echt, vanaf nummer 1, het meest country album ooit. En dan bedoel ik niet dat het over trucks, whisky en honkeytonks gaat. Dit is een western country album, hoe fijn is dat? Maar het is niet pure country? 160 acres klinkt juist heel zomers, bijna als een soort eiland lied? De nummers zijn allemaal echt super sfeervol en Marty is ontzettend duidelijk in waar de nummers over gaan. Het is echt stokoud, en ik zal dit waarschijnlijk nooit meer luisteren, maar mocht je ooit zin hebben in een soort Country/Western audioboek dan is dit album eigenlijk best wel een aanrader. FAVO: Big Iron, They're hanging me tonight

Back in the day Cowboy!

Favourite tracks: big iron; hanging me tonight; cool water; el paso; a hundred and sixty acres; running gun

Gunfighter Ballads And Trail Songs is twee as all hell, it's alright at times and forgettable at others, and the most interesting songs sound like inferior versions of stuff that Gene Pitney did a few years later that I far prefer. Give it a 2.

This is fine, gets up to good in places but feels like that it's mostly on the list because it's really old. He's got a nice voice, there's the occasional good lyric, but it's so simple in terms of structure (both storytelling and musically) that it's hard to give it any more than a 2/5.

Robbins is one of the most interesting figures in music I’ve ever read about. Mostly a country & western musician (as on this album), he helped develop the outlaw country sub-genre, forayed into blues, pop, and folk, had a small film career (mostly playing himself and/or a singer), and then even had a career as a NASCAR driver. And he was apparently a decent racer, with a handful of top-10 finishes. I know songs like “El Paso” and particularly “Big Iron” have become meme songs, but it does take a catchy tune to get to meme status. And “Big Iron” is definitely that. You can definitely see the origins of outlaw country on this album, not necessarily in the pacing or style of instrumentation, but definitely in the lyrics.

Lovely Melodies and singing

Quite a good listen and wasn't expecting it to be. Only rating it a 3 because it's just not my type of music...

I dunno I feel like this is really good for this era and this style. I’m going 3.6.

Lieder aus einer anderen Zeit.

loved the cowboy vibe, actually really enjoyed all the way through

Dats my shit

Excellent songs. Not quite my speed but lots of fun.

Hilariously weird and wonderful

Great voice, but "Big Iron" was the only interesting song; the rest are a bit too simple.

Honestly, I almost want to give this a 5, just because it is so fun to listen to and has such classic songs. However, I can't quite feel it deserves that, for me, due to it being more a "flash in the pan." However, it is a fun listen and something I could see myself putting on around the family when making dinner or cleaning up.

The story telling and setting on this album is really good. His voice and instrumentation make me really happy throughout the album. I really really enjoyed it. Some of these tracks are some of my favorites I have listened to so far in rating these albums. Very solid album! Favorite songs : big iron, they're hanging me tonight, the masters call, El Paso, saddle tramp.

Fun album. Not an everyday listen but makes you feel like a cowboy

well it's 1959 country. We are past that and it's for the best. 1 stars

About as big of a surprise as I’ve had on the list yet. From the album artwork to every song, 5 stars and completely up my alley. Ennio Morricone for romantics.

Marty Robbins recorded popular country music over a thirty year year career. He recorded albums in a variety of styles - Elvis' odd, movie soundtrack section of his catalog may have been inspired by Robbins' eclectic mix. In the late 50's, Robbins recorded a few albums of "cowboy myth" country. Gunfighter Ballads is one of those albums. This is simple, cowboy country - voices and guitars - and Robbins is at least partially responsible for popularizing this part of country music.

Old and timely

I've heard countless covers of El Paso by the Grateful Dead. Always loved it in their live show, and come to find they really didn't stray far from the source material. Had this on in the background for the most part. While it isn't exactly what I go in for, I really did enjoy this detour into country western territory. For what it is, this was very enjoyable. His voice is great and storytelling was very solid. High 3 for me.

Lol, I actually know the song Big Iron. Bad ass old western sounding song. The rest of the album is a rootin tootin country old western vibe as well. Not a tough listen but felt very repetitive. 3 stars for me

Sure. Definitely feels like a 50's album. As I was finishing I was like "I have totally heard El Paso somewhere". It turns out I heard it about 20 minutes earlier. Idk there's nothing really wrong with this to make it less than a 3, but I can't really warrant giving it a 2.

Yeehaw! What a way to start a morning that was so peaceful. This was surprisingly close to a 4.

Some pretty run of the mill country music to me. Infinitely better than todays country but still not 100% my jam. My ears did perk up at El Paso as I know that as a Grateful Dead song. Weird that the "full length" version is like 20 seconds longer but whatever pop off Marty.

I do not like the genre, so I had low hopes for this album. I recognised the first song from Fallout, but other than that slight joy from recognition, I was right in having low hopes. I think people who like country music will probably enjoy it. It sounds like country music, but that's not for me.

Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawn.

This album can be enjoyed as if you were reading a book. The lyrics are very detailed and each song tells a different story. Very interesting and entertaining

I love the feel of this album, real rancher/outlaw country songs. My only complaint is that a lot of the songs and even lyrics start to feel repetitive by the end of the album. Very similar cadence with very similar themes. But still excellent overall. Top tracks: Big Iron, Cool Water, El Paso

Albums before the mid-60s tended not to capture the concept of what really makes a great album. This is a collection of good songs - but when listened to in one sitting, the style isn't quite good enough to boost it to 4 stars or higher. It's at the upper end of 3 stars. It's performed well, with a very strong vocal and simplistic backing arrangement. Big Iron, El Paso, They're Hanging Me Tonight, and Billy The Kid are highlights that could really shine as concept album material if placed in the right order. The chords definitely lack inspiration, being primarily the 3 blues chords plus the occasional minor 6 for moodier pieces. The instrumental backing the vocals also really doesn't add much to the table, being mostly bass, acoustic guitar, and light drums, all of which could be further forward in the mix and played with more energy. Overall, good music, but not pioneering - which isn't a bad thing, but I feel it doesn't fully belong in this list. 3/5

I didn’t mind this and would probably give it a 2.5 if I could. All the songs sound similar, only a few stood out to me.

This is okay but I have heard many other versions of these songs that I prefer over the ones performed by Marty Robbins here. But as a collection of ballads and trail songs it's not bad, just kind of mid and melodically monotonous.

Growing up, we spent a ton of time at my grandparents’ house. I don’t really remember much music around their house (which is ironic since my dad was a musician). Still, I watched a lot of old westerns with my grandfather and he read a bunch of old Louis L’Amour books. This album reminds me of him. He died when I was still a teenager, but I loved him about as much as I have ever loved anyone. It’s really special to see that there are things 35 years later that can bring me back to that appreciation.

Fun little album with some memorable songs, although I still prefer Cash's version of "Big Iron"

The album title gives you a pretty clear picture of what you’re in for. I like it. It was delightfully old-timey even in its time and still delights. 3.0

He's got such a great voice. The ballad format gets a little tiresome after a while, but these are great. "El Paso" is too perfect. This takes me back. 4.2

I've loved this album for a while, partially thanks to Fallout NV. I don't know why it surprised me to see it on this list, but I was glad to get it and have a reason to listen to it again. Robbins has a beautiful voice, the lyrics and the storytelling are strong throughout the whole record, and the mixing is so clean for its year without sounding glossy or fussy. As a fellow reviewer said: "YE-(and I cannot stress this enough)-HAW" Highlights: Big Iron, A Hundred and Sixty Acres, Cool Water, The Master's Call, El Paso, The Little Green Valley, Saddle Tramp

I honestly didn't think I'd like this. But I honestly really did. On paper, nothing about this should have been my jam but Marty's delivery is so good, and the musicianship behind him is top notch, and the engineering is great for the time, and the stories were a mix of hopeful and hilarious and heartfelt and heartbreaking. For some reason, it worked.

I thoroughly enjoyed that. I am certainly no authority and this is wildly speculative but this could be the best country album of its era. The best I’ve heard anyway….but I haven’t heard that many.

This album cemented my belief that country isn’t bad, only modern country is.

Fun Cowboy ballads. Smooth crooning voice like Roy Orbison or Elvis Presley. The Strawberry Roan (horse song, but sounds like swearing each time he sings "buck") El Paso

Good to have in the background

My sibling has always said this album reminded them of my late grandfather, and while I don't totally see it, I do get the vibe that those who would've heard this album when it released would've been the coolest of cool, a total cowboy in the truest of (fictional) forms. The guitar playing is great, the singing is great, and its all got this mix of coziness and great storytelling, like watching one of those Western TV shows. Its repetitive, I'd even say some songs sound the exact same save for a chord here or there, but I still enjoyed myself enough. Perhaps cut out some of the fluff and this would be like an exciting addition to a story you were already in the middle of, but instead it has too much filler. Someone should make a list of all the episodes (songs) I have to watch (listen to) so I can skip the fluff, eh?

Good album, very cohesive for its time, but only a couple of songs clicked with me.

If you want a cowboy to sing stories to you, it's hard to do better than Marty Robbins. If you want anything else that isn't that, you're out of luck.

This rules.

First of all, single greatest album cover in the history of music. Second, the influence a record like this had on country nusic and especially someone like Johnny Cash is obvious. Though novelty or sounding like a movie soundtrack today, they songs themselves are catchy and arrangements are a fun example of a bygone style.

This is awesome. I recognize there are no foul words on this album, but literally every song is about murdering and killing. I guess it's not as violent if you don't curse. I knew El Paso and somehow each song on here is catchy and tells a very interesting story. This is the kind of country music that I can get behind. "They're Hanging Me Tonight" is about a guy whose girl gets with another man and the narrator goes in and just kills them both. Did not see that one coming. Marty Robbins has a really good voice and this is really a pretty irresistible album. I'm not even sure this is country music but is more just western music.

Not my thing but if you like old country music this is the thing for you.

Great classic, western music that doesn’t get old no matter how “old” it gets. Listen again: yes Purchase for my collection: yes Favourite Song: Big Iron

Fun (and and also some downright depressing) country-western ballads. Such is the life of a gunslinger in the Old West! The storytelling in "Big Iron" and "El Paso" will have you coming back to this album.

An album full of story-songs? Fuck yeah! A couple of all-time classics (El Paso, Big Iron). More than a few hokey songs, but it's from 1959. Overall, liked this a lot.

Nice 3/5

Fucking everybody in these stories is armed to the teeth. They love their hip iron. Musically, pretty boring, but nice enough. The stories are okay haha

Ég hélt ég fílaði ekki kántrí en vona kántrí er nú bara nokkuð gott. Ætli það sé ekki gamaldagskántrí sem ég fíla frekar en þetta nýmóðins söngl. Þessi plata er alveg líklegt til að vera spiluð aftur ef ég man þá eftir henni. Fínasta stöff alveg hreint.

A great album , not amazing

Reminds me of driving up the mountain to Estes Park. Favorite track: Cool Water

Thoughts before listening: Early country music with some songs that have become staples over the years like "El Paso". Should be an interesting listen full of story songs with an antiquated sounding musical style. Review: Yeah, this is fun. Marty Robbins has a great, soothing voice and these songs are like little western movies with the stories they are telling. The music is pretty typical for the 1950s era of country music, and there are some interesting little guitar licks happening low in the mix. Not something that I would typically come back to very often, but I'm glad to have heard this today. 3-stars

A classic of the genre. I've never been a c&w fan but I do like these murder ballad. I can't tell how many times I've heard the Grateful Dead play El Paso.

This was a great album. Great music to accompany Red Dead.

Sam always listens to songs on this album <3

This album has it all... Country AND Western!

Ik heb nog nooit van Marty Robbins gehoord, maar ik ben meteen enthousiast na het eerste nummer Big Iron. Zijn boterzachte stem, de achtergrondvocalen, de vertellende wijze van zingen… een recept voor feel good country muziek. Ja, een lekkere inkomer zeg. Je waant je in het Wilde Westen. Best wat nummers gaan zo’n 65 jaar na dato nog makkelijk mee. Maar helaas (maar verwacht natuurlijk) gaat echt niet alles zo goed mee, er zit ook wat oubollige muziek tussen. Conclusie: Marty Robbins was een uitstekende zanger, storyteller en heeft een paar nummers gemaakt die nogsteeds lekker meegaan. Voor een album dat zo lang geleden uitgebracht is, vind ik dat uniek, en meer enjoyable dan een Fats Domino of Little Richards uit ongeveer deze tijd. Rating: 7,5/10 Highlights: Big Iron, The Master’s Call, El Paso,

De tijdmachine heeft ons deze week afgezet in 50s 'Murica, en ging daarna kapot. Maar dit is - in tegenstelling tot Fats en Ray Charles - een plaat die vooral leeft in een nog verder verleden, en een specifieke subcultuur aangaat. Het is cliché om te zeggen dat die Wild Western cultuur uit de 19e eeuw, ver verwijderd van het hedendaagse Nederland, bij mij weinig emotionele aantrekkingskracht oproept. Maar dat doet deze plaat al niet echt bij een New Yorker rond die tijd, lijkt me. Toch, ondanks dat het geen match made in heaven is, weet Marty wel aardig een beeld te schetsen die past bij oude Westerns, die ook de gemiddelde Hollander wel bekend zijn. De ambiance is die van een oude saloon, en van de Lone Ranger en zijn harde bestaan op de prairies en in de woestijnen van de US. Die sfeer beviel wel, ondanks dat sommige nummers echt tenenkrommend stereotype cowboy zijn. Sterke momenten zijn de nummers die niet alleen klinken maar ook lezen als een oude Western movie. 'Big Iron' opent het bal, en etaleert direct dat Marty Robbins een behoorlijk fantasierijke pen game heeft. Je kan niet anders dan het verhaaltje volgen. De donkere ondertonen waren al merkbaar, maar de 'southern goth' komt nog duidelijker naar voren in 'The Master's Call', wat m'n favo van het album is. Die spookachtige achtergrondzang en grimmige topics laten een indruk achter zoals geen ander nummer op het album. Ik kan me voorstellen dat andere sleutelfiguren, die later de 'Southern Gothic' beweging zouden vormgeven, dit nummer wel hebben gehoord. Neem een Townes Van Zandt, een Johnny Cash, of The Handsome Family. Het wat lichtvoetigere 'Running Gun' sluit goed aan. Maar toch heeft het album te weinig van deze momenten, waarin hij de clichématige cowboyhoed en poncho even van zich afgooit, om mij helemaal voor zich te winnen. Maar het viel me ontzettend mee, en de verhaaltjes waren vermakelijk. Absoluut de beste van de drie oldies deze week. 7/10 Highlights: Big Iron The Master's Call

Nog nooit van deze Marty gehoord maar positief verrast door dit album. Overduidelijk een voorloper van de country-folk waar Cash en Townes zoveel furore mee hebben gemaakt. Moet bij veel nummers aan Johnny Cash denken, zeker bij de intro van the Hanging Tree De plaat wordt op een gegeven wel wat smartlapperig. Zoals in the Little Green Valley. Dat zie ik zo een gepensioneerde mannenkoor zingen op net niet goed bezochte kerstmarkt. 6,5/10 Highlights The Strawberry Roan The Masters Call

I love Marty Robbins' voice. His story telling is very fun and he has some true classics on this record. It's country that just feels truly western.

Such a freakin cool record. This is an overlooked time stamp in American and Country music. I love how every song is just a story. Its like listening to an audiobook or watching a movie. The music flows and bounces. Its engaging, but simple. The spanish guitar licks in the background keep it from sounding mundane. And then Marty's voice is just so unique. Who else sounds like this?? I love this record. This is one that was always playing in my Dad's truck when I was a kid.

Too old-fashion for me

5 stars for 'Big Iron' alone. This is a classic for a reason.

Marty Robbins possesses one of the most iconic country vocals there is. I could listen to him tell me tales of the open prairie and its many outlaws day in and day out.