Reviews (page 2 of 14)
Enjoyment: 6/10 Replayability: 5/10 Cohesion: 5/10 Flow/Pacing: 5/10 Artistic Merit: 6/10 Weighted Average: 5.5/10 Review: Good rock music, but the tracks were long and sometimes overstayed their welcome. I wouldn't add any one of these to a playlist, but I would listen to this album again. Liked Song(s): Yours Is No Disgrace, I've Seen All Good People: a. Your Move, b. All Good People Disliked Song(s): (None) Recommend? Yes Heard Before? No
Great musicians. A little too many twists and turns for me sometimes.
OMG I LOVE THIS ALBUM. I don't even need to go listen to it again to know that. But maybe I will when I'm studying tomorrow.
I don't know why, but parts of "I've Seen All Good People", particularly the nonsense syllable part, still move me every single time. It feels like sorcery. I'm not really a fan of the rest of the band's work, but some moments on this album take me to a happy place, usually reserved for my most favored tunes.
No matter what part of their career, no matter who was in the band, Yes time and time again delivered creative, challenging but non-pretentious and pleasant takes on pop rock. Unlike King Crimson, ELP (definitely) or Rush (to some extent), they always seemed to be focused more on the music side than on the ego side of their prog rock. There wasn't much 'hey I'm very epic, let me wank and masturbate on my instrument for this particular section'. It flowed like a well oiled machine. After Pink Floyd, this was one of the more easy to digest prog rock bands that wouldn't bore your socks off. But then again, this is why as soon as it was not working out, they just started kicking out people here and there, which led to bands like the aforementioned. If you are a new guitar player here, or rather are you new to instruments in general, stop what you are doing right now and listen to this album right now blind. Inject this shit into your bloodstream NOW. Let it hit...... Appreciate how tight this band is despite how long these songs can drag on and how many styles and mood swings this band can go through. Jon Anderson's vocals are goofy and light-hearted, in contrast to the poe-faced nature of most prog rock. Bill Bruford's drumming is flowing and rock steady, with jilted time signature changes that seem almost natural to keep you dancing. Chris Squire's basslines are groovy and incredible. Tony Kaye's keyboards, although not often present, is noticeable enough to blend into the sound of the band and add an extra layer of timbre to put in great drive to the music, and when he gets time to shine, he really puts his keyboard to great effect. The standout here is Steve Howe, a virtuoso newcomer. Unlike most guitar wizzes, his style is surprisingly a lot more restrained. Compare to predecessor Peter Banks, Howe's style is very planned, less bombastic, but flowing with great flexibility, filled with great riffs, impressive tones and effects and some very free-flowing solos that don't seem to be in your face. Compare it to KC's Fripp, where you know the main show is his wicked fingers overwhelming the majority of the band. In Yes, Howe seems to fit very perfectly with everyone else so well, it makes those solos seem so much more grand. Like eating a good meal and the flavours just seem to phase one after another in a pleasing manner. Containing psychedelia and Beach Boys-esque harmonies and styles, you also have your usual prog suites. But these suites sound a lot more simpler than they sound, and that's incredibly genius. Yours Is No Disgrace, Starship Trooper and Perpetual Change all sound like sweet pop songs, but look closely and they are doing some seriously funky shit. And the funky shit is why these pop songs work really well. Furthermore more, you have interludes scattered here and there. And they aren't self-indulgent or bombastic or annoying or masturbatory. They simply serve a little bit extra to the abilities of the band, and they sound like really good pop songs. I'm basically driving in a point that this band is a band that actually THINKS instead of simply WANKS. It is incredibly listenable. The music is technically solid and unique. The vocal performances are great and sugary. There's a great array of moods and emotions to enjoy. And there's hardly a dull moment. Very good music here.
More like, “Maybe.”
Yes, there is a limit to how long I want a Yes track to be, and preferably under 8 minutes. As with almost all Yes albums, the more accessible singles are worthy and enjoyable. They get you to say “yes” to their work and invite you in for tea. Then you sit there unable to leave until they finish the rest of their album. Did you enjoy it? Yes. Are you ready to leave? Yes.
Fart noises from poop water. The '70s were truly gauche if this is considered good for the time.
V [Yours Is No Disgrace]* #1 [3.5] #2 [3.5] #3 [3.5] [The Clap] #1 [3.5] #2 [3.5] #3 [N/A] [Starship Trooper…]* #1 [3.0] #2 [4.0] #3 [4.0] [I’ve Seen All Good People…] #1 [3.0] #2 [3.5] #3 [N/A] [A Venture] #1 [3.5] #2 [3.5] #3 [3.5] [Perpetual Change] #1 [3.0] #2 [3.0] #3 [N/A] Listens/ 1: Haphazard, One Earbud, Background 2: Speaker In Room, Folding Laundry OR In Car Driving 3: Focused, Headphones, Lyrics Up *=Playlist Submission (0-3 songs per Album)(up to 5 songs if its a 5/5) Final Score: 3.5/GOOD
Didn't enjoy quite as much as Fragile, first couple tracks didn't grab me much, but the back 4 were pretty good! "Starship Trooper" "I've Seen All Good People" and "Perpetual Change" were the standouts for me
3.5 - good
Since widely regarded this is not their best album I expect minimum one more Yes record but I'm glad The Yes Album made the cut. First of all Steve Howe is an absolute god. This is their first album with Howe and I really admire his playing and incredible guitar tone on here. Then we got Jon Anderson nailing the vocals like he always does I don't think anything else needs to be said. Also this is for many years the last album of Yes featuring the keyboardist Tony Kaye before he got replaced by Mr Rick Wakeman because he was too normal and the madness really began. So this is still quite accessible for a Yes record and a progressive album in general. Some brutal 10 minute epics like Starship Trooper or Perpetual Change are there but also something like Steve Howes "Clap" which is a beautiful pure accoustic guitar song. No weak song on this album every one has its rightful place. The ending of Perpetual Change equally the end of the album is so good I enjoyed that a lot it's a perfect ending. I do think The Yes Album is kind of underrated I consider it one of the best progressive rock albums of the 70s. Not like top 3 but up there. 4,5/5
ok im familiar with yes so i was kinda worried this would be long as fuck but thankfully its just Normal Length. although.. maybe it'd be ok if it was kinda longer provided it was like the first track cos this is exactly the type of shit im after when im listening to prog rock. the electric organ on "yours is no disgrace" sounds fucking incredible. the rest..... idk. it's a little softer than i'd like, really? especially "the clap" and the first half of "i've seen all good people". it's still alright but like.... it feels like other than parts of "starship trooper" a few moments in "perpetual changes" it's not really what i was hoping for. maybe that's on me as yet another person whos main experience to yes is checking out roundabout after watching jjba but like. idk. idk! that first track bangs but i dont think its enough to pull this up from a 3 for me really. oh well.....
Hesitating over whether this is 3 or a 4. For somebody who doesn't like jazz noodling, I'm weirdly fine with prog noodling. I couldn't tell you why. I don't know if this is "fine but probably won't listen again" or "actually I'd put this on again either in the background or for a further listen." If the point of this process is to expand my interests in musical genres, it succeeded in confirming I'm more into prog rock than I thought.
Like the previous album a mixture of some good stuff and other tedious nonsense.
I know Rick Wakeman is a sacred cow of the genre, but noodly keyboards are my least favourite thing about prog rock, so I like this slice of pre-Wakeman Yes. They're relatively noodle-light and I can enjoy the guitar and bass in peace. I can't decide if I rate Jon Anderson's voice or not – he sounds like if you threw Peter Gabriel down a well and left him – but he does the job and I like the harmonies. Big fan of Tony Kaye's foot being in plaster on the cover; more bands should sport a random unlucky injury in their artwork. There's quite a fun and buoyant vibe about this album that I just like. It's very listenable, even sort of cute? 🌞
It was always Yes vs ELP amongst friends at school and beyond. Although a die-hard ELP fan I did still try to understand what Yes had going for them but for the most part failed and they still come in a poor second to this day. Although I can listen to a lot of their stuff and even rate “Close to the Edge” very highly I think maybe it’s Anderson’s voice approaching falsetto which is hard to handle after a couple of tracks on most albums. Or maybe it’s the inferior percussion compared to Carl Palmer? And obviously nobody could ever compete with Keith Emerson for keyboards (even Rick Wakeman after he joined them). This album is a good example of why they have always been something of a let-down in my eyes. The promise from the opening track on this album soon turns out to be an empty one as the rest of the album doesn’t feel as if it has any direction. Steve Howe’s live acoustic guitar bit on Clap is OK but does it deserve to be on a studio album at all? The rest is almost like an in-studio practice session where they are just trying out ideas for new songs. My attention drifts away after that one anyway which is never a good sign. It does come back for the final track though which I do like. Also – it’s a shame the cover doesn’t have the Roger Dean artwork of later records to marvel at while you are wondering why on earth you bought the album!
I really just wish they would play one song and stick with it. That being said it was better than CTA and ELP, in fact I quite enjoyed track 4 and parts of track 3. Still not quite a Yes from me!
A pleasant surprise, as I was expecting ELP levels of awful. That’s not to say i particularly enjoyed it, but when they calm down and just getting on with playing one song it’s okay. The track where dude is explaining how chess pieces work was the best.
A fun listen, it led me to 90125 which I quite enjoyed.
Pretty good album, loved the vocals and bass was excellent, I kept thinking it was a live album, just really great, felt super 70s
Ok but not really my cup of tea a few tracks are ok
Was pretty bored most of the way through outside of one absolute slapper of a track. So like 2.5
The Yes Album is pretty ambitious. Songs are longer epics, but they go by really quickly. "Starship Trooper" and "I've Seen All Good People" are great jams. The rest of the album was good, but faded a bit into the album as I listened. A very good effort, this is a definite 4/5 for me.
I liked this one better than Fragile. I'm still not a fan of the vocal parts, which sound a bit like a discount version of Queen. Jon Anderson has a weak, slightly annoying voice that always kind of ruined Yes for me. It might also be a bit too upbeat for my taste ; I like my prog rock to be darker, weirder or trippier than this. However, I must admit that the instrumental parts are pretty solid. It's a great prog album, complete with nine-minutes songs and a certain cheesiness that reminds me of Rush. Bass, guitar and drums are real tight, and I think the jazzy bits are more organically integrated here than on Fragile. No song really stands out, and it kind of drags on toward the end, but it's still a nice record overall. 5/10
I liked this one less than the previous Yes album we had, which was actually its direct successor. I find this one less eclectic, with fewer truly memorable tracks. Still, it’s Yes: inspired and inspiring, complex without completely disappearing up its own ass, and with that incredible bass that I just can’t get enough of. Not a masterpiece, but a solid prog rock album.
Favorite Track: I've Seen All Good People: a. Your Move, b. All Good People
Yes to this. I enjoy the jam band aspect of yes, even tho it can be a little tiring at times. There always seems to be a moment of magic somewhere in the meandering jams.
This is good, a bit repetitive but good!
Quintessentially prog
Not my cup of tea
a chill listen
Better than I feared. Less crap than ELP or Supertramp. Kinda genuinely charming. Sometimes they sound like CSN. The tunes are good. They got so lost, ELP-level lost, later.
Yes is one of the greatest symphonic rock groups. They have a perfect blend and I can listen to them again and again without boredom. I wish that The Yes Album might have had a bit better production value, but still, it is a great early album . 4.5/5
Admittedly, I’m a bigger fan of prog rock than a lot of other people. I’ve always liked bands like Genesis, Alan Parsons Project, Queensrÿche, and others. So when this popped up, I was pretty excited. It’s not perfect, far from it actually. However, this is an excellent album with a lot of great musicality to it. They are rightfully, considered one of the better bands of all time, and this record is no exception. Favorites were Starship Trooper and I’ve Seen All Good People. Four stars
Clarkson's favorite album. 5.0/5.0
outstanding
Bastante MEEEEEH
That middle section in the last song really pissed me off. Like, please stop. Aside from that it was fairly inoffensive but, once again, not for me.
Jon Anderson’s faux falsetto is one of the most unpleasant sounds in all of popular music to my ears, so this album wasn’t going to fare well. The inexplicably overrated “I’ve Seen All Good People” is nothing more than a relentless, grating ear worm. Kudos to Yes for apparently being able to manipulate time. How else can it be explained that the three minute and twenty second song, “A Venture” feels like three years? There is undeniable musicianship but the songwriting (aside from “Starship Trooper”, somehow) is garbage. Let’s not even get into the lyrics. Like most prog-rock, I’ll leave this to the math class nerds. I’ll take the English class nerds any day.
This yes album was a no from me. For a band that is so curated and particular, this felt disjointed and like a hot mess.
Favorite songs: I’ve seen all good people, Yours is no disgrace
Definitely interesting, good background music.
Maso
For an album that starts with what sounds like a 70s sports program intro this is surprisingly listenable (just), Prog before it got too tedious. Heavy on melody and mystery played with great musicianship, but still suffers from overly long songs, noodeling and unnecessary changes in pace
I was expecting weirder music with the album art.
Yes... Maybe?? Yes....
yes album
…wait, do I like prog rock
More great prog from Yes. I love how the bass stands out on this album. The short tracks seem a bit too much like filler than anything that belongs on this album, though.
I feel like I’ve been listening for 30 minutes and I just started the third song. This was ok I guess. Decent background music, but not anything particularly memorable. Reminds me of Rush. (3)
In the words of Doctor Evil, "How about NO."
Good
Not my thing. It gets a two because of a couple of decent riffs.
Es interesante. Capaz debería reescuchar Fragile, porque este me gustó más. Aunque sí debo admitir que se pone por momentos repetitivo y se hace muy largo, pero está bastante bien.
I really want to get more into prog so Yes is a band I definitely gotta spend more time. Favorite track: A Venture 3.5/5
Il Rock fatto bene, ricordano molto i Queen.
I was expecting to like this album because I liked Fragile but it was really boring. Maybe it was added to the list as an album with historical value for what was to come for the band.
Niet echt bijzonder als ik heel eerlijk moet zijn. Al heb ik wel een zeker zwak voor yes natuurlijk.
An absolute classic. Those first moments of Yours is No Disgrace is iconic. Love so much of it, just wish that Sarship Trooper didn't end so abruptly, and A Venture is a little underdeveloped. 4.7/5 -> 5/5
Well well the album where I seen all good people come from. About what I expected - Prog Rock all day - 6 tracks and 40 minutes. It was fine... Favorite Track: Starship Trooper (obv) Track that would annoy Casey the most: Perpetual Change ("Dad will it ever end????")
Rating: 4.7/5 Short Review: Prog rock that’s complex without disappearing up its own ass. Great musicianship, constant movement, and surprisingly catchy. Steve Howe is ridiculous throughout. Favorite Track: Starship Trooper - That ending is fantastic.
7/10
I didn’t really vibe with this album. It was alright. Would relisten to if I came across the songs but wouldn’t pick them to listen to
i'd never listened to Yes before this. oh, okay i get it, Yes are like if The Mars Volta were pre-punk and never did meth: all the same flaws but less interesting 'a venture' is a fantastically hooky-but-knotty prog-pop song that i'll return to, even though it still has irrepressible virtuousic jackoff energy (pejorative). 'starship trooper' is pretty good and even has some (partial) restraint in the three-chord chug of its final section. 'the clap' is fine, but ultimately still an overly-virtuosic contribution to a form (solo acoustic guitar instrumenal) that i prefer more emotionality from. the rest of the album sucks, especially 'i've seen all good people' which is like a bloodless prog christmas carol.
don't like it
Outstanding and worth a listen as often as possible.
While the first two Yes albums only hinted at the band's potential, they achieved their first of three perfect albums with "The Yes Album". The quantum leap in quality had two reasons: Firstly, the virtuoso Steve Howe replaced the first guitarist Peter Banks, whose angular style did not quite fit the band's concept. Secondly, they found a producer in Eddie Offord who helped create the Yes-typical sound. The band's transformation would be completed on the follow-up, "Fragile", on which the Hammond organ-focused keyboardist Tony Kaye was replaced by the more experimental and much more virtuoso Rick Wakeman. However, even without Wakeman, "The Yes Album" was a milestone in progressive rock. Howe brought not only his musical talent to the band, but also contributed good ideas to the complex compositions. Finally, they abandoned cover versions and dared to create long, expansive compositions. The baroque pop-ish Sixties patina of the first two albums had disappeared. Yes were modern and progressive. The interplay of multi-part vocals and virtuoso passages was celebrated. The album contains two of the band's best-known songs, "Starship Trooper" and "I've Seen All Good People", as well as the fan favourites "Yours Is No Disgrace" and "Perpetual Change", in which, alongside Howe, the rhythm section Squire/Bruford plays at its best. It may be that the two subsequent albums were even better, but that does nothing to diminish the flawless quality of "The Yes Album", an album that defined progressive rock with its exuberance and virtuosity and set the direction for all future masterpieces of the band and the genre as a whole. No matter how much mediocrity and bad music the band will release in their later years (and they will release it), this is an album for the ages.
Jammy background, fine.
this is the yes that I enjoy. can't hate on it. whoops Would I listen again: yeah. sometimes. Deserves to be on this list: they went off with this one 3.7
Not as good as close to the edge imo, but still excellent prog
Did not enjoy this
They peak so hard that even such a good album doesn't feel as good.
Solid early progressive rock. Their harmonies on this album were fantastic, and I definitely enjoyed the finger plucking guitar solos. They give off a Crosby, Stills, and Nash meets Rush meets Appalachian hill people vibe. I dig it. All around, fun and easy to have on. 4/5
already forgot about it. that's how memorable it was
Very complicated song writing but still catchy
Was alright
I REALLY dug this album. I feel like I need to do more looking into the guitar parts and how talented Steve Howe is. Really great! 4.5
A pleasant proggy surprise! The gritty tone on the bass in some of these songs is so *chefs kiss* sounds like the amp is filled with rocks, and it rocks!
Great, prog rock for the whole weekend. Honestly as prog rock goes this wasn’t so bad, I enjoyed chunks of each song and the sound itself is good. But still, just too much repetitive jamming and endless noodling around for me to fully be on board. I did go ahead and listen a second time to be a good sport and there’s some cool stuff going on in the transitions but it still gets tiring in between. Second act montage needle drop in my biopic: “Starship Trooper”
Nice guitar riffs, at some points the album sort of dragged and lost my attention but overall I liked it
I'm catching up on some albums and listening to yes immediately after listening to 2112 by Rush. 2112 made me feel like I just don't like rock music but Yes makes me remember how rock can be good - where 2112 sounds like a witch in some parody movie giving you a riddle in the form of a slapdash song, Yes feels like something that comes from a legitimate spaceship that actually has plans and goals. I like the organ sounds, I like the singers voice, I like the twangy guitar riffs. I don't know if I would listen to this all the time but I like the vibe it creates and I enjoyed listening to the music they make. It's just funkier, it's twangier, it has more dynamic range. Likelihood that the members of this band lezzed out IMO: 1/5 I just don't really see it here for some reason and thats ok
i liked this fine .. i think yes has better albums probably. i was more familiar with their tracks off of fragile and 90125 before this. my dad loves this stuff and your dad probably does too big fan of the clap big fan of the organ moments all over the album not a big fan of the vocals, i kind of wish it were instrumental
In July 2016, I went on a road trip across the country that included a stop at the Grand Canyon. We had booked a hotel on the North Rim of the Grand Canyon with little knowledge of where we were going and how to get there. We got incredibly lost, and didn't get to the hotel until nearly 3AM. It felt like we were literally the most isolated people on the planet as I walked from my car to the hotel. It was very dark, and it was kind of foggy, and there was a strange noise in the air. As I got closer to the hotel, I realized there was someone working in the kitchen and had a door propped open. The sound was a radio in the kitchen, but it was echoing off the building, the rocks, the atmosphere. It sounded eerie and very cool. The song was Your Move, by Yes. I had liked the Yes songs that I have heard over the years on the radio, Roundabout and the aforementioned Your Move were both cool songs. There is something about Yes that I really like, when I have mostly not enjoyed the proggy offerings on this listening experiment so far.
There were elements of folk ('The Clap') and elements of prog. Put simply, I liked the former a lot more than the latter. Overall not bad but not my thing
Not my taste
Between 2-3.
After I fell in love with FRAGILE (thanks to a gift of a scratched copy from my brother when I was very young), THE YES ALBUM was the second Yes LP I got into. It remains one of my favorites.
Pleasantly surprised at how much I liked this
Pretty boring. When I hear “prog rock” this is what I worry it will be.
Yea nah get fucked.
The Hell Nah Album
I think I only knew I've Seen All Food People from this album. I enjoyed the rest of the album. Yes could get rather bombastic, but not on this album. Steve Howe was a great addition to the band. And his acoustic guitar playing on Great listen.
Music/instruments: Enjoyed Lyrics/vocal: Nah
Glad to actually listen to this entire album once. While I have heard songs from this album before, I had never listened to the whole thing. I think that I am still more of a fan of other Yes albums vice this one, but that is a personal choice. Owner of a Lonely Heart will always win out for me.
Not terrible. Terrible would imply it was more interesting than it was. I thought that this had musicianship, and it had musical structure. I technically understand the quality of the solos. But a good album should have a little bite in my view, and this didn't do that. Steve Howe is on occasion strikingly technically good, and I'd have liked to hear a little more complexity from him. I guess I might get that in the later Yes albums when they come up. I don't know why, but I'd also thought it would be more of a concept album. A Venture is an odd relatively normal single in the middle for unknown reasons, and sticks out. A slight tech demo of an album, and quite forgettable after the sensation of listening to it passed.
como había salido ya el fragile no pensé que fuera a estar este tmb, pero yo tampoco habría sabido elegir
Now this is much closer to what I expected from these characters. Love the breadth, love the complexity, love the variety. You know I love them long tunes. Had our paths crossed at a different time this album could be foundational to my musical identity. As it happened I’ll just appreciate & be on my way
It's a pretty good listen overall. There's plenty of extended jams that run throughout, and there's also a good amount of proggy noodling, but it doesn't sound anywhere near as wanky as a lot of other prog. The good musicianship is allowed to take centre stage without it being ruined by being painfully earnest and generally pretentious. I'm not put-off by the extended length of these tracks. Don't get me wrong, it's still not 100% my thing, but I enjoyed it well enough and I appreciate the craft and musicianship. 3.5 rounded down
Yes yes yes, good stuff.
Album reminded me of Queen and Pink Floyd, I liked all but one song. Up until now I've been rating on a scale from 1-10 however since the star rating only goes to 5 I'm going to start rating on a scale from 1-5, with that being said despite me not liking every song I think this is the first full rating album that I have listened to so far.
I thought Yes would be kinda boring but it’s kinda better.
Just not my thing
Not really my thing
Good but a little odd
Pretty basic touch album. Nothing great but nothing bad either.
This album is fine. Nothing too amazing but still good.
It’s not as bad as some other prog mostly because it feels self aware and actually knows how to have a good time
Probably the longest short album I've ever heard. Only 6 songs but they just keep going.
interesting
An excellent Yes album. Their third but the first with the amazing Steve Howe. Love this one.
Not my usual thing, but I enjoyed it more than I thought I would. Can’t tell my Dad I liked it though, as he’ll never talk to me again. Favourite track: Perpetual Change
No words kys
yes more like maybe
fun in a mostly nondescript way
Un disco importante per la discografia di un gruppo altrettanto importante. Per quanto corto si tratta sempre di un disco abbastanza lavorato,e si sente. "Perpetual change" , "starship troopers" , "Yours is no disgrace". Senza mancare di momenti più "commerciali" (sempre da riferirsi all'epoca in cui uscì). "I've seen all good people" 4,3/5
Was alright felt like Wish Beatles
A 2 for I've Seen All Good People.
Like most, I'm familiar with Yes through listening to classic rock. As a result, I recognize All Good People. The trouble with The Yes Album is that the opening track, Yours Is No Disgrace, sets the tone with nearly 10 minutes of noodling and music for musicians, with sparse and weak lyrics. Starship Troooper is vaguely familiar, but it also suffers from being overly long and self-important, qualities that really stand out on Perpetual Change. No doubt these are talented musicians, and I appreciated the radio friendliness of 90125 much more, but this wasn't great.
Yes might not be my favorite Progressive Rock band, (even though I like some of their albums), but they have often sounded fresh and modern for their time. And this album is in that category in my opinion. It reveals more details with each listen through its rich instrumentation and sounds. It's always nice with that kind of rewarding album.
How much do you have to love your new guitar player to make track 2 of their debut with you a solo guitar piece, recorded live no less? Whatever the answer, it’s justified. Steve Howe crushes it this entire record, bringing an unpredictability and virtuosity that fits in seamlessly with the rest of the band’s Positive Prog.
Felt way different than their later stuff, but somewhat enjoyable.
why the songs so gd long is my question. atleast its not overly repetetive like modern pop songs (ik yes is rock not pop)
No es mi estilo
Listened
This was a great album...sounds of Grateful Dead, Pink Floyd-esque. Five stars
Didn’t really think it was that interesting of an album and it seemed to drag on a bit. Just doesn’t feel like its for me. Undeniably q good though. Fav song: yours is no disgrace
happy good vibes, very 70s. Some very long songs
Very good 70s rock
Better than I'd expected, but a lot of noodling A Venture - I can't tell if I like it or loathe it. Very sort of bouncy. Ok - didn't hate it, but wouldn't actively seek it out unless I'm looking to explain to someone what "prog" is.
Gostei overall. Mas é um conceito um bocado repetitivo. Gostava que as músicas fossem mais divididas (prefiro as single versions).
Social media pea brain can't comprehend 9 minute songs. I did really enjoy it though. High 3, almost 4.
I just think the long instrumentals of the 70s aren’t for me
Such a good album, All Good People sounds almost Beatlesy with the vocal harmonies? The bass on Yours Is No Disgrace slapsss
Not a Yes man, their brand of prog just isn't for me. They certainly aren't bad by any means, they do what they do and they do it well, I just can't connect. Oh well.
Surprise to hear folks, almost Bluegrass-y licks in some of these songs.
Did not care for this. Boring.
I’m just gonna get right into it. Did I like this album? Yes I did!(Insert rimshot here). Good ol’ Yes puns. But in all seriousness, I did enjoy this album. Going in, I’d already heard this album before, but I didn’t really catch too much the first time or remember a lot of the stuff from my first listen. After listening to it again, I definitely appreciate it more than the first time I did. I think one of the things that this album does best is the fact that the prog elements do not feel pompous or showy, but instead serve to create a sonic landscape. One song on the album demonstrates this well is Starship Trooper, the second longest song on the album. The song’s spacey guitar arpeggios, played by Steve Howe, whose guitar playing really helps this album shine, sets the tone for such a cosmic sounding track. The song’s goes through a few sections, starting with a more proggy sounding section, before moving into a mainly acoustic section. Howe’s guitar playing also shines through on the bridge of Yours Is No Disgrace, my second standout, and Yes’s anti-war song, which has a really impressive guitar interlude. Even though I’ve talked about Howe a lot, I think that the whole band’s contributions are what really set this album apart. They keep the songs remarkably tight, even though they are complex. Chris Squire and Bill Buford are definitely one of the greatest rhythm section duos in prog rock. Chris’s iconic bass tone combined with Bill’s driving drums gives this album the drive that it needs on its faster moments, and the fullness it needs in its slower ones. Tony Kaye’s keyboard playing also helps this album shine, as keyboard and synth textures are an integral part of most prog rock bands. A Venture, my third standout is really his shining moment, with its beautiful piano intro, though his playing on Perpetual Change, another great track, is also impressive. Finally, Jon Anderson’s vocals fit in the Geddy Lee School of High Voiced Prog Singers very nicely, I definitely enjoyed his vocals on I’ve Seen All Good People, my final standout. The Clap was also pretty good, though not my favorite on the album. Overall, definitely a great work of one of the titans of prog rock. I’ll be looking forward to re-listen to their other works on this site. Now, I’m gonna take a venture to the next album.
I first heard this album from when I listened to a couple Yes albums a couple years ago. I remember this one being my favourite out of the three I listened to (Fragile and Close to the Edge are the others.) Re-listening to this was a delight, I'd hear some of the songs on rotation in my main playlist (the highlighted songs) but only listened to it again just now. It has quite lush harmony vocals. The bass playing by Chris Squire is nothing short of phenomenal that guy was/is completely cracked at bass. The production is really well done, everything is quite clear and spelt out in the mixing. I think this album definitely deserves a place on the 1001 albums you must hear list. Highlight Song/s: "Starship Trooper", "I've Seen All Good People" and "A Venture"
Prog shite
Groovy riffs, rolling guitars, and Beach Boys influence make for a fun album that flies by.
No song needs to be 9 minutes long.
Of the Yes albums I've heard, this is certainly the most straightforward. This honestly feels like a pretty good baseline for Yes's sound. They do, notably have a little less experimentation here, but some of the experiments that Yes do sound a little bit silly, so I'll take it. Although, I don't quite think this has the highs of some later Yes projects. Despite this, The Yes Album is a very solid prog rock project; it's more good Yes songwriting, executed with the band's signature precision, and I don't have much more to say than that.
First listen. I’m familiar with Yes and have reviewed their 4th album within this format. This album feels a bit less prog-y than the previous Yes album I’ve listened to. Lowlight- The Clap, it doesn’t seem to fit with the rest of the album. Highlight- I’ve Seen All Good People. This track was frequently on the classic rock stations growing up and I am extremely familiar with it. I prefer Close to the Edge over this album, still not bad.
"YES" is exactly what I said when I saw what the day's album was. These guys are the gateway to all things prog-rock, and for very good reason. Whether it's lyrical poetry or technical musicianship you want, Yes has you covered, and this self-titled odyssey is one that contains a multitude of styles. From melodic organ-driven melodies to acoustic delights, you'll find no shortage of creativity here. Definitely one I'd recommend for sure, especially for that opening track.
Maybe no? Yeah. No. Not my thing. I appreciate it? But does it move me? Do I ever want to hear it again? Do I even remember how this is different from Rush? Oh I know “symphonic prog” vs. whatever Rush is “prog hard rock?” Whatever. The answer is: no. NO. NO 3 for noodles and absurd lyrics Boolean: true- can’t deny history- if we don’t know it we’re condemned to repeat it
gillade denna jättemycket. känns verkligen som något jag genuint hade kunnat lyssna på. härligt långa och dynamiska låtar som smidigt flyter in i varandra, och älskar soundet! 8/10
The first album for Yes to really sound like Yes. Although I prefer their later 20+ minute songs, this is still the most accessible "starter pack" for Yes.
Komm Ich nicht ran. Vllt falscher Tag.
Super Urlaubssoundtrack
There's some good stuff on here and it's all really cool but ultimately it's not as good as Close to the Edge.
Not another fucking prog rock album with 1 good song…. Had dinner with them once and saw them on the 90125 tour…
Knew a few
Enjoyed some parts but probably wouldn't listen again
To me it seems they were so exhausted after gathering all their material that they lacked inspiration when delivering it, as if actually performing it was a strain.
4/5. The first in a trilogy of classic Yes albums, this is just some great prog music. Not quite as wild, experimental or adventurous as “Fragile” or “Close to the Edge” but still very captivating for its full runtime. You get some lengthy prog epics with tracks like “Starship Trooper” or “Yours is No disgrace” but also a handful of more digestible, shorter tracks like the live acoustic cut “The Clap.” And of course the playing is great all throughout.
nothing really stood out but it was fairly enjoyable at the same time
нравится
Solid rock prog rock album, nice synth and organ and stuff, but didn't stick in my mind.
I was always a Yes fan
All I can recall about Yes is Owner of A Lonely Heart, which I quite liked in the 80's, so interested in hearing another album from their career TLDR - that is not this Not even close This is absurb prog nonsense that gave 70's music a bad name, and provoked the much-needed punk backlash Three song here clock in around nine minutes, and a couple are broken into several movements FML - I have no time today to hate on how terrible this is Let's keep it at HELL NO! and move on
Not bad, I was concerned when I saw the multiple 9+ minute run time of these songs but there was enough variety and wasn’t just jam band indulgence…some cool spacey stuff going on here.
I’d never heard a Prog Rock album from beginning to end before. But I liked this so much. It’s way before my time, but I think if I had been in college in the early 1970s, this would’ve been on in my dorm room all the time and I would’ve made all my friends listen to it while we were hanging out. This album is full of constant surprises. You never know what you’re going to hear next. Will it be futuristic sounding synthesizers or will it be jazzy piano accompanied by upright bass? Who knows? A song slowing down and down and getting lower and lower so it reminds you of a vehicle coming to a stop? Fun. Spaceship sounds out of Star Trek? All of the audio cutting out of your right ear so that for 30 seconds the sound is only in the left? Sure, why not. Poppy harmonies that sound like The Who? Sometimes. It’s experimental but accessible and was a nice surprise from a band that I thought I wasn’t going to like.
Jon Anderson's voice will always make a Yes album distinctive - love love love how it soars. But, if I want prog rock, I want more nonsense about epic tales of Thor and pixies. Another entry in my increasingly long "I really enjoyed it, but not special enough to give it 4 stars" category
Decent but always thought YES were missing something for me. Some moments of brilliance but lacking something in many songs.
Good album, not much else to say, good basslines, though i wouldnt normally listen to stuff like that
I liked the long songs pretty cool album overall
I like yes's big hits but that's really it
Pretty mediocre. Rounding up from a 2.5/5.
The music was interesting but the vocals were lackluster
I’m not a huge Yes fan but this had some good songs. 3.5
Apart from the annoying Clap, all the songs here are fun to listen to. However, they're a bit meandering and slow paced. I now understand what people mean when they talk about noodling.
This is so good. Love the beat, the rhythm, the feel, the vocals. Really hit the spot for me.
Doesn't reach the heights of their later stuff, but still so good
great yes album. There are better but I still think it warrants a 4 for me
solid consistent prog but didn't blow me away.
I just don't have anything. It wasn't bad?
okay banjo. otherwise whatever
Сара 4 Марко 4
Not so much
Not bad! Little too much instrumental for me but was pretty ok.
I feel that the band were trying for something complex here. Some kind of epic story, some sort of big thing, which just didn't come to fruition perfectly. Or more charitably to them, it flew over my head. But in this case, I feel that it doesn't really matter all that much. What's left behind are some fun pieces of music, which strike a delicate balance between energetic/upbeat, and relaxing. There may have been a rock-opera kind of thing intended here? But the story feels a bit too esoteric to make much sense to me personally. I still enjoyed it, even if I felt like I was missing something.
It was fine. Not something I'd go out of my way to listen to though.
This album was good enough for a 2nd listen, but it's not great. As is the case with prog rock of this era, it's a wierd and all over the place.
I remember this album growing up great album. A song about the game chess how brilliant.
Great songs
I enjoyed this album quite a bit and have a copy on vinyl already, Yes are a bit of an oddity to me, they’re exceptionally talented musicians, but I’ve always found their music to be a bit too clinical, like it’s missing some emotion in the music
Prog is a fine genre, but outside of Rush, not my favourite.
No skips, one of the best programs rock albums.
Truly graceful. The bass gives so much taste
*listened before the project* They are not a band that may be considered legendary, but they are the band appear from the deep when you are (when I am) contemplating something
Love the sound. I’ve Seen All Good People is transcendently good.
No.
Album #123: The Yes Album Genre (W): Progressive rock Singles: Yours Is No Disgrace, Your Move I have listened to this album once before. Thoughts?: Yes is an extremely talented group of musicians. They might be “pretentious”, but I believe that they have an absurdly high music knowledge. Although the lyrics are cryptic, I am reminded a lot of classical music when I hear songs like Starship Trooper or Yours Is No Disgrace. Amazing album! Favorite tracks: All of it!!
Interesting progressive rock listen from a band I never heard of. I enjoyed the folk, punk, and thematic qualities of the record. In particular, the Starship Trooper song never got stale despite being 10 minutes long. Great record to listen to while binging 70s music. Might take a few more listens to really enjoy all the elements.
More like the No Album 4/10
This album rocks. very enjoyable. different styles. good vocals. new instruments. 5 out of 5
75
This is the third Yes album I’ve come across on this list, wtf.
This is #day715 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and… here's to some prog rock again, aka my third and final Yes record. Finally, I must confess. As with their previous two albums, I appreciate the skills and all that, but this kind of prog rock leaves me freezing cold. Same goes for Rush. This a 2 out of 5. Looking forward to #day716.
Some long songs but also the least stereotypically “proggy” album here from Yes. Adding a guitar helps a lot.
at the start i was like yes and then sorta lost interest as it went on
One of my favorite all time albums. This is the one Yes album that rocks.
I love prog rock 🤘
I could stand about 3 minutes of these 41 minutes. Clap was it, and thankfully no Yes vocals. The rest was like fingernails on a chalkboard for me. An absolute no to yes. 1 "at least they can play their instruments" star.
Yes yes yes!!!!*******
fun!
1. "Yours Is No Disgrace" 2. "I've Seen All Good People" 3. "A Venture"
It's fine, didn't thrill me. There's other prog I like better.
quintessential prog rock. plays like the nerdiest end of the 70's rock spectrum, kind of weird and self-indulgent. i like the big stupid overdeveloped anthems which is basically the whole album. listened through a second time to see if the Yes harmonies got old for me and honestly they still hit. favorite song is I've Seen All Good People. soft 4
Rating: 7/10 Yes, a cool band playing long and fun prog rock tunes. Playing them really well, almost no complaints. I could probably do without The Clap but otherwise it's very solid. Favorite track maybe is Yours Is No Disgrace
Kinda fun, feels like Diet Rush. Like Rush with the volume turned down. Like Rush but with one less band member. More Hurry than Rush. At times, Prog Folk. Nothing bubbly or thrilling about this one but I could see myself liking this or potentially their other albums more with a few more listens 6.7/10
Liking prog more every day
YES
An amazing example of the power of progressive rock. I really enjoy the bass in the tracks because of how clear it is. I’ve listened to it countless times and in my opinion it's one of the greatest albums of all time. 5⭐️
Eh. It wasn't bad, but it kind of put me to sleep. I felt like I was lost in a shopping mall with neon lights, songs blend together and it was pretty hypnotising. But nothing memorable or that I'd come back to
I'm more into this than Fragile and I think it's because I've Seen All Good People was often played on the rock station where I grew up. Probably when the DJ needed a bathroom break.
This project has provided quite the education on Yes.
I was going to run with a "No" joke, but the album is actually great background music at work.
Not bad but literally sounds like every early 70s rock band. Just boring
Totally worth the listen. As an album is 5/5. Its unique and the insturmental is soothing to the brain. Great pieces!
Mhmm.. it's ok, I'd like smth more 2.5
No track stood out to me and am kinda surprised as I usually like this type of music so was pretty disappointed. Don’t exactly feel this is a must listen to album.
Hard to hum
I've listened 3 times but have been a bit distracted so but can barely remember anything about it. Nothing offensive but nothing that grabbed me. Some nice moments - did not feel too proggy but overall lacking oomph.
A bit dull and pretentious. I thought I liked prog rock, but the more I listen to, the less impressed I am.
"We didn't have that "aUtIsM" when I was your age. Now get out, I'm gonna listen to Yes while playing with my model trains"
Ironically its a No from me
Technical and fluid without being (too) stuffy, it’s a yes from me
I've never really though of myself as a prog rock guy. It's not that I don't appreciate the talent it takes to make, it's just that I usually don't fully get it. But Yes surprised me an album that keeps the elements of prog that make it eclectic and impressive but manage to do so in a way that someone like me can still appreciate. They have some solid music fundamentals and aren't afraid to make their 9 minute experimental songs about the novel Starship Trooper catchy
Call me a democratic socialist Robert Plant the way I love progressive rock. 4.5/5
Unexpected solid album. Bigger fan of Yes now, good stuff.
I had hoped to like this album more than I did because I really liked Sweetness, but ended up not caring much for most songs. The vocals are well done, especially the harmonies. I like the Beatles cover and the last song
An interesting and fun album, lotta cool ideas, tapers off a bit for me in the last 10 but other then that pretty great.
Yes yes yes
Not my favourite from the classic prog bands, but I like the songs. Fragile is a way better record though.
*In 5-part harmony* This album is pretty good. *Pan flutes enter* I like the instruments and stuff. *4 minute organ solo*
Best album on this list so far. A true masterpiece.
“Death defying mutilated armies scatter the earth” is quite a lyric. (First song-“Yours is No Disgrace). I’m not a Yes fan, but they have a distinct sound. Unfortunately, the album sounds dated to me.
Yes
Classic in the Yes canon
No clue what to expect. Ok, so 6 songs of varying lengths. Interesting. Not at all what I thought it would be. This first song is so good. I love the constant sound change, and the vocals too. The second track, entirely instrumental (guitar mostly) falls flat. The third track, another long one, follows a similar structure to the first, with various sound shifts (including about 20 seconds of just silence), but is not as successful at it. I've Seen All Good People feels like medieval folk, and I quite like it. The genre shift is unexpected but well executed. Next track is nice, but its lenght prevents it from standing out among the tracklist. The closer's great though. I really liked this! The album manages to have a sort of signature sound, while changing throughout. Besides being good, it's also a lot of fun. Great stuff.
Nope.
Not my favorite Yes! album by far, but still a lot of interesting instrument work going on
I know some of these songs, but the shorter radio edits. Listening to the whole album makes me like the band less than I used to. My ears feel numb, like I'm trying to block it out as static. Jam bands are just not my thing.
What an album. That dutty organ. "The Clap" is a fun surprise. The build up and release on Starship Trooper is excellent, what a journey. "I've Seen All Good People" is one I have heard before, and I'm glad to hear it again. Overall this is a thoughtful album. It flows well, grooves when it should, and the band shows off in a good way. Five stars!
Brilliant guitar parts overshadow and paper over the relatively week songwriting and vocals.
not remotely sticky. this challenge is turning me against long songs which is such a tragedy they used to be my favorite thing!
Great!
More of a fragile or close to the edge fan, this one is not prog rocky enough for my liking tbh
Yes, I expected to hate it … it was OK.
Outstanding songs: yours is no disgrace, i’ve seen all good people
Enough with the prog. Thank you.
Te progressief
Yeah, it was alright. It got my foot tapping, and fingers drumming. Not sure I'll remember it tomorrow, though.
⭐⭐+ Prog. Inte direkt dåligt men i mina öron svänger det inte, det är musikaliskt men saknar vibe. Det är nog inget jag kommer söka upp igen. Blir en stark 2a. Bäst är I've seen all good people
Another joyful ride with Yes, who are I think one of my favourite discoveries/ revelations of this whole Dimery project (c. 165 in)
I appreciate the invention and there are some lovely moments, but for me Yes often feels a bit too clever / contrived and lands a bit soulless and cold (as opposed to say KC, which hits me as effortless and joyful despite the complexity). A slice of cheddar straight from the fridge can be just the thing, just not what I fancied today.
Yes
I’ve not listened to this for quite a long time. I’ve tried in the past to like Yes but despite my best efforts they really don’t do it for me. I appreciate the musicianship but it all seems a little bit contrived
Prog rock isn't my thing. This was fine.
This album is an interesting one in the sense that some of the songs stretch out to over 9 minutes. The overall tone is rock, which I like, but most of the songs don't seem to have an eclipse, which I don't like. This is definitely a listen to album rather then an album to dance to. Some more things I do LIKE us the inclusion of many different instruments and odd noises but the one thing that truly brings this album down for me is the repetition that seems to drag on and on in some of the songs. BUT because I like rock and some of the things that this album achieved, I'll give it a 3/5.
Pretty cool
Incredible strong start in "Yours is no disgrace" and then I feel lulled in. 🥱 "A venture" seems good too
Good prog. I appreciate the bass being so prominent in the mix.
Great
The NO album
I won't lie, this was slightly disappointing. I don't really like giving low reviews but I have to be honest with myself. Right off the bat the album feels extremely slow, the acoustic guitar as well doesnt really help. It picked it back up a bit later but it couldnt maintain it. To top it all of it really all just sounds too similar to each other to the point I was wondering if I was listening to song I heard previously before lmao. There was one fantastic part though, the middle of the 3rd song is genuinely fantastic. One of the best riffs I've ever heard, I just wish it was consistent like that throughout the album.
Prog makes me sick.
Okay
After already listening to Fragile before, i was hoping to at least a similar experience: Some great songs mixed with some tracks i couldn’t care less about. Sadly, The Yes Album doesn’t come close to the highs found on Fragile. And i was wondering why that was, as there are some pretty glaring similarities in style here. So i listened again to the tracks from Fragile i enjoyed and what was different about them is that they managed to take me along for the ride. Yes, songs like Roundabout also have many moving parts, just like many songs on The Yes Album. But on The Yes Album these parts seem so severed from each other, there often isn’t a throug-line to cling to. So sadly, this album didn’t really grab me. Another big problem are the vocals on here. They sound hollow and thin. I don’t know if it’s an issue with the vocal production or if they were just missing a singer that can carry their harmonies and give them more strength. Of course there are some things i like on here. The intro to Yours Is No Disgrace is great, the third oart of Starship Troopers is great and I’ve Seen All Good People is quite pleasant. But overall, this album left me desiring more focus and precision.
this wasn’t bad actually but again didn’t do a lot for me
no yes
Not for me
not for me
Classic
The clap is a crazy name for a song. Great vibe. Great band. Great vocals. Just not my vibe.
Songs too dang long but they rock
Did I love it? See band name
The album happened. I can't really recall it.
I always gravitate towards Fragile whenever I feel the itch to put on a Yes album. This was surprisingly good!
i really like close to the edge.
'If the summer change to winter / Yours is no disgrace.' The Yes Album has got some unwonted funk - not Floyd's 'Money' funk, but funk nonetheless. But it also has the worst of the British Folk Revival, which is really the basis of the whole prog thing anyway, e.g., check out 'The Clap,' definitional of instrumental inanity & amnesia. Of what I can remember of Close to the Edge & Fragile, I took to this one more, but prog has a way of reliably spoiling the fun, i.e., not just pretentious but undetermined & languorous. I will concede tho that 'I've Seen All Good People' is a worthy track, & better than that 'Roundabout' shit. 'Make the white queen run so fast / She hasn't got time to make your wife.' Yeah, a lyrical mess, but it sure sounds right.
not bad at all, so good early work from the band
they're called yes bc thats what you say when they start playing
This is a great prog album. Maybe one of the more complete prog albums ever made. What I mean by that is that each song seems to add to the overall aesthetic of the record itself. This is rare and when it happens it turns a good album to a great one. 8/10
i really liked the different changes in the music. however i didn't really like the guitar.
Great vocals! I loved the vocals and lyrics a lot. But what got me not really liking this album is the instrumentation. It wasn't that diverse. But I would definitely recommend this album.
I liked how the song was like three parts and not like. One whole part like most of the songs that we heard. But I really like how the song was built and whatnot and I also liked the. Beat and the effects of the song And I would recommend this to my brother but not my mom.
The music was really good in my opinion I reccomend it to anyone who wants a new taste in music
I quite down't like it. I down't like it b/c ibk anymore.
Prog rock is one of my favorite genres, and they executed it really well. I would recommend to anyone.
I like the different transitions in the songs in this album. I like the different instruments used in the songs. Overall I'd give this 3 stars.
An okay album, I do recommend to some but it wasn't my favorite.
Really impressed by this album. It has a ton of songs I just love to leave on and let play. The whole album is short and sweet at only 9 tracks in the deluxe edition. Fav tracks: StarShip Trooper and Clap
Prog is 100% my favorite genre. What can I say, I can’t get enough of proggy noodling. Perpetual change is a masterpiece in my opinion. Tied for second on this album are Yours is No Disgrace and I’ve Seen All Good People.
Like a more chill Led Zeppelin pretty great stuff. Will be listening to Yes more often.
Listen again
Some fun, trippy jams, and their big hit: “I’ve seen all good people turn their heads each day so satisfied I’m on my way”
No