Reviews (page 12 of 14)
No. This was mostly the no album. A couple of good songs, good musicianship, but just not my thing.
No (Lol, how original is that? I bet NO ONE else ever makes that joke!)
Bass
eh
Enjoyed this one, nothing too crazy but an easy listen 8/10
Yes!
I liked some bits but they’re all over the place. Rock? Funk? Blues? Folk? Last song was too much, and the random organ solos interrupted songs I otherwise thought were okay.
This album was mostly unfamiliar to me. The only song I recognized was "I see All Good People". The sound reminds me of Rush, and in some places of Phish. I listened to the album through twice. The sounds is OK, but I didn't find myself getting particularly hooked.
At least it wasn't Rush. I'll stand by that part of my review.
You know that scene in Beetlejuice, where they're in the waiting room for hell? This is the music playing there.
Add one star to the organ bit
Damn soulful, a really great album. Standouts are 'Cry Baby' and 'Mercedes Benz' (Women do be feelin' tho.)
Reminds me of Stix grand illusion. Don't like it as much tho.
my favourite part was the instrumental at the end of starship trooper. otherwise i don't have any strong feelings about this album. it kinda just comes and goes
Great album!! Reminds me of a mix between Zeppelin and Boston Exactly what an early 70s rock album should be 5/5
A while ago I got to rate their next record Fragile. I gave it 3 stars. This record sounds more natural than Fragile. I like it better. I still don't like the singer's voice very much. Favorite song: Yours is no disgrace.
Now I am a yes fan. The album is great and it is not the best one that they have. Also - epic bass player!
Actually really liked it
Yes!
Yes are undeniably talented artists with a cool sound, but this album was a little more rambling and unfocused than I really enjoy.
I really like Yes' sound. This album isn't as engaging for me as Fragile but it's still good.
I have no strong feelings one way or the other. I’ve listened to the album all the way through twice now, and no parts have stuck out to me at all. This music just does not move me. It’s marginally better than listening to nothing at all. It’s background music. If you get something from this then more power to you. But I really cannot different any separate bits of the album, because it all sounds the same to me. And all the positive reviews seem to say the same. ‘No thoughts, head empty, just vibes’ is a direct quote from a review I just read. That isn’t what I want from my music, I don’t want the audio equivalent of a Fast and Furious film. I want something that engages me. I want more than just, oh this sounds pleasant. The best song on the album is an instrumental Portuguese folk guitar show piece. And it’s the best song because it actually sounds passionate, it feels like there was an actual idea that the writer wanted to explore. The idea may just have been, ‘I’ve just bought a Portuguese guitar, let’s write a Portuguese folk song’ but at least it’s an idea. God I hate Prog Rock
Yes
Better than pink Floyd
there is a lot to think about on this record. It's rockin' but it's very cerebral. Sounds a bit like Rush and Pink Floyd and the Grateful Dead, vocals can sometimes get CSN-ish,... Overall pretty enjoyable. Doesn't /quite/ make it over the hump to a 4 for me, though it's close
Leuk album, was niet zo bekend met Yes behalve de hitjes. Volgens mij ook het eerste prog album in de lijst na 240 albums. Ga zeker meer Yes checken!
Who would’ve thought the clap could be so enjoyable. Album is a banger!
Love this. Favorite: Starship Trooper.
It’s okay, kinda sounds like the Beatles but a lot worse
A coming of age album for a 70's rock icon
Prog spaceship
3/5
As much as I love prog music Yes is has always been a band I could just never fully get into. I enjoy listening to their music and exploring the many avenues their songs go down but I can never prioritize them over other bands of the same style I enjoy more. Every song on The Yes Album is pretty solid though featuring many pretty cool moments. Starship Troopers is always worth the time whenever I do get around to listening to it which if I'm being honest. Isn't very often.
Of the many repeat artists on this list, I have to say that Yes may be be the most frustrating of all. I don’t enjoy listening to them, and find their music immeasurably dull. Knowing as I do that I still have at least one more Yes album to go before I may be free of them forever, I dread the inevitable day that I have to subject my ear drums to this kind of brain-smoothing music again.
pretty good psych
Very likable and progressive, but I'm not sure if I'd listen to this again.
Oh I absolutely love this! Such tight vocal harmonies and meandering but still interesting jams. I was immediately reminded of CSNY but like a funkier, rockier version. Love getting a full rock opera with Starship Trooper. It's so cinematic and full of intrigue, I'm a very big fan.
Banger. Classic Yes. IMO not as majestic as Close to the Edge or Fragile but this is definitely up there in the Yes tier list.
Great album
Gave this several listens before settling on a conflicted 3. Enjoyed my time in Yes Land more than I usually do. To me they too often have a frenetic, ADHD-afflicted, too-smart-to-care sense about them, where every idea is boring and is discarded for the next new thing. The other records we've had by them certainly suffer from this. This is less bad, in that regard! There are really good moments, and some glimpses of good songs here! And it's a little less self-serious and kind of whimsical and silly. Still, I struggle to remember more than a couple of passing melodies here. My time in Yes Land has been more enjoyable and somewhat charming than other outings, but the idea of putting on yet another record of there's makes me feel somewhat queasy. 3/5
This is friggin awesome gamers! 😎😎
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Enough Yes albums!
Honestly The Yes Album is pretty interesting, particularly because it reminded me of Animals by Pink Floyd (In song structure mostly) but the songs here just aren't nearly as long. I thought this album was fairly okay, My biggest issue with it is some of the songs felt directionless but other than that simple gripe, the album was fairly okay and didn't have any bad songs on it. Best Song: Perpetual Change Worst Song: I've Seen All Good People: a. Your Move, b. All Good People
No idea how I got it in my head that I don’t like Yes but I enjoyed nearly every minute of this
The bass player rules. There are plenty of great riffs and musical ideas here, but for me, prog rock always shoots itself in the foot by shifting too quickly from one thing to another. Idk, very forward thinking especially for 1971, but you can also tell how rooted it is in the 60s rock scene. With all the clean guitar and organ lines, I keep thinking that this is what Grateful Dead wishes they sounded like.
I actually quite like Yes’ take on Prog-Rock, but this one is relatively inconsistent for me. We still have some great tracks in the opening Yours Is No Disgrace and the well-known All Good People, and although I feel it is a bit overrated in their catalogue Starship Troopers is still a great performance. Unfortunately for me, including a live guitar solo as track 2 (great work by Steve Howe but still a baffling choice) and closing with 2 mediocre tracks back-to-back spoil the fun. Still a wonderful example of creative musicianship, but I feel the next couple records in their discography really highlight the shortcomings of this one.
Good people 👍 live songs not as bonus tracks 👎
Prog rock at its proggy rocky synsthesiser best I suppose! If you dig it, you’ll dig it. If you don’t, you won’t. Can’t make it any more simple than that I suppose!
Lenge siden eg har hørt da. Da e et stykke fra Fragile, men litt Yes slår sjelden feil
Obligatory 5, Yes is one of my favorite bands and I was probably listening to them nearly every day during my senior year of highschool. This was first album Yes would release in a string of album releases that are all arguably 5/5's. The elements for Yes came together with this album. Steve Howe was brought on for guitar and was able to write some of the most interesting guitar riffs and chords. Chris Squire with the fat bass tone, Jon Anderson with his elf like vocals and lyrics. The percussion and organ from Bill Bruford and Tony Kaye. All of it created a unique and original sound in an era where the popular bands were just doing blues and turning up the distortion and screaming into the mic
So good
A good prog rock album.
This is phenomenal. So much good on such a small album.
Classic. Love every minute of it.
The good parts are really good. But the weird country influence is jarring and really distracts from the rest.
nice
I quite liked this. It gives the feel of music being made in a room filled with people making weed
"How about no?" - Dr. Evil Little Britain CSNY. Psychedelic folk prog with lots of ideas - few of them good.The bass sounds like farts, pretty cool! Nice acoustic instrumental on The Clap in a virtuoso folk style. The guitar and bass interplay on Starship Troopers is great throughout, especially the spacey ending. But the vocals are irritating, flutes have no place in rock music, and there're too many parts all jammed together into each song, you're just getting into a groove then here comes a tempo/key/instrumental change. Very taxing to listen to and the whole thing reeks of cider. Oh, 'All Good People' is by Yes? Hadn't realized. I hate that song. I gather this was a very influential album, unfortunate.
New to me but I enjoyed this one
Good prog. Love Seen All Good People.
Yes, I liked it prog rock pioneers.
Not bad, but I couldn’t wait for it to be over
Another Yes album. Another 8-minute jam. It’s not bad but I just don’t see the significance.
ok
There's a reason they're called Yes - because YES I love this band. They do prog like no one else really does it. Super unique with more classic rock influence. The harmonies are amazing as well.
An incredible progressive rock album that never gets dull for me.
I got tired of this album very quickly. Instead of feeling timeless, like much of the music from their era, it felt dated and repetitive. All the Lonely People will always resonate, but I don't think I need to listen to the rest of it again.
Har aldrig riktigt lyssnat på Yes tidigare men blev lyckligt överraskad! Bra igenom hela albumet. Inte en enda skip! Bästa låt: Starship Trooper
Bästa låt:Starship trooper
Fett roligt rock album. Tyckte att det var en mycket trevlig lysning även om det inte riktigt är min genre Favorit låtar: Perpetual Change, Yours is no Disgrace, Starship trooper
Didn't really dig it, but I could see that it could grow on me. Should listen to some Rick Wakeman too.
Pretentious wankery.
When this album popped up for me on my tracker for the 1001 albums, I audibly said "Yes!" aloud. I love Yes. I have loved Yes for a long time, and had a big prog rock phase a while back. The Yes Album is an interesting one for me, because I always knew of its existence, but I wasn't sure when I would go back to give it a listen. I'm glad I was given the excuse to check it out, given my love for Fragile and Close to the Edge. I see this as the Meddle of Yes' discography. It acts as the point where you can see when they find their footing. Steve Howe had made his way into the band, which is easily one of the best things they could have done for themselves. And the energy that would carry them forward into having one of the strongest runs of albums in the 70's shows up here. John's voice is as beautiful as ever, Chris Squire's signature bass sound is delightfully sharp, Steve's guitar work is amazing, and Bill's drum sound is so bright and snappy, which fits his style of play perfectly. I see this album as their Meddle, and I see Starship Troopers as their Echoes. It may not be as ambitious, but it shows them experimenting with their longer, multi-phased song structures they would become known for. Specifically the section titled "Würm". This part is so heavy and psychedelic, and has one of the best jams Yes has ever done period. Easily the most striking moment on the whole album. I have to speak on one gripe I have with this album though. I think Tony Kaye does a fantastic job as the keyboardist up until this point. But just like how Steve Howe was an addition the band needed to succeed, Rick Wakeman is in the same boat. Although technically not with Yes until after this album was released, I can feel the gap left when he is not the one behind the keyboard. He is probably the single greatest prog keyboardist of all time, and maybe just in general across all rock music, and that golden age lineup of Anderson, Squire, Howe, Wakeman and Bruford is absolutely unbeatable. I think for the first album from Yes that can truly be considered a substantial piece of work, that set them on the map and would help them become one of the leading bands in the progressive rock movement of the 70's alongside other giants like King Crimson, Rush and Pink Floyd, they did a stellar job.
Proggy
solid
The prog champ of our generation? Not according to Nolan (Rush)
You know what I say to this album? YES! I liked this album. My main complaint was I wish it was longer
Kinda sad this isn't the album with Roundabout, but I'll take it I guess. This band suffers from all the tropes of being a '70s band in a bad way, unfortunately. Their songs are good but could either be split into more or just have their runtime cut down by a minute or 2 at least. I actually like this album quite a bit, but because of the '70s band tropes, they fall into it kills it for me. This would be a 4, but imma have to downgrade it This is a strong 3/5
Need to give this another listen. I was doin something else while listening and I honestly didn’t absorb much
I wanna be yespilled so bad but unfortunately I am nopilled. Also was it just me or was the back half of this album much better than the front?
Every once in a while you should open your mind and ears, and listen to some prog-rock. This album is among the best the genre has to offer.
Reminds me of the music my dad would listen to
Bra men ikke helt der Ass 3.7
Prog rock with experimental excursions towards jazzy and Caribbean sounds, which is overall lightfooted and positive.
Highlight - Ive seen all good people. Great band, not necessarily a go-to genre for me.
Just not feeling it.
Yes! It sounds so good! Maybe the greatest bass tone of all time. RIP Chris. Vocals are very classic on this album, especially on Good People. A really good mix of poppy and progressive. Very accessible but technical. The Clap is kind of out of nowhere but sort of love it for that... I guess it's to introduce Steve Howe. It's up there for favorite Yes albums... might be my favorite because I'm kind of a pleb, though I'm sure some others come up so I can give them a more critical listen. It's not Close to the Edge, it doesn't have Roundabout on it, but it's really good!
Enjoying these Yes albums more than I'd expect
Sounds like prog rock!
70s prog rock that’s surprisingly poppy.
I've reached Yes overload with this list of albums. Yes this is a decent album, yes this is a good band, no I don't need to hear anymore Yes.
Meh.
Thoroughly enjoyed this. Loved the sound.
Experimental, immaculate shredding. Amazing drummer and guitarist.
Pfff
Oh god, these nerds again but now with extra nerd flavour! It's still gunna be a no for me, dawg.
Not their best album but this does introduce their progressive rock style that eventually birthed Fragile.
the band named yes say yes to 10 min songs
This kind of symphonic/progressive rock never captured me, and still doesn´t
I liked the guitar but this music is not really my style but I liked the first song
I did not finish it 😔 but the first like 2/3 are very good and I will finish it but busy day with work and pole vault. I do love some anti war propaganda music though. Yes is fantastic
yeah no
Alright pop prog
Wakeman-less, but still slaps. The first of their classic trilogy, but not without its tripey moments (why is the second track a live instrumental?)
This was perfectly fine I would say and elements of it I enjoyed but I wasn't blown away or remember loads about it even a day later
Was fine, but that's it, sounded exactly like I thought it would. Not bad but not great.
The Yes Album is anchored around four long-form songs with two shorter tunes sandwiched within. It's an inconsistent record, but there are good moments to be found. 'Yours is No Disgrace' might be the best of the bunch; nevertheless, the intentionally out-of-time organ grinds my ears in the intro. I think a band like Gentle Giant could pull off such polyrhythm in a much prettier way. Nevertheless, kick-ass guitar solos, and several nice dynamic variations on the chorus make for a magical track. Following this epic intro, we hear the live solo recording 'The Clap' which must have been included to showcase new guitarist Steve Howe—while it's nice enough, it's awfully out-of-place! 'Starship Trooper' rocks really hard, and somehow features a bluegrassy break in the middle of an otherwise epic prog-song. My only complaint lies with the four-minute outro. Following its faux folksy intro, 'I've Seen All Good People' goes on way too long with the same rollicking refrain. 'A Venture' is moody and punctured with punchy rhythms. It's short and fails to offend. And while I quite like the catchy choruses and Steve Howe's versatile guitar work on 'Perpetual Change', I think the song is ultimately ruined by the weird two-band stereo experiment in time signatures that only kind-of align. Again, Gentle Giant would come up with much more compelling (and gelling) types of polyrhythm! There's a lot to be bothered by: Jon Anderson's lyrics are weird and wacky—Bill Bruford likes to hit strange syncopated snare beats that don't really fit the rhythm—Chris Squire treats his bass like a melodic instrument on top of everything else already going on—Tony Kaye evidently didn't like synthesizers, but the whole band urged the use of a few which explains the random appearance of a few really loud synth bits here-n-there. Ultimately, I have no problem with Steve Howe's ever-tasteful guitar; still, 'The Clap' really didn't need to be here! Yet, here's five guys putting together songs that sound like nothing else. The songs operate on an ambitious scale, and they are all packed with catchy, memorable little licks and melodies. There are rewards to be had within the record for those willing to patiently wait to hear them.
Genres: Progressive rock[ Formed: London, England in 1968 Run time: 9 songs, 51 min, 53 sec This is the third studio album by the group. Spotify: Least popular song: 572k plays Most popular song: 26.5M plays Track 3, "Starship Trooper" has 10M plays. It contains a lot of words, but manages to say nothing of any significance. The words make sense, the sentences are complete, but they appear to have been generated at random. In contrast, other tracks on the album have meaning and convey a message. Musically, the album is very good. Yes have produced some good songs, but not on this album. Listen Again?: No My Rating: **
I know half the songs on this album, I'm delighted to learn the rest! The Kings of prog rock!
Induced a flash back
Disco maravilloso.
still not quite my cup of tea but I enjoyed it more than most Yes I'd already heard. some really cool passages but doesn't do heaps for me overall
очень вкусно и разнообразно алкоальбом: текила санрайз
легко вкусно, думал между 3 и 4, но это как будто не альбом просто альбом, а чет интересное, поэтому 4-
Неплохо
Ahhh let the prog become you. The Yes Album is a masterpiece from one of the best prog bands to ever do it. Yours Is No Disgrace opens the album with a very characteristic Yes sounds. Some aggressive bass stabs that give way to some glittery instrumentals and eventually break way for Anderson to douse us in his falsetto. Everything with Yes feels so well-calculated. As with most Yes songs, this one just rides the bassline all the way through. The Clap picks up on a completely different tone with an acoustic guitar instrumental that evokes almost Spanish, folky vibes. Forgot about this one, not to say it isn't a good-un. Starship Trooper goes right back to the heart of Yes; a multi-part prog saga. Tis a jam. I've Seen All Good People is a great one. Who doesn't love a song about chess. The harmonizing on A Venture is wonderful. Love the staccato work of the drum with the guitar weaving in and out of focus. Kind of tuned out for the last track focusing on work, but I was bobbing along... 4 / 5
Fantastic album
really good album, including Starship Trooper, first with Steve Howe
It was okay. I think I heard it before. Can't exactly say which songs I liked best (I forgot), but it's groovy.
Boring pretentious and no rick wakeman. No thanks.
Really rather good
Awesome album.
meh
Yes are a bit too proggy for me, and with the psychedelia that most people wisely left in the 60s there's not a lot here to like. Not sure we get to a 2 here.
I like this, unsurprisingly, but not loads. It feels like it's almost really good, but doesn't quite hit the heights of what their contemporaries were doing - then I check my dates and realise that Pink Floyd at this point haven't come out of their proper psychedelic period, and Genesis hadn't really got going either. So this is actually ahead of a pretty forward looking bunch (in the early seventies, anyway). Doesn't feel disjointed at all, but also doesn't quite get me going in the way that the later work from Genesis/Pink Floyd did - hope we get some later Yes albums. Just about squeaks a 4.
I’ve been really impressed with each Yes album I’ve heard (I think this is the third on this list?). Either way, each record is like a compilation of dozens of class riffs and melodies somehow woven together into songs that work. I imagine most artists would kill for just 10% of the ideas and creativity Yes show. Strangely for me though, despite really enjoying them I never seem to go and listen to them outside of this list.
Hugely talented band with loads of music ideas that separate them from their prog rock peers. Doesn't quite reach the heights of Fragile but still thought it was great.
I preferred Fragile. This album is more meandering and a bit less interesting. And I was a bit confused at times too, the Deluxe version having single versions of a few of the tracks. Pretty crazy how different this album is to Fragile, maybe the influence of Rick Wakeman. I was going to give it three stars, but I've gone back and listened to the single versions of Your Move, Starship Trooper, and The Clap, so pushed me over to 4, but only just. Would still listen to Roundabout over anything on this album though.
I didn't enjoy this as much as Fragile but it's still a good album. The songs go on a bit too long sometimes but its nice to get lost in the music. Highlights Starship Trooper I've Seen All Good People
Probably enjoyed this less than the last yes album we had but still enjoyed this. Long meandering guitars. I do like the sound, but I find myself wanting the long songs to really go somewhere and end up with something more and they don't really tend to. 3.5
No
Þetta er fínt, get alveg hlustað aftur. Þarf ég þess? Nei, get ekki sagt það.
Suckah for Yes
The last Yes album I had climbed from a 2 to a 4 over a weekend of listening. I probably really like this one too, if I had the time to put the effort in - jazzy, funky, folky - but should you have to “put the effort in”?
A superb album, only bettered by Close to the Edge. This is prog at its peak, with a clutch of classic tracks including Yours is no disgrace, Starship trooper and I've seen all good people. A Venture and the Clap are less essential listening, even if the latter is a perennial favourite. Overall a really great listen
I remember studying Yes album art at the tender age of 4 of 5. I grew up hearing this album, as well as my dad telling me that the later albums were too "popular" (I really like their later work, but I like a lot of popular music!). This album is more experimental but still has a lot of catchy grooves. I enjoyed hearing it again. 4/5
-okay these songs are SO long -very cool sound -album cover is SO moody in SUCH a cool way -okay that little live bit in the clap is cool as hell -im going to be honest the songs are too long for me -other than that the music itself is good!
Ok
There is such a thing as third times a charm. With The Yes Album, the titular band finally find their groove and step into the nascent program scene with a confidence that would guide them through the next set of pivotal albums such as Fragile and Close to the Edge. Yet The Yes Album is just as much of a beast as those albums, not just because it's the first of them but because of the seemingly urgent vibrancy that occupied the sounds coming out of them that is just persistent from start to finish. A yes to this album? Yes indeed.
Ok
Has the potential to be something, takes you into a sound and then repeatedly meanders off into misdirection and completely irritating nothingness. I found this a very difficult album to listen to, and I guess it's just from an era.
Bit boring for me
Listenable album, nothing stand-out though but I wouldn't switch it off, nor would I probably choose to play it though.
Très emblématique des années 70. J’étais contente de l’écouter, mais je suis restée un peu sur ma faim. Aurait besoin d’une autre écoute
Prog Rock/Pop, der mich nie wirklich berührt. Ist aber ganz sicher nicht schlecht und hat gute Momente. Mit Rush kann ich aber mehr anfangen. Zwischen 3-4.
No.
Judging this album by it's cover I thought it was going to be some gloomy, droning songs; was not looking forward to it. I certainly did not expecting the first song to come out swinging like that. Certified jam right out of the gate. Listen to this one with headphones cause they really like to play with stereo. Some songs on here that I have definitely heard before like "I've Seen All Good People" This album rocked from start to finish. Encapsulates classic rock, but has a unique sound with a variety of instruments and a great voice.
Awesome first song on the album to kick things off. The all good people is an absolute jam which I knew of but didn't know the name and honestly didn't really care for until hearing it on this whole album and now I have relistened to it 3 times. Such a great progressive rock album. I am happy that Yes finally got their breakthrough on this album after the third try of albums
This is some good shit. I can see why Jack Black gave that Yes cd to that kid in School of Rock. Starship Trooper is baller in that its pretty much 3 songs smashed into one and flows so well. Will seek out more Yes.
Nothing super flashy hear! While I didn’t hate it, it wasn’t something I would actively seek to listen to
Fun listen. Influenced a lot of the music I love now. Respect to da OG's.
Pretty solid with good ballads
Nah
Yes's kind of goofy predecessor to their two best albums. Panning in the mix is a little off-putting. Favorite Tracks: Starship Trooper 4-4.5/5
Great prog!
Pretty good
None of the songs really grabbed me, I paused the album halfway through to listen to something else
Me gustó, pero se siente menos. Luego de escuchar Close to The Edge, me quedé con un muy buen concepto de Yes, sin embargo, debo admitir que sí que se siente más flojo que este último. Hay muchas canciones que me parecen algo aburridas y otras que no cumplen muy bien su objetivo al tomar riesgos. Por esto, le pongo 3 al momento de escribir esto, pero estuvo muy cerca de las 4.
4/5, once again surprised by how much fun this was
Great album !
A bit rambly for me.
A lodestone album. I can sing the guitar solos. When I need to indulge, it's this one followed by Fragile.
I’ve loved this album for a 100 years. If someone wants to be introduced to Yes, this is the album I would suggest.
they got a little sauce and pizzazz
I happen to have a vinyl copy of The Yes Album, but I probably haven't listened to it in about twenty years, if I've ever even listened to it in its entirety at all. And that's a shame, because I think that Yes is one of the most underrated bands in prog rock and classic rock as a whole. Granted, I think their music tends to work better as whole albums than as singles, which might make them a little less accessible (oh, and song length too). I this is a really good album, and I was happy to see it on this list since it has my favorite Yes song, "I've Seen All Good People" on it (for the record, I would have preferred to see Fragile on this list, but whatever). This was their first album to feature Steve Howe on guitar, but in my opinion their lineup was at their best with Rick Wakeman on keyboard and synth. Despite not having Wakeman in the lineup, Bill Bruford does a superb job of creating drum fills that blend perfectly with the keyboard-heavy music of this album. Musically, this album ticks all the boxes for me: each member of the band feels like an expert of their instrument, creating a sound that's incredibly unique. The lyrics are definitely kind of 'out there,' but that's on brand for these guys and prog rock in general. Still, "I've Seen All Good People" is incredibly fun to sing along with. Overall, this is a great album, even though it's not Yes's best work in my opinion. Still, anything beats "Owner of a Lonely Heart." Woof.
Pretty close to peak Prog rock. It manages to keep on the right side (barely at times) of lyrics becoming overly narrative to the point all poetic snap is lost, and for complicated art rock it remains accessible and rocks pretty hard.
How many fucking yes albums are in this list. No.
No, not quite
I've always just liked what I've liked without really realising why but I'm learning along this journey. This band sounds like a mix between the Beatles era and heavy rock like guns n roses or Metallica. Never heard yes before but I really liked it.
This is a good album, really enjoyed it
Rocking with some decent riffs, pretty catchy tunes
There were some funky times, there were some rockin' times 3.5/5
For all intents and purposes, “Eurythmics” and “The Eurythmics“ mean the same thing. The same cannot be said for “Clap” and “The Clap”
I think songs like “Yours is No Disgrace” and “Seen All Good People” laid the foundations for future Yes epics. Steve White’s guitar playing is a standout. He overshadows Tony Kaye, though Tony Banks says Kaye was the best Yes keyboard player. “Perpetual Change” is my favourite. I think that the acoustic “Clap” is a distraction, similar to the shorter pieces from “Fragile”, and shouldn’t be there.
After two uninspiring albums, Yes recruited Steve Howe and the band was immediately elevated. Combined with Chris Squire’s melodic bass and one of Jon Anderson’s best performances they really hit it out of the park with this one. They peaked later with Fragile and Close to the Edge but this is still a fine album. The album lags a bit with A Venture but other 5 / 6 songs are real bangers.
Album senza senso incredibile ogni traccia perfatta vibe immacolata
To me, this album is more easily respected than it is enjoyed. My takeaway was that Yes is filled with talented musicians who know what they're doing, not that this was a record I liked listening to. It's like watching an opera - you leave feeling impressed with the talent that was displayed, before you get home and put on a favorite record by Carole King or Led Zeppelin.
Not a fan of Yes
Honestly this album didn't interest me. I can't quite put my finger on why. It just seems dull and lifeless. I saw a couple other reviewers said it was like Rush, but boring. I think I have to agree with that.
Woah, almost back to back Yes albums. I liked this one better than Close To The Edge. Gotta give these musicians credit, the songs have some complexity to the rock. A fun listen
Clap was the only song that stood out to me, everything else was just too ordinary. Two rounds of applause out of five. 👏👏
Very blah, nothing stood out to me.
Hell Yes
This one was really enjoyable, will listen again for sure.
Noodly progressive rock. Pretty much what I expected. Quite enjoyable.
tarvi tollattiin kattoo kameraa kohti... KÄNKKYISÄSTI. noh.. progressiivista, lyhyesti: prog. heh... prog rock... hyvä MUTTA EI NIIN HYVÄ.. EI OLLUT NIIN HYVÄ ETTÄ BANJOT HOI.... akustinen osio kiva. vokaalit taas bändin heikoin lenkki.. starship troopers
Me gusta como empieza. "I've seen all good people" está bastante bien y en general un disco interesante que oír al menos una vez. Interesante.
Yes album Yes was one of my favorite bands in junior high and high school. I would listen to albums like tales of topographic oceans and close to the edge regularly and religously, but I haven’t listened to this in a super long time. Such a great band- they all have such a distinct sound and it’s totally unique sound they play play together. Maybe everyone thinks that about their favorite band but I can only think of a few groups that have that kind of thing. Chris Squire- I love his an iconic crunchy bass sound from that rickenbacker with a pick. The grit of the bass is the perfect contrast to Steve Howe’s clean guitar sounds. Also his lines are all perfect melodies. His mccartney- esque walking line on yours is no disgrace works so perfectly against the melody. His melodic playing on Starship Trooper is so great. Bill bruford- I love his playing at the end of Venture and the interplay with the bass and piano ( would love to hear what happens on the fade-out). The first time I ever heard that kind of thing was on Heart of the Sunrise when he does an almost drum solo over the groove before the verse and I still think of that it all the time. Steve Howe- such beautiful guitar playing and different from what most 70’s rock players were doing. He was the first time I heard volume swells and harmonics and I still associate those sounds with him. John Anderson- the dude has the voice of an angel. I have no idea what the lyrics mean but he writes great melodies that tie the epic compositions together. Their group vocal harmonies are great too. Tony Kaye- so many great sounds and textures. I love the organ and synth sounds. I like the Wakemans playing on his albums better but I think that tony kaye and Patrick Moraz albums. I hear people call Yes self indulgent and lump them in with other prog rock bands but I’ve always felt that they are in a lane of their own. I think they were probably just really nerdy guys who were intense about their music. I’ve always appreciated their attention to detail and I think they were In the pursuit of beauty and not perfection or complexity. This album still kind of sounds like rock music and you can hear them moving more towards the farther out stuff. by the time they got to close to the edge, tales, and relayer it was like you put on the record and you can get transported into the fantasy world of the roger dean painting album covers. They got so deep into the compositions and I think they really explored the possibilities of what can be created with rock instrumentation and their imaginations. It is sounds so collaborative too I’d be so interested to see what their process was like. This album is kind of the transitional album from earlier sounding yes ( your move) to stuff like Starship Trooper. Yours is no Disgrace- is a jammer I love the feel when the “sailing ships to nowhere” part comes back. The Clap- I always thought having a live solo track on an album was kind of random. I he does like 3 different endings on this one but they are all awesome. Starship Trooper- The finger picking part with the harmonies sounds so joyous to me. the three chord part at the end is such a great build. Rocks so hard and they add so many textures before the solo finally comes in. Your Move- probably the most accessible song from 70s yes. Love the John Lennon “all we are saying is give peace a chance” part in the bgvs. Cool cyclical modulating harmony at the end. The venture- cool tune but I tend to forget it because it is not as catchy melodically. Perpetual change- probably the most proggy song on the record it has two totally different grooves with two yes’s panned to opposite sides at the end -So wild.
Wow what a ride. This is tough to rate objectively because it’s so ahead of it’s time. This must’ve been insane to hear in 1971. It’s so jam packed, in the first like 20 seconds there are synths, organ, les paul style country guitar, rock guitar, jazz guitar etc. Beginning sounds like Mario kart to me. I hate the bass tone in most of track one. The end of track one made me lol. The acoustic in the clap is really well done and the guitar tones are pretty good throughout. They really added every style of guitar to this record 😂 The trem-bass is cool and weird in starship trooper, But I don’t love that it’s panned to the left. I like the rawness of some of the guitar tones. This one is really testing my rubric, I feel like this objectively gets a 5 for arrangement and execution, but I don’t think I could listen to this again.
This album is wild! I feel like they came up with a bunch of ideas and said, "Let's do all of them". It's super cool.
Good first impression
Solid classic rock
Pretty good album but unlikely to become a regular fixture in my playlist
It was good. Good tunes and overall enjoyed my time, but nothin more than 3 stars 3/5
It was chill
All I can muster up is ‘meh’.
The less I pay attention to it, the more I like it.
OK. Okay! Xans for my breakfust, huh! Molly for my dinner, yuh. I'm writing a lab report... been writing this all day, huh. It's due at 11:59 tonight, ain't nobody write it better than me. all the other TAs are jelous of me
Leuk, gewoon de yes sound
- Never listened to a Yes album in full before - Thought it was very good, enjoyed it a lot - Always a big fan of long songs with multiple parts - Fav songs: I've Seen All Good People, A Venture, Yours is No Disgrace
Parece que va a ser bonico, pero es bastante rollo. Un poco musical inventado. Cantan bien. No lo volvería a escuchar.
It's good music, just didn't necessarily click with me sadly.
Un imprescindible del rock progresivo, aunque tampoco había escuchado un disco entero de estos. Especial mención a the clap (LNB) No me gusta mucho el rock progresivo(PSP)
Thought I had already voted for this album, but it turned out to be Close to The Edge. We also had Fragile, so this is the third Yes album on the list... ..which is 3 too many. In the 80s / early 90s I quite liked bands such as Genesis / Marillion / Twelfth Night / Pendragon / Aragon / Eloy etc or Rush. Couldn't stand bands like ELP, Focus ..or 70s Yes. Still gave these three Yes albums several tries and even own them on cd due to their classic status. This one is the best out of 3, it is close to 3 stars.
This is in fact listenable, with even a few quite acceptable grooves (e.g., Starship Trooper c).
This was fine, but just a little too much. I sense prog is going to be overrepresented on this list.
Yes this band rocks. Might get it another listen.
Wow, that was pretty fun---I listened twice and will revisit in the future. Yours is No Disgrace grabbed me pretty quick though the vocals take some getting used to.
YES
Meh
Really great, need to listen to it again
Its a Yes from me dog
A Yes album with a bit more pop sensibility mixed in along with their usual blend of classic prog. Wish Squier’s bass sat a bit higher in the mix and had more presence overall, but hey , not every album can be ‘Fragile’
Classic 70s, not my favorite but its a classic
sounds like pretty basic rock with extra steps. not as much fun as eg Jethro Tull or Queen but OK
3.5
Yes is a band that, twice now, I half-heartedly put on one of their albums only to remember just how much I like them. Maybe this doesn't top "Close to the Edge", but: - "Starship Trooper" & "I've Seen All Good People" is some of the catchiest music I've heard from this band - The shorter tracks, "Venture" & "The Clap" are great in their own right yet sound like they're from very different albums - First & last tracks didn't particularly move me today, though the psych-jazz in "Perpetual Change" was more enjoyable. February 17, 2023
Some of the harmonies are reminding me of Crosby, Stills, and Nash in a way. My mom's a huge fan of them so I would know.
Best Song: Starship Trooper: a. Life Seeker, b. Disillusion, c. Wurm. This is what I want when I listen to prog rock: expansive, meandering rock that takes its time to get anywhere, and goes some weird places along the way. Worst Song: Perpetual Change. That tempo change at around the 5 minute mark is exactly what is annoying about a lot of prog. It happens absolutely out of the blue. The whole song changes in an instant, without foreshadowing or any built anticipation. Why is this the same song? Why isn't this the next song? These kind of harsh cuts make listening to the music feel disjointed. Chaotic for its own sake. Overall: Music to stroke shag carpet to. Nothing here is particularly revelatory, even if all the band members seem musically quite talented. It just suffers from that heartless musicality that seems to plague a lot of prog rock.
I don’t get prog. It’s irritating how they cram four songs together and try to say it’s one track. And I bet they’re doing inventive things with rhythms and chord progressions, but it makes it a real slog to listen to. Having said all that - still better than Pink Floyd.
Better than Steely Dan, that's for sure.
Had its moments, good musicianship. Ultimately…not feeling it.
Incredible talent! I could really get into this band some more. Worth sitting down and focusing on.
A seminal prog release, the songs are much stronger than Fragile but not the coherent masterpiece of Close to the Edge. Despite all, we have collection of 6 flashy prog pieces, sunshiney and witty (somewhat Beatlesesque) compared to their contemporaries, seeing influence from American folk and classical, especially with the creative use of happy acoustics and a unique spacey, electronic production style. All the songs were impressive, but only "Starship Trooper" and "I've Seen All Good People" blew my mind.
I always forget that there are Yes records before “Fragile” & I wonder if I’d have listened to this one more if it had a Roger Dean cover.
Not bad. Some good songs and some…eh.
Some people say the key change from See all Good People is still going
Do I like prog rock? YES Do I like YES? YES Do I like this album? SURE
I'm really trying, but it's just dated drivel now isn't it? It might've been revolutionary at the time, but it's pretty tiresome now. I'm certain if I'd have been 15 or 16 in 1971 I'd have been right on board with this, but I was minus 2.
Some solid hits
Experimental in a way I didn’t mind. I could bop my head to this
Groovy as hell 😎😎
Really enjoyed it - reminds me a lot of the sound and feelings from a song like roundabout
Garbage
not memorable but not bad
Another great album from Yes. I've seem all good people is probably their beat known and most popular song from this time period. But every song on this album is prog rock at its finest. Starship trooper, perpetual change, and yours is no disgrace are great songs. The clap shows off Steve Howe's guitar skills. Great album overall.
Good guitar
Oh, I thought I was in for torture, but it let me down easy. It's not a record I will ever like, but it's listenable, and it's earnestness is actually infectious. In this class of 70s prog, this is probably the most grounded.
Already listened
I loved it. It feels like good old classic rock. Great melodies, catchy riffs, and amazing voices. Overall just pure fun and excellent musicianship. You don't even feel the 9 min songs pass by...
Not bad, and ~400 albums in, it's definitely my favorite prog rock thus far.
I was hoping to like this album more, but it never really clicked for me other than a few nice moments.
Pretty fun, but not my favorite Yes by any means 3.75
This is the first Yes album I ever owned and it became a favorite during my first prog phase. It still rocks, and I like how tight it is, not super willy-nilly. It may not be their strongest work but it’s a good recommendation for prog newbies. B+
Loved this when I was 15 … love the dated proggy sounds still, but honestly it is a bit tedious isn’t it?
S'aight. I've Seen All Good People pulled this one up to a 3.
Groovy music OuO
A decent album, good moments, not sure its grabbing me but pleased prog rock was not as scary as all that.
This album took me so long to get through and it wasn’t enjoyable. A few tracks had some nice guitar work, but nothing memorable.
Hyvää prog rockia. Levy kokonaisuutena ehkä vähän heikohko, tuntui tosi sekavalta kuin olisi ollut bändin shuffle vain päällä. Muuten olisi 4 tähteä
The rising of a prog rock legend. Still raw and edgy here and there, but full of impressive new ideas, it is the start of Yes' epic journey (on a sailing ship to nowhere)...
First time listening to Yes. Having never listened to it before this is what I imagined prog rock would sound like. Not the largest fan but it's satisfying enough I can't hate it. 3.5/5
Yes, it’s good. Yeah I do like it. It can be a bit too proggy at times but still good. The sound mixing on perpetual change is insanely bad
Quite fun but not much more to say really. Not a hell yes but not a no, probably more like a 'Yeah, sure!' album for me.
I'm a sucker for prog and psych. Perpetual change is a particular highlight. Not a mind-blowing album, but really enjoyable. Overall a 3 but a very honourable 3 - will very likely listen again.
Hated it
goodness do i love to hear a guitar ripped to shreds, fingertips calloused and splintered from the intensity. Yes deliver on that front and then some with their record The Yes Album, a complex body of work filled with deliriously meticulous instrumentation and melodramatic performances that gives rock music its verve. the music is borderline operatic — Yes does not care for subtlety, and they overlay their oft minimalistic compositions with loud guitar and bass moments that holds the music together. all of these elements feel best coalesced on the seminal “I’ve Seen All Good People”, a near-perfect mission statement that would drive Yes to the fore of a progressive rock movement still echoing in the ears of musicians today. their intricate melodies draw inspiration from jazz and folk music, which is what gives it rich personality, and Jon Anderson works his falsetto to the bone, all the emotion pouring out of him the second he takes a breath. the album is simple and restrained, but it isn’t until it ends that you actually realize how far it’s flown.
cool
Hell YES for Yes.
Hadn't listened to this one before, but I love Fragile and Close to the Edge, so was excited to check it out. Its almost as good as those, and might grow on me with further listens. Hard to believe they brought this and Fragile out in the same year - that's some impressive creative juice flow!
Meh
Melodisch, variërend en verrassend.
I find their sound rather addictive. I liked it a lot more than I thought I would considering 9-minute songs are the norm here. 'All Good People' is like two songs in one, it just switches halfway through. The first half is fine, the second half is great. I may come back to this.
This is my favorite Yes album, largely due to Starship Trooper, or more specifically, part C: Wurm. Might be my favorite 3 chord progression in all of rock. Steve Howe is a severely underrated guitarist. The thing that really gives Yes their signature sound though, are those super melodic basslines from Chris Squire. Love how they foreground it in the mix. Gives them a really dynamic, three dimensional sound.
Not a general fan of the vocals or prog rock in general, but this is still more interesting to me than a lot of modern prog-rock. Still not my thing, prog always feels like there isn't "heart" to it and virtuosity/technicality is the litmus-test for greatness.
Each song was a showcase of musical talent -- great instrumentation and the harmonizing vocals are always super pleasing!
This was a pretty enjoyable album. I found myself just sitting back and jamming along with this.
I don’t think we talk enough about how brilliant Yes is/was. Their harmonies are insane and the way they use their various instruments just blow me away every time.
This is the album where Yes became Yes. It's not just because Steve Howe joined, though that did define the sound for the next ten years, but because the songs took on the defining sound. It's Your Move is as classic a Yes song as you'll get outside of Roundabout. I saw this lineup around 20 years ago and, at the time, recognized very little of what they played. The encore started with It's Your Move, which was like coming home.
My knowledge on Yes is spotty at best. I remember Owner of A Lonely heart video freaking me out as a kid and loving it. I know "I've Seen All Good People" from this album and love it, but there is a lot more here and while it's not all for me and borders a little all over the place in a song aptly title "Perpetual Change" it never goes toooooo far. This album flew by though and was over before I knew it, would definitely revisit.
Ei tää oikein lähtenyt, vaikka eka biisi oli lupaava. Vähän sekava kokonaisuus, kuin kaks vahvaa tyyppiä tappelis tilasta ja kumpikaan ei oikein saa sitä.
Sain tästä keskittymishäiriön.
This is the start of Yes' classic run. The stuff that everyone who is even a casual fan knows starts here. "I've Seen All Good People," "Starship Trooper," "Yours Is No Disgrace" ... these are concert staples that would pretty much be in the bands' live setlists even now. I have heard them so many times in so many different line-ups, but this is the first group, the line-up that gave us these songs. I liked Peter Banks in the previous two albums, Time and a Word is really great. But The Yes Album is definitely brought up a level with Steve Howe. His guitar work is all over the place (but in a good way). I think the only things I dislike about the album are: 1) the ending to "I've Seen All Good People." It always feels like the record player is running out of battery power. Real lack of energy there. 2) "A Venture" fade out. The song itself is... okay, but the fade-out always made me wonder what happens if the song continued. But then, when you do get to hear the extended piece, it was probably good that they faded out after all. 3) Starship Trooper - the opening portion of Wurm always feels repetitive to me. Kaye's keyboard work could have been so much more. Live versions with Wakeman really show what this piece could have been in the studio. It's a shame here. So really, it's the ending of songs the band seemed to have a problem with. Something they would tighten up on their next album. But as it is, I'm nitpicking, because I would still listen to this album pretty much all of the time. I do get a little tired of "I've Seen All Good People," only because it was played on the radio WAY too much. Live versions work better for me, really. Still, a damn good album.
I'm not a prog guy, so maybe that's why I wasn't over the moon with this album. I mean, it's still very good but not a masterpiece to me. And my favorite, standout song is only 3min long - The Clap. Holy crap, I did not realize how good a guitarist Steve Howe is. Maybe I should've. Otherwise, yeah, the longer songs are all solid and it shouldn't just be I've Seen all Good People that gets the accolades - Yours is no Disgrace and Starship Trooper are also ambitious and artful.
I remember the first time I heard this album. I bought the CD and put it on a boom box in my bedroom, hanging out with my girlfriend. It was the first Yes album I bought, and I only knew the 80s Yes sound that was played on MTV and pop radio when I was a kid. I already knew that I liked progressive music from the Pink Floyd and Rush albums that I was into, but this took it to a whole new level. Steve Howe became one of my favorite guitarists and that was mainly due to the impact of this album. It is and always had been my favorite Yes album. Chris Squire's bass line on “Yours is No Disgrace” still fills me with awe even decades after I’ve first heard it. The intense solo that keeps switching channels at the end of “Starship Trooper” used to get blasted in the car almost daily as well as the crazy speaker shifting solo in "Yours is No Disgrace" . This is another easy 5-star album. I probably didn’t even need to listen to it again because it’s etched in my brain but of course I did.
This is the album where Yes became Yes. Sure, it wasn't until the next album that Rick Wakeman cemented the "Classic Yes" lineup, but this album is absolute prog rock perfection. The two previous albums suggested what Yes was going to become, but this album found the missing ingredient with the addition of Steve Howe. Not a weak track on the album. The first four tracks are simply amazing: Yours is No Disgrace rocks. It's about the Vietnam war, but you would probably never guess only by listening to the typical Yes-obtuse lyrics. The fantastic opening riff punches so much harder live, but sounds great here also. The song takes you on a journey of different styles, all fantastic. Then we hear Steve Howe's excellent imitation of Chet Atkins in Clap (as he says, "not THE Clap, thank you very much"). Then one of the absolute Yes greats: Starship Trooper. Man, those guitars - Steve Howe just tears through this song. The last part (Wurm) absolutely takes you into space - every member of the band is on the top of their game in this song (and let's take a moment to acknowledge Tony Kaye - kicked to the curb after this album but did an admirable job here). Of all the songs on the album, this one most shows where Yes was heading from here. I've Seen All Good People is a classic rock radio staple and has so many great moments: The first section has some of the best harmonies in a rock song and then you have to give tons of respect to the jam section at the end. A Venture is the weakest track IMO - not bad, but it has a lot to measure up to on this album. Finally, Perpetual Change is a solid track. It probably took me longer to get into this one than others, but nothing can compare to the first four tracks on this album. Absolutely perfect album and an easy 5.
frustrating! there are some great parts of this album but they're all hidden inside songs that are way way too long. best track: half of the opener
Guitar virtuoso Steve Howe enters the fold, and at last Yes finally begin to understand what they’re capable of. Unorthodox arrangements and bewildering lyrics, Jon Anderson’s ethereal voice, Chris Squire’s delicate bass, Bill Bruford’s jazz-tinged drumming, Howe’s commanding guitar-all combine for a true prog masterpiece, and the start of a truly epic run for Yes.
Definitely not their best
I don’t love yes but I can’t say anything bad 4/5
The vocals are actually pleasant to listen to, which I wasn't expecting. The long songs don't intimidate me but it doesn't have replay value. I was a bit worried seeing it was another 1970s rock album but to my surprise I enjoyed it more than others! I definitely think they could have been split into smaller portions. A decent album on my scale, but not enough to save. Highlights: Yours Is No Disgrace, A Venture
It's always refreshing when a young band has gained the confidence and experience to no longer cover songs on their studio albums. Happened with the Beatles etc, and this is Yes' moment, three albums into their career. This album benefits from the extended collaboration of the band members, especially with the breath of fresh air from Howe, eclectic in his playing style, such as when he wields the Portuguese guitar.
Quite beautiful. Great musicianship. Great bass tones, crystal acoustic guitar clarity for some reason. Also keys and synth sounds are also on point. These combined with the artistic rhythms and vocal harmonies are something that Yes definitely had down in this ear of the band. It's a safe 5 stars whilst not being my favourite of theirs.
Some songs were OK but not all.
Fantastic. What a band, what a sound, such great writing and performance by everyone.
I still stand by the theory that Yes were just making shit up as they went along and they only made great albums through sheer cosmic luck. Kind of like somehow always picking the right answer on a test you didn't study for. That is the only explanation as to why their output is like a random number generator of quality. They're probably the only band that has an album in their catalog for every possible score from 0/10 to 10/10. This particular album is very green. Not their greenest though. 7/10.
The first 'proper' album that I ever bought. Absolute stone cold classic and in the top 3 of all Yes releases in my opinion along with Yessongs and controversially for many, Relayer. Steve Howe's guitar playing - superb. Chris Squire's bass likewise. Just also love Tony Kaye's keys as well. Again, in my opinion the best keyboard player they ever had, which says a lot given that Wakeman and Moraz are extra special too. Nothing sweeter than Anderson's voice, and this is when Yes lyrics were still mainly of this planet. Mustn't forget Bruford too, a top quality drummer.
Très bon!
Yes
Interesting but wouldn’t listen again.
Singing annoys me somewhat, music is good but the songs are very forgettable.... A slightly harsh 2*
Not bad
Yes!
This is great, definitely one I'll check out again
Bello como todo lo que he escuchado de Yes.
The production quality is perfect and the musicianship is outstanding
O K
Stream of consciousness notes: I like prog rock when I hear it, but never have actively sought it out. Loving the first track so far! Interesting that there are some acoustic instrumentals mixed in. I like the flow of this album. I really appreciate songs with a multi-part structure that flow really well together. Starship Trooper and I've Seen All Good People are the highlights for me!
prog, good sound, repetitive songs